Latest / Math Therapy / Why telling someone they're a math person can backfire w/ Teresa Brown
Transcript
- 0:03Teresa Brown: I still remember placing so much pressure on myself that this is who I am.
- 0:08Teresa Brown: I am a math teacher.
- 0:09Teresa Brown: I am a curriculum specialist.
- 0:11Teresa Brown: But I had to catch myself.
- 0:13Teresa Brown: I was like,"No, that's not I am.
- 0:16Teresa Brown: That's what I do." Who I am as a teacher is a temporary identity, and realizing that in that moment I didn't know if I was gonna get it back.
- 0:25Teresa Brown: When I was in the hospital, I had no idea of whether I would be able to do my job again.
- 0:30Teresa Brown: But there's a sort of peace in that, because at the root of it, I am still me.
- 0:34Teresa Brown: It's about this identity shift, right?
- 0:35Teresa Brown: And it was in that moment of having my stroke and realizing that I didn't know if I would get my career back that I was able to come to this peace with this is where I am right now, and if I wanna be anywhere else, I just have to work for it.
- 0:52Vanessa Vakharia: Hello, hello, and welcome back to another episode of Math Therapy.
- 0:56Vanessa Vakharia: Today we are dissecting two of the most loaded words in math education: math person.
- 1:02Vanessa Vakharia: Because when someone says,"I'm not a math person and we immediately fire back with,"Yes, you are", are we actually empowering them, or are we invalidating the very lived experience that brought them to that belief?
- 1:14Vanessa Vakharia: Look I know this sounds backwards.
- 1:16Vanessa Vakharia: We say it for, like, the best reason, right?
- 1:18Vanessa Vakharia: Like, we want people to feel included and capable, but I've noticed that when I go full cheerleader and yell,"You're a math person" at someone, the response I get isn't always what I hoped for.
- 1:28Vanessa Vakharia: Instead of my expected,"Wow, you're right.
- 1:30Vanessa Vakharia: I now feel amazing.
- 1:32Vanessa Vakharia: Thank you for believing in me", it's more like,"Whoa.
- 1:35Vanessa Vakharia: Like, why the are you coming at me?
- 1:37Vanessa Vakharia: You don't even know me." And I've had this growing feeling that my words are falling flat, or worse, they're contradicting the identity someone has built from real evidence.
- 1:46Vanessa Vakharia: Well, today's guest, Teresa Brown, wrote the LinkedIn post that finally made me ask, could telling someone they're a math person actually be damaging?
- 1:54Vanessa Vakharia: Teresa is a veteran STEM educator, doctoral candidate in curriculum and instruction, and a powerlifter That's right, a powerlifter, who makes a convincing case that math has more in common with lifting a giant barbell than we think.
- 2:06Vanessa Vakharia: You don't need to love the gym to go lift weights, so maybe you don't have to be a math person to be good at it.
- 2:11Vanessa Vakharia: The conversation also went somewhere I didn't expect.
- 2:14Vanessa Vakharia: Last December, Teresa had a stroke that left her with acalculia, the inability to recall basic math facts.
- 2:20Vanessa Vakharia: And what happened next forced her to confront everything she thought she knew about learning, and ask whether our need to identify as the expert is actually stopping us from being the learners we keep asking our students to be.
- 2:33Vanessa Vakharia: I know you're already thinking of that teacher who tells every student they're a math person, or that friend who recoils every time you try to cheerlead them into a new identity.
- 2:40Vanessa Vakharia: So send them this episode right now, and let's get to it.
- 2:47Vanessa Vakharia: Theresa, welcome to the podcast.
- 2:49Teresa Brown: Oh, I'm thrilled to be here.
- 2:50Teresa Brown: Thank you so much for having me.
- 2:52Vanessa Vakharia: Well, it- we've started on a wild goose chase trying to find my lip gloss.
- 2:55Vanessa Vakharia: You've actually been very supportive.
- 2:56Vanessa Vakharia: I can see why you're a great teacher.
- 2:58Vanessa Vakharia: You never made me feel like, there was something, like, wrong with me for coming to the episode unprepared.
- 3:04Vanessa Vakharia: I appreciate it.
- 3:05Teresa Brown: No, and I wouldn't even consider it unprepared.
- 3:07Teresa Brown: We're all fully human.
- 3:08Teresa Brown: So I mean, we're just living every day one moment at a time.
- 3:11Vanessa Vakharia: Oh my God.
- 3:12Vanessa Vakharia: Okay, what a beautiful fall equinox reminder.
- 3:14Vanessa Vakharia: Now, usually I know a little more about the guests I'm interviewing, or I know them, But I, this is like a rare moment where I saw a LinkedIn post you wrote, and I read the LinkedIn post and was like,"I need to have a conversation with you, and we need to record it." So thank you for being down.
- 3:33Vanessa Vakharia: And I feel like we should just start there.
- 3:35Vanessa Vakharia: Like, what was this LinkedIn post about?
- 3:38Teresa Brown: I gave a bit of a controversial Ignite presentation at the Pennsylvania Council for Teachers of Mathematics annual conference in 2026 that everybody thought was titled I Am Totally a Math Person.
- 3:49Teresa Brown: It was actually called I Am Totally Not a Math
- 3:53Vanessa Vakharia: What?
- 3:53Vanessa Vakharia: Wait, hold on.
- 3:54Vanessa Vakharia: Why did everybody think it was titled that if it wasn't?
- 3:57Teresa Brown: I might have misled them to think that with the first slide, which did in fact start by saying that I'm totally a math person.
- 4:03Teresa Brown: it was kind of a bait and switch once I got going
- 4:06Vanessa Vakharia: and maybe like it's also a like we are seeing what we wanna see.
- 4:09Vanessa Vakharia: Like, do you know what I mean?
- 4:10Vanessa Vakharia: Like, they're just kind of like she must be saying she's totally a math person.
- 4:13Vanessa Vakharia: Okay, so you're up there, you're doing your Ignite.
- 4:16Vanessa Vakharia: It's called I'm Totally Not a Math Person, and we're starting with I totally am a math person, and what happens?
- 4:23Teresa Brown: So I like to remind folks of the position that we put our students in every day.
- 4:28Teresa Brown: I, I launched this Ignite, which at this point has been built out to a keynote, to say that every person has what it takes to be a nationally ranked powerlifter.
- 4:35Teresa Brown: Whether that means bench pressing one and a half times your body weight, squatting two and a half times your body weight, or deadlifting three, three and a half times your body weight.
- 4:44Teresa Brown: You just have to be willing to put in the work, you have to be willing to sit with the discomfort, and you have to be willing to make it a priority above everything else.
- 4:52Teresa Brown: A- and as you might imagine, when I tell people
- 4:54Vanessa Vakharia: Wait, I know.
- 4:56Vanessa Vakharia: Hold on.
- 4:56Teresa Brown: What?"
- 4:56Vanessa Vakharia: I am, I am.
- 4:58Vanessa Vakharia: I'm like, I wanna hear this through, but I am feeling some resistance.
- 5:02Vanessa Vakharia: But go- okay, keep going'cause I don't wanna interrupt you this early on.
- 5:06Teresa Brown: In
- 5:07Vanessa Vakharia: But I am like, I am like, is that true?
- 5:10Teresa Brown: It, well, so here's the thing.
- 5:12Vanessa Vakharia: Yeah, keep going
- 5:13Teresa Brown: people, everybody starts sitting there and they're like,"Okay, wait.
- 5:16Teresa Brown: I weigh, and so if I were to deadlift 3.5 times my body weight," and I can see the gears turning, and right away I kind of start seeing some folks kind of pumping the brakes.
- 5:25Teresa Brown: Because it's very easy for us to look at something like becoming a nationally ranked strength athlete and feel like, well, that's not the thing for me.
- 5:33Teresa Brown: That is so hard and that is so lofty a goal.
- 5:35Teresa Brown: That's somebody else.
- 5:37Teresa Brown: Somebody else has what it takes from the earliest of their upbringing to be that elite in their field.
- 5:44Teresa Brown: And instead, I like to pause and I, I remind everyone that that is the same sense of disbelief that our students feel when they're in our math classes.
- 5:53Teresa Brown: And, and I strongly believe this is true because I have been there.
- 5:57Teresa Brown: I have worked for years and then failed to set a national deadlifting record in my weight class, and I have failed math tests.
- 6:05Teresa Brown: And I am confident from my own lived experiences that there's a lot of similarities between those two things
- 6:13Vanessa Vakharia: okay, hold on, hold on, hold on.
- 6:15Vanessa Vakharia: So first, let's pause because am I getting...
- 6:18Vanessa Vakharia: You are a powerlifter, so you're coming at this, this isn't just like a hypothetical thing really.
- 6:23Vanessa Vakharia: Like, as you said, you've lived both.
- 6:25Vanessa Vakharia: You are a nationally ranked powerlifter.
- 6:27Vanessa Vakharia: Is that what you said?
- 6:27Vanessa Vakharia: I don't even know what this means.
- 6:29Vanessa Vakharia: I'm just repeating your words.
- 6:30Vanessa Vakharia: Okay, so that means, okay, I can, I can logic my way through what that means.
- 6:35Vanessa Vakharia: But okay, you, you have ranked in some way nationally with regards to powerlifting.
- 6:40Vanessa Vakharia: Okay, so this is really interesting because as soon as you started saying like,"Everybody w- has what it takes, la, la, la," I did the thing, and this is so funny'cause I know exactly what you're saying.
- 6:50Vanessa Vakharia: Math teachers will do this.
- 6:51Vanessa Vakharia: They'll be like,"Well, anyone can do math," but then they have their own limitations with regards to, like, what they can do, right?
- 6:57Vanessa Vakharia: And it's funny'cause I'm in a band, so with me, I will often hear educators be like,"Well, no, I can't sing." Like, it'll be like the thing they say.
- 7:03Vanessa Vakharia: Like,"Oh, I'm not a singer," like I don't...
- 7:05Vanessa Vakharia: "i'm tone deaf," like,"I can't hold a tune," and I'm always like, well, just like you said, we all can.
- 7:11Vanessa Vakharia: We're all...
- 7:13Vanessa Vakharia: But I think, and tell me, I don't know.
- 7:15Vanessa Vakharia: I feel like I'm getting my back up when you're saying that because I'm like, wait a second, we all have what it takes to be a powerlifter?
- 7:20Vanessa Vakharia: Like, doesn't some of this have to do with, like, our physical bodies?
- 7:24Vanessa Vakharia: Like, physical limitations?
- 7:27Vanessa Vakharia: In my mind, I'm like, well, hold on.
- 7:28Vanessa Vakharia: That's not the same as math because, like, anyone can do math because that's like a mental thing, but not anyone can be a powerlifter'cause that's a physical thing, and what if you're born like, I don't know, the wrong si- I don't, I don't know what powerlifting entails, actually
- 7:39Teresa Brown: Yeah.
- 7:39Teresa Brown: Okay, so a little bit of background.
- 7:41Teresa Brown: Powerlifting is a strength sport.
- 7:43Teresa Brown: A lot of people liken it to weightlifting.
- 7:45Teresa Brown: It has a similar attribute of lifting as much weight in a single repetition at each of three movements: a squat, a bench press, and a deadlift.
- 7:53Vanessa Vakharia: Oh
- 7:54Teresa Brown: putting a barbell on your back, squatting down so that your hip joint goes a little bit below the top of your knee, and standing back up, but you're doing that with the heaviest possible bar on your back it deals a lot with leverages.
- 8:04Teresa Brown: In fact, there's tons of math that we could play around with there.
- 8:07Teresa Brown: I, and I don't know that my idea and that analogy is so much to say that quite literally anyone could become a power, an, an, a nationally ranked powerlifter.
- 8:14Teresa Brown: Could you put in the work over years and decades to build the muscle fiber necessary to be able to do it?
- 8:20Teresa Brown: Sure, absolutely.
- 8:22Teresa Brown: M- my position is more in helping us to sit with the discomfort of, that our students are experiencing every day.
- 8:29Teresa Brown: it's so easy for us as teachers to say, I know how to do math.
- 8:34Teresa Brown: I know how to engage my students." And so we lose sense of what it is that our exper- our students are experiencing in their day-to-day of coming into our classes.
- 8:44Teresa Brown: And so what I want teachers to take away from that presentation that I give is not to say I can be a nationally ranked powerlifter, but that's a really lofty goal, and there shouldn't be anything stopping me from working toward it
- 8:58Vanessa Vakharia: Tell me if I'm getting this right.
- 8:59Vanessa Vakharia: You're basically saying to the teacher in the room or whoever is listening, you're like,"Yes, maybe you can't powerlift now," but if I were to say to you,"Well, everyone can be a powerlifter," that wouldn't make you feel any better about the fact that you can't currently powerlift because it doesn't change the fact that you have not t- up to this point been powerlifting, and now you are currently not as capable as me of powerlifting.
- 9:21Vanessa Vakharia: Am I right?
- 9:22Vanessa Vakharia: Like, just like we're saying, it's like if a student's like,"Well, I don't feel like a math person," us being like,"You are a math person, you can do it," is not making them feel any better about the fact that they currently do not feel that way.
- 9:34Teresa Brown: Right.
- 9:34Teresa Brown: And in essence, that was what my LinkedIn post that we had connected over was, getting to, is this idea that students who are coming to us with these apprehensions, with their sense of disbelief, and quite literally with lived experiences that have shown them that they weren't previously successful in math classes for a myriad of reasons, we tell them,"You are a math person," what we're saying in our language is a conflict of their identity.
- 10:01Teresa Brown: It's not to say that they aren't capable of it.
- 10:03Teresa Brown: It's not to say they couldn't work toward it, and it's certainly not to say that we don't think that they are capable, because we believe that they are capable.
- 10:10Teresa Brown: But the words that we are saying and the intent behind them do not actually match what is the outcome of telling students that statement.
- 10:20Vanessa Vakharia: Obviously we're not malintentioned, right?
- 10:22Vanessa Vakharia: We're doing it because we want them to feel included.
- 10:24Vanessa Vakharia: We wanna be like,"Yes, you can." We wanna be the cheerleader.
- 10:26Vanessa Vakharia: But in a sense, what you're saying is, when we say those words, we're almost invalidating their lived experience so often, and I don't think many of us think of it that way.
- 10:38Vanessa Vakharia: And I'm curious, let's talk through a little more why saying,"You're a math person," or, or even,"Everybody's a math person," any of those statements, in what ways that might actually be damaging.
- 10:51Vanessa Vakharia: I'm pretty big on what you just said, which was this idea of evidence, right?
- 10:57Vanessa Vakharia: Like, you're saying their evidence to this point in time has shown them that the statement you are yelling at them is not true.
- 11:05Vanessa Vakharia: I almost feel it's a bit gaslighty
- 11:08Teresa Brown: Yeah, and, and actually that's a, a term that I put directly into my presentation.
- 11:13Teresa Brown: so, as several of my friends work in the social work field, as you might imagine, education and social work are quite adjacent.
- 11:20Teresa Brown: So we commonly utilize a structure in helping people work through previous experiences called cognitive behavioral therapy.
- 11:28Teresa Brown: And, cognitive behavioral therapy, right, is not about taking a traumatic incident or a, a triggering situation and saying,"Oh, no, no, no.
- 11:37Teresa Brown: Oh, you're in a math class?
- 11:38Teresa Brown: No, you can do math.
- 11:39Teresa Brown: You will be successful.
- 11:40Teresa Brown: You are a math person," right?
- 11:42Teresa Brown: In any given circumstance, we would apply CBT by utilizing a neutral thought to slowly retrain the brain, to respond differently in the moment.
- 11:50Teresa Brown: And so I, I do think about that analogy quite commonly in the sense that it's essential that we help integrate our teaching practices to be more reflective of what we know to be true and how students learn, not just academically, but socially and emotionally as well.
- 12:05Vanessa Vakharia: Do you, can you give us an example?
- 12:07Vanessa Vakharia: It's funny, like CBT is all of Math Therapy, so that is my framework for everything I do because exactly what you said, I feel like I, I talk often about the term believe, behave, become, which, like, is from Joe Dispenza's work, and how he talks about how the belief, like just yelling a belief at someone or being like,"I want you to believe this thing," doesn't make it true, right?
- 12:27Vanessa Vakharia: Like, something that makes a belief true is behavior.
- 12:30Vanessa Vakharia: It's something physical.
- 12:31Vanessa Vakharia: It's something material.
- 12:32Vanessa Vakharia: It's having evidence, right?
- 12:34Vanessa Vakharia: Even if we think about faith and spirituality, when people have faith, it's usually because they have...
- 12:41Vanessa Vakharia: I mean, maybe this is a whole other thing.
- 12:42Vanessa Vakharia: I mean, there, there's the concept of blind faith, yes, but faith is strengthened when we, like, have an apparition or we feel like we've been spoken to by the creator or, like, we see a sign, right?
- 12:54Vanessa Vakharia: Like, we like to look for actual evidence that this belief is true.
- 12:58Vanessa Vakharia: So back to what you were saying, this idea of being like, well, you're a math person, without anything substantial behind it, doesn't really do anything.
- 13:06Vanessa Vakharia: It kind of feels hollow.
- 13:07Vanessa Vakharia: So I'm curious if you can, help us with that cognitive behavioral therapy.
- 13:10Vanessa Vakharia: What would it look like to pick a neutral thought in this circumstance?
- 13:14Teresa Brown: Oh, that is such a great question, and I don't think I've ever been asked anything like
- 13:17Vanessa Vakharia: Ooh.
- 13:18Vanessa Vakharia: Let's come up with it together'cause I actually don't know the answer
- 13:20Teresa Brown: So, I mean, part of it, I think, is situational, right?
- 13:23Teresa Brown: So I think the first thing we need to do is establish a context
- 13:25Vanessa Vakharia: Yes
- 13:26Teresa Brown: we would be faced with this decision to make and how we can help either from I, the teacher, supporting my students in retraining their experience, or I, the mathematics learner.
- 13:35Teresa Brown: So which, which angle do we wanna dive into, I the learner or I, the teacher?
- 13:40Vanessa Vakharia: Let's do I, the learner, because I actually feel like we focus a lot on educators helping their students, but I know we have so many listeners who then themselves feel like,"I'm not a math person." Right?
- 13:51Vanessa Vakharia: Like, do you know what I mean?
- 13:52Vanessa Vakharia: Let's do, let's do I, the learner.
- 13:53Vanessa Vakharia: So like, I, the learner, I come in, I don't think I'm a math person.
- 13:56Vanessa Vakharia: I'm teaching grade five math.
- 13:58Vanessa Vakharia: I'm doing it every day, but I still don't feel like a math person.
- 14:01Vanessa Vakharia: I still feel, like, so nervous every time I get in front of the classroom.
- 14:04Vanessa Vakharia: I feel like it's just a fluke that I'm getting through this, and like, I don't know what the fuck's going on.
- 14:09Teresa Brown: So I think my first step is to give myself some sort of mantra.
- 14:12Teresa Brown: In my case, I always remind myself that everything new is hard at first.
- 14:15Vanessa Vakharia: Uah
- 14:16Teresa Brown: So I, I, actually I had that plastered up on my classroom, and I haven't been in my own classroom now for five years, and I recently went back and I saw that it is still there.
- 14:24Teresa Brown: The teacher in the room has left it, so I'm thrilled.
- 14:27Teresa Brown: But I think a step back and saying,"What is something else that I'm learning to do in this moment?" So for me personally, I actually have it right next to me.
- 14:36Teresa Brown: I recently just got into doodling.
- 14:38Teresa Brown: Oh i've alwa- I- not at all ironically, you know, I'm not a math person.
- 14:42Teresa Brown: I've always said I'm not an artsy person either.
- 14:45Teresa Brown: and I recently have found that as a part of my recovery process So for anyone listening to this for the first time who's never met me before, I did have a stroke back in December of 2025, and it has reframed, much of my identity, much of my cognitive learning processes, and I've had to take a pause on my academic studies and continuing my dissertation.
- 15:03Teresa Brown: And instead, I've been finding new ways to kind of train my brain, and one of those for me has been doodling.
- 15:10Teresa Brown: And so getting back to where I was heading with this is that I can even snag one
- 15:13Vanessa Vakharia: We're gonna go back to that though.
- 15:15Vanessa Vakharia: I do wanna talk about it, but I want, I don't wanna interrupt mid-sentence because knowing us, we're then gonna go on a tangent and never come back.
- 15:21Vanessa Vakharia: So show us some doodles and tell us what's up.
- 15:23Vanessa Vakharia: Also, remember it's a podcast, so you have to describe what you're holding up to the screen.
- 15:27Teresa Brown: So, and I can't take credit for these as being original designs.
- 15:30Teresa Brown: I've been taking inspiration from, like, tutorials and things online.
- 15:34Teresa Brown: So I've got a style that I would consider kind of like hand sketch clip art-y.
- 15:38Vanessa Vakharia: I was gonna say, I was gonna say it looks like Canva clip art.
- 15:41Teresa Brown: Yeah.
- 15:42Teresa Brown: Yeah,
- 15:42Vanessa Vakharia: That's cute.
- 15:42Vanessa Vakharia: Okay, so what we're looking at is, like, an envelope with a little heart, like a love note.
- 15:46Vanessa Vakharia: We've got a bumblebee.
- 15:47Vanessa Vakharia: We've got a notepad.
- 15:49Vanessa Vakharia: We've got some daisies, and we've got another little flower with some buds.
- 15:52Vanessa Vakharia: The- you could be a tattoo artist.
- 15:54Vanessa Vakharia: These are actually very cute.
- 15:54Vanessa Vakharia: Oh! Oh my God.
- 15:55Vanessa Vakharia: Okay, now...
- 15:56Teresa Brown: I do love tattoos.
- 15:57Teresa Brown: So,
- 15:58Vanessa Vakharia: now, yes, go on
- 15:59Teresa Brown: so this is something that's brand new for me.
- 16:01Teresa Brown: And so coming into something
- 16:04Vanessa Vakharia: I love this
- 16:05Teresa Brown: it's so easy for me to say,"Why would I expect myself to be good at this?" I've never taken an art class in my life.
- 16:12Teresa Brown: I don't know any of the mediums.
- 16:14Teresa Brown: I don't know the textures that I'm working with with the papers.
- 16:16Teresa Brown: I have no idea what it has to do with the specific markers that I'm using.
- 16:20Teresa Brown: So why would I expect myself to be an expert at something that I've never taken the time to be formally trained in?
- 16:27Teresa Brown: And so if I take that attitude of, almost like radical acceptance into this newness of this is where I am in this moment, why couldn't or shouldn't I translate that into my academic work?
- 16:38Teresa Brown: Why would I expect myself to be an expert math teacher if I've never had the opportunity to develop my pedagogical content knowledge?
- 16:45Teresa Brown: Why would I expect myself to be a master at implementing low-floor, high-ceiling tasks, or at curiosity-building tasks if I've never had the opportunity to learn from experts, to learn from them as a learner myself, as a math student?
- 16:59Vanessa Vakharia: Okay, there's so many thoughts going around my head.
- 17:01Vanessa Vakharia: First of all, I think it is so TANC and synchronistic that you just pulled out a sketchbook because I started The Artist's Way a few months ago, and my- I've been like,"I need to get more into, like, a visual creative medium,"'cause it's something I used to love.
- 17:14Vanessa Vakharia: And I'm looking over my shoulder, like, at what I bought myself a month ago, which was, like, a set of watercolors and watercolor paper.
- 17:21Vanessa Vakharia: And I still have not dipped a brush in water.
- 17:24Vanessa Vakharia: Like, so you- you're moti- This is like, I'm glad you're here reminding me because I actually think tapping into our creativity of learning something new is exactly that.
- 17:32Vanessa Vakharia: It's beginner's mind.
- 17:33Vanessa Vakharia: Raj Sa- Shah talks about this all the time, of like, getting back into the seat of being a learner at something new and how that can help you relate to how your students feel about math.
- 17:42Vanessa Vakharia: So I love all of this, but it's making me think.
- 17:44Vanessa Vakharia: Like, I love what you just said there.
- 17:46Vanessa Vakharia: It's like, why would I expect myself to be an expert?
- 17:48Vanessa Vakharia: Like, I just started this thing.
- 17:50Vanessa Vakharia: And I wonder if there's, like this misconception that, like, well, I went to teachers college, and I'm an adult, so I should be able to do grade five math.
- 18:00Vanessa Vakharia: Like, we- remember that show, like, Are You Smarter Than a Fifth Grader?
- 18:03Vanessa Vakharia: Like, I guess a teacher isn't thinking,"I've received no training." Like, in their minds, they're like,"Well, I'm a grown-up.
- 18:10Vanessa Vakharia: I should be able to do this thing that little kids are doing." I don't know.
- 18:13Vanessa Vakharia: What do you think?
- 18:14Teresa Brown: my brain's kind of going right to the difference between content knowledge and co- and pedagogical
- 18:18Vanessa Vakharia: Yeah.
- 18:18Vanessa Vakharia: Okay
- 18:19Teresa Brown: right?
- 18:19Teresa Brown: We do have a distinct distance or difference between being able to solve a problem and get the answer versus richly understanding the concept, how it relates to, similar or different strategies, how it can be modeled in different ways, and how it progresses along a continuum of reasoning as opposed to just approaching a problem procedurally or algorithmically
- 18:41Vanessa Vakharia: I actually think you just, I just had such an aha moment thanks to you.
- 18:45Vanessa Vakharia: I think that's exactly it.
- 18:47Vanessa Vakharia: I think I want teachers listening to know that there is that difference, and the truth is that most of us adults in the field right now really never did get the training that you're talking about.
- 18:59Vanessa Vakharia: We, we did not learn math in the way that we are expected to teach our students.
- 19:04Vanessa Vakharia: We learned it procedurally or algorithmically.
- 19:07Vanessa Vakharia: We did not learn the deep thinking.
- 19:09Vanessa Vakharia: So, we probably had a PD here or there with it.
- 19:12Vanessa Vakharia: We certainly did not learn it in teacher's college, right?
- 19:15Vanessa Vakharia: So it's like, actually, you have probably not received the training, and I, I, but I, I actually think that's really important for everyone to hear, is that just because you are a teacher and you're a grown-up, you know what I mean?
- 19:27Vanessa Vakharia: Like, you're an adult and you're teaching, like, a grade five math, there's a very distinct difference between, like, knowing how to add and knowing how to teach adding in this deep layer-y, onion-y way.
- 19:37Vanessa Vakharia: And like, you have likely not received the training, so why the fuck should you be good at it?
- 19:41Vanessa Vakharia: You shouldn't.
- 19:42Vanessa Vakharia: You should be treating it how Theresa is treating her doodling.
- 19:46Vanessa Vakharia: And remember what the first thing you said was?
- 19:47Vanessa Vakharia: You're like,"Oh, I can't take credit.
- 19:49Vanessa Vakharia: I'm doing tutorials.
- 19:50Vanessa Vakharia: I'm copying other people's designs." Fuck yes, right?
- 19:53Vanessa Vakharia: That's how we can be approaching math.
- 19:55Vanessa Vakharia: Like, you don't have to invent the wheel.
- 19:57Vanessa Vakharia: You don't need to be good at it at first.
- 19:58Vanessa Vakharia: You just need to start messing around, talking to other...
- 20:01Vanessa Vakharia: Right?
- 20:01Vanessa Vakharia: Like, what do you think?
- 20:02Vanessa Vakharia: Are we working on a theory here?
- 20:03Vanessa Vakharia: I feel like we're building something.
- 20:05Teresa Brown: No, wholeheartedly.
- 20:06Teresa Brown: I- in fact, it's something that I've been developing a, a, a sort of side interest or passion in for some time, is this idea of teacher humility, um, where because our field and our profession feels so exposed, we feel as though everything that we're doing is being seen by our community, by our students.
- 20:23Teresa Brown: We really have a hard time giving ourselves permission to say,"I don't know," because we associate our identity as a teacher to say,"Well, I am a teacher.
- 20:32Teresa Brown: Therefore if there's something that I need to develop, it means that I have, like, a broken or a, a- or an issue with my identity," when really we know that isn't the truth.
- 20:40Teresa Brown: A- and a second thing that I kind of think about is how that changes over time.
- 20:45Teresa Brown: I- in my role, I get to work with teachers of all experience levels.
- 20:48Teresa Brown: Uh, I get to work with folks who are in their last years right before retirement, people who have been teaching for 15 years and transitioning to math maybe for the first time, or even new graduates who are in their very first math classroom.
- 21:01Teresa Brown: And amongst all these experience levels, I can see a distinct correlation.
- 21:06Teresa Brown: Of course, we know that, the aggregate of anecdote is not data.
- 21:10Teresa Brown: So just because I have a, a plethora of experiences with my own teaching staff, that does not necessarily translate to a legitimate statistical analysis.
- 21:18Teresa Brown: However, see that
- 21:21Vanessa Vakharia: That's good
- 21:21Teresa Brown: my teachers who are newly out of college have no problem stepping back and saying,"Whoa, whoa, whoa.
- 21:27Teresa Brown: I did not learn insert topic in undergrad." And we all s- tend to do that in retrospect.
- 21:33Teresa Brown: We can look back and while we did learn a lot, we have no problem looking back to say,"Ah, but in my insert topic methods course, in my math methods, in my science methods, I didn't learn structured literacy," if I'm teaching reading.
- 21:47Teresa Brown: "I didn't learn progressions of mathematical reasoning.
- 21:50Teresa Brown: I didn't learn specific modeling strategies." And it's interesting that I hear that so much from my, my new grads when they will say things like,"Oh, my math topics courses in undergrad were basically algebra one.
- 22:04Teresa Brown: I never had somebody show me or work with me to understand that an area model and a partial products notation and a standard algorithm are really showing the same mathematical concepts of decomposition, multiplying, and then putting the together." But as we get older, because of the, the external judgment, the internal pressure on ourselves, it gets harder to look at ourselves as a very highly accomplished professional in our field and say, I still have something to learn." Because that just
- 22:33Vanessa Vakharia: Oh, yeah.
- 22:34Teresa Brown: right?
- 22:34Teresa Brown: It
- 22:34Vanessa Vakharia: Oh my God.
- 22:36Teresa Brown: your soul
- 22:36Vanessa Vakharia: Yeah.
- 22:37Vanessa Vakharia: You're so right.
- 22:38Vanessa Vakharia: I'm even thinking about this, like, as a musician.
- 22:41Vanessa Vakharia: I'm thinking about this in, like, all walks of my life.
- 22:43Vanessa Vakharia: You're right.
- 22:44Vanessa Vakharia: I feel like we think there's, like, this, like, grace period or this honeymoon period where you're allowed to be, like, the new teacher or the new band member or the new ultimate Frisbee player.
- 22:55Vanessa Vakharia: Like, you're allowed, and you're, during that period, whatever, I feel like everyone's idea of when that period is is different, but whatever that period is, that's when you're allowed to ask questions and say,"I don't know." It's like being a new employee when you're training, right?
- 23:07Vanessa Vakharia: Like, during wh- while you're training, you're allowed to ask questions, but once you're, like, fully on the job, it's like you're expected to know everything, and I think you're so right.
- 23:15Vanessa Vakharia: I think that's probably one of the biggest, barriers to teachers embodying beginner's mind every day, if you ask a teacher, they would say a student is never too experienced to have a question, right?
- 23:29Vanessa Vakharia: Like, they're never supposed to know it all.
- 23:31Vanessa Vakharia: They're never, like, you know, we would never expect that of anyone.
- 23:33Vanessa Vakharia: But for ourselves, I think we do have that bar of, like, once X amount of time is over, then fuck, we better know every single thing, and you're right.
- 23:41Vanessa Vakharia: How do we break out of that?
- 23:44Vanessa Vakharia: Like, let's do, how do we do it right now?
- 23:45Vanessa Vakharia: Like, how do we let go of that?
- 23:47Vanessa Vakharia: Because that is a barrier to learning anything new.
- 23:50Teresa Brown: I, I wish, I wish that I knew.
- 23:53Teresa Brown: I, I, I find that when I work with teachers in, like, professional development settings, right, it makes it a little bit easier to have those little micro moments of vulnerability.
- 24:02Teresa Brown: So I strongly believe in the power of facilitating, like, professional learning circles, of having some type of consciously self-reflective, learning experience.
- 24:11Teresa Brown: So whether it's something like recording our lessons or using an AI instructional coaching tool, having something that allows us to feel vulnerability with ourselves, but really that's where it starts is self-awareness.
- 24:22Teresa Brown: And that is truly, like, as much as I love math teaching, I really have dove into my academic work and my professional work cente- centered around developing cultures for learning.
- 24:34Teresa Brown: So developing a classroom culture where students feel safe or they feel accepted, where they're willing to take risks because risk-taking is a key component to academic learning.
- 24:43Teresa Brown: And I recognize that that idea of emotional intelligence is important to foster in our classrooms, but it's also important for us as teachers.
- 24:51Teresa Brown: I know that it's a lot easier to step back and be introspective or be reflective upon myself and my abilities when I can be aware of my strong suits and recognize that I'm not gonna judge myself and I'm not worth less in any aspect just because I'm actively trying to develop some part of me to be better.
- 25:11Vanessa Vakharia: Well, yeah, and it's, like, almost the opposite, right?
- 25:13Vanessa Vakharia: Like, how could that not be such a noble, incredible thing to do for somebody to be like,"Oh, like, I could work on this, and I'm going to," as opposed to being like,"I am going to, to make sure I do not see any of the areas that I have to work on because I don't wanna feel a sense of la-" Right?
- 25:28Vanessa Vakharia: Like, it's like, so y- I mean, you were talking about creating cultures of belonging in the classroom and risk-taking, and I think it's pr- it's the exact same, right?
- 25:35Vanessa Vakharia: Like, I think what we are trying to do with our students is often what leaders wanna do with teachers.
- 25:39Vanessa Vakharia: Is there anything that you've come across that really works in terms of creating an atmosphere where it's okay for somebody in the class, whether it's an adult or a young person, to say,"Whoa, whoa, whoa, I actually don't know.
- 25:51Vanessa Vakharia: I don't get it"?
- 25:53Teresa Brown: I think it's just a matter of, of modeling it and help
- 25:55Vanessa Vakharia: Yeah
- 25:56Teresa Brown: that they are a part of it, too.
- 25:57Teresa Brown: I, I actually just had a teacher tell me, a, a couple of days ago, I was working in a, PLC that we were facilitating at our, at, at our central office, while we were doing a sort of thinking task where the I ask the teachers to tell me,"Well, how did you, how did you add that, and how did you subtract that?" One of the teachers gave a, a really out-of-the-box strategy that she had just kinda said,"Oh, I don't know.
- 26:17Teresa Brown: The numbers just seemed to say that this was the right way to solve this problem." And another teacher responded from across the room,"I never would've seen it that way.
- 26:24Teresa Brown: My brain just went right to the standard algorithm, and that's what I did." And the other teacher had remarked that,"I have to be honest, I never did until I was working with Theresa and I started to feel comfortable playing with numbers." And it was a cool little compliment, but for me, it just, the testament was that I, I had tried to create a circumstance where my teachers felt like they too could be vulnerable learners.
- 26:43Teresa Brown: But it's hard, right?
- 26:44Teresa Brown: Like, we know it takes ongoing conversation.
- 26:46Teresa Brown: It takes, sustained vulnerability on the part of everyone, and I strongly believe in modeling that as an instructional leader myself.
- 26:53Teresa Brown: I, I always tell teachers one of the first things they learn about me, of course, is that I didn't wanna be a math teacher in the first place.
- 26:59Teresa Brown: I made it there by accident, my whole area of expertise in curriculum and instruction blossomed from one of my students basically calling out my poor instruction.
- 27:09Teresa Brown: I'm just gonna put That's the best way that I
- 27:11Vanessa Vakharia: What did they say?
- 27:13Teresa Brown: So it, it wasn't anything direct, but it was my second year of teaching.
- 27:18Teresa Brown: I was teaching seventh grade proportions, and I still remember I could beat my students in experience.
- 27:22Teresa Brown: I knew all of the rules, right?
- 27:24Teresa Brown: I had the classroom engagement.
- 27:26Teresa Brown: Like, we were ready to go.
- 27:27Teresa Brown: They would fill in the blanks when I would do, like, a choral response.
- 27:30Teresa Brown: We would have chants to remember things.
- 27:33Teresa Brown: And so I went through a proportion.
- 27:34Teresa Brown: My students knew to draw the X, cross-multiply, divide both sides, and you're left with the, the missing component.
- 27:40Teresa Brown: And one of the students looks at me, he's like,"Mrs.
- 27:42Teresa Brown: Brown"
- 27:43Vanessa Vakharia: Oh my God
- 27:44Teresa Brown: That seems like a lot of work when can't I just multiply, whatever the circumstance was?
- 27:49Vanessa Vakharia: All right.
- 27:49Vanessa Vakharia: Yeah, yeah
- 27:50Teresa Brown: factor of two and a half.
- 27:51Teresa Brown: He's like,"Well, couldn't I just multiply the denominators by two and a half since that was the relationship at the top?" And remember looking at him and thinking I have no idea Genuinely, I didn't know, right?
- 28:03Teresa Brown: I didn't wanna be a math teacher, I developed my competency in math through rote memorization, and it served me well, right?
- 28:10Teresa Brown: I had no problem passing my practice certification exams, anything like that.
- 28:14Teresa Brown: But knowing content and facilitating meaningful discourse around develop mathematical reasoning are two vastly
- 28:23Vanessa Vakharia: Two different things, yeah
- 28:25Teresa Brown: is So coming back to where this started, is that in that moment, actually told him,"I don't know.
- 28:31Teresa Brown: I have no idea.
- 28:32Teresa Brown: Do me a favor.
- 28:33Teresa Brown: Solve every problem like that, and then we're gonna compare." So here I am.
- 28:37Teresa Brown: I've got two examples at the board.
- 28:39Teresa Brown: One is cross multiplication, and the other was showing my students either multiplication, if he could see the relationship between the two equivalent ratios, or working backwards through division and then multiplying.
- 28:50Teresa Brown: And I remember projecting them at the board, and we looked at it, and I stood side by side with my kids, and I was like,"All right, guys.
- 28:55Teresa Brown: What's the same here, and what's different?" And I remember I was just looking back and forth trying to figure it out.
- 29:00Teresa Brown: And of course, years later, I came across the same but different instructional routine, and that was when I started to have the realization of, huh, so it was actually that, that humility and vulnerability with my students that helped me to become more proficient as a math teacher, and it helped me to see the significance of it.
- 29:17Vanessa Vakharia: Well, and you know, it's funny'cause it's also that you took the time to be like,"Okay, you do this, and then we'll look together." Whereas I imagine many of us would be like,"Fuck, I don't, I don't know.
- 29:26Vanessa Vakharia: Like, we need to get through this lesson.
- 29:28Vanessa Vakharia: We just need to move on.
- 29:29Vanessa Vakharia: Just do it this way." And I just wanna say to anyone listening, like, I get why you're doing that.
- 29:33Vanessa Vakharia: Like, we get it, right?
- 29:34Vanessa Vakharia: Like, I assume, I imagine that many of the folks listening are like, I'm down to model mistakes.
- 29:39Vanessa Vakharia: Like, I don't have an ego.
- 29:41Vanessa Vakharia: Like, I'm okay with it." But there is this whole other part of, like, I think this comes from our own schooling of, like, getting in trouble when you have the wrong answer, right?
- 29:49Vanessa Vakharia: And feeling like you're supposed to know because, you know, everyone else knows it.
- 29:53Vanessa Vakharia: So, like, I just wanna give us grace to be like, those are very real feelings, and we need to unlearn that response in order to now adopt the response that you're very generously sharing with us.
- 30:04Vanessa Vakharia: But it's really hard to adopt a new response when you're still hanging on to the learned response you have from your own education.
- 30:10Vanessa Vakharia: So, like, we're trying to do two things here.
- 30:12Vanessa Vakharia: And you know, you said something a bit earlier that has really kind of stuck with me.
- 30:17Vanessa Vakharia: You said something, I can't remember exactly what it was, but you talked about, teachers having an identity of being a teacher and how that might conflict with the reality of not knowing something.
- 30:28Teresa Brown: Yeah
- 30:29Vanessa Vakharia: I thought that was really, really powerful because you were like, you know,"Teachers identify, with being like,'I'm a teacher, and if I'm a teacher, I'm supposed to teach.'" Like, it's almost like we've taken the learn out of the teacher, right?
- 30:39Vanessa Vakharia: A teacher is supposed to teach.
- 30:41Vanessa Vakharia: They can't possibly be supposed to also learn, right?
- 30:44Vanessa Vakharia: And I wonder how we reshape that identity, and I'm wondering Sorry, that's a very long-winded way of saying I'm wondering if you can talk us through how your identity around being a math learner and teacher changed after your stroke, because you had a lot of rebuilding to do, I imagine.
- 30:59Teresa Brown: Absolutely.
- 31:00Teresa Brown: A- and I think that I can kind of answer almost both of those questions in tandem.
- 31:04Teresa Brown: The,
- 31:04Vanessa Vakharia: Love that.
- 31:05Teresa Brown: As well as my personal lived experience, because they kind of hinge on an important lesson that I learned in a conversation with one of my good friends, Evelyn.
- 31:12Teresa Brown: she had shared this idea of identity and how often we associate our identity as what we do.
- 31:21Teresa Brown: Think about it, like, even when you were thinking about how to introduce me, the conversation became,"Well, what are you degree credentialed in?
- 31:26Teresa Brown: What is your past experience in, in your line of work, and what do you do now?" All of those things hinge upon what I do.
- 31:34Teresa Brown: I am a teacher.
- 31:36Teresa Brown: I am a curriculum specialist.
- 31:38Teresa Brown: I am a powerlifter.
- 31:39Teresa Brown: I am a strongman athlete.
- 31:41Teresa Brown: Those things are all fleeting, and they are all temporary.
- 31:44Teresa Brown: There's no given that when I wake up tomorrow, I will be in my position as a curriculum specialist.
- 31:49Teresa Brown: There, when I was in the classroom, it was never an assumption that I would wake up the next morning and have the capacity to teach, that never became more apparent than when I suffered a stroke back in December of 2025.
- 32:01Teresa Brown: Because when they administered the, essentially a cognitive reasoning test with a speech therapist, it was very apparent that I was struggling with short-term memory.
- 32:11Teresa Brown: So both in the sense of basic recall, they would say, you know,"I want you to remember three words," and it would be something like, I don't know, house, monkey, and mailbox.
- 32:22Teresa Brown: And we would just go into conversation, talk about some other things, and she would say,"Hey, do you remember those three things from the beginning?" No, I did not.
- 32:30Teresa Brown: Moving forward into this assessment, whenever we got to our first math problem, it was a word problem.
- 32:35Teresa Brown: I don't remember the context about it other than it was something like you were buying an item and you had this much money, how much was left over?
- 32:43Teresa Brown: It was a very small problem, and by the end of the question, I couldn't remember what was being asked, and when given the numbers, could not solve the problems anymore.
- 32:53Teresa Brown: I had the realization that I had acalculia.
- 32:55Teresa Brown: my ability to recall basic multiplication facts was literally gone.
- 32:59Teresa Brown: I,
- 33:00Vanessa Vakharia: Wait, is that, is that the definition?
- 33:02Vanessa Vakharia: What did you say it was called?
- 33:03Vanessa Vakharia: Acalculia?
- 33:04Vanessa Vakharia: What is that?
- 33:05Teresa Brown: so it is a, and I'm gonna give a terrible clinical definition, so
- 33:09Vanessa Vakharia: Okay.
- 33:09Teresa Brown: along the lines someone's gonna hear this and say,"Well, not quite."
- 33:12Vanessa Vakharia: No, that's
- 33:13Teresa Brown: it's essentially your ability to recall basic math facts and apply them in a problem-solving context.
- 33:19Teresa Brown: So multi-digit operations, and, and word problems as
- 33:23Vanessa Vakharia: Okay
- 33:24Teresa Brown: So for me, I kind of had a twofold issue.
- 33:27Teresa Brown: Well, threefold.
- 33:28Teresa Brown: Short-term memory, problem-solving, and then rote recall of facts.
- 33:32Teresa Brown: To this day, I still cannot just tell you my multiplication facts that I had memorized, aside from, what I now know to be foundational fact relationships, so doubles, squares, 10s, 5s, and then working relationally from those.
- 33:46Teresa Brown: I no longer can just pull them from memory.
- 33:48Teresa Brown: I have to work to it in about five or six seconds
- 33:50Vanessa Vakharia: Okay, one second.
- 33:51Vanessa Vakharia: You're saying so many really important things, and I wanna br- I wanna break them down a bit because I feel like there's a lot of depth to them.
- 33:58Vanessa Vakharia: What you just said right there, you said you cannot recall basic facts from memory, but then what did you just say after?
- 34:06Vanessa Vakharia: Aside from foundational working...
- 34:07Vanessa Vakharia: w-
- 34:08Teresa Brown: right?
- 34:08Teresa Brown: And, and
- 34:09Vanessa Vakharia: what's the difference there?
- 34:10Vanessa Vakharia: What does that mean?
- 34:11Teresa Brown: So, that's pulling from the work of Jennifer Bay-Williams and, apologies that I can't recall h- the other person who I know is associated with the texts and the books.
- 34:21Vanessa Vakharia: No worries
- 34:21Teresa Brown: but basically this idea that when we're solving multiplication facts, if we can master foundational facts, we can use those relationally to identify others.
- 34:31Teresa Brown: So for example, I know 5 times 5 is 25, so if I need to multiply 5 times 6, I really just have one more 5, so therefore it's 30.
- 34:39Teresa Brown: So I use that relational idea when I'm solving any of my facts that I'm now working with in 6s, 7s, 8s.
- 34:46Teresa Brown: I've started to get my 3s back, though.
- 34:48Teresa Brown: We can all celebrate on that one.
- 34:49Vanessa Vakharia: Yay.
- 34:50Vanessa Vakharia: So wait, is a, is a foundational fact any fact, or are there certain ones that are called foundational facts?
- 34:55Vanessa Vakharia: Or are you just saying a foundational fact is, like, a fact that you build a foundation on?
- 34:59Vanessa Vakharia: So right now it's fives because we're now building around the fact that you know your fives, or is there, like, are there certain facts that are called foundational facts?
- 35:07Teresa Brown: I- in my language, I have mine that are foundational,
- 35:09Vanessa Vakharia: Oh
- 35:10Teresa Brown: the literature, there are clearly identified foundational facts.
- 35:13Vanessa Vakharia: Oh.
- 35:14Teresa Brown: and, and I, I know somebody
- 35:16Vanessa Vakharia: We'll look it up.
- 35:16Teresa Brown: the
- 35:17Vanessa Vakharia: Dave,
- 35:17Teresa Brown: if
- 35:18Vanessa Vakharia: go look it up.
- 35:19Vanessa Vakharia: Producer.
- 35:20Teresa Brown: it should be one to
- 35:22Vanessa Vakharia: Five and 10
- 35:23Teresa Brown: I think it's one, two, and 10 because five is half of
- 35:26Vanessa Vakharia: As half of 10.
- 35:27Vanessa Vakharia: Okay, cool.
- 35:28Vanessa Vakharia: So we're gonna fact-check this.
- 35:29Vanessa Vakharia: You're saying you knew some foundational facts, and then you would build on those.
- 35:35Vanessa Vakharia: Like your example with you knew five times five was twenty-five, so five times six would just be an additional five, and you would add on to there.
- 35:42Vanessa Vakharia: But after your stroke, you lost access to the memorization of the entire, all of the facts.
- 35:47Teresa Brown: Now, I did still retain my doubles.
- 35:49Teresa Brown: So doubles for me are very visual and tens are a place value shift.
- 35:53Teresa Brown: So I was able to effectively operationalize everything from there.
- 35:57Teresa Brown: So that was a nice little saving grace.
- 35:59Teresa Brown: but again, it was all because I was highly visual.
- 36:01Teresa Brown: I- if I'm being totally transparent with you, when I was teaching seventh grade math, I had developed the pedagogical content knowledge to think in terms of visualizing those skills, right, that I was teaching to my students.
- 36:14Teresa Brown: I had not developed quite a wide arsenal of understanding as I have now as a curriculum specialist since I work with grades K to 12.
- 36:23Teresa Brown: So I am curious to know how I would've been impacted had this happened while I was still in the classroom, because I don't know that I would've been equipped with the tools to regain my multiplication fluency as I have
- 36:35Vanessa Vakharia: Oh my God, this is so crazy.
- 36:36Vanessa Vakharia: So okay, so when's this happen?
- 36:38Vanessa Vakharia: I'm curious, I'm like, I'm tr- like, where did we start this?
- 36:41Vanessa Vakharia: We were talking about identity.
- 36:42Vanessa Vakharia: So I'm curious, like, what were you like, like, I mean, it's actually kinda interesting because you didn't identify as a math person in the first place, so,
- 36:50Teresa Brown: Yep,
- 36:50Vanessa Vakharia: so what happened?
- 36:51Teresa Brown: Especially not now.
- 36:52Teresa Brown: Well, so I sat in occupational therapy.
- 36:54Teresa Brown: I still remember this day like it was yesterday because I had a worksheet that I was trying to solve, a long division problem with decimals, and I just started sobbing.
- 37:03Teresa Brown: I was alone at this table.
- 37:04Teresa Brown: I still remember seeing the snow falling outside because it was right before Christmas.
- 37:08Vanessa Vakharia: Oh my God
- 37:08Teresa Brown: one of the occupational therapists, so sweet, came over and was like,"Honey, it's okay.
- 37:12Teresa Brown: Like, you can just use a calculator if you need to in life." And, like, I just
- 37:16Vanessa Vakharia: True
- 37:17Teresa Brown: like You don't understand what I do for a living! I was like,"I am a math teacher educator." And it was in that moment that it kind of spurred this realization that, well, why would I try to regain my understanding and work through this in any way other than the way that I support my students and the way that I support my teachers in supporting their students?
- 37:37Vanessa Vakharia: Which means what?
- 37:39Teresa Brown: Well, it became a part of my, speech therapy sessions where we would sit down and work on solving multiplication problems by progressing through a continuum of abstraction from concrete to pictorial representative into abstract, and then eventually progressing through different, strategies as well.
- 37:57Teresa Brown: And it was a long process and a sticky process.
- 38:00Teresa Brown: But this ultimately brings us back to kind of where this story started, was this idea of identity lesson learned.
- 38:08Teresa Brown: I still remember placing so much pressure on myself that this is, this is, this is who I am.
- 38:15Teresa Brown: I am a math teacher.
- 38:16Teresa Brown: I am a curriculum specialist.
- 38:18Teresa Brown: But I had to catch myself.
- 38:20Teresa Brown: I was like,"No, that's not I am.
- 38:23Teresa Brown: That's what I do." I am as a person, I, I am a service-oriented person.
- 38:28Teresa Brown: I love supporting others.
- 38:29Teresa Brown: Um, I, I am a wife.
- 38:31Teresa Brown: I am a sister.
- 38:32Teresa Brown: I am an aunt.
- 38:33Teresa Brown: I am an avid dog lover.
- 38:35Teresa Brown: I am someone who loves being outside in the outdoors and feeling my, my toes dig into the soft grass on a warm summer day and feeling grounded to nature.
- 38:45Teresa Brown: Those things are who I am in all situations, all circumstances.
- 38:49Teresa Brown: Who I am as a teacher is a temporary identity, and realizing that in that moment I didn't know if I was gonna get it back.
- 38:57Teresa Brown: Truly, when I was in the hospital, I had no idea of whether I would be able to do my job again.
- 39:02Teresa Brown: I didn't know if I would ever be able to finish my research, if I'd be able to write up my findings, or if the data that I collected would just become lost to the world.
- 39:12Teresa Brown: And but there's a sort of peace in that, right?
- 39:13Teresa Brown: Because the pressure doesn't to me mean that I have to accomplish any of those things.
- 39:19Teresa Brown: It's, it's a matter of working toward it, and I get to.
- 39:21Teresa Brown: Because at the root of it, I am still me.
- 39:23Teresa Brown: I am still the type of person that I believe in being at least somewhat vulnerable.
- 39:28Teresa Brown: I, I'm the type of person that I believe in owning my mistakes and my shortcomings and continuously working through them.
- 39:34Teresa Brown: And so I hope that that's making sense outside of my own head, but it's, it's about this identity shift, right?
- 39:39Teresa Brown: And it was in that moment of having my stroke and realizing that I didn't know if I would get my career back that I was able to come to this peace with this is where I am right now, and if I wanna be anywhere else, I just have to work for it.
- 39:53Vanessa Vakharia: Yeah.
- 39:53Vanessa Vakharia: Wow, that's so powerful.
- 39:57Vanessa Vakharia: This identity of,"I am a teacher," perhaps the whole secret is that w- we separate the word teacher from the career of being a teacher, right?
- 40:08Vanessa Vakharia: Because, like, I'm thinking about you and being like, you know, I love acts of service and I love this and that, and it's like you are...
- 40:15Vanessa Vakharia: Like, a core part of your identity is serving others and learning and imparting wisdom, and, like, you are through and through a teacher whether or not you are working in the classroom.
- 40:28Vanessa Vakharia: And if we look at it like that way, and I'm thinking for, like, those listening, it's like, you know how they say, like, whatever that Instagram meme is, that it's like teach- being a teacher is a calling, not a profession?
- 40:39Vanessa Vakharia: Like, have you seen that sticker?
- 40:41Vanessa Vakharia: Right, right?
- 40:42Vanessa Vakharia: Like, so many of us are teachers because we genuinely love to help others, and, like, teachers are healers, and we like all this.
- 40:48Vanessa Vakharia: So it's like if we take out the, like, fear around being like,"But if I'm a teacher at the front of the room getting paid, I need to know the answer," to,"But what do teachers do?" Great teachers learn.
- 40:59Vanessa Vakharia: Great teachers admit they don't know.
- 41:00Vanessa Vakharia: Then it's almost like there is no identity sacrifice to admit you don't know.
- 41:05Vanessa Vakharia: I want everyone listening to actually think, I want you guys to text us.
- 41:09Vanessa Vakharia: Okay?
- 41:09Vanessa Vakharia: Text the podcast.
- 41:10Vanessa Vakharia: There's a link in your show notes.
- 41:12Vanessa Vakharia: I wanna know what your, your id- like, what your definition of being a teacher means.
- 41:18Vanessa Vakharia: What does it mean to be a teacher?
- 41:21Vanessa Vakharia: What characteristics go along with that?
- 41:23Vanessa Vakharia: What words would you use to describe it?
- 41:26Vanessa Vakharia: What physical, mental, emotional, spiritual attributes, like anything, like anything you can send us,'cause I kind of, this is such a fascinating question because actually, oh my God, Theresa, are you ready for me to full circle this in, like, the best...
- 41:38Vanessa Vakharia: Okay, are you ready?
- 41:39Teresa Brown: it back
- 41:39Vanessa Vakharia: Okay, because I, I'm like, we're way...
- 41:41Vanessa Vakharia: Like, I mean, I, I just wanna talk to you for another hour, but I do have to somehow close this, and I still have 40 things to ask, but watch this move I'm gonna do.
- 41:48Teresa Brown: I'm so ready.
- 41:49Vanessa Vakharia: Okay, so I'm like, I want everyone to text us about what it means to be a teacher because this almost circles us back to how we started, which was the question: What does it even mean to be a math person, right?
- 42:00Vanessa Vakharia: Like,
- 42:01Teresa Brown: there it is.
- 42:02Vanessa Vakharia: did you like it?
- 42:03Teresa Brown: I love it I always think about,'cause, like, this is something that I've sat with s- for so many hours and in so many informal and formal conversational spaces, that our definition of what it means to be a math person within the math education space, or within just education in general, often feels so different from the way society interprets Like, we often say in math ed, and I hear people say it all the time, that there's no other field that people have no problem saying,"I'm not a person." Like, we always say,"Nobody says I'm not a reader." actually disagree.
- 42:35Teresa Brown: I hear people say all the,
- 42:35Vanessa Vakharia: That's not true.
- 42:36Teresa Brown: the
- 42:37Vanessa Vakharia: All
- 42:37Teresa Brown: to read
- 42:38Vanessa Vakharia: the time
- 42:38Teresa Brown: people say,"I'm not an artsy person." And then of course my claim to fame is people always say,"I'm not a gym person." But you don't have to be a gym person to lift weights, and you don't have to be a math person to math.
- 42:50Vanessa Vakharia: Okay, so I wanna r- I wanna close on this, because it's so funny.
- 42:54Vanessa Vakharia: I was like, that's, that's actually what I wanted to talk to you about, but our conversation went in so many directions, but it all ties together because it is this idea of identity, actually.
- 43:02Vanessa Vakharia: I actually think that's what we're kinda hitting on, and I actually think by yelling you're a math person, you're disrespecting somebody's identity that they've created and honed, right?
- 43:11Vanessa Vakharia: You're kind of trying to put something else on them, and it's funny, like, I was actually on the Debate Math Podcast debating this exact thing with Chris Noe.
- 43:18Vanessa Vakharia: Chris Luzniak's and Rob Bayer's Debate Math Podcast, talking about this, and I argued for the fact that we should stop using the term math person.
- 43:25Vanessa Vakharia: I was like,"I'm over it.
- 43:25Vanessa Vakharia: I'm gonna stop saying it." It's, I actually think it's really the same thing as you.
- 43:29Vanessa Vakharia: I think it's really invalidating.
- 43:31Vanessa Vakharia: Okay, by the way, though, if you're listening and you're telling people you're a math person, like, go ahead.
- 43:34Vanessa Vakharia: I don't think you're a bad person or anything.
- 43:35Vanessa Vakharia: It's just a personal stance I'm taking.
- 43:37Vanessa Vakharia: Okay, but back to what you were saying, this i- you, you just said you don't have to be a math person to do math.
- 43:45Vanessa Vakharia: You also said, I think in la- that LinkedIn post, you were like,"It doesn't need to be fun, and it doesn't need to be easy.
- 43:51Vanessa Vakharia: It can be difficult, and you can still do it." Can you, can you give us a little bit of that?
- 43:55Vanessa Vakharia: Because I actually think we've gotten really, like, caught up in math ed of being like,"We have to make it fun for everyone, and the joy, and everyone needs to..." Like, it needs to be, like, you know, like, everyone needs to feel so good.
- 44:07Vanessa Vakharia: As a powerlifter, sorry, this is a term I'm now just using.
- 44:10Vanessa Vakharia: I j- I am just learning what it is.
- 44:12Vanessa Vakharia: Like, you are making me think.
- 44:13Vanessa Vakharia: It's not like I go to the gym and I'm like,"This is gonna be really fun." I do not think that, but I do it anyways, and I am proud of myself after.
- 44:23Vanessa Vakharia: It must be the same thing, no?
- 44:25Teresa Brown: I would think it is pretty much the same.
- 44:27Teresa Brown: and so let's go back to that first part of your
- 44:29Vanessa Vakharia: Okay, yeah
- 44:31Teresa Brown: kind of unpacking this idea that you don't have to be a, a math person to math.
- 44:35Teresa Brown: So when I think about this idea of doing math while not identifying as a math person, the first thing that kind of comes to mind is this idea that we have, like you said, so many people, and, and I appreciate it, who are so entranced by the beauty of mathematics.
- 44:50Teresa Brown: love that for them,
- 44:52Vanessa Vakharia: Great
- 44:52Teresa Brown: and I always love to wonder, do you feel that same way about my love of picking up a heavy barbell that takes so much strain on my body that I quite literally fry my nervous system?
- 45:03Teresa Brown: Or
- 45:03Vanessa Vakharia: Damn, what?
- 45:04Teresa Brown: Feel...
- 45:05Teresa Brown: Oh, I love it.
- 45:06Teresa Brown: do you feel the peace and grounded-ness of the earth whenever you are walking barefoot and meditating, listening only to the sounds of the cicadas and the birds and the sway of the corn in the cornfield next to you?
- 45:18Teresa Brown: Right?
- 45:18Teresa Brown: Across every discipline, we have folks who are so deeply passionate about their field that all they want and long for is for everyone to see and understand the significance of that field, right?
- 45:29Teresa Brown: If I'm talking about historians who are exploring the, similarities and differences between how history once was and to the characteristics of today, if I'm looking at someone who's studying, like, the semantics of the English language or, somebody who's a linguist who understands, like, the shifting in terminology that we use.
- 45:47Vanessa Vakharia: Or like those history buffs.
- 45:49Vanessa Vakharia: Like, do you know what I mean?
- 45:50Vanessa Vakharia: Like, those history buffs that are like,"The Civil War," and I'm always like,"Ugh, I don't care." Like, you know what I mean?
- 45:55Teresa Brown: and there is so much beauty and validity to all of those
- 45:58Vanessa Vakharia: Sure, yeah
- 45:59Teresa Brown: you imagine a world where you feel personally responsible for having such a liberal perspective on the world, like, like a, like a liberal, education in terms of curriculum development, right?
- 46:09Teresa Brown: You wanna see and understand so much that you feel pressured to be a master in all of it.
- 46:14Vanessa Vakharia: No, my god.
- 46:15Vanessa Vakharia: And also be- I'm exhausted.
- 46:17Vanessa Vakharia: No, I'm tired.
- 46:18Vanessa Vakharia: I honestly need a nap.
- 46:19Vanessa Vakharia: I don't like it.
- 46:20Vanessa Vakharia: You're right
- 46:20Teresa Brown: the way that I see some folks who just truly look at the world around them, and they're intrigued by, by a math problem, and they just start to wonder, like,"Oh, wait." understanding some sort of pattern.
- 46:29Teresa Brown: That joy and love is the same joy and love I feel when I'm pushing myself through a workout.
- 46:34Teresa Brown: My heart rate is through the roof.
- 46:35Teresa Brown: I am dripping in sweat, and I don't know if I can do one more rep.
- 46:39Teresa Brown: I think it's okay for math to feel that way because where math might be somebody's thing where they just don't love it, something else out there that they are equally or perhaps even more so in love with, that they're able to, um, envelop in all parts of their lives.
- 46:54Vanessa Vakharia: I completely am with you.
- 46:56Vanessa Vakharia: I think I would put in, not a caveat, but, like, an important piece, which is, like, I do feel that, w- there's power in saying not everyone needs to love it, but we also want everyone to feel like they have the opportunity to do it regardless.
- 47:12Vanessa Vakharia: And I think that's maybe a bit of it, right?
- 47:14Vanessa Vakharia: Like, it's like, I think with you too, like, you're like,"You don't need to love powerlifting," but, like, you kinda started it that way by being like,"You could do it if you want.
- 47:21Vanessa Vakharia: I just want you to know you could do it if you want." And I think that almost is the heart of the entire discussion is, like, we just want people to know you can do it if you want to, but doing it or wanting to do it does not, have to equate to you being a person who loves it or identifies as a math person, or, like...
- 47:40Vanessa Vakharia: You know what I mean?
- 47:41Vanessa Vakharia: Like, it's like I, I'm not identifying as an athlete or a powerlifter.
- 47:44Vanessa Vakharia: I go to the gym three times a week because I know it's good for me.
- 47:47Vanessa Vakharia: I feel good about myself after.
- 47:49Vanessa Vakharia: Like, you know what I mean?
- 47:50Vanessa Vakharia: So and so, whatever.
- 47:51Vanessa Vakharia: But, like, I'm not like,"Oh yeah, I'm a fucking athlete." I'm like,"No, I don't, honestly don't really like it, but, like, I feel better about myself when I do it." And maybe that's the invitation is, like, you don't have to love math.
- 48:02Vanessa Vakharia: We would love our stu- I would love everyone to know, hey, if you wanna learn math, you can.
- 48:08Vanessa Vakharia: That's kind of where I'm at.
- 48:09Vanessa Vakharia: I'm like, you can if you want to.
- 48:11Vanessa Vakharia: I just don't want anyone thinking, like, they are born without the capacity to do it.
- 48:17Teresa Brown: Yes, I love that.
- 48:18Teresa Brown: A- and I think that that kind of ties the bow on it quite nicely is this idea that we can simultaneously believe that somebody doesn't have to love math to be successful in it while still actively taking the stance of,"But I'm gonna do everything in my power to still get you to love it, to make you feel comfortable in my class, and make you think that it's possible."
- 48:35Vanessa Vakharia: Oh my God.
- 48:39Vanessa Vakharia: That was fucking good.
- 48:40Vanessa Vakharia: That was, I was, that, that was, there, done.
- 48:42Vanessa Vakharia: We're done.
- 48:43Vanessa Vakharia: We're, except, except, I mean, I, w- I have to ask you the two questions I ask everyone, but now one of them's gonna be kinda weird.
- 48:48Vanessa Vakharia: the first question is, I normally ask,"So what would you say?" And I am actually curious, so what do we say?
- 48:55Vanessa Vakharia: What is the appropriate response when someone says,"Cool story, I'm just, I don't, forget it, I'm just not a math person"?
- 49:01Vanessa Vakharia: What's a response you would like us to consider saying?
- 49:04Teresa Brown: my instinct says, and, and this is the teacher in me, I'm just curious why.
- 49:09Teresa Brown: Like, where does, where does your love fall?
- 49:11Teresa Brown: Like, what is the thing that you enjoy, and what experiences got you to feel that way?
- 49:15Vanessa Vakharia: Girl, we are vibing because that, this is my new thing.
- 49:20Vanessa Vakharia: Over the past few years, I've been like, I actually think there's no response from me.
- 49:24Vanessa Vakharia: On my end, we don't, I don't respond, I ask.
- 49:26Vanessa Vakharia: I'm just like,"Oh, how come?" Wow.
- 49:28Vanessa Vakharia: We are syncing so hard for never having met before.
- 49:31Vanessa Vakharia: Great.
- 49:31Vanessa Vakharia: Okay, last question.
- 49:33Vanessa Vakharia: If there's one thing you could change about the way math is taught in schools, what would it be?
- 49:36Teresa Brown: okay, if I had to choose one answer, one thing that I wish we could change about education, it would be this idea of operating in isolation or in silos.
- 49:45Teresa Brown: I see so often our teacher prep programs, our continuing professional developments, and then the actual active instructional practice are so disjointed from one another, when really we have three systems working for the same goal, just the right hand doesn't know what the left hand is doing
- 49:59Vanessa Vakharia: I love how you're like,"I don't know.
- 50:01Vanessa Vakharia: I have nothing prepped," and then you just said the most perfect, like, well-articulated response.
- 50:07Vanessa Vakharia: Are you, is this a hustle?
- 50:09Vanessa Vakharia: Are you bluffing?
- 50:10Vanessa Vakharia: Did you have that written down?
- 50:12Teresa Brown: Oh no, I truly was just thinking that.
- 50:16Vanessa Vakharia: You are honestly incredible.
- 50:18Vanessa Vakharia: You're so inspire- I'm so glad- Social media's, like, the worst until it's not.
- 50:22Vanessa Vakharia: Like, I'm so glad I saw that post.
- 50:24Vanessa Vakharia: Like, I'm so inspired by so much of what you said, and I, I'm really leaving thinking a lot about that concept of identity and how it can be, you know, our attachment to, to an identity can be such a, a barrier, you know?
- 50:37Vanessa Vakharia: And when we, like, loosen that grasp, it, it really goes back to the stories we tell ourselves, and I'm, I'm excited for everyone to think about this.
- 50:44Vanessa Vakharia: And guys, I want you to text us.
- 50:46Vanessa Vakharia: We are looking at the texts.
- 50:47Vanessa Vakharia: Hit the link in the show notes.
- 50:49Vanessa Vakharia: Text us.
- 50:49Vanessa Vakharia: What does it mean to be a teacher?
- 50:51Vanessa Vakharia: Did this episode make you change your mind at all?
- 50:53Vanessa Vakharia: Thank you so much for being on the podcast.
- 50:55Teresa Brown: This was great.
- 50:56Teresa Brown: I, I appreciate you.
- 50:57Teresa Brown: I, I truly am so thrilled to get to meet you.
- 50:59Vanessa Vakharia: Me too
- 51:01Teresa Brown: The myriad of times that I've come across your work on, in so many different avenues, I'm constantly looking, like,"I don't know what it is exactly, but I like her."
- 51:09Vanessa Vakharia: Aww
- 51:10Teresa Brown: I was super thrilled whenever you reached out to me, and I'm so glad I got to do this, so thank you.
- 51:14Vanessa Vakharia: Thank you so much for coming on the pod.
- 51:16Vanessa Vakharia: It was so inspiring.
- 51:17Vanessa Vakharia: I'm so happy I found that LinkedIn post, and goodbye.
- 51:22Teresa Brown: Vanessa, it has been such a joy to share all my experience with you.
- 51:25Teresa Brown: Thanks for having me on the show.
- 51:27Teresa Brown: Bye everyone.
- 51:31Vanessa Vakharia: Okay, wow.
- 51:32Vanessa Vakharia: I just want you guys to know that after the official recording part ended, Theresa made me feel so much better about my disdain for jump squats, and literally was like,"Who cares?
- 51:41Vanessa Vakharia: Just do the workout stuff that you like." And I felt instantly relieved.
- 51:45Vanessa Vakharia: Like, there are so many other gym things I like doing.
- 51:48Vanessa Vakharia: Why do I feel like I need to do the things I hate in order to be, quote-unquote,"healthy"?
- 51:52Vanessa Vakharia: And this, my friends, ties into our whole convo about math and identity, and feeling like we're never there until we can do it all, and that's just unrealistic and, quite frankly, unnecessary.
- 52:02Vanessa Vakharia: I do also wanna say that I think there's a bit of a difference on how we approach the idea of choosing to do math or not, depending on whether we're talking about kids and adults.
- 52:10Vanessa Vakharia: When you're a kid in school, there needs to be a healthy balance of, as Theresa said, not loving it, but doing it anyway'cause it's good for you.
- 52:17Vanessa Vakharia: And I think as teachers, we can facilitate that.
- 52:19Vanessa Vakharia: But as adults, I think it's reasonable and appropriate to be like,"I tried it, I don't like it, and I'm not doing any more fucking jump squats".
- 52:26Vanessa Vakharia: Or algebra.
- 52:27Vanessa Vakharia: The two are interchangeable for the purposes of this conversation I'm dying to hear what you think, and Theresa and I really wanna hear from you, so text the podcast by hitting the link in your show notes that says,"Text us".
- 52:37Vanessa Vakharia: Math Therapy's hosted by me, Vanessa Vakharia, produced by David Kochberg, and the theme music is by our band, Goodnight Sunrise.
- 52:43Vanessa Vakharia: As always, thank you guys so much for listening, sharing, and being a part of the community.
- 52:47Vanessa Vakharia: If you want more Math Therapy, join our Facebook group.
- 52:50Vanessa Vakharia: We have over 500 amazing members.
- 52:52Vanessa Vakharia: Just hit the link in the show notes to join, and see you next week.
- 52:55Vanessa Vakharia: It's gonna be amazing.