Latest / Common Sense Rankings Podcast / CSR Podcast #18: Week 5 Recap, another AP Poll audit and biggest Week 6 games
Transcript
- 0:12Hello and welcome to another episode of the Common Sense Rankings podcast, where we rank the resume, not the expectation.
- 0:19This is episode number 18.
- 0:21I'll be recapping the week five's on-the-field results, how they impact the Common Sense rankings.
- 0:27I'll assess the AP poll and where they may have left some to be desired, and we'll look at the highest leverage games of week number six.
- 0:35In week five, 115 FBS teams took the field as 23 teams took their bye this season.
- 0:41That included Texas, the number one team in both the AP poll and in the CSR, and a total of five of last week's top 25, guaranteeing those teams a drop in the rankings.
- 0:51At the CSR, we look at the totality of the resume, so in most cases, five and O is going to look a lot better than four and O, giving a slight advantage in the weekly rankings to teams taking a bye later in the season.
- 1:03Just three teams played an FCS school, including ranked LSU, leaving us 56 matchups between FBS programs.
- 1:12There were three games that could impact conference head-to-head superiority in week five.
- 1:17First, Kansas obliterated Middle Tennessee Saturday afternoon, solidifying the Big Twelve's head-to-head record over the Conference USA this season at two wins, zero losses.
- 1:27The American Conference had been two and O against the Mountain West until Saturday when Air Force took down Navy in the first battle between service academies.
- 1:35While the American Conference is still up two to one on the Mountain West, Army's game with Air Force later in the season is now crucial as it could lower the American Conference in the eyes of the common sense rankings.
- 1:47The third high leverage game of the week had a major impact on our conference strength.
- 1:52The California Golden Bears of the ACC fell on the road to the UNLV Runnin' Rebels of the Mountain West.
- 1:58That put the season series between the two conferences at one and one.
- 2:02Since the ACC cannot now claim they were better on the field than the Mountain West, they drop a bit in the CSR behind the Big Twelve and will remain fourth in the conference rankings if the Big Twelve can win their remaining non-conference matchups.
- 2:16There will be college football fans, and more specifically ACC fans, that will claim it was on the road, and I wanna give the Golden Bears their due for being willing to go to a group of six stadium.
- 2:26But the common sense rankings does not look at the location of the game.
- 2:30If California were a better team, they should have won the game.
- 2:35We had three ranked CSR matchups on the field in week five.
- 2:39The first was between number two Mississippi State playing host to number three Alabama.
- 2:44Unfortunately for the Bulldogs, they couldn't keep pace with the Tide losing big in Starkville.
- 2:49The CSR does not take into account margin of victory, but the Tide will still move up to number one in this week's CSR.
- 2:57CSR number eight Miami had a similar result against number twenty-four Clemson going on the road to flatten the Tigers.
- 3:03Miami is currently the top team in the ACC in the common sense rankings and looks to have the firepower to compete for another national title.
- 3:12Lastly, CSR number fifteen played number fourteen Virginia Tech.
- 3:16This was a much closer game than the other two matchups coming down to a controversial final play.
- 3:21The Virginia Tech kicker raised his hands in triumph thinking his kick that had sailed over the uprights had snuck in, but the referees thought differently, calling it no good on a non-reviewable ruling.
- 3:31Pittsburgh escapes with a win.
- 3:33They did, however, lose their QB for the season, so while the common sense rankings does not take into account injuries, we'll see if the Panthers can continue to win here in 2026.
- 3:44Let's next take a look at the conference strength rankings based on week five results.
- 3:49The SEC and Big Ten remain atop the college football world, with the SEC having winning records against each of the nine other conferences.
- 3:57The Big Ten has seven winning records.
- 4:00The Big Twelve remained at six thanks to the Kansas Jayhawks win, but the ACC is now a step behind the Big Twelve, so a win in ACC play will get you slightly fewer points than last week, and losses will hurt slightly more.
- 4:14The American stayed tied with the Pac-12 and Sun Belt even though Navy lost.
- 4:18While that could still change depending on the Army-Air Force result in week 10, the Pac-12 is now fully in conference play, so their place in the CSR is locked in, and the Sun Belt too has made their strength known in the 2026 season.
- 4:32There are no changes to the bottom three of the CSR conference rankings either.
- 4:36The Mountain West, even with UNLV's win, cannot claim a winning record against the ACC, so they remain slightly behind the American Pac-12 and Sun Belt.
- 4:45Conference USA and MAC will bring up the rear.
- 4:48Those conference rankings could still change as there are just a couple non-conference games that could impact head-to-head winning records.
- 4:57With the conference hierarchy mostly set for 2026, let's talk about what that means in practice.
- 5:03In the Common Sense ranking formula, the stronger a conference performs against each of the other conferences, the more a value of a win against a team from that conference is worth, and on the flip side, the less a loss is worth.
- 5:15Last week, we compared a team from each conference to a four and five SEC team, showing where a school would need to finish in conference play to have a comparable direct win total.
- 5:25While nine conferences remain unchanged, we need to take another look at the ACC now that they're a step below the Big Twelve.
- 5:31Had California won, an ACC school would have needed to go five and four to have their conference slate align with a four and five team from the SEC.
- 5:39But due to on-the-field results, five and four is now no longer equivalent.
- 5:44They'll now need to finish six and three to claim they played better than an SEC school in conference in 2026.
- 5:51Those head-to-head results account for about fifty percent of a team's total CSR points.
- 5:56So there is wiggle room, but the ACC is playing from behind a little more this season based on previous week's games.
- 6:04Now let's play a little game I enjoy doing with each new week's rankings, putting teams up in a blind resume test.
- 6:10I admit there are ulterior motives here as I'm trying to prove my formula is fair considering on-the-field results.
- 6:17But it is also an attempt to b- show that biases build up in a lot of fans and poll voters' minds, and they fail to account for on-the-field wins and losses.
- 6:26Neither win margin nor specific opponent names will be mentioned as those do not matter in the common sense rankings formula.
- 6:34Blind resume test number one.
- 6:35Team A is five and O.
- 6:37They have wins over two MAC, two Big Ten, and an FCS school.
- 6:41Their opponents have a combined five wins over FBS programs.
- 6:45Team B is three and one.
- 6:47They have a win over the Big Ten, the Big 12, as well as an FCS win.
- 6:50They lost to a team from the American.
- 6:53The teams they've beat have fewer wins with just four, and the team to which they lost has lost an additional time.
- 7:01Team A is Nebraska, who remains unranked after beating Maryland in week five, while the other is Oklahoma State, who is ranked eighteenth in the AP poll, which seems to be a result of their beating Oregon but not much else Blind resume test number two.
- 7:16Team A is undefeated five and O with three wins over the SEC, one over the ACC, and one over the American.
- 7:23Those five teams that they've beat have a combined 11 wins over FBS squads.
- 7:28Team B, meanwhile, is four and one.
- 7:31They have wins over two MAC and two Big Ten teams, while they lost their game against the SEC.
- 7:36The opponents they have beat have a combined five FBS wins.
- 7:40This will likely look a little closer, but it feels like Team A should have the edge.
- 7:46Team A is the CSR number one Alabama Crimson Tide, who sit at number six in the AP poll.
- 7:52Team B sits a spot above them according to the voters, the Ohio State Buckeyes.
- 7:56But Ohio State has the fifteenth best resume of the year thus far, according to the CSR.
- 8:03Blind resume test number three.
- 8:05Team A has wins over one Big Ten and one Pac-12 school, as well as an FCS team.
- 8:11Their lone loss was to a team from the Big 12.
- 8:14The teams that they've beaten have a combined eight FBS wins.
- 8:18Team B, meanwhile, has five FBS wins, two over the Big Ten, one over the Pac-12, one over the Mountain West, and one over the Sun Belt.
- 8:26Their lone loss was to a Big Ten school.
- 8:29The teams that they've beat have a combined 11 FBS wins.
- 8:33So Team B has essentially matched Team A's resume with wins over the Big Ten and Pac-12, but then added three more FBS wins on top of it, including another Big Ten team.
- 8:44By virtue of having more FBS opponents, those opponents have also racked up more wins.
- 8:49Team A is Oregon, who admittedly beat USC head-to-head, while Team B is the Trojans.
- 8:56The goal of this side-by-side comparison was to attempt to prove that head-to-head result is only one aspect we should be looking at.
- 9:02The totality of the resume should be considered when ranking teams, and the totality of the wins and losses to this point shows USC has the better resume.
- 9:13Let's do one more blind resume.
- 9:16Both of these teams have one loss.
- 9:18Team A has wins over two SEC teams and one Sun Belt program.
- 9:22Their loss was to an SEC school.
- 9:25Those three FBS teams they beat have combined for six FBS wins, and their loss was to an undefeated team.
- 9:32Team B, meanwhile, has a win against the SEC, the ACC, and an American team.
- 9:37Their loss was to an SEC team as well.
- 9:40The teams they've beat have four FBS wins, and their loss was to a one-loss team.
- 9:46Team A apparently doesn't deserve a ranking.
- 9:48That would be the Kentucky Wildcats, who won't have a number next to their name for their game this week against LSU.
- 9:55Team B, however, is obviously a top 10 team for the AP poll voters.
- 10:00That resume belongs to Ole Miss.
- 10:02Even within a conference, we're having a hard time letting go of preconceived notions and putting the most deserving teams at the top of the list Moving on from our resume test, let's launch into what this week's top 25 in the CSR looks like.
- 10:17At the top is the Alabama Crimson Tide.
- 10:20They played the CSR number two team and won while last week's number one was on bye.
- 10:25The result?
- 10:26Their ascension to the top spot, and quite frankly, it's not even close.
- 10:29Alabama's direct wins are earning them the most points with three SEC victories, plus a win from the ACC and the American, mostly due to Mississippi State and Kentucky both having two SEC wins of their own.
- 10:41Is this SEC bias?
- 10:43Some may say so, but it's all formulaic.
- 10:45The SEC is better head-to-head than every other conference in the country.
- 10:49A win versus an SEC school should mean more this season, and Alabama has three of them.
- 10:53They've put up nearly twenty percent more points than the number two team in the CSR through five weeks of games.
- 10:59Moving up to number two and also taking advantage of Texas' bye week is the Notre Dame Fighting Irish.
- 11:05Starting with three of your first five against Big Ten and going five and O against FBS teams will almost always put you near the top of the common sense rankings.
- 11:13In addition, their wins against the Big Ten, they also sport an ACC victory and a win over the American.
- 11:20Number three is last week's top team, the Texas Longhorns.
- 11:23They had an early bye, so they still sit at four and O, but they did gain more points as three of the four teams they beat won in week number five.
- 11:32Number four is our top ACC team this week, the Miami Hurricanes.
- 11:36Even with the ACC's slight decline in the common sense rankings, the Hurricanes three wins over ACC programs looms large at this point in the season.
- 11:45A fourth win over a Max school gives them the nudge they need to get that hypothetical college football playoff bye.
- 11:51Number five will be the first controversial ranking this week.
- 11:54The Trojans from Southern Cal have five FBS wins, tied for the most in the country.
- 11:59They have the third-best quality of direct wins in the common sense rankings formula.
- 12:04They get additional credit for the 11 wins those five teams have accrued.
- 12:08Their loss to Oregon and the Ducks' loss to Oklahoma State hurt them, but the Trojans get the benefit of having played in week zero and not having had a bye.
- 12:16Once they've played the same number of games as everyone else, their ranking should normalize.
- 12:21The rest of the top 10 all received a ranking in the AP poll this week, so credit to the voters there, but several were under ranked.
- 12:28Number six is Georgia, three and O in the SEC plus a fourth FBS win puts them just behind the Trojans.
- 12:34Number seven goes to Mississippi State.
- 12:36I know they just got blown out at home by Alabama, but in the common sense rankings it counts as an SEC loss to an undefeated team.
- 12:44They lose the fewest points allowed due to the SEC's non-conference success, and all their wins more than make up for that loss.
- 12:51Number eight is Pittsburgh with two ACC wins and a third Power Four win over UCF.
- 12:56Number nine is UCLA following their bye week.
- 12:59Three Power Four wins to their credit, including two Big Ten dubs gets you top 10 through five weeks.
- 13:05While their direct wins got them more points this week than Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh's opponents have delivered more quality wins thus far, putting UCLA just behind the Panthers.
- 13:14Number 10 is Texas Tech, which coincidentally is comparable to their position in the AP poll.
- 13:22Quickly listing off the rest of the top 25, you have number 11, defending champion Indiana.
- 13:27Number 12 is Nebraska, who is unranked in the AP poll.
- 13:31Number 13 is Florida.
- 13:32Number 14 is James Madison, your top group of 16.
- 13:36Number 15 is Ohio State.
- 13:37I look forward to the comments on that ranking.
- 13:40Number 16, Utah.
- 13:41Seventeen, BYU.
- 13:43Eighteen is Duke.
- 13:44Nineteen is Kentucky.
- 13:45Number 20 is North Dakota State.
- 13:48Twenty-one is Wake Forest, who is also unranked in the AP.
- 13:51Twenty-two, LSU.
- 13:52Twenty-three, Missouri.
- 13:53Twenty-four, Ole Miss, and 25, Wisconsin.
- 13:57All of the 15 undefeated FBS teams are in the CSR top 25, and among all the two-loss teams, we have Auburn as the closest at number 32.
- 14:08As always, if you want to see the full rankings, numbers one through 138, you can see them at commonsenserankings.com.
- 14:15The conference breakdown for the CSR top 25 is nine SEC teams, which is one more than last week.
- 14:21You have six Big Ten, also one more than last week.
- 14:24Four ACC, three Big 12, one Mountain West, one Sun Belt, and the independent Notre Dame.
- 14:33When we compare the top twenty-five in the Common Sense rankings to the AP poll, we see that the number of SEC teams is the same with both having nine.
- 14:41The Big Ten has the correct amount at six.
- 14:44There are only three teams in the AP top twenty-five from the ACC, whereas the Common Sense rankings have four.
- 14:51The CSR is a little bit lower on the Big Twelve than the AP v-voters, putting two less teams in our top twenty-five.
- 14:58Notre Dame is in both, while the AP's lone Group of Six rep is Boise State, while the CSR has James Madison and North Dakota State as more deserving resumes If you listen carefully to the teams as I listed them off in our top 25, you will have heard that James Madison's name is higher than both Utah and BYU.
- 15:18Big 12 fans are likely screaming unfair, so let's dig into it.
- 15:22All three teams are undefeated, but James Madison has yet to take a buy, so they have four FBS wins compared to three each from Utah and BYU.
- 15:30Let's look at the quality of those wins.
- 15:32I'll compare just to Utah to keep things a little easier.
- 15:35James Madison has wins over Conference USA, Pac-12, and two over the Sun Belt.
- 15:40Three of those wins are against the best conferences in the group of six.
- 15:43Utah, meanwhile, has a win over the SEC, the Big 12, and the Pac-12.
- 15:48In the CSR formulas, a win over the SEC right now is worth nearly double the value of a win over the least successful conferences, the MAC and Conference USA.
- 15:57But the strength of the Sun Belt in non-conference play is boosting the Dukes' two wins in conference.
- 16:02Through JMU's four FBS games and Utah's three, the Dukes have barely more points to their name via direct wins.
- 16:10If both teams win in week six, that'll flip as Utah's win over a Big 12 team would mean more to their resume than James win-- Madison's win over another Sun Belt team.
- 16:20In addition to a slight edge in direct wins, James Madison's opponents has six FBS wins compared to Utah's four, and the conferences of those opponents' wins also gives JMU the edge.
- 16:31This is all through week five.
- 16:33As Utah continues to pick up wins over successful Big 12 teams, they'll continue to ascend while James Madison will need to win just to try to maintain its spot in the rankings.
- 16:45If we put the CSR rankings into a college football playoff bracket, uh, we would send Alabama, Notre Dame, Texas, and Miami straight to the quarterfinals.
- 16:55Our first round matchups would see USC against James Madison, the group of six representative, number six Georgia versus number 11 Indiana, number seven Mississippi State against number 10 Texas Tech, and number eight Pittsburgh against number nine UCLA, two teams whose resumes are horribly under ranked by the Associated Press.
- 17:14The first teams to not make the bracket would be Nebraska, who is number 12, Florida and Ohio State The 69 men and women who vote in the AP poll improved after week five, correctly ranking 18 of the top 25 resumes in college football.
- 17:30They ranked Pittsburgh, finally, and not a single two-loss team received a vote.
- 17:34There is, however, plenty of room to improve.
- 17:37Nebraska is five and O, yet unranked.
- 17:39Not good.
- 17:40SMU is still somehow in the top 25, even though they have the 43rd best resume according to the Common Sense rankings.
- 17:47Kentucky is unranked, yet LSU and Ole Miss are both top 10.
- 17:51Fortunately, we have 10 more weeks for them to further improve Let's talk about some of the specific ballots that were submitted by AP poll voters.
- 18:01Each week I look for a few specific things amongst those who turn in a ballot and call out men and women who are properly evaluating a few key teams.
- 18:09Alabama is the number one team in the Common Sense rankings, but didn't pick up a single first place vote in the AP poll this week.
- 18:17They did, however, get ranked second a total of five times, so shout out to Steven Means, Pat Welter, Mike Griffith, Javon Edmonds, and David Jablonsky for being appropriately high on the Tide.
- 18:28Nebraska was the highest team in the Common Sense rankings at number 12 to be unranked in this week's AP poll.
- 18:34Greg Luka from the San Antonio Express-News had the Huskers the highest of any ballot submitted, putting them at number 17.
- 18:40So well done, Greg.
- 18:42The two most overrated teams according to the CSR are Oklahoma State and SMU, and several voters correctly left them off their ballots.
- 18:50Craig Stevenson, David Jablonsky, Garland Gillen, Greg Luka, John Johnson, and Randy Johnson, thanks to you While several ballots made good decisions, there were a few that left something to be desired.
- 19:03First, Pittsburgh and UCLA did both make the AP poll this week, coming in between 21 and 25.
- 19:09But according to the Common Sense rankings, both of their resumes deserve a top 10 number.
- 19:14Brenna Green, Eric Hansen, Pete Yannity, Reese Davis, and Trevor Hass didn't have either team on their ballot at all, which is disappointing.
- 19:23Oklahoma State sits at number 18 in the AP poll but sport just two wins over FBS schools.
- 19:28I know it's two Power Four wins, including a win over Oregon, but the Cowboys are the second lowest team in the CSR's resume rankings that made the AP top 25.
- 19:38Ralph Russo was a big reason the Cowboys are so high in the poll, as he had them the highest of any pollster at number 11.
- 19:46Looking ahead to week six, we have four of the top 25 in the CSR on bye, including three of the top ten, Miami, Mississippi State, and Texas Tech.
- 19:56So expect those three teams to fall in next week's rankings.
- 19:59There's just one non-conference matchup that could change the CSR conference strength.
- 20:04The Big 12 plays the Mountain West for the second time this season when Arizona State plays Hawaii at nine thirty on FS1.
- 20:11Arizona's win over Northern Illinois in week three is carrying the Big 12 in that head-to-head matchup.
- 20:17But if Hawaii can pull off the upset, the Big 12 will drop back into a tie with the ACC and would be a distant third, well behind the SEC and another step behind the Big Ten in the twenty twenty-six season There are three ranked matchups in the CSR in week six, including another one involving Alabama.
- 20:36College GameDay will be live from Tuscaloosa Saturday morning for the Tides game against CSR number six, Georgia.
- 20:42Alabama is leaps and bounds ahead of everybody else in the CSR, but a loss to Kirby Smart and the Dogs would likely move them down out of the top five.
- 20:50Georgia, meanwhile, would launch themselves into the top three depending on results elsewhere.
- 20:55The defending national champions and CSR number eleven Indiana Hoosiers will head west to battle CSR number twelve Nebraska at twelve noon on Fox.
- 21:05The winner will have a top ten ranking in the CSR next week, while the loser will be hovering around the top twenty-five.
- 21:11CSR number nineteen Kentucky will host number twenty-two LSU in primetime on Saturday on ESPN.
- 21:17The Wildcats have a better resume according to the CSR but sit well behind the Tigers in the AP's eyes.
- 21:23A home win over Lane Kiffin's LSU team would give the Wildcats a boost in both the CSR and the AP A couple more games to include in your quad box on Saturday include UCLA's battle with Oregon, both teams ranked in the AP top 25.
- 21:39They will play on CBS at 3:30.
- 21:41Oklahoma and Texas will be renewing the Red River Rivalry Saturday at 3:30 on ABC.
- 21:47While the Sooners are having a tougher start to the season than they would have hoped, a win over the rival Longhorns would give them some momentum going into the second half of the season.
- 21:56Week six will also introduce the earliest weeknight games so far in 2026, with games starting on Tuesday and running for five consecutive nights.
- 22:07The biggest questions in week six likely revolve around the Big 12.
- 22:10There's a lot of chatter about if the Big 12 is a one-bid league, and the top teams in the conference, Texas Tech, Utah, and BYU, will need to keep winning to give them a shot at an at-large bid in this year's college football playoff.
- 22:23The ACC too will need its horses to continue to win, especially Miami, but can Duke, Pitt, or Wake Forest also put up enough wins to impress the committee?
- 22:32Among the Group of six teams, Boise State is the AP poll's darling right now, but I would argue James Madison and North Dakota State have better resumes through week five.
- 22:41If each of those teams win out, what will the committee do come the first Sunday in December?
- 22:47All those questions and more will be answered in due time.
- 22:50Thank you for listening to another episode of the Common Sense Rankings podcast.
- 22:54I'll continue to post on the socials at commsenseranking, and I'll continue to update the full season rankings at commonsensererankings.com.
- 23:02Enjoy week six, and please, as you go about your day-to-day, use some common sense.