Latest / The New Paris Podcast / 36: Feminism à la Française: Live Panel Discussion
Transcript
- 0:06You're listening to the New Paris.
- 0:09It's this episode sounds a bit different and runs a lot longer
- 0:12than usual. It's because it's a special one.
- 0:15It's a recording of a discussion hosted at the American library
- 0:18in Paris on June 12. I was invited to speak on a
- 0:21panel about French feminism, we three fellow journalist, I
- 0:25admire greatly okay, Ed yellow Alice, Pfeiffer, and Lauren
- 0:30Collins who moderated the discussion and has previously
- 0:32been a guest on this show. There were some technical issues
- 0:36with the recording. However, and as a result, the
- 0:39Question from the talk is missing.
- 0:42I hope you'll forgive any sound discrepancies.
- 0:44You might encounter as you listen, but it was important for
- 0:47me to share the discussion on the less particularly for those
- 0:50who couldn't make it and requested a recording, I hope
- 0:54you'll find the talk is interesting and enlightening is
- 0:56I found it to be as a participant.
- 1:02Thank you, Audrey. Thank you so much.
- 1:04All of you for being here tonight and thank you to the
- 1:06panelists. We have a really great group
- 1:09tonight, all of whose work, I very much admire and learn from.
- 1:13So we will begin women. Wake up the alarm Bell of
- 1:19Reason. Sounds throughout the Universe,
- 1:21recognize your rights, the powerful Empire of nature is no
- 1:25longer surrounded by Prejudice fanaticism Superstition and
- 1:29lies. The torch of of Truth has
- 1:32dispersed all the clouds of folly and usurpation enslaved.
- 1:36Man has multiplied his multiplied.
- 1:38His force and needs yours to break his chains having become
- 1:42free. He has become unjust toward His
- 1:44companion, a women women. When will you cease to be blind?
- 1:49What advantages have you gathered in the revolution?
- 1:52That was a nom de guiche writing in 1791 to protest the way the
- 1:57egalitarians ideals of the revolution had an Two women, the
- 2:04Declaration of the rights of women and female citizens was
- 2:08not adopted. De guiche had been annoying
- 2:10people in Paris for a long time. One of her contemporaries.
- 2:14I'll let you guess whether it was a man or a woman said,
- 2:17Madame de guiche makes you want to give her razor blades.
- 2:20As a present. The Declaration was dedicated to
- 2:26Marie Antoinette and a lump de guiche also went to the
- 2:30guillotine. Along with the dedicat.
- 2:32T of those words, I'm beginning this way to say that.
- 2:35The struggle for Eagle equal rights for women has been going
- 2:39on for a long time. And this is where we ran into
- 2:43technical troubles. Let's Jump Ahead to the rest of
- 2:46the conversation. We're gonna you've been on the
- 2:50Forefront of the fight to get people to think about whether
- 2:55racism and sexism or sort of siloed in France and how it
- 2:59might benefit both struggles. For them to be approached
- 3:03together. Can you can you talk about that?
- 3:05Has that been in a, has that been a struggle to get people to
- 3:09see that or talking to talk to us about your work?
- 3:12So yes, I'm going to thank you for for, thank you.
- 3:14Thanks to the American, I referring videos.
- 3:17It's a good thing to have the to here.
- 3:21I can what I can say for about intersectionality that I think
- 3:26that we've had a woman of color being a teen feminism, but They
- 3:31were not visible to the mainstream.
- 3:32So if we take friends as a, the only country who is on five
- 3:37continents, meaning that we are also in other items that are and
- 3:41in the, in the Caribbean and Indian Ocean, we've had women of
- 3:45color of fighting the fight for feminism for a long time but
- 3:49they were not visible. And the other thing is that the
- 3:52Republic the French Republic conceives itself as being
- 3:55universities. But they have there has always
- 3:57been a double standard in the way women were treated, for
- 4:00example. In the 70s in the early, 70s
- 4:03abortion was was, was Liam, was that it was an authorized in
- 4:07France in the in the French Mainland.
- 4:09But at the same time, the government considered not the
- 4:12government, but luckily, it was considered that women in an area
- 4:16which is a Korean island in the Indian.
- 4:18Ocean had too many kids too many children, so that many of them
- 4:23were we're forced to abort. And we know that sensitive
- 4:28course. The example, for instance is
- 4:30kept up for today. Yes, he said, we had like four
- 4:36times that African woman had much to too much to children and
- 4:40that was the reason for poverty. So at the time when French women
- 4:45to watch French women in the mainland were fighting for the
- 4:47rights to to to just to access to a to assess abortion.
- 4:52In her new women were forced to 22 to do a sterilized or new
- 4:59Force to force through to abort. So there was the to that they
- 5:03want that, they have always been that there are sender.
- 5:06And the thing is that we are speaking now about English
- 5:08intersectionality but in the late 70s, there was a group
- 5:12called the record player. Countless from the formula.
- 5:15That was that was led by our chairman, whatever.
- 5:18That was part of the like the MMF, which was the mainstream
- 5:22feminist group, but it was totally forgotten.
- 5:25And the thing is that we don't have We do you think fit within
- 5:2712 document the fights of women in the colonies women even in
- 5:31the French Mainland who are women of color?
- 5:34So that the new generations of families who are, who are from
- 5:38immigrant or Colonial decent. Don't really know what happened
- 5:40before them and I think that what is, what really
- 5:43characterized. France activities friends, is
- 5:46the fact that we erase every generation erased, the memory of
- 5:50the former Generations. It has the same for all the
- 5:53files that are related to especially to racial issue.
- 5:56Shoes. So today it's very difficult as
- 5:59a feminist to make people understand that.
- 6:03We need to focus on specific issues.
- 6:05Whether you are a Muslim woman, a black woman and Asian women,
- 6:08you have certain certain specific.
- 6:10These specificity that need to be addressed.
- 6:14And when you do, so you are seeing as challenging the
- 6:18universal ideology and you are perceived as being divisive.
- 6:22So you called community-based and and and The mainstream
- 6:27feminists who are mostly white call themselves Universalist and
- 6:31to me, they're white, they're not Universalist, but to them,
- 6:34they feel that white men's universalism.
- 6:36So it's something that's very difficult to make people
- 6:39understand because when you label someone to focus on the
- 6:44fact that the person is Islam belongs to to, to group that is
- 6:50that is stigmatized using as questioning the very core.
- 6:56Geology of France. So, how do you compare that?
- 6:58I mean, what are some of your strategies for trying to explain
- 7:01to people that, no, you're not Universal.
- 7:04You're white or what, what, what's been successful or what's
- 7:07been effective for you? I think that do change has
- 7:11occurred. Thanks to social media, me.
- 7:13It was very difficult because the the, what about visible?
- 7:17What was public, was controlled by the people who have put the
- 7:20power to give the microphone to the people that they consider as
- 7:25being irrelevant. But the fact that we have now
- 7:29social media, that's who you have a younger generations of
- 7:32families, who are able to vote the account, their concerns
- 7:34really change the game because it's very difficult for
- 7:37mainstream media. Now, to ignore what its name.
- 7:40So, what I said, for example, to a group of families who think
- 7:45that there are Universal that they are not that they're white,
- 7:47I'm called racist because, you know, we believe very strongly
- 7:52here that anti-white racism exists.
- 7:55So, oh, I'm seeing as, as being the person who constantly remind
- 8:02that race exists and you may not be familiar with the fact that
- 8:06last summer, the world race was erased from the Constitution.
- 8:10It was in the first article of the Constitution.
- 8:13So because we believe so strongly.
- 8:15That race doesn't exist that we don't have to mention it in any
- 8:19legal document. So it was erased because when
- 8:23you speak about trans people think about dying.
- 8:26Not as race as a social construct, construct its
- 8:29associated with Nazis. Yes, exactly, exactly.
- 8:33So, there is a Trona because of the war and, and it's very
- 8:38difficult to make people understand that trace, of
- 8:40course, we all the same, all have a red blood and I'm sure
- 8:43that there is no difference, no human difference between People
- 8:47based on their and they're under it.
- 8:48Lisa T, but we are not seen in the same way and we are not
- 8:51really in the same way and the fact that the world race was
- 8:55erased, Aged from The Constitution's, the Constitution
- 8:58tells a lot about how deeply we are trying to to, to, to how can
- 9:05you say that to buying any z-scores?
- 9:08That would be very related to race Alice.
- 9:11One of the places where all of these, you know, feelings often
- 9:20coalesce is, is fashion, is clothing.
- 9:24You know, for instance, There was a kind of polemic as we have
- 9:28to say here about decathlon recently which offered hijab for
- 9:35women to play sports. And, and, you know, there was
- 9:38all kinds of drama and I don't know.
- 9:39Do they end up Van it up? Keeping it?
- 9:40No, they pulled it, they pulled it from the stores.
- 9:44So talk to us a little bit about why why clothing is so
- 9:51important. So many of these fights.
- 9:53And also whether Whether you think that French feminism,
- 9:59sometimes, you know, tips into the policing of women's bodies
- 10:05or what, first of all, nothing gets in in the language.
- 10:08Used around things, for example, what we call shampoo for
- 10:13straight, there is called port rahulonmove for normal hair, and
- 10:18then make up that stuff for darker.
- 10:21Skin is Luke with Nick, the ethnic corner.
- 10:24So all of this is That the the main customer is always white,
- 10:29except doesn't want to be addressed as such.
- 10:31It's like, they're they're neutral, you know, you either
- 10:33the turn new Duke will share means beige, you know?
- 10:37And but the problem the French are having is that.
- 10:40We're also a big luxury, a country with big luxury groups
- 10:43and the main people buying are in large part coming from the
- 10:46Middle East. So there's this problem of the
- 10:48good Arab and the bad Arab. So while all the main house has
- 10:52might produce, you know they they produce hijabs like leprosy
- 10:55to do. W & Gabbana produces hijab.
- 10:57So the Middle East yet. Other brands, we'll all the same
- 11:02brand will even sell it in the same country.
- 11:04I remember fast-fashion Brands you can probably guess, who
- 11:08produces hijabs in throughout Europe, and the one country
- 11:11didn't want to sell to wasn't where I wasn't accepted was
- 11:14France, and it said to me, oh no.
- 11:16The police have cleared out there who do not want of this
- 11:18clientele, meaning that what they see, as Arab or black is
- 11:23intersects. With this sort of post-colonial,
- 11:26Encino. So use of colonial descent
- 11:29Associated to the volume and but they're still profit from the
- 11:34Arab other Arab error money. So it's two markets conflicting
- 11:39but it's very much. It's its Associated to sort of
- 11:44working class from second generation immigrants that that
- 11:48are called cayhall, which is a terrible word, which means sort
- 11:51of thuggish kids. And, and I was, I was at me.
- 11:56Neither Have a million anecdotes.
- 11:57I was ordered not to order an Arab in turn because at the
- 12:01heian era been turned because they steal.
- 12:03And that's comes from a big fashion magazine.
- 12:05I worked at one point. So I think people come to find a
- 12:09myth, and the mrs. White myth, and the French woman
- 12:12is white woman and from Mayan to me stance, it's the majority is
- 12:18is always a thin wavy food. What white woman who doesn't?
- 12:22You know, who's the straighteners and Zhang are
- 12:23probably with a bed yet and bear arms there.
- 12:25Howard Howe, Deconstructing, that notion in your book.
- 12:29Well, I look, I read the definitions of one woman called,
- 12:32it is directly Sarge. And if you look at it, if you
- 12:36look at everything, all the steps that she describes, it's
- 12:39all, it's all between the lines, so she's like, don't brush your
- 12:42hair and you're like, well, you don't have curly hair clearly
- 12:45you like, and then she says, by wear vintage Chanel.
- 12:49So you come from a family that owns Channel and then she's as
- 12:52just boyfriend Jean. So you're straight and And then
- 12:57would not work because she gets to the Border.
- 12:59No, no, bra. As soon.
- 13:00Yeah, one said, so you're tiny and skinny.
- 13:03So there you go. There who is that woman?
- 13:05Who is skinny has a boyfriend is white and come from Chanel and
- 13:11that's the universal figure that we have.
- 13:13Because we remember come to me. There's a lot of police officers
- 13:15made a business about it was Mayan, and the Muse with Karl
- 13:18Lagerfeld for a long time. So that's been an iconic French
- 13:21figure. And that has moved on to, it
- 13:25hasn't moved on and it was just to say that, you know, Carl's
- 13:32additional Muse, was counting to make it a, who's a little bit
- 13:34more rock and roll but still exhibits the same character
- 13:37traits skinny but they're, but they're all sort of a variation
- 13:42on a theme. Yeah.
- 13:44And you know who were not Muses where the Women's World Cup
- 13:49team. The French team I just read in
- 13:50the newspaper that The phone had wildly underestimated.
- 13:57The amount of interest that Spectators would have in the
- 14:01women's team. The first game came on last
- 14:04week. 10 million people watched on TV, which was exactly the
- 14:08same number as the number of people who watch the men's.
- 14:10The first men's game in the World Cup and tie a thumb is
- 14:14Raising unbelievable. Whose job it is to know these
- 14:25things underestimate women to Athens raising their ad rate,
- 14:2950% for the rest of the games. That's how much money they lost
- 14:33by under estimating women on the first one.
- 14:36I mean, it's been said, time and time again that equality and
- 14:41proper representation of women. And also you know just a more
- 14:46diverse population is good for business that statistically has
- 14:50been shown and yet that is not what's being executed.
- 14:53Didn't companies. So it's not surprising that they
- 14:55undervalued. I mean, women are constantly
- 14:57sort of all surprised. We're here.
- 14:59You know, we were over half the population, but we're still
- 15:02fighting to be seen and I think that's a testament to the way.
- 15:07Women have always been perceived and that's a, that's a fight.
- 15:10That's the same here in the United States, and the UK were
- 15:14inferior. And we've got this sort of mans,
- 15:18not monster, but this like Monster Mountain were climbing
- 15:21constantly and then Every so often were thrown a little
- 15:24obstacle and we keep stepping back.
- 15:26And to your point, you know, the way you started this discussion
- 15:29with thoughts from what the 18th century that are still, you
- 15:33know, you could that could be from today.
- 15:35And so the fight is is ongoing and it's very troubling that
- 15:38it's on going to the same, to the same extent.
- 15:41President macron declared equality, between men and women.
- 15:45The Kong cause of his five-year term.
- 15:49What are we thinking? Discuss the only Thing.
- 15:53I'll say about that first, and I'm going to pass it on to you.
- 15:56Is that the UN just reported that no country in the world is
- 16:03on is slated to reach, gender parity by 2030.
- 16:07So, it's really nice that he has that objective, but he's not
- 16:11doing much to actually get there.
- 16:13And, you know, even when it comes to pay him out, which is,
- 16:16you know, IVF treatments for, for women in this country are
- 16:21not authorized. If you're a single, Eagle woman
- 16:23or you're in a lesbian couple other than it will be on the
- 16:27Slate with the bioethics in September law.
- 16:30And so what they've been but the you know, the women who are
- 16:33affected by this have been fighting to get this on the
- 16:35docket from you know long before my home as president.
- 16:38So it's just these things that you know, one might say oh but
- 16:41it's not that important of an issue except it really is for
- 16:45women and it's just another thing to add to the list where
- 16:49women have to consistently fight to be like, no, this is
- 16:51important because it means and this is my life and it's a
- 16:54quality-of-life thing and it shouldn't, you know, there's
- 16:58enough time and enough energy to, to discuss, all sorts of
- 17:02issues, but that one keeps getting marked down.
- 17:08I think I mean, coming from someone who's just erase the
- 17:12word race, he doesn't have many non like friends, so I don't
- 17:16know which woman he's talking about, but it's clearly women
- 17:18around him. I think I think you just
- 17:20instrumentalize his wife if you want my opinion to get the
- 17:22opinion like to get the appreciation of LGBT groups and
- 17:28then women groups, because I remember when he was accused of
- 17:30being gay, his response was actually quite clever.
- 17:32But coming from a businessman, not a president.
- 17:34He said that It would mean I'm homophobic and and that would
- 17:38mean that a man who's attracted to an older woman is therefore
- 17:41not is is therefore gay. So he's he has these clever
- 17:45twists and of words but behind it there's nothing.
- 17:48I mean what does he ever does? Is changed up.
- 17:50A raging, is it is the gap is still, there is then safe.
- 17:55Recently proudly announced that they only pay women 30% less the
- 17:59men, and they made a whole ad campaign about it.
- 18:01She's someone has books on them one and I Working at a date that
- 18:07daily magazine. And I remember the guy sitting
- 18:09next to me was had exactly the same position and was just
- 18:12paying more for absolutely no reason instead of it's just an
- 18:15old code that we have you know so I think it's I think he's
- 18:19talking as a startup dude you know and I don't think it's as
- 18:24much much straight behind it. I mean I think maybe what we
- 18:27could give him credit for is the fact that the first class of
- 18:32deputies a for his party. The Derby already was very good.
- 18:37I mean, it was okay, very good for gender, parity. 47%, we'll
- 18:41take it but I'm interested to hear what you have to say on
- 18:45that account. To me.
- 18:46The first thing to do is thrown he really wanted to make that
- 18:51promise. Meaningful would be to have a
- 18:53natural minister of elements, right?
- 18:55She's as a catalyst, which is not a minister item, is it's not
- 18:59the same level of power. It means when you are, when
- 19:02you're not a minister but the Secretariat are, it means that
- 19:05you have no Administration and you have no money.
- 19:07So she has much visibility in the media but she actually
- 19:12doesn't have the means to do what she's supposed to do.
- 19:15And just just to add to what you were saying before.
- 19:17She is a former blogger, which is, which is interesting.
- 19:20Yes, you she she froze, she goes from, do brings fear.
- 19:23She used, she studied the book which was named, it's not in
- 19:26Champa, but my mom's clients who about him.
- 19:31Yes, she wrote a book. It was a book, right?
- 19:33Sexually. Yeah, it was a Sex book.
- 19:35Ugh called Dad to sleep with around a curvy woman.
- 19:39She also wrote a book about it called rape culture, which
- 19:43introduced better. So she's an interesting figure.
- 19:45I'm interested to hear you talk about her.
- 19:46She's yeah, she's written about the and she's in charge of
- 19:52discrimination. But yeah.
- 19:59So the thing is that, you know, we and over for so long as you
- 20:03believe it was not enough, there was Minister of the women's
- 20:06rights and there's a better vacation was a minister.
- 20:08So she was she do, she was not in the same range.
- 20:11So I think that there is much communication around, man
- 20:15Shabbat, but what that, she's she's not term, really able to
- 20:20do what she's supposed to do. And you talked about talked to
- 20:24emmalin back home, said, several times in Africa, but saying, you
- 20:28know, blaming on women who I was, who have too much too many
- 20:32children and saying that they are the reasons for Um poverty
- 20:36in Africa is like Jess, it's insane.
- 20:38It's better to me and it means a lot about the way he sees
- 20:44development and I wanted to also to just to to go back to what
- 20:49you said about the the controversy around the hijab.
- 20:51It was very interesting because so they got clone, which is a
- 20:54French brand decided to just 22 to make hijab.
- 20:58He Jabs from women who wanted to run with a hijab so it shouldn't
- 21:03have been a big deal but it Also, a controversy started from
- 21:09people on Twitter, but also people in the government and
- 21:12everybody said, it was legal to make a jobs.
- 21:16But French values were conflicting conflicting with
- 21:20the, the making of hijab. So you mean that there is the
- 21:23low. And every there is something
- 21:24above the low, which is French values.
- 21:27And, and who decides, what is, what are those values?
- 21:32And at some point, how can they affect something?
- 21:35Which is Lego. So the controversy was so.
- 21:38So rough. That at some point you can only
- 21:41the captain decided to withdraw their jobs because their
- 21:45employees were threatened by people.
- 21:48They want that, they said that if you have those in your store
- 21:51will come and beat you. So for the safety of the MVD,
- 21:55they had to redo it which you know, should be a controversy
- 21:59but it wasn't and you hard like the president of the Senate,
- 22:03Josh luxury, who said, yes. But you cannot tell everything
- 22:07in the name of money. Making money coming from someone
- 22:10from the, right? Like we are in the capitalist
- 22:12country. So we are supposed to encourage
- 22:15companies, whether they were different, when they find a
- 22:18market and they found a market tried to make it profitable and
- 22:24Because of the French values, we decided to withdraw it.
- 22:27And what is interesting about the difference between the
- 22:31University's feminists and the others is that the controversy
- 22:36was mostly led by feminists. Because they say that.
- 22:40As a woman, you are supposed to be free and you cannot be free
- 22:43with her hijab. So you are you have to be free
- 22:46in the way that we in the way, we decide to.
- 22:51So being free means be looking Like, what is supposedly a
- 22:56French woman and you have had for like 30 years.
- 23:00Those French families who are fighting for the rights of
- 23:05Muslim women. Silencing them, and forcing them
- 23:09to not to not to go out of their home or two, just to remove the
- 23:15hijab. And it's it's it's to me, it's
- 23:18very, it's very specific to here because you you promote the fact
- 23:22that anyway, Men should be able to do whatever she wants to do
- 23:26with her body. But Muslim women, they have, if
- 23:30they have, if they want to be seen as feminists and to be
- 23:33respected, they have to speak without a hijab.
- 23:36And you wouldn't you would rarely see a hijab woman
- 23:39speaking for herself in the public sphere like they have
- 23:42been debating about for 30 years.
- 23:45Like the first of controversy was in 1989 in the inner kind,
- 23:49which is in the in the financial differentiable upon you but you
- 23:52never see them. Them speaking for themselves and
- 23:55to me universalism is that way of patronizing, a category of
- 23:59women, who are not French enough to decide for themselves for
- 24:03themselves, how they should, they should treat their own
- 24:05bodies. That puts me in mind of the me
- 24:10to movement of the balanced important movement.
- 24:15There was a lot of debate I guess it was maybe it was two
- 24:20years ago now but when all these you know and in France as an
- 24:26America, this movement you know Unleashed this great outpouring
- 24:31of people's stories. I mean, I know also you've had a
- 24:35lot with your new book. You've heard a lot of stories of
- 24:39people being, you know, humiliated or underestimated in
- 24:44the workplace but through all these stories could start coming
- 24:47out. And then some women cackling to
- 24:49know if most prominently among them published an opinion piece
- 24:54in Ormond, which says rape is a crime, but hitting on someone
- 24:58insistently or awkwardly is not an offense, nor is gallantry is
- 25:01chauvinistic Russian. Now my alarm Bells start to go
- 25:04off on a year. Rape is a crime, but But what I
- 25:09want to do is first of all, did this piece represents something
- 25:13specific to French feminism? Was it a French thing.
- 25:18Was it a class thing. What do we make of that?
- 25:25I think that there was something interesting in doing the
- 25:27internet in the car down because it was said that there is, there
- 25:31was there was a right to to annoy the yeah, we are.
- 25:55I'd like to know how do you know it's okay to be annoyed in the
- 25:58surveys of know. So I think that there was a
- 26:00class ring because she obviously there was there was a very
- 26:04romantic idea of the Met hole that was nothing to do with what
- 26:10we experience. When you take the metro and
- 26:13there is to me there is that this idea that there is a
- 26:16distribution of process. And so there is a way French a
- 26:20man behave that has nothing to do with her with harassment and
- 26:24that is super CD in our culture. And I and it's interesting to
- 26:28connect that with the older hijab controversy, because I
- 26:31have seen, I don't know if you've seen that on Twitter,
- 26:34the, the tweet from rocket connect with friends and allies
- 26:37from the bathroom. He was saying that it was it was
- 26:40during the decade or more controversy, it tweeted
- 26:42something saying that he has when you see a Muslim woman with
- 26:45a hijab, it means that she would never marry a non-muslim man and
- 26:51it's very violent to us and to me it s.
- 26:55Because he's not a non-muslim number skinny, white man, to me.
- 26:59It's kind of like wearing a wedding ring.
- 27:01Yes. Understand, why do you think,
- 27:03why would you do that? It means that I cannot, I
- 27:05cannot, I cannot even see you. And to make has to do with the
- 27:08idea that in the street. Women are supposed to be
- 27:12accessible, right? So if you wear a hijab, you're
- 27:14not part of the game anymore and and and it means that if you
- 27:19don't you're supposed to be, you know, to the accessible and you
- 27:22have that little thing of opportunity that Applies to you.
- 27:27I think all these women come from a time where they were part
- 27:31of a sexual Revolution, sort of get into nerve was, in, in
- 27:33Belle, De Jour. And it's his story of a board
- 27:36book Jesus who turned to prostitution for fun, and then
- 27:40capellini a was direct about press and then brought the
- 27:42shipping Booker lady 613 M, but that was a different time.
- 27:47That was the different today. There's, there's been ography
- 27:49everywhere. It's not, it's not the same idea
- 27:52at all, and it's just the idea that Women were more willing to
- 27:57stand up for someone of their own social class than rather
- 28:00than gender. So Kathleen do nerves to that
- 28:02for Polanski and and she stood up for, you know, there were
- 28:06more Deeds is the same women who stood up for Dominique
- 28:09strauss-kahn and her nephew said to the arrows.
- 28:11So there's there's definitely in France, and stronger social and
- 28:15he has social class connection rather than then gender-based
- 28:18solidarity. And today--is discourse is, I
- 28:22mean, it's part of his Every now and it's and there's not very
- 28:26much left of it. And those women are also, you
- 28:29know, they were, I believe they were all white and this would
- 28:33have internalized misogyny, that exists all over the world, which
- 28:36is why we have women who continue to vote against their
- 28:38own interests. Because they still think that
- 28:40somehow the white man is going to save them, and they're going
- 28:43to be up uplifted by this system of inequalities somehow.
- 28:50But, but similarly, you know, Women are due to their class and
- 28:58due to their experiences, are simply citing with the Power
- 29:02Systems that continue to allow them to flourish and keep
- 29:07rising. And so it's at once, I think,
- 29:09like you said a very clear class issue and then there's the idea
- 29:13that somehow, you know, you bring up the hijab again as a
- 29:16link and that goes back to the Algerian War where you know, men
- 29:21were these women were fetishized and they were exotic and And the
- 29:25fact that you couldn't see them, like, only sort of push them the
- 29:29men further to want to sort of win that conquest and so women,
- 29:34regardless of the situation are continued to be there, they're
- 29:38objects. And so, it's just in this case,
- 29:41these women believe that there's nothing, I guess inherently
- 29:44wrong with that, and don't see the line as being too easy.
- 29:48To cross tube about this. The six organization, that means
- 29:52really interesting to see that in France, there are zero I have
- 29:55models because that's not how you imagine French luxury yet.
- 29:59It's the number one, search on YouPorn.
- 30:01There's a term called bullet, which is awful.
- 30:04And it's, it just means sexualized, female Arab, and
- 30:06it's the number one on. It's the number one search in
- 30:09the country yet, it's never the face of luxury.
- 30:11It's never the face of Miami. It's never the face of any of it
- 30:14of the country, but it's still, it's still sort of excitement.
- 30:17So I think removing these women from that bill heads, status and
- 30:22choosing to wear the veil and not fall into the abyss.
- 30:24White man. Savior ISM aspect is something
- 30:27that made the French Furious the you know it was like using a
- 30:30battle. I think here's a final question
- 30:36and then we'll be very happy to hear questions from you should
- 30:41French and American and other feminism's converge or is there
- 30:47something valuable in in the particular particularity of you
- 30:54know are there? Useful differences, or is there
- 30:57a universal way to go forward for feminists?
- 31:04I think just recognizing your own privileges, you know, naming
- 31:07yourself white, if you're white and recognizing that that's been
- 31:09a through the strength, you know, and recognizing what you
- 31:13have, and what you don't have, and also, what you do have and
- 31:15what's an advantage to a with someone else, you know, like
- 31:22being recognizing that probably being thin and white and
- 31:25francophone and speak English and being franco-british, Robin
- 31:28friend girl, Jerry and is probably helping my whole life,
- 31:31you know. So I think the one thing we can
- 31:32do is recognizing what what we what we have and to build
- 31:37stronger solidarity in real Bridges between between causes
- 31:43Yeah, I was going to say that there's there's again A Million
- 31:46Ways to Be feminists and so there are similarities between
- 31:50all cultures and we could make that bridge between the US and
- 31:52France. But I think it goes beyond these
- 31:56borders and I think I keep going back to intersectionality
- 31:59because I think it's the only way you're going to ever fully
- 32:03put yourselves in the fight to end all sorts of oppressions.
- 32:09And so yes, the white woman is far less oppressed by nature of
- 32:13what. I was born with but in moving
- 32:16forward and supporting a cause and uplifting women.
- 32:18It really requires people to understand that there are
- 32:21certain opportunities that other people don't have and will never
- 32:25have because of everything else that comes with them.
- 32:27They're not just women, they are also a list of other things, and
- 32:32that there are factions within the the feminist movement all
- 32:35over the world. In the u.s. you see, sort of
- 32:38infighting and that does nothing to, but sort of build up the
- 32:41patriarchy even further. So I think Think we have limited
- 32:44resources, we have limited energy and we need to all be
- 32:46sort of figuring out a way to remain sweet if and and come
- 32:51together and see that this is not about pushing a white
- 32:55agenda. It has to be looking at all
- 32:57women as in their nuances and and the things that they lack
- 33:02and work together to correct that.
- 33:04And that's going to be require sort of a real dedication to
- 33:09what intersectionality really requires and There are certain
- 33:14generations of women in this country that are vehement Lee
- 33:17opposed to doing that. So I would say regarding friends
- 33:23and maybe we should just we should step it.
- 33:26Aside from ourselves, we tend to just analyze everything from the
- 33:32Frenchman's and and I think that we tend to forget that we are,
- 33:38as I said a country, which is on five continents, which means
- 33:42that we have so many different Even in our only inside of
- 33:46French borders, different stories, different histories of
- 33:50feminism, that We don't really take it to India taking into
- 33:54account, our Justin going to purr, like a couple of weeks
- 33:57ago. And, you know, there's the the
- 34:00story of women who are from, you know, and slave descent is just
- 34:04so interesting. And, you know, knowing that and
- 34:07including that in the way we see our history would be very
- 34:11fruitful. So, I think that we for Shirley
- 34:14to be has essentially there with other women from other
- 34:17countries. And I'm sure that I was I was I
- 34:20was fortunate. To have my my family comes from
- 34:23Senegal. So I have that perspective from
- 34:26two different continents and having you know the been
- 34:30fortunate to be in a country that is so so diverse means that
- 34:35we really know to need to get into character and 22.
- 34:39Just to, for example, with we spoke about exposed, we spoke a
- 34:44lot about Muslim women it for the if you see, if you see my
- 34:49art, which is a French territory now. 95% of the people there are
- 34:53Muslim in a new. You have so many different
- 34:55religions and they have found a way to face that diversity in a
- 34:59very local way. So, being inspired by what
- 35:02happens in other places than parents would be very, very
- 35:05profitable and How are we going to do this for question?
- 35:15So, we're going to pass the microphone because we have some
- 35:17Spectators out there behind. So, please just raise your hand,
- 35:21if you have a question and I see a first question right there and
- 35:25the panelists will answer as they feel prepared.
- 35:30Hi. I have a question for all four
- 35:32panelists. My name is Eddie and I host a
- 35:3551% France, 24 show that women's issues and I'm delighted to hear
- 35:41what you have to say. But one question I like to
- 35:43direct to the panel is the generational difference.
- 35:48You know, the fact that we're talking about women behind that
- 35:51Infamous letter, most of them, not all of them, but most of
- 35:54whom were of a certain age and I'm curious to know whether You
- 35:59know, particularly Alice and the others, whether you sense that
- 36:02there is a change in the way younger French, women view,
- 36:07feminism and that you know, for me as a foreigner, living in
- 36:12France, for nearly a decade. One thing that strikes me, it's
- 36:14all about propping up, the Latin male ego, which is uniquely
- 36:20French and away. And whether as a result with
- 36:22younger women to them, that's irrelevant and that the time has
- 36:27come to move forward. I think the internet has helped
- 36:34loads. I think I think the millennial
- 36:35generation has managed to build communities that weren't and in
- 36:38their immediate surroundings. So you might be the only black
- 36:42or Arab kid in an area but suddenly their online
- 36:44communities that would dog throughout the country.
- 36:47So now I think I think they're much more aware.
- 36:50I think the internet has taught sort of globish English to
- 36:54everyone which is brought in things such as post-colonial
- 36:57studies and Understudies. So these have been brought in
- 37:01and are now taught in universities.
- 37:02So I think I think the the, the, the younger the kids, that the
- 37:06more sort of culturally aware they are at what do you think?
- 37:12Yeah, I was going to say that. I was also going to say that
- 37:15social media is a big, big help, but also specifically since me
- 37:21to broke, I think a lot of women young women, especially feel
- 37:26liberated to speak that sort of Was a catalyst for all sorts of
- 37:32anger. We see Rebecca tracers book
- 37:34that, you know, about being angry and angry women in the, in
- 37:38the follow-up after Trump was elected.
- 37:41After all of these sorts of scandals broke, I think that
- 37:43says a lot about the climate where in and the reaction to
- 37:47that. I know, for me, it was quite
- 37:49visceral. You know, I went from sort of
- 37:51having opinions, but being sort of unsure of how to express them
- 37:55to now, being irate and Just looking for other types of
- 38:02opinions looking for other women or looking to other women, for
- 38:06how they express it, how they're living at their stories.
- 38:08And so, I think for younger women, it's sort of like, you're
- 38:12not going to tolerate the things that a lot of women in previous
- 38:15generations tolerated. And that's also a product of our
- 38:19context, our unique time and place in history.
- 38:23So, I mean, one of the women, I just to give you an example that
- 38:27I spoke to for my, for my Book who had something very.
- 38:31She had very interesting things to say about motherhood, but one
- 38:33of the things she said she's in her early 60s.
- 38:37She said it really bothers me that women would choose to stay
- 38:41home today, we were fighting to have, right?
- 38:45So that women could go back to work.
- 38:46And I feel like you a lot of young people are now choosing to
- 38:49stay home and that that's, you know, that's a real, that's a
- 38:51real shame that does a disservice to everything we've
- 38:53worked for. But today, the fight is about
- 38:56choice and that as a Woman you, if you want to stay home and
- 39:00your and that is your genuine choice, and no one is forcing
- 39:03your hand in that, then that's what we want.
- 39:06We want women to choose and the choice has not always been part
- 39:09of our experience, same thing with the hijab.
- 39:13If those women say that it is their choice, we need to respect
- 39:16that and stop trying to to save them.
- 39:18So, to your point, I think that's just one example.
- 39:21There are, I'm sure there are older women who are very much
- 39:24more in line with the way we feel.
- 39:26But I do think that that must play Into this a little bit.
- 39:32Okay, we have a question back here.
- 39:39Hello. My name is Chris and I like to
- 39:42know if you you think that we're facing right now kind of a
- 39:45backlash. I've been working on feminism
- 39:49since 10 years now and I never saw this kind of violence when
- 39:54you talk about this subject. When you talk about feminism and
- 39:59race topics, I think people are going crazy.
- 40:01We saw that on social media media's, the different political
- 40:06world is also really violent when it comes to this.
- 40:08Questions. So, how can we organize
- 40:10ourselves and how can we fight back?
- 40:19Yes, it's a violent but I think it's violent because it has an
- 40:26effect. Like if you say something that
- 40:29has no affect people with will ignore you.
- 40:32And I think that all the backlash until seeing the fact
- 40:36that ever, since I say something about Vinny's family, some of
- 40:39our race who I have like, major backlash on social media.
- 40:44It means that There's something we we force people who had the
- 40:51means week, know what we experience to hear us like
- 40:56before we were speaking about those issues but, you know,
- 40:59among ourselves. Now, we have the power to bring
- 41:02them to the public, the public sphere, and it's very
- 41:05uncomfortable to people who have privileges because it's
- 41:08questioning their Privileges and the have to deal with what we
- 41:12are saying. And the violence to me is It
- 41:15just means that they have to deal with what we say.
- 41:19So it's not, it's of course, it's very difficult to face that
- 41:22but at the same time, it means that what we say matters and to
- 41:27meet at something, it's at some point.
- 41:30It's positive to have to have a response because if you didn't,
- 41:34if we didn't have any any effect on if we didn't affect change,
- 41:41we would be ignored simply You know I'm an artist and I'm I I'm
- 41:55interested in addressing your perception of universality.
- 41:58This idea my preoccupation is not with activism is not what I
- 42:02spend my life doing. Although it's something that
- 42:04obviously I'm sympathetic and connected to and I think that
- 42:09there's an in some people have said over the years that if
- 42:11women ruled the world that It would be in a very different
- 42:15kind of world. So there is something that's
- 42:18inherent in every woman and in one could say in the female part
- 42:21of men that could enact to shift.
- 42:25And so obviously, yes. I understand that there's issues
- 42:27of ethnic and sexuality and religion and everything that
- 42:30also influence it. But there is do you not believe
- 42:33that there's something that's Universal among women and say
- 42:36the female part of men that needs to be addressed?
- 42:39That needs to be brought forward?
- 42:55The problem with the word universalism comes in in this
- 42:58conversation and in this context is just that it's often been
- 43:01used. As a means of justifying
- 43:06decision-making by a group of people who has four kind of
- 43:11explain, do not represent a default Baseline woman.
- 43:16It's a very specific. It's it's you know, upper class
- 43:21white women have often used Universal to mean, You know, to
- 43:25cover for not bringing other people into the movement.
- 43:30So it's that's my very simple answer.
- 43:32I mean, I think what your question is very interesting and
- 43:38you know, I think the universalism of women or the
- 43:43universalism of yes it's a given I think two people who are also
- 43:49talking about intersectionality that all women have common have
- 43:54some common political goals. But by the problem is we can't
- 43:58use University universality as a kind of euphemism for a certain,
- 44:05a very narrow segment of women and I think that's that's the
- 44:08history of that turns. ERM and then in the debate about
- 44:12feminism, it's not forget that semen.
- 44:14De Beauvoir was a French Aristocrat who never addressed
- 44:17that. A new sap throughout World War
- 44:19Two in the Cafe's flow writing down the menus of the food.
- 44:22She was having. So we need a bit of context and
- 44:25in who wrote what texts and who had access to education.
- 44:27And you know it's like A Room of One's Own.
- 44:30Well it's these are these are first world problems.
- 44:33You know, and these wanting to work, women have always worked
- 44:37in in low class background, you know.
- 44:39So Let's get the, I think the basing it on both of our thought
- 44:44is is a problem. That's yes, what you said at the
- 44:53beginning about that the French Constitution, no longer includes
- 44:57the word racism, Frank's taking three race.
- 45:01I'm sorry. French thinking to me on this
- 45:04seems to be extremely confused. I fail to see how that in any
- 45:07way constitutes an advanced. It's not as if having eliminated
- 45:10that work that in any way, solves, the problem of racism,
- 45:13in France, in America, we do break individuals down our
- 45:17community, stronger minorities down demographically.
- 45:20So we know exactly What the rate of unemployment among black
- 45:24black youths is we know the rate of high school graduation and
- 45:27college graduation and France. Not in any way doing this.
- 45:31It gives them a perfect excuse to ignore the problem of
- 45:34minority unemployment education. Etc.
- 45:37So, would you agree? It's like it's denial.
- 45:48It's like because legally either your French or you're not.
- 45:52And you know, among French people, what you have no doing
- 45:54different but at the same time, you know that if you are black
- 45:58or Arab man, you are 20 times more likely to be checked by the
- 46:02police. But then if you're not and it's
- 46:04documented something that we know, so, being non-white,
- 46:07affects your life, your everyday life in.
- 46:10When you trying to find to find a job, when you try even
- 46:13experiencing the streets, it's not the same.
- 46:16So I think that it's a it's a way just to, to be the
- 46:20delusional about About the fact that we have issue Affairs.
- 46:24When I for example, when I bring race in, in the debate people
- 46:28say that I'm americanizing the debate and I think that I am
- 46:33importing issues that I'm importing issues from the US
- 46:37that don't exist here in friends because we have no rest because
- 46:41nothing the Constitution. So I believe I have, I guess, I
- 46:44don't take this as a black person here as well.
- 46:47And the same thing is by, ignore, not it by ignoring it.
- 46:52Denying that exists. You don't have the tools to
- 46:54confront the racism that is going on and so that is hugely
- 46:59problematic and that's also the work that Milwaukee is doing is
- 47:03really confronting that and then she gets backlash for trying to
- 47:06do that. So in this case, when you go to
- 47:09the work that voce is doing, you know, again her experience as a
- 47:14journalist and a woman is different from our experience.
- 47:20When we have other things that You know, we were up against,
- 47:23but no, those are, those are big serious issues.
- 47:25And so until France, and I don't think it'll ever happen to be
- 47:29honest, but until they can sort of detached this obsession with
- 47:33the national identity as being, you know, tied to this one
- 47:37image, that isn't even realistic.
- 47:39We're going to keep facing the same, the same battles.
- 47:42It will take one more question. Hello, I'm a retired educator.
- 47:50I used to teach in a public French University and I had
- 47:54quite a few Muslim, female students.
- 47:58And we've tonight, you've spoken a lot about the white male.
- 48:04You haven't spoken about the, the communities that some of
- 48:09these girls live in. And I remember under Olam, there
- 48:14was a minister was A woman called a new food, new sumi's,
- 48:19or something like that. And she brought up this issue.
- 48:22She said that often times there is pressure from the community
- 48:29from the man and the brothers Etc to to wear the hijab for
- 48:35example, and I had colleagues who were, who are of North
- 48:41African descent and who were really against the veil.
- 48:46They said, But we have as feminist North Africans, we've
- 48:49really fought for this. We don't want to see the veil in
- 48:53in a public university. I was wondering if you'd like to
- 48:56mention any of that. Thank you for your questions,
- 49:02your question because it's, we really need to to make a here.
- 49:06So, I'm missing too, and I don't wear a hijab.
- 49:08My mother is covered. So to me, what's most important
- 49:12is what you said in tonight Choice.
- 49:15Like, I don't want to force anyone to look as I look, so if
- 49:19a woman wants to wear hijab, we have to support her, but if she
- 49:22doesn't, we also have to support her in a few choice.
- 49:26And the minister you mention is for the Rama who started an
- 49:29organization, Wasn't any business with you as a minister
- 49:32and a Sarkozy and organization. It was it was started I think in
- 49:35the early 2000s to support women in the volume who were facing
- 49:43sexism in their communities. And the thing is that I think it
- 49:47was very necessary. But at the same time I have the
- 49:50feeling that it was used as an excuse to focus on a certain
- 49:55type of sexism and to excuse the rest of the society.
- 49:59Like, oh, Oh, those people are so sexist.
- 50:01We need to support them. And not questioning the fact
- 50:04that if you are Muslim women in the value, you are facing a
- 50:07sexism from your in your community but also also out of
- 50:11your community. If you're looking for a job, if
- 50:13you're trying to have a corporate, you are facing
- 50:15sexism. And so it puts us, I said us as
- 50:18a Muslim women in a very difficult position because we
- 50:23know that there is a racist bias focusing on the mailman of your
- 50:28communities and That's questioning the whole sexism but
- 50:32at the same time we have to address that specific sexism.
- 50:35So there is a there was as idea that as a women and minority
- 50:40women. You have to leave your community
- 50:43to the free and it's very, you know, and you know, you have to
- 50:49chew to leave your brother your father because it was the source
- 50:53of your oppression. And if you leave your community,
- 50:56you will be a French woman and you will be free, because you
- 50:59would be Loading in the Republic and that was it that the issue I
- 51:03had with me pretty soon he's because I started with, you
- 51:06know, as I stand with them but at the same time there was there
- 51:09were there were used. I remember there was the face of
- 51:12the woman from leaving. His room.
- 51:14Is that was posting in front of the desolate, like the also
- 51:18swimming those women who are Arab and blacks with the the
- 51:21bone Ephesian, you know, the have that denying the symbol of
- 51:25the Republic has, and it was very funny because inside the
- 51:28seen it does, it does. Most of the elected official,
- 51:33We're Men. So what does it mean to say that
- 51:36you are families, you know, having those displaying those
- 51:39faces when you are not inside earlier, have having, you know
- 51:45the same number of women elected as it was I think it was like
- 51:4980% mayor and 80% male assembly. So it was to meet was very
- 51:55hypocrite, a hypocrite because you know it it's a load of a
- 52:01group of you know universities to to to have that to give the
- 52:09impression that they were families and not addressing
- 52:11their own sexism. So it's okay.
- 52:15Thank you so much everybody for being here again and for your
- 52:17questions and thank you to our family.