Latest / Beyond This by Zaheerah Bham Ismail / Charity Beyond Giving - Season 2: Episode 1 - Beyond This with Zaheerah Bham Ismail
Transcript
- 0:14Asilo Molique Marama Talahi Wabarakatuh.
- 0:17Welcome back to Beyond This, a space where we explore faith,
- 0:21purpose and what comes next, both personally and
- 0:25collectively. Today we're speaking about
- 0:27something that every single one of us as Muslims understand, but
- 0:31perhaps don't fully appreciate it in its entirety.
- 0:34Charity in Islam. Is it simply giving money or is
- 0:38it actually a system designed to transform societies and we
- 0:42couldn't think about having someone better qualified to be
- 0:45able to have this discussion in studio with us.
- 0:47Then check Ibrahim Mahaboudi. Shahi Ibrahim is an Islamic
- 0:51scholar, community development practitioner and the author of
- 0:55The Institution of Zika as a Development Tool from a South
- 0:58African Perspective. Assalamualaikum Sheikh and
- 1:01welcome to the studios. Sara Shukran for the invitation.
- 1:06It's my great honour being. Here, Al Hamriya, it's always a
- 1:09pleasure to be in your company and to learn from you.
- 1:11Check. We know you as a very prominent
- 1:14scholar in the South African context, but we've also seen you
- 1:17as an author putting yourself in the forefront, whether you
- 1:20intended or not, but from charity, from a South African
- 1:23perspective and shaping the way many of our organisations see
- 1:27charity and do charity. But before we get into that,
- 1:31tell us a little bit about yourself, Chef, in terms of your
- 1:34own story and how you've had this lived purpose that's
- 1:38brought you to where you are. Yeah, firstly, Shukran for the
- 1:42question Stasera and I'm sure you're going to ask me quite a
- 1:46bit of questions related to that.
- 1:48Feel free. What I can answer, I will
- 1:50answer. If I cannot answer, I will let
- 1:52you know. Yeah.
- 1:53So I'm a rivet. I'm the blessed me and my family
- 1:59with the religion of Islam, which is a blessing that I
- 2:02cherish. Why do I say this?
- 2:04Because I cannot speak of my story without speaking about the
- 2:11meaning that Islam has brought into me.
- 2:14It's it's a it's what defines me.
- 2:17It's who I am. You know, as much as growing up,
- 2:20there were many extended families, but I think as soon as
- 2:23myself and my family, my mother having embraced Islam, Islam
- 2:28became almost the primary family even before my, you know,
- 2:33extended relatives. So I'll Handler.
- 2:35That is one blessing that I always highlight whenever I come
- 2:38to speaking platforms which I thought I should share.
- 2:41That's absolutely beautiful. Share all your lived experience.
- 2:45You wrote about this in your interview at Al Kalam that it's
- 2:48impacted greatly on how you saw charity in a South African
- 2:53perspective, obviously from an Islamic context as well.
- 2:56How is that shaped your vision in terms of how we need to be
- 3:00doing charity? That basically was the
- 3:01inspiration behind your book as well.
- 3:04Yes, yes, yeah. So quite often people would
- 3:07wonder why are you so obsessed about, you know, charity being
- 3:12and means of changing lives, Why you're so obsessed about charity
- 3:16and dignity? Why is this obsession?
- 3:18Because I mean, if you look at the study of Zaka, there are so
- 3:22many topics, Zaka and charity in a broader sense, there are so
- 3:26many discussions that take place within Zaka from a fake
- 3:29perspective. You would quite often find
- 3:32myself as well-being versed in the Zakar in terms of his
- 3:36physical conduct workshop on behalf of Senseof as well.
- 3:39You would find quite often we speak about Zaka from the thick
- 3:43perspective. We speak about who has to give
- 3:45zaka, what is the threshold of Zaka?
- 3:48What are the rules of zaka? Well and good.
- 3:51And those should be in place because Zaki is an act of
- 3:54Rabada. So you've got to be very almost
- 3:57intentional and scientific and well calculated in the manner
- 4:01that you do. So why my obsession with regards
- 4:05to the changing lives, the dignity that is related to the
- 4:08zaka. For me, this is not too much of
- 4:11an academic exercise as much as I've written a book and
- 4:15obviously it may come across as academic.
- 4:18This is something which comes from a very deep place within
- 4:22me. This come from my lived
- 4:24experiences being someone who has been through, you know, the,
- 4:29the, the road of poverty, difficulty and suffering.
- 4:34Along the way. You do realise, you know what,
- 4:37there's a lot of value that has been added in your life, but in
- 4:41spite of that, there's quite a huge gap that exists with
- 4:45regards to the other dynamics that are related to Zaki,
- 4:48especially the inner dimensions, the social dimensions and
- 4:52elements of spirituality as well.
- 4:54Hence the motivation of writing this book and I can share with
- 4:58you, you know, examples in my personal life with regards to
- 5:02some of what motivated me to write the.
- 5:04Book I know in Ramadan we often say we are probably the most
- 5:09generous community. People just give and give and
- 5:12give. But the car is not just an act
- 5:16of kindness that we're doing because it actually is a pillar
- 5:18of Islam and it has been defined as that.
- 5:21And as she's saying, there's so much more to it than just a
- 5:24handout or giving. It has to be transformational.
- 5:27But when she's talking about dignity, I think as a community,
- 5:31and I've often mentioned this and posted about it, that we
- 5:34often forget that in our acts of doing for others, we may be
- 5:38causing more harm or violating people's dignity in our aspect
- 5:42of trying to do good. Yeah, yeah.
- 5:45Well, as much as I'm passionate about this subject, Sister
- 5:50Zahra, I wouldn't blame many a person who hasn't been through
- 5:54the corridors of poverty. Sometimes people do it
- 5:57unconsciously, they are not aware.
- 5:59You know, quite often when Muslims give charity, the first
- 6:03thing that is in the mind is how can I maximise thawab?
- 6:07There's nothing wrong with it. So sometimes the charity that we
- 6:11do is also done from a business type of mindset.
- 6:15So meaning if I've got 1000 rands, how do I try to make this
- 6:19thousand rents go further? Meaning I must make 100?
- 6:22Question probably. Yes, I must make 100 hampers
- 6:26from the 1000 rands. So the mindset of I'm trying to
- 6:30maximise the web. So people tend to forget that
- 6:33Thawab is illustrative. A person can give something
- 6:37which is seemingly small, right? Or you can even give a an amount
- 6:41of 100,000 tends to one individual, but you are purpose
- 6:44driven, you are outcomes driven. You want to make a
- 6:47transformation and a change in that person's life.
- 6:50Do you think Allah is not aware what you are trying to do as
- 6:53opposed to saying I want to in my mind so Allah the dumb
- 6:56stretching. Ultimately The thing is about
- 6:59intentionality. It's about what you ultimately
- 7:02wanting to achieve. Just give you a simple example
- 7:05with regards to when I was growing up, right, how sometimes
- 7:11well-intentioned and people may not be aware.
- 7:15I grew up going to school where you would find in schools
- 7:19generally children who are poor, children who come maybe without
- 7:23lunch boxes and so forth. You would find there's a feeding
- 7:26scheme that happens within the school, which is very good.
- 7:29I'll Hamdullah and it really closes a massive gap.
- 7:32But I want to tell you an angle of me being the recipient of
- 7:36that type of charity during my school days.
- 7:39I would say from the what grade four, grade 5 at that time.
- 7:43So what would happen during break times, the lady that
- 7:47distributes the free meals, they would come to the class and say,
- 7:51those who are on the charity less may come and collect their,
- 7:55you know, they collect the, their lunch and so forth.
- 7:58So for the school or for the person who's distributing, they
- 8:01don't see us anything wrong for them.
- 8:03They distributing food, They, they, they making it easy for
- 8:08the learners. And you cannot say be too harsh
- 8:10on them. You just need to sit them down.
- 8:13I only realise this at a later stage that this type of
- 8:17approach, this type of giving was actually eroding on my
- 8:21dignity because even as young as I was, I must have been 10-11
- 8:25years old. There was a sense of feeling
- 8:28that this is uncomfortable that all your friends and your peers
- 8:32are sitting there. Many of them have come with
- 8:34their fancy lunches and so forth.
- 8:37You on a daily basis, you are coming to be called from the
- 8:40class. Why what, what makes you so
- 8:42different? You know what that does that
- 8:44makes you feel from that very young age that you are probably
- 8:48different. You probably do not, do not
- 8:50deserve better in life, even with kids.
- 8:53I mean, there are those elements of mockery to say you're getting
- 8:55free food from the school and this continues.
- 8:59Can you imagine this continues for a period of four or five,
- 9:02six years of your schooling, How much of psychological damage it
- 9:06does emotional, even if you may be the smartest kid in the
- 9:09class, there's always a sense of, you know what?
- 9:13I don't think I'm that good. It cannot be.
- 9:16And this has a major impact in your life throughout wherever
- 9:19you go. Now one day someone comes and
- 9:21gives you an opportunity to uplift you.
- 9:25You sort of very skeptical about it.
- 9:27You're not sure about it because why you don't see yourself as
- 9:31someone that can be developed to such a level where you can be
- 9:35able to be the giver next time. So it really, really has some
- 9:39impactful. That's why I'm saying this thing
- 9:40is very emotional, very close to home.
- 9:43And sometimes I get too personal and angry about it.
- 9:47But I, you know, I tell myself and admonish myself the journey
- 9:51that I've been through, not everybody's, you can't blame
- 9:53people. All you can do, whenever you get
- 9:55a platform, you share with people, whether individually on
- 9:58a one to one basis, whether on public platforms, when, whether
- 10:01in writing your books and hoping inshallah that the mindset would
- 10:05shift overtime. No shift, I think.
- 10:08Highly, highly justified and these are the discussions that
- 10:11we need to have. We could so often people are
- 10:13well-intentioned, well meaning, but we don't understand.
- 10:16I think we have to bring back our level of consciousness in
- 10:20how we doing things because something is simple.
- 10:22I mean, I'm listening to the Shaheed thinking something as
- 10:24simple as the words that are being used are groups being
- 10:27isolated from a class being identified differently.
- 10:31Those are things that make children feel so different, so
- 10:33other. And as Sheikh rightly said, how
- 10:37psychologically the impact of that becomes so long lasting and
- 10:40that in the attempt to do good we end up doing more harm to the
- 10:44people around. Us precisely.
- 10:46Yeah. You know, the aspect of dignity,
- 10:50what actually drives any individual person to say, I want
- 10:55to uplift myself, I want to come out of the dungeons.
- 10:58I want to be someone who's a giver the most.
- 11:01In my experience, my 20 experience, being in community
- 11:04development, interacting with people.
- 11:06One of the most outstanding factors is the fact that if
- 11:10anyone has dignity, do you know how easy or how much more
- 11:15simpler is going to be for you to be able to uplift them, to
- 11:18develop them as opposed to a person who's got no sense of
- 11:21dignity? Once the dignity is ripped out
- 11:23of a person, they've got nothing to lose.
- 11:26So for them is that how can I get entitlement bring no matter
- 11:30what it takes, My face can be scarred in front of people, it
- 11:34doesn't matter. But if a person still has that
- 11:37sense of dignity within them, any developmental opportunity
- 11:41that comes to to the fore in front of them, irrespective of
- 11:45how long it's going to take, irrespective how how painful the
- 11:48journey is going to be, they are prepared to say no, bring it on.
- 11:52I'm ready for the pain. I know it's not easy because why
- 11:55my dignity matters? I'm not going to be disgracing,
- 12:00humiliating myself on a daily basis, stretching my hand for a
- 12:04loaf of bread because why Allah has given me something which
- 12:07there's no price for it, no amount of money can pay for the
- 12:12dignity. Once a person loses their
- 12:14dignity, which is sometimes we as charity organisations are
- 12:18mistake that we make. So you think you are giving
- 12:22handouts so much handouts to a person or to communities, you
- 12:26know, they're happy for that particular moment.
- 12:28Guess what? The next person from whichever
- 12:31other religion, theology, ideology that comes with a
- 12:35better hamper, a better gift, they're going to grab it and
- 12:38follow that. So why, why is the person being
- 12:41able to why, why, why does the person just grab anything that
- 12:44comes from anyway? It's because they've been
- 12:46stripped out of the dignity. Had they had dignity, they would
- 12:49have said, no, I know where I get my my food.
- 12:52I know where my plate of food comes from.
- 12:55I just thank you very much. I know you offered me something,
- 12:58but I've got a sense of dignity to preserve.
- 13:00Now that is dignified. Now that is community building
- 13:03and that this person did belding.
- 13:06That's amazing. But sure, how do we, where
- 13:08there's communities, as charity organisations, as individuals
- 13:11who are doing this, how do we preserve and maintain the
- 13:14dignity or even enhance the dignity of individuals?
- 13:17I know one of the things that I read that I and I thought we've
- 13:21made so many mistakes over the years as an organization that
- 13:25we've gone into homes and given hampers to families with the
- 13:29father standing there, the mother standing there and
- 13:31children are watching that somebody else is providing for
- 13:34them instead of calling the parents separately to a separate
- 13:37area and allowing them to take those hampers and to give it to
- 13:40their family. So they are still seen as a
- 13:42providers. Yeah.
- 13:43What a what a very important point that you mentioned.
- 13:46I mean, I mentioned to you how painful as a kid when you see
- 13:51your dignity being eroded. Just imagine a father who's a
- 13:54breadwinner, a father who goes out trying to fend for their
- 13:58families, goes out in the morning and then the next thing
- 14:04when they come back in the evening with some parcel of
- 14:06food, they are seen on some social media that aim.
- 14:09My daddy went to go and pick up a parcel of food from swim.
- 14:12So the father came back home with a sense of pride to say,
- 14:16you know what, my wife, my children, I went to go and slog.
- 14:20I went to go and make, I brought this home.
- 14:22And then they see the picture. What Can you imagine the
- 14:25psychological damage on the children, not on the father
- 14:28alone on himself. And like you mentioned,
- 14:30sometimes you go, you're giving out the temper given that food
- 14:33parcel, the mother is there, the wife is there, the children are
- 14:36there. They're all watching.
- 14:37They're all, you know, pictures been taken in front of
- 14:39everybody. The poor father is emasculated
- 14:42in front of his own family. He cannot say anything, even
- 14:46though I mean the the children or the family to a very large
- 14:49degree, there's a sense of diminishing in respect to say
- 14:53you're a father, but you can't, even though the children won't
- 14:55say right. And you know what this happened,
- 14:57what this leads to, it leads to a perpetual cycle, an
- 15:01intergenerational of impoverished mindsets.
- 15:04My father was a receiver of handouts.
- 15:07My father who used to always seem on pictures, people used to
- 15:10come from on the outside on a daily basis and give them.
- 15:13And that's what who that means. That's our destiny, That's who
- 15:15we're supposed to be as opposed to say if we This is why this is
- 15:19Zaki should be localised. Zakar should be with people that
- 15:23you you sort of make your homework.
- 15:25You know these people, you can more or less people see people
- 15:27who are poor. You call the father.
- 15:30You know, whether in your institution, what are you
- 15:33struggling with? What is the problem?
- 15:35Why are you unable to make ends meet?
- 15:38And you'll be surprised the amount of things that you will
- 15:40dig out of there. And hopefully, inshallah, he may
- 15:43be a proper breadwinner if we do it from that perspective, with
- 15:48that patience, with that focus and, you know, giving our
- 15:52attention and focus to to uplifting the father.
- 15:56I want to come back into that because I think that unpacks a
- 15:58whole lot for us in terms of the dynamics of a way forward.
- 16:01But I want to touch on something that Check mentioned now this
- 16:04this picture taking because I have a big issue with that.
- 16:09And I just think that, you know, as checkpointed out, imagine
- 16:12seeing something on social media that it's one of your family
- 16:15members in much the same way. It could be one of us standing
- 16:18in that line. And now our picture is put all
- 16:20over. And I always say to donors, if
- 16:22you want pictures, we'll take pictures of the hampers or of
- 16:25the building or something else. But I don't understand the need
- 16:28of having to take videos and pictures of recipients
- 16:31collecting food, regardless of who they are.
- 16:33Because as Shahi saying, we're taking away dignity consistently
- 16:37from people. Yeah, I guess you're right
- 16:40Sister Zahra. I think the problem also is the
- 16:43sensationalism that has to come into the marketing.
- 16:47So you find a charity organisation are between a rock
- 16:51and a hard place. Now thinking if I don't
- 16:53sensationalise and emotionalise this type of giving, I may lose
- 16:57an important donor who says they want to see the picture.
- 17:01They want to see the child with torn clothing patch face, You
- 17:05know, I mean, and some of these pictures, sometimes they remain
- 17:08on the brochures for years. They remain on the social media
- 17:11even way after that person has passed through that stage.
- 17:15I think a donor education is also very, very important.
- 17:18You know, the donor mindset has to shift because as long as the
- 17:22donor mindshift doesn't mindset doesn't shift, organization will
- 17:26perpetually do that. Because if that brings them the
- 17:28ultimate, that most amount of income, they'll they'll, they'll
- 17:33thrive on that. They'll thrive on that.
- 17:34It's very difficult for an organization to say no.
- 17:37We, we we're taking a principle point.
- 17:39You know, you may keep, we're not being unkind to you.
- 17:42We're not being, you know, not considerate to your request.
- 17:47But this is not how we do business because, yeah, this is
- 17:50not how we do business. This is how because our aim of
- 17:54giving charity is to uplift and dignify a human being that Allah
- 17:58says well Akaram Nabani Adam, each and every single child of
- 18:02Adam and this does not even mention about belief system
- 18:05whatever. Every human being has been given
- 18:08a sense of dignity, that is the birth right which they possess.
- 18:12So uphold that. Why start the person out of
- 18:14dignity? If they if we cannot give them
- 18:17anything, at least keep their dignity intact and walk away
- 18:20from them. But there's so many points.
- 18:23One of the points Sheik mentioned now also is the fact
- 18:26that we wait to see people with those torn clothes, and we wait
- 18:30to see them completely desolate and in complete despair before
- 18:33we decide that they should be recipients of charity.
- 18:37And is this not also a problem with us as organizations has
- 18:41Donna mindsets that we need to change, that we decide how what
- 18:45level of poverty there needs to be before we uplift people's
- 18:48dignity, before we start using Zakar to transform.
- 18:51Because at that level, all we are doing is consistent handouts
- 18:55and nothing more than that. Yes, precisely, very, very book.
- 18:58Important point which I also mentioned in the book Sister
- 19:02Zahra. So sometimes to us, poverty as a
- 19:05particular face, you know, poverty as a particular type of
- 19:08garb that it looks in. If it doesn't look that way, it
- 19:11means the person is not poor. There are people who are just
- 19:14not accustomed to begging. There are people who are just
- 19:17not accustomed to knocking on the doors of organisations and
- 19:20saying I've got a need, They've got a sense of self respect,
- 19:23they've got a sense of self earth and dignity.
- 19:27When they think sometimes the amount of red tape that they've
- 19:31got to have to go through. And you know, I mean the, the
- 19:37disrespecting themselves that they have to go through in order
- 19:39to receive sometimes something amounting to 500 rands, they'll
- 19:43rather do without it. So this is the mistake where we
- 19:46look for poverty too. We wait for poverty to look a
- 19:50particular way. Take for instance, I think I
- 19:53mentioned in the book as well, during the time of COVID.
- 19:57Well, it was a very sensitive time and people were struck with
- 20:00their calamity. Even people who were well off
- 20:03became poor, right? But if you look at the trend,
- 20:06that time, the people were given much more attention.
- 20:09The street kids, people who are roaming around, people who
- 20:12already they're accustomed to begging, they are gonna get food
- 20:16in any case. But there's a father who lost
- 20:19his job overnight. Someone's business became
- 20:22bankrupt overnight. They could provide.
- 20:24Suddenly they cannot provide. Who goes to those people's doors
- 20:28and say, you know, Imran is Haq Mohammad, I know you were doing
- 20:32well and I know your particular type of business is a business
- 20:35that with COVID, you're not going to make it.
- 20:38How is it? Can we, how in which way can we
- 20:41keep you afloat so you don't become, you know, like porn and
- 20:46tattered and red. Keep it quiet silently because
- 20:50we know if you come up you, you get onto your feet, you are
- 20:53going to give 10 times more than us just blushing the zaka all
- 20:58over. So unfortunately this mindset
- 21:00that the zaka must have that face is what also perpetuate
- 21:04this type of thing Allah says in the Quran.
- 21:09With similar Rohan Rahim Lil for Cora in Ladino 0 Fisabilillah
- 21:13lies the tour owner Darban Filardo.
- 21:17I mean, I thought of so a lot speaking about sadaka in the
- 21:21Koran just to Conte's Sadaka is for the for Kara, right?
- 21:26These are people who they are not able to travel or they are
- 21:30not able to go out. Yeah.
- 21:32Sabu who will Jahilo Aranya Aminata awful.
- 21:35If you look at them outwardly, you know someone who is who is
- 21:39not aware. When you look at a person
- 21:41outwardly, you may think that they are rich because why?
- 21:44Because of the type of the way they conduct themselves, their
- 21:47self respect. The Alfie means abstention from
- 21:51begging. They're not people who would go
- 21:53around asking this is you would mistaken them for being rich and
- 21:57you deprive them of sadaka and charity.
- 21:59Whereas there are people who are actually deserving of Sadaka.
- 22:02John Hamm Ruler Sheikh, just to go back a little bit when Sheikh
- 22:06mentioned now in terms of the faces that we see or we paint as
- 22:10being Zakar eligible. How do we as organisations find
- 22:14that balance of we need to do right by the funding that has
- 22:17come in to ensure that it goes to the right recipients, but
- 22:20also being able to ensure that you're giving it to the people
- 22:24who may not always like she says, look the face of poverty.
- 22:28But we know I need is it because we don't have the capacity, we
- 22:31don't have people who are trained enough to be able to
- 22:34understand that the car has to be transformational and not just
- 22:37a mere handout where we how do we fill that gap so that we
- 22:41change it? Yeah.
- 22:42I think part of it, what you mentioned, I think it's a very
- 22:45fact that we cannot runaway from the fact that there's a lack of
- 22:48capacity, there's a lack of skilled people.
- 22:53You know, sometimes if you accompany or an organization
- 22:57wants to hire, if you tell them this is an accountant that needs
- 23:01to be hired and they want to hire community development
- 23:04practitioner, their salaries will be miles.
- 23:06Yes, yes, because it is seen as if the content is bringing more
- 23:11value as opposed to the seasoned community development
- 23:15practitioner who has been through the grassroots, who's
- 23:17been through the mill, who knows what's what.
- 23:20He's not moved by sympathy anymore.
- 23:22You are not moved just by mere sensationalism or emotion.
- 23:25You can be bombarded with so many type of social media
- 23:28advertisements. You can see right through the
- 23:30gaps. Excuse me, you know what is
- 23:35happening, but that type of a person if he says to say no,
- 23:38this is what I need for me to be able to perform statistically,
- 23:42to do the analysis for you to take a gradual path towards
- 23:46outcomes based development and charity giving people to look at
- 23:51you and say you sick, you know something wrong with you.
- 23:53This is not going to happen. And also, I mean, you can blame
- 23:56the organization, but even donors themselves to say I'm
- 23:59never going to pay for something like this.
- 24:01It doesn't make sense. So you would rather continue
- 24:05dishing out exorbitant amount of charity for 20 years in the
- 24:09community without seeing any tangible results as opposed to
- 24:14putting money up front, which is meant to really put a strategy
- 24:18in place, a plan in place, a focus in place, which may part
- 24:23the type of giving probably by half or even less than that.
- 24:27But why? You've done your homework,
- 24:28you've done your due diligence before you gave your charity.
- 24:32So as long as that exists where people see more value in just
- 24:36dishing out as opposed to investing in the resources, then
- 24:40we are constantly going to the type of.
- 24:43Work, but that's a check. When I look at the amount of the
- 24:45car that comes out just out of South Africa, forget the world.
- 24:49I mean, if we look at the Zika in our communities that come out
- 24:52that we know we have to give, that we have to distribute, I
- 24:55almost feel like it's become a tick box.
- 24:57Ohh, I've given my Zacar tick. I can continue for the rest of
- 25:00the year. But with the amount that we've
- 25:02been given, how are we not transforming and changing lives?
- 25:06I almost feel like sometimes it suits us to keep people in
- 25:10positions they in so we can go, here's our recipients of Zika.
- 25:13Let's just go keep ticking these boxes.
- 25:15But how often do we go to these places and say, why haven't we
- 25:18changed lives of communities, lives of families here to be
- 25:22able to make a difference so they become recipient givers of
- 25:25Zika? Yes, you're right.
- 25:27I mean, it's, it may sound harsh to say sometimes it may appear
- 25:30as if it suits us, but I mean, I work in communities, most
- 25:34communities, this is what they tell us.
- 25:35They tell me in certain instances to say it suits these
- 25:39organisations to actually keep us in a state of perpetual state
- 25:43of poverty so they can be employable, so they can have a
- 25:46purpose for, for, for continuity, Because if they take
- 25:50us out of poverty, then they will never purpose of existence.
- 25:53And I mean, and that's a fallacy because they may have other
- 25:56purposes. There's always work to be done.
- 25:58But unfortunately, so community says, I mean, I met communities
- 26:01who would even say we don't want zaka hampers here in our
- 26:05communities, Although you can see there's a need, there's
- 26:08poverty, there's people who are impoverished, but they're sick
- 26:11and tired. They say, how long are we going
- 26:13to be receiving handouts for the rest of our lives?
- 26:15Certain communities that I've ever been involved with my
- 26:18sister's here you would find a community for the last 20 years
- 26:22without any exaggeration, badges of 200 to about 400,000 being
- 26:28pumped into those communities and those madaris 20 years you
- 26:33go into the community, you ask yourself what change has
- 26:36happened, What difference has happened?
- 26:38No change whatsoever. The needle has not moved yet.
- 26:42What the money still Cape keeps on pumping no questions asked.
- 26:46If I can address us. You know, sometimes there's this
- 26:48obsession about how many keys you have in your madressa.
- 26:51You know if if some if certain share has 20 kids, he still got
- 26:562 little number. You know someone else has 100
- 26:59keys or 200 kids, but nobody opposed to that community after
- 27:03five years and say share. Five years ago you told us you
- 27:06have 200 kids. Out of those 200 kids, how many
- 27:10are on their feet? How many can you pinpoint and
- 27:12say they are still Muslim up to this day?
- 27:15How many can you pinpoint and say they are a resource now for
- 27:19your community? Nobody asks that particular
- 27:21question. You know what the donor does
- 27:23every year come and ask you the same question.
- 27:25How many students do? Has the number increased?
- 27:27What does number increase has to do with any sort of impact and
- 27:31meaningful difference in our community?
- 27:33So it's a mindset change which has to be really passionately be
- 27:37spoken about and driven into our heads.
- 27:40And at every level, like she's saying, at the charity
- 27:43organizations level, at the donor level, at the recipient,
- 27:47but it has to be done at every level cohesively so that we
- 27:50start seeing more impactful differences in our lives.
- 27:53But check, where do we start? How do we start making those
- 27:56changes? How?
- 27:56Because Zika also, like we said, as much as it's a collective
- 28:00duty, it's a very personal duty as well.
- 28:02How do we change, start making changes that our charity,
- 28:07whether it's a car, Sedaka Lila, is not just a once off tick the
- 28:11box through the year, but it's something that we change the way
- 28:14we do it so that we make those transformational changes.
- 28:18Yeah, I think part of it is that the education that we start
- 28:21Alhamdella, we can say that as a starting and there are many
- 28:23organisations also who are beginning to speak about the
- 28:27development and they're really trying to go towards the right
- 28:31direction. But I think the deeper thing is
- 28:34also about intentionality. You know, I mean intentional
- 28:38intention people can say is intangible how you judge
- 28:40people's. But I think each and every
- 28:43organisation or donor that gives to any organisation needs to ask
- 28:47themselves, what is it that I want to see posted as giving off
- 28:52my money? What are the outcomes that I'm.
- 28:55I'm not saying things are going to be perfect.
- 28:57Remember, development is a very long path.
- 29:00It's got many obstacles and challenges along the way.
- 29:03It's not, it's not an ideal type of a situation.
- 29:06But as long as we've, we've done due diligence when we started
- 29:10it, we've done our homework, just like how someone does what
- 29:13they call it market research. Before you start a business, you
- 29:16do, you do needs analysis and so forth.
- 29:19That type of a due diligence where the organization, the
- 29:25donor as well. Yeah.
- 29:27And the donor ask themselves, after a period of five years, a
- 29:31period of 10 years, what are the tangible results that we need to
- 29:34see as opposed to giving emotionally?
- 29:37Quite often the giving is emotionally.
- 29:39This is why there's no even question about the results being
- 29:43present. So yeah, I guess the education
- 29:47and the changing of mindset in terms of giving and also
- 29:51involving communities in the what you call the thing, the
- 29:58cycle of this whole cycle of charity.
- 30:00Quite often the ones that are poor, they are, they are just
- 30:04recipients, they are just one side there.
- 30:07They are not, they are not to be consulted.
- 30:09Their opinion doesn't matter. Sometimes asking a poor person
- 30:12what do you need is very, very important.
- 30:15And how do you ask that that you ask through the community
- 30:18development practitioner, people whom you can trust, people who
- 30:21got a track record, people who got a, you know, working
- 30:25relationship with community. And they give you written type
- 30:28of analysis and evidence based input with regards to where you
- 30:32should spend your money. And I think that's so important
- 30:35because we often make the mistake of giving people what we
- 30:39think they should have. And I've often seen this where
- 30:41we go into places and again, well meaning, just not well
- 30:46executed, where we'll pack a hamper, go into a community with
- 30:50no insight into the type of food the community eats.
- 30:53The cultural implications of the community are the taste buds of
- 30:57the community. And for example, you'll be
- 30:59giving Haleem into an area where they have no idea what that's
- 31:02about. And we don't even, but we just
- 31:05think, ohh, we're doing good. So again, it comes back like
- 31:07she's saying that awareness for ourselves as well to have an
- 31:11understanding of the communities we working with, know the
- 31:14people, the community are practitioners in the area who
- 31:17would be able to help facilitate this in a more dignified manner.
- 31:20Yes, yeah. You know, there's a very famous
- 31:22statement that I read which says as, as a charity organizations,
- 31:28we tend to focus more on, on products as opposed to focusing
- 31:32on relationships. O our thing is about giving out
- 31:35the product and not building relationships.
- 31:37There's a particular community that I worked in a couple of
- 31:40years ago. So this organization every
- 31:43Thursday evening, they come to a grave site where I think for the
- 31:49Salah thawab of the deceased shack and they distribute the
- 31:52soup, whether it's halim or some sort of a speciality for their
- 31:55community, which is good for the palette.
- 31:58So any of the impoverished people within the community
- 32:01would come and line up in that grave site and they, you know,
- 32:05they dish for them that soup and they now working in that
- 32:09community. I would hear like the way this
- 32:11thing is taken like a joke, how people who go in that line are
- 32:15mocked and taken, you know, like they take it like with the
- 32:18lowest of the low in the community because you know what
- 32:21happens as well. Besides the fact that they
- 32:23queuing up for that free soup, it makes the stomach run, you
- 32:26know, because of the spiciness or whatever.
- 32:28It's not part of the pellet is not what they eat.
- 32:31So people would make joke. It means if you go and collect
- 32:34food, then it means you've researched desperation,
- 32:36desperation levels that you've got no other option besides you
- 32:40can collect that type of a soup because I think even if you had
- 32:42a tinned fish and a loaf of bread in your house, you would
- 32:45rather stick to that than when stand in that queue and collect
- 32:50that free meal. Now this recognization little
- 32:54realising the damage they are doing in the community in their
- 32:57mind, us our up is our are we gaining so much rewards?
- 33:01You are killing a community. You are destroying people's
- 33:04mindsets, you know, and and that is associated with Islam.
- 33:08Remember, they view Muslims at this type of people who impose
- 33:11their giving. They impose their way of doing
- 33:14things in a community as opposed to consulting and engaging with
- 33:19community for the betterment of themselves and their, you know,
- 33:22future generations. Very, very well said.
- 33:26I think, you know, if any part of this is making any of us
- 33:29uncomfortable, it's something we need to introspect and we need
- 33:32to look at how we doing it. Are we doing right by the people
- 33:36that we are providing our charity to?
- 33:39Are we including them in the process and decision making
- 33:42process? And most importantly, are we
- 33:44preserving the dignity of people?
- 33:46So if the one thing I'm taking so strongly from this is the
- 33:48importance of having community practitioner, development
- 33:52practitioners as part of our processes.
- 33:55Where there's organisations, we see so many families opening
- 33:58trusts to do charities to do good.
- 34:00But if you don't have this, that link between you and the
- 34:03community that's receiving, it won't be there.
- 34:06It is going to be challenging and broken.
- 34:08Yes, and you hold the community petition accountable, you ask
- 34:10them questions. It's just like how you would do
- 34:12in your reporting in business. There has to be a constant
- 34:15reporting. There has to be accountability.
- 34:17It's not it's not the sympathy thing.
- 34:19Shame. You know, it's a poor Malana.
- 34:20No. Do you like a skill about a
- 34:22particular thing? Do you like a skill about
- 34:24survey? Do you like a skill about
- 34:26community strategic planning? Do you like a skill about
- 34:29community visioning? We can take you for that.
- 34:31We can train you for that. Maybe you have other skills, but
- 34:35we can train you for everything so that you become competent to
- 34:37the core. We want to spend money on you
- 34:39anyway. We're going to, we're going to,
- 34:43we look for the best from you after we've spent that type of
- 34:46money. So there has to be that element
- 34:48of, you know, the community practitioners that you, you, you
- 34:50speaking about and you find quite often this type of
- 34:54homework is not done and communities realise that, you
- 34:58know, what if, if I fold my hands and don't do work, I roam
- 35:02around. I'm, I'm, I'm in a better
- 35:05position to receive handouts than the person who is trying.
- 35:08So quite often you would sign someone you're just trying a
- 35:11small home industry or someone sending a fruit, fruit on a
- 35:14corner of the street. We bypass that person and then
- 35:17look for the one that is, like we said, how they look and how
- 35:20and they, they, they, they sort of they very good.
- 35:22They've got a gift of the gab in terms of wanting from
- 35:26organizations or from individuals.
- 35:29So what, what are you doing with that in communities?
- 35:31You are actually sending the message to say, you know what
- 35:34folding your hands and relaxing and not doing something is
- 35:38actually more avoiding that someone who is standing and
- 35:41trying. And this perpetuates that
- 35:43entitlement mindset even amongst the recipients.
- 35:46When you tell the recipient to say, no, I cannot give you
- 35:49Zakharov by you folding your hands just roaming around and
- 35:53not doing anything without any any.
- 35:54They tell you, Zaki is my right. Who are you to come?
- 35:57I've been I've been receiving the car for free for the last 10
- 35:59years. Who are you as someone you are
- 36:01you are you are you are garden boy that has been sent here to
- 36:05come and police or to come and do whatever.
- 36:07Because why the organization themselves sometimes will bypass
- 36:11you and say you know you, you, you these people deserve it
- 36:14while depriving them. But you are trying to build a
- 36:16particular discipline. You are trying to build a
- 36:19particular mindset. They don't understand.
- 36:21And it's a development of communities, it's the
- 36:24enhancement of communities, it's maintaining of the dignity of
- 36:27communities so that we start changing mindsets and we start
- 36:31changing communities and outlooks as well.
- 36:34Check if there was one thing from your book that you had to
- 36:39take that you could give back as a strong message not just from
- 36:44your book but even from your experiences that you feel this
- 36:47is something people should actually know and should
- 36:49actually be aware of when and dispersing of Zakar Sedaka Lila.
- 36:55Yeah, Yeah. So like we, I think it's a good
- 36:58point that you're mentioning, Saira, that is not only just
- 37:00about Zakar, the Zakar Sadaka Lila, all of these are
- 37:04institutions which Allah Subhana Atallah has put them at our
- 37:08disposal that can help improve the image of Islam, improve
- 37:14communities, create goodwill among the people.
- 37:18Yeah. So that the important thing that
- 37:20I, I mentioned in my book, I think that the dignity aspect of
- 37:24it, Sister Zahra, I think that stands out as well as the
- 37:29intentionality. Because if we're not intentional
- 37:33about the way we give charity, we're not saying don't focus on
- 37:37reward. Because I, I think, I think what
- 37:40people find difficulty is that association of reward and the
- 37:44manner of giving which people is very difficult to shake off.
- 37:48Don't worry about your your spread like your broad spread.
- 37:53Worry about the outcomes. Worry about that Allah is the
- 37:57giver of reward, irrespective of how little your impact may seem
- 38:03at that time, but in the long run has a greater multiplier
- 38:06than you can ever imagine. And you would definitely see the
- 38:09reward in the sight of Allah in this world and in the Hereafter.
- 38:13You know, if Allah wills. Inshallah, I mean Shekhar and
- 38:15Sheikh for joining me on a today, Shukran for helping us
- 38:18rethink giving responsibility and justice.
- 38:23Sheikh Ibrahim Mahaboudi is honestly one of my favourite
- 38:26checks who's really transformed the way we see charity, the way
- 38:31we need to do charity, the way we need to be a part of the
- 38:34process, how to take personal responsibility, how to take
- 38:37collective responsibility. And I'm quite certain Ashik it
- 38:40will. We will make contact details
- 38:42available. We'll shark is reachable.
- 38:44But this is a book without a doubt that should be in every
- 38:47single person's home, regardless of whether you are part of an
- 38:52organization or not. This is something that you
- 38:54should be you should be having on your bookshelf that you
- 38:56should be sharing with your families because it changes the
- 38:59mindset of how we give charity to ensure that we keep the
- 39:02dignity of the recipients, which is most important.
- 39:05We will be giving away a few copies of the book.
- 39:07So stay tuned to our social media pages to be able to find
- 39:10out how you can try and get a copy of this in your hands.
- 39:15Shukran for joining us on a today on a very pertinent topic
- 39:18that affects every single one of us.
- 39:20Because what comes next starts right here with teaching us how
- 39:25to be more responsible with what is entrusted to us.
- 39:29Until the next time, Assalamualaikum or rahmatullahi
- 39:32Wabarakatuh.