Latest / The Office Politics Podcast with Fexingo: Workplace Dynamics, Influence, and Getting Things Done / How to Build Trust When You Are the New Person
Transcript
- Lucas: You walk into a new job. You’ve got the credentials, the interview charm, the handshake. But here’s the uncomfortable truth: no one in that building trusts you yet. Luna: And they shouldn’t, right? Trust isn’t a one-time thing from the offer letter. Lucas: Exactly. Trust is earned. And when you’re the new person, you’re starting in the red. I call it the trust deficit. You have zero track record at that specific company, with those specific coworkers. Luna: So how do you start filling that gap? What’s the first deposit? Lucas: Let’s talk about the trust bank. Every interaction is a deposit or a withdrawal. A deposit: you say you’ll send the deck by 3 PM, and you send it at 2:59. A withdrawal: you miss the deadline, or you overpromise and underdeliver. Luna: And the new person tends to overpromise, because they want to prove themselves fast. Lucas: Right. And that’s the fastest way to a withdrawal. Research from MIT’s Sandy Pentland shows that humans use pattern-matching to quickly evaluate trustworthiness. They pick up on consistency – do you do what you say? Every time? Small things matter more than big gestures. Luna: So what’s a small thing someone can do in their first week? Lucas: Take notes in a meeting. Send a brief summary afterward with action items. That’s a deposit. It signals reliability and attention. Another: ask for a small task with a clear deadline and deliver it early. Luna: I’ve seen the opposite. Someone joins and immediately tries to change the whole process. Major withdrawal. Lucas: Classic. They come in with a big idea, but they haven’t built the trust to sell it yet. The trust deficit means you have to earn the right to be heard. You can’t start by challenging the status quo. Luna: So you’re saying the first few weeks are about listening and delivering, not innovating. Lucas: Exactly. Build a foundation. I remember a study from a large tech firm—they tracked new hires and found that those who asked for small tasks and completed them reliably were trusted forty percent faster than those who tried to prove themselves through grand ideas. Luna: Forty percent faster. That’s huge. So the ask itself is part of the strategy. Lucas: It is. Asking for a specific task shows you’re engaged and want to contribute. It also gives you a low-risk way to make a deposit. And it forces the manager to think about what you can handle. Luna: What about when you inevitably make a mistake? Because new people will mess up. Lucas: Mistakes happen. The key is how you handle the withdrawal. If you hide it or make excuses, that’s a bigger withdrawal. If you surface it early, own it, and present a fix, you can actually make a net deposit. Luna: Transparency as a deposit. I like that. Lucas: Think of it this way: a mistake shows you’re human. How you recover shows you’re professional. One study in the Journal of Applied Psychology found that leaders who openly admitted mistakes were seen as more trustworthy than those who tried to cover them up. Luna: So the cover-up is worse than the crime, even in office politics. Lucas: Exactly. And there’s another layer: consistency across contexts. If you’re reliable in small ways, people start to generalize that to bigger responsibilities. It’s the halo effect of trust. Luna: What about building trust with peers versus building trust with your boss? Different strategies? Lucas: The principles are the same, but the signals differ. With your boss, it’s about delivering what they explicitly ask for. With peers, it’s about being a reliable collaborator—showing up on time, pulling your weight, sharing credit. Luna: And giving credit is a deposit too, I assume. Lucas: Big one. If you publicly acknowledge a peer’s help, they’ll trust you more. It signals that you’re not just looking out for yourself. That’s a deposit in the team account. Luna: So as a new person, you’re building a reputation from scratch. Every interaction matters. Lucas: It does. And that might feel exhausting, but it’s also freeing. Because you get to choose what deposits to make. You’re not stuck with old baggage. Luna: Speaking of making deposits, if you find value in episodes like this and want to help us keep the show ad-free and accessible, you can support us at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Lucas: Yeah, we don’t run ads, and listener support is what keeps this going. Even a small contribution makes a difference. But back to trust—what about when you’ve been there a few months and you feel like you’ve built some trust, but then something happens that shakes it? Luna: Like a missed deadline or a blown presentation? Lucas: Right. The trust bank can take a hit. But the key is to not ignore it. Address it directly with the person affected. Say, ‘I missed the deadline, here’s why, here’s how I’ll fix it.’ That honesty often rebuilds faster than pretending it didn’t happen. Luna: And then you start making small deposits again right away. Lucas: Exactly. Trust isn’t a one-time achievement. It’s an ongoing process. You keep making deposits because you never know when you’ll need to make a withdrawal. Luna: So the new person’s goal isn’t to be immediately trusted. It’s to start building a track record of reliability. Lucas: That’s the one-line takeaway. Show up, do what you say, and don’t overpromise. The trust will come. Luna: I think that’s a good note to end on. Thanks for listening, everyone.