Latest / The Buckeye Weekly Podcast / Is It Conceivable That Michigan Will Be Barred From Postseason Play?
Transcript
- 0:01Hello, everybody, Welcome to the Buckeye Weekly Podcast. I am Tony Gerdaman
- 0:05here as always with Tom or Tom. How's it going well, Tony?
- 0:11Since the last time we spoke on a podcast, which we did in person
- 0:15inside the Boody Hayes Athletic Center, we are now speaking in places where it
- 0:20is probably about twenty degrees cooler and the humidity has gone from ninety eight percent
- 0:26down to a much more manageable number. So Tony, I'm wonderful. I
- 0:30am truly truly wonderful. Tony. How are you doing much better? You're
- 0:36absolutely right. It is nice to be in a climate controlled environment as opposed
- 0:39to a climate uncontrolled environment, because that climate was out of control. I
- 0:45got a text on Tuesday from my sister in law. She's like, you're
- 0:49not outside, are you? Like, yeah, we're outside, thanks.
- 0:52It was it was it was more humid, I think on Tuesday, like
- 0:56Monday was it was bad. It was hot, but Tuesday just out thicker.
- 1:00Like. Fortunately, I wasn't out there nearly as long as you were.
- 1:03You know, I was busy and you were just hanging out outside watching
- 1:07some seven on seven. Yeah, it was those camps. I always look
- 1:12forward to those camps every year because this is a time of year when you're
- 1:15looking for stuff to talk about and there's real legitimate stuff to talk about and
- 1:19shoot pictures of and shoot video of, and so those are great. And
- 1:23then there's always like one or two every summer where it's like, well,
- 1:26if it's eighty two degrees, that's okay, it's hot, but you know
- 1:30it's not it's not too bad. And then it's like, oh, it's
- 1:33in the mid nineties and the sun is beating down and we're on the artificial
- 1:37turf and it's real humid, and it's twenty degrees hotter on the artificial turf
- 1:40than it is over on the grass, and Tony I got to go check
- 1:42out whatever's going on on those natural turf fields over there. I'm sure it's
- 1:47very important. It is amazing. You're because we're over on the outdoor practice
- 1:52fields at Ohio State at the Woody and you've you can you've got grass fields
- 1:59there, and then it's hot, but you're walking along from that grass field
- 2:04in the end zone to get to the to another field that you can just
- 2:07feel like if you're walking with your eyes closed, you could feel from the
- 2:12time you go from the grass field to the plastic field the artificial field,
- 2:15because you just hit this wall of heat where it's just you're like, it's
- 2:21just radiating on you. And so yeah, it was always always better to
- 2:24like, you know, let's go like the running backs erver on the grass
- 2:29field. You're gonna go check that out, or I want to go watch
- 2:31this particular game, this particular seven and seven matchup between I don't know,
- 2:37but I just know I want to be there. And so yeah, I'm
- 2:39not saying they should get rid of the artificial turfstim because it's hot, but
- 2:45I'm not saying they should keep it. Yeah, there are injury concerns linked
- 2:51to artificial turf and the split film artificial turf. There are also, to
- 2:55me, some heat stroke concerns in certain situations. So yeah, I would
- 2:59not I would be okay with them going to all natural grass. But you
- 3:02know, the reason they have two natural grass fields and two artificial turf fields
- 3:07is then you're prepared for whatever you're playing on that week. You can practice
- 3:09on whatever that is. So that's why they do that. There's a reason
- 3:14for it. But yeah, I greatly greatly appreciated the natural turf this week,
- 3:19and for the people out there, don't wear your jelly shoes on the
- 3:22plastic turf because you might it might just all melt together. Tom. Now,
- 3:28this is not us coming up with this topic. This is a topic
- 3:31that was sent to you and like, hey, could you, gentlemenly please
- 3:37discuss this topic on the show. And it's not something we would normally discuss
- 3:43unless the many times we have. But this is somebody asking us to discuss
- 3:46this. So when we get the responses from Michigan fans a value rent free
- 3:53co parter, we're doing a service here. We're answering a question. We're
- 3:58discussing a topic that was sent into Tom and it is this from at OL
- 4:02underscore Pete, nineteen twenty six. Is it conceivable that Michigan will be banned,
- 4:10will be barred from postseason play? And for one, thank you for
- 4:14the title of the show. That's fantastic, it's going to be good for
- 4:16YouTube. Thank you for that. But the easy answer here, Tom is
- 4:20absolutely it is conceivable. Now we may have to get into the conceiving of
- 4:26the ways it would happen, but it is definitely conceivable. Even if it
- 4:30doesn't happen. Much anymore. This is something that it would be inconceivable if
- 4:35it wasn't a possibility. So to me, this is very conceivable and we
- 4:41can go from there. Right, It's yes, this is a punishment that
- 4:46can still be levied. And they are facing significant accusations, shall we say,
- 4:53I guess we can't say allegations yet because the notice of allegations has not
- 4:56come out yet from the nc doable, But yes, conceivably they could be
- 5:00barred from postseason play. That is a possible outcome here is it a likely
- 5:04outcome? Probably? Not possible? Conceivable? Sure, I mean I guess
- 5:13theoretically, can you still get a TV ban? I think a TV ban
- 5:17would probably fall on the inconceivable side of yes, theoretically possible, but absolutely
- 5:25not going to happen the side of the ledger a Bowl ban of some kind
- 5:30of postseason ban of some kind. Sure, it's possible, you could,
- 5:34You could conceive of a scenario where it happens. Is it likely? Probably
- 5:41not? And you pulled up some recent examples of cases where not so much.
- 5:46Well, and I'm just looking really quickly at the the the NCAA major
- 5:53infractions cases, and I just clicked on TV bans of one year, which
- 6:00would be the MAX. The last TV band television band that I have here
- 6:03is nineteen ninety six, so and that was the University of Baulburn, Oh,
- 6:10University of Maine, well, I mean Maine. Yeah, if you
- 6:13remember the TV landscape in nineteen ninety six when there were not a million,
- 6:16not a million TV channels and not a million games on TV, I'm sure
- 6:19the University of Maine was was the backbone of a lot of a lot of
- 6:25TV networks big plans for that season. So a a big shock and definitely
- 6:29something that we all remember happening. Couldn't even be on local Maine television due
- 6:33to extra benefits provided to numberus can you do it as sick while you're reading
- 6:41it via a podcast? Numerous student athletes, and proper certification of academic eligibility.
- 6:46This all sounds bad and proper recruiting, but Baylor in ninety five,
- 6:53and these aren't necessarily all football, but just what other sport was on other
- 6:57than basketball and football, So you kind of get the idea. They're Ole
- 7:00miss in ninety four, Washington in ninety four. These are all handed down
- 7:05that you're in Texas, A and m in ninety four as a repeat violator.
- 7:11Even before the SEC. They were in the SEC, they were already
- 7:14repeat violators out there Oklahoma State and then boy you can it used to happen
- 7:21several times a year. Now it hasn't happened in several decades. Washington had
- 7:28won in nineteen ninety four because they Ohio State played at Washington in nineteen ninety
- 7:31four. That was the same day as the Cordell Stewart Hail Mary game.
- 7:35I did not live in Ohio at that point, so the Ohio State Washington
- 7:40game not being on TV where I lived was not a thing that was remarkable
- 7:43in any way. Was the Washington Ohio State nineteen ninety four game really not
- 7:46on TV? Well this let me just see here. Yeah, it was
- 7:53nineteen ninety four, and I'm wondering if maybe the television band was in ninety
- 7:58five as it just tried to read all this real quickly, But they were
- 8:03banned for one year. That was handed down in July of ninety four for
- 8:07actually, the Washington Ohio State game in Ohio Stadium in nineteen ninety five was
- 8:11on TV. I remember watching that one, But maybe they really did have
- 8:15a TV ban. In nineteen ninety four. But that was back when it
- 8:18was not an absolute given that your team was on TV every week. Was
- 8:22that was a time when sometimes they were and sometimes they weren't. And there
- 8:26was I think the last Ohio State game to not be televised live was nineteen
- 8:31ninety seven, maybe like a Minnesota game or a nineteen ninety six there was
- 8:35a game I had to watch on WOSU or something or something like later on
- 8:43that night or the next morning or something like that that that really has not
- 8:46happened in twenty five plus years. And with this database you can look to
- 8:54see like, Okay, when was the last postseason band handed down sports?
- 9:00And it's been since twenty twenty two that the NCAA has handed something down.
- 9:05There have been other self imposed postseason bans when you kind of feel like you're
- 9:09going to get it anyway, so you try to be the bigger man or
- 9:13the bigger person in this instance. The two most notable and egregious football cases
- 9:24in the last few years have been Tennessee in Arizona State. Both of those
- 9:28programs were paying players. The allegations and the findings that they're players being paid,
- 9:35which is before this before the Michigan gigantic cheating scandal, paying players basically
- 9:41the worst thing that you could do other than gambling, and so using this
- 9:46as an idea for what may happen. Tennessee did not get a postseason ban,
- 9:52but one of the reasons is because they're very forthcoming and helping to fix
- 9:58this, and it also helped that they wanted to get rid of the head
- 10:03coach, and so they're very proactive in getting rid of Jeremy Fowler. Arizona
- 10:07State self imposed a ban, and and so the question becomes, would would
- 10:15maybe Michigan ever self impose anything if they see things going the wrong way?
- 10:20And I'll have to see when did When When did Arizona State actually self imposed
- 10:24their band. Wasn't after like an zero to three start or something like that.
- 10:28Was it was it during the season. I can't remember, like they
- 10:30weren't going to have a great season because I think Jaden Daniels is already off
- 10:33to LSU at that point. Yeah, that happens. I don't remember if
- 10:37it was right before the season or a couple weeks into the season, but
- 10:41it was they self imposed it at a point where it was like, well,
- 10:45you're gonna go six and six this year anyway, So who cares that
- 10:50was? That was a little later in the process. The interesting part of
- 10:54the Tennessee thing in twenty twenty two is there were two factors that went into
- 10:58this to Tennessee not getting a postseason ban. One of these applies directly to
- 11:03this Michigan case, and one of these very much does not apply directly to
- 11:07the Michigan case. One of them was, you quoted an article here from
- 11:13the Knoxville News. The new NCAA constitution, which went into effect on August
- 11:16first, twenty twenty two, encourages leniency towards programs that route out cheating themselves
- 11:20and discourages punishing current athletes for violations committed by former coaches and athletes. So
- 11:26obviously discouraging punishing current athletes for violation violations committed by former coaches and athletes.
- 11:33That would potentially apply here because Michigan's coaching staff, a huge chunk of them
- 11:37are off to the NFL. They lost a ton of seniors off of last
- 11:41year's team, so that would obviously apply. Now, how does that mesh
- 11:46with the idea that was getting screamed from the Hilltops last fall that you can't
- 11:50possibly punish any of these players now the investigation's not done, so then it's
- 11:54like you can't punish us now and you can't punish us later. So I
- 11:56guess you have to just let us go Scott free. That's one, you
- 12:00know, that's certainly one argument there. The other piece of it is continuing
- 12:03this Knoxville News article. In the new approach, cooperating schools are supposed to
- 12:07get lighter penalties and bad actors are supposed to get harsher ones, and UT
- 12:11considered that in its strategy to aggressively aid the NC DOUBLEA investigation. Now Tony,
- 12:16we have seen that Jim Harbaugh has not really cooperated with the NC double
- 12:20A in either of its multi recent major infractions investigations. There at the University
- 12:26of Michigan, we have also seen you know, university President Santa Onno tweeting
- 12:31Bett and stuff like that. I would say that Michigan's cooperation in this matter
- 12:35has probably been slightly less than exemplary. So I'm not sure how much that's
- 12:41going to carry over. But on the whole, I do think the you
- 12:45know, the the idea that you don't want to punish future players for you
- 12:48know, past actions. Is you know that that is certainly a viable one.
- 12:54I would be interested in knowing how many of the people who are currently
- 12:58you know, making that case for why Michigan shouldn't ge punished now, how
- 13:01many of them feel that Ohio State was unjustly given a bull band in twenty
- 13:07twelve for actions taken by players who were no longer on that team. That's
- 13:11you know, that's probably a little bit of a separate conversation, but it's
- 13:15you know, the rules and the application of the rule has certainly changed quite
- 13:18a bit over the last decade or so. The new rule that as you
- 13:26mentioned went into effect in twenty twenty two August to just, hey, let's
- 13:31try not to punish the future players the existing players, and punish instead the
- 13:39bad actors harsher, more harshly. And the thing is, all of the
- 13:43bad well, not all of the bad actors. We'll see what the allegations
- 13:46say, but many of the bad actors are gone. Jim Harborugh is gone,
- 13:50and a defensive coordinator has gone, so conter Stallions has gone. So
- 13:56and when I call them the bad actors, they're just they're involved in this
- 14:00of their names, and Jim Harbaugh is the head coach. The coordinators are
- 14:03taking direction or you know, taking taking the word of of Connor. Stallion's
- 14:09on the sideline. So there there's a connection there. And I know,
- 14:13I don't know how open any of the coordinators have been in any of this.
- 14:16Jim Harbaugh has not seemingly been available to to talk, certainly not available
- 14:22to be punished. So you know, you can go hand hand down whatever
- 14:26penalty you want to. You can give them a ten year show cause and
- 14:30they might, but it's not going to impact him in any way, so
- 14:33he would probably Yeah, if you want to give all of the penalties to
- 14:35me, please do so. And you know, or maybe Ward Manual if
- 14:41you want to get Jim Harbaugh's probably like, if you want to give Ward
- 14:43Manual a ten year show cause. But the idea that they're just going to
- 14:50take this out on Jim Harbaugh is kind of an empty thing for the NCAAA.
- 14:54Now, it may be a good way for the NCAA just to wrap
- 14:56this up and move on. I do under the NCAA's how tired is the
- 15:01nca of losing court cases? Is this? You know, is is there
- 15:07an opportunity to win something here against Michigan, And do they are they do
- 15:13they feel like lashing out? Do they feel like doing something like that,
- 15:16or do they know at this point that every penalty they hand down there's going
- 15:20to going to be an appeal? Is there a lawsuit after that as well?
- 15:26And it's like is that even worth they kind of fight it in terms
- 15:28of if you put somebody out of the postseason. I don't see a program
- 15:33like Michigan or anybody taking that just sitting down. No, I wouldn't expect
- 15:41them to take it sitting down. I also think that there's a little bit
- 15:45of a line between a lot of the typical NCAA cases. Let's just use
- 15:52the you know case from Ohio State. But she's Louise fourteen years ago.
- 15:56At this point that was exchanging memorabilia for cash and services. So like tattoos,
- 16:04Tony, what a quaint time when that was big enough to get you
- 16:07on the cover of Sports Illustrated, which was a thing that used to be
- 16:11a thing at that point. Just in case you're wondering how long ago that
- 16:14was. This is a little different. This is not a everyone does it
- 16:19thing. This is not a well the courts have said you can kind of
- 16:22do this kind of thing, So we really can't go after this anyway because
- 16:26it's related and we've lost a bunch of court cases and we've had you know,
- 16:30state legislatures saying you can do this kind of thing. And you're working
- 16:34in a little bit of a gray area or you're working in the sort of
- 16:37the black market related to the legal nil market. This is something that is
- 16:41you know, this is objectively cheating, objectively against the law. So this
- 16:48is a little bit like you know, baseball players betting on baseball, where
- 16:51it's like, yeah, you've got you've got Major League Baseball has gambling partnerships,
- 16:56but at the same time, you are still getting baseball players suspended for
- 17:00betting on baseball and there's not really a you know, there's not really a
- 17:03recourse there. So it's I think this would be a harder case for Michigan
- 17:07to just say, you know, not fair and get those punmel you know,
- 17:12whatever the penalty is, get it wiped off, because it's not you
- 17:15know, this is not the typical everyone does it bag man under the table,
- 17:22you know, illegal payments kind of thing, where you're working in areas
- 17:26that are sort of related to legal areas. This is pretty clearly a big,
- 17:30dark, you know, red line in between these two things. And
- 17:33you saw that in terms of the response from other coaches and other programs.
- 17:37You saw that in terms of a response from Big ten last year. You
- 17:41see that in terms of the response from the NCAA fast tracking the investigation.
- 17:45So you know, I think it would be I think it would be very
- 17:48hard for Michigan too. Whatever the punishment, whatever the allegations end up officially
- 17:52being in the notice of allegations, and whatever the punishment ends up being.
- 17:55I don't think that's just going to be a gimmey for Michigan to just go
- 17:57to court and say nope, we're going to just not have anything and it's
- 18:00gonna be fine, and just get everyone to say, yeah, sure,
- 18:03okay. Turns out you're right. I don't think that's going to be quite
- 18:07as easy as you might think, based on the NCAA's recent court record.
- 18:11Well, and really both sides in terms of what the punishment will be and
- 18:15what Michigan's argument would be towards that punishment. There's no precedent in this because
- 18:18this is completely time. As I say, unprecedented, this cheating scandal where
- 18:25you can't look at me like, well, when Auburn cheated with their illegal
- 18:27science stealing scheme back in two thousand and four, this was the penalty.
- 18:32This is not something that to this level and this scope has been done before,
- 18:37and so it is completely different. So it would follow that there may
- 18:41be larger penalties, different penalties, new penalties that would happen. And certainly
- 18:48this has not happened since the NCAA decided, hey, let's go a little
- 18:52bit more peaceably with the infractions in August of twenty twenty two. In terms
- 18:57of postseason bands, and it is interesting that there have been no NCAA handed
- 19:03down postseason bans since that went into effect. The last the last one listed
- 19:10on the the nc's database is Ohio State, which it was April twenty two
- 19:15was given postseason bands and women's basketball fencing, I believe, and and one
- 19:22other sport and that was all ended up being self imposed. But again,
- 19:26once you realize you're not getting out of this one, hey, we're going
- 19:30to self impose and maybe save ourselves. I don't know, a scholarship here
- 19:34or scholarship there. You're just trying to save face at that point, and
- 19:38no part in this, as Michigan acquiesced. They've always been very steadfast and
- 19:44defiant and in just about every way other than appealing any kind of suspensions that
- 19:52have been handed down or you know, they've they've just agreed to that.
- 19:55Now, let's not confuse the two NCAA cases going on with Michigan. They're
- 19:59two different suspension. But the Michigan has back down when they've talked tough,
- 20:03so maybe they would back down again later on down the road. And so
- 20:11Tom, let's go ahead and bring in this Chris Partridge thing and just open
- 20:15this whole thing up. So John, you Bacon, you guys may know
- 20:18him, you should know him. Has written about Michigan for many, many
- 20:23years. One of their insiders there, has a lot of connections. Fantastic
- 20:26author. He tweeted out a series of three tweets on Tuesday, and I'll
- 20:32just read these all as one and we'll go from there. So says here,
- 20:37not looking for football scoops these days, but I occasionally hear one anyway
- 20:41from insiders. Chris Partridge, who is the former Michigan linebackers coach who has
- 20:47fired amidst All of this counter stallion stuff for allegedly speaking about the case or
- 20:53perhaps destroying evidence. There are a bunch of different allegations there that that were
- 20:59going on. But anyway, from insiders, Chris Partridge retained Tom marrs an
- 21:03attorney and in Michigan lawyer a few months ago. They're quote digging into how
- 21:07and why Ward Manual fired Partridge without any investigation or opportunity for him to tell
- 21:12his side of the story, and what Manual told the board of trustees about
- 21:17the grounds for termination. There will be studying new information and they're apparently getting
- 21:22close to filing a lawsuit in federal court. As always, we shall see
- 21:27no telling what's actually on the table until the full suit until the suit is
- 21:30filed. But it heads up that the Partridge case apparently ain't over. And
- 21:37my first thought when I saw this was this will never go to any kind
- 21:41of trial. This is going to be settled so quickly out of court because
- 21:45Michigan doesn't want to have anything out there and nobody wants any kind of discovery.
- 21:48But then my second thought was Tom Mars is involved, and he's Jim
- 21:52Harbaugh's attorney, so this is in no way going to put Michigan, the
- 21:56University or Jim Harbaugh in a poor light. So this is more about to
- 22:00putting Ward Manual in a bad light. Yeah, we can do some kin
- 22:04kremlinology here. There is one person other than Chris Partridge on the Chris Partridge
- 22:10side who is named here. So I have a guest who told John U.
- 22:12Bacon this wills. You know, I can't tell you for a fact
- 22:15that that's where it came from, but I would bet a shiny nickel that
- 22:19that is probably where that came from. And yeah, Tom Marr is obviously
- 22:23not a real big fan of Ward Manual, So this is an opportunity to
- 22:27go after Ward Manual, and I think that that's probably you know, the
- 22:33amount of money that we're talking about here is not an enormous amount of money.
- 22:37This is and Chris Partridge already has a job. He has a job
- 22:40in the NFL. I think he's with the Seahawks now, So this is
- 22:42not about you know, oh, this has rendered him unemployable. This to
- 22:47me feels like, yeah, you're going after Ward Manual because you're mad that
- 22:49you feel like Ward Manuel did not you know, he did your boy dirty.
- 22:55After the season when he you know, in the in the contract negotiations,
- 22:57showed insufficient feel to you to Jim Harbaugh and did not give him enough
- 23:02money and did not vow to completely hold him blameless and you know that he
- 23:07was going to get paid no matter what, and all that kind of stuff.
- 23:08They had all sorts of demands those were not met in a sufficient to
- 23:12haste based on how the Hardball camp viewed all of that. So now,
- 23:18yeah, it feels like this is probably a little bit targeted. Get you
- 23:22know, getting ward manual and I had the same exact first thought that you
- 23:26did. The thing with the NC double A is if they're investigating you,
- 23:32they can't subpoena. They do not have a power of subpoena. So you're
- 23:34going to turn over what you're going to turn over, and you're going to
- 23:36cooperate, agree that you're going to cooperate. They don't have the about ability
- 23:41to subpoena, so you know, stuff that you turn over to them.
- 23:44There is no like force of law behind the NC double a's investigative arm.
- 23:49If you are in a court case, a judge can you know, and
- 23:52you don't turn stuff over, a judge can come after you for that you
- 23:56could be held in contempt of court or whatever else. So there's a you
- 24:00know, while it is not a subpoena, you certainly there's a little more
- 24:02force of law behind the discovery process in a civil case like this would be.
- 24:07So how eager is Michigan to just open the books and throw throw open
- 24:11the doors and turn everything open, turn everything over and you know, potentially
- 24:15have that become part of an NCAA case. Probably not in a huge hurry
- 24:19to do that. So yeah, I am with you on this one.
- 24:23It feels like this is Partridge. I think maybe was in his last year
- 24:29of his contractor had one more year of his contract. So you know,
- 24:32we're not for a position, coach. We're not talking millions and millions of
- 24:34dollars here. This is probably a relatively small, easy settlement where Michigan says
- 24:41we're sorry, we should not have full we should not have fired you,
- 24:45gives him a quarter million dollars and a half a million dollars, three quarters
- 24:48of million dollars, whatever it is. And you know, maybe this is
- 24:51you know, this is enough to get Ward Manual fired for Michigan and then
- 24:55everyone on the Tom Mars, Jim Harbaugh side of things is happy, so
- 24:59that that's probably where I would see that potentially going well. I think his
- 25:07salary last year was five hundred thousand dollars and so I assume he got most
- 25:12of it in terms of he was he was getting paid until he got fired.
- 25:17So this feels like a very easy, simple payday just if almost you
- 25:22look at it, and it's kind of like, this seems like free money
- 25:26for an attorney in terms of and for Partridge honestly, because this is gonna
- 25:30be something that Michigan's just gonna Yeah, let's make this go away. Don't
- 25:33want to have any don't wanna you want this thing, all of this to
- 25:37go away as quickly as possible in terms of the digging that could come from
- 25:42this, like you don't want to open up this can of worms. He
- 25:45just let the NCAA do what it's doing. You don't want to have them
- 25:49dealing with anything that you don't want out there. And if they, as
- 25:55long as Partridge is happy, then he's not going to talk to the nca
- 25:56either. So there's also that I'm not it's not Tom You're saying hush money.
- 26:02I'm not saying hush money. I'm saying, pay the man his contract
- 26:07and and just go from there. But what you certainly don't want to do
- 26:11is anger somebody. But he'll get his he'll get his money, and Michigan
- 26:17will be able to move on from that. But with this this whole thing,
- 26:22like I you would you see this as like, oh, coach lawsuit,
- 26:26something's gonna happen. And I don't think this is going to impact the
- 26:32NCAA side of things. It's salacious, it could be, and it's it
- 26:37could be something to talk about. But I don't want Buckeye fans thinking oh,
- 26:41or even Michigan fans seeing this and being like, oh, I don't
- 26:45see this impacting the overall NCAA thing. I don't know that that's going to
- 26:49delay anything as the NCAA moves forward with what they're doing about the ongoing case.
- 26:56No, I don't. I don't see this as something that's a huge
- 26:59needle move for this is as you said, it feels like this is probably
- 27:03a relatively easy payday because you know, Michigan is not going to want to
- 27:07drag this out. Michigan is not going to want to make this a bigger
- 27:10deal than it already is. And you know, this is a on the
- 27:14big you know, in the big picture of the University of Michigan athletic department,
- 27:18the University of Michigan on the whole, we are talking about a relative
- 27:23pittance in terms of the amount of money involved here, even if it is
- 27:27three quarters of a million dollars that that's just not that much in the big
- 27:33picture for an athletic department the size of Michigan. And if you can make
- 27:36this go away, well you maybe just make this go away. And you
- 27:40know, maybe there's maybe there's a you know, we'll see. I don't
- 27:42know if I'm sure. Tom Mars, based on his past thoughts on Ward
- 27:48Manual, might view, hey, maybe you should think about not having Ward
- 27:51Manual be or athletic director as part of the settlement or as a suggestion may
- 27:56be made during this process. We'll see if that plays out that way.
- 28:00But yeah, I think this is this is not something that I think is
- 28:03going to materially change anything about the NCAA investigation, simply because I don't think
- 28:11Michigan is going to give anyone the opportunity to have this materially change anything with
- 28:15the investigation. Although it would seem odd for the university president to be so
- 28:22supportive and so steadfast that nothing has gone wrong to then fire the ad for
- 28:30failure to monitor that sort of thing, Like if something happens, you're like,
- 28:33oh, you didn't know any of this is going on, and so
- 28:36you're gonna have to go. And when the president has already been you know,
- 28:38as you said, tweeting out Bett. And so you've got some interesting
- 28:45situations going on here. One of the last things from the Knoxville News clip
- 28:48that I've got here is that the just a note here that the university spent
- 28:52more than one point six million dollars to investigate itself and share the results with
- 28:57the NCAA. And I don't know that Michigan has spent that much investigating this.
- 29:03In fact, based on some reports from from up north, I think
- 29:07maybe you might see like Ohio State has been paying that much to investigate the
- 29:11case based on some of the reporting up there. In terms of where the
- 29:15investigations are actually coming from, I don't know that Michigan has been as helpful.
- 29:21I'm pretty sure they have not been as helpful in this court in this
- 29:25NCAA case as Tennessee has. And so that is still going to be something
- 29:30where I think that's going to be a factor because not Tennessee fired their head
- 29:34coach, Michigan kept trying to extend theirs, kept putting an extension on his
- 29:41desk, saying, please sign it. Do you want more money, We
- 29:45can give you more money. And those are two very different things. And
- 29:48the NCAA is going to look at that as well, and it'll ultimately come
- 29:52down to what they find as it should, and they'll go from there.
- 29:57But ten worked with the NCAA and they didn't get a postseason man Michigan to
- 30:04this point has really not been as forthcoming, not nearly as forthcoming. And
- 30:10so I don't think you can use the Tennessee case as a guideline in terms
- 30:15of, well, you know what you think the the results are going to
- 30:18be, because again, this is a completely different infraction and its completely different
- 30:23response, and so you may get a completely different answer from the NCAAA,
- 30:32right, and the fact that the head coach is responsible for anything that happens
- 30:36underneath him, and that the head coach the NCAA in the last major Infractions
- 30:40case talked about how not cooperative the head coach had been, well not cooperative.
- 30:44One party had been Tony who was it, Well, it's impossible to
- 30:47say who that could be. I'm going to guess that that same party is
- 30:49probably not going to be overly cooperative with this case as well, especially since
- 30:52that party may be currently in Los Angeles coaching the Chargers. So yeah,
- 31:00will see how this all shakes out. I do think to your point,
- 31:03I think that the the fact that the you know, Tennessee got its,
- 31:07you know, kind of got I don't want to say got away with it,
- 31:11but certainly had a lighter punishment and more lenient punishment because of the cooperation.
- 31:15A lot of that cooperation had to do with the fact that I don't
- 31:18think there were a lot of people in Tennessee who were super excited about Jeremy
- 31:19Pruitt continuing to be the head coach of Tennessee based on on field performance.
- 31:25I think that you're probably you know, the fact that Michigan did seemingly want
- 31:29to have Jim Harball continued to be its head coach, or many parties involved
- 31:33that Michigan did seem to want to have Jim Harball continue to be their head
- 31:34coach. There, you know, they have they have maybe not they certainly
- 31:38did not serve Jim Harball up on a plotter the way Tennessee did for Jeremy
- 31:42Pruitt. So I you know, there are pieces of that, as we
- 31:45said off the top of the show, Yeah, some of the don't punish
- 31:48the future players for the past players transac transgressions or past staffers transgressions. In
- 31:53this case, that is certainly going to potentially apply the well, you were
- 31:59very cooperative, so therefore that's you know, so therefore you're going to get
- 32:02a lighter punishment that I don't feel like is probably particularly applicable in this case.
- 32:07And the last thing here, Tennessee lost had some scholarship restrictions. As
- 32:13we saw, you know, Taggate brought some scholarship restrictions. The thing about
- 32:16that, it's like you can't just I don't I don't know that you can
- 32:21just rely on that anymore because a school can get around that with nil.
- 32:25So if you want to be like, you know what, let's not do
- 32:27the postseason ban. Let's just take five more scholarships a year from them.
- 32:30That's not really a punishment. That's that's as much a punishment anymore as vacating
- 32:36wins. Vacating the title is completely I think is something different. But taking
- 32:40away scholarships doesn't really move the needle for me anymore, or probably for any
- 32:45schools that are of Michigan's level or higher States level, Alabama's level. Go
- 32:52ahead, you know, take give us. You know, you want us
- 32:53to operate on seventy five scholarships. That's not going to change anything we do.
- 33:00Right, It's like the Nebraska thing where they can just you know,
- 33:05you can get around this eighty five scholarship cap by just having nil that covers
- 33:08the cost of guys being at Nebraska. And that's something that we've seen a
- 33:13number of schools do over the past you know, year or so, where
- 33:15okay, you're at eighty five and so yeah, you have to walk on
- 33:21and for a year and then but you'll have nil that will more than cover
- 33:24the cost of tuition and room and board and attendance and maybe you get some
- 33:28I don't know, academic scholarships or something like that as well. So yeah,
- 33:31that is not the absolute you know, getting the boom lowered on you
- 33:37that it used to be. That was something that absolutely killed Penn State in
- 33:40the wake of the Jerry Sandusky case, was they had I think what sixty
- 33:45five scholarship something like that for a year or two, and it took them
- 33:50like almost a decade to build back a competent offensive line after they lost and
- 33:54they got lost all those scholarships and lost all those players and got so thin
- 33:59and the lines that took forever to build back from. So that a little
- 34:04bit with USC as well. I think in the wake of the Reggie Bush
- 34:07scandal, they lost a bunch of scholarships and that that really cost them for
- 34:10a while. So yeah, that is kind of just not no longer a
- 34:15viable punishment for you know, in terms of actual on field impact. And
- 34:21so you go through it's like, well, they can't do a TV punishment
- 34:23anyway anymore, just because TV runs the sport, So that's really functionally not
- 34:28going to happen. And the scholarship thing doesn't really move the needle the way
- 34:32it did. It kind of narrows what you're looking at in terms of what
- 34:37are some possible punishments. Well, and that Penn state scholarship reduction penalty was
- 34:42so steep that the NCAA backed off of it because it was so destructive to
- 34:49them that they kind of they brought it, relieve them a bit a year
- 34:54or two early on that I do wonder Tom and this is the last thing
- 35:00she can starts two and or two and two this season. I wouldn't be
- 35:02shocked to see a self imposed postseason ban. They've got Texas in week two,
- 35:07USC in week four. If they start two and two at that point,
- 35:12you're like, you know what, let's be the good soldiers here.
- 35:15Let's be the good people here and offer up a little sacrifice of this season
- 35:23and go from there. But I don't necessarily expect them to lose to USC,
- 35:28but stranger things have happened, so that will do it. I want
- 35:30to thank you all for tuning in as I always find us at Buckeyehuddle dot
- 35:34com. Become a member if you have not yet done so, and for
- 35:37those of you who have over the last month or two, we do appreciate
- 35:39that. And of course you can find us at YouTube dot com slash bucke
- 35:42Huddle. If you're watching us there right now, go ahead and give us
- 35:45a thumbs up. We would appreciate that, and go ahead and subscribe to
- 35:47the channel if you have not yet. So thank you all for tuning in
- 35:51and We'll talk to you guys later.