Latest / No Way Out / The AI Edge: Why OODA, Cybernetics, and Neuroscience Matter with Sean Manion
Transcript
- 0:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Hey, moose, I want to kick this one off, moose.
- 0:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And here's why.
- 0:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Here's my frustration with the way a lot of folks go forward with the OODA loop.
- 0:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They start with the military, they always start with the military, make a connection, say it's a decision or tactical decision-making process.
- 0:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What I've discovered is, had Boyd been a football coach, had he been a musician, he could have still come up with the same OODA loop sketch.
- 0:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And here's why.
- 0:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's because the natural sciences, things like cybernetics, biology, evolutionary biology, plexadaptive systems, neuroscience these things matter more than his background in the military Unfortunately everybody gets fixated on matter more than his background in the military Unfortunately everybody gets fixated on that.
- 1:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They get fixated on it, they go.
- 1:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's all about warfare.
- 1:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm like bullshit.
- 1:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's about how living systems persist through time.
- 1:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And if you start there, you start to see the real beauty of the OODA loop.
- 1:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I imagine Sean and I think you know Sean, so I want you to introduce Sean for our audience.
- 1:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I think Sean may have started in that position of hey, what is this thing?
- 1:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And, based on the work that I've read from Sean, he's been following this path of cybernetics, information theory, connections to Von Neumann, connections to, I think, who else?
- 1:37Mark McGrath: Ashby Pitts Bateson.
- 1:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, that's the pathway you should start with when you look at the OODA loop and unfortunately I think a lot of military folks start with the military connection and I just like, well, that's only going to drive you into the linear orient or, excuse me, observe orient.
- 1:54Sean Manion: Plus, when you Google it, it's going to send you right there, anyway, yeah, yeah.
- 1:57Sean Manion: So, hey, could you introduce our?
- 1:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: guests.
- 1:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I just wanted to start there because I think we have an amazing show set up today.
- 2:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So, Mark, can you introduce?
- 2:04Sean Manion: us.
- 2:05Sean Manion: It is a small world and we talk about at VUCA.
- 2:09Sean Manion: We talk about complexity, and one of the things is the connectivity between people.
- 2:13Sean Manion: Sean and I this is not our first meeting, so Sean and I are both graduates of Central Catholic High School in Pittsburgh, pa.
- 2:21Sean Manion: He was a senior, I was a freshman, and Sean's first cousin, mike, is one of my best friends and Mike is also a brother Marine of mine.
- 2:29Sean Manion: We went to the recruiting office together.
- 2:31Sean Manion: So Sean and I this is a really interesting circle to bring us together.
- 2:37Sean Manion: You're the first Central Catholic graduate that we've had as a guest.
- 2:40Sean Manion: Dan Marino hasn't returned any of our calls, but absolutely so we're glad to have you so well.
- 2:49Sean Manion: Why don't you break it down for us?
- 2:50Sean Manion: So you know we were talking about before.
- 2:52Sean Manion: You know, before we hit record, how you stumbled into this stuff.
- 2:55Sean Manion: As you know, planche and I have military backgrounds and you don't.
- 2:59Sean Manion: So give us the you know, give us the story of how you got there.
- 3:02Mark McGrath: Certainly, and thanks for having me on here.
- 3:04Mark McGrath: I Give us the story of how you got there, certainly, and thanks for having me on here.
- 3:07Mark McGrath: I've been excited about the work you've been doing and the deep dives you've been going into with where Boyd and his work can stretch, and not just the OODA loop but beyond that.
- 3:13Mark McGrath: Sean Mannion, neuroscientist by training, spent a lot of time supporting the military health system, moved into tech and health tech several years back and focused on that area right now.
- 3:24Mark McGrath: But kind of get my hands in a lot of different pots.
- 3:26Mark McGrath: So I've never served in the military but I did end up going as a civilian, starting in 99, to Uniformed Services University of the Health Sciences to do my graduate work in neuroscience.
- 3:37Mark McGrath: Started doing PTSD research in the psychiatry department there in 99.
- 3:41Mark McGrath: So this is pre 9-11.
- 3:42Mark McGrath: We had to.
- 3:43Mark McGrath: We had to struggle a little bit to justify our funding sometimes because they were they were thinking that's a veterans problem.
- 3:49Mark McGrath: I mean, you know it's.
- 3:50Mark McGrath: It's after a long stretch without a whole lot of hot wars going on and then 9-11 happens and everything kind of switches.
- 3:57Mark McGrath: And you know the research we're doing is in demand.
- 4:00Mark McGrath: One of the reasons I went to uniformed services as opposed to Georgetown or somewhere else was that the military has an appreciation for the acceleration of science into practical, evidence-based medicine and there was a guy who kind of the captain Will Watson, who kind of introduced me to that concept and it was what drew me into military medicine to start.
- 4:19Mark McGrath: But as you know we're, you know I'm seeing people I know go off to the Middle East.
- 4:24Mark McGrath: You know we have OEF, oif kickoff and I'm trying to understand what's going on and you know it's early 2000s.
- 4:31Mark McGrath: I'm learning on the Internet a little bit but I'm mostly just kind of reading newspapers.
- 4:34Mark McGrath: I was taking the train between Baltimore and DC so I was like a five newspaper a day habit and I keep seeing I start going on the internet.
- 4:42Mark McGrath: I keep seeing terms like fourth generation warfare and there's the name that pops up over and over again and it's Boyd, and I don't have a background, I didn't know who he was, I didn't understand the context of a lot of it.
- 4:53Mark McGrath: So it was 2003, 2004.
- 4:56Mark McGrath: I'm learning about this and I don't know.
- 4:58Mark McGrath: I was reading a lot of the war bloggers back then either Richard Fernandez, it probably was John Robb who you've had on the show that started to impress upon me the importance of this one individual and his ideas, and right around that time a couple of biographies came out.
- 5:13Mark McGrath: So I started diving deep and I was amazed, I was fascinated.
- 5:22Mark McGrath: And I'm busy, I'm doing work.
- 5:23Mark McGrath: I'm 80 to 100 hours a week as a grad student but I have a lot of downtime time to read and so I start reading things about him, looking at some of the stuff that was thin but available on the internet.
- 5:31Mark McGrath: It was really when Ossinga's thesis turned book came in that I looked at it and I looked at all the stuff Boyd was reading and it was a cross section of the stuff that I had been studying as biochemistry undergrad, interest in neuroscience, philosophy of mind.
- 5:45Mark McGrath: Definitely.
- 5:46Mark McGrath: He was moving into a direction in the later years where he was expanding his ideas into places that I knew well.
- 5:52Mark McGrath: Now, as we all know, and sometimes is a little bit of a misdirection, he's got his application training as a fighter pilot in the military, so that's where he took these ideas as they grew, and gave examples, but it was definitely the case that I saw a connection between him and all these other areas that I didn't really think about as being connected and I think, punch, that's what you were talking about.
- 6:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Spot on.
- 6:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's what I was bringing up.
- 6:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: There is it isn't until you start looking at the Toyota production system and learning how control is outside and bottom up and you start looking at the parallels between that and then maybe what you're seeing in neuroscience and complex adaptive systems thinking and you think about how those evolved independently.
- 6:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Perhaps you know Shingo and Ono I don't think were studying as far as I know, they weren't studying complex adaptive systems and neuroscience to come up with the Toyota production system.
- 6:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So you get this consilience that John Boyd.
- 6:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It emerged from the interdisciplinary approach to how he looked at the world, what he studied, his curiosity, always challenging assumptions.
- 6:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I didn't know a lot about cybernetics until I picked up I still don't know, by the way, but I wasn't aware of it until I picked up Asinga's book and I was like what is this thing?
- 7:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I thought it was like something that you did in college for weightlifting you took some pills and you worked out funny.
- 7:09Sean Manion: You know what I mean?
- 7:10Sean Manion: Cybergenics, oh yeah, there you go.
- 7:12Sean Manion: Wow, that's a Gen X reference, yeah.
- 7:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So it was a Singha's book that started taking me down the path of hey, let's start looking at complex adaptive systems, and then now we're looking into neuroscience your field.
- 7:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And hey, let's start looking at complex adaptive systems.
- 7:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And then now we're looking into neuroscience your field.
- 7:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And then I was reading through some of your material over the last few days and the connection to Brownian motion, claude Shannon, information theory there may be some loose connections of Popper and all you know going back to the 30s and 40s and what was going on then.
- 7:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So just absolutely thrilled that you're here to kind of walk us through your journey and then kind of have a back and forth conversation about what is this thing that John Boyd gave us, you know, and what could it be, and how can you apply it to artificial intelligence.
- 7:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So thanks for being here, sean.
- 7:52Mark McGrath: No, I appreciate you having me and I love seeing this constant ongoing conversation in parallel tracks across different ideas and different industries tied back to Boyd, because I think he would have appreciated the vastness that you're touching.
- 8:07Sean Manion: I mean Ponch and I have spent days in the archives down in Quantico and it's amazing to see the diversity of books, all these books that he read.
- 8:17Sean Manion: But, as you were pointing out, the interdisciplinary nature of it, and it's interesting, when we talk about theorists, that we bring up a lot like John Boyd, marshall McLuhan and some others.
- 8:28Sean Manion: I mean these were well-read people across and down.
- 8:33Sean Manion: I mean these were deep thinkers across many, many different disciplines and you're not the first neuroscientist we've had.
- 8:39Sean Manion: And I think that's feedback that we also get is like, well, you guys have a lot of people that are not in the military on your show or were never in the military, and I think that's feedback that we also get is like, well, you guys have a lot of people that are not in the military on your show or were never in the military.
- 8:46Sean Manion: And I'm like, yeah, and we bring on people that know a lot about John Boyd.
- 8:49Sean Manion: In your case, you do know a lot about John Boyd.
- 8:51Sean Manion: Sometimes we say so you know everything about John Boyd, but you know nothing about John Boyd, just the nature of his work and what he was actually doing.
- 8:58Sean Manion: I was having a conversation with somebody.
- 9:00Sean Manion: What you think of this, you know, when we Google Boyd or you go looking, it does reduce it to sort of that military, maybe that linear depiction of the OODA loop.
- 9:07Sean Manion: You end up getting like maybe 1% of what the guy was actually trying to do.
- 9:13Sean Manion: And then when you dig into the Ocinga book, as you mentioned, you realize that well, there's 99% of this guy's thinking that no one's talking about and that's that's kind of what.
- 9:22Sean Manion: That's why you're here, that's what we're, that's what we're trying to do.
- 9:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, we've had a Bobby Azarian on to talk a little bit about cybernetics and the connection, you know, to what was happening in the forties and how it was suppressed by potentially suppressed by our government.
- 9:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You know, going coming out of the forties and the fifties.
- 9:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But I'd like to unpack that for folks to understand the basics of cybernetics and how it influenced John Boyd's thinking and how it even influences today's AI, the race for agentic AI and there's so many different names for it generative AI, active inference AI and, of course, mental health.
- 9:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So can you help us unpack what is cybernetics, what are the controversies around it, who are the key figures and how does it fit into John Boyd's observed oriented side activity?
- 10:05Mark McGrath: Decide, acclimate, sure, sure.
- 10:07Mark McGrath: And, to be upfront, I mean I appreciate you saying I know a lot about Boyd, but I feel like an amateur.
- 10:11Mark McGrath: I've had a 20-year run of looking at his stuff but it's like it fades to the background.
- 11:19Mark McGrath: It's definitely influenced me, but then it comes back again and I think this is sort of my yeah.
- 11:21Sean Manion: Yeah, see, that's proof that you know a lot about Boyd, because we would say the same thing.
- 11:24Sean Manion: We're constant students of this.
- 11:25Sean Manion: You have to take that amateur approach to keep going at it, at it, at it, because he even told us the minute you call yourself an expert, you're screwed.
- 11:34Sean Manion: We don't want to be the experts, we want to be the students and the teachers of it.
- 11:39Mark McGrath: And with the cybernetics I feel the same way.
- 11:41Mark McGrath: And with the cybernetics I feel the same way.
- 11:43Mark McGrath: I mean I am three or four years into a pretty steady dive into the history of cybernetics.
- 11:47Mark McGrath: I mean, if I was like you, you asked me five years ago what's cybernetics?
- 11:53Mark McGrath: I was like, ah, you know the cybersecurity and cyberspace and cyberpunk and whatever internet stuff you're associating it with.
- 11:58Mark McGrath: But I didn't really have a concept of what this was historically and honestly, it was a blind spot to me.
- 12:03Mark McGrath: I read Ocinga and there's cybernetics in it, but I didn't know what it was at the time so it didn't really resonate the system.
- 12:09Mark McGrath: Science did a little bit more.
- 12:10Mark McGrath: But a few years ago I started working with a group an oral history of all the original Dartmouth 1956 AI conference people and she worked with them and knew them on a personal level.
- 12:20Mark McGrath: So they opened up in ways that I don't think they would have for just someone who was just an interviewer and she put together an awesome book.
- 12:34Mark McGrath: So in looking at that book and she passed away in 2021, unfortunately and she donated all of her archives to CMU.
- 12:41Mark McGrath: So I started going to CMU, diving into the archives paper archives, some that haven't been digitized yet, and I'm seeing all these things.
- 12:49Sean Manion: And for the non-Pittsburgh natives like Sean and myself.
- 12:56Mark McGrath: Carnegie Mellon University.
- 12:57Mark McGrath: Carnegie Mellon University, not Central Michigan, which used to be Carnegie Institute of Technology until the early 60s and that's where Herb Simon and Alan Newell that actually did the first and only working AI program at that 1956 Dartmouth meeting.
- 13:11Mark McGrath: That's where they were based and, as Herb Simon who won the Nobel Prize and the Turing Award and was the first person to be an AI person to win it in the 70s, everyone forgets about that with the recent Nobel Prize for AI.
- 13:22Mark McGrath: They were the center point, cmu, along with MIT, along with Stanford and AI back in the day.
- 13:30Mark McGrath: But everyone talks about 56 and the Dartmouth meeting as being the kickoff of AI, sometimes the 1950 paper by Turing.
- 13:38Mark McGrath: But what I started seeing was there were precursors to that and there's always precursors to everything.
- 13:42Mark McGrath: Simon in one of the interviews and I listened to the interview she did with him he's like he's like, yeah, we were doing AI before 1956.
- 13:48Mark McGrath: We just called it operations research.
- 13:50Mark McGrath: So you look into it with new light, you start to look at what's going on.
- 13:54Mark McGrath: And there was a guy by the name of Norbert Wiener who who coined the term cybernetics.
- 13:59Mark McGrath: But even before he coined that term there was work he was doing developing essentially a predictive targeting for airplanes and for gunners to hit airplanes using the pilot and the airplane as a combined entity, using the gunner and the gun as a combined entity, and he set up a program that did that in 1941 and 42.
- 14:24Mark McGrath: That was classified.
- 14:25Mark McGrath: It didn't make it out but there was a lot of that work that went into.
- 14:29Mark McGrath: Shannon was one of the students so he kind of helped inform the whole idea of entropy as information theory.
- 14:37Mark McGrath: But this time in the 40s and into the 50s there was this tremendous amount of excitement and activity almost to the level we have now with AI, about cybernetics.
- 14:46Mark McGrath: There was a parallel group in Britain with Turing involved called the Ratio Club, where they got together they drank beer, they ate food and they presented on all of these things and they would bring over the head of the defense intelligence from the US because they knew them from the war and these people were all having conversations about thinking computers.
- 15:05Mark McGrath: And this is in the late 50s, in the early 50s, prior to any AI talk.
- 15:10Mark McGrath: And so all of this stuff with cybernetics had this rich, very distinct history and for a variety of reasons some was untimely, deaths of a few individuals involved and some was very political the US decided to pursue AI and thought that the intelligence in that, you know, connected with intelligence.
- 15:29Mark McGrath: We used it and set the Central Intelligence Agency.
- 15:32Mark McGrath: Meanwhile the Soviets dove deep into cybernetics and at the same time cybernetics in the US and in the West in general kind of took on a very social and antisocial component of the counterculture drug use, a lot of art, a lot of different things and so it took on a different tone in the US than what it had in other places.
- 15:52Mark McGrath: And a lot of this culminated in there was a guy named Stafford Beer who was a sort of second generation physicist and there was a second order cybernetics, sort of thinking about the cybernetics of cybernetics, and all of this just sounds Boydian when you start to dive into it.
- 16:07Mark McGrath: And he advised the Chilean in what was a coup there.
- 16:11Mark McGrath: But they had a group called Cybersyn or an approach called Cybersyn, which was a cybernetic approach to centralized running of the government.
- 16:33Mark McGrath: Now the feedback was solid in thinking of the loops, but the information gathering and the time lag were too slow so they weren't able to do it that effectively, probably because of the centralization, but it was really the death knell in the West of that being an acceptable area of government expenditure and things that helped keep that funding going.
- 16:59Mark McGrath: So, as you had some of the early proprietors, like Warren McCullough who worked with Wiener and did one of the first artificial neural network designs in 1943, he passed away.
- 17:10Mark McGrath: The other people who were involved ran out of funding and it just kind of died a slow death through the 60s into the early 70s in the US.
- 17:17Mark McGrath: There were some threads of it that didn't go away entirely but it was very much just kind of viewed differently and viewed as this dormant old thing that nobody touched anymore and that to me was fascinating.
- 17:30Mark McGrath: So I've been spending time getting deeper into it.
- 17:34Mark McGrath: I've met the people who are involved in the American Society for Cybernetics, again based at CMU, the head of that.
- 17:39Mark McGrath: Right now he's starting up.
- 17:41Mark McGrath: There was a series of meetings.
- 17:43Mark McGrath: I'm going through here's the minutes of the 12 meetings that they had in late 40s and early 50s.
- 17:48Mark McGrath: It's absolutely fascinating read.
- 17:50Mark McGrath: I would have loved to have seen Boyd get a hold of this information.
- 17:54Mark McGrath: He definitely got into cybernetics but if you look at what Ocinga says he was looking at some of the most popular end stage pieces.
- 18:03Mark McGrath: He did start into some of Wiener's like on human use of human beings, but I think by and large he hadn't gotten to delve all the way back yet, which would have been amazing if he could.
- 18:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Sean, there's some connections to like stochastic process or stochastic math and the Brownian motion.
- 18:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm not sure if you've been diving into that at all and the reason I bring that up is the connection to economics.
- 18:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Boyd had a background in economics and Moose has a background in economics, as do I, but stochastics are being used and I recently one of our guests, actually Enos Hippolito, brought out a point that large language models are stochastic parrots, right, so there's some interesting connections again that connect back to things like Brownian motion and cybernetics.
- 18:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Can you speak to any of those connections that you've come across between I forgot Brown's first name, who came up with Brownian motion, maybe Mandelbrot who looked at that and stochastic processes?
- 18:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is there a connection in there that you've come across?
- 18:58Mark McGrath: I don't know the history of those things exactly, but where it does start to intersect with cybernetics is with Norbert Wiener, the man who coined the term, who set up some of these initial cybernetics groups and the focus on it.
- 19:11Mark McGrath: He had actually had success as a mathematician before World War Two.
- 19:15Mark McGrath: He was, he was working at MIT and Brownian motion was the area that he had focused on the most at that point, and it wasn't until he was tasked with essentially figuring out the time series activity involved in targeting a plane, where the time to get to the plane was seconds to a minute and in that time the pilot could see you firing and make adjustments.
- 19:38Mark McGrath: And so it was some of that randomization, that trying to break down what seems random but how we can project what random things could move forward.
- 19:48Mark McGrath: I think Wiener's work with Brownian motion, which Einstein had done as well that was an area Back in the late 40s.
- 19:58Mark McGrath: He was almost as famous as Einstein for being a scientist, but then he pissed off the Soviets, he pissed off the FBI, he pissed off his colleagues at MIT and he didn't play well with others.
- 20:10Mark McGrath: So I think he kind of tarnished his own image and didn't get remembered for as much as he should have, but he definitely was approaching some of those areas way back before AI was even up.
- 20:25Mark McGrath: Twinkle in John McCarthy's eye.
- 20:28Sean Manion: I just put up John Boyd's collection in Quantico.
- 20:31Sean Manion: You see, norbert Wiener's the Human Use of Human Beings, cybernetics and Society was one of the books that he had.
- 20:39Mark McGrath: Yeah, that was when Wiener came out with cybernetics in 48.
- 20:44Mark McGrath: In 49 he published the time series um book that was actually published in 43 but classified, and then 50 he started getting upset with.
- 20:54Mark McGrath: He was upset with a number of things.
- 20:57Mark McGrath: He stopped taking government funding.
- 20:58Mark McGrath: He didn't like the military use of of some of his ideas, um, and he published on human use of human beings which was really a very prescient tale of these.
- 21:09Mark McGrath: Automations are going to take over jobs, they're going to ruin human lives.
- 21:13Mark McGrath: And most interesting and it was interesting to me that Boyd had that 67 version because the original 1951st edition had a chapter in it called Voices of Rigidity.
- 21:24Mark McGrath: It was the last chapter where he warned that the Soviets, the Catholic Church, the FBI could use technology to survey and to abuse their power with individuals.
- 21:36Mark McGrath: They made him take that out of the second edition.
- 21:38Mark McGrath: At that time he was under investigation by the FBI and his publisher was like we're going to take that chapter out.
- 21:45Mark McGrath: So I don't know if Boyd ever saw that chapter.
- 21:47Sean Manion: Wow.
- 21:48Sean Manion: So this is the Anderson US Anderson Success Cybernetics.
- 21:55Mark McGrath: That one, and then I think Psycho Cybernetics was listed.
- 21:58Sean Manion: Maxwell Maltz.
- 21:59Sean Manion: Yeah, this one.
- 22:00Sean Manion: Fh George, cybernetics.
- 22:03Mark McGrath: FH George and I think he was at Bell Labs and then Ashby or two people he read Ashby was one of the original British cyberneticians.
- 22:13Mark McGrath: Those would have been very much the first order cybernetics.
- 22:17Mark McGrath: So he was starting to get some exposure.
- 22:20Mark McGrath: But I don't think he got as deep.
- 22:21Mark McGrath: He didn't get back to wiener's original 1948 cybernetics.
- 22:25Mark McGrath: So I feel like he only scratched the surface on the first order.
- 22:27Mark McGrath: The, the psycho cybernetics, the success success cybernetics in the late 60s and 70s were starting to be that sort of pop psychology, you know, sort of feedback to improve yourself and how to improve your life.
- 22:40Mark McGrath: Valuable in in some ways for some people more than others.
- 22:43Mark McGrath: But I don't know that that gave him as much depth as I would have really loved to have seen what he would have done with if he would have gotten into some of the meat of it.
- 22:52Sean Manion: Is SAP Arena cybernetics within us?
- 22:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I think there's so many connections inside the archives you just passed over, mandelbrot.
- 23:01Sean Manion: Yeah, I saw Mandelbrot and.
- 23:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Mandelbrot.
- 23:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So we have a connection here.
- 23:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We have Wiener with a connection to Schadklanen, with information theory.
- 23:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Schadklanen was a Weiner student.
- 23:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What's the correct German pronunciation?
- 23:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Weiner or Weiner or Wiener.
- 23:18Mark McGrath: I say Wiener, and I haven't been connected it might be Weiner, I don't know.
- 23:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We'll ask one of our german-speaking friends on that.
- 23:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So a lot of connections in here.
- 23:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But can we unpack what cybernetics is?
- 23:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So we got a lot of business leaders that listen to this, that they're probably going.
- 23:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What the hell are you talking about?
- 23:35Mark McGrath: yeah, they're thinking.
- 23:36Mark McGrath: They're thinking it's like I was a few years ago.
- 23:38Mark McGrath: It just means like something with computers.
- 23:40Mark McGrath: Oh, so what it was referred to as is the science of control and communication in animals and machines animals including humans, and it was a look at it was really also a science of feedback.
- 23:55Mark McGrath: It stemmed out of a lot of control theory from the late 1800s and early 1900s and then thinking how that interacted with individuals and entities and those entities were computers that were starting then and they were thinking about how computers could think like humans and how you could model humans and computers together.
- 24:16Mark McGrath: It did set us into a little bit of a tight loop and that I think has been a little challenging to get out of humans as computers and computers as humans, but not any way to think of them differently to really expand upon that.
- 24:28Mark McGrath: But it's that science of communication and control in animals, humans and machines, and how feedback can give you fine-tuned complexity out of very simple devices.
- 24:41Mark McGrath: And I was teaching just the other day and using a textbook I teach brain behavior and cognition and there it is.
- 24:47Mark McGrath: There's a, there's a set of feedback cells and I'm demonstrating it for the undergraduates and it it really is textbook, what, what, what Wiener was thinking about, what all these others were thinking about.
- 24:58Mark McGrath: And the thing about Boyd is he was coming at all of this without the same background that they had, but finding the same conclusions.
- 25:06Mark McGrath: He was moving in the same direction.
- 25:08Mark McGrath: And it's you know, it's you know.
- 25:10Mark McGrath: We all have a certain amount of time and it's a shame he didn't have more, because I think what he probably would have done was start to absorb some of that the way he had, you know, different military strategists, and started to change his thinking based on all this new information he was absorbing.
- 25:26Mark McGrath: But that that science of control and communication some people think it did sort of work its way into some of the managerial systems.
- 25:36Mark McGrath: Stafford Beer wrote you know, a brain of the firm, how to design a firm.
- 25:40Mark McGrath: You know, design an organization around, how a brain works.
- 25:43Mark McGrath: A lot of robotics.
- 25:45Mark McGrath: The whole British cyberneticists were very heavy into robotics.
- 25:48Mark McGrath: They had essentially, like you know, little robots that could go around since when their battery was low and then find their home to recharge.
- 25:54Mark McGrath: It was a Roomba without the vacuum to it they were playing with like it was a game in the late 1940s and 1950s, and so the science itself is very broad.
- 26:05Mark McGrath: It did spin into systems theory, complexity theory, chaos theory.
- 26:10Mark McGrath: All of these really grew out of cybernetics, so there are elements of it still around.
- 26:14Mark McGrath: It's just some of the core thinking of it just got left behind in history, I think.
- 26:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And the concept of Stearman.
- 26:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's what it means in Greek.
- 26:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is that correct?
- 26:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: The term they actually that's what it means in Greek.
- 26:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is that correct the meaning?
- 26:24Mark McGrath: The term they actually.
- 26:25Mark McGrath: There's some interesting.
- 26:26Mark McGrath: John von Neumann and Norbert Wiener and Howard Akin hosted a conference at Princeton in early 1945, I think January 1945.
- 26:37Mark McGrath: They called it at that time, they called it teleology and some of the early 1943 papers.
- 26:42Mark McGrath: Wiener's paper called it teleology, but that had that and that means sort of a purposeful action, but it had a religious connotation.
- 26:49Mark McGrath: So they decided they needed a new name and so he went with and he kind of developed this on his own and got credit for it with his 1948 book.
- 26:57Mark McGrath: He called it cybernetics, which means steersman, comes from the Greek, same root as governance, so it basically means governance.
- 27:04Mark McGrath: People think it was a nod to Maxwell, a physicist who developed control theory and governance theory.
- 27:10Mark McGrath: So it had been used once in 1800s France to mean control and governance of a population, of a government, but he didn't know about that, so he thought he was kind of giving it a new life.
- 27:22Mark McGrath: But it's a very useful name in that respect because it really does mean to steer and to direct something.
- 27:28Mark McGrath: And so how do you steer something?
- 27:30Mark McGrath: You steer something not only with the control of it but with the feedback.
- 27:34Mark McGrath: You need to make the right choices with that and it really gets into what Boyd's general thinking and Odo Oda was also arriving at different language sometimes, but really similar concepts that just aligned in a lot of different ways and in ways we probably still can.
- 27:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I can't remember if cybernetics has the internal model of the external world, or what's that called.
- 27:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Does it call for having an internal model that reflects the outside?
- 28:00Mark McGrath: world.
- 28:01Mark McGrath: There are like just a representation model.
- 28:03Mark McGrath: There's threads of it that do.
- 28:05Mark McGrath: I don't remember that as being a core element, though Maybe in some of the second order.
- 28:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Okay, and the feedback loops.
- 28:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So again looking at it, when you're sailing a boat, now, I'm not a, I don't sail.
- 28:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What do you call sail people?
- 28:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That sail boat?
- 28:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm in the Navy, I can't tell you Sailors.
- 28:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Sailors, sailors, that's right.
- 28:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 28:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Targets, yeah, well, yeah, you got trim tabs on all there.
- 28:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You got feedback, yeah, shoes Driving a boat.
- 28:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You get feedback from the ocean.
- 28:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You have currents, you have wind, you have all these things.
- 28:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You just can't go straight, right.
- 28:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You got to adjust to the external environment and I think that's what the feedback loops kind of reflect.
- 28:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: There is you take the feedback from the external environment and update two things, right, or maybe one thing your perception of the external world.
- 28:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's what you're trying to do.
- 28:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Or take actions, shift the boat, turn the boat to counteract the forces in nature or the features of the world.
- 28:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Right, right, Moose.
- 29:00Sean Manion: Yeah, yeah, I mean that's.
- 29:02Sean Manion: I was just looking over Cybersyn, the history of that, and it's interesting how, as you pointed out, when the coup happened, they destroyed it Like they destroyed all the off-centers.
- 29:14Sean Manion: Now I imagine too, there's probably a dystopian view of that too, that, cybersyn, if we lived in an algocracy which is a word I just learned democracy or government by algorithm, do you think so?
- 29:27Sean Manion: I mean, maybe that's a discussion point Do you remember when the doctor got thrown off of a United flight and they beat the shit out of him?
- 29:38Sean Manion: I mean, they grabbed him and they dragged his ass off the plane?
- 29:42Sean Manion: Yeah, and it was just basically, though and Rob wrote about this that's what the algorithm said to do.
- 29:48Sean Manion: It said to free up the space so this pilot could jump the plane to get to his next location because of whatever, and they had to pick a passenger, and they picked this guy who's a doctor, and they not got his teeth knocked out or whatever, but it was saying that no one was able to intercede above the algorithm.
- 30:06Sean Manion: The algorithm said to do this.
- 30:07Sean Manion: No one injected any humanity in it to realize that we should not be beating the shit out of passengers and tossing them off of planes.
- 30:15Mark McGrath: I think there's an important aspect that's missing from our current use of AI technology and technology in general, and that's trust and technology in general, and that's that's trust.
- 30:31Mark McGrath: We tend to trust systems and then that trust is somewhat mislaid for algorithms that don't do the right thing or situations where we're used to someone having the ability to intervene if something doesn't make sense One of the things that you know I mentioned.
- 30:45Mark McGrath: I kind of come back to Boyd again and again.
- 30:48Mark McGrath: I went to grad school trying to understand the world just at its basic level.
- 30:52Mark McGrath: I was applying it when I was playing soccer there, just to try and figure out how it worked, and it worked wonderfully, because I was a terrible soccer player and I needed some help, and Boyd's loops helped me in that respect.
- 31:02Mark McGrath: But then it went away for a little while came back to me when I was in an administrative policy position in DC a lot of bureaucracy.
- 31:10Mark McGrath: I called it bureau science.
- 31:11Mark McGrath: Understanding those systems was very interesting to me, and so I revisited it again, but then, when I left government in 2017, got very interested in blockchain technology and not cryptocurrency.
- 31:23Mark McGrath: Per se, that's one application and a popular one, although a troubled one.
- 31:28Mark McGrath: Per se, that's one application and a popular one, although a troubled one but what you can do with a distributed system of information, of knowledge and an automated governance across that, and so that automated governance and at that time I had no idea cybernetics kind of tied in with governance as well, and I wish it did, but I'm starting to get all the dots together.
- 31:44Mark McGrath: I got very interested in how Boyd would have perceived or how, the sort of net centricity that he implied as something you were able to do if you had the right trust in a group that everyone's operating on the same principles and so can go off and do their own thing without having to have tight command and control on those units.
- 32:04Mark McGrath: And I started looking at that with respect to different governance structures and control on those units.
- 32:07Mark McGrath: And I started looking at that with respect to different governance structures and blockchain different applications of blockchain in health and life sciences, health and human services.
- 32:15Mark McGrath: I had a white paper contest in 2016 that I was studying and trying to understand how it would work, and I actually reached out to Chet Richards and a great guy I'm sure I don't know if you know him personally, but you know who he is and he's retired now and I hope he's still with us.
- 32:32Mark McGrath: I haven't talked to him.
- 32:34Sean Manion: Yeah, he just wrote the foreword to our transcript of Conceptual Spiral and he's been on two or three times with us.
- 32:40Mark McGrath: That's right.
- 32:41Mark McGrath: I see his blog once in a while, Slightly East of New.
- 32:45Sean Manion: But we had if you go to slightly east of new.
- 32:46Sean Manion: Right now we're the featured article at the time.
- 32:48Sean Manion: Really Nice.
- 32:49Mark McGrath: That's that's all coming together but he was very gracious to like listen to me I mean by email.
- 32:54Mark McGrath: We had a brief diet listen to my questions here about this weird technology he didn't really know anything about and and it was.
- 33:02Mark McGrath: Then I got busy in the startup world and I wasn't able to.
- 33:05Mark McGrath: You know, once I had dreams of like kind of putting some papers together or something on it, but I really see one of the gaps in trust of AI, of institutions.
- 33:16Mark McGrath: You know, it's not just the algorithm we don't trust all the time, as being perhaps augmented by this automated trust.
- 33:23Mark McGrath: If you know what governance went into the system, if you know what things are going to be done, you have a better sense of whether you can trust an algorithm, a group, it's when, it's when an or it's you know something he had purchased a ticket for and he was able to go sit down and then that didn't happen.
- 33:39Mark McGrath: That's.
- 33:40Mark McGrath: That's completely outside of not just the algorithm but what the organization was doing.
- 33:45Mark McGrath: So how to bring trust back?
- 33:46Mark McGrath: What blockchain and cryptocurrency came out of was the financial crisis, and how do you trust that if you say you have a unit of currency?
- 33:55Mark McGrath: And you say you have a unit of currency and I say I have it that I don't try and tell you.
- 34:00Mark McGrath: I'm going to send you one and send you the same one.
- 34:02Mark McGrath: Well, we trust banks, we trust institutions, but what if there was a process, an automated process, that allowed each of us to have that ledger of what was going on?
- 34:11Mark McGrath: That simplistic audit trail for any data system, that transparent governance, as well as agreed upon governance, can allow a lot of things to happen with data and a lot of things that happen with data going into algorithms, and so there's a lot of interest now in how we can keep data private, but also trust that data that's going into an algorithm is appropriate for the decision-making level that we give it.
- 34:40Mark McGrath: You can't take a sample of 10 college kids and then take that health data and apply it to a geriatric population.
- 34:49Mark McGrath: It just doesn't work, and yet we don't know what's going into these algorithms, and so having a transparent audit layer, which blockchain or distributed ledger technology allows us, is a way to bring that together.
- 35:00Mark McGrath: So I think, going back to your question, that trust issue is missing, and finding ways of bringing trust to a system gives you the value that Boyd saw and discussed, whereas if you have trust, you can operate much more independently across a network.
- 35:16Mark McGrath: Where I think things like Cybersyn failed was the authoritarian need to control it in the center and not to make them my example.
- 35:27Mark McGrath: But I was a DHA employee and a little bit antiquated and maybe the wrong direction.
- 35:31Mark McGrath: There were some good people working on it, but it hasn't played out the way it was supposed to.
- 35:54Mark McGrath: And does decentralization of those systems, or re-decentralization of those systems, provide better mobility, better agility and a better sense of independent operations?
- 36:09Mark McGrath: And I think if you look at what Void was going into not simply in the OODA loop it does point to that being more successful Centralization, and we have the ability to automate some of that trust and governance now, which I think is valuable.
- 36:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So explainable AI is critical now.
- 36:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And then there's a connection to net centric warfare that I think a lot of people like the military you know we were taught net centric warfare was about systems like computer systems, and I know that's not what the intent was behind it.
- 36:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So the distributed approach to decision-making is something that we put into the flow system, right?
- 36:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We call it distributed leadership and I think in one of your articles you kind of highlight the difference between a decentralized approach and a distributed approach where you can kind of graph it out and see that what it looks like in a network, right?
- 36:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So the example of blockchain connected to explainable AI, which I don't think we have right now.
- 37:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We have these black box approaches and you gave a good example of that that you don't know what you're going to get.
- 37:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They're hallucinating at the moment.
- 37:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: My view is, if you take some of the things we talked about with cybernetics and neuroscience and you move that forward and you borrow some of those ideas, because you can't go one for one and copy a human, as far as I know you can take a lot of lessons from natural science and apply them to AI.
- 37:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We get closer and closer to explainable AI, something that we can trust?
- 37:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's where I see the path right now.
- 37:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is the current status of LLMs?
- 37:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is they're that closed, linear OODA loop that we push back against, right?
- 37:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We can't tell you what's on the inside.
- 37:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We want an open system approach, a lower energy approach, one that adapts, one that learns, one that perceives just like we do.
- 37:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Can you talk a little bit about the connections to network-centric warfare and this path to explainable AI and what you've seen?
- 37:56Mark McGrath: I can.
- 37:56Mark McGrath: And there's probably another important element to put in there, and this goes back to the stuff that I was doing in my prior company, equidium Health, and now we've spun off.
- 38:04Mark McGrath: I am the co-founder and chief scientific officer for a nonprofit called AI Mind Systems, where we're trying to apply blockchain technology for that audit layer as well as an incentivization layer.
- 38:16Mark McGrath: In more advanced cases, AI, but in this case, federated AI.
- 38:20Mark McGrath: We are obsessed with this.
- 38:22Mark McGrath: Bring all the data to a center and put it through the paces there.
- 38:28Mark McGrath: One, it makes data less valuable because you're copying, pasting it.
- 38:31Mark McGrath: Two, you're getting further away from the source of the data, where people who know how it was collected which in health matters I mean, if I take my blood pressure at home versus it gets taken in the clinic, versus someone who's very well trained and being very careful with the best equipment is taking it in a hospital setting for a research study.
- 38:49Mark McGrath: Those are three similar data points that look the same to a data scientist, but you need to know which is which, depending upon which questions you're going to ask of it.
- 38:57Mark McGrath: So keeping that data decentralized, keeping data at rest and sending compute to the data is another technology advantage we have right now that's entirely possible.
- 39:07Mark McGrath: So I think being able to look at net-centric warfare health business as how do we operate without the time lag of needing all the data to come to a central repository speeds up decision-making while still enabling all the data to be available and that trust.
- 39:29Mark McGrath: And there was a wonderful example of this in 2017 or 2018.
- 39:35Mark McGrath: The first blockchain system with authority to operate in the federal government a friend of mine, jose Arrieta, who went on to be the chief information officer for health and human services.
- 39:44Mark McGrath: He had put together a program called HHS Accelerate and it took.
- 39:48Mark McGrath: They had 20,000 buyers.
- 39:51Mark McGrath: So if you're an HHS, you can buy stuff for some unit or entity you have.
- 39:56Mark McGrath: You've got the credit card to buy.
- 39:57Mark McGrath: If you are making a, you know whether it's software or whether it's nitrile gloves.
- 40:02Mark McGrath: If you are making a purchase above a certain amount, you need to shop for the best.
- 40:08Mark McGrath: The only way for them to do that strategic buy was to go to a centralized office that was crunching all the numbers from 20,000.
- 40:14Mark McGrath: It would take them four months to tell you where to get the best purchase.
- 40:17Mark McGrath: What he did was set up a system that allowed all of those individuals to have access in almost real time to all the data across all those other individuals.
- 40:27Mark McGrath: It was a closed system, so it was open within there, but it wasn't open to the public and so, instead of four months, they were able to have the best value and the target of where they're going to purchase in seconds, and it saved the government 25 million in the first year they had it.
- 40:41Mark McGrath: He got promoted and they sundowned it because no one wanted to maintain a system that you know undercut their sundown because no one wanted to maintain a system that undercut their budget.
- 40:51Mark McGrath: The government is, unfortunately, sometimes incentivized to not cut money, but it was an amazing demonstration of what you can do with a simple thing like purchasing.
- 40:59Mark McGrath: Walmart used similar technology to figure out how they could track through their entire supply chain.
- 41:04Mark McGrath: They did one test in China and one test in the Americas pork in China and one test in the Americas pork in China and mangoes in the Americas.
- 41:11Mark McGrath: It used to take them days to figure out if there was mango recall where all their mangoes came from.
- 41:16Mark McGrath: So they just have to pull them all off the shelf, throw them all away, because they didn't want to get sued for making somebody sick.
- 41:21Mark McGrath: But with having all that data of all the supply chain in the hands of the guy with the handheld computer inside one of the Walmarts, they could know in seconds if a batch came from the bad place, where there was a recall or somewhere else and they could leave it on the shelves.
- 41:38Mark McGrath: So this ability to look at data stretched across a network without having to centralize that data speeds things up remarkably.
- 41:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So this is interesting.
- 41:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I don't know if you know the answer to this, and I'm curious.
- 41:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It sounds to me like the brain kind of operates this way already, right?
- 41:55Mark McGrath: The brain operates not only like this, but levels and levels above that that we barely understand.
- 42:00Mark McGrath: I mean, I'm a neuroscientist and I'm the first to admit we know little about the brain and we know amazing amounts, but we keep getting these little incremental bits that we haven't integrated.
- 42:12Mark McGrath: There are governance structures at the subcellular, cellular and systems level of the brain that we haven't even studied.
- 42:19Mark McGrath: How it's, with light bulb level energy doing everything.
- 42:24Mark McGrath: My heart still beats, my body temperature is being maintained while I'm talking to you, while everything else is going on.
- 42:30Mark McGrath: It's doing all of that in multiple different systems operating and where they need to be integrating, and we we've barely scratched the surface.
- 42:39Mark McGrath: So I think, yes, the brain is an example of this, but at the same time, you know when, when you ask a neuroscientist, you ask anybody where is the memory of you know, Central Catholic, my graduation, where does that sit in my brain?
- 42:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We have no idea.
- 42:53Mark McGrath: We simply don't know.
- 42:54Mark McGrath: We can, you know, we can poke holes in it until I don't remember it anymore, but that's not very effective or useful, especially if it differs across people.
- 43:02Mark McGrath: So what the brain is doing probably has some similarities to it, but probably goes well beyond in ways we don't even know.
- 43:08Mark McGrath: Which is why I say that the most successful computer or tech companies of the future are going to start employing neuroscientists and doing their own research, rather than just waiting for it to come out of NIH.
- 43:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Right.
- 43:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So the naturalistic approach to engineering.
- 43:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I hate to call it engineering, but we should mimic what's in nature.
- 43:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We should learn from nature anthropology, biology, neuroscience and try to figure out why.
- 43:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Why does that work that way, and see if we could scale it.
- 43:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: When you read about the Toyota production system, to me it kind of mirrors everything we just talked about, right, what Shingo and Ono were looking at and what John Boyd looked at before he got into the neuroscience and complex adaptive systems.
- 43:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I think he looked at cybernetics before he looked at TPS.
- 43:48Sean Manion: Yeah, because cybernetics was one of the that was for destruction and creation.
- 43:52Sean Manion: It was one of the sources.
- 43:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, but just taking a look around and seeing what's actually working in nature, what actually scales, is important.
- 44:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And to me there's a fractal approach behind all this too, because if you could take the OODA loop and say this is how a cell works and for the most part this is how a neuron works and a person works and the team works, then you just reduce the energy required to understand and again, it's not a full understanding of how the world works.
- 44:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It gives you a good abstraction, but that's the way Moose and I are looking at this is.
- 44:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's a fractal approach to understanding how natural things persist through time, right, and if you understand it, how do we fend off the second law of thermodynamics?
- 44:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Right, that's what we're trying to do here and I think, by the way, is there a connection between cybernetics and the second law, by any chance that you know of?
- 44:38Mark McGrath: I feel like we're looking at it from an information perspective.
- 44:40Mark McGrath: Cybernetics definitely kind of grew out of the same information theory component that both Wiener and Shannon.
- 44:48Mark McGrath: Shannon got most of the credit, but Shannon actually referenced Wiener's still, you know, not public work in his work.
- 44:54Mark McGrath: So there's a there's an information theory aspect and there's an entropy aspect to information theory and to some extent, figuring out what we're doing with AI and the internet right now.
- 45:04Mark McGrath: Are we, are we facing an information entropy death of the internet by allowing it to continue to feed garbage, garbage, garbage and then learn off of the diluted garbage?
- 45:15Mark McGrath: This model collapse that could be some, you know, parallel of the heat death of the universe is the information death of the internet.
- 45:24Mark McGrath: So I think there's definitely things to be learned from that and I think you know what Boyd did in Creation and Destruction is conceptually start thinking about these things Now, applying that concept to different areas.
- 45:35Mark McGrath: You know he was applying it in a general respect, but thinking about it at that time mostly in a combat situation or in a war situation.
- 45:44Mark McGrath: But if you think about how that same lack of information, how that same incompleteness of a system and how that same uncertainty in the system come together.
- 45:55Mark McGrath: That can be applied in a lot of different places.
- 45:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm going to throw this at Moose.
- 45:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Everything Sean just said to me connects right back to Boyd's Trinity.
- 46:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Take it from there, moose.
- 46:05Sean Manion: Yeah, entropy, incompletenesseness and uncertainty by by fusing second law with uh girdle's incompleteness theorem and heisenberg's uncertainty principle, thus required us to.
- 46:19Sean Manion: I mean, that's really where oodaloo sketch comes from, is like, because of these three, three, because of these three things.
- 46:26Sean Manion: How do we create mental concepts in our minds to help us engage that, as time unfolds, as the circumstances in our environment?
- 46:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, and the internet bringing that trash together, collapsing on itself, is a great analogy of Boyd's strategy, which is you cannot change the system from within, right, you have to go outside the system.
- 46:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, and that's why you can't determine the nature, you have to go outside the system.
- 46:49Sean Manion: Yeah, you can't determine the nature of a character of a system within itself.
- 46:52Sean Manion: Yeah, and the more that you attempt to do so, will you increase confusion and disorder there you go.
- 46:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's what Sean, I think what Sean just said.
- 46:59Mark McGrath: Yeah, that's what Boyd covered very, very succinctly.
- 47:09Sean Manion: I still read that paper and I'm just amazed at how just just short and to the point.
- 47:11Mark McGrath: It is um that's, that's hard it's still dense though it's not.
- 47:12Mark McGrath: It is.
- 47:12Mark McGrath: It is, but you know it's not a hundred pages it's.
- 47:14Mark McGrath: You know what like have you?
- 47:15Sean Manion: ever.
- 47:15Sean Manion: Have you ever looked at evolutionary epistemology by chuck spinney?
- 47:19Sean Manion: So, chuck spinney, I I call it the codex of destruction creation.
- 47:22Sean Manion: You know my my history slash economist mind had a hard time really grasping destruction and creation, other than I could see the quote unquote, stonewall building.
- 47:32Sean Manion: But anyway, chuck Spinney, who was Boyd's closest collaborator that helped him illustrate this OODA loop sketch, he created this evolutionary epistemology which you can get on Chet Richard's site in the article section, and one of the cool things that it does is it draws a boundary between the internal and the external role.
- 47:51Sean Manion: You know Ponch talks about this a lot, that you have to understand what's inside your cognition and what's in the external world.
- 47:57Sean Manion: I also think that it does a pretty good job of helping us understand the difference between perception and perspective.
- 48:04Sean Manion: You know.
- 48:05Mark McGrath: I haven't looked at that.
- 48:06Mark McGrath: I definitely need to.
- 48:07Mark McGrath: I've, you know, slowly working my way through, like all the different threads, but it just amazes me.
- 48:12Mark McGrath: I need to revisit the same things each time, because the depth that they, they, they got to, and even the things that they arrived at independently and I'm starting to say they, is it not just boy, but you know the lack of a better term the acolytes that he had but pierce sprayay with, I don't know.
- 48:27Mark McGrath: Have you guys ever checked out what Maple Shade Records did, what Spray did after he retired?
- 48:32Mark McGrath: He was a record producer.
- 48:33Mark McGrath: I knew that.
- 48:34Mark McGrath: He set up a completely analog record studio in Pennsylvania in an old house.
- 48:40Mark McGrath: He actually had a studio in Baltimore.
- 48:42Mark McGrath: I walk by there sometimes and no one was ever in there.
- 48:45Mark McGrath: I would have loved to have met him.
- 48:46Mark McGrath: But I walk by there sometimes and no one was ever in there.
- 48:50Mark McGrath: I would have loved to have met him.
- 48:52Mark McGrath: But he does completely analog recording and it's beautiful, and I know people who know music a lot better than I do and there are things on analog records and now they brought records back, but a lot of times they're just recording the digital recording onto them, which loses everything, and so he's got this and at the same time I'm looking at it and I'm talking with people.
- 49:08Mark McGrath: There's areas of neuromorphic computing and analog computing that are starting to come into play because we're hitting caps on energy for digital and if you can do analog at the edge, if you can have certain types of analog processing happening, you get more exacting this to it.
- 49:26Mark McGrath: It wasn't feasible technically years ago, but now they're starting to be analog computing companies that are coming into the AI discussion and it might be the future and I'm like they were moving in directions and sensing things that I don't even think they realized have parallels to what the rest of the world is catching up on.
- 49:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well, that makes an interesting connection to fine temperament tuning.
- 49:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You can't digitally shift the frequencies.
- 49:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It doesn't work that way.
- 49:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: When you digitally do it, it has to be done in situ.
- 49:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: When you tune an instrument, is it 440 or 432?
- 49:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: See that as a connection to something else we're talking about quite a bit on the show, which connects to aliens.
- 50:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So some other time.
- 50:05Sean Manion: Well, it's interesting, interesting.
- 50:06Sean Manion: We've talked a lot about.
- 50:07Sean Manion: We've talked a lot about jazz.
- 50:09Mark McGrath: Maple shade is a jazz label primarily yeah yeah I think it's got some gospel and some other things, but it's primarily jazz, huh dang, do you know what your cousin and I used to listen to?
- 50:19Sean Manion: a lot that comes up, that's come up on the podcast.
- 50:22Sean Manion: Quite a bit was grateful dead we were, and there's a lot, there's a lot of those concepts in there.
- 50:32Mark McGrath: Yeah, it takes you into a different dimensionality, whether that's aliens or other dimensional beings.
- 50:34Mark McGrath: And there's a great, there's a neuroscience slash, psychedelic book called Reality Switch Technologies Love it.
- 50:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We've been trying to get them on the show forever.
- 50:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That thing blows my mind getting into DMT and then to get into affordances and attractor states and fitness landscapes and complex adaptive systems.
- 50:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I read it.
- 50:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm like everybody needs to read this book and of course people are like what the hell are you talking about?
- 50:56Mark McGrath: I mean we could go in this direction as well.
- 50:57Mark McGrath: I actually my niece, was an undergrad and she and I and another colleague presented on the medical evidence that's out there or lacking that's out there on ayahuasca at the last Society for Neuroscience meeting and I got to dive deep into some of the literature on ayahuasca and you know what's going on.
- 51:14Mark McGrath: I think it's the Bronx, va is heading up the psychedelic research area.
- 51:18Mark McGrath: Rachel Yehuda, who was a PTSD researcher that I cited heavily in my thesis work for the government, is now, you know, on on VA side doing psychedelic research.
- 51:28Mark McGrath: I was in Baltimore, hopkins had a big community there and so I think I think seeing not only what it can do for people with trauma but also how some of the impacts on the brain parallel different approaches to looking at other technologies elsewhere.
- 51:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, and I think that reality.
- 51:46Mark McGrath: switch technology gave me that sense that there's again kind of like Boyd arriving at some of the same cybernetics conclusions without fully diving into that whole library.
- 51:56Mark McGrath: There's different approaches to the same questions and answers and you can't dismiss the stuff even though it's got a negative aspect to it which we could go into too.
- 52:07Mark McGrath: A lot of weird things.
- 52:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We can.
- 52:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We've done that quite a bit.
- 52:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I want to connect a few things to the Alien Switch Technologies book.
- 52:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: In there he talks about how we perceive reality, some connections to Anil Seth and the free energy principle.
- 52:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Going back to the psychedelic piece, when I drew the entropic excuse me, the entropic OODA loop, it was inspired by the entropic excuse me, the entropic OODA loop.
- 52:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It was inspired by the entropic brain hypothesis through Robin Carhart-Harris and Carl Friston, right?
- 52:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So that's that neuroscience connection there.
- 52:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And then the way we explain it, when we say we're trying to minimize, surprise, we're trying to get rid of free energy, not get rid of free energy.
- 52:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But the OODA loop exists for one reason and that's to say, let me just say, minimize free energy.
- 52:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's where we get that from is from the neuroscience of the free energy principle and active inference, right.
- 52:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So my view is that Boyd's OODA loop was on that path and had he been an academic, other academics would have picked it up and they would have made the connection to Bayesian updating.
- 53:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Active inference perception is top-down, inside-out.
- 53:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's a controlled hallucination.
- 53:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: With the OODA loop, the way we draw it, with the boundary and the entropic boundary in it, I can explain ego, death default mode network and how you press that down and gain access to novelty using things like counterfactuals, using the pathway that moves from act back to observe as a pathway.
- 53:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: A counterfactual pathway that helps you update your internal orientation so, again, we've been looking at a lot of these things on here actual pathway that helps you update your internal reorient, or your, your orientation.
- 53:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So, um, again, we've been looking at a lot of these things on here and, by the way, that's all connected to cybernetics, complex adaptive systems as well.
- 53:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um, and and then, on the market side of the house, moose and I and some others are looking at, um, understanding Brownian motion stochastics, using sacred, sacred geometry, which again is connected back to a lot of psychedelic therapy.
- 53:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So, yeah, we're, we're loving that space right now.
- 53:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I think a lot of so much, so much potential.
- 53:59Sean Manion: I mean, this is this is where, like you hope, your competitors stop at the linear oodle loop.
- 54:04Sean Manion: They looked at boyd he's a fighter pilot, he has this little tactical thing and that's where they stop and they don't realize this whole other world that he opened us up to.
- 54:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Hey Sean, in your updated orientation I looked at this and I was trying to understand what memetics is.
- 54:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Am I getting that right?
- 54:21Mark McGrath: Memetics I was using an older term to probably cover two broad things and just for your audience back in 2017, I kind of got it in my head that you know.
- 54:31Mark McGrath: Another thing I wish Boyd would have had more time with is to dive deeper into neuroscience.
- 54:35Mark McGrath: I think he got deep, but you know he was coming from a different place, whereas I was coming from the neuroscience place and saw all these connections, and so I attempted to update some of the small orientation sub-details with some things that may give it a better framing for how it fits into what we know about neuroscience.
- 54:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Let's build on this.
- 54:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: This is great.
- 54:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So in there you have biases.
- 54:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Sometimes you call them heuristics.
- 54:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So let's paint the picture.
- 55:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: The current orientation, excluding analysis and synthesis and new information, is comprised of three components.
- 55:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It has three things genetic heritage, cultural traditions and previous experience.
- 55:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Help us build out what you would put underneath genetics, to kind of genetic heritage, to kind of try to build this out.
- 55:17Mark McGrath: For genetics.
- 55:17Mark McGrath: I think you know that there's a major component of genetics in there, but I think the thing that he you know it wasn't really popular until several years after his death and it's still something we're just scratching the surface on is epigenetics.
- 55:29Mark McGrath: And I think the epigenetics which, for people who don't know you know your genetics is a, is a, you know, a ACGT code that that is in all your cells and is relatively the same.
- 55:39Mark McGrath: Epigenetics is changes in methylization spots or areas that, and methylization spots or areas that so your DNA translates to, transcribes to RNA which goes to your proteins that are created.
- 55:53Mark McGrath: How much of any stretch of DNA gets turned into proteins is dependent upon not only how many copies there might be but also how actively that is accessed, based on different chemical structures in the DNA and how it sits can change during someone's lifetime based on experience.
- 56:14Mark McGrath: Exposures stress a lot of things, but some of that epigenetic change which isn't in the code can also be passed along through generations.
- 56:24Mark McGrath: So you hear things like generational trauma.
- 56:25Mark McGrath: There's been studies where you know you've got you've got stressed rats who have babies and then stress unstressed rats who have babies and they switch the babies with the mother and it's, it's DNA based impacts on how you behave and how you react and how much your body makes certain proteins, and it's it's an area that we I mean there's there's a million methylation sites and that's just one type of epigenetic change on your DNA.
- 56:51Mark McGrath: So every cell has a million different options of ways things could be different based on things that aren't DNA related Intelligence, how the brain works, what's going on in the brain, is probably far more heavily influenced by that than we realize.
- 57:04Mark McGrath: So I think that genetic component is.
- 57:07Mark McGrath: It was smart, it was what he knew at the time, but it's just the surface.
- 57:10Mark McGrath: So I think, adding to that, I think it was right on the experience, although the experience starts to cross over physically with memory in that respect and we want to be conscious of that.
- 57:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Let's go back to the psychedelic piece here real fast.
- 57:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So epigenetics you brought up trauma can be inherited from other generations.
- 57:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I've learned recently that there's something known as a multiple hit hypothesis, which connects to genetics, culture and experiences, right, so those three things kind of make up how we see the world.
- 57:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It kind of clouds how we see the world from, like a PTSD or even TBI.
- 57:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But the point I'm trying to make here is inheriting the trauma of your ancestors is not proven yet.
- 57:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We're starting to understand that can be carried through the DNA and that could actually cause trauma or the way people view the world.
- 57:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But that slide I shared with you a few months ago has epigenetics as a way on how we explain genetic heritage, right, and some people push back on that and say hey, it's not proven yet.
- 58:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So can you talk a little bit more about where we are on the I mean epigenetics is not fantastical, it's a reality.
- 58:16Mark McGrath: What and where can be epigenetically translated?
- 58:20Mark McGrath: That's something that we don't have the full edges of.
- 58:23Mark McGrath: So sometimes people will take a known or something that's been demonstrated or has got evidential support, like epigenetics, and then translate it to a much broader thing, and that's where we maybe have extrapolated it too far.
- 58:35Mark McGrath: We don't know how many generations it can pass through, what types of changes occur, what types of things get carried down.
- 58:42Mark McGrath: The challenge with science is it's very exacting, and then the communication of science is much more of a narrative and those two don't always line up, which is, I think, what they're bringing up.
- 58:50Mark McGrath: But it's kind of like the psychedelic piece where it's you know, you've got these things that, for whatever reason, people are afraid to touch or afraid to admit, and on the one hand they sometimes are overblown.
- 59:00Mark McGrath: On the other hand, we're not lacking in some evidence that there is something involved.
- 59:05Mark McGrath: It takes a balance to be able to say we want to look at this intently and we want to look at this scientifically, but we're not going to dismiss it because there's cultural, dismissive aspects of oh no, it's the hippies taking the drugs again.
- 59:19Mark McGrath: That I think is happening a little bit.
- 59:20Mark McGrath: People are very reactionary to having their narrative changed and so when that comes into play, or if they've had somebody push a broader narrative with, well, there's, you know, you know, I'm of Irish heritage and I could say, well, you know, I might, my ancestors haven't been in Ireland for five generations.
- 59:38Mark McGrath: But I could say, well, you know what the British, you know, there I still have, am suffering because of the what the British did to my ancestors five generations ago.
- 59:46Mark McGrath: There might be some validity to that.
- 59:48Mark McGrath: But if I push that too hard, should policy be changed with how we interact with Britain because of that?
- 59:55Mark McGrath: Well, you know, we need to not take it and extrapolate it too far, but if you're used to me doing that, then anything I say about epigenetics might become well, you know, that dude hates the British and that's all there is.
- 1:00:08Mark McGrath: And so we don't want to get too caught up in the broader narrative when we're trying to talk about the small specifics, and we don't want to get too caught up in the specifics when we're talking about the broader narrative.
- 1:00:19Mark McGrath: But again back to Boyd he talked about, you know, general to specific and specific to general, with the analysis and with the synthesis, and I think people get tripped up being on either one side or the other of that and it's hard for them to flow back and forth.
- 1:00:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I want to talk about what's behind you and make the connection back to where it would go.
- 1:00:38Sean Manion: in orientation I was going to say something about it till you.
- 1:00:40Sean Manion: Beat me to it.
- 1:00:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You got the biases.
- 1:00:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's the great graphics.
- 1:00:43Mark McGrath: That was a Valentine's Day present from my wife.
- 1:00:45Mark McGrath: That is he knows me well.
- 1:00:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Oh man, yeah, where were they?
- 1:00:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Are they a combo of culture?
- 1:00:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is it genetics?
- 1:00:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Where do those biases fit in?
- 1:00:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: How do they?
- 1:00:56Mark McGrath: manifest themselves inside of orientation.
- 1:00:57Mark McGrath: It's one of those situations where it's a term and I'm gearing up to bring this to my class and I've touched upon it a little bit.
- 1:01:03Mark McGrath: The term bias is used very broadly and sometimes we talk about a social or a cultural bias and sometimes we talk about a cognitive bias, and these are not completely discrete things.
- 1:01:16Mark McGrath: But when we talk about a social or cultural bias, it's generally a macro bias against a group of people or against certain things, and it oftentimes it oftentimes is a negative and it almost always has a negative connotation.
- 1:01:30Mark McGrath: When you talk about cognitive biases, a lot of times they're just shortcuts.
- 1:01:35Mark McGrath: Our brain works on a very low power and does a lot of stuff because we don't have to analyze everything constantly, and that makes us jump to conclusions.
- 1:01:44Mark McGrath: And now there are some things, there are some biases you've got it right there.
- 1:01:47Mark McGrath: There are some biases that are extremely evolutionarily beneficial, and if we didn't have them we wouldn't be sitting here but at the same time, they can be exploited, they can be exacerbated, and when they are, sometimes they show up as those cultural biases, and so we need to be clear where we're thinking about it.
- 1:02:08Mark McGrath: Are we thinking about it at the neuronal level?
- 1:02:11Mark McGrath: Are we thinking about it at the brain systems level for how we make quick decisions with limited information, or are we thinking at the policy level of whether or not we've got this bias impacting that policy decision?
- 1:02:24Mark McGrath: I think that's one of the reasons we often and in science we do this we assume we've got bias from certain things, and so we look for a consensus process to actually refine the information before we move forward with it and you said sometimes these are good.
- 1:02:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We talked to a lot of neuroscientists who say that 2% of our body weight burns 20 to 25% of our energy, that humans are naturally lazy.
- 1:02:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It just saves energy to have these things and that's the way I kind of look at it is when you get into implicit guides to control those habits, those skills, that type zero, type one cognition, that system one thinking, whatever you want to call it, muscle memory, that is a low energy approach to dealing with the external environment.
- 1:03:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So athletes, dribbling a basketball, hitting a baseball I don't know, hitting a baseball is a good one.
- 1:03:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But those repeatable things that are built up, those skills that are built up over time, to me they kind of parallel those biases.
- 1:03:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You know they're formed in our orientation, but they really emerge and manifest themselves through that rapid pathway that takes us through implicit guidance, control and then out to the external world.
- 1:03:28Mark McGrath: And potentially, if you change the term muscle memory to muscle bias, it wouldn't be that inaccurate but it would take on a whole different connotation.
- 1:03:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Good or bad, I don't know.
- 1:03:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Help me out.
- 1:03:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I want to make sure we get this right, yeah.
- 1:03:41Mark McGrath: I don't know.
- 1:03:41Mark McGrath: Did you have something you wanted to say there?
- 1:03:44Sean Manion: No, I mean like the implicit guidance and control aspect of that is huge.
- 1:03:48Sean Manion: I think that that's probably the most misunderstood thing about Boyd, generally speaking.
- 1:03:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I never heard muscle bias, I just want to make sure.
- 1:03:56Mark McGrath: I just made that up.
- 1:03:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Okay.
- 1:04:00Mark McGrath: Because the way you were describing it, I was thinking of the.
- 1:04:02Mark McGrath: You know we often call that muscle memory.
- 1:04:05Mark McGrath: But if we called it muscle bias, because it was just a, you know, efficient way we move, it would take the same connotation as the cognitive bias in many respects.
- 1:04:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: There you go, it's an efficiency.
- 1:04:17Mark McGrath: And yet it wouldn't have a term that you know, if we called it muscle memory.
- 1:04:21Mark McGrath: If we call these cognitive, you know memories gets confusing because we do do memory in the brain.
- 1:04:26Mark McGrath: But if we call them cognitive repetitions or cognitive shortcuts, people would get less up in arms about them in their own right because they wouldn't confuse them with the cultural, the social bias.
- 1:04:38Mark McGrath: That is usually what the problem is.
- 1:04:39Mark McGrath: Yeah but they can lead to that.
- 1:04:41Mark McGrath: You know, I think you've got muscle, you know, think about someone with PTSD.
- 1:04:44Mark McGrath: Maybe while they're sleeping, they're having a nightmare and they, you know, reach out and they hit their spouse.
- 1:04:49Mark McGrath: I mean, that's that's.
- 1:04:50Mark McGrath: That's a muscle bias, that's a muscle memory.
- 1:04:52Mark McGrath: That's going on.
- 1:04:52Mark McGrath: There's no intentionality to do harm, but in that case some harm can be done because of what that individual is trained to do when they're stressed, which is to respond in a physical way.
- 1:05:04Mark McGrath: And so I think there are examples where, like a cognitive bias translating to a negative societal bias, you could have muscle memory translating into this negative connotation, but we just don't call it bias.
- 1:05:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm curious about this.
- 1:05:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Back to the genetic side, genetic heritage.
- 1:05:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is there something in our DNA or bodies that prevents us or filters information from the outside world and I might be talking about the reticular activating system or something like that but don't we have a filter that keeps information from flowing in?
- 1:05:37Mark McGrath: Well, the thalamus is sort of the gatekeeper of information.
- 1:05:40Mark McGrath: Well, four of our five senses, all the information that comes in, goes through the thalamus.
- 1:05:45Mark McGrath: It's a grand central station, as I refer to it as olfactory.
- 1:05:49Mark McGrath: Our smell does put stuff through there, but a parallel path goes, like directly to the amygdala, which is why you can smell something that's a threat and humans don't have a threat response to smells as quickly as some other animals which must much more robust smells.
- 1:06:03Mark McGrath: But you can have an immediate fear of a fight or flight response to a smell because it doesn't even have to go through the thalamus.
- 1:06:10Mark McGrath: You can also have you know we get nostalgia with that it can kick off emotions without going through that thalamus, that area that's doing the initial processing.
- 1:06:19Sean Manion: Isn't smell the most?
- 1:06:20Sean Manion: Isn't that the most memory-inducing or the most triggering?
- 1:06:24Mark McGrath: That's why you could put it as it's not being filtered, it's going direct to the reactive mechanisms of some of our emotional memory.
- 1:06:31Mark McGrath: But at the same time you do have some initial we'll call it initial screening of information flowing in from all of your other senses before it starts being processed.
- 1:06:41Mark McGrath: What that screening does and I said the term screening, that's probably inappropriate or incorrect in a lot of different ways, but it's going through the thalamus and it's the first step of processing and so that processing we don't have a full understanding.
- 1:06:56Mark McGrath: I mean, what would happen if we didn't have a thalamus?
- 1:06:58Mark McGrath: Well, I don't know that.
- 1:06:59Mark McGrath: We've got those case studies to understand that.
- 1:07:02Mark McGrath: Could we start to computationally look at that when we have fine-tuned enough imaging or neurophysiology testing?
- 1:07:09Mark McGrath: You probably could.
- 1:07:10Mark McGrath: Maybe it's out there and I just haven't come across it.
- 1:07:12Mark McGrath: There's a lot of new work being done every day, but what happens if you stop screening that out?
- 1:07:16Mark McGrath: What if you change your screening mechanism to mine or vice versa, because I have a different epigenetic profile than you do?
- 1:07:24Mark McGrath: Or we could be twins and then be raised separately and I have a different epigenetic profile, and does that change how sounds are processed in my thalamus before they even make it to my auditory cortex.
- 1:07:36Mark McGrath: I don't know the answer to that.
- 1:07:38Mark McGrath: It seems like it's possible, but that's a hypothesis.
- 1:07:42Mark McGrath: I don't know whether it's true or not.
- 1:07:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Let's continue the going around orientation with genetic heritage, cultural traditions and previous experience.
- 1:07:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Anything else you want to add that you think Boyd could have really put into the orientation?
- 1:07:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: By the way, I don't want to say, well, let's pack orientation with everything.
- 1:07:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's just what else would influence Boyd to have put genetic heritage, cultural traditions and previous experience in there?
- 1:08:03Mark McGrath: I did use the term in almost a double entendre with using mimetics with an MI.
- 1:08:08Mark McGrath: Mimetics refers to sort of like representation in art and those things versus memetics, which is another.
- 1:08:17Mark McGrath: I've seen those misspelled or deliberately used similarly sometimes, and I think I was doing the same it was 2017, because I was interested in memetics, what the neural underpinning of memes and how.
- 1:08:31Mark McGrath: Not means necessarily in the modern computer, on the internet sense, though that captures an element of them, but in the in the Richard Dawkins who, who first coined the term as being.
- 1:08:41Mark McGrath: You know, if I watch you do a task or create a tool and I remember how to do that.
- 1:08:46Mark McGrath: That's a meme.
- 1:08:48Mark McGrath: That's a transfer of information.
- 1:08:51Mark McGrath: Now, what we see in these pictorial memes is like an image meme that translates to some, often mocking or some assessment of a situation in a way that then I can quickly translate to you.
- 1:09:05Mark McGrath: But those all, that whole collective, what are the things that we transfer to each other?
- 1:09:10Mark McGrath: Both, you know, religion is a meme.
- 1:09:12Mark McGrath: Tools is a meme.
- 1:09:13Mark McGrath: Cultural, you know, ideas, is a meme.
- 1:09:16Mark McGrath: If you look at the original use of the term meme, and even including the newer use of the term meme, which is probably taken over for it.
- 1:09:23Mark McGrath: There are components of what's been put in my head that could be called experience, but I think needs to be thought of distinctly.
- 1:09:30Mark McGrath: So thinking of the genetic and epigenetic thinking of experiential aspects and then thinking of these, call them complex memory, or sometimes in memory research is called engrams, like the E-N-G-R-A-M, like the memory engrams of where a memory lies and we don't know.
- 1:09:47Mark McGrath: It's a pattern, it's something that moves about in the brain.
- 1:09:49Mark McGrath: There are complex engrams that are included in that memetics idea, that are different than the contextual aspects of an experience or the specific details of an experience or that more general genetic and epigenetic aspect.
- 1:10:03Mark McGrath: So that's kind of what I was going for.
- 1:10:05Mark McGrath: It wasn't so much adding to what Boyd had done, so much as starting to detail and articulate it.
- 1:10:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, I like that, I like that type of thinking, so using a triad.
- 1:10:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So when you're talking about the let's see memetics the one with the eye that to me it kind of sits between genetics and culture and previous experience, right, it doesn't, it doesn't fit in one box completely, and that's what I.
- 1:10:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's why I put the triad out there to kind of explain things that you know.
- 1:10:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Epigenetics are not just one thing.
- 1:10:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's influenced by the external environment, those previous experience.
- 1:10:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: How many hours are you putting on your iPad a day?
- 1:10:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That type of thing, right?
- 1:10:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So there's a nice triad approach to kind of get people to go okay, it's not one thing, it's not just this, it's connected to maybe two or three, any other things you would put within previous experience, cultural traditions or genetic heritage.
- 1:10:57Mark McGrath: There, no, but I think the you know, I kind of you know, did that just kind of.
- 1:11:01Mark McGrath: There's the layer of the input coming in, there's a layer of the output going out, the analysis and synthesis.
- 1:11:06Mark McGrath: I think there's definitely almost a repeat of some of those components that are going to be an either.
- 1:11:14Mark McGrath: Actually, your question before, how information is processed and can you know generational trauma change how that initial input is processed?
- 1:11:21Mark McGrath: I mean it might be, but also, you know, do we tend towards analysis?
- 1:11:25Mark McGrath: How are we doing analysis?
- 1:11:26Mark McGrath: Do we tend towards synthesis?
- 1:11:27Mark McGrath: How are we doing synthesis?
- 1:11:28Mark McGrath: Can we jump back and forth those things together?
- 1:11:31Mark McGrath: I think that there's complexity in each of those side layers that mirrors some of the central complexity too.
- 1:11:38Mark McGrath: So you have sort of a center pool of, or center filter of.
- 1:11:42Mark McGrath: It's going to go through these three filters, but the conveyor belt on either side is going to work in a certain way that's also impacted by the filters, or the same way the filters are impacted Makes sense, yeah, and so I think there's nuance and details that can be teased out there, both at the psychological level and at the neurological and neuroscience level.
- 1:12:03Mark McGrath: And this is this is getting back to some of the discussion about ai we've kind of jumped the gun with ai and talking about intelligence.
- 1:12:12Mark McGrath: We don't know what intelligence is.
- 1:12:14Mark McGrath: We don't have a good way of doing it.
- 1:12:16Mark McGrath: We go with the I everyone's oh.
- 1:12:18Mark McGrath: The iq is garbage, oh, but we only have one way of doing it.
- 1:12:20Mark McGrath: There's like what the waste for?
- 1:12:21Sean Manion: that's one.
- 1:12:22Sean Manion: It's not one of your titles of your articles and says stupid or something and I.
- 1:12:27Mark McGrath: I drew that from a book that I reference in there, where there's a french philosopher.
- 1:12:30Sean Manion: What's the?
- 1:12:30Mark McGrath: proper title, that's 8.1 of the brains are complex.
- 1:12:34Mark McGrath: Intelligence is stupid, yeah okay and the next one coming out is actually called ai ain't intelligent, because it simply isn't.
- 1:12:42Mark McGrath: And we talk about the term idiot savant, where my calculator is smarter than me and putting math together.
- 1:12:48Mark McGrath: But I'm not going to be like oh my calculator is intelligent.
- 1:12:51Sean Manion: No, it's not.
- 1:12:52Mark McGrath: It does one task way, way better than me, and maybe some of these things do a couple of tasks.
- 1:12:57Mark McGrath: But here's the thing Humans are really good at fooling themselves.
- 1:13:00Mark McGrath: We are.
- 1:13:01Mark McGrath: I mean, if you look at any of like you know, persuasion and how, like you know, they used to run seances and trick crowds with mediums like we're doing that to ourselves with these LLMs to some degree, and these are really smart people, but they're really narrowly focused in their intelligence and I'm talking about some of the groups that are not just hyping it up but are like, oh my goodness, this thing is rational.
- 1:13:25Mark McGrath: Well, I mean, in the 60s, carl Sagan.
- 1:13:28Mark McGrath: Now Carl Sagan is famous for saying you know amazing, you know, statements require amazing evidence, or forget the exact term.
- 1:13:40Mark McGrath: He was a scientist, he was evidence based and he looked at ELISA, which Eliza was like a psychotherapy, not an LLM, but effectively a psychotherapy AI tool.
- 1:13:48Mark McGrath: That had people wowed and even people who knew it was a tool started revealing all their secrets to it and he said this is going to change everything with psychotherapy, there's not going to be psychiatrists or psychologists anymore, there's just going to be these computers doing it, because it's that good Novelty, especially, especially, really gets us.
- 1:14:06Mark McGrath: Our brains really get tricked by novelty, and then we want to believe that there is something on the other side of that box.
- 1:14:14Mark McGrath: And I think a lot of what we've done is take a very effective writing tool for really middling writing and decided oh my goodness, it's got these amazing abilities to it in the same way that people used to get.
- 1:14:28Mark McGrath: You know, there's a sucker born every minute, and the circus used to make a bunch of money off of them.
- 1:14:32Mark McGrath: And I'm not dismissing the importance of what we're creating, but I'm saying that we haven't even gotten close to what is intelligent, because we don't know what it is, and so we're just targeting one system and you had said earlier the modeling after the nature, before we build something.
- 1:14:49Mark McGrath: So a lot of people say, oh, but planes don't fly.
- 1:14:51Mark McGrath: You know, airplanes don't flap their wings like birds, so therefore an LLM must be super intelligent.
- 1:14:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They sure look like whales, though, don't they?
- 1:14:59Mark McGrath: I like that, but we also understood flight a lot better, and there's like four components to flight that need to be matched.
- 1:15:05Mark McGrath: With regard to intelligence, we don't even know what that is.
- 1:15:08Mark McGrath: So, you know, I could, I could, you know.
- 1:15:15Mark McGrath: Oh, this pen is intelligent because birds flap their wings and airplanes, don't that?
- 1:15:17Mark McGrath: That doesn't ask for a logical argument.
- 1:15:19Sean Manion: Yeah, it's kind of like, yeah, you'd said something.
- 1:15:22Sean Manion: I was just trying to think we're trying to avoid myopia, like we're trying to.
- 1:15:26Sean Manion: Who's going to decide what comes out of an LLM?
- 1:15:28Sean Manion: Who's the ultimate arbiter?
- 1:15:47Sean Manion: If something's not open source, or if something's not at some point, someone's going to have control over it.
- 1:15:55Mark McGrath: And I mean we could going back to the discussion of AI and having data, being able to track the data that goes into an AI, the model training as well as testing, as well as decision making, what the weighting is for all of that.
- 1:16:13Mark McGrath: We spent a lot of time with that in my previous company and you can do that.
- 1:16:14Mark McGrath: It's going to take some time and some structure, but it also includes the individual, and the individual is self-sovereign, being able to make a decision or be part of the general consensus decision that is being made.
- 1:16:26Mark McGrath: If the model is making a decision, I want to know what it's making that decision based on, when it was last updated and who set up the governance for it.
- 1:16:35Mark McGrath: And that's what you're getting to.
- 1:16:36Mark McGrath: Most is who's setting it.
- 1:16:38Mark McGrath: And in the brain there's lots of governance that includes a variety of cells or a variety of structures involved in how the patterns are passed around to make an action or make a memory.
- 1:16:50Mark McGrath: We have very good for us historically, governance we build into our laws and things like that, but it can be so much more fine tuned once we start to connect things and, like it or not, sooner or later you've got not just through a keyboard but through neurotechnology we're able to.
- 1:17:10Mark McGrath: You know, let's say we all live on a block with 20 people and we have to make a collective decision what time in the morning someone can start up their lawnmower.
- 1:17:20Mark McGrath: Well, right now it's like don't start up the lawnmower before nine o'clock.
- 1:17:23Mark McGrath: But if we get to a point where, like during the summer, when it gets hot out really fast, as long as we've got 17 of us that ping on, you can start up your automatic lawnmower.
- 1:17:34Mark McGrath: That goes on over there, we can start to have decision making collectively in a way we haven't had before.
- 1:17:42Mark McGrath: And I don't mean from a, you know, a socialist standpoint.
- 1:17:47Mark McGrath: People get political.
- 1:17:49Mark McGrath: When you say collective, I mean from a group consensus standpoint, based on a governance we decide upon.
- 1:17:54Mark McGrath: And you could say 17 out of 20 is enough to start start up the you know the lawnmowers, but it takes 20 out of 20 to make a more important decision.
- 1:18:04Mark McGrath: You can grade decisions.
- 1:18:06Mark McGrath: You can have a lot more nuance to decision making instead of again relying on a third party with a delay in incentivization.
- 1:18:15Mark McGrath: Like a politician, you could start to set up you know group algorithms to be a representative.
- 1:18:21Mark McGrath: There's even a movement out there called like AI in 2030, or something like that, where replacing, you know, replacing some representatives with AI decision making that's just fed in by its constituencies.
- 1:18:31Mark McGrath: Could you have that in real time?
- 1:18:33Mark McGrath: Could you have that with an appropriate level of feedback?
- 1:18:36Mark McGrath: Would it be less corruptible?
- 1:18:38Mark McGrath: Would it be more reliable?
- 1:18:42Sean Manion: Hey Sean.
- 1:18:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I have to drop in a minute.
- 1:18:44Sean Manion: Yeah, we're going to pause round one.
- 1:18:46Sean Manion: We're going to send people to the unjournaling.
- 1:18:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Actually, I want to try something again.
- 1:18:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: One question to you.
- 1:18:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Given your knowledge of neuroscience and your understanding of the current landscape in AI, can you give us some insights?
- 1:18:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What are the good technologies?
- 1:19:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What are the emerging things?
- 1:19:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What are those things on the edge that people don't know about that?
- 1:19:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: May that excite you, I guess.
- 1:19:09Mark McGrath: I mean, it's not brand new, but it's less appreciated than it should be is the area of neuromorphic computing.
- 1:19:15Mark McGrath: Neuromorphic computing is trying to learn from how the brain works and we're really at a nascent stage with it but meme resistors and things that can change their state rather than just be on off of current transistor status.
- 1:19:27Mark McGrath: So the neuromorphic computing world is amazing.
- 1:19:30Mark McGrath: The brain is a digital analog hybrid in ways that we, you know, have known for years, and yet we're relying fully on digital.
- 1:19:38Mark McGrath: I think the hybridization between digital and analog computing is something else that is coming.
- 1:19:42Mark McGrath: And finally, I would go with.
- 1:19:45Mark McGrath: You know, we've got all of this connectionism with the machine learning that has come back into vogue but was really set on the chew gum at the same time.
- 1:19:52Mark McGrath: It's not going to be one or the other.
- 1:20:06Mark McGrath: We've got several dozen systems and multiple subsystems in our brain.
- 1:20:11Mark McGrath: One algorithm isn't going to replace that very effectively.
- 1:20:14Mark McGrath: So there's going to be a variety of integration of different types of systems and I think you're going to see connectionist, symbolic and other.
- 1:20:22Mark McGrath: We don't know yet that'll probably come into play.
- 1:20:24Mark McGrath: So that's where the sort of three things that I would say definitely have the cutting edge along with you know a federated or distributed data approach, the blockchain, auditing and incentivization layers all of these things come together.
- 1:20:37Mark McGrath: So you know the future is a five lane highway.
- 1:20:38Mark McGrath: If you're just looking at one lane, you're going to get run over.
- 1:20:41Sean Manion: We'll do this again, for sure, sean, and we're going to send everybody to the unjournaling.
- 1:20:50Mark McGrath: Thanks for coming on and we'll send people your way to both the unjournaling and to your ex.
- 1:20:52Mark McGrath: I appreciate that and I thank you for having me on and actually kind of bringing me back into the next phase of me diving into Boyd, because I threw a question out on X and it was, you know, because I looked at Boyd in cybernetics and you were like yeah, it's in a Senga and I was like I gave my.
- 1:21:08Mark McGrath: I have a bad habit I give books away when I really like them, and so I didn't have a physical copy anymore and I went into the electronic copy.
- 1:21:14Mark McGrath: I was like, oh yeah, there it is.
- 1:21:15Mark McGrath: So good stuff.