Latest / First Trust ROI Podcast / ROI Podcast | Episode 16 | Has the Balance between Potential Risks and Returns Shifted in Favor of Bond Investors? | Bill Housey | March 12, 2024
Transcript
- 0:11Ryan Issakainen: Welcome to the First Trust ROI podcast.
- 0:13Ryan Issakainen: Ryan Issakainen, ETF Strategist at First Trust.
- 0:17Ryan Issakainen: On this episode of the podcast, I'm joined by Bill Housey, managing Director of Fixed Income at First Trust.
- 0:23Ryan Issakainen: Bill and I are going to discuss what is happening in the economy, what that means for inflation, what that means for interest rates and where some of the risks and opportunities lie in the bond market.
- 0:34Ryan Issakainen: I hope you enjoy this episode of the First Trust ROI podcast.
- 0:37Ryan Issakainen: So, bill, thank you for arranging your schedule.
- 0:41Ryan Issakainen: It's always a pleasure to talk to you and a little bit tricky getting our schedules to align.
- 0:45Ryan Issakainen: So thanks for joining us again on the podcast.
- 0:49Ryan Issakainen: So, as I was traveling, I had to fly into Chicago.
- 0:52Ryan Issakainen: We're recording this at the last day.
- 0:54Ryan Issakainen: It's a leap year.
- 0:55Ryan Issakainen: It's the 29th of February and it seems like everything just kind of went wrong with travel today.
- 1:00Ryan Issakainen: And I got thinking of some old episodes of Seinfeld.
- 1:04Ryan Issakainen: Remember Seinfeld?
- 1:05Ryan Issakainen: Of course, one of my favorite episodes is where George Costanza decides that he's just going to do everything the opposite, and it got me thinking that to be successful in this market, that's kind of what you had to do over the last at least 15 months, and maybe longer In the last year if you were an equity investor and you thought well, there's a recession coming, prices are going to drop.
- 1:27Ryan Issakainen: If you did the opposite and just bought the S&P 500, you made 26% Sure.
- 1:32Ryan Issakainen: You know if I was not aware that Bitcoin was going to rip higher to whatever it's near all time highs.
- 1:39Ryan Issakainen: If I took the George Costanza contrarian approach, I would have bought Bitcoin, Maybe sold everything else is about Bitcoin In the long term.
- 1:47Ryan Issakainen: Those things don't always play out and maybe the George Costanza approach isn't the right approach, but I wanted your take on that.
- 1:55Ryan Issakainen: I mean, do you think that that's the right approach going forward, or do we just need to take that contrarian George Costanza approach?
- 2:02Ryan Issakainen: And you're a fixed income guy, so in the bond market you know where am I off in that.
- 2:08Bill Housey: Well, I think it's a great analogy for the environment that we've had, and I think you don't have to go back very far to find a very reasonable example in the bond market of what you just described.
- 2:19Bill Housey: Remember, it was only October that the narrative in the market and that's really what we talk about when we talk about, you know, doing the opposite.
- 2:28Bill Housey: Right, it's doing the opposite of what it's the narrative.
- 2:30Bill Housey: What is the narrative in the market?
- 2:32Bill Housey: At the time?
- 2:33Bill Housey: And when we go back to October, the narrative was what no one's ever going to buy a treasury bond again.
- 2:38Bill Housey: Right, the government is pumping out so much in terms of treasury debt.
- 2:42Bill Housey: Rates were surging into October and if you blinked, you missed it right, Because by December, you had an incredible rally from those really attractive levels into the end of the year as rates came down, and so it was a very similar backdrop to what you just described, and these things happen all the time, frankly, and I think that our job is to look at these stories I call them bedtime stories in the market and try to put data to them.
- 3:10Bill Housey: Right, and you know, I think for a lot of good reasons, we thought the bond market was very cheap in October and I know we're going to get into that more.
- 3:19Bill Housey: But the data said the opposite of the story and I think that that's really, as professional investors, what we try to do every day is let the data lead that decision making, and not as much the bedtime stories that make for the narratives.
- 3:34Ryan Issakainen: Right so, and that hopefully gets rid of some of the noise and you can identify the signal better, and that is always a challenge, though, because you have to kind of go against your behavioral instincts.
- 3:45Ryan Issakainen: So I wanted to ask you about something that last time you were on you were nice enough to be one of my first guests on the podcast and we talked about this was in the summer of last year, how the yield curve was inverted and how that had signaled, almost invariably, a coming recession.
- 4:04Ryan Issakainen: We didn't have a recession last year, and so I wanted to start there and get your take on.
- 4:10Ryan Issakainen: Is there a recession still coming, and how do we interpret the inverted yield curve which, by the way, is still inverted?
- 4:17Bill Housey: It is absolutely.
- 4:18Bill Housey: Yield curve remains inverted.
- 4:20Bill Housey: If we look at two year treasury yields against 10 year treasury yields, the two year treasury yield is higher than the 10 year, and you're absolutely right.
- 4:28Bill Housey: I mean, when we look back through time and one of the things we have done is having studied previous business cycles and manage money through previous business cycles we've come to learn that when these warning signs flash, they don't resolve themselves in a matter of days or months.
- 4:45Bill Housey: Sometimes it's literally years.
- 4:47Bill Housey: And in the case of the most recent notable recession, the great financial crisis, I mean you have to look back at that data yield curve inverted in 2006.
- 4:58Bill Housey: And you had almost you know, going off the top of my memory here almost two years of inversion before you ultimately made it to a recession.
- 5:07Bill Housey: And so you know, when I look at the data, you know we, from the point of inversion, call it the summer of 2022.
- 5:17Bill Housey: To where we sit today, I would say we're not out of the proverbial woods from that hard landing scenario.
- 5:23Bill Housey: In fact, if we just think about what's happened in most business cycles, typically the Fed is raising rates right, in this case, obviously fighting inflation, and there is a bit of euphoria, if you will, or a breath of fresh air when the Fed says you know what we're done raising and I really believe that's what Powell gave us in December.
- 5:43Bill Housey: I think Chair Powell came to the podium and he said you know what we're done raising I mean, that's what I heard him say, basically, right, if I interpret what he was talking about thinks the Fed has done enough.
- 5:54Bill Housey: Right, willing to continue to look at the data, but they've raised you know, I like to articulate it this way the equivalent of 21, 25 basis point hikes in a very short period of time.
- 6:05Bill Housey: I think the Fed believes that's sufficient For this business cycle.
- 6:10Bill Housey: After all, I mean, inflation was 9% and and it's come down to roughly 3%.
- 6:15Bill Housey: So you know, it's hard to argue that the the inflation is going up when, in fact, it's gone from 9 to 3.
- 6:21Bill Housey: So I think they believe that they've done enough and they want to wait and see.
- 6:25Bill Housey: So, as you, as you, consider these variables, the fact that the Fed has said they're done, you know the market breathe is a sigh of relief, right, as you would expect, and this has happened in previous cycles.
- 6:35Bill Housey: Right, you know you can look back to, you know prior cycles.
- 6:40Bill Housey: I think it was roughly February 2007 when Fed chair Ben Bernanke famously said we believe the Fed is engineered a soft landing at that point and and, and I believe it was roughly October, when the S&P put in the new high.
- 6:52Bill Housey: Then we all know what came in December of 2007 the rest recession.
- 6:56Bill Housey: And famously, I believe you know, chair Ben Bernanke Was giving speeches in early 2008 and still suggesting that the Fed didn't foresee a recession, and we were already in one.
- 7:08Bill Housey: Now I don't believe we're in one today.
- 7:09Bill Housey: But do I think that the narrative of a soft landing?
- 7:13Bill Housey: It could potentially be overdone?
- 7:16Bill Housey: Sure, I do, and I think that we're not out of the proverbial woods yet and we'll give it time and continue to wait and see.
- 7:21Bill Housey: And, and that drives a lot of our thinking with respect to what we're willing to do with cyclical exposures, for example, in the portfolios we manage, and Wow, we want to be positioned for the market that we're in, but I don't think that we're necessarily out of the woods, based on the data.
- 7:35Ryan Issakainen: Okay, I want to talk more about that positioning in a moment.
- 7:38Ryan Issakainen: Before we do that, though, you brought up the Fed and how there's a high probability that they paused, and what was Pretty much immediately priced in was that you know they had not only paused, but there were going to be aggressive in cutting.
- 7:52Ryan Issakainen: Sure, at the end of last year, I think, there was something like a hundred and fifty basis points of cuts priced in over the next 12 months.
- 8:00Ryan Issakainen: From that point, right right, did.
- 8:02Ryan Issakainen: Did you think that was the case?
- 8:03Ryan Issakainen: Obviously, some of that has come off, and so talk to us a little bit about how that's evolved and Whether or not that has matched your expectations.
- 8:11Bill Housey: Well, let's let's even rewind the tape a little bit further than that.
- 8:14Bill Housey: Go back to September, right, you had a Fed meeting and you had Powell talking about the willingness of the Fed to hold rates higher for longer.
- 8:23Bill Housey: And if you really think about what's been sort of unique about this rate-hiking cycle, it's been the fact that, no matter what chair Powell said, the bond market has always been sort of betting against it in terms of, you know, putting in more cuts or or not as high of a R-star, if you will, a terminal Fed funds rate that would ultimately be in the market.
- 8:43Bill Housey: So the market was continuously betting against.
- 8:45Bill Housey: So in September you have chair Powell basically say this Fed is willing to hold rates Higher for longer in the market for the first time, sort of took it hook, line and sinker and said you know what we believe you now and what we saw were was this move up in interest rates into October.
- 9:03Bill Housey: Of course there were strong economic data that led to some of that and you know now you, you pair this strong data with what chair Powell was saying in September, you get into October and there's some big Treasury auctions hitting the market and the narrative just fed on itself.
- 9:17Bill Housey: But as you fast forward a little bit and it was maybe late October, early November.
- 9:22Bill Housey: It all blends together now.
- 9:24Bill Housey: You know you had Lori Logan out of the Dallas Fed start to talk about the term premium, the in the bond market and what they were seeing with respect to interest rates and how some of that.
- 9:33Bill Housey: You know those higher back-end yields were doing a lot of the work for the Fed and that it was less likely that they'd have to do more.
- 9:40Bill Housey: And then it was just a short while after you had that famous December meeting where chair Powell, you know, sort of said, hey, I think we've done enough right, where you know that it's not like you can't possibly Conjure up a scenario where the Fed might have to raise rates again.
- 9:55Bill Housey: I just think it's a very low probability event based on what we heard.
- 9:58Bill Housey: But that's what we got to and you know the Fed puts out this dot plot right and so everybody gets a dot and on the, on the Fed, and they get to say here's what I think will happen over time as we move forward.
- 10:12Bill Housey: And as you looked to say, december 2024, the expectations Around central bank policy from the Fed, the median right, that that median middle dot point was three cuts, and so, of course, the bond market.
- 10:26Bill Housey: What do they do?
- 10:27Bill Housey: They said, oh, three, that must mean six, and and so you had this immediate Collapse in yields, and it was way overdone, frankly, because it was really dislocated from the data, right in terms of what we see in the employment, in terms of what we see in inflation, and in fact, I would argue and I wrote about this in December that the fact that this is what came from that meeting led to a situation where it almost promoted the potential for a greater probability that you would have a nonlinear path to 2% inflation.
- 11:00Bill Housey: So it's just going to create more ripples because you had such an extraordinary easing of financial conditions around that euphoria, and that's really what we've seen.
- 11:10Bill Housey: With higher stock prices, financial conditions of these rates came off those highs also leading to easier financial conditions relative to where we were.
- 11:18Bill Housey: So all of that tied together.
- 11:20Bill Housey: Today, you're absolutely right, though We've seen the bond market wake up to the reality that it's probably not six cuts.
- 11:26Bill Housey: I mean, eventually in the cycle, will we have six cuts?
- 11:29Bill Housey: I think six, I think eight, right, but is it premature to price those in today?
- 11:35Bill Housey: Absolutely just as it was in December.
- 11:37Bill Housey: And so today what we've seen is half of those have been priced out of the market and we're looking at a bond market where there's about three cuts priced in by year end, which I would call fair value.
- 11:48Ryan Issakainen: So eight cuts, roughly two percentage points.
- 11:51Ryan Issakainen: Do you think that it would take a recession in order to encourage the Fed to lower rates that much?
- 11:58Ryan Issakainen: Or do you think that, irrespective of when a recession comes, that that'll just sort of be a more natural place for rates to be, because it's a little bit above the 2% inflation target?
- 12:09Ryan Issakainen: How do you?
- 12:10Bill Housey: Yeah, no, absolutely.
- 12:11Bill Housey: So let me tie that all together With respect to if we have a hard landing, you'll get that six to eight cuts.
- 12:17Bill Housey: In my opinion.
- 12:18Bill Housey: Prior to that, it's not likely that you'll get that many cuts.
- 12:23Bill Housey: Of course, there's an old adage that the Fed takes the stairs up when they raise rates, in the window down when they begin to cut, and that's largely because what happens is the Fed does raise rates and holds them too high for too long, which is inevitably what has historically led to the end of the business cycle.
- 12:41Bill Housey: And while we're not at that point today, certainly when we get there, that is when the Fed does begin to aggressively reduce those interest rates.
- 12:50Bill Housey: So, absolutely, I would circle those things together.
- 12:53Bill Housey: You're not likely to see that, and I do think, though, the Fed is aware of the fact that we've gone from 9% inflation to 3% inflation and probably looks at the 21, 25 base points hikes and says maybe we can begin to take our foot off the gas, Although I personally think that it's more likely than not that the Fed will begin to address the pace of quantitative tightening first.
- 13:16Bill Housey: So that will be the first sort of foreshadowing, if you will, with respect to the next move which could potentially be that first cut in the cycle and I do think that, as you see, that disinflation trend continue to work its way through.
- 13:31Bill Housey: Of course it won't be a straight line down.
- 13:33Bill Housey: Then they'll continue to work some of those cuts in to the market.
- 13:38Ryan Issakainen: So you mentioned reducing the pace of quantitative tightening.
- 13:42Ryan Issakainen: That is going to affect the longer end of the yield curve.
- 13:45Ryan Issakainen: More right Is that.
- 13:47Bill Housey: Am I correct in that?
- 13:47Bill Housey: Well, I think if you look back at what has been written by the Fed and I haven't seen anything lately on this, but in prior cycles when we had QE, as the Fed has looked at prior QE and QT, I think that they would probably, or at least have perceived QT as being an incremental hike.
- 14:08Bill Housey: And maybe because you're talking about something like $60 billion of Treasuries in QT and $30 or $35 billion of Securitizing QT, maybe just given the amount we've reduced the balance sheet by over a trillion dollars $1.3, $1.4 trillion, something like that Is that the equivalent of an additional hike or two into the market?
- 14:33Bill Housey: Probably, I think that's more or less how the market would perceive it.
- 14:36Bill Housey: I mean, they're not outright selling.
- 14:38Bill Housey: These are maturities that are rolling off the balance sheet.
- 14:40Bill Housey: So there's a difference in my mind between allowing a maturity to occur and forcing a salient to the market.
- 14:46Bill Housey: So I don't necessarily think that those two things play out in that way.
- 14:53Bill Housey: I think that when we look at Fed policy, it's really important with respect to the front part of the yield curve.
- 14:58Bill Housey: That's why, in large part, we have the inverted yield curve.
- 15:01Bill Housey: As we look further out the curve, that's more about expectations.
- 15:04Bill Housey: If I look at a 10-year Treasury yield, well that really ties back to what are my expectations for inflation over the next decade.
- 15:11Bill Housey: Growth over the next decade?
- 15:13Bill Housey: Interest rate policy over the next decade.
- 15:15Bill Housey: Will we have a business cycle over the next decade or two?
- 15:19Bill Housey: I mean all of those variables get priced in, so there's more than one variable at play there.
- 15:27Ryan Issakainen: So let's say the yield curve normalizes the Fed's cut enough to bring rates down at the front end.
- 15:34Ryan Issakainen: The longer end maybe moves up a little bit, maybe it bounces around.
- 15:37Ryan Issakainen: It's more market-based.
- 15:38Ryan Issakainen: To your point, there are a lot of companies especially you're involved in managing below-investment-grade companies.
- 15:47Ryan Issakainen: I suspect there's a lot of companies that might be a bit uncomfortable that they're going to have to roll over their debt and pay more for that.
- 15:55Ryan Issakainen: Is that a concern as you evaluate the credit of these companies and what they need to borrow to continue their operations?
- 16:04Bill Housey: Well, sure, for the best quality companies, the best quality issuers in the market, they realize that they can come to the market now, price of deal and refinance it when rates come down.
- 16:17Bill Housey: They have complete access to the capital markets.
- 16:19Bill Housey: And for good quality companies, the market's open.
- 16:22Bill Housey: For weaker companies, those that were really levered going into a higher rate regime, particularly one that was such an aggressive pace for those companies that maybe didn't have hedges, on some of that floating rate debt, for example they're going to face some challenges and they're burning cash as we work our way through this part of the cycle.
- 16:45Bill Housey: So it really comes down to how long do these rates stay this high before there's some easing that takes place with respect to some of those companies.
- 16:53Bill Housey: So, at the end of the day, quality companies are going to be just fine.
- 16:56Bill Housey: They're going to have no problem printing deals even if they have to pay a higher coupon, and that's what we've seen.
- 17:00Bill Housey: Companies where they're good, strong stewards of capital will come and they'll say, hey, we're going to address these balance sheet issues.
- 17:08Bill Housey: But businesses that have too much debt, and a lot of it floating rate based, are definitely going to be squeezed in a higher rate regime like we've had and they're going to have to find ways to buy more time and when.
- 17:23Bill Housey: We've seen some of those transactions already, so that could potentially put upward pressure on weaker quality companies into this next year as we move forward.
- 17:31Bill Housey: I think the longer rates stay high, in terms of the default rate, for example.
- 17:36Bill Housey: I mean you could certainly see that that wouldn't surprise me at all, but ultimately it's a big ecosystem of debt.
- 17:43Bill Housey: So there are companies that are really well capitalized, companies with full, unfettered access to capital markets.
- 17:49Bill Housey: They're going to be just fine and they're going to look to price the bonds that they need to to clear the market today and they'll look to refinance those as they need to later.
- 17:58Ryan Issakainen: So it seems like your analysis would lead me to think it's being selective is pretty important, so active management would probably be one of the keys, and maybe it is all the time to managing a fixed income portfolio.
- 18:10Ryan Issakainen: But that brings me to my next question, and that is, as you're evaluating the broad sectors and fixed income and the different credits, and where you're being compensated for risk and not where, should investors be positioned in the bond market today?
- 18:28Bill Housey: Yeah, it's a good question and absolutely the short answer is you absolutely need risk management when it comes to the bond market, because while buying equities, of course, there's a lot of the potential upside when you think about buying a bond.
- 18:41Bill Housey: It's really one of asymmetry.
- 18:43Bill Housey: In the best case scenario, we get our coupon and our money back if we nail it, if we knock the cover off the ball.
- 18:51Bill Housey: So maybe in a time like today where we're buying bonds at discounts, we can incubate a total return.
- 18:56Bill Housey: Maybe if interest rates move the direction we expect them to, that can incubate some total return.
- 19:01Bill Housey: But at the end of the day, in the simplest form, the bond market is asymmetric and therefore it truly is rooted in risk management.
- 19:09Bill Housey: It's rooted in process and discipline in terms of how you approach it.
- 19:12Bill Housey: So I think the answer is you absolutely need to be very selective, and all the time.
- 19:16Bill Housey: Really Now, as you think about applying that to today's market, we talked a lot about the Fed and we talked about that sort of repricing of those cuts coming out of the bond market, but we didn't talk about what that's meant for interest rates.
- 19:32Bill Housey: And what has really occurred here isn't that the market is saying, hey, the Fed's going to raise 21 more times.
- 19:39Bill Housey: Right?
- 19:39Bill Housey: I believe the Fed has done and I think the market largely believes the Fed has done.
- 19:42Bill Housey: I don't think that's the big risk today.
- 19:43Bill Housey: I think that risk is over and what I think the big thing that we're focused on now is just the repricing of the timing of those cuts.
- 19:53Bill Housey: Now that puts a much narrower standard deviation around.
- 19:57Bill Housey: I think interest rates from here, at least in the near term, and so as you've priced out from the bond market those cuts, that's had the biggest impact on the front part of the yield curve, because that's the part most influenced by the Fed.
- 20:11Bill Housey: So that leads to the two-year treasury, say, going up more than the 10-year.
- 20:15Bill Housey: But we didn't talk about those back-end yields, and we should for a minute.
- 20:18Bill Housey: So first I want to go back to the narrative that we heard in October that no one's ever going to buy a treasury again.
- 20:24Bill Housey: Right, the bond vigilantes they're absolutely.
- 20:29Bill Housey: They peaked their head out and it was about three weeks that they stuck their head out, right.
- 20:33Bill Housey: And then by December we watched the 10-year go from 5% to 380.
- 20:37Bill Housey: Do you know what that means?
- 20:38Bill Housey: That means there were a lot of buyers of treasuries in the market between 5% and 380 into December.
- 20:43Bill Housey: Right, that's ultimately what that means.
- 20:46Bill Housey: Now, when we looked at the 10-year in October and we saw rates moving up, one of the things that we found that was very compelling at that time, and I think continues to be compelling even today, was the fact that when you looked at real yields so when I'm talking about real yields, what's my compensation for inflation?
- 21:06Ryan Issakainen: And by real yields, just so we're all on the same page.
- 21:09Ryan Issakainen: You're talking about inflation-adjusted yields.
- 21:11Bill Housey: That's right.
- 21:11Bill Housey: So what as an investor in the bond market?
- 21:14Bill Housey: If I just looked at treasury yields, what is my compensation as an investor in a treasury bond for inflation?
- 21:21Bill Housey: We're not even thinking about when we buy a corporate bond that hasn't even higher yield or a high yield bond that hasn't even higher yield, right?
- 21:29Bill Housey: Let's just talk about the treasury market.
- 21:32Bill Housey: In October, when rates peaked at 5%, if you looked at the tips market, the embedded inflation rate in tips was about 2.5% per year for the next 10 years.
- 21:43Bill Housey: That's what was priced in when we got to 5%.
- 21:45Bill Housey: So, effectively, your real yield was 250 basis points above that inflation rate.
- 21:52Bill Housey: So at 5%, 2.5% was that premium to what was expected over the next 10 years.
- 21:58Bill Housey: And you want to be careful because I've seen people try to compare the current CPI rate with the 10-year treasury.
- 22:04Bill Housey: Well, 10 years is about those 10 years of expectations.
- 22:07Bill Housey: So I think it's great if you want to compare current inflation with Fed funds right, five and a quarter to five and a half against current inflation, a spot rate with kind of current inflation.
- 22:16Bill Housey: But as we look forward, we have to say what is the bond market pricing in terms of expected inflation and what do I think will happen.
- 22:23Bill Housey: Well, when I looked at that and I said, wait a minute, we're getting 250 basis points above inflation and so, meaning, even if inflation ended up being 3% for the next decade, I'm getting 200 basis points above that.
- 22:39Bill Housey: And I think about how far back I have to go, to a time where the bond market was compensating investors in a way that was producing real yields.
- 22:50Bill Housey: At these levels.
- 22:51Bill Housey: You have to literally go back to a time like 2008, for example, to find 250 basis points of excess above inflation.
- 22:59Bill Housey: And off the top of my mind, off the top of my head, maybe the average is 135 basis points, but, as we know, for prolonged periods of time we had negative real yields.
- 23:11Bill Housey: Right, you were literally under earning inflation in the bond market.
- 23:14Bill Housey: So when I looked at that, at about 250 basis points, I thought, boy, that's a lot of protection in the bond market from what I think is likely to be the outcome with respect to inflation.
- 23:25Bill Housey: And there's added protection at 250 basis points.
- 23:28Bill Housey: It's not like it's five basis points above what the market thinks, it's 250, and we hit fast forward to today and perhaps that number is around 2% above inflation.
- 23:39Bill Housey: So not quite the 250 that we had, but around 2% above expected inflation for the next 10 years, and I think that's pretty compelling.
- 23:47Bill Housey: So when I look at the three cuts that are priced in for the Fed, sure, maybe it ends up being two this year, maybe we don't get that hard landing.
- 23:54Bill Housey: Maybe Fed cuts before the election once, maybe cuts one after.
- 23:58Bill Housey: Whatever it ends up being, what are we talking about?
- 24:00Bill Housey: Right, we're talking about moving around the timing, because if they're not priced in this year, my bet is that the market will price them in next year.
- 24:08Bill Housey: And what happens as this disinflation trend continues to take hold under the end of the year, does the bond market continue to extrapolate out 2.5% inflation or 2.3% inflation for 10 years, or does that rate start to come down?
- 24:21Bill Housey: And so all of that suggests that to me.
- 24:24Bill Housey: When I look at what's priced in from Fed fund futures with respect to the front part of the curve, when I think about real yields, where they are today, I think this bond market is at fair value.
- 24:34Bill Housey: I think it's as attractive as it's been in a long time.
- 24:38Bill Housey: Sure, even if you didn't lift the perfect top at October, where we sit today, after moving back up from December, I think this bond market is pretty attractive today.
- 24:50Ryan Issakainen: So is there a specific part of the yield curve that you think is most attractive?
- 24:55Ryan Issakainen: I mean, should people still be if they've got a benchmark?
- 25:00Ryan Issakainen: Should they be at the benchmark?
- 25:01Ryan Issakainen: Should they have more duration or less duration?
- 25:04Bill Housey: Yeah.
- 25:04Bill Housey: So it's a really good question because you know, make no mistake about it, If you're out there and you're trying to buy a very, for example, long duration product, where you know you're targeting a point on the yield curve that's, say, 20 years out, Okay and there's, you know, as you know, specific ETFs, for example, that do this and understand that you know that's a very idiosyncratic bet, right, I need you know this part of the curve to react in the way that I've laid the bet.
- 25:33Bill Housey: When I think about fixed income, for most people, right over the last couple of years, the easy trade has just been to hunker down ultra short, right, you know, I think back to.
- 25:45Bill Housey: You know, go back to before the Fed started hiking, right, A lot of bond fund managers were out saying, oh, it's okay, the Fed's not going to raise very much, it's okay to buy duration, but at that time duration was very expensive, right, there was very little yield in the market at that time.
- 26:02Bill Housey: It was all duration with no protection, no income protection.
- 26:05Bill Housey: That was a pretty bold bet in my mind, right, Betting that you know, hey, this is safe, even though you're really not paid to take that risk.
- 26:14Bill Housey: Well, when I look at the bond market today and I think about duration.
- 26:18Bill Housey: I think about where most bond fund managers benchmark off of the ag roughly.
- 26:23Bill Housey: So think about, you know, core fixed income as being kind of a roughly six year duration for, you know, easy discussion.
- 26:30Bill Housey: So it's not saying go buy this specific point on the treasury curve and hope you get it right Now.
- 26:36Bill Housey: It's fine if you want to make that bet for a specific reason, but that's like buying a stock in many respects.
- 26:42Bill Housey: Right, You're picking a specific point on the curve.
- 26:43Bill Housey: When I look at the ag, you know you've got bonds from the front end to the back end.
- 26:47Bill Housey: You own the curve.
- 26:48Bill Housey: It blends out to about a six year duration.
- 26:50Bill Housey: It's widespread, it's diversified diversified across sectors, diversified across maturities, diversified across durations, right.
- 26:58Bill Housey: So I think for most investors you know that have hunkered out ultra short for a long period of time here today, after 21 hikes and where we sit in the cycle, I think it's just as bold to be that short than as it was to be, you know, really long going into this cycle.
- 27:15Bill Housey: So after 21 hikes, it yields, and real yields that are, I think, pretty compelling with a trend probably in inflation that is disinflationary.
- 27:24Bill Housey: Right, there's, you know, you have to kind of think back to what was the cause of inflation the massive spike in M2, trillions of dollars of stimulus, the trillions dollars of stimulus that came into the market.
- 27:37Bill Housey: Right, those things are not likely to repeat themselves, right?
- 27:40Bill Housey: So disinflation is underway, and so I think that, as I look at the bond market today, there's no reason to be bold, right, there's no reason, and I think you can own something in that.
- 27:50Bill Housey: Call it six year duration, or we would think of that as intermediate, right?
- 27:54Bill Housey: Maybe you want to use opportunities where yields move higher.
- 27:57Bill Housey: My personal belief is that, you know, the 10-year Treasury probably tops out around four and a half to four, 55 in this move.
- 28:04Bill Housey: I think there's a lot of FOMO in the market, right?
- 28:07Bill Housey: A lot of investors feel like, boy, I wish I bought in October.
- 28:09Bill Housey: So they're going to be coming out of the woodwork as rates, you know, do make that move.
- 28:13Bill Housey: You're going to have some, you know, bedtime stories about how the four and a half percent that means they're going to five and a half or six.
- 28:20Bill Housey: But I do think the bond market is a lot more durable today, after 21 hikes, and that kind of proved itself, through October even, and so I think that intermediate is a very comfortable place for most investors today, based on risk tolerance, because I do think the risks are more balanced today.
- 28:35Ryan Issakainen: So Bill, a couple times you have mentioned the term asymmetry, asymmetric returns.
- 28:42Ryan Issakainen: Can you talk a little bit more about what you mean by asymmetric returns in the bond market?
- 28:47Bill Housey: Yeah, I mean, there's this.
- 28:49Bill Housey: You know there's this fancy word in the bond market.
- 28:52Bill Housey: We call it convexity, and you know it's the nonlinear relationship between interest rates and bond prices and it's you know.
- 29:00Bill Housey: A lot of people hear this word and they say, boy, I don't ever want to learn that again.
- 29:04Bill Housey: If they've ever had to learn it for a licensing exam or something like that.
- 29:07Bill Housey: I just call it bond market magic, right, let's just call it what it is.
- 29:11Bill Housey: When I look at bond prices, remember, a bond is a mathematical equation right, it's got a maturity, it's got a coupon, maybe call provision, perhaps some credit risk these are things we can calculate, we can account for.
- 29:23Bill Housey: When we look at a bond, we can shock a bond's value.
- 29:26Bill Housey: What happens to the price of that bond if interest rates go up?
- 29:31Bill Housey: What happens if rates go down?
- 29:32Bill Housey: Well, when we were shocking bonds back in December 2021, before the Fed embarked on this, you know 21 hike expedition right, there was no protection in the bond market.
- 29:44Bill Housey: It was a completely linear relationship between bond price and interest rates for the most part.
- 29:50Bill Housey: Right, you had very little protection because you had very little coupon.
- 29:52Bill Housey: Well, after 21 hikes, the bond market has insulation again, some shock absorption.
- 30:00Bill Housey: Again, it has some income and, very simply put, if I buy a bond that has a 5% coupon or, in the case of high yield, and 7% or 8% coupon, right, I have to lose 5% or 7% or 8% before I lose a dime because over the course of 12 months I'm going to carry that coupon.
- 30:19Bill Housey: That carry is going to offer some insulation.
- 30:21Bill Housey: So, as rates have reset higher and yields have reset higher, what we're seeing now is, when we shock our bond prices, the drawdown on, say, the next 100 basis point move let's just say, for example, treasuries went up another 100 from here right, the drawdown is a lot more durable because of the carry that you're getting.
- 30:40Bill Housey: However, if rates go down, it's an asymmetrical turn up in the potential return of these bonds in the market today, based on that convexity that exists in large swaths in the market.
- 30:55Bill Housey: So it's the math driving that decision right.
- 30:59Bill Housey: There's this extraordinary asymmetry that's building into the market at these higher rates that didn't exist before COVID.
- 31:05Bill Housey: The math has changed after COVID into those lower yields, right.
- 31:10Bill Housey: So the math is much better today than it was then from an asymmetrical return perspective.
- 31:15Bill Housey: Bill.
- 31:16Ryan Issakainen: I'm also wondering, given that it's an election year and the Fed is supposed to be completely separate from any politics, but I sometimes wonder if that in reality is the case and I'm curious what you think with respect to I don't know the influence that being an election year will have on Fed policy.
- 31:38Ryan Issakainen: Do you think that that will be at least in the back of the mind of Jerome Powell later this year?
- 31:44Bill Housey: Well, I'm not a mind reader, and there's an old saying and it probably stems from law enforcement at some point, but it's made its way into my lexicon with respect to what I do every day, and it's follow the money to find the motive, right.
- 32:01Bill Housey: And so when I think about if I were chairman of the Federal Reserve, right, would I be thinking about boy, I like this job, boy, I'd like to keep this job right.
- 32:09Bill Housey: And you have the potential for two candidates and one who has openly said hey, I know, this isn't my guy, right?
- 32:16Bill Housey: And so you'd like to think that it's not at play, but, at the same time, it's hard to imagine it isn't on the minds of some of these officials, right?
- 32:26Bill Housey: It would be sort of unnatural if it weren't, right?
- 32:29Bill Housey: So I think, at the end of the day, though, you really have to believe that the people that are making these decisions are making them based on the data.
- 32:39Bill Housey: They're making them based on the belief that they're making the best decisions they can to address the inflation problem, to avoid a recession, right?
- 32:49Bill Housey: So I certainly will give the people the benefit of the doubt that are in these seats, but of course, you always wonder, right?
- 32:54Bill Housey: So I wish I had a perfect answer for that one, but I don't, my friend.
- 32:59Ryan Issakainen: Conscious or unconscious.
- 33:00Ryan Issakainen: It seems like that has to play into at least in the back of their mind somewhere.
- 33:04Ryan Issakainen: We'll give them the benefit of the doubt.
- 33:06Ryan Issakainen: Okay, my last question for you, bill, is what are you reading these days?
- 33:12Ryan Issakainen: Is there anything you know?
- 33:13Ryan Issakainen: I'm trying to it's been great, because every every guess that I have on the podcast, I tend to ask what they're reading, and I've got this great book list that I'll probably never get through.
- 33:21Ryan Issakainen: But is there anything that either you've read recently or is on the horizon that you're considering reading, that you would recommend?
- 33:28Bill Housey: The one I just finished.
- 33:29Bill Housey: Last time I was on with you we talked about Ernest Shackleton, right?
- 33:33Bill Housey: We talked about that in our conversation, and I just finished by the recommendation of a friend, river of Doubt, and it's about Teddy Roosevelt and his expedition to go, after losing re-election to you know, basically explore the Amazon, and it's an unbelievable story and you know, if you're into these sort of real stories about expeditions that have taken place, I mean I read this story and I think about Teddy Roosevelt as kind of being like a, you know, back in his day, the David Goggins, I mean this guy would have something hard that happened to him and he's like I'm, I'm going like let's go down to the Amazon, and which is by the at that time was just a blob on a map.
- 34:17Bill Housey: You know, the blue, the Amazon River was just a blob on a map, hadn't really been explored.
- 34:21Bill Housey: You know really dangerous conditions and and so I won't spoil the story, but it's it's a pretty cool story.
- 34:27Ryan Issakainen: That's great.
- 34:28Ryan Issakainen: I bet you he had a big, a big gun where he killed some pretty interesting animals in that expedition.
- 34:33Ryan Issakainen: I'll let you read the story.
- 34:35Ryan Issakainen: Read the story and find out what.
- 34:36Ryan Issakainen: Bill, it's always a pleasure having you on the on the podcast.
- 34:39Ryan Issakainen: We'll have to do this again soon.
- 34:41Ryan Issakainen: Thanks again for joining us and thanks to all of you for joining us on the First Trust ROI podcast.