Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Last Trade E061: The Great Deleveraging with Sam Callahan
Transcript
- 0:00What you're telling me is that music is about to stop and we're
- 0:04going to be left holding the biggest bag of odorous excrement
- 0:08ever assembled in the history of gutless 1974198792972000 and
- 0:18whatever we want to call this, it's all just the same thing
- 0:20over and over. We can't help ourselves.
- 0:23I say when we sell. Hey, OK.
- 0:27I say when we sell. All right, welcome back to the
- 0:34Last Trade. This week we have Sam Callahan
- 0:37and Mark Connors joining us. Sam, maybe we can start with
- 0:41you. If you just want to give a
- 0:44overview of your background, I know you've accomplished a lot
- 0:47in the Bitcoin split in the Bitcoin space.
- 0:49So really, if you want to just highlight your journey
- 0:52personally and professionally, maybe any of the notable work
- 0:55achievements you had in the space, we could kick it off
- 0:57there before we get into the meat of the conversation.
- 1:01Yeah, thanks. And hey, Mark.
- 1:03Hey, Michael. It's great to be here.
- 1:07Yeah. So I mean, my background is, I
- 1:11mean, I studied business in Indiana and then I switched
- 1:14majors to physics and biology after.
- 1:16I wasn't really excited about what I was learning there in
- 1:20terms of the Keynesianism. So I switched majors to physics
- 1:24and biology to better understand another complex system, which is
- 1:29the human body. And you know, I went down that
- 1:32route of, of healthcare, worked as a sports physical therapist
- 1:35for a number of years with professional athletes developing
- 1:38algorithms to help prevent injuries from happening in the
- 1:411st place. And so we had a lot of success
- 1:44incorporating that into organizations because if you
- 1:47think about the athletes, they're, they're prized assets,
- 1:50right? The organizations, if they go
- 1:52down, not only does it hurt their performance on the field,
- 1:55it also doesn't fill seats, doesn't sell tickets.
- 1:57So got to prevent those injuries from happening.
- 2:00And so that's what I was doing for a number of years.
- 2:01But I, I was such a geek when it comes to financial history
- 2:05investing. I, I, I just read a lot, I read
- 2:09a lot of books. And so I'd studied financial
- 2:12history, central banking, and kind of understood the problem,
- 2:18I guess, of, of money printing. And so I was kind of primed to
- 2:22understand Bitcoin when I randomly came about some article
- 2:26describing it. And what really grabbed my
- 2:28attention was Satoshi Nakamoto. I just thought it was a movie.
- 2:31It just didn't sound real that nobody knew who this guy was at
- 2:36the time. This was like early 2017.
- 2:39Then I started reading a lot of books on Bitcoin.
- 2:41Then like everybody else, fell down the rabbit hole and just
- 2:44became absolutely obsessed. Read every single thing I could
- 2:47get my hands on, every podcast, you know, just constantly
- 2:51thinking about Bitcoin. Then I just knew I had to do
- 2:55something about it. I had to change careers, had to
- 2:57work in it somehow. It wasn't enough for me to just
- 2:59hold it and benefit from the price appreciation.
- 3:01I wanted to teach people about it.
- 3:03I wanted to kind of drive its adoption because I just thought
- 3:07it was extremely important. It could solve the problem of
- 3:10central banking and the ability and finally have an ability to
- 3:13save. And so, yeah, I, I guess it was
- 3:16like the fix the money, fix the world.
- 3:17I wanted to be a part of that. So I started like posting
- 3:19content on Twitter. I was on Bitcoin Twitter back
- 3:23then under like a pseudonym. Ended up doxing myself on
- 3:28purpose just because back then it was kind of harder to get a
- 3:30job in Bitcoin if you weren't doxed.
- 3:33Honestly it's kind of changed now, but then ended up at Swan
- 3:38as one of the early employees doing a lot of different things
- 3:41but then carved out a niche as the senior analysts.
- 3:45I was doing a lot of in depth research reports, ended up
- 3:48publishing like over 100 publications over a couple years
- 3:52I was there. Market updates in more industry
- 3:55specific research, diving into pretty much every aspect of the
- 3:59ecosystem, Mining, lightning, different like innovations,
- 4:04custody, like no matter it was like a regulatory updates really
- 4:08anything that I was interested in that was one of the good
- 4:10things about Swan. I had a lot of freedom with
- 4:12where I would research. And so, yeah, in terms of
- 4:16achievements, I mean, I guess I feel like my greatest
- 4:19achievement is just the relationships I was able to
- 4:22cultivate over the years with so many remarkable individuals.
- 4:26I mean, it's just so inspiring to be surrounded by these
- 4:28people. So it's really the relationships
- 4:32that I've cultivated is my #1 achievement by far.
- 4:35So that's, that's the best part about being a Bitcoin is you're
- 4:39surrounded by really inspiring, intelligent, driven people to
- 4:43make the world a better place. Yeah, that that makes a lot of
- 4:47sense. There's two things that stood
- 4:48out to me that I remember when you kind of came on the scene.
- 4:52I mean, I guess it was 21 when the CBDC conversations were
- 4:55coming up, but it makes a lot of sense that you were primed
- 4:57because you had studied a lot of the intricacies and I think you
- 5:00were kind of one of the first that were really well spoken and
- 5:04understanding the gravity that. And so that kind of anchoring
- 5:08back to it feels like, you know, decades ago at this point, three
- 5:10years and Bitcoin feels like a decade.
- 5:14But then the other thing that's really transformative.
- 5:16I know, you know, Mark jumped into the space with three IQ
- 5:21from trad Fine. He's been, he's spoken about the
- 5:24notion of getting in and the number of connections you make
- 5:26in Jackson coming over from the private equity space.
- 5:29And myself, I remember back in 2020 when I joined Unchained,
- 5:32one of the things that I've always anchored to when I, when
- 5:35I told individuals is I don't even remember looking at the
- 5:38offer. Like I remember there was a
- 5:39number and there was equity or whatever, but it was more about
- 5:41if you jump into the space, it pays for itself 100X over in the
- 5:45connections and network that you make.
- 5:47And I think you're probably, you know, a testament to that the
- 5:49past few years, the number of doors that are open independent
- 5:52of any monetary value that was gleaned from working there.
- 5:56It's just that the channels you can't, you can't put a price on.
- 5:59And so I'd always encourage anybody that's thinking about
- 6:01jumping into space is just like, do it because if you're really
- 6:03passionate about, it's going to work itself out 100%.
- 6:07At On Ramp, we believe that Bitcoin is the most important
- 6:10asset of the 21st century. The hard part is securing it
- 6:14right. There are shortcomings with
- 6:16keeping your coins on an exchange, but also with setting
- 6:19up your own self custody arrangement.
- 6:22On Ramp solves for these concerns.
- 6:24Our multi institution custody solution maximizes security and
- 6:28minimizes counterparty risk, ensuring that your Bitcoin
- 6:31remains securely in your possession and provides built in
- 6:34inheritance planning to ensure your family is protected as
- 6:37well. On Ramp provides Peace of Mind
- 6:40for your Bitcoin journey, whether for your whole stack or
- 6:43for part of it as a compliment to your existing self custody
- 6:45setup. For more information, check us
- 6:48out at on rampbitcoin.com. Yeah.
- 6:51Another cool thing, Sam, that I didn't realize about your
- 6:54background is really how you started in the science space and
- 6:57nutrition and helping athletes. Kind of goes to show like
- 7:00Bitcoin really allows anyone who is driven, hardworking, curious
- 7:05to get into the space. You don't need to follow like a
- 7:08cookie cutter kind of career path that typically, I mean, I'm
- 7:12coming from the traditional finance world and it's very
- 7:13regimented in terms of like the steps that you take in your
- 7:16career. So it's cool to see that.
- 7:17And then, you know, a lot of similarities just in terms of
- 7:21low time preference, athletes having to care for their bodies
- 7:24and kind of the scarcity of the human body, scarcity of Bitcoin,
- 7:27like interesting parallels there.
- 7:29Definitely. You know, throughout the past
- 7:31couple of years, I've followed a lot of your research.
- 7:35I know you've continued to put out research.
- 7:36And one of the ones that caught my eye recently was your piece
- 7:40about the yen carry trade and the Bank of Japan.
- 7:43So maybe that was only 10 days ago or so.
- 7:47It feels like it's been a lot longer just given the volatility
- 7:50that we saw in markets and a lot of a lot of uncertainty at the
- 7:55time in in terms of how other central banks would react,
- 7:58implications for financial markets.
- 8:00So maybe you could just give a high level overview kind of
- 8:03breaking down the research you put out recently explaining what
- 8:06happened there and that we can dig a little bit deeper into the
- 8:09global macro. Yeah, I mean, he just what you
- 8:16know, I said I studied, you know, a lot of research in
- 8:19financial history. Well, one of those persons is
- 8:21Hyman Minsky. And So what I, what I thought it
- 8:24was kind of a classic Minsky moment, which is what he always
- 8:27said that, you know, periods of low volatility can lead to
- 8:30periods of high volatility. And why that is, is investors
- 8:33get really complacent. And when they get complacent,
- 8:36they start to feel safe. They start to, you know, take on
- 8:38riskier bats, take on leverage, and then eventually that leads
- 8:42to asset bubbles. And at least eventually that
- 8:44leads to a popping of those asset bubbles and a huge spike
- 8:47in volatility and a deleveraging event occurs.
- 8:50And that's what like a Minsky moment is.
- 8:52And I think that's what happens with the yen carry trade.
- 8:55I mean, it's basically a short Vol position.
- 8:58You're basically you're borrowing yen at a super low
- 9:02interest rate, then converting that yen into dollars and then
- 9:05buying other high yield assets. It doesn't have to be dollars,
- 9:08but let's just say it is dollars for this example.
- 9:11Then you're buying other high yielding assets, say U.S. stocks
- 9:14or US bonds, and you make a, the profit is the difference between
- 9:18the cost to borrow the yen and whatever your return is for
- 9:22that, the stocks or bonds. And so it's basically a short
- 9:26vowel trade because though if, if, if the exchange rate between
- 9:29the yen and dollar remain stable, you're fine.
- 9:31But if there's a lot of volatility there and say the yen
- 9:34spikes against you, you're going to get in trouble pretty fast.
- 9:37And especially if you take on leverage, it's going to really
- 9:40blow up in your face. And leading up to the summer,
- 9:44we've been in this period of extremely low volatility.
- 9:47And when you look at the equity markets and then in Bitcoin
- 9:49actually too, we were hitting the kind of historic low
- 9:51volatility, you know, And so it was kind of like this period
- 9:56where people, I think, were taking on more risk than maybe
- 9:58they were expected. And then what happened was, you
- 10:02know, this yen carry trade became extremely popular because
- 10:05the Bank of Japan interest rates were so low compared to other
- 10:08central banks who had risen so fast to try to defeat inflation.
- 10:12Now, Japan hadn't risen rates in a very, very long time because
- 10:16obviously they have this huge debt burden that they had to
- 10:19deal with and they basically pinned it at 0.
- 10:21And even you use things like yield curve control since 2016.
- 10:25But lately, inflation has started to creep back up in
- 10:28inflation, which is a problem. And also the yen has been
- 10:31depreciation depreciating pretty rapidly.
- 10:34And so they're getting pressure from obviously the citizenry who
- 10:38don't like inflation, like every other citizenry around the
- 10:40world. And they're getting pressure to
- 10:43raise interest rates to try to, you know, improve their
- 10:46currency's position. And so I don't know where kind
- 10:51of last week or was this last week yet last week the, the Bank
- 10:55of Japan decided that they're going to raise interest rates to
- 10:570.25%, which doesn't sound like a lot, but it's a lot for the
- 11:02Bank of Japan. And that really scared people.
- 11:06You know, there's a, a, a trend shift that occurred there.
- 11:10And and so. Damn, wasn't that like an eighth
- 11:13of a point? Like didn't they only raise it
- 11:15like that's bananas? So 'cause you're right, the
- 11:18headline was a quarter point. And.
- 11:21But they raised it from an eighth, they decided another 8th
- 11:25and yeah. Like another eighth.
- 11:26Yeah, it's, it's like it's a lot in percentage terms, you know,
- 11:30But I think it's more about like, you know, the trend that
- 11:33they would even raise it at all after not doing it for so long.
- 11:36And that little change led to a lot of this volatility.
- 11:41At the same time, he had the Fed kind of talking about cuts.
- 11:44At the same time, you had like poor economic data coming in
- 11:46with the PMI manufacturing hitting like an 8 month low.
- 11:50And then the jobs report was just garbage on Friday.
- 11:53So you had this like kind of culmination that led to this
- 11:56like volatility blow up, which really like caused a huge
- 12:00deleveraging event with this yen carry trade as these, you know,
- 12:04traders went to basically close that out.
- 12:07And so the yen spiked to A7 month high against the dollar
- 12:11and that just caused a huge deleveraging event.
- 12:13And to me, it just shows like how fragile the traditional
- 12:17financial system is. I mean, you have to bank Japan
- 12:19trying to raise 8th of a point and it causes a global meltdown
- 12:24across multiple assets. I mean, pretty wild.
- 12:27I'd love to hear your thoughts. I've been, you know, that's how
- 12:30I'd kind of summarize it. It's a I'd love to hear Marker
- 12:34or Michael or anybody else. Yeah, Mark, I'm generally
- 12:37curious like based on what Sam just shared in like the
- 12:40contextualizing that because I would imagine 20-30 years ago,
- 12:43let alone 10 years ago that move happening doesn't make that
- 12:47impact. But the leverage is so great at
- 12:49the system now. Like how do you how do you think
- 12:50about that? Yeah, the the gear is greater
- 12:54because there are there are fewer banks in any given
- 12:57country. So the balance sheets that can
- 13:00engage in this trade are fewer and certainly there are hedge
- 13:03funds, but there are fewer of those and those are
- 13:05concentrated. So the players are more
- 13:08concentrated. The pile of paper they're
- 13:10playing with is larger under any measure for Senate GDP or
- 13:14nominally. So when you have as and Sam
- 13:18pointed out right, we said an eighth, it's doubling.
- 13:22And the reason why that distinction need to be made or
- 13:27was appropriate that you made Sam is because that's the trade
- 13:31they have on. They are borrowing at A at an
- 13:35eighth and they are then investing at say five and a
- 13:39quarter or whatever the forward curve is in U.S. dollars.
- 13:44And that's a tremendous gearing. Think of that gearing and then
- 13:48the leverage they have is based on that ratio.
- 13:52So when they, when, when it, when the cost of their borrow
- 13:57doubled, that caused an unwind because their trade is
- 14:01predicated on an eighth, not 1/4, which is absolutely crazy.
- 14:06That 12 1/2 basis points, you know, that's we, we did that.
- 14:12We're looking at a piece called chaos theory about the
- 14:14butterfly's wings, right? It's the, it's the wings.
- 14:17And you know, that little 12 basis points ripped it through.
- 14:22You also said something else about fragility.
- 14:24And this is what this is a major topic.
- 14:28Why didn't the Fed intervene? Should they have intervened?
- 14:31And what does it mean going forward?
- 14:34And I think what happened here was the shock did not 'cause any
- 14:41player to break, whether it was like a prop desk at a bank or a
- 14:48hedge fund to be bailed out like 98.
- 14:50And and that little Gordian knot of risk is just tightening and
- 14:56someone's going to lay it in half, which is the only way you
- 14:59take care of that knot. And something's going to break,
- 15:01Sam, which is Bitcoin. Bitcoin don't break I guess is
- 15:06the point that you know my thoughts there.
- 15:10Yeah. And like, I, I don't know, I to
- 15:12me like connecting the dots of like, well, how did this cause
- 15:14like a crash in Bitcoin and, and U.S. stocks, U.S.
- 15:19Treasuries? It's because when they put on
- 15:21this year, yen carry trade, they borrow and yen, they turn around
- 15:24and buy other assets, right? That's what I mentioned before.
- 15:27Well, to close out the trade, they got to sell those assets,
- 15:30convert the, you know, get the dollars, then convert the
- 15:32dollars back to yen and then close out the, you know, trade.
- 15:35And so that's why you have selling that occurred.
- 15:37Whatever they were kind of used with the borrowed money to buy.
- 15:40They had to sell that. And then usually when there's
- 15:42margin calls, they also have to sell other things, you know, to
- 15:45meet the margin calls, even things they don't want to sell.
- 15:48And so that's how you had this like, you know, Frost asset
- 15:51class meltdown at the same time, sort of with this leveraging
- 15:55event. And Bitcoin obviously is the
- 15:56only thing that trades over the weekend 24/7.
- 15:59So it's the first thing. If somebody found out they were
- 16:02in trouble like Friday, which there was already kind of
- 16:04shakiness going into the weekend, then they're going to
- 16:06be selling Bitcoin. And that just shows like, you
- 16:08know, the liquidity profile of Bitcoin is so, you know,
- 16:12superior to other asset classes because it trades 24/7.
- 16:15It's always available. And then, you know, why did the
- 16:18Fed didn't come in and cut? I think it's because partly
- 16:22because it would have just worsened the situation.
- 16:24I mean, just remember the yen carry trade is more profitable
- 16:28the more that the interest rates between, say, the Federal
- 16:30Reserve and Bank of Japan diverge from one another.
- 16:33And so if the Bank of Japan was raising interest rates and then
- 16:37at the same time the Fed cut interest rates, you actually
- 16:40making that smaller. And so you're actually making it
- 16:42even more unprofitable. So you could have even led to
- 16:45more, you know, blow UPS happening and more deleveraging
- 16:48if you went in and tried to cut rates.
- 16:50I mean, I don't know if they're that smart or something, but,
- 16:54you know, I just think I'm kind of glad they didn't do that
- 16:56because I think it would actually cause things to
- 16:58actually get worse, which would have been, you know, even more
- 17:03panic. And that's what these things
- 17:05are. And honestly, it seems like,
- 17:07like Mark said, there hasn't been any major bodies that float
- 17:10to the surface. So potentially this was just
- 17:12like a necessary, you know, deleveraging event.
- 17:17But you did see the Bank of Japan capitulate a little bit.
- 17:20So that's what like that's actually what I expected to see
- 17:23was the Bank of Japan saying, yeah, yeah, we're we're not
- 17:26going to do it as long as things get volatile, you know, And so
- 17:29perhaps like we'll keep a steady eye on them and what the yen
- 17:33does, because if the yen continues to fall now and they
- 17:37had to go in and start intervening again in their
- 17:39currency, they they dropped like 10s of billions of dollars
- 17:42trying to intervene in their currency this year alone.
- 17:44If they had to start doing that again, you can just see there in
- 17:47a in there in a catch 22, like they're they're in a rock and a
- 17:51between a rock and a hard place, like raise interest rates.
- 17:55You know, you, you blow things up.
- 17:57If you don't raise your currency is going to keep plummeting and
- 18:00you got to keep putting band aids over it.
- 18:02The 10s of billions of dollars in currency intervention.
- 18:05So, yeah, it's this is the end game, I think when it comes to
- 18:10these super accommodative central bank policies.
- 18:14And it's why I think we're all into Bitcoin and into some money
- 18:18because we kind of see the path that all central banks are on
- 18:21and and Japan's just a little bit further down the road.
- 18:23Yeah. Yeah.
- 18:26And, and, and look, just following that one point up,
- 18:29Jackson, Yeah, what Sam was saying in Japan, it wasn't a
- 18:33direct impact or reason, but you had the resignation of Kishida
- 18:38and you know, it was because of scandals and, you know, we're
- 18:41not the only folks, so it's good to know.
- 18:43And, and it's also because of the economic situation.
- 18:47I mean, like they are learning to live on like 8 breaths a
- 18:50minute there, you know, back to what you did for a living and
- 18:53keeping that organic body moving, very low growth.
- 18:57And it's hard and it's having impacts on, you know, birth
- 19:01rates and everything else. So the fact that they 'cause it
- 19:04is perfect, like you said, they are the cautionary tale.
- 19:08They're decades ahead of us on how to live in low growth.
- 19:11And it isn't pretty. And now there's metal on metal
- 19:15as far as accommodation. But yet, Jackson, I interrupted
- 19:18you. Not at all, Mark, appreciate
- 19:20that. I was just going to say that,
- 19:22you know, now this kind of ties into US fiscal policy, right?
- 19:26Because Sam, you mentioned that the Fed cutting rates could have
- 19:31exacerbated the problem that we saw last week, because it
- 19:36decreases the margin that is the yen carry trade has, right?
- 19:40So now we have a slowing economy in the US.
- 19:43We just passed $35 trillion of federal debt.
- 19:48I think it's like up 50% or so since 2020.
- 19:52The the federal debt, right? So it's growing very rapidly.
- 19:55And now policy makers in the US have to think about not only
- 19:59their over indebted economy and how these higher rates will
- 20:03impact their fiscal position, but now they also have to think
- 20:06about well, how will lowering rates impact global financial
- 20:09markets if there's trillions or 10s of trillions of dollars tied
- 20:12into the yen carry trade, right. So any thoughts you know to any
- 20:17of you in terms of tying this now into US fiscal policy where
- 20:21we're at today with debt and also.
- 20:24Looking ahead the next couple of months or quarters with monetary
- 20:27policy and how the Fed will have to react to that, why?
- 20:33Don't you take that spam? Yeah.
- 20:37You know, I guess, you know, when I look at the fiscal
- 20:41situation, I just think about, I, I always, I'm not the first
- 20:46person to say this. I just think, you know, the
- 20:48Fed's lever for interest rate policy is like broken, right?
- 20:52This is the fiscal dominance thing where it's actually, you
- 20:55know, becoming ineffective at bringing down inflation or price
- 20:59stability because it increases the fiscal deficit because of
- 21:02the amount of debt in the system.
- 21:04And and so I've always thought that they're actually going to
- 21:07probably not focus on interest rate policy and actually use
- 21:12other tools in their toolbox to become more accommodative if
- 21:17they need to. So for instance, like the
- 21:19balance sheet, like using QT and QE, they've already like kind of
- 21:22reduced their QT. They didn't eliminate it, but
- 21:26they reduced it. And they're gonna come up with
- 21:28other acronyms and other creative ways, whether that's
- 21:32changing requirements for commercial banks to buy
- 21:36treasuries or something like this, like somehow changing the
- 21:38regulations. There's different tools that can
- 21:40use outside of just interest rates, but the entire market is
- 21:43focused on interest rates. And so they can't like just cut
- 21:46it and cut, cut. And I don't even think it would
- 21:48even do anything. And it would actually probably,
- 21:50you know, when all that brings this up as well, like if
- 21:53interest rate hikes at the fastest pace in history didn't
- 21:57really do what we thought it was going to do, which was blow up,
- 22:00you know, cause a recession, do all these things.
- 22:02Well, maybe interest rate cuts actually won't have as much of
- 22:05an impact either because everyone has locked in all like
- 22:11debt at ultra low interest rates for the last like 10 years.
- 22:14So whether that's like fixed mortgages or corporations that
- 22:17have turned out their debt, you know, perhaps cuts and hikes
- 22:21just aren't gonna be as effective and have this huge
- 22:23impact that people believe. And, and I kind of, I, that,
- 22:28that speaks to me like I, I think that makes a lot of sense.
- 22:31And so if I'm thinking about monetary policy and fiscal
- 22:35policy, I'm actually looking at what the feds gonna do with
- 22:39other tools. So like their balance sheet,
- 22:41like I mentioned, or like if, if, if the Bank of Japan got a
- 22:45lot worse, I think they would have done some other thing like,
- 22:49you know, some kind of acronym, some kind of new acronym and
- 22:52liquidity targeted liquidity program or something like that,
- 22:56similar to the bank term funding program with the banking crisis.
- 22:59So they can get creative and they can like kind of kick the
- 23:03can down the road in a lot of different ways.
- 23:06As we've seen, the Fed, it seems to work outside of its mandate
- 23:10whenever it wants to. That's what I'll say, as we saw
- 23:14during COVID and, and other financial crises that they
- 23:18obviously had a hand in creating in the 1st place.
- 23:21But I think they'll work outside their mandate if they have to
- 23:24and do other unique ways to, to bring liquidity to the market.
- 23:28And that's again, that's why Bitcoin ultimately benefits
- 23:31because it benefits from liquidity conditions.
- 23:34But love to hear Mark's thoughts.
- 23:37Totally that's I was like nodding when you said fiscal
- 23:40dominance. I remember back in O 8 this at
- 23:45that time I think he was with Bank of America.
- 23:49Now he's with Black Rock, Jeff Rosenberg, I think he's and he
- 23:55was involved in credit and he said America runs on credit.
- 23:58This is I think he got really picked up in July of.
- 24:01O. 8. When Fannie and Freddie were
- 24:04just flaming out right before Lehman in September and he said
- 24:09America runs on credit, you know, aping off of Dunkin'
- 24:13Donuts. And he said when the world knows
- 24:16who Sheila Bair is, that's when we'll know where near the
- 24:20bottom. And I think when people know
- 24:24what fiscal dominance is, it's not as good.
- 24:26We'll have to pick up later on other podcasts to get what that
- 24:29moment is, but that's it. It is no longer about the price
- 24:33of money. They have so much debt.
- 24:35They have to figure out where to put it because they have 8000
- 24:39institutions that don't know how to manage risk.
- 24:42And we saw that. And there are not people who are
- 24:45incentivized to go to these SNLS or these banks and manage the
- 24:51risk. They aren't able to pay them.
- 24:53There aren't. There isn't profitability.
- 24:56Citibank, Citibank stock today, all cuts adjusted.
- 25:02It's if you bought it in 1993, you lost money, not including
- 25:07dividends. It was not a good store of
- 25:09value. The banking system is broken and
- 25:13the Fed, as you said, is now the reason I mentioned and belabor
- 25:18that point that, you know, many have, including Larry Leopard
- 25:21and and and others and, and yourself, is that the central
- 25:25bank say, I'm not going to rely on those banks or whoever works
- 25:28there. They now account for 40% of the
- 25:31money supply and they only accounted for 12:00 So I think
- 25:35you're right. The price of money is going to
- 25:37come and go. It's it almost can cause a
- 25:40problem, but the supply of it, it's being centralized.
- 25:43No doubt. They have to control it and
- 25:45they're going to jam it. Like you said, cost free,
- 25:48collateral free at the banks when they change that SLR,
- 25:53probably, you know, who knows, but that's the next one.
- 25:56So I, I agree with you BTF. PS and.
- 25:59I do think the one caveat with what Sam said is like, I think
- 26:03it's been muted or tempered some of the volatility, but things
- 26:06have blown up with the rising of interest rates, like the BTFP
- 26:09program and the banks kind of, yeah, blow it up.
- 26:12And then the the Fed speak, something we talked about on the
- 26:14show a lot is like this notion that recession is finally coming
- 26:17into the conversation. It's like anybody that's been
- 26:19around living in the real world has seen a recession in the
- 26:22sense of looking at people losing their jobs, the housing
- 26:26situation that's happening, whether it's the amount you go
- 26:28to Airbnb, like all these different tailwinds are
- 26:31happening. It's just catching up from the
- 26:33like now standard conversation, you know, layoffs, the amount of
- 26:38tax receipts. And so that cost of capital is a
- 26:42big component of it. And I think we all probably
- 26:45agree there are going to be cuts because that also is a
- 26:47secondary. But that's a factor of once you
- 26:49start cutting, you can start to increase risk across the board.
- 26:52You can start to, you know, start to buy, you start to take
- 26:54out debt. So I think that there are a lot
- 26:58of tools coming in place, but there one that we all know is
- 27:00the cost of capital has to be reduced or it's just going to be
- 27:03mad. It's going to be increasing
- 27:04pain, which we've seen in the past couple of years.
- 27:07The the last part in that, that I think helped muted as well as
- 27:11all the savings that happened during COVID.
- 27:13So there was excess capital built up that, you know, we're
- 27:15obviously on the other side of it now.
- 27:17We went from like increased savings all the way down to like
- 27:19we're at like all time highs in debt across the board, missing
- 27:23payments, you know, whether it's mortgages, cars, credit cards.
- 27:27So we're at this like level of where this, you know, Japanese
- 27:32yen situation like we're almost at a tipping point and it feels
- 27:36anti climatic what happened with the yen that maybe it's still
- 27:40not, we're not out of the woods yet.
- 27:41And I know we're kind of in this retrace with BTC and BTC is
- 27:45usually the Canary in the coal mine that maybe there's still
- 27:48something else like out there before this is settled and and
- 27:51maybe we still do see some kind of accommodation or something
- 27:54else that takes place. I think that's completely fair.
- 27:59Like I, I think the longer rates stay, the more things are going
- 28:03to feel pain. And then I, I, I, I'm definitely
- 28:09not claiming victory like over this yen carry trade.
- 28:12Like you don't see vowels spike like that without at least some
- 28:17kind of bias coming up. And so I, I do think like we
- 28:21potentially haven't seen the end of it.
- 28:23And it reminds me of like 2008 and 2007, 2008, like there was
- 28:28moments where the market rallied for months on end, right?
- 28:31And everything. It's like, you know, there's a
- 28:33couple scares. I mean, Mark, you probably
- 28:35remember you were probably there, right?
- 28:37So, but like, I just, I'm very cautious right now for sure.
- 28:44Very cautious. It was really, it was really
- 28:46similar to the SPB situation. I, it feels like, I don't know,
- 28:50was that 22? I think it was 2223, maybe 20.
- 28:55It was 23. 23 You remember going in, it was like Friday morning
- 29:02when stuff started to break and then he went into the weekend
- 29:05and everything was just haywire. It was very similar to this like
- 29:07yen situation. And he came out on like that
- 29:10Sunday night, you know, fed intervention.
- 29:14But that's where we're like felt very strange with how this kind
- 29:17of transpired last week, but it feels like there's still
- 29:20something else left to drop. So interesting.
- 29:23So it plays out. I always.
- 29:25I always people forget about Credit Suisse with that whole
- 29:30thing, you know, I. Don't bro, I don't.
- 29:32Yeah. That was like, that was the
- 29:34real, that would have been catastrophic.
- 29:37That's a globally systemically important bank.
- 29:40That was basically there's a shotgun acquisition on a Sunday
- 29:44night. UBS was basically forced to
- 29:48acquire them more. That would have been some
- 29:51contagion. So like, you're right.
- 29:53I mean, there was, it was close to blowing things up, no doubt
- 29:56about it. But they somehow, you know,
- 29:59papered things over and. It's Mark.
- 30:03What's the sorry Mark? What's the sentiment in the trad
- 30:07fi world with your, I'm sure you have peers and colleagues that
- 30:10are still been on the street for a while and are still at firms.
- 30:13We're all sitting here. We understand this thing is not
- 30:15sustainable, right? Like it's a, it's like a lens.
- 30:17Once you see it, you can't Unsee what, how how do you you
- 30:22reconcile when you're in this system and you believe it's
- 30:24going to last there and your career is tied to it and your
- 30:26whole livelihood and your reputation.
- 30:28Like what it what did help us to understand that because we don't
- 30:30I don't think us on our side. Get a lens into that because we
- 30:33once you get this, you start in you're kind of in an echo
- 30:36chamber, right. We all talk with.
- 30:37Yeah. No, that's a good it.
- 30:39It is good to go to new places, you know, just change the
- 30:43scenery. Michael, you're right.
- 30:45And I've learned a lot coming obviously over to the Bitcoin
- 30:48side from 30 years in Tranfi. I would say that the sentiment
- 30:54in Tranfi has PI3 arcs and a lot of them follow the path of
- 31:03interest rates. I mean, salespeople got paid for
- 31:09claiming to have for the sunrise in the east and setting in the
- 31:13West. I mean money was made just
- 31:16having asset prices rise as we went from 20% down to 0.
- 31:20You just had to show up and press the button.
- 31:23So as far as the current sentiment and and there are, and
- 31:27I loved there were very creative people Wall Street, that's
- 31:30that's overarching. And I loved the integrity, the
- 31:33hustle, the the specificity of, you know, when you got an order
- 31:39saying, yeah, OK, so you want to sell 2.5 million, you know, tail
- 31:43sixes of, you know, 2004, OK, at par of the figure and not held
- 31:48great. And then you would repeat it
- 31:50back like there was, there was great exchange.
- 31:52It was great community. But right now technology has
- 31:55ripped away the role of a lot of those people.
- 31:58And so there's a nutrition going on and there's not the same
- 32:03money, as I said about Citibank. So I think people are
- 32:10incentivized to keep the train going wherever they are.
- 32:15And Wall Street needs leverage. Like look at Craig Swiss.
- 32:18Sam, I don't know if you knew, but I was at Craig Swiss for a
- 32:21couple years up until 2020, one I think.
- 32:28Yeah, till till late 21. I did not.
- 32:31Oh, yeah. No, my friend, I was, I was, I
- 32:34was there and saw. I mean, there's a lot.
- 32:38There's a lot that's already written up in a 200 page report
- 32:40by law firm Paul Weiss. I think that explained what
- 32:44happened in the holes and the and the mismanagement.
- 32:47But when I was actually, I was with Fred Pie, my at 3 IQ.
- 32:52We're in Florida. We're doing a podcast in March
- 32:55and we're about to do it, and I'm in my hotel room and I'm
- 32:59looking at the Saudi Prince. I'm like, wait a minute, that's
- 33:03the guy who buys all the stock and we provide leverage for them
- 33:07to buy it. That was public.
- 33:09And the Qataris, they're not buying the stock, they're buying
- 33:13it. They're borrowing it cash from
- 33:16us to buy our stock. So they basically said, I don't
- 33:20want free money, I don't want free equity.
- 33:22That's how bad the trade got for them.
- 33:25So when we saw that happen, you knew that it was, you know, as
- 33:28you said, it had to be a forced marriage.
- 33:29It would have been a lot worse. So back to the sentiment on the
- 33:34street. And this is what people say to
- 33:37Bitcoiners. It's true.
- 33:38You can't have Bitcoin take over the world right now.
- 33:41It would it would go in flames. Hyper bitcoinization is a
- 33:45process and it needs to be slowly walked in to serve the
- 33:53financial system over time. And the Fed is, as my friend
- 33:58Zoltan poster says, has foamed the runway to let the banks
- 34:02fail, but not burn the whole place down.
- 34:06And that's so people on Wall Street, Michael, answer your
- 34:10question, know that it's not a happy place to be.
- 34:13This is the unwind of a 40 year rally.
- 34:16And that's what it and that's what it is like on Wall Street.
- 34:19I know at a lot of firms. Maybe it's worth talking about,
- 34:25Mark, to piggyback on that, maybe it's worth talking about
- 34:27how did we even get into this mess, right?
- 34:29Because today we're recording on August 15th, it's historic day
- 34:36for us in the Bitcoin community. And Mark, you broke out your
- 34:40jacket specifically for the occasion.
- 34:42So maybe you could tell us what happened 53 years ago that has
- 34:47pretty much gotten us into the situation of over leveraged
- 34:51sovereign nations, over leveraged financial markets,
- 34:55rampant currency to basement and maybe you can talk through what
- 34:59happened back in the 70s for a bit.
- 35:03All right, I'll be quick. Thanks.
- 35:04Yes, I did. So as Jackson, you just noted,
- 35:08and obviously there's a little prep there, but you know, if you
- 35:10couldn't tell, I gave you a little heads up about why I'm
- 35:13wearing a jacket when it's 80° here and the AC is not working
- 35:17is because Nixon basically wore a jacket on August 15th of 71 to
- 35:24the funeral of sound money, like getting off a bandstand a little
- 35:28bit. He broke the record the promise
- 35:31of Bretton Woods on August 15th of 71 by saying I've instructed
- 35:36Senator Connelly to suspend temporarily the convertibility
- 35:40of gold into dollars or something like that.
- 35:44And I mean, there were ships that were that were bringing
- 35:48dollars over to take gold out of the Federal Reserve in New York
- 35:51Harbor. This is something when when I
- 35:54talk to my family, when they allow me to talk about this, I
- 35:56don't talk about Bitcoin, talk about monetary history because I
- 35:59have a window of time to talk about that, but never for
- 36:02Bitcoin. And there and no one knows about
- 36:05that and they're fascinated by the story.
- 36:07So, Sam, when you're reading about financial history, we
- 36:12don't talk about it to say, oh, you know, it's terrible.
- 36:15And you know, Nixon was basically wearing a suit to the
- 36:18funeral to sound money and and I'm wearing it to the birthday
- 36:21of Bitcoin, you know, to kind of round that square and why I'm
- 36:24doing it. It's more that when doors close
- 36:28and the door and the wind, you know, he called the window the
- 36:30door closed on those 43 countries that agreed to bring
- 36:36their gold over during World War Two and take dollars back in
- 36:39order to build the world back up.
- 36:42It was it was really magnificent technology never done before
- 36:46that ended. But the banks that then suffered
- 36:51because of inflation and all the loans they made to third world
- 36:54countries Chase someone's went out of business.
- 36:56They had a new business arise. You know, this is where the
- 36:59window opens, store closes, window opens.
- 37:02It was called the FX. The FX market did not exist in
- 37:06full force until Nixon broke the peg.
- 37:10And then everyone's like, well, what do I do now?
- 37:13And what they did is they had to call Citibank, who was a global
- 37:15leader in FX and that worked for about 3 decades for them.
- 37:21And then that wasn't enough to carry the bolus of expenses on
- 37:26that, you know, supermarket of a business that they became.
- 37:29So I, I didn't think they were going to come here, Sam, but FX
- 37:34was a boon for banks. But now it's turned into this
- 37:36like weaponized crazy trade. Yeah.
- 37:41You know. That's a good point.
- 37:44I mean, yeah, I, I my memory is a little hazy.
- 37:48I'm like, but like, this is when they suspended the gold standard
- 37:54or whatever, Brent Woods in 1971, suddenly it was like these
- 37:58free floating currencies everywhere and everyone was just
- 38:01like, how do we even do this? And this is actually when like
- 38:03the Bank of International Settlements in the IMF started
- 38:05to get really involved with these different emerging market
- 38:09countries because their currencies were just all over
- 38:12the place. And so the Bank of International
- 38:14Settlement was in charge with kind of keeping things in line.
- 38:17They had these like short term loans.
- 38:19And then then in the 1980s, you just saw a ton of blow UPS.
- 38:22The Latin American blow up had the Plaza Accord in 85.
- 38:26You see all these currencies were just going completely
- 38:28haywire. And Wall Street, I mean, was
- 38:31probably cash in it. Yum Yum.
- 38:34It's like a, it's like a new market was created for them to
- 38:37play around with and it was just happened to be that the
- 38:39currencies. Of arsonist and fireman might do
- 38:43what that sounds. It sounds like, Sam, if we took
- 38:45that clip which you just described, a bunch of free
- 38:47floating currencies and things blowing up.
- 38:50This just sounds like what we're doing today as bitcoins
- 38:52monetizing. You have crypto currencies that
- 38:55are being created at thin air. They're trying to find the peg.
- 38:58That's the thing that most people don't get is it all
- 38:59correlates to one. When it comes early, it all
- 39:01competes with one. It's just the most efficient
- 39:03use. So you ended up at a dollar
- 39:04based currency. And that's the thing that most
- 39:06people don't get that have like stepped in on the financials
- 39:09like you have tried five step into this market and they
- 39:11misunderstand. I like to joke and say it's like
- 39:13they read the forward to the Bitcoin standard.
- 39:15They never actually read the book or opened it.
- 39:17So they're playing often like law and when it comes to digital
- 39:20assets and they don't realize like there's only one thing here
- 39:24and everything in in around is just blowing up and getting
- 39:27pegged or traded around it because that's the unit ultimate
- 39:29everybody's competed with. Yeah.
- 39:33Yeah, an interesting point there too is just counterparty risk,
- 39:36right? Like in 1971, there was
- 39:38significant counterparty risk for those sovereign nations.
- 39:41They had their gold deposited at the US and then one day that,
- 39:47you know, one day that obligation or contract that
- 39:49existed no longer existed. And you know, for the four of us
- 39:52here contributing to the Bitcoin space, counterparty risk is like
- 39:56always very top of mind. And I think, you know, we're at
- 39:59a point now with Bitcoin kind of breaking into traditional
- 40:03finance, like market ties into what you're talking about.
- 40:05Like people are looking for new avenues and new products to
- 40:09financialize and make money in. And how do you keep this old
- 40:11system kind of alive, right? And now we're looking at the
- 40:15proliferation of ETFs within the US.
- 40:18And while there's a lot of positives to it.
- 40:22There are a lot of risks associated with that.
- 40:23There's a lot of layers of counterparty risk.
- 40:26And you know we're only I guess seven or eight months now, seven
- 40:29months into US spot ETFs and the uptick and interest has been
- 40:36pretty phenomenal. I would say we just got the 13 F
- 40:39data from Q2 today. All the filings had to be in.
- 40:43So we'll start to see a lot more information through the weekend.
- 40:46But counterparty risk is something that we should all be
- 40:49talking about, not only the four of us, but really as an industry
- 40:53right in Bitcoin and traditional finance.
- 40:55This is this is a decentralized money.
- 40:58We haven't seen anything like it before.
- 41:00The Bitcoin and crypto industry is 2 1/2 trillion dollars.
- 41:03There's been nearly half a trillion dollars of losses in 15
- 41:07years. Like that is remarkable.
- 41:09That's. How much?
- 41:11400 billion, almost a half a trillion dollars of losses.
- 41:15And this is just due to a lot of things, right?
- 41:17There's just rampant counterparty risk with third
- 41:20party custody, effectively trying to map third party
- 41:23custody from traditional finance to Bitcoin and crypto with
- 41:26digital bearer assets. And then of course, a lot of
- 41:28challenges with people learning how to use this technology and
- 41:31secure it themselves. So maybe we open up the
- 41:34conversation there, like Wall Street's embracing a new asset
- 41:38finally this year. We thought it'd come sooner, but
- 41:41there are trade-offs associated with these products and people
- 41:44you know, should should be aware of it.
- 41:46It's a great place to start, but maybe there's some other things
- 41:48worth considering. Yeah, One thing to throw out
- 41:51because I don't know if Sam, I know Jackson, we're on a lot of
- 41:53calls he hear me bring this up for curious here Sam and Mark's
- 41:56feedback on like this whole notion of like money's a product
- 42:00and Bitcoins the best product, right.
- 42:01And if you think about Bitcoin, like did you talk about product
- 42:06market fit that you have an asset right now since it's like
- 42:09one $1.1 trillion that you tell somebody you can get the trade,
- 42:15right? But the next day you wake up, it
- 42:17may be completely gone and it still got to a trillion dollars
- 42:20because that's effectively what we're talking about.
- 42:22For 15 years, individuals have allocated and they've had to get
- 42:26comfortable with the fact that it could just go up in smoke,
- 42:29whether it's like the directional versions or each
- 42:32side, it's like could end up by North Korean hackers or end up
- 42:35in a landfill in a hard drive, right?
- 42:37That's how people think about it.
- 42:38And the core or the analogy or where that ties, if you leave it
- 42:41on an exchange, somebody may get between your phone and that
- 42:44exchange, you leave it on a hard drive, it may end up in a
- 42:46landfill because somebody, you know, goes in and cleans out
- 42:49your wife's cleaning out the the safe, you know, for that annual
- 42:52cleaning throws away your little USB stick because you haven't
- 42:55touched it in three years. Like that's how, and that's how
- 42:58people have allocated. And we still got into $1
- 43:01trillion. And I like in it too, that's
- 43:03product market fit. But it's also how early we are
- 43:05that the market structure is fully not figured out yet.
- 43:09And so there's still a lot there.
- 43:11The ETF's are obviously a big deal, but they're in, you know,
- 43:15in the Bitcoin circles like the least sophisticated thing you
- 43:17can ever imagine about putting a wrapper around Coinbase.
- 43:20So that's a little bit more meat on that.
- 43:22Does your Bitcoin custody setup keep you up at night?
- 43:25Maybe you still have coins sitting on an exchange worried
- 43:28about hackers? Or maybe you've set up your own
- 43:30self custody but don't feel safe with your Bitcoin savings
- 43:33stashed on a little plastic device in your desk drawer.
- 43:36Gain Peace of Mind with On Ramp and our multi institution
- 43:40custody solution. Here's how it works.
- 43:43On Ramp creates a dedicated multi sig vault just for you. 3
- 43:47separate institutions each hold a key on ramp bit go and coin
- 43:51cover, but none can move funds unilaterally.
- 43:54Instead only you have control over your coins with On Ramp's
- 43:58multi institution custody. You'll sleep better at night
- 44:01knowing your Bitcoin is stored with best in class security on
- 44:05chain with fault tolerant multi sig.
- 44:07If you believe your Bitcoin is going to be worth a lot someday,
- 44:11don't jeopardize that future by exposing your coins to hackers
- 44:14on exchanges, $5 wrench attacks in the real world, or perhaps
- 44:18most importantly, the risk that you might screw something up
- 44:21with a highly technical self custody set up on ramps.
- 44:25Multi institution custody eliminates single points of
- 44:27failure, reduces your personal attack surface and technical
- 44:31burden, and provides access to financial services that allow
- 44:34you to confidently secure your Bitcoin, including inheritance
- 44:38planning, insurance backed warranties for all balances and
- 44:40transactions, low cost trading, and more.
- 44:44Bitcoin is a once in a species asset, secure it right.
- 44:48Learn more at onrampbitcoin.com. Yeah.
- 44:50And Sam, when when you've done the work in talking to folks is,
- 44:55is what Michael and Jackson just talked about about owning it and
- 45:01versus having economic impact is that at.
- 45:03All. Appreciated by investors who
- 45:07aren't, let's say on the pub Lord podcast or you know, or you
- 45:12know, normies or people in tried father you've spoken to.
- 45:17Yeah. I mean, I just think that the
- 45:18ETF is kind of top of funnel for somebody who just wants the
- 45:21exposure to Bitcoin and then the idea of counterparty risk and
- 45:27using it in a sovereign way that kind of is farther down the
- 45:32rabbit hole and the funnel. And then they realize like I
- 45:36should actually own this, I should actually take self
- 45:39custody of this. And I think that's just a little
- 45:41bit farther down the funnel for a lot of people.
- 45:43And that's natural. I mean, that's my journey as
- 45:46well. I think a lot of people's,
- 45:47especially they're not very technical.
- 45:51I think the ETF saying, you know, they're more suitable for
- 45:55institutional investors who for whatever reason can't, can't buy
- 45:59spot Bitcoin, do this like investment mandates or
- 46:02regulatory requirements. You know, that's like that's
- 46:06where I see them really getting a ton of uptake.
- 46:10And I think these 13 FS are they're kind of a lot of noise
- 46:13in them because if you look at like the top holders, they're
- 46:17like these large hedge funds that are actually just like ARB
- 46:20trading trades. You know, they're like huge,
- 46:23like Renaissance tech. I mean, they don't even care
- 46:25that it's Bitcoin related. They just see an ARB opportunity
- 46:29and their their elbows picking it up.
- 46:32Or you see, like with the major banks, and I, I brought this up
- 46:36before, it's like the major banks are authorized
- 46:38participants for the ETFs. And so the Fed has basically
- 46:43prohibited these banks from holding Bitcoin straight up.
- 46:48The Fed prohibited them and but they are allowed to do, you
- 46:51know, crypto related activities like being an authorized
- 46:55participant or market making. And and so I think like when you
- 46:59see these big banks holding it, I don't think it's really a
- 47:02indication that they're suddenly bullish and put in another
- 47:05balance sheet. I think they're just market
- 47:06making and then they're involved with the creation and redeeming
- 47:10of ETF shares as authorized participants.
- 47:13Now that's what SAB 1/21 was all about because the American
- 47:17Bankers Association actually wrote multiple letters saying
- 47:20this is, you know, we want this overturned because we want the
- 47:23custody Bitcoin and Bitcoin related products, AKA ETFs on
- 47:28behalf of our clients. And obviously Biden vetoed it
- 47:33and they're, you know, that didn't go through for them.
- 47:36But now the SEC is quote UN quote, making exceptions.
- 47:38So we don't really know like what who got those exceptions
- 47:42and if they, you know, are able to custody.
- 47:44So maybe things have changed and and they are custody now for on
- 47:48behalf of clients, but I just think there's a lot of noise
- 47:51with the 13 F now. It's like the financial advisors
- 47:54and some of these like multi asset strategy firms and some of
- 47:58these like there's certainly firms that are into Bitcoin and
- 48:02bought a substantial position. It's just hard to kind of
- 48:04delineate which ones are which. You got to do a little bit of
- 48:07research to see what their their investment strategies are, if
- 48:10they're an Elgo ARB trading, you know, a firm or if they're like
- 48:15a macro firm that's like, you know, yeah, we're we're long
- 48:18Bitcoin. So anyway, Mark.
- 48:23Yeah. So you, you mentioned Saab 121.
- 48:26Do you? Can you, for the audience, go
- 48:28back in just because? Yeah.
- 48:31So and I'll just give where where we are seven months into
- 48:36the ETFs, 50 odd billion, maybe a little more fastest growing
- 48:41ETF for the guys Balconus and Seaford at at Bloomberg and they
- 48:46feed the system for banks because they can do the AP
- 48:49business and they can get into the plumbing.
- 48:50So that's been a huge plus. But SAB 121, what, what does
- 48:55that prevent and, and who did it?
- 48:57Because I agree that that's a big deal.
- 48:59For well, SAB, 1/21 was basically set up by the SEC.
- 49:05They didn't have any kind of comment period when they laid it
- 49:10out. They didn't go through any kind
- 49:12of congressional procedure. They just laid down this rule.
- 49:15And this is the exact kind of thing the Chevron deference will
- 49:19prohibit in the future. But the SEC just laid down this
- 49:22rule basically saying like, OK, you know, you banks can hold
- 49:26Bitcoin, but they made it prohibitively expensive for them
- 49:29to do so. So, you know, they basically had
- 49:32to treat it as an asset and a liability on their balance
- 49:35sheet. And it just it became incredibly
- 49:37expensive for them to do it basically was a if so facto
- 49:41banned for these banks because it just didn't make sense
- 49:43economically for them to do it. And so this is the thing that
- 49:47eventually went to, I believe the Government Accountability
- 49:53Office declared that, yeah, this was a rule that should have went
- 49:56through Congress. And so eventually it hit the
- 49:58congressional floor and it made it all the way through the House
- 50:02and the Senate to overturn the rule.
- 50:03And then it went to Biden and Biden vetoed it.
- 50:07And so now we're in the situation where it's probably
- 50:10going to hit the floor again, but maybe a new administration
- 50:12has to come in to eventually overturn this.
- 50:14But the fact is, is that the banks want it.
- 50:17And then when the banks, when the bank lobby wants something,
- 50:20eventually they're going to get it.
- 50:21And they they're just saying, you know, this is ridiculous.
- 50:24This asset class is being treated differently than every
- 50:27single asset class for no reason whatsoever.
- 50:30And we want access to it and we want, you know, basically
- 50:33they're saying that the Federal Reserve and the SEC don't want
- 50:37Bitcoin and traditional financial system integrated with
- 50:41one another. They don't want that to happen
- 50:43too fast. They're scared.
- 50:45They're saying that it's going to create financial instability.
- 50:47This is exactly what happened with the Custodia Bank by the
- 50:49way, if you read the actual lawsuit, they say they don't
- 50:53want Bitcoin or crypto related activities to be intertwined
- 50:57with the financial system due to stability instability concerns.
- 51:00But the the funny part is is that if you.
- 51:03They've done a great job with instability in their own.
- 51:05But anyway, go. Ahead, Yeah, I know exactly.
- 51:06But then you would want, you would want the most, you know,
- 51:09trusted and, and largest and most regulated financial
- 51:12institutions in the world to be able to custody this on the
- 51:15behalf of their clients, the state streets, the BNY Mellons
- 51:18who are building out their own infrastructure for years.
- 51:22But then they had to basically can it.
- 51:25I think they've kind of restarted it now, but they
- 51:27canned it because they couldn't get through and they couldn't
- 51:30get regulatory approval to to do it.
- 51:32And you would want them to be able to hold it because if you
- 51:34wanted, that would provide more stability rather than have this
- 51:37stuff offshore or, you know, with less experience, let's say,
- 51:43you know, firms. And so it just doesn't make
- 51:45sense. And it's all about just, you
- 51:48know, another example of, let's say, Operation Choke .2 Point O
- 51:51is, as some people call it, trying to prevent the
- 51:55integration of Bitcoin into the traditional banking system.
- 51:58But as I said, the banks want it now, so they're gonna get it
- 52:02eventually. Thanks for running through that.
- 52:04I don't think it's talked about enough or broken down like how
- 52:07much of aberration that is from the highest level knowing the
- 52:10folks at BNY that we're working on building a custody product.
- 52:13And to your point, how to just like kind of sunset it because
- 52:15of the capital requirements to the local level, knowing that
- 52:19local banking entities, credit unions or looking for ways to
- 52:23generate revenue and not be disintermediated by the big four
- 52:26banks is like this is it's kind of funny because you said
- 52:29they're afraid of the concern of instability.
- 52:32And I think this is what stabilizes.
- 52:34It's the opposite because now you can have the ability to not
- 52:37only offset, you know, inflation from the individual, but then
- 52:40you can build capital markets around it.
- 52:42Like we all know the lending side of Bitcoin and that you can
- 52:45now naturally start to, if you don't want to incur capital
- 52:47gains, you can have the ability to lend against the asset.
- 52:50Well, who's the best lender? It has the cost of capital, but
- 52:52bank the bank can actually see the assets that are sitting
- 52:54within the clients depending on the custodial relationship.
- 52:57There's a whole slew of things that can be built around that
- 52:59asset once it's like sitting right next to somebody's
- 53:02deposits. And I've been having these
- 53:05conversations with banks since like 2021 and I've just in
- 53:08everybody like there's a little known doesn't get talked about
- 53:11enough. But USAA member owned banked for
- 53:15the military insanely large. They really forward thinking on
- 53:19technology. They own the patent for back in
- 53:22the day. Now it's just standard where you
- 53:23can take a picture of a check. We don't even use checks
- 53:25anymore. But at the time when you take a
- 53:26picture of a check and do deposit, so they would, you
- 53:28know, patent it out to other banks.
- 53:30They invested in coin basis series B in 2000 and I don't
- 53:34know, but it's going to be 14 between 14 and 16.
- 53:37And it was really neat because you could have a drop down where
- 53:41you could see your Bitcoin balance right next to your
- 53:44checking account balance. And so this was back in like
- 53:47mid, you know, teens. And then they sunset it because
- 53:50they got spooked by like everything related to all the
- 53:53blow UPS, all the offshore stuff that you're talking about.
- 53:55And now they won't go anywhere near the asset because of all
- 53:57the kind of antagonistic behavior by the big, you know,
- 54:01four letter or three letter agencies.
- 54:03So hopefully there is something that changes because I think
- 54:05this is like the big dead. And once it gets intertwined,
- 54:07now you start to normalize that asset as a savings vehicle for
- 54:11everyday Americans or treasury balances and all the things we
- 54:13talked about. And you can see it proliferated.
- 54:16You know, you can see a path to that soft landing that we're
- 54:18going to need ultimately when things start moving and the
- 54:21volatility picks up. Yeah.
- 54:25Yeah, the OCC did a lot too. I mean, Brian Brooks was the
- 54:28head of the OCC and did a lot of good things.
- 54:30And then everything he did was immediately overturned when he
- 54:33left. And then the OCC, after FDX blew
- 54:36up and everything, the OCC came out to all these banks who were
- 54:39offering, you know, services to, you know, Bitcoin businesses and
- 54:44and Bitcoin users. And they said basically, you
- 54:48know, you have to suspend it and then we're going to provide
- 54:50supervisory feedback and we'll get back to you on your internal
- 54:54controls and risk management and then you could resume those
- 54:57activities. But of course, they never got
- 54:59back to them after they made them suspended.
- 55:01And that's what the Coinbase lawsuit is about.
- 55:04They sent a letter, I think they sent a lawsuit to to the SEC and
- 55:12the FDIC. This actually might be the FDIC.
- 55:16This actually I might be mixing up the OCC and FDIC.
- 55:19They're all the same. They wrote letters all together
- 55:22the FDIC, OCC and Fed after the FTX blowout.
- 55:27It's extremely rare, so they temporarily suspended it.
- 55:32Quote UN quote temporarily suspended the crypto.
- 55:34I've seen that movie. OK.
- 55:37See, not to put you on the spot, but or anybody like, do you know
- 55:41if the credit unions are the same like SAB 121 appeal to the
- 55:48credit unions? And the reason why I'm asking is
- 55:51I saw recently, I think it was as today or yesterday that
- 55:54they're starting, there's a trend happening in the markets
- 55:56where credit unions are starting to buy banks because of the
- 55:59requirements, because credit unions are nonprofits and
- 56:02there's just certain requirements, but they're you
- 56:05don't have to adhere to. And so that there's this trend
- 56:07where they're purchasing private banks and I was just curious if
- 56:12credit unions, the SAB rules appeal to them.
- 56:15Does anybody? Know I I don't know.
- 56:19I don't know. That's a good question.
- 56:22Yeah, I'll look into it after because that was something
- 56:23that's like popped up around that trend.
- 56:27But then also credit unions wanting to get involved given
- 56:30their localized nature and the require like they they're right
- 56:33there at the tip of the spear, right?
- 56:34They're dealing with local Sally Mary that comes in and they're
- 56:36trying to work to get their deposits passed to the
- 56:38generation and keep them within their bank and Bitcoin could be,
- 56:42you know. Fixing out athletes.
- 56:43That's one of them. I would have to look at the
- 56:45language of SAB 121 if it's specifically names like
- 56:49federally chartered banks or something like maybe not because
- 56:53credit unions aren't banks, but if it's something more broad
- 56:57maybe they fall into it. That's a good question.
- 56:59I don't know. And I I think sad 121 is going
- 57:02to go away because what I believe and that was 2021 when
- 57:07it came out, I believe that it was specific almost to Coinbase.
- 57:14That's why they did it because they, what they said that your
- 57:17separate business cannot, your custody business has to be
- 57:22conflated with your operating business and that we can't say
- 57:26that you would be as separately, that your assets in the custody
- 57:31business would not be a general unsecured creditor because
- 57:33there's not enough bankruptcy law.
- 57:35I, I've, maybe I'm conflating two different events, but I
- 57:37thought that that was also when and now with all the bankruptcy
- 57:40proceedings, we do have that law.
- 57:43So I, I agree with you, I think it's going to be undone and the
- 57:46courts, like Judge Rao's decision, taking a newspaper to
- 57:51counselor's nose and whacking them by saying arbitrary and
- 57:56capricious 8 times in a 21 page report and just getting really
- 58:00basic in how he just delayed and she didn't understand why.
- 58:09So I, I, I do think that there's going to be progressions on
- 58:13this. Like you said, Sam, there have
- 58:15been more successes as we saw the people screwed things up
- 58:19like Sam Bankman free, but the protocol did exactly what it's
- 58:23supposed to do. And so you just need to clean
- 58:26out, you know, the bad actors and let the good protocol run.
- 58:29And I, I think that's coming to the surface.
- 58:34Yeah, it's, it's really a shame how much spot Bitcoin access has
- 58:40been stymied within the traditional finance system
- 58:42because those are the exact people who need Bitcoin as a
- 58:47savings technology. Like 50% of people in the United
- 58:50States don't own investable assets, right?
- 58:53They, they may own their home or they may rent it, but they don't
- 58:56own equities and fixed income and investment properties.
- 58:59And at the end of the day, at a very fundamental level, these
- 59:03are the people that need access to a better form of money that
- 59:06will actually protect their purchasing power.
- 59:09And it's really a shame, especially like, you know, to
- 59:12think or on the left side or the progressive side, Bitcoins, a
- 59:17very progressive technology. It enables everyone to have
- 59:20access to a savings technology free from debasement and
- 59:24censorship. And really I'm hopeful and I
- 59:28will be curious to hear like what you guys are paying
- 59:30attention to now, kind of looking forward federal level,
- 59:33state level regulatory, like what are some things we should
- 59:37all be paying attention to, you know, from now through the end
- 59:41of the year and into next that could either be more favorable
- 59:43for the industry or could maybe even present more challenges to,
- 59:47you know, getting Bitcoin in the hands of of more U.S. citizens.
- 59:52Before jumping into that, just to add a chilling notion to what
- 59:55Jackson shared that I had popped up right before we recorded that
- 59:59it came out, 14% of adults have saved over 100,000 or more for
- 1:00:02retirement. For GOP banking rates and then
- 1:00:0678% of Americans have saved 50, eight, $50,000 or less.
- 1:00:12Wow. It's not good.
- 1:00:15Yeah, problem. That's a problem.
- 1:00:20I don't know. I mean, in terms of what I'm
- 1:00:23looking at right now, I mean, it's, you don't want to get
- 1:00:26political, but I mean it, it's naive to say that the election
- 1:00:29outcomes won't have an impact on specifically this industry.
- 1:00:33I mean, the Biden administration, Biden and Harris
- 1:00:37administration has been extremely hostile to this
- 1:00:40industry the entire time. I mean by either those that they
- 1:00:45appointed in regulatory positions or through some of
- 1:00:50their proposals like the tax on Bitcoin miners, or when they
- 1:00:56tried to get information from Bitcoin miners and that was
- 1:00:59deemed to be unconstitutional. Right, right.
- 1:01:02And all the different, you know, just the consistent narratives.
- 1:01:05I mean, it just hasn't been positive.
- 1:01:08And I'm not saying like, you know, well, the another
- 1:01:12candidate would have to prove itself, you know, come through
- 1:01:14on promises and stuff like that. But, you know, I do think that
- 1:01:17they if, if there isn't a status quo change, then our industry is
- 1:01:23going to have more barriers in front of it rather than the
- 1:01:27other way around. And so I am looking at the
- 1:01:29election. I think it's important.
- 1:01:31I think it's important for our industry.
- 1:01:33Now, Bitcoin is global. So it would just be, you know,
- 1:01:37the United States shooting itself with really bad policy if
- 1:01:40that happens, and other countries around the world will
- 1:01:42benefit. So it's like the game theory.
- 1:01:44But that is something coming up that you can't really ignore as
- 1:01:48much as I'd like to ignore politics.
- 1:01:51You know, policy is important. If you have really good policy
- 1:01:54and that embraces this new technology that can bring all
- 1:01:58these benefits to the United States, that's going to be good
- 1:02:03for Bitcoin adoption. There's no way, no doubt about
- 1:02:05it. I mean, it's the largest,
- 1:02:07wealthiest country in the world and or one of them.
- 1:02:13But you know, and then in terms of just like in general, like I
- 1:02:17look at liquidity conditions a lot.
- 1:02:19And so if we do see some, we are seeing kind of an uptick in
- 1:02:23global M2 just kind of starting to break out a little bit.
- 1:02:26If we see that continue, I think Bitcoin is a very pure measure
- 1:02:32of global liquidity conditions. And and so I think Bitcoin would
- 1:02:38actually really benefit in in those situations.
- 1:02:40And then, you know, I am looking at corporate treasury adoption.
- 1:02:45I just think it's fascinating what's happening there.
- 1:02:48And I think the timing is really right.
- 1:02:50And I think there's been case studies now like with
- 1:02:53MicroStrategy and I'll set more scientific or just it's like
- 1:02:56that meme, you see where the guy's dancing and then another
- 1:02:59guy joins and then everyone starts to join.
- 1:03:03That's what I think we're at. And I think the infrastructure
- 1:03:06is in place now where these corporations can really come in
- 1:03:10and there's a playbook and to get their legal accounting, you
- 1:03:14know, the auditing, all right, reporting and have the proper
- 1:03:19vendors and partners in place that have they have the internal
- 1:03:24controls that they need as well to make it all happen to
- 1:03:27actually execute on the strategy.
- 1:03:29And so I think you're going to see more corporate treasury
- 1:03:32adoption, which is exciting. And then institutional
- 1:03:37investors, I'm looking at like I'm looking at Rias, that's
- 1:03:42where I think there's going to be a lot of Rias and
- 1:03:46specifically probably more in the ETFs.
- 1:03:48But Rias, pension funds, I think those are interesting.
- 1:03:53I think advisors are interesting because I've always thought of
- 1:03:55them as like a one to many orange pill, you know, because
- 1:04:01if they understand Bitcoin, they're teaching all their
- 1:04:04clients about Bitcoin and then, you know, a portion of those
- 1:04:06clients get orange peeled and then they start talking to their
- 1:04:09friends. So if you can just convince
- 1:04:11those financial advisors to start allocating a small
- 1:04:14percentage and you know, it can make a meaningful dent in in
- 1:04:19driving Bitcoin adoption. So I'm looking at the 13 F
- 1:04:23filings for like Rias big, big investment firms like that.
- 1:04:27And yeah, I think that's what I'm looking at right now.
- 1:04:32I think, yeah, I'll stop there. Yeah, that's a great recap.
- 1:04:36I think the the 13 F, you probably hinted a little bit at
- 1:04:39that, like how much is actually signal versus noise early,
- 1:04:42earlier in the pod. And that's kind of where I felt
- 1:04:44like anecdotally, there's not too many buy holds yet.
- 1:04:47We're still like it's early days.
- 1:04:48There's a lot of requirements from the SEC with these Ras,
- 1:04:50making them jump through hoops and the natural education and
- 1:04:55then the corporate adoption you referenced is really fascinating
- 1:04:57because I thought about last night seeing that oversubscribed
- 1:05:00bond offering or debt offering for, was it, Mara?
- 1:05:03And yeah, it was kind of scary. It's kind of scary because I
- 1:05:07like sat there and I told I'm up here, you know, visiting the in
- 1:05:11laws and told my mother was like, I think you need more
- 1:05:12Bitcoin because she's been thinking about wine.
- 1:05:14I was like, I could see, like, you know, we all know this is
- 1:05:16going to get to six figures sooner or later, but you can see
- 1:05:18how this gets accelerated once, you know, these bond investors
- 1:05:21seem to love these converts and it's known in the market that
- 1:05:25they're just going to be oversubscribed.
- 1:05:26And now it's just you're basically talking about free
- 1:05:28money at this point, Like how long, how much more downward
- 1:05:31pressure can you put until the thing rips?
- 1:05:33Because everybody's seen this. It's like what you just
- 1:05:35referenced the dancing. So I think that's going to be a
- 1:05:37fascinating thing to play out at the corporate level.
- 1:05:40Yeah, I one another one that went under the radar was Bit
- 1:05:44Deer. There's $100 million convert
- 1:05:49same deal. And I, I mean, we could maybe we
- 1:05:53can talk about this a little bit.
- 1:05:54I actually just wrote on this today.
- 1:05:55So it's fascinating to see like a miner go down this route
- 1:05:58because there's obviously a little bit more risk.
- 1:06:02You know, micro strategy score business is like a profitable
- 1:06:07business that's kind of separated from Bitcoin, you
- 1:06:11know, good cash flows. But miners, I mean, they are all
- 1:06:15in on Bitcoin and they have operational risk to consider.
- 1:06:18And so there is more risk on their side.
- 1:06:21But then you think about it and you're like, well, it makes a
- 1:06:23lot of sense because I think marathons convertible offering
- 1:06:28was like 2.1% or something like that per annum until 2031.
- 1:06:33Bitcoins returned like 40% per year over the last five years
- 1:06:38so. It's a home run the because
- 1:06:41think of it your your, your points well taken that that
- 1:06:46miners have miners are long and long and they also have daily
- 1:06:52liabilities. They have current liabilities
- 1:06:54and then they need and if Bitcoin gets halved, that double
- 1:06:58that current liability just doubled for effectively because
- 1:07:01they have to sell twice the amount of Bitcoin, but they term
- 1:07:04out. You said 2031.
- 1:07:07If I'm remembering, yeah. Marathon, yeah, they're, they're
- 1:07:10usually five years or longer, sometimes 7:00.
- 1:07:12So that is, that's a home run. They term out.
- 1:07:16They don't have to worry about that.
- 1:07:17Maybe that gives them more flexibility to manage a tighter
- 1:07:21treasury, you know, Yeah, exactly on it.
- 1:07:25And, and this is another podcast, but I grew up in the
- 1:07:27convert market in the 90s watching Merrill Lynch.
- 1:07:32I had a friend who worked there just print money.
- 1:07:35The easiest trade is to say to someone you have a lot of
- 1:07:38volatility on your firm's equity and you think it's bad.
- 1:07:42I got people that really like it.
- 1:07:44Yeah. And oh, it's the easiest trade
- 1:07:46in the planet, my friend, And that's what's going on here.
- 1:07:50Yeah. I mean, it's nuts.
- 1:07:52It's, I'm sorry, but the convertible debt market, the
- 1:07:57convertible debt market doesn't see this kind of volatility,
- 1:08:00right, Mark, like they just rule with it like Microstrategies.
- 1:08:06Not any not anymore. And the and the company that
- 1:08:11that had it. The funny thing is it's it's a
- 1:08:13flywheel. When you bring the Bitcoin on,
- 1:08:15guess what happens? Your volatility goes up.
- 1:08:18So it so then the second convert could be even easier to spell.
- 1:08:23Can you bring down? Can you break down Mark just
- 1:08:26that they convert trade and Y, they like the volatility just so
- 1:08:30you can, everybody understands. I know we're going, but it'd be
- 1:08:34good. So if, and this is what what
- 1:08:41what traders try to do is beat time, they could hold a stock by
- 1:08:45the 10 and at the end of the year goes to 20 and they'll
- 1:08:49double and that's good. But that's 12 months and you
- 1:08:53know, double S still good. What a trader might do is buy it
- 1:08:57at 10. If it goes down to 8, buy more
- 1:08:59and then sell some at 12 and try to actively monetize what they
- 1:09:04call gamma, the rate or delta or the change.
- 1:09:10Now in convertibles, since you have a bond, there's something
- 1:09:15that arises out of the relationship.
- 1:09:18Let me let me let me back up. I got the visual in my head from
- 1:09:21my my, my, my one O 1 trade. A convert trader will be long.
- 1:09:28The bond that will go up and down based on the stock as well
- 1:09:35as the credit worthiness of the company.
- 1:09:37Two things drive it. The bond is not that big a deal
- 1:09:41unless things start to go South and the equity goes down.
- 1:09:44But it goes up and it goes up on a curve.
- 1:09:45I think I'm on a camera so convexity it follows like what
- 1:09:49fixed income, what Fabozzi talked about in his books and
- 1:09:52why U.S. Treasury market became such a
- 1:09:55big component for pension funds. Because you have more upside
- 1:09:59than downside. The rates of change have a
- 1:10:01changing dynamic like acceleration.
- 1:10:04Convertible traders are able to then trade the stock short
- 1:10:10against the embedded equity that's in the long, and because
- 1:10:14it's so volatile, think about that thing about $10.00 or $20.
- 1:10:18They can trade that thing 6-7 times in a week and make money
- 1:10:22again along this funny little curve called a convex curve.
- 1:10:26Convex curves are wonderful because they have an asymmetry
- 1:10:30that trading equity alone doesn't have the bond.
- 1:10:34Equity inside a bond gives you convexity.
- 1:10:36Yum Yum. That's why they get to buy it
- 1:10:38and they'll buy it all day long and they'll short the stock
- 1:10:40against it. I hope that got people close to
- 1:10:43kind of understanding the uniqueness of what that bond
- 1:10:46does to arbitrage audience. Is there an oversimplified?
- 1:10:50Version of like the convertible gives you the down downside
- 1:10:53protect, protection of the entity, repaying that note in
- 1:10:57the upside of the warrants and the appreciation of the of the
- 1:11:00equity. I think, I think that they're
- 1:11:06oversubscribed. Oversubscribed.
- 1:11:08Yeah, I think that I think you can say that the size of the
- 1:11:15equity market is now $45 trillion.
- 1:11:17We are pretty high on valuations and the convertible market has
- 1:11:23been capped. I don't know if it's 300
- 1:11:26billion, 500 billion. I could be off by a little bit,
- 1:11:30but it's a much smaller market, Michael.
- 1:11:31So just like how we think bitcoins going to, you know,
- 1:11:34osmosis and be pulled in because it has so many good attributes,
- 1:11:38the convert market does not have enough good product and there's
- 1:11:41a growing demand. So that's how I would say is
- 1:11:45that there's a lot more equity than bonds and a convert gives
- 1:11:48you both and that's unique. That's my story.
- 1:11:56The, the thing when Sam referenced, he was salivating
- 1:11:59over the bond markets and the research he was writing about,
- 1:12:01which I'm interested in reading is thinking about like you can,
- 1:12:05you know, Mara and market strategy are specifically
- 1:12:08interesting because they have large treasuries in Bitcoin.
- 1:12:10So even if like the price moves against them, they can hold
- 1:12:14their, like they can hold their breath underwater because they
- 1:12:16can lend against that asset if they're paying 2.1% or whatever.
- 1:12:19You know, I think MicroStrategy is like the how about the 20
- 1:12:24zero? Yeah, exactly.
- 1:12:26Exactly. 0.75 or. Something so if the rate of
- 1:12:29inflation, inflation's 1015% you're letting against, there's
- 1:12:35the problem that is kind of scary.
- 1:12:37What you're referencing is if you're a miner, your cash flows
- 1:12:40are tied to BTC, you can't issue debt or you you're not having
- 1:12:44the revenue. And now that's a problem if you
- 1:12:46don't have a treasury as well to be able to lend against and you
- 1:12:49owe, you know, 2% on, you know, $100 million, that's where.
- 1:12:53Well, The thing is like if you, I mean, what Mark said is true.
- 1:12:57It's, I mean, it's turned out, I think, I don't think they have
- 1:13:00to like, yeah, it's 2031. But anyway, but just a situation
- 1:13:04where like if they have to pay operational costs or, you know,
- 1:13:11their debt obligations, if they get bad leverage, you know,
- 1:13:14there's good leverage, there's intelligent leverage, there's
- 1:13:16not intelligent leverage. So like the miners of the last
- 1:13:19cycle kind of learned the difference in the hard way.
- 1:13:21But if they do, if they, if they use it to buy Bitcoin, then it
- 1:13:26could be a situation where they had to sell the Bitcoin at the
- 1:13:28worst time. And then they're hurting the,
- 1:13:32you know, adding sell pressure to the very thing their entire
- 1:13:34business revolves around at the same time, you know, and so it's
- 1:13:38it's an issue that like MicroStrategy or somewhere
- 1:13:41scientific doesn't really have to think about.
- 1:13:42Now, I think Marathon is using intelligent leverage here.
- 1:13:47But in Marathon, what's interesting is that like they're
- 1:13:49utilizing their size and the liquidity of their stock, which
- 1:13:54is what differentiates it from a lot of other miners, especially
- 1:13:58smaller miners. You know, these large publicly
- 1:14:03traded Bitcoin miners have access to capital markets and
- 1:14:07that's other miners don't or not so easily.
- 1:14:10And so they're basically leveraging their ability to
- 1:14:13raise capital in the convert market, in the equity market,
- 1:14:17which is what they've been doing.
- 1:14:18And if they turn around and start buying Bitcoin and if they
- 1:14:21get the timing right, so Marathon owns double the Bitcoin
- 1:14:25in the next miner. I think Cut 8 owns like 9000 and
- 1:14:28they own 25,000 now. So if they get the timing right
- 1:14:32on this thing and Bitcoin, you know, goes up like we think it
- 1:14:36is the next couple of years, they could really separate
- 1:14:38themselves from the pack. And so it's a bold strategy, you
- 1:14:43know, but at the same time, like what the math, what Mark was
- 1:14:46mentioning the and so and they're just going to be able to
- 1:14:51do it again because because again, it's just going to add
- 1:14:54liquidity to their stock. You know, this is what we've
- 1:14:57seen with micro strategy. It just add increases the
- 1:15:00trading activity, which adds liquidity, which like wakens up
- 1:15:03the options market and the debt market allows them to even raise
- 1:15:06again. And then they buy more Bitcoin
- 1:15:08and that adds more volatility. And it's just like this
- 1:15:11liquidity flywheel that ends with more Bitcoin on the balance
- 1:15:15sheet or I guess Bitcoin per share going up, it's accretive
- 1:15:21to shareholders. Yeah, yeah, that's what that's a
- 1:15:24thought. I'd like to read what you wrote
- 1:15:26because that's a that's a huge emergent dynamic that would be,
- 1:15:31I think, to have investors appreciate.
- 1:15:34Yeah. So it's, yeah, it's.
- 1:15:36It's can we call Michael's Can we call Michael's seller the Lou
- 1:15:39Ranieri of of Bitcoin, right? Kind of, yeah.
- 1:15:44Taking mortgages to Bitcoin and you know, it was one guy, it
- 1:15:49wasn't an industry. One dude did it solid.
- 1:15:51Mortgage-backed securities, is that?
- 1:15:53Yeah. He created it.
- 1:15:56Yeah, I mean, it's it's going to be wild.
- 1:15:57And again, it's just it's very interesting thinking about the
- 1:16:01competitive advantage that these large publicly traded miners can
- 1:16:06have with that ability and whether it will last.
- 1:16:10So like if we do go down into a big downturn, like will their
- 1:16:15ability to raise like becoming a lot more difficult and then, you
- 1:16:21know, they come into trouble that way because right now the
- 1:16:24market loves it, right? I mean, not only are they
- 1:16:27raising equity a lot at ATMs, just like they did that a few
- 1:16:31times, but now they're hitting the convertible debt market as
- 1:16:35well, and they're just turning around and buying Bitcoin, which
- 1:16:38is the big difference now too. They're just literally adopted.
- 1:16:41Yeah, strategy. So yeah, fascinating,
- 1:16:45fascinating stuff. I think final thought or
- 1:16:48question would just be like, do you think Sam, this is an
- 1:16:51inflection point now because Sailor was on an island for a
- 1:16:54while executing the strategy, obviously insatiable demand for
- 1:16:59for the strategy. Now you know, we're talking
- 1:17:01about public minors getting involved.
- 1:17:03I didn't even realize that bit Deer did as well.
- 1:17:06I just had seen the marathon news.
- 1:17:08But do you think now it's kind of an inflection point for
- 1:17:11publicly traded minors specifically?
- 1:17:13Do you think that we're going to see more companies like
- 1:17:16MicroStrategy or just like tech companies in general or other
- 1:17:20sorts of publicly traded businesses adopt A strategy or
- 1:17:24do you think there's still maybe a little bit more?
- 1:17:28Do we have to see some more time pass before that really, you
- 1:17:32know, before we hit that flywheel?
- 1:17:35I think, I mean, Michael and I have talked about this too.
- 1:17:38It's just there's a yeah, I mean, Sailor talks about this as
- 1:17:42well. Like zombie companies are
- 1:17:44typically described as companies who take on a ton of debt that
- 1:17:47can't, you know, pay back the interest on their debt for I
- 1:17:51think 3/4. That's like the traditional
- 1:17:55can't even pay the interest on the debt for 3/4 I think with
- 1:17:58their current revenues or something like that.
- 1:18:00That's how traditional people think of zombie companies.
- 1:18:03But Sailor has a different kind of definition of it.
- 1:18:07A zombie company is just a a company that's, you know, solid
- 1:18:11good growth or not good growth, you know, good cash flows,
- 1:18:14durable cash flows, a lot of cash, but they're not growing
- 1:18:17right. They're not innovating.
- 1:18:19They look out 20 years and their share price is just boring.
- 1:18:23Nobody cares about them. You know, they're just kind of
- 1:18:26they're zombies. They're just waiting to die.
- 1:18:28They're kind of like just trucking along.
- 1:18:31And Bitcoin offers this like adrenaline.
- 1:18:35It's just like orange adrenaline popping in the in like not only
- 1:18:40does it have benefits to the balance sheet, but it transforms
- 1:18:43the culture and identity of the company.
- 1:18:45And suddenly the stock sees increased trading activity and
- 1:18:48things start to come alive. And you know, miners, you know,
- 1:18:52tech companies, you know, those are obvious choices for, you
- 1:18:57know, adopting a Bitcoin treasury strategy.
- 1:19:00But it's these like these like mid to small size publicly
- 1:19:05public companies like the bottom, like the everything in
- 1:19:11the Russell 2000 outside like the top tests, like anything
- 1:19:16that has like good cash flow and is cash rich and is just
- 1:19:21trucking along waiting to die. They should probably think about
- 1:19:24adopting a Bitcoin treasury strategy.
- 1:19:27In my opinion. It could just change their
- 1:19:30entire identity. And so that's what I'm looking
- 1:19:33for. And then the other thing is just
- 1:19:34like corporate board, you know, if if if Sailor had a lot of
- 1:19:41control as we know over the boating rights of the company
- 1:19:44that allowed them to easily adopt it.
- 1:19:46But if you look for things like how much the corporate board
- 1:19:51members own the stock themselves, like that could be a
- 1:19:55good sign actually, because they actually care about increasing
- 1:19:59shareholder value. Eric Sembler talked about this
- 1:20:02in Nashville, and I thought that was a really great point because
- 1:20:05a lot of these boards, they just like collect a paycheck every
- 1:20:07quarter. But if the board is full of
- 1:20:09people who actually own equity in the company.
- 1:20:13Then they're more likely to think about how do we maximize
- 1:20:15shareholder value and there probably isn't a better way to
- 1:20:19do that than adopting a Bitcoin treasury strategy.
- 1:20:23It's really the underlying question is like you have to
- 1:20:27come to the realization as a treasurer of a corporation or
- 1:20:30CFO or CEO that cash is no longer an asset, Cash is a
- 1:20:35liability and you got to make that distinction.
- 1:20:38It's a complete shift, but you have to, you have to understand
- 1:20:42that and then then ask question, what do I do with all the cash?
- 1:20:46And that kind of starts you down that road.
- 1:20:48And that's what Michael Saylor did in 2020, end up with
- 1:20:51Bitcoin. But now it's much easier for
- 1:20:54them to do that because he's paved the wave.
- 1:20:57My question He's paved the wave. Yep.
- 1:21:00Yeah, it's fascinating on the on the incentives as we wrap up
- 1:21:03with thinking about it's, it was little known.
- 1:21:05There's a really good podcast allocators forget the exact
- 1:21:10name, but they had the CIO from Wisconsin pension and they have
- 1:21:13a unique incentive model at the pension level to pass through a
- 1:21:17post like a certain performance or benchmark goes to the
- 1:21:22fiduciaries that run that pension.
- 1:21:23And so you naturally have this out performance because they're
- 1:21:26not sitting through the flat structure.
- 1:21:28Yeah, so it's it's interesting model.
- 1:21:30You see the incentives and we kind of see the outcomes as
- 1:21:32well. That's.
- 1:21:33Probably why it's like one of the best funded pension funds in
- 1:21:36the country. Best run incentives.
- 1:21:40In Spaniel. Hey, everyone said they're the
- 1:21:429th largest state pension in Wisconsin.
- 1:21:45How's that? Yeah, Michael just told us
- 1:21:47incentives. Yeah.
- 1:21:51Yeah. Well, Sam, maybe now's a good
- 1:21:55time to wrap it. Really appreciate you hopping on
- 1:21:58this week and joining us. Fantastic conversation.
- 1:22:01I learned a lot too. Just some topics that I want to
- 1:22:04go deeper in and excited to read that new research report you'll
- 1:22:08be publishing soon. Maybe just if you want to give a
- 1:22:11hand off, feel free where folks can find you and see what you're
- 1:22:15working on these days. Yes, I've been writing, you
- 1:22:18know, a weekly market update called the News Box.
- 1:22:23So you can subscribe at the news block at substock.com, where I
- 1:22:27just kind of give an overview of developments that I think are
- 1:22:29important in the macro and Bitcoin landscape.
- 1:22:32And so check that out. I'm on Twitter a lot at Sam Cala
- 1:22:35S AM CALLAH. And then I'm actually throwing a
- 1:22:40event next month in Saint Louis for all the Midwest Bitcoiners.
- 1:22:46Natalie Brunel, Matt Dines from Build Asset Management as well
- 1:22:50as myself. We're throwing 1/2 day seminar.
- 1:22:53It's called Bitcoin lunch and learn.
- 1:22:56So come learn about Bitcoin, grab lunch networking it's
- 1:23:02called. You can find more information at
- 1:23:03bitcoinhyphenlunch.com. Love to have you there.
- 1:23:07If you're in the Midwest. We're just trying to educate
- 1:23:09people about Bitcoin and and meet some Bitcoiners in the
- 1:23:11community. Build a build a matter of good
- 1:23:14friends of on ramp. So encourage everybody to check
- 1:23:17it out and Sam would you even get into tether and Bitcoin and
- 1:23:21bonds and the tying the whole financial system to the other.
- 1:23:23I feel like you. Have man.
- 1:23:25It's based on we can be. So.
- 1:23:27We'll definitely. We'll hopefully have to have you
- 1:23:30on again and get them do a deep dive as that gets into a larger,
- 1:23:35as they're a larger treasury holder.
- 1:23:36So look forward to. Hoping totally, totally.
- 1:23:38Yep, let's do it. Thanks, guys.
- 1:23:40Thanks for having me on, Mark. It's been a pleasure.
- 1:23:42Michael, Load. Jackson, load of fun, Sam.
- 1:23:44Thanks. Thanks, Jackson.
- 1:23:45Thanks, Michael. Thanks guys.
- 1:23:48Thanks for listening to this week's episode of the show.
- 1:23:50If you found the information valuable, please share the
- 1:23:52episode with a friend or leave a rating on your favorite podcast
- 1:23:55app. All the links we discussed in
- 1:23:57today's show will be in the show notes inside your podcast app.
- 1:24:00Before we finish, a quick reminder that On Ramp Media is
- 1:24:02for informational and entertainment purposes only, and
- 1:24:05nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 1:24:08Regardless of where you are on your Bitcoin journey, we'd love
- 1:24:10to hear from you. Visit on rampbitcoin.com/contact
- 1:24:14to schedule a consultation with one of our private Client
- 1:24:17advisors.