Latest / Soccer Down Here / Football Consultant Jason Stephens on MCO's: SDH AM 8.19.25
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: We are starting our multi club Ownership Master's class, and
- 0:07we get to do it with a football consultant over
- 0:11in England, Jason Stevens. And Jason with his extensive experience
- 0:17in clubs in England and his extensive research on specifically
- 0:24multi club ownership models, we were like, yeah, with everything
- 0:27going on that we've been talking about an hour number
- 0:29one before we talked about transfers and things, we figured
- 0:33what we would do is catch up with Jason so
- 0:36we could understand more about what we see when you
- 0:40have City Football Group owning Manchester City and sending Tati
- 0:45Castianos to Girona and you know, sending Maxi Morales and
- 0:49players all over the place. That kind of a thing.
- 0:52And that's just one example. But what we wanted to do,
- 0:56especially with what we've been talking about, was try and
- 0:58find someone who can walk goes through the whole thing, pitfalls, dangers,
- 1:06all of the elements that are attached. Next week we'll
- 1:09get into why folks are going into multi club ownership
- 1:12models and ideas, but this is the first conversation that
- 1:15we're having with Jason about MCOs, what they mean and
- 1:21what they do. So here's week number one of our
- 1:26understanding of multi club ownership with football consultant Jason Stevens
- 1:31and our interview over in London that we had yesterday.
- 1:35Speaker 2: Here we go in time to.
- 1:38Speaker 1: Catch up with our friend Jason Stevens, who is known
- 1:41as a consultant in football circles internationally, and we get
- 1:45to start our I guess, is this our graduate level
- 1:48course when it comes to finding out about MCOs and everything?
- 1:52Speaker 2: Jason? Are you officially saying it is our graduate level course?
- 1:55Speaker 3: What are we doing? Yeah?
- 1:57Speaker 4: Absolutely, I think we'll start offered with we as soon
- 1:59quicking to masters level and beyond.
- 2:03Speaker 1: So for those that kind of sit there and they're
- 2:07the casual fans of teams around the world, a lot
- 2:10of the big names and a lot of the companies
- 2:13that are attached are MCOs. How prevalent is the idea
- 2:19of the MCO within world football today do you think?
- 2:24Speaker 3: Yeah? I mean big.
- 2:25Speaker 4: In the last study I did recording all the ones
- 2:30across the world, we had over four hundred clubs now
- 2:34connected to over one hundred and forty seven multi club
- 2:38ownership groups.
- 2:39Speaker 3: That's defined as a multi club.
- 2:41Speaker 4: Ownership group that has more than one soccer club within
- 2:45the portfolio. Now when I'll say more than one soccer
- 2:48club in the portfolio. We sort of break it down
- 2:51now under the term of what we call influence, and
- 2:54there's sort of five angles that we look at influence.
- 2:57And the first one is an individual or group that
- 3:01owns the majority stake or the largest stake in more
- 3:03than one football club. That's traditional what MTOs have been
- 3:06built up, but what we have seen in the last
- 3:09few years is at point number two is that an
- 3:12individual or group that owns a majority stake in one
- 3:15club but also has a minority stake in other clubs.
- 3:20Speaker 3: And then we've got number three.
- 3:21Speaker 4: We're an individual or group that has a minority stake
- 3:25in two or more football clubs, but is also influential
- 3:29in the decision making. And then we've got an individual
- 3:32or group that has a stake in one club, that
- 3:35has formed influential partnerships with other clubs, et cetera. And
- 3:40the last one is a group influenced by state backed investment.
- 3:44So we sort of break down multi club ownership, multi
- 3:47sports ownership within those five categories, because the key term is.
- 3:51Speaker 3: Now is influenced.
- 3:52Speaker 4: Right, theres more and more governing bodies, regional governing bodies
- 3:55have rules around ownership stakes or one of the ways
- 3:59to get around it is not to actually own an
- 4:02influential stake, but actually to have a minority state where
- 4:05you may bypass some of the owners and directors tests,
- 4:10but you still have an influence within the decision making.
- 4:13And often these guys or groups, they tend to have
- 4:18more monetary influence along the way.
- 4:21Speaker 3: So yeah, it's definitely evolved over the last couple of years.
- 4:25Speaker 1: So the idea of each of these five categories, is
- 4:31one category more seen more than the other four or
- 4:36when you look at the five categories that you have, literally,
- 4:40do you have any idea as to what the breakdown
- 4:42might be is to which one is more prevalent these days?
- 4:45Speaker 4: Well, again, if we look at like the City Football Groups,
- 4:50the global one, you know they're the ones with the
- 4:52biggest brands, one of the early front runners. So City
- 4:55Football Group in itself, it has a number of clubs
- 4:58within the portfolio, but it also has partnerships. Now a
- 5:02partnership don't contain any ownership stakes in the clubs, but
- 5:07there's significant control because the owners of City.
- 5:12Speaker 3: Football Group are also conducting.
- 5:14Speaker 4: Business with the owner of the other football clubs, and
- 5:18therefore they're influencing the decision on the football field as well,
- 5:22favors for favors in a sense, just to give you
- 5:26an example of that. So what we've got is a
- 5:29club Olivier. They've also which is in Bolivia. Now the
- 5:35guy behind that also owns ten percent in New York
- 5:42City and he also owns a significant stake in Jerona.
- 5:48And his name is Marcello Claude. He's Oblivion, one of
- 5:53the wealthiest men, and he's also got multi billion dollar
- 5:57global investment firm.
- 6:00Speaker 3: Is connected to a.
- 6:01Speaker 4: Number of blue chip companies like soft Bank Corporations and
- 6:05et cetera, and they use those companies to influence business
- 6:10and other decisions, et cetera.
- 6:12Speaker 3: And in turn, they've got club partnerships.
- 6:14Speaker 4: And another one for that is the Turkish club Potasca
- 6:20et cetera. Seems to be the home club of the
- 6:24President of Turkey. And there seems to be some wide
- 6:30the business deals between UAE and Turkey. And then there's
- 6:34some interesting partnerships connected with football club et cetera. And again,
- 6:39if it was to go into Indonesia, they've got a
- 6:43partnership over there. And it's funny because one Gaylang International,
- 6:50and that's part owned by Well City Football Group was
- 6:55part owned by the.
- 6:56Speaker 3: Chinese Media Capital. They used to run.
- 6:58Speaker 4: About ten percent, but that's sort of like which is
- 7:00over the years, but they still own about just under
- 7:02one percent. Still they've still got significant partnerships in China
- 7:06and Asia, and the Chinese Media Corporation has significant in
- 7:11Gayalen International as well. So we can see that type
- 7:15of state influence on partnerships as one form of entity,
- 7:20and then we can look at how clubs are actually
- 7:24you know, we're creating ownerships, but we're also creating club partnerships.
- 7:27And I suppose the most common one and recent one
- 7:30is Aston Villas Group, which is the sports. Now the
- 7:34sports themselves made up of free groups individuals, and what
- 7:42they've got is well started off between two of them,
- 7:45Wes Edians and Nassive Safari.
- 7:47Speaker 3: Was Ediens being a prominent American investor.
- 7:50Speaker 4: Also he was a co owner of the Monkey Bucks
- 7:54and Nassive Safaris. He's got ownership stake in Madison Square
- 7:58Gardens and with that year I was obviously a percentage
- 8:02of the New York Knicks and New York Rangers, et cetera.
- 8:05But he also he's got significant stake in added US.
- 8:09So those two come together to create a ownership group
- 8:14and then they renamed it the Sports and then they
- 8:16bought in the Teros Private acty group and then between
- 8:21them they own Victoria and Portugal. They've got club partnerships
- 8:27with their cel COB in Japan, z FC in Egypt
- 8:32and Real Union in Spain. The last two Z and
- 8:36Real Union they're connected to family members as well, so
- 8:40there's a little bit of our director in that one.
- 8:44Speaker 3: And then we've got Chelsea.
- 8:45Speaker 4: Obviously Chelsea, as we all know, very high profile football brands,
- 8:50taken over by top boreies Consultium and that included clear
- 8:56Aid capital. Then what we've seen since that formation is
- 9:02that one of the big private exty groups jumping on
- 9:07that one. I'm sure its Area's Management, Yeah, and they've
- 9:14provided five hundred million towards that and in turn they've
- 9:16got an only ship stake in one of the holding
- 9:18companies as well. And although Areas Management is considered a
- 9:25passive investor, we've seen signs that has changed in the
- 9:27last couple of years as they've got states in Biro
- 9:31Athletic and Madrid and even football holdings. And then obviously
- 9:35hot topic at the moment is with our friend John Texta.
- 9:38He seems to hog all the media attention.
- 9:43Speaker 1: Yeah, egle football holdings with our viewer base and listener
- 9:46base in the Southeastern United States and those that follow
- 9:50Major League soccer. He has definitely been in the crosshairs
- 9:53with a lot of different folks when it comes to
- 9:57the idea of influence, not owning as much, but having
- 10:02the influence with material goods and investment and all these
- 10:06kinds of things. When did that shift to go from
- 10:08just the straight financial to understanding value in those cybe
- 10:13relationships and influence as opposed to just the financial aspect
- 10:17of it all.
- 10:18Speaker 3: Well, I think, I mean, obviously we're not talking in
- 10:19years and years of this.
- 10:20Speaker 4: I think obviously since COVID, the COVID sort of provided
- 10:24opportunities for investment groups to invest in football. What we
- 10:28saw with COVID was that there was a huge consumer
- 10:31loyalty and where the economy, the global economy was suffering,
- 10:36what we found was our football teams, sports teams were
- 10:39still being able to turn over significant revenue because our
- 10:42fans had this desire to support the clubs, so they
- 10:47couldn't provide the traditional revenues of gate receipts and merchandise sales.
- 10:52They were looking at innovative ways in which they can
- 10:55create revenues, and the fans were coming up with all sorts.
- 10:58Speaker 3: Of innovative ways with the clubs, et cetera.
- 11:00Speaker 4: And over the period of what just over a year,
- 11:03what we saw was at clubs we robust against this,
- 11:08i'd say, this economic scale of decline, and then private
- 11:13actually sort of realized actually with football, I suppose providing opportunity. Now,
- 11:20they also sort of analyzed the sponsor and entertainment market
- 11:24and realized actually that football in Europe is underdeveloped. And
- 11:30whilst we're seeing brand value still hold their own during
- 11:34that big period of decline, we've also seen those same
- 11:39brands increased drastically over the last few years. And you know,
- 11:43the way I tried to explain it in simple terms,
- 11:45our football clubs are a bit like property. Yes, they
- 11:48tend to go up more than down over the years.
- 11:50And where we look at European football clubs have now
- 11:53been around between one hundred and twenty one hundred and
- 11:56fifty years. They've one that kept themselves going into They've evolved,
- 12:01and three they've developed a significant loyal fan base. I mean,
- 12:06to the point I use this one, which is quite
- 12:08a funny line. In general terms, a football fan is
- 12:12more likely to change his wife than he years to
- 12:14change his club in his lifetime. So it just shows
- 12:17you the the group connections that football clubs have. And then, obviously,
- 12:22what we have seen a couple of examples where football
- 12:25clubs did make some fast money. The Eniosk Group, for example,
- 12:31they bought a club from the Pacific Media Group, which
- 12:34was nice. The Pacific Media Group brought it for twenty million,
- 12:38and then they sold it for one hundred million eighteen
- 12:42months later, and that's sort of well, this was a
- 12:44bit of an eye opener, and everybody thought, well.
- 12:46Speaker 3: This is that easy, then we should be doing this.
- 12:48Speaker 4: I mean, at the time, I think the economy, with
- 12:51some of the wider markets were only offering anything between
- 12:54four and twenty percent return of investment. Football clubs started
- 12:57to offer five hundred to two thousand, dependent on the brand.
- 13:00So a lot of private actor you're thinking, Okay, this
- 13:02makes sense, let's get.
- 13:03Speaker 3: Involved in here.
- 13:05Speaker 4: And then the only thing that we've seen change is
- 13:08the length period in which the exit terid of investment
- 13:11strategies are being place a lot of private actor that
- 13:14get involved in football clubs.
- 13:16Speaker 3: I looking at.
- 13:17Speaker 4: Exit strategies as a minimum of seven years and the
- 13:19maximum of twenty twenty five and beyond that just depends
- 13:25helps I'll lost myself vitals.
- 13:27Speaker 2: That's all good. So what I wanted to follow up
- 13:31with that is.
- 13:34Speaker 1: With all of these corporations and funds and all these
- 13:39other individuals that are diving into this idea of owning
- 13:43football clubs, believing in multi club organizations and things like that,
- 13:49and it is basically treated as lines on a balance
- 13:53sheet where they can sit there and they can manipulate
- 13:55the bottom line and all this kind of stuff.
- 13:57Speaker 2: How much exploitation.
- 13:59Speaker 1: Are you seeing when it comes to the idea of
- 14:04profit and loss and ownership and manipulating relationships as MCOs.
- 14:09How much exploitation are you seeing from either individuals who
- 14:12are trying to dive in or companies trying to create MCOs.
- 14:17Speaker 4: Yeah, I think you know, there's plenty of examples of that.
- 14:20I mean Seven seven Partners were quite the expose of that.
- 14:24You know, they raised a bit of money against one
- 14:26club and then they used the money that they raised
- 14:28originally against the value of the next bookball club, and
- 14:31they added that together to go and buy another club,
- 14:34and then they've got exactly the same in the original
- 14:36plus one club.
- 14:36Speaker 3: Plus two club the value and they're going to embowed against that.
- 14:39So they were just resocling the same.
- 14:41Speaker 4: Money in multiple times and then eventually, you know, when
- 14:44you had to start repaying that back, they they just
- 14:47didn't have the revenues to be.
- 14:48Speaker 3: Able to do that.
- 14:49Speaker 4: Now, what they needed was a big, big club, which
- 14:53was you know, someone like the Premier League where the
- 14:56bottom club in the Premier League turns over one hundred
- 14:59million because of the broadcastingdal et cetera.
- 15:02Speaker 3: That gives them that.
- 15:02Speaker 4: Safety net and a lot of private actuality groups, and
- 15:07they use that Premier League club as your store in
- 15:11order to to be able to justify and pay those
- 15:16loans back.
- 15:17Speaker 3: So there was one example there.
- 15:22Speaker 4: You know, I'd say there's probably loads of different ways
- 15:25in which money is being leveraged in these organizations.
- 15:31Speaker 3: One of the concerns.
- 15:32Speaker 4: That the governance has is how the club's balances can
- 15:37be manipulated through money laundering.
- 15:40Speaker 3: It's a bit harder in the top top.
- 15:42Speaker 4: Leagues because they have to provide you know, strict financial
- 15:46accounting and they're regulated yearly and every three years in
- 15:51certain competitions, but in some of the lesser leagues in Europe,
- 15:55and you can belong to an MCO then not really
- 15:58asking your bank accounts. So it can be all subjective,
- 16:01and we are concerned that a lot of those clubs
- 16:05are subject to that money laundering, the criminal organization. So
- 16:10there isn't a perfect world. But the problem is with football.
- 16:15You know, every club is fighting for itself in that sense,
- 16:19and they need to exist because they are pillars of
- 16:22the community. And I suppose there's only a certain amount
- 16:25of big world fee owners around.
- 16:28Speaker 3: So football.
- 16:30Speaker 4: The problem with football is that the revenues it generates
- 16:35is nowhere near enough to.
- 16:36Speaker 3: Support its costs.
- 16:37Speaker 4: So therefore a lot of football clubs are just not
- 16:41sustainable without that un cash injection organizations cash injection and
- 16:46where we've seen now football club's sort of value increase.
- 16:49You know, they've gone from you know, seven hundred million,
- 16:54which was the most expensive club on the planet in
- 16:56two thousand and five two thousand and seven, are Man
- 16:58United Chelsea going for two point two billion four billion
- 17:03depending on commitments in twenty twenty two. So we've seen
- 17:07a massive jump there and there's not that many biller theres.
- 17:10They have a passion for football, so they need to
- 17:12form collaborations with different investment groups. But one of the
- 17:16biggest problems with private equity or venture funds is that
- 17:19nobody's really tracking who belongs to.
- 17:21Speaker 3: These venture fundings and private equity. It's like an organization.
- 17:25Speaker 4: You know, it could be Jason Stevens organizations, but I've
- 17:29got commitments from probably ten thousand people. We don't checks
- 17:34who those ten thousand people are, and you couldn't do
- 17:36that because that just be a governance nightmare. But we
- 17:40don't know what's actually going on in those equity funds,
- 17:42et cetera at the moment, and obviously the big clubs
- 17:45it's a little bit more scrutinized, but I wouldn't say
- 17:49the investors are. But as I said before, you know,
- 17:52we've got some examples where investors are passive, and we've
- 17:55also seen where they started off passive and they started
- 17:58to become more active and influential. And who's to say
- 18:02that that's not going to change with these venture funds,
- 18:04et cetera. Depending on how much people commit to them
- 18:07in the way. So it is a concern. I don't
- 18:10think governance is ever going to manage it completely because
- 18:15unfortunately it's already got out of the blocks, and therefore
- 18:18it's impossible to try and pull something back because as
- 18:22quick as you pull something back, the way football works
- 18:25is you may invent a rule and then what I
- 18:28do is employ two or three people to find a
- 18:30loophole in that rule for me to be able to
- 18:32navigate your sideways. And football clubs do employ people to
- 18:37navigate the rules, you know, to find those loopholes, to
- 18:40be creative. And because it's not breaking the rules, they
- 18:44breaking the rules. And a great example of that again
- 18:46is Chelsea and they're selling their own assets to themselves,
- 18:49creating this false value, false revenue, et cetera. But because
- 18:53they're not actually changing hands, is just settling the balancing.
- 18:57The government's okay, because it's self governed now the Premier
- 19:03League is run by its twenty owners. So once Chelsea
- 19:07exploited that loophole, and every club was thinking, okay, we're
- 19:11not going to vote against it because we may need
- 19:13that on a rainy day ourselves, you know. So we've
- 19:16already seen this year Everton and asked them to sell
- 19:18their women's team to themselves as well to generate an
- 19:21extra of forty to fifty million in our own PSR accounts.
- 19:25And more and more clubs are going to do that
- 19:26because that's there for them, you know. And this again
- 19:29is now driving Another avenue for football clubs is that
- 19:33to invest in real estate. And if they can create
- 19:36a number of real estate projects, then down the line
- 19:39when it comes to PSR, as Chelsea did, they sold
- 19:44a couple of hotels and a car park to themselves,
- 19:47So we're going to see more and more clubs probably
- 19:50manipulate that same rule as well. It comes to question
- 19:53and what do we do with PSR to stop all
- 19:55this scott Wly going on? Is there now the time
- 19:59to either be a little bit more flexible REPSR or
- 20:05do we just we're away with it for now and
- 20:08just pick up the pieces as football did once before.
- 20:12I do think there needs to be a happy medium
- 20:14where we need to be a little bit more flexible
- 20:16because actually, by not having some rules where some new
- 20:21players can actually invest into the clubs, you're just favoring
- 20:25all the big teams right because at the moment if
- 20:27we look at it, the big clubs are turning between
- 20:30six hundred and seven hundred euros million euros a season,
- 20:34and PSR restricts tend to seventy percent of that on
- 20:37transfers and wages, et cetera. Seven hundred million is four
- 20:43hundred and ninety million. A lot of clubs are not
- 20:45getting anywhere near that in terms of their annual revenue.
- 20:48So you know they're going to be completely outdone and
- 20:51that needs to stop. A none of our discussions of
- 20:53it happening, et cetera. But this then all ties back
- 20:56into you know, how do we leverage money, need to
- 20:59keep it.
- 21:03Speaker 3: I don't think we're going to get with that one
- 21:06anytime soon, that's for sure.
- 21:08Speaker 2: It is a world of and I had to circle terms.
- 21:11I literally as we were we were talking.
- 21:14Speaker 1: I went to two pages of notes and I started
- 21:18circling terms as we are here in our master's class,
- 21:21passive investors, private equity, and of course Eagle Football Holdings,
- 21:24which is another thing in and of itself. Uh, false
- 21:27value and false revenue and leverage money in real estate
- 21:32and ps R.
- 21:34Speaker 2: That's a lot to digest. That's a lot going on
- 21:38with a lot of different things.
- 21:40Speaker 3: Just for sports.
- 21:41Speaker 4: Yeah, it is, and it's going to get more complicated,
- 21:46right because now you know, when we look at clubs
- 21:49trying to create new revenue streams, when we look at
- 21:51new leagues and competitions coming into play, you know, now
- 21:57the law your opinion, or open the door for new
- 22:02competitions which are outside of UA for FIFA's control. Was
- 22:06waiting for that one, whether that's a private equity movement
- 22:10or whether that's a couple of clubs coming together to
- 22:12create something big up, and we're still waiting for that
- 22:15play to happen. The super League, for example, many of
- 22:20us don't believe that's dead. We do believe that will
- 22:22reinvent itself in another form very soon.
- 22:27Speaker 3: It's not.
- 22:27Speaker 4: You know, we know that the company behind the Super
- 22:30League proposal, Way twenty two, Sports Management, is still very
- 22:33operational and they've been still actively engaging with clubs. And
- 22:38we also know that a number of what we call
- 22:40Tier two clubs, not the big big ones, but the
- 22:43ones that fall on the tier underneath, are in favor
- 22:46of a bigger European competition obviously because it provides more money.
- 22:50And this is not going off track, but I'm I'm
- 22:55saying controversial, but I'm actually.
- 22:56Speaker 3: In favor of the super League. And the reason I'm
- 22:59in favor of super.
- 23:00Speaker 4: League is because in England you've got four or five
- 23:03clubs that are pretty much dominating the landscape, and they've
- 23:07become so big that the Premier League's now draw for
- 23:12all the other leagues. By twenty thirty, it's probably going
- 23:14to double the revenues what the other top four combined equal.
- 23:19Speaker 3: And then in a.
- 23:20Speaker 4: Way you've created a super league by the Premier League,
- 23:22and now we're going to kill.
- 23:26Speaker 3: The European football landscape.
- 23:28Speaker 4: It's the European football landscape that has made football so attractive.
- 23:31Speaker 3: In the first place. So I think we all have
- 23:33a responsibilities to.
- 23:35Speaker 4: Make sure that there's an equal place for all the
- 23:38leagues in Europe.
- 23:40Speaker 3: You know.
- 23:40Speaker 4: So whether a super league, yes, that provides a top
- 23:43tier product, but we also know that in football lead
- 23:47to league free.
- 23:48Speaker 3: League four in.
- 23:49Speaker 4: Certain countries can be proactive, you know, And we look
- 23:52at what's happening in America. You've got the MLS. That's great,
- 23:56but you've also got the US out which is friving.
- 23:59The MLS is cities, the USLS more for local communities,
- 24:03et cetera. And I actually do believe that the USL
- 24:05over time will be stronger than the MLS because it
- 24:09will have it would have had time to develop core
- 24:13routes into the communities, which is what English football clubs
- 24:17Upean football clubs have been built on, you know, so
- 24:19that I think that will actually benefit USL long term.
- 24:22I'm not talking anything probably in my lifetime. That night,
- 24:25I think that will be the case.
- 24:27Speaker 3: Well.
- 24:28Speaker 1: As always, my friend, thank you for the first class
- 24:32in the education of everything going on involving m CEOs
- 24:36and all of the economics and hold codes and bid
- 24:39co's and blue cots and all this kind of stuff
- 24:41that we have seen. This is just the beginning of
- 24:44a great conversation as we keep an eye on things
- 24:46and keep an eye on the sport. Thanks for hanging
- 24:48out for class number one in all of this, and
- 24:51we will definitely be following up. And I got to
- 24:54get my class schedule, my syllabus I'll figured out so
- 24:56we can make sure we know when we're going to
- 24:58catch up again. Thanks again for all of your health
- 25:00up and we will catch up with you soon.
- 25:01Speaker 3: Yeah, jeez, I