Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Medical-Legal Quality Assurance Checklist - They’re Not Just for Physicians: Understanding the Impact of Labor Code Sec. 4062.4.
Transcript
- 0:03Hello, and welcome to Medical Legal Quality Assurance
- 0:07Checklist. They're not just for physicians, understanding
- 0:10the impact of Labor Code Section 4062 .4. I'm
- 0:14Michael Falati, and I'm chair of the Workers'
- 0:16Compensation Section. I'm an attorney at Grayward,
- 0:19Kaplan, Vernick & Evans, and a certified specialist
- 0:21in workers' compensation law. Before we begin,
- 0:25I'd like to take a moment to plug the Workers'
- 0:26Compensation Section, a new and growing section
- 0:28of the Beverly Hills Bar Association. I encourage
- 0:31all work comp practitioners, as well as practitioners
- 0:34and overlapping practices like personal injury,
- 0:37labor and employment, and social security disability
- 0:40to join the section. For those interested in
- 0:42becoming involved as a section leader, I encourage
- 0:45you to reach out to me or contact the BHBA help
- 0:47desk. We'll throw out my email in the chat and
- 0:51also the help desk email. So please get in contact
- 0:53with us. And now I'm delighted to introduce our
- 0:56speaker for today, Judge Rasp, Judge Robert Rasp.
- 0:59Although anyone who's been practicing long enough
- 1:01would know that no introduction can really capture
- 1:04the full extent of Judge Rasp's invaluable contributions
- 1:07to the practice. Judge Rasp practiced workers'
- 1:11compensation and social security disability law
- 1:13for decades before being appointed as a workers'
- 1:16compensation administrative law judge in 2018.
- 1:21And he has served as a presiding judge of the
- 1:24Workers' Compensation Appeals Board for the Los
- 1:26Angeles District Office since December of 2019.
- 1:29A leading authority in the field, he is the author
- 1:32of the Lawyer's Guide to the AMA Guides in California
- 1:34Workers' Compensation and Editor -in -Chief of
- 1:37RASP and Herlic California Workers' Compensation
- 1:39Law, among other treatises and publications,
- 1:43many of which share a permanent spot within reaching
- 1:46distance on my own desk. Judge RASP has also
- 1:49taught as an adjunct professor at Pepperdine
- 1:51Caruso School of Law and chaired Friends Research
- 1:54Institute's Board of Directors. And now, let's
- 1:57begin. Thank you, Michael. I appreciate the intro
- 2:01and welcome everybody. I'm happy to be here.
- 2:05Thank you for the invitation. I'm going to share
- 2:07my screen and bring up a PowerPoint, if I may.
- 2:14Let me do that first. Hang on one second. Are
- 2:17we going to share? Just one second here. Okay,
- 2:33somehow the PowerPoint dropped off for some reason.
- 2:41Let me grab it. Stand by. Get it down here. Okay.
- 3:01Boy, this is going to take a while for my disclaimer,
- 3:04isn't it? Now what I'm going to do is get the
- 3:17slideshow. There we go. Can everybody see the
- 3:25slides? I hope you can. Anyways, so the Most
- 3:31interesting discussion today is the project that
- 3:35has been going on since the summer of 2024, it's
- 3:38been two years, in the development of a medical
- 3:42legal quality assurance checklist and a separate
- 3:45one for psychiatric injuries. And so I was recruited
- 3:50to do this in my capacity both as a author with
- 3:55LexisNexis as well as working with Friends Research
- 3:58Institute. which is a medical research institute
- 4:04headquartered in Baltimore, Maryland. I've been
- 4:06with them for 35 years, 15 years working as a
- 4:11chair of an institutional review board, which
- 4:14is the process of going from animal studies to
- 4:18human studies for medications, devices, and biologics.
- 4:24After that 15 -year stint of investigational
- 4:27new drugs, I got elected to become a member of
- 4:31the board of directors. I've been the chair since
- 4:332005, 2009. And so I have a group of around 75
- 4:40researchers in Baltimore, Maryland, headquarters
- 4:44where we're doing research in New York state,
- 4:47Pennsylvania, California. lots of HIV research
- 4:51and so forth. So they recruited me to do this
- 4:54project and I was happy to do so. So I do want
- 4:57to express my disclaimer that the opinions that
- 5:03are expressed today in this seminar are my own
- 5:05and not that of the State of California Department
- 5:08of Industrial Relations, Division of Workers'
- 5:10Comp, or the Workers' Comp Appeals Board. So
- 5:13my disclaimer is there and that's that. So I'm
- 5:18going to go through about 19 slides, actually
- 5:21fewer than that, just to kind of get you oriented
- 5:24towards where we're going today. The most important
- 5:28thing that we're going to talk about early on
- 5:31is Labor Code Section 4062 .4. And in other seminars
- 5:36I've given, live ones, I've asked the audience,
- 5:39how many of you have read that section? And almost
- 5:41nobody has. And the reason why, even though it's
- 5:44in your uh, two thousand twenty six blue book.
- 5:48It's buried of course in that big thick thing
- 5:51that's over fourteen hundred pages and nobody
- 5:54really knew what it was and what it's for. It's
- 5:58extremely important to your law practices for
- 6:01both applicant and defense and for that matter
- 6:04for judge. And so I want I want to understand
- 6:08you to understand that forty sixty two point
- 6:11four is kind of a culmination. of applying these
- 6:15labor code sections from compensability examinations
- 6:19by a Q and E to a PD issue, to any other issue
- 6:24that under 4062 point, 4062, and then applying
- 6:29for, you know, the ex parte communications issues,
- 6:33all the other issues that you see in a medical
- 6:35legal report in order for that report to constitute
- 6:39substantial medical evidence. The regulations,
- 6:43if there's any one in particular that I would
- 6:46recommend all of you on both sides to memorize,
- 6:50is 35 .5. You know, that's one of those types
- 6:54of things where there's something for everyone.
- 6:56There's something for defense, there's something
- 6:57for applicant, and it's also mainly for doctors.
- 7:01But it's an extremely important section. 10682
- 7:05is the laundry list of things that have to be
- 7:08in a medical legal report. 9785, I didn't put
- 7:13it up here, but it's still important, is for
- 7:15PTP reports. So 9785 is kind of a mirror image
- 7:20of 10682. So what does 4062 .4 say? I'm not going
- 7:27to read this to you. What it says is that it
- 7:31mandates a medical legal template form for QMEs
- 7:38to provide be provided by the administration
- 7:42so that they comply with all of the statutes
- 7:45and regulatory sections that we just went over.
- 7:49And so, you know, just because somebody uses
- 7:52a form doesn't make their report substantial
- 7:54medical evidence. We are concerned about substance
- 7:58and not just form. So the preamble to each of
- 8:02the checklists tell the doctors and you, you
- 8:05don't have to follow this, but you need to cover
- 8:08the information that we're just we're talking
- 8:10about here in order for your report to be complete
- 8:13and compliant with the regulations and the statutes.
- 8:18So subsection B1 is relevant to all of you, attorneys
- 8:22on both sides. The administrative director shall
- 8:26develop and make available a medical evaluation
- 8:28request form for communicating with the panel
- 8:33QME. This does not replace an advocacy letter.
- 8:38But what it does, it's going to force both sides
- 8:41to sit down and meet and confer to decide what
- 8:45information and what communication is being sent
- 8:48to a QME or an AME. And 4062 .1 applies to unrepresented
- 8:54applicants, 4062 .2 applies to represented applicants.
- 8:59So everybody who is involved in this system,
- 9:02who requires or requests a medical legal evaluation
- 9:05from a QME through the medical unit has to use
- 9:09this request form. I helped design this request
- 9:12form. Again, it's a whole group of us that has
- 9:15designed it. It is now at the Office of Administrative
- 9:18Law because it's becoming a regulation. As soon
- 9:22as the OAL approves it, actually they're gonna
- 9:25have to have some public hearings on it first
- 9:27before they approve it. The timeline of this,
- 9:30as you can see in the last section and subsection
- 9:32C, the deadline is January 1st of next year.
- 9:36So hopefully by this fall, maybe at the latest
- 9:39late fall, we'll have a mandated request form
- 9:43that both sides must use. Can you still use a
- 9:48joint letter? Of course you can. But this is
- 9:51not replacing an advocacy letter necessarily.
- 9:54This could be in addition to an advocacy letter.
- 9:56So we are not prohibiting advocacy letters, but
- 10:00this is something that we will hope will prevent
- 10:03the disputes over what information and communications
- 10:06are being made to QMEs and AMEs. I decided to
- 10:11put this additional item in the materials for
- 10:17you. When the medical record and the medical
- 10:23evidence is not substantial enough for a judge.
- 10:27And we're applying the McDuffie case where it
- 10:30says, you know, all the attempts in the world
- 10:32are not going to rehabilitate a bad QME report,
- 10:36or for that matter, an AME report. I've seen
- 10:38some bad AME reports as well. Labor Code Section
- 10:425701 allows a judge to order a regular physician.
- 10:47It used to be called an IME, Independent Medical
- 10:49Evaluator. They got rid of that terminology because
- 10:52so many other states use the terminology independent
- 10:56medical evaluator. So they decided to distinguish
- 10:59California from all the other workers comp systems,
- 11:02and they're called regular physicians. So you've
- 11:06gone to trial, you submitted it for decision,
- 11:08the judge opens up the file, looks at the medical
- 11:11reports, and he goes, Fooey, this is lousy. The
- 11:15judge is required to vacate submission of the
- 11:19case for decision, order the parties to appear,
- 11:24Post submission and say, okay, I vacated submission
- 11:27because doctor Smith and doctor Jones reports
- 11:31do not constitute substantial medical evidence.
- 11:33They obviously did not use the checklist. So
- 11:36you have 2 choices council. 1 is to go back and
- 11:40try to rehabilitate doctor Smith and doctor Jones.
- 11:42And if you don't. Or if it's irreparable, then
- 11:48I'm going to. Order a regular physician. Some
- 11:53judges will give you three doctors names and
- 11:55have the applicant strike one, defense strikes
- 11:58one, and the last one gets the case. I don't
- 12:00do that. I let my judges do whatever they want
- 12:03when it comes to this. The point is, is to get
- 12:06an AME quality doctor involved. And if the parties
- 12:09don't agree to one, then the judge will appoint
- 12:12someone. And, you know, I want to focus on rule
- 12:1710410D. that prohibits the parties from sending
- 12:22anything to the regular physician unless the
- 12:25judge orders it. And the reason why is because
- 12:29discovery cut off at the MSC. You know, 107 .59
- 12:33says what it says, and it says that discovery
- 12:36has cut off at the MSC. Fine. It's cut off. The
- 12:40judge takes control over the case. At that point,
- 12:42the trial judge, everything goes forward. There's
- 12:46maybe testimony, maybe no testimony. But the
- 12:49final word is the judges and if the judge believes
- 12:53that that record is insufficient and we all know
- 12:56that the board is remanding cases back to the
- 12:59trial level over and over again to develop the
- 13:03record because you know, Dr. Smith and Dr. Jones
- 13:05just don't get it and they haven't written the
- 13:07right reports. That constitutes substantial medical
- 13:10evidence. So rather than go through the QME process
- 13:14again, the judge is going to order a regular
- 13:17physician and will probably, I encourage my judges
- 13:21to write the letter because it's their case.
- 13:24They're the ones controlling discovery at this
- 13:26point because discovery closed between the parties.
- 13:30And then the judge will order the defense attorney
- 13:33to send the record of the case specifically admitted
- 13:38into evidence. the record of the case to the
- 13:42regular physician. The other thing is is that
- 13:46if a party doesn't like what the regular physician
- 13:48says, they can't just go ahead and depose them.
- 13:52The defendants or the applicant's attorney is
- 13:55going to have to file a DOR requesting that the
- 13:58judge allow a deposition of that regular physician.
- 14:03So again, everything is controlled by the trial
- 14:05judge at this point. So the fee schedule, there
- 14:08actually is a fee schedule for a regular physician.
- 14:12It's set at the AME modifier and that's under
- 14:16subsection H. It's buried in 9795. In fact, I
- 14:20had a hard time finding it. I remember it existed.
- 14:22I just couldn't remember where it was. I finally
- 14:24found it. So I also wanted just to include the
- 14:28checklist here in your materials for a Guzman
- 14:31process, very important one. I don't want to
- 14:35go over each of these because you know how to
- 14:37do this. I just wanted to give you a template
- 14:40to use to make sure that your QMEs and your PTPs
- 14:45and your AMEs go through this process if they're
- 14:48doing an alternative rating method. So again,
- 14:53the applicant has the burden of proving permanent
- 14:56disability. The defendants have the burden of
- 14:58proving apportionment, if any. I also wanted
- 15:03to include these two slides or three slides on
- 15:05how do you get to 100 % PD under the current
- 15:09rubric. These are the six ways of doing that.
- 15:15The second one is a group and those are the 4662A
- 15:19presumptions. And we see some of these from time
- 15:23to time in LA and in general. One of the things
- 15:30that's nice is that if you have a doctor after
- 15:32apportionment, finding WPI ratings at 72 % or
- 15:37higher, that defaults to a hundred percent disability
- 15:40without consideration for age and occupation.
- 15:44Okay. And that's of course, if there's no apportionment
- 15:46or the apportionment is considered in that. The
- 15:50other avenue to a hundred percent is if the doctor's
- 15:54apportionment is not substantial medical evidence.
- 15:56And the defendants have failed in their burden
- 15:59of proving apportionment of permanent disability
- 16:02under the Pullman Kellogg case. Another one is
- 16:06kind of an interesting one. And if a new injury
- 16:08causes a new condition that results in permanent
- 16:11total disability, what happened in the Nielsen
- 16:14case that's actually quoted in Nunez, I think
- 16:17it's a Nunez 1 or Nunez 2. I forgot which one.
- 16:21In that case, the applicant in Nielsen sustained
- 16:24a back injury. resulting in a permanent disability
- 16:30award. He then returns to his usual and customary
- 16:34occupation and eventually has a new back injury.
- 16:39That new back injury resulted in a chronic pain
- 16:43syndrome. And the evaluating doctor opined that
- 16:48the 100 % disability was due to the chronic pain
- 16:52syndrome. Think in terms of Fakida. It's like
- 16:55an iatrogenic effect. And so there was no apportionment
- 17:00to the prior percentage award in that case. It's
- 17:04an interesting case to read. The sixth way is
- 17:07if a vocational expert follows the doctor's apportionment
- 17:10in accordance with NUNIUS and concludes that
- 17:14the permanent total disability is caused by the
- 17:17industrially related injury. So those are the
- 17:20six avenues. Pick one. And if you come up with
- 17:23the seventh one, I'd like to know about it. Of
- 17:26course, we have rebutting the combined values
- 17:29chart, which every applicants attorney wants
- 17:31to do. Why is that? We'll get to that in a second.
- 17:36Please do not refer to kite. Kite is obsolete.
- 17:42Kite is a 2013 panel decision. Vigil, and that's
- 17:47how it's pronounced. Vigil, it's not Virgil,
- 17:50it's not Vigil. It's Virgil. It's Vigil. Okay,
- 17:55it's Vigil. See, I did it myself. So Vigil is
- 17:59the case that you want to use now. Why? Because
- 18:01it's a WCABN bank decision. It's binding on all
- 18:04of us, all the commissioners, deputy commissioners,
- 18:08judges, you, and everybody who touches a workers'
- 18:12comp case. So please get rid of Kite. The elegant
- 18:16thing about Vigil is that it also involved bilateral
- 18:20hip replacements. So it's consistent with the
- 18:22facts. In the prior case, that was the panel
- 18:25decision, we'll call it that. So why does the
- 18:29CVC exist in the first place? It's because it's
- 18:33in the AMA guides on page 604. By the way, there's
- 18:36a bunch of typos in there. It's inaccurate. Don't
- 18:39use it. Use the one in the PD schedule, please.
- 18:44You know, we've adopted the descriptions and
- 18:47measurements of the AMA guides. Simple as that,
- 18:50that CVC exists in the AMA guides in Chapter
- 18:521, and, you know, we're stuck with it. And then,
- 18:56of course, the DEU adopted the entire CVC because
- 19:02it's adopted in the AMA guides. So, you know,
- 19:06remember the whole purpose of this combined values
- 19:09chart? is to prevent any of the seven regions
- 19:13of the body to exceed 100 % whole person impairment.
- 19:17That's it. And they go ahead and say, listen,
- 19:20we don't really have a scientific reason for
- 19:23a CVC. It's nonsense. It's just a mathematical
- 19:27formula to prevent someone from being over 100
- 19:29% WPI. And they then go on to say, in multiple
- 19:36impairment cases, it's possible to have them
- 19:39additive as they affect ADLs by putting an increased
- 19:44burden on the injured worker. Here are the ADLs.
- 19:46You all know about them. Now that we have vigil,
- 19:49I think everybody in the room should be memorizing
- 19:52these or have at least a big chart in front of
- 19:54you everywhere you go, especially when you take
- 19:57a depo of a doctor or you write a advocacy letter.
- 20:00By the way, I just got back in front of 450 QMEs
- 20:05down in San Diego at the CSIMS conference last
- 20:08weekend. And you know what their biggest gripe
- 20:10is? Is that applicants' attorneys never send
- 20:13advocacy letters. Never say never. Most applicants'
- 20:17attorneys don't send advocacy letters. It makes
- 20:20them crazy. Please, write those letters. Make
- 20:25sure that you serve the other side first before
- 20:28you send it. please do those reports. All right.
- 20:33So, you know, this is the gist of the vigil case.
- 20:38I'm not going to read this to you because we're
- 20:40going to go over it later in a few minutes. Here
- 20:43are some examples of how there can be a synergistic
- 20:48effect or if there is a separate body part that
- 20:53has an impact along with another body part. So
- 20:57I love the example they give in vigil that the
- 21:00appeals board did imagine a hand injury I had
- 21:04one recently and I had a hell of a time but in
- 21:08my shirt with that bad hand imagine someone who
- 21:11has both hands injury and Trying to button a
- 21:14button That's a great example of the synergistic
- 21:17effect and a higher justification to add each
- 21:22of those ratings for each hand I think it's an
- 21:25elegant example of how adding is more accurate.
- 21:29And remember, this is the bottom line about VIGIL
- 21:32and about any QME report. They have to be relevant.
- 21:39They have to be reliable. They have to be complete.
- 21:42And they have to constitute substantial medical
- 21:45evidence. All right. So we just talked about
- 21:50this. You have to have the doctors evaluate overlap
- 21:57between the impairments for separate body systems
- 22:00or body parts and how each of those affect the
- 22:04ADL functioning. I'll show you this in a minute.
- 22:07I included the definition of synergy. That's
- 22:11important because it's in the board decision.
- 22:13They actually quoted the American Heritage Dictionary
- 22:17version of it. So that becomes a law. So if you
- 22:20haven't bought the American Heritage Dictionary,
- 22:22you don't need to. It's quoted here in their
- 22:25decision. Okay. So, you know, questions and answers.
- 22:31Can a judge decide to add the WPI ratings and
- 22:34not use the CVC? Absolutely not. This is strictly
- 22:39a medical issue. Judges cannot do this. We are
- 22:42not doctors. At least some of us aren't. Can
- 22:45an orthopedic surgeon, QME or AME, say that the
- 22:49ortho -psychian's internal rating should be added?
- 22:52Or how about a psychiatrist or psychologist saying
- 22:56that all of these different impairments ratings
- 23:00should be added? The answer is yes, and that's
- 23:03the Eddie Avakian case. It's a panel decision.
- 23:06I think this should have been a higher decision.
- 23:09It probably will be someday like a kite went
- 23:12to vigil. But right now with this board, this
- 23:15panel decision is actually into CCC's 89 and
- 23:19CalComp cases for 18. That allows one specialist
- 23:22to review everybody else's reports and indicate
- 23:26that it's their opinion and why they're making
- 23:28that opinion that these ratings should be added
- 23:31and not combined values chart. Do not sit idly
- 23:35by while the record is deficient, it needs to
- 23:38be developed. Delores Loren's case was mine when
- 23:42I was an attorney. I liked this case a lot because
- 23:44the defense attorney sat on their rights and
- 23:47didn't realize that they had a right to request
- 23:50a QME when they should have. And I used an AME
- 23:53report in a companion case against the same employer
- 23:56where the AME actually talked about both cases
- 24:00that were pending. And I won the case against
- 24:03the defendant that was half asleep at the wheel.
- 24:06So don't be half asleep at the wheel when you're
- 24:08doing your discovery. It's a very important thing.
- 24:11And remember, Vigil, I want to do a shout out
- 24:14to Dr. Newton because Peter Newton was the AME
- 24:16and Vigil. Dr. Newton, as most of you use him
- 24:20on both sides, I'm sure, with Beverly Hills Bar
- 24:23Association. This is not an advertisement. It's
- 24:26an endorsement of his skills. What I know in
- 24:29the background and backstory of Vigil is that
- 24:31the board was looking for a case. They were looking
- 24:35for a case where they could justify adding rather
- 24:39than combining. And this was it. And they have
- 24:42an AME quality doctor behind this case. And that's
- 24:45kind of the politics behind it. So shout out
- 24:48to Dr. Newton. So, oh, this is my band. We are
- 24:53playing at the Hotel Del Coronado for the second
- 24:55year in a row on the 22nd of September. That's
- 24:59me back here. You know, they always put the keyboard
- 25:01as they hide us, you know, the drummer too, but
- 25:04we're always in the back. But anyway, so that's
- 25:07how that works. That's that for it. And then
- 25:10I'm going to switch documents here. Let me do
- 25:13that right now. And I'm going to share the first
- 25:18medical quality assurance checklist with you.
- 25:20So again, this was a project that we started
- 25:25many months ago, over two years ago. And it was
- 25:34a collaborative effort on our part. It was approved
- 25:37by the head of OD Legal and their team. And this
- 25:44is not required by law. It is a guideline. And
- 25:48whether the office of administrative law decide
- 25:53to adopt this as the template that's mandated
- 25:55under 4062 .2, we'll find out eventually. So
- 26:01we have a table of contents. We're not going
- 26:04to go over that. That's no reason to. But you
- 26:06can see how extensive it is, where we have discussions
- 26:10of a lot of things. All right. So I'm going to.
- 26:13Scroll down this and and try not to get dizzy.
- 26:16I'm going to go to my red notes because my red
- 26:18notes are important. OK, so you know we don't
- 26:23use joint letters anymore. I wish you would.
- 26:26It would be kind of nice and I think it's always
- 26:28been best practices to Northern California. There
- 26:31are a lot more congenial between each other between
- 26:34the applicant and defense. I think they use more
- 26:36joint letters than we do down in the South. I
- 26:40think part of that reason is there's so many
- 26:42law firms in the South that are driven by non
- 26:45-attorney folks that either handle the cases
- 26:51in -house and then appear as hearing reps. So
- 26:55you don't get the cooperation that you have in
- 26:57the North here in the South. So I want to talk
- 27:02to the defense attorneys for a second. So applicants,
- 27:04attorneys, close your ears for a minute. When
- 27:07you write an advocacy letter to a doctor, First
- 27:11of all, the doctors always want advocacy letters
- 27:14from both sides. They don't get enough of them,
- 27:16as I said earlier. But don't put in your legal
- 27:19defenses. What we tell the doctors that we have
- 27:23the formula in California and pretty much other
- 27:26states, AOE, COE, injury arising out of employment,
- 27:31specific CT or combination of them in California,
- 27:35right? So, you know, applicant has the burden
- 27:39of proving injury AOE, COE, arising out of employment.
- 27:44That's a medical issue. That is not a legal issue.
- 27:49AOE means that it is a medical issue for a doctor
- 27:53to determine if there is a medical condition
- 27:56that is work related, period. Then once the applicant
- 28:01meets that burden of proof, the burden shifts
- 28:04to the defense to assert their affirmative defenses
- 28:07under Labor Code Section 3600. I think every
- 28:11lawyer, every hearing rep, should read 3600 once
- 28:16a year. The first part of it talks about the
- 28:19applicant's burden of proof. The second part
- 28:21of it talks about the defendant's burden of proof.
- 28:25So when you stick your letter in the face of
- 28:27a doctor and says, this is a post -termination
- 28:30defense or is a statute of limitations defense,
- 28:34You are crossing a line. It is irrelevant. All
- 28:39we want doctors to do is tell us, are we dealing
- 28:42with an injured worker? And in a psychiatric
- 28:45case, we're going to get to in a minute, same
- 28:47thing. We want to make sure that the doctors
- 28:50understand they have to stay within the rails.
- 28:56They can't stay in their lane is what Dr. Sones
- 28:59likes to say. That means don't make opinions
- 29:02on what constitutes a personnel action. Tell
- 29:05us what's causing the DSM diagnosis and ignore
- 29:08what the defendants are saying in their letters
- 29:10to you about this being a post -termination CT
- 29:15or it's a denied statute of limitations case.
- 29:17That's none of your business as doctors. That's
- 29:20what we tell the doctors in our seminars. I don't
- 29:23mind and we don't mind as judges if defense lawyers
- 29:26within their advocacy letter says we're denying
- 29:30this injury AOE, COE. That's good enough. Doctors
- 29:33have passed the QME exam. They know what that
- 29:36means. So stop the advocacy on the legal side.
- 29:40Just address the medical issues, please. Okay.
- 29:44We covered this issue about 5701 regular physicians.
- 29:49In the checklist, we're telling the doctors this
- 29:51applies to you too. And again, the judge should
- 29:56write the letter. Now sometimes a judge will
- 29:59not know how to write a letter and will order
- 30:02the parties to do a joint letter or will invite
- 30:06the defense attorney to write the letter subject
- 30:08to the approval by the applicant. And then it
- 30:11goes to the judge to make sure it's okay. Then
- 30:13it goes to the doctor. That's fine. It's perfectly
- 30:17okay. Now what happens if you receive the regular
- 30:22physician report And one of you wants to depose
- 30:25that regular physician. You can't just schedule
- 30:28the depo. What do you have to do? File a DOR,
- 30:32expedited hearing. I think it's expeditable.
- 30:35Get in front of that trial judge and say, Your
- 30:37Honor, I want to take Dr. Smith's deposition.
- 30:39He's a regular physician in this case. And I'd
- 30:41like to ask him the following questions, A, B,
- 30:44C, D. That judge has control over discovery.
- 30:47Remember, I said that earlier. So then you're
- 30:50going to have to really do an offer of proof
- 30:51at that point, at least with me, you would. And
- 30:54I would think with the other judges you do as
- 30:56well. Now, remember the trial judge keeps control
- 31:00over this and they can choose whether to allow
- 31:02it or not allow it, or they can write the letter
- 31:05themselves. It's really up to them. Okay. Briefly,
- 31:10what we're telling the doctors, this red mark
- 31:13here is actually part of this checklist, by the
- 31:15way. This is not my note to myself. This is a
- 31:18note to everybody. So, We understand that AI
- 31:25is here to stay and that AI is getting better.
- 31:29We know, you know, in medical research, we are
- 31:32allowing our researchers, all 75 of them, to
- 31:36subscribe to AI programs. And Friends Research
- 31:40Institute is paying for them. But there's a rule.
- 31:44That rule is that any time anybody uses AI for
- 31:48anything, there has to be a human being behind
- 31:52it. whatever the outcome is, you have to be the
- 31:56last straw. So if Dr. Smith sends out his medical
- 32:02record review for a summary by an AI company,
- 32:07and that 1600 pages of Kaiser records are summarized
- 32:11by an AI program, he has to disclose that in
- 32:15his report. He has to disclose what AI program,
- 32:20what company he used, or if he used his own software,
- 32:23which one it is, and then he has to attest under
- 32:26penalty of perjury in his declaration that he
- 32:29has reviewed that summary with the applicant
- 32:32and has made his own inquiries of the actual
- 32:35records. Does it mean he has to go through all
- 32:381600 pages of Kaiser records? No, but he has
- 32:42to go over the summary of them to make sure it
- 32:45is accurate. And we want a 95 % accuracy rate.
- 32:50That's what's required. And so if, you know,
- 32:54I listed Gorell and Martina's case at the bottom
- 32:57of this note, I urge all of you to read it. It
- 33:01is a very important case. And there's a whole
- 33:04series of five or six other cases where the appeals
- 33:08board is sanctioning applicants' attorneys and
- 33:11defense attorneys for writing petitions for reconsideration.
- 33:16that have hallucinations. Very clearly those
- 33:21citations are not checked and they don't exist.
- 33:25So even if you're using Gemini or Compass that's
- 33:29built into LexisNexis, you still have a affirmative
- 33:33obligation as licensed attorneys when you sign
- 33:37a petition for recon as to its accuracy. And
- 33:41the same thing is here for doctors when they
- 33:44write their reports. They have to tell us if
- 33:46they're using AI. They have to tell us that they
- 33:51are disclosing the name of the application they're
- 33:57using and they're certifying the accuracy of
- 34:00it. Very, very important point. And we have made
- 34:04this clear to the doctors. By the way, I wrote
- 34:08these two paragraphs and we had a huge argument
- 34:11over it because Dr. Feinberg likes to use AI.
- 34:16And he's very good at it, but he stands behind
- 34:20the product of it, like every physician and lawyer
- 34:23should. Okay. Can other people appear during
- 34:28the med legal evaluation? The answer is yes.
- 34:32Can the applicant bring his or her attorney or
- 34:35somebody from the attorney's office? The answer
- 34:37is yes. How about bringing a court reporter?
- 34:40Sure. How about audio taping it? Absolutely yes.
- 34:44There's no prohibition on it. They just have
- 34:46to be honest that they're doing so. They can't
- 34:48do it so repetitiously. That's not right. There's
- 34:53case law in this, by the way. Otherwise, I wouldn't
- 34:55have put it in red. Okay. Now, you know, you've
- 35:00got to send your declarations to the QME and
- 35:04to the AME about what you are sending them. 4062
- 35:10.3 is very important. ex parte communication
- 35:15statute. Please always, always do that declaration.
- 35:21The cover letter is in process of being approved.
- 35:24You're going to have to use the cover letter.
- 35:27But you really need to include that separate
- 35:30declaration. The cover letter is only a cover
- 35:33letter. You still have to do a declaration once
- 35:35that cover letter comes out as to what documents
- 35:39you're sending to that doctor. And we're telling
- 35:42the doctors here if they don't get the records
- 35:45or if there's a discrepancy, you know, your declaration
- 35:48says, you know, 500 pages and there's only 400
- 35:52or 450 or 499. The doctor is still required by
- 35:58the regulation to issue their report within 30
- 36:01days of the exam and indicating that report,
- 36:05I don't have a complete record, please send them
- 36:07so I can issue a supplemental report. And you
- 36:10just cost the defendants another $1 ,100 to $1
- 36:13,600, plus the cost of over 200 pages. So we
- 36:18want you to really spend some time doing this.
- 36:21Meet and confer. You're not just meeting and
- 36:23conferring. Here's section 35 .5, at least part
- 36:27of it, and 35 as well. It's very important. You
- 36:31look at this. By the way, 4628 of the labor code
- 36:34is one you should read once a year. It's the
- 36:36anti -ghostwriting statute. It's really fun to
- 36:39read. It tells the doctors what they cannot do.
- 36:42Okay. So, and if they do it, then their report
- 36:47is inadmissible. They don't get paid or they
- 36:49have to pay their money back. And that's what's
- 36:52going on in the Gorilla Martinez case. That's
- 36:54why I put it up on your materials. All right.
- 36:57So these are the information that the doctor
- 36:59has to include in the reports. I like to put
- 37:04out for history of present illness, HPI. That's
- 37:07what you see in notes. in records that you review
- 37:10so you know what HPI means. I always tell the
- 37:13doctors, and I'm telling you, always circle back
- 37:16to the mechanism of injury. What's the definition
- 37:20of a specific injury? You know, something, an
- 37:24incident at work that results in a disability,
- 37:28either temporary or temporary partial, temporary
- 37:31total, or permanent partial. or treatment beyond
- 37:35first aid and a follow -up visit. So that's from
- 37:373208 .1, and a CT is repetitive mentally or physically
- 37:42traumatic activities extending over a period
- 37:45of time causing a disability or need for treatment.
- 37:50If you want to know what that means, look up
- 37:52the Coultharpe case. That defines injurious exposure.
- 37:58Now, what we try to tell people is that the date
- 38:03of injury for a CT is different from the injurious
- 38:08exposure. Applicants' attorneys are notorious
- 38:12for writing down one year in their application
- 38:15for adjudication of claim when the applicant
- 38:18did that type of work for 30 years. Think the
- 38:20movie industry. That's wrong. It's misleading
- 38:23to a doctor. So what we tell the doctors here
- 38:27with this checklist is that The date of injury
- 38:31is a totally different legal question, and it's
- 38:33not a medical one. They just have to establish
- 38:36whether there's injurious exposure. So we want
- 38:39them to ask the applicant, how long did you work
- 38:42in this industry? Not how long did you work for
- 38:45this employer? That's a separate question. They
- 38:47can ask that too. Because liability under 5 ,500
- 38:50.5 is a legal question. And the LAPD example
- 38:54is one of my trials that I did as a judge. The
- 38:59applicant was a LAPD officer for 12 years, ending
- 39:03in 1987. He was assigned to a really bad neighborhood
- 39:10with lots of heroin addicts were shooting up.
- 39:14He had to arrest a lot of people who had needles
- 39:17on them. You watch the cop shows. Do you have
- 39:19any needles or sharp things that are going to
- 39:23hurt me or prick me? That's because he worked
- 39:26in a high drug -infested area. Think MacArthur
- 39:29Park, okay, unfortunately. So in 1999, specifically
- 39:36August 8th of 1999, he got diagnosed with hepatitis
- 39:40C, all right? He didn't work since 1987. So I
- 39:46made a finding that the date of injury was August
- 39:498th of 1999. Why did that make a difference?
- 39:52The injurious exposure ended in 1987 after 12
- 39:57years of being a police officer. The date of
- 39:59injury of 1999 made a difference because his
- 40:03PD schedule was in effect in 1999. He was not
- 40:07subjected to the pre -1988 PD schedule. His dollars
- 40:13almost doubled because of that date of injury
- 40:16being established under 5412. So I want you to
- 40:20understand the difference between the date of
- 40:22injury and the injurious exposure period. I encourage
- 40:26applicants, attorneys, when you file an application
- 40:28in a claim form, you include the entire period
- 40:32of injurious exposure. Even though you're making
- 40:35an election against the last year, still make
- 40:39it clear in your pleadings that you're claiming
- 40:42an entire period of injurious exposure. I've
- 40:47had two doctors call me in the last two years.
- 40:50Can there be a CT in one day? The answer is yes.
- 40:54Absolutely yes. I don't have time to give you
- 40:56the examples, but take my word for it. OK. I
- 41:01like to use this example on the treatment. This
- 41:05is an inconsistency in the regulations. 35 .5
- 41:11G2 says a QME or AME cannot provide an opinion
- 41:13on any disputed medical treatment. But when you
- 41:17look at title eight, same title eight, 10682B10,
- 41:23it says treatment indicated including past, present,
- 41:26and future medical treatment. So here's the issue.
- 41:30Can an AME or a QE discuss UR or IMR denials?
- 41:34And the answer, in my opinion, is yes. So let's
- 41:37give you an example. Let's say Dr. Smith, the
- 41:40treating doctor, puts in an RFA for the total
- 41:42knee replacement. There's a timely UR denial
- 41:45saying it doesn't meet the MTUS requirements.
- 41:48Applicant's attorney appeals that to IMR. IMR
- 41:51upholds the denial, says he can't do it for another
- 41:54year, right? No more RFAs for one year from the
- 41:58date of the original RFA. That's what it says
- 42:01in the regulations. But then, lo and behold,
- 42:04three months later, after this denial, the applicant
- 42:07goes to Dr. Smith at QME. And the QME reviews
- 42:11everything that's said, including hopefully applicant's
- 42:14attorney sending the IMR -UR documents. And the
- 42:19doctor takes the appropriate x -rays, AP x -rays,
- 42:23maybe even an MRI scan or a CT scan, and he observes
- 42:27currently zero millimeters of articulating joint
- 42:32in all three of the knee compartments. So he
- 42:36says in his report, I've seen my own x -rays.
- 42:39I've seen the records here. This guy needs a
- 42:42total knee replacement and his TTD until he gets
- 42:45one. Does that supersede the one year? I believe
- 42:49it does. It's newly discovered evidence, as long
- 42:53as it's sent to the PTP. Dear PTP, here's Dr.
- 42:58Smith's QME report. Please take a look at what
- 43:01he says about future medical Can you please put
- 43:04in another RFA and that little nice box is the
- 43:07upper right hand corner? It says change of circumstances
- 43:09You have a change of circumstances here because
- 43:13you have another doctor a QME saying this person
- 43:16needs a total knee replacement So I said this
- 43:20in front of George Parisado during one of our
- 43:22doctor Programs last year and he said afterwards.
- 43:25He said to me that was really really interesting
- 43:28so We'll see what the appeals board does with
- 43:31that. I think that it's a solid argument and
- 43:34it's one that you can take to the bank. It's
- 43:37a way to work around UR denials. Okay, so the
- 43:42doctor needs to also get a notice of what their
- 43:46medication is, what they're taking, and I included
- 43:49cannabis. I added that here. It's the most recent
- 43:52version of it. We also want to know from a patient
- 43:56whether they're adhering to their medications.
- 43:59You know, and I make a note here, studies show
- 44:02even for hypertension prescriptions in America,
- 44:06adherence is only 48%, okay? Psychotropics are
- 44:10even worse than that. We know that because Friends
- 44:13Research Institute has done adherence studies
- 44:15for years. We want to know if people are taking
- 44:18their, you know, opioid antagonist medications
- 44:22like subluxone and buprenorphine. We're trying
- 44:26to do time release formulas for these drugs.
- 44:29So people stay off of opioids. So we know that
- 44:32people don't comply. And, you know, if I asked
- 44:34you to raise your hand, how many of you forgot
- 44:36to take a medication last week, regardless of
- 44:39what kind? I would say half of you would raise
- 44:41your hands. I'm raising my hand. I forgot to
- 44:43take something too. So anyways, we want every
- 44:48doctor who sees a patient for a QMA or an AME
- 44:51to do a mental status evaluation. Make sure that
- 44:55the lights are on and someone's home. Otherwise
- 44:58a report is useless. So, you know, we want to
- 45:02make sure that people are there. And if they're
- 45:05not for the doctors to make a note of it, they're
- 45:08not supposed to diagnose anything. They just
- 45:10have to make sure that the person, you know,
- 45:13time, place and matter is, is current and up
- 45:17to date. All right. Work occupational history.
- 45:21Very interesting thing. That's new. Social Security
- 45:24guidelines used to be for the last 15 years before
- 45:26they became disabled. As of 2024, it changed
- 45:30to the last five years. So what did this injured
- 45:32worker do for the five years before they became
- 45:35disabled? Why is that different? It's because
- 45:38of technology. You know, everybody's reading
- 45:40now about the types of jobs are being eliminated
- 45:43by AI. It's not just AI that's eliminating jobs,
- 45:46it's the economy that's eliminating jobs and
- 45:48creating new ones. So the skills that people
- 45:51developed, 15 years ago are totally irrelevant.
- 45:56Think about it. What was driving your IBM PCs
- 45:5915 years ago and what is it now? We're at Windows
- 46:0211, right? I remember when it was 1 .5. So, you
- 46:07know, those are the differences. We have a huge
- 46:09difference in the way work is done across the
- 46:12board. So look at your last five years. Okay.
- 46:16What happens if a doctor discovers a new pathology?
- 46:19You know, there's a low back injury or the blood
- 46:21pressure is 220 over 110 in an ortho exam. They
- 46:25have to note it. And my notes to you is always,
- 46:29always look at the physical examination part
- 46:32of the case. See if the doctor found something
- 46:34that's not claimed because the burden goes back
- 46:37to the applicant to amend an application and
- 46:40request an additional panel. This is good cause
- 46:42right here. if the doctor is examining somebody
- 46:45for a back injury and they're palpating their
- 46:48abdominal areas to rule out liver disease and
- 46:51other diseases that can mimic a back problem
- 46:54and they find a hernia, you know, gee, that iron
- 46:58worker might have a hernia. So, you know, you
- 47:01have to read these physical exam parts and then
- 47:04act accordingly. Diagnostic studies, big deal
- 47:08here. Does a QME rely on the radiology or other
- 47:11lab reports or do they want to see the films
- 47:13themselves? I've deposed QMEs where they don't
- 47:16know how to read a CAT scan. They don't do a
- 47:19clinical practice other than conservative treatment.
- 47:22They don't do surgeries anymore. So what I want
- 47:26defense attorneys to do, because I get too many
- 47:29DORs for expedited hearings on this, please have
- 47:33the claims examiner pre -authorized diagnostic
- 47:37studies by a medical legal doctor in advance
- 47:40for anything not requiring hospitalization. Do
- 47:44not require them to go to one call. Doctors who
- 47:47are QMEs have a right to go to any diagnostician
- 47:51facility they want. Why? Because it's subject
- 47:55to the same fee schedule as a treating doctor.
- 48:00So they're not obligated to go to a contract
- 48:02facility. If they want to send the person to
- 48:05Cedars -Sinai or to UCLA for a diagnostic imaging
- 48:08study, fine. We will order it as judges. Okay?
- 48:13We are not wed to a contract between a claims
- 48:15administrator and a clearing house for scheduling
- 48:19diagnostic studies. I would rather have my doctor
- 48:22review a study that my doctor has ordered with
- 48:26his buddy, the radiologist, where they go golfing
- 48:28every week and talk about my case. All right?
- 48:31I think applicants are entitled to the same standard.
- 48:34That's my personal opinion. We always tell doctors
- 48:38that causation of injury is separate from causation
- 48:41of PD and to give us a how and why of their conclusions.
- 48:45I'm not going to go very much further on this
- 48:47one. What I want to do instead, I'm going to
- 48:49share quickly the psychiatric one. Here it is.
- 48:54And it looks similar to the other one. And the
- 48:56psychiatric one, we're going to pick up where
- 48:59we left off on the other one in a second. We
- 49:02were the same three principal authors of this.
- 49:05Again, this started back in August of last year.
- 49:09Bobby McDonald, I don't know if you know Dr.
- 49:11McDonald, but she was the kind of the leader
- 49:13of the pack once we did the basics of this. We
- 49:17did this one with applicant defense, judge, doctors.
- 49:21Most of you know Dr. Sones because he's out of
- 49:23UCLA, of course. and Dr. Bocarias, both him and
- 49:29his son. We have a lot of father -son doctors
- 49:34nowadays. David Soanes' son, Alex Soanes, is
- 49:37now at QME. I just met him last week. And so
- 49:42these are really good, solid AME quality doctors.
- 49:46You have AME quality applicant attorney and AME
- 49:49quality defense attorney. So we really went back
- 49:52and forth on this for a long time to come up
- 49:56with information that is useful to the legal
- 49:59community, as well as to the medical community.
- 50:02And what I did on this myself, with the approval
- 50:06of everybody on the panel and the committee,
- 50:08is I deconstructed 3208 .3. I went through every
- 50:14single line of 3208 .3 for best practices. So,
- 50:21you know, we talk about causation of injury,
- 50:24you know, a lot of it is coming from the applicant
- 50:26in that initial examination, you know, to get
- 50:30an idea of what happened chronologically, what
- 50:33kind of pathology did the applicant bring to
- 50:37the actual job. What happened at work? Was it
- 50:42the work itself that was stressful or was it
- 50:45interactions with management or coworkers that
- 50:48was stressful? We get the question all the time.
- 50:51Do I have to do a Rolda analysis in every case?
- 50:54The answer is yes. If you are a psychiatrist
- 50:57or psychologist, because Rolda relates to the
- 51:00causation of injury, not causation of permanent
- 51:04disability. That's a separate analysis, as you
- 51:06know. in general cases, in orthopedic cases,
- 51:10and internal medicine cases. It's always a separate
- 51:13analysis. But in psych, the Rolda analysis has
- 51:17to apply in every case because it relates to
- 51:21the causation of injury. So we give you a listing
- 51:23of information that is required to be done by
- 51:26the doctor in terms of information in the initial
- 51:31evaluation report. Give us a DSM diagnosis. I
- 51:37do want to talk about DSM diagnosis. Which one
- 51:40do we use? There's a whole bunch of them. 32
- 51:43.8 .3A talks about, just above here, it's quoted
- 51:49in this form, I actually put it in here, the
- 51:53terminology diagnostic criteria of other psychiatric
- 51:55diagnostic manuals generally approved and accepted
- 51:58nationally. Okay, so DSM -5 tech revision came
- 52:02out last year. It is the result of extensive
- 52:07research, more research than any of the other
- 52:10DSM versions. And even though the DSM -IV has
- 52:14a GAF code, conversion to whole person impairment,
- 52:19that doesn't matter. We use the DSM -V text revision
- 52:23for diagnosis only. It's only when you get maximum
- 52:28medical improvement do you use the GAF whole
- 52:32person impairment conversion table in the PD
- 52:35schedule. So it's not the DSM -IV anymore, it's
- 52:38the PD schedule when it comes to permanent disability.
- 52:41Is that going to change in legislation next year?
- 52:43Who knows? I'm not in the legislature, I can't
- 52:45tell you. But I recommend using the DSM -V text
- 52:49revision. I recommended it to the docs. It's
- 52:51a consensus among us who wrote this, including
- 52:54psychiatrists and the academic psychiatrists,
- 52:57use the DSM -V text revision because it is the
- 53:02most research based. It's not just the United
- 53:05States, it's also Canada and the World Health
- 53:08Organization. And not only that, they interviewed
- 53:10family members of people who have mental illnesses
- 53:14to get an idea of what their behavioral aspects
- 53:17are. So it's a very robust section in there.
- 53:21Don't cherry pick the diagnosis. I have a definition
- 53:25here, preponderance of the evidence. This comes
- 53:28from, this all comes from the large case and
- 53:31from Roald Depp. Okay. I'm not going to read
- 53:35this to you. Then we have the violent act with
- 53:37the 30 to 35 and 40%. The issue of what constitutes
- 53:43a violent act is a legal conclusion. Read the
- 53:45Wilson case. The determination of whether their
- 53:50substantial cause is a medical issue. Whether
- 53:54something is, you know, a good faith personnel
- 53:56defense under subsection H, that too is a legal
- 54:01question. The doctor has to tell us the percentage
- 54:04of causation here. Let me show you that. By the
- 54:07way, the six months of employment does not need
- 54:09to be continuous. We have case law that we talk
- 54:12about here. An injury must be both sudden and
- 54:15extraordinary if it's less than six months of
- 54:17employment. And then we go into the post termination
- 54:20defenses, which is the defense attorney's dream,
- 54:23because you get to do a lot of discovery. All
- 54:26right. So subsection H is here. I quote it. We
- 54:29quote it completely. And we tell you, the doctors,
- 54:33that they cannot determine what a personnel action
- 54:36is or if the personnel actions were lawful, nondiscriminatory,
- 54:40and in good faith. We do what's called a Fujitomo
- 54:44chart here. More than one cause of the psychiatric
- 54:48condition is occurring. And I like you to kind
- 54:52of use this as your template when you cross -examine
- 54:54a doctor to kind of have a doctor break this
- 54:57down if they can. Sometimes you don't need to.
- 54:59You know, if you have a serious injury with a
- 55:03psychiatric component to it, that's catastrophic.
- 55:06Or as a result of a violent act, you don't need
- 55:09to do this template. You still have to do the
- 55:11roll -dead analysis. So anyways, I got about
- 55:14five minutes left. I do want to jump down at
- 55:17the end of this and show you. I already talked
- 55:21about personnel actions. Here's Avakian again.
- 55:24I don't need to repeat it. I'm going to go down
- 55:27to the end. Again, we have best practices, we
- 55:30have all kinds of information, what constitutes
- 55:34a CT, and we walk you through all of the information
- 55:38for a medical or legal report on a psychiatric
- 55:42basis. I have a very large discussion of apportionment.
- 55:46I think Judge Corio would like it. I'm sure he
- 55:50does. We have a discussion of vigil here, a vacuums
- 55:54repeated. So here we have, and the same form
- 55:57here is in the regular medical legal quality
- 56:01assurance checklist, ADL metrics, body part one,
- 56:04two, three, four, could be psych, could be one
- 56:07of those body parts. And here's table one dash
- 56:10two on page four of the guides on the left. And
- 56:13it gives a doctor a visual guideline. These forms
- 56:18are not required. These templates are not required,
- 56:20by the way. These charts are not. They're only
- 56:24for the purpose of assisting the doctor to write
- 56:29their narrative reports. It's a visual aid. Same
- 56:34thing here, a visual aid for the doctor to kind
- 56:38of think about those functions, including work
- 56:42functions. This is optional. You notice we say
- 56:45at the top of this, this is optional. It's not
- 56:48required. None of this is required. But we want
- 56:52someone to think about how each body part affects
- 56:56their ADL functioning. And sometimes you have
- 56:59to do work restrictions and activities of daily
- 57:02living to comprise that. Especially, you know,
- 57:08cognitive behavioral limitations, workday tolerances,
- 57:13sustained tolerances. I had them put meds in
- 57:16here, metabolic equivalent testing. I wanted
- 57:20that in here because that sometimes becomes important
- 57:23for cardiac conditions. Anyway, so that's that's
- 57:28kind of it. I am hoping that you all are happy
- 57:34and everything has gone well for this seminar.
- 57:38I could use another half hour at least to do
- 57:40this. I'm back up and you know I want to thank
- 57:45everybody for attending and if you have questions
- 57:49I'm sure that Mr. Filati will have some. If not,
- 57:55I can always come back and do a part two of this
- 57:58if you want. Anyways, I want to thank everybody
- 58:01for your attendance and it's been fun to do this
- 58:06program. And I look forward to seeing you in
- 58:08person in department one at the WCAB in Los Angeles.
- 58:12I'm there on Mondays, Tuesdays and Wednesdays
- 58:16in person unless there is a holiday during that
- 58:21week. If so, I'm not there. I travel. Next week
- 58:24I'll be at the WCI conference in Florida, in
- 58:27Orlando. I'm on two panels there. And I look
- 58:31forward to seeing any of you who are going to
- 58:33Florida tomorrow or for next week. It's a wonderful
- 58:36event. It's about a mile or so outside of Disney
- 58:40World. And it's the largest Marriott hotel I've
- 58:43ever seen in my life. It's about 6 ,000 people
- 58:46who attend the conference. And it's a lot of
- 58:51fun to talk to see everybody from literally every
- 58:56aspect of workers comp in the country. So I wish
- 58:59you all well. And if you have questions, send
- 59:02them to Mr. Falati. He will get back to me or
- 59:06Beverly Hills administrators will get back to
- 59:08me and I'll be able to respond to questions.
- 59:11Please don't ask questions about specific cases.
- 59:14I can't answer those for you. Have a good weekend
- 59:17and we look forward to seeing you again sometime
- 59:21in the future.