Latest / Bourbon Bytes Podcast / Bourbon Boos Finale 💀: The Smokiest Surprise Yet - Smokehead Single Malt Scotch Review
Transcript
- 0:00Hey everyone, this is Clifton. Before we get into today's episode, I do want to say I had a bit of
- 0:04a technical difficulty with today's episode. I recorded a couple of additional news stories,
- 0:09but for some reason they became corrupt during the export. So not sure what happened there,
- 0:14so I'll save those for next week. Nothing pressing, nothing too crazy, but just wanted
- 0:19to let you guys know why today's episode is a little bit shorter. But yeah, stay tuned,
- 0:23this should be a fun one. Today on the Bourbon Bytes podcast,
- 0:27I'm sharing new whiskeys from across the industry, including Heaven Hill's new
- 0:31Grain To Glass Specialty Barrel series, a Glenlivet aged in Jamaican rum casks,
- 0:37this year's new release of a Midwinter's Night Dram, and more. Plus I'm doing my final
- 0:42'Bourbon Boos' review of Smokehead Single Malt Islay Whiskey.
- 0:59Hello everyone and welcome to the Bourbon Bytes podcast. I'm your host Clifton,
- 1:03and this is the week of Thursday, October 30th, 2025. We are entering our final week of my bourbon
- 1:10boos series, and this week we have a whiskey that is actually a whiskey, believe it or not.
- 1:17This week we'll actually be reviewing an Islay Single Malt with a very spooky logo on it,
- 1:23but we have some whiskey news to get into first before we do the byte-sized review.
- 1:27As with previous weeks, we are going to list off a ton of new and upcoming releases that
- 1:33were announced this month, and many of these I am very, very excited for. I'm just going to
- 1:37dive right into it with the first one that hit my inbox earlier last week actually, and this is the
- 1:44new Heaven Hill Grain to Glass Specialty Barrel series. Now as with the original Grain to Glass
- 1:50series that came out a while back, each release begins with corn seed varietals chosen annually
- 1:56in partnership with Beck's Hybrids, but this year they are taking it a step further with a barrel
- 2:02selection that complements the corn type. So with the help of the Independent Stave Company,
- 2:07Heaven Hill's Master Distiller selects a barrel. This year they chose chinkapin oak, which we've
- 2:13been hearing a lot about. A lot of releases are using chinquapin oak these days, but they say this
- 2:18is a rare white oak native to Missouri that was chosen for its unique character, and it's going
- 2:24to be available for all three of the releases, including the Kentucky Straight bourbon whiskey,
- 2:28the Kentucky Straight wheated bourbon whiskey, and the Kentucky Straight rye whiskey. I think the
- 2:33most recent whiskey that I've had that's used chinquapin oak has been the Shenk's Homestead
- 2:39from Michter's, and I think it does have a significant impact on the flavor of the whiskey.
- 2:45Would I choose it for three different whiskeys? I don't know, but maybe something this year
- 2:51with the corn varietal. It just works really, really well. Now I will admit that I've not had
- 2:56a chance to try any of the Heaven Hill Grain to Glass series, mainly because I've heard mixed
- 3:01reviews on it, and the price is pretty up there for what it is. It's relatively younger whiskey.
- 3:07I do love to see the experimentation and collaboration with farmers and
- 3:11specific farms. That's really cool to me, but this is definitely a try-before-I-buy type of whiskey,
- 3:17and I just have not had a chance to try it. I would be curious to try it side by side with
- 3:21previous releases that use typical American white oak compared to this chinkapin oak. I think that
- 3:28would be a really fun comparison. Usually we see chinkapin used as a finishing cask, but from my
- 3:34understanding it seems like this release was aged entirely in this oak. They do say these are all at
- 3:39least six years old, and the series is going to continue with different oak casks. This is just
- 3:45the first in the series of releases. So very interesting, but it's definitely a try-before-I-buy
- 3:50like I said. But we're not stopping there with the new releases. Just saw that an email came
- 3:55through about the new Bunnahaban 12-year cask strength for 2025. I've bought two previous
- 4:01years releases for this and have absolutely loved that whiskey. This one though, the price has gone
- 4:07up a relatively decent amount. It's gone up to $149 MSRP. The ABV on this one is 56.4%,
- 4:17which is in line kind of with what they usually do. But yeah, the price is an 82% increase over
- 4:24last year's bottle. And you know, I know price increases are inevitable, but such a massive
- 4:29increase, I think that's what people are mostly talking about. I will say in the past this has
- 4:33kind of been an instant buy for me when I see it for, I think it's like usually, well let's see,
- 4:3782%. That's more math that I'm willing to do right now, but I know it's previously been,
- 4:41under, I would say $80 and it's been like an instant buy. But this one, I'm definitely not
- 4:47going to be pulling the trigger on it because to me, it's a great whiskey and it's always been
- 4:52one of the favorites on my shelf for the price. But for something that drastically different in
- 4:58price, it's going to have to be a much better whiskey. And until I try it, I'm not going to
- 5:04put the money down for that, but sad to see it because I've really enjoyed this release.
- 5:08Like I said, I had the 2024 and I think I had the 22 release of it and have usually, you know,
- 5:13really wanted to seek it out, but not for 82% higher of a price. Now there is a new Glenlivet
- 5:2012-year-old that is called the Jamaica edition, which is pretty fun. I love the bright
- 5:26colors on the label. This one is a 12-year-old single malt scotch that has been finished in
- 5:31Jamaican rum casks. Jamaican rum is typically a more of a funky rum. It's not one of my go-tos,
- 5:37but I know it's used in a lot of really great tiki cocktails that I'm a fan of.
- 5:42I think a funky rum is always a fun addition to a finishing cask. I've had a rye whiskey,
- 5:49I think from Doc Swinson's called the Funky Drummer that was also finished in Jamaican rum cask. And I
- 5:55really loved the unique twist that it gave the whiskey. I think Glenlivet is such a,
- 6:01I don't want to say like basic whiskey, but a approachable, not too nuanced whiskey. I think
- 6:08adding something like that to a Jamaican rum cask could allow for a really fun flavor experience. So
- 6:15I'll keep an eye out. Retail on that's about $55. I think that's a very fair price. And
- 6:20traditionally I've kind of liked some of these fun finishing casks, so I'm keeping an eye out
- 6:25for that one for sure. Another new announcement is the 12-year edition of Old Overholt Cast Strength.
- 6:30This has been a release they've been putting out every year and always goes up one year in age,
- 6:35so I feel like they're dealing with the same stock of whiskey that they're just holding some
- 6:38of it back. I will say the 10-year version of this was absolutely delicious. One of my favorite
- 6:45whiskeys I've ever had from Jim Beam. I was lucky enough to buy a backup bottle of that last year
- 6:50and compared to the 11-year that came out in 24, there's no comparison. The 10-year to me was a
- 6:56drastically better whiskey. So I'm hopeful that this one is going to be right there with the 10-year,
- 7:04maybe a little less like the 11-year, but I definitely want to do a comparison. I am almost
- 7:09out of my 10-year. I need to save a sample so I can do a 10, 11, and 12 comparison. Retail on this is
- 7:15$110. ABV will range between 53% and 65% because it is bottled at Cask Strength. So that's on my
- 7:23must-buy list, at least to do a comparison for the channel. I think I talked about this a couple
- 7:27weeks back when it was first announced, but now that it's out, High West has released their 13th
- 7:32act of A Midwinter Night's Dram Rye. This one's coming in at a retail of $150. ABV is $48.3.
- 7:40Always been a fan of this release, but it's still creeping up there in price. I think last year,
- 7:45or it was actually two years ago, I bought it for $120. Now it's up to $150. I still will probably
- 7:52buy a bottle, let's be real. I have the opportunity to buy one through my local liquor store, and I
- 7:57haven't done that yet, but I just really love this release year over year, and it always, to me,
- 8:03drinks like a high-end whiskey. So even with the price increase, I think, at least for now,
- 8:08I'm willing to give it a shot. Now this is aged for four to ten years old. It's combining both
- 8:14MGP's distillate and High West's distillate. They don't tell you exactly how much, but I know over
- 8:19time, more of High West's whiskey is going to go into this. So again, it's one that I have just
- 8:25loved personally. I love a port cask on a rye whiskey, and High West is one of the best ones
- 8:32I've ever had that do it. Now there's some more affordable options that do it almost as good,
- 8:37from Old Scout, one in particular. That one is a favorite of mine, but I still think A Midwinter's
- 8:43Night's Dram is one of my favorite limited edition releases, and it's one that's not
- 8:47extremely hard to get my hands on, so yeah, I'll probably pick it up. All right, well,
- 8:53as I mentioned, this week's episode of Bourbon Boos isn't as scary as previous weeks,
- 8:58because we have an actual whiskey here to review, not a spirit drink as we did last week. So this
- 9:04is one that I've seen staring at me on the shelves for pretty much all year, and I thought, what
- 9:09better time to review it than around the Halloween season? This episode's coming out the day before
- 9:15Halloween, so I thought it was an appropriate one to review for today's episode. This is
- 9:21Smokehead Islay Single Malt Scotch Whiskey, and there's a few different releases of this. I just
- 9:26picked up the basic one just to kind of get a baseline impression of this brand, and it's
- 9:32actually bottled by Ian Macleod Distillers, based in Scotland, of course. They actually own three
- 9:38different distilleries, Glengoyne, Tamdu, and Rosebank, and one gin distillery, actually,
- 9:43Edinburgh Gin, is owned by them as well. But this lineup from them, the Smokehead series,
- 9:49is from an undisclosed Islay distillery. There are some theories about where it's from, but nothing
- 9:55official is out there, so we're just going to go into this assuming it's from probably one of the
- 9:59major ones, maybe some of their younger distillate. Of course, this one isn't age-stated, but it's at
- 10:04least three years old. I know some of their other releases do have ages on them, but this one is
- 10:10their most approachable pricing-wise from the lineup. This one was only $35 on sale. I think
- 10:17retail on it's $40. Of course, it is a Spirits Direct brand from Total Wine, so you can often
- 10:22get it at a cheaper price. But yeah, I thought I would pick this up because one, it is very
- 10:28Halloween-y, and two, that's a very affordable price for a single malt Isla whiskey. By the way,
- 10:34this comes in at 43% ABV, which is better than expected with it being such an affordable bottle.
- 10:40There's really not much information on the back of the bottle itself. It just says,
- 10:44it is intensely rich yet subtly sweet. Smokehead embodies a wild spirit and appeals to those
- 10:49with an appreciation for heavy, earthy peat. With immense smoke and notes of sea salt and spice,
- 10:55this is a vigorous whiskey that stands out from the crowd. But other than that, I really don't
- 11:00know much about it, but I had to give it a try for you guys. Let's go ahead and get it poured.
- 11:05Ooh, ooh, on the nose, this is actually pretty pleasant. I mean, if you are a fan of peated
- 11:09scotch, it's not too crazy with the peat. To me, it's almost more like a smoked barbecue note,
- 11:16a little bit sweet, definitely some ashiness there as well. It's not overwhelming my palate like
- 11:21some peated scotches do. I would say it's a little bit of like a maritime kind of peat,
- 11:25a little bit of like an ocean spray kind of note. The actual ocean spray, not like cranberry juice,
- 11:30but it's got a sweetness to it that actually I'm enjoying quite a bit compared with that peat.
- 11:35Kind of more of like a candy, like a caramel sweetness compared to like a fruitiness.
- 11:39And I wouldn't expect too much of like a fruitiness on this anyways. As much as I love
- 11:43my sherry cask and port cask single malt Islay scotches, this one is not cask finish, I believe.
- 11:51Some of the other lineup is though. All right, let's go ahead and give it a taste. Cheers.
- 11:56Hmm. Okay. Yeah. I mean, it's definitely smoky. You can usually tell from like a younger Islay scotch,
- 12:05the smoke kind of dominates and that's kind of what's happening here. But I do actually think
- 12:11the proof works in its favor, you know, being low proof. It's not kind of like blowing your socks off
- 12:16with the peat. It actually gives you some time to kind of process it and really think about what's
- 12:21going on before you try to quickly down it. And surprisingly, this one has a really nice finish
- 12:28on it. Even just from the first sip, it's lingering on the palate and it's going really sweet on the
- 12:33back end. Up front still, there's that maritime kind of smokiness, a bit of ashiness, almost a
- 12:37little bit of like cigar, like some tobacco, not like burned tobacco, but more of like a tobacco
- 12:44leaf. But as it goes across the mid palate and finish, it goes into that sweet direction. Like
- 12:48I said, caramel, a little bit of like butterscotch I'm getting there. And all the way through the
- 12:52finish, that smoke is kind of goes down very, very easily. Wow. I don't know what I was expecting
- 12:58going into this being, you know, a sub $40 bottle. It's probably one of the least expensive
- 13:03Islai single malts I've ever had. I mean, even some of my favorite blends from Islay or whiskeys that
- 13:08do use Islay whiskey in it. I had a pour of Peat Monster actually earlier today, just because I
- 13:13know I'd be reviewing this. That one drank really, really nicely and a bit more complex than this
- 13:17one, but that's, you know, $20 more and it's a blended malt versus a single malt. So I think
- 13:23what Smokehead has done here is actually pretty impressive for the price. I wouldn't say it's
- 13:28necessarily an entry-level Islay unless you just don't know what smoke tastes like. I think there
- 13:32are other ways to ease into it if you're not familiar with a smoky palate. But what's
- 13:38interesting is, like I said, they have quite a few bottles in this lineup. They all have really
- 13:42colorful labels. One I'm very interested in, they have a 15-year edition of it for $65. So for 30
- 13:48bucks more, you're getting an age statement, still the same ABV. They also have what they call a high
- 13:54voltage release for 60 and that one comes in at 58% ABV. So honestly, I am very impressed by this
- 14:02entry-level into their lineup. I don't think it's, you know, the most complex isla in the world.
- 14:07I think it's, you know, relatively simple in terms of complexity. But it's a really nice experience
- 14:14and like I said, that finish is really surprising for such a moderately priced bottle. So in terms
- 14:19of ranking, you know, I consider all things including price, availability, um, you know,
- 14:24flavor, of course. And this one, it impresses me in a lot of different ways. I'm gonna have to give
- 14:29that a 8 out of 10, all things considered. While it doesn't have some of the complexity and nuance
- 14:35that, you know, a lot of namesake single malt scotches do, it makes up for it in price and
- 14:41availability. I mean, uh, it's really hard to find fault in this other than the fact that it is young
- 14:46and it's a little bit, you know, simplistic in terms of complexity. But again, it's a $35 bottle.
- 14:52You have to think of it from that perspective. And I think for that, you're, you're hard-pressed
- 14:56to find another Islay single malt in that price range. I mean, yeah, this one is definitely one
- 15:02worth trying, especially some of their higher end items in their lineup. This makes me really
- 15:06curious to explore. Like I said, they're 15 year, they have a sherry one, a stout cask, a tequila
- 15:11cask. Um, and of course that high voltage, uh, version of Smokehead. So yeah. Wow. Ending bourbon
- 15:18boos with a bang. So that does it for this week's episode of the podcast. Thank you all for
- 15:24listening. Thank you for entertaining my 'Bourbon Boos' series. Um, let me know if you guys want to
- 15:28see more themed months. Uh, not quite sure. Maybe we could do a holiday one coming up in November,
- 15:33December. Not quite sure what we're doing yet, but I look forward to bringing you more episodes.
- 15:38Uh, make sure to follow me on your favorite podcast platform. If you can leave a rating,
- 15:41please do. If you leave a review, I'm happy to read it out here on the podcast.
- 15:45Of course, if you want to leave a voicemail message, you're always welcome to do that.
- 15:49You can give me a ring at 9 1 6 6 4 2 9 8 3 7 or 9 1 6 64 bites. Of course, follow me everywhere
- 15:57on the web bourbonbytes.com has all my links, but most of all, thank you so much for listening.
- 16:02Cheers. And I'll talk to you guys next episode.