Latest / Chatter that Matters / Phil De Luna - Dreaming and Doing
Transcript
- 0:04We've all heard the expression, a picture's worth a 1,000 words.
- 0:10You know, the idea is that a complex idea or message can be delivered
- 0:13more effectively with a single image that sort
- 0:17of lets you create the narrative. But does the opposite
- 0:21hold true? What about a single word or a few words? Can
- 0:25they capture a 100 years? A 1000 years?
- 0:29And when you think about the 17th 18th century, it's
- 0:32been framed the age of enlightenment for good reason. We
- 0:36focused on reason, science, individual exchange, democracy,
- 0:40and the separation of church and state. Building from the
- 0:4418th 19th centuries, the industrial revolution, that significant
- 0:47shift in economic and social structures, rapid technological
- 0:51advancements, urbanization, changes in labor practices.
- 0:56And as we close the 19th century, the the concept of nationalism,
- 1:00this need for self determination, redrawing borders, forming new
- 1:03states. 20th century, the civil rights movement, particularly in
- 1:07the states, secured equal rights and end racial segregation.
- 1:12I'd say the end of 20th century, maybe globalization was the word,
- 1:15as we saw how the digital revolution could interconnect economies
- 1:19and cultures and societies. Key question to you is, what do you think will
- 1:23define this century? Will it be that pandemic,
- 1:26artificial intelligence, upheaval, migration, climate
- 1:30change? Or if all of these headwinds coming together, and we're
- 1:34gonna frame it the age of complexity as we battle, or the age of
- 1:37creativity
- 1:44And this year, I want to devote a few of my episodes to breakthroughs, And
- 1:46this year, I want to devote a few of my episodes to breakthroughs
- 1:50that could solve some of our biggest problems. Today, I want to talk
- 1:54about RBC Capture. A Canadian company called Deep 6,
- 1:58and a 33 year old as one of the smartest and most
- 2:02energetic individuals I've ever interviewed on Chatter That
- 2:05Matters. His name is Phil De Luna. He's a chief carbon scientist
- 2:09and head of engineering at Deep Key, a firm focused on carbon
- 2:13removal. Imagine the year is 2050. It's the day that we
- 2:16declared victory in our fight against climate change. We live in a
- 2:20net zero world. Humanity finally removes more carbon
- 2:24from the atmosphere than we emit. But none of this is real.
- 2:28But at h Three, he's managed to accomplish a few other things,
- 2:32including a Governor General's Gold Medal winner, Material Science.
- 2:35He's ranked in the top 1% of the world in his field. He's a member
- 2:39of the College of the Royal Society of Canada, an adjunct professor of
- 2:42Materials Science and Engineering at the University of Toronto, a Forbes top 30
- 2:46under 30. He's worked at McKinsey, and he's
- 2:50also had political ambitions. This
- 2:53is Chatter that matters with Tony Chapman presented by
- 2:57RBC.
- 3:03Phil De Luna, welcome to Chatter That Matters. If I can be
- 3:07so personal, how old are you? I'm 32. So how is it
- 3:10possible at age 32 you've accomplished so much? I don't know.
- 3:14I guess I get bored easily. I always try to find a new talent.
- 3:17No. Honestly, I owe a lot of what I've been able to do to
- 3:21the mentors in my life, and whenever you see someone who's
- 3:25successful or you think is successful and they have this impressive CV, you have to
- 3:29remember that there are so many people that help them along the way. And
- 3:32no one gets to where they are their own. And I appreciate that. Maybe I
- 3:35was gonna save this towards the end of the show, but we were on and
- 3:38talking about mentorship. And I was reading about you, and you give
- 3:42so much credit to both your parents and your wife.
- 3:46And let's just start about your your parents, where they're from,
- 3:49and the fact that they came to Canada and all the reasons why. Yeah.
- 3:53So my parents I'm Filipino. I was born in Taiwan,
- 3:57actually, but my parents were temporary foreign workers there,
- 4:01when they were around my age or in their early thirties. They weren't supposed to
- 4:04have a kid, but, surprise, I was born. Then I moved to Canada when I
- 4:08was 5 years old, grew up in Windsor, Ontario. My dad, who is an
- 4:12engineer in the Philippines, was an auto worker in Windsor, automotive
- 4:16capital of of Canada right next to Detroit. My mom, like Tony
- 4:19typical, immigrant women, worked in customer service.
- 4:23We didn't have much money growing up. I remember one night, my dad was working
- 4:27a night shift, and my mom was working, a night shift as well.
- 4:31And because we couldn't find or afford a babysitter, she just brought me to the
- 4:34hotel that she was working at, and I stayed in one of the empty rooms.
- 4:38I don't know to this day whether she was allowed to do that or
- 4:41not, but I just remember that very vividly as one of the earliest memories I
- 4:45have as a kid. Anyway, so that was an auto worker. Mom worked
- 4:49customer up for a sec because your dad was you just you just rolled it
- 4:52off. And I hear this so often, these immigrants coming to Canada
- 4:55searching for a better life. But he was an engineer. He had that
- 4:59in his knapsack, and yet he's forced to do shift work. How did you
- 5:03feel that made him feel? Because I've always questioned the
- 5:07sense of chasing a dream and then all of a sudden being having cement poured
- 5:11on your feet. You know, it's interesting you asked that because I think for both
- 5:14of my parents, they knew what they were giving up in order to come here
- 5:17and that knew the sacrifices that they would have to make in order to give
- 5:20their kids a better life. And so I I'm sure it
- 5:24was difficult. I know it was difficult. He worked
- 5:27shift work. There were some times where he'd be driving home from work, and
- 5:31he'd fall asleep at the wheel at the intersection. And he wouldn't know how long
- 5:34he'd be out for, but he'd wake up and the light would be Three, and
- 5:37someone would be honking behind him. It could have been a few seconds. It could
- 5:40have been a few minutes. I hope that least what I've been able to achieve
- 5:43and what my sister is doing right now, is some some
- 5:47modicum of accomplishment. And, you know, my parents had always said
- 5:51growing up that, people can take things away from you, but they can never take
- 5:54away what you know. And that's why education is so important, and,
- 5:59I've I've always taken that to heart. Where did the love of science come from?
- 6:02I mean, you know, you you roll off at age 32, and I just spent
- 6:05half the podcast interview talking about your resume. So it had to begin somewhere. Yeah.
- 6:09I mean, I I'd always loved science as a kid. Magic School Bus was my
- 6:13favorite TV show growing up. I would always beg my parents for
- 6:17some change so I could buy, little chemistry kits at the Scholastic book
- 6:20fair. I don't even know if they still have those, but that I remember that
- 6:24again. It's a walk on memory lane for me on this podcast.
- 6:27I don't know where it come comes from, to be honest with you. I just
- 6:30always knew that I love science, that it was a a curiosity of
- 6:34mine, and that I wanted to understand the world and discover new
- 6:37things. You're Filipino. You're growing up in Windsor. So you're not, I
- 6:41would say, part of the majority. Did you find in school
- 6:45that the sense of the science brain allowed you to find like minded
- 6:48people and create a community? Or, you know, this combination of your
- 6:52ethnicity and your love for science kinda made you not part of the
- 6:56cool kids, not having that table at the cafeteria everybody wanted to sit at?
- 7:00You know, I unfortunately, I would say it's the second piece. And I would, I
- 7:03would actually say that I downplayed, my intelligence when I was a
- 7:07bit of a kid. I tried to be more of a a social troublemaker,
- 7:11very talkative, very social kind of guy. And, you know, to be honest with
- 7:14you, I just wanted to belong, like, with everyone else. But, you know, growing up
- 7:17in Windsor, I was one of the only Filipino kids, if not the only Filipino
- 7:21kid in my class. Again, another childhood memory. I remember coming to school
- 7:24with, this adobo chicken and and fried rice,
- 7:28for lunch. Today, I'm, like, craving it, just talking about it. But when
- 7:32I was a kid, I was like, I just want a peanut butter and jelly
- 7:35sandwich next to me. I can't trade any of my food with
- 7:39them. And so I I remember, like, shame shamefully, you know,
- 7:42before lunch would start, I, like, I threw it out. I threw out the
- 7:46chicken and rice because I didn't want my classmates to know that that's what I
- 7:50was bringing, and I just pretend like I didn't have anything that day. I didn't
- 7:53hide away from being smart or anything like that, but, you
- 7:57know, I I thought that there was the stereotype of, oh, yeah. Yes. He's Asian,
- 8:01so he has to be good at math. And if there's one thing you'll know
- 8:04about me, you could see that my career, I hate to be pegged in any
- 8:07one box. I hate to be called any one thing, and so I'm always
- 8:11constantly trying to improve and reinvent and evolve myself.
- 8:14And did you ever take that troublemaker out of you? Because what you know, I
- 8:17first was reading about you. I said that is gonna be a very serious interview,
- 8:20but it's gonna be a lot of fun. I mean, did you ever did it
- 8:23ever leave you, or is that kinda one of the things that defines you is
- 8:26the sense that status quo, process
- 8:30and rules aren't necessarily the best way to lead
- 8:34someone of your of your Three? Absolutely. It's it's absolutely
- 8:38something that's defined me, and it's something that I've had to keep in check. You
- 8:41know, it's interesting. When I was at the National Research Council of Canada, for example,
- 8:45when I was working the government, you know, I often felt that I was pushing
- 8:48the boundaries, and I was frustrated by the pace that the government was moving
- 8:51at. And I was seen as a sort of young, and
- 8:55and it's funny because when you go into a large organization that is hierarchical,
- 8:59being a young person, you can be discounted because you don't
- 9:03necessarily have experience. But I would actually take that on its head and say,
- 9:06Key, I'm young, so I don't know any better. Why don't we try this? Why
- 9:09don't we do that? And, you know, oftentimes, it would work. I would
- 9:13do things that were, you know, bending the rules in some ways,
- 9:17but they were effective. And then people would just chalk it up, oh, he's just
- 9:20young and he he doesn't have kids yet. He doesn't know how the way the
- 9:22world works, etcetera, etcetera. And I would I would take that, and I would use
- 9:26it. So, being a little bit of a troublemaker, I don't think the party's
- 9:30ever really left me. And I know I I inherit that a little bit of
- 9:33that from my parents as well that, you know, my dad who's had a rebellious
- 9:36Three. He's always controversial, always talking at the dinner table about,
- 9:40whatever the the latest political thing was to rile people up. And I I
- 9:44don't know if he ever believed anything he said. He just wanted to see a
- 9:46reaction. So I think I've I think I've kept a bit of that. Talk to
- 9:49me a little bit about university. You go for your master's in
- 9:53science. Mhmm. And along the way, you know, you just you say, you know, I
- 9:57probably to your teacher, I'm pretty excited. I'm gonna go after my PhD.
- 10:00And they say you're not good enough. That's almost like Delco Records saying to
- 10:04that Beatles, we think guitar and rock and roll bands are done. What do
- 10:08you do as a young person? Because there's a lot of young people that
- 10:12get rejected all the time, as you said, because of their age or their stigma.
- 10:15Like, what did you do to kinda use that to your advantage? Yeah. So for
- 10:19a bit of context, I did my master's at the University of Ottawa, and I
- 10:23did it in computational chemistry using computers to solve
- 10:26chemistry problems. And in that field, my professor was this guy who
- 10:30was really interested in method development. There's kind of 2 types of people in the
- 10:34space, those who like to code and build the tools and those who like
- 10:38to apply them. I'm more of an application guy. I like, I'm big picture thinking,
- 10:41less than the details. And so we clashed. And it was a very valuable
- 10:45lesson for me, actually, which was understand the people that you
- 10:49work with, the people that are your mentors, your supervisors, their working style, what
- 10:53they value, what they what how they operate, and make sure that it
- 10:56matches with what you want. And in that situation, it just didn't match.
- 11:00And, you know, I I I think he was probably judging my coding ability. I'm
- 11:04not the best at Python. And he felt, oh, this guy is not gonna be
- 11:07good enough to do, a PhD. Despite the fact, by the way, that I had
- 11:10published a couple of papers in my masters, more so
- 11:14than anyone else in my cohort, I took that as a piece of evidence.
- 11:18Right? Like, I was very analytical about it, and I said, okay. Do I wanna
- 11:21do this? The answer had always been yes. 100%. Am I gonna let this guy
- 11:25tell me that I can't? And then I looked at okay. Do I
- 11:28have the intrinsics to do this? I have public I have publications.
- 11:33I I I think about things and, you know, and so I decided, screw
- 11:37it. I'm gonna apply to every single university that's better than this one. I'm
- 11:40gonna have the best PhD. I'm gonna publish more papers than this guy's ever
- 11:44published in his life. And I did. And, you
- 11:47know, it's it's funny to say, but spike can be a very strong motivational
- 11:51factor sometimes, and, I certainly use it that. A lot of people maybe
- 11:55that are sports fans wanna understand this, but I do because I've actually
- 11:59had the privilege of talking to some PhDs. I mean, you were published over
- 12:0250 times in university, cited over 16 1,000 times. I
- 12:06mean, those are kinda Michael Jordan numbers, aren't they? They're those are pretty
- 12:10that's a lot of effort and a lot of thinking and a lot of peer
- 12:13to peer reviews giving you a thumbs up. Yeah. A lot of writing. A lot
- 12:16of a lot of writing. No. I mean, I again, I
- 12:20was very lucky and I, to to land at a university with
- 12:24a professor who believes in me. My my PhD supervisor was
- 12:28professor Ted Sargent, and and he's a bit of a savant himself. You know,
- 12:31he's not a typical academic. He runs his lab like a company. You know, you
- 12:35have deliverables. You have hierarchy. You have, projects that
- 12:38have strict timelines and stage gates. It's it it taught me a
- 12:42lot about how high operating organizations function
- 12:46and entrepreneurial organizations function, but it was all within
- 12:50the academic setting, so we had a lot more freedom. And I was able to
- 12:53publish a few papers, you know, multiple in science and nature with
- 12:57that professor. And, again, you know, it's it was about
- 13:00the team atmosphere, about meeting on and building upon
- 13:04the work that others had done before you. And, I
- 13:08I I I owe a lot of my career to to Ted. I do find
- 13:12it's challenging to recreate the excitement and
- 13:15atmosphere you had in that lab. You talked about going to the research
- 13:19council and such. You're the young person. I mean, do you ever you ever go,
- 13:22oh, those that's the kind of situation I always wanna set myself up in,
- 13:26where you have conditions for success versus just
- 13:29conditions to impress? Yeah. Absolutely. I mean, I think a lot of what people
- 13:33want in their life, ultimately like, Key, competition is fantastic, and
- 13:37it's great. You have to feed your family. But I think people want to feel
- 13:40that the work that they do matters and that they have control over their own
- 13:43destiny. So purpose and autonomy. And while I was that
- 13:46NRC, I definitely felt that the work
- 13:51that I did mattered. It it was, you know, I was serving my country. And,
- 13:54what I didn't perhaps share is I I also read for office, in,
- 13:58the 2021 federal election and a part of that being an immigrant
- 14:01coming to Canada. I don't think my life story could have been possible in
- 14:05any other country. And so I feel an immense amount of debt to this
- 14:09nation, and I love Canada with every fiber of my
- 14:12being. So being able to work and use my skills
- 14:16to help the public good was so fulfilling,
- 14:20but the lack of autonomy was was honestly crushing.
- 14:23And so is that balance between the the rebel,
- 14:27the troublemaker, the one who wanted to go do things, and the
- 14:31intelligent, logical, sort of effective person. And I
- 14:35think there's that struggle inside Key all the time. And the places that
- 14:38I thrive the most is where those 2 people are happy. Where did this
- 14:42whole fascination with carbon
- 14:46capture begin? One of the reasons I went to do my master's with this
- 14:49professor, was because of the type of research that he was doing. I
- 14:53went to an undergraduate conference and he was showing,
- 14:56his research on screen, giving a presentation, and he was
- 15:00discovering new materials to capture carbon dioxide. And
- 15:04at the time, you know, a lot of people thought this was gonna be too
- 15:06expensive. It was never gonna work, etcetera, and it has completely blown
- 15:10up as a field since then. But the very first
- 15:13time I thought about, you know, using or the things that
- 15:17I would be excited about doing in my life, I knew was about chemistry. I
- 15:21knew I wanted to do material science because, I didn't really like organic
- 15:25chemistry Three much. And then when I thought about
- 15:28materials and looked into it further, you know, you know, you could go down the
- 15:31electronics path. You could go down structural materials, functional materials.
- 15:35That I realized that underlying all of these things is that, yes,
- 15:39materials are key to the quality of life that we have, but they've also
- 15:42led to an incredible problem that we face, which
- 15:46is climate change. And we have to rethink and reimagine the ways
- 15:50that we build the things that we use, the materials, the way that
- 15:54we make them. And so my fascination with with carbon capture
- 15:57started with okay. Actually, it's gonna be
- 16:01very difficult to completely reimagine every single thing that
- 16:05we've done. There's so much sunk cost, so many,
- 16:08ways and entrenched the pipelines that you're gonna have to tear down and build back
- 16:12up, which would lead to social unrest. And so if you
- 16:16can't underlie if you can't change that quickly, and
- 16:19we have to deal with climate change quickly, then why don't we at least capture
- 16:23the emissions either before it hits the atmosphere or
- 16:26remove it once it's already in there? So let's talk a little bit about
- 16:30RBC, and we'll weave in some of the work you're doing right now. But in
- 16:34this century, my opening, I talk about sort of 1 or 2 words that
- 16:37define centuries, Three age of enlightenment, the industrial
- 16:41revolution, globalization. And I would argue that
- 16:45either this is gonna be the age of complexity because we have so many problems
- 16:48to deal with or climate change. Yet when I
- 16:52read out there, there's so many people still denying climate
- 16:56change. And I don't know if that's just because of social
- 17:00media, that's because if the problem seems so big that I
- 17:03or it's becoming very personal because I have to pay taxes on it. But
- 17:07why do you think we are still at a point where
- 17:11the concept remains intangible and therefore easy to
- 17:14debate. There's something about interesting about humanity and our psyche in
- 17:18general that no matter what topic, there are going to be people who
- 17:22disagree. We still have folks who truly believe that the
- 17:25world is flat. Right? Like, incontrovertible,
- 17:29scientific evidence that you can see, touch, feel. It's increasingly
- 17:33becoming clear with climate change that's the same thing. Look outside.
- 17:37Look at what happened this summer. Look what happened what's happening right now in the
- 17:40winter. It's one of the warmest winters. When I was in Ottawa, doing
- 17:44my masters, I could skate on the Rideau Canal. I have you you're not able
- 17:47to Key you haven't been able to skate in the Rideau Canal for a few
- 17:50years now because of how warm it's getting. So why do I think that's the
- 17:54case? I I I think there's a few things. There's the the very slim
- 17:57population that no matter what topic, no matter no matter anything,
- 18:01there's gonna be something that's hardwired in folks to disagree. Sounds like your dad, by
- 18:05the way. Yeah. A little bit, honestly, in many ways.
- 18:08There's gonna there's gonna be a a subset of the population whose livelihoods
- 18:12depend on the way that things were done before and who
- 18:16see the energy transition or who see
- 18:20addressing climate change as a threat to their way of life or a threat to
- 18:23their economic security. And and that's true in
- 18:26fossil fuel producing nations, Canada being one of that.
- 18:30And that's true across people, again, whose livelihoods
- 18:34depend on being able to get to work every day, and they're just looking at
- 18:38the gas prices increase and inflation, which, by the way, has been
- 18:41proven isn't actually very much tied to the carbon tax. The carbon tax
- 18:45only, accounts for about 2% of inflationary
- 18:49pressures on the index. But
- 18:53in any case, I think it really comes down to those 2 things,
- 18:57being hardwired to disagree and also
- 19:01seeing this as a threat rather than the opportunity that it actually is.
- 19:04So talk to me about Dakota Protocol, the Paris Agreement 2015,
- 19:08the COP Conferences. It seems to be that the
- 19:12narrative has changed from leaders shedding their self
- 19:15interest to becoming much more the way the media presents it
- 19:19often is a lot of jet setters and their private jets showing up
- 19:23and not really getting beyond rhetoric. Do you
- 19:27think that we are seeing progress on a global
- 19:30stage where there'll be less talk and more action? All we
- 19:34have to do is look at the the numbers, right, in terms of
- 19:38the number of policies that have been announced, the number of private
- 19:41corporations that have set net zero targets. So first, let me
- 19:45address your comment about that is just a a a, you know, with the World
- 19:48Economic Forum, but for climate. Right? Like, a little bunch of jetsetters coming down.
- 19:52Yeah. So I went to COP 28 this year, and it was the first time
- 19:55that I'd ever been. And I was I was excited. Right? I mean, this is
- 19:58this is the Super Bowl for Climate Nerds. And
- 20:02when I went, I was surprised the thing that struck me the most was not
- 20:06the number of of Key setters or celebrities, but the number of
- 20:09policymakers, municipal workers, public
- 20:13servants from every single country in the world coming together
- 20:17focused on one problem. And it was it was it
- 20:21was actually quite beautiful because, you know, you would have, you you
- 20:24had representatives from low lying Caribbean states who's were
- 20:28worried, like, quite quite seriously about whether or not their country
- 20:32will exist to, you know, Tony gas petrol states in the Middle
- 20:36East who are thinking about how do they transition away in a world
- 20:39that they know will have to wean itself off of oil and gas.
- 20:44And they're all all together. So what is the value of something
- 20:47like this? The value is having a forum
- 20:51where literally every single person, every country in the
- 20:55world can come and be represented and have a discussion and try to
- 20:58make progress on climate. The thing that we don't want
- 21:02is for rogue states or for a part of
- 21:06the world to not care, to not do anything, to not feel
- 21:09the pressure from the rest of the global community. Because
- 21:13climate change emissions, just like COVID, you know, does not know
- 21:17borders. So unless we have these gatherings and unless we
- 21:20actually talk to one another, and, by the way, in a
- 21:24society that is increasingly in a world Chatter is increasingly becoming more
- 21:27polarized and, fractious, If we don't
- 21:31have this place for us to have this conversation and try
- 21:35to find common ground, then there's no hope for us to make action
- 21:39at all. But you could argue that Canada has, you know,
- 21:42stood on this topic for quite some time, but the
- 21:46mass would suggest we've really made very little progress. And you wouldn't be wrong. And
- 21:49it's one of the the biggest disappointments that I have in in Canada
- 21:53in general, is the lack of of of
- 21:56progress. But we have to recognize a few things. When you when Key
- 22:00think about the climate reduction goals, it's often towards a baseline, you know,
- 22:0450% from this year, etcetera, etcetera, etcetera. We have a very
- 22:08low baseline compared to other countries because our electricity grid
- 22:12is relatively clean, the majority of which is actually hydroelectric.
- 22:16There's a little bit of coal, or a little bit of oil and natural
- 22:20gas. We've we outface coal before we set our targets.
- 22:24So other countries, all they have to do it's not
- 22:28all they have to do. It's a difficult thing, but they can address much of
- 22:30their emission reduction targets, their low hanging fruit before
- 22:342030 by, switching their electricity production from
- 22:38coal to other sources, renewables, even natural gas.
- 22:41They'll they'll lower their emissions. We don't have that luxury. So
- 22:45we're starting off at a very low point and are asked
- 22:49to decrease even further down. That's 1.
- 22:522 is it takes a long time to do this.
- 22:56We have a cold climate where we have to heat our homes and population.
- 23:00We have an infrastructure that needs to be built out even further in order to
- 23:02electrify heating around the country, And we have
- 23:06immense population increases that many can argue are
- 23:10leading to inflationary pressures, costs of living
- 23:14crises, affordability, and that has a ripple effect on how we're able to
- 23:17decarbonize per capita as a country. Because the more people that we have, the more
- 23:21energy that we need. Do I think that we could be doing more? Yes. A
- 23:24100%. Do I wish we were? Of course.
- 23:28But I I do think that we're starting on a pathway,
- 23:32And a lot of it, I'll give credit to trying to keep up with the
- 23:35United States, you know, with their inflation reduction act that the Biden
- 23:38administration passed a couple of years ago, which was a massive,
- 23:42subsidy, one of the largest climate tech bills ever passed in the
- 23:46world. And so Canada has come forward with a few of their own
- 23:49targeted investment tax credits to help spur the industry, like the
- 23:53carbon capture realization that storage tax credit. And so
- 23:57Canada is doing its part in in in trying to, trying to remain
- 24:00competitive, trying to keep up in this transition, and really walk that
- 24:04laser thin, tight rope,
- 24:08between what is politically palatable, and what can
- 24:11actually drive emissions on fast enough. Before I get into your work with Deep Sky,
- 24:15just my last question is carbon tax, which seems to be
- 24:19so polarizing. Is that something
- 24:23you buy into in terms of a strategy moving forward, or do you
- 24:26think there's a better path to accomplishing our goals? So if you're an
- 24:30academic, if you're an economist, and I love economists, no offense to
- 24:33economists, the carbon tax is the best thing in the world because it
- 24:37is a broad based, market driven thing. You
- 24:41set a tax. You don't choose an industry. You don't give subsidies
- 24:44away. You just let the market do its thing, free market capitalism at its
- 24:48greatest. The biggest issue so far with the carbon tax has been
- 24:51that it hasn't been high enough to actually influence factors. It was a half
- 24:55measure. They set the carbon tax too low. Well, maybe I'll
- 24:59put it this way. If the carbon tax was introduced in that 19
- 25:02eighties at the prices that we had now, it would have been perfect because it
- 25:06would have been a slow ramp up. We would have been able to decrease emissions
- 25:10at the same time as have this carbon tax. And in many ways,
- 25:13that's what they did with acid rain, emissions, and,
- 25:17we were very effective at decreasing, acid rain, NOx and
- 25:21SOx, these sorts of things in the eighties. And also and we we never
- 25:25hear about the ozone, being depleted anymore because we were able to
- 25:28deal with that with, chlorofluorocarbons. CFC is the biggest
- 25:32contributor, to to to ozone depletion. But when it
- 25:36comes to CO2 emissions, we weren't able to do that early enough.
- 25:40So the carbon tax that exists today in Canada or anywhere else in the world,
- 25:43in my view, is a half measure because it's not
- 25:47biting enough to actually spur Chatter. And so I
- 25:51think the time for the carbon tax unfortunately has passed. We
- 25:54live in a complex world that is no longer governed by
- 25:58economic equations and ideal free market capitalism.
- 26:02Key live in an emotional world. We live in a political world. And so I
- 26:06actually think what the United States has done by creating
- 26:09incentives, carrots rather than sticks, and
- 26:13having a bit more of a hand in shaping the industrial policy
- 26:17and the destiny of its country and how it will
- 26:21that least try to meet the challenge of this energy
- 26:24transition is what we should be doing here. And we've started to do that. We've
- 26:28started to see that with, these investment tax credits.
- 26:32But I think the one of the worst things, frankly, that the Trudeau
- 26:35administration could have done was that carve out for Atlantic provinces on a
- 26:39home heating oil because that's exactly what you're not
- 26:43supposed to do on a broad based free market
- 26:47tool like attacks is erect or create carve outs.
- 26:50You become the chief carbon scientist and hedge engineering at Deep
- 26:54Sky. I have to imagine, at age 32, with what's in
- 26:58your resume, with the work you published, you had a lot of
- 27:01doors that you could have gone through. What made you choose
- 27:05DeepSky? Purpose and autonomy. At DeepSky, it's the first time in my
- 27:09Chatter, since my PhD, actually, where I
- 27:13feel that I have both the purpose in the work that I do, but also
- 27:16the Three, the autonomy to drive things and that I am my own
- 27:20limiting Chatter. Not the organization, not the rules that were there before me, but
- 27:24myself. And so the story of how I came to be at Deep Key, I
- 27:27was at McKinsey and I was getting a little bit frustrated. I knew that, it
- 27:30was an interesting role, and I was having a lot of fun, but I I
- 27:33wanted to do something on my own. So I was actually thinking of starting my
- 27:36own company, of of starting a carbon removal company. And, as an
- 27:40adjunct professor at the University of Toronto, I had a colleague of mine who I
- 27:43made a Three recent discovery. He was gonna patent a new technology. I was gonna
- 27:46license it. I was gonna go start, like, a company. And I met the
- 27:50folks at DeepSky, because DeepSky is a a technology
- 27:53agnostic project developer. And I met the founders, Fred Lalonde and
- 27:57Joost Overkirk. And what they were doing is they were going around the world trying
- 28:01to find people who are developing carbon capture technology, carbon
- 28:04removal technology, to bring them to Canada to scale it. And
- 28:08so I met that, and I thought, Key, I'm gonna wow them. They came to
- 28:11the University Toronto. I I showed them the technology. They said it was amazing. I
- 28:15thought they were gonna fund my start up, prepurchase my first pallet, and I'd be
- 28:19off to the races. Instead, they said, Phil, come join us.
- 28:22Join our mission. We already have the funding, so you're not gonna have to spend
- 28:26the first two years of your start up career, in the worst venture
- 28:30capital raise environment ever. And in a few years, if you still
- 28:34wanna go start your company, we'll support you. And I
- 28:37talked earlier about finding mentors and people who believe
- 28:41in you and that will support you. And you know it when you see it,
- 28:45and I felt it immediately. So I've I've always I've never really
- 28:49followed a role or an organization or compensation.
- 28:53I followed people, and people that I feel that I could really learn
- 28:56from. And these are these are folks that for context, Fred and,
- 29:01and Yost, cofounded a company called Hopper, which is a,
- 29:04you know, a $5,000,000,000 Canadian tech company in
- 29:08the travel space. They still travel. They're a competitor to Expedia.
- 29:12And so, you know, I I felt that I could really learn from people who
- 29:15had built $1,000,000,000 businesses before. And then I so I left
- 29:19McKinsey, and I've it's been a rocket ship ever since. I love when you talked
- 29:22about I'm not sure if it was on your in your obituary or your Key
- 29:26page, but how you wanna be remembered. Know? It's funny that that
- 29:30age 32, you're already thinking about that, but that's quite interesting. It had nothing
- 29:33to do with your awards. It had nothing to do with your ranking. It had
- 29:36everything to do with how many tons of carbon you've captured. Yeah. I
- 29:40always joke. I say, you know, on my Wikipedia page when I die, I wanted
- 29:44to say Phil DeLuno Three responsible for x tons of Key
- 29:47removed from the atmosphere. And, you know, it's it's it's
- 29:51this north star objective. People are aided by
- 29:55having these these points of focus. Right? Whether it's a deadline that you're striving
- 29:59towards or an objective or goal, it really does help get
- 30:02people to be effective. I've found a way to have a
- 30:06very simple metric, tons of carbon removed from the atmosphere
- 30:10that I can monitor, measure, and track, and that I could I could put my
- 30:14life against. And is carbon capture gonna be
- 30:19the magic bullet, the panacea that's gonna
- 30:23absolutely make a massive impact on the quality of our
- 30:26planet? No. The answer is no. And no one solution is
- 30:30going to be. It's a combination of every single
- 30:34lever that we can pull. And so first, let me talk
- 30:37about, you know, my 5 step plan for us to save the world. And then
- 30:41I can talk about, carbon capture as part of that 5 step
- 30:44plan. So the first step is protect what we have. You know,
- 30:48we should we need to stop deforestation, cutting down the Amazon. The
- 30:52lungs of the world that give us our oxygen, we need to protect them. The
- 30:56second thing is, we need to have renewables
- 30:59everywhere. We need to scale up the renewables as quickly as possible.
- 31:03Solar today is Chatter, and wind is cheaper than many forms of fossil
- 31:07fuel electricity, and that's a good thing. So we have to get going and start
- 31:10building. The third step is to electrify everything we
- 31:13possibly can. In Canada, we have really cold
- 31:17Matters. And right now, we use natural gas to heat our homes when we could
- 31:20be using electric heat pumps instead. So we have to retrofit every single
- 31:24building in this country, which is a massive undertaking. We need
- 31:27to transition away from gas guzzling internal
- 31:31combustion engines to electric vehicles, electrify as much of
- 31:35the of the world as we can with those clean and green electrons in
- 31:38step 2. In step 4, is
- 31:42once we've electrified as much as we can, we have to tackle hard to
- 31:46abate sectors that are impossible or difficult to electrify. Things
- 31:49like freight or aviation flight. We
- 31:53can make new sustainable aviation fuels, concrete. We can
- 31:56embed carbon dioxide into a concrete or make green concrete. So
- 32:00all these materials that Key being a material scientist that gets so excited about,
- 32:04we have to find new ways to make those. And then step 5,
- 32:07finally, once we've done all of those things, is capture carbon. And
- 32:11we have to capture carbon both from the flu stack, from its
- 32:15point source of emission. So in all of these factories and
- 32:18these big chimneys that you see in TV, we have to
- 32:22capture c o two before it hits the atmosphere and we actually have to remove
- 32:26carbon dioxide that already exists in the atmosphere and take it
- 32:30out. So those are the 5 things that we have to do. Protect what we
- 32:33have, renewables everywhere, electrify everything,
- 32:38tackle hard to abate emissions, and then capture the carbon that remains.
- 32:43When we return, Phil Del Luna offers some compelling
- 32:47advice for anyone on how to chase their dreams, and
- 32:50then I provide my Three takeaways.
- 32:57Hi. It's Tony Chapman, host of Chatter That Matters. I wanna congratulate
- 33:00RBC in the launch of the RBC Climate Action Institute.
- 33:04Canada needs more dedicated approaches to climate policy and action across
- 33:07agriculture, energy systems, buildings, and the RBC Climate
- 33:11Action Institute will be the place for advancing climate smart ideas to
- 33:15help Canada reach net 0. Mother Nature and the future of our
- 33:18planet, well, that matters to you, to me, and to RBC.
- 33:26Unfortunately, today we are divided. One side is fighting
- 33:29for the eradication of an entire industry, the other side is
- 33:33fighting just to preserve itself. For me, it's never been an
- 33:37issue of us versus them. We
- 33:41urgently need to move away from this thinking of us
- 33:44versus that, and come together against the real problem,
- 33:48us versus the emissions. You're listening to Chatter That
- 33:52Matters with Tony Chapman presented by RBC.
- 33:56Phil De Luna is my guest today. There's few I've ever met
- 34:00in my entire life, let alone uncharted that Matters, that has this intellectual
- 34:04firepower with this incredible emotional
- 34:07connection to the human race.
- 34:11Just listening to you, do you think you're going to once
- 34:15again put on your hat and run for office
- 34:19and sort of drive this change with this kind of
- 34:22conviction? Because you come at a very pragmatic basis.
- 34:26You understand there's capitalism involved. You understand that there's
- 34:30political rhetoric involved. I mean, there's a lot of things that you get.
- 34:34Do you see that one day you might go back into the into the ring?
- 34:37Not now. Because of the work that I'm doing at Deep Key is so meaningful.
- 34:40It's a way that I can make change. Even in politics,
- 34:43you're confined by your party. You're confined
- 34:47by the public opinion, by the rhetoric, and what you can do. A lot of
- 34:51people think that, you know, Justin Trudeau is the source of all of our problems
- 34:54and he's this all powerful, scourge or something.
- 34:59But the reality is even he is just trying to stay afloat like
- 35:03everyone else. He's trying to stay keep his head above water. And
- 35:06so to answer your question directly, would I run again? I I think,
- 35:10yeah, absolutely 100% because I still believe in the political
- 35:13process, in the democratic process. I believe that
- 35:17if we don't have pragmatic, experienced,
- 35:21well thinking people who lead this country, then what will we have left?
- 35:25We'll just have career politicians who, who
- 35:28know how to divide people and who know how to highlight
- 35:32problems rather than find solutions. And I think that's very dangerous
- 35:36for our country. But will I do it now? No. I'm I'm
- 35:40too, I'm too excited to entranced,
- 35:44too focused and obsessed with the work that I'm doing, to to give
- 35:48that up, and then to go through the grueling process and of
- 35:52of, and heartbreaking one of running for office again. Although,
- 35:56if there's anyone listening out there who's ever thought of doing it, please do
- 36:00it, because we need more people, of every walk of life. We
- 36:03need more, nurses and plumbers and teachers and carpenters
- 36:07and scientists and doctors and engineers and everyone running for
- 36:10office. Because, again, if we don't have,
- 36:14regular people running for office, then what will we
- 36:18have left? As we close that the interview, time and time
- 36:22again, I've seen you give credit to your wife. You gave credit to
- 36:25your parents earlier in this interview. What role has your wife
- 36:29played in allowing you to find that sense of
- 36:33purpose and autonomy? It's it's corny, and it's so cliche, but I really would
- 36:37not be the person I am today if it wasn't for her. And I'll I'll
- 36:41give a few examples in my Chatter, so where her
- 36:44influence, her support that meant everything to me
- 36:48and has enabled me to do what I can do, in my PhD. So
- 36:52I I thought I was gonna be a professor. You know, I thought I was
- 36:54gonna go on the academic path, and, you know, I was publishing all these papers.
- 36:57I was on that pathway. And then halfway through my PhD, my wife
- 37:01who, my girlfriend that the time said, you know,
- 37:05Phil, she's from Toronto. She works at Sick Kids. She's an operating room
- 37:08nurse. She loves her job loves her job. We have our friends
- 37:12here. She wanted to build a life here. And if you're in academia, anyone who's
- 37:15in academia knows, if you wanna be a professor, you can't choose where you live.
- 37:19You go to your PhD somewhere. You go to a postdoc that some top five
- 37:22school around the world, and you get a job in who knows where they'll just
- 37:25wherever you can get one. And then she said, Phil, I wanna stay in Toronto.
- 37:29And I made that decision then that I wanted to be with her more than
- 37:32I wanted to be a professor, and it it it catapulted me down this
- 37:35this unconventional and much more fulfilling career, I think,
- 37:39than if I had just gone down academia. When I decided that I wanted to
- 37:43run for office, the the the the thing that made me the most nervous
- 37:47was actually telling her, hey. This is something I think I wanna do. Keep in
- 37:50mind, I had to take 6 months off without pay. I had to give up
- 37:53my paycheck because I was working for the federal government, so it was a conflict
- 37:56of interest. And at that time, we had no idea when the election was gonna
- 38:00be called. So I I was taking time off, and it could have been 6
- 38:04months. It could have been a year. You know, she said, we're gonna make it
- 38:07work. We'll figure it out, and I support you a 100%. So,
- 38:11you know, having someone that you can come home to,
- 38:15that you can talk to, that doesn't necessarily, know your field
- 38:19or is gonna debate you and everything, but can just listen and and and
- 38:22and support and be empathetic, has has has meant
- 38:26everything to me. And, yeah, we got married in
- 38:29September. We we went, you know, it was the first time I'd taken,
- 38:33you know, like, 3 weeks off of work and, like, my career. We went to
- 38:36Italy, and I actually unplugged. And I I, you know, I could say it was
- 38:40probably the happiest I've I've been in my life. You're 32, and
- 38:44I've talked to a lot of young people. And I would say,
- 38:48sadly, the vast majority don't have the shining eyes that you do. They don't have
- 38:51the sense of passion. They don't have this excitement about what you're doing. What
- 38:55advice can you give to the young people today who might be
- 38:58feeling very beaten down by the headwinds that there is
- 39:02opportunity to have, you know, as you call it, purpose
- 39:05and autonomy, and a great life. You can have purpose, and
- 39:09you can have autonomy. Anyone can do it. You just have to
- 39:13want it hard enough and try. And I know that sounds so privileged
- 39:17in the sense that, you know, people have bills to pay. They probably
- 39:20have families to feed. Why are you telling people to just
- 39:24take risks and try? You the the big unlock in my
- 39:28career, in my life, was for applying for things and
- 39:31trying and reaching for things that I knew I wasn't qualified to
- 39:35do because you'd be surprised the number of people
- 39:39that post applications, or that post
- 39:42jobs where they know that no one is gonna be able to meet it, and
- 39:45they're just looking for the best available. And oftentimes, people are their own worst
- 39:49enemy. They say, ah, I'm not qualified for this. I I I'm not ready for
- 39:52that. And they just don't they don't they don't take that step to try.
- 39:56And so, like, I I've always believed that in one's
- 40:00career, we you need to optimize for different things in order to find that purpose
- 40:03and autonomy. When you're younger in your career, you need to optimize for diversity of
- 40:07experience and try as many different things as possible. A lot
- 40:11of people will think, you know, oh, Phil. You've haven't been able to stand
- 40:14still. You've you've done one thing that longest. You've stayed at a place is 3
- 40:17years. Aren't you worried that that's going to look badly in your career? No. If
- 40:21anything, if you look at the career trajectory, every pivot that I've
- 40:25taken hasn't been a pivot downward. It's been a pivot up. And
- 40:29you have to take that that perspective of always constantly
- 40:32trying to find new things that are going to excite you.
- 40:36And don't don't rest and and
- 40:39allow the world to beat you down in a in a position or a
- 40:43place that you don't feel utilized. If you don't feel happy, if you
- 40:47don't feel excited about what you do, then try something else. And it
- 40:51could be something completely different. Like, you could you could be a scientist doing your
- 40:55PhD and decide that you watch The Bear and you wanna go become a Michelin
- 40:58star chef and go start, learning how to cook and go work in a in
- 41:02a in a restaurant. It doesn't doesn't matter. Just keep
- 41:06trying different things until you find the thing that you love.
- 41:09That what I think that's what you have to do when you're young. Then you
- 41:13move into the mid part of your career where I think a lot of people
- 41:16are focused on impact. You found the thing that you love. How do you figure
- 41:20out how to turn that into something that's impactful? And
- 41:23that that a lot of people transition away from being an individual contributor
- 41:27to a manager or to a leadership role, and people stumble through
- 41:31how to become a leader and leading through example and making impact. And then
- 41:34in the last stage of one's career, I think a lot of people are focused
- 41:37on legacy. What is it that you want to leave the world behind? What
- 41:41is it you wanna be known for? And, you know, those Three stages,
- 41:45thinking about, you know, where you are in your life, in your
- 41:49career, what you wanna do, working backwards from where you wanna be,
- 41:53those are all things that have helped me plan and map things out.
- 41:57And I should say that my life was never really purely mapped out.
- 42:01There were lots of failures along the way and every and lots of turns that
- 42:04I didn't expect. It looks like a perfectly planned
- 42:09travel experience on paper, but that's not the way it was.
- 42:13So, again, my advice for young people at any stage is just keep trying
- 42:17until you find the thing you love, and and don't be afraid to
- 42:20fail. You know, Phil, I always end my podcast with my
- 42:24Three take aways and put this number 1, just listen to you. You know, you
- 42:27really talk about life as this accordion that opens up. And as you get on,
- 42:31you get into leadership and then legacy. And what really
- 42:35interests me about you is this accordion comes together. Here's the 5
- 42:39things we need to do about the planet. Here's the Three things you should be
- 42:41thinking about. It's like you're almost a fusion of the past, present,
- 42:45and future. And I find that incredibly fascinating about you. And the
- 42:49second is you're just a great student of human nature. I love when you said
- 42:52early on, spike can be a motivator. You know? Or here's what you'd be
- 42:56thinking about. Or here and your curiosity of human nature is
- 42:59another fascinating thing about it because I don't often associate
- 43:03that with scientific nature, which is scientific nature is much more process
- 43:07driven. And the third thing is which is the the sense of purpose and
- 43:10autonomy, something you've landed on, but more importantly
- 43:14landed on because you give credit to the people that matter most to
- 43:18you, starting with your parents, obviously, your wife, and, of course, what you did with
- 43:22just finding mentors through university and finding mentors where you are today. So for all
- 43:25of that and more, at age 33, I hope I'm around for
- 43:29another 33 years just to see what how much carbon you take out of this
- 43:33planet, how much of this government you get to run, and just continue to follow,
- 43:37your trajectory. And I am so happy you're in Canada and love Canada because
- 43:41you're the kind of, sadly, the kind of person that can very easily get picked
- 43:44off by countries that might be a little bit more advanced in terms of,
- 43:48providing the capital to keep minds like yours, gainfully thinking
- 43:52and employed. So thank you for joining me in Chatter That Matters. Canada is the
- 43:55best country in the world. It really is. It really, really
- 43:59is. And a lot of people, it's very Canadian to be shy and to
- 44:03not say it and to, to to be humble,
- 44:06but it it it really is the best country in the world and I wouldn't
- 44:09be anywhere else. And I think we all have a duty to make it better
- 44:13and to keep it the best country in the world. I hope everyone does their
- 44:16part to do that.
- 44:21Joining me now is John Stackhouse. I first met John when he was editor in
- 44:25chief that The Globe and Mail. Today, he's the senior vice president in the office
- 44:28of the president of RBC. John, welcome back to Chatter that
- 44:32matters. Always good to be with you, Tony. Thanks. What I'm fascinated with is
- 44:36what you're doing with this Climate Action Institute because you're opening the
- 44:39doors and inviting the world to be part of the conversation. Yeah. The
- 44:43key part of the institute is that word action. We feel and we hear from
- 44:46a lot of people, there's a lot of talk. It's important to discuss,
- 44:50debate, and inform a lot of critical questions around, around
- 44:54climate, but we gotta get moving, and get moving right across the
- 44:58economy. As we know that climate crisis and all the
- 45:01challenges that come, with it are on
- 45:05all of us to, to get going on. So we're working with
- 45:08clients, we're trying to bring together communities and help Canadians
- 45:13act, and move faster, which we know Canadians not
- 45:17only wanna do, we're already seeing it, across the economy. We just need
- 45:20to scale it up and, and accelerate. What I like about what you're
- 45:24doing is that you're trying to get this conversation happening
- 45:28so that it's not us feeling helpless, which is what I think a lot of
- 45:31the media is doing. It's too late. But you're keeping this positivity and
- 45:35possibility saying if we start acting now, putting
- 45:39dents into this problem, that our collective energy can, in fact, not only solve
- 45:42it, also create a renaissance in terms of what capitalism
- 45:46stands for, which is, you know, a social conscious doing the right thing. Yeah. And
- 45:50I agree fully, Tony. I think one of the things we underestimate is the power
- 45:53of business and of of markets to drive change.
- 45:57We're seeing extraordinary change in the United States,
- 46:01in in large part because of the inflation reduction act, But that has
- 46:05created incentives and unblocked disincentives
- 46:10for for industry Chatter it's in scaling electric vehicles
- 46:14or expanding hydrogen, or to invest
- 46:17in what's called climate smart agriculture with a speed and
- 46:21scale that is really breathtaking. So when when we talk to
- 46:25clients or groups in the in in the US, we want
- 46:28to ensure Canadians are keeping pace with that and and
- 46:32we can. I get to deal with a lot of RBC's best
- 46:36clients, whether it's in real estate or energy systems, from electricity
- 46:40to oil and gas to agriculture. And the amount of
- 46:43innovation going on across the economy from farmers
- 46:47to gas companies to developers is really
- 46:51impressive. It's as good as anywhere in the world, but we have to
- 46:54come back to that point and remind ourselves of speed and scale. How are
- 46:58we gonna do this bigger and faster? Because
- 47:02the challenges are right before us. They are bigger,
- 47:05and planet Three keeps reminding us that we don't have as much
- 47:09time as perhaps we'd like. So as an invitation to my
- 47:13listeners to get involved, is there an opportunity for them to
- 47:17learn more about what you're doing, to participate, take
- 47:20action, or is it more is this more sort of, in the inner
- 47:24circle of just a sort of people with the greater influence? No. No. This is
- 47:27on all of us, and I love the advice of Katharine Hayhoe.
- 47:31She's a climate scientist, a great Canadian. She teaches
- 47:35in Texas and is a world leader in terms of
- 47:38climate advocacy. And she likes to remind
- 47:42her followers action groups in your
- 47:46neighborhood, in your community, in
- 47:50your company, or action groups in your neighborhood, in your
- 47:54community, in your company, or in your your sector.
- 47:57You'll find them everywhere. Get involved. Don't leave this
- 48:01to the scientists
- 48:10Institute at RBC. Come to our website at just Google
- 48:14RBC and Climate Action Institute. You'll find us sign up for our
- 48:17weekly newsletter called Climate Signals, which has a lot of really
- 48:21interesting ideas, and insights on what we can all be doing and what Key should
- 48:25be, what we should be watching and listen to our podcast RBC
- 48:29Disruptors, which has a lot of great, great climate conversations.
- 48:32I've known you for probably 20 years. I certainly saw you in the editor in
- 48:36chief of the Globe and Mail. I've never seen you more passionate and more
- 48:40focused about, a body of work that you're involved with. So thank you for joining
- 48:43me in Chatter That Matters. Thank you, Tony. Chatter That Matters has been a
- 48:47presentation of RBC. I know. This can feel overwhelming.
- 48:51Just know that you're not alone. The best thing that you can do
- 48:55is talk to your loved ones about climate change.
- 48:59Every CEO that I've talked to has had their minds and their hearts
- 49:02changed at the dining room table with a conversation with their grandkids.
- 49:07That stakes are high, but so too is the opportunity,
- 49:11And we are fighting, not for ourselves, but for
- 49:15the generations to come. It's Tony Chapman. Thanks for listening.
- 49:19Let's chat soon.