Latest / The National Debt Podcast with Fexingo: Treasury, Borrowing, and Long-Term Fiscal Outlook / How Slower Growth Makes the National Debt Harder to Manage
Transcript
- Lucas: The second-quarter GDP number came in at 1.5 percent this week. That's the slowest reading since the first half of 2023, and it raises a pretty uncomfortable question for anyone tracking the national debt. Luna: Because slower growth means less tax revenue, right? That part is straightforward. Lucas: Exactly. But there's a subtler problem. Even if Congress somehow cut spending and reduced the deficit — which, by the way, we did see a small improvement this fiscal year — the debt to gdp ratio can still go up if the denominator, GDP, grows too slowly. Luna: Right, because debt to gdp is a fraction. If the numerator is the total debt and the denominator is the size of the economy, then if GDP stalls, the ratio can climb even if the debt grows more slowly. Lucas: Exactly. And we're seeing that play out right now. The total federal debt hit 39 trillion dollars as of January. The annual deficit for the fiscal year ending September 2025 was about 1.77 trillion — actually down a bit from the prior year. But debt to gdp still ticked up, from 122.57 percent to 122.6 percent. Luna: So a smaller deficit but a higher ratio. That's the growth problem in a nutshell. Lucas: Now layer in interest rates. The 10-year Treasury is yielding 4.61 percent, the 30-year is at 5.09. Those are above the nominal GDP growth rate, which in Q2 was probably around 4 percent if you add inflation. So the effective interest rate on the debt is higher than the growth rate of the economy. Luna: That's the classic condition for a debt spiral — when interest costs grow faster than the economy's ability to service them. Lucas: Economists call it the 'r minus g' problem. When the real interest rate on government debt, r, exceeds the growth rate of the economy, g, then the debt to gdp ratio tends to rise on its own, even without new borrowing. We are firmly in that territory. Luna: How big is that gap right now? If I take the 10-year yield, roughly 4.6 percent, and subtract nominal GDP growth, which is real growth plus inflation — maybe 1.5 plus 3.3, that's 4.8 — then r minus g is actually slightly negative. But the 30-year is 5.09, and the average interest on the entire debt is lower because of older, cheaper bonds. Lucas: Right. The average coupon on the debt is lower than current yields because the Treasury refinances gradually. But every new bond issued today locks in a higher rate. The Treasury's average interest rate on marketable debt has been climbing and is now well above 3 percent. The Congressional Budget Office projects that if interest rates stay here, net interest costs will exceed a trillion dollars by 2030. Luna: So slower growth isn't just a revenue problem. It makes the debt math worse on the interest side because we're borrowing at higher rates to fund a slower-growing economy. Lucas: That's why this week's GDP number matters so much. At 1.5 percent real growth, the economy is not generating enough momentum to outgrow the debt. And with core inflation still at 3.3 percent, the Fed can't cut rates aggressively without risking a re-acceleration of prices. Luna: So we are stuck between slow growth and sticky inflation. That's a tough place for fiscal policy. Lucas: And it's exactly the kind of conversation we try to unpack here — no ads, no noise, just the numbers and how they fit together. If walking through the economy with us has made something click for you, we do rely on listener support to keep the show ad-free. It's a small way to ensure this kind of detailed analysis stays accessible. Luna: Yeah, it really does help. If you find value in episodes like this, you can find the link at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. No pressure, just a way to keep the lights on. Lucas: So back to the math. One of the things that often gets missed in the headline deficit numbers is how much of the borrowing is just to pay interest. For fiscal 2025, net interest on the debt was roughly 880 billion dollars. That's more than we spent on defense or Medicare. Luna: And that number is only going to grow as bonds mature and are refinanced at today's yields. The Treasury has to roll over about 7 trillion dollars in debt over the next year, much of it short-term bills that need to be refinanced at higher rates. Lucas: Right. The 2-year yield is 4.26 percent, the 3-month yield is 3.90. The curve is positively sloped, which means longer-term debt costs more. But the Treasury has been issuing more short-term debt to keep borrowing costs lower. That's a gamble — if rates don't fall, they'll have to refinance at potentially higher rates down the line. Luna: So the debt isn't just a stock; it's a flow. Every quarter, the interest cost compounds. Lucas: Exactly. And the slower the economy grows, the harder it is to generate the tax revenue to cover those interest payments. You end up borrowing more to pay interest, which adds to the debt, which increases interest costs — that's the spiral. Luna: Is there any good news in the data? The deficit did shrink a bit, and the yield curve has flattened recently — the 10-year minus 2-year spread has narrowed, which might signal expectations of lower rates ahead. Lucas: That spread went from 35 basis points to 45 basis points in the last week, actually. But it's still relatively low by historical standards. A steepening curve usually means growth expectations are improving. Right now, the curve is modestly steeper, but not by much. The market seems to expect a slow growth environment for a while. Luna: So the takeaway is that slowing growth makes the debt problem worse regardless of what happens on the spending side, at least in the short term. Lucas: Yes. And it's a reminder that fiscal sustainability isn't just about cutting deficits. It's about boosting the growth rate. Easier said than done, but that's the fundamental challenge for policymakers right now. Luna: And for investors, it means Treasury yields could stay elevated if growth doesn't pick up and inflation remains sticky. That would keep the pressure on both the stock market and the government's borrowing costs. Lucas: We'll be watching the next GDP revision and the Fed's September meeting for any shift. For now, the slow-growth reality is setting in, and the debt math is getting harder. Luna: Thanks for listening. We'll be back with more next time.