Latest / Together 4 Good: Making Sense of Life and Faith / Sunday School Remix: Are We Our Brother’s Keeper? Rethinking Cain and Abel
Transcript
- 0:00What if the story of Cain and Abel isn't about jealousy, but
- 0:03about what happens to us when we feel rejected?
- 0:10I'm Pastor Nate, and this is another episode of The Sunday
- 0:13School Remix. Welcome to The Sunday School
- 0:16Remix, the show where we take Bible stories you learned as a
- 0:19kid and look at them with fresh eyes.
- 0:21Each week. We dig into the context and the
- 0:24overlooked details, and we often discover interpretations we
- 0:28never heard growing up. This isn't about winning
- 0:31arguments, but simply hearing God's living Word speak to our
- 0:35lives again today. So grab your Bible and put aside
- 0:38your assumptions and let's dive into another episode of the
- 0:42Sunday School Remix. So the story of Cain and Abel
- 0:46maybe isn't exactly a Sunday School story.
- 0:49It seems that it might be one that the Sunday School teachers
- 0:53want to skip because it's about two brothers and one of them
- 0:57getting murdered. But it's certainly a story that
- 1:01I think is pretty well known amongst church people.
- 1:06And I'm not exactly sure of the reasons for it, but just this
- 1:10sense that there's this story early on in our Bibles and we
- 1:14want to know what happens to Adam and Eve and their kids.
- 1:17And so this is the story we're told about their children, Cain
- 1:21and Abel. And it results in something
- 1:24pretty gruesome. And so it sticks in our mind in
- 1:27a particular way. And I think the way that this
- 1:29story is most often framed is as a story of jealousy.
- 1:34The way that goes is that Abel and Cain go and they make a
- 1:38sacrifice to God. And now Abel is a shepherd, and
- 1:43so he has a sheep to sacrifice, and he does.
- 1:48Meanwhile, Cain is a farmer, and so he has vegetables to
- 1:53sacrifice, and he does that too. And we're told that Abel's
- 1:57sacrifice is more pleasing to God, and this makes Cain upset.
- 2:05And so he kills his brother. Now we can see why this gets
- 2:12framed as jealousy. And and I'm not saying that
- 2:14that's not there, but I think that this story is actually far
- 2:18more complex than just like, hey, don't be the jealous
- 2:21brother. Be the, you know, the good one
- 2:24who gives a sacrifice to God that is pleasing to God.
- 2:28And you can see quickly how this can just be framed as another
- 2:32shame based story. Well, if you don't have your
- 2:35heart in the right place like Abel did, if you're not making
- 2:39the right kind of sacrifices, then God will be displeased.
- 2:44And additionally, when we get upset with our fellow church
- 2:48people who seem to be closer to God than we are, we should re
- 2:51examine that jealousy that's taken root in our heart.
- 2:55And again, there's a little bit of that message in this story,
- 2:59but I think it's a little more than that.
- 3:03One of the pieces that we assume in it that I've seen in like
- 3:07cartoons about this story, Veggietales, I don't know if
- 3:10Veggietales does this, but certainly Hanna Barbera, those
- 3:13are those are my jam. When I was a kid.
- 3:17Cain's sacrifice is shown as being rejected by God, and the
- 3:23text ever actually says that. And in fact, even later on in
- 3:28the passage, God never abandons Cain, which is really remarkable
- 3:34given what transpires. And so this idea of being
- 3:39rejected never happens. And that's an important piece
- 3:44for us to hang on to because we often just assume that the bad
- 3:49people get punished. And this story gets lumped into
- 3:53all these other stories where we make that assumption and that
- 3:56conclusion. But God is actually very
- 3:59faithful to Cain, as we'll see, and never rejects not only his
- 4:03sacrifice or even Cain after the murder of his brother.
- 4:07What the story does do, though, is it raises deeper questions
- 4:10about worship and shame and responsibility and the way that
- 4:16God's grace works. So let's just go through this
- 4:20passage a little bit slowly to to see what I'm talking about
- 4:23here. Abel, we're told, and we need to
- 4:28and all of our study of Scripture focus so carefully on
- 4:31what the text actually says, because these are the words that
- 4:34have been given to us that have been passed down.
- 4:37And it's really the temptation is there is to read our own
- 4:43ideas into it and and that you can kind of twist some words
- 4:48quickly to make it fit your narrative.
- 4:51And so it's always good to just go back like, no, no, like, what
- 4:53does it say? In very plain speak, we're told
- 4:57that Abel brings forth the first fruits and the fat portions of
- 5:04his shepherding business of the sheep that he has.
- 5:09And meanwhile, we're told, you know, compare that to Cain, who
- 5:13brings forth some of the fruits of the soil.
- 5:19And so this framing at the start of our story really gives us a
- 5:23clue as to what this is about. Abel is the one who brings his
- 5:29relationship to God. It puts that first and foremost
- 5:33while Cain is doing something that's just a little more
- 5:36perfunctory. You can see why that would be
- 5:39significant. And what we're told is that God
- 5:42regards Abel and his offerings, but doesn't have a strong
- 5:46regards for Cain and his offerings.
- 5:48They're not rejected. But clearly the text is trying
- 5:51to show us that one of these stances, one of these mindsets,
- 5:55is more pleasing to God. And this question that God asks
- 6:00of Cain is also sort of the setup for the next question that
- 6:05God asks, the next statement that God makes Cain, which is
- 6:09like, hey, sin is already crouching at the door, You must
- 6:13rule over it. And so it's very much God
- 6:16encouraging Cain to make the right decisions.
- 6:19It seems as if God understands where this anger of his is
- 6:22headed and what's about to happen, and he's trying to
- 6:25encourage Cain to sort of revisit the stance of his heart
- 6:30and look at where that lines up with everything that's happened.
- 6:33For he is, yes, upset. He's jealous.
- 6:35Why didn't God like my gift as much as Abel's gift?
- 6:40But really, that comes even further back from the fact that
- 6:43Cain just grabbed some stuff from the garden.
- 6:46It's like, I guess this is good enough.
- 6:48Whereas Abel put First things first, as we might say.
- 6:52And so, so much of this story is about orienting our self towards
- 6:59what really matters and who God calls us to be, not getting
- 7:02caught up in the minor details. Putting First things first.
- 7:10And what ends up happening is that when we don't put First
- 7:13things first, Cain allows his anger to take him over, and it
- 7:19results in violence and the death of his brother.
- 7:24When God shows up again in the story to ask Cain, hey, where
- 7:27have you seen your brother Abel? And Cain uses the very
- 7:32important, really critical question of this whole passage,
- 7:35which is, am I my brother's keeper?
- 7:40This is the question that underlies the overall message of
- 7:46this entire story. Am I my brother's keeper, or is
- 7:51it just all about me? The answer to that hypothetical
- 7:57question that Cain poses is, of course, yes, you are.
- 8:03When we turn in on ourselves like Cain does in the story, and
- 8:08we make it all about like, yeah, what what's most comfortable or
- 8:12beneficial for me? Oh, which is what he does
- 8:15originally with the giving of the random leftover vegetables
- 8:20that no one wants, the rutabaga, no offense, rutabaga, but come
- 8:23on. Additionally, Came then turns in
- 8:28on himself again. When it seems as if his offering
- 8:33is not as acceptable to God, he gets angry and downcast.
- 8:38Woe is me? Why am I so different?
- 8:42Why doesn't God love me? He's turning inward again, and
- 8:48ultimately this continual turning inward leads him to
- 8:54violence and the killing, the first murder, and the story of
- 8:58Scripture of not just anyone but of his brother.
- 9:03This is also the warning that the text is giving to us.
- 9:07If we are so flippant about the way that we come before God and
- 9:13offer worship and prayer and praise and sacrifice.
- 9:17If we are so flippant about our anger and allowing that to get
- 9:22the best of us. If we are so flippant about the
- 9:25care of our brothers, our neighbors, those closest to us,
- 9:32all of this results in real destruction within the human
- 9:37family. This is what the story is trying
- 9:41to encourage us to reflect on. And the additional interesting
- 9:45detail is that at the time that this was written, there was some
- 9:48real, you know, a continual rivalry, as there probably still
- 9:52is today, just in different ways, but between the
- 9:55shepherding community and the farming community.
- 9:58And notice how they are represented by the characters in
- 10:01this story. Well, which is better?
- 10:03Which is more pleasing to God? Like, no, like you're your
- 10:06brother's keeper. We need both.
- 10:08And, and what really matters is that you're bringing the all of
- 10:12the vocation that you have selected, be that shepherding or
- 10:15farming or in our modern day sense, something else.
- 10:19Bring all of that. Bring the first fruits of that
- 10:23to God. Do it with a heart directed
- 10:26towards God rather than one of competition or one of shaming
- 10:31others, because that is just the turning in on our self, in our
- 10:35individual vocations. So the danger has always laid
- 10:42inside the human heart. And Cain is simply the
- 10:46character, the character who invites us to reflect on this.
- 10:53And there's more to the story. I don't want to just leave us
- 10:58here in this space because there's more to the story.
- 11:02Yes, God is not pleased with what Cain has done to his
- 11:06brother. And yet, when Cain asks God for
- 11:12mercy, God gives it. God says that he will place his
- 11:17mark on Cain and that God will avenge anyone who does harm to
- 11:25him. And so it's this fascinating
- 11:28story of judgement, yes, came being banished, but also mercy.
- 11:34And this is, of course, the tension that we all live with
- 11:37every day of knowing that we are all sinners who fall short and
- 11:43the are deserving of punishment, whatever that might look like or
- 11:46mean, but that God is merciful even in our sin.
- 11:52The very echoes of what we'll see in the Jesus story are found
- 11:56here at the very beginning of the Bible.
- 11:59Again, one other piece to this entire story, and it's that
- 12:06character of Abel. His the Hebrew word for Abel is
- 12:10Havel, which means breath. It's very temporary, and
- 12:15interestingly enough, Abel never says anything in this entire
- 12:19story. He's just this tragic figure.
- 12:23And more than anything else, he's also used there as a source
- 12:28of reflection for us about how temporary righteousness can
- 12:34really be. Yes, he did the right thing, but
- 12:36it's like vapor. It's here 1 moment and gone the
- 12:40next. It's almost ethereal, kind of
- 12:42pointing to the fact that none of us can be completely faithful
- 12:46all of the time. And not only that, but the use
- 12:50of this word for Abel's name, that the significance of that.
- 12:54Many rabbis have reflected on the fact that it's also
- 12:57compelling us to understand the vulnerability of our brothers,
- 13:03of those around us. Yet, yes, we are our brother's
- 13:06keeper because our brothers and sisters are like vapor, that
- 13:11they're fragile, they're vulnerable, and we need to be
- 13:14looking out for them in ways that Cain did not for Abel.
- 13:20So there's a bunch of thoughts about Cain and Abel.
- 13:24The story that we easily make into just one about jealousy,
- 13:27but one that actually draws us in to consider our own
- 13:31sinfulness and God's immense graciousness, as well as our own
- 13:37needs to be our brother's keeper.
- 13:40To be caring for those around us and positioning our hearts in
- 13:44such a way that we're bringing our first fruits to God and that
- 13:47we're turning our care towards others and not constantly
- 13:51inward. Because the more inwardly
- 13:53focused we become, the more self-righteous we become, the
- 13:58more selfish and narcissistic. All of this leads to violence
- 14:04and even death. This is what our story is
- 14:07leading us to help it give you some thoughts about new ways of
- 14:11considering this old, old story. Thanks for listening, for
- 14:15watching however you participated in this little
- 14:20study. And as always, friends, remember
- 14:22the story didn't stop with Sundays.
- 14:25Thanks for listening to another episode of Sunday School Remix.
- 14:29If you'd like more resources for your walk of faith, feel free to
- 14:32check out my Church's website, bethanydenver.org.
- 14:36Or you can download our mobile app by searching Bethany Connect
- 14:40in your phone's App Store.