Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / How Post-IPO Companies Use Insider Trading Windows Strategically
Transcript
- Lucas: If you've been watching the big movers this week, Coinbase up eleven percent in five days, Robinhood up nearly nineteen — you might wonder, is this a signal that insiders are about to start selling into the rally? Luna: That's the classic fear, right? A stock pops, and everyone assumes the executives are lining up to cash out. Lucas: Exactly. But the reality is much more structured. Most post ipo companies have very formal insider trading windows, and they use them strategically — not just to let executives sell, but to manage the market's perception of those sales. Luna: So let's break down the mechanics. What's the standard window look like? Lucas: For a typical company that went public in the last two or three years, the standard approach is a quarterly blackout period. It starts roughly two weeks before the end of a fiscal quarter and runs until about two days after the earnings release. That blackout can be six to eight weeks total. Then the window opens for a few weeks — sometimes as narrow as ten trading days — and then it closes again. Luna: So there's this very compressed time frame where insiders are actually allowed to trade. That's a huge contrast to the old stereotype of executives just selling whenever they want. Lucas: Right. And the key tool here is the 10b5-1 trading plan. That's the SEC rule that lets insiders pre-schedule trades months in advance, during a time when they don't have material non-public information. Once the plan is set, they can't modify it later — it's locked in. Luna: That's the rule that Elon Musk famously doesn't use, by the way. He's been sued multiple times over his Tesla sales because he tweets about them or sells without a plan. Lucas: Exactly. And that's why institutional investors actually prefer when companies mandate 10b5-1 plans for all insiders. It removes the timing suspicion. If a founder sells stock on a day the stock drops, the market might assume they knew something. But if the sale was pre-scheduled six months ago, it's just a liquidity event. Luna: So how do post ipo companies actually use these windows to their advantage? Give me a concrete example. Lucas: Take Palantir. They went public in 2020 via a direct listing. Their lockup expired in early 2021, and there was this huge overhang in the market — everyone assumed insiders would flood the market. But Palantir's management actually staggered their insider sales through structured 10b5-1 plans. They sold a fixed number of shares each month over a six-month period, which avoided the price cliff. Luna: And that's exactly what we've seen with the recent Palantir run-up — up fifteen percent in five days. The market knows the selling is pre-planned, so it's not spooked. Lucas: Exactly. Contrast that with a company like Rivian. They went public in late 2021, and when their lockup expired in May 2022, insiders sold aggressively — no 10b5-1 plans, just open-market sales. The stock dropped fifty percent in the following month. The lack of structure signaled panic selling. Luna: So the lesson is: it's not just about whether insiders sell, it's about how they sell. A well-designed program can actually be a positive signal. Lucas: Right. And some companies are now taking it a step further. They're using what's called a 'buy-write' program within the trading window, where insiders sell call options against their stock holdings. That generates income while capping upside. It's a way to monetize without sending a bearish signal. Luna: That's clever. But doesn't the SEC require disclosure of those option trades too? Lucas: Yes, through Form 4 filings. But the market reads them differently. A straight stock sale is often viewed as bearish. A structured derivatives trade is seen as a portfolio management tool. Luna: I want to talk about the role of the CFO here. They're usually the ones designing these programs, right? Lucas: Absolutely. The CFO and the general counsel work together to set the blackout calendar, approve 10b5-1 plans, and ensure compliance. One CFO I spoke with at a recent SaaS IPO said they actually schedule the company's secondary offerings to coincide with the open window, so that the offering prospectus is filed during a period when insiders are allowed to sell. Luna: So that's a strategic use of timing — the secondary offering happens when the window is open, not when it's closed. Lucas: Exactly. If a company announces a secondary offering during a blackout period, the market assumes insiders are desperate to get out. But if it's during an open window, it feels like a normal capital markets event. Luna: And what about the new SEC rules that went into effect in 2023 around 10b5-1 plans? I remember there was a big push for more disclosure. Lucas: Yes, the SEC adopted new requirements in late 2022 that took effect in 2023. Now, companies must disclose their insider trading policies in their annual reports, and insiders must certify that they are not aware of material non-public information when they adopt a 10b5-1 plan. Also, there's a cooling-off period — at least 90 days for officers and directors before the first trade under the plan. Luna: That cooling-off period is a big deal. It used to be that an insider could set a plan one day and sell the next. Lucas: Right. The old system allowed for abuse. Now, with the 90-day cooling off, it's much harder to time the market. And the SEC also requires that only one 10b5-1 plan can be active at a time for each insider, to prevent gaming. Luna: So the regulatory environment is tightening, but the smartest companies are already ahead of it. They're using these windows not just for compliance, but as a communication tool. Lucas: Exactly. And that's the takeaway for investors. When you see insider selling at a post ipo company, don't just assume the worst. Look at the structure. Is there a pre-announced 10b5-1 plan? Is the sale happening during an open window? Is it part of a larger, staggered program? Those details tell you whether it's a signal or just liquidity. Luna: Speaking of liquidity — quick honest thing here. This show, like all Fexingo shows, is ad-free and listener-supported. A handful of listeners chip in monthly through buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo, and that's literally what funds making this many episodes. If you find these conversations useful for what you're building or running, that's the way to keep them going. Lucas: Yeah, and it genuinely makes a difference. So back to the markets — one final point. The data shows that companies with well-structured insider trading programs actually outperform those without them. A 2024 study by the Rock Center for Corporate Governance found that firms with mandatory 10b5-1 plans had 12 percent less stock price volatility around earnings. Luna: That's a tangible benefit. Less noise, more trust. Lucas: Exactly. So when you see a stock like Coinbase jumping eleven percent in a week, the question isn't just 'will insiders sell?' It's 'how are they selling?' That's the real story.