Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #No.45🎙️ Public Inquiry Government Departments Under Scrutiny -Day 3
Transcript
- 0:04So this is how it goes. It's sort of like school. We turn up
- 0:08in time put our bags away and await to hear what goodies are
- 0:12in store for us for the next few hours. Proceedings begin with a
- 0:16question usually addressed to the departments either DFI or
- 0:21doe, and are revealed with drip like progress over the course of
- 0:25the day, we all sit waiting for the next question to be released
- 0:30from the lips of the Reverend Mother of the universe.
- 0:32Apologies, of course, I mean the commissioner. There's a frantic
- 0:36scribbling of notes as we endeavour to capture at least
- 0:38the essence of the question as each pearl of wisdom falls. In
- 0:43my case, I'm lucky if I can manage to write down half of
- 0:45what has been pronounced, not least, understand it there
- 0:48afterwards. In this world, a truly different language is
- 0:53spoken. They're quite fond of the abbreviations, acronyms and
- 0:57truncated words. I think it's English, but I couldn't be
- 1:00certain, joking aside, the day started by returning to two
- 1:05overnight issues.
- 1:07Mr. Fagan, barrister for
- 1:08fodc, agreed there had been a failure to comply with planning
- 1:11conditions, but stated that enforcement does not require the
- 1:15removal of the infill. This relates to a case inherited by
- 1:21the council originally investigated by the department
- 1:24doe in 2014
- 1:27which concluded there had been
- 1:29no breach of planning control. However, the original permission
- 1:33was a temporary three year consent with no environmental
- 1:37impact assessment required. The application clearly stated that
- 1:41the land should be
- 1:42restored to its original condition,
- 1:45which did not include unauthorised infill. This raises
- 1:49the question of how doe could determine the development was
- 1:53acceptable without proper planning assessment. In essence,
- 1:57dalradians
- 1:58use of landfill appears unlawful,
- 2:01potentially circumventing EIA regulations, which say
- 2:06unauthorised development should not be retrospectively
- 2:10legitimised
- 2:11or used to gain an unfair
- 2:12advantage by bypassing environmental law.
- 2:17Just to clarify
- 2:19EIA is focus on the environmental effects of
- 2:22specific projects, assessing their impacts before planning
- 2:26permissions granted. The other overnight, somewhat contrary
- 2:32topic was, of course, the cyanide. When the DFI came back
- 2:36with the proposed conditions for cyanide, you could have heard a
- 2:40pin drop as we listened carefully, no cyanide or cyanide
- 2:44base compounds shall be brought onto, stored, handled, used,
- 2:48disposed of anywhere within the application site at any time,
- 2:52whether directly or indirectly, in connection with the
- 2:55construction, operation, processing, treatment,
- 2:58mitigation or decommissioning of the development hereby
- 3:01permitted. As I said yesterday, we all thought that the cyanide
- 3:05had been removed permanently from the files, but it seems
- 3:10not. It was decided that this discussion will be moved to the
- 3:14designated day for mine waste. I think there was a collective
- 3:18sigh of secret relief, as it is, one contentious topic. After
- 3:25this, the questions came thick and fast, ranging from the
- 3:28discussions about the precautionary approach to the
- 3:31lack of a HRA, yes, we're back to the abbreviations, HRA, also
- 3:37known as habitats, regulations, assessment. I think if I had a
- 3:41name like that, I would be shorten it also turns out it
- 3:44doesn't matter what it's called, because it doesn't exist. Yes,
- 3:48you've heard that correctly. There is a shadow one produced
- 3:52by the company, but it is somewhat limited for the main
- 3:56mine and water applications. Why is this important? Because the
- 4:01HRA is crucial to ensure a mining project does not harm
- 4:05protected habitats or species, especially in designated sites.
- 4:09It assesses potential impacts in conservation areas and ensures
- 4:13compliance with strict environmental law. Without a
- 4:18HRA, a project cannot legally proceed if there's a risk of
- 4:22significant ecological damage. One thing one might say about
- 4:28the process is that the conversation is broad. In one
- 4:31instance, we grappled with turbo rights and the Crown Estate in
- 4:36the same conversation, who knew that these two topics could be
- 4:41bedfellows, albeit reluctantly, our next topic took us to the
- 4:46henhouse. Well, not quite. The question was around issues of
- 4:50conflict of interest raised by third parties. That's us again.
- 4:55There were many examples quoted in the room and offered up. Some
- 4:58were accepted and. Others were shot down in flames. The most
- 5:03significant one seemed to be around a company called Golders,
- 5:06who designed the original development for the mine.
- 5:09Nothing wrong with that, but now it appears that they are
- 5:12employed by DFI to oversee and review their own work. Hence my
- 5:17mention of chickens in that you wouldn't ask a fox to guard the
- 5:22hen house, and on that intriguing thought, I'd bid you
- 5:26adieu. I'd be back next week. You.