Latest / Dharma Lab / The Shadow Side of Meditation
Transcript
- 0:00SPEAKER_03: There have been a lot of headlines coming out of a lot of
- 0:02SPEAKER_03: the research that's happened over the years about a supposed dark side
- 0:06SPEAKER_03: to meditation.
- 0:07SPEAKER_03: Does meditation put us at risk for difficult mental,
- 0:11SPEAKER_03: emotional, perhaps even physical experiences?
- 0:15SPEAKER_00: What's the view that people bring to the meditation?
- 0:17SPEAKER_00: What's the conceptual understanding of what meditation is supposed to do?
- 0:40SPEAKER_01: Because if your motivation is to not feel sad and you believe meditation should be
- 0:48SPEAKER_01: the absence of sadness and you experience sadness in meditation,
- 0:52SPEAKER_01: then your subjective experience of that is going to be very different than someone
- 0:56SPEAKER_01: who feels like, well, My motivation is to train the mind and develop equanimity.
- 1:02SPEAKER_01: And I expect that anything that can arise will arise in meditation.
- 1:06SPEAKER_01: And so when sadness arises, then,
- 1:08SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 1:09SPEAKER_01: like you said, Cort,
- 1:10SPEAKER_01: like people have just reflected,
- 1:11SPEAKER_01: that actually might be an invitation to develop that equanimity.
- 1:15[music]
- 1:32SPEAKER_03: Welcome everyone to another episode of Dharma Lab.
- 1:35SPEAKER_03: I am Cortland Dahl,
- 1:37SPEAKER_03: your co-host,
- 1:38SPEAKER_03: along with world-renowned neuroscientist Dr.
- 1:41SPEAKER_03: Richard Davidson, who many of you probably know.
- 1:44SPEAKER_03: And we are here to have a really important and what I Dr.
- 1:47SPEAKER_03: Richard J. Davidson and Dr. Richard J. Davidson
- 2:08SPEAKER_03: This has been a major topic of research,
- 2:10SPEAKER_03: including the research that we've done at the Center for Healthy Minds.
- 2:14SPEAKER_03: So we're going to unpack that a little bit.
- 2:15SPEAKER_03: What does the science really say?
- 2:17SPEAKER_03: There are actually some very surprising and even counterintuitive findings here.
- 2:22SPEAKER_03: And we have an all-star panel to have this discussion.
- 2:26SPEAKER_03: So here joining Richie and I are Polina Belaboradova,
- 2:31SPEAKER_03: who is a social psychologist and a postdoctoral research associate at the Center
- 2:37SPEAKER_03: for Healthy Minds.
- 2:38SPEAKER_03: We've also got Simon Goldberg.
- 2:40SPEAKER_03: He's an associate professor in counseling psychology at UW-Madison,
- 2:45SPEAKER_03: also one of our colleagues at the Center for Healthy Minds.
- 2:48SPEAKER_03: And finally,
- 2:49SPEAKER_03: Matt Hirschberg,
- 2:51SPEAKER_03: another colleague from the Center for Healthy Minds and
- 2:53SPEAKER_03: a research assistant professor at the center.
- 2:56SPEAKER_03: So all three of our colleagues in a In addition,
- 2:59SPEAKER_03: of course, to Rishi are some of the leading researchers on this topic.
- 3:03SPEAKER_03: So, Rishi, why don't I just turn it over to you?
- 3:05SPEAKER_03: Maybe you could just provide a little bit of context.
- 3:08SPEAKER_03: Why is this even on the map of scientific research?
- 3:11SPEAKER_03: And then we can dive into the specifics of paper that was published recently
- 3:15SPEAKER_03: and some of what we've learned.
- 3:17SPEAKER_02: Yeah, so meditation and related practices today are being used in a wide range
- 3:23SPEAKER_02: of contexts,
- 3:24SPEAKER_02: one of which is with individuals with elevated rates of depression and anxiety
- 3:31SPEAKER_02: and other kinds of psychiatric issues.
- 3:35SPEAKER_02: And whenever we are dealing with interventions,
- 3:40SPEAKER_02: particularly when they're applied to patient populations,
- 3:44SPEAKER_02: in addition to looking at the
- 3:48SPEAKER_02: We always want to monitor for side effects, if you will.
- 3:53SPEAKER_02: This is something that is true of really all areas of clinical science,
- 4:00SPEAKER_02: whether it's a medication trial for a physical disease or
- 4:06SPEAKER_02: A behavioral intervention for a psychiatric problem where we really need
- 4:13SPEAKER_02: as researchers be attentive to the possibility that of course,
- 4:19SPEAKER_02: although our motivation for utilizing these interventions is to benefit people,
- 4:25SPEAKER_02: there are times when the interventions that we're working
- 4:29SPEAKER_02: with can actually either not have much effect or potentially even produce harm.
- 4:35SPEAKER_02: And it's our obligation and responsibility to carefully
- 4:39SPEAKER_02: and honestly characterize these potential side effects and publish them so
- 4:46SPEAKER_02: that we can be alert to these possible dangers.
- 4:50SPEAKER_02: And of course,
- 4:51SPEAKER_02: one of the most important issues is can we predict who might be likely to have
- 4:57SPEAKER_02: a possible negative effect and in that way ameliorate the possibility of So
- 5:05SPEAKER_02: that we can tailor the interventions more specifically to those who are most likely
- 5:11SPEAKER_02: to actually have benefit.
- 5:13SPEAKER_02: So that's the kind of broad framing.
- 5:15SPEAKER_02: And in the area of meditation, there have been a number of scientists.
- 5:19SPEAKER_02: Dr. Richard
- 5:19SPEAKER_02: Davidson, Dr.
- 5:19SPEAKER_02: Richard
- 5:20SPEAKER_02: Davidson, Dr.
- 5:20SPEAKER_02: Richard J.
- 5:20SPEAKER_02: Davidson, Dr.
- 5:21SPEAKER_02: Richard J.
- 5:21SPEAKER_02: Davidson, Dr.
- 5:21SPEAKER_02: Richard J.
- 5:22SPEAKER_02: Davidson, Dr.
- 5:22SPEAKER_02: Richard J.
- 5:22SPEAKER_02: Davidson, Dr.
- 5:23SPEAKER_02: Richard
- 5:23SPEAKER_02: Davidson, Dr.
- 5:23SPEAKER_02: Richard J.
- 5:23SPEAKER_02: Davidson, Dr.
- 5:24SPEAKER_02: Richard J.
- 5:24SPEAKER_02: Davidson, Dr.
- 5:24SPEAKER_02: Richard J.
- 5:25SPEAKER_02: Davidson, Dr.
- 5:25SPEAKER_02: Richard J.
- 5:25SPEAKER_02: Davidson, Dr.
- 5:25SPEAKER_02: Richard J.
- 5:26SPEAKER_02: Davidson, Dr.
- 5:26SPEAKER_02: Richard J.
- 5:26SPEAKER_02: Davidson, Dr.
- 5:27SPEAKER_02: Richard J.
- 5:27SPEAKER_02: Davidson, Dr.
- 5:27SPEAKER_02: Richard J.
- 5:28SPEAKER_02: Davidson, Dr.
- 5:28SPEAKER_02: Richard
- 5:28SPEAKER_02: Davidson, Dr.
- 5:29SPEAKER_02: Richard J.
- 5:29SPEAKER_02: Davidson, Dr.
- 5:29SPEAKER_02: Richard J.
- 5:30SPEAKER_02: Davidson, Dr.
- 5:30SPEAKER_02: Richard
- 5:30SPEAKER_02: Davidson, Dr.
- 5:31SPEAKER_02: Richard
- 5:31SPEAKER_02: Davidson, Dr.
- 5:31SPEAKER_02: Richard
- 5:32SPEAKER_02: Davidson, Dr.
- 5:32SPEAKER_02: Richard J.
- 5:32SPEAKER_02: Davidson, Dr.
- 5:33SPEAKER_02: Richard
- 5:33SPEAKER_02: Davidson, Dr.
- 5:33SPEAKER_02: Richard J.
- 5:34SPEAKER_02: Davidson, Dr.
- 5:34SPEAKER_02: Richard J.
- 5:34SPEAKER_02: Davidson, Dr.
- 5:35SPEAKER_02: Richard
- 5:35SPEAKER_02: Davidson, Dr.
- 5:35SPEAKER_02: Richard J.
- 5:36SPEAKER_02: Davidson, Dr.
- 5:36SPEAKER_02: Richard J.
- 5:36SPEAKER_02: Davidson, Dr.
- 5:37SPEAKER_02: Richard J.
- 5:37SPEAKER_02: Davidson, Dr.
- 5:37SPEAKER_02: Richard
- 5:38SPEAKER_02: Davidson, Dr.
- 5:38SPEAKER_02: Richard J.
- 5:38SPEAKER_02: Davidson, Dr.
- 5:38SPEAKER_02: Richard J.
- 5:39SPEAKER_02: Davidson,
- 5:39SPEAKER_02: I've been doing for quite some time and we really have the all-star team here.
- 5:45SPEAKER_02: I'd like to first turn it over to Polina who has published a very recent paper.
- 5:51SPEAKER_02: She's the first author of this paper on potential adverse experiences associated
- 5:57SPEAKER_02: with digital forms of meditation training,
- 6:01SPEAKER_02: something that has not been Thank you, Richie.
- 6:07SPEAKER_02: Indeed, previous
- 6:14SPEAKER_00: research has examined this question on meditation programs
- 6:17SPEAKER_00: that are either very intense,
- 6:19SPEAKER_00: like meditation retreats,
- 6:22SPEAKER_00: or longer-term programs like
- 6:23SPEAKER_00: the standard eight-week mindfulness-based stress reduction course.
- 6:27SPEAKER_00: And in this paper,
- 6:28SPEAKER_00: we were interested in whether People have some negative experiences
- 6:32SPEAKER_00: during their engagement with digital meditation programs.
- 6:36SPEAKER_00: And in this paper, we looked at the program that has been developed at CHM.
- 6:41SPEAKER_00: It's called the Healthy Minds Program App, and anybody can download it.
- 6:45SPEAKER_00: And first in this paper,
- 6:48SPEAKER_00: we make a distinction between adverse effects,
- 6:51SPEAKER_00: the term that has been used in the literature previously, and adverse experiences.
- 6:56SPEAKER_00: And the way we distinguish between these two variables We say
- 7:01SPEAKER_00: that adverse effects are the negative experiences that have been caused
- 7:06SPEAKER_00: by meditation and adverse experiences are just negative experiences that happened
- 7:12SPEAKER_00: while a person was engaged with a meditation program.
- 7:15SPEAKER_00: So we say that to call some experience an effect,
- 7:18SPEAKER_00: we need some strong evidence that it was caused by meditation.
- 7:22SPEAKER_00: And if we start with literature review,
- 7:24SPEAKER_00: where we say that in previous research,
- 7:28SPEAKER_00: the majority of the previous studies didn't apply the scientific techniques
- 7:31SPEAKER_00: to distinguish between effects and experiences.
- 7:34SPEAKER_00: And many of them claim that from the observational data
- 7:38SPEAKER_00: that people had adverse effects that were caused by meditation,
- 7:42SPEAKER_00: although the evidence doesn't support that.
- 7:46SPEAKER_03: This is a super interesting one.
- 7:48SPEAKER_03: In fact,
- 7:48SPEAKER_03: I was a subject in one of the first papers published in this by one
- 7:53SPEAKER_03: of our colleagues at another university.
- 7:56SPEAKER_03: We will be Britain.
- 7:57SPEAKER_03: And I was interviewed, you know, as part of that study many, many years ago.
- 8:01SPEAKER_03: So I've been on the other side of the microscope, so to speak, of this particular study.
- 8:06SPEAKER_03: And this whole point about adverse effects and adverse experiences is a really important one.
- 8:11SPEAKER_03: And I just want to ask kind of a grounding question to see if this way of thinking
- 8:14SPEAKER_03: about this is helpful or useful and how we might understand this.
- 8:19SPEAKER_03: So when I think about meditating or really any kind of mental training,
- 8:24SPEAKER_03: Dr. Richard J. Davidson and Dr. Richard J. Davidson
- 8:36SPEAKER_03: But the question,
- 8:37SPEAKER_03: it seems like what you're saying,
- 8:38SPEAKER_03: Kalina, is that that injury may or may not be due to their exercise regimen.
- 8:45SPEAKER_03: Like if you just took a thousand people and you didn't have them exercise,
- 8:48SPEAKER_03: some of them would just get injured just because people get injured as part
- 8:51SPEAKER_03: of their daily life.
- 8:52SPEAKER_03: So it's whether or not people get injured.
- 8:55SPEAKER_03: And then the question is, are they more likely?
- 8:57SPEAKER_03: Like are more people getting injured because they're doing the exercise program?
- 9:02SPEAKER_03: Or it could be the opposite.
- 9:03SPEAKER_03: It could be protective.
- 9:04SPEAKER_03: There's still people getting injured,
- 9:07SPEAKER_03: but it's actually less people than you would expect by virtue of
- 9:11SPEAKER_03: the exercise program.
- 9:12SPEAKER_03: And then there's yet another question, which is how do people relate to that when it happens?
- 9:17SPEAKER_03: Whether or not it was caused by the training intervention itself,
- 9:21SPEAKER_03: how do people tend to relate to that?
- 9:22SPEAKER_03: Do they stop exercising if they got injured because they view exercise as problematic?
- 9:27SPEAKER_03: Or does it teach them something important about the exercise?
- 9:31SPEAKER_03: How to exercise effectively?
- 9:32SPEAKER_03: There's all sorts of interesting questions that I think go beyond the headline
- 9:35SPEAKER_03: of just You know, it does or does not create these challenging experiences.
- 9:40SPEAKER_03: But maybe Simon, do you want to jump in here?
- 9:42SPEAKER_03: You can share your own thoughts.
- 9:43SPEAKER_03: And maybe first, is that parallel with physical exercise way off?
- 9:48SPEAKER_03: Or is there something similar that might be helpful in terms of how we might think
- 9:52SPEAKER_03: about this and understand it?
- 9:54SPEAKER_03: Yeah, I think that's a really nice one.
- 9:55SPEAKER_03: And I know it's one,
- 9:57SPEAKER_03: you know,
- 9:57SPEAKER_03: our group has talked about just to put some,
- 10:01SPEAKER_03: put up maybe fine point on the causality issue.
- 10:05SPEAKER_03: And in scientific research, we're fortunate to have the randomized trial.
- 10:08SPEAKER_03: Dr. Richard J. Davidson and Dr. Richard J.
- 10:23SPEAKER_03: Dr. Richard J.
- 10:24SPEAKER_03: Davidson and Dr.
- 10:25SPEAKER_03: Richard J.
- 10:25SPEAKER_03: Davidson and Dr.
- 10:26SPEAKER_03: Richard J.
- 10:26SPEAKER_03: Davidson and Dr.
- 10:26SPEAKER_03: Richard J.
- 10:27SPEAKER_03: Davidson and Dr.
- 10:27SPEAKER_03: Richard J.
- 10:27SPEAKER_03: Davidson and Dr.
- 10:28SPEAKER_03: Richard J.
- 10:28SPEAKER_03: Davidson and Dr.
- 10:29SPEAKER_03: Richard J.
- 10:29SPEAKER_03: Davidson and Dr.
- 10:30SPEAKER_03: Richard J. Davidson and Dr. Richard J. Davidson and Dr. Richard J. Davidson.
- 10:54SPEAKER_03: So it's really important.
- 10:55SPEAKER_03: I'm hoping today we can talk some about the different outcomes that can be assessed
- 10:59SPEAKER_03: in the kind of range of different experiences that people can have,
- 11:02SPEAKER_03: because I think that's quite important for understanding what meditation may
- 11:06SPEAKER_03: or may not do in those areas.
- 11:10SPEAKER_03: Super helpful.
- 11:10SPEAKER_03: So let's dive into some of the details.
- 11:12SPEAKER_03: Maybe before we get there, Matt, I'd love to just bring you into the conversation.
- 11:17SPEAKER_03: I remember just personally some of the first conversations I've had about this
- 11:21SPEAKER_03: and were around some earlier work you had published.
- 11:23SPEAKER_03: And you've published really interesting work and obviously been very,
- 11:26SPEAKER_03: very involved,
- 11:27SPEAKER_03: both as a practitioner,
- 11:28SPEAKER_03: as a meditator yourself, but also one of the kind of leading figures studying this.
- 11:33SPEAKER_03: But what are your just kind of opening thoughts just to help give some context
- 11:37SPEAKER_03: and what the science is showing in this whole area?
- 11:40SPEAKER_01: Yeah, I mean, I think Paulina and Simon covered a lot of it.
- 11:44SPEAKER_01: I think maybe a little more historical context would be helpful.
- 11:49SPEAKER_01: To some extent,
- 11:50SPEAKER_01: the initial studies looking at trying to understand whether and
- 11:55SPEAKER_01: to what extent there were difficult experiences in meditators was a response to,
- 12:01SPEAKER_01: I would say,
- 12:02SPEAKER_01: more than the scientific literature,
- 12:04SPEAKER_01: the sort of public And presentation of meditation or mindfulness is like a panacea
- 12:09SPEAKER_01: for kind of all ills.
- 12:11SPEAKER_01: And so I think people who had had some challenging experiences meditating sort
- 12:17SPEAKER_01: of took a step back and said,
- 12:18SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 12:19SPEAKER_01: I'm not sure Meditation,
- 12:21SPEAKER_01: all types of meditation,
- 12:22SPEAKER_01: really intensive meditation is good all the time for everybody and we should try
- 12:27SPEAKER_01: to get a handle on that.
- 12:28SPEAKER_01: And to some extent that's where this started.
- 12:32SPEAKER_01: That narrative became quite powerful in the public sort of sphere which led us
- 12:38SPEAKER_01: to ask the questions that we've been asking which is really like if we look at data
- 12:43SPEAKER_01: and causal data in particular where people Are randomly assigned
- 12:47SPEAKER_01: and we can actually make a statement that meditation caused X, Y, or Z.
- 12:54SPEAKER_01: Do we see evidence actually that people who,
- 12:56SPEAKER_01: for example,
- 12:57SPEAKER_01: do mindfulness-based stress reduction or in the case of this current paper do
- 13:01SPEAKER_01: a digital meditation training have higher rates of
- 13:12SPEAKER_01: So that's kind of where we ended up here.
- 13:15SPEAKER_01: And I think Paulina and Simon described that there's a technical issue here, which is causality.
- 13:21SPEAKER_01: So from the meditator's point of view,
- 13:24SPEAKER_01: You might have an experience and associate that or attribute that to meditation.
- 13:29SPEAKER_01: That's not necessarily causal in the way that we talk about the word in science.
- 13:34SPEAKER_01: So what we really need to do is where there's randomization,
- 13:38SPEAKER_01: see if that leads to more of one sort of experience than another.
- 13:44SPEAKER_01: And then I think, Cort,
- 13:45SPEAKER_01: you pointed to this,
- 13:45SPEAKER_01: the other side of this that's really important that we've paid less attention to is
- 13:50SPEAKER_01: So people may have negative experiences during meditation or,
- 13:56SPEAKER_01: you know, they attribute it to meditation, but what do they make of those?
- 13:59SPEAKER_01: So, I mean,
- 14:00SPEAKER_01: people have negative experiences every day just doing the things they do
- 14:04SPEAKER_01: in their life.
- 14:05SPEAKER_01: So in a way, almost more important is how do they make sense of it?
- 14:09SPEAKER_01: How do they How do they evaluate the meaning of that experience?
- 14:14SPEAKER_01: And in the case of meditation trainings,
- 14:17SPEAKER_01: like the things that we're studying,
- 14:19SPEAKER_01: in this study, we ask people, you know, are you happy that you learned to meditate?
- 14:26SPEAKER_01: Are you happy that you had exposure to this training?
- 14:29SPEAKER_01: Those are some of the more interesting findings from my point of view,
- 14:32SPEAKER_01: because some of those people are people who are reporting negative experiences
- 14:36SPEAKER_01: and are also saying,
- 14:38SPEAKER_01: Yeah, I had some difficult experiences, but I'm still really happy that I learned.
- 14:42SPEAKER_01: Actually, it's the vast majority of people who fall into that category.
- 14:48SPEAKER_02: I want to bring up one other issue very,
- 14:50SPEAKER_02: very briefly,
- 14:51SPEAKER_02: which I know you guys have all touched on in one way or another,
- 14:55SPEAKER_02: and anyone who wants to comment on this, please do.
- 14:59SPEAKER_02: But one of the other important insights from this work is that there's reason
- 15:06SPEAKER_02: to believe that at least certain kinds of meditation can increase
- 15:11SPEAKER_02: a person's sensitivity to anxiety or to certain kinds of Dr.
- 15:17SPEAKER_02: Richard J.
- 15:18SPEAKER_02: Davidson, Dr.
- 15:18SPEAKER_02: Richard
- 15:18SPEAKER_02: Davidson, Dr.
- 15:19SPEAKER_02: Richard J.
- 15:19SPEAKER_02: Davidson, Dr.
- 15:20SPEAKER_02: Richard J.
- 15:20SPEAKER_02: Davidson, Dr.
- 15:21SPEAKER_02: Richard J.
- 15:22SPEAKER_02: Davidson, Dr.
- 15:22SPEAKER_02: Richard J.
- 15:23SPEAKER_02: Davidson, Dr. Richard J. Davidson, Dr. Richard J. Davidson, Dr. Richard J. Davidson.
- 15:33SPEAKER_02: But what's really occurred is that they simply have become more aware.
- 15:37SPEAKER_02: And that may be an important,
- 15:40SPEAKER_02: actually,
- 15:40SPEAKER_02: early benefit and a marker that a person is indeed engaged in this practice in
- 15:48SPEAKER_02: the correct way, if you will.
- 15:51SPEAKER_02: So I wonder how that adds to this mix.
- 15:56SPEAKER_00: Yes, in this study we did look at what we call in science the predictors
- 16:00SPEAKER_00: of adverse experiences or what are the characteristics of people who are more likely
- 16:06SPEAKER_00: to report these experiences and one of our Our studies that went
- 16:12SPEAKER_00: into this paper show that people who had a higher level of baseline anxiety
- 16:17SPEAKER_00: and depression were more likely to report adverse experiences.
- 16:21SPEAKER_00: And one of the themes that goes through the series of three studies
- 16:25SPEAKER_00: which are included in this paper shows that one of the characteristics
- 16:28SPEAKER_00: that does predispose people to The reason we have these experiences is loneliness,
- 16:34SPEAKER_00: which we found out in study one and study two,
- 16:38SPEAKER_00: as well as study three,
- 16:39SPEAKER_00: which was a qualitative study,
- 16:41SPEAKER_00: which means that we actually asked the participants in
- 16:44SPEAKER_00: the training what It was protective for when they had some negative experiences
- 16:50SPEAKER_00: during meditations.
- 16:51SPEAKER_00: And one of the themes that showed up again and again in their answers was
- 16:56SPEAKER_00: that social support was important for them,
- 16:58SPEAKER_00: that being able to speak with their friends and their family and receive support
- 17:02SPEAKER_00: from these people as well as support from their therapist.
- 17:07SPEAKER_00: What was helpful for them to deal with these experiences?
- 17:10SPEAKER_00: And people showed remarkable resilience when we allowed them to speak
- 17:14SPEAKER_00: about their experience and how they related and what was helpful for them in dealing
- 17:19SPEAKER_00: with these experiences.
- 17:22SPEAKER_01: Can I add something, Cort?
- 17:26SPEAKER_01: So this isn't in the current paper,
- 17:29SPEAKER_01: but we've been doing some other analyses that Pauline has also been leading,
- 17:33SPEAKER_01: looking at trajectories during a meditation training.
- 17:37SPEAKER_01: So, for example,
- 17:38SPEAKER_01: you introduce somebody to a meditation training and what does it look like over
- 17:43SPEAKER_01: the first week, the second week, the third week, the fourth week like that.
- 17:46SPEAKER_01: And what we're finding across different samples and also different types
- 17:51SPEAKER_01: of training is that in some on some outcomes,
- 17:54SPEAKER_01: you actually see pretty consistently the meditation group is getting worse.
- 17:58SPEAKER_01: I think this is to Richie's point.
- 18:01SPEAKER_01: So,
- 18:04SPEAKER_01: But that worsening, so to speak, recovers.
- 18:07SPEAKER_01: And then by the end of the training, they've done much better than the control groups.
- 18:12SPEAKER_01: And in Tibetan tradition,
- 18:14SPEAKER_01: there's this analogy for meditation for mind training of the waterfall.
- 18:18SPEAKER_01: And the first phase of meditation training is sometimes described as becoming aware
- 18:24SPEAKER_01: of the flood,
- 18:25SPEAKER_01: so to speak, of your thoughts, emotions, sensations, and can even be overwhelming.
- 18:31SPEAKER_01: Not because the meditation is causing thoughts,
- 18:34SPEAKER_01: emotions,
- 18:34SPEAKER_01: sensations,
- 18:35SPEAKER_01: but because it's training awareness to recognize everything that's already going on
- 18:40SPEAKER_01: in the mind.
- 18:42SPEAKER_01: And so that just becoming aware of what's going on in and of itself can kind
- 18:47SPEAKER_01: of be overwhelming.
- 18:48SPEAKER_01: But over time,
- 18:49SPEAKER_01: as you increase your training,
- 18:50SPEAKER_01: then the mind starts to settle down and settle more and settle more.
- 18:54SPEAKER_01: And we're seeing some evidence in other analyses that we're running that
- 18:59SPEAKER_01: that general trajectory does seem to be happening.
- 19:04SPEAKER_01: So, yes, so I think related to the question, this is an interesting question.
- 19:10SPEAKER_01: Intersection with harm because some people may have that initial experience and
- 19:16SPEAKER_01: then stop meditation training.
- 19:19SPEAKER_01: And so what that means,
- 19:21SPEAKER_01: I think it's an important question what that means for their ultimate outcomes.
- 19:26SPEAKER_03: Yeah, I think it's important to disentangle a difficult experience from
- 19:32SPEAKER_03: a harmful experience, one that is sort of like a negative outcome.
- 19:36SPEAKER_03: Because actually, in many ways, meditation is just training you to deal with life.
- 19:41SPEAKER_03: That's one way to think about meditation.
- 19:43SPEAKER_03: And what happens in life?
- 19:44SPEAKER_03: You ruminate.
- 19:46SPEAKER_03: You have emotional outbursts.
- 19:48SPEAKER_03: You have bad habits that you're trying to work on.
- 19:51SPEAKER_03: You have good habits you're trying to build.
- 19:53SPEAKER_03: And And what meditation is doing is helping you relate to all of that,
- 19:57SPEAKER_03: hopefully in a more effective, balanced way.
- 19:59SPEAKER_03: And so if you just were able to meditate
- 20:02SPEAKER_03: without ever having any challenging thoughts,
- 20:05SPEAKER_03: for example,
- 20:05SPEAKER_03: any kind of toxic rumination or any emotional upheaval,
- 20:09SPEAKER_03: like how could you do that training?
- 20:11SPEAKER_03: Of course, if it's always challenging, then meditation is just a grind.
- 20:15SPEAKER_03: There needs to be something uplifting and You know, energizing about it.
- 20:19SPEAKER_03: But for me,
- 20:20SPEAKER_03: if I look back over my meditation,
- 20:21SPEAKER_03: a lot of it,
- 20:22SPEAKER_03: especially early on when I had a lot of social anxiety,
- 20:26SPEAKER_03: it was precisely because I felt anxiety during my meditation that allowed me in
- 20:30SPEAKER_03: the real world to actually not be totally overpowered by the anxiety.
- 20:34SPEAKER_03: In fact,
- 20:35SPEAKER_03: that was the biggest benefit of my practice,
- 20:37SPEAKER_03: I would say,
- 20:38SPEAKER_03: in my early years, is I was more grounded when things happened in real life.
- 20:42SPEAKER_03: And so If you had asked me questions, I would say, yeah, I was having a lot of those.
- 20:48SPEAKER_03: I had anxiety during my meditation practice.
- 20:51SPEAKER_03: I was ruminating during meditation, and those would be adverse experiences.
- 20:57SPEAKER_03: But that was the training.
- 20:58SPEAKER_03: That was why I was doing it.
- 21:00SPEAKER_03: So anyways, there's something a little interesting.
- 21:04SPEAKER_03: It's like,
- 21:04SPEAKER_03: are we detecting the right signal,
- 21:06SPEAKER_03: is the question,
- 21:06SPEAKER_03: because it could be very easily,
- 21:07SPEAKER_03: and when I see the headlines about this,
- 21:10SPEAKER_03: I always feel like, okay,
- 21:11SPEAKER_03: we're like missing,
- 21:11SPEAKER_03: we're missing something here, because it can, it could be so misleading in a way.
- 21:16SPEAKER_00: Yes, in one of the studies,
- 21:17SPEAKER_00: we actually asked people how they rated the specific adverse,
- 21:23SPEAKER_00: adverse in quotations here,
- 21:25SPEAKER_00: the experiences that they had,
- 21:26SPEAKER_00: and they rated some of the experiences as actually a positive,
- 21:30SPEAKER_00: so the list of These experiences that has been developed
- 21:33SPEAKER_00: by previous researchers include things like increased sensitivity to sound,
- 21:39SPEAKER_00: which participants read it as more positive than negative.
- 21:44SPEAKER_00: But then it includes experiences that are more universally negative,
- 21:48SPEAKER_00: like feeling isolated from people and disturbances in sleep and things like that.
- 21:54SPEAKER_00: But even those experiences that We would say they do sound pretty negative.
- 22:01SPEAKER_00: They didn't get a universal negative rating from all participants.
- 22:05SPEAKER_00: So it was what we call in science a distribution.
- 22:07SPEAKER_00: Some participants rated them as more negative,
- 22:10SPEAKER_00: some participants rated them as more positive,
- 22:12SPEAKER_00: but we didn't see a uniformly negative rating across any of these experiences.
- 22:19SPEAKER_03: So how many people,
- 22:20SPEAKER_03: just to get some numbers here,
- 22:22SPEAKER_03: how many people have these so-called adverse experiences?
- 22:26SPEAKER_03: Leaving the effect,
- 22:27SPEAKER_03: whether or not it's an effect of the meditation or not, to maybe the follow-up.
- 22:32SPEAKER_03: How common is it when people do these kinds of interventions?
- 22:38SPEAKER_00: I would say that it is pretty common to have negative experiences during meditation training.
- 22:44SPEAKER_00: And if I look at the statistics that we found in this paper,
- 22:48SPEAKER_00: we found out that about 30% of the participants across both
- 22:52SPEAKER_00: of our studies did have some sort of negative experiences
- 22:55SPEAKER_00: during their meditation training.
- 22:57SPEAKER_00: Again, which may not have been caused by meditation training,
- 23:00SPEAKER_00: but which have been subjectively attributed by participants to
- 23:03SPEAKER_00: the meditation training.
- 23:05SPEAKER_00: And in one study, 6%,
- 23:07SPEAKER_00: and in the other study,
- 23:10SPEAKER_00: 3% of the participants had what we call functional impairment.
- 23:15SPEAKER_00: Again, that was subjectively attributed to meditation,
- 23:18SPEAKER_00: which means that they reported Thank you very much.
- 23:21SPEAKER_00: Thank you very much.
- 23:44SPEAKER_03: And how does that compare to,
- 23:47SPEAKER_03: because this is with the Healthy Minds app, so it's a digital intervention.
- 23:51SPEAKER_03: I don't know if Matt or Simon, you have memory from previous research.
- 23:56SPEAKER_03: How does that compare?
- 23:57SPEAKER_03: How does what Polina just shared?
- 23:59SPEAKER_03: How does that compare to in-person interventions, for example, things like MBSR?
- 24:02SPEAKER_03: Do you see a similar, is it more people because those are more intensive interventions?
- 24:07SPEAKER_03: What do you tend to see in those interventions?
- 24:11SPEAKER_03: Matt, what did you find?
- 24:12SPEAKER_03: Do you remember?
- 24:13SPEAKER_01: The
- 24:16SPEAKER_01: way that study was sampled, we didn't just look at how frequent this sort of thing is.
- 24:22SPEAKER_01: I think actually the cross-sectional study is probably the best data to speak to this.
- 24:28SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 24:28SPEAKER_03: And I do think it's important.
- 24:31SPEAKER_03: Well, two thoughts, and I promise I'll answer your question, Cort.
- 24:35SPEAKER_03: One is that clearly people do have really challenging, disruptive experiences.
- 24:40SPEAKER_03: So for me, reading, you know, the Yeah, it's part of the training process.
- 24:44SPEAKER_03: Yeah, it's very much part of the training.
- 25:11SPEAKER_03: And in our cross-sectional work,
- 25:13SPEAKER_03: and this has been replicated more recently almost to the exact percent,
- 25:17SPEAKER_03: about 50% of people who have lifetime exposure
- 25:19SPEAKER_03: to meditation report some what they describe as an adverse experience.
- 25:25SPEAKER_03: Finding meditation,
- 25:25SPEAKER_03: the phrase that's often used,
- 25:27SPEAKER_03: challenging, distressing, there's another adjective in there.
- 25:30SPEAKER_03: But it's this sort of quality of the...
- 25:34SPEAKER_03: And we've modified that term because keeping your attention
- 25:38SPEAKER_03: on your breath is challenging for most of us,
- 25:40SPEAKER_03: but isn't necessarily what we would want to characterize as an adverse experience.
- 25:44SPEAKER_03: But we do see that these experiences are very common.
- 25:49SPEAKER_03: When you look at these checklists of specific things,
- 25:52SPEAKER_03: like Paulina mentioned the sensitivity to hearing,
- 25:54SPEAKER_03: there's feeling cut off from other people.
- 25:57SPEAKER_03: There's a whole number of them that have been identified and actually selected
- 26:00SPEAKER_03: from other symptom measures.
- 26:02SPEAKER_03: People do report those sorts of things,
- 26:03SPEAKER_03: and they're reporting it in our context with the Healthy Minds program.
- 26:09SPEAKER_03: But the causal evidence,
- 26:10SPEAKER_03: and I know we alluded to this earlier,
- 26:13SPEAKER_03: in all of the studies that we've run,
- 26:14SPEAKER_03: all of our Healthy Minds Program trials,
- 26:17SPEAKER_03: our reanalysis of MBSR data,
- 26:20SPEAKER_03: some recent reanalysis that we've done for mindfulness-based cognitive therapy in
- 26:24SPEAKER_03: a randomized context,
- 26:25SPEAKER_03: to my knowledge,
- 26:26SPEAKER_03: we haven't found any evidence that there's increased likelihood
- 26:30SPEAKER_03: of symptom worsening,
- 26:31SPEAKER_03: which is a way that we're able to measure harm and Dr.
- 26:36SPEAKER_03: Richard J.
- 26:36SPEAKER_03: Davidson and Dr.
- 26:37SPEAKER_03: Richard J.
- 26:37SPEAKER_03: Davidson and Dr.
- 26:38SPEAKER_03: Richard J.
- 26:38SPEAKER_03: Davidson and Dr.
- 26:39SPEAKER_03: Richard J.
- 26:39SPEAKER_03: Davidson and Dr.
- 26:39SPEAKER_03: Richard J.
- 26:40SPEAKER_03: Davidson
- 26:40SPEAKER_02: and Dr.
- 26:40SPEAKER_02: Richard
- 26:41SPEAKER_02: Davidson and Dr.
- 26:42SPEAKER_02: Richard J.
- 26:42SPEAKER_02: Davidson and Dr.
- 26:44SPEAKER_02: Richard J.
- 26:44SPEAKER_02: Davidson and Dr.
- 26:45SPEAKER_02: Richard J.
- 26:46SPEAKER_02: Davidson and Dr.
- 26:47SPEAKER_02: Richard J.
- 26:48SPEAKER_02: Davidson and Dr.
- 26:48SPEAKER_02: Richard J.
- 26:49SPEAKER_02: Davidson and Dr.
- 26:50SPEAKER_02: Richard J. Davidson and Dr. Richard J. Davidson and Dr. Richard J. Davidson.
- 26:53SPEAKER_01: Yeah, I mean,
- 26:53SPEAKER_01: this goes to Cort's sort of original point,
- 26:56SPEAKER_01: which is that it's not uncommon for people to experience difficulties
- 27:01SPEAKER_01: during meditation that they will frequently attribute to meditation.
- 27:06SPEAKER_01: But when we look at causal evidence,
- 27:08SPEAKER_01: we basically have never found evidence that A meditation condition leads
- 27:13SPEAKER_01: to higher rates of whatever it is, anxiety, depression, etc, etc.
- 27:19SPEAKER_01: And in many instances,
- 27:21SPEAKER_01: we've seen the opposite,
- 27:22SPEAKER_01: which is assignment to the meditation, people in the meditation condition.
- 27:26SPEAKER_01: Actually have lower rates of increased symptoms.
- 27:29SPEAKER_01: So it seems that meditation may be protective against the increase of symptoms over time.
- 27:36SPEAKER_01: And then the third thing that we see that Paulina spoke to at the beginning,
- 27:39SPEAKER_01: but I think the importance of the finding makes more sense in the context
- 27:43SPEAKER_01: of this conversation is meditation.
- 27:45SPEAKER_01: What are the characteristics that predict difficult experiences during meditation training?
- 27:49SPEAKER_01: And the things that are robust are difficult experiences.
- 27:53SPEAKER_01: So people who have higher levels of anxiety, loneliness, etc.
- 27:56SPEAKER_01: going into a meditation training are more likely to report anxiety, stress, loneliness, etc.
- 28:03SPEAKER_01: throughout the meditation training.
- 28:05SPEAKER_01: And this is another way of distinguishing causality from inexperience, right?
- 28:12SPEAKER_01: So I think about it like,
- 28:14SPEAKER_01: People who don't meditate walk around in the world and they get depressed
- 28:18SPEAKER_01: and they have anxiety disorders, of course, right?
- 28:22SPEAKER_01: So it's difficult to be alive.
- 28:24SPEAKER_01: We experience difficulties.
- 28:26SPEAKER_01: And so the question is really,
- 28:28SPEAKER_01: is there evidence that meditation increases the rates of those sorts of experiences?
- 28:32SPEAKER_01: And I think the overwhelming evidence to date is that it does not.
- 28:37SPEAKER_01: But I also think there's a nuance that we need to attend to,
- 28:42SPEAKER_01: which is There are different types of meditation, right?
- 28:46SPEAKER_01: And like the early work,
- 28:48SPEAKER_01: like the study that you were a participant in court,
- 28:50SPEAKER_01: that was talking to people who did very intensive meditation, long-term retreat.
- 28:55SPEAKER_01: And that's qualitatively different.
- 28:58SPEAKER_01: That's a different question than do people who,
- 29:02SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 29:02SPEAKER_01: are normal people who do a meditation app that they download from
- 29:06SPEAKER_01: The Apple Store have higher rates of X, Y,
- 29:09SPEAKER_01: or Z after doing it,
- 29:11SPEAKER_01: or a program like MBSR that relatively speaking is still pretty light touch.
- 29:16SPEAKER_01: And all the data that we're talking about is from these sorts of interventions,
- 29:22SPEAKER_01: meditation programs that a regular person walking about the world is likely to do.
- 29:29SPEAKER_01: So it's a different question to ask.
- 29:31SPEAKER_01: If you take a meditation night,
- 29:33SPEAKER_01: somebody who's never meditated and you say,
- 29:35SPEAKER_01: go do a one-month intensive meditation retreat, that's a different scenario.
- 29:39SPEAKER_01: And there's a lot of things that would need to be considered
- 29:45SPEAKER_01: where you would feel good about putting somebody into a situation like that.
- 29:48SPEAKER_01: Like, do they have the proper sort of pre-training?
- 29:51SPEAKER_01: Is it the right context?
- 29:52SPEAKER_01: Is there a good teacher or What are the practices that they're going to do,
- 29:56SPEAKER_01: and et cetera, et cetera.
- 29:57SPEAKER_01: And I think sometimes these two things get conflated because the anecdotal evidence
- 30:02SPEAKER_01: of real harm,
- 30:03SPEAKER_01: like where people are really suffering,
- 30:05SPEAKER_01: debilitating,
- 30:07SPEAKER_01: psychological,
- 30:07SPEAKER_01: and other sorts of difficulties that they attribute to meditation,
- 30:10SPEAKER_01: those are almost always from people who have done very intensive forms
- 30:15SPEAKER_01: of meditation,
- 30:15SPEAKER_01: not the sorts of programs that,
- 30:18SPEAKER_01: frankly, almost everybody who's been touched by meditation in some way is doing.
- 30:25SPEAKER_02: I would like to just ask a follow-up question.
- 30:30SPEAKER_02: Given the thrust of the recent work that you guys have done that's focused
- 30:35SPEAKER_02: on what probably is the most prevalent kind of meditation that large numbers
- 30:43SPEAKER_02: of people are exploring through Dr.
- 30:45SPEAKER_02: Richard
- 30:45SPEAKER_02: Davidson, Dr.
- 30:46SPEAKER_02: Richard
- 30:46SPEAKER_02: Davidson, Dr.
- 30:46SPEAKER_02: Richard
- 30:47SPEAKER_02: Davidson, Dr.
- 30:47SPEAKER_02: Richard
- 30:48SPEAKER_02: Davidson, Dr.
- 30:48SPEAKER_02: Richard J.
- 30:48SPEAKER_02: Davidson, Dr.
- 30:49SPEAKER_02: Richard
- 30:49SPEAKER_02: Davidson, Dr.
- 30:49SPEAKER_02: Richard
- 30:50SPEAKER_02: Davidson, Dr.
- 30:50SPEAKER_02: Richard J.
- 30:50SPEAKER_02: Davidson, Dr.
- 30:51SPEAKER_02: Richard J.
- 30:51SPEAKER_02: Davidson, Dr.
- 30:52SPEAKER_02: Richard J.
- 30:52SPEAKER_02: Davidson, Dr.
- 30:53SPEAKER_02: Richard J.
- 30:53SPEAKER_02: Davidson, Dr.
- 30:53SPEAKER_02: Richard J.
- 30:54SPEAKER_02: Davidson, Dr.
- 30:54SPEAKER_02: Richard J.
- 30:54SPEAKER_02: Davidson, Dr.
- 30:55SPEAKER_02: Richard J.
- 30:55SPEAKER_02: Davidson, Dr.
- 30:55SPEAKER_02: Richard J.
- 30:56SPEAKER_02: Davidson, Dr.
- 30:56SPEAKER_02: Richard J.
- 30:56SPEAKER_02: Davidson, Dr.
- 30:57SPEAKER_02: Richard J.
- 30:57SPEAKER_02: Davidson, Dr.
- 30:57SPEAKER_02: Richard J.
- 30:57SPEAKER_02: Davidson, Dr.
- 30:58SPEAKER_02: Richard
- 30:58SPEAKER_02: Davidson, Dr. Richard J. Davidson, Dr. Richard J. Davidson, Dr. Richard J. Davidson.
- 31:01SPEAKER_02: Are there any individuals for whom you would say meditation is contraindicated,
- 31:07SPEAKER_02: where you would recommend as either a scientist or a clinician
- 31:11SPEAKER_02: that they not explore meditation based on your current understanding?
- 31:18SPEAKER_03: I mean, 20 years ago,
- 31:20SPEAKER_03: I think an answer to that would have been someone with psychosis
- 31:24SPEAKER_03: or experiencing psychotic symptoms.
- 31:26SPEAKER_03: But now there's a literature of meditation for psychosis
- 31:30SPEAKER_03: that there's some amazing work that's come out around that.
- 31:33SPEAKER_03: I don't think there's a category.
- 31:35SPEAKER_03: Just to be clear, showing what?
- 31:37SPEAKER_03: Showing that it can be quite helpful.
- 31:38SPEAKER_03: That it can be beneficial?
- 31:39SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 31:39SPEAKER_03: I mean, they modify the practices.
- 31:40SPEAKER_03: So even in those very extreme cases, it can still be helpful.
- 31:42SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 31:43SPEAKER_03: And the same around trauma.
- 31:44SPEAKER_03: I mean, there's a whole kind of trauma-informed mindfulness movement,
- 31:47SPEAKER_03: and there's good evidence that it can be helpful for PTSD.
- 31:51SPEAKER_03: We see evidence in our own data that people
- 31:53SPEAKER_03: who have adverse child experiences can even benefit more in some cases than those.
- 31:58SPEAKER_03: So, Richie,
- 32:00SPEAKER_03: I don't think there's a category of people that I would say,
- 32:03SPEAKER_03: blanket, don't try this, this won't be safe for you.
- 32:06SPEAKER_03: I do think it's important to pay attention to the experience and to connect
- 32:10SPEAKER_03: with teachers and support.
- 32:12SPEAKER_03: And really,
- 32:12SPEAKER_03: one of the findings that's threaded through many of these papers
- 32:15SPEAKER_03: that Polina mentioned is this loneliness piece,
- 32:18SPEAKER_03: which I think is quite fascinating in that sense of A lack of sense of connection
- 32:24SPEAKER_03: with others does seem to be a consistent predisposing factor.
- 32:29SPEAKER_03: And really, to me, speaks to where these practices came from.
- 32:33SPEAKER_03: Sangha, the spiritual community, has been a huge factor.
- 32:35SPEAKER_03: We're part of these traditions often passed down with teachers,
- 32:39SPEAKER_03: and we have these maybe less embodied ways of accessing them.
- 32:42SPEAKER_03: So making sure that people are paying attention to their experience.
- 32:46SPEAKER_03: If things are getting strange, talk to someone that you trust, get connected with a teacher.
- 32:50SPEAKER_03: There's lots of amazing teachers out there, therapists, lots of ways to get support.
- 32:54SPEAKER_03: But I wouldn't say that it's contraindicated for a whole class of people,
- 32:59SPEAKER_03: certainly, from the data that we've seen.
- 33:02SPEAKER_02: Thank you.
- 33:03SPEAKER_01: The context here again is really important.
- 33:07SPEAKER_01: So like the studies that Simon is referring to with participants
- 33:11SPEAKER_01: who have psychotic disorders,
- 33:13SPEAKER_01: those are not people going off on their own and just meditating in a room and trying
- 33:18SPEAKER_01: to figure it out, right?
- 33:19SPEAKER_01: Those are done in a place where there is a teacher or a therapist
- 33:24SPEAKER_01: and there's some structure and So,
- 33:27SPEAKER_01: I mean, I think that also is very relevant to this conversation.
- 33:31SPEAKER_01: Like, what's the context in which somebody is doing meditation and experiencing difficulties?
- 33:38SPEAKER_01: And is there a structure in place to help them work with those difficult experiences?
- 33:44SPEAKER_01: And when there's not, then, yeah,
- 33:46SPEAKER_01: I think there's,
- 33:46SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 33:47SPEAKER_01: particularly for certain types of people,
- 33:49SPEAKER_01: there's a risk that things can go off the rails, so to speak.
- 33:53SPEAKER_01: So just wanted to add that again,
- 33:55SPEAKER_01: this is one of these nuances that I don't think has been attended
- 33:58SPEAKER_01: to carefully enough in the scientific literature,
- 34:01SPEAKER_01: at least when people talk about meditation and difficult experiences.
- 34:07SPEAKER_03: And Matt,
- 34:07SPEAKER_03: to your point,
- 34:08SPEAKER_03: you know,
- 34:08SPEAKER_03: in a lot of our big Healthy Minds program trials,
- 34:11SPEAKER_03: we haven't been recruiting folks with psychosis because
- 34:14SPEAKER_03: of feeling just like you're saying that there might not be adequate support.
- 34:17SPEAKER_03: So I think it's super, it's important to be careful and delicate.
- 34:22SPEAKER_03: And we're also not studying meditation retreats, which, as you said, is one of those contexts.
- 34:26SPEAKER_03: You know,
- 34:26SPEAKER_03: I've heard many stories,
- 34:28SPEAKER_03: tendency to experience mania when you're not sleeping in retreat.
- 34:31SPEAKER_03: And so there are contexts,
- 34:33SPEAKER_03: sort of aspects of the retreat context,
- 34:35SPEAKER_03: people sleep in retreat, but where sleep can get reduced.
- 34:39SPEAKER_03: And I have heard stories of people having manic episodes in that context
- 34:42SPEAKER_03: that can be kind of triggered in a way by the intensive practice.
- 34:45SPEAKER_03: So it's
- 34:48SPEAKER_03: I think there is something here to the need to be cautious about this.
- 34:53SPEAKER_03: But in some ways,
- 34:55SPEAKER_03: some of the statements in the literature seem to have swung too far,
- 34:58SPEAKER_03: emphasizing the harms and sort of throwing out the baby with the bathwater.
- 35:01SPEAKER_03: So I'm hoping that our work that we're doing,
- 35:05SPEAKER_03: especially our randomized trial work, is able to get more in the middle.
- 35:08SPEAKER_03: And then one other point,
- 35:09SPEAKER_03: just to not lose it,
- 35:11SPEAKER_03: is to acknowledge that Willoughby Britton,
- 35:13SPEAKER_03: who's been one of the amazing scientists really leading work
- 35:16SPEAKER_03: in this I know has written several places that from her perspective,
- 35:19SPEAKER_03: randomized trials aren't a good context for evaluating harm.
- 35:23SPEAKER_03: And I'd love at some point to have,
- 35:25SPEAKER_03: I've talked to her about that some,
- 35:26SPEAKER_03: but to understand more what she sees as the limitations.
- 35:30SPEAKER_03: I know some of it is the measurement.
- 35:32SPEAKER_03: We're not measuring the kinds of things that do get disrupted for people in
- 35:36SPEAKER_03: a bad way in our trial.
- 35:38SPEAKER_03: So our symptom worsening is a pretty gross measure of harm.
- 35:41SPEAKER_03: But I think from her perspective,
- 35:43SPEAKER_03: there's other aspects of the randomized trial that make it not ideal
- 35:46SPEAKER_03: for evaluating this.
- 35:47SPEAKER_03: So just to acknowledge that kind of counterpoint.
- 35:51SPEAKER_03: Yeah, maybe we could end.
- 35:52SPEAKER_03: I realize we're coming to the close of our session,
- 35:56SPEAKER_03: but I do think it's the,
- 35:57SPEAKER_03: from the point of view of the tradition,
- 36:00SPEAKER_03: there's a lot of context of just how to understand this and kind of coming into it
- 36:05SPEAKER_03: where you wouldn't,
- 36:06SPEAKER_03: you If you're learning how to meditate in a more traditional setting,
- 36:11SPEAKER_03: there's actually a lot of discussion about the challenging stuff that can
- 36:15SPEAKER_03: and does come up in practice.
- 36:17SPEAKER_03: And it's kind of viewed as just part of the process.
- 36:19SPEAKER_03: Like the training in large part is how to navigate the highs and lows,
- 36:24SPEAKER_03: which can be in some cases even more accentuated.
- 36:27SPEAKER_03: And Winger Rinpoche,
- 36:28SPEAKER_03: who I think we probably all know and we've had on Dharma Lab a few times,
- 36:32SPEAKER_03: he often says that meditating even for a few minutes with
- 36:36SPEAKER_03: a difficult situation is more impactful than meditating for months
- 36:40SPEAKER_03: when you feel like you're all...
- 36:41SPEAKER_03: Your mind is peaceful and things are going well,
- 36:44SPEAKER_03: precisely because you're training your mind to deal with the difficult stuff
- 36:47SPEAKER_03: that happens in everyday life, which everybody experiences.
- 36:50SPEAKER_03: There's nobody who gets through life.
- 36:52SPEAKER_03: Is there a life without adverse experiences?
- 36:54SPEAKER_03: I'd like to meet that person.
- 36:58SPEAKER_03: One
- 37:01SPEAKER_02: of the things Rinpoche also says,
- 37:04SPEAKER_02: which I found personally very helpful in my own practice,
- 37:07SPEAKER_02: is that when you have days when your practice just is not so good,
- 37:14SPEAKER_02: it's distracted,
- 37:15SPEAKER_02: it's obstacles arise,
- 37:18SPEAKER_02: that may be ultimately just as helpful,
- 37:21SPEAKER_02: maybe even more helpful than a day when you're really feeling great.
- 37:27SPEAKER_02: That instruction has really helped me just personally really stay engaged and motivated.
- 37:35SPEAKER_02: And inevitably, there are days that are less clear than other days.
- 37:41SPEAKER_02: And I think it's really helpful to keep that in mind.
- 37:47SPEAKER_03: Yeah, I would even take that a step further and say that 35 years of meditating,
- 37:54SPEAKER_03: There's a pattern where I think a lot of the breakthroughs and insights
- 37:58SPEAKER_03: in my practice have often come on the heels of periods
- 38:01SPEAKER_03: where it felt like my practice was going backwards,
- 38:03SPEAKER_03: where my mind was more distracted.
- 38:05SPEAKER_03: There was like just stuff coming up and it felt like, whoa, what's going on with my practice?
- 38:09SPEAKER_03: Oftentimes,
- 38:10SPEAKER_03: those were periods where although it wasn't necessarily as pleasant as times
- 38:14SPEAKER_03: where my mind was really peaceful,
- 38:16SPEAKER_03: oftentimes that was where really clearly important kind of some psychological,
- 38:20SPEAKER_03: emotional process was going on.
- 38:22SPEAKER_03: So...
- 38:23SPEAKER_03: Why don't we just close it out here?
- 38:24SPEAKER_03: We've just got a couple minutes left.
- 38:26SPEAKER_03: Maybe any just closing thoughts,
- 38:28SPEAKER_03: especially what for people who are out there who aren't scientists
- 38:31SPEAKER_03: who might be meditating or thinking about meditating or just broadly interested
- 38:34SPEAKER_03: in this whole area.
- 38:36SPEAKER_03: What would you say are the most important takeaways just from the deep dive into
- 38:40SPEAKER_03: the science that you all have done?
- 38:42SPEAKER_03: Anybody want to go just kind of start on the left of my screen here?
- 38:46SPEAKER_03: Simon,
- 38:46SPEAKER_03: you want to kick off just any kind of closing thoughts that you think it's important
- 38:49SPEAKER_03: for people to know?
- 38:51SPEAKER_03: I think there's a lot of rich stuff.
- 38:52SPEAKER_03: I mean,
- 38:52SPEAKER_03: I think the lack of causal evidence to me is important to kind of put out there from
- 38:57SPEAKER_03: the randomized trial work that we've done.
- 39:00SPEAKER_03: And also that challenges happen and people should, you know, pay attention and not...
- 39:05SPEAKER_03: Just barrel ahead thinking that this is a panacea, as folks put it.
- 39:10SPEAKER_03: And then one last thought just to put in the air is the metaphor to therapy.
- 39:14SPEAKER_03: And we know that when people go to therapy, all sorts of challenges can come up.
- 39:18SPEAKER_03: Exposure therapy for anxiety disorders in particular,
- 39:21SPEAKER_03: you're intentionally going in and— Utterly unpleasant process.
- 39:26SPEAKER_03: But one of the most clearly therapeutic techniques that's out there if it's done skillfully.
- 39:31SPEAKER_03: And I think, I mean,
- 39:32SPEAKER_03: in Ruth Baer and some of the early work on the mechanisms of mindfulness talks
- 39:36SPEAKER_03: about exposure as a mechanism.
- 39:37SPEAKER_03: And it's surely true that that's one of the main things that happens.
- 39:42SPEAKER_03: So I feel so grateful that we're getting to do this work with this group.
- 39:44SPEAKER_03: And it's been exciting.
- 39:46SPEAKER_03: And there's more to come that we didn't touch on today.
- 39:49SPEAKER_03: That's a very cool paper.
- 39:50SPEAKER_03: We'll share some of these papers in the show notes.
- 39:52SPEAKER_03: Polina, what would you share?
- 39:55SPEAKER_00: I would say in addition to what Simon said just now
- 39:58SPEAKER_00: and what has been said throughout our conversation,
- 40:02SPEAKER_00: what stood out for me in this study is the importance of exercising kindness
- 40:07SPEAKER_00: and compassion to oneself while just Dr.
- 40:10SPEAKER_00: Richard J.
- 40:10SPEAKER_00: Davidson and Dr.
- 40:11SPEAKER_00: Richard J. Davidson and Dr. Richard J. Davidson and Dr. Richard J. Davidson.
- 40:25SPEAKER_00: Dr. J. Davidson and Dr. J.
- 40:26SPEAKER_00: Davidson and Dr. J.
- 40:27SPEAKER_00: Davidson and Dr. J.
- 40:27SPEAKER_00: Davidson and Dr. J.
- 40:28SPEAKER_00: Davidson and Dr. J.
- 40:29SPEAKER_00: Davidson and Dr. J.
- 40:30SPEAKER_00: Davidson and Dr. J.
- 40:31SPEAKER_00: Davidson and Dr. J.
- 40:32SPEAKER_00: Davidson and Dr. J.
- 40:32SPEAKER_00: Davidson and Dr. J.
- 40:33SPEAKER_00: Davidson and Dr. J.
- 40:34SPEAKER_00: Davidson and Dr. J.
- 40:35SPEAKER_00: Davidson and Dr. J.
- 40:36SPEAKER_00: Davidson and Dr. J.
- 40:36SPEAKER_00: Davidson and Dr. J.
- 40:37SPEAKER_00: Davidson and Dr. J.
- 40:38SPEAKER_00: Davidson and Dr.
- 40:39SPEAKER_00: J. Davidson and Dr. J. Davidson and Dr. J. Davidson and Dr. J. Davidson.
- 40:48SPEAKER_00: That's wonderful.
- 40:49SPEAKER_00: Matt, what about you?
- 40:49SPEAKER_00: I think there's two areas for future research investigation that come out
- 40:52SPEAKER_00: of this area of research and we're both pointed to in this conversation and
- 40:54SPEAKER_00: the first
- 41:13SPEAKER_01: And we've paid very little attention to this thus far,
- 41:15SPEAKER_01: but why are people meditating in the first place?
- 41:18SPEAKER_01: And what role does motivation have in the way people interpret the experiences that arise?
- 41:26SPEAKER_01: And related to that is what's the view that people bring to the meditation?
- 41:30SPEAKER_01: So what's the conceptual understanding of what meditation is supposed to do?
- 41:36SPEAKER_01: Because if your motivation is to not feel sad,
- 41:41SPEAKER_01: And you believe meditation should be the absence of sadness
- 41:45SPEAKER_01: and you experience sadness in meditation,
- 41:48SPEAKER_01: then your subjective experience of that is going to be very different than someone
- 41:52SPEAKER_01: who feels like, well, My motivation is to train the mind and develop equanimity.
- 41:57SPEAKER_01: And I expect that anything that can arise will arise in meditation.
- 42:01SPEAKER_01: And so when sadness arises,
- 42:03SPEAKER_01: then like you said, Cort,
- 42:05SPEAKER_01: like people have just reflected,
- 42:06SPEAKER_01: that actually might be an invitation to develop that equanimity.
- 42:11SPEAKER_01: So same experience,
- 42:13SPEAKER_01: but With a different motivation,
- 42:14SPEAKER_01: a different view, it can mean something entirely different.
- 42:17SPEAKER_01: So I think we haven't done very well asking people like, why are you doing this?
- 42:23SPEAKER_01: What do you think you're going to get out of it?
- 42:24SPEAKER_01: And that view part also really important and something that we're starting,
- 42:30SPEAKER_01: the science is starting to pay more attention to,
- 42:32SPEAKER_01: but historically we haven't done a great job with.
- 42:37SPEAKER_03: Great point.
- 42:38SPEAKER_03: Richie, why don't you wrap this up for us?
- 42:41SPEAKER_02: Just very briefly,
- 42:42SPEAKER_02: I think that the overall pattern of findings
- 42:46SPEAKER_02: which you guys have shared is actually quite encouraging.
- 42:50SPEAKER_02: And it's a kind of message that I often give to people when I give public talks
- 42:55SPEAKER_02: in suggesting that
- 42:58SPEAKER_02: There's really very few serious adverse effects that are caused by this.
- 43:05SPEAKER_02: The practice is freely available.
- 43:09SPEAKER_02: There's a lot of work to suggest that it actually is beneficial.
- 43:14SPEAKER_02: So please try it and investigate and explore.
- 43:19SPEAKER_02: And if you find it's beneficial, you can then continue.
- 43:25SPEAKER_03: Great way to conclude.
- 43:26SPEAKER_03: Well, thank you for a great discussion, hopefully the first of many.
- 43:30SPEAKER_03: I imagine we're going to have many more papers to come on this topic and lots
- 43:35SPEAKER_03: of interesting questions to explore together.
- 43:37SPEAKER_03: So thank you for being here today.
- 43:39SPEAKER_03: And especially thank you for all the important work you are doing.
- 43:43SPEAKER_03: And for everybody listening, thank you for tuning in.
- 43:46SPEAKER_03: And we will hopefully see you soon for another episode of Dharma Lab.
- 43:50SPEAKER_03: Take care, everyone.
- 43:52SPEAKER_01: Thank you.
- 43:53SPEAKER_02: Thank you.
- 43:55SPEAKER_02: Thank you.
- 43:56[music]