Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Strategic Negotiation for Lawyers - Lessons from the FBI & Military
Transcript
- 0:02Thanks, folks, for joining us this afternoon
- 0:06for strategic negotiation for lawyers, lessons
- 0:09from the FBI and military. My name is Nada Saghafi.
- 0:13I am an attorney at Panache Raviputi. I am part
- 0:18of the firm's sexual assault litigation team.
- 0:21I have been working in California litigation
- 0:24after moving from the East Coast since October
- 0:272022. I'm licensed in California, New York, the
- 0:32District of Columbia, and Maryland. I'm a foundation
- 0:35board member for the Women's Lawyers Association
- 0:38of Los Angeles and vice chair of our very own
- 0:41Beverly Hills Bar Association litigation section.
- 0:46More importantly, though, our very important
- 0:50speaker for today. I'm just the moderator here
- 0:53is Judge Alan Honeycutt. Judge Honeycutt has
- 0:56served in Los Angeles Superior Court for 19 years
- 1:01and currently sits in Independent Civil Court
- 1:04of Unlimited Jurisdiction. He is the longest
- 1:07serving supervising judge of the Southwest District,
- 1:11has served on the executive board of the California
- 1:14Judges Association. and helped oversee the court's
- 1:19billion -dollar budget through its budget and
- 1:22personnel committee. The Los Angeles County Bar
- 1:25Association recently honored him with its outstanding
- 1:29jurist award for 2026. A major in the United
- 1:34States Army Reserve assigned to the Civil Affairs
- 1:37Command for the Indo -Pacific region, Judge Hanika
- 1:40is an FBI -trained crisis negotiator who trains
- 1:44military units on negotiation at the tactical
- 1:48level. And he brings earlier experience in law
- 1:52enforcement and police misconduct litigation.
- 1:55And as a dedicated educator, he has taught Hundreds
- 1:59of judges served as an adjunct law professor
- 2:02and instructed trial advocacy through the National
- 2:06Institute for Trial Advocacy. So thank you, Judge
- 2:10Honeycutt, for being here with us. Thank you
- 2:12so much. That's quite an introduction. Thank
- 2:14you so much. Well, today's discussion is about
- 2:18taking specific lessons from FBI crisis negotiation
- 2:22and military training and applying them directly
- 2:26to how we practice law and serve on the bench.
- 2:30Judge Hanneke, I understand that you can't share
- 2:33or discuss any specific work with the military
- 2:37or FBI. But can you give us an understanding
- 2:41of what FBI crisis negotiation training looks
- 2:46like? Absolutely. So the FBI has taken the responsibility
- 2:51of training law enforcement primarily across
- 2:55the United States in the areas of crisis negotiation.
- 3:00So the training course, there's really two courses,
- 3:03there's a basic certification, and then there's
- 3:05an advanced certification. I've attended the
- 3:08basic certification through the Los Angeles branch
- 3:12of the FBI, and so their crisis negotiation team
- 3:16puts on a week -long course. It's a full 40 -hour
- 3:22course that is taught by those active instructors
- 3:26for the FBI. to law enforcement and those that
- 3:29are related, some in the military such as myself.
- 3:33And it's really a scenario -based. So they'll
- 3:35do a lot of case studies. They'll walk us through
- 3:38the case studies that they have developed over
- 3:40the years. And then probably 50 % of it, the
- 3:44last several days, are really scenario -based
- 3:48training. So they will bring in... actors and
- 3:51we will go through scenarios involving active
- 3:54shooter, barricade situations, kidnap situations,
- 3:59suicides. So it is a very interactive and very
- 4:03reality -based training program. It is the preeminent
- 4:06training offered in the United States, and frankly,
- 4:09across the globe on crisis negotiation. There's
- 4:13a more advanced course, which is an 80 -hour
- 4:16course that is offered exclusively at the FBI
- 4:19headquarters in Quantico, Virginia, and I have
- 4:21not yet attended that program. Not yet. That's
- 4:24the key word. Not yet. keywords there. So I understand
- 4:28that you have been engaged in crisis negotiation
- 4:31outside of the FBI and military contacts. I have.
- 4:36You can share that with us. And I'd be really
- 4:39curious for you to share what those scenarios
- 4:42were, who was engaged, how did those scenarios
- 4:46unravel really paint a picture for us? Sure.
- 4:50So let me let me talk generally really to do
- 4:53talk about really kind of the the respecting
- 4:57the privacy of the individuals that were involved.
- 4:59But there are really two that stand out, and
- 5:01then there's a whole series of incidents while
- 5:05I'll just kind of address a collective. But the
- 5:09two are involving suicides. And sadly, members
- 5:12of the military are... have some of the highest
- 5:16suicide rates. So these are individuals that
- 5:18I knew in that connection where I spoke to an
- 5:22individual who was, this was over the phone,
- 5:25but in the context of stresses that they were
- 5:29dealing with, I think this was really the stressors
- 5:31were outside of this person's job in the military,
- 5:34but as a first responder, and they were expressing
- 5:38suicide ideation. And so it was, I think I was
- 5:43fortunate that having gone through and having
- 5:44had the background that I spent a lot of time
- 5:47with this friend of mine who was, he was suicidal.
- 5:54And I spent some time with him talking through
- 5:57his problems that he had. And as we'll discuss
- 6:02through the next 45 minutes or an hour. Most
- 6:07of it is simply listening and really helping
- 6:11that person kind of walk through and get in touch
- 6:14with what they're feeling and trying to help
- 6:16them find a light at the end of the tunnel. I
- 6:21can tell you that at that day, everything, my
- 6:24contact I've had with them has been positive
- 6:26and they seem to certainly be in a much better
- 6:28place today. The other incident that I had was
- 6:32actually a person in my courtroom. who was also
- 6:36expressing suicidal ideation. And I would have
- 6:41never expected an incident where I would have
- 6:44had to talk someone through that, but we did
- 6:47that here in the courtroom. And that was probably
- 6:51the most memorable day I've had in my career
- 6:55of walking this person through who was expressing
- 6:58that they were at the end and was really expressing
- 7:01that they were... This was really in the kind
- 7:04of context of a criminal matter when I handle
- 7:06criminal cases. But being able to talk them through
- 7:10that very dark time in their lives. And the other
- 7:14incidents, the kind of third category, second
- 7:17category of incidents, were all happening almost
- 7:19on a daily basis. You know, in a large portion
- 7:21of my career in the last 19 years, I've been
- 7:25about five, six years in civil, and the balance
- 7:27of my time was in criminal. But you would oftentimes
- 7:30have people who were in a very desperate situation.
- 7:33They found themselves in custody. They found
- 7:35themselves looking at multiple year sentences
- 7:36or life sentences and trying to address the stresses
- 7:41that they were under at that moment to keep them
- 7:44calm, to keep them focused. and to keep them
- 7:48safe and I would say that I use a crisis negotiation
- 7:51intervention techniques on a daily basis with
- 7:54those people particularly that were in custody
- 7:56and finding themselves in very desperate desperate
- 7:58situations. Yeah thank you so much for sharing
- 8:02those experiences with us that I sure are very
- 8:05memorable for you and how you really took those
- 8:10high stress high pressure situations and we're
- 8:13able to really tone down the temperature, which
- 8:15is going to be applicable to our conversation
- 8:18today. And I want us to backtrack a little bit
- 8:21and have you tell us a little bit about the history
- 8:26of crisis negotiation and the training engaged.
- 8:32Thank you. Thank you. So, you know, the the I
- 8:36think the birthplace of crisis negotiation as
- 8:39we know it today is really out of New York PD,
- 8:42the NYPD model following the Munich games in
- 8:461972, which was the taking of hostages, a terrorist
- 8:51taking of hostages and a lack of a organized
- 8:57process through negotiation resulted in the death
- 9:00of all of the, sadly, of all the hostages and
- 9:03many of the hostage takers that were involved.
- 9:06But following that, NYPD developed a model that
- 9:09we really use today, and the FBI took that on
- 9:12in 1974, and it's been adopted and changed and
- 9:16modified as the years have progressed, but it
- 9:19really, that is the birthplace of it, is through
- 9:22the NYPD and they're establishing this hostage
- 9:25negotiation. We use the term hostage negotiation,
- 9:30which kind of it was the incident that really
- 9:32kind of sparked this movement. But today we refer
- 9:36to it as crisis negotiation. So when we think
- 9:39of crisis negotiation and you contemplate it,
- 9:42what's the ultimate goal there to really. Narrow
- 9:46it down for the ultimate goal. I mean, if you
- 9:48can take to consider what a crisis situation
- 9:50is, I've mentioned a few kidnappings, barricades,
- 9:53bank takeovers. Those would be in the traditional
- 9:56law enforcement sense. But really what we're
- 9:58dealing with at the heart of those each of those
- 10:00situations is a person who is in a very dangerous
- 10:06situation. stressful situation, and they are
- 10:11in a position where they are not able to rationalize
- 10:14and think through, and we're trying to effectuate
- 10:17a safe outcome through really bringing them down
- 10:23from that stressors and those levels to the point
- 10:25where they can make an intelligent and more rational
- 10:28decision and really ultimately change their behavior
- 10:30is what the end goal is. So later we're going
- 10:34to... discuss a crisis negotiation model known
- 10:39as the behavioral change staircase. Yes. And
- 10:43why is crisis negotiation and that affiliated
- 10:48model that we'll discuss so critical in litigation?
- 10:52Thank you. This is the whole premise of this
- 10:55talk. When we started talking about this subject
- 10:57probably four or five months ago, I really wanted
- 11:01to bring this program because I do think that
- 11:02there's such a crossover between what law enforcement
- 11:06does and the crisis negotiation models to what
- 11:10we do. And I say, I use the term we, and I understand
- 11:12and recognize that I'm on the bench, but the
- 11:14audience and those that are listening in today
- 11:16are going to be primarily attorneys who are litigators.
- 11:20And I really hope that we can accomplish a change
- 11:23of mindset in applying crisis negotiation to
- 11:29the litigated case for this primary reason. 95
- 11:34% plus of all of our cases are going to resolve
- 11:37through a negotiated settlement. And I want to
- 11:39encourage people that they should be really preparing
- 11:42for that negotiated settlement. What is the likely
- 11:46outcome? Is the likely outcome going to be trial?
- 11:48Certainly, you need to prepare for trial. such
- 11:51as the motion for summary judgment, the dispositive
- 11:54motions, and preparing for trial. But you also
- 11:57should be preparing for that settlement negotiation
- 12:00on day one. And we'll also talk about how the
- 12:05tools and the steps and the process will get
- 12:07into momentarily. Let me add something, Lita.
- 12:09We talked yesterday about when I was an associate
- 12:13at a firm, Burke Williams and Sorenson, I was
- 12:15on the defense end doing a. public defense of
- 12:18cities and counties, governmental agencies. And
- 12:21I received a letter that I still remember to
- 12:26this day from a lawyer of plaintiff's counsel
- 12:28in Orange County, very well known plaintiff's
- 12:31counsel now. And he and I, just by happenstance,
- 12:34were exchanging messages today. I told him, I'm
- 12:37bringing up what happened between us, gosh, it's
- 12:41probably now 25, 26 years ago. But I opened up
- 12:45a letter from him that set the tone. And his
- 12:48letter, something to the effect, was introducing
- 12:51himself, that he was looking forward to working
- 12:53with me, that he believed in civility, professionalism,
- 12:57and if I ever needed an extension or courtesy,
- 13:00that he would be happy to oblige and look forward
- 13:04to continuing to work collaboratively on the
- 13:06matter and work together. That really set the
- 13:10tone. And so that's the example of what I think
- 13:12people should be doing, starting with that negotiation
- 13:16and starting with settling in on what are the
- 13:20expectations and the tenor and the tone, the
- 13:25temperature of the negotiation, because the negotiation
- 13:27really starts on that day one. It doesn't start
- 13:29at the day you walk in and see the mediator or
- 13:33see the judge for the mandatory settlement conference.
- 13:35It begins on day one. Yeah, it's so interesting
- 13:39that you bring up this experience from 25 years
- 13:42ago stuck in your mind because I think we are
- 13:45in a naturally perceived and indeed antagonistic
- 13:49profession where from day one we can still be
- 13:53doing right by our clients and create a tenor
- 13:59and tone and temperature that really calms things
- 14:03down a bit. And that's kind of a perfect segue
- 14:07to this idea of a parallel response that you
- 14:11and I have discussed with respect to crisis negotiation.
- 14:16Right. So I love this picture of Teddy Roosevelt
- 14:18and his famous quote, speak softly and carry
- 14:20a big stick, you'll go far. And if we took that,
- 14:24and of course, in the government and military
- 14:26context, we talk about negotiations on the world
- 14:29stage, having a very strong military that's ready
- 14:32to act if necessary, helps certainly promote
- 14:36diplomacy, is that threat of military action.
- 14:41But how do we then apply that if we look at that
- 14:44in our context is really kind of what we'll be
- 14:48talking about next. Yeah, and you know, this
- 14:50parallel response when you spoke of it is my
- 14:53understanding of that is employing these crisis
- 14:56negotiation skills, really bringing down the
- 14:59temperature alongside a tactical response. And
- 15:04as a lay person, when you initially use the term
- 15:07tactical response, I wasn't entirely clear on
- 15:10what that meant. And now I understand that, you
- 15:14know, and in my mind, a tactical unit is that
- 15:17fully armed unit that's ready to go, I think.
- 15:21Right. So in the context of like an FBI, a law
- 15:23enforcement, or even a military, the tactical
- 15:27response is the soldiers or law enforcement officers,
- 15:33the SWAT officers, that are prepared, if necessary,
- 15:36to use force. So the crisis negotiator is oftentimes
- 15:41a separate and a part. should be separate and
- 15:45apart from those that are on the actual SWAT
- 15:47unit or the tactical units, because they are
- 15:51establishing a communication with a person who's
- 15:56in crisis, but at the same time, that there is
- 15:59a tactical unit that is ready and is a presence
- 16:03there, credible. And if the negotiations, the...
- 16:09communication lines are not kept open and there's
- 16:12no alternative, they are prepared to bring in
- 16:16the SWAT team or the military unit, whatever
- 16:18it might be in that particular case. And when
- 16:21we were talking the other day, you asked me about,
- 16:23well, what is the term tactical? And oftentimes
- 16:25you'll see through some of my materials that
- 16:27we put together, putting in the term tactical,
- 16:31I jokingly described as sometimes the audience
- 16:33that I speak to and I train are those that aren't
- 16:36necessarily open to the ideas that are maybe
- 16:41foreign to law enforcement. They might be a little
- 16:44bit foreign to soldiers in the field. And so
- 16:48sometimes if we use tactical, they understand
- 16:51the terms and it's a little bit easier for us
- 16:53to explain to them. So that's a term of art that
- 16:57might be used. Yeah, yeah. Let's discuss that
- 17:02parallel response in the context of litigating?
- 17:06What are we considering a tactical response in
- 17:11litigation? So in other words, what is the SWAT
- 17:14unit response in litigation? Absolutely. So you
- 17:17can go to that. I came up with a new quote at
- 17:19the bottom, speak softly, but be ready to try
- 17:21the case. I mean, that's it right there. Being
- 17:25involved in, if we're starting negotiations from
- 17:28the beginning and from day one, we are always
- 17:32ready to try the case and be able to try the
- 17:34case competently, to be able to try to put the
- 17:36case on and to have the reputation, to have the
- 17:40ability to try that case. But understanding that
- 17:43only maybe 5 % or even less than 5 % of our cases
- 17:47are actually going to resolve through going through
- 17:50to jury trial or to court trial. Many of them
- 17:53are gonna be resolved. Some might be resolved
- 17:56through summary judgment motions or the like,
- 17:58but again, the vast majority, 95%, are going
- 18:02to be settled through a negotiated settlement.
- 18:04The tactical response is the trial that's maybe,
- 18:08unfortunately now, two years down the road, that's
- 18:11been set. But being able to negotiate in conjunction
- 18:16and in parallel with being prepared and getting
- 18:19prepared for trial through discovery, appropriate
- 18:21motions. And with that trial date that's looming,
- 18:26that's one of the reasons why I always set a
- 18:28trial date early on as soon as the case is at
- 18:31issue. Because I do think that it does help push
- 18:34things along. So really in the context of litigation,
- 18:38thinking of the tactical response of the trial
- 18:40and the associated motions, including that MSJ
- 18:44or those motions to compel, those are kind of
- 18:47the tactical responses. And we want to be utilizing
- 18:49those. alongside in parallel with kind of cooling
- 18:54the temperature, those negotiation tactics. Absolutely.
- 18:58Got it. So let's talk a little bit about what's
- 19:02going on and happening biologically in our brains
- 19:06when we're in full tactical response mode and
- 19:10negating the crisis negotiation side of things.
- 19:14Right. So this is what we call the amygdala hijack.
- 19:18And I want you to think for a moment about a
- 19:21time that you were engaged in an argument, whether
- 19:25it is someone who you might have a relationship
- 19:28with or maybe opposing counsel that was particularly
- 19:31heated. and your emotions are on fire. You have
- 19:35been, you're convinced that your position is
- 19:39right and when they tell you that, no, your position
- 19:42is wrong or that we're gonna take you to trial
- 19:45or whatever argument that you're having, there's
- 19:48nothing that that person can tell you in that
- 19:50moment that is gonna convince you that you are
- 19:53wrong. And why is that? Because the high emotions,
- 19:57the stresses that we go through and those instances,
- 20:00whether they be in the courtroom, whether they
- 20:02be in a crisis situation involving law enforcement,
- 20:06or whether either involved in our own personal
- 20:09relationships. When our emotions are high, we
- 20:12are not able to act rationally and think clearly.
- 20:16The brain's emotional center is really overwritten
- 20:20at that time. And there are studies that are
- 20:23available that show a person may actually have
- 20:26a reduced IQ level. Their adrenaline and cortisol
- 20:29surges and releases through the body. It really
- 20:32causes them to have a very narrowed focus and
- 20:34they're unable to really determine and consider
- 20:36long -term consequences of their actions. And
- 20:40they really become, as I said, very much unable
- 20:44to process and think rationally through these
- 20:46circumstances that they're involved in. And,
- 20:50you know, we have slides up and there's a side
- 20:53by side of. the amygdala hijack and kind of what's
- 20:56happening there as opposed to your normal functioning
- 20:59level. You went into this a little bit. Do you
- 21:01want to explain a little bit further? No, I think
- 21:02this illustration, for me, I always have to draw
- 21:06pictures. I'm on the bench and people are testifying
- 21:08and I'm literally drawing a picture and it helps
- 21:11me. So this slide was really meant to demonstrate
- 21:14if we're at a normal functioning level, our emotions
- 21:18are stable, whatever our baseline is, that we're
- 21:21much more closer to being able to make rational,
- 21:26intelligent, unemotional decisions, as opposed
- 21:29if we're in a highly volatile, stressful situation,
- 21:33our emotions are high, everything is volatile,
- 21:36our ability to think rationally goes down at
- 21:39the same time. So there's an inverse correlation
- 21:41between high emotions and volatility and our
- 21:44ability to think rationally. And so the entirety
- 21:47of the goal of Christ's negotiation is to bring
- 21:50the temperature down. to bring the volatile emotions
- 21:54down, to restore the rationality, the stability
- 22:00to the situation so that we can work it through.
- 22:04Yeah, and so I alluded to this earlier, which
- 22:07is the framework developed by the FBI's Crisis
- 22:10Negotiation Unit, known as the Behavioral Change
- 22:13Staircase. And I want to discuss that with you.
- 22:17And first and foremost, what is the intent behind
- 22:20the model? Right. So the intent of the model
- 22:22is to demonstrate in a very easy to understand
- 22:28step -by -step process. So it's kind of employing
- 22:32the KISS principle, right? Keep it simple and
- 22:36so that it's easy to understand for everyone,
- 22:39right? So this is something that would be taught
- 22:41to a patrol officer, to the soldier who's in
- 22:47the field. I'll throw you through a crisis negotiator
- 22:50at the FBI, and in this case, two lawyers. It's
- 22:54very simple to understand. And if you imagine
- 22:56it, that you have to be in order to effectuate
- 23:00what we're moving towards, which is the behavioral
- 23:03change, we have to go through these particular
- 23:07steps. And the first one is empathy, where we're
- 23:11establishing some understanding, not that we
- 23:15agree with the person's position, not that we
- 23:18are changing our own position, but that we have
- 23:23an understanding of what their position is. Rapport
- 23:27is we have established a bit of trust between
- 23:33the two. individuals, and that influences when
- 23:36we're ultimately be able to change their behavior
- 23:39to what we're asking them to do. And at the basis
- 23:41of each of these steps is the skill of active
- 23:45listening. And I know that everyone's heard about,
- 23:48well, active listening, sure, we know what that
- 23:50is. But we're going to go into it a little bit
- 23:52more in depth and really encourage all of you
- 23:55to practice this every day. So once you have
- 23:58a better understanding of what does it mean to
- 24:00be an active listener, that you really work this
- 24:02into your daily routine, not necessarily just
- 24:04in court, but in your everyday interactions with
- 24:08people. So we know that active listening is a
- 24:11foundational part of each of the steps of the
- 24:14behavioral change staircase. It is. But really,
- 24:17to start with, we've got to have self -control.
- 24:21Why is self -control so critical to the model
- 24:25in crisis negotiation and behavioral change in
- 24:29general? Right, so I think the self -control
- 24:33is the most important first step. It's really
- 24:38kind of the foundation of this whole idea of
- 24:40being able to try and influence the outcome of
- 24:43a situation. If we can't control ourselves, the
- 24:46whole idea is that we are trying to bring down
- 24:49the temperature. So if my first response to opposing
- 24:53counsel, or introduction rather, is a letter
- 24:56that says, I'm gonna take you to trial and you
- 24:59better be ready and we're gonna rake you over
- 25:00the coals, I'm not doing a very good job of keeping
- 25:04the situation cool, calm, and collected. I have
- 25:07to be able to one, recognize and be emotionally
- 25:10intelligent enough to reflect on, what are my
- 25:13triggers? what's gonna cause me to step out of
- 25:16line and to raise the temperature and to be prepared
- 25:20going into these conversations and into these
- 25:22interactions, knowing that, you know, opposing
- 25:25counsel is likely to say X, Y, and Z, and I need
- 25:28to anticipate that in advance, and here's how
- 25:30I'm going to react. Perfect example, yesterday,
- 25:34I was involved in a settlement negotiation here
- 25:37in my courtroom, and it started to get very contentious.
- 25:43I will tell you that as much as I practice this,
- 25:48I started to step out of that role. I started
- 25:50to lose control in the sense that when counsel
- 25:53made a statement, I immediately shot their position
- 25:58down. And I shouldn't have done that. It's counterproductive.
- 26:01And there's certainly ways and techniques that
- 26:04we'll discuss and ways that you can learn on
- 26:08how to handle people on an individual basis.
- 26:11But again, most importantly, I failed for a moment
- 26:15yesterday to control my emotions and I let that
- 26:21get the best of me yesterday. And so it's something
- 26:23that has to be practiced and it's really foundational.
- 26:25Absolutely. It seems like such a simple thing
- 26:29to practice. It sounds simple, right? Active
- 26:32was the self -control, right? But when you put
- 26:34it in practice, it is not as easy to do. Particularly
- 26:40when you're in highly contentious proceedings
- 26:43as we generally are as attorneys or, you know,
- 26:47officers of the bench. I think it takes a lot
- 26:50to recognize, hey, I'm stepping outside. of being
- 26:53in a position of control, and I need to be able
- 26:57to get back into it so that I can, again, cool
- 27:01the temperature and have the tactical response
- 27:04alongside the behavioral change where we can
- 27:07get things done. So that's a really interesting
- 27:11point there. Great way to summarize it. Thank
- 27:12you. Yeah. And so we talked about active listening.
- 27:16We can have an entire session on active listening.
- 27:20It's not the theme of today's session, but it's
- 27:23critical to the model. So how do you define active
- 27:27listening and what are some generalized active
- 27:30listening skills? Sure. So there are ways that
- 27:35we can employ to reduce the temperature, set
- 27:41the tone. I put some examples of voices that
- 27:45I like, Morgan Freeman's voice, Cliff Huxtable,
- 27:49a character on TV from many years ago, Yoda.
- 27:52So these are all voices and demeanors that I
- 27:57try to emulate when I'm trying to think about
- 28:00how am I going to bring the temperature down,
- 28:04slow the pace of the conversation, lower the
- 28:07emotions in the room, and project through sincerity
- 28:13of my voice, my actions. And then we go into...
- 28:18What are, I think is a terrible way to think
- 28:23about it, but the FBI has come up with this and
- 28:25you know, you might want to transition to the
- 28:27next, the more pies is what the FBI has come
- 28:31up with is to really kind of set up what are
- 28:33active listening skills and how can we remember?
- 28:36This is, you know, kind of keeping it, you know,
- 28:37simple and, you know, keeping it something that's
- 28:40memorable. But if you use the mnemonic more pies
- 28:42and try to work in, I find it very difficult.
- 28:47to utilize all of the active lifting skills at
- 28:50one session. But I really like to grab onto two
- 28:54or three or four that I feel comfortable with
- 28:56and use them as appropriately within a conversation
- 28:59such that it's not forced, it's natural, it's
- 29:04what's comfortable to me. And if it's comfortable
- 29:06to me, it's gonna be projected as being comfortable
- 29:09as opposed to forced and making someone feel
- 29:14as if you are, that they are being manipulated.
- 29:16Right? So if we talk about what are minimal encouragers,
- 29:20it's the, mm -hmm, yes, okay, those would be
- 29:24minimal encouragers. Again, we're trying to go
- 29:26along that behavioral change stairway by establishing
- 29:30empathy, trust, or rapport, and then ultimately
- 29:35influencing the behavioral change. Asking open
- 29:39-ended questions. How did that happen? How did
- 29:43we get here today? How are we going to do that?
- 29:46What do you see happening? How do you see this
- 29:48resolving? Reflecting, mirroring. So there's
- 29:51examples that are out there. Utilizing the first,
- 29:55or rather, the last three words of somewhat what
- 29:57someone has said. And some of these sounds so
- 30:00simplistic and so elementary. But if you really
- 30:05start to incorporate them, particularly the reflecting
- 30:08and mirroring. Reflecting is parading back, I
- 30:14use the term parading back, but in essence, taking
- 30:17the key words of what someone has said or the
- 30:19last three words and repeating them back to them,
- 30:22mirroring is really meant to be if you're in
- 30:24a situation where you're seeing the person face
- 30:27to face or they can see you maybe through a camera,
- 30:30that you're kind of mirroring their body language.
- 30:31So if the person has a tendency to lean forward
- 30:34in their chair, you're not gonna automatically
- 30:37lean forward at the same moment, but you may
- 30:38pause for a moment and then lean forward as well.
- 30:42it establishes a bit of comfort between them
- 30:44and starts to bring their guard down. Emotion,
- 30:49labeling emotions, so more, the E and the more
- 30:52pis. Labeling, you seem frustrated, you seem
- 30:57upset. Labeling how that person is feeling allows
- 31:03you then to continue and establish empathy, rapport,
- 31:07and eventually that change in behavior. Paraphrasing,
- 31:12Nina's doing an excellent job of paraphrasing
- 31:14and summarizing the P and the S right there.
- 31:18Just a moment ago, she's doing an excellent job
- 31:20of paraphrasing and summarizing what I'm saying.
- 31:24I messages, the I and the pi, the I messages,
- 31:28something might be the effect of I feel that
- 31:33we're unable or feel distracted from our ultimate
- 31:38goal of trying to resolve the case. or a collaborative
- 31:41when you're raising your voice at me. Effective
- 31:45pauses, sometimes people are talking and sometimes
- 31:48the most effective response is just silence to
- 31:51allow them to continue talking. Next time you're
- 31:54engaged in a conversation and someone is telling
- 31:55you something and they're going off and maybe
- 31:58the temperature's raised a little bit, try it.
- 31:59Just pause and they'll probably, in almost every
- 32:02instance, continue talking. And I find... that
- 32:06in a negotiation, settlement negotiations, oftentimes
- 32:09just allowing the parties to go through and spend
- 32:1230 minutes, 45 minutes, sometimes longer, depending
- 32:15on the nature of the case, getting their emotions
- 32:18out, letting them talk, letting them feel as
- 32:21if we've established that portion where I understand,
- 32:25I've established empathy, then we can move on
- 32:28to the point where they are starting to trust
- 32:29me. And these are getting constantly skills that
- 32:32we need to practice and incorporate in our or
- 32:35day -to -day lives. It doesn't necessarily have
- 32:37to be in the context of litigation or actual
- 32:40crisis negotiation. And, you know, you said it's
- 32:47a kind of potentially silly mnemonic, but I hadn't
- 32:50heard of it before chatting with you and seeing
- 32:52these slides. So I find it very effective. And
- 32:55it's a good reminder of kind of, oh, yes, more
- 32:58pies, those open -ended questions. Let me try
- 33:01some paraphrase. phrasing, let me pause, you
- 33:05know, easy way of kind of reminding myself of
- 33:08these active listening skills that I can employ,
- 33:11like you said, maybe three or four at a time,
- 33:13you know, we can't generally employ all of them
- 33:17all at once, but it's a good practice to remember
- 33:21to employ them in our even day -to -day conversation.
- 33:25So thanks for that, for that. Next time we're
- 33:27at the restaurant, you're having a conversation
- 33:29with a friend, co -worker, really try to take
- 33:33two or three of them and work them into your
- 33:35conversation. You've given us a quick rundown
- 33:40of active listening skills, what they are, what
- 33:43are they not? Right. Telling the other person,
- 33:47hey, let me tell you how you solve that problem.
- 33:50Let me tell you what you should be doing. It's
- 33:53giving advice. That's certainly not active listening.
- 33:59or let me tell you about what I did in my situation
- 34:02that you're facing, or discussing subjects that
- 34:05are not expressed, changing the subject to, we
- 34:09oftentimes want the focus to be on us. Unfortunately,
- 34:13I'm guilty of it sometimes. But I think that
- 34:16these certainly are examples of what active listening
- 34:19isn't, and it's certainly not giving advice or
- 34:22passing judgment or really solving a problem.
- 34:25It is truly. listening, and it is very difficult
- 34:28in those scenarios that we worked through with
- 34:31the FBI. You really had to force yourself to
- 34:38refrain from offering solutions. I think that
- 34:41many of us are action -oriented, solution -oriented,
- 34:45problem -solving. And the tendency that we have,
- 34:49and particularly A -type personalities, is to
- 34:51fix the problem. And that's not what we're doing
- 34:54here. That is not the idea of active listening,
- 34:57nor influencing another person. I want you to
- 34:59think back again to the time that your emotions
- 35:02were high and you got in an argument with someone,
- 35:04maybe with someone close to you. And they were
- 35:07telling you how to solve the problem. Hey, you
- 35:10need to change this behavior. You need to do
- 35:12this. that was something that is definitely not
- 35:14going to solve the problem or make us feel any
- 35:17better. We're more inclined to listen to what
- 35:19they're telling us. Yeah. So how or what are
- 35:23examples of how we can apply active listening
- 35:26to a litigated case? Sure. I think in situations
- 35:31where maybe you're involved with meeting with
- 35:34counsel, listening to what they have to say.
- 35:37If they're telling us, well, you know, this is
- 35:39the why our case is so strong, A, B, C, and D,
- 35:43I think a lot of times is that we get too involved
- 35:46where we want to tell them why their case isn't
- 35:49as strong, why they feel, why we think our case
- 35:53is strong, or whatever the particular issue might
- 35:56be. be able to provide them facts at a later
- 36:00time. But oftentimes, listening to the individual,
- 36:03I can give you an example. I had my daughter's
- 36:09fiance. We went through this exact scenario at
- 36:13his work. He's a lawyer. And they were having
- 36:17problems negotiating contract with another lawyer.
- 36:21And we talked about going into the meeting, and
- 36:25not listing out why this other person's points
- 36:29shouldn't be considered or why they were wrong.
- 36:34But he spent almost an hour simply listening
- 36:39and practicing the more pies. And it was amazing.
- 36:44He said he called me afterwards and said, my
- 36:45gosh, it works. And this was literally three
- 36:48weeks ago. And he called me and said, it's unbelievable.
- 36:52He just wanted to be acknowledged that his points
- 36:58had been considered, that they were correct or
- 37:01that they were intelligent, that they were acknowledged,
- 37:05but they just didn't work into the particular
- 37:07scenario that they were dealing with at that
- 37:09moment. So I think that any time that you're
- 37:11dealing with it, you're not necessarily agreeing
- 37:13with the other person, but through this active
- 37:15listening skills to establish empathy. Again,
- 37:18empathy is not that you agree with the other
- 37:20side, but that you simply understand and can
- 37:22appreciate their point of view. So interesting
- 37:26because we do so often kind of bring up the aspects
- 37:31of our case or the strengths of our case and
- 37:32we want others to hear them. But the reality
- 37:35is the other side wants to be able to be heard.
- 37:38on those same strengths. Absolutely, absolutely.
- 37:41they're going to know, right? They're going to
- 37:43know on the other side. And you'll have other
- 37:44ways, not maybe necessarily a face -to -face
- 37:46conversation, but you're going to be able to
- 37:48point out through your discovery, your deposition,
- 37:51your letter. There's so many different ways that
- 37:54you can point out the strengths of your case
- 37:56and the weaknesses of their case. And let's try
- 37:58to find that common ground and influence the
- 38:02outcome of the case without being in their face,
- 38:05confrontational, and again, raising the temperature
- 38:09and really shutting down the focus and the ability
- 38:11to find that collaborative solution. Again, 95
- 38:15% of our cases are going to resolve. They're
- 38:17going to resolve through a negotiated settlement.
- 38:20So I think it's an opportunity for lawyers to
- 38:23really kind of set the tone from the beginning
- 38:24and influence the outcome from the beginning.
- 38:28So we've talked about the necessity of self -control
- 38:32at the outset and active listening as a foundational
- 38:36part of the model. Now let's talk about each
- 38:40of the steps of the model and you've, you know,
- 38:43you in passing, you've mentioned pieces of it,
- 38:45but let's start with empathy, which in FBI or
- 38:49military circles is commonly referred to as,
- 38:52as you said earlier, tactical empathy. Tell us
- 38:55about tactical empathy and why it's necessary
- 38:59for behavior change. All right. So Nina and I
- 39:02had a conversation, you know, at length about
- 39:04why, why am I using the term tactical empathy,
- 39:07as opposed to simply establishing empathy. Well,
- 39:10for many reasons, the audience, again, that we're
- 39:15talking to, they may not be as touchy -feely
- 39:18with the idea of, hey, we want to establish empathy,
- 39:20or in their minds, sympathy for the other side,
- 39:23the person on the other side of the wall who's
- 39:25barricaded in the bank. So if we put the title
- 39:29tactical, it's a little bit more palatable for
- 39:32the law enforcement officer or the soldier to
- 39:35understand. And the idea is that we're using
- 39:37it to establish a connection that they feel that
- 39:42they understand, that you understand. FBI agent,
- 39:47law enforcement officer, opposing counsel, you
- 39:49understand the position that we have and what
- 39:52my client has gone through or what I've gone
- 39:55through and why I'm here. It's not accepting
- 39:57their situation. It's not necessarily agreeing
- 40:00with it. It's certainly not that we have sympathy
- 40:03for their situation, but it is tactical in the
- 40:06sense of we are practicing establishing empathy.
- 40:11in order to move us along towards the stated
- 40:15goal of influence and behavioral change. So kind
- 40:19of being like, yes, there is a identification
- 40:25of your feelings. And so I'm identifying that.
- 40:30And then we're moving to the next stage of the
- 40:33model, which is rapport. And what are things
- 40:38that you have seen whether a practicing attorney
- 40:43or on the bench that, you know, he'll rapport.
- 40:48And first let's backtrack and talk about what
- 40:50is rapport? Right, so rapport is the establishing
- 40:53of trust. So empathy, if we think about empathy
- 40:56as the establishing of a connection where maybe
- 40:59the other side understands what I'm going through.
- 41:03Rapport is, I'm starting to be able to trust
- 41:05this person. I can trust them, right? How do
- 41:08we build trust? I think if you give your word,
- 41:12you follow through. If you've made a mistake,
- 41:15admitting you've made a mistake. Trust is not
- 41:17necessarily friendliness or an agreement with
- 41:20the other side's position. It is standing by
- 41:24your word. Being a professional, civil is, I
- 41:31believe, predictable. They're all means that
- 41:34we can establish trust through report building.
- 41:38And going back to that question, what have you
- 41:40seen, again, either as a practicing attorney
- 41:43or on the bench that kind of kill rapport between,
- 41:48you know. Well, I mean, I know that no one in
- 41:51the audience or who's watching has ever been
- 41:53guilty of it. Never, never. But pointing out
- 41:56to the judge, I hear this pretty regularly. Your
- 41:59Honor. The other side is making a disingenuous
- 42:04argument. That's the least offensive term right
- 42:07here, right? But when you call out the other
- 42:09side and you say, in essence, the other side
- 42:12is a liar, Your Honor, what is that going to
- 42:16do to establish trust or build rapport as you're
- 42:23moving again towards? not this parallel approach.
- 42:26Trial is one thing. You have to get prepared
- 42:29for trial. You have to advocate. You have to
- 42:31file your motions. You have to advocate on behalf
- 42:33of your client. But there's a way to do it. Even
- 42:36in my writing, when I try to, when I make rulings,
- 42:40I make sure that I'm not using language that
- 42:43denigrates the other side, that calls out the
- 42:46other side. Unless, of course, if someone has
- 42:48done something that is clearly unethical, malicious,
- 42:54then that, of course, needs to be called down.
- 42:57But short of that, I'm always taken aback by
- 43:01how freely the insults or the underhanded insults
- 43:05are exchanged back and forth and the lack of
- 43:08cooperation. Yeah, you know, on the flip side,
- 43:12the things that we all do, obviously, how do
- 43:14we build rapport in litigation, whether that's
- 43:17with opposing counsel or with a jury? Right.
- 43:22So I think, when I was practicing, I was always
- 43:27operated, if it doesn't hurt my case, it doesn't
- 43:30hurt my client, I use that as a filter in making
- 43:36my decisions on how I'm defending a case or prosecuting
- 43:42a case. And a perfect example are giving extensions.
- 43:49making some accommodations for your opposing
- 43:52counsel. The case itself, if you really thought
- 43:55about it, while a bank takeover or crisis negotiation
- 44:00in the sense of like a hostage or a kidnap situation,
- 44:02that might be 12 hours. It might be 24 hours.
- 44:06It might be 36 hours. It's over an extended period
- 44:08of time. But what we're doing is we should be
- 44:11focusing on building rapport over the entirety
- 44:14of that case. And that could be a multi -year
- 44:17case, two years, three years, and really establish
- 44:20it at every point of our interaction with opposing
- 44:24counsel and frankly with the court and sometimes
- 44:27with mediators or third parties that are involved
- 44:31or in case ultimately, establishing that rapport
- 44:33and building trust with the jury. I think sometimes
- 44:36I mentioned one earlier, admitting mistakes.
- 44:39I do that quite regularly on the bench. If I
- 44:42get a ruling wrong, make an evidentiary call
- 44:45and see the error that I made or if I make a
- 44:48decision and I think it's an error, I'm gonna
- 44:51admit that I was wrong and I think it certainly
- 44:53establishes credibility with those that are in
- 44:55front of you, those that are on the other side
- 44:57of you, and those that are in front of you perhaps
- 44:59in the jury box by establishing a credibility
- 45:02through admitting your mistakes. Absolutely,
- 45:05I think it also humanizes attorneys and bench
- 45:09officers when we admit our mistakes. I think
- 45:11that's a really important component. I'm going
- 45:15to skip the next slide for the sake of time.
- 45:20And we can circle back to it if we have the time
- 45:23for it. But I want to move from rapport to influence
- 45:28in the behavioral change staircase. And I really
- 45:31want us to break down the tactics of psychological
- 45:35influence. So the first establishing connection
- 45:41through similarity. Can you give us some examples
- 45:44of that? Sure, sure. So the idea of psychological
- 45:49influence is certainly ingrained in the ideas
- 45:53of influencing the individual to gain, to maybe
- 45:58come out of the bank or give up and release the
- 46:01hostages. But in the context of what we do as
- 46:03far as interaction with people, opposing counsel,
- 46:06witnesses, there's a whole series of books and
- 46:13resources out there that really go in depth.
- 46:16And this is such an interesting area. You and
- 46:18I were talking about, we might end up doing a
- 46:20whole separate program just on How do you go
- 46:25about influencing someone? And certainly the
- 46:27behavioral change staircase and establishing
- 46:30empathy and rapport is certainly part of it,
- 46:33but there's so much more as far as the nuance
- 46:35behind it. And I've pulled out three of my favorites
- 46:39that I think are very, very powerful in establishing
- 46:44the ability to influence the other side, to come
- 46:49to see things your way. And one of which is establishing
- 46:54similarity. There's been psychological studies
- 46:56that if you establish similarity between the
- 46:59parties, so oftentimes during settlement conferences,
- 47:02I'll bring everyone together. And I know in advance
- 47:05that, you know, my silly example is, you know,
- 47:08that each of the parties both went to SC, right?
- 47:10So the fact that they have that connection. I
- 47:13try to establish a connection because right now,
- 47:15though, when they walk into the room, whether
- 47:17it be the plaintiff and the defendant, They are
- 47:22in complete opposite ends of the spectrum. But
- 47:24if you're able to establish some connection,
- 47:26it really starts to break down that wall to eventually
- 47:29bring them a little closer together in any way
- 47:31that we can do that. bringing up, oh, did you
- 47:35know that the plaintiff went to SC? And didn't
- 47:38you also go to SC, Mr. Defendant, Ms. Defendant?
- 47:41It really, really establishes some similarity
- 47:44and connection. I do that with people who I meet.
- 47:48So if I meet someone and I know that they also
- 47:51went to UCLA, I'll ask them, oh, and I think
- 47:53it's pretty common when you say, oh, you went
- 47:55to UCLA, I went to UCLA, right? So we try to
- 47:58find those similarities. Even having the same
- 48:04letter of your first name has been shown to establish
- 48:08similarity and connection and establish influence
- 48:12when you're able to point out even similarities
- 48:14as seamless, seemingly meaningless as the first
- 48:19letter. of your first name. So I met someone
- 48:21the other day who had the first name Alan. And
- 48:24so if you remember meeting someone who has your
- 48:26first name, you know, there's always that little
- 48:27bit of rapport that's built between you. And
- 48:29there's a little bit of connection when you have
- 48:31someone who has the first name or me as you,
- 48:33or maybe has the same, even the first letter
- 48:36of your first name. Well, put simply, really
- 48:38finding common ground with people. Absolutely.
- 48:40And you did this with me the very first time
- 48:43we met. You said, oh, Netta, you speak Farsi.
- 48:46Is your family? is your family from Iran? Right.
- 48:50And it's not a put on. I mean, it's really something
- 48:55that I try to do. And I want to make sure that
- 48:58I listen and I know about you and ask about your
- 49:03interests so that when I meet other people, I'm
- 49:05doing the same thing. I'm asking, well, tell
- 49:07me, oh. Where's your family from? Where I hear
- 49:10that you're from Boston. Oh my gosh, my daughter,
- 49:13she's a lawyer in Boston. And so you'd establish
- 49:15those connections. And when we have those connections,
- 49:18we're able to work together towards that common
- 49:20goal of, in this case, negotiations and settlements,
- 49:25right? Absolutely, absolutely. The second one
- 49:27I think is probably one of the most powerful.
- 49:30which is loss aversion and risk aversion, right?
- 49:33So what are we doing through someone that I had
- 49:36in my courtroom earlier in the week when we were
- 49:38doing another settlement negotiation, said, Judge,
- 49:41what we're doing here is we're simply... We're
- 49:43simply calculating how much risk we can tolerate
- 49:46and are we willing to take that risk and how
- 49:49much is it worth? And I love this quote, cash
- 49:55in your hand today or you're gambling on promises
- 49:56of gold after trial. Someone gave that to me
- 50:00and I think that's absolutely appropriate. And
- 50:04I try to make sure that people understand that
- 50:08and they appreciate that. And I ask them to imagine.
- 50:11what would it be like if you had this case resolved
- 50:14and you had maybe this money in your hand today
- 50:16as opposed to going forward and then running
- 50:18the risk of seeking a larger return after trial
- 50:24or being hit with a larger judgment after trial,
- 50:27certainly. Yeah. And you know, this third psychological
- 50:30influence tactic that you have listed on the
- 50:32slide is reciprocity bias. And I understand reciprocity
- 50:36bias is a psychological tendency that causes
- 50:39people to feel obligated to return a favor, to
- 50:43want to return a favor. examples, can you provide
- 50:47us a reciprocity? Absolutely. So this is, you
- 50:49know, one of my favorite movies is The Godfather.
- 50:52And when I taught law school, I taught evidence,
- 50:55I would use the Godfather movie. And one of the
- 50:58great scenes out of The Godfather is where at
- 51:03the wedding day of the Godfather's daughter,
- 51:08a gentleman comes to him and there's a quote
- 51:09that says, Godfather says, someday, that day
- 51:13may never come, I'll call upon you to do a service
- 51:15for me. And then he says, what has he done? He's
- 51:18established reciprocity. He's done some favor
- 51:20to right the wrong that this person came to the
- 51:22Godfather for. And the Godfather now has this
- 51:25person in their debt. So the best example, I
- 51:30think, and I can come across from what we do,
- 51:33what you do, is granting an extension. Oh, sure,
- 51:37you need an extension, not a problem. Or you
- 51:39need some accommodation, happy to enter a stipulation
- 51:42to continue the deposition or the trial date.
- 51:45But what have you done? You've created now a
- 51:48debt that is owed to you. And you may then at
- 51:52some point want to collect on that debt, and
- 51:54if not explicitly, certainly implicitly. Well,
- 51:58thank you so much for all those pleasure, you
- 52:01know, I your CLE materials has more fulsome.
- 52:06set of slides and also resources in the last
- 52:10page that Judge Honeycutt very nicely provided
- 52:12with respect to further reading. I do want to
- 52:15provide some time for Q &A. I see some comments
- 52:20in the Q &A box. I've been moderating, so I haven't
- 52:24been taking a close look at the Q &A, but I'm
- 52:26going to go ahead and read them out loud. Clayton,
- 52:29you said, here's another acronym. Wait, why am
- 52:32I talking? To remind yourself to listen and not
- 52:35attempt to give advice prematurely in an emotionally
- 52:38charged situation. That's a great one. That's
- 52:40a great one. I've got to use that. I'll put that
- 52:42in materials for the next talk. Yeah. So thanks
- 52:46for that. Sarah, you said, is it not part of
- 52:50professional and even moral responsibility? to
- 52:53share the wealth of experiences that we have
- 52:56and to make suggestions based on those experiences
- 53:00after we've gathered all the information following
- 53:03the active listening process. Oh, absolutely.
- 53:07I think that certainly can be done. And there's
- 53:09certainly ways that we need to communicate that.
- 53:11And if we consider the parallel approach. So
- 53:15it's establishing empathy, establishing rapport,
- 53:18keeping the temperature down, and through your
- 53:21motions and through your advocacy and that parallel
- 53:27approach. you are certainly providing your background
- 53:32and expertise. Maybe a junior opposing council
- 53:36who doesn't have your background and expertise,
- 53:38and maybe they're kind of going down the wrong
- 53:40path, so to speak. And one of the slides that
- 53:43we skipped over talks about the Titanic effect,
- 53:47right? And it's like everyone, sometimes we see
- 53:48people in the opposing council, they're going
- 53:50down with their ship and they just can't see
- 53:52that they truly have an absolute loser of a case,
- 53:56but they just keep going down. And I've seen
- 53:58it when people go to trial and we try to tell
- 54:01them this is not going to go well. And in fact,
- 54:03it doesn't go well. But they just can't see that
- 54:07tunnel vision is really narrowing. Yeah. Absolutely.
- 54:11Yeah. Jack said, is zealous advocacy in the 21st
- 54:16century AI enabled world just too zealous? And
- 54:21does that rule need to change? If so, how? and
- 54:28his mediation uses creative dispute resolution
- 54:31and the idea of zealous creativity trumps zealous
- 54:35advocacy. I don't know exactly what zealous creativity
- 54:39would mean, but it sounds very interesting. Do
- 54:42you have an idea of kind of what I have heard
- 54:45of that term? Well, I certainly think that I'm
- 54:49not in any way suggesting that you should step
- 54:52away from your role as a zealous advocate. But
- 54:54unfortunately, I think the term zealous advocate
- 54:57has been... it's really kind of lost its meaning
- 55:01over the years where if you, maybe if you did
- 55:03an AI search as far as what's the model, zealous
- 55:07advocate look like, you might get someone who's
- 55:10a yeller and screamer and who's telling, we're
- 55:13gonna take you down to trial or you fill in the
- 55:15blank of whatever stereotypes that we have. zealous
- 55:19advocacy can be just like this plaintiff's counsel
- 55:22who I dealt with in Orange County, who has an
- 55:24incredible reputation and a very successful firm,
- 55:29plaintiff's firm, who has the ability to go to
- 55:33trial, has the ability to win at trial, who has
- 55:35the ability to win giant verdicts, but who is
- 55:39yet, who is as calm and as cooperative as anyone
- 55:45that's out there. there are really two parallel
- 55:47tracks. And I think that he is certainly a zealous
- 55:49advocate, but yet at the same time, is a masterful
- 55:54negotiator because he is really practicing influence
- 55:57and collaboration with his goal of trying to
- 56:02influence the outcome towards his benefit and
- 56:06the benefit of his client. Yeah. Yeah, certainly
- 56:08points to be thinking about AI. It's here, folks.
- 56:11Yeah, absolutely. Clayton, your question gets
- 56:16to, when is the proper timing of when to segue
- 56:22from tactical empathy or active listening to
- 56:25providing professional advice? And it says, often
- 56:28many attorneys transition prematurely from the
- 56:31first stage to the second. Right, I think that's
- 56:34a wonderful point. In some of the larger, the
- 56:38fuller slides that you'll get through your CLA
- 56:39materials, there should be one of them that talks
- 56:42about what are the kind of the problems that
- 56:43we see. And that's just exactly the point there
- 56:46is abandoning, not thinking, well, this. This
- 56:49nonsense that Judge Honeycutt talked about, about
- 56:51being empathetic and rapport building, and that's
- 56:56just not working. They haven't seen it my way,
- 56:57so I'm going to go back to my old ways. So the
- 57:00abandoning of that and going back to the traditional
- 57:04adversarial rules is one of the biggest mistakes
- 57:09that we see. And we've seen that through case
- 57:11studies to the FBI and law enforcement, where
- 57:13there's really this tendency to lean on the use
- 57:18of force and solution to maybe a hostage situation
- 57:22as opposed to this idea of being able to kind
- 57:25of talk it through and trying to reach a resolution
- 57:28without something short of the tactical response,
- 57:31whether it be SWAT, military action or trial.
- 57:36Yeah, absolutely. Lan, I apologize if I'm saying
- 57:41your name incorrectly. Civility goes a long way.
- 57:44I usually pick up the phone when I feel the communications
- 57:46are getting too email heavy. Absolutely agree.
- 57:50There's a lot of power in picking up the phone
- 57:52and just making the phone call. Even face -to
- 57:55-face meetings, which I think we have kind of
- 57:58lost touch with, unfortunately, those also go
- 58:01a very long way, particularly when it comes to
- 58:04utilizing a lot of the skills that we talked
- 58:06about today. Michelle quickly, I've had situations
- 58:11where I have counsel going at each other and
- 58:13I'll we'll go into chambers and we'll bring or
- 58:16go in the back hallway. And I'll just simply
- 58:17ask, you know, Mr. Jones, what's what's what's
- 58:22wrong? We know what how are you doing? What's
- 58:24going on today? And I'm always amazed at, you
- 58:28know, they'll just open up and talk about, you
- 58:30know, I'm sorry, Judge, this has been happening.
- 58:31We've had this situation at home problem in my
- 58:34office. this case, counsel, whatever it might
- 58:37be, but just really trying to diffuse in this
- 58:38situation and kind of getting back to maybe what
- 58:41they're dealing with. So please continue. Yeah.
- 58:44Michelle, thank you for your comment. We appreciate
- 58:48that you found this useful. Skye says, how can
- 58:51we take the FBI course, Judge Honeycutt? Unfortunately,
- 58:55it's only open to law enforcement. Or in my case,
- 59:00I was able to get into the military. I left law
- 59:03enforcement before I became a judge. But I would
- 59:07suggest that there are some really great resources
- 59:09that are out there. And we do have some of them
- 59:11listed in your slide. One of them is a book by
- 59:14the name. Many people are familiar with it. It's
- 59:17called Never Split the Difference by one of the
- 59:19original NYPD hostage negotiators, Chris Voss.
- 59:24He does a great job. It's very easy to read.
- 59:27It's a fun read, but he takes it. It's not quite
- 59:29as structured as what we're putting on here today,
- 59:32but you can take that away. There's a author,
- 59:36a psychiatrist by the name of Cialdini, and I
- 59:39think I have two of his books. One is called
- 59:40Influence. The one I think that's better to read
- 59:43is called Presuasion. One is influence, the other
- 59:47is persuasion. I'd start with persuasion and
- 59:49then go to influence. There's another person
- 59:51out there by the name of Brad Hughes who was
- 59:53formerly in a unit similar to mine, psychological
- 59:57operations in the military. His materials are
- 1:00:01good, but they are very much like a technical
- 1:00:04manual, sometimes a little bit too dry to really
- 1:00:08kind of take a material out of. great resources
- 1:00:12there. So, unfortunately, you can't take it,
- 1:00:14but you can check out those books. Those are
- 1:00:16my favorite. Thank you. And I'll take this last
- 1:00:23question. I know we're a few minutes over from
- 1:00:25Jess who says, I come in contact with opposed
- 1:00:29parties that often have mental illness, often
- 1:00:33high functioning, but not rational. Do you have
- 1:00:36any suggestions for how to handle these individuals?
- 1:00:39perhaps double down on active listening? Yeah,
- 1:00:44when I've had situations in my former days as
- 1:00:46a criminal judge, when we had those situations,
- 1:00:50there's the universal language of a smile, of
- 1:00:54a head nod. And fortunately, some people are
- 1:00:57so far gone in their mental illness that you
- 1:01:01can't meet and address them. And sometimes they
- 1:01:05need to get the help before or medication treatment
- 1:01:08before they can engage in any rational conversations.
- 1:01:12A very difficult situation, it sounds like, that
- 1:01:14you're in there. I certainly can understand those
- 1:01:19hardships that you're dealing with there, mental
- 1:01:21health. at or over time, but thank you all for
- 1:01:27joining us. Judge Honeycutt, thank you so much
- 1:01:29for giving us your time. Absolutely, my pleasure.
- 1:01:33And your expertise. I have found this to be really
- 1:01:36helpful. Hopefully all of you have as well. Please
- 1:01:39feel free. You can certainly reach out to me.
- 1:01:43And I'm always happy to be a thought partner
- 1:01:45as well. And thank you again. Thank you. Thank
- 1:01:49you to you all. I always invite people to reach
- 1:01:52out. And I think you have my LinkedIn that's
- 1:01:55there. It's a lonely job. Nobody comes to see
- 1:01:58and talk to the judge or say hello to the judge.
- 1:02:01So please reach out. Obviously, we can't talk
- 1:02:03about any particular cases, but happy to meet
- 1:02:05you and talk through. We've obviously only just
- 1:02:08touched the tip of the iceberg. This is something
- 1:02:10that's a 40 -hour class to really understand
- 1:02:13and get into just to begin the basics of it.
- 1:02:15So hopefully that you'll have all started your
- 1:02:17journey with some interest in this area. Take
- 1:02:19care. Thank you all.