Latest / Journey to the Fringe / Fringey Minis - Labor to the courts
Transcript
- 0:00Okay, let's see what I got. I felt like I was gonna pick one this week.
- 0:04I think you'll like this one from our favorite vice and it's entitled I think you'll like it.
- 0:10Amazon joins Elon Musk's SpaceX in mission to destroy federal agency protecting workers.
- 0:16Oh, yeah, I've been following this. It's nuts.
- 0:18Have you? I actually have a reddit.
- 0:20The Supreme Court's crazy enough that this just might work in the US, but let's go through the story.
- 0:25Okay, I know nothing about it.
- 0:26I was waiting to read this so that I could react with everybody as well.
- 0:30Of course, you know, in in live time, not at the time of everyone listening.
- 0:34So what starts here?
- 0:36Amazon is the latest company facing labor charges to argue that the National Labor Relations Board is unconstitutional.
- 0:42I don't think that was the article.
- 0:44Amazon argued in a court filing on Thursday that the National Labor Relations Board is
- 0:52unconstitutional as part of an ongoing case against the company for retaliation against unionized workers.
- 0:58It is the third company to do so in recent months joining Trader Joe's and Elon Musk's SpaceX.
- 1:05Musk's is hard to say.
- 1:06The NLRB is investigating numerous unfair labor practice charges against Amazon for its anti-union activity in JFK 8,
- 1:15the famed Staten Island warehouse that became the first in the US to unionize in 2022.
- 1:20Despite being certified by labor officials, the union has still not managed to bring Amazon to the bargaining table.
- 1:26The current case involves the allegedly illegal firing of union workers,
- 1:30retaliation against organizing activities and unilateral changes made by management without negotiation.
- 1:36Amazon in response argued that the NLRB's actions and structure violate the Constitution's separation of powers
- 1:44and Amazon's due process right under the Fifth Amendment.
- 1:47Due process right under the Fifth Amendment.
- 1:49The structure of the NLRB violates the separation of powers because its administrative law judges are insulated from presidential oversight
- 1:59by at least two layers for case removal protection,
- 2:02thus impeding the executive power provided for the Article 2 of the United States Constitution.
- 2:08Amazon's Thursday filing stated,
- 2:10it said that the NLRB's structure additionally violated Article 2 of the Constitution
- 2:15because its board members were insulated from removal by the president except for inefficiency,
- 2:20neglect of duty, or maleficence, malfeasance, or malfeasance of office.
- 2:25SpaceX made similar arguments in a lawsuit against the board.
- 2:28Amazon argued that the NLRB's structure also violated its due process rights under the Fifth Amendment
- 2:34because the board members quote,
- 2:36currently exercise legislative, executive, and judicial powers in the same administrative procedure.
- 2:42I always do that and judicial powers in the same administrative proceedings and quote,
- 2:46it also argued that NLRB proceedings violated Article 3 of the Constitution
- 2:51by seeking to adjudicate private rights outside the Article 3 court and award a broader range of legal remedies
- 2:58beyond just equitable remedies without trial by jury.
- 3:02Quote, this major attack on the American labor movement said Seth Goldstein,
- 3:06a lawyer at Julian Herrera, Singla, and Goldstein, who represents the fired Amazon workers
- 3:12and has long worked with the Amazon labor union.
- 3:15They want to knock down the whole process and make it impossible for us to organize
- 3:19because if they're successful in what they're doing, the board won't be able to issue any decisions.
- 3:24They're going for everything.
- 3:25They think that Trump is going to get elected.
- 3:27This is what the 2024 election needs to be about.
- 3:30During his presidency, Trump significantly undermined workers' rights on multiple fronts.
- 3:35Oh, yeah.
- 3:37Amazon also argues that the case should be dismissed because it implicates the major questions doctrine.
- 3:43A new principle followed by the current Supreme Court, Laura Phillips Sawyer,
- 3:47a professor of law at the University of Georgia who studies antitrust,
- 3:51previously told Motherboard that this doctrine asserts that the court can and will evaluate administrative rulemaking
- 3:58by agencies and determine if the... God, there's so many words in here.
- 4:01...promulgated rule falls within the authorities granted by Congress and the statute,
- 4:06and that by virtue of the doctrine, all rulemaking might be challenged.
- 4:10I can give you a brief kind of summary of what's going on with that part.
- 4:15Okay.
- 4:16All these law words are above my head.
- 4:19What they're talking about with Trump, the big part you need to know right now is he got three justices in on the Supreme Court.
- 4:25It's what is it, six to three, I believe, conservative right now or Republican appointed.
- 4:31So they're doing a lot of things that are very aligned with that kind of movement.
- 4:35One of them that they're doing right now, I forget what the name of the case is.
- 4:38I keep wanting to say it's the Enron doctrine, it's not.
- 4:41Chevron doctrine.
- 4:42It's basically where a regulatory body is given authority from the government
- 4:47and they'll come up with their own rules within that because they're the experts on the subject.
- 4:51And generally the courts will agree that, you know what, yeah, technically elected officials didn't make this rule,
- 4:57but these people know a lot more about it and these things change so fast that they need to be able to make these rules on the fly.
- 5:03The Supreme Court can't remember it has already or if it's on the way to and has signaled that it's going to overturn this
- 5:09and say that every regulatory body needs all powers given to it in legislation from elected officials.
- 5:16Yeah, that's good, right?
- 5:17No, that's terrible.
- 5:18Okay, that's no.
- 5:19We don't want this overturned because basically this comes from environmental protections.
- 5:25Like they'll say that I forget what the name of that group is, but basically we put a regulatory body in place
- 5:30that can govern and watch over environmental issues and they'll just say that you have coverage over the environment
- 5:37and anything that might happen there.
- 5:39Okay, okay, that just sounds good if you put it that way.
- 5:41Instead of specifically stating that you can regulate CO2 or you can regulate PFOS because that just came up.
- 5:49No, let's just give an overall governing body the idea of what they can regulate because they're the experts on it.
- 5:54Not the people that are elected.
- 5:56So they've changed it where if it doesn't say you can regulate CO2 over this many parts per million or something like that.
- 6:04You're not allowed to regulate that.
- 6:05Okay.
- 6:06The regulators lost a lot of power.
- 6:08Business people are very happy because that means there's less regulation out there, but overall it's fairly bad.
- 6:13Okay.
- 6:14That's why they're bringing this right now is because it looks like this could fall under the same category
- 6:20in that if it wasn't specifically delegated to the NLRB, they shouldn't be able to make rules about it.
- 6:27And therefore they're saying that the NLRB has no authority and therefore shouldn't be there.
- 6:32The NLRB is huge because it's how you unionize and it is how you get a collective bargaining agreement
- 6:38and it watches over the votes.
- 6:40Although Biden has been pretty terrible in a lot of ways.
- 6:43He's been very good when it comes to labor groups.
- 6:46They actually just made a change to the NLRB where if you get it to a vote on whether or not you want to unionize
- 6:52and it's deemed that the company who you be unionizing with tampers in that vote in any way.
- 6:58It just immediately goes through.
- 7:00They say, no, you know what?
- 7:01You're fucking around.
- 7:02So we're just going to make this a union.
- 7:04Before the old rules were that if there was any tampering, they'd just have another vote.
- 7:09Companies could screw around as much as they want and it'll just go to another vote and people get fed up
- 7:13and they eventually end up leaving and it was much harder to unionize.
- 7:17So they put this rule in place.
- 7:18So just so that because I'm going to say it simply because I don't know if anyone's following it as I am.
- 7:25Basically the National Labor Relations Board is in charge of the rules for unions and stuff like that.
- 7:32For unionizing for bargaining and overall if there's issues between a union or unionizing
- 7:39and a company that they're working for, it would go through the NLRB.
- 7:43Okay. So they're trying to take it away.
- 7:45Yes.
- 7:45Amazon has been ardently anti-union.
- 7:48Musk is ardently anti-union.
- 7:49He actually owns the only major car company in North America or possibly the world.
- 7:55I don't know for sure without a union.
- 7:57Very sketchy business practices.
- 8:00Yeah, no kidding.
- 8:01So I thought that was interesting because it's big corporations letter.
- 8:05Yeah.
- 8:05All without unions.
- 8:07Coming out for it.
- 8:08And it should be noted that if this does end up getting upheld, which it could or it ruled in favor of these big companies,
- 8:16it basically be impossible to unionize because the NLRB would have no authority to do it.
- 8:20And someone that comes in like Trump would be in favor of it because he's...
- 8:24Oh yeah.
- 8:25Yeah.
- 8:25His I forget who it was, but his appointment to the Secretary of Labor was incredibly pro business anti-union.
- 8:34I can't remember who it was though.
- 8:36Yeah.
- 8:36Well.
- 8:37And yeah, keep an eye on this.
- 8:39It's going to be huge for employment rights, labor rights in North America as we've in America.
- 8:45As we've seen, it's been a big push for centuries to get the rights that we do have in place and they're being a road.
- 8:51Yeah.
- 8:52So yeah, maybe we'll see some violent labor strikes.
- 8:57Yes.
- 8:57No longer a history of violent strikes.
- 9:00And actually the UAW has a great union head right now.
- 9:04He is very open and upfront about how much he believes in the past like that.
- 9:11So if it's coming from everywhere, I wouldn't be surprised if it's a UAW.
- 9:15I forget his name, but Sean something.
- 9:18Like, if you go take a look at anything he says, it's great.
- 9:24I mean, that's how you bring about radical change, I guess.
- 9:27It is Sean Fain is the head.
- 9:29Sean Fain and that's reading for later.
- 9:32I believe he did a live stream when he was doing some of that bargaining.
- 9:36The UAW just went through a strike.
- 9:38I believe he had a shirt on that said eat the rich.
- 9:40Like it was pretty great.
- 9:41That's nice.
- 9:43I do like that.
- 9:44And yeah, if you've never heard of him or the UAW, I'd do some research over the next 48 hours, you know, to keep you guys busy and not lonely without us.
- 9:50Exactly what I was just gonna say.
- 9:52And yeah, we'll see you on Friday.
- 9:55Bye.