Latest / The Film Hobbyist / Wicked Part 1 (2024): An Argument for the Public Domain
Transcript
- 0:11Come on in and spend some time with the film
- 0:14hobbyist. My name is Lydia, and I love movies.
- 0:31We're sitting here in my attic room. I'm in an
- 0:35old desk chair. You're sitting. on a forest green
- 0:39Walmart futon with a black metal frame. We're
- 0:43in a little nook here, next to the wall, a window
- 0:46between us looking out at my backyard. Normally
- 0:50this is a lovely view, but it's early spring,
- 0:54which means everything is pretty dull and lifeless.
- 0:57I'm convinced that people who say they love spring
- 1:00actually just love May, when it's sunny and 75
- 1:04degrees and the grass is a vibrant green, the
- 1:08trees have leaves and all the flowers are in
- 1:11bloom. Now it is damp and chilly and gray and
- 1:17the trees are mostly bare. If it wasn't for my
- 1:21neighbor's bright red tulips, I'd be pretty miserable.
- 1:24But... Speaking of colorful tulips, this week
- 1:28we're talking about last year's Wicked Part 1,
- 1:32directed by John M. Chu. I've been a fan of this
- 1:36movie since 2021 when I saw John Chu's last film,
- 1:41In the Heights, in theaters. I was one of maybe
- 1:44five people who saw that movie in theaters. It's
- 1:48magnificent, by the way. Thrilling and vibrant
- 1:51and alive. Around the time of release, John Chu
- 1:55was announced to be in talks to direct Wicked,
- 1:58and it was during 96 ,000, a hip -hop musical
- 2:03number set at a community pool with Busby Berkeley
- 2:06-style choreography, that I realized I needed
- 2:10to see his version of Wicked, particularly his
- 2:14version of What Is This Feeling? In the Broadway
- 2:17staging, that number is dynamic in the shape
- 2:20of its choreography. A lesser director would
- 2:24just have repeated the choreography on a courtyard
- 2:27set with a million cuts between angles. John
- 2:31Chu fleshes out time and setting, adding layers
- 2:34of story underneath each verse through his visuals.
- 2:39Universal smartly released that number online
- 2:42in its entirety the week before the film's debut.
- 2:45It tells you what I knew in the theater in 2021.
- 2:50that John Chu is a master of the film language
- 2:54of movie musicals. He doesn't just know how to
- 2:58work with a choreographer and some decent singers.
- 3:01He understands the camera movements and editing
- 3:05rhythms, the necessity of interesting sets and
- 3:09an excellent ensemble. And this time, the theaters
- 3:14weren't empty. It's been really lovely to see
- 3:18this movie connecting with so many people, not
- 3:21just former theater kids like me and their moms,
- 3:25but curious dudes who wanted to understand the
- 3:28hype. It's had a much bigger audience than I
- 3:31expected. And the more I've thought about it,
- 3:34the more I think it has to do with this movie's
- 3:38relationship with the 1939 film version of The
- 3:41Wizard of Oz. and how it's the first movie to
- 3:44dare risk treating that film as if it isn't just
- 3:48some corporate -owned property, but as it should
- 3:51be, part of the public domain. So what is the
- 3:58public domain? It's a term connected with copyright
- 4:01law, but on a conceptual level, it boils down
- 4:04to this idea. Once a particular work has existed
- 4:08long enough, it no longer belongs to the creator,
- 4:12their estate, or the corporation that owns them,
- 4:15but belongs to the public to use and iterate
- 4:18on and to rework. In 1697, Charles Peralt published
- 4:24a version of the fairy tale Cinderella, one with
- 4:27a fairy godmother, a pumpkin carriage, and a
- 4:30glass slipper. The public domain understands
- 4:33that this story and the glass slipper and the
- 4:37fairy godmother do not belong to Charles Perrault
- 4:40anymore. He's dead. His heirs are dead. This
- 4:45story and these elements are bigger than him.
- 4:48And anyone may publish and sell what he wrote
- 4:52or translate his words or iterate on the same
- 4:55concepts. So in 1950, Walt Disney could make
- 5:00an animated movie called Cinderella with a fairy
- 5:03godmother, a pumpkin carriage, and a glass slipper.
- 5:06And they can make money off of that. And Rodgers
- 5:11and Hammerstein in 1957 could also write a TV
- 5:15musical called Cinderella with a fairy godmother,
- 5:18a pumpkin carriage, and a glass slipper that
- 5:21they can profit from as well. because those elements
- 5:25and that story belong to the public, even if
- 5:30Bibbidi -Bobbidi -Boo and Impossible Things Happen
- 5:34Every Day belong to their respective songwriters.
- 5:38It's good that people who make things get to
- 5:42make money off their creations. I have my own
- 5:46personal artistic projects that I would like
- 5:49to earn money from and not have anybody else
- 5:52republish, reiterate, or rework without my permission
- 5:55or remuneration. This is not a bad thing. But
- 6:01the version of the public domain we have here
- 6:04in my country is deeply, deeply broken. In 1998,
- 6:10as a result of heavy lobbying from Disney, ironically
- 6:13enough, Copyright laws in the United States were
- 6:17changed so that a work wouldn't enter the public
- 6:20domain for 95 years after its creation. This
- 6:24was done solely to keep Mickey Mouse from entering
- 6:27the public domain. And it's bad. It means that
- 6:32we have to pretend that an entire generation
- 6:35of works that are part of the public inheritance
- 6:38of story and music and words are off limits for
- 6:43republication, reiteration, and reworking. And
- 6:48The Wizard of Oz is one of its greatest victims.
- 6:53The Wonderful Wizard of Oz, the novel by L. Frank
- 6:56Baum, was published in 1900, and its impact has
- 7:00been extraordinary. It is an American fairy tale.
- 7:06The United States has oral traditions in the
- 7:10forms of tall tales about Pecos Bill and Paul
- 7:13Bunyan, and of course the deep layers of indigenous
- 7:17mythology and legends, tales of Coyote and the
- 7:21terrible myth of the Wendigo. We have cryptids
- 7:24like Bigfoot and Mothman and the Jackalope. But
- 7:28our literary tradition of fairy tales is pretty
- 7:32small. We have Washington Irving's Rip Van Winkle
- 7:36and the Legend of Sleepy Hollow. And we have
- 7:39the Wizard of Oz. The forms and places here are
- 7:44so American. Gray and bare Kansas. The Emerald
- 7:49City, which has always felt very much like the
- 7:52technological wonders of big cities like Chicago
- 7:55and New York. Deserts and forests and wide open
- 8:00spaces. It's a story of snake oil salesmen and
- 8:04grifters. We even have a tornado, a uniquely
- 8:08American disaster, and it has imprinted on the
- 8:11public's consciousness. Except, has it? Okay,
- 8:18picture our main crew. You have a scarecrow,
- 8:22a tin man, and a lion. There's a little dog and
- 8:27a girl. How old is she? Baum's novel describes
- 8:34a little girl. The math of later Oz books, yeah,
- 8:38there are more, a lot more, put her at about
- 8:4211. But you are picturing a teenager, 16 -year
- 8:48-old Judy Garland, aren't you? And now I want
- 8:54you to picture the Wicked Witch of the West.
- 8:57What would you say was her defining physical
- 9:00characteristic? Her single eye that can see far
- 9:05distances like a telescope, right? No? Oh, you
- 9:11saw her as green, dressed all in black, with
- 9:14a pointed hat? Then you are not thinking of Baum's
- 9:19Wicked Witch, a crone with a golden cap that
- 9:23allows her to call upon the flying monkeys if
- 9:26she hops on one foot and says a charm. You are
- 9:30thinking. of the 1939 movie. The green skin was
- 9:35added to take advantage of the wonders of technicolor,
- 9:38the same reason the magic slippers were changed
- 9:41from Baum's silver to ruby. And it wasn't assumed
- 9:45from the get -go that she would look like this.
- 9:48Original concepts of the Wicked Witch had her
- 9:51looking a great deal like the Evil Queen from
- 9:53Disney's Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs. The
- 9:57green was a choice. Now there's been lots of
- 10:01pretending that the green doesn't belong to the
- 10:041939 movie. When Gregory Maguire first published
- 10:08the novel Wicked in 1995, he had to, for copyright
- 10:12reasons, insist that he was only basing his book
- 10:16on Baum's novel, which entered the public domain
- 10:19in 1954. And everybody just pretended he was
- 10:23telling the whole truth. Now, I would agree that
- 10:27Maguire's reworking of The Wizard of Oz is absolutely
- 10:30more in conversation with Baum's book than the
- 10:331939 movie. He's very interested in the different
- 10:37lands of Oz, their particular colors and cultures,
- 10:41and he's very interested in the political implications
- 10:45Baum set up, especially since Baum's later novels
- 10:49make it clear that the wizard is only in charge
- 10:52because he deposed a royal dynasty. But his witch
- 10:57is green. It's incredibly important to her character
- 11:02and the plot. And everybody has just decided
- 11:06to let all that slide. Now, when Stephen Schwartz
- 11:10and Winnie Holtzman adapted Wicked for the stage,
- 11:13they had to be a lot more careful when interacting
- 11:16with the 1939 musical, especially in its iconography.
- 11:22Glinda only wears pink once, during Dancing Through
- 11:26Life and Popular, which follows later that night.
- 11:30Everyone wears green glasses in the Emerald City,
- 11:33and the libretto implies that's the reason the
- 11:36city is green, as no one notices Elphaba's skin
- 11:39color. And the slippers are decidedly silver.
- 11:45Every reference to the 1939 movie in this show
- 11:50is a joke. Madame Morrible refers to something
- 11:53regarding Elphaba as a gulch. A punch is described
- 11:57as containing lemons and melons and pears, which
- 12:01is followed by, oh my. Elphaba, when asked by
- 12:05her sister why she dares return to a place where
- 12:07she is a wanted criminal, responds, there's no
- 12:10place like home. Every one of these is a laugh
- 12:14line. Unlimited theme. The first seven notes
- 12:26are the same as the beginning of Somewhere Over
- 12:29the Rainbow. The rhythm is different, as are
- 12:32the underlying chords. It's only seven notes
- 12:35because of copyright. Eight would be an infringement.
- 12:41And so, Wicked the Musical got away with Elphaba's
- 12:44green skin and became the most successful Wizard
- 12:48of Oz retelling since the 1939 film, even if
- 12:52new audience members continue to be confused
- 12:55by the silver slippers, pardon me, the jeweled
- 12:59slippers. And then John Chu made his film adaptation.
- 13:04In the opening shots of Wicked Part One, the
- 13:07camera zooms along behind a flock of flying monkeys
- 13:11as the intense ostinatos of Schwartz's overture
- 13:15blares. And then, as the music shimmers out into
- 13:19the unlimited theme, The camera zooms over a
- 13:24rainbow. Screw copyright. Somewhere over the
- 13:29rainbow belongs to us. By all rights, it should
- 13:34have entered the public domain 10 years ago,
- 13:37January 2015. If Disney hadn't broken copyright
- 13:42in 1998, it would be ours. Then we go to Munchkinland,
- 13:49surrounded by colored tulips, filled with people
- 13:53in whimsical colored outfits. In Baum's world,
- 13:57Munchkins dress in blue. Maguire retained this,
- 14:01as did the stage show. Shiz's colors are blue
- 14:04and white to match the munchkins, but in Chu's
- 14:07film, they are colorful, and they run into town
- 14:10underscored by the opening notes of Ding Dong
- 14:13the Witch is Dead, ringing bells, shouting, come
- 14:16out, come out, wherever you are, the opening
- 14:19words of that very song. Then, Glinda arrives
- 14:24in a bubble, exactly like she does in 1939, wearing
- 14:29a pale pink ball gown, and a tall crown. Because
- 14:34the Wizard of Oz belongs to us. It shouldn't
- 14:40be the exclusive property of Warner Brothers,
- 14:43copyright claiming every ruby slipper and pink
- 14:46bubble. And every audience member who watches
- 14:50this movie knows that it isn't just a knockoff
- 14:54of Wizard of Oz, it's a retelling, a reworking,
- 14:58a reiteration. It isn't content to just dabble
- 15:03with public domain, off -brand, copyright -safe
- 15:06versions of Wizard of Oz. It's the version you
- 15:11have in your head. The one we've all inherited.
- 15:15This is a musical like that is a musical. This
- 15:21world is Art Nouveau by Art Deco, like that film,
- 15:25somehow in 1900 and 1939 at the same time in
- 15:31fashion and imagination. And it's so good when
- 15:35the public domain gets to be the public domain.
- 15:40I felt it most when Elphaba and Glinda go to
- 15:43see The Wizard. I have a deep sense memory of
- 15:47watching the 1939 movie as a kid. getting very
- 15:51uncomfortable when Dorothy and her friends walk
- 15:54down that claustrophobic, rounded hallway. In
- 15:58my mind, that hallway lasts forever. The atmosphere
- 16:02has shifted from delight to dread. In the stage
- 16:07show of Wicked, the focus is on the Oz head,
- 16:10a prop more silly than intimidating. And while
- 16:14Elphaba and Glinda are scared, we aren't. We
- 16:17know what that is. The stage show wants us happy.
- 16:21It's still very much luring us into happy thoughts.
- 16:25In Chu's film, the palace again becomes an art
- 16:30deco nightmare. Elphaba and Glinda must walk
- 16:34past a legion of monkeys, stoic and intimidating.
- 16:38The rounded hallway is dark and sinister and
- 16:42filled with dread. It put me right back in that
- 16:46place of watching the 1939 movie, pure discomfort.
- 16:51And the flying monkeys themselves. In the stage
- 16:55show, they're a reference, an afterthought. John
- 16:59Chu gives us a flying monkey jump scare, allowing
- 17:03them to be as terrifying as the 1939 monkeys
- 17:07are in our collective imagination. Now, I want
- 17:12to make a distinction. We live in a media ecosystem
- 17:16filled with reboots, remakes, and regurgitative
- 17:21sequels. We're used to seeing the same story
- 17:25told to us over and over again, held together
- 17:29by references and iconography. Every studio is
- 17:34squeezing money out of each piece of intellectual
- 17:38property they've scrambled over. Jurassic Park
- 17:42gets a new movie this summer, complete with repetitions
- 17:46of famous lines and returned raptors. This is
- 17:50after they already squeezed out a messy and shallow
- 17:53trilogy, finishing up with soulless reappearances
- 17:57from its original stars. This year, we also get
- 18:01a near shot -for -shot remake of How to Train
- 18:04Your Dragon, only with fewer colors, terrible
- 18:08green screen, horrible acting, and a toothless
- 18:11improved by next generation PlayStation graphics.
- 18:16It's easy to say references are cheap and lazy.
- 18:21They often are. It's easy to say originality
- 18:26is where true art lies. That's only partially
- 18:30true. All art is built on the art that comes
- 18:35before it. And good art is often in overt conversation
- 18:40and dialogue with what has come before. The Wonderful
- 18:44Wizard of Oz gets a lot of credit for its weirdness,
- 18:47its fascinating, interesting, bizarre world.
- 18:51But that ignores the fact that it is in conversation
- 18:55with Alice in Wonderland, itself in conversation
- 18:58with Mother Goose. Did you forget that the Queen
- 19:02of Hearts is a nursery rhyme? Oh! And who compiled
- 19:07Mother Goose? Why, our old friend Charles Peralt,
- 19:12who collected folktales and sayings and put his
- 19:15own spin on it. Yes, he gave us the most identifiable
- 19:21Cinderella, but that's a story far older than
- 19:25him, tracing initial roots back to both Egypt
- 19:28and China. There are academics who have boiled
- 19:33down stories to their separate components, arguing
- 19:36there were really only seven plots. But of course,
- 19:41that isn't our experience of them. Every good
- 19:45story is changed by its teller, and in its differences
- 19:50we see meaning. Baum took Lewis Carroll's Wonderland
- 19:55and gave it a distinct structure with unique
- 19:58peoples run by specific politics. Both books
- 20:03held satire for their separate societies. Carroll
- 20:06critiqued the absurdism of Victorian England's
- 20:09rigidly articulated roles and systems. Baum critiqued
- 20:14the quackery and scams of American myth -making,
- 20:17the way we let leaders build stories of themselves.
- 20:22Gregory Maguire took Baum's book into adult realities
- 20:25of corrupted systems, of religion and government
- 20:30and systems of oppression. Schwartz and Holtzman
- 20:34softened those realities to explore how change
- 20:38really happens, the importance of soft power
- 20:42alongside heartfelt identification with the oppressed.
- 20:47And yes. John Chu is just retelling the story
- 20:52Schwartz and Holtzman broke, except he has this
- 20:57ingrained filmic language of the 1939 Wizard
- 21:01of Oz, these assumptions held by his audience.
- 21:05So he uses them to lead his audience on a journey
- 21:10to point them to jarring differences. We see
- 21:15a pointed black hat in a puddle of water. We
- 21:18see flying monkeys. We go over the rainbow. There's
- 21:22the yellow brick road and a teenage Dorothy.
- 21:25There's an art deco emerald city. Here's a colorful
- 21:29munchkin land and a pink Glinda in her bubble
- 21:32while we sing about a dead witch. So why does
- 21:37this feel uncomfortable? They're so angry. But
- 21:42the music is happy, aggressive in its happiness.
- 21:46The new elements stand out. There's this creeping
- 21:51sense that maybe Glinda isn't actually a good
- 21:55guy. There's tragic backstory for our baby witch.
- 21:59The differences shake the audience, make them
- 22:03question the assumptions we want them to focus
- 22:06on. Not, why are the munchkins blue? But, why
- 22:11are they cruel? Not, Why is Glinda in an ordinary
- 22:16white suit, but, oh gosh, she's not very nice?
- 22:20Oh gosh, she's never been very nice. I think
- 22:26if Warner Brothers, who owns the film rights
- 22:29to the 1939 film, if they had made Wicked, the
- 22:33similarities would have been merely superficial,
- 22:36merely there to make this movie as marketable
- 22:39as possible. And while Wicked did rely heavily
- 22:43on recognizable imagery in its marketing, it
- 22:46seems very clear that John Chu isn't merely regurgitating
- 22:50that imagery for easy consumption. He's adding
- 22:54context and layers of storytelling, reframing
- 22:59the familiar in an interesting and engaging way.
- 23:02He isn't taking the stage choreography and placing
- 23:07it in a school courtyard edited together with
- 23:09different cuts. He is using that which should
- 23:13be, in the public domain, the film language of
- 23:17one of the most influential movie musicals of
- 23:21all time to tell us a new story, one that has
- 23:25resonated beyond the confines of theater kid
- 23:28audiences, over the rainbow, to the whole. varied
- 23:33spectrum of the film -going public. Thanks for
- 23:40coming.