Latest / Dark Murder: True Crime Cases / Episode 93
Transcript
- 0:06Dark murder, True crime cases five four, three, two one one.
- 0:27Welcome back. I'm your host, Jordan Lee. I'm sure you are all
- 0:31ready to dive into some dark, creepy stories, so let's get started.
- 0:39The medical student who disappeared into thin air. The Brian Schaefer Mystery. It's
- 0:46every person's worst nightmare to be lost in a crowd and never be seen or
- 0:51heard from again. Unfortunately, this is what happened to Brian Shaeffer. Schaeffer
- 0:56was a medical student who went out with friends to kick off their spring break.
- 1:00After entering the bar, Shaeffer got lost in the crowded bar. After
- 1:04a while, friends assumed he left and had gone home, but this was
- 1:08not the case. Shaeffer would never be seen or heard from again. On
- 1:12Friday, March thirty, first classes ended at OSU for spring break. The
- 1:18next week, Shaeffer and his father, Randy, went out for a steak
- 1:21dinner to celebrate. Shaeffer's father noted that he seemed exhausted from having pulled all
- 1:26nighters earlier during the week. To further celebrate finishing his final exams, Shaeffer,
- 1:34William Florence, and some fellow medical students were bar hopping and enjoyed their
- 1:38evening. This kicked off spring break for the students of Ohio State University College
- 1:42of Medicine. They started their night at the Ugly Tuna Saluna, then moved
- 1:49to a few other places before going back to the Ugly Tuna Saluna. Meredith
- 1:55Reed, a friend of Florence's, drove them back during a group celebrate.
- 2:00Before heading home, they noticed Brian Shaeffer was missing. They didn't think it
- 2:04was suspicious, though. After the bar closed and the last call was made,
- 2:07Reid and Florence waited for Brian outside to see if he needed a ride
- 2:12home. When he failed to appear after some time, they assumed he must
- 2:16have already gotten a ride and left. At two a m. On April
- 2:21First, a security camera near the entrance of a Columbus bar recorded Shaffer talking
- 2:25to two women. He then re entered the bar without any evidence suggesting he
- 2:30had left the area. Shaeffer and Shaffer's girlfriend were scheduled to fly to Miami
- 2:36on Monday morning. When boarding was complete and Schaefer was nowhere to be found,
- 2:40he was officially declared missing. The trip had originally been booked with the
- 2:46assumption that Schaeffer would propose during it. The search for Schaefer began at the
- 2:51ugly tune of Salouna, the last place he'd been seen. The area around
- 2:55South Campus Gateway has a high crime rate, so the bar bar had security
- 3:00cameras installed. Footage from the cameras showed Schaefer, Florence and Reed going up
- 3:06to the main entrance at one fifteen a m. Shaeffer was seen outside of
- 3:09the bar talking to two women around one fifty five am, then moving off
- 3:15camera in the direction of the bar. The last time he was seen was
- 3:19on the bar's security footage when he re entered at one fifty five am.
- 3:23After an exhaustive search that covered the city's dumpsters and sewer system, police were
- 3:30unable to find any trace of Schaeffer. His abandoned apartment was later burglarized,
- 3:35but it is unclear this crime is related to his disappearance. Schaeffer's father,
- 3:40recently widowed and desperate for a clue in the right direction, consulted a psychic.
- 3:46He was told that Brian's body was resting in water near a bridge.
- 3:51He spent hours waiting in the Olden Tangee River in Columbus with a search party,
- 3:54but they were unable to find him. As you can't imagine he was
- 4:00crushed in feeling defeated, unable to move on. Shaeffer's girlfriend, Alexis Wagoneer,
- 4:06would call his cell phone every night, even though it would never ring
- 4:10and go straight to voicemail. One night, however, Wagoneer was elated when
- 4:15during one of her evening calls, the phone did in fact ring. It
- 4:19rang three times, with renewed hope, she died again, her finger shaking
- 4:25from the adrenaline rush, although there was no answer. Shaeffer's cell phone later
- 4:30pinged a cell tower in Hillyard. This was approximately fourteen miles from Columbus,
- 4:35where Shaeffer had last been seen. However, after further investigation, it was
- 4:41determined that the ringing and pinging could have been caused by a system glitch,
- 4:46rather than by Shaeffer turning his cell phone back on. As the investigation continued,
- 4:50nearly everyone connected to Brian Shaffer or who had been with him on the
- 4:55night he vanished, agreed to take a lie detective test. The exception was
- 5:00Clint Florence. Florence's attorney said his client had nothing to hide and felt he
- 5:04had already told police everything he knew about the case. The two women who
- 5:10were last seen with Shaeffer have been cleared of any suspicion by the police.
- 5:14They also stated they were not asked to take a polygraph test. The police
- 5:18received numerous tips, but none of them led to any significant progress in the
- 5:24case. At a Pearl Jam concert later that year in Cincinnati, lead singer
- 5:29Eddie Vedder took time between songs to ask for tips about Shaeffer's disappearance, but
- 5:33none of those were useful either. Possible sightings in Michigan, Texas, and
- 5:39even Sweden were investigated. Randy Shaeffer passed away in two thousand and eight after
- 5:45being struck by a branch while cleaning up debris from a windstorm. An online
- 5:49condolence book was created for him, and someone posted a note that said to
- 5:56Dad love Brian us Virgin Island. Despite the initial appearance of Brian's note,
- 6:02police determined that it was in fact a hoax. The note was posted from
- 6:08a public computer in Franklin County, Ohio. The investigation led to the conclusion
- 6:13that Brian was not alive and was still missing. Columbus police are still investigating
- 6:18the disappearance of Schaefer following up on leeds both promising and far fetched. They've
- 6:25received tips from across the globe, including an alleged sighting in Sweden and a
- 6:30phone call from a woman in Michigan who thought Schaefer was heir waiter. They
- 6:34even received anonymous tips claiming to know the location of the body, but so
- 6:40far these have been unsuccessful.