Latest / MBA Training Marketing / AI citations: the share of voice metric for CMOs
Transcript
- 0:00Host: This is Leaders Insights. On the table, AI citations are becoming the new share of voice
- 0:10Host: metric. 43%. That's ChatGPT's share of AI-driven discovery this week. Down from a number that
- 0:16Host: used to have a 5 in front of it, ComScore just published it. Is this the story?
- 0:22Expert: The share drop is the headline everyone's chasing. It's the boring part. Gemini and
- 0:27Expert: Claude eating into ChatGPT is a horse race and horse races end. What doesn't end is
- 0:32Expert: what the fragmentation does to your ability to measure anything at all. Walk
- 0:36Host: me through that. Why does one assistant losing ground to two others break
- 0:40Expert: measurement? Start with how discovery used to work. Someone had a problem. They
- 0:45Expert: searched. They clicked a few links. They compared. They bought. Every one of those
- 0:50Expert: steps left a footprint. A click. A session. A referral source you could trace
- 0:55Expert: back. Attribution, which is just working out which touchpoint gets credit for the
- 1:00Expert: sale, lived in those gaps between steps. And the AI interaction closes the gaps. It
- 1:06Expert: collapses them into one turn. Somebody asks Claude, what's the best project
- 1:11Expert: management tool for a 10-person agency? And Claude names three. No search page,
- 1:16Expert: no comparison clicks, no referral trail. The discovery, the comparison, and half
- 1:22Expert: the purchase decision happen inside a black box you can't instrument. So the
- 1:26Host: metric that replaces it is what? This AI citation idea? How often an assistant
- 1:31Expert: names you in what context and whether it links you. Think of it as share a voice
- 1:36Expert: for a world with no shelf. Share a voice. The slice of the conversation
- 1:41Expert: your brand owns versus rivals. Except the conversation is now a machine
- 1:45Host: deciding whether you exist in its answer. Let's tear one apart. If I'm a
- 1:50Host: CMO looking at my dashboard Monday morning, what's on it that's now lying to
- 1:55Expert: me? Your organic traffic line first. It'll look soft and your team will blame the
- 2:00Expert: algorithm. Some of that traffic didn't leave. It never clicked through because
- 2:04Expert: the assistant answered on your behalf. The visit died. The influence didn't.
- 2:08Expert: Your dashboard has no column for mentioned but not visited. So it reports
- 2:14Expert: a loss where you actually won. What else? Your last click attribution,
- 2:18Expert: crediting whichever touchpoint came right before the sale. When someone buys after
- 2:23Expert: an AI recommendation, the last click is often a direct visit or a branded search.
- 2:28Expert: So the dashboard credits your brand or credits nothing and your paid team
- 2:32Expert: quietly takes a bow for a sale Claude actually made. That's uncomfortable.
- 2:37Host: Whose budget is wrong then? Everyone's slightly. SEMrush has a tool now
- 2:42Expert: that tracks how often you appear in AI answers and they'll tell you the
- 2:46Expert: citation gap between you and competitors is enormous. Worth remembering,
- 2:50Expert: SEMrush sells the software that measures it. So cross check the scale with
- 2:55Expert: someone who isn't invoicing you. Forrester's independent work says most
- 3:00Expert: marketing teams still can't see AI source demand at all. They're flying
- 3:05Expert: with an instrument that stopped moving. HubSpot's been loud about AI
- 3:09Expert: attribution being solvable inside their platform. Buy it? HubSpot puts AI
- 3:14Expert: influenced pipeline at something like a third of new deals for their customers.
- 3:18Expert: They sell the CRM that reports that figure. So treat it as a vendor's best
- 3:23Expert: case, not gospel. The direction is right. The precision is marketing. Nobody
- 3:28Expert: has clean attribution for a conversation that happened inside a model they don't
- 3:32Host: own. So what actually works on that dashboard? Name the piece that
- 3:36Expert: survives. Branded direct traffic and branded search. People typing your name
- 3:41Expert: in cold. That's the closest on a signal you've got. If an assistant recommended
- 3:46Expert: you, the human often goes and searches you directly to confirm. That spike is
- 3:50Expert: your new referral log. It's crude, but it's not lying. Give me the one thing to
- 3:55Expert: do Monday. Pick your 10 highest value buyer questions. The actual sentences a
- 4:00Expert: customer would type. Ask Chat GPT, Gemini and Claude, each one this week.
- 4:06Expert: And write down whether you're named, how, and against whom. That's your baseline
- 4:12Expert: citation audit. Do it monthly. It costs an afternoon and tells you more than the
- 4:17Host: traffic report your board's been staring at. An afternoon and some honesty.
- 4:21Expert: Cheaper than the software. Considerably. And it doesn't send you a renewal invoice.
- 4:26Host: What we read for this one. Forrester Research DigiDay SEMrush vendor SEO
- 4:32Host: analytics tools HubSpot vendor CRM marketing automation. We'll leave it there.
- 4:38Host: The CMO self-assessment at MBA-training.com will tell you where you really stand.