Latest / Bloomberg Law / Texas Tough Law & Broadway Casting Decisions
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:10Speaker 2: The Biden administration says that Texas's sweeping immigration law, known
- 0:14Speaker 2: as SB four, is unconstitutional because it violates the federal
- 0:20Speaker 2: government's sole authority to set immigration policy. The law authorizes
- 0:25Speaker 2: state officials to arrest, detain, and deport non citizens who
- 0:29Speaker 2: enter the country illegally, but it's only gone into effect
- 0:32Speaker 2: for a grand total of nine hours. That's because it's
- 0:36Speaker 2: been meandering through the federal courts, including a trip to
- 0:39Speaker 2: the Supreme Court, and in the law's second appearance at
- 0:42Speaker 2: the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals, the Texas Elicitor General
- 0:46Speaker 2: Lloyd Nielsen made a remarkable admission, maybe the law goes
- 0:50Speaker 2: too far.
- 0:51Speaker 3: What Texas has done here is they have looked at
- 0:54Speaker 3: the Supreme Court's president and they have tried to develop
- 0:57Speaker 3: a statute that goes up to the line of court
- 1:00Speaker 3: precedent but allows Texas to protect the border. Now, to
- 1:04Speaker 3: be fair, maybe Texas went too far, and that's the
- 1:06Speaker 3: question the Sport's going to have to decide. But that's
- 1:09Speaker 3: the context of which we are here. Texas has looked
- 1:12Speaker 3: at the Supreme Court precedent and the laws that Congress
- 1:15Speaker 3: has enacted and has tried to develop a law that
- 1:19Speaker 3: goes up to the edge, but no further.
- 1:21Speaker 2: It was before the same panel that on March twenty six,
- 1:24Speaker 2: by a two to one vote, blocked the law temporarily
- 1:28Speaker 2: in an opinion by Chief Judge Priscilla Richmond, who wrote
- 1:31Speaker 2: that the law likely interferes with federal immigration policy, but
- 1:36Speaker 2: at oral arguments, the Solicitor General now claimed that Texas
- 1:40Speaker 2: doesn't deport anybody. He said police would take migrants to
- 1:44Speaker 2: a port of entry controlled by the federal government, leaving
- 1:48Speaker 2: Chief Judge Richmond to question the point of the law.
- 1:52Speaker 2: You can take let's say, one hundred and fifty people
- 1:53Speaker 2: at a time back to Eagle.
- 1:55Speaker 3: Pass, Yes, or some other port of entry, Yes.
- 1:59Speaker 2: Your honor, and then the federal government's going to process him.
- 2:02Speaker 3: Is that how you yes, your honor, And that's it's
- 2:06Speaker 3: going to.
- 2:06Speaker 4: Say, here's your notice or whatever you can stay in.
- 2:10Speaker 2: And so then Texas, what's the status?
- 2:13Speaker 4: What has the statute accomplished?
- 2:15Speaker 2: I'm just curious. Yes, joining me is immigration law expert
- 2:18Speaker 2: Leon Fresco, a partner at Holland and Knight and a
- 2:21Speaker 2: former Justice Department official. Leon Tell us about the litigation
- 2:25Speaker 2: over this law.
- 2:27Speaker 4: This case has gone through quite the long and winding road.
- 2:30Speaker 4: To use the Beatles reference, where it starts in the
- 2:34Speaker 4: District Court, and the District Court enjoins the law very
- 2:37Speaker 4: simply as being in contravention to the Supreme Court's twenty
- 2:41Speaker 4: twelve decision in Arizona. Then the Fifth Circuit actually lifts
- 2:47Speaker 4: the same momentarily and says that the law can go
- 2:52Speaker 4: into effect, and then that goes to the Supreme Court,
- 2:56Speaker 4: who then says, hey, wait a second, there actually wasn't
- 3:00Speaker 4: a real ruling here with regard to the merits of
- 3:06Speaker 4: whether the state should be lifted or not, so we're
- 3:09Speaker 4: not going to get involved in reviewing what is a
- 3:12Speaker 4: de facto decision that just says, go to the Supreme
- 3:15Speaker 4: Court and figure that out. So when they kicked it
- 3:18Speaker 4: back to the Fifth Circuit, the Fifth Circuit, paneled two
- 3:21Speaker 4: to one, actually put in a temporary stay. And then
- 3:26Speaker 4: what happened is while the law is temporarily saved, there
- 3:30Speaker 4: is now an oral argument that occurred on whether that
- 3:33Speaker 4: state should be extended. But at the moment, the law
- 3:36Speaker 4: is not in effect and it stayed pursuing to a
- 3:39Speaker 4: temporary state, and what.
- 3:41Speaker 2: Would the law allow Texas to do.
- 3:44Speaker 4: The law would allow Texas to basically create the facto
- 3:49Speaker 4: deportation events, essentially, because while Texas cannot actually deport people
- 3:55Speaker 4: to Mexico, what they would do is if they apprehended
- 3:59Speaker 4: people who were unlawfully in Texas, they would then take
- 4:03Speaker 4: those people, transport them to the Mexico Texas border and
- 4:07Speaker 4: say you have two choices. Either go into Mexico or
- 4:12Speaker 4: if we catch you again, you will be arrested and
- 4:16Speaker 4: you will actually be charged with a felony of remaining
- 4:20Speaker 4: in the United States or re entering the United States,
- 4:23Speaker 4: depending on what you do after you've already been charged
- 4:26Speaker 4: with the misdemeanor. And so that was placed under great
- 4:30Speaker 4: scrutiny in this oral argument because Texas tried to recast
- 4:34Speaker 4: that as no, we're not actually creating these self deportations,
- 4:38Speaker 4: we're just going to give them to the federal government
- 4:41Speaker 4: and we're cooperating with them so that they can do it,
- 4:44Speaker 4: to which the court said, well, guess what the federal
- 4:48Speaker 4: government's doing you and they're saying they don't want this cooperation,
- 4:51Speaker 4: So how can you say that's what you're doing. And
- 4:53Speaker 4: this is where there was some complications in the oral argument.
- 4:57Speaker 2: Yeah, it was kind of surprising that the Czexas Solicitor
- 5:01Speaker 2: General said that the law was crafted in a way
- 5:06Speaker 2: that goes up to the line of Supreme Court President,
- 5:09Speaker 2: and he admitted that maybe across.
- 5:12Speaker 4: The line, right, he was basically trying to get what's
- 5:15Speaker 4: known as a severance doctrine, where the illegal parts of
- 5:19Speaker 4: the law could be severed away while still keeping the
- 5:22Speaker 4: legal parts of the law. But the problem is, it's
- 5:25Speaker 4: not really clear what's legal under the Arizona case. The
- 5:29Speaker 4: only thing that Arizona permits is for state officials to
- 5:33Speaker 4: check on someone's status and report them die. So, yes,
- 5:37Speaker 4: they can do that, and they've been doing that, and
- 5:39Speaker 4: they can continue to do that. But with regard to
- 5:42Speaker 4: actually arresting people and charging them for a crime, the
- 5:46Speaker 4: Arizona Supreme Court decision actually already says that is illegal.
- 5:50Speaker 4: And then when you add this second component of actually
- 5:54Speaker 4: taking human beings back to the Mexico US border line
- 5:59Speaker 4: and telling them and you have two options to port
- 6:01Speaker 4: yourself or face four criminal charges, that would be completely
- 6:06Speaker 4: in contravention of the Arizona Supreme Court case.
- 6:10Speaker 2: Let's say Texas does this will Mexico take those people back?
- 6:14Speaker 4: Well, this is where Mexico has said that it's not
- 6:17Speaker 4: going to cooperate with any state or local deportation efforts.
- 6:21Speaker 4: It will only cooperate with the federal government. Now what's
- 6:24Speaker 4: not clear is what does that mean. So Mexico could
- 6:27Speaker 4: say if the individuals are crossing the ports of entry,
- 6:32Speaker 4: they could say, we're not going to let you cross
- 6:35Speaker 4: the ports of entry. But if Texas basically scares people
- 6:39Speaker 4: into recrossing the river back into Mexico, not clear what
- 6:44Speaker 4: Mexico would do there. Are they going to try to
- 6:46Speaker 4: grab them and push people back into the US. That
- 6:49Speaker 4: can create a horrible you know, human ping pong essentially
- 6:53Speaker 4: where you have forces taking people and pushing them back
- 6:57Speaker 4: and forth. So it's not clear what would happen realistically
- 7:01Speaker 4: in that Todario. But in any case, Texas what it's
- 7:05Speaker 4: really trying to do is use fear to deter people
- 7:10Speaker 4: a from not even coming into Texas in the first place,
- 7:13Speaker 4: instead going into California or Arizona. But also if they
- 7:18Speaker 4: do go into Texas, then to go away and either
- 7:21Speaker 4: leave Texas or go into Bangsico.
- 7:24Speaker 2: Did they even discuss in the oral arguments Texas's claim
- 7:29Speaker 2: that their law mayrors federal law and the federal government
- 7:33Speaker 2: divide administration isn't enforcing federal law, so they get to.
- 7:39Speaker 4: Well, correct, that's the claim of Texas. They're basically making
- 7:42Speaker 4: two claims. One is that their law mirror's federal law,
- 7:45Speaker 4: like you said, and the federal government isn't enforcing it,
- 7:48Speaker 4: so they should get the opportunity to enforce it. And
- 7:51Speaker 4: one of the judges who used to be the former
- 7:53Speaker 4: Texas solicitor General is now in the Fifth Circuit who
- 7:56Speaker 4: was appointed by President Trump. He had a lot of
- 7:58Speaker 4: sympathy for that and certainly pushing the federal government on
- 8:02Speaker 4: this lack of enforcement issue. But at the end of
- 8:05Speaker 4: the day, the point is it's very difficult to say
- 8:09Speaker 4: you're cooperating with the federal effort when the federal government,
- 8:13Speaker 4: who gets different in these proceedings, says, and I think
- 8:18Speaker 4: successfully and persuasively to the other two judges, that this
- 8:22Speaker 4: isn't contravention of what the federal government is trying to do.
- 8:26Speaker 4: They don't want this assistant. They view this assistant as illegal.
- 8:30Speaker 4: It puts the judges in a very difficult position as
- 8:33Speaker 4: to whether it will allow this to continue.
- 8:35Speaker 2: So you had the Trump appointee asking tough questions of
- 8:40Speaker 2: the federal government's attorney, and then you had one judge
- 8:44Speaker 2: who had ruled against Texas in this matter before didn't
- 8:48Speaker 2: say much, but then the Chief Judge had a lot
- 8:50Speaker 2: to say, right.
- 8:52Speaker 4: And the Chief Judge is actually appointed by George Bush,
- 8:55Speaker 4: and she's the Chief Judge of the Court, and was
- 8:57Speaker 4: actually in the past considered a conservative who might potentially
- 9:02Speaker 4: be on the Supreme Court. And she was very out
- 9:05Speaker 4: of it about how difficult it was to square the
- 9:07Speaker 4: circle with regard to the claims that the State of
- 9:11Speaker 4: Texas was making and how it was going to actually
- 9:14Speaker 4: implement this law if it was getting all of this
- 9:16Speaker 4: resistance from both Mexico and from the federal government. Because
- 9:21Speaker 4: at the end of the day, if the states were
- 9:23Speaker 4: going to take the matters into their own hands, how
- 9:26Speaker 4: would that actually work as a functional matter when this
- 9:28Speaker 4: has so much of a foreign policy nexus into what's
- 9:32Speaker 4: being negotiated between the United States and Mexico.
- 9:35Speaker 2: After this Fifth Circuit rules, what happens next in.
- 9:39Speaker 4: The case, Well, then it can be appealed again to
- 9:41Speaker 4: the Supreme Court, where the Supreme Court would decide whether
- 9:45Speaker 4: to uphold the Texas law or whether to continue to
- 9:49Speaker 4: say that the Texas law is unconstitutional. It's likely the
- 9:53Speaker 4: Fifth Circuit that here is actually likely to say that
- 9:56Speaker 4: the Texas law is unconstitutional. Perhaps Texas will try to
- 10:00Speaker 4: get a momentary victory by going on bank in the
- 10:03Speaker 4: Fifth Circuit for the full panel, which is a more
- 10:06Speaker 4: conservative court, but regardless, even if they get the temporary victory,
- 10:10Speaker 4: he will ultimately go to the Supreme Court. And even
- 10:14Speaker 4: though there are three justices that are unaccounted for, you
- 10:17Speaker 4: have Kavanaugh, you have Cony Barrett, and you have Gorsas
- 10:21Speaker 4: who are unaccounted for and could vote to overturn the
- 10:25Speaker 4: Arizona law, along with Justices Thomas and Alito who voted
- 10:29Speaker 4: during Arizona on the side of Arizona. So perhaps the
- 10:33Speaker 4: Flights could vote to overturn the Arizona decision, but it
- 10:38Speaker 4: seems unlikely that that would happen because again of these
- 10:41Speaker 4: ramifications of how a state then ends up interacting with
- 10:47Speaker 4: the Mexican government with regard to this act of basically
- 10:52Speaker 4: self supporting people back into Mexico who oftentimes will not
- 10:57Speaker 4: even be Mexican, will be from Venezuela or Cuba or
- 11:01Speaker 4: some other place where Mexico has no reason to take
- 11:04Speaker 4: people back into Mexico.
- 11:05Speaker 2: Yeah, and the Chief Judge did mention that Arizona case,
- 11:09Speaker 2: saying the laws on the books. So we'll see when
- 11:12Speaker 2: that ruling comes out. Stay with me. Leon. Coming up next,
- 11:15Speaker 2: I'll continue this conversation with Leon Fresco of Holland and Knight.
- 11:19Speaker 2: The Texas governor journeys to New York City, but not
- 11:22Speaker 2: by bus. It wasn't by bus, but Texas Governor Greg
- 11:28Speaker 2: Abbott did make the trip to New York City to
- 11:31Speaker 2: headline the New York Republican Party's annual gala last Thursday,
- 11:36Speaker 2: and Abbot said he had no plans to let up
- 11:38Speaker 2: on busing migrants to the sanctuary city, continuing his war
- 11:43Speaker 2: of words with the Mayor Eric Adams.
- 11:46Speaker 5: The complaining by Mayor Adams, there's nothing short than stunning.
- 11:52Speaker 5: What he has is a tiny fraction of what Texas
- 11:56Speaker 5: gets every single day.
- 11:58Speaker 2: The governor did not take the mayor up on his
- 12:01Speaker 2: offer to spend a night in one of the city's
- 12:04Speaker 2: migrant shelters. I've been talking to immigration law expert Leon
- 12:07Speaker 2: Fresco of Holland and Knight Leon. Immigration is going to
- 12:12Speaker 2: be one of the top issues in the presidential campaign.
- 12:17Speaker 2: And we've talked before about hints from the Biden administration
- 12:21Speaker 2: that there might be an executive action by the president.
- 12:25Speaker 2: Is there any more talk or thought by the Biden
- 12:29Speaker 2: administration of taking some kind of executive action in light
- 12:33Speaker 2: of the fact that they couldn't get the immigration bill
- 12:36Speaker 2: passed well.
- 12:37Speaker 4: The Biden administration is certainly continuing this process. They are
- 12:42Speaker 4: really engaging in a lot of debate whether it's better
- 12:46Speaker 4: to place a policy in effect that they know will
- 12:50Speaker 4: be enjoyed by the court simply so that they can
- 12:52Speaker 4: say they tried, or whether they should try to engage
- 12:56Speaker 4: in a policy that might not be as effective dominant
- 13:00Speaker 4: if you looked at it on its face, but could
- 13:02Speaker 4: actually survive judicial scrutiny. But the interesting news is that
- 13:08Speaker 4: when March ended, March was actually as a hair lower
- 13:12Speaker 4: than people were expecting with regards to border crossings. And
- 13:16Speaker 4: that's because Mexico has agreed along with the Biden administration
- 13:20Speaker 4: to help the Bide administration, especially with regards to Venezuelan.
- 13:24Speaker 4: So they are detaining Venezuelans, they are preventing Venezuelan from
- 13:28Speaker 4: entering the United States, and they're actually removing Venezuelans back
- 13:33Speaker 4: into Venezuela. And so this is having some nominal but
- 13:38Speaker 4: yet somewhat appreciable effect on the border with regards to
- 13:42Speaker 4: numbers crossing. And so only if those numbers were to
- 13:45Speaker 4: get back to the rates that were worried about, I
- 13:50Speaker 4: think is when you'd see these policies potentially being promulgated.
- 13:55Speaker 2: Leam. We've talked before about many migrants who are arrested
- 13:58Speaker 2: and then released. But in the case of eight Venezuelan
- 14:03Speaker 2: migrants who were illegally squatting illegally squatting in a home
- 14:08Speaker 2: in New York and they were arrested and found with
- 14:10Speaker 2: drugs and guns, they were released, but I seem to
- 14:14Speaker 2: have gotten involved. Then Ice then arrested or re arrested
- 14:19Speaker 2: three of them and lodged detainer requests for four others
- 14:23Speaker 2: being held in local custody.
- 14:25Speaker 4: Yes, so depending on where the Venezuelans cases, and some
- 14:29Speaker 4: of the Venezuelans who were apprehended in New York actually
- 14:32Speaker 4: already had final deportation orders and the problem was Venezuela
- 14:36Speaker 4: won't take those individuals back and so the US government
- 14:40Speaker 4: needs to decide what it's going to do with those
- 14:42Speaker 4: But some of those individuals actually hadn't even had their
- 14:46Speaker 4: process finished, because what happened was they were in the
- 14:49Speaker 4: middle of the deportation process and the individuals absconded and
- 14:53Speaker 4: didn't show up at their hearings. And so in those situations,
- 14:58Speaker 4: I have said, look what the City of New York
- 15:01Speaker 4: is done with. Whatever criminal penalties are going to be
- 15:05Speaker 4: provided to those individuals, then we want them so that
- 15:09Speaker 4: we can try to place them in deportation proceeding. Now,
- 15:12Speaker 4: the ultimate problem with all of these Venezuelans is going
- 15:15Speaker 4: to be what happens next. If Venezuela will not accept
- 15:19Speaker 4: those individuals, what is the federal government willing to do.
- 15:23Speaker 4: Is it willing to sanction Venezuela in some way that
- 15:26Speaker 4: will actually be meaningful to Venezuela so that it will
- 15:29Speaker 4: start accepting individuals. Will it actually try to do something
- 15:33Speaker 4: different in terms of parrots to make it more attractive
- 15:37Speaker 4: for Venezuela to accept people but that's the larger issue.
- 15:41Speaker 4: Or will it try to find some country who will
- 15:44Speaker 4: accept Venezuelans in exchange for some favor that the US
- 15:49Speaker 4: government is willing to do, perhaps with regard to foreign
- 15:51Speaker 4: aid or trade or something else. But those are the
- 15:55Speaker 4: options that are available to the federal government. But this
- 15:58Speaker 4: Venezuelan issue is going to continue, ne you to be
- 16:00Speaker 4: complicated so long as Venezuela is not accepting people that
- 16:04Speaker 4: the United States is trying to remove there.
- 16:07Speaker 2: So is that why Venezuelans are in the spotlight because
- 16:12Speaker 2: the country's not accepting people back or are there other
- 16:15Speaker 2: reasons why?
- 16:15Speaker 4: Well, there's a lot of issues going on at one time. One,
- 16:18Speaker 4: obviously there's a mass exodus of Venezuelans into the United States. Second,
- 16:23Speaker 4: there are now appearing to be some efforts with regard
- 16:27Speaker 4: to Venezuela with sort of emptying out some of the
- 16:31Speaker 4: undesirables from Venezuela in a way similar to what Fidel
- 16:35Speaker 4: Castro did in Cuba in the nineteen eighties to make
- 16:38Speaker 4: Venezuelan to sort of alleviate the social pressures on Venezuela.
- 16:43Speaker 4: But those pressures now get transferred to the United States
- 16:46Speaker 4: as some of those individuals arrived who are not necessarily
- 16:50Speaker 4: as safe as some others. And so I think that's
- 16:53Speaker 4: what you're seeing, is you're seeing the confluence of a
- 16:56Speaker 4: different group of Venezuelans entering into the United States, addition
- 17:00Speaker 4: to the fact that those individuals then can't be removed
- 17:03Speaker 4: back into Venezuela. And so this is something, like I said,
- 17:07Speaker 4: the last time you saw this was in the nineteen eighties,
- 17:09Speaker 4: and when this happened then it was destabilizing the quite
- 17:13Speaker 4: some number of places until those communities could figure out
- 17:17Speaker 4: what they were going to do.
- 17:18Speaker 2: Let's say Ice has some Venezuela's in custody, what are
- 17:22Speaker 2: its options.
- 17:23Speaker 4: So what happens is there's an opinion from the Supreme
- 17:27Speaker 4: Court that actually was post this nineteen eighties issue, which
- 17:31Speaker 4: was called Zavidas. And in that opinion, what they said was,
- 17:35Speaker 4: if you can't deport someone and you know you can't
- 17:38Speaker 4: support someone, you've tried for six months while you've had
- 17:42Speaker 4: them in detention and you can't support them, you have
- 17:45Speaker 4: to release them back into society under an order of
- 17:49Speaker 4: supervision where they have to report and check in, unless
- 17:53Speaker 4: you can show that there's such a danger to society
- 17:57Speaker 4: that you can indefinitely detain them. And so the federal
- 18:00Speaker 4: government has been very concerned about trying to stretch out
- 18:05Speaker 4: the constitutionality of whether it can indefinitely detain people, but basically,
- 18:10Speaker 4: anytime someone breaks their conditions, you can place them back
- 18:14Speaker 4: in detention for six months at a time, but that's
- 18:17Speaker 4: very difficult, and so if you're going to be tracking
- 18:20Speaker 4: people and they're going to be committing crimes in between
- 18:23Speaker 4: the time they're in immigration detention, that's the sort of
- 18:26Speaker 4: thing that the public doesn't like to year about when
- 18:29Speaker 4: the federal government's doing that. They don't understand what's going on.
- 18:32Speaker 4: But the problem is there is the Supreme Court decision,
- 18:35Speaker 4: which you know, understandably, you don't want to have someone
- 18:38Speaker 4: in detention for fifty years because their government won't accept them.
- 18:43Speaker 4: And all they might have done is commit something like
- 18:45Speaker 4: a shoplifting offense, and now they're suddenly in prison for
- 18:49Speaker 4: fifty years. So you have to be careful. There obviously
- 18:52Speaker 4: is a balance, but here the balance has led to
- 18:56Speaker 4: a situation where there's a little bit of a lack
- 18:58Speaker 4: of safety and stability some places because there are all
- 19:02Speaker 4: these Venezuelans who are being caught doing things in New
- 19:05Speaker 4: York City and they can't be detained because there's a
- 19:10Speaker 4: cap to how long they can be detained. Due to
- 19:12Speaker 4: the fact that they can't actually be removed back to Venezuela.
- 19:16Speaker 2: It is so complicated because you're right, you read the
- 19:19Speaker 2: stories and you go, well, why are they still here?
- 19:21Speaker 2: They've been in and out of jail and continue committing crimes.
- 19:25Speaker 2: You know, why isn't something being done? I mean, it's
- 19:27Speaker 2: just so complicated and confused.
- 19:29Speaker 4: I mean, you could, you could conceivably And this is
- 19:32Speaker 4: the thing nobody's ever tried to do, is have an
- 19:35Speaker 4: aggressive action against some country like Venezuela and say, look,
- 19:38Speaker 4: we are by force. And this is the kind of
- 19:40Speaker 4: thing Trump has talked about, we are by force bringing
- 19:43Speaker 4: people here, and go ahead, shoot out us. You know,
- 19:45Speaker 4: try whatever you're gonna try, but we're gonna We're gonna
- 19:48Speaker 4: still deport these people. We don't care. But obviously something
- 19:51Speaker 4: like that hasn't yet been dried in American history, so
- 19:55Speaker 4: it's not clear. Maybe President Trump would try that, or
- 19:58Speaker 4: maybe with scare a country to accepting people under the
- 20:01Speaker 4: threat that he's going to try these forced deportations, but
- 20:05Speaker 4: it would be considered an act of aggression because you're
- 20:08Speaker 4: invading a country's territorial boundaries without their permissions.
- 20:14Speaker 2: And the numbers in March were better, but still incredibly high.
- 20:18Speaker 4: Right, It's still very high compared to past years, that
- 20:22Speaker 4: past decades, but compared to this recent last twelve months.
- 20:27Speaker 4: March was a bit of a break from what people
- 20:30Speaker 4: expected was going to happen in March, and that's because
- 20:33Speaker 4: all of the Venezuelas people thought were coming were not
- 20:36Speaker 4: coming because Mexico was stopping them. And Venezuela has agreed
- 20:41Speaker 4: to allow deportations from Mexico, even if it hasn't agreed
- 20:45Speaker 4: to allow deportations from the United States.
- 20:47Speaker 2: The majority of migrants, what country are they from?
- 20:52Speaker 4: Well, people are still coming from all over the world,
- 20:55Speaker 4: and Mexico actually still is the highest number in terms
- 20:59Speaker 4: of just your number. But they're coming from Cuba, they're
- 21:03Speaker 4: coming from Haiti, They're coming from Venezuela. They're coming from Nicaragua,
- 21:07Speaker 4: They're coming from Central America, savad or Juatemala, there is
- 21:11Speaker 4: they're coming from Ecuador. They're coming now from parts of
- 21:15Speaker 4: Africa and from China, and so it's everywhere, but Venezuela
- 21:19Speaker 4: has sort of been the choke point in terms of
- 21:23Speaker 4: just the numbers get really high when the surges of
- 21:26Speaker 4: Venezuelan come in.
- 21:28Speaker 2: And this is why immigration is going to be one
- 21:30Speaker 2: of the top issues this presidential election season. Thanks so much,
- 21:35Speaker 2: Leon for once again helping us to understand how complicated
- 21:39Speaker 2: immigration issues are. That's Leon Fresco of Holland and Knight.
- 21:44Speaker 2: In other legal news today, Donald Trump asked a New
- 21:47Speaker 2: York appeals court to move his hush money criminal trial
- 21:51Speaker 2: out of Manhattan and reverse his gag order in an
- 21:55Speaker 2: eleventh hour bid for delay just a week before the
- 21:58Speaker 2: trial is scheduled to start. At an emergency hearing today,
- 22:02Speaker 2: the former president's lawyers asked an appellate judge to postpone
- 22:06Speaker 2: the April fifteenth trial while they fight for a change
- 22:09Speaker 2: of venue. Trump's lawyer argued that he faces quote real
- 22:13Speaker 2: potential prejudice as a defendant in heavily democratic Manhattan. Citing
- 22:19Speaker 2: defense surveys and a review of media coverage. Trump Is
- 22:23Speaker 2: suggested on social media that the trial should be moved
- 22:26Speaker 2: to Staten Island, the only New York City borough he
- 22:29Speaker 2: won in twenty sixteen and twenty twenty. The appella chief
- 22:33Speaker 2: for the Manhattan District Attorney's Office, Stephen Woo, said the
- 22:37Speaker 2: question in this case is not whether a random poll
- 22:40Speaker 2: of New Yorkers from whatever neighborhood are able to be impartial.
- 22:44Speaker 2: It's about whether a trial court is able to select
- 22:47Speaker 2: a jury of twelve impartial jurors. He also blamed Trump
- 22:52Speaker 2: for stoking pre trial publicity with countless media appearances talking
- 22:56Speaker 2: about the facts of the case, the witnesses, and so on.
- 23:01Speaker 2: Justice Elizabeth Gonzalez noted at today's hearing that it didn't
- 23:04Speaker 2: involve an appeal per se, but the defense's desire for
- 23:08Speaker 2: an emergency stay, an order that would prevent the trial
- 23:11Speaker 2: from starting on time. She said she would review related
- 23:15Speaker 2: court filings and issue a decision quote at some point.
- 23:19Speaker 2: Coming up next on the Bloomberg Law Show, the First
- 23:22Speaker 2: Amendment shields a Broadway producer's casting decision from discrimination claims.
- 23:28Speaker 2: I'm June Grosse and you're listening to Bloomberg. He hadies
- 23:44Speaker 2: down is the Tony Award winning musical about the myth
- 23:47Speaker 2: of Orpheus and Euryticy, and it's now the latest example
- 23:51Speaker 2: of how the First Amendment can shield casting decisions from
- 23:55Speaker 2: claims of discrimination. Joining Me's employment law expert Anthony Ansee,
- 24:00Speaker 2: a partner at Pross Gower Rose Tony, tell us about
- 24:03Speaker 2: the facts here because it seemed like the producers of
- 24:06Speaker 2: this show were sort of between a rock and a
- 24:08Speaker 2: hard place when they realized that the chorus consisted of
- 24:13Speaker 2: all black actors and Orpheus, who rescues the chorus from
- 24:17Speaker 2: never ending labor, was a white actor.
- 24:21Speaker 1: So I think they were trying to balance some very
- 24:25Speaker 1: important issues on both sides, and interestingly, I think they
- 24:29Speaker 1: were being racially sensitive. That's perhaps the most ironic part
- 24:34Speaker 1: of this case. By making the decision that they made,
- 24:37Speaker 1: They in the initial configuration of the cast, had a
- 24:42Speaker 1: white actor on the one hand who was playing one
- 24:46Speaker 1: of the lead roles, and a number of other cast
- 24:50Speaker 1: members were all black, and the inadvertent message that apparently
- 24:55Speaker 1: was being inferred from that was one of a white
- 24:58Speaker 1: savior saving the black cast members, and that was what
- 25:02Speaker 1: sort of touched off the ultimate decision that they made
- 25:05Speaker 1: with respect to the casting.
- 25:07Speaker 2: So the producers fired a black actor in the chorus
- 25:10Speaker 2: and replaced her with a white actor, and she sued them.
- 25:13Speaker 2: What were the grounds of her suit?
- 25:15Speaker 1: She sued for a number of things, most particularly employment
- 25:19Speaker 1: discrimination because she said that she was in a protected
- 25:23Speaker 1: class as she is, that she was terminated because of
- 25:27Speaker 1: her race, and that in almost every other context, you
- 25:32Speaker 1: can imagine in an employment setting would probably be enough
- 25:35Speaker 1: to at least continue to pursue the case. Interestingly, with
- 25:38Speaker 1: those claims with respect to employment discriminations were dismissed at
- 25:42Speaker 1: the very earliest stage, at the pleadings stage.
- 25:45Speaker 2: So was it dismissed because the producers raised a First
- 25:49Speaker 2: Amendment defense and tell us about that right?
- 25:52Speaker 1: So what the court did is they very deliberately went
- 25:55Speaker 1: through first her allegations and concluded that she had at
- 25:59Speaker 1: least the makings of a successful lawsuit. As I said,
- 26:03Speaker 1: she was in a protected category. She says that her
- 26:05Speaker 1: race was a factor, if not the primary factor, in
- 26:09Speaker 1: the termination decision, and sought to pursue a claim for
- 26:13Speaker 1: discrimination based upon her race. The producers, however, argued in
- 26:19Speaker 1: response that they had a First Amendment right to make
- 26:23Speaker 1: the decision that they made, and in particular with respect
- 26:26Speaker 1: to casting a Broadway play, they said was an expression
- 26:32Speaker 1: of their First Amendment rights and they therefore were immune,
- 26:37Speaker 1: they argued from a discrimination claim such as the one
- 26:40Speaker 1: that was being brought by the former employee in this case,
- 26:44Speaker 1: and am Matt and.
- 26:45Speaker 2: Federal judge agreed with the producers as far as the
- 26:48Speaker 2: discrimination claim she dismissed the plaintiffs discrimination claims, but allowed
- 26:52Speaker 2: her retaliation claims to go forward.
- 26:55Speaker 1: I should offer a cautionary note here, and that is
- 26:58Speaker 1: that this arose obvis in the entertainment context for a
- 27:02Speaker 1: Broadway production. And there are a few other cases, and
- 27:06Speaker 1: I emphasize just a few, that have similarly arisen in
- 27:10Speaker 1: the entertainment industry, principally involving casting related decisions that are
- 27:15Speaker 1: made by employers. And most, if not all the cases
- 27:19Speaker 1: that I found, at least so far, and there's probably
- 27:21Speaker 1: not more than five or six of them, have endorsed
- 27:24Speaker 1: the producers or the directors, or the individuals who are
- 27:29Speaker 1: otherwise making the employment decisions. For example, there's been some
- 27:32Speaker 1: cases involving beauty contests and things like that, involving, for example,
- 27:36Speaker 1: transgender applicants to an all female beauty contest, And almost
- 27:40Speaker 1: all these cases come out the same way, and that
- 27:42Speaker 1: is that the courts that have reviewed these claims of
- 27:45Speaker 1: discrimination have come down on the side of the defendant
- 27:49Speaker 1: of the employer, saying that this is a very unique
- 27:52Speaker 1: situation in which there is creative expression that occurs, and
- 27:57Speaker 1: that creative expression in the form of casting is detected
- 28:00Speaker 1: by the First Amendment.
- 28:01Speaker 2: And you have to tell me about the case involving
- 28:04Speaker 2: the Bachelor, because that's such a popular, popular show appointment viewing.
- 28:09Speaker 1: Yes, And this most recent opinion, which came out just
- 28:11Speaker 1: on March seventh, so it's brand new, it does rely
- 28:15Speaker 1: to some extent on the so called Bachelor opinion, which
- 28:18Speaker 1: is from a federal court in Tennessee in twenty twelve,
- 28:22Speaker 1: so it actually is quite a while ago. And that
- 28:25Speaker 1: case involved two black men who claimed that they sought
- 28:30Speaker 1: to but were not permitted, to be on the Bachelor
- 28:34Speaker 1: show in twenty twelve. And they said that the reason
- 28:38Speaker 1: was that they were black, and they noted in their
- 28:41Speaker 1: lawsuit that up to that point, at least all of
- 28:44Speaker 1: the contestants had been white. And they went further and
- 28:48Speaker 1: said that the producers were refusing to cast non white
- 28:52Speaker 1: bachelors and bachelorettes by the way, to avoid the quote
- 28:56Speaker 1: controversy stemming from an interracial romance, and to convey the
- 29:00Speaker 1: message quote that only all white relationships are desirable and
- 29:04Speaker 1: worthy of national attention. Now, not surprisingly, the producers vehemently
- 29:09Speaker 1: and categorically denied that those were the messages that they
- 29:13Speaker 1: sought to send or that those were the motivating factors
- 29:17Speaker 1: behind the decisions that had been made, but the court
- 29:20Speaker 1: said it didn't matter. The court said, again using the
- 29:23Speaker 1: First Amendment affirmative defense that played out in the Hadestown case,
- 29:29Speaker 1: that even if let's assume for a moment, because that's
- 29:31Speaker 1: what happens on emotion to dismiss, you assume everything that's
- 29:34Speaker 1: being alleged is true. And then the court asks itself
- 29:37Speaker 1: the question, even if everything that is being alleged is true,
- 29:40Speaker 1: is that a basis to continue with this lawsuit? So
- 29:43Speaker 1: for purpose of promotion to dismiss. In the Bachelor case,
- 29:46Speaker 1: the court assumed that the producers may have had those
- 29:49Speaker 1: unsavory points of view with respect to interracial romance and
- 29:54Speaker 1: with respect to all white relationships and so on, and
- 29:57Speaker 1: said that even if that were the case, it wouldn't matter.
- 30:00Speaker 1: That this is still expression of a creative nature that
- 30:04Speaker 1: is being exercised by the producers, and as a result
- 30:08Speaker 1: of that, the inquiry stops. That the First Amendment basically
- 30:12Speaker 1: stands in the way of a discrimination claim by someone
- 30:16Speaker 1: who is claiming that there was some invidious discrimination behind
- 30:20Speaker 1: the decision making.
- 30:22Speaker 2: This casting claim was even used with regard to television news,
- 30:28Speaker 2: which I found really interesting. I think most people know that,
- 30:32Speaker 2: in general, the decisions to hire TV news reporters or
- 30:36Speaker 2: in this case, whether people are based in part on
- 30:39Speaker 2: how they look.
- 30:41Speaker 1: In California, these kinds of cases, and again there's just
- 30:44Speaker 1: a smattering of them, very few cases involving these kinds
- 30:48Speaker 1: of claims and these kinds of defenses, at least in
- 30:52Speaker 1: the published record, but they are dealt with slightly differently
- 30:55Speaker 1: in California. We actually in California have something called the
- 30:58Speaker 1: Anti SLAP stat which is kind of acronym's gone wild,
- 31:03Speaker 1: and slap is spelled with two p's, so it's the
- 31:05Speaker 1: anti slapp statue, and that stands for strategic lawsuit against
- 31:12Speaker 1: public participation. So yeah, I think it's an acronym in
- 31:17Speaker 1: search of words and not the other way around. But
- 31:19Speaker 1: in any event, what it is is a means by
- 31:22Speaker 1: which a defendant who is making a casting decision, as
- 31:26Speaker 1: you mentioned in one case involving an on air weather reporter,
- 31:32Speaker 1: is able to essentially dismiss the claim that's brought alleging discrimination,
- 31:37Speaker 1: and the basis for dismissal is this first amendment. The
- 31:39Speaker 1: same kind of first Amendment defense that we've been talking about.
- 31:43Speaker 1: So that's what happened in this case. An older white
- 31:46Speaker 1: male challenged decision that was made to instead of hiring him,
- 31:53Speaker 1: hiring younger, more attractive female weather reporters, and he alleged
- 32:02Speaker 1: that that was discrimination based upon his age and his gender.
- 32:07Speaker 1: And he said that because younger attractive female form being
- 32:10Speaker 1: hired as on air weather reporters, that obviously had a
- 32:14Speaker 1: discriminatory effect and precluded him from being hired. And again
- 32:18Speaker 1: this same analysis was used in the case. The court
- 32:22Speaker 1: indulged the possibility that that was in fact what was
- 32:26Speaker 1: going on, that the local weather reporter was being hired
- 32:31Speaker 1: based upon gender, or based upon age or attractiveness, what
- 32:35Speaker 1: have you. And the court said, nonetheless, the television station
- 32:41Speaker 1: in that case was involved in quote expressive activity under
- 32:45Speaker 1: the First Amendment, and that such selection choices were quote
- 32:49Speaker 1: essentially casting decisions. We don't typically think of the weather
- 32:53Speaker 1: reporter as a casting decision, but it's not very difficult
- 32:57Speaker 1: to imagine that because it does have some of the
- 32:59Speaker 1: same characters. And therefore, once again the employer, the producer,
- 33:05Speaker 1: under these circumstances was immune from this discrimination claim that
- 33:09Speaker 1: was being alleged by the prospective weather reporter.
- 33:13Speaker 2: So do you think that all these cases mean that
- 33:18Speaker 2: you know, whether it's film or theater or TV, that
- 33:23Speaker 2: producers can cast whomever they want in a roll and
- 33:26Speaker 2: know that if discrimination claims are filed, they're going to win.
- 33:31Speaker 1: I think that we're close to that if it is
- 33:33Speaker 1: genuinely a casting related decision, and it is genuinely connected
- 33:38Speaker 1: to some kind of creative expression, and I know those
- 33:41Speaker 1: are rubbery words, and it's probably going to be the
- 33:45Speaker 1: case if it hasn't already been the case, and maybe
- 33:48Speaker 1: some cases that we've not yet seen published that those
- 33:50Speaker 1: might be inapplicable in certain decisions. But I think that
- 33:54Speaker 1: anybody who is either thinking of suing an entertainment company
- 33:59Speaker 1: and who might be subject to some form of casting
- 34:02Speaker 1: or some form of selection by the producer or by
- 34:06Speaker 1: the entertainment related company, I think is going to have
- 34:09Speaker 1: tougher odds in being able to proceed with a lawsuit. Conversely,
- 34:14Speaker 1: I think that anybody who's defending as I do defend
- 34:17Speaker 1: employers many within the entertainment industry, if there is something
- 34:21Speaker 1: related to expression of creativity or casting, this should be
- 34:26Speaker 1: a first stop consideration and I think, obviously there's going
- 34:30Speaker 1: to be limits to that that probably would not apply
- 34:33Speaker 1: to an in house lawyer at a studio or at
- 34:36Speaker 1: a Broadway production, or an accountant. It probably wouldn't apply
- 34:40Speaker 1: to somebody who's a member of the crew who's not
- 34:44Speaker 1: necessarily going to be in any way exposed to the
- 34:48Speaker 1: public in terms of the performance. So I think, although
- 34:50Speaker 1: this is interesting and categorically uncharacteristic, I guess of what
- 34:54Speaker 1: we typically think of in terms of discrimination lawsuits, it
- 34:58Speaker 1: is a very powerful defense, very narrow area within the
- 35:01Speaker 1: entertainment industry, and one that I think you don't have
- 35:05Speaker 1: to look much further than I went back and checked.
- 35:09Speaker 1: In my view of The Godfather, I think the motion
- 35:12Speaker 1: picture movie from the nineteen seventies would be much different
- 35:15Speaker 1: if the casting decisions had been different. And we all
- 35:19Speaker 1: know it's a matter of public record that some of
- 35:21Speaker 1: the most influential producers of that film preferred some of
- 35:26Speaker 1: the leading actors of the day, including Laurence Olivier, George C. Scott,
- 35:32Speaker 1: and even Danny Thomas as the Godfather Beato Corleone, over
- 35:38Speaker 1: Marlon Brando. And it was really only the very strong
- 35:43Speaker 1: creative decision and the force of personality, and of course
- 35:48Speaker 1: the influence that Francis Ford Coppola had as the director
- 35:51Speaker 1: that he was able to make sure that his singular choice,
- 35:54Speaker 1: Marlon Brando, was chosen for that role. But it doesn't
- 35:57Speaker 1: take a lot of imagination to think what would that
- 35:59Speaker 1: motion and picture have been like if any of those individuals,
- 36:02Speaker 1: all fine actors had been cast and not the iconic
- 36:07Speaker 1: Marlon Brando or al Pacino.
- 36:09Speaker 2: Because Francis Ford Coppla had a fight tooth and nail
- 36:13Speaker 2: to get al Pacino in that.
- 36:14Speaker 1: Role, that is correct. There's been a lot of post
- 36:18Speaker 1: Godfather history, including a relatively recent television dramatization about the
- 36:22Speaker 1: casting and the production of the film that talked a
- 36:25Speaker 1: lot about that and that mister Baccino was on thin
- 36:27Speaker 1: ice and the producers very much did not want him.
- 36:29Speaker 1: And of course you can't imagine anyone being Michael corleone
- 36:32Speaker 1: other than al Pacina.
- 36:33Speaker 2: You really can't at this point. Thanks so much, Tony
- 36:36Speaker 2: for your Godfather insights as well as your legal insights.
- 36:40Speaker 2: That's Anthony on Seedi of Pross Cower Rose