Latest / Old School, New School, Next School with Dom Giordano / Inside Mississippi’s Reading Revolution | Dr. Kymyona Burk
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to Old School,
- 0:05New School, Next School with Dom Giordano,
- 0:08a podcast devoted to shedding light on issues pertaining to making America smart again.
- 0:15These include, among many topics,
- 0:17school choice and parental rights.
- 0:19This podcast is dedicated to reversing the deeply disturbing trend known as the dumbing down of America.
- 0:27Now,
- 0:28here's your host,
- 0:29Educator.
- 0:30and noted talk media commentator,
- 0:32Dom Giordano.
- 0:34Hey everyone,
- 0:35this is Dom Giordano and welcome into this week's edition of Old School,
- 0:40New School,
- 0:40Next School.
- 0:41Pretty excited this week because it's like I've discovered gold or plutonium.
- 0:46I know it's been out there and from afar before I started doing this podcast,
- 0:51I knew about it, but now I know the details.
- 0:53And we are bringing you today Dr.
- 0:56Kimonia Burke from Mississippi.
- 0:59She is billed as, and I believe she is, one of the architects of what's happened in Mississippi that's called the Mississippi Miracle,
- 1:08where Mississippi used to be down there in the lowest rungs when it came to proficiency in reading,
- 1:15math, that kind of thing.
- 1:16And now they're approaching the very top.
- 1:19Now,
- 1:20Dr.
- 1:20Burke is a former state literacy director in Mississippi,
- 1:23now currently the senior fellow for early literacy at Excel.
- 1:29in ed,
- 1:30the foundation for excellence in education.
- 1:32And that's what this is about,
- 1:34excellence.
- 1:35But it's doable.
- 1:36You have to answer the question. We're spending a trillion dollars a year.
- 1:40After the doctor,
- 1:41I'll give you a little bit more detail on this.
- 1:44What is holding up what was done in Mississippi from being done in every one of the other 49 states and D.C. and the rest of it?
- 1:53What's holding it up?
- 1:54The teachers unions.
- 1:56They don't want to do it.
- 1:57They're gonna fight this to the death.
- 2:00That's exactly what's going on here.
- 2:02And I'll give you a little study that was out right now that says the stronger the teachers union is in a state, meaning the more control they have,
- 2:11the lower the student literacy levels are.
- 2:14But without further ado,
- 2:16let's learn in detail what's going on in Mississippi.
- 2:20And as we move into this new school year,
- 2:24this could be done in your area or your state.
- 2:27This is where all the emphasis should be. And Republicans ought to be all over this. The media is not going to cover it.
- 2:34Do they not want kids to be able to read,
- 2:36write,
- 2:37and do math well?
- 2:39Here's Dr.
- 2:39Camila Burke with Dom Giordano on Old School, New School, Next School. Thank you so much for having me.
- 2:46This is out-of-the-world news.
- 2:51Yes.
- 2:52That Mississippi,
- 2:53you know, I've been in talk radio right after teaching Dr.
- 2:57Burke.
- 2:57And Mississippi,
- 2:59let's face it, historically,
- 3:00by these standardized tests,
- 3:01proficiencies and all, were in the 48, 49,
- 3:0450 Louisiana.
- 3:05You guys were around there.
- 3:08And now it's making a drive, as I understand it, on the top five or so.
- 3:14Yes,
- 3:14it has been a long journey. I think the question is around,
- 3:19you know, as always,
- 3:20what did you do?
- 3:22And there's not just one thing. And so I'm hoping I'll get to talk about,
- 3:26you know,
- 3:27how we're teaching reading,
- 3:28but also some of the other supports that are being included to improve those outcomes.
- 3:32Oh,
- 3:32yeah.
- 3:33Without a doubt.
- 3:33Sure you will.
- 3:34And feel free.
- 3:35You know,
- 3:35you're the expert here.
- 3:38I'm just someone agog at what you guys have achieved.
- 3:42So the science of reading is conditioned on something we've known,
- 3:46I've known since I was teaching, and my wife is pre-K and uses this stuff in her own business now big time, is phonics,
- 3:54right? It's not just phonics, but that is a key
- 3:57That's the way to teach reading.
- 4:01Yeah, I think there are beliefs,
- 4:03right, about how to teach reading, and then there is evidence about how to teach reading.
- 4:08And so in Mississippi,
- 4:10just as in so many states across the country,
- 4:12teachers go into their classrooms.
- 4:15I'm a former teacher.
- 4:16Go into your classrooms, and you close your door,
- 4:18and you just get to do what you believe,
- 4:20right,
- 4:21is right for children.
- 4:23But there's evidence.
- 4:24And now we have that evidence about the science of reading and how teachers should explicitly teach students how to break the code of reading.
- 4:33And that's one thing that we've been doing here in Mississippi. And we've been supporting teachers in classrooms with literacy coaches and, of course, providing training for teachers to build their knowledge base to make sure that they're able to do that.
- 4:45Now, you mentioned the word coaches. I'm glad you said that because that's exactly the word that I would use. We use it in athletics.
- 4:53We ought to use it here to the same energy that you and others are doing to coach up these kids.
- 5:00And they are paid well.
- 5:02And there are a lot of them, as I understand,
- 5:05which is exactly the intensity of this to say every child can read unless there's something so severe. We,
- 5:12you know, that's another category.
- 5:14And we should not think that most of these kids can't read.
- 5:18Right.
- 5:19And I think that that's been the story of Mississippi.
- 5:22And it's been the story that so many have told about,
- 5:25you know, the societal ills,
- 5:27right? It's not a secret that Mississippi is the poorest state in the country.
- 5:32And for so many years,
- 5:34that has been used as an excuse,
- 5:37right? The poorest state,
- 5:38you know, low income,
- 5:40you know, a lot of racial diversity,
- 5:42a lot of black and brown students,
- 5:43all of those kids.
- 5:44And so those have been a lot of the excuses as to why it was okay for Mississippi and our other southern states to for the expectations to be low,
- 5:55right? That,
- 5:56okay,
- 5:56well, it's okay that they're in the bottom ten in the country.
- 6:00But I think what we've done here in Mississippi,
- 6:02and as you mentioned, Louisiana, Alabama, what's happening is that what we're showing is that those excuses are not true.
- 6:09We can teach all children to read for,
- 6:13you know,
- 6:14except for those that you've mentioned that may have significant disabilities.
- 6:18As long as we use the right practices in the classroom.
- 6:22Dr.
- 6:22Burke with us here. And doctor,
- 6:24let's talk about the third grade part of this as kind of a deadline.
- 6:29And as a former educator and someone that still works in this field, you do it on a spectacular level day to day.
- 6:37What is the reason why,
- 6:39you don't graduate or move on from third grade.
- 6:42Why third grade? Why is that critical?
- 6:45Well,
- 6:46there's research,
- 6:47especially from the Annie E.
- 6:48Casey Foundation,
- 6:49which you will hear many people reference around following students from pre-K or kindergarten through high school.
- 6:58And the one thing that they were able to identify was that those students who had not gained the foundational literacy skills by third grade, being able to read and comprehend and apply,
- 7:10those skills to different types of text,
- 7:12then they were far less likely to be successful as they moved on to fourth grade and beyond,
- 7:18where the text become more complex.
- 7:20They're being asked to do other things and not just read and comprehend,
- 7:25but read charts, graphs,
- 7:27make inferences,
- 7:28and those things.
- 7:28So it comes from that research that says that third grade is the threshold for students to be able to have the skills that they need in order to move on.
- 7:38What we've learned also is that learning to read doesn't stop in third grade.
- 7:44Students continue to learn more advanced phonics, right, more advanced opportunities to engage with text and learn more about the world.
- 7:55But that has been considered a threshold as far as the research is concerned.
- 8:00Now,
- 8:01I talk about this a lot,
- 8:03doing this and formerly being a teacher,
- 8:05this conflict of something where there shouldn't be conflict.
- 8:09And in Mississippi, the word is collaboration,
- 8:12meaning it seems to me the two political parties,
- 8:15this is bipartisan.
- 8:17What about the teachers unions,
- 8:19though? Are they on board with it?
- 8:21Well,
- 8:23Dom, I'm glad you asked,
- 8:24because we do not have collective bargaining in our state.
- 8:29So we have, of course,
- 8:32teachers associations,
- 8:35but they cannot bargain as a union as in most of the states that we see, especially our northern and northeastern states.
- 8:43So some people will say,
- 8:44well, you don't have unions, so you really don't face a lot of the problems that some states face in getting teachers to participate in a number of hours of professional development or,
- 8:55you know, these other things that unions may kind of fight back on.
- 8:59to protect teachers,
- 9:01right?
- 9:01So we are able to,
- 9:04we do have local control,
- 9:06though.
- 9:06So I will say that. We do have local control where our districts have been able to make a lot of the decisions around what is taught, the curriculum that is used, how things are taught in the school district.
- 9:20But I'm a believer in policy.
- 9:22I truly believe that we did not have a law related to how literacy and how reading would be
- 9:29taught in our state that we would not have been able to improve,
- 9:35especially to the degree that we have over the last decade.
- 9:38I couldn't agree more.
- 9:40And again,
- 9:42the teachers unions part of this, you know, there's a place for that.
- 9:46But and I don't want to draw you into it. I mean,
- 9:48I talk about it a lot. What I saw as a teacher,
- 9:51I was in Jersey and it's mandated there.
- 9:54They take the money out of your paycheck,
- 9:57doctor.
- 9:57By state law.
- 9:59By state law.
- 10:02But it seems to me the teachers unions are on the wrong side of this.
- 10:07You know, accommodation,
- 10:09if you're forcing members to take too much extra training and not pay. All right, we can debate all that.
- 10:15But the fundamentals of this are not debatable.
- 10:20And I can hear it in a voice in a softer way. What you're saying,
- 10:23these are not debatable.
- 10:24is my whole thing now as a talk show host.
- 10:27We know what to do.
- 10:29All we have to do is follow Mississippi with our own state cultures at all and do it.
- 10:36And America will succeed like Mississippi.
- 10:41And I'll tell you this,
- 10:43too. I think that the the approach that we've used across the country for so long, as I mentioned,
- 10:49you know, the silos,
- 10:50right?
- 10:51Yeah.
- 10:51Where even with the legislature,
- 10:53sometimes the legislature,
- 10:54will have,
- 10:55you know, their agenda.
- 10:57There may not be a conversation with the Department of Education,
- 11:00right, who is actually set to implement this agenda.
- 11:03I always talk about our big three here in Mississippi,
- 11:06where we had not only our legislature,
- 11:08as you mentioned, a bipartisan effort,
- 11:10our governor,
- 11:12and our State Department of Education,
- 11:13who were all involved at the very beginning.
- 11:17The Department of Education was able to communicate with the legislature what they would need in order to make this happen.
- 11:23We need funding.
- 11:24We need to support infrastructure at the department to even be able to support school districts to do these things.
- 11:30And I honestly believe that if we took the same approach with unions,
- 11:35with bringing them in at the very beginning to say this is why these changes are needed,
- 11:41this is how we can do that, you know, what are your gripes against like these particular strategies that we'll be using so that everyone can come to the table and get a full understanding.
- 11:51I think that that could be the start.
- 11:53of having these conversations where the adults are not getting in the way of student progress.
- 12:00Well,
- 12:00my parting question is, are you available to be cloned so I can bring you to Pennsylvania and New Jersey,
- 12:07Dr.
- 12:07Burke?
- 12:09Because you are determined,
- 12:11but you do have the flexibility.
- 12:14You would have to be an oaf to be hollering at you and saying, hell no, we're not going to do what this woman is saying.
- 12:20Thank you, Dr.
- 12:21Burke.
- 12:21Thank you so much for having me.
- 12:23Boy, I feel like I have unleashed the whirlwind here.
- 12:28Are you believing me?
- 12:29You can always email me at domshow at AOL.com and tell me,
- 12:35do you believe this?
- 12:36Well,
- 12:37the results are there. We can prove it.
- 12:39You heard the doctor and you heard what she said about the teachers unions in Mississippi.
- 12:43They have associations.
- 12:45Big study out,
- 12:46New York Post published it,
- 12:49that says that at least eight of the 10 states where students had the
- 12:53The worst literacy scores this last year were liberal strongholds with politically powerful teachers unions,
- 12:59while just five were Republican and one was a swing state in a recent assessment from the Progressive Policy Institute.
- 13:07New York,
- 13:07where more than half of the third to fifth grade students failed their reading proficiency exam this year,
- 13:13was among the worst performing states and also had some of the strongest teachers unions.
- 13:18Yeah, I would say that's the case.
- 13:20So what do we do?
- 13:23is we have to be taking this piece by piece.
- 13:26You heard Dr.
- 13:27Burke,
- 13:27some of the pillars of this.
- 13:30What do they object to? For some reason,
- 13:33I've talked to Corey DeAngelis, the big school choice guy.
- 13:36They object to phonics.
- 13:38Some of them still refuse to sign off on the science of reading.
- 13:42We know that phonics versus the look say method works.
- 13:46He theorized phonics is a lot of work.
- 13:50Saying kids ought to know certain words when they come to school.
- 13:53and lists and all that, that's easier.
- 13:55What could they be about with the intervention of students if they're not performing well?
- 14:03Literacy coaches.
- 14:05Well, maybe they think that's eroding their power. They want some more control to determine that, pay how many and everything else.
- 14:14What could they object to by saying, if you can't read proficiently by the end of third grade,
- 14:21then you're not going to move forward?
- 14:23That would I'm clueless. Why would they object to? Because they do.
- 14:27That's what teachers unions do.
- 14:28That's what they did during COVID. That's how they throw around their power.
- 14:32What could they object to as far as taking this in en masse?
- 14:39Well, they don't want to be told how to do something.
- 14:43So they're invested in the status quo because that's how they know to incrementally make gains each year in salary,
- 14:51power, more days off, and everything else.
- 14:53So we have in front of us,
- 14:56and I don't believe it, by the way, that the differences are that great state by state.
- 15:00What, in Mississippi,
- 15:01they eat some particular food in New York? They eat something different?
- 15:04They can't do the same things?
- 15:05Of course they can.
- 15:07Of course they can replicate this.
- 15:09In Mississippi,
- 15:09they're only spending about $14,500 per student.
- 15:12New York City, it's about $44,000 per student.
- 15:15Why not do this? So here's what this podcast is all about.
- 15:20We're trying to make America
- 15:23Smart again.
- 15:24The way to do that, parental rights and school choice.
- 15:29Long term,
- 15:30we ought to be trying to win state by state to do exactly what they do in Mississippi.
- 15:36Show me anyone else that's getting these results. Do they want to challenge the results?
- 15:41We need to draw them into a great debate. The teachers unions,
- 15:44the NEA,
- 15:46the AFT with Randy Weingarten.
- 15:49Can they debate this? Do they really want to rain on the parade?
- 15:54They wouldn't want to debate someone like that.
- 15:57She's winning on this. You heard what her group is with the Excel Ed.
- 16:00You see what they're about.
- 16:02They believe every child, minority kids, white kids, it doesn't matter, has the capacity to do these things.
- 16:09And they are going to work step by step to make that happen.
- 16:13What is happening in America?
- 16:16Well, the teachers unions are about one thing,
- 16:19the adults,
- 16:20the teachers.
- 16:21That's all that they are about.
- 16:23And sometimes they're actually the enemy of progress.
- 16:27That's the way that I see it. It's that simple.
- 16:29And we need to pull it now with the big, beautiful bill and school choice coming in. That may help.
- 16:34But remember,
- 16:35they have failed before.
- 16:37They'll fail again.
- 16:38And they're a monopoly.
- 16:39So we have to go state by state in addition to freeing kids up by school choice money.
- 16:45We have to go state by state to take this apart,
- 16:49to take it on.
- 16:51That means you have to have people running on this for governor and things of that nature in states.
- 16:57I mean,
- 16:58what's going on in America?
- 17:01It's called a miracle.
- 17:03You know what that word means?
- 17:04Shouldn't everybody in the world?
- 17:06Well, we're grabbing onto it,
- 17:08and we're going to bring these people back again and again and again to push this.
- 17:12So again,
- 17:13the Mississippi miracle in your state might be more inspirational.
- 17:18In the short term,
- 17:19we want to get you out of the
- 17:21We want to get you out of these failing schools and go to the school of your choice.
- 17:25Parental rights.
- 17:26Make American kids smart again.
- 17:29They are not going to be smart again in these failing schools.
- 17:33To close,
- 17:35headline recent Wall Street Journal,
- 17:36yes,
- 17:38children really are getting dumber.
- 17:39Let's use that word. They're getting dumber.
- 17:41The author, Elisa Finley,
- 17:43says COVID shutdowns, great inflation, and now AI are degrading the quality of American education.
- 17:50Ah,
- 17:51come on now.
- 17:52That's ridiculous.
- 17:54She writes, listening to my seven-year-old nephew
- 17:56sounding out words last week, a dark thought occurred.
- 17:59How long before the three R's become as outdated among young people as Thomas's guide maps?
- 18:07As machines get smarter,
- 18:08kids are getting dumber.
- 18:10Yeah, this is a five-alarm fire.
- 18:12What you're witnessing is what I'm seeing.
- 18:16And Mississippi said no.
- 18:18And they pushed back.
- 18:19And that's what we ought to be doing.
- 18:21That's a little bit more long-term, but take a couple years.
- 18:24In the short-term,
- 18:25we need today to free up parents and their kids from this machine run by the teachers'
- 18:32unions.
- 18:32They are the enemy of progress here,
- 18:35up and down the line.
- 18:36They can come on the show.
- 18:38They can come on my radio show. They can come on anytime. They can debate me anywhere in America,
- 18:42anywhere in the world, for that matter.
- 18:44All right, if you have a comment on this miracle,
- 18:47if you hear this and want to know more about it or you challenge it,
- 18:50whatever it might be.
- 18:51You can always email me.
- 18:53Dom show D O M S H O W at AOL.com.
- 18:57Dom show at AOL.com.
- 19:00We'll continue next week.
- 19:03New York has now gotten rid of what is called the regents test.
- 19:08Meaning no longer do you have to be proficient to graduate from New York high schools in reading or math.
- 19:16They said instead,
- 19:18you ought to be able to do things that you know,
- 19:20like a portfolio.
- 19:21I think they're going to model Philadelphia. Do you know that in Philadelphia where I am?
- 19:26They let you pass if you do things like sit there in a room and watch a video on ladder safety.
- 19:34Yeah, they'll give you a certificate.
- 19:36And apparently by law,
- 19:37that allows you to graduate high school.
- 19:40Come on, Dom, you got to be making okay anytime,
- 19:43anywhere the challenge.
- 19:44And I'll give you more of that next week because that's where New York is going now. That regions used to sound so regal.
- 19:52You had to pass or there was going to be a lot of remediation.
- 19:55Now,
- 19:56no reason to pass.
- 19:58Why not if we just shut down schools all but for the top 5% of students?
- 20:02Let the rest just go and worry about ladders.
- 20:06All right.
- 20:07We got a new website,
- 20:09too,
- 20:09that you can check out.
- 20:10Old school,
- 20:11new school,
- 20:12next school.
- 20:13A lot more next week.
- 20:14Be engaged.
- 20:16Help is on the way.
- 20:17That's what this podcast is about.
- 20:19Please tell people about it.
- 20:20Old School,
- 20:21New School,
- 20:22Next School. Old School,
- 20:23New School, Next School with Dom Giordano is a presentation of Giordano Productions LLC.
- 20:29Copyright 2026.
- 20:31All rights reserved.