Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #No.46🎙️ Public Inquiry - Week 1 in Review Fri 17th April 2026
Transcript
- 0:05Well, hello again, and here we are at the end of the first week
- 0:09of the not so public
- 0:11public inquiry.
- 0:13For those of you new to the podcast, have a listen to the
- 0:17very first podcast to learn about our campaign. To those of
- 0:21you familiar with the podcast and who are just catching up, I
- 0:25suggest starting at podcast number 41 entitled public
- 0:29inquiry begins. What happens next?
- 0:33Looking back over the past few days,
- 0:37I'll try to pull together some of the key thoughts and moments
- 0:42in no particular order, though, the ones drawing the most
- 0:45attention do sit closer to the top. I suppose the top of the
- 0:51list is cyanide in that it is removed, but not gone.
- 0:57There are references still in the planning documents,
- 1:01new draft conditions were circulated by dfi, seemingly
- 1:06with input from Mr. Beatty, counsel for dalradian,
- 1:10suggesting a rather cosy cohort at work in producing a revised
- 1:13set of conditions.
- 1:15Though the extent of that involvement remains unclear,
- 1:20leading us to the conclusion that cyanide could still be used
- 1:24for processing off site in Northern Ireland,
- 1:29or, for that matter, in the Republic of Ireland.
- 1:34Bottom line, it's still not a closed issue, more like it's
- 1:40been parked, yet keeps it reappearing through the back
- 1:44door next up processing. Where is it actually happening?
- 1:50There's no clear answer to this. They are talking about
- 1:54transporting 60 tonnes per day of toxic slop. There are
- 1:58suggestions this could go to the existing plant at Kavanagh. Oh,
- 2:06by the way, we have it on good authority that galantas, the
- 2:10licence holders of Kavanagh, have abandoned the mine and may
- 2:13now be found instead, approximately 55 kilometres
- 2:18south east of the coastal city of La Sirena in Chile, where
- 2:21they've acquired 100% ownership interest in the anda cola ora
- 2:26Gold Project. Good luck to anyone endeavouring to get them
- 2:30to fulfil their obligations to close the mine and maintain the
- 2:33site in perpetuity. I wonder when the acid mine drainage will
- 2:38force its way to the surface and into the surrounding water
- 2:41table. And just to remind you, this is less than three miles
- 2:45from the town of OMA, downstream of the mine. Anyways, to get
- 2:51back on topic, I guess this whole issue has left us,
- 2:54certainly with a lack of clarity and definitely with a lack of
- 2:57trust. So as I mentioned during the week, there is no completed
- 3:02habitats regulation assessment, but it didn't seem to matter,
- 3:06because the inquiry is proceeding anyways, there was
- 3:09strong pushback against the submission. I wondered, how
- 3:13would the public be able to fully assess the impacts of the
- 3:16proposed mine without having the full
- 3:18environmental picture?
- 3:19It doesn't exactly inspire confidence.
- 3:25Much in evidence over the three days was the clear frustration
- 3:29from third parties. Late submissions of new information
- 3:33prompted repeated complaints. The sheer scale, volume and
- 3:38complexity of the documentation would challenge even a
- 3:42professional forensic auditor trying to untangle what feels
- 3:46like a deliberately complex web. Naturally, this leads to ongoing
- 3:52tension arguments and delays, which impacted the momentum of
- 3:56the inquiry. For one rather horrible moment during the week,
- 4:00I had a vision of myself sitting here for the rest of my life,
- 4:04frozen in some kind of Kafkaesque drama where the
- 4:07commissioners questions loop endlessly, circling back on
- 4:11themselves, quietly trapping us there, ad infinitum. As far as I
- 4:17can establish, these three days alone have created one and a
- 4:21half more days of work, which will be tacked on at the end.
- 4:26Fairness is not what comes first to mind, but as a friend
- 4:31explained to me, when you're up against big business, it's
- 4:34rarely a level playing field. Another contentious area is to
- 4:40do with access and transparency,
- 4:43no remote access to proceedings,
- 4:45no recordings, no transcript.
- 4:47I can't tell you how angry
- 4:49that makes me feel. As I witnessed three families this
- 4:52week who wanted to participate in real time but had to leave
- 4:56because of other obligations, and yet they are all stay.
- 5:00Holders. These impediments, along with the not easily
- 5:04accessed, heavy documentation meant that participation was
- 5:08limited to one being physically present and two to be ably
- 5:13resourced. Meh, the cross border dimension keeps bubbling up with
- 5:18questions around the environmental impacts far beyond
- 5:22Northern Ireland, because,
- 5:24as we all know, pollution,
- 5:27either water or airborne, does not stop at the border. There is
- 5:31a suggestion that consultation gaps exist, adding yet another
- 5:36layer of
- 5:36jurisdictional complexity and accountability
- 5:41our community representation
- 5:43was strong, though at times clearly strained.
- 5:47With the inquiry described as both farcical and controversial,
- 5:52there's a genuine sense that the process is difficult to engage
- 5:55with, and perhaps designed in a way that creates maximum
- 5:59obstruction. Again and again, we see the project being framed as
- 6:03an economic opportunity, much of which will leave these shores.
- 6:09We continue to offer the counter narrative that what remains is
- 6:13risk and long term liability, exposing the underlying tension
- 6:19between short term gain and long term consequences. There was a
- 6:25good turnout on the first day, with over 100 in attendance and
- 6:29a visible presence of land protectors outside the venue.
- 6:33The message was clear, no toxic mining and yes to life,
- 6:38reinforcing our values of identity and place, understand
- 6:42for the air we breathe, the water we drink, and the well
- 6:45being of all, both now and for future generations.
- 6:49So where does week one leave us?
- 6:53I think the tone being set for the inquiry lies somewhere
- 6:56between complex, contested and far from straightforward. Have
- 7:00to add in that as a third party,
- 7:03sometimes we felt bullied,
- 7:05manipulated and corralled.
- 7:07I would like to be persuaded
- 7:08that this is not the case.
- 7:11Always approaching life as a glass half full,
- 7:16to quote Dr Amy Strecker, there's a lack of transparency,
- 7:20lack of variety and lack of respect for me, it is perhaps
- 7:26the strangest expression of democracy I have ever
- 7:28experienced. See you all on Monday, you.