Latest / The KAJ Masterclass LIVE / Analyzing Geopolitical Turbulence: Biden, Blinken, Israel, Hamas & Ukraine With Irina Tsukerman
Transcript
- 0:19Welcome to this fresh episode of The World According to Irina
- 0:23Superman, our very special series on global politics on the
- 0:27KJJ Master class slide Irina Superman as you can see her on
- 0:31the screen. She is a US based national
- 0:33security and human rights lawyer as well as a renowned
- 0:36geopolitical analyst. Writings and commentary have
- 0:40appeared in diverse US and international media and have
- 0:43been translated to over a dozen languages every fortnight in the
- 0:47world according to Irena Zuckerman.
- 0:49We traverse the geopolitical landscape and delve into
- 0:53pressing international issues and gain insight from Irena's
- 0:56expert perspective. And today we will be talking
- 0:59about a lot of things with her. Welcome to the show once again,
- 1:04Irina. Thank you.
- 1:06Glad to be here. Thank you, Thank you and it's
- 1:10nice always talking to you, you know and thank you viewers for
- 1:14all the love that we have shown to this special series and that
- 1:18motivates us to bring much more deep insights, you know, on the
- 1:22geopolitical situation that we are facing today.
- 1:25So several big topics today. One, let us first get to the big
- 1:30topic arena that is the Blinken strips to Israel and see CIA
- 1:36chief Bill Burns also trip to the Middle East.
- 1:39How do you see? And at the other side, Saudi
- 1:42defense minister, he was in the US.
- 1:44How do you see all these strips? And what can the world, you
- 1:48know, especially someone sitting in India, can make sense of what
- 1:51this is all about? Well, I'll explain what the
- 1:56troops were about, then I'll explain why they were a complete
- 1:59failure and the and what should have been said instead.
- 2:04Burns's people was slightly better than blinking because
- 2:09they were focused on more logistical issues of security
- 2:12cooperation given the whole situation with the war and the
- 2:17increasing number of proxies entering the the field.
- 2:21At the end of the day, however, Burns is not.
- 2:23A decision maker, he can only adjust the strategy of
- 2:28intelligence gathering, which up until now has been a failure on
- 2:32US side as much as on Israel's side, for the reason that US has
- 2:37actually stopped the monitoring of Hamas for the past several
- 2:42years. Having decided that Hamas is a
- 2:45local issue, that it presents no direct.
- 2:49No direct danger to the United States and essentially it would
- 2:54be a waste of resources to focus on it, which is surprising
- 2:57because the the agency has a very big personnel, it has over
- 3:03100,000 employers and you would think that at least a small
- 3:07group could be dedicated to to Hamas.
- 3:10But apparently that was not the case.
- 3:12So now there's an effort to to fix the gap, to coordinate
- 3:17actions, to coordinate responses, and it's difficult to
- 3:21do in the fog of war, but that sort of visit is to be expected
- 3:26and should probably have happened a lot sooner.
- 3:30In terms of blinking, however, that was a a complete failure.
- 3:34He has been playing shuttle diplomacy between Israel and
- 3:37various Middle Eastern states. And the one hand administration
- 3:41claims victories in the sense of getting Israel to agree to a
- 3:46number of humanitarian gestures. And even now, Israel stated it
- 3:51is considering short humanitarian pauses.
- 3:54It has allowed exit, exit of Palestinian refugees to
- 4:01humanitarian corridors in the South and there's also been a
- 4:06corridor for foreign nationals. Leaving Gaza and entering Egypt
- 4:12for treatment and now the latest is that there's been an
- 4:15arrangement with Turkey and Egypt to transport cancer
- 4:21patients from the hospital in Egypt to Turkey.
- 4:27Israel has also allowed Jordan to bring.
- 4:32To AirDrop, humanitarian aid and the Emiratis are also now
- 4:37providing medical treatment, building a hospital inside Gaza.
- 4:42So from that sense, the administration can claim credit
- 4:46for going a very long way to provide civilians in Gaza with
- 4:51assorted forms of humanitarian relief.
- 4:54But they have failed to secure the release of hostages,
- 4:57according to Qatar, which has been.
- 4:59And intermediary in the process. There would need to be a
- 5:02ceasefire of some sort for the hostages to be released.
- 5:06Israel, on the other hand, demands that the hostages to be
- 5:08released before there was any comprehensive stop to
- 5:12hostilities. Israel has gone quite far into
- 5:15Gaza. It has divided the area by half.
- 5:19It has destroyed a number of tunnels and thousands of
- 5:24terrorists belonging to Hamas. It has still the number of
- 5:27commanders. But so far has failed to secure
- 5:32some of its leading targets, such as Yahya Sinbar and
- 5:35Muhammad Dave, who are now to be found.
- 5:40It even encouraged. It even encouraged the locals to
- 5:45try to kill them in order to save civilian lives.
- 5:49It is approaching the Shifa hospital where Hamas has its
- 5:54headquarters. And it has surrounded Gaza City.
- 5:59So from a territorial perspective it has made a lot of
- 6:01progress. But there seems to be no end to
- 6:03hostilities. And Lincoln has attempted to
- 6:07persuade Israel to put a stop to all of this, to allow the
- 6:10securing the release of the hostages, to provide for the
- 6:16communitarian relief, and to also get other Arab states on
- 6:22board. But so far with no success.
- 6:25Israel does not believe it serves its military and security
- 6:28agenda to put a stop. Furthermore, there's been
- 6:33there's been evidence that from the West Bank, Judea and some
- 6:37areas it's known in Israel, the areas under the Palestinian
- 6:42Authority control, there is a potential effort to replicate
- 6:47the Hamas attack with at least 1000 trained terrorists looking
- 6:52to breach. The to breach the borders to
- 6:58breach them divisions and enter Israel proper.
- 7:04So has asked asked the army to prepare for that.
- 7:10But Blinken now explain the reason why Blinken has failed to
- 7:15get attention from anybody with Israel.
- 7:17It's pretty obvious that they view any stop to to combat.
- 7:23As an opportunity for homes, for Hamas to rearm and reload, as
- 7:26every proxy, every Iranian and Muslim Brotherhood proxy in the
- 7:30region has done during conflicts, even once unrelated
- 7:34to Israel, any humanitarian poses essentially an invitation
- 7:39for the fighters to secure additional weapons aid and to
- 7:47regroup. But the Arab states have.
- 7:51Have been pushing for the ceasefire as a condition to any
- 7:54sort of expansion of diplomatic efforts.
- 7:58The reality, however, is that blinking could not put anything
- 8:04to the table from the diplomatic perspective.
- 8:06He has promised on behalf of President Biden to push for A2
- 8:12state solution, but that sort of discussion is clearly premature
- 8:17during this while the fighting is still ongoing.
- 8:20And while the situation is unresolved, the transition plan
- 8:24that Israel discusses may include potential long term
- 8:29control of Israeli silver. Gaza, which would be on the one
- 8:33hand unacceptable to the Arab states, on the other hand
- 8:36expensive and difficult for Israel and possibly not actually
- 8:40resolve anything. Because at the end of the day,
- 8:43the war is as much political and ideological as it is military
- 8:47and. The bigger but the biggest
- 8:49central issue to all of this is not the Palestinian state, which
- 8:52by the way, has been rejected by Palestinian governments in much
- 8:57more peaceful times than now. The biggest issue is that
- 9:01nobody's talking about the elephant in the room, which is
- 9:03Iran, and the fact that Iran is calling the shots not only on
- 9:07Hamas hostilities, but on Houthis, who had been firing
- 9:12missiles at Israel, and the US, who have been attacking Saudi
- 9:15Arabia multiple times. And Iraqi and Syrian militias,
- 9:20which have attacked the US bases in their respective countries
- 9:26for over 40 Times Now, injuring in many cases severely, at least
- 9:3145 members of the US military until the start of Iran is
- 9:38actually brought. And discussed.
- 9:43I don't really see how anyone in the Arab world will take this
- 9:48shuttle diplomacy effort seriously.
- 9:50Their security and economic interests are simply not being
- 9:53met by anything Blinking is bringing to the table.
- 10:00Absolutely, absolutely. From our outsiders perspective,
- 10:04what do we understand from this? What does the US want?
- 10:09We all are hearing many voices, and US and Israel, you know,
- 10:14after Bidens visit all this, if their communication is so good,
- 10:18why does the US have to travel again and again to Israel and to
- 10:23other nations around it? Is it such a difficult part of
- 10:28them to lay down something concrete and move forward?
- 10:32Or is it just much more of optics posturing and giving a
- 10:37chance for other countries? Also, you know that OK, you keep
- 10:41on making some noises. We are with you, Let Israel do
- 10:45what it wants, let the way it wants to.
- 10:47But actually is it moving towards any concrete solution to
- 10:52this issue. Thus the world is fearing it
- 10:55might lead to escalation of this crisis.
- 10:58But we nobody is getting a clear picture where this goal was is
- 11:03what does us want Israel. We know it is a tough situation,
- 11:07tough posturing at the moment, but the humanitarian crisis,
- 11:10more than 10,000 people dead, a lot of, you know, even among the
- 11:15European Union there is there have been now several voices out
- 11:18there. How do we understand in terms of
- 11:21solution? The world wants to see a
- 11:23solution, not a stalemate. Well, the problem is this
- 11:31administration has no strategy. For settling the conflict, they
- 11:35can't force Israel to to drop the issue before the military
- 11:41goals achieved. And the military goals are not
- 11:43unreasonable even President Biden that he supports the ideal
- 11:47of relieving Hamas of its control over Gaza.
- 11:51Secretary Blinken today described the way Hamas holds
- 11:56uses civilians as human Shields. He went into great detail
- 12:00discussing why there's so many civilian casualties.
- 12:03Which are unavoidable because Hamas has completely infiltrated
- 12:07every civilian institution. And I think there is.
- 12:13There is first of all a split within the administration as to
- 12:17what to do, and 2nd, a very awkward effort to balance
- 12:21different interests between allowing Israel to secure its
- 12:26its borders from terrorism and to put an end to Hamas
- 12:30stronghold. And then to respond to all the
- 12:32critics pushing for a ceasefire, and there's a lot of them,
- 12:35including in the United States, there have been mass rallies
- 12:39from all sorts of people. Some of them are pro Hamas
- 12:43voices and some of them are assorted human rights activists
- 12:46who may be well informed, but they're loud, they're vocal and
- 12:49they're very visible. And of course, there's some
- 12:53pressure from Europe and from around the world as well.
- 12:56There is an effort to continue to shield Iran from
- 12:59accountability and This is why we haven't seen any concrete
- 13:03military response to all the regional escalations.
- 13:07But we have seen increasing number of visible deterrence,
- 13:12such as the nuclear submarine that has just been transferred
- 13:15to the Middle East. There's a concern about China.
- 13:18The President Biden is preparing for the meeting with Jinping and
- 13:24trying to settle. Some of the tensions, just as
- 13:27China is apparently getting more involved in the Middle East in a
- 13:31in a more visible way, so there is a lot going on.
- 13:35And of course the Arab states have not been quite either.
- 13:38There's been an Max mass exodus of diplomats from a number of
- 13:44countries from Israel, and the Israeli diplomats have also been
- 13:49kicked out of a couple of places and Israel has also had to
- 13:53withdraw. And a number of ambassadors for
- 13:56security reasons from several countries.
- 13:59So there's been a lot of political controversy that the
- 14:02administration is trying to navigate.
- 14:04And the problem is it's trying to please too many interests
- 14:08with no real real next step vision of where it's all going.
- 14:15There's no plan, no plan for the transition from Hamas rule to
- 14:19something else. No plan to put an end to the
- 14:22financial support for Hamas from sources outside the Western
- 14:27world. No plan to deal to deal with the
- 14:32with the Arab states over the growing internal polarization
- 14:37over the issue. The administration is also
- 14:39suffering from political problems.
- 14:41Recent polls are showing a split in the Democrat fold over the
- 14:46Israel Hamas war. With the many of the Muslim and
- 14:49Arab constituents increasingly dissatisfied with the
- 14:53administration and and because of because they see that there
- 14:58there's insufficient support for the Palestinian 'cause as they
- 15:02claim it, the Jewish constituents are not happy with
- 15:04the response for the opposite region and so now and to impress
- 15:09and former President Trump. Appears to be gaining support in
- 15:12five key swing states. So we see both a policy and a
- 15:16political problem, and we see a very academic approach to all of
- 15:20that. There are no concrete deals
- 15:22being brokered. There are no political, there's
- 15:25no talk of political leveraging of any interest in order to gain
- 15:30some sort of a concrete solution.
- 15:33And the reason why there is no solution is because there are no
- 15:36proposals, there's no vision. And nobody really knows what to
- 15:40do. Everything we've seen so far is
- 15:42completely reactionary. Absolutely, absolutely.
- 15:47At least. Even if they may have something
- 15:49in their minds, it is not getting reflected at IS in this
- 15:53part of the world. We are not trying understanding
- 15:56what exactly is happening and is in this state.
- 15:59Of right, right, right. So it is not as one confusion.
- 16:07We are still trying to make sense of that.
- 16:09Let's move on to the Ukraine thing.
- 16:10You know, in the economics article they are criticizing
- 16:14Ukraine strategy and corruption and the big part is rumors about
- 16:20US pressure to give up territory to Russia.
- 16:22Is it about one more confusion coming on or the US?
- 16:27What should we make out of that? It is a rumor, but you would
- 16:30know better. You have got great insights and
- 16:32information about all those things.
- 16:34So help us understand what is happening to Ukraine, what what
- 16:39one might remain make out of the Economist article and what can
- 16:43one make out of what is happening in the Ukraine Russia
- 16:46war? So, so the US is facing a number
- 16:52of challenges. The primary challenge is that
- 16:55there's a shortage of professionals capable of of
- 16:58navigating between multiple simultaneous crises.
- 17:01And by the way, most of these crises have the same set of
- 17:04actors who are involved in in whatever capacity.
- 17:11So it's not like we have completely independent things
- 17:15happening at the same time. They're not completely
- 17:17independent, they are related, but we have a shortage of
- 17:19trained personnel. A lot of the foreign policy
- 17:22people in the Biden administrations come from very
- 17:25theoretical backgrounds and they're not equipped to handle
- 17:28the political processes for dealing with these issues and
- 17:31that. So it's not that they're
- 17:33becoming a complete distraction. Nobody has forgotten that
- 17:36Ukraine, the deeper in Ukraine, is still ongoing and needs to be
- 17:40dealt with in the result. But there's a very strong fear
- 17:46of immediate escalation in the Middle East.
- 17:49Where there's a number of U.S. troops physically stationed,
- 17:53unlike Ukraine, where they're only press, whether political
- 17:57personnel, occasional present in advisory capacity, but no direct
- 18:02US environment whatsoever. So it's not an issue of
- 18:05distraction, it's an issue of prioritizing more immediate and
- 18:09direct conflict where US is more directly involved and where
- 18:14there is a more immediate concern about the expansion of
- 18:18conflict. Russia has been far more careful
- 18:21about pushing for its agenda more slowly through proxies in
- 18:26various parts of Europe, through political and the asymmetrical
- 18:31warfare, and less so also for logistical reasons.
- 18:35It cannot start major wars directly everywhere because it
- 18:40has a shortage of personnel and most of its attention has been
- 18:44directed towards Ukraine at the moment.
- 18:46So while there is a. A fear that Russia will escalate
- 18:51and push its agenda over time. It's not as immediate as what
- 18:55we're seeing in the Middle East where a number of proxies are
- 18:59active simultaneously. There is another issue which is
- 19:03that the White House cannot really control Congress and it
- 19:07has well, it has some leverage. It does not necessarily knows
- 19:11know how to use it wisely. It's it's strategic proposals
- 19:15for dealing with the Ukraine aid have been.
- 19:19Shall shall we say met with scepticism, first of all due to
- 19:23initial failure to articulate concrete objectives and concrete
- 19:26strategies and to provide weapons in in advance, and not
- 19:31providing public discussion of what is necessary and for what
- 19:35purpose. So now we are facing a backlash
- 19:39from the Republicans in Congress who are fighting over budget,
- 19:43who've prioritised cutting Ukraine aid over over all the
- 19:47other possible. Expenditures who could, which
- 19:51could be, probably should be cut.
- 19:54And it's become a political football between parties which
- 19:57and national security issues should never be.
- 20:00But we're operating in a very polarized climate with very poor
- 20:03communication and poor policy on both sides, so on on the part of
- 20:09the Democrats, there's not a concrete vision because they're
- 20:12also double dealing with Russia. They're also buying.
- 20:16Metals from Russia, expanding their exports, trying to deal
- 20:20with Russia and China and climate change this and that.
- 20:23Not really fully going on all in on economic and financial level,
- 20:29and certainly not providing any concrete road map for enforcing
- 20:34A victorious military strategy with and for Ukraine.
- 20:38The Republicans, on the other hand, I'm making it seem like
- 20:42none of it is a big deal, does not concern the United States
- 20:45and exaggerating the the budget issue a great deal.
- 20:51Is this also a fight over whether Ukraine aid should be
- 20:55connected to Israel? And now there's a problem even
- 20:57with Israel aid, which is significantly less because
- 21:01Israel needs fewer weapons. It is.
- 21:03It is already well equipped, but there are certain things that it
- 21:06needs for continuing to to use the weapons that it has, the
- 21:12Iron Dome and so forth. But they have tried to tie it to
- 21:17the reduction of budget on the IRS, which is completely
- 21:20unnecessary. Those could be separate bills in
- 21:23the House has a Republican majority and none of those bills
- 21:28will go through Senate. So we are at the stalemate.
- 21:31They refuse. The Republicans are refusing to
- 21:35negotiate with the Democrats. The border issue, which is has
- 21:39also been tied into all this, has been a disaster because it
- 21:42does not really deal with border security so much as expanding
- 21:47the processing power of of the migrants entering through the
- 21:50southern border. So there's now come, come
- 21:53address either Republican for that matter, growing Democratic
- 21:57concerns. So all of these political issues
- 22:00are just not being well dealt with by anybody in this
- 22:03equation. There's simply is a political
- 22:06morass with absolutely no progress whatsoever.
- 22:12Absolutely, Absolutely. All this infighting is going to
- 22:16impact Israel, Gaza, Ukraine, Taiwan, and you know, so we
- 22:20don't know what's going to happen to all these situations.
- 22:25It's very concerning as well, because some of the issues that
- 22:28The Economist pointed out points to mistakes within the Ukrainian
- 22:33governance that are not being well dealt with.
- 22:36There's a concern of a recent issue involving the fact that a
- 22:40journal who wrote this article has been reprimanded for
- 22:43pointing out that the war is at a stalemate.
- 22:46President Zeloski disagrees with this characterization and views
- 22:50views this as a defeatist commentary that will likely
- 22:54undermine support. Others criticise that the overly
- 23:01optimistic PR strategy by Ukrainian lobbyists, which has
- 23:04created a false impression that Ukraine does not in fact really
- 23:08need a lot of American help and that we are wasting resources by
- 23:12continuing to give money. So there's been this discrepancy
- 23:16that needs to be resolved, there needs to be a a unified strategy
- 23:20from Ukraine, and right now is not the time to play politics,
- 23:25right? Right, good enough.
- 23:29How do we what do we make out of this?
- 23:31Lots of pro Hamas rallies around the world and increasing
- 23:36anti-Semitism. You know how to semitism.
- 23:39How do we deal with this? What can people understand about
- 23:43these things? You know, because Hamas is a
- 23:46totally different thing. anti-Semitism on the rise is
- 23:50also very alarming. What should how should people
- 23:53look at it? Are we seeing a much more
- 23:56polarization in the coming days? All through the world, is there
- 24:00chance for more peace or is it going to be a difficult world
- 24:04going forward? Well, first of all, I don't
- 24:10think there's an increase in in anti-Semitism.
- 24:13I think there's an increase in in public expression of
- 24:16anti-Semitism. In other words, people who
- 24:18previously had reasons to stay quiet now feel unencumbered by
- 24:24social restraints to come out and publicly say it.
- 24:30Sometimes it's due to the way their governments behave and not
- 24:33take the serious issues. Sometimes it's because they feel
- 24:36that their numbers collectively have grown sufficient and their
- 24:39political and social influence is sufficient.
- 24:42And sometimes because they feel that Israel is in a weak
- 24:45position, US is polarized, Europe does not have a unified
- 24:49position on anything. And so they feel empowered to
- 24:53come out much more strongly and to take take action in the way
- 24:56that they will not have previously in majors in big
- 25:00cities. In the US, for instance, there
- 25:02has been a problem with law and order even before the war.
- 25:05There has been a rise in crime due to the to the policies in
- 25:09those cities. None of that has gone away once
- 25:12the war started, so this general attitude that has allowed crime
- 25:17to proliferate is now giving room for political expressions
- 25:22and politically motivated crimes to take place as well.
- 25:27The other issue is that over decades there's been cultivation
- 25:32of radical views in through various institutions in the US
- 25:36and as well as a congregation of politically radical pro Islamist
- 25:41sympathizers who have grown up listening to that sort of
- 25:46rhetoric in their religious institutions, family circles and
- 25:51so forth. And there's been no effort to
- 25:54understand that ideology on either government or academic
- 25:58level. There has been essentially a
- 26:02disinterest in it. And I think this leaves the West
- 26:05completely unprepared to confront the reality of these
- 26:08worldviews and ideologies once they become prevalent and
- 26:13publicly active. We have seen these
- 26:15manifestations before during Women's March and some of these
- 26:20we've seen expressions of this anti-Semitic conduct in
- 26:23Congress. All of that has encouraged the
- 26:26sort of activity on the street. Even if Rashida Clay today is
- 26:30censored by the House, which she was, it doesn't.
- 26:33She's already been in Congress for for three terms, which has
- 26:37allowed her to grow her audience to kind of create a sense of
- 26:45political impunity. And so whoever is already
- 26:48radicalized now feels more confident in coming out in
- 26:51greater numbers, and others who are critical of such views now
- 26:54feel less powerful, less equipped to confront and to
- 26:58reject those sorts of ideologies.
- 27:00So on the one hand, we have a growing power of hate and
- 27:04bigotry and fanaticism motivated groups.
- 27:07On the other hand, less equipment, less backing, less
- 27:12law enforcement interest for whoever is opposed to such
- 27:18views, whether in Muslim communities or outside of them.
- 27:21So we are seeing the the power dynamic shift which encourages
- 27:26these voices. Right, right from here.
- 27:29Now let's move to the Pacific Islands Forum and Australian
- 27:34PM's trip to China. What do you see?
- 27:37Ongoing Pacific Island Forum for Several top leaders are not
- 27:42attending it for whatever home issues they have.
- 27:45And Australia's Prime Minister in the meantime, Visit to China
- 27:49is it, you know, Australia? China.
- 27:51China ties are finally defrosting.
- 27:53First visit. You went to China by an
- 27:56Australian leader in seven years.
- 27:58How do you see all this forum is Pacific Iron Forum is is is
- 28:02going to be actually impactful this time?
- 28:05And what about what do you, what is your understanding of the
- 28:08Australian PM's trip to China? I think I, I I think it's a very
- 28:14strong signal strategic communication when the head of
- 28:18state is goes to to a country and then doesn't when there's a
- 28:23number of high level representatives who fail to
- 28:26appear at a major gathering. When, for instance, recently
- 28:30President Biden chose not to attend Asian Forum and chose to
- 28:34send the Vice President instead, even though it was still a high
- 28:38level visit, it sent a signal that it's not a priority.
- 28:41Similarly, the leaders who are not attending this forum are
- 28:44saying that this garden is not a priority and the optics are that
- 28:51the real story is happening with the Australian Prime Minister's
- 28:54visit to China and therefore the Pacific Forum, which would
- 28:57probably not normally confront issues involving China, is
- 29:02taking a back seat. Maybe it's not contradicting the
- 29:05agenda completely, not reversing its course, but it's certainly
- 29:09being seen as less important. This is not the main thrust of
- 29:13the policy right now and therefore I'm not sure what kind
- 29:17of impact it is to have when only mostly lower level
- 29:23officials are attending and this major trip has just happened.
- 29:28I think I think we can expect a very drawn down, muted
- 29:35discussion with very few concrete resolutions and
- 29:38policies for the future. But we can probably try.
- 29:42They will. There's a probably an effort to
- 29:45gather some sort of a unified response, some commitments to
- 29:49some, you know, practical cooperation measures among the
- 29:53members towards economic, you know, and security cooperation
- 29:59of some sort. But again, it will not carry as
- 30:02much weight in terms of public policy as the trip to China.
- 30:06Now what do I make from the trip itself?
- 30:09To me, it shows a radical shift in Australia's direction,
- 30:13probably following the parallel optics of what is happening in
- 30:17the United States as President Biden is preparing for the visit
- 30:22with the Xi Jinping in San Francisco in the near future.
- 30:27And the government in Australia has previously dedicated a
- 30:33strong response claiming that they are committed to
- 30:36confronting and countering China and and so on and so forth.
- 30:40But actions speak loudly louder than words.
- 30:44China has so far not backed away from any of its meddling
- 30:48activities in Australia and and there hasn't been any
- 30:51intermediate steps between the two countries.
- 30:54So this, this high level visit out of nowhere without trust
- 30:58building measures to me smacks of kind of appeasement and
- 31:02desperation on the part of that particular portion of the
- 31:07Australian government, which by the way, I think all, all of it
- 31:11necessarily approves of everything that happens.
- 31:15Just like in the United States, institutions, sometimes an
- 31:19agency, sometimes have parallel policies.
- 31:22I believe that this political step does not necessarily align
- 31:26with everyone's vision in Australia.
- 31:28But I do think that they believe that because China is an
- 31:34economically difficult situation and because there are some
- 31:38narrow issues which could be discussed, China will be more
- 31:45likely to at least not escalate or agree to some sort of
- 31:50establishing communications and mechanisms for waiting for the
- 31:54problems in the future. It doesn't mean that they will
- 31:57necessarily resolve all their problems immediately means they
- 32:01agreed to continue negotiating and to find to look for
- 32:04diplomatic solutions to differences personal.
- 32:07I don't buy any of it. To put it blind.
- 32:10Bluntly, China has been very consistent with this course of
- 32:13action and it uses these diplomatic pauses much as much
- 32:20as Hamas has uses humanitarian would use humanitarian process
- 32:24to regroup. It is buying time by engaging in
- 32:28this diplomatic a subterfuge precisely to to get concessions
- 32:34from Australia without necessarily making any major
- 32:39policy concessions on its own. In other words, China is not
- 32:44going to change any of its damaging behaviour.
- 32:47It can agree to some business deals, to some new mechanisms,
- 32:52but none of it will change these old things that will continue as
- 32:56they are. So actually I think they will
- 32:59see this visit as a sign of weakness because it has been
- 33:06granted to them. You have a Prime Minister
- 33:09travelling to them and asking for a meeting without any
- 33:15process in between that would prepare grant for such a visit.
- 33:18So I I really don't think it was well handled at all.
- 33:22And I think it will cause a great deal of damage to
- 33:24Australia's future efforts to blunt China's influence, even if
- 33:29all other institutions are trying to do exactly what I
- 33:32described. This one big visible step for
- 33:35China from China's perspective is a sign of of capitulation in
- 33:41some way, political capitulation to China's position.
- 33:44They don't view these events in the same way as Westerners do.
- 33:48For Westerners, a high level meeting is a sign of
- 33:51partnership. For China, it's a sign of power
- 33:54play. They got what they wanted.
- 33:57OK, for optics purpose China has got lots of, you know, good
- 34:01photographs images. And you know, while while they
- 34:05send out a much more diplomatic sort of you know that China is
- 34:10approachable, China people, countries can do business with
- 34:14China with this Australian Prime Minister visit.
- 34:17China, in the meantime, will be able to take care of its
- 34:20internal issues. With including the economy, how
- 34:24do you look look out? Is Australia getting anything
- 34:27out of it or is it only there for along with China?
- 34:31Some good pictures for for the Australian Prime Minister, I I I
- 34:36think, I think the Australian Prime Minister is looking to use
- 34:39it to as a sort of diplomatic win to bring to his own
- 34:43political supporters. I also think he honestly
- 34:46believes he can get some minor concessions from China that they
- 34:50will avoid more direct confrontations.
- 34:53So this is an avoidance mechanism.
- 34:56From his perspective, I don't think it will.
- 34:58I think it's basically kicking the can down the road and not
- 35:01even to the some future administration.
- 35:03It may just buy everyone a few weeks or three months times
- 35:06until China and the bulls in China's court decides it's it's
- 35:11time to violate whatever short term arrangements it has made
- 35:15and we won't know when that is because, again, China is the one
- 35:19in control of that situation. Right, right.
- 35:25So Irina, now let's move on to India, Canada relations.
- 35:30Now we thought that it is going towards the mend, but I see this
- 35:36now new diplomatic situation. Indian High Commissioner in
- 35:40Ottawa, Sanjay Varma, he accused China, Canada for again on on
- 35:44this tainted probe as he called it.
- 35:46And you know there was that this they did not say anything of.
- 35:51Important so that India could do needful or anything any sort of
- 35:55a looking at this and at the same time now there are these
- 35:59threats coming on with Kalistani leader video and all that stuff
- 36:04of danger to the Air India carrier.
- 36:08So that is the problem that and they have specified that a date
- 36:12also 19th November. How do you look at all these
- 36:16things happening in terms of India, Canada relations?
- 36:20India, you know, looking at the whole situation, India is also
- 36:22right to protect itself in every way.
- 36:25It is coming and people are here amidst all these threats and you
- 36:30know, of terrorism along the way.
- 36:33Now the biggest question everyone had when this whole
- 36:35issue broke out was why didn't India simply petition for the
- 36:40release of this Khalistani separatists into its custody for
- 36:48extradition of people who made threats.
- 36:51Now my understanding is that the claim from Canada's side,
- 36:55general speaking, is that such requests were not made.
- 37:00But even if they were, a lot of the many of these people have
- 37:04been granted asylum and citizenship and therefore it is
- 37:07against Canada's political position to do anything and they
- 37:11did not take the whole issue seriously.
- 37:14Now it seems to me that my understanding of the situation
- 37:19is that it appears as the story, more of the story comes out, is
- 37:22that such overtures in various forms have been made.
- 37:25There were discussions about this issue.
- 37:28There were discussions about concrete individuals who
- 37:32appeared to be directly involved in plotting of the activity in
- 37:36on India's soil from Canada's territory.
- 37:39Much as we have discussed the issue of Hamas plotting attacks
- 37:45on Israel inside Turkey, we we are seeing that Canada has
- 37:50essentially given a platform to these separatists to plot
- 37:56attacks somewhere else. And because these attacks were
- 37:59not in Canada, although there have been terrorist attacks
- 38:01against Canada as well, which likewise were kept as a separate
- 38:05matter from whatever was going on, in my opinion, he mistake,
- 38:14strategic mistake. I'm not even talking about the
- 38:17moral case. I'm talking about law
- 38:18enforcement. Now it seems to me that the
- 38:24story was less clear, that there was this engaged discussion, and
- 38:27that essentially from India's perspective, Canada was impeding
- 38:31its own ability to take care of its domestic issues by harboring
- 38:36all these individuals. And the more time passed, the
- 38:39more the conflict became intensified in India.
- 38:45And you know the words, it all looked from the perspective of
- 38:49all these people having unfettered access to to Canadian
- 38:56institutions to do what they were doing.
- 39:00Not I'm not entirely sure how all of that will ultimately be
- 39:04resolved, but I I want to see one real way to resolve it which
- 39:08is to come to an agreement to navigate this law enforcement
- 39:12aspect and for Canada to start taking these issues seriously
- 39:15only for its own sake. These individuals have a clearly
- 39:18dangerous and now as if you know, you would think from a
- 39:23logical perspective, Canada is sort of giving, you know,
- 39:28shielding these individuals from foreign efforts to to deal with
- 39:34them whether by extraditing, assassinating, whatever you
- 39:37want. You would think that at this
- 39:39point they would be smart enough to keep their mouths shut and
- 39:42not make public threats that discredit the policy of the
- 39:46government that is protecting them.
- 39:48That is not the case. Now we have a Palestinian
- 39:51terrorists openly threatening to blow up our Indian airplanes,
- 39:56which is as direct a terrorist threat as you can imagine.
- 40:01That puts Prime Minister Trudeau in a very foolish position after
- 40:06he came out publicly with accusations against India and
- 40:09now they kind of discredited his entire claim to Canadian
- 40:13sovereignty because someone in just claimed that they will blow
- 40:17up airplanes full of civilians travelling for their own
- 40:22purposes. All of that is the extremely
- 40:26counterproductive to security issues.
- 40:28All of that is not helpful to the Indian Canadian relations at
- 40:33all. And I I I think at this point
- 40:35Canada should make some sort of clear statement that any sort of
- 40:40threat like that will not be tolerated.
- 40:42And the people engaging terrorism who are naturalized
- 40:45citizens, their their papers should be reviewed.
- 40:49Making making threats of violence is the opposite of, you
- 40:54know, genuine asylum claim. If you're a terrorist or
- 40:59national security threat, you should not be entitled to that
- 41:02sort of protection and you should not be allowed to use
- 41:05that Canadian soil to to engage in crime or terrorism abroad
- 41:13either. It's not.
- 41:14It's counterproductive. If if they don't want India
- 41:17getting involved, then they should take measures and put
- 41:20these people on trial. That's that's the only way to
- 41:25really resolve this issue to mutual satisfaction and to avoid
- 41:30potential, you know, potential tragedies in the in the future.
- 41:33I don't know how serious the threat is.
- 41:36I have no way of telling it. But when somebody threatens to
- 41:39kill you, I think generally it's good that you get I get to take
- 41:44it seriously. Absolutely, absolutely, with all
- 41:49this. Essentials going on this
- 41:51diplomatic row, you know, moving in a very different direction
- 41:55than anticipated amidst all these things.
- 41:58You see, Israel has called, I read it a news report that
- 42:03because of the lot of work they are getting stalled because of
- 42:06all these issues down there, they are looking at Indian
- 42:10workers, more than 100,000 Indian workers going to Israel.
- 42:14That is the report I read. More details I will have to see.
- 42:18So that is a good sign that there is, you know there is a
- 42:20lot of market for Indian workers outside you know and and this is
- 42:26a good thing. How do you see India's role
- 42:29growing role in the Middle East in this whole thing politically
- 42:33as well as in terms of the economic aspect because India is
- 42:38has been a part of lot of growth even in difficult regions and
- 42:42and politically also it has. Been long line but along with
- 42:46that it has also has to has to take care of its political
- 42:50interests by you know international relations and all
- 42:52that. Well, from an economic
- 42:58perspective, I think India is a major is becoming a major player
- 43:02not only by virtue of all the workers that that now in various
- 43:08GCC contrition now coming to Israel which which is extremely
- 43:15impactful and contributes to any major accesses in those
- 43:20countries. But also most strategic level as
- 43:23we have seen from various agreements concluded during the
- 43:27last 320 meetings even if due to the political situations they do
- 43:32not fully materialize as planned.
- 43:34What we see clearly from from that is a strategic direction
- 43:38for asserting and projecting power in the Middle East, for
- 43:41engaging in bilateral and multilateral high level
- 43:46initiatives, for having a lot to contribute and being seen as a
- 43:49very important economic factor, strategic factor and also
- 43:55looking to counter China's influence, particularly the Belt
- 43:58and Rd. initiative in a very concrete and clear way.
- 44:02That much is evident And there's another aspect to the story
- 44:05which is India is also a place which with national resources in
- 44:10that it is it is also providing a potential alternative to
- 44:14China. It also has growing and strong
- 44:18relations in Africa. Another aspect very, very there
- 44:22may be a new challenge to to China's increasing monopoly in
- 44:25those countries. And we are seeing that there is
- 44:29a smaller countries here all over the world are now seeing
- 44:34for an alternative to China. Because China is not necessarily
- 44:39the kindly uncle that everybody has that has presented itself as
- 44:45now all these smaller countries, $1.1 trillion to China in debt,
- 44:52which means a potential takeover of all of their critical
- 44:54infrastructure, virtual financial slavery, you know, or
- 44:58tributary status to China. That is not something anyone
- 45:03wants. And I think many of these
- 45:05countries may look to India as a potential country who may wish
- 45:10to buy out some of their debts in the future, which would put
- 45:14India in an extremely financially powerful position
- 45:18and could be a huge response to China's economic efforts.
- 45:24From a political perspective, we're seeing another role.
- 45:28India has very good relations with most countries in the
- 45:31Middle East without necessarily being seen as a politically
- 45:35assert, as a militarily assertive power, which which
- 45:39presents it as an ideal broker for many future situations.
- 45:44In the way that some of the Middle Eastern countries who
- 45:47have tried to do that have not been really successful or not,
- 45:51have not acted in good faith necessarily.
- 45:53India could play that role while being seen as genuinely neutral
- 45:59on many issues. It has had a positive relations
- 46:04with both Israelis and Palestinians in terms of
- 46:07conflict. There has been a shift in
- 46:10India's position. It has shifted from being
- 46:14relatively neutral in the conflict and some would say more
- 46:18pro Palestinian leaning to being very anti terrorism.
- 46:21I wouldn't say it's become anti Palestinian.
- 46:24It has under Prime Minister Modi has set out a very clear anti
- 46:29extremist position and has grown close to Israel over a variety
- 46:34of mutually beneficial issues. So I think that has been a
- 46:38major, major factor. I think it will in such a
- 46:41position will ultimately benefit everyone, including Palestinians
- 46:45themselves and certainly Middle Eastern countries, aside from
- 46:49Israel, who also who also, without necessarily sticking it
- 46:53out loud for political reasons, feel that Hamas and other
- 46:56terrorist organisations are threat to their own security and
- 46:59security interests. Egypt is one of those countries,
- 47:03certainly, so we can we can see that India in the future, its
- 47:06political role in countering extremism, may be called upon as
- 47:10well for cooperation with all these actors.
- 47:15Right, right. And staying with India, you know
- 47:17about this I iPhone hacking news.
- 47:21How did you see this news? What is the the understanding
- 47:26that you get of it? You know, because India is also
- 47:30looking at it in its own way. And Apple has its own statement
- 47:34on this. Help us.
- 47:36You know, from your perspective, how do you see this whole
- 47:39iPhone, iPhone hacking stuff happening?
- 47:44I've been following this issue for several years, because this
- 47:47is exactly how long it's been ongoing since 2016.
- 47:52It didn't start with India, but India became a major target,
- 47:55especially as its relationship with Israel on security issues
- 47:58has grown closer. Not all of these articles
- 48:01explicitly mention it, but the major target of these hacking
- 48:06accusations has been against Israeli software and there's
- 48:09been a concerted effort to divide and break up relations
- 48:13between India and Israel on those grounds and to Force India
- 48:18to look for other options due to the bad optic optics from the
- 48:22various scandals related to these accusations.
- 48:25Now if you look at that, Apple has not been a disinterested
- 48:28actor. Apple has used it for for its
- 48:32own publicity. Apple has tried to dominate
- 48:36security market among iPhone among phones with very mixed
- 48:41results because these hacking attempts have revealed the
- 48:47number of significant vulnerabilities.
- 48:50So it has viewed these Israeli security companies as as
- 48:53business competition quite simply and as an embarrassment
- 48:57to its own efforts to dominate this sphere.
- 49:00So there is a a bad face interest in Apple.
- 49:04Apple's part it hasn't worked with a number of Ng OS that
- 49:10focus on digital rights and that have ties to assorted the act,
- 49:15state and non state actors ranging from other big tech
- 49:19companies with particular interests in the area to George
- 49:23Soros to Russia, China and Qatar and Muslim Brotherhood entities.
- 49:29All of these have actually backed the digital NGOs, digital
- 49:33rights and news. Let's have sent out reports on
- 49:38Apple's behalf claiming that these Israeli security companies
- 49:42are the ones responsible for these hacks, with nary a
- 49:46technical evidence. None of it has been released to
- 49:49the public fully, and there's been an intermix of of experts
- 49:56among these digital angels, some with very dubious professional
- 50:00credentials in digital forensics.
- 50:03Essentially, just just to put it bluntly, I'm not an expert in
- 50:08this area, but it's been a lot of propaganda without much
- 50:11evidence, and some of the lawsuits against these Israeli
- 50:14companies in the US have already been thrown out.
- 50:19What's more most interesting is that examining these efforts and
- 50:23notice that a peak in accusations occurs during
- 50:26politically significant events. In this particular case, the the
- 50:30accusations against India have emerged at the same time as
- 50:34accusations against Azerbaijan. Why?
- 50:37These two countries, which have actually at at various points,
- 50:40have been at odds with each other over various political
- 50:43issues, certainly back different regional camps.
- 50:47They have one major thing in common, which is they're very
- 50:51positive relations with Israel, security and defence
- 50:55cooperation, growing economic and energy cooperation, and both
- 51:01of them back to Israel in this instant conflict with Hamas.
- 51:07And these accusations once again emerged at a significantly
- 51:12politically significant time at the peak of the conflict between
- 51:15Israel and Hamas. So if you look at the past
- 51:19claims, they have also in the past been coordinated with
- 51:23significant events, peaks of different conflicts pre election
- 51:28or election periods in various countries.
- 51:31So none of it has just been random.
- 51:34It has also always been tied to some important political events,
- 51:38which leads me to believe that Apple and all these actors are
- 51:41looking to use propaganda and these accusations on human
- 51:45rights to meddle in influence policy in those countries.
- 51:49Specifically towards the entry Israel perspective in this
- 51:53particular case, but also in general to favour their
- 51:59particular constituencies they're trying to protect who
- 52:04are generally aligned with Iran, China, Russia, Islamists and and
- 52:11by Russia, I mean specifically intelligence agencies and not
- 52:14just random, you know, Russian, Russian citizens.
- 52:20Right. Right.
- 52:21A lot of a lot is happening in the world and a lot of minds are
- 52:24working overtime. And let's be that as it may,
- 52:29let's move to Bangladesh now. Now that is a problem area that
- 52:33is coming up in terms of political turmoil sweeping
- 52:36Bangladesh and its economy is already, you know, facing its
- 52:40tough challenges. How do you see that opposition
- 52:43is asking for Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina to resign ahead of
- 52:47the general election expected in January?
- 52:50How about how do you see this politics impacting economics in
- 52:55especially when Bangladesh in such a difficult position at the
- 52:58moment? Well, none of it is particularly
- 53:01surprising for those of us observing the situation in
- 53:05Bangladesh for the past many years.
- 53:09It has suffered from a lack of democracy, lack of respect for
- 53:12the rights of the opposition groups, and extreme polarization
- 53:17between its parties and the current leader, Shekhar Shekhar
- 53:22Hasina. She's considered an ally by the
- 53:25United States. But if you look closer to
- 53:27politics, there have been accusations of your support for
- 53:31Islamist terrorist groups and corruption, and of course,
- 53:37complete a lack of respect for the opposition and their rights.
- 53:42People have disappeared. Political leaders have been
- 53:45arrested and thrown in prison with no clear legal
- 53:51justification. And economically it seems that
- 53:55extreme groups have grown significantly because they
- 53:59provide some sort of a political and financial leeway for the
- 54:05government which has otherwise been mismanaging the economy.
- 54:09And I think Bangladesh is heading very much in the
- 54:12direction of a potential trauma or a situation similar to Sri
- 54:16Lanka and other or even Pakistan, where they had to rely
- 54:21very much on China to bail them out with very negative results.
- 54:27If China gets involved in bailing out this whole and
- 54:30resolving the situation, it may put a stop to the economic
- 54:35turmoil, but it will not stop, put a stop to political issues
- 54:38and it will not solve them. China does not generally get
- 54:43directly involved in governance, and if it does, it's never good
- 54:46news for anybody for either side.
- 54:51I'm not entirely sure what IMF and Western institutions are
- 54:55going to do, but it's very clear that once again, the West has
- 54:58put its faith into the wrong person, the wrong hands.
- 55:04They have allowed a very illiberal process to take place
- 55:08over a number of decades and number and many years more
- 55:11recently. And there's been for reasons of
- 55:15convenience, because they have seen the political Bangladesh
- 55:19appear to be going along with the general trends, even though
- 55:22internally the picture is quite, quite the opposite.
- 55:26And if this breaks out, it could affect neighboring countries in
- 55:30the entire region because terrorists and extremist groups
- 55:34take advantage of any form of chaos.
- 55:36And they certainly work across borders with each other, with
- 55:40groups in Indonesia, groups in Pakistan, in here, with the,
- 55:45with the certain groups in Malaysia and so forth.
- 55:48We can see home network building up from this one situation.
- 55:56Absolutely, absolutely. As I said, and you know, there's
- 55:59a lot of things happening in the world and you have, you know, in
- 56:02this new episode, you have explained and made given us some
- 56:06understanding, better understanding of all that is
- 56:09happening, you know, which are sometimes very difficult.
- 56:12To understand with this, it's a wrap on this very special
- 56:15edition of The World According to Irena Superman.
- 56:19Thank you so much and hope to see you again soon.
- 56:23Thank you so much. Looking forward.