Latest / WonkyFolk / Vol 32 - Between "Historic" and "Nuanced": Understanding Ed Reform in Denver
Transcript
- 0:01Jed Wallace: Hey, Andy.
- 0:02Hey, Jed.
- 0:03How are you?
- 0:04Good.
- 0:05you always beat me on the tacky Christmas sweaters.
- 0:09but I, it seems like you might be like doing tacky sweaters all year.
- 0:12Ro all year long now, dude.
- 0:14Andy Rotherham: Tacky.
- 0:15This is just some old fisherman sweater.
- 0:17these things are classic.
- 0:20Jed Wallace: I'm going hoodie on you.
- 0:21Andy Rotherham: The classics Never go outta style, Jed.
- 0:25Jed Wallace: I, all right.
- 0:25I, like it.
- 0:27and knowing that you're fishing in it, I guess I'll give it a, and
- 0:29Andy Rotherham: it's freezing cold here.
- 0:30It's actually really is legit sweater weather in Virginia.
- 0:35Jed Wallace: I'm glad that we're starting off the new year, with, and
- 0:37maybe we'll be disciplined about it.
- 0:39and we'll remind everybody.
- 0:41Hey, this is Wonky folk.
- 0:42This is Jed Wallace, and Andy Roth room.
- 0:44We've, It had been doing this now for a few years.
- 0:47If you guys can hit likes and if you can hit subscribes, that's all great stuff.
- 0:51We really appreciate it.
- 0:53meanwhile, we're delighted to have, a great guest to get things started.
- 0:58Andy, you've actually known Parker longer than me.
- 1:00You wanna start with the intro here?
- 1:02Andy Rotherham: Yeah, look, I'll like Parker's one of my favorite.
- 1:04So like other like bias fully like on display.
- 1:07Parker's one of my favorite people in the sector.
- 1:10He's smart, he's fearless, he does creative work and he is just
- 1:13a absolutely wonderful human.
- 1:15I've been doing a thing last few years.
- 1:17It allows me to suspend some informal, time with him fishing out in
- 1:21Colorado, which is where he is based.
- 1:24and he'll talk more about the different work he does.
- 1:27He runs a really fascinating fellowship that I'd urge you if you are a Colorado.
- 1:31Person who is either into ed policy or, leading that way that you would look at.
- 1:36He's based in Denver, but it's the University of Colorado, but
- 1:39it's a, they're based in Denver.
- 1:42and he can tell you, he can tell you more about all of that.
- 1:45But, just a fantastic, longtime person.
- 1:49I don't even know.
- 1:49I'm trying to remember.
- 1:50Parker, you're one of those people I can't even remember actually when we just
- 1:53literally first met, but he's someone, if I'm out in Colorado with teams, I try to
- 1:57get him to come by and sit with them for a little bit so they can learn from him.
- 2:00Just a fantastic person.
- 2:05so expect
- 2:06lots of hard, expect lots of hard hitting questions.
- 2:10Baxter Parker: Hi.
- 2:11Hi both.
- 2:11Thanks for having me.
- 2:13Great.
- 2:13Yeah.
- 2:13Jed Wallace: Look, I, don't know how it is that you and I
- 2:15haven't, crossed paths earlier.
- 2:18I've been like quoting your stuff for a very long time.
- 2:21I'm from Colorado.
- 2:22You've been sending me decks.
- 2:23I'm already sending them to my parents, just to share with all of their old
- 2:27retired education, folk about just the progress that's been made in Denver.
- 2:32But, thanks for joining us and I, it's, I for our guests that may, know less
- 2:38about you, how do you talk about your experience in the ed reform world?
- 2:42You're in Denver now, but I was intrigued to learn about all sorts of things that
- 2:46you've done earlier in your career.
- 2:47So can you just set a little context for our folks about, what you've done
- 2:51previously and how it's put you, in this position to make the unique contribu
- 2:55contribution you're making right now?
- 2:58Baxter Parker: Sure.
- 3:01I, I guess in some ways I, my, my career is I follow the trajectory of ed
- 3:09reform a little bit in the sense that I was in college when charter school.
- 3:13I'm sorry to hear that,
- 3:15Andy Rotherham: Parker.
- 3:15I thought, you were doing better than that.
- 3:18Baxter Parker: No, I, I, have, I was in college, when charters
- 3:24were first created and, in, in Colorado, went to Colorado College.
- 3:30And so I had a, firsthand view of the beginning of that, work in Colorado.
- 3:37And even as a college student, I was just fascinated by frankly, the
- 3:46debate over whether there was some other way to provide public education,
- 3:55than the traditional system.
- 3:57And so I, I actually then joined Teach for America.
- 4:02I, was one of the early, in the early years of Teach for America
- 4:06and actually taught in New Orleans, before Hurricane Katrina at a, high
- 4:11school called Booker t Washington.
- 4:14and to be frank, it was a, it was, I was a witness to a crime.
- 4:20It was an ongoing denial of the American dream.
- 4:29and, I, here, I fully admit, I'm, privileged white boy in a lot of ways,
- 4:38had a white savior complex and, yet, like that was really the most humbling
- 4:45experience of my life, but also just really fundamentally shattered my naivete
- 4:54about the American dream and about.
- 4:57The reality of equal opportunity in America.
- 5:00And I actually went to law school then 'cause I wanted to sue New Orleans Public
- 5:06Schools for, special ed violations.
- 5:12but also knew I didn't wanna be a lawyer forever.
- 5:15So I got a Master's in public administration, worked on Capitol
- 5:19Hill for, a year for the late senator Ted Kennedy, on the health education,
- 5:25labor and Pensions committee.
- 5:27And that was right when, there was an effort to reauthorize
- 5:32No Child Left Behind.
- 5:33And this is actually, Early years, or at least I think for me, when I first
- 5:39started reading edu wonk and, couldn't stop, couldn't, I know why it all,
- 5:47Andy Rotherham: now we know why it all went sideways.
- 5:50Yeah.
- 5:51No, you're,
- 5:51Baxter Parker: yeah.
- 5:52You're such
- 5:53Andy Rotherham: a promis, you're such a promising young
- 5:55Baxter Parker: man.
- 5:56No joke that a lot of what you wrote at the time really,
- 6:02resonated with me as someone who, here I was probably Senator Kennedy had
- 6:08never hired a Teach for America person.
- 6:11That in itself was, controversial.
- 6:16The fact that I was at that point already really, interested in, Choi
- 6:22public school choice, chartering as
- 6:28as a, what I view as a progressive, Way to, think about
- 6:34reinventing public education.
- 6:36And I got, it sounds crazy, but I got lucky because I, moved out to Colorado,
- 6:43with my wife, but we didn't have jobs.
- 6:46and, somehow I got, lucky enough to be connected to Michael Bennett,
- 6:51who was then the superintendent of Denver Public Schools.
- 6:55And I got hired, to be in charge of what was then only a small
- 7:01number of charter schools.
- 7:03When I first started in Denver in 2000, eight, there were
- 7:07about 17 charter schools.
- 7:10And by the time I left, three years later, there were almost 50.
- 7:16and today there still are, almost, 50 charter schools in the city.
- 7:22So that, that whole experience of teaching in a really dysfunctional.
- 7:28Environment where I could, it was just obvious that the system had not
- 7:34been designed for, for my success as a teacher or for my student's success.
- 7:41And, and then I, was really inspired by, frankly inspired by what,
- 7:50what Denver was proposing to do.
- 7:52when I arrived, they had just launched this whole strategy to fundamentally
- 7:58reinvent the school district.
- 8:01that's where I started, and I've been obsessed ever since
- 8:06Jed Wallace: with many stops along the, way, including working at nsa,
- 8:11which I, was not remembering before.
- 8:14You mentioned it when we last spoke.
- 8:16also now you're at the University of Colorado, Denver.
- 8:19And, it's an amazing perch from which to, to look at the Denver experience now.
- 8:24Andy Rotherham: You're doing just some amazing work out there.
- 8:26Why don't we just dive into that.
- 8:28I think there's probably some contextual questions, but you've done sort of two
- 8:32landmark studies on student achievement in Denver as part of these reforms.
- 8:39and it's, interesting that, you talked about getting to know Michael
- 8:43Bennett and he was, then, the super, he became the superintendent, then
- 8:47he was appointed to the Senate, and now he's running for governor and is
- 8:50in a contested primary for governor.
- 8:52And I think that's, some of that we can, when we get to the
- 8:53politics is a backdrop for this.
- 8:56But he, put in place a number of changes, and then you went, and you've looked at
- 9:02them now twice in two different ways.
- 9:04So why don't you, why don't you talk about that, like both
- 9:06those studies and your work.
- 9:10Baxter Parker: Sure.
- 9:14I guess I, I think I should say that,
- 9:22When I, first started learning about charter schools, I was very,
- 9:29sympathetic to the concerns of, of those who were, who were worried that
- 9:37they would simply provide an escape patch from the existing system and,
- 9:45not engage in how to, reinvent it.
- 9:52and so part of my interest in Denver really does, come from what I believe is
- 9:59it is real unique about Denver, in this, in that, rather than just pursuing these
- 10:07various reform strategies, charter schools were one of them, but there was also a
- 10:13pay for performance program for teachers.
- 10:19Autonomy for district level schools, et cetera.
- 10:23these different,
- 10:26reform activities, were tried in different pla have been tried in different places.
- 10:32But what I think is different about Denver is that like the model, the
- 10:36portfolio strategy, from Paul Hill and his colleagues, like the, just
- 10:43like that strategy is intended to provide an alternative model for
- 10:49providing public education at scale.
- 10:53I think Denver's, effort is a very explicit, and, from the very beginning
- 11:01was a very explicit attempt, not just to improve the existing system,
- 11:06but to fundamentally transform it to the point of replacing it with an
- 11:12alternative paradigm oriented around different operating assumptions, namely.
- 11:18Choice for families, empowerment for schools, and accountability for outcomes.
- 11:23So for me, like I, I've been working, I spent most of my
- 11:27career as a practitioner, right?
- 11:30I did work for nsa, but I also, I worked primarily in authorizing and fascinated
- 11:36by, the, regulation of, new public delivery systems and how do we, how, can
- 11:46we, how can we find ways to fulfill the public and private purposes of government
- 11:57in ways that are adaptable to current realities And, and that, ultimately can
- 12:07be hopefully more effective and equitable.
- 12:10And so for me, the fundamental question, about the Denver reforms and.
- 12:15Part of what fascinates me so much is that I really do think they
- 12:19call the question of whether it is possible to provide public education,
- 12:26through some mechanism other than the traditional unified school system.
- 12:30And
- 12:33I also,
- 12:36I've always been a politics junkie and so I, I, really, especially after leaving
- 12:43DPS and then I've worked, in, education all over the country in almost every
- 12:50state as a result of my work with nsa.
- 12:52And I ended up working in Louisiana for the State Department of Education there.
- 12:57And I've seen all these different educational contexts and it was just
- 13:01fascinating to look back on Denver.
- 13:05'cause I was, I've been tracking Denver since I left there,
- 13:09in a pretty obsessive way.
- 13:11And it was just it was, frankly.
- 13:17Mind blowing to me that, Denver could be having the conflict
- 13:23that it was having circa 2015.
- 13:28at the beginning of the conflict, nationally, but also in Denver.
- 13:33it was just mind blowing to me that conflict could occur without a recognition
- 13:39of the vast array of different ways that this, these kinds of reforms are
- 13:47actually taking place across the country.
- 13:50And so I had witnessed places where there were real inequities, around things like
- 13:57special education or, equitable access during enrollment and things like that.
- 14:06and, yet, here Denver was, and I think, I hope we'll talk some about.
- 14:11The various ways that Denver actually is explicitly designed to address the
- 14:18very real challenges that autonomous schools present for the provision
- 14:27of public education at scale.
- 14:30And
- 14:32what I mean by that is that, there, there are real fundamental features
- 14:38across Denver's reform strategy that acknowledge that, the introduction of
- 14:46these autonomous independent operators into what is intended to be a centralized
- 14:52system can create externalities in, economists talk, but, negative,
- 15:01consequences for the, broader system.
- 15:07and that especially as those schools grow, get to scale, the, it
- 15:12becomes all the more important to be attentive to those challenges.
- 15:18And
- 15:20yeah, I think Denver, I think on then the last thing is, just that, it was
- 15:26just fascinating that the, that how little the conflict over the reforms
- 15:32in Denver was focused on the actual outcomes that the reforms had produced.
- 15:39And so for me, and that ultimately is probably the thing, I, really wanna give
- 15:46a shout out to Paul Teskey, who was, for many years the dean of the School of
- 15:53Public Affairs here, at cu, but is also.
- 15:58one of the pioneers of school choice research, and was in the nineties, writing
- 16:04about, parents and their preferences for schools, and most importantly for
- 16:12me, frankly, the obstacles that those parents, particularly low income parents
- 16:17faced in accessing those choices.
- 16:20And
- 16:23I, met Paul very early on, when I first started working for Denver
- 16:27because I was reading his work and realizing how much it spoke to what
- 16:32we were trying to do in the, district.
- 16:36and he and I have had a great relationship, but, and I really am
- 16:41grateful that he's given me this opportunity because part of what I,
- 16:47remember, we were both looking at each other what is going on here?
- 16:51Like these reforms.
- 16:53Are demonstrably effective.
- 16:55And we didn't even have the kind of rigorous empirical evidence that we
- 16:59have now then, but there was lots of descriptive evidence that the
- 17:04reforms in Denver, were successful.
- 17:07just the fact that the district went from the bottom fifth percentile, of
- 17:12all districts in the state in 2007, a 39% four year graduation rate,
- 17:21all the way up to above the 60th percentile of districts in the state
- 17:26performing near the state average.
- 17:30even with, a much more disadvantaged population.
- 17:34And so we really just, we both of us wanted to, dig in and really
- 17:39try to understand, as much as we could about, about what, happened
- 17:46in Denver and what it might, show us about, the future of reform.
- 17:52Jed Wallace: Parker on several occasions at, charter Folk,
- 17:55I've cited your research.
- 17:58and I usually find a slide or two that uses the term historic.
- 18:04You use historic progress or something like that.
- 18:07now that might be historic as it's relative to Denver over a long
- 18:12period of time, but I also think the use historic is relative to what's
- 18:16happened across the entire country.
- 18:18When you're using terms like that, can you just be a little bit, just
- 18:21put a little more color on it.
- 18:22Why did you use that terminology?
- 18:24Why is Denver's progress historic, in your opinion?
- 18:32Baxter Parker: Yeah, so first of all, I think Denver is really
- 18:36one of the first districts,
- 18:40in, in US history to willingly, voluntarily give up its authority to.
- 18:51Operate all public schools within its jurisdiction and in without giving up
- 19:00its authority to govern public education.
- 19:06And, for me that's a massive, Lee important, shift because, as many
- 19:16of us are well aware, historically, the unitary school district model,
- 19:24the, direct connection between governance and operation is, it is,
- 19:31one of the core features of, public education in the United States.
- 19:37And, so I think, it is really important to recognize how rare and
- 19:42even radical it, it was for Denver to.
- 19:47To say, Hey, this traditional model, it's fundamentally broken and it's not working
- 19:55and unlikely and is unlikely to work for the students we have, here in Denver.
- 20:03And we need to be willing to, fundamentally change the model.
- 20:09And I do think, the reforms are, historic in that sense.
- 20:15there's another interesting just aspect I have to just note 'cause I am a
- 20:19real history junkie, but part of why I'm still so obsessed with Denver is
- 20:26because when I first got into academia about eight years ago now and really
- 20:31started, digging into this, I discovered that for, lots of different reasons,
- 20:37Denver actually was a model school system at the turn of the 20th century.
- 20:46And, it was actually viewed by, educators all over the country as, this, example of
- 20:54what was called the modern school system.
- 20:59and so it's just fa it's been fascinating for me to, dig back into that history
- 21:06and to realize sort of the connection between the historical realities that
- 21:12led to the creation of very large school systems in the beginning of,
- 21:19public education in the United States.
- 21:21Even as we had over a hundred thousand one room schoolhouses in, cities due to
- 21:29mass immigration, industrialization, these systems became massive almost overnight.
- 21:37And for example, Denver went from 150 students in 1875.
- 21:45To 30,000 in 1910,
- 21:5130,000 students in 1910.
- 21:55And, so what we, part of what is so fascinating to me about that is that the
- 22:02modern school system, from a structural point of view, was designed to address
- 22:07that, that rapid, massive growth and to figure out a way to, to do it at scale.
- 22:19today it's just blows my mind that we have, we continue to
- 22:24essentially operate that way, more or less all over the country.
- 22:29And That in itself I think is, just interesting is how much Denver, by
- 22:35the way, was the first city also, and perhaps not coincidentally, to have a
- 22:39single salary schedule for teachers.
- 22:44it was, the teacher's union in Denver had the first contract
- 22:49west of the Mississippi.
- 22:52And, so Denver has, since its very beginning, been this sort of site
- 22:59where it could, on the one hand be a model, for, others, but also has gone
- 23:06through like the exact challenges that I think are, representative,
- 23:13of the entire sort of struggle of public education in the United States.
- 23:18similarly, Colorado itself is an interesting place where we have 178
- 23:24school districts, but a hundred of them have less than 2000 students.
- 23:31So it's, this dynamic of, how do we operate education,
- 23:38public education at scale?
- 23:40I think is a really, fascinating question and important one for the
- 23:46future of education in the United States.
- 23:49But, yeah, that's part of, again, what, what drew me to Denver
- 23:54and is keeping me obsessed.
- 23:56Andy Rotherham: So before we get to the, some of the analysis, which we
- 24:00will get to, if you were listening probably I thought we were gonna,
- 24:03real quickly, you mentioned a moment ago there, pieces of Denver.
- 24:08Let's talk about those and then also I think for people who may not be familiar
- 24:12with Colorado, if you could just real quickly just universal public school
- 24:16choice, open enrollment in Colorado.
- 24:18So there's some features there that are not, that you don't find everywhere.
- 24:22I,
- 24:25Baxter Parker: yeah.
- 24:27I think it is important to know that, that Colorado has had public
- 24:32school choice through o mandatory open enrollment within districts and
- 24:39across districts lines since 1994.
- 24:44so over 30 year, for over 30 years.
- 24:49parents in, in Colorado have a legal right to enroll in any school
- 24:55in their school district and any school across district lines.
- 25:00So long as there's capacity, there's some restrictions around that.
- 25:05But that's a very important feature because, and then Colorado
- 25:09also was the third state, to adopt a charter school law.
- 25:14and, in 1994, around the same time that open enrollment.
- 25:19And I think one of the interesting things and essential to understand about.
- 25:27the beginning of Denver's reforms and the rationale for them is that they were
- 25:33launched in response to the disruption that had been created by open enrollment
- 25:44and the introduction of charter schools.
- 25:47And, and also,
- 25:50Andy Rotherham: wasn't there, there was pressure still out there for
- 25:52private school choice as well?
- 25:55There was a referendum and so Yes.
- 25:57Baxter Parker: Yeah, there were, certainly have always been people, some
- 26:01people in Colorado who really have, been dedicated to private school choice.
- 26:06But I think even more remarkable for me is that, that there, there
- 26:12has just been this, long lasting bipartisan support for open enrollment
- 26:18and choice in education in general.
- 26:21And I think that's just an important thing to remember because when we first
- 26:27started, looking at how to improve the functioning of school choice
- 26:34within Denver Public Schools, one of the things that we realized was that,
- 26:4145% of the district was choosing a school and other than their school of
- 26:48assignment, and this was in 2008, 2009.
- 26:52And that in itself is remarkable.
- 26:55And it was this, I still remember this because it was a real sort of awakening
- 27:01moment for the leadership of the district at the time because they realized that
- 27:06this reality was already here, and yet they were not managing it in any way.
- 27:15And, I think it's, I, it's true.
- 27:18I was there because.
- 27:21I think that actually was a real problem for the leadership of the district
- 27:25because they viewed that not just as a threat to the district from a financial
- 27:29point of view, but as a real threat to equitable access and equitable provision.
- 27:35And so from their point of view, just letting this thing happen around them
- 27:40and not trying to actually lead it, was from their point of view, causing the
- 27:50district harm and actually was gonna prevent it from ever being able to
- 27:55actually take control of its own destiny.
- 27:57So I do think that dynamic, another dynamic that's just important to
- 28:01recognize is that Colorado is a, is really one, one of the, it's one of
- 28:07the few states in the country that is really a local control state.
- 28:11In the sense that there are about six of the 50 states that have some
- 28:15provision in their constitution that references local control.
- 28:18Colorado is one of those states, nonetheless, Colorado also has
- 28:24a relatively unified governance structure, and in that there
- 28:28are 178 approximately districts.
- 28:32But the state board of education is directly responsible
- 28:38for oversight of the state.
- 28:41And so this is, again, I think a tension that we see still today
- 28:45playing out all across the country is, is education actually a state
- 28:50function or is it a local function?
- 28:53And to what extent should we try to balance those things.
- 28:57And so again, these are all the kinds of things that I just, that are, fascinating
- 29:02to me on an intellectual level.
- 29:05but and so then the point there is that.
- 29:10the state board does have the authority to intervene in districts.
- 29:16they could shut down a district entirely or whatever.
- 29:18And interestingly, Denver, sued, color, the state back in the late
- 29:26nineties to block charter schools because they claim that they were
- 29:31a violation of local control.
- 29:33And, the, Colorado Supreme Court denied that, claim on the grounds that the
- 29:40state still maintains the authority to, intervene in cases where they think, it's
- 29:47necessary to promote equity of access or opportunity or, performance or, any
- 29:53of those, fundamental public purposes.
- 29:55And so I think it is really important to recognize when I was first hired in DPS,
- 30:03the district had for the first time at the time.
- 30:07Just tried to close an extremely low performing charter school
- 30:12and was overturned by the state.
- 30:15And, I remember Michael Bennett telling me, we're never
- 30:20gonna let that happen again.
- 30:23And that's your job, Parker.
- 30:26and part of that is what he meant was like, we need to actually own
- 30:31this in a way that we can demonstrate to the state board that this school
- 30:38should not be receiving public funds because it's not fulfilling its public
- 30:42responsibilities and it has nothing to do, whether it's a charter school
- 30:45or district school or anything else.
- 30:47And the only way to do that is it was from Michael Bennett and Tom
- 30:51Berg's eventually point of view was to actually become the best charter
- 30:57authorizer we could possibly become.
- 31:00And so it's no joke that a lot of the work, in Denver around trying to become
- 31:06a strong charter school authorizer was to ensure that, that the district
- 31:13actually maintained its authority to govern public education in the city.
- 31:19Jed Wallace: Well, Parker, I the use of the term historic
- 31:23that, I was referring to, yes.
- 31:25There are historic things about the unprecedented nature of the reforms,
- 31:31especially in the continuum of, public education across the United States.
- 31:36There's also just the historic progress.
- 31:38There's not that much reason to pay any attention to Denver, if they've made all
- 31:43these changes and it hasn't done anything.
- 31:46but your research shows in two very compelling bites at the Apple that what's
- 31:51happened in Denver is unprecedented in terms of growth, of improvement, of equity
- 31:59and excellence, and the job's not done.
- 32:03But, it's in a, in an environment where Denver's itself is not even aware of this.
- 32:09And I know Andy, you wanted to talk about, just the publicity and communications,
- 32:12what was going on related to Denver?
- 32:15I, for whatever reason, school board elections happened, started
- 32:20happening in 2015 or 17, and sending things in the opposite direction.
- 32:25But seemingly, without even being aware of the fact that Denver
- 32:29is one of the national success stories, how, do you gr that?
- 32:34And Andy, if there's something different around the messaging and communication.
- 32:37no.
- 32:37Before we get to that
- 32:38Andy Rotherham: though, we still haven't just gotten to, I think Park you should,
- 32:40like you have, you did two studies.
- 32:42Yeah.
- 32:43I'll briefly summarize them and then you should fill in some details
- 32:46just briefly and then we can, I think Jed's question's important.
- 32:49One was looking at, data across the district and you found gains,
- 32:53but it wasn't student level data.
- 32:55You then spent several years trying to get student level data against
- 32:59a fair amount of resistance.
- 33:00And we could talk about that.
- 33:01That's a weird thing.
- 33:03that people were so reluctant to want you to have data to be able to do a
- 33:06good, a better, even better analysis.
- 33:09You then did a second one that had student level data and
- 33:12found very significant effects.
- 33:14And I guess I disagree with Jed a little bit in the sense of.
- 33:17All this work in Denver.
- 33:19If we, if, the results hadn't found anything interesting, I do
- 33:22think that would be important.
- 33:23That would be like we, we'd wanna know why and so forth.
- 33:26Okay.
- 33:28because it was such an ambitious set of reforms, but in fact
- 33:31you found the opposite.
- 33:32You found really substantial.
- 33:35Jed used the word historic level gains for a, school reform project.
- 33:39So what am I missing in the story there?
- 33:41Phil was filling color.
- 33:44Baxter Parker: Yeah.
- 33:45So, thank you for, bringing me back to the present.
- 33:49'cause I really do love the historical, but, but I do.
- 33:55Yeah.
- 33:55So just briefly to explain, we, we set out, when we first started this research,
- 34:04to answer the question of whether Denver's reforms improved educational performance.
- 34:15Citywide districtwide.
- 34:18And, I should note that in itself is, relatively difficult to do almost
- 34:25everywhere else other than Denver.
- 34:28And, there are reasons for that, that we can talk about if we want, but Denver's
- 34:32unified structure in which all of these different schools are operating.
- 34:38So there were two, there are 200 total public schools in Denver,
- 34:4350 of them are charter schools and 50 of them are innovation schools.
- 34:48And the question, is it, does this actually result in better educational
- 34:53outcomes and especially does it result in better educational outcomes
- 34:58for the students who the district has historically failed to serve?
- 35:03And through a series of two different studies.
- 35:09we have examined this question, this basic question, did the
- 35:12reforms work in the sense that, did they actually improve outcomes?
- 35:17And so what we find is, on average these re these reforms resulted in
- 35:25large academic gains in both subject areas for the average Denver student
- 35:33across almost every subgroup and, and over multiple years of reform.
- 35:42And we, look at 40,000 total students.
- 35:4720,000 of them are part of the Denver reforms and 20,000 of them
- 35:54are, are comparison students in surrounding districts who've been
- 35:59matched on their demographics.
- 36:01And so what we wanna know is, did a student, an A, the average student.
- 36:08Benefit by going to Denver Public Schools instead of one
- 36:13of the surrounding districts.
- 36:15And
- 36:17part of what is so historic is that it is, educational, improvement is rare.
- 36:25in, to, it is rare to find strong educational improvement in
- 36:30education research in itself, right?
- 36:33Most interventions actually don't have an effect, and, are either negative or null.
- 36:39But, part of what is remarkable is that not only are the results we find
- 36:45consistently positive, but they, are among the largest ever observed in education
- 36:54research in terms of their duration, their scale, and their actual size.
- 37:05and
- 37:07We see that the average Denver student who experienced the reforms, and it's
- 37:12important to know we only look at kids who were in Denver before the
- 37:17reforms began for at least two years, and then who were then thereafter.
- 37:24So there's no way that, that something could be different
- 37:28about this population of students.
- 37:30Andy Rotherham: And that was the critique of your first study, which was
- 37:34like, from a descriptive standpoint, it told an important story, but we
- 37:37couldn't quite, you couldn't say, 'cause you, it wasn't at that student level.
- 37:41So you came back and what you're talking about now is you're able to
- 37:44actually track the students so you can make sure these are actually students
- 37:47who were there, not just on them.
- 37:49Yes.
- 37:49And
- 37:50Baxter Parker: that's important.
- 37:51That's important because another, again, interesting fact about Denver,
- 37:56is that it added 20,000 new students.
- 38:01When, between, from when these reforms first began all the way till 2019?
- 38:10that's almost unheard of, right?
- 38:12For a, large urban district that had a graduation rate of 39% and was among
- 38:20the lowest performing in the state.
- 38:22And so that in itself is a fascinating question.
- 38:26Like what, that's part of what led us to looking at this.
- 38:28But yes, our first study included all of the students that entered into DPS and
- 38:35was at the school level, and so did not allow us to separate improvements that may
- 38:41have come from, better performing students or students with more opportunities
- 38:47coming into the district later.
- 38:50Now it's important to note too, that's actually still an out, a
- 38:54positive outcome of the reforms.
- 38:57In many ways, that was actually one of the, points of the reform was
- 39:01to bring people into the district.
- 39:03But it is almost certainly the case that population that came in later
- 39:09did have advantages perhaps that, that students who were in the district
- 39:13before the reforms began really did.
- 39:16And so another fascinating example of this, and again, another indicator
- 39:20of success of these reforms is that, during the reform period, the percentage
- 39:26of students enrolled in private school in Denver was cut in half.
- 39:34and so from 15% to seven 8%, it's gone up now since the pandemic
- 39:44some, and, as the reforms have.
- 39:46Have, been changed, but I, that, in itself means that there are students in Denver
- 39:52today who would never be there otherwise.
- 39:56and, anyway, so that, that's, we, and let's
- 40:00Andy Rotherham: talk real quickly about getting that data.
- 40:03'cause I think this is an important part of the story that sort of, I
- 40:07suspect the average person who doesn't work in our sector is just watching
- 40:11or listening to this and is of course you'd wanna evaluate this stuff, but
- 40:15actually getting access to that student level data so you could come back and
- 40:20do the more fine grained analysis.
- 40:22That was a whole fight and you ran into sort of nonstop resistance, on that.
- 40:29So talk a little bit about that.
- 40:31that's, just a very illustrative thing about the politics of the sector.
- 40:37Baxter Parker: Sure.
- 40:38I think first of all, it's just important to remember.
- 40:42That, 2015 we had this whole backlash against standardized
- 40:47testing, opt out, et cetera.
- 40:52And, in Colorado that the sort of anti-testing movement has
- 40:56always actually been bipartisan.
- 40:58There are people on the right who, wanna get rid of testing and
- 41:02who don't like, data collection.
- 41:05And there are people on the left who, who for different reasons, don't
- 41:10like testing and data collection.
- 41:12And yet that had, that's those two sides coalesced, during that period
- 41:20to make it what kind of almost known within Colorado that it's hard to
- 41:26get access to student level data.
- 41:29So I think in some ways my, experience with the politics of education reform
- 41:35before I became a researcher helped me.
- 41:39to see that landscape before I began the research.
- 41:44And so I definitely approached this research knowing that it, was going to
- 41:51be difficult to get the data needed.
- 41:54Interestingly, it might be interesting for your listeners, I
- 41:58did not intend to do two studies.
- 42:02IOI, it took me almost four years to get the actual student level data.
- 42:12And the reason why I released the first study is because I, we, we were doing
- 42:20the study, the goal was to do this entire study, this comprehensive study
- 42:25that would look at both the system level indicators and student level indicators.
- 42:31But, as we were proceeding, we were running into, Opposition.
- 42:36And so first, the district itself refused to work with us
- 42:42or, or acknowledge the research.
- 42:45and, and then, I, were they doing a different evaluation?
- 42:50Andy Rotherham: did they have 'cause you would think, given all the
- 42:54conversations of the sector about continuous learning and transparency,
- 42:57they'd be excited to have high quality evaluation happening to learn from.
- 43:01So was there I'm, trying.
- 43:03I'm yeah.
- 43:03And I'm trying to give them, they're doing steelman there.
- 43:07What, seems a tricky position that they took.
- 43:10is there any, is there any reason for it other than they didn't want, because
- 43:16they had been elected on a platform that this was terrible and you were coming
- 43:23in to see, is it in fact terrible?
- 43:26Baxter Parker: Yeah, I think that's, it's just very difficult to separate.
- 43:31There, the district's response from the change in leadership at the
- 43:37school board and superintendent level.
- 43:41and so if anything, I think the leadership of Denver public schools
- 43:47during the reform period welcomed this kind of scrutiny, frankly, 'cause it
- 43:52was confident that, what it was doing, would uphold, but, would, would be
- 43:58able to sustain that kind of scrutiny.
- 44:01I think, what's interesting is, that,
- 44:06I think that people on, at both extremes of the education reform
- 44:12debate have an interest in preventing nuanced understanding of these issues.
- 44:22and so I think there's like a combination of factors where the district.
- 44:29Was able to just say, we, aren't interested in exploring this.
- 44:34we're going in a different direction.
- 44:37I think also it's important to remember at the time that the
- 44:40rhetoric, the political rhetoric was
- 44:44was so comprehensive and so longstanding that lots of people actually believed
- 44:50that the reforms had been harmful.
- 44:53and I think still do believe, and so one extent the district just may have
- 44:57not thought it was worth looking at.
- 45:01I think, again, it's important to recognize even in a local control
- 45:05state, that ultimately though the authority over, this data does come
- 45:11from the State Board of Education.
- 45:13And interestingly, the State Board of Education has, members that are
- 45:20elected by congressional district.
- 45:22And that also was a, an interesting process where I needed to try
- 45:30to convince a majority of the members at the time it was nine,
- 45:37to, to vote for in favor of releasing this data.
- 45:43and so that process even after, getting rejected by the district, took, another,
- 45:52year or so, until I was able to finally,
- 45:58access the data.
- 45:59I will share with you just a little bit of inside baseball, but, I was, trying
- 46:05to get the state board to acknowledge my request, because that meant that they
- 46:10would then need to place the item on the agenda and actually have a public
- 46:16meeting about it and potentially ev vote.
- 46:19but they, internally.
- 46:23I, they were basically slow, walking the whole thing.
- 46:28And, so finally, I threatened to show up at public comment, and to
- 46:35basically make my request in public.
- 46:38and, I was told, that wouldn't be necessary and that it would be on
- 46:43the next board meeting's agenda.
- 46:47and so I did go, and you can watch on YouTube, but they grilled me
- 46:50for two hours, in a public meeting.
- 46:54And there was a vote, which I, won by, one vote, a five to four.
- 47:03fortunately two, moderate Democrats, two moderate Democrats, joined with the three
- 47:11Republicans in favor of this research.
- 47:16and and the four Democratic members who have been most.
- 47:21Vocal about their opposition to education reform broadly in charter schools.
- 47:25And,
- 47:28so I'm ask you
- 47:28Andy Rotherham: to speculate on something, Parker, that you may not be
- 47:30able to, but what would you estimate the percentage of the people who
- 47:35are fighting against you on this?
- 47:38What percentage of a sign on their front lawn about how much they love science?
- 47:47Baxter Parker: Yeah.
- 47:48I, won't, speculate.
- 47:50I won't speculate on that, but
- 47:55I'll just, say that, that part of the challenge of even talking about this
- 48:02is that it sounds so unbelievable.
- 48:06Andy Rotherham: No, I tried to tell people this and they were like, they assumed
- 48:10you had to be embellishing for a fact that like you struggle to get the data
- 48:15Baxter Parker: Yes.
- 48:18Yeah, no, an honor of, Bobby Weir, grateful Dead.
- 48:22One of my favorite li lines is if you knew all about what went down,
- 48:27it would burn off both your ears.
- 48:30Andy Rotherham: Oh, I thought you were gonna go with the
- 48:31black throated wind line.
- 48:32You ain't gonna learn what you don't want to know.
- 48:38Baxter Parker: Hey, now you're, now we know why Andy and I are Soul Brothers.
- 48:42But, yeah, I, I, I really, it is, it's, it is, this is happening in almost
- 48:51every area of our political life right now, where it feels like to talk about
- 48:56reality is to sound like a crazy person.
- 48:59Yeah.
- 49:00And, yeah, I think it is really, it's really unfortunate that, that this,
- 49:09this played, or this got to this level.
- 49:11I guess I would just say where was media?
- 49:15Andy Rotherham: Oh, sorry Parker.
- 49:16I just like talk.
- 49:17Where was the media?
- 49:19'cause this seems like a classic David and Goliath story that they would
- 49:23like, the media generally wants stuff to be out in public and so forth.
- 49:28That's their project.
- 49:29So like where were they on all this?
- 49:32We can talk about, I was stunned by the deafening silence when
- 49:36the second study came out.
- 49:37But prior, like where were they when you were fighting to try to get this release?
- 49:41Were they just not aware of it?
- 49:42'cause you were trying to do it discreetly behind the scenes?
- 49:45Baxter Parker: I think that's, the main reason that they were not aware of it,
- 49:50for most of the two years was that I really was trying not to play politics.
- 49:56and one of my strategies in the face of extreme politics is to not play along.
- 50:04and, what I mean by that is that I made my request where I. Work.
- 50:10I'm, on the faculty of the, of a, state University School of public affairs.
- 50:17I have, institutional review, board approval.
- 50:21I did it all in a very straightforward way and did not try to pull strings or lobby
- 50:29or anything like that because I wanted it to stand on its own because I knew that
- 50:34it actually was deserving of approval.
- 50:37Irrespective of any lobbying that I, or strings I could pull.
- 50:41I think ultimately that, that was helpful because once I did decide to
- 50:46contact the media, which was right around the time I was preparing to go
- 50:51and give public comment, I, alerted them.
- 50:55And I want to give a shout out to Erica Meltzer who, was at the time,
- 51:01or just transitioning at the time from, from her role as bureau chief
- 51:06for Chalkbeat, Colorado to, to her role today as, bureau ch, bureau
- 51:13chief of, Chalkbeat, nationally.
- 51:18she, bel she believed me and, then did her due diligence and discovered that
- 51:25what I was telling her was correct and the answer she was getting from people
- 51:30about why were not satisfying to her.
- 51:34And so she actually wrote a series of articles.
- 51:38that encourage anyone to, dig into, because they really
- 51:42do tell, we'll, put those
- 51:42Andy Rotherham: in the show notes.
- 51:43Yeah.
- 51:44Yeah.
- 51:48but then when the study came out though, I was struck how little national
- 51:52attention there was and there was plenty of national attention to the fight
- 51:56over the school board and all that.
- 51:58So how little national attention there was to the results.
- 52:00And even in Colorado, relatively, and honestly in the education
- 52:04community, even the reform community, like I, it, it, there was like
- 52:09a, the silence was deafening.
- 52:12was that your, experience?
- 52:19Baxter Parker: yes.
- 52:19You know what I mean?
- 52:19It's hard because honestly, academics are not very used to having their research get
- 52:25publicized anyway, so I wanna be sure to, note that in and of itself, it's strange
- 52:33to get a lot of attention, but I think.
- 52:35Yes, in terms of the stakes at play, right?
- 52:40How high the stakes are here, and in light of the really, intense politics
- 52:48and, very explicit rhetoric around these reforms, I do think it's somewhat strange
- 52:55that there has not been more coverage of,
- 53:01of these improvements.
- 53:03and I guess I would just point your listeners, and I imagine it, many
- 53:08of you already have seen the article by Ravi Gupta, about New Orleans and
- 53:13the reforms there, and this, I think it's the inconvenient truth of, of
- 53:20reform in New Orleans, but I think it's essentially the same story.
- 53:24You can read that and it's essentially the same story.
- 53:28And, what I mean by that is that I think both.
- 53:31New Orleans and Denver in different ways and to different extents and in different
- 53:35context represents something that is truly threatening to both wings of the
- 53:44education and policy debate in America.
- 53:49They're, they, are truly threatening to the defenders of the existing
- 53:54system because they, really do provide a, an a different alternative, model
- 54:02that, evidence rigorous, empirical evidence indicates can be more,
- 54:08effective than the traditional model.
- 54:11But then also because they, for those on the right who are I think more
- 54:17interested and more willing to basically blow up existing systems, the idea
- 54:24that you could in fact create such dramatic improvement within, without.
- 54:30Doing that.
- 54:32it, both systems are radically different than the traditional
- 54:35one, but they are, still within the paradigm of public education.
- 54:41And I think for people who are, concerned with,
- 54:48abandoning the paradigm of public education writ large,
- 54:52I think it's very threatening.
- 54:56I think another important thing to, to think about is the extent
- 55:02to which traditional school systems are really one of the last remaining
- 55:10entitlements for the middle class and even the upper middle class.
- 55:17They are this thing that, that operates in ways to, to, provide privileged
- 55:27opportunities to people with privilege.
- 55:31And, so I do think that there is, almost like a cultural aversion, to,
- 55:39to challenging the one best system or traditional unitary model in a
- 55:45way that would really cause massive,
- 55:53consequences all across society.
- 55:56And the politics on that
- 55:56Andy Rotherham: are pretty through the looking glass, which I think is hard
- 55:59for people to get their heads around.
- 56:02Jed Wallace: I have to say though, I'm not, having grown so cynical,
- 56:05I'm not at all surprised by the response of other parties.
- 56:10This is what I would've expected.
- 56:12The thing that, I just can't understand is the response of the ed reform
- 56:16world ourselves, and especially of charter school people too.
- 56:20I just, we have this last election and, the, press coverage afterwards talks
- 56:26about, charter school advocates really saying the same thing that the teacher
- 56:33union, advocates were talking about.
- 56:36and it's like we ourselves can't claim that this has been, historic progress.
- 56:41We ourselves can't, tell the Denver story.
- 56:45It's like we shy away from it.
- 56:46I think we shy away from New Orleans too.
- 56:48The first thing we say, as Ed Reformers in urban context is, oh, we would
- 56:53never wanna get to New Orleans.
- 56:54Don't get me wrong, we're not talking about New Orleans.
- 56:56Oh my God.
- 56:56Not New Orleans.
- 56:58when really there's nothing to be ashamed of about the progress that's been made
- 57:02in New Orleans over the last 20 years.
- 57:03All sorts of problems, all sorts of mistakes.
- 57:05Like we made mistakes in Denver too, of course.
- 57:08but Parker, what's your reaction to, that?
- 57:12how do you think the ed reform world ourselves are responding to this?
- 57:16And are we telling the story as we should be?
- 57:22Baxter Parker: Yeah.
- 57:22So this is a complicated question and with a complicated answer,
- 57:27but I'm gonna try, I'll try not to, go off in lots of different
- 57:31directions and try to stay focused.
- 57:32But, it's important to recognize that the reaction of reformers to both New Orleans
- 57:41and Denver is can't be disconnected from the larger campaign of opposition that
- 57:50has been in place for over a decade now.
- 57:54and.
- 57:55And so I think especially when we consider just the comprehensive nature
- 58:00of the existing system and how truly dominant it is even still today, 30 years
- 58:08after what we first began introducing these alternative delivery mechanisms,
- 58:14it is, still, I think, true that, that many people have an almost instinctual,
- 58:24sort of sympathy for the traditional system.
- 58:28And so I think the more that people heard that messaging, the harder
- 58:33it was for them to, to feel brave enough to even, challenge it.
- 58:41And these things are complicated, right?
- 58:43And so in some places, some of these claims are true.
- 58:46In other places they're not.
- 58:49I guess one thing I think is important.
- 58:56I'm gonna try to say this as concisely as possible, but I think
- 59:00that within re within the reform movement, there have always been
- 59:05these multiple wings of, reform.
- 59:08And so I think that certainly, Denver is representative of a particular wing,
- 59:16but there have, but there also have been others with, who have supported
- 59:21the reforms, but not necessarily for the reasons that the people who
- 59:26led the reforms in Denver and in New Orleans, might have for themselves.
- 59:33And so what I mean by that is that I think, there is still a big contingent
- 59:40of people who consider themselves education reformers who are primarily
- 59:45about improving the existing system.
- 59:49They're the Marshall Tuckers of, the, basically trying to, double
- 59:54down on, on the core model.
- 59:59and I think what's interesting about one of the things that's interesting
- 1:00:02about Denver is that it combined these people who were really trying to
- 1:00:07improve the traditional system, without necessarily changing it all that much.
- 1:00:15and then other people who actually were on a, on, it really saw a, an opportunity
- 1:00:23to completely re reinvent everything.
- 1:00:27And so I think that part of what happened in Denver was that you,
- 1:00:32have people who, as charters and innovation schools continue to
- 1:00:37grow, and as that generates more and more backlash from the traditional
- 1:00:42system, including from teachers,
- 1:00:47Though, the people who maybe were not necessarily on board with the theory of
- 1:00:53change, that created the reforms, but they were supportive of them in general,
- 1:00:58started to get uncomfortable with them in a way that made them, unwilling even to
- 1:01:04defend them even in the face of success.
- 1:01:08and I, do think,
- 1:01:13that is definitely,
- 1:01:17partly responsible for this.
- 1:01:20I also think another aspect of this is that context is so different everywhere.
- 1:01:25There's so much variation across the country, in the
- 1:01:29way that these things work.
- 1:01:31That there are lots of features in Denver that I don't think people
- 1:01:36ever really fully understood or even were willing to believe were true.
- 1:01:43and, that, then, on.
- 1:01:46That combined with the nationalization of the political debate around
- 1:01:52these reforms meant that, it became really difficult to hold on to the
- 1:01:59differences and, to live in that nuance.
- 1:02:04live in the question like I like to tell my students, but that I think that
- 1:02:08the more, and, certainly as polarize, things get more and more polarized.
- 1:02:14The, center actually shrinks.
- 1:02:17and the space for that kind of nuanced, reform, goes away.
- 1:02:25Andy Rotherham: You said an interesting thing there that I, mean we need to, we
- 1:02:28don't need to double click on it, but just, you've got people who kind of wanna,
- 1:02:31there's almost like three camps now.
- 1:02:32You've got people who wanna double down on the existing system.
- 1:02:34You got people who wanna double down on the existing principles, but are open
- 1:02:39to new ways for delivery and so forth.
- 1:02:41And then you got some people who, neither of those things is very
- 1:02:44interested, interesting to them.
- 1:02:46They're pushing off in new, very different and sort of radical directions.
- 1:02:50And they're
- 1:02:52and, maybe it's part of the reasons where it's a stasis around reform
- 1:02:54is none, neither of those camps are entirely strong enough to carry the day.
- 1:03:00Baxter Parker: Yeah.
- 1:03:01Yes.
- 1:03:01I, think that's right.
- 1:03:02And,
- 1:03:05and that, the attempt to do these reforms in a way that was not like explicitly
- 1:03:15adversarial to the district itself did I think, cause this, Create a dynamic
- 1:03:23where people may have been unwilling to, do things that in other places, in other
- 1:03:30contexts they would absolutely have done.
- 1:03:33and so just to give you an example, I mentioned there are
- 1:03:3750 charter schools in Denver.
- 1:03:39Half of them are in district facilities.
- 1:03:44And so it, it's just a very, that's, it's a fundamental thing that then
- 1:03:52arguably compromises charters, right?
- 1:03:56In the sense that maybe then they aren't as, autonomous and willing
- 1:04:00to be themselves, et cetera.
- 1:04:02We can talk about that, but it's, not clear that we would have 50
- 1:04:06charter schools in Denver if the district hadn't offered half of
- 1:04:10them space in its own facilities.
- 1:04:14And so it, it, we have to be real about, about the,
- 1:04:19politics of the possible, right?
- 1:04:22And, that like what it takes to actually make progress here it is, I don't, I
- 1:04:29think is probably some level of compromise between these sort of idealistic visions
- 1:04:35of what we think should happen and what is actually possible, on the ground.
- 1:04:42Jed Wallace: I'm glad that you, believe that there are some
- 1:04:44idealistic visions that are out there.
- 1:04:45I'm not aware of any.
- 1:04:49and,
- 1:04:51Baxter Parker: let me give you one.
- 1:04:52let me just say it as an example.
- 1:04:54Like the idea that we are going to just like suddenly flip a switch and
- 1:04:59we could make all schools, charter schools is I think some people's vision
- 1:05:06and yet not, I think a realistic.
- 1:05:10vision for the immediate future or one that, likely.
- 1:05:14And so the, and the reason for that, again, I'm not like, part of this is
- 1:05:19my own learning through this, where it is just remarkable how durable the
- 1:05:27existing, traditional model really is.
- 1:05:31And, and as we all know, there are lots of places where charters are really
- 1:05:37operating at the margins, of the system.
- 1:05:41And, and I am, I, one of the lessons I learned from, from, Paul Hill and,
- 1:05:49also I guess from Ted Calie is just the, importance of recognizing that
- 1:05:54charters are an institutional innovation and that what they're really about
- 1:06:00is, providing an alternative model.
- 1:06:05For fulfilling the public and private purposes of education in a free society.
- 1:06:10And from my point of view that if we're serious about that, then that means,
- 1:06:20trying to recognize the extent to which autonomy at the school level, choice among
- 1:06:26schools, accountability for performance are all things that are actually,
- 1:06:32that actually require public action.
- 1:06:36And that probably can't be done solely through the private sphere.
- 1:06:41And so I think that, I don't want to try to characterize anyone in any, kind
- 1:06:48of generalistic sense or, whatever.
- 1:06:51But it's more, I'm just trying for us.
- 1:06:54To say, to recognize that likely the answer is going to be different
- 1:06:59in different contexts everywhere.
- 1:07:01And that there are like different stages of this, work that actually we are at
- 1:07:10different, like there are different places that are at different stages.
- 1:07:14And so I think we need to be much more thoughtful about what that means
- 1:07:19and, like what it would look like to have, a sort of unified theory
- 1:07:26of change amidst the reality of that kind of diversity of experience.
- 1:07:33So I don't know if that,
- 1:07:35Jed Wallace: this, this, I could go on for another half hour here.
- 1:07:38We, I, but, we, but I have at least another question or two here.
- 1:07:43I, appreciate Parker, you spending this time this, and I love the nuance.
- 1:07:46this conversation is great.
- 1:07:48I like, I will also say, I think there's just some broad swaths that are true here.
- 1:07:54One is that the backlash has just been scary.
- 1:07:58and it's making people, some people lack the courage to go through it.
- 1:08:03And, the experience in Indianapolis right now and what people are living
- 1:08:05through there, I think speaks to that.
- 1:08:09if you, name the, unnameable, this is what happens to you.
- 1:08:12Second thing is, I don't know if it's our natural impulses or if we're being
- 1:08:17coached to, into a point of saying.
- 1:08:21Don't say anything negative about the traditional system.
- 1:08:23The, on the margin voters don't like it, so give up your critique and
- 1:08:29without any critique, then we don't have any fuel to keep going forward.
- 1:08:33But the thing I think more than anything else is.
- 1:08:36In places where we get to 30, 40, 50% of kids in charter
- 1:08:40schools, we run out of ideas.
- 1:08:42We run outta gas.
- 1:08:43What's happening all over the place.
- 1:08:45And the thing that's just interesting about New Orleans is I don't think
- 1:08:48that the storm was the anomaly.
- 1:08:50The anomaly was the vision.
- 1:08:52An idea for finishing the job and the way we finish the job
- 1:08:56is not the way we start the job.
- 1:08:58You've got to bring all sorts of schools into innovation
- 1:09:00status or something like that.
- 1:09:02In New Orleans, they were unapologetic about it.
- 1:09:05There are gonna become charter schools, that's fine.
- 1:09:07In other places we might wanna call them different things.
- 1:09:09Mayoral academies, innovation schools, renaissance schools.
- 1:09:13I don't care what they are, finishing the evolution of the system toward
- 1:09:17an end state, consistent with what we started in the first place.
- 1:09:21And our inability to say what that thing is and to call it a noble thing to aspire
- 1:09:26to is, in my mind, the central failure.
- 1:09:30Yeah.
- 1:09:30That's holding us back right now.
- 1:09:33Baxter Parker: So,
- 1:09:33let me, respond to some of this, in a couple different ways.
- 1:09:36'cause I think you're, I think this is a really important issue that I
- 1:09:42certainly think about, maybe all the time.
- 1:09:47but so I think, First of all, part of what, we talked earlier about what, I find
- 1:09:56so interesting about, Denver and one of the things I find so interesting about
- 1:10:00Denver is precisely this point, is that the reforms were built around the idea
- 1:10:09that the traditional model was failing and was destined to fail into the future.
- 1:10:17And not only was it ineffective and un and, inefficient, it was unjust.
- 1:10:25And, I think we have somehow lost the ability to claim this injustice and to
- 1:10:32name it and to stand for the idea that we can and must do better as a, free society.
- 1:10:42And, and so yeah, I mean I think this is really one of
- 1:10:46the things that is, definitely.
- 1:10:50most fascinating for me is how much pressure there has been
- 1:10:56to abandon that, that kind of, that way of talking about this.
- 1:11:03because it really does mean that actually today, even at, systems in, most places
- 1:11:11actually still have almost all of the pathologies that led to the creation of
- 1:11:19this reform movement in the first place.
- 1:11:22And so it's something that again, is, why, is another reason why it's very,
- 1:11:27important to recognize the elements of Denver's reforms that are not about
- 1:11:33charters, not about innovation schools.
- 1:11:37They're actually about making the traditional system function.
- 1:11:43More equitably for everyone.
- 1:11:46And we've talked a lot about charters and I know, that's in, in, innovation schools
- 1:11:52are an example, but, or another example, but, things like forced teacher placement,
- 1:12:01Like one of that was one of, Tom Boberg.
- 1:12:04I'll never forget, I, witnessed how angry it made him when he learned that
- 1:12:12the, only schools that were receiving forced place teachers were the schools
- 1:12:18serving the most vulnerable students.
- 1:12:21And so it, people need to know that, that, Tom Boberg, made a change in 2010, said an
- 1:12:29after a state law that helped, passed by.
- 1:12:32Mike Johnson, now mayor.
- 1:12:35but at the state and district level, they were working to fundamentally change
- 1:12:40these elements of the traditional model, which are, demonstrably inequitable.
- 1:12:47and, and that, that's a great example where people may not know, but the,
- 1:12:53Colorado Education Association, the Statewide Teachers Union and
- 1:12:57the Denver Teachers Union spent a decade stewing in court to block the
- 1:13:05provision that ended force placements.
- 1:13:09And I think it, that's just, if we could talk politics for a second,
- 1:13:12it's really important to think about when were they doing that?
- 1:13:15Why did they sue instead of fight publicly?
- 1:13:20I'm almost sure that it's because Obama was in the White
- 1:13:24House reform was bipartisan.
- 1:13:28The idea that we weren't gonna address things like last in,
- 1:13:31first out or fourth placement of teachers or in equitable internal
- 1:13:37district funding allocations, right?
- 1:13:40Like those were not gonna probably, at least at that
- 1:13:43time sell well with the public.
- 1:13:45So they went to court and they lost repeatedly and finally
- 1:13:49lost at the Supreme Court.
- 1:13:50But like those are still issues that people fighting about today in Colorado
- 1:13:56and, like you need to understand charter politics and choice politics
- 1:14:02in connection to that, those politics also, that we're actually still fighting
- 1:14:08to defend the existing system tooth and nail, even in places where there
- 1:14:13has been massive change for the better.
- 1:14:17Andy Rotherham: So lightning round question for you.
- 1:14:20How much of this overlay every, a lot of people are watching?
- 1:14:23So Michael Bennett, he worked for the former mayor, became the superintendent,
- 1:14:27was appointed to the Senate, has won reelection, multiple times since then,
- 1:14:33but he's now, his term was then for a few more years in the Senate, but he is
- 1:14:37running for governor and he's running against the state's attorney general.
- 1:14:43And the big flashpoint seems to be like, how much are we about, we democrats
- 1:14:48about building for the future versus how much that just fight Trump now?
- 1:14:54is there an education overlay to that primary?
- 1:14:57sorry, I said lightning round then I asked you a long question, but, okay.
- 1:15:00Oh, oh.
- 1:15:01Is there an education overlay to that primary education reform
- 1:15:04overlay related to some of the stuff we've been talking about?
- 1:15:07Number one and number two, do you
- 1:15:08have any predictions on how that primary is gonna go?
- 1:15:13Baxter Parker: I definitely do think there is some overlay, in the upcoming
- 1:15:19primary, it for, the governor in Colorado.
- 1:15:24I think really, and this is again, in some ways why it's so interesting
- 1:15:28is that Denver in many ways is this microcosm of the larger national
- 1:15:34challenges around these issues.
- 1:15:35And democrats are debating whether we should, whether Democrats should
- 1:15:39moderate or whether they should, double down on and move left.
- 1:15:46and I think that in some ways, like that actually is a question in this,
- 1:15:53in this upcoming election is whether, whether there is actually still a
- 1:16:00vital center, whether there is still a place where people can agree, that,
- 1:16:09We may, not be able to agree about whether to keep the system exactly as
- 1:16:13it is or whether to blow it up entirely, but at least we can agree that we should
- 1:16:18be doing things that, make progress.
- 1:16:21and there's lots of evidence that Colorado has had, lots of progress
- 1:16:26with, not just in Denver, but across the state, through many of the reform
- 1:16:32strategies that have now become so unpopular among a certain set.
- 1:16:39that's one point I would just make though about this, is that I do think
- 1:16:42it's, a mistake to think that reform is unpopular in Denver be because
- 1:16:49of the flipping back and forth.
- 1:16:51First of all, part of what makes Denver so, interesting is that,
- 1:16:56reformers held almost un unanimous control for almost a decade.
- 1:17:03Five board elections.
- 1:17:05Four bond elections.
- 1:17:07So that is, the change is actually post 2019.
- 1:17:13And I think if anything, what we're seeing is the incoherence of trying to
- 1:17:19undo reforms which have created better outcomes and more equitable access.
- 1:17:26And so it's the, I hope that the, the debate doesn't devolve into these
- 1:17:33national level, talking points, because I think actually what's most exciting
- 1:17:40about Colorado is that we can be a place where people actually focus
- 1:17:46on what's real and what's in front of them and, and are practical and
- 1:17:51pragmatic about, about what's possible.
- 1:17:54And, and so I'm hopeful there,
- 1:17:59I, do think it does, it will come down to whether Democrats in the state
- 1:18:04and other, moderates, we have lots of independents, whether they will be
- 1:18:10able to come together and stand up for, improvement, even if that improvement
- 1:18:16requires challenging the status quo.
- 1:18:22Jed Wallace: Status quo.
- 1:18:22Love it.
- 1:18:22On the macro, any, my, my last You got away without the predict.
- 1:18:26Andy Rotherham: Do you have a prediction or is it just hard to tell yet?
- 1:18:30Baxter Parker: Oh, I think it's very hard to tell.
- 1:18:31I think, I think definitely, Michael Bennett has a lot of support.
- 1:18:37bill Wiser has lots of support too, but there's actually lots of overlap there.
- 1:18:42And so that's where it get, perhaps will get interesting.
- 1:18:45But I think, yeah, I think I do.
- 1:18:48Just if we could just make sure to talk about, what concerns me about, the future
- 1:18:55more broadly of this work and, About, some of the sort of immediate points
- 1:19:02in terms of, the need for leadership.
- 1:19:05I think you know more.
- 1:19:07Yeah.
- 1:19:07Andy Rotherham: This is your,
- 1:19:08moment to do that because I think Jed was about to bring us in for a
- 1:19:10landing, so you get this, as well.
- 1:19:12This is, it was really in this, I this is fantastic as you lawyer,
- 1:19:15as you lawyers say, this is
- 1:19:17Jed Wallace: your closing statement.
- 1:19:18Yeah.
- 1:19:19But it was, it give us the future, in Denver specifically too.
- 1:19:23Optimism, pessimism, and it seemed like you were going there naturally Anyway.
- 1:19:26Pat Parker.
- 1:19:27Yeah.
- 1:19:28Baxter Parker: Yeah.
- 1:19:28so I think it, it is, tempting to look at Denver and say, oh, reform has failed.
- 1:19:34And look, it, we had to do something else.
- 1:19:37And I think, that is a mistake because it underestimates the extent to which the
- 1:19:43reforms have really changed the allocation of power and control in the city.
- 1:19:52and, I think also.
- 1:19:54Underestimates, the extent to which the system has been, changed in ways that make
- 1:20:01it demonstrably more effective and more equitable that are gonna be hard to undo.
- 1:20:06On top of that, remember we have 30,000 students out of 80,000 that are in
- 1:20:13autonomous public schools in Denver still.
- 1:20:16And, and if anything, I think one example of this is that, even though all of
- 1:20:24this stuff is still so controversial, the school board, the new school board,
- 1:20:29which is now controlled entirely by, candidates that were supported by the
- 1:20:34teacher's union, and they have been very vocal about their opposition to
- 1:20:38reforms, they're likely to approve.
- 1:20:41next week unanimously the renewal of five.
- 1:20:45Charter schools and just, and, are also likely to renew, Denver's one innovation
- 1:20:53zone with seven innovation schools.
- 1:20:56And it's just important to, to not yeah, sometimes we can get distracted,
- 1:21:03by other things that are more, maybe more sexy or more exciting.
- 1:21:09but actually the, sort of long-term sustainability work is, I think the
- 1:21:15kind of work that is what will actually get us to scale, in, a more broad way.
- 1:21:23And so I really respect and admire the work that Brandon Brown is doing in
- 1:21:28mine trusts in Indianapolis because it's so representative for me of
- 1:21:33exactly what we've been talking about, this whole conversation, where as
- 1:21:38that system has fragmented over time.
- 1:21:42the new operators who actually care about public education as a goal and not a
- 1:21:49particular set of institutions, right?
- 1:21:51Big lesson from Paul Hill, but the people that are in that city that are there to
- 1:21:55provide public education and that have that as their goal, they recognize that
- 1:22:00something has to change in the future if they are gonna go to the next level.
- 1:22:06And I think, again, that Denver has lots of those elements already in place.
- 1:22:10And, it's rather than trying to, which is better, which is worse, like for
- 1:22:16me, both of them need to be held up as examples because this kind of work is
- 1:22:20going to be different because we have 50 different states with vastly different,
- 1:22:27educational governance models, et cetera.
- 1:22:30And I am,
- 1:22:35I, am very hopeful that,
- 1:22:39that, the.
- 1:22:41These examples will actually, become the foundation for the,
- 1:22:47this a new vision of the future.
- 1:22:50one thing I just gotta say about your, some of your, focus on the
- 1:22:56North Star, the need for North Star and the short movement.
- 1:23:00I think one thing I'm concerned about is that I do think there is a tension
- 1:23:05between the growth goal there, on the North Star and the goal to the
- 1:23:14question to what's next, all kids.
- 1:23:19and the,
- 1:23:22the, the other, what is the,
- 1:23:28the, the, other on the star, remind me of your, sorry, I'm, blanking on
- 1:23:35your, but basically that there's a tension between Oh, public that, apol, I
- 1:23:41apologize, but this tension between the growth of, these alternatives and then
- 1:23:47the desire to hold strong to the idea that we're not actually trying to do
- 1:23:53something other than public education.
- 1:23:55We are actually trying to provide education at the public
- 1:23:58expense in the most equitable and effective way we possibly can.
- 1:24:03And for me, that's intention with growth, especially because we know that these,
- 1:24:11sectors are so different across the country that I think it's possible that
- 1:24:16some growth in some places actually doesn't move us towards the question
- 1:24:23two or to, or, and, doesn't provide a new vision for what public might mean.
- 1:24:30So I don't know if you wanna respond to that or if we have time, but I just, I
- 1:24:34wanna, think about whether that, whether the, pol, the political pressure to
- 1:24:41maintain coherence within the movement might limit our ability to actually,
- 1:24:52message what we're trying to do more clearly to the public.
- 1:24:58Jed Wallace: we could definitely go down this for one, for quite, quite a
- 1:25:00while in terms of landing this plane.
- 1:25:02I will just say that I do, I did choose the five points of, a,
- 1:25:07star for the charter school world.
- 1:25:10very intentionally, and I don't think that you can make it work with four.
- 1:25:14And what you're basically saying is, Hey, if you pull out, the part
- 1:25:19of qe the question two part that results in all schools getting
- 1:25:23better and all schools getting fairer, then it, falls apart on us.
- 1:25:28And and I think it's really great to have people like you pushing on us and
- 1:25:32saying, Hey, you've gotta make sure that this all wraps together into, a
- 1:25:36comprehensive vision for the future.
- 1:25:39but I also just think what you've shared today, Parker, along so
- 1:25:42many lines, it's just so helpful.
- 1:25:44It's just so help, I've learned a ton from this.
- 1:25:47I'm looking forward to our beer and coffee time as I come and
- 1:25:50visit my folks in the months ahead.
- 1:25:51But just thank you for this.
- 1:25:53Thank you for your work.
- 1:25:54I, can't wait.
- 1:25:55I know you're working on a big book.
- 1:25:56I can't wait to see that.
- 1:25:58just really appreciate everything you've shared today.
- 1:26:02Andy Rotherham: Thank you very
- 1:26:02much.
- 1:26:04Just, yeah.
- 1:26:04Fantastic.
- 1:26:05Yes, a lot.
- 1:26:06I think a lot here for people who listened and not just a deep dive on Denver
- 1:26:11where I agree with you, by the way.
- 1:26:12I don't think reform failed.
- 1:26:13I think reform politics failed and we've talked about that before and there's,
- 1:26:17some reasons for that.
- 1:26:19and so on that, but also then just the more larger implications
- 1:26:22of it and, what it means.
- 1:26:23So thank you just so much for your, your
- 1:26:26Baxter Parker: time.
- 1:26:26lemme close on one, one point real quickly that I hope will resonate with
- 1:26:29your listeners is that one of the most,
- 1:26:33hopeful aspects of my work, now that I'm teaching, and researching is that
- 1:26:41I now have students who are in my graduate courses who went to schools in
- 1:26:48Denver that did not exist a decade ago.
- 1:26:54And, that I'm hopeful because there are thousands, tens of thousands.
- 1:27:00of those students that are, in, in coming out of better systems like
- 1:27:07Denver and in New Orleans and in Houston and all over the country.
- 1:27:11And that, there really is a, new generation of, young people that I think
- 1:27:18are gonna be unwilling to have their experience denied and, and are, going to
- 1:27:25challenge the idea that, that there is only one way to provide public education.
- 1:27:32And, that, that keeps me hopeful.
- 1:27:36Jed Wallace: Love that.
- 1:27:37Love that.
- 1:27:38Thanks.
- 1:27:39Thank you so much, Parker.
- 1:27:40Thanks Jed.
- 1:27:40Good to see you.
- 1:27:41Yeah, you too.
- 1:27:42Baxter Parker: You guys take care.