Latest / TheThinkingAtheist / Hell for the Holidays? Dealing with Religious Families on Christmas
Transcript
- 0:05The Thinking Atheist. It's not a person, it's a symbol, an idea.
- 0:10The population of atheists in this country is going through the rule, rejecting
- 0:14faith, pursuing knowledge, challenging the sacred. If I tell the truth,
- 0:20it's because I tell the truth, not because I put my hand on a
- 0:24book and made a wish and working together for a more rational world. Take
- 0:29the risk of thinking, feel so much more happiness. Truth Beausian wisdom will
- 0:33come to you that way. Assume nothing, question everything, and start thinking.
- 0:42This is the Thinking Atheist podcast hosted by Seth Andrews. Two parts to
- 0:58the show today. The first part it's just you and me phone calls from
- 1:03people talking about their experiences. And then I'm going to talk to an actual
- 1:07expert psychologist and religious recovery consultant. Her name is doctor Marlene Winnell, and
- 1:15she deals a lot with people dealing with religious family, post religious trauma,
- 1:23etc. She's going to be the last half of the broadcast today, going
- 1:26to be great interesting article before I talk to you about how you deal with
- 1:36family over the holidays. On the website the Goodmen Project goodmenproject dot com.
- 1:44This is a religious site and I sometimes talk about how there are people in
- 1:49the faith who are on our side when they look around at people banging their
- 1:55bibles and shouting the name of God. And if the best version of Christ
- 2:00appeared, he would be very upset with them because they were not emulating meekness,
- 2:07kindness, generosity, humility, etc. And so the Good Men Project
- 2:13published this article by Dan Foster November nineteenth, twenty twenty three. And as
- 2:21I wait for the switchboard to populate, let me read this. The title
- 2:23says, this research shows that being a Christian makes you less like Christ.
- 2:32Now again caveat. Anybody who's done christ studies knows that there is a really
- 2:38good Christ and there is a shitty, bigoted, petty, very awful Christ.
- 2:45They are both in the Bible, depending on where you look. But
- 2:47we're just talking about the good Christ, right, We're looking at the happy,
- 2:52clappy, love your neighbor, you know. Turn the other cheek,
- 2:55be meek, feed the poor Christ. Article says the preacher man paced back
- 3:02and forth across the stage, banging his fist on an open palm. Red
- 3:08faced with sweat pouring from his brow, he was building to the climax of
- 3:14his sermon and was about to deliver an impassioned plea to the impressionable young minds
- 3:20before him. I sat in the congregation, and boy, oh boy,
- 3:23was I desperate to know what I needed to do to please God, or
- 3:28perhaps appease God. Finally, the preacher arrived at the punchline of his message.
- 3:36He leaned forward across the pulpits and with a pained expression on his face,
- 3:40delivered the knockout blow. He said, if being a Christian were illegal,
- 3:46would there be enough evidence in your life to get you arrested, tried,
- 3:51and convicted beyond all reasonable doubt? Then he repeated it for effect.
- 4:00Well, gosh, I thought to myself, I really don't know if there
- 4:02would be enough evidence, and I descend it into a pit of anxiety,
- 4:08wondering if I were Christian enough for God. I look back on it now,
- 4:14and I realized that the kind of evidence the preacher man was referring to
- 4:18was things like telling your school friends about Jesus, reading your Bible, praying,
- 4:24attending church, and not sinning too much. This was the stuff of
- 4:28performance based religion. It has very little to do with actually following Jesus.
- 4:35I see that now, the real evidence of Christian faith is expressed primarily in
- 4:42our attitudes and actions towards others rather than jumping through the hoops of religion.
- 4:48And again, this is a Christian writing the article. But stick with me.
- 4:54Here's a real challenge for you. If you call yourself a Christian and
- 4:57you really want to know if there is evidence that cried has made a difference
- 5:00in your life, then ask a non Christian, would you know I'm a
- 5:04Christian if I never told you that I was be prepared to confront an uncomfortable
- 5:12truth. When researching for his book on christian David Kinneman discovered something incredible.
- 5:20Eighty four percent of non Christians say they know a Christian personally, yet only
- 5:28fifteen percent say the lifestyles of those believers are noticeably different in a good way.
- 5:36Or to put it another way, most people who know a Christian don't
- 5:40notice any observable positive difference in the life of that Christian. In fact,
- 5:46the study by the Barna Group asked non Christians about their perception of Christians and
- 5:51discovered that eighty seven percent of those surveyed said Christians were judgmental, eighty five
- 5:59percent said Christians were hypocritical, and seventy eight percent said Christians were out of
- 6:05touch. Ouch. If you're a Christian, perhaps you wile against these damning
- 6:13statistics. Those non Christians have got it all wrong. You might say,
- 6:16we are simply misunderstood. However, it turns out when it comes to hypocrisy,
- 6:25judgmentalism, and self righteousness, many Christians are self reporting offenders guilty as
- 6:32charged. In fact, Christians are statistically more likely to display the actions and
- 6:40attitudes of the Pharisees than they are to display the actions and attitudes of Christ.
- 6:47And then he goes into statistics some polling data reports that are coming in
- 6:54from believers that talk about how they practice or do not practice their Christianity.
- 7:00It's worth a Google search if you want to go deeper. The Good Men
- 7:03Project research shows that being a Christian makes you less like Christ. Now,
- 7:13I think this is very much the case. Everywhere we go we see people
- 7:17who are giving lip service to their faith and they are practicing and kind of
- 7:21the framework of belief. You pray before the meal, thank you Jesus for
- 7:27the mashed potatoes. Someone's in the hospital, we pray for them. We
- 7:31go to Sunday morning church, maybe Sunday night, and if you're really quote
- 7:36unquote devout. Let's call it Wednesday night two. Most people, I think,
- 7:42just go Sunday morning and then they go off the hook. Let's go
- 7:46eat, enjoy the rest of our day. You own a Bible, you
- 7:50don't really know the Bible, you don't care. You are living essentially a
- 7:57non religious life. You claim divine protection. You're locking your doors at night,
- 8:03You're installing security cameras. You're locking and loading your guns because God's not
- 8:07going to protect them. Right, God's not going to protect me. I've
- 8:11got to protect myself. This is someone who does not really put trust in
- 8:16someone who is supposed to be ultimately trustworthy. I find that very telling.
- 8:22I'm interested in how many people who claim that God wants them to have health
- 8:28and wealth and wisdom continue to try to solve their own problems check their medicine
- 8:35cabinets. How many Christians get wasted at a party, who get drunk with
- 8:43wine in contradiction to that command in the Bible. How many Christians use the
- 8:50Lord's name in vain Jesus Christ. I know that one is a little more
- 8:56rare. I was always afraid of doing it, rate of blaspheming. How
- 9:01many people don't say or do anything Christian until they're either put on the spot
- 9:07or sitting in the freaking pew. I'm just saying anyway, we're talking about
- 9:16dealing with religious families. Those of you who are going to enter the lion's
- 9:20den, so to speak, and be in the presence of a religious family
- 9:24over the holidays. How would you deal? What would you do? How
- 9:31do you approach? Maybe you've got advice for other people, Maybe you've got
- 9:35a horror story about something that happened to you when you just want event,
- 9:39I'm your guy, I'm your bartender. Call me and we'll talk. Three
- 9:46four seven. Hi. Who's this? Hey, My name's Jessica. How
- 9:50are you doing. I'm well, Jessica. We're talking about religious family on
- 9:54the holidays. So I am a native New Yorker. My father's family is
- 10:00Wish. My mother's family is Catholic. Every Thanksgiving, until very recently,
- 10:05we would go up to Westchester to my conservative Catholic aunts and uncle's home for
- 10:09Thanksgivings. Over the course of all the years that we have been going to
- 10:15these parties, as these political issues have come up, this one very very
- 10:20small part of my mother's family who are conservative and everybody else is progressive,
- 10:26left liberal, all that good stuff. But going to this one house,
- 10:30because this is my mother's aunt that's really more like a sister to her because
- 10:33they're close in age, always means that there's a battle. And as my
- 10:37aunts and uncle have gotten older, it's gotten worse because they've lost their filters.
- 10:43So do you feel like they're anticipating the opportunity to go mono imano so
- 10:48to speak? In this room? Oh, hey, we've got a territory.
- 10:52Definitely. Now, My brothers and I are all anti theist atheists and
- 10:56like pretty strong about it, and we have been since we were kids,
- 11:01and so like. Ironically, this aunt was my sponsor for my Catholic confirmation
- 11:05that I was forced to make two weeks before I made my BOTMTX boy,
- 11:09which I was also forced to make and didn't want to do. So she
- 11:13tends to think that when we come to her house that we should respect her
- 11:16by conforming to what she demands of us. She very cheekily asks one of
- 11:24us to say, grace my brother's or eye. She's fully aware that you
- 11:28were not a religious person, oh a hundred percent. So the last time
- 11:35that I went up there for Thanksgiving, which was before COVID. She asked
- 11:39me to say grace, knowing that none of us are religious, and I
- 11:43looked at her and I said, you know, it's very interesting that you
- 11:46want to sit here and give thanks for the food in front of you,
- 11:50when what that tells me is that the god you believe in picks and chooses
- 11:54who gets to eat and who gets to starve. And aren't you grateful to
- 11:58be one of the ones to eat? And there was a very long silence,
- 12:03and then I said, dig in, everybody, and we all start
- 12:07to eat. Was anything else said after that? Yes? My aunt got
- 12:11very angry at me and told me that I needed to repent. I don't
- 12:16know much anybody else. If I was the known atheist in the room somebody
- 12:20asked me to say grace, I would say goodbye, enjoy your meal.
- 12:26You know, I thought about that, But I'm also, like, you
- 12:28know, a good bit away from home when I'm up in Westchester, and
- 12:33I think it's far more hilarious to hold them accountable for what it is they
- 12:37claim to be true by telling them. Isn't it interesting that if your God
- 12:41is real, he chooses who eats? And who starves. No, I
- 12:45think your approach is absolutely terrific. I'm just saying after I said that,
- 12:50I think I would have probably removed myself. That's just me. I certainly
- 12:54you know, yeah, I don't wan. What do you want to do
- 12:56and how you want to do it? And honestly, if they do it
- 12:58again, call us. We got a bunch of listeners who have your back.
- 13:01Well, just show up at their house and say this is inappropriate.
- 13:05Okay. Can I give a little bit of advice to people who are dealing
- 13:09with religious families. Sure, don't want it affects you personally because it isn't
- 13:13personal. They may make it sound personal because they're telling you you will go
- 13:18to hell, you are a bad person. You you you, you you.
- 13:22But actually all they're saying is I am scared. I don't know,
- 13:28I can't explain, and you are bothering my personal comfort zone. And for
- 13:33that you owe those people absolutely nothing beyond your basic civility. Eat your food.
- 13:41If you must argue with them, do so without getting angry, because
- 13:45you are in the right and it is not for you to get angry when
- 13:48you are in the right. Let me chew on that one. Jessica,
- 13:52thanks for calling. I appreciate it, take care, We'll see you by
- 13:58It's not per personal. I understand what she's saying that many people preaching outwardly,
- 14:05I think, are trying to convince themselves inwardly. Dan Barker used to
- 14:11talk about how if scientists were always affirming and reaffirming the discoveries or the the
- 14:18scientific theories that they held over and over, and then they held worship services
- 14:24and prayed and affirmed and at bumper stickers, they would seem rather insecure about
- 14:30whatever these scientific theories or facts were. And yet we see in religion there's
- 14:35this constant repetition, and many times when people are trying to convince you,
- 14:41it does feel like they're trying to convince themselves. But I'm not convinced,
- 14:46having been through this, that much of it is not hugely personal. If
- 14:52someone is even if they are also trying to convince themselves telling you that you
- 14:56are broken, that you are not capable of morality or goodness, perhaps an
- 15:03agent of Satan. You're raising your kids wrong, You're part of the problem
- 15:07in this world. You're going to burn and scream and writhe and pain unimaginable
- 15:11agony forever. I mean, I don't know if you can get much more
- 15:15personal than that, but I take the larger point right, don't get sucked
- 15:20into a shouting match over Christmas Turkey because you're not going to change any minds.
- 15:28Everybody leaves frustrated. If you're going to leave, just leave. You
- 15:31know what. This environment is not suiting me. I don't feel comfortable here.
- 15:37I certainly don't feel welcomed here. Merry Christmas. I'm going to finish
- 15:43the day with people who do respect boundaries and accept me for who I am
- 15:48as an equal. Have a nice holiday. I'm out seven zero six high.
- 15:52Who's this Hey, my name is James. Thanks for calling James.
- 15:56We're talking about families on the holidays, so I'm going to be spending family
- 16:02Thanksgiving with my family. My family is a religious family, as the podcasts
- 16:07asking, and it's going to be slightly different. I only recently came clean
- 16:15to my mother that I'm an atheist now. And I, like many people
- 16:18who call into this show and many of these newer atheists, I was raised
- 16:22in an extremely rigid fundamentalist background and my mother is still aligned with that,
- 16:30and I know that for a lot of fundamentalists. There's often a power dynamic
- 16:33that over the holidays there can be some push and full about who's going to
- 16:38convince the other. But I'm not going to be doing that this year.
- 16:42I want it at first to talk to my mother and say, hey,
- 16:47Mom, I've come out of what is the most oppressive system that I've ever
- 16:52been exposed to in my life, and I am free. Praised Jesus,
- 16:56hallelujah, I'm finally free. But I'm not going to be doing that over
- 17:02the holidays. The reason my mother is almost sixty years old, and Christianity
- 17:07is specifically the church, it's almost a micro culture. It's almost a standalone
- 17:12community. They've got their own cultural element, they've got their own vocabulary music,
- 17:18they've got their own inside jokes, holidays, and it really is a
- 17:22microcosm of a culture and a community. And that's all that my mother has.
- 17:29She has no friends outside of her church, she has no community or
- 17:33support outside of her church. And so I was initially going to talk with
- 17:40her and say, hey, Mom, let's talk about how you can be
- 17:41free as well. But I know that if I do that, there's going
- 17:47to be just a vacuum left behind and in New York City. It's not
- 17:51the easiest thing in the world for a six year old woman who comes from
- 17:55a house where she was abused by her husband to reach out and make new
- 18:00friends that she loves and trusts and loves her and trusts her. So I
- 18:04won't be spending it in a way that I had expected I would. It
- 18:08is going to be slightly unique for me. There of course be times where
- 18:12I'll feel that I've got to address what you just said. We need to
- 18:17talk about that. But I'm going to do my best to hold my tongue,
- 18:21keep my peace, and try and just maintain a happy holiday. I'm
- 18:25hearing a lot of banging around on your end of the phone. Is there
- 18:27something going on? You playing basketball? You move in boxes? It's raining?
- 18:33And those are my windshield wipers. Oh you're in the car, okay.
- 18:36I just want to make sure that you know something wasn't going to fall
- 18:38on your head while we were having a conversation. Leave the wipers on,
- 18:42be safe. But you know, I don't. I do think those conversations
- 18:48are important, they're necessary, but there is a time and a place,
- 18:51and the only time I personally would engage would be if somebody engaged me or
- 18:56put me on the spot at Thanksgiving, Christmas, Easter, I don't know
- 19:00whatever the event was, and then I would feel like, well, my
- 19:03hand was forced. But I think you know your comments have merit. The
- 19:07cost benefit for her is she's got community and support. Otherwise she'd be alone.
- 19:12And that's where you start, which is a position of compassion, and
- 19:15I appreciate you sharing it, James. I appreciate you having me on.
- 19:18Thanks a lot. All right, be safe, We'll see you later.
- 19:22Still to come. I have doctor Marlene Wennell, psychologist and the founder of
- 19:27Journey Free, which is a great website for people who are navigating their post
- 19:33religious lives and they're currently religious families and friends. We'll talk to her plus
- 19:38more of your calls next. If you'd like to give a Christmas gift to
- 19:53this broadcast, become a patron. I would so appreciate your support. Twenty
- 20:00twenty four. You can decide how much you want to be a patron four.
- 20:03You can cancel at any time, but it really helps me to do
- 20:07what I do. Patreon dot com, slash Seth Andrews. I've got doctor
- 20:15Marlene Wenell, psychologist and religious recovery consultant to talk about dealing with family.
- 20:21She's coming up back to the phones right now. Two five zero, Hi,
- 20:27who's this James? What do you have for us as we talk about
- 20:33religious family in the holidays. Yeah, I'm just a new subscriber to your
- 20:38channel. The Bible depicts a lot of quotes to slaughter earth. What's your
- 20:47point of view on flatter Earth? I think it's astounding that we even have
- 20:52to have the conversation in the twenty first century. This was settled long ago.
- 21:00No, I do not believe. In fact, I know for a
- 21:03fact the Earth is not flat. Why do you ask, Well, there's
- 21:07this camera out to P. Nine hundred that does twenty miles and when all
- 21:14the tests that have been done it proves that there's no curvature over water,
- 21:18and they've already came out and said that, yes, water does lie flat.
- 21:22So being a pull a boat out of ten miles and see it's still
- 21:30sitting on water with a P. Nine hundred begs to differ with the idea
- 21:33that, yeah, possibly it is flat. And with the North Star being
- 21:38stationary, and with all the other constellations there that are stationary too, it
- 21:47kind of opens the door. Maybe there's something else that people are missing that
- 21:55all of the planet's space agencies have missed. Everybody who's ever launched a satellite,
- 22:00meteorologists have missed, geologists have missed. By the way with it.
- 22:04Now, I'm going to finish my sentence. Hang on, hang on.
- 22:08Not only not only can you see ships disappear over a curved horizon, you
- 22:15don't need a telephoto lens to see it. You can see it happen with
- 22:19the naked eye. The way planes navigate the planet requires a spherical earth.
- 22:26Astronauts at the International Space Station are in orbit around a spherical Earth. And
- 22:33I'm not sure what the Bible has to do with this. Are you a
- 22:36Bible literalist. I've read a few things, picked a few things out.
- 22:45I don't live by anything in it. Books can be taken in several different
- 22:51manners. I'm not one to say or judge other people for what's in the
- 22:56Bible. You know, Johnny verse thirty two, the truth will set us
- 23:00free. That's a great quote to live by. But now we all have
- 23:06to make our judgment calls in life. I'm just saying, you know,
- 23:10when you research how high can the human body go in the space There's a
- 23:15whole bunch of information there that they haven't documented a human body going past sixty
- 23:22five thousand feet. That's right there for anybody to look up. So the
- 23:27International Space Station is supposed to be one million, two hundred and fifty thousand
- 23:32feet. Now that's a lot more than sixty five thousand feet. If you
- 23:37research this stuff, it just doesn't make sense now, having all these videos
- 23:41out there floating around with the International Space Station and them hanging on wires,
- 23:48them filming something in water, and spacesuits filling up with water. Person has
- 23:53to make his own decision is it real or is it all fake? I'm
- 23:59gonna let this call ago. I appreciate you very much. You and I
- 24:03stand far apart on flat Earth to that I really wanted to hear a little
- 24:10more information from you, because when you understand that they fake so much stuff
- 24:15out there. Okay, dokie, I appreciate the call. I'm tremendously concerned
- 24:21about your sources of information and how that information might be vetted. But even
- 24:26astrophysicist Dan Batcheldor, who I've interviewed several times, who works on a daily
- 24:33basis with NASA came up with a great, great point that if the Earth
- 24:38was flat, flat earthers at different points of the flat disk planet or whatever
- 24:45would have to be lying to each other about the position of the Sun.
- 24:51There is simply no way that flat earthers even agree on their own flat Earth.
- 24:56Thank you for calling. See later. The Bible says the planet has
- 25:07corners, the corners of the Earth. The Bible also says people can live
- 25:12to be a thousand years old, men can live underwater for three days inside
- 25:19submerged prison. Fish, zombies marched through Jerusalem, you can heal blindness with
- 25:29magic mud. Bible says that, and Bible says lots of stuff. Do
- 25:36flat earthers think that the other planets are flat? Do you think they believe
- 25:41that they're disks and they're right there, like can we just see them from
- 25:45a profile point of view? Or do they believe that all of the other
- 25:48planets in the Solar System are spheres but we are flat, so we are
- 25:55an anomaly for some reason? What does someone get out of claiming the Earth
- 26:00is flat? Because I qualified this in many ways as an identity belief.
- 26:06The people who are part of a flat Earth community culture et cetera. Take
- 26:11it so very personally, and I find that very telling. You and I
- 26:17don't walk around as part of the Spherical Earth club, but flat earthers have
- 26:22these, They have a family bond Ermano. You are also the one who
- 26:27figured it out while everybody else is deceived. What do you get out of
- 26:32that? And what does that have to do with families on the holidays?
- 26:37Nine two five? Who's this? Hey, it's George. How are you?
- 26:44I'm well, what do you want to talk about? I'm wondering,
- 26:47you know, how do I I mean, I'm I'm still very much Christian,
- 26:51but my views have changed quite a bit over the years. I was
- 26:57conservative, seriously conservative, from the time I became a Christian until probably about
- 27:03two thousand and three ish, I guess, I don't know, it's been
- 27:07a while, and I actually, over the last few months have really come
- 27:12out against a lot of the ultra conservative side of Christianity. So, you
- 27:18know, I'm wondering how do I go about giving my stance on things without
- 27:23really upsetting people that are still ultra conservative. I don't think their reaction is
- 27:30your responsibility if you talk about your values, I mean, I think you
- 27:34can say well, I don't believe Jesus would condemn gay people, and I
- 27:40don't believe Jesus would want us to be bigots and Christian nationalists or whatever.
- 27:47Support this politician or that position. You can do that. I get that.
- 27:52Hey, this is part of my journey, this is where I'm at.
- 27:53I get that. But if they flip out, that's not your responsibility.
- 27:57Their reaction is on them. So don't walk in thinking, well,
- 28:02how do I keep them from losing their shit and hitting the roof? I
- 28:04think you walk in and make it about you. How can I go in
- 28:07and responsibly in a mature way present my position if it's appropriate to do so,
- 28:15and you're the adult in the room, and if they lose their minds,
- 28:18that's not your fault. Okay, oh yeah, I get you.
- 28:22All right, have a wonderful Christmas. We'll see you later. Okay,
- 28:26alrighty, thank you, Seth. I appreciate it. Five three nine?
- 28:30Who's this done? Now? Thanks for calling? What do you want to
- 28:33talk about? I want If you don't mind some advice, I'll do my
- 28:40best. Sunday was my daughter's sixteenth day. Okay, we invited my niece
- 28:45and my sister found out about it, and she kind of threw a fit,
- 28:49so we felt bad and we invited her. And she is a Christian.
- 28:53I did not know how Republican Christian she was, but she is.
- 29:00She kind of took over my daughter's birthday party, and as towards the end
- 29:03of it, she decided to tell everybody that the country was going to hell
- 29:10because of trans people and how she's voting for Trump again. And I sit
- 29:17there, I'm like, we're not talking politics. I'm like, and you're
- 29:19in a house full of liberals. I guess my question is I don't like
- 29:25her, and I don't like hateful people like her. I don't agree with
- 29:30her, and I don't want her around. Would it be wrong in me
- 29:33if I bought her on everything and didn't have anything to do with her.
- 29:38Oh my gosh. I do not want the responsibility, especially given the fact
- 29:42that I am not a relationship counselor. All I can say is that I
- 29:48got a little bit stuck on massive boundary violation. She co opted your daughter's
- 29:53birthday to come in and essentially preach, and you don't like her. All
- 30:00I can say is if it was me, I mean, why would I
- 30:03open my door why would I open my life to that? I myself would
- 30:08draw a harder line, but I can't give you a definitive answer other than
- 30:15you know, I think it's important to live our lives with boundaries and self
- 30:18respect. I'm sorry it happened, And happy birthday to your daughter. Thank
- 30:23you, all right, thank you, all right, take care, We'll
- 30:27see you later. Man, you know, somebody walks in under your roof
- 30:33for in your event and takes over. That would last about eight seconds,
- 30:41and there's the door. Don't let it hit you, right, don't let
- 30:45it hit you. I'm also struck by this notion that we're supposed to like
- 30:52everybody in our direct and immediate bloodline. My father used to be the kind
- 30:56of guy where if he found on somebody who was a relative who lived elsewhere,
- 31:03when he discovered they were a relative, he just show up at their
- 31:07house in another state. We're connected, we're blood, we're kin and he
- 31:12felt that kinship and he never understood me growing up. I just didn't get
- 31:18it. I'm like, when did it become like a thing where just because
- 31:22somebody is a relative, we're already what friendly? We like each other.
- 31:26They're good people, they're not irritating people. But just because it's an aunt
- 31:32or an uncle. Trust me, an aunt and an uncle they had a
- 31:34family reunion. Do you think I want to spend four hours with those people?
- 31:37But it's your aunt and your uncle and what that? And five bocks
- 31:42will get you a cup of coffee at Starbucks as far as I'm concerned,
- 31:47No, I think out a boundary four h five. I think that's uh
- 31:52Western Oklahoma. Hi. Who's this? Hey? This is Sam? Sam.
- 31:57Where are you calling from? I'm just curious, Actually, I'll Golahoma
- 32:00City. Yeah, all right, great to have you, fellow Oki.
- 32:04What's on your mind? I know people have problems with their family, and
- 32:08I'm sure some people have had a similar experience to mine. When Coach started,
- 32:14we didn't want anything to do with anybody. So for the most part,
- 32:19you know, I haven't seen much of my extended families for a couple
- 32:22of years now. And you know, this last year we learned my my
- 32:28mom had cancer. And you know, despite at this point already being vaccinated,
- 32:34we still don't want to take any any chances now. But in the
- 32:37end, she she did pass away from the cancer a couple of months ago.
- 32:43But I just know that if someone's going to bring up some nutty,
- 32:47bright wing conspiracy like the vaccine gives you cancer, I'm just going to lose
- 32:53it. Oh, I understand your frustration, but in this I don't mean
- 32:59for this to sound dismissive. But it's up to you whether or not you
- 33:05lose it. You can mentally prepare yourself if you decide you're going to subject
- 33:09yourself to that environment. You can decide. In fact, you can work
- 33:14through scenarios, situationals, you can practice. You know some people who go
- 33:19into conversational environments, So if they worry that, well, I'm going to
- 33:24encounter this, or I may hear that, or someone may say this.
- 33:29I think there's merit in setting that up in your brain at the least if
- 33:32this happens. How will I react if someone else does this? What's the
- 33:36appropriate response? If any how will ideal? But if you lose it,
- 33:42if you pop an O ring and start screaming, that's not going to be
- 33:45their fault. And I think that may be an exercise for you to decide.
- 33:52I'm going to expect insanity. I'm going to expect that these people have
- 33:57some very bad anti science propagain and at conspiracies, etc. I know what
- 34:01I'm in for when it shows up. What's the cost benefit on blowing my
- 34:07stack? And if it's something you can't handle, I would think again about
- 34:14attending in the first place, because that's grief you don't need. But I
- 34:16do hope that you find some goodness over the Christmas holiday and into the new
- 34:21year. Okay, all right, thank you, all right, thanks for
- 34:23Cohen standing by. I've got psychologists and religious recovery consultants from journey Free dot
- 34:34org Doctor Marlene Winnel. She's going to bring some actual expertise to the conversation.
- 34:40Next, Doctor Marlene Wentels. She's been on the show before and I
- 34:52had to have her back around the holiday. She is a licensed psychologist.
- 34:58Her doctorate is in human development and family studies. She has written the book
- 35:02Leaving the Fold, a guide for former fundamentalists and others leaving their religion,
- 35:09and her organization, called Journey Free, focuses on religious trauma and the recovery
- 35:16from religious trauma. Doctor Winnow, good to have you back. Yeah,
- 35:22I'm happy to be here. How some people don't think religious trauma is a
- 35:24thing. I've heard some dismissive people they're like, oh, come on,
- 35:30right, you stop going to church, big deal, you stop believing in
- 35:34the magic sky Daddy you grew up. Let's talk about religious trauma is a
- 35:38thing you want to explain, well, I think there are are two aspects
- 35:43of it. One is the kind of ongoing trauma from being in a restrictive
- 35:49religion, and I'm talking about fundamentalist style authoritarian religions that put people in the
- 35:55categories have saved and damned and have both teaching and practices that can be toxic
- 36:04or even abusive. And I'm talking about teachings like telling you that you are
- 36:07basically bad, you're born bad, original sin, and also teaching that you're
- 36:14going to go to hell if you don't conform, that you should be afraid
- 36:17of everything in the world of good and evil. And also the practices such
- 36:22as isolating children from the world and not letting them grow up normally. So
- 36:28there are developmental delays that are pretty serious. All this can go on just
- 36:32as part of growing up in a religion or joining it later. And then
- 36:37the other aspect is when you leave a religion. This can be a traumatic
- 36:43life event because you basically have the rug ripped out from under you. The
- 36:47religion defined everything in your life, who you were, what you're doing,
- 36:52what the world is, who other people are, what's going to happen if
- 36:54you die, Your career, your work, your love life. It defined
- 36:59absolutely everything, and all of that comes crashing down, and it's a devastating
- 37:04kind of experience to have to really reconstruct yourself from the bottom up. So
- 37:09that can be quite dramatic. People tell me all kinds of stories, like
- 37:14having to stay in bed for dayson and trying to figure things out. You
- 37:17just don't even know who you are. So yes, there are traumatic.
- 37:22It varies. There's a range. Some people who didn't take it very seriously
- 37:27in the first place, or who had parents that modified it and mediated it
- 37:31can claim to just walk away. So we're not saying that it's necessarily traumatic,
- 37:37but it can be highly traumatic. There is a parallel that I'm drawing.
- 37:42You tell me if I'm nuts relating to fundamentalist religions and cults, or
- 37:46are these totalistic cults where you were locked into the alternate reality. There's usually
- 37:52an authority figure. It can be a god figure or an actual I don't
- 37:57know, a cult leader, a shepherd type, and there is an absolute
- 38:01removal of the identity. Right, we have to surrender the individual because you
- 38:06will now assimilate or assume the identity of the group. Would you say there's
- 38:10a lot of cult like aspects to fundamentalist Christianity, Islam, etc. Oh.
- 38:15Absolutely, absolutely. In fact, when people talk about cults, I
- 38:19just kind of laugh because I think the fundamentalist versions of large religions are cults
- 38:24in themselves. They're very authoritarian either or dogmatic thinking. And there may not
- 38:32be a live leader, but Jesus and Jehovah are absolute leaders that you're supposed
- 38:39to conform to and obey. And then there's the scripture. People sometimes call
- 38:45it bibliolatry, where you worship the Scripture and you can't deviate. Every word
- 38:51is God's word, and that's very cult life. In this country, there
- 38:55is a I think it's rooted in the Christianity of the United States. You
- 39:00know, God commanded honor your father and mother. You know, it's in
- 39:07Exodus, it's in Deuteronomy, it's in the New Testament and Ephesians. There's
- 39:10a verse in Matthew that threatens your life, honor your father and your mother,
- 39:15and whoever reviles father or mother must surely die. I think there's a
- 39:21version that says if you honor them, you will live a long life,
- 39:23and there's an implied threat there. Do you feel like that we, even
- 39:29quasi religious or even non religious people in this country have been infected with this
- 39:34idea that honoring means you got to put up with everything they say and do.
- 39:37No, I don't think people live that out. I think, well,
- 39:40this is kind of another subject, but I think we have a lot
- 39:44of ageism in our country generally, so I'm not sure that fathers and mothers
- 39:47get honored all that much. But the reaction, I'm not talking about the
- 39:52elderly. As much as I birthed you, I brought you into this world.
- 39:55This is how we raised you. And if you then stray, you
- 40:00get emotionally blackmailed. This is not how we raised you. And a lot
- 40:04of people get guilted into their locked in to an inherited world, so to
- 40:08speak. Yeah. Yeah, definitely, well in religious families in particular,
- 40:15and there's a big confusion about responsibility because of that, where children are feeling
- 40:20responsible for their parents' feelings and it makes it very hard for them to come
- 40:25out as non religious because they're all worried about what is going to do to
- 40:30their parents, and it makes it very difficult to be honest. Doesn't that
- 40:34pinball back to you. Let's say you're a rebel and I have a feeling
- 40:37you have been a rebel in your life, doctor Winnell, and you leave
- 40:43the straight and narrow and begin to carve your own path, and your mother
- 40:46and father do that shame thing. We're disappointed. There are tears, there
- 40:51are shouts, they're nasty conversations. You have a cost benefit as to how
- 40:55much grief you want in your own life because what they do can spill inside
- 41:00the threshold of your house. Right, Yes, depending on how they handle
- 41:06it. Yes, is their merit to then playing a slower game or not
- 41:09telling them? I mean, how what advice might you give someone's like,
- 41:14Oh, this is grief I don't need. So maybe I'll just shut up
- 41:16and, at least in front of them, not be my authentic self.
- 41:20Maybe I just won't even appear at family functions and you know, just leave
- 41:24them at entirely. Well, that would be one way of going about it.
- 41:29But this is a situation I call intimacy versus integrity, And sometimes people
- 41:35can play that game for a while, or at least stay very low key
- 41:38and go to family gatherings and pretend everything is fine. But the cost is
- 41:44that you're not being your authentic self, and that starts to feel kind of
- 41:47bad. You're not being known for who you really are, and people do
- 41:52crave being known for who they really are. So often with time, people
- 41:57end up needing to come out in order to feel like they've got some integrity,
- 42:02some authenticity. So then that becomes a matter of how to do that,
- 42:07and there are no rules about how you do that or with who or
- 42:13how long it takes. So you have to navigate that so that you are
- 42:17having a combination of being assertive and also having compassion because you know, like
- 42:23for your elderly grandmother, for example, and this has been the center of
- 42:28her life forever, you know, how are you going to handle that in
- 42:30a way that isn't hurtful or not necessarily even include everybody. She may not
- 42:36even be included, But there is this craving I find with clients who are
- 42:42trying to keep the peace so to speak with everybody, that they end up
- 42:46needing to be honest with people just for their own integrity. Perhaps this is
- 42:52a selfish conversation because so much of it relates to my own experience. I
- 42:55was strange from parents and with Christmas coming up, so I walk in if
- 43:00I decide to go, I walk in, and you know, there's Jesus
- 43:04paintings on the wall, and there's scriptures over the doorways. You know.
- 43:07As for being in my house, we will serve the Lord, and everybody's
- 43:10talking about what happened to church, and we pray before the meal. And
- 43:14that's fine. I'm in somebody else's house, their house, their rules.
- 43:17I don't raise a stink, but I do find myself conscious of the fact
- 43:22that I am the outlier and there's an other ring that happens even when no
- 43:29one says anything. I don't know. Does that make sense to you,
- 43:30doctor Winnow? Well, sure, I mean you're on the other side of
- 43:36the divide. You hear that a lot from people there my tribe, but
- 43:39they're not really my tribe. I feel like, I, you know,
- 43:43it's the black sheep thing. I don't know how else to say. Well,
- 43:46the big recommendation is to try to relate to them as normal human beings.
- 43:52And the way I explain this is that I think that Christians and other
- 43:57religious people have like a dual personality. Part of them is living in this
- 44:02so called spiritual world that has angels and demons, and you know, Satan
- 44:07is out there trying to get you, and there are cosmic forces going on
- 44:12in the world, and you pray and you have this relationship with this imaginary
- 44:16friend in the sky. There's this whole spiritual part of the one side of
- 44:22the personality. And yet there's another personality that's just a normal human being that
- 44:29cooks meals, that enjoys food, that enjoys going out for a walk,
- 44:34enjoys gardening, enjoys playing with children, and can be a normal human being.
- 44:39And believers navigate these two personalities. They go back and forth all the
- 44:45time. So I think the way to relate to them is to stick with
- 44:47the normal human being, connect on the human level, and basically ignore the
- 44:52religion. Don't get into it. I mean, you may have had experiences
- 44:58with arguments and so forth, and find doubt that your likelihood of persuading them
- 45:04to come to your side of your point of view, is pretty small.
- 45:07So it's more if you want to have some connection, if you want to
- 45:10have some relationship that it's better to just talk about those subjects that you can
- 45:15connect on. Do you ever draw the hard line in the sand. There
- 45:20is a point when this isn't healthy and you have to say no, I'm
- 45:24not going I will not participate. Oh yeah, yeah, definitely. This
- 45:30is a cooperative kind of thing. So if you find that you personally are
- 45:36not being respected at all in that context, that certainly you have a right
- 45:42to take care of yourself. And the way I talk about this is in
- 45:45terms of the inner child and the inner adult and basically taking care of your
- 45:51child to the point where you do not expose that child to a toxic situation
- 45:58that's going to be hurtful. When you start out that way, you may
- 46:01even go to a visit and be with them, but if it gets to
- 46:05where it's just too painful, you have a right to leave. You have
- 46:07a right to go do something else. Well, doctor Winnell, if I
- 46:10can interject, what do you mean by inner child? Can you explain that
- 46:15the inner child is that sub personality that you have that is childlike, that's
- 46:22innocent, that was born with just the desire to live and be free and
- 46:27be happy, and is emotional that doesn't necessarily know how to make rational thought,
- 46:35plan ahead, be time conscious, be intentional, just the very childlike
- 46:40part of you. And I think everybody has that, and it doesn't go.
- 46:45Your child does not grow up. You will always have an inner child,
- 46:49and the idea is to take care of that child so that instead of
- 46:52a wounded little being, you have a happy, healthy part of you that
- 46:57can enjoy life. So when I'm seventy five, will I still have my
- 47:00inner chant? Yes? You will, hopefully. Some would argue that all
- 47:05men have or sort of grown up hill. I mean you should see me
- 47:07on Halloween. I'm a child. That's a whole other, different kind of
- 47:10digression. Forgive me. When we talk about relationships, the word toxic is
- 47:15thrown all over the internet. H I think sometimes it's used appropriate, and
- 47:21this is just me sometimes appropriately, and sometimes I think that it's overused.
- 47:25Someone gets into a conflict, you're in an argument, I don't know,
- 47:29you have a moment of discomfort, and you perhaps overreact. You call them
- 47:34toxic. You cut all ties. Do you use as a professional as a
- 47:37psychologist, Do you use the word toxic in any context? I use it
- 47:44in terms of particular beliefs particular dogma and not for people. Okay, I
- 47:50think that it's not a good idea to call it person toxic, but what
- 47:54they're using, and this also pertains to just the anger that people have towards
- 48:00religion and religious people, and that is to recognize that people are just people,
- 48:06and your parents were born innocent and were then brainwashed into the religion as
- 48:10well, they are also victims. So it's more accurate and emotionally more and
- 48:16more feasible to treat the religion as toxic rather than people, so that you
- 48:23know, well, those two big things, big teachings for example, that
- 48:28I consider the toxic the assumptions that you are basically bad, and secondly that
- 48:34you should be afraid. And those two teach those two doctrines. They're not
- 48:37doctrines, they're just assumptions, beliefs that go to the core of who we
- 48:44are, and those are highly toxic. And I think it's good to recognize
- 48:47that. So if somebody on the family, true anybody comes at you and
- 48:52they're like, you disgust me, what an embarrassment you are, You're a
- 48:55disappointment, You're ugly. I don't know. I mean, there's no threshold
- 49:00because I can hear the listeners are now sitting forward in their chair going,
- 49:05oh God, I know some toxic people. Doctor Wenell doesn't know what she's
- 49:08talking about. I mean I would call that toxic behavior. Or am I
- 49:13mislabeling that? No? I think you're right, it's toxic behavior. The
- 49:17thing is, the thing that we try to do with religious people in our
- 49:22lives is to be assertive, to take care of yourself, and also have
- 49:27compassion because they are also indoctrinated and victimized. So when decisions come up,
- 49:34if they are unwilling to talk with you in a respectful way, you might
- 49:38want to avoid being with them and have that kind of contact with them at
- 49:43least temporarily. But that doesn't necessarily condemn them. Where does this hyper targeting
- 49:50of religious trauma come from for you personal experience? Oh, I was raised
- 49:54in a religious household, and then I became very very religious myself when I
- 50:00was a teenager. So yes, I've been through it all myself. Did
- 50:04you experience trauma? I mean, did you have to grieve your old religion
- 50:08or were you named and blamed and shamed in some way? My family basically
- 50:14avoided me. I have four siblings and they're all still religious, and several
- 50:19of them are still are missionaries. My parents have passed away, but they
- 50:22were missionaries, so they were all in. And I'm talking about charismatic fundamentalism,
- 50:30and so I'm definitely the black sheep of the family, if you want
- 50:35to use that term. Mostly the hard part for me was just avoiding me
- 50:39and not wanting to talk to me, not wanting to discuss it, not
- 50:43treating me like my view was also valid, because there's no way, I
- 50:47mean, when we discuss things with other open minded people, we have this
- 50:53kind of mutual respect. You know, we can disagree or agree to disagree
- 50:59on a whole number of things. But when you're talking to a fundamentalist,
- 51:01there is only right and wrong. Right you can be right about something or
- 51:07wrong, and that's it. So it's very hard to have relationships that are
- 51:13deep enough to talk about important things. I'm struck by the elephant in the
- 51:16room phenomenon. I'll get around, you know, deeply fundy religious people who
- 51:22have an opinion about me, the apostate, you know, the guy who
- 51:25left the reservation. And even though we're talking about superficial things the weather,
- 51:31Hey, I heard you took a vacation. How was it? Do you
- 51:35have any photos? We talk about a restaurant, Hey, you went to
- 51:38this restaurant. How was the food? We're talking just I don't know on
- 51:42the surface, but I can feel something under that surface. Did you experience
- 51:46that. I'm sure you've spoken to others who have. Well, yeah,
- 51:52and you know, I have a cousin who will not go to any family
- 51:54gatherings because he doesn't want to be around anybody that thinks he's going to help.
- 52:00And so he's got that in his mind. And I think that we
- 52:04don't necessarily have to pay attention to it because it's not real. Okay,
- 52:08so somebody, maybe somebody is thinking you're going to that's their problem. I
- 52:14figure it's their problem. And here's where my Leprechaun story comes in. You
- 52:22if you play anthropologist a little bit, you know, step back and observe
- 52:29what everybody's doing in this religion. It can be pretty interesting and pretty funny.
- 52:34Some of it, you know, like talking to an imaginary person and
- 52:37bowing your heads, closing your eyes and talking to an imaginary person at dinner,
- 52:42going to a Christmas event where you're going to be discussing some little baby
- 52:46that was born two thousand years ago and then somehow died for you, and
- 52:51that's supposed to make everything okay. I mean, the whole thing is very
- 52:54weird and actually interesting if you've never even if you've never heard of it,
- 53:00for example, and you're just studying it, And then you can also reframe
- 53:04the words. You know, Let's say somebody or your father asks you,
- 53:07so, where are you fellowshipping? Now? A question like that, that's
- 53:12just a typical question, right to find out what's going on with you spiritually.
- 53:16But you in your head, you don't necessarily say this out loud,
- 53:21but in your head you can think, when was the last time you talked
- 53:23to your leprechaun king? Or where have you been to church? You know?
- 53:29Could we translate that to when have you been out at midnight dancing with
- 53:32the fairies? Would you answer the question, let's say I'm a heathen in
- 53:38the room, Hey, Seth, where do you and your wife go to
- 53:42church? Would you recommend that I I don't know if I hate the word
- 53:46keep the peace in that context and just dodge, or should I just say
- 53:52we're not church goers or just say I'm an atheist. I don't know.
- 53:55I know it's situational, but you're the psychologist. What do you think,
- 54:00Well, it depends on the situation, but you might want to just be
- 54:02open about that. And I don't go to church anymore. I've become an
- 54:06atheist. Or you can just say that's not a part of my life anymore
- 54:09and have it be very matter of fact like that and stay, you know,
- 54:14in your own integrity, this is who I am. And I or
- 54:17sometimes I will give my testimony a little bit more than that and say,
- 54:21no, I don't go to church anymore. In fact, I'm not really
- 54:23just at all anymore. And I feel so much better. I feel so
- 54:27much fear and so much connected to life. Oh the word testimony, you
- 54:30just gave it away, and you and I had I have a lot of
- 54:36fun doing that. Sometimes I went up to a street preacher who was going
- 54:40on, and when he paused, I went up and I said, hey,
- 54:45you know what, I understand what you're talking about because I used to
- 54:47be you. I used to preach, and I used to believe all the
- 54:52things that you believe. But you know what, my life change and I
- 54:55let go of this belief and all this this whole structure of thinking people are
- 55:01stamped and going to hell, and now I'm just more connected with humanity and
- 55:07my life is so much better. And you know what, I think that
- 55:09might happen to you someday. And if so, here, here's my card,
- 55:14you can call me and get some support. How does that go over?
- 55:16Do they receive that as condescending or in good faith or something else?
- 55:21No, it was like, oh, oh okay. But then the people
- 55:24around hearing the whole thing are just like busting up. Wow, you graized
- 55:30on something. I know you have other actual clients. I mean, I
- 55:34need a lot of work, and I can try to keep you here all
- 55:37day, doctor Winnell. But I know you've got other clients lined up who
- 55:40have been through religious trauma, so we want to honor that. But before
- 55:44we finish up, you talked a little bit about, if I heard you
- 55:47right, sort of the buttons that we allow other people to push. Uh
- 55:52huh. And I'm interested in that, you know. We It's strange because
- 56:00I sound calloused if I say that sometimes we do allow other people too much
- 56:06access, too much power, to be able to shoot us into oblivion.
- 56:12We but we also have to recognize there are many people who do have legitimate
- 56:16damage open wounds, and we want to be careful with them. But I
- 56:21worry that we're bubble wrapping the world in ways that are maladaptive. At some
- 56:27point, you are going to have people are going to have to try at
- 56:30least to overcome, to try to heal these wounds and live in an often
- 56:35complicated and difficult world. How do you navigate these conversations about buttons and triggers
- 56:42and trauma. Well, I think the first step is to be aware of
- 56:46all of that. Be aware of what's going on and what kinds of things
- 56:50are going to be more or less difficult for you, and make choices about
- 56:53what kinds of environments so you want to be in depending on your own state,
- 56:59whether or not you feel like you can handle it or not. And
- 57:00by handle it, I mean having your adult in charge. Like when I
- 57:06talk about going home to see family for Christmas or Thanksgiving, to go as
- 57:10your adult self and talk to your child before you get there, and also
- 57:15take care of your inner child while you're there, and relate to the other
- 57:20people and relate to the situation as a rational adult, and that can help
- 57:24you not regress. I mean, it's easy to regress when you're in family
- 57:29situations anyway, become a child in the sense that you were many years ago.
- 57:34But to be careful. You're taking care of your child and talking like
- 57:37the little testimony I gave a minute ago, I'm talking as an adult.
- 57:42I'm talking very rationally. I'm not going to become all emotional and reactive to
- 57:46that. But you have to work with yourself and learn how to do that,
- 57:52especially when you know you're going into a tricky situation, to do some
- 57:57journaling, to do some self talk before you even go, which seguays be
- 58:01right into your book and website. These provide those types of resources you want
- 58:06to just pitch those real fast. Well, you can certainly get some support
- 58:09from well if you go to journey free dot org. There are lots of
- 58:14resources there and some services that you might want to avail yourself up, primarily
- 58:19the group that we have a support group that meets three times a month on
- 58:22zoom. There's a couple hundred members and you can talk each time. We
- 58:28take turns talking about how you're doing and any kind of growing edges that you
- 58:34have that you want to talk about. Some challenges in your life and get
- 58:37the group support, and the feeling that you have then is that you're not
- 58:40alone, You're not making this up, and if something is really difficult and
- 58:45painful, people are not talking you out of it, but supporting you through
- 58:50it. And you also can just brainstorm my jeas with other folks when you've
- 58:54got a challenging situation. It's journey free dot org and if you roll down
- 59:00to where it says services, one of them says group support, and you
- 59:04click on that and you can join the group and then you'll get emails about
- 59:07when the meetings are. I heard a rumor that you are not just an
- 59:12author and you're not just a counselor and a psychologist, but you are now
- 59:17a film maker or about to be or what's going on with this? It's
- 59:22a documentary right? No, No, it's actually a feature length narrative film.
- 59:30It's a trauma. Yes, it's a trauma that I have written.
- 59:34I'm rewriting now and also getting more people involved. We are looking for a
- 59:38producer. We do have people that have responded in terms of being interested in
- 59:44cinematography, composing, being involved with the production, but we are definitely needing
- 59:51a producer right now. The story is called Mysterious Ways. You know how
- 59:55often we hear that God moves in mysterious ways. This is a story that
- 1:00:00you might call Big Chill Meets God. It's about a group of people that
- 1:00:05were in a Christian boarding school when they were in high school, and they
- 1:00:09come together after twenty years. Some of them have left the faith and some
- 1:00:13of them have not, So there's all this conflict about philosophy and religion.
- 1:00:17There's also a personal drama because an old romance gets kicked up. And also
- 1:00:22one of the members finds out that his call from God that sent him into
- 1:00:28missionary work was actually a trick with somebody that was talking through the ventilator system
- 1:00:32while he was praying. So he finds out that his whole life is built
- 1:00:36on a lie. And so we have this whole theme of what's real and
- 1:00:43what's conjured and what kind of responsibility do you have to manage your own life
- 1:00:49instead of looking for God's will? And what is God's will anyway, So
- 1:00:52there's a lot of good stuff in it, and it'll be I'm pretty sure
- 1:00:57it'll be a good movie. I will link the web site and your book
- 1:01:00in the description box of this conversation heading toward Christmas, people feeling anxiety,
- 1:01:07Final thoughts Advice counsel for anybody watching or listening. Yeah, if you're going
- 1:01:13to visit family, to work out what your intention is ahead of time,
- 1:01:16and have a journal that you're keeping and also take with you to keep track
- 1:01:22of what is your intention? What do you want? What are you going
- 1:01:25to go there? Do you plan on coming out or going to Is this
- 1:01:30really a good time for that? Probably not. But if you're planning on
- 1:01:34being with family, what do you want out of it? And to think
- 1:01:37about it both in terms of being assertive and compassionate, and you know,
- 1:01:42what kinds of things do you want to do while you're there? Do you
- 1:01:45want to play with the kids, make cookies, cut snowflakes out of paper?
- 1:01:50What kinds of things are you interested in? And what are you not
- 1:01:52interested in? Can you stay clearly to your parents that you're not going to
- 1:01:57the service, the Christmas service and be fine with that and maybe even practice
- 1:02:01with a friend what you're going to say and be clear with them ahead of
- 1:02:05time. You know I'm coming, and you might say you're coming for a
- 1:02:07day or two instead of several days like you normally have in the past,
- 1:02:12but just try and be as clear as you can. And if you run
- 1:02:15into a problem, I'll give you doctor Winel's cell number. You just call
- 1:02:19her from on Christmas Day ask her what to do next. Yeah. I
- 1:02:22appreciate you and your work, your counsel, your expertise. You're always a
- 1:02:28joy to speak with. Links to your work, the book, and the
- 1:02:30website are in the description box and in advance of the holiday, I hope
- 1:02:35it is a wonderful time for you and yours and thanks for talking to us.
- 1:02:38Okay, very welcome. Enjoyed it. Follow The Thinking Atheist on Facebook
- 1:02:44and Twitter for a complete archive of podcasts and videos, products like mugs and
- 1:02:49t shirts featuring the Thinking Atheist logo, links to atheist pages and resources,
- 1:02:53and details on upcoming free thought events and conventions. Log onto our website,
- 1:02:59The Thinking Atheist dot com.