Latest / Film And Whiskey / The Best Whiskey at Every Price Point
Transcript
- 0:00The truest expression of craft doesn't come from a recipe, a
- 0:04process, or even a perfect season for aging.
- 0:07Now it happens naturally, deep inside the barrel, untouched by
- 0:11human intervention. That's why, at Blackwood
- 0:14Distilling Code, they don't rush perfection.
- 0:16Rather, they let time and nature take the lead.
- 0:20Their proprietary Blackwood toasting process isn't just
- 0:23about tradition. It's about unlocking layers of
- 0:26complexity that only emerge when you extend the maturation of a
- 0:30spirit. By carefully toasting their
- 0:32barrels, they coax out these rich, nuanced flavors.
- 0:35Flavors like Creme brulee, toasted pecans, warm baking
- 0:39spices. Flavors that cannot be forced.
- 0:43Each sip reveals something new, something distinct, something
- 0:46that can only be achieved when craftsmanship meets patients.
- 0:51To raise a glass and taste what happens when we step back and
- 0:54let the barrel do the talking. Head over to
- 0:56blackwooddistillingcode.com and discover the unhurried elegance
- 1:01of Blackwood Distilling. Today on Film and whiskey, we're
- 1:08going to be looking at the best whiskey you can get at every
- 1:11price point, and we're going to be sampling a new bourbon from
- 1:14our friends at Green River. This is.
- 1:17The Film and Whiskey podcast. Well, hey everybody, welcome
- 1:39into the Film and Whiskey podcast.
- 1:42I'm Bob Book. I'm Brad G and.
- 1:44We're coming at you with another special bonus episode.
- 1:47Bonus. Episode I am thoroughly enjoying
- 1:53these bonus episodes, Brad, because we have gamified things
- 1:56and I love playing some games. It's the best man.
- 2:00We had so much fun with last week's episode where we built
- 2:03our beginner whiskey shelf with $300.00 that we said let's do
- 2:06something similar here. My my beginner shelf with
- 2:09$105.00 bottle of log full in 16.
- 2:12Dude if you want to impress somebody as a beginner, go get
- 2:16that loggy 16 man. That's the way to do it, man.
- 2:19So today what we're doing once again inspired by our friends
- 2:22down at Green River Distillery, they have just come out with a
- 2:25new bourbon called Green River 1885, and we're going to review
- 2:29it here in just a second. But we were mostly inspired by
- 2:32the fact that this is a very inexpensive bottle of whiskey
- 2:36because of that and because we are one of the only podcasts,
- 2:40whiskey podcast that I'm aware of that really considers the
- 2:43price point when we score out our whiskies.
- 2:47I think we kind of have a corner on the market here, Brad.
- 2:49And I think that it it's time that we really just say out loud
- 2:53what we've been implying all these years, which is what's the
- 2:56better than everyone else? Well, that too.
- 2:57I mean, I used to bet a lot all the time, but like, what's the
- 3:02best whiskey you could get at any price point?
- 3:04If someone says I want a Scotch and I can't spend more than $50,
- 3:08here's our recommendation. And so I I went ahead and looked
- 3:11at every whiskey score we've ever given Brad.
- 3:13I pulled them all into a document.
- 3:15You and I are both looking at this document.
- 3:17We've broken it down by the type of whiskey and by general price
- 3:22ranges, and we're going to recommend whiskeys at each of
- 3:25these price ranges. This doesn't sound like a fun
- 3:27game, but for me, and hopefully for you Brad, it sure is.
- 3:32Yeah, there there are more than enough whiskey drinkers out
- 3:35there that love a good spreadsheet who I just know
- 3:38we're going to enjoy this episode.
- 3:41Well, before we get into that, I say it's time we try this Green
- 3:43River. We teased it a little bit on
- 3:45last week's episode. So this is called Green River
- 3:481885 Bourbon Whiskey. We don't know too much about it
- 3:52other than the cell sheet that we found when we googled it
- 3:54online. The side of the bottle, the copy
- 3:57says that it is a four year age stated bourbon.
- 4:00It is only 85 proof though that's part of the 1885 appeal.
- 4:05We do know the mash bill on it is 76% corn, 15% rye, 9% malted
- 4:11barley. Perhaps most importantly, Brad
- 4:14is the price on this bad boy. Yeah, not only are you only
- 4:19going to spend $22.00 on this bottle of whiskey, Bob, this is
- 4:23not A750 milliliter bottle of whiskey.
- 4:27You know how much comes in this bottle.
- 4:29One full. Liter baby, a whole liter of
- 4:34whiskey at $22.00. Seriously folks, this is among
- 4:38the most inexpensive bourbons you can get at this size and I
- 4:42already inherently trust that it's going to be better than
- 4:44most of those whiskey's because it is from Green River.
- 4:47We've, you know, right, their initial release we were a little
- 4:51bit cooler on, but I feel like every single thing they've put
- 4:53out since then we have not only liked but have been effusive in
- 4:58our praise of. Yeah, 100% Green River continues
- 5:03to put out spectacular quality whiskey.
- 5:06Of all the distillers we follow, I feel like they understand
- 5:09their price points better than anyone else.
- 5:12Yeah, for sure. Now, one more thing I will say
- 5:15about this before we dive into the actual tasting is that I
- 5:18love a good piece of marketing. Brad, you know that I am a
- 5:22marketer in my day job and the way that they are branding this
- 5:25here bottle of 85 proof bourbon is that it is blended and
- 5:29proofed for the bar. They're trying to put this
- 5:31behind the bar in every bar in America and I think that this is
- 5:34a brilliant way to do it. You know, if you're going to.
- 5:36How'd you like their How'd you like their tagline Make mine an
- 5:4085. I love it.
- 5:41Dude, if you're going to release a low proof whiskey, then lean
- 5:44into it and say we have proved this so that it can be used in
- 5:48cocktails all throughout America.
- 5:50We're going to put it in a big bottle so that bars don't have
- 5:52to buy a whole bunch of it. And then we're going to price it
- 5:55where bars are going to want to compete for it.
- 5:57Like it's a brilliant marketing strategy.
- 5:59Green River, hats off to you. Yeah, hats off to you with the
- 6:03marketing. And now the most important
- 6:05question is Bob, does the whiskey inside the bottle live
- 6:09up to the label on the outside? Well, I have just poured it out.
- 6:12Brad, I'm going to be drinking this live.
- 6:14I know that you have already tried it, so why don't you go
- 6:17ahead and influence me by giving me your nosing notes on this?
- 6:21The nose on this 1885 is a little bit slight, but you get
- 6:27all sorts of black pepper. There is some orange people.
- 6:34I believe we call them Oompa Loompas, Brad.
- 6:36Oompa Loompas, yes, oh man, there is some orange peel is the
- 6:42word I was looking for and and some hints of caramel vanilla.
- 6:46It's, it's not coming across incredibly strong, but there is
- 6:50a little bit of complexity here that I like and I, I give it a 7
- 6:54out of 10 here. We used to have a black tea box
- 6:58of black tea that was like orange spice.
- 7:00It had like a bunch of kind of fall spices to it with just a
- 7:03little bit of orange peel. I get that here.
- 7:05It's not quite like nosing an old fashioned in a glass because
- 7:09I don't get those Angostura bitter's notes, but I get orange
- 7:12peel, I get cinnamon, I get nutmeg, I get clove and kind of,
- 7:16I don't want to say overwhelming that.
- 7:18But on top of all of that is that black pepper.
- 7:20The rye really comes through on this one.
- 7:23I like it a lot, but it's like, it does remind me of like a a
- 7:27black tea where you can kind of nose the sweetness, but you know
- 7:30that it might not taste super sweet.
- 7:33So yeah, I'm looking forward to trying it.
- 7:34Brad, what are your tasting notes here?
- 7:36As I got into the palate, the caramel really came around for
- 7:40me. There's some some flavors of
- 7:43like a golden delicious apple. The vanilla comes through,
- 7:47there's a little bit of a nutty pecan flavor going on.
- 7:50Not a vast plethora of depth, but once again, just really
- 7:56solid flavors that come across nicely.
- 8:00And an 85 proof whiskey. I'm going to give it a 7 1/2
- 8:03here. Yeah, and again, I think this is
- 8:05where you got to keep the $22.00 price point in mind because it
- 8:08like if this was a $50 bottle of whiskey, I do feel like I'd
- 8:12probably judge it a little bit more harshly than I am.
- 8:15The apple is super strong here. This is a perfect fall whiskey.
- 8:19I just get apple, I get orange, I get all those baking spices.
- 8:23I can imagine like mixing this with apple cider in the fall, it
- 8:27just make a really, really good spiked apple cider.
- 8:31It does tip a little bit sour for me towards the back end,
- 8:35kind of like what we get with some toasted bourbon sometimes.
- 8:39And you know, it's not like overly sour.
- 8:42It's not super bitter, but I think that I'm going to be a
- 8:46little bit less harsh on it because it's a $22.00 bottle of
- 8:49whiskey because of that. Now that said, Brad, the finish
- 8:54is great. It kind of keeps rolling back up
- 8:56my palate. I think it's really creamy on
- 8:58the finish. It drinks spicier than an 85
- 9:01proof whiskey would, and I think that it would hold up really
- 9:05well in a lot of cocktails that they're going to be making
- 9:07behind the bar across America. Dude, I don't know, man.
- 9:10If we were going to score this out, it would certainly be
- 9:13getting a 10 out of 10 value for me, 100%.
- 9:17I think on the nose, I'd give it about A7.
- 9:18On the taste I'd give it, I'd say A7, 6 1/2 to A7 finish about
- 9:24the same. This is like a really solid
- 9:26whiskey across the board. And then it's absolutely
- 9:29bolstered by the fact that it's a 10 out of 10 value.
- 9:33Yeah, I feel like we've seen lots of whiskies like this get
- 9:37hit by the the bubble that is the current whiskey world.
- 9:42And so you're going to pay 30 to $40.00 for a bottle like this.
- 9:46And Green River just kind of cut through all the BS and said,
- 9:49Nope, this is a really solid whiskey at $22.00 that you can
- 9:54buy in a one liter bottle to use for your mixed drinks.
- 9:59And I I absolutely love what they are doing here because the
- 10:03final product is incredibly delicious, especially
- 10:07considering the value that you're getting.
- 10:09Yeah. I mean, if we were considering
- 10:11this as like a 7:50, we'd be talking about a $1516 bottle of
- 10:15whiskey. So I think my score would
- 10:18probably come out somewhere in the 35 to 38 range on this.
- 10:22And that's like an immediate thumbs up.
- 10:24I would recommend trying this just on the merits of how good
- 10:26it tastes. But then when you get to the
- 10:28value on it, it's like, I don't know, Brad, this is probably one
- 10:31of the best values we've had in the last year, two years on the
- 10:34podcast. Yeah, and I, I think that this
- 10:37whiskey kind of gives you a sense of why you add a little
- 10:42bit of water to your whiskies 'cause when you have a really
- 10:45well made whiskey at 100 plus proof, adding a little bit of
- 10:49water can bring out some texture and flavors and and help the
- 10:54whiskey. And if you gave somebody
- 10:57something like this, this Green River 85, I think he would start
- 11:00to understand that concept. 100%, man.
- 11:03All right. We are in a really good spot
- 11:04with this one and I think it becomes a candidate for our next
- 11:08order of business here, which is picking the best whiskey at each
- 11:12price point. We'll get to that right after
- 11:14this break. Hey there whiskey lovers, You
- 11:18ever wonder what happens when you mix Kentucky Derby winners,
- 11:20legendary bourbon masterminds? In a dash of bold ambition you
- 11:24get Blackwood Distilling Co, a premium brand born from the wild
- 11:2865 to one odds victory of Country House in the 2019 Derby.
- 11:33They have crafted luxury toasted bourbon and America's first
- 11:36triple barreled toasted ride that'll knock your socks off in
- 11:39the most delicious way possible. Picture this 7 to 9 year old
- 11:43Kentucky Bourbon. Think deep creamy vibes, soft
- 11:47barrel spices, and that smooth as velvet warmth kissed by a
- 11:51hint of vanilla from Kentucky's golden era.
- 11:53And that's just the bourbon. If rye's more your thing like it
- 11:57is for me, how about a five to seven-year old Indiana rye
- 12:00triple barreled and toasted barrels that blend spice, dark
- 12:04fruits, mint and A dash of white pepper.
- 12:07It's basically a liquid holiday wrapped in oak and fire.
- 12:11The batches are continuously rolling out in states all across
- 12:14the Union, so if you want in on luxury, head to
- 12:16blackwooddistillingco.com to get yourself some Blackwood Toasted
- 12:20Bourbon and Toasted Rye. Cheers to the good stuff.
- 12:28All right, Brad, it's time for us to pick the best whiskey at
- 12:30each price point. Now, I I'll leave it to you.
- 12:34Here we have this nice little fancy document broken down with
- 12:37the color coding and everything else.
- 12:40We do have it broken down by type of whiskey.
- 12:42So where would you like to start?
- 12:44Bourbon is obviously the most dominant type of whiskey we've
- 12:47had on this podcast, so there's a lot to go through with
- 12:50bourbon. Would you rather knock out some
- 12:52of the ones that we've had fewer of, or just start right with
- 12:54bourbon? Yeah, I was going to say let's
- 12:57go with our rye, our Irish and international.
- 13:01And then from there, I think we should do Scotch and then
- 13:05bourbon. Now I put international as a
- 13:08category here, which is not really fair because obviously
- 13:11Scotch and Irish whiskey and if we did Canadian, those would all
- 13:15be international too. But we've had some whiskeys like
- 13:17Japanese whiskeys, we've had Taiwanese whiskeys, Indian
- 13:20whiskeys, that there just aren't enough of them to form their own
- 13:24category. So perhaps unfairly, I said
- 13:26international as a category. That's what I mean there.
- 13:29Brad, why don't you go ahead and walk us through the price point
- 13:33ranges that we're going to be choosing from?
- 13:36Yeah, it's pretty simple. We're going to be looking at
- 13:38whiskeys in five categories under $25.00.
- 13:42So you know kind of your bottom level whiskeys that you'll be
- 13:45drinking day in and day out 25 to $50.50 to $80, 80 to $120.00.
- 13:54And then we're kind of getting into our luxury tier of $120.00
- 13:58plus. Now.
- 13:59I can tell you right now, Bob, that is going to get really
- 14:02expensive when it comes to the scotches that I I picked out.
- 14:06Well, yeah. And I will say that the list
- 14:08that we're looking at here, Brad, I went back through all of
- 14:10our whiskeys that we've reviewed and I just kind of arbitrarily
- 14:13said, I'll, I'll put the cut off at 38 out of 50 on average.
- 14:18Now, I think that's going to unfairly impact like our under
- 14:20$25 category because a lot of times those whiskeys aren't
- 14:24great, but they're like far and away the best thing you can get
- 14:27for 15 bucks. And so I think when I look at
- 14:29this list, a lot of those whiskeys are missing and it's
- 14:32going to really come down to us to kind of nominate some of
- 14:35these. But this gives us a nice
- 14:36baseline. So why don't we go ahead and
- 14:39start walking through Brad? Do you want to start with Rye or
- 14:43Irish or international? Let's go ahead and start with
- 14:47rye. Might as well start at the top.
- 14:49Now I don't have any whiskeys categorized here for the under
- 14:5325 category. And in fact I think maybe the
- 14:56only one we've ever done that would fall into that category is
- 14:59old Overholt. Not even the 100 proof old
- 15:02Overholt, but the regular and I think that you might be able to
- 15:06get the 100 proof for under 25. So it's just a question of Brad,
- 15:10which one would you rather have on your shelf, the under the the
- 15:1480 proof or the 100 proof? Probably the 100 proof.
- 15:19I think that would be my go to. You just have.
- 15:21There's just a depth of flavor you you can't quite get on 80
- 15:24proofs. Well, there you go.
- 15:26By by virtue of being the only one that we could pick from Old
- 15:30Overholt 100 is your Under 25 Rye representative now in the
- 15:35$25.00 to 50 range? We've really only got 2 here.
- 15:38We've got the Old Overhold 114 proof, which our friend Chris
- 15:42Blattner raves about. And then we've also got your
- 15:46standard US1, Mcter's Single Barrel Rye, one of Brad's
- 15:51highest rated rise of all time on this podcast.
- 15:54I have a feeling I know where this is going.
- 15:56Yeah, the the Mcter's rise far and away the obvious choice here
- 16:01at $45. Do you have any other nominees
- 16:04in this area or or is this pretty much the one?
- 16:07I I would say it's mixtures rye that that's the the only option
- 16:11at this price point that I think is worth your money.
- 16:14OK. Why don't you go ahead and walk
- 16:15us through our next range, the 50 to $80.00 range, because once
- 16:19again, we don't have anything on our spreadsheet in that range.
- 16:22So it's going to take us kind of brainstorming here a little bit.
- 16:25Yeah, I was going to say, I think here this now I am, I am
- 16:30reporting this based on friends and the Internet.
- 16:34I'm going to say the Wild Turkey rare Breed rye is probably your
- 16:39best value in this range. I I think it's at like $65.
- 16:44OK, yeah, that sounds about right.
- 16:46The only one that I would put up that came from a bonus episode
- 16:50so it doesn't have a full score from us, was this one we tried
- 16:53last year. We tried two ryes on one episode
- 16:56and one of them was the Tumblin Dice Rye, which is really good,
- 16:59but like 80 or 90 bucks. And then we tried one called
- 17:02Hunting Creek Rye, which became like one of our best loved
- 17:06whiskeys of that season. That's a $50 bottle and I just
- 17:10tried it again a couple weeks ago and I don't know if I could
- 17:13get a better ride for 50 bucks than the Hunting Creek.
- 17:16Yeah, I do remember that. Hunting Creek I'll I just looked
- 17:20at the price. The wild Turkey rare breed rye
- 17:22is 60 bucks. So I, I'm probably going to buy
- 17:25myself a bottle that soon that hunting Creek rye was stunning.
- 17:32So I yes, that that's the winner in my book.
- 17:35Awesome. All right, well that takes us to
- 17:36the $80.00 to $120.00 range where we've got 3 nominees and
- 17:42they are all Bradgy beloved favorites.
- 17:45One of them at 100 plus dollars. Depends on where you get this
- 17:48bottle is your Midwinter night's DRAM.
- 17:51This is the tater bottle of all tater bottles.
- 17:54People seek this out every year. It ends up getting way marked up
- 17:58so I I almost hesitate to put it in here at 100 because it's so
- 18:02rare to find it at 100. And it has to compete with Beryl
- 18:07Seagrass. The other, the other competition
- 18:10here, if we can put that in quotes, is Old Forester Single
- 18:13Barrel Rye, which we tried and really, really loved that one.
- 18:16But dude, I'm not even the world's biggest rye fan and I
- 18:21have had to listen to you go on and on about Beryl Seagrass over
- 18:24the years. So I know where this is going.
- 18:26I like, I don't think there's any competition here.
- 18:29This is the easiest choice for any price point of any type of
- 18:34whiskey We're going to do today $85 barrel Seagrass.
- 18:37I would probably choose it above our luxury category whiskies.
- 18:44Yeah, where we only have two entries, they're both like at
- 18:47least $200.00 and depending on how much you want to spend, if
- 18:50you can spend unlimited money on these.
- 18:52One is the Barrel Seagrass 16 year, which I believe is the
- 18:56Gray Label one. The other one is the Thomas H
- 18:59Handy Sazerac Rye, which we've tried multiple variants of.
- 19:03I think the 2020 was the one that was our highest rated
- 19:07whiskey of all time. Yes I think that would be my
- 19:11choice here. I like the Seagrass 16 but it is
- 19:14not better enough than the regular one for me to merit like
- 19:19spending the extra like I I'm happy if all I could ever get
- 19:22was the regular seagrass forever.
- 19:24Agreed. Yeah, 100% agreed that Thomas H
- 19:27Handy was like the heavens opening up and like there is so
- 19:34much going on with the Sazerac Rye there.
- 19:39Absolutely incredible poor. And I think that's our luxury
- 19:42winner in the rye category. All right.
- 19:44So from the bottom to the top here in the budget category,
- 19:47we're picking Old Overholt 100. In the next tier up, we're going
- 19:51with US1 Mcter's US1 Single Barrel Rye in that 50 to $80.00
- 19:56range, Hunting Creek Rye in the 80 to 120 barrel Seagrass and
- 20:01then in our luxury category, Thomas H Handy Sazerac Rye.
- 20:06That's a damn good shelf of rye right there, dude.
- 20:09That's that is an incredible shelf of rye, Bob.
- 20:12Let's knock Irish whiskey out here, Brad, because I've only
- 20:15got 3 entries on the spreadsheet and they're all like under $50.
- 20:20We've had some upper level Irish whiskeys in the past,
- 20:24specifically in season one. We tried a bunch of red breast
- 20:27and I don't think that we were ready to score high end Irish
- 20:31whiskeys yet. So I'm going to go ahead and
- 20:34just recuse us from those like let's, I think we should only
- 20:37kind of give what we reviewed and what we put confidence in
- 20:41our review for with maybe a caveat of like, hey, we've tried
- 20:45more Irish whiskey outside the podcast, Maybe try this if you
- 20:48want to spend a lot of money is that.
- 20:49Fair. I I think that's 100% fair.
- 20:52Well, in our under $25.00 range, I think there's really only one
- 20:56that I would recommend and it's because it comes in right at the
- 20:59high end of that at 2499 in the state of Ohio, it's the Sexton
- 21:05Single Malt Irish. Whiskey dude, this whiskey still
- 21:09like lives on in my brain as one of the best whiskeys we've had
- 21:14just because of the price point and the amount of flavor that
- 21:18you get in what I think is an 86 proof whiskey.
- 21:22Yeah, something like. That yeah, dude, so much flavor,
- 21:26all sorts of depth and complexity that you get in Irish
- 21:29whiskeys and I like, I just think it's such a cool bottle to
- 21:33go on top of all that. 100% OK. In the next category, up our 25
- 21:38to 50, we've got two nominees. One is just your standard
- 21:42everyday Jameson, which we've tried multiple Times Now as a
- 21:45way of confirming that we weren't just noobs back in the
- 21:49day, which we were, but we were correct.
- 21:51Noobs Jameson is a delicious whiskey and despite being mass
- 21:55produced like it, is one of the higher quality mass produced
- 21:59whiskeys you can get. Yeah.
- 22:01And our other option is the Bushmills Redbush, a whiskey
- 22:05that, if I'm being honest, Bob, I don't really remember
- 22:08drinking. We did three Bushmills right in
- 22:10a row and there were standard white label Bushmills, not very
- 22:13good. Then we tried the black Bush and
- 22:15that was not very good. And then we tried the Redbush,
- 22:17which I believe is finished in bourbon casks and it is like way
- 22:22spicier and so much more complex.
- 22:25And I like, I have it on my shelf still.
- 22:27I really love that. And when I'm in the mood for an
- 22:28Irish whiskey that's a little has more pop to it, that's what
- 22:31I pull off. Now I will say in this category,
- 22:35slightly on the cheaper side, coming in at $29.00 for a 750.
- 22:40I would also personally recommend Tola Mordu.
- 22:43Oh yeah, I believe you gave that a 40 out of 50 on average.
- 22:47Yes, I was going to say I remember drinking that and
- 22:50really, really liking it. Now it's been a little while,
- 22:54but man, oh man, it's a great value at $29.00, but I think I
- 22:58am going to go with Jameson for just a few dollars more.
- 23:02I'll pick Jameson as well. I think my personal choice would
- 23:04be the Red Bush, but I'm OK with Jameson.
- 23:07Now. Again, we have had some Irish
- 23:09whiskeys on the way, high end actually, back in March we went
- 23:12to this event that was hosted by the Ohio Liquor Bureau where we
- 23:16drank a bunch of really great Irish whiskeys.
- 23:18Waterford blew my mind. Booa was really, really good.
- 23:24Yep. We've also had an Irish whiskey
- 23:26from a company called Ahru ATHRU that they they mailed them to us
- 23:32from Ireland. That was the coolest package of
- 23:35mail I've ever gotten. I don't know how it got through
- 23:36customs, but it got to my house somehow and that was the best
- 23:39Irish whiskey I've ever had. But it was also like $250 a
- 23:43bottle. Yeah, there, there are
- 23:45incredible Irish whiskeys out there.
- 23:47We're not going to finish up the line up for Irish because we
- 23:50just haven't had quite enough of it, but if you haven't gotten
- 23:54into Irish whiskey yet, you need to.
- 23:57All right, Brad, let's knock out this one that I called
- 23:59international. Now, we've had probably four or
- 24:01five Japanese whiskeys on the show and then intermingled with
- 24:05some other areas, one of them being whales, where we had a
- 24:08flight of, I think, 4 different Pandarin whiskeys.
- 24:12The Pandarin Portwood is still one of our highest rated
- 24:14whiskeys of the last few seasons.
- 24:17I'm freaking love that thing. We've gone over to India and had
- 24:20a couple, the Amrut Fusion, one of our highest rated whiskeys
- 24:24ever. We had one from Taiwan called
- 24:26Kavalan, which was pretty good. I don't think it's in the league
- 24:29of those other two. And then the best Japanese
- 24:32whiskey that we've had on the show so far was the Yamazaki 12,
- 24:35which is a higher end Japanese whiskey.
- 24:39Brad, I think that honestly what we really have to decide here is
- 24:45between the Amroot Fusion and the Pandaren Portwood, what
- 24:50would get our pick in that 80 to 120 range because they both come
- 24:53in around $90.00. OK, Yeah, I mean, the Portwood
- 24:59from what I remember was similar enough to kind of that Irish
- 25:06Scotch experience. And the the the Amroot fusion
- 25:13was just spectacular. And I, I don't know if I've ever
- 25:17tasted plum on a whiskey so clearly before.
- 25:22Nothing against Pandarin. Pandarin makes incredible
- 25:25whiskeys. I, I remember we loved all four
- 25:27of them, but I'm going to give the the Amroot the my vote of
- 25:32confidence here all. Right.
- 25:33So Amroot Fusion and then I guess by default Yamazaki 12 are
- 25:38our representatives from the international bracket, if you
- 25:42want to call it that. Yeah, and I will say literally
- 25:45just a few nights ago I drank some Nika from the barrel.
- 25:49Oh. Dude, it's so good.
- 25:52It's incredible, man, and it's coming in at $70.00, so it also
- 25:58would be in that 50 to 80 price point range.
- 26:01And Oh my gosh, dude, it was spectacular.
- 26:05OK, let's jump down to Scotch. And Scotch is an interesting one
- 26:09because I don't have anything in the under $25 price point and I
- 26:12think. That's well, I have something
- 26:15for you, Bob. Oh, do you really Cuddy?
- 26:17Sark, baby? Oh Cuddy.
- 26:19Heck yeah, dude. Let's do Cuddy.
- 26:20Come on man. I like cuddy gets a bad.
- 26:23Rep But for it sure does. $17.00 like it's a damn good mixer.
- 26:29It's an incredible mixer, and if you really just want to have
- 26:32some fun times on cheap Scotch, get yourself some Cutty Sark.
- 26:36There you go. The our our sub $25 entrance is
- 26:40Cutty Sark in the 25 to $50 range.
- 26:43We've got some legitimate single malts and then some blended as
- 26:47well. We had one that I totally forgot
- 26:50we drank Brad called the Spayburn 10.
- 26:53This was a whiskey that I don't know how they sell it for so
- 26:57cheap. It's like a $30 single malt.
- 27:00Freaking blew our minds, dude. We were, we were at like a 40
- 27:02out of 50 on that one. We also really liked your
- 27:05standard Glenn Livett 12, which I don't know how that got such a
- 27:08high score. Like it's good, but I don't
- 27:10think it's like I thought Spayburn was better this past
- 27:13season. We drank one called the old
- 27:15Poulton E12, which also got about a 40 out of 50 from us.
- 27:18I was remember being a huge fan of old Poulton E12.
- 27:23And then we had the Nomad Outland Whiskey, which was like
- 27:26$30.00 and is one of the most like sweet, decadent Scotch
- 27:31whiskies I have ever had. I think I'd also throw a Monkey
- 27:34shoulder in here as well. I don't know.
- 27:36How do you want to proceed, Brad?
- 27:37I almost feel like we should do. We should give an award out for
- 27:40a single malt and for a blended. Yeah, I I think easily Monkey
- 27:45Shoulder is your blended winner here.
- 27:48I am actually going to go off script Bob.
- 27:51I have had a single malt that comes in at $35 called Jura 10
- 28:00year. I've never had anything from
- 28:02Jura. Oh dude, like don't tell anybody
- 28:07but Jura 10 year is incredible and I don't want the price to go
- 28:10up. It's dude, it is.
- 28:14It would be my vote at this range and nothing against Nomad.
- 28:19I still really like Nomad, but every time I drink it I have to
- 28:24like, convince myself that it's good because I like it so much
- 28:29but it's so weird in the world of Scotch.
- 28:33That's for sure. Yeah, it's definitely an outlier
- 28:35in the world of Scotch. I think since I haven't had the
- 28:38Jura and I want to try to keep my picks to ones we've actually
- 28:41reviewed on the show. I think I'll go with the
- 28:43Spayburn 10 because I liked the other ones, but I don't know
- 28:46that I liked them enough to to pay 12 to $15.00 more.
- 28:50And if you can get Spayburn for 30 bucks, like that's a great,
- 28:53great deal. Yeah, 100% man.
- 28:55I'm with you there. OK.
- 28:57In our 50 to $80.00 price point, we've got quite a few nominees
- 29:01here, Brad, like yes, we do quite a few.
- 29:03I'm I'll just read them from the bottom up.
- 29:05We've got Highland Park 12. We've got the Shivas, Regal
- 29:09Mizunara, Finish, Ardbeg 10, Glen Moringy, Nectar Door Glen
- 29:14Moringy, Lesanta. How do you how do you pronounce
- 29:16that pop? Nectar D Glen Moringy, Lesanta
- 29:23Tam Do 10, Port Charlotte 10, Pandarin Madera Finish, Talisker
- 29:2910, and Quinta Rubin 14. I think we know our winner here,
- 29:33Brad. It really sucks that this
- 29:35whiskey's like almost $75 now though.
- 29:38Yeah, I was going to say I I love keen to Reuben 14, but I
- 29:44love it at like 60 bucks, not at 70.
- 29:47I think $374 It is now, man, I'm I'm going to be honest with you.
- 29:54I think in this list I think Talisker 10 might be my.
- 29:59Winner Yeah, me too, man. So again, I kind of want to do
- 30:03these are, I think these are all single malts now, but I almost
- 30:05want to do like a non peeded and a peeded sure that Port
- 30:10Charlotte is like a freaking Pete bomb.
- 30:12That's a little too much for me. Ardbeg 10 might be too, but I
- 30:16think Quinta Reuben is my favorite whiskey here.
- 30:19And I, I want to keep telling people to buy it, but they are,
- 30:22they're starting to test my patience with the pricing on
- 30:24this thing. Talisker 10 has been $70.00
- 30:28forever. So I'm used to seeing that.
- 30:29I think I'm with you. I think Talisker 10 is probably
- 30:32the representative here, Brad. Yeah, 100%.
- 30:36There is a depth of flavour in the Talisker 10 that I loved and
- 30:40you get everything that you want out of a really beautiful single
- 30:46malt Scotch at this price point. OK.
- 30:49In our, I don't want to call it luxury, but our special occasion
- 30:52category of 80 to 120, we're going to say, let's see, five of
- 30:56them came out of our spreadsheet here.
- 30:58We've got the Lefroy 10 task strength, we've got Lefroy
- 31:02Galore, Lageval and 16, Ardbeg, Oogadol and Glenn Moringy 18.
- 31:09Now the 18 year old Glenn Moringy I think is like really
- 31:12pushing the upper limits of that 120.
- 31:14It might even go over in some places.
- 31:17Regardless of that, my pick would not be that Glenn Moringy
- 31:2118. I have a feeling I know exactly
- 31:23what your pick is going to be. Brad I.
- 31:25Mean this is this is the barrel seagrass of of Scotch.
- 31:28Bob Lageval and 16 cost $105.00 and if you gave me $110 to spend
- 31:37on whiskey I would buy this and then I would try to bum A10ML
- 31:42sample off somebody else for 5 bucks.
- 31:45Like Lagavulin 16 is creamy and rich and there are so many
- 31:52beautiful flavors going on here and I I can't encourage you
- 31:58enough, go eat a beautiful salt and peppered steak with your
- 32:04Lagovolin 16 and it'll change your life.
- 32:08I'm not picking Lagovolin 16 here because I think I just
- 32:11personally like the ARD Bag Oogadol better.
- 32:14This is the I I by far my highest rated ever peated
- 32:18Scotch. I think the Oogadol does such a
- 32:21great job of capturing what you get in Lagovolin in ARD bag, but
- 32:25then adding just that little bit of sweetness underneath that we
- 32:29don't typically, yeah, do you usually just tastes like
- 32:32medicinal and swampy and like this one I think couples that
- 32:37with a little bit of a nice kind of floral note as well.
- 32:40Honorable mention for me would be that Lefroig lore, which is
- 32:43like it was our highest rated Lefroig for a really long time.
- 32:47I just, I think you could do a lot worse than any of these ones
- 32:49that we've picked so far. Now again on the high, high end
- 32:53of Scotch Brad, we have a couple samples that were given to us by
- 32:56a friend who I will not name here of some Mcallen's that are
- 33:00apparently selling for $40,000 right now.
- 33:04And I'm going to break into your house and steal those.
- 33:06Well, I mean, I'm going to share them with you.
- 33:07I'm just saying like the the world of Scotch is truly
- 33:11unlimited in terms of how much money you can spend.
- 33:15So I don't really have a recommendation on the high high
- 33:17end do. You.
- 33:19I do actually Obon 18 is a really good pick up at like I
- 33:25think 180 bucks. The Macallan 15 comes in at
- 33:31about 180 as well. Another really exceptional
- 33:35expensive bottle whiskey. And I finally this is this is
- 33:41like I might buy a pour sometime.
- 33:44I spent $50 on a pour of this a while back and it was one of the
- 33:48best decisions I've ever made. Lagavulin 26 Bob.
- 33:54This is a 2.4000 dollar bottle of whiskey that I will never
- 34:00buy, but man oh man, that poor was special all right.
- 34:06So starting from the bottom up, we're going to recommend Cutty
- 34:10Sark folks at like $17.00 a bottle.
- 34:14From Cuddy to Lagavulin 26 baby. It's all the same, you know, and
- 34:19the next tier up we're going with monkey shoulder followed by
- 34:22Spayburn 10 at 30 ish dollars. We've got the Talisker 10
- 34:27representing the next tier up at roughly 70 bucks.
- 34:30And then if you want to get a little bit crazy, you want to
- 34:33break triple digits, you can either get the Lagavoulin 16
- 34:37brat's pick or the ARD bag Ugadal my pick.
- 34:40And finally, if you are just rolling in it, you can either do
- 34:43the Oban 18 or the Lagavoulin 26.
- 34:47Brad, this just leaves one category for us and it is a
- 34:50doozy. And we're talking about the
- 34:52world of bourbon. Kind of a a small category.
- 34:55You know, just just a slight category here.
- 34:58One of the things I do love about bourbon, and it's because
- 35:00of our access to it, you know, we're in the native country of
- 35:02bourbon, is that despite inflation, you can still get
- 35:06really good bourbon for under $20 if you know where to look.
- 35:11Yeah, there there are all sorts of really great cheap whiskeys
- 35:15out there that don't fall into the trap of, you know, poor man.
- 35:21Swell. We reviewed one of them earlier
- 35:25today, Bob, that Green River 1885 easily jumps into the
- 35:31highest end value category that we've ever had.
- 35:36But it, it was so impressive, Bob, that I, I actually almost
- 35:41had a little bit of a cage match.
- 35:43I brought out my bottle of Rebel 100 that I actually rarely drink
- 35:48from because I had to know, I had to check to see can this
- 35:541885 stand up to Rebel 100? And at the end of the day, Bob
- 36:00Rebel 100 is like a 15 out of 10 on value.
- 36:04It's so good dude. It's mind boggling how easy of a
- 36:10pick this is for me. The crazy thing is, like,
- 36:14listeners of our show now know how much we've hyped it.
- 36:16And we've had some people say I went out and bought a bottle
- 36:20because you guys hyped it up so much.
- 36:21And they're like, it's pretty good.
- 36:24It's like, yeah, dude, it's $20. Like I didn't tell you it was
- 36:27the best bourbon I've ever had. But but you could easily sell
- 36:31that bottle of whiskey for $30.00 and I still wouldn't bat
- 36:34an eye at it. And the fact that they're
- 36:35selling it at 20 is kind of like you said, it's mind boggling.
- 36:40The only other one that I would put in contention here, aside
- 36:42from the Green River that we had today, and I actually
- 36:45miscategorized this one as being $25.
- 36:48It's $22.00 in the state of Ohio.
- 36:50Benchmark foolproof. It's 125 proof whiskey for
- 36:56$22.00. Yeah, that's really hard to pass
- 36:59up on, man. Let's walk through this next
- 37:03category. Brad.
- 37:03This is our 25 to $50 range. Starting from the lowest end.
- 37:08We've got Ezra Brooks 99 Bullet Bourbon, Cooper's Craft 100
- 37:14Proof Early Times Bottled and Bond, Jack Daniels Triple Mash,
- 37:201792, Foolproof, Johnny Drum Rebel Distillers Collection, and
- 37:26New Rif Bottled and Bond Bourbon.
- 37:28This is a tough matchup. There's like four or five here
- 37:31that I could easily pick. Yeah, I, I was going to say,
- 37:33let's just get like 3 on the docket and talk about those
- 37:38three. I personally am going to
- 37:41recommend Cooper's Craft 100, I think it's called Distillers
- 37:46Blend. I, I'm going to put that one up.
- 37:49Bob, what about for you? Let's see, I can I just throw a
- 37:52couple names out here and you tell me yes or no on these?
- 37:54Sure. I think that Jack Daniels triple
- 37:57match deserves to be in the conversation.
- 37:59Yes, I think Rebel Distillers Collection deserves to be in the
- 38:02conversation. Yes.
- 38:05I would say New Riff, Bottled and Bond, but I also might
- 38:11recommend 1792 Foolproof. We haven't really had anything
- 38:14barrel proof yet or close to it, you know?
- 38:17Yeah, I think I would lean towards the 1792 over the new
- 38:22riff, but man, this is a stacked category.
- 38:26And honestly, of all the whiskeys we've done so far, I I
- 38:30almost feel like you need like a subcategory of 30 to 40 and 40
- 38:34to 50. I think that's fair.
- 38:37Let's do that. OK, so sub $40, we're talking
- 38:40about Cooper's Craft 100. We're talking about Jack Daniels
- 38:44Triple mash, which I categorize as bourbon.
- 38:46I know it's Tennessee whiskey, which is.
- 38:49Bourbon. I think, OK, let's do that.
- 38:51I would say I think the triple mash is the better whiskey, but
- 38:56I would pick the Cooper's Craft here, honestly.
- 38:59Yeah, I would slept on. I think, I think 100% people
- 39:03sleep on the Cooper's Craft. It's got great labeling, it's a
- 39:06good looking bottle on your shelf, and it makes some of the
- 39:10absolute best cocktails you will ever have if you're willing to
- 39:15spend, you know, 35 bucks on a mixer.
- 39:19OK, so between Rebel Distillers Collection and 1792 Foolproof, I
- 39:24obviously know my choice. What would your choice?
- 39:26Be yeah, I I think my choice is, is pretty obvious too.
- 39:29The The Rebels Distiller Collection takes everything you
- 39:32get with Rebel 100 and shows you why that is so good when you
- 39:38give it a. Higher quality addition.
- 39:41Yeah, for sure. All right, in the 50 to $80.00
- 39:44range, we're looking at Green River Foolproof, which is
- 39:48immediately a contender. Rebel Cask strength Rebel.
- 39:52Seriously, start paying us money.
- 39:55We have given you so much publicity.
- 39:57Oh, my gosh. A. 100% man.
- 40:00Old Forester 1910 You've got Woodford, Double Oaked, Wild
- 40:05Turkey, Rare Breed, Maker's Mark, Cask Strength, Rabbit
- 40:10Hole, Cave Hill, Old Forester 1920, Russell's Reserve, Single
- 40:15Barrel, Weller Antique, and Joseph Magnus.
- 40:18Holy crap, dude. Dude, we've drank some really
- 40:22good whiskey. We sure have.
- 40:25All right, once again, let's do, let's do the same thing.
- 40:27Let's go like 50 to, I don't know, 50 to 60 and then sixty
- 40:32and above. Yeah, I I think that's fair.
- 40:35I think if we're doing 50 to 60, oh man, how are how are you
- 40:41going to this is the might be the hardest category, Bob,
- 40:45because you want. My hot take My hot take is I
- 40:49would take every single one of these over the 60 to $80.00
- 40:54ones. Oh.
- 40:57I don't think there's one in there.
- 40:59The 60 to $80.00 ones are Rabbit Hole, Cave Hill, Old Forester,
- 41:021920, Russell's Reserve and Weller Antique and Joseph
- 41:06Magnus. I would take literally any one
- 41:08of these. Underneath it, above that.
- 41:11The Weller Antique One O 7 is the only one that would come
- 41:14close for me, but I think I'm with you.
- 41:19Like honestly, I think if I had to pick two from this category,
- 41:23it would probably be the Green River Foolproof and the Woodford
- 41:28Double Oat and and that's including the 60 and $70.00
- 41:32stuff. I would cut out, yeah, I would
- 41:34for sure cut out the Rebel cask strength.
- 41:36I just think the Distillers collection is better.
- 41:39Maker's Mark cask strength blew us away.
- 41:42Oh, so good. I think that that's actually
- 41:45$45. Is it really?
- 41:47I I believe it's 45 bucks in the state of Ohio, yeah.
- 41:51All right. Well then we're just going to
- 41:52eliminate it here and I'm going to say sorry that we didn't get
- 41:54to you earlier, but that makes our decision easier.
- 41:57I would probably nominate Rare Breed Wood for Double Oaked and
- 42:05Green River Foolproof. Those will be my 3:00.
- 42:07Oh man, if I had to pick one of those three because I I'm with
- 42:11you. I think the Old Forester 1910 is
- 42:14worthy of another mention. One of the best bourbons at that
- 42:17price point. I, I think that I'm just going
- 42:21to stay loyal to my journey as a whiskey connoisseur.
- 42:28And Woodford Double Oaked was the first whiskey I ever had
- 42:32that made me step back and go, oh, yeah, that's what whiskey
- 42:36can be. Yeah.
- 42:37So I I think I'm just going to stick with Woodford Double Oaked
- 42:41here. I think I am too, and part of it
- 42:43is because I love Rare Breed and I love the Foolproof from Green
- 42:47River so much. I don't know which one of those
- 42:49I would if you made me choose one forever, I don't know that I
- 42:53could make that choice. Whereas Double Oaked is kind of
- 42:55like in a category of its own. So I'm going to put Double Oaked
- 42:58on here. And that takes us to our 80 to
- 43:00120 range where we've only got a few contenders from our
- 43:04spreadsheet. We've got the Pursuit United
- 43:07Bourbon from our friends at Bourbon Pursuit Barrel Vantage.
- 43:11I think our highest ranked whiskey of season 8, John J
- 43:15Bowman Single Barrel, a whiskey that apparently dominated that I
- 43:18don't even remember drinking Rebel 10 Single Barrel and
- 43:23Booker's. Booker's is kind of the gimmicky
- 43:26choice here. I would say Brad, like if you
- 43:28want a nice box, you can get Booker's.
- 43:30Yeah, I I'll go ahead and I know that nobody can get this
- 43:35anymore, but I will just honorable mention the Pfeiffer
- 43:38Pavit Reserve that we had ages ago.
- 43:41And I think that that was a 120. So it's, you know, it's kind of
- 43:45on the edge of this category, but Bardstown Bourbon Company is
- 43:50always going to put out good whiskey.
- 43:53I'm going to say my honorable mention would be the Pursuit
- 43:56United, but I'm going to go with Barrel Vantage.
- 43:59Here I dude, we are we're in lockstep here man, that barrel
- 44:04vantage is so good. I, like Beryl continues to be
- 44:11the greatest blender of whiskeys of any company we've ever
- 44:15encountered. OK.
- 44:17That takes us to our ultra premium category where we've got
- 44:21the Bardstown En Route Collaborative series at 160
- 44:25dollars. We've got the old Forrester
- 44:27150th anniversary now. As I recall, when we had former
- 44:32blender Jackie Zikan on the show, there were three blends
- 44:36that they came out with as the 1:50 and I think we had blend #1
- 44:40and it knocked our freaking socks off.
- 44:43That whiskey is got to cost like $1000 now because they only came
- 44:46out once. And then finally we had Blanton
- 44:49straight from the barrel. The barrel that we had was
- 44:53bottled I believe in 2002. It was sent to us by our
- 44:57Instagram friends, bourbon and stuff.
- 44:59It was no joke, the best bourbon I've ever had in my life.
- 45:03It's hard for me to say that any other Blanton straight from the
- 45:06barrel will taste like that, but like for me, even on the off
- 45:11chance that it might echo that, I think my pick would be the
- 45:14straight from the barrel. Now I I will say we have also
- 45:18had Pappy Van Winkle 15 year. I don't know if that just didn't
- 45:24quite reach the this level. We we were underwhelmed, Brad.
- 45:28OK. Based on the I think it was
- 45:30based on the price honestly. Yeah, exactly.
- 45:33Now we have also off Off the Record, off the film and Whiskey
- 45:38Record had the likes of Eagle Rear 17 and I was personally
- 45:44blown away with that. I think if I had to pick from
- 45:48these three I would probably. Oh man, that old Forrester 150
- 45:56was good. I'm going to.
- 45:57I'm with you man. I'll go with the Blanton
- 45:59straight from the barrel. That one was so stunningly good.
- 46:03We've had, I think, 4 different kinds of Blanton's on the show,
- 46:05and I think only two of them are even worth the price.
- 46:08And it was the Blanton's gold label and the Blanton straight
- 46:11from the barrel. And I think that if you're ever
- 46:13going to try to tell people to go buy Blanton's, you got to
- 46:18have like it has to be the straight from the barrel.
- 46:20It's the only one that I think is worth springing for in terms
- 46:22of the money you're going to invest.
- 46:24Brad. It's it's also worth noting that
- 46:26our presenting sponsor today, Blackwood Distilling, all of
- 46:29their bottles kind of fall into this 120 to $160.00 price range.
- 46:34And I got to say, man, like that toasted rye that we have had
- 46:38from them. That's obviously not bourbon
- 46:39here that we're talking about, but that toasted barrel rye is
- 46:43freaking phenomenal. It's not available nationwide
- 46:46yet, but if you can find a pour of it anywhere, I highly
- 46:50recommend trying a pour of that at the bar.
- 46:52Yes, you. Man, we talked about how a lot
- 46:55of bonus episode whiskeys didn't make it in here because we don't
- 46:59quite have it on our spreadsheets the same way as all
- 47:01of our regular episodes. I, I feel ashamed, Bob, that
- 47:05Blackwood rye is so good. I mean the the amount of the
- 47:12depth of flavor, the richness that you get reminds me of like
- 47:15a barrel seagrass where you get the best of both worlds of a
- 47:19bourbon and a rye. And so we have our list of
- 47:23Bourbons now, Brad in the sub 25 category, Rebel 100 in the 25 to
- 47:2950. You can take your pick between
- 47:31Rebel Distillers Collection, My Favorite whiskey, and Cooper's
- 47:34Craft 100 in the 50 to $80.00 range.
- 47:38Woodford Double Oaked 80 to 120. We picked Barrel Vantage and in
- 47:43the above 120, Blanton's straight from the barrel.
- 47:48I want to drink all of these whiskeys right now.
- 47:51Yeah, I I was going to say, this has given me cravings to like go
- 47:53back and and drink all of these over again.
- 47:56Yeah, well folks, there are our picks for every whiskey you can
- 48:00get at every price point, but we want to know what your personal
- 48:03favorites are. Is there something we completely
- 48:05whipped on or just forgot about? You can let us know on all of
- 48:08our social medias, Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, Tiktok or
- 48:12YouTube at Film Whiskey. Or jum onto the Discord.
- 48:16We are on there every single day talking to you guys, fans of the
- 48:19Film and Whiskey podcast. So if you'd like to join the
- 48:22conversation, you can find a link to our Discord server at
- 48:25the end of every single one of our show notes.
- 48:28We want to say thanks again to our presenting sponsor,
- 48:30Blackwood Distilling Company. Check out their website,
- 48:33blackwooddistillingco.com. Grab yourself a bottle today.
- 48:37We'll be back next week with another special bonus episode,
- 48:40but until then, I'm Bob Book. I'm Brad G.
- 48:44And we'll see you next time.