Latest / The Team House / Ukraine War Update, Prigozhin Housecleaning w/ Geopolitical Analyst | Aaron Schwartzbaum | Ep. 230
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, folks, I just want to take a minute to ask you to
- 0:03go in rate this podcast, let the Team House know how you think we're
- 0:07doing. Go and rate us on whatever platform you're listening to this on,
- 0:11whether it's iTunes or Spotify or whatever else. Those ratings really help us out
- 0:16and we really appreciate the feedback to let us know what you like and what
- 0:19you don't like. And if you do like the Teamhouse and you'd like to
- 0:23support us, go check out our Patreon page and you can actually support the
- 0:27stream and well as get access to our bonus segments and bonus episodes. Yeah,
- 0:32if you're gonna give us a great review, please do. And if
- 0:35you're going to give us another secret review, why don't you just send us
- 0:37an email. We'll talk about special operations covert. Ask me a the Team
- 0:52House with your hopes. Jack Burphy, David Park, Everyone, Welcome to
- 1:03episode two hundred and thirty of The Team House. I'm Jack Murphy who with
- 1:06David Park, and we're really happy tonight to have in studio our guest Aaron
- 1:10Schwartzbaum, who is a Russia expert. We had him on about a year
- 1:12and a half ago, like really a week or two after the war kicked
- 1:17off to really do kind of a deep dive on the war in Ukraine,
- 1:19and I'm gonna catch back up. We got a lot to talk about tonight.
- 1:23But first first we want to say thanks to our first sponsor of the
- 1:27evening, re Medical. Let's take a moment to tell you about our sponsor,
- 1:32re Medical. We know how difficult it can be to get accurate disability
- 1:34rating and the proper benefits despite your best efforts and multiple doctor business. When
- 1:40it comes to the Veterans Administration, connecting new or worsening disabilities to your service
- 1:45just adds to the frustration because they all act like the money is coming out
- 1:49of their pocket for some reason. This is re medicals wheelhouse. The documentation
- 1:56process they've designed to help veterans is unmatched, and the experience of the doctors
- 2:00in their network is invaluable. Now, every case is different and Remedical can't
- 2:06guarantee what the VA is going to decide, but ninety five percent of their
- 2:10clients reported receiving a disability rating of seventy or higher. Re medicals nationwide network
- 2:16of disability specialists and medical professionals are ready to help veterans across all fifty states
- 2:23and those working or living overseas. So if you need an evaluation of your
- 2:27disability rating and accurate medical evidence to support your VA claim, turn the team
- 2:31Remedical. Head over to re medical that's r eemedical dot com. Slash the
- 2:38teamhouse that's r ee medical dot com. The slash the teamhouse for more info.
- 2:44Don't fight that bottle by yourself, guys, like it's a complicated system.
- 2:47Get professionals on your side. Reach out to re medical. So,
- 2:52Aaron, can you give us like a brief recap recap on your background and
- 2:58where you're coming from. I know we talked about it probably in depth on
- 3:00the last one, the origin story, right, Yeah, just for people
- 3:02who haven't heard it yet. Well, first of all, thanks for having
- 3:05me back. Good to be here. So yeah, by background, I'm
- 3:07a Russian analyst, but I've also bounced around the political risk and startup space
- 3:13federal facing for the last couple of years, so kind of a tech risk
- 3:16and subjects matter regional hat I wear so currently and just want to emphasize speaking
- 3:22for myself tonight. So my Russia Eurasia affiliation is with the Foreign Policy Research
- 3:27Institute FPRI. Which is a non partisan think tank in Philadelphia where I live.
- 3:31To great city folks, that's the one I'm working with. The startup
- 3:37called Altana actually here in Brooklyn that does supply to an analysis applying artificial intelligence
- 3:44and machine learning to global trades. Really cool analytics there, And also working
- 3:47on a DoD Grand project about great power influence and seeking to measure and quantify
- 3:53and visualize how the US, China, and Russia exert influence globally. So
- 3:58a lot of hats but I think this Russia stuff is the technical term is
- 4:02my first love. So yeah, it's been a pretty wild year and a
- 4:06half. Crazy to think how much has happened since last tight was on.
- 4:10There's a lot of grounds to cover today. I think, do you have
- 4:14any thoughts about where you'd like to start that conversation? I mean, we
- 4:18can start big picture and go small picture, or that's probably the right way
- 4:25to go about this. So since the invasion kicked off, I mean,
- 4:29I think we talked in the last episode a lot about the drivers for the
- 4:31conflict and sort of where it stood at the time. Big picture, how
- 4:35have you seen things unfold over the last year and a half. Yeah,
- 4:39so a couple of I guess you could say, like the big themes we've
- 4:43seen so, I mean, for one, the tenacity of the Ukrainian people.
- 4:46We saw that at the very get go, that was true true the
- 4:49first time we did this, and that's true now, and that hasn't really
- 4:53flagged or wavered over this whole thing. I think, I guess last time
- 4:58we talked, the Russian military forces are probably what a weekend still parked fairly
- 5:03close to Kiev in the suburbs. So we've seen the war swing back towards
- 5:10Ukraine's favor largely. It's I don't want to say stalemated, right, we
- 5:14don't want to use two loaded terminology here, but kind of taken on more
- 5:17stable contours, like it's less maneuver, more of a slog of late I
- 5:21think we can talk a lot more, a lot more about the battlefield is
- 5:26matured a lot. Yeah. Yeah, So there's that. I think those
- 5:30are the two big trends. I think the other other thing worth mentioning is
- 5:34some of the lessons that we've kind of learned time and time again about the
- 5:40nature of warfare and the extent to which we're seeing some new technology and new
- 5:44developments. But what is this the line about how like the character of war
- 5:47changes, the nature of war doesn't, and seeing like the whatliferation of drones
- 5:53and new stealths cruise missiles being tested from Western countries xyz. But ultimately there's
- 6:00a lot of math problems that you know, relate to fighting a large interstate
- 6:04war. And I think, Okay, another lesson, big takeaway is how
- 6:09nasty near peer competition is. And there's just there's no ifs ends or butts
- 6:13about it. It's it's bloody and it's brutal, and it's horrible, and
- 6:18that's just that's just the nature of it. There's no it's not a desert
- 6:21storm thing. It's not how it works when you're fighting an opponent who's at
- 6:26your kind of weight class. Right. This is more of a war of
- 6:30attrition where there are front lines. Yeah, oh yeah, profoundly. I
- 6:33mean there was the New York Times did it report? I want to say
- 6:36it was around Bachmu talking to a medic, a Ukrainian medic who just I
- 6:43mean, it still sticks with me, just the real like thousand yards stare
- 6:46in his eyes. He wasn't even on the front, but I mean,
- 6:49was I mean almost like hollow as a person from like the stuff he had
- 6:53seen. Basically said like, I don't know any if any of you would
- 6:58understand like even worth sharing what I've seen. I just you won't get it.
- 7:02And yeah, it's stilled like that, faces like stuck with me.
- 7:04I hope he's doing okay. Yeah, that's a that's a tough one to
- 7:09watch. And I think it was you that pointed out to me that,
- 7:13you know, one of the big lessons to come out of all of this
- 7:15is that for all of our talk about cyber warfare and stealth technology and you
- 7:20know, in an American side, we talked about all these things that are
- 7:24over the horizon, directed energy weapons and all this sort of far flung almost
- 7:27buck Rogers sounding technologies. Here we are in a modern battle space, but
- 7:32it still comes down to at some point you got to go and clear the
- 7:34trench line. You need to clear through the breach. You need to send
- 7:38soldiers out there, lob and hand grenades into the trench. Yeah, there
- 7:41was Russia's push in the east when that started. So after Russian military forces
- 7:46withdrew from kind of central North Ukraine from around Skiev, assuming that area,
- 7:54and then concentrated on Dunbas and they're offensive. There was an episode where they
- 8:01lost apparently and it's hard to know the specific numbers here about like maybe five
- 8:07hundred people, multiple units of like material and tanks trying across the river.
- 8:13Yes, trying across the river is hard. That is armored. That's just
- 8:18tough. It doesn't matter if there's cyber or what. It's just like that
- 8:22has remains true of warfare. You can tell like a Roman general that to
- 8:26be like, yeah, like that's that's hard to get across the river opposed
- 8:28when when the Germans tried to push into Rush or they encountered all of this,
- 8:33So yeah, not not new to anyone. That's kind of like a
- 8:35reminder of some of the kind of the rules, the rules and laws that
- 8:41govern how this sort of thing tends to tends to happen. So I mean,
- 8:45if I if I'm remembering quickly correctly, and so much stuff has happened.
- 8:48But I mean, yeah, they successfully defended Kiev. The assault the
- 8:52offensive from Belarus is pretty much you know, done with. But then we
- 8:58saw, you know, I guess at the halfway point, we saw are
- 9:01very successful Ukrainian offensive to recapture some of these areas, and these like stunning
- 9:07images of Ukrainians rolling in these little villages and like old ladies coming out and
- 9:11hugging them and giving them morraages. I mean, did that surprise you how
- 9:15effective they were at that time? I think that caught everybody by surprise,
- 9:18and I think it's it's interesting to see how that set expectations for what's happening
- 9:24now down south Stopardasia around what they both talking about, and we can talk
- 9:28about some of the geography and the counter offensive now, but yeah, what
- 9:33was happening at the time was Ukraine pushing on sun which was the only major
- 9:39city to fall to Russian military forces, and it was in a certain respect
- 9:45kind of similar to what we're seeing now in southern Ukraine, where it became
- 9:50kind of like a bloody, protracted slog through defensive line after defensive line,
- 9:56and albeit not as well dug in as the Russians are and places they're defending
- 10:01now, and that wounds up being a successful offensive, but actually a bit
- 10:07of sleight of hand on the part of Ukrainians who really broadcast and I think
- 10:11in international media too, like this is the thrust where we're really aiming for
- 10:16and actually no, they're secretly on the side gathering forces up north to move
- 10:22clear at the rest of hat Kiev Oblast, so up north, and yet
- 10:26I had a tremendous success pushing back the Russians there, And I mean that's
- 10:31I think, really the example of maneuver warfare kind of in the quintessential form,
- 10:37just moving around strong points. And I mean you have to think there
- 10:41was some older gentlemen in the US somewhere who helped build the Humby who must
- 10:46have been delighted watching them zooming around the flat plains of eastern Europe as they
- 10:50were you know, designs and like, that's what they were built for and
- 10:54they were good at it. But yeah, that's given way too is we'll
- 10:58get into kind of a different kinds of combat here. But yeah, that
- 11:01was a real bloody nose for Russian kind of shocked the world that Ukraine was
- 11:07able to right that off, right right. I want to ask you real
- 11:09quick in retrospect, you know, you talk about a bloody nose in retspect,
- 11:13Like there's a video of Jack and I and I think Annie Milburn all
- 11:16prior to the war saying it's not gonna happen. Right, we were wrong.
- 11:22A lot of people were wrong. We were wrong. Yeah, then
- 11:26I think for most people in the United States, for most analysts, for
- 11:31most you know, people interested in military stuff. They thought the Russian army
- 11:33would like it, would you know, three days, five days, it'll
- 11:37be done, and we were wrong. Through the course of this war.
- 11:43What are some other things aside from those two big ones. Have you seen
- 11:46people kind of go out there on the not on the limb, whether it's
- 11:50popular, you know, a popular theory or not. Where have you seen
- 11:56people just really fall short looking in retrospect in their assessment of what was happening,
- 12:01whether with Ukraine or Russia or anything else like that. I think one
- 12:05of them. We can talk about the larger kind of trends we've seen with
- 12:09the war. I call it the boom bust cycle, and it describes a
- 12:13lot of the coverage of russia domestic politics too, where coverage of the war
- 12:20tends to vacillate. It's never hey, this is like a brutal near Pier
- 12:24Slog it's extremely bloody, and Ukraine is slowly advancing. That'd be a pretty
- 12:28nuance to think their take it's either Ukraine is about to collapse, their forces
- 12:33are falling apart, or you know, hey, Ukraine is gathered for this
- 12:37counter offensive and there's absolutely nothing Russia could do a nuclear armed state, like
- 12:43there's nothing Russia could do. This is the end, and it's like that's
- 12:45it's never really either of those extremes, and it still is the tone of
- 12:50coverage of like Ukrainians are demoralized. It's like, well, no, they're
- 12:54like still advancing in the south, like they're making progress. And there's other
- 12:58report that they're actually feel pretty good to be making progress despite the heavy costs
- 13:03thereof. So yeah, I think that's one of the things to be on
- 13:07the lookout for. Whereas it's these complete swings. So after the Krakiev offensive,
- 13:13oh, like Ukraine they've got it in the bag now, and then
- 13:16Russia pushed into Bahmut is absolutely blood bath, urban slog fests and oh no
- 13:22Russia. Ukraine's broken down, they got pushed out of bach Mut, and
- 13:26that they gathered for the counter offensive. O, now Ukraine's gonna win and
- 13:30it's like no, So it keeps doing that again and again, and it's
- 13:33a good habit kind of be aware of that pattern in coverage because the truth
- 13:39remains somewhere in the middle. There's the classic line about Russia what never never
- 13:45as strong as you fear, never as weak as you hope, And I
- 13:48think that is true for Russia now. But I think, yeah, good
- 13:52thing to keep in mind about the coverage, right, Yeah, you're right
- 13:54that it's often portrayed as being hopeless for one side or the other, one
- 13:58of the big tray. I just want to drill down on I had hopes
- 14:01to mention it and forgotten now reremembered making peace with the fog of war.
- 14:07I feel like with a lot of military coverage. I don't know if this
- 14:11is unique to Ukraine, but like the over ocdentification, where like we can
- 14:15know everything happening exactly, like the motivations, what's going on in each village
- 14:20and each mile of dirt, and like we can't and making peace with yet
- 14:26not really knowing exactly what may be happening at any given moments. And that's
- 14:31easy to spit out like hot takes like this is what happened here, and
- 14:35we especially with the counter offensive, now, we we don't really know like
- 14:39a super granular level. There are people who do. They're not going to
- 14:43tell us what's actually happening. But yeah, it's it's it's acknowledging that there
- 14:48there's a lot happening that we just we just fundamentally don't now. Yeah,
- 14:52no, you're you're you're right now. I mean I was thinking that this
- 14:54week and we'll talk about it more about with progosion. I mean right away
- 14:58everyone's like, this is how it happen, and it's like, hey,
- 15:00you don't know that. Calm down, you know, to take a step
- 15:03back. No, but no, that's that's that's true. That's a very
- 15:07that's a reoccurring theme throughout the conflict. And you know, I think modern
- 15:11technology has kind of brainwashed us. We like self delude ourselves that we know
- 15:16more than we actually do. Technology for that. That's uh. Some of
- 15:22these big battles Croissan, Bach, Moot, Mariapol. I want to talk
- 15:30to us a little bit about the geography of Ukraine. And there's a lot
- 15:33always a lot of talk about is this. You know, the cities are
- 15:35often the centers of gravity. Are they strategic? Are they not strategic?
- 15:39Should they? Should the Ukraines be fighting, you know, pulling the resources
- 15:43into this conflict or not? I mean what what is the significance of these
- 15:46various centers of gravity and the conflict. Yeah, so I think we can
- 15:50talk about maybe more helpful to talk about the front lines. Now we can
- 15:56talk about kind ofsan and mari Upo. I think one of the things when
- 16:00we're talking about strategic it's important to talk about strategic how because there can be
- 16:04strategically importance. Let's talk about this city in the south, Tokmak is not
- 16:08a large city, more of a town really, that's just an importance transit
- 16:14hub. So like that's one way of measuring strategic importance from the other.
- 16:18From the other hand, a city like Bam, Yeah, there's some rail
- 16:23junctions that's like importance ish, but there's symbolic importance, there's political importance and
- 16:30not to get to like Klass with Sien here. But like people say,
- 16:33oh, there's the politics side and and that's just all one big spectrum.
- 16:37So like Ukraine choosing to fight for bach Mut wasn't a lot of the experts
- 16:41in the field, and there's a lot of people who know this stuff way
- 16:45better than I do, but would would say it wasn't military militarily necessary to
- 16:51defend that particular city, but politically became kind of this point of resistance they
- 16:56shall not pass if they're done style, like we will stop that here.
- 17:00And as it were, Russia kind of exhausted itself by going after the Russia
- 17:04too, like no, like we will take this place that was not strictly
- 17:07necessary. When they did, they ended up taking like a ghost town,
- 17:11just the hollowed out skeleton of what it was. Ghost town is maybe even
- 17:15generous. I mean the kind of flattens the hall place, so it's not
- 17:18really much of a place anymore. Unfortunately, as far as that the geography.
- 17:25So at the beginning of the war last time we last time we spoke,
- 17:30it was around Kiev. This was like an attempted decapitation. They were
- 17:33going to try to encircle Ukraine's capitol, forced political concessions, bing mang Boom
- 17:38done three days, have a big parade through the city and leave. And
- 17:41I think that's one of the things we we learned, maybe around the time
- 17:45we were talking, or maybe soon after that, a lot of the Russians
- 17:48who rolled in up north had their like parade gear with them and yeah,
- 17:53like in their tanks. And I was listening to a podcast actually by a
- 17:56colleague at FPRII who blaines they like, for like tankers, there's no extra
- 18:02space in there. I haven't served, I wouldn't know that offhand, but
- 18:04like to bring parade equipment that takes up these are cramped places. And yeah,
- 18:08these they just tried this thunder run into Kiev and got completely shredded to
- 18:14bits and didn't work. So we can talk about that geography, the geography
- 18:18that matters, I think particularly. So two pieces, two focuses here.
- 18:22So there's the lands bridge. So if you think of Ukraine, Russia is
- 18:27now in control of the strip of lands that connects Russia proper to occupied Crimea,
- 18:34and Russia built a bridge over the Kirch Strait which connects the mainlands to
- 18:40Crimea. They did that, but that's one pretty key vulnerability, right if
- 18:45there's one bridge, that one bridge can be attacked and destroyed, as Ukraine
- 18:48has attempted, and some success come knocks the bridge out of action. So
- 18:52the lands bridge that it's land you can drive drive over it. So that's
- 18:56really the focal points. Ukraine's haul offensive now is really predicated on severing the
- 19:02land bridge, and we can talk about like what severing means doesn't have to
- 19:07take all the territory to effectively sever the land bridge. That's one. Part
- 19:11two is Dunbass so eastern Ukraine. So before the war, these people's republics
- 19:17which were nominally controlled by Russia with some local players who had their own agenda
- 19:22to controlled a chunk of these two oblasts, these two regions the equivalent of
- 19:27a state, large chunks of it. But Russia's stated aim at the beginning
- 19:33of the war, before Karson and Zaporagia was to seize it's the entirety of
- 19:41Dunyetsk and Luhansk. Russia has most of Luhansk now, but Dunyetsk is there's
- 19:48a large chunk of the oblast that Ukraine has held and has been really strongly
- 19:55fortified since twenty fourteen. And there's places where the front lines basically changed since
- 20:00since the seizure of crime Nei, but that have just been so dug in
- 20:04and fortified. Ideas a city that comes to mind is one example where Russia's
- 20:11strategic game ultimately is to seize this territory. Hasn't been able to yet and
- 20:17is on the defensive right now, so unclear whether Russia has the ability to
- 20:21generate forces to achieve another offensive. So the current offensive, do you want
- 20:27to talk about a little bit about the run up to it? And there
- 20:32because there was an extended period of arming and supplying Ukraine for this offensive,
- 20:37bringing over the Bradley's and everything else. I mean, do you want to
- 20:41talk a little bit about the run up to the offensive before we get into
- 20:42it. Yeah, So the story here is Ukraine kind of playing defensive in
- 20:48the east over time, all the while in some cases trading trading space and
- 20:56lands for time to kind of wind up it's fit to basically generate more forces.
- 21:02And this was one of the things we saw early in the war where
- 21:06Ukraine underwents national mobilization that the start of the war Russia didn't. Russia did
- 21:11around you know, as as I think back on this, we came up
- 21:15with a list of like key events that happened, and I keep thinking of
- 21:18more of them as we have this conversation. Russia declaring partial mobilization in twenty
- 21:23twenty two, that was a pretty wider shed event that has led Putin I
- 21:29think scared is not the right word, but certainly put him off of declaring
- 21:33more formal mobilization. Because of the internal strife. But yeah, Ukraine basically
- 21:40built up a lot of new forces to try to launch this counterattack and sever
- 21:45Russia's land bridge, so make this church straight bridge the only place that Russia
- 21:52could resupply Krimia ostensibly go after Crimea too. I don't know if Ukrainian leaders
- 21:56themselves actually think that's going to happen or should happen, but they certainly talk
- 22:00about it. They want to demonstrate a will to be able to attack everywhere
- 22:06and keep Russia and military forces. We saw the Ukrainians kind of like probing
- 22:11the wire for quite quite a bit in the run up to this, and
- 22:12then there's the whole incursion into Belgarade by some sort of proxy force. Yeah,
- 22:18so that was one of these like weird episodes where these are Russian nationalists
- 22:26who you would think would also have imperial views towards towards Ukraine. Interesting,
- 22:33but yeah, they launched this incursion into Russia proper and took over a couple
- 22:38of towns for a while, and they're like a little fascist ostensibly a little
- 22:44fast, just a little just a bit a bit of fast as as a
- 22:45treat. Yeah, but they yeah, kind of haven't been heard from since.
- 22:52So I don't know what happened to think the Western leaders, I think
- 22:57maybe fairly kind of slap on their race, take like, don't associate with
- 23:02those people, but they're effective. And it's the same reason Ukraine in twenty
- 23:06fourteen has relied on this Azova battalion. We can talk about them like they're
- 23:11they're willing to fight, and Azov, as it were, has become more
- 23:14professionalized and isn't really the same organization it was with the same problematic and Insignia
- 23:21still had some of that too. Yeah, no, we should, we
- 23:22should get into that a little bit. But then over the summer we saw
- 23:29that the offensive start to kick off in earnest I mean there are high hopes
- 23:34for that. I mean we had conversations with it on this show with with
- 23:37Andy and some other folks. How how is it kind of played out from
- 23:41your perspective? Do we gotta do this? Uh? Yeah, sorry to
- 23:45interrupt you, Aaron, Go ahead, David, which one did you want
- 23:48to do this? Yeah? January mark the third time of power station North
- 23:56Carolina was damaged by gunfire. Recently, authority are saying the attack raises a
- 24:00new level of threat authorities are now checking our grid for vulnerabilities. They've identified
- 24:06nine key substations. If these substations are attacked, power could be knocked out
- 24:11from coast to coast for up to eighteen months. Imagine a blackoutlasting not days,
- 24:15but weeks or months. But weeks or months, your life would be
- 24:22frozen in time. Right at the moment power fails, lights all over the
- 24:25world would go out, throwing people into darkness. That's why having your own
- 24:30solar power is more important than ever. With the Patriot Power Generator, you
- 24:36get a solar generator a doesn't install into your house because it's supportable. You
- 24:40can take it with you, even use it inside. But as power enough
- 24:44is powerful enough for your phones, medical devices, and even your fridge.
- 24:48Right now, you can go to four Patriots that's number four patriots dot com
- 24:52and use code Teamhouse to get ten percent off your first purchase on anything in
- 24:59the store, including the Patriot Power Generator. You'll also get their famous guarantee
- 25:03for an entire year after your order, plus free shipping on orders over ninety
- 25:08seven dollars, and a portion of every sale is donated charities who support our
- 25:12veterans and their families. Just go to four the number four Patriots dot com
- 25:18and use code teamhouse to get ten percent off. That's the number four Patriots
- 25:25dot com teamhouse to get yours today. And I want to tell you guys
- 25:29about the AARP Veteran Report. It's a free, twice monthly email newsletter that
- 25:33salutes military service and provides a mixture of inspirational human stories in practical information for
- 25:38vets. You can subscribe to the AARP Veteran Report by going to AARP dot
- 25:44org slash Vet Report. It's free. The newsletter goes through your inbox on
- 25:48the second and fourth Thursdays of each month. Toby is the senior editor and
- 25:52Justin is one of the writers. He's got a great piece about Badger six
- 25:55in this issue. It's unique in that it combines really badass stories about a
- 26:00credible warriors, but it will also give you articles about saving money through discounts
- 26:03and benefits, plus stuff about healthcare and work. We really like the style.
- 26:07It's patriotic but not ra rad respects military service in a very positive way,
- 26:12but it's real and the writing is high quality. There's nothing else out
- 26:15there quite like it. There are a couple of regular features that are cool.
- 26:19My hero about a veteran is someone really admires and also then and Now,
- 26:25which is a cool story about veterans back in the day and what they're
- 26:27doing today. It's got positive up it's got a positive upbeat vibe, and
- 26:33there's no politics in it. So yes, it's free. You won't get
- 26:37spammed. It's well curated and nice balance of light stuff and some items that
- 26:41are serious. It's obvious a lot of thought has gone into what veterans really
- 26:45need. Obviously Toby is a veteran himself, and lots of the newsletter writers
- 26:48are as well. AARP is a great organization. It's kind of a kind
- 26:52of a secret but the discounts you get for being a member pretty much pay
- 26:56for the membership on day one, and it really caters to any one from
- 27:00their forties onwards. It maybe used to have this image of being for senior
- 27:03citizens, but that's just not the case nowadays. What is membership a year?
- 27:08It can be I think nine dollars, but there's a big discount for
- 27:11veterans. I believe it's forty three percent. So go to AARP dot org
- 27:15slash vet report and subscribe to the AARP veteran report. It's very easy,
- 27:21costs nothing, and you'll get something really worthwhile out of it. So thank
- 27:23you guys for supporting our sponsors and that first at I'm just imagining that substation
- 27:29situation with like no social media for like four months and kind of bliss fault,
- 27:34but not for the economy, not for the rest of life that specific.
- 27:37Yeah. Right, So when the offensive did kick off, what was
- 27:42your perception of how it played out? It didn't work as planned, and
- 27:48that's I feel like speaking of the boom bust, it's like call that like,
- 27:52oh, this is Ukraine is doomed, this is the end. A
- 27:56Western military equipment doesn't work is advertised. The Leopard two German main battle tank
- 28:04turns out can be destroyed, which is like, yeah, like it's a
- 28:07tank. If you blow up the tank, it will blow up. Like
- 28:11that's but I think what became clear is that Western leadership had been and Ukrainian
- 28:17leadership had just been accounting that it would just break on straight through this very
- 28:21well prepared defensive line in a similar fashion to what happened in hard Kiev up
- 28:26north. But was the cases that really with the geography of Ukraine and one
- 28:32of these like fundamental laws of gravity of war, like geography is king it
- 28:37matters. And to the I guess we'll say, to the west of where
- 28:42this is happening, there's the Nieper River, which was another critical incident,
- 28:47and the explosion of the Kahoka damn likely by Russia. We think we can
- 28:52talk about that later, but that kind of makes a river crossing very very
- 28:56difficult, or at least a large scale river crossing. Russia kinds of has
- 29:00this front running up the rest of Ukraine, so it was pretty clear where
- 29:06Ukraine would have to launch its counter offensive. So Russia was dug in prepared,
- 29:11like really dug in. There's kind of the the parallel you can see
- 29:15with like the German trenches in World War One, where they were like there's
- 29:18nothing nice about trench warfare, but compared to the Allied trenches at the time,
- 29:23we're like considerably nicer and like prepared for the long haul. Some of
- 29:27these Russian trenches you see, like their their fancy as far as trenches,
- 29:32As far as trenches go, so became clear that these armored assaults into mine
- 29:36fields were just not working. Now I've heard good things about the survivability of
- 29:41this Western hardware. It's like the Bradley would get blown to bits, but
- 29:45I mean people would still get hurt or killed, but like there would be
- 29:48a higher survival rate than would be expected with like a Soviet BMP other infantry
- 29:52fighting vehicle. But yeah, it wasn't leading to success. And so what
- 29:56appears to have happened is Ukraine's military pivoted strategy a little bit and now uses
- 30:03a lot of these armored vehicles to bring troops closer to the front and then
- 30:08very very piecemeal, bye bye bye the nail clipper, salami tactics, approach
- 30:14trench by trench. It's bloody, but it's unbalanced saving lives. They're trying
- 30:18to preserve their forces, and it's had some success. Now there's a town
- 30:25that's been in the news these last last two weeks, maybe three weeks,
- 30:32has been like the center of fighting, and people say, I with this,
- 30:34Ukraine's been fighting two months to take this tiny little town. Wasn't a
- 30:38major population center. But on the other hands, Russia fought really really hard
- 30:42to keep it. So clearly that's Russia signaling the importance of this town.
- 30:49Kind of a fun language fact of a giant language nerds. I wanted to
- 30:53bring this up. There's another town north called Niskuchne and Ukrainian which literally means
- 31:00not boring, and there was like a massive fight for that town too,
- 31:03which is I think actolutely named if you will. So, yeah, that
- 31:07counter offensive have been has been a slog. There's been a lot of coverage,
- 31:11I think this week, a lot of the negative Western coverage of like
- 31:15it's hard, it's bloody, it's brutal, but Ukraine is continuing to advance,
- 31:21and you don't have to take territory to commands territory. Every bit Ukraine
- 31:27advances, it can ring its artillery further and further kind of down towards the
- 31:33coast and then shell and attack more infrastructure, and that makes it harder and
- 31:37harder for Russian military force. It's to do their job of defending the last
- 31:41offensive. It seems like they're sweeping right through these villages. This time they're
- 31:44creeping forward. I think I was reading today. Sometimes they're taking five hundred
- 31:48meters a day, sometimes they're taking a kilometer. But there's also some give
- 31:52and take with the Russians there, And to point out the goal of the
- 31:56offensive you were talking about the onland bridge, and so they're correct me if
- 32:00I'm wrong, it's a punch through Zaparnesia and sever that land bridge. Zaparigia
- 32:05is the name of the oblast. Yeah, so there's there's two critical places
- 32:09that you really need to pay attention to. There's also not a uple.
- 32:13You know, some people talk about Ukraine breaking through and making a run at
- 32:15the sea, which would be a spectacular victory. But Tookmak is a town
- 32:21that's kind of south of maybe not directly south, probably more southwest southwest of
- 32:25this root and folks at home, you can look at a math will make
- 32:29this make a lot more sense. I can talk with my hands like a
- 32:31fighter pilot here, like, oh, they're going this way and but now,
- 32:36so Tookmak is a major rail and road junction on the land bridge.
- 32:39Right, there's it's a land bridge's land where there's a couple of main roads.
- 32:43So they can sever that artery. That's important. And then Melitopel would
- 32:46probably be the largest intact city that Russia continues to hold in Ukraine, so
- 32:53that would be a pretty symbolic victory to take that back. The other piece
- 32:57to keep an eye on, so we have the Neeper River are running to
- 33:01the west of Crimean and down into the Black Sea, and they have gotten
- 33:06to the other side in a few cases something. Yeah, so there's been
- 33:08some probing special forces action. I'm sure you'll hear some great stories after the
- 33:13war from people who were part of that. There's this kind of lingering possibility
- 33:17that very difficult for Ukraine to get across the river because the main bridge is
- 33:22out and the destruction of the dam kind of turned this into a flat,
- 33:27marshy plane that's just like a lot of pontoons you need. It's very muddy.
- 33:30You can't really get across that easily. But it's the least defended part
- 33:35of Russia's front, the hardest to dig into. So there's a kind of
- 33:38ever lingering possibility that Ukraine could somehow get across. But regardless of whether a
- 33:45mass attack is possible, it's certainly been able to provide pressure. And I
- 33:50mean one of the one of the kind of the pieces of pieces of like
- 33:54fundamental military laws. If you defend everything, you defend nothing like because Russia
- 34:00and or sorry, because Ukraine can poke and probe, Russia has to keep
- 34:04some amount of forces there. So it's but if that works in reverse to
- 34:08right that wherever Russia decides to focus their forces, I'm sorry, wherever Ukraine
- 34:15decides to focus their forces, Russia can just kind of roll in a you
- 34:19know, sort of like a stress ball in a way, which which leads
- 34:22me the question, and and how how do we see an end to this
- 34:30conflict when when everything is right, when when it's very hard to create such
- 34:37a decisive victory nobody unless they march into Kiev or into Moscow, Like,
- 34:43how does how is the victory one where Ukraine maintains its stability as a country,
- 34:51Russia, you know, gets out, you know that that idea?
- 34:55So ye had a wars enser. I actually did an episode about this on
- 34:59the podcast I Do for a pr I Bear Market Brief had a conflict resolution
- 35:02specialists come by, and she described this condition called the mutually hurting stalemate where
- 35:08both sides have kind of become cognizant to the facts that they can't achieve further
- 35:13gains and they're kind of just trading trading blows frozen well, no, but
- 35:20not a frozen conflict, like an active conflict where they're just just hurting each
- 35:23other with no gains at all. And that's the one of the things that
- 35:30one of my pet peeves about coverage coverage of the war, that coverage some
- 35:34of the arguments made about the war, like why don't they just talk,
- 35:36why don't they just make peace? Like peace is good. I hope the
- 35:39conflict ends. This is a blood bath. It's terrible for all concerns.
- 35:45But wars don't end because peace is good. Wars ends because of the status
- 35:52quo on the ground. One side has completely won, or both sides are
- 35:55tired out and don't think they can go any further and they declare an armstae.
- 36:00So I still think the most likely scenario here is probably some kind of
- 36:07stalemate. I don't know where that's going to be, right. You could
- 36:09have a stalemate where Ukraine is threatening Crimedia again has made a breakthrough. You
- 36:15could have a stalemate along the line as it exists. Now seems less likely
- 36:19Russia is going to generate enough forces to launch an attack, although Russia,
- 36:22speaking of like Russia being a stress ball, has up north in this near
- 36:28Hardki of the city but near Karkiv Oblast, has been trying to attack.
- 36:31We think to make Ukraine defend that territory and take away forces from the offensive.
- 36:37So this whole theory, Yeah, if you're defending everything, you're defending
- 36:40nothing. Ukraine hasn't really taken the bait and has evacuated people from these places
- 36:46it has liberated. I think understanding, we can actually not give back this
- 36:51land, but let Russia take it because it's more important. We're prioritizing the
- 36:54counter offensive right now. But yeah, how does it end. There'll be
- 36:58a time where yet neither side's really able to to make to make further gains,
- 37:04and I think that leads to discussion. But there's there's not really a
- 37:07military situation that would suggest that that's likely right now, because Ukraine is advancing,
- 37:12they force has utility. There's domestic politics of it. Zelenski is dead
- 37:20in the water if he gives up Ukrainian territory, and there's I think the
- 37:24polling has shown I was checking today just to be up to date, So
- 37:30I think it's something where like thirty percent of Ukrainians, which is still a
- 37:35minority. So like, oh, like we'd really like piece like we're willing
- 37:37to make concessions. But then you ask Ukrainians about like here the concessions Ukraine
- 37:40could offer and they're just like nope, nope, nope, nope. So
- 37:45peace is nice, but if you ask about like the mechanics of it,
- 37:47that's the one Pudin probably could turn on the diamond and say, Hey,
- 37:52we were ending the war and we're just taking the territory we had when the
- 37:54war began and Crimea we're leaving for another day. We did it victory,
- 37:59and like he controls the information environment, so like he probably pulled that off
- 38:02decently, right, But do you do you think at this point though,
- 38:07do you think that Ukraine because I mean, let's face it, like Putin
- 38:12took Crimea in like twenty fourteen. I mean we didn't really do shit about
- 38:16it, like the US government, like it was kind of a non issue
- 38:20for US. Right now it's now this invasion is an issue. But but
- 38:27also now it's sort of it's political talk. So if Putin were to pull
- 38:32out and just say it look no harm from no foul, we still got
- 38:36Crimea. I don't think Ukraine's going to stand for that. I don't think
- 38:38that US or Europe will allow that to stand. Or do you think so?
- 38:43It depends so like will Ukraine likely ever say like Crimea is Russia now,
- 38:47like I doubt that. Is there a situation where the war has kind
- 38:52of not frozen. They're still fighting but like stalemated, right, and it's
- 38:57this is there's an armistice or like this is the status quo likes gets to
- 39:00have X, Y, and Z Crimea. We will re visit in ten
- 39:02years and we're not admitting anything, but we're not going to fight over it
- 39:07now, Like that's a possibility. But the other problem is that we can
- 39:10get it to some of the international relations absolutely theory here. Hell yeah,
- 39:15So there's the credibility issue that Russia. This war seems in One of the
- 39:22lessons we've learned is that seems to really have been planned in Pudin's head,
- 39:27where there was not I didn't buying's not the right word, but like the
- 39:29Russia's military wasn't deeply involved in planning with just ready for this. Yes,
- 39:36it was planned, and it was kind of a fever dream based on his
- 39:38belief that Ukraine's not a real country. They're just Russians anyway, and they're
- 39:42just going to welcome us like like we're liberators. Did not did not happen.
- 39:46It turns out when you bomb people, doesn't endear them to you go
- 39:52go figure. But yeah, he doesn't have like a way to signal credibility
- 39:58because he decided to go to war. If he says, oh, no,
- 40:00like this is done now, like how would he signal that it is
- 40:05not going to happen again. So you need to have other powers involved with
- 40:07China say like no, like we're going to sanction them if they go back
- 40:10to wars. So like now you can trust that it's not gonna not gonna
- 40:15happen. And so yeah, he has limited credibility. And there's theories about
- 40:17like negotiations and how like having a democracy actually is a really helpful signaling tool.
- 40:23If you have a house in the Senate who vote for what the president
- 40:28says about foreign policy, that shows there's buy in among the hall political system
- 40:34that commitment is likely to be upheld. Right, do you feel in any
- 40:37way that Ukraine the z Lensky, that Ukraine his military advisors feel they need
- 40:46to push into Russia take parts of Russia in order to in order to go,
- 40:51Okay, you give a sist, we'll give you that. I don't
- 40:52think I think it would when Russia is occupying pieces of Ukraine. That's kind
- 40:58of an afterthought now attacking in Russia to change perceptions in Russia or the situation
- 41:04on the battlefield. There's one thing. So these drone strikes against Moscow happening
- 41:09at night, they're not really intending. It seems like just killed civilians and
- 41:13mass and and still terror. But they are maybe hoping to demonstrate to Russia
- 41:16we can touch you back, like we can make it hurt too. They're
- 41:21hoping to maybe make Russia move air defense assets away from Ukraine. Just have
- 41:25more to defense, right, it's forces out, So like attacks in Russia
- 41:31against military important, militarily importance targets, sure, but taking territory like that's
- 41:37distraction from freeing Ukrainians who are living under occupation. And I mean another thing
- 41:43we've learned. I guess we hadn't heard about what happened in like Bucha when
- 41:47we last talk, like torture Center is basically every major town Ukraine liberates,
- 41:52like there is a desire to free these people from probably very oppressive conditions,
- 42:00not at least due to supply issues, but human rights abuses out right murder.
- 42:06And yeah, part of the reason Ukraine can't just like leave its people
- 42:09behind because it's already known what is probably happening today, right, It's interesting,
- 42:16you know, it's interesting because you think of how a war ends,
- 42:21especial war like this without a drive straight to the capitol, without nuclear weapons
- 42:30hopefully, you know, and what Ukraine would be willing to tolerate? Tolerate?
- 42:37You know, will they be willing to like, Okay, you can
- 42:39have rush, or you can have Crimea or now is is is their hair
- 42:45up? You know? Are their hackles up? It's like, no,
- 42:47you don't get shit and not until you're completely to use a technical term part
- 42:53in my French. But I was at a company before my current job that
- 42:57did a lot of pulling, including and you Ukraine and the consistence theme.
- 43:01We saw across the polling some deviation like hey, we could float the most
- 43:06popular concession that's been floated to Ukrainians is maybe saying okay, we're not going
- 43:10to join NATO after all. By the way, that has eighteen percent support.
- 43:15That's the most the highest level of approval for a concession. But you
- 43:19ask Ukrainians, we ask them about like free text, like just like say
- 43:22like what are you what are you thinking? Now? What's your thought on
- 43:24the war and it's pain, it's tragedy, and it's fuck Russia. I
- 43:28mean that's yeah, it's it's no. But that that really is like the
- 43:31fundamental, like single unifying factor in Ukrainian politics right now, and it's it's
- 43:37I don't know if average Russians have truly grasped the extent like that this is
- 43:42going to be a generational hatred. Yeah, I mean it comes up again
- 43:45and again. Yeah, like pre twenty fourteen Ukraine. And I'm not saying
- 43:49this to like dehumanize anyone or anything, but I mean Ukraine had a reputation
- 43:53for being kind of a basket case state and the invasion of Russia. You
- 43:58know, it's the saying goes, you know, war makes states, like
- 44:00the invasion of Russia unified these people, and you can see they want to
- 44:04make it work. So I need one of the things we've seen during the
- 44:07war, talk about politics and Ukraine and politics and Russia too. The more
- 44:10we talk, the more it's like, oh, that's an important thing.
- 44:13That's an important thing we have seen. But yeah, in Ukraine, so
- 44:16people have said a Ukraine wasn't a nation before and that's overblown bullshit. But
- 44:23this Ukrainian nationalism was If you think about a Ukrainian nationalist, it's a Western
- 44:29Ukrainian who speaks Ukrainian. There wasn't I would say, a healthy civic nationalism.
- 44:35And you can see that the pro Western, pro Eastern, pro Western
- 44:37prominant politics vacillated every election or so between these two camps. And it's kind
- 44:44of incredible to see if the language politics were central in Ukraine. Should we
- 44:49speak more Russians that okay, should we all learn Ukrainian? How that's kind
- 44:53of become I don't want to say a non issue, but kind of a
- 44:59non issue. See videos early in the war with Ukrainians speaking Russian and Ukrainian
- 45:05firing and javelin at a Russian tank, blowing it to Kingdom come and screaming
- 45:09together in two languages. That's totally well and good. We've seen the video
- 45:14of Ukrainian special forces and a firefight talking in Russian with each other, not
- 45:20even to like prisoners of war, just with each other. That's like totally
- 45:23fine. And then yeah, in the language note, a lot of Ukrainians
- 45:28who grew up speaking Russian their whole life now refusing to utter a word of
- 45:32it. I met. I met one at a wedding recently. Was I've
- 45:35actually been learning some Ukrainian too, Like fascinating to like hear that shift.
- 45:39One of the other really interesting things is there's that views about the war,
- 45:45but from a fundamental kind of identity perspective. Here a polling question about,
- 45:51like whether you thought the fall of the Soviet Union was a good thing,
- 45:54asking that to Ukrainians, and from twenty twenty to twenty twenty three, twenty
- 46:00percent more Ukrainians now think it was a good thing. Has nothing to do
- 46:05with anything that's happened in the war, but like, no Soviet Union is
- 46:07Russia bad? So like really, didn't they just move away from some of
- 46:14the Soviet era iconography and adopt that the Ukrainian Yeah, the statue in Kiev
- 46:17with the shield and the sword Mother Ukraine, they removed the hammer and sickle
- 46:22and added the trident instead. Yeah. No, I was thinking of all
- 46:31the all the private consulting groups that stood up, like the Trident groups and
- 46:37whatnot that aren't seals that are actually like Ukrainian military advisors and whatnot. But
- 46:45what do you think? And we may I have talked about this one the
- 46:50last year and I don't I don't recall, But how do you think Russia,
- 46:54whether it's Putin or somebody else, Russia will deal with this idea of
- 47:01NATO being open to Ukraine, You know, because there have been arguments for
- 47:06years, like this isn't something that just popped up after the Russian invasion,
- 47:09but there have been arguments for years that NATO was pushing Russia towards war,
- 47:15right, It's it's been a talking point now whether that is factual, whether
- 47:22that played a part in Putin's decision, I don't know what some Putin said,
- 47:24but there have been those discussions. Do you do do you think that
- 47:30NATO it can be a calming effort in this Do you think they can be
- 47:35an insanitary, incenary sort of effort. Depends. It seems at presence like
- 47:42maybe the most likely reasonable concession to be offered, because the Ukraine has proven
- 47:49it's able to, I mean, not maybe necessarily take back all its territory,
- 47:52but defend itself. If you had told someone at the outset of the
- 47:57war Russian tanks are rolling in, Hey, Ukraine is going to fight Russia
- 48:00to a stalemate, they'd be like get out of here, Like that's ridiculous,
- 48:05and that's what's happened. So hasn't needed an Article five guarantee of mutual
- 48:09assistance to defend itself effectively. So it's certainly possible. Now the extent to
- 48:15which NATO was or wasn't a factor is I mean, that's going to be
- 48:19debated for years. It's certainly talked about by Russian elites. We now have
- 48:22an interesting counter factual with Finland's joining NATO is also very close to Russia,
- 48:28and Russia removed forces from its border with Finland to send to Ukraine. And
- 48:34that's all well and good. So I it's probably part of the equation and
- 48:37to some extent, but I think one of my pet peeves with some of
- 48:42the arguments, so like Russia was provoked because of NATO expansion, but as
- 48:46never that never really it's never articulated. And then what NATO expanded and then
- 48:53what did Russia lose by that? And it seems to be Russia's the gripe
- 48:58is that losing the ability to really invade any country and it's periphery. It's
- 49:01so chooses right different fundamentally than the US or NATO putting nuclear missiles in Turkey
- 49:09or the Soviet Union putting missiles in Cuba. That's an offensive capabilit That does
- 49:15change things. But if you look at you know, native forces in Eastern
- 49:19Europe before, before Russia's latest invasion, not a whole lot there. What
- 49:27are they going to conquer Russia with ten thousand troops and some strikers, Like
- 49:30that's kind of hard to believe. Or I saw an argument so like NATO
- 49:36was pumping Ukraine full of weapons before the war. Yeah, Like actually,
- 49:39incidentally, Trump was the one who started arming Ukraine more seriously than Obama had,
- 49:45sending javelin missiles, which are useful, but like you're not gonna take
- 49:50Turf with that. That actually got approved on the very tail end of the
- 49:53Obama administration. Okay, the javelins, but but I mean, yes,
- 49:57it continued through the Trump administration. Yeah. I mean it seems like you
- 50:05know, Putin accidentally, you know, fought against his own cause and that
- 50:09he proved like yeah, you joined NATO, you don't get invaded, and
- 50:13you have Finland and what the Sweden is on track. Yeah, so it's
- 50:17hard to imagine Ukraine wanting to give up that. I mean, this was
- 50:22a pretty great strategic blunder for Russia, I think is the takeaway. They
- 50:25turned the Baltic Sea into a NATO lake essentially, that's happened. Have weakened
- 50:34their position in the world. They talk about oh bricks and the global South,
- 50:37but Russia has become very highly dependent on China. We can talk about
- 50:42Russian politics and it's a kind of maybe we can talk about pre Gooja and
- 50:45I mean there's there's yeah, lots of yeah, before before we turn to
- 50:49that, I do want to talk about that before we we totally leave Ukraine.
- 50:53Though. You mentioned Aswalov Battalion, and let's roll into that a little
- 50:59bit because that's one of the mean arguments that the are counter arguments people make.
- 51:04Some of it is Russian propaganda. Some of those Americans maybe who have
- 51:07legitimate concerns like, hey, these people are Nazis, Why are we supporting
- 51:10them? Are there neo Nazis? We want to jump into Oswalv Battalion.
- 51:15Yeah, So look a lot of shades here. So like the origins of
- 51:20this battalion and group Ukraine in twenty fourteen desperately needed folks who were willing to
- 51:23fight and motivated, and yes, these folks were neo Nazis. That is
- 51:28not good. I knew people foreign fighters who joined up with OSWOV back in
- 51:34twenty fourteen, and yes, I can confirm as well there was a neo
- 51:37Nazi presence in OSWALV battalion. That was no bullshit. They were brought then
- 51:43under military commands, rolled up into formal like state control, governance, civilian
- 51:52control. And the last I've heard is that these views are there's still maybe
- 51:59they're less prominence than they used to or they used to be. Look fundamentally
- 52:07like I have on one hand understanding like I don't want to make any sweeping
- 52:10generalizations, which of course means I'm about to you. But there's been this
- 52:15trend of like Eastern European countries pointing the finger like year full of anti Semites,
- 52:20year full, And it's because it's Eastern Europe. I'm a Jew of
- 52:23Polish descents, by the way, so like my folks know know this well,
- 52:27like there are there's anti Semitism, and well not just Eastern Europe,
- 52:30Western Europe and a lot of places. But the question is, like,
- 52:36okay, like is has Ukrainian statement co opted by neo Nazis? If you
- 52:39look at like percentage representation in parliaments, how much the far right has well.
- 52:45Ukrainian politics are kind of on nice now, but that wasn't a factor
- 52:47before the war, less than in places like you know, Finland and France
- 52:52and other countries, mind you. So that's one you talk about attitudes towards
- 53:00sexual minorities, gay folks, members of that community, Jews in Ukraine weren't
- 53:06really getting harassed by these folks either, So that's kind of in defense of
- 53:12Ukraine. On the other hands, you've also had these kind of far right
- 53:16symbology kind of laundered into the public. You see, like soldiers who have
- 53:21like death's head and they're fighting for independency idea. It's not good, and
- 53:25I think it should be mentioned that's like not a great thing. The flag
- 53:30of the Ukraine People's Army this you'll see it common red and black flag,
- 53:36which were Ukrainian nationalists for independence before and after during World War Two and sided
- 53:43with Nazi Germany for partially understandable. The grievance is understandable. Didn't like what
- 53:47Russia had done in Ukraine and you know, potentially genocidal famine, but did
- 53:53side with the SS and Stepan Bandera killed a lot of Jews in Poland,
- 53:58So like a good guy here reasonable grievance, but not a so like you're
- 54:05seeing that symbology and I and you're seeing you know it not I'm not saying
- 54:08it's it's mass and throughout there, but you are seeing troops with Bandera with
- 54:14a Bandera patch, you know, you know, and and you know like
- 54:19it's it's there. It was written about in twenty eighteen. We stopped funding
- 54:22them because of of that. It's important to contextualize though, because like it
- 54:29is a war, it is complicated. There are shades and Ukraine not even
- 54:34by and large almost entire it's it's a country fighting for its survival as a
- 54:37nation and state. The morals are with shades, and that's true in any
- 54:42war, but the morals are pretty clear here. So I don't want that
- 54:45to be used or taking out of context to sure it will dilute, to
- 54:51dilute the kind of morally just cause of Ukraine broadly, right, Yeah,
- 54:58to color it as a as a some sort of neo Nazi forces not sure,
- 55:02drawn it way out of proportion, And I maybe some people don't want
- 55:07to hear this, but I was told that, you know, when NATO
- 55:09started getting involved in Ukraine after twenty fourteen, now we're talking like twenty fifteen,
- 55:15sixteen seventeen, that actually did start to professionalize Azov and start to push
- 55:19some of those more extremist elements out. What I've heard in the coverage here.
- 55:22Yeah, okay, So jumping over to Russia, I think that there's
- 55:30an interesting conversation that comes up about this war potentially pushing Russia closer to cooperation
- 55:38military or otherwise with China. You brought up bricks. Let's talk about that
- 55:44a little bit about the effects that this war is having internally on China.
- 55:47And I'm sorry on Russia and Russia's foreign policy in regards to some of its
- 55:52other neighbors. Yeah, I mean a lot of places we could start if
- 55:57I could talk kind of get back to my old stomping grinds. Russia economy
- 56:00has been really interesting. Oh, those sanctions don't work. The sanctions are
- 56:02crushing Russia's economy, the rubles stable, the rubles devaluing, And I think
- 56:07what we're seeing is Russia muddling through doing all right because the state is fundamentally
- 56:16I mean, I think rough comparison if you're not an economist. So,
- 56:20like what happened, what happens with the US and World War Two. We're
- 56:23ramping up for a war effort created tremendous economic growth. It's also creating some
- 56:29tension inflation. There's a lot of young men who've been sent to the front
- 56:31with not enough not enough people to work, so that's leading to price increases.
- 56:36Government spending leading to price increases. Inflation is not popular anywhere you go.
- 56:42The Russia's economy is doing fine for now. The question is you have
- 56:45this rubber band that's been stretched and is no signs of breaking. I think
- 56:49that's one of these other like metaphors that applies, where like Russia's defensive lines
- 56:52in southern Ukraine are have been unbreakable, but like a defensive line doesn't break
- 56:58until it does, it holds and then all at once, that's that's it.
- 57:00So Russia's economy is pulled back. It's doing fun. But what happens
- 57:05in the long term when the war ostensibly eventually ends, hundreds of thousands of
- 57:12people come home, There's dislocation, there's price pressures. These are soldiers who
- 57:16are going to have political demands Eventually, the Decembrist rebellion in the Russian Empire
- 57:22was folks coming back from fighting against Napoleon. So that has dislocated. Is
- 57:29that even a word probably affects on Russian society. The economy is now being
- 57:35essentially held up by state spending. What happens when there is no more war?
- 57:38What happens then? Part of the incentive for Putin to not make peaces
- 57:44that right now, like that is what is keeping his engine and one of
- 57:46his fundamental sources of legitimacy afloat is that government spending is up. What happens
- 57:54if Russia starts running out of money to spend it probably have a couple more
- 57:58years. But like there's some much bigger questions, And I think the sanctions,
- 58:01if you're wondering, like are they working demonstrated resolve. They've hurt Russia
- 58:07in the long term. It doesn't mean that that's going to be immediately visible.
- 58:12What else is there Russia in China? Has that changed the dynamics between
- 58:19those two countries. I mean, there's a whole history there that you can
- 58:22go back to the ideological split between them. But I mean we can focus
- 58:25on yeah, we focus more on the contemporary aspects of it. You know,
- 58:30these are two countries that have global aspirations. Has the war in Ukraine
- 58:35pushed them closer together and further away from the West. It's certainly made Russia
- 58:39more dependent on China. I mean, that's that's for sure. China has
- 58:45helped here and there to arm Russia, although it's also sending or selling weapons
- 58:52to Ukraine. You can see that continuing to happen, I think, and
- 58:55that is I think indicative that China has I want to say, played both
- 59:00sides, but I think it's very content with whatever the outcome is. If
- 59:04Russia merges strong and victorious, that's great. They have a partner and their
- 59:08fight with the US maybe too strong a word, but competition with the US,
- 59:13that's great. If Russia's week, the Russians have a term would be
- 59:19like the resource appendage, just like this extra little what is it, like
- 59:22the angler fish where the males it's a tiny little thing that clips on Like
- 59:27that's what RUSSI will be for China, just like sends China oil but has
- 59:30no real power anymore. So those are both good outcomes, and by the
- 59:34way, China has repeatedly not just during this ward taken advantage and places or
- 59:39situations where it can set prices or like you need to sell us your gas
- 59:44where like we're getting fifty percent discount. There's nothing you can do about it,
- 59:47So tough cookies. So that's been a factor too. Now Russia and
- 59:53China have a common enemy, it's not the right word, but like a
- 1:00:00foe, common competitors, and that's brought them together. Traditionally, lands powers
- 1:00:06that are next to each other don't get along, so like that ought to
- 1:00:09structurally push them apart, but I think right now they're common interest has made
- 1:00:14them, made them closer. Is it possible for Russia fully pivot away from
- 1:00:19Western markets towards you know, purely you know Eastern or Eurasian markets eventually,
- 1:00:25but there's nuance, theres there's Gulf money, which certainly is willing to play
- 1:00:30nice with Russia. These things take time, though, Like you can't like
- 1:00:34snap and make supply chains turn on a dime. So like, let's talk
- 1:00:37about hydrocarbons, for example, your oil and gas gas, specifically Russia's gas
- 1:00:45infrastructure. Pipelines were built in the Soviet Union to carry gas from Russia to
- 1:00:51Europe, and they can say all they want, we're going to sell gas
- 1:00:53to China, but again, China can dictate prices and you have to build
- 1:00:58pipelines and restructure to China. That takes years. Even if you're rushing it
- 1:01:02like that takes that takes time, right, so you can pivot. It's
- 1:01:07possible, but not immediately. The other issue is that with Russia's currency situation
- 1:01:14and inflation, there's a technical term capital control, so limitations on how Russian
- 1:01:20companies and individuals can move money in and out of Russia. Russia wants to
- 1:01:23prop up their ruble ruble rather, so they want companies and folks abroad to
- 1:01:29sell their foreigness that's in purchase rubles to keep in Russia. While if you
- 1:01:32need to be flexible with supply chains and dealing with international players and all of
- 1:01:37your moneys in Russia, that makes that harder. So there's competing interests here
- 1:01:43on short term economic keep the war effort, but long term economic we need
- 1:01:45to invest, and that's been Russia's economy has been starved of investment for decades
- 1:01:51now. It's hasn't really grown meaningfully since twenty twelve. I think real disposable
- 1:01:59incomes twenty twent twenty ten has grown like five percent in what like thirteen years.
- 1:02:05It's not that's not good. People are inflation no matter where you are.
- 1:02:09That like makes people angry. It's true in the States, too true
- 1:02:12in the West. And if this war does go on for another couple of
- 1:02:15years, I mean, what does that due to the Russian economy. So
- 1:02:19again, as long as the state is continuing to spend, they should be
- 1:02:22able to stay afloat. But like the pressures, they grow and they grow
- 1:02:25and they grow. And this is one of these situations where people saying,
- 1:02:29oh, like Russia is going to fragments, Russia is gonna remain. Like
- 1:02:32I think my prior here and like base assumption I think for folks watching should
- 1:02:37be that like Russia willmuddle through. It tends to do that, but the
- 1:02:40pressures will grow. Look, Ukraine isn't an existential fight. So while there's
- 1:02:46poverty and the economy has been largely rexed, there have a really strong impetus
- 1:02:51to fight, and Russia is fighting a war of aggression entirely outside of its
- 1:02:54own territory. Like that, those contradictions maybe out morally with the controlled media
- 1:03:01environments, but certainly difficult in the in the economy start to get felt more
- 1:03:08and more and more, and that is one of the things that may push
- 1:03:10towards push towards a stalemate. What Germany's economy and World War One that like
- 1:03:16finally gave out, that was that was what led to the end of the
- 1:03:21war. If you were you know, this is an impossible question. So
- 1:03:25I'm just going to ask you to make wild ass guesses. But what are
- 1:03:29the tertiary effects of this that we don't even see now that that may be
- 1:03:37beneficial for us, that may bide us in the ass? You know,
- 1:03:39what would what would a strong after years of building these pipelines, what would
- 1:03:44a strong Russia China, you know alliance look like? If Russia fragments,
- 1:03:51what would that look like if there's a power vacuum? Like, what are
- 1:03:53some of the pros and cons of the tertiary effects that could result from this?
- 1:03:58Okay? So if good for us for talking about like good for the
- 1:04:00United States and bad for us like both like and again I know these are
- 1:04:03just guesses, but you know, being a student of history, I wouldn't
- 1:04:09count on Russia fragmenting. Okay, we can talk about that, like that
- 1:04:13is a like some of all fear situation. It's a nuclear armed country where
- 1:04:16folks who have the most guns are going to call the shots and various trunks
- 1:04:19of it. That's not good. We don't want that because we saw that
- 1:04:23with the Soviet Union, but that was with bush one that was like well
- 1:04:27managed, that was relatively relatively peaceful as far as empire is collapsing, goes
- 1:04:34civil war handed over the nukes, and as did Ukraine want to be maybe
- 1:04:41historically maybe they're regretting that. Yeah, yeah, to say to say that,
- 1:04:45to say the least, not a situation I think the US should encourage.
- 1:04:50I mean, I wish I would probably be helpful. One of the
- 1:04:54things I'd love to see from Biden to clearly state, like what does the
- 1:04:57US want out of this? Might be benefici all to say like we don't
- 1:05:01have pretenses towards Russia here is you can't invade and try to destroy neighboring nations.
- 1:05:09Like that's really the line here, like be pudin like do your thing.
- 1:05:13But we didn't. We didn't get a what would be nice to happen
- 1:05:16in twenty years of war and Afghanistan Iraq, I doubt we're going to get
- 1:05:20it from any administration, you know. I mean, the thing is,
- 1:05:24no one in Russia's gonna believe it anyway, that's true. I think it's
- 1:05:27good to part of the issue here now whether or not NATO actually caused this,
- 1:05:31But there was this sort of foot see with Ukraine over the course of
- 1:05:34years, like there's a possibility, and I think it would have the Western
- 1:05:39hindsight would have been better served saying like, yes, this is happening,
- 1:05:42No, it's not happening. Here's our policy, and being just a little
- 1:05:45more upfront about that. I think that's not a particularly controversial thing to say
- 1:05:50as far as like knock on effect. So there's what this is. We're
- 1:05:55starting to see very very slowly, like the red militaryization, Europe re emerges
- 1:06:00a geopolitical power. Interesting, and it's going to take time a because it
- 1:06:09takes time to restart supply chains to build one of these fundamental mass problems we've
- 1:06:14talked about, Oh, should Ukraine get the F sixteen or not? Like
- 1:06:16no, can we build enough produce enough artillery shells every month to like supply
- 1:06:20this like the gears of war here, Europe starting that process starting to be
- 1:06:30like geopolitical again, Hey, this European project can't just be purely idealistic,
- 1:06:35like there must be military power and forced not used to conquer, but like
- 1:06:42that has to have that backing. And you see this moment again. It's
- 1:06:45slow, but Germany like all off Schultz at political rallies like we can like
- 1:06:48resist Russian aggress and he's kind of like as he's saying, like like wait,
- 1:06:51like we can resist Russian aggression, Like yeah, like this realization he
- 1:06:56can be he can be like political in that way and talk about like national
- 1:07:00security interests. It's gonna there's a real uh yeah, yeah, there's there's
- 1:07:05a real impetus against talking like that in Germany is yeah, well yes,
- 1:07:10and so this is it's gonna take a while to it's gonna take a while
- 1:07:14to change. I've had very funny conversations with with German friends who are like
- 1:07:18hesitant about rearming, and it's weird, like the Jew arguing like Germany should
- 1:07:24be like a robust geopolitical power they've learned historical and the German being like,
- 1:07:28no, we should not rearm. It's uh, it's not because there's there's
- 1:07:31such a iron age, there's such a belief that they can't achieve their political
- 1:07:35names through military force. And I don't think it has to do that,
- 1:07:38But like I think safe to say, had Ukraine been like a credible military
- 1:07:43actor, not Ukraine star, had Europe been a credible European Had Europe been
- 1:07:46a credible military actor, what happened Ukraine might not have happened because Europe would
- 1:07:51be able to I mean, when you say Europe there is a credible military
- 1:07:55actor, I mean, are you talking about the formation of European military have
- 1:07:59to be so many there's so many, like political economy complicated questions there.
- 1:08:03Who's doing what? I mean, we're seeing trends accelerate. The Netherlands is
- 1:08:09focused, doesn't really need tanks anymore. It's kind of put its tank units
- 1:08:13into Germany's military. So we're seeing that this gradual ramp up. It's slow.
- 1:08:17What Germany was talking about at the beginning of the war, We're going
- 1:08:20to have the svenda, this political moment change and eras, we're going to
- 1:08:25spend on our military again. That's kind of gotten slowly. I mean,
- 1:08:29one of these the US is going to have to decide about what we're gonna
- 1:08:32do with Europe. That ultimately we'll make year up to start actually taking security
- 1:08:38seriously, as the US saying okay, like here's the date, Like we've
- 1:08:42we've done enough, We'll be here to help if anything happens. But like
- 1:08:45you got to take the lead. And as long as the US is taking
- 1:08:48the lead, Europe doesn't have that incentive to really gear up. And for
- 1:08:55the longest time, I don't think we wanted them to know. But like
- 1:08:59I think with some of the political difficulties we're having in the States, like
- 1:09:02there's increasing consensus that has to happen. As far as other kind of geopolitical
- 1:09:09trends we talk about bricks dedollarization, I think are certainly compared to the amount
- 1:09:15they're talk talked about, very overblown. That's my two cents. People may
- 1:09:20disagree. It may becomes something Sunday someday, But like bricks, as an
- 1:09:25organization, I think it was was it Goldman Sachs, It was an economic
- 1:09:30designation, it was like a it was an investment report, like here are
- 1:09:33the countries that are going to be growing fast as of twenty and ten.
- 1:09:38But that's not like a political unit. The organization certainly is like in opposition
- 1:09:44to continued US global hegemony, you know, where all the pluses and minuses
- 1:09:50of that, but it's never They've never come to a collective decision about something.
- 1:09:56It's two main powerhouses are China and India, who have like a border
- 1:09:59disagreement, like could go to war at some point. Argentina's was just invited
- 1:10:04their two presidential candidates that like absolutely not, We're not joining bricks. So
- 1:10:09like hard to see, like what they they just had this like big like
- 1:10:15what do they have in common? What are they really what are they really
- 1:10:17doing? And it's unclear, unclear, like if they can actually like act
- 1:10:24as a cohesive Oh, they're competing with the G seven. Yeah, but
- 1:10:28the G seven is a group like can create sanctions together and coordinate economic policy
- 1:10:31and COVID policy and financial regulation. Like that's there's something a lot more serious
- 1:10:36to that now that may change going forward, but yeah. The other dynamic
- 1:10:42is like the global South, Africa, South America being maybe cozier with Russia.
- 1:10:47And I think a lot of this stems from skepticism of US leadership and
- 1:10:53people. It's almost funny when people see like Lula in Brazil talking about,
- 1:10:58oh, we shouldn't make peace like not being a fan of the US.
- 1:11:01He's a Latin American leftist. Like, it's not a particularly surprising, of
- 1:11:05course, they're skeptical of the US, like that's there's a lot of history
- 1:11:10there. So, Like, I don't think it's because they're attracted to Russia
- 1:11:15as a necessarily as like a geopolitical leader, see that Russia as a country
- 1:11:18that can offer them something in a way China can. But you know,
- 1:11:23they're also smaller countries that have to balance their you know, calibrate their foreign
- 1:11:27policy between these other great powers. Right, yep. One of the things
- 1:11:30in this project I mentioned where we're thinking about and looking at. But yeah,
- 1:11:34I think a lot of it is maybe more about the US than Russia
- 1:11:39per se, and it's using the opportunity to agitate shuffle great change. How
- 1:11:46about the subject of Putin himself. As you know, in America, I
- 1:11:53think we have this sort of I don't want to say infatuation, but certainly
- 1:11:56a fascination with dictators at times, and there's this continued fascination on the character
- 1:12:01of the personality of Vladimir Putin. If you, from your observations, have
- 1:12:06you seen any changes in him from the beginning of the war to where we
- 1:12:10are today over the course of the war, not particularly Yeah, our our
- 1:12:16boy Vova. Fun fact for audience people say, look, he's lad.
- 1:12:20Lad is not the short form of short form of Vladimir and Russias. Vova
- 1:12:26is the nickname. So yeah, I sometimes referred to him by that nickname
- 1:12:29as Vova Vova here. But I think the change started before the war where
- 1:12:38he kind of found religion. Like his foreign policy and hall approach was like
- 1:12:43reputation was like very like neolists before, where like whatever situationally can be advantageous,
- 1:12:49but there's not really like a strong belief, and seems to have kind
- 1:12:53of yet found this religion that Russia as a great country, the heir to
- 1:12:57this former empire and like this these lands or hours and the eyes glaze over.
- 1:13:01I mean, he wrote this treatise in what Sember twenty twenty one about
- 1:13:05how like Ukraine's not a real country. Well, well, the sidebar,
- 1:13:09we were talking about this a little bit before the show. I wanted to
- 1:13:11ask you about some of the things I had read that I think are controversial
- 1:13:14maybe about Russia, but that there's this sort of some people would say a
- 1:13:18neo fascist ideology in Russia about the Third Rome and this idea that the of
- 1:13:25the unique character of the Russian people as being the leaders of the Slavic people
- 1:13:30worldwide, and that they're going to lead the world through their authenticity and all
- 1:13:33these kind of like ideas that as Americans, seem very strange and maybe you're
- 1:13:39kind of overhyped, you know, as you know, we have this tendency
- 1:13:43to like see the entirety of Russian character through you know, a couple literature
- 1:13:47figures. But I'd like to hear your thoughts as a as a Russia experience,
- 1:13:51I would strongly advise against, Like I don't want to say it's necessarily
- 1:13:58racial, but like that kind of like the inscrutable Russian mind, Like how
- 1:14:02can we truly understand like that, like people have suggested on Putin, it's
- 1:14:06not like a rational actor. What it's like, No, he has interests,
- 1:14:10Russia has interest. They're acting on their interest. Russia. My only
- 1:14:14editorial angle in my coverage of Russia over the year, it's like a real
- 1:14:16country that like maps onto other things, that like real country, recognizable human
- 1:14:21beings with the same sort of with unique characteristics and nuances that any other country
- 1:14:29would have, but like Russia being a kind of this having this like messianic
- 1:14:34approach that has this clear purpose, I mean like clear purpose, manifest destiny.
- 1:14:42Like oh, actually the kind of maps onto some elements in US history
- 1:14:45too, So it's not this like outlier per se. I saw we were
- 1:14:49talking about this before recording, and a piece of WAPO coverage Washington Post quote
- 1:14:57a quote about like the potential for continued Ukrainian military offensive. I said,
- 1:15:02like, oh, like in the winter, like grounds conditions maybe tough,
- 1:15:05and also like Russians are uniquely good at fighting in the winter, and it's
- 1:15:10just like, oh my god, you've got to be the Russian people are
- 1:15:13the Arctic variant of human beings. You've got to be kidding me, Like
- 1:15:16no, like if they have cold weather gear, they'll do fine, and
- 1:15:19if they don't, they'll freeze like anybody else. Like yeah, So I
- 1:15:24wouldn't lean too hard into that kind of that kind Russia is uniquely able to
- 1:15:30take casual But you think Putin himself has bought into this idea of sort of
- 1:15:35religious mysticism. I don't if it's necessarily like religious mysticism per se, but
- 1:15:40like found finding religion and like there's like a clear purpose for not all policy
- 1:15:45is fungible depending on the moment in time. And it makes him a little
- 1:15:49more dangerous, I think, less harder to do it because he has this
- 1:15:54ideologerver to his belief that Ukraine is part of Russia. That that arguments that
- 1:16:00Ukraine's and made up country is frustrating because every country is made up, Yes,
- 1:16:04yes, every all. We had to count the what was it during
- 1:16:09not the it was a couple presidential elections. A little conversation that the Palestinian
- 1:16:14people aren't invented people so offensive and you hear that, it's like, well,
- 1:16:16we're all invented people. I mean the notion of west from what is
- 1:16:20frequently and frequently when you have actors Russia and with Palestinians Israel in this case
- 1:16:26acting under like the notion that people are made up, they tend to do
- 1:16:30things that make nations. So like yeah, go figure, Yeah, so
- 1:16:36what can putin find acceptance on the world staging? And do you think that's
- 1:16:43a tough question? Like we'll have to deal with with Russia one way or
- 1:16:47another. It's I don't think it's going away. We're on the talk of
- 1:16:49decolonization and collapse, Like I think it's going to be now how much sticking
- 1:16:55power Putin has as a question? He will drop dead eventually? Is we
- 1:16:59all will? Like that's that's gonna happen. How old is he seventy?
- 1:17:04Yeah, they're but I think older than that now getting on in years,
- 1:17:09and like he's been unable to figure out how to hands power away. And
- 1:17:13one of the sources of kind of the war how this bubbled up is his
- 1:17:16belief that like you create was his final unanswered thing before he can spot the
- 1:17:20stage. But like will he be welcomes back? I don't know in the
- 1:17:26same way. I mean, he's not able even now even among the global
- 1:17:30Southford like to Brick, somebody couldn't appear in person, right, He is
- 1:17:33afraid of getting arrested since lab Rod. He had a recent speech where they
- 1:17:38had like someone dub over his remarks. It wasn't his voice, so like,
- 1:17:42well, it's interesting to see although it's a very different situation Assad being
- 1:17:45oh so slowly ingratiated back into the international community. Well, I think there's
- 1:17:50degrees and I think you know, if and when this ends, like he
- 1:17:55will be dealt with it's certainly because for like a durable piece like he is,
- 1:18:00partyt right, they'll have to need guarantees or guarant tourists potentially, but
- 1:18:03is going to have to be talked to you with something cassidy. And then
- 1:18:08what about Zelenski, because I mean prior to the invasion, right, he
- 1:18:12had already sort of he had already tried to infringe a bit on on the
- 1:18:16media in Ukraine and then successfully did that once the war started, banned unions,
- 1:18:24you know, band uh, pro Russian politicians, you know, things
- 1:18:29like that, And I know that in Ukraine, like they can't have you
- 1:18:32know, under their constitution there can't be an election while there's you know,
- 1:18:36military law to just note like for historically speaking for for countries and existential wars,
- 1:18:44this is not an outlier. So no, no, And I'm not
- 1:18:46like I'm not saying that that's in their constitution, like that's not an issue.
- 1:18:51The challenge I think is that there was a lot of talk about you
- 1:18:58know, corruption, there was a lot there were a lot of issues surrounding
- 1:19:00Ukraine prior to the invasion. Do you think that Zelenski will get away with
- 1:19:05more post invasion because people want to justify having sent Do you think that he'll
- 1:19:12like jump in line, because again, like I said, there were things
- 1:19:15he was working on against the freedom of the press and things like that even
- 1:19:19prior to the war. Now with military law, like he's been able to
- 1:19:25pass that stuff, saying it it's an existential threat, you know, unions
- 1:19:29and things like that, and it very much is to wait, Like I
- 1:19:32think that's safe, safe arguments. But yeah, what happens in Ukrainian politics
- 1:19:36after the war is it's really interesting. Yeah, I was talking to a
- 1:19:43Ukrainian professor at a recent event in the sidelines. The takeaway from that is
- 1:19:50really that like Ukrainian politics are largely on pause, and I think for understandable
- 1:19:55reasons outstation around the war. But I mean, are there questions about how
- 1:20:01Zelenski prepared the country for war, Like could he have mobilized earlier, could
- 1:20:08he have moved forces? Should he have taken us US warnings more seriously?
- 1:20:13Had a really interesting points there that part of the reason maybe is that Zelenski's
- 1:20:17formative experience as a politician was being jerked around by the US. The Trump
- 1:20:23administration is like looking for not concessions, but like what Biden's or x y
- 1:20:28z and was kind of skeptical of American political systems. So when when you
- 1:20:33know Burns or whoever, it was said like, hey, like you're going
- 1:20:38to get attacked. Maybe I thought there was an angled there, which is
- 1:20:41an interesting, interesting read on it. But there will be kind of a
- 1:20:44reckoning for that, and I think there will be political hay made. Zelenski
- 1:20:48is certainly emergent's kind of a national hero figure. The irony hears that he
- 1:20:54was not popular before the war. His popularity was in the twenties and there
- 1:20:58were corruption concerns. There's still corruption concerns. One of the poll numbers I
- 1:21:01found today for some homework is that seventy seven percent of Ukrainians think that Dlenski
- 1:21:08is responsible for corruption, not in the sense that he's done it himself,
- 1:21:12but that he as president owns that outcome. It's something that Zelenski has been
- 1:21:15sensitive to even during the war. So recently fired all of the regional heads
- 1:21:20of recruitment because of perception they were operating cleanly. Clean's House and the Defense
- 1:21:26Ministry. Reznikov, Ukraine's defense defense minister, was nearly fired, according to
- 1:21:32reports, because of corruption concerns and people ingratiating themselves, So that's still going
- 1:21:39to be a factor. Basically, Zelenski will have, depending on how the
- 1:21:43war ends, accumulated a ton of political capital for himself, and the question
- 1:21:47is how he's gonna spend it. Now some of the media questions. Ukraine
- 1:21:51still has a very very vibrant free media scene. So the question is balancing
- 1:21:59between we have this I think fairly liberal democracy, largely because it was a
- 1:22:03state that was too weak to be more authoritaria. How do we maintain freedom
- 1:22:10as will also like eliminating the influence of this oligar class who has not exerted
- 1:22:15a good influence in the Ukrainian political system, while like respecting property rights and
- 1:22:21interesting questions, Yeah, very interesting. I don't have a good answer.
- 1:22:25Yeah, and it's interesting whether America or the Europeans, you know, the
- 1:22:29Allied nations will take him to task, like okay, now now this is
- 1:22:34done, clean up Ukraine, get rid of all you know, handle these
- 1:22:39issues, or if it'll be we supported him, you know, these years
- 1:22:44and sent all this money. Let's not give anybody any reason to doubt what
- 1:22:50we did and just treat them with kid gloves. Well, if he wants
- 1:22:53to join NATO in the European Union, they're all like some pretty specific things
- 1:22:57all happen. Yeah, and that's the European Union. A europe should that's
- 1:23:00something they can handle and deal with. But look, I think it's not
- 1:23:04that people say like Ukraine's like fundamentally corrupts. It's again like Ukraine, like
- 1:23:11Russia, is a real country too, and like this has been an issue
- 1:23:14in post Soviet states with like weak central authort, Like this is not not
- 1:23:18out of the realm of the norm. It's something that like it's not like
- 1:23:23something Ukrainians are happy with either, mind you, like they're part of the
- 1:23:27issue. Whi Zelenski was unpopular before the war was a perception he wasn't cracking
- 1:23:30down on corruption enough. I mean, there were rumors about him being owned
- 1:23:34by Kalamoiski and some of these oligarchs, and you know, I don't can't
- 1:23:40say like the extent of the extent of that, But there's going to be
- 1:23:45a social demand in a country that's going to be I think for this for
- 1:23:49a window after the war, depending on how it ends, Right, if
- 1:23:51there's a painful piece, that may change things. But uniquely, uniquely united,
- 1:23:59I think, more united than it's been in its entire history, where
- 1:24:00there's now a common experience, like every Ukrainian who was born at the time,
- 1:24:05we'll be able to answer like, where were you in February twenty twenty
- 1:24:10two, And that's hasn't been the case before. So there's gonna be a
- 1:24:14common a common purpose, and the country will have an opportunity to basically be
- 1:24:19whatever wants to be. And that like there would be a lot of a
- 1:24:23lot of political capital to make changes. So yeah, it'll be it'll be
- 1:24:26interesting. Ukraine has been able to govern and manage itself shockingly effectively. Their
- 1:24:30train system runs better than Amtrak and it's being bombed regularly. So yeah,
- 1:24:35can we talk about Progosa Yeah, I was just gonna ask. Yes,
- 1:24:39Let's get into it. Let's get into it. Let's let's first start with
- 1:24:41the coup. How did we get how did we get to that point?
- 1:24:45I mean Progosian of course, running the Wagner Group Russian mercenaries to point into
- 1:24:49Ukraine, emptying out prisons and sending convicts up to the front lines. I
- 1:24:55mean, pick up wherever you'd like to pick up. Why why Proosi Progosian
- 1:24:59uh felt motivated to do this coup. What was going on, Well,
- 1:25:01let's talk about let's talk about Pregan, Pudin's chef. We'll talk about some
- 1:25:08some language. As I mentioned, I'm a language nerd that I was trying
- 1:25:11to think of, Like the good puny title for this episode is like pre
- 1:25:15Goosen is now post gozen. That's the that's the ends of him. But
- 1:25:18yeah, so how did he like why was he around Puden's inner circle?
- 1:25:23So he was one of these very wildly clever folks who in the nine Dies
- 1:25:26was able to kind of get his hands into the state budget and was catering
- 1:25:30catering events for Pudent's inner circle. The chef that was literally catering. That's
- 1:25:36not a literally catering. It's not like a mob with with this guy with
- 1:25:45food. Now the language fact here, so Petty Goshan is language wise related
- 1:25:51to the Russian verb podizza, which means to come in handy, to be
- 1:25:58useful. Now, the word goojin good is the same place that we get
- 1:26:03our word good from, So like this is useful, it's a it's a
- 1:26:06good good thing to have around. And so his role in in Russian foreign
- 1:26:15policy was kind of to be this off hand actor. Wagner group can take
- 1:26:19casualties and do things that the Russian state doesn't want to be directly affiliated with.
- 1:26:26Yeah, like Syria, like the incidents trying to attack US special forces
- 1:26:30and getting the fifty two. You know, the Russian your regulars don't want
- 1:26:35none. Of course, of course not apparently have conducted themselves fairly professionally.
- 1:26:41They're not the ones you know going on murder spreeze in Syria. Ukraine maybe
- 1:26:45different, different story, but yeah, so he was used to be useful,
- 1:26:51and so bach Mut he was able to actually achieve some degree of military
- 1:26:58success because he just tolerance for casualties. Their prisoners. There's Russia's worst who
- 1:27:04they were freed from prison and we're able to The tactics that I've read about
- 1:27:09were kind of interesting where they would basically just run at Ukrainian positions and the
- 1:27:15goal wasn't necessarily to take them, just to get folks alive close enough to
- 1:27:19call in artillery and then dislodged the Ukrainians then attack again human wave. Just
- 1:27:28you need one or two people to survive, that's all you need, just
- 1:27:30to say here's where the Ukrainians are attacked them. It's it's very morbid.
- 1:27:33Yeah, but it was working. It was working well. Now. So
- 1:27:39the issue politically with with this, with this fellow is that he was kind
- 1:27:45of a rival of Russia's defense ministry. He thought he was being more effective.
- 1:27:49Sir Geyshoigu, Russia's defense minister, never actually was a military guy.
- 1:27:54He worked in Russia's and basically Russia's FEMA, but that does firefighting and just
- 1:28:00see response too. Kind of became this rival figure and wanted more more of
- 1:28:04a bigger piece of the pie. The other piece Storry to mention is his
- 1:28:09role in Africa too, is like off hands foreign policy, being places where
- 1:28:12Russia doesn't have the resources or time to kind of duct foreign policy, like
- 1:28:17Molly, some of these coups we've seen providing support to these regimes after they
- 1:28:21take power. Interesting implications with precursion out of the picture, now, what's
- 1:28:27going to happen in Africa? But anyway, so what happened is, I
- 1:28:31guess earlier earlier this summer, Putin gave basically an order that all these private
- 1:28:40military companies, which by the way, have been traditionally illegal in Russia,
- 1:28:44so like unclear how this was even operating. And there's a great quote one
- 1:28:48of these like Russian nuggets from the I think eighteen hundreds that the strictness of
- 1:28:55Russian law is mitigated by the fact that it's optional. So this is one
- 1:29:00of these like it was like not technically legal, but still there and doing
- 1:29:04work. So anyway, couldn't get disorder down. That all of these private
- 1:29:10military contractors were to be rolled up into the army and that was kind of
- 1:29:15the end of the road for Pregosi and they were going to take his forces
- 1:29:17away. He's done, unclear what would happen with Africa and his kind of
- 1:29:23his fiefdom. Has that changed kind of fundamentally changed his logic where marching on
- 1:29:30Moscow is an insane is an insane thing to do. It's like one hundred
- 1:29:34percent certainty of death, which as a word, seems to have led there.
- 1:29:39But if you're going to lose everything and there's a one percent chance you
- 1:29:44might succeed by doing this thing, it's actually kind of a logical step to
- 1:29:47take. If the choices you're going to lose everything or have a one percent
- 1:29:50chance of success, you go for the there's a whole like theory about like
- 1:29:55human decision making and risk taking, where prospects theory humans are very, very
- 1:30:00risk averse. Do you think he was legit marching on Moscow to as for
- 1:30:05a coup or was he marching on Moscow as a statement. It's a great
- 1:30:11question and one I think we'll hear about in a couple of decades when those
- 1:30:15archives are potentially open. Part of like making peace with the fog of war.
- 1:30:19Difficult to know with that episode, Like, I don't think he was
- 1:30:24trying to overthrow Pudin. He may have done damaged to Puddin's reputation anyway.
- 1:30:30It was more about overthrowing Russia's defense ministry, getting a bigger slice of the
- 1:30:34pie piece of the action, maybe more forces, more commands, more influenced.
- 1:30:39But I mean when he marched into rostov Dan, which is a city
- 1:30:44in the south of Russia, he was like trying to capture the generals,
- 1:30:46like you guys, like you're under arrest. I'm talking to you, folks.
- 1:30:51So I don't think it was necessarily about Pudin, more of like an
- 1:30:55appear appeal to Pudin, and for whatever reason, he kind of chickened out
- 1:31:00before Moscow may have been tolled off, bought off, didn't wanted to avoid
- 1:31:04bloodshed. That parts a little unclear. Where did he exist in the larger
- 1:31:09like Russian political consciousness, because I just remember all these like pictures of like
- 1:31:13people taking selfies with them and all this kind of that was one of the
- 1:31:15most aside from the people who got killed on that hard day Russia. They
- 1:31:19shot down a Russian like intelligence aircraft they killed I think it was like thirteen
- 1:31:25people, which was wild. But what a fun day on Twitter and the
- 1:31:28Russia community, where I mean normally it's a lot of takes, this is
- 1:31:31what happening, that's what's happening, and everyone just like health, I know
- 1:31:35what's going or just gonna take out the popcorn and see how this, see
- 1:31:40how this plays out, And it was. It was a bit of fun
- 1:31:42camaraderie in that. But so sorry, resach that question. Well, I
- 1:31:47mean, where did Pergoshin exist, like within the Russian like social context,
- 1:31:51right, great question. So where he existed? And I think interesting in
- 1:31:57light of recent events and his elimination is kind of became like a folk hero
- 1:32:02of more nationalist Russians. Oh yeah, and this is. So Putin has
- 1:32:06been more wary over the war in Ukraine, less concerns with the liberals against
- 1:32:11the war and more concerned with the rara national ultra nationalists. Let's mobilize everybody,
- 1:32:17like World War two. Yea, let's do it again. There's a
- 1:32:21idea said, there's a Russian phrase, we can do it again. Yeah,
- 1:32:26so like kind of bad. That was not a good episode in Russia's
- 1:32:29So when Progoshan did like his like selfie video from the front dead boys,
- 1:32:34we need resources, like all the ultra nationalists were like, yeah, this
- 1:32:38is our dude. Yeah yeah, But that's also Putin's fault for selling it
- 1:32:42as we are invading a Nazi country, because those ultra nationalists, I mean,
- 1:32:48I'm sure that like they're tracing their lineage probably even further back, but
- 1:32:54a lot of it goes back to War two, and a lot of it
- 1:32:56goes But the ultra nationalists, no, they can they can be alter right
- 1:33:00national socialists who but they're Nazis has a very fungible meaning in Russia depending on
- 1:33:04the enemy of the enemy of the day. So there are Russia Nazis.
- 1:33:08I mean, it's fungeable everywhere. These days. That's true. Yes,
- 1:33:12fascist is like not even helpful term anymore. But yeah, who are like
- 1:33:16Russia doing very Nazi like fascist things, But it's the Ukrainians and the West
- 1:33:21who are actually the fascist and it's like a meaningless term. It's been warped
- 1:33:27by history. I did a great episode on my podcast again, bear Market
- 1:33:30Brief, if you want to get really into the weeds on the Russia stuff
- 1:33:33about like memory and Russia and World War two and this. Yeah, I'll
- 1:33:36check it out. It's really everybody check out Bear Market Brief, And in
- 1:33:42particular you probably don't remember the episode, but do you remember the title of
- 1:33:45it. It was some wordplay, but the guest was Jade McGlynn, who's
- 1:33:48a great expert. She just wrote a book actually about memory and Russia.
- 1:33:51I think Memory Makers is the title. So yeah, worth checking out if
- 1:33:56you're interested in this kind of historical memory angle. Everybody check it out.
- 1:34:00You love it. World War two is a lot of meaning to Russian It's
- 1:34:03kind of a important important time for Yeah, I mean it's look I mean
- 1:34:10it when you look at their their their losses, both civilian and military.
- 1:34:15You know, it was immense like they fought some major battles with virtually nothing.
- 1:34:20I mean alongside Ukrainians who yeh, the percentage wise took even more casualties
- 1:34:26and there then yeah, so Progosian gets a little cooie over there. Yeah,
- 1:34:31and I mean what what what was the outcome from that? So yeah,
- 1:34:36we had this weird moment where Belarus's president Lukashenko kind of came riding in
- 1:34:42on his white horse and was like, actually, we'll take him to Belarus.
- 1:34:47Unclear, like what was it? Did like he was instructed by Pudin
- 1:34:50to mediate. I mean Pudin's big things as a leader, just as far
- 1:34:57as the defense ministry versus Pregojian, he's kind of the refere Everyone thinks that
- 1:35:00he's like making the decisions personally, but he tends to like mediate between factions.
- 1:35:04It's kind of his superpower. So yeah, unclear where Luca Shiko came
- 1:35:10from. So yeah, basically Pregosan moved to moved to Belarus with some of
- 1:35:18his dudes who decided to go with him somewhere like rolled into the military.
- 1:35:21After all. There's an interesting I think psychotomy worth noting in Wagner. So
- 1:35:27you have a lot of these like prisoners cannon fighter, but also like former
- 1:35:31like spetz Nas, like very serious people who were like good, good at
- 1:35:36fighting. And the Ukrainians there's reports like they learned very quickly when they were
- 1:35:40fighting against Wagner, like these are real deal troops, not moby kiss like
- 1:35:44a Russian mobilized troops. These are there, they're real deal professionals. Moved
- 1:35:48to Belarus, were evidently like stirring shit with Poland's just to poke, hey,
- 1:35:53like we can cause problems, nothing too too serious. And then then
- 1:35:59yeah, kind of once quiet, and then was flying over Moscow and seems
- 1:36:02to have been and then putin I don't know if you caught this today,
- 1:36:08gave his like comments like eulogy, kind of like a mob boss, like,
- 1:36:11oh, like he did well for himself and for Russia when he was
- 1:36:14a man of a complex fate. Yeah, something like that. It's very
- 1:36:17Yes, Yes, solution suba is comedy weird. Yeah, And the plane
- 1:36:25very clearly was not like a mechanical issue like they had like the flight radar,
- 1:36:29the altitude recording like cruising cruising, cruising, cruising, and it wasn't
- 1:36:33like a descending Yeah, is speculation intelligence, early intelligence is appointing at Ukraine.
- 1:36:44Is a pointing up Putin is ap pointing up Belarus pointing at Putin.
- 1:36:48I think it's honestly the simplest explanation, which is kind of a crazy thing
- 1:36:51to say that, Like, yeah, like he crossed Putin. He made
- 1:36:55him look completely impotent, pants him in a way that Pudin has not looked
- 1:36:59weak basically since the beginning of his administration. Open to Pandora's box. Now
- 1:37:05people said like, oh, this is this is like Pudin's going to collapse.
- 1:37:09I said, it is the beginning of the ends, but like that
- 1:37:12period of the ends could take, you know, another fifteen years. But
- 1:37:15it made it possible that there's a world in which Putin could be challenged and
- 1:37:19made to look weak. Similarly, in the example I give is when Trump
- 1:37:24like floated the possibility of the US not defending NATO, like he lost the
- 1:37:30election, there's a new administration, even the military, you know, made
- 1:37:33it clear that that was honored the treaty obligations. But like the fact that
- 1:37:38was uttered became possible. I think, like that you can't put that back
- 1:37:42in the box now, like that is a possibility. So this is he
- 1:37:45made Putin looked weak and he can't he can't do that. I mean the
- 1:37:50other thing that just like I mean maybe this is like an ass and I'm
- 1:37:55I mean tactical thing, but I mean the fact that like him in ten
- 1:37:58of his like boy, he's got into this little plane and flew to Moscow
- 1:38:03ut fellow who founded Wagner Is it of itself a very very go odd thing.
- 1:38:10Well, this Utkan guys, this weird looking ball dude as tattoos.
- 1:38:14So like it's like all Ukrainian na. There's like not a uniquely there's plenty
- 1:38:18of Russian ones too, but including this high ranking but yeah, like it
- 1:38:23was a decapitation and strike against like Russia's own warlord is kind of wild and
- 1:38:29there's a lot we don't know what we have to make peace with that,
- 1:38:30Yeah, And I mean from an American or Ukrainian perspective, I mean,
- 1:38:35when they start cannibalizing their own people, that's a pretty good napoleons. I
- 1:38:40never interrupt your enemy where he's making a mistake. Yeah, exactly what do
- 1:38:43you think? Uh? You know, we've seen on a little bit of
- 1:38:45action at least with like the US embassy and the Lithuanians. The Poles and
- 1:38:48everything with Belarus lately. Do you do you see Belarus at all like ramping
- 1:38:55up or do you think they're just kind of kind of give give tacit support.
- 1:39:00Lukashenk Goes a very very interesting person. The traditional like question, who
- 1:39:05would you want to have like a drink with? Like I'd be fascinated to
- 1:39:09have a conver He's very clever. He's i mean, managed to hold onto
- 1:39:14power for a long a long long time, longer than putin minds you.
- 1:39:20Has really done everything possible to not get involved while looking like he's on the
- 1:39:27Russian side. Belarus is a belligerent in this war, Like there has been
- 1:39:30combat action launched from Belarus the invasion itself, but air strikes, missile strikes
- 1:39:35like Ukraine would have justification to invade and attack Belarus doesn't make sense. They're
- 1:39:42not going to. But he's a belligerent. There are Russian forces there,
- 1:39:45but he's yeah, been very demonstrative about like, yeah, we're gonna put
- 1:39:53Russian forces here, x y Z will take in Wagner, but like hasn't
- 1:39:57really done anything. Yeah, here's been reports and hearts and know that like
- 1:40:00Belarus is military basically made it clear that like we're not getting involved. They
- 1:40:05be They're they've been poorly funded, poorly trains that get torn to bits by
- 1:40:10trains motivated Ukrainians. Speaking of World War Two casualties, Belarus is actually not
- 1:40:15allowed to use as military constitutionally outside of the country. Really, they suffered
- 1:40:20the highest casualties as a country really during World War Two. Yeah, devastated.
- 1:40:29I think. I think the movie Come and See, which is one
- 1:40:31of the most fucked up movies, what's Come and See dis matri is about
- 1:40:35Belarus and World War Two. It is if you want to ruin your day
- 1:40:41and like have a lot, like a drink, like, oh my god.
- 1:40:44Yeah, that's a powerful World War two movie. Oh yeah, yeah,
- 1:40:46because yeah, it's fascinating. So so when you say they are belligerent
- 1:40:51and missile strikes, has it been them? Hasn't been the Russian side?
- 1:40:55They Russians using Belarus as a launch pad. But that's kind of right,
- 1:40:59right, the same same difference. Yeah, yeah, yeah, I just
- 1:41:03shouldn't know, if you know, Belarus is kind of like or if they
- 1:41:08were like, oh you guys, you guys, you had to defend the
- 1:41:11border. Ukraine has lobbed some missiles into Belarus, but like at Russian facilities.
- 1:41:16But so like that's and the like Belarus Lukashenko. Just I guess it
- 1:41:20was yesterday they congratulated Ukraine with like congratulated sorry thinking in Russian congratulated on independence
- 1:41:29Day. Hey, like Belarus and Ukraine are are close peoples and we like
- 1:41:33it's just this Yeah, And they trolled each other over the border. They
- 1:41:38have like radio broadcast. They put like signs up, Hey you're under a
- 1:41:41dictator ship. Hey you're under not like but they don't shoot at each other.
- 1:41:44Yes, I feel like if Pudin falls tomorrow, Russian and chaos,
- 1:41:48Lukashik will be like I was the only one keeping this from like really blowing
- 1:41:53up, like it was all me. Yeah, really interesting dude, and
- 1:41:58also a brutal dictator who has done grievous harms and man eight other Russians.
- 1:42:01We just want to Belarusians rather. Yeah. So before we get into questions
- 1:42:06for Aaron, I guess like the last question I would have is, at
- 1:42:10this stage in the conflict, do you see any limitations of American power,
- 1:42:16limitations of American military assistants. Are we running up against a wall? I
- 1:42:24think there's still more political will to send goods. There's still more cold war
- 1:42:29stockpile we could unleash. There's still more current stockpile we could unleash that just
- 1:42:33there's been pretty clear political signal that's not going to happen. There's supply,
- 1:42:39there's supply check, there's the math, the fundamental the gears of war here,
- 1:42:44like actually, we can't make enough artillery rams to supply Ukraine. We
- 1:42:49have to wrap that up. There was a story, I think about a
- 1:42:54month or so ago that like Raytheon had to invite a bunch of like sixty
- 1:42:59sixty seventies and things to like restart their Stinger missile line because it had been
- 1:43:02dormant so long and we're just kind of out of them. So we're going
- 1:43:05to need to build more and then get to optimize start building those again.
- 1:43:10Like that's a that's a factor at play. So there's some parts that just
- 1:43:13have to be like ramped up again. As far as good supplied, there's
- 1:43:16been talk of what Abraham's tanks eventually. The export model I think has been
- 1:43:23the kind of the older older variants. The S sixteen has been kind of
- 1:43:27kicked around a while. The pilots that are going to be pilots that are
- 1:43:30going to be trained, but like what that'll come online in maybe next year,
- 1:43:34and I don't think we'll play a huge difference in the war. So
- 1:43:40we've enabled Ukraine to keep fighting, but I don't think have provided any like
- 1:43:45one off game changer wounderbaffa. You know, weapons that would like like single
- 1:43:50handedly everyone talks about like precision cruise missiles x y z and the the grounds
- 1:43:56launched small diameter bomb x y z. It's really like artillery shells and APCs
- 1:44:01that are like the main bullets and mass that you know allows you crazy kep
- 1:44:06fighter. Do you think that the numbers in this conflict are now ticking down
- 1:44:11towards some sort of negotiated settlement, like we're moving towards an endgame. I
- 1:44:15think we'll war. I just inherently like is going to lead to some negotiated
- 1:44:18settlements. I don't see it happening. There's nothing, I guess would say,
- 1:44:21nothing that suggests to me that isn't going to happen anytime soon. But
- 1:44:26I think it will wars ended negotiated settlements, whether it's the complete capitulation or
- 1:44:30otherwise. And I don't think it's going to be a I don't think there's
- 1:44:33going to be a desk and a paper and key of or Moscow. But
- 1:44:38there will be some agreement sometime or an armistice like Korea style, like where
- 1:44:44we're like the war is on pause, and that will just be okay because
- 1:44:46it has to be with you know, you mentioned that you know we're we're
- 1:44:51emptying that we're giving Ukraine or stock pow. And we've talked about this on
- 1:44:58the show before with like any Milburne maybe some other people about this idea that
- 1:45:03the US isn't in this as much to help Ukraine as it is to bleed
- 1:45:09Russia. And you know, when you look at some of our arms deals
- 1:45:14with other countries like F sixteens to Jordans, you know, you know weapons
- 1:45:17of Saudi Arabia, the cal States, you know, Turkey, you know
- 1:45:21these other countries that maybe we have that there aren't even actively involved in an
- 1:45:30engagement. We're here, we're sending you know, a billion two billion worth
- 1:45:36of or I mean one hundred billion, two hundred million worth of weapons in
- 1:45:41cash. Do you do you think that? Uh, I'll just ask what's
- 1:45:47your opinion on the idea of slow rolling. Are we giving the Ukrainians the
- 1:45:51weapons they need to actually win the war in a timely fashion or are they
- 1:45:57are? Yeah? Are we just slow rolling it? So I would say
- 1:46:00that I don't believe that harming Russia is like the principal guiding factor here.
- 1:46:04Now we're getting a very good return on investment for providing weapons. I mean,
- 1:46:11it's like it's an externality I think of the core reason of the policy.
- 1:46:15Yeah, there's a lot of opinions on this. I think certainly Ukraine.
- 1:46:19Ukraine's military would say, like, we haven't been given especially for the
- 1:46:23counter offensive. They're trying to take on a very very tough military challenge with
- 1:46:28no air superiority, Like that's and that's hard. I think they'd be very
- 1:46:32grateful to have a lot of F sixteens. The military commanders are always going
- 1:46:36to want more resources for even ours. Yeah. Yeah, so I think
- 1:46:43Biden, the administration broad they have slow rolling is maybe not the word I
- 1:46:48use, but would would I've tried to manage escalation, and you know,
- 1:46:53they've talked about like attack thems and like long range missiles to gradually ratchet up
- 1:46:59to demonstra continued to resolve, but not in a way that would lead to
- 1:47:02like a fundamental break in like Russia to completely collapse, which could become dangerous
- 1:47:08for Russian escalation. Now Russia has also demonstrated it's, uh, the credibility
- 1:47:13of its deterrent is not very serious. So like if the US gives tanks,
- 1:47:16it's nuclear war. US gives tanks nothing. If Ukraine attacks Russian territory,
- 1:47:21it's war and nuclear war, and Ukraine does that nothing. So it
- 1:47:25certainly hasn't done it tough any favors there, But I think, yeah,
- 1:47:29there's Biden has tried to like put limits on what these weapons can be used
- 1:47:33for realistically and yet signal some degree of moderation to leave maybe leave opened the
- 1:47:41possibility of talks that you know, without completely showing that there's this is a
- 1:47:45fight to the bloody finish and there's no way this could be negotiated. Well,
- 1:47:49we talked about, uh, like the WE on one of the past
- 1:47:53shows, we talked about like the Biden administration blocking Wallace's uh, you know,
- 1:47:57bid for you or for native or UN was UN or NATO over the
- 1:48:02F sixteen It was maybe NATO. I think it was NATO Uh, I'm
- 1:48:10pretty sure. Yes, NATO secretary, Yes, NATO secretary when he's like,
- 1:48:14well loved, you know, and everything else like that. Over just
- 1:48:16one, I think wanting to train you know, uh, Ukrainians and f
- 1:48:23sixteens. Uh. Do you have any insight in that, like where that
- 1:48:29might come from or what what that was about? That gets a little more
- 1:48:32into some of the military politics that can really focus on day in and day
- 1:48:35out. But yeah, I think that the hope here. I think that
- 1:48:40we can talk about like what the US wants out of this, and I
- 1:48:42think maybe the main motivation as this is kind of the the we use the
- 1:48:46term like order defining, where Russia is basically proposition that it is okay on
- 1:48:53the global I mean they wouldn't say this broadly, but demonstrating in Ukraine it
- 1:48:58is okay to invade countries and conquer territory, which is very, very problematic
- 1:49:01if you're the leading global power. I mean, US IS has an eye
- 1:49:06on Taiwan as it's watching what happens in Ukraine. Hey, if we don't
- 1:49:10demonstrate the credibility of defense commitments in our interests, I want is next and
- 1:49:15that's not good. China Scarier than than Russia. Right, Yeah, we
- 1:49:20have questions for Eric, we do, and we have some on Patreon.
- 1:49:26Let me get the ones on YouTube real quick. If I could have on
- 1:49:38my hobby horse for a seconds here. One of the things we talked about
- 1:49:43the arguments that the US isn't spending money domestically because it's funding Ukraine. I
- 1:49:47just want to like whack that with a hammer. That the reason that we
- 1:49:51can continue to fund Ukraine is because there's maybe fraid a little bit, but
- 1:49:57there's a political consensus in the States that that's a doable thing. There isn't
- 1:50:01about other domestic spending. If there is a consensus about domestic spending, we
- 1:50:05could do that too. So it's not because there's no money left because we
- 1:50:09gave it all to Ukraine. We talked about that on our our patreons,
- 1:50:13but you know our Patreon viewer or special day. Yeah, we're given a
- 1:50:17lot of money Ukraine. But the idea that we're taking that away from people
- 1:50:21in Hawaii or or or or you know people and you know who live below
- 1:50:28you know, the poverty level wherever, like our government wasn't doing that anyway,
- 1:50:32right, you know, and and they could give they could help out
- 1:50:35Hawaii, they could help out you know, there's a coherence isolationist world view
- 1:50:41that would say we shouldn't support Ukraine. But like the number part of it
- 1:50:46that like fiscal policy, that's not that's not their reason. You can make
- 1:50:49that arguments without saying, oh, because we need the money for domestic reasons.
- 1:50:54Now, the fiscal policy is interesting because I think right now most people
- 1:50:58who are in support, supporting, who support Ukraine or support our efforts you
- 1:51:02know in Ukraine, say yes, keep sending the money. It'll be interesting
- 1:51:09to see if this goes on another five years, another ten years, you
- 1:51:14know what if that's if that changes because we're blissfully like we are blissfully and
- 1:51:23removed from the horrors of what's going on. So all all it is to
- 1:51:27us is a is a budgetary number, right and dropping the bucket at that
- 1:51:31for budgetary number. But but we're we're blissfully removed from the actual toll that
- 1:51:36this war is taking on new Ukrainians and the Russian you know, the Russians
- 1:51:41who are being pushed in this war too. I mean, obviously they could
- 1:51:44another hobby horse item that like we're making the Ukrainians fight when they don't want
- 1:51:48to like yeah, I don't like yeah. Well so I think people say,
- 1:51:55like the war is like, oh, it's because of the counter offensive,
- 1:51:57Like the war is getting less popular. There was the recent's pull,
- 1:51:59like fifty five percent of Americans say enough, And I think that's probably getting
- 1:52:05way over Our ski is to suggest that, like most Americans are following the
- 1:52:09ebb and flow of the war very closely. I think it's more about inflation
- 1:52:13and the economy and the amounts to which the wars and the news and the
- 1:52:15trend I've sent it to see when we had the heart give counter offensive and
- 1:52:19Ukraine made this smash and grab amazing offensive America, you know, it started
- 1:52:25noticing Ukraine was in the news they did something good. Oh yeah, like
- 1:52:28r raight Ukraine, like let's give them more money? And then there's been
- 1:52:30kind of added the news the kind of same like malais with the economy here,
- 1:52:35there's still inflation. It's bad. Oh Ukraine, what's even going on?
- 1:52:39Right Ukraine breaks through again, I'll be like, oh wait, like
- 1:52:41way to go Ukraine and r rah so like right, so dark point,
- 1:52:45thank you very much. Did experts correctly assess the improvements Ukraine made to its
- 1:52:50defense capability since twenty fourteen? What did they get right and wrong about the
- 1:52:55beginning? So I think the entire field, most of the entire field.
- 1:52:59There's a couple of people when I would shout out Mike Kaufman, who does
- 1:53:02a lot of podcasting on War in the Rocks is like him and Rob Lee,
- 1:53:08who does work with FPR right too, are like the pre eminent if
- 1:53:10he wants tactical updates and like real nitty gritty military in a way I be
- 1:53:15above my pay grade. Great great follows. So, yeah, what changed
- 1:53:21since twenty fourteen? But Ukraine's military, So we've seen the adoption of Western
- 1:53:29style delegated warfare, like the emergence of a strong NTO corps. We've seen
- 1:53:33that kind of take hold in the military. We saw that particularly in the
- 1:53:38chaos of the first days of the war where there were there was kind of
- 1:53:42just chaos going on in these in so many cases just civilians picking up guns
- 1:53:45and fighting, and these initiative but smaller units able to do that. And
- 1:53:49I think one of the things that we're now budding into with the counter offensive.
- 1:53:53And I've heard and again on podcasts like and War in the Rocks from
- 1:53:56from Mike and Rob that smaller units have been able to adopt this, but
- 1:54:00like division level coordinated, when you have like generals involved, they tend to
- 1:54:05be even more Soviet mindset and and that's that's complicated things. They are very
- 1:54:12you know, like objective, you go here and then you go here,
- 1:54:15and casualties be darned. We're gonna do what we have to do there.
- 1:54:18I think the Ukrainians have demonstrated a lot of ingenuity adopting new hardware and technology.
- 1:54:24They have this real like patchwork of different military equipment, tanks and vehicles
- 1:54:30they've strapped like what like jay dams to like Suhoy aircraft, Like they're not
- 1:54:35built to attach to each other. They've figured figured that out. So they
- 1:54:41have a lot of technical ingenuity, which is not surprising. I mean,
- 1:54:45pursuing like drone warfare that's been crazy to see sinking. There's a great article
- 1:54:49and the Economist magazine about how the Moscow was sunk and Ukraine. Ukraine had
- 1:54:56they built a lot of missile rocket motors for Russia before things back to the
- 1:55:00Soviet Union. They were like their main supplier of ballistic missiles. I believe
- 1:55:04I wouldn't be surprised if in you know, the war drags on, like
- 1:55:06Ukraine will build nuclear or otherwise, but we'll build ballistic missile capabilities because they
- 1:55:12can. They have the know how right on hand, right. Yeah,
- 1:55:16as a desserrence, do you see them at all attempting to restart their program?
- 1:55:24It's interesting. So the politics would potentially favor it. It would be
- 1:55:28a way to extract concessions from the West that they have nuclear power points in
- 1:55:31the case that they have the capability to produce, so they have the technical
- 1:55:35know how. If they're only as far as like to do that stealthily like
- 1:55:41break out and what is mechanically required to do I would defer, I would
- 1:55:45refer to experts. But as far as the politics, yeah, you could
- 1:55:48say, like Russia, this is our our final line of defense to ensure
- 1:55:53the existence of our state. Hey, West, like, we would hate
- 1:55:56to do this, so why don't you keep sending us stuff and will agree
- 1:55:59that we're not going to build a new But like the politics, the politics
- 1:56:02are there. I mean one of the one of the agreements we made with
- 1:56:05them. When they n your eyes random you defend them integratory yeah, territorial
- 1:56:14integrity, couple of glass whiskey, Yeah, yeah, and dark point.
- 1:56:18Asking did you work with other Tier one years or FBI h R T what
- 1:56:23did you think of them? Just kidding grats on the hundred thanks dog,
- 1:56:29I appreciate a man and then AUSSI Roberto. How would you adjust sanctions go
- 1:56:35after transhitments countries like Kyrgyzstan. Yeah, it's a great, great question.
- 1:56:41It's something in my my job now that we the transhipments, it's figuring out
- 1:56:45how we still see US dual use and chips winding up in Russian military components.
- 1:56:51So adjusting sanctions, there's kind of a theory with sanctions. They're either
- 1:56:56getting stronger or getting weaker. You can't have consistent sanctions because people start finding
- 1:57:01loopholes. Now it's much easier to adjust sanctions than to find new loopholes.
- 1:57:08The sanction what OPHAK is the Office of Foreign Asset Control at Treasury. They
- 1:57:12just write a sentence on a piece of paper that's implemented. But to build
- 1:57:16a supply chain to get around sanctions takes time and money. But yeah,
- 1:57:20there's certain trans transitments issues. It's enforcement of existing sanctions. There's certain limitations,
- 1:57:29like sanctions against Kyrgyzstan would land a lot better than sanctions against Turkey because
- 1:57:34we need Turkey as a as a NATO allied. There's like there's much and
- 1:57:40they could be realistically honest broker for like peace deal, so there may be
- 1:57:43limitations there. The part with sanctions about Russias as far as Russia goes,
- 1:57:47is that like this is a delayed fuse damage, Like Russia is basically mortgaging
- 1:57:53its future right now, and like that the impact of sanctions will be felt
- 1:57:57a lot more going forward is to forred investment that really starts to bite,
- 1:58:01so we may see the true impact of sanctions later. To say they haven't
- 1:58:08worked against Russia is wrong. They haven't stopped the war, certainly not by
- 1:58:12by any means, but they they have done damage and made it harder for
- 1:58:15Russia to operate. And then a couple of questions from Patron, how do
- 1:58:20you assess the state of European support for Ukraine if you have support waivers as
- 1:58:26the twenty four election cycle approaches, can Europe provide enough of a backstop to
- 1:58:30avoid to steal meat? Yeah, so we'll take time. Europe is kind
- 1:58:34of remilitarizing, ramping up production. I've seen certainly European political will do.
- 1:58:42Okay, there's Orbon in Hungary as kind of the the counter example there for
- 1:58:48his own political reasons. Turkey came around after the election because it was really
- 1:58:53seems like it was mostly domestic politics and this long term geopolitical agenda. But
- 1:58:58now it's it's fine, but yeah, this this Schultz moments of like,
- 1:59:01yes, we actually can't hey, we can resist Russia. Look, there's
- 1:59:08the kind of ever presence threat of populism in Russia like Leapin in France.
- 1:59:14I still think my view, and this maybe proven wrong, it's more about
- 1:59:17inflation in the economy than Russia or se. I don't think anybody among European
- 1:59:24populists or even in the even the United States like gets points for being for
- 1:59:29Russia anymore, because it now means something it didn't used to me. And
- 1:59:31you know, for Trump or the pen to be like, oh, like
- 1:59:33we can do business with Russia or who's the newer in the Republican debate,
- 1:59:40Vivek the I don't want to pronounce his last name wrong, but he was
- 1:59:46talking about like him doing business with Russia. I don't think if he became
- 1:59:49presidents would actually come to any meaningful agreement. But I think it's it's differentiation
- 1:59:55versus Yea. In the debate, you get to say all kinds of stupid
- 1:59:58stuff, like we're gonna bomb mex Ago you would never never do if you
- 2:00:02were actually elected. But I think it's more about inflation and domestic political factor
- 2:00:06than it is actually about Russia or Ukraine per se. Yeah, now,
- 2:00:11and you in Europe, what's happening, Like the decoupling from Russia has a
- 2:00:15much greater political and economic impact than it does in the States because Europe and
- 2:00:18Russia were much more tightly integrated. One of the things we saw between less
- 2:00:24time I spoke with you and now is that Europe got really lucky because it
- 2:00:28was an extremely warm winter last year and it's spared the worst of Russia turning
- 2:00:31off the gas Pickett. Yeah, well, not just them turning off from
- 2:00:35too like getting blown up another mystery along the way, Yeah, Isaac.
- 2:00:43Thanks. How do you think Chinese PMCs are reacting to everything Wagner related in
- 2:00:47addition to the assassination or does the PRC even have their Wagner I'm less familiar
- 2:00:55I'm not a China specialists, so I don't want to get out of my
- 2:00:58lane here. As far as I understand, these pmc's have been largely around
- 2:01:01like resource plays in Africa, as best they understand. I think it's different
- 2:01:08politics, yeah around that. Yeah, yeah, there there is. I
- 2:01:12mean, in my opinion, I think there's going to be a certain amount
- 2:01:15of like social learning or military learning that like they see what's possible. You
- 2:01:21know, did Russia see what was possible with private military companies from what we
- 2:01:26did in Iraq? I mean the Chinese try to bring out of prince into
- 2:01:30the fold. I mean literally that won't. So it's not the end of
- 2:01:32pmc's in Russia, I mind you. So there's Gazprom. Gazprom, as
- 2:01:36we would say English has has like an affiliated like a like a torch is
- 2:01:45I guess that say that in English like a PMSC. And I mean these
- 2:01:51local military formations and private military companies. It's a way of distributing rents like
- 2:01:56these excess economic profits, keeping the system in line. So like that need
- 2:02:01is still there for Russia. Just that Wagner got like a little out over
- 2:02:05its skis by marching on Moscow. Yeah, don't do that. Yeah.
- 2:02:12And then who were the people on the plane. Who are the other people
- 2:02:15on the plane? Were they just collateral damage? If so, this is
- 2:02:18the Kremline killing their own citizens so they can raise the tensions among the Russian
- 2:02:24people. That's their government, not to raise tensions among people. Yeah,
- 2:02:27there was collateral damage, but you know what the casualty report is the one
- 2:02:31hundred and forty thousand Russians have died in this war, So like, what's
- 2:02:38another four? So it was the key the key players, so was it
- 2:02:43was pretty go and then Utkin were the two primary leaders of Wagner who are
- 2:02:47who are offt They're the ones who were Yeah. And then flight attendants,
- 2:02:53which is you know sad, Yeah, another unfortunate aviation mishap. Yeah.
- 2:02:59Yeah, And so it has Vironer group been completely like absorbed by the military.
- 2:03:09They're apparently leaving Belarus last I read. I think we'll see kind of
- 2:03:13what happens, but I think that's likely the outcome. And that's it for
- 2:03:20questions, all right, I mean, any final thoughts as we wrap up
- 2:03:26here about we covered a lot of grounds that was that was a lot,
- 2:03:30a lot to bring back up to speed. I would just float. It
- 2:03:32was really sexy at the beginning of the war to donate to Ukraine to hang
- 2:03:35flags. And there's a lot of humanitarian need still, I mean, especially
- 2:03:41the destruction of the Damn, like the huge ecological catastrophe. It's not talked
- 2:03:46about it anymore. Razam for Ukraine are a z o M. If you
- 2:03:50feel generous, I want to truck him a buck. I would still recommend
- 2:03:55it. It's still very very much needed. Yeah, some of buck folks.
- 2:03:59I mean your man turn eight is always cool. And where you mentioned
- 2:04:03that you do this podcast, you work with this think tank. I mean,
- 2:04:06where can people find you and find your work? Yeah, so if
- 2:04:10you look up at Twitter at the handle at bear Market Brief, Bear you
- 2:04:15can find it there. Bar ere b b e a r like Russia like,
- 2:04:20but also bear Market it was a plan words at the at the time.
- 2:04:26You can find it, so you can find it there. If you
- 2:04:28look up Chain Reaction podcast anywhere you listen to podcasts, you can find stuff
- 2:04:32there. So I do a couple. I do bear Market Brief, which
- 2:04:35is about get Russian Eurasian Ukrainian politics. I do another series called The Continents
- 2:04:43where each episode I visit quote Uno, I wish I could visit in person,
- 2:04:45but I visit a country in Europe as a nine expert to learn about
- 2:04:48hey Warren Ukraine. Has it impacted Germany? Poland? I did a Serbia
- 2:04:54Kostovo one recently, so I'm going to do one in September about Moldova.
- 2:04:59So like learning on the grounds about what's actually happening as a nine experts are
- 2:05:02very accessible, so another way you can learn with me. It's been kind
- 2:05:05of fun to do anywhere else. Yeah, that's I think. Oh yeah,
- 2:05:12so as far as countries or I mean places where people can find your
- 2:05:15work or and then on Twitter that I try to stay off of it as
- 2:05:20much as I can. Sorry on x I've seen your dad jokes on there.
- 2:05:25Yeah, a lot of a lot of dumb wordplay sometimes analysis, But
- 2:05:28I think the podcast is really where I do most of most of the work.
- 2:05:31And then on Twitter some remarks as we have interesting weeks like this one.
- 2:05:35Now, I guess the kind of final fun Russia subjects matter in fact
- 2:05:40is that August is traditionally an inauspicious month for Russia, and there's a few
- 2:05:45days left of August, so we'll see we'll see what happens. Well,
- 2:05:49hopefully we'll have you in here next year, but we will be discussing how
- 2:05:55the war ended. Uh, you know, let's hope for the people involved.
- 2:06:00Yeah. Absolutely, And next Friday we will be back with Chris Whitcomb.
- 2:06:05Chris served on the FBI hostage Rescue Team and we'll have him here in
- 2:06:10studio, so we're really excited to talk to him. Aaron, thanks for
- 2:06:14coming by tonight, appreciate it. Yeah, we'll do it again, you
- 2:06:16know sometime, you know, like Dave said, maybe in next year.
- 2:06:20Have you back for another update, and we really appreciate having you, know,
- 2:06:24your expertise on the show. Great to be back, all right,
- 2:06:27guys, so we will see you next Friday. Take care out there. Oh and