Latest / Sobering Stories / Murdered After Exposing Her Husband
Transcript
- 0:45Can we vape in here? Oh, no.
- 0:55Yeah, yeah, I think I'm ready whenever you guys are.
- 0:59Oh, this one. OK,
- 1:16Talk about irony, right? Because there's definitely going
- 1:18to be a Netflix special about this case.
- 1:40All right, welcome back to Sobering Stories with me, DJ
- 1:43Petrovsky. This is your first time here.
- 1:46Thanks for joining me. We do mini dives on Tuesdays,
- 1:49deep dives on Fridays. We go live on Mondays.
- 1:52We're just out here looking for the truth.
- 1:54Like this video on the way in? If you don't subscribe, please
- 1:58subscribe. Tick that little bell over there
- 2:03and follow me on my other socials 'cause I got a bunch of
- 2:06other ones. And if you want Early Access and
- 2:08uncensored content members only Patreon, Let's go.
- 2:14On July 23rd, 2026, at exactly 1116 PM, Owosso County dispatch
- 2:21receives a strange 911 call on the other end.
- 2:25All they hear is a woman screaming and then the sound of
- 2:30a gunshot. The line goes silent.
- 2:32Dispatchers call back, no answer.
- 2:35They call back again, no answer. 3266 I'm trying to reach him
- 2:38back but I could hear a female in the background screaming and
- 2:41crying. Some sort of loud bang in the
- 2:44background, That old male that we were looking for a few weeks
- 2:49ago after you got caught kissing a juvenile, They suddenly get
- 2:53another phone call from a nearby neighbor's house.
- 2:56It's a teen boy who's saying my stepdad just shot my mom and I
- 3:01need your help right away. Within minutes, police arrive at
- 3:05the 130th East Ave. address in Collinsville, OK.
- 3:10As they enter the home, they find 2 adult deceased bodies,
- 3:14one belonging to Jeremiah Sean Duffy and the other belonging to
- 3:19Sarah Gilson Duffy. The boy is completely unharmed.
- 3:23He's taken into custody, asked some questions and then he's
- 3:27released into the custody of his real biological dad.
- 3:31Some of you might even follow these two TikTok influencers.
- 3:34Jeremiah's name is Duff Daddy and Sarah goes by Misses Gilson.
- 3:39She's a lifestyle influencer. She does a lot of Tiktok
- 3:42marketplace like TikTok shop, sales stuff, affiliate stuff.
- 3:47OK, you guys look at his eyes. Look at this eye compared to
- 3:52this eye. I got this instant firm eye
- 3:57temporary eye tightener from Peter Thomas Roth, and I wanted
- 4:02to try it on my husband because he always has dark circles and
- 4:05he always gets a little bit of wrinkles around his eyes like
- 4:09that. And so I put it on this eye and
- 4:12not that eye to show you guys the difference.
- 4:14I mean, whoa, isn't that amazing?
- 4:19It's tight. Does it look good?
- 4:23Really good. And Duff Daddy, I don't really
- 4:27know what to describe his content as he posts a lot about
- 4:30how to respect women. Listen.
- 4:33If you go out to eat with your man and he don't sit where he
- 4:38can see the front door, you probably had a wrong one.
- 4:41Be a protector man. Protect your ladies.
- 4:44I'm just. Oh my baby, I'm coming.
- 5:02And how to treat your woman and how to be the best man for your
- 5:05woman all. Right.
- 5:07Fine, fine. I'll see you soon.
- 5:18I know I didn't do anything I don't want to.
- 5:26I didn't like any new pictures or anything or follow anybody.
- 5:55He also just posts some like weirdly inappropriate just like
- 6:00kind of funny TikTok things. He doesn't really ever say
- 6:03anything he just plays music and has like a little caption.
- 6:16I mean, he had like 350,000 followers and Sarah had like, I
- 6:20don't know, 30,000 maybe before before all of this happened.
- 6:24Obviously now she probably has more outside of influencing on
- 6:28TikTok. Jeremiah was actually the head
- 6:30of security for the Osage Nation reservation, Osage Casinos.
- 6:36He was also a part time youth basketball coach.
- 6:39It was a travelling team and it wasn't associated with any of
- 6:43his kids schools, but he was a youth basketball coach.
- 6:48Jeremiah had five kids prior to Sarah and him getting together,
- 6:52and Sarah had two of her own kids that she brought into this
- 6:56relationship. Sarah's two kids actually come
- 6:58from a previous marriage to a guy named Lyle Landers.
- 7:01They got divorced in 2019, but at this point in 2026, they
- 7:06would consider each other friends.
- 7:08Lyle was even telling Sarah that he felt like she really needed
- 7:11to get out of this relationship. It doesn't seem like Jeremiah's
- 7:15kids lived with them at all, but I couldn't find any information
- 7:19about them. All I know is that they were
- 7:21interviewed for this PTO embezzlement story that the
- 7:26local news was working on and in this interview they both say
- 7:29that they have seven children and I only knew about the two
- 7:33that Sarah had. So I'm assuming the other five
- 7:36come from a previous relationship that Jeremiah had.
- 7:40I spoke with Owosso parents Sean and Sarah Duffy.
- 7:43We have 7 kids combined and so our kids work hard to go earn
- 7:47money for their schools. It's so important for them to
- 7:50have what they need for their education, emotionally,
- 7:54mentally, to support the teachers.
- 7:56And I think it just takes out of the pockets of the school.
- 7:59The teachers, obviously, but honestly, it's really about the
- 8:01kids. It's disgusting.
- 8:03It's honestly disgusting because it's I mean, like I said, I got
- 8:067 kids. I also coach basketball
- 8:08crossover prep. They're in Tulsa and just to
- 8:12hear stuff like that just blows my mind that people would take
- 8:15away from the kids. We obtained a copy of the
- 8:17statement sent from the school's principal, who says quote.
- 8:20Upon this discovery, district leaders and I immediately took
- 8:23action by starting an internal investigation.
- 8:27Based on those findings, the district notified local law
- 8:30enforcement and a police report was filed.
- 8:33Sarah was also a TikTok influencer, like I mentioned,
- 8:36but she was a local hair stylist.
- 8:38She was very popular, very successful, and she was known as
- 8:42the life of the party. Very energetic, bubbly, just an
- 8:45amazing person to be around. Everybody in the community that
- 8:48knew her loved her. And by all accounts, this
- 8:52couple, this little family, they seemed totally normal,
- 8:56successful online. They've got successful social
- 9:00media profiles. So everything seemed to be going
- 9:03great until it wasn't. In August of 2021, Jeremiah was
- 9:07actually arrested for domestic violence against Sarah.
- 9:10A protective order was issued and the two of them were ordered
- 9:13to stay away from each other, couldn't be within 100 yards of
- 9:16each other. But because Sarah never showed
- 9:18up for any of the court hearings after that, the charges were all
- 9:21dismissed. The court order, the protection
- 9:24order was dropped. I don't know that was that.
- 9:26But despite Lyle's warnings, Sarah felt like everything was
- 9:29fine. They had some issues in the
- 9:31past, but everything seemed good.
- 9:34And a lot of their tik toks, you know, she includes him and the
- 9:37tik toks, he's kind of silly and goofy.
- 9:39They seem like they genuinely work well together.
- 9:42Seemingly no red flags. Then on June 9th, Jeremiah is
- 9:46coaching a basketball game with his youth basketball team.
- 9:50At some point during this game, whatever is going on, another
- 9:53one of the coaches for one of the other basketball teams
- 9:56catches Jeremiah making out with a 15 year old girl who's also a
- 10:02member of his youth basketball team.
- 10:04This other coach reports this information to the girl's
- 10:07parents, and the girl's parents immediately file a protective
- 10:12order and file charges against Jeremiah.
- 10:16Sean Duffy AKA Duff Daddy. We're not sure exactly how she
- 10:21found out, but I'm sure a word like that doesn't take very long
- 10:25to travel. But Sarah finds out what
- 10:27happened and she also files another protective order on
- 10:32Jeremiah. So he's actually kicked out of
- 10:34his own house and he's told he can't come within 100 yards of
- 10:38Sarah or her kids or the residents for that matter.
- 10:43Police would eventually find out that this was not a one off.
- 10:46Jeremiah had been continuously having weird interactions with
- 10:50this girl. He'd even tried to pay her so
- 10:52that she would keep quiet about what they were doing.
- 10:55She says that it made her very uncomfortable, but she didn't
- 10:58really know what to do, so she just stayed quiet Because this
- 11:01was a travelling basketball team.
- 11:03This abuse had occurred over multiple different time periods
- 11:08in multiple different states. So we're looking at a pretty
- 11:11serious, you know, Interstate case here.
- 11:15But to make things even more complicated, it happened on the
- 11:18Osage National Reservation, so that automatically moves it to
- 11:23the federal courts as opposed to the Owosso County courts.
- 11:28So things got real serious real quick for Duff Daddy.
- 11:32And I think he knew that because he took off that night on June
- 11:3510th and Owosso County says that they weren't able to locate him
- 11:40and he was never seen again. That is, until July 23rd.
- 11:44What is this bro? What the this you're admitting
- 11:48to making out with a 14 year old right here bro.
- 11:50Why don't we contact the coach that busted you?
- 11:53Why the fuck did the little coach have to go get a bigger
- 11:56coach to get you the fuck out of the gym?
- 11:58Help you help you Because the little coach was so scared and
- 12:00like distraught. He was crying and shit though he
- 12:03had to go get another coach to get your ass out the
- 12:05motherfucking place. Please bro please please explain
- 12:11that one dog and you was trying to get 13 and 14 year olds drunk
- 12:17at your house when Sarah wasn't there and you told him not to
- 12:22let Sarah find out that you was giving them alcohol.
- 12:25Was served my 14 year old alcohol daughter and her friends
- 12:29while they were out in bathing suits.
- 12:34You're cooked. Because Sarah told the
- 12:36authorities that Jeremiah had taken a weapon, he had
- 12:40threatened to pass himself away, and he hadn't been seen for
- 12:45multiple days, they felt like he was a pretty serious threat, and
- 12:49they extended Sarah's protective order from June 23rd all the way
- 12:55out through their next hearing date.
- 12:57At this point, there's a viral trend going around on TikTok
- 13:01where people are filming themselves saying this is me
- 13:04prepping for my upcoming Netflix documentary series about blank,
- 13:09can we vape in here? Just a viral trend that happens
- 13:15a lot on TikTok. But on July 11th, Sarah decides
- 13:19to make a post. And initially this post seems
- 13:21like, oh, is that some weird dark humor that I just don't
- 13:25get? I don't know.
- 13:26But the caption, or like the title of this TikTok is, I wish
- 13:31I were kidding. Plus, Sarah looks visibly shaken
- 13:34up. She seems visibly distraught,
- 13:36visibly upset, like she might be on the verge of crying or just
- 13:41finished crying. And completely understandable.
- 13:44I'm sure it was a little bit cathartic for Sarah to get that
- 13:47out, kind of share what she's going through, especially since
- 13:50she has a decent following online.
- 13:52And on top of it, Jeremiah's still gone.
- 13:55Nobody knows where he's at. He's not taking accountability.
- 13:58And ultimately, she's probably still scared for her life.
- 14:01So we're not really sure what pushed her to make this post,
- 14:04what pushed her to out him like that.
- 14:07But maybe it was just a coping strategy.
- 14:09I mean, a lot of people use social media to help them cope
- 14:13because you can get that validation or people who
- 14:16understand and empathize with your situation.
- 14:19So I don't know, maybe she was doing that or maybe she was just
- 14:21posting to update her followers because she had been Mia since
- 14:26all this happened because who could focus when this is all
- 14:30going on? On her Facebook, we see her
- 14:33spending time with some girlfriends just trying to get
- 14:35some me time in, trying to just cope with this heavy, heavy
- 14:41news. And on top of that, there's tons
- 14:43of videos showing Jeremiah and Sarah's daughter doing these
- 14:48TikTok dances. And Sarah's daughter looks to be
- 14:52like 13 to like 15, maybe 16, I don't know.
- 14:57She looks young, she's a teenager.
- 14:59So here's a little fun fact for you guys, 'cause I know you love
- 15:03fun facts. Did you know that a protective
- 15:05order is actually not protective at all because it's just a piece
- 15:10of paper. So if somebody wants to say go
- 15:14over to the protected person's house and pass them away and
- 15:20then pass themselves away on July 23rd at like 11:00 PM, then
- 15:25that's totally possible. The protective order isn't going
- 15:29to do anything at all. It's just going to be a piece of
- 15:31paper. That pointless.
- 15:34Now, I'd say protective orders are not completely useless
- 15:37because in a situation where a person isn't going to do that,
- 15:41it can give people the needed space to calm down and either
- 15:46figure out if they're going to leave or work things out.
- 15:49So it can be a good thing, but in this situation, pointless.
- 15:53Now unfortunately we have no information about motives or how
- 15:59things happened anything. The only person who knows
- 16:03exactly what happened is going to be Sarah's son because he was
- 16:07in the house was clearly on the phone with dispatch when his mom
- 16:12was taken away. I can't even imagine the trauma
- 16:15that that poor kid just experienced and I was extremely
- 16:18sad thinking that he had lost both of his parents.
- 16:21But then I found out that Jeremiah was just his stepdad.
- 16:24You're not my. Dad, you also hear something
- 16:27ugly. Ass fucking.
- 16:29Which made me a little bit happier because he at least has
- 16:32his dad Lyle to fall back on and he can live with his dad now and
- 16:36same with Sarah's daughter. But man, both of these kids just
- 16:40lost their mom and their stepdad in a truly gruesome, violent,
- 16:46horrific, traumatic experience. This happened just 12 days after
- 16:52Sarah made that post outing Jeremiah online.
- 16:55We can only assume that he felt like this had ruined his life
- 16:59even more than it already was. It seems like he was displacing
- 17:03blame pretty hard because if he's going to take Sarah with
- 17:07him when he does that, well then that implies that he felt like
- 17:11she was guilty or had some sort of fault or caused this.
- 17:15That's where he needed to take her out for it.
- 17:17Get revenge. Yo dog, you put yourself in this
- 17:20position and if she's going to out you well, don't make out
- 17:24with 15 year olds. I mean it's pretty simple
- 17:26actually. We don't truly know the motive,
- 17:29but with things really stacked up against Jeremiah, clearly his
- 17:33hard work building up a massive following on TikTok all for
- 17:37nothing and now he's got federal charges against him.
- 17:41Plus he just got outed. You're.
- 17:43Cooked. I can totally understand him
- 17:45wanting to leave this world but for him to take Sarah with him
- 17:49pisses me off so much. And I'm sure I'm not alone but
- 17:53that just pisses me off. That guy douche daddy dude.
- 17:58Unfortunately Jeremiah's accounts were all privated so I
- 18:01couldn't really get a lot of info there.
- 18:03I do know that Lyle has been asking Sarah to leave Jeremiah
- 18:07for like 5 years, which is most of their relationship.
- 18:11And that makes sense because in 2021, five years ago, he put his
- 18:15hands on her to the point where he got arrested.
- 18:18So she was nice enough to take him back after that.
- 18:21And then he goes and does this and who knows what else.
- 18:25None of Jeremiah's previous partners have come forward.
- 18:28And right now there's not a lot of information floating around
- 18:31because this did just happen. But as more information comes
- 18:35out, obviously we'll learn more about what possibly happened,
- 18:39motives, if the kids are OK, everything.
- 18:42But I do want to know what you guys think.
- 18:44Please drop your thoughts down in the comments.
- 18:47I appreciate you guys chilling listening to Sarah's story.
- 18:50And man, this one was truly heartbreaking for me.
- 18:54Like just so sad, so sad. Oh, and I almost forgot there is
- 18:59a GoFundMe that I've LinkedIn the description if you want to
- 19:03donate, all the funds are going to Sarah's kids and the victim
- 19:08of the situation. So yeah, if you want to donate,
- 19:11feel free to donate there, contribute to a good cause, and
- 19:15hopefully do something for these poor kids.
- 19:18I cannot even imagine for real. But that's all I got for you
- 19:21guys today. Please like this video on the
- 19:23way out. If you like what we're doing,
- 19:25subscribe, hit the notification bell, follow my other socials,
- 19:31and I look forward to doing this again with you guys on Friday
- 19:35for another one. But until then, sleep safe, stay
- 19:39sober, stay awake, and stay alive.
- 19:42And if you get a protective order out on someone, you need
- 19:45to follow that up by purchasing a gun.
- 19:49Protect yourself. But yeah, thank you guys.
- 19:52Love you guys. Later Sobers.
- 19:54Let's go.