Latest / Manager Mondays with Fexingo: People Management, Team Leadership, and First-Time Managers / Why Your Best Employee Is About to Quit
Transcript
- Lucas: You ever have that moment where your best person — the one who never complains, hits every deadline — walks into your office and says they're leaving? And you're completely blindsided? Luna: Yeah. It's a gut punch. And honestly, it happens way more often than managers want to admit. Lucas: Well, there's actually a name for it. It's called 'quiet quitting' flipped around — I've seen it called 'quiet resignation.' The employee doesn't signal anything. They just one day hand in notice. And the manager is left thinking, 'But your last review was stellar. You got a raise six months ago.' Luna: So what's going on? Are they just not being honest in reviews? Lucas: Sometimes. But more often, the issue is that managers are asking the wrong questions. We ask 'How are things going?' and we get 'Fine.' We ask 'Any concerns?' and we get 'Nope.' We are not creating space for the real conversation. Luna: So what's the fix? I've heard of something called a 'stay interview' — is that what you're getting at? Lucas: Exactly. Instead of waiting for an exit interview — which is too late — you proactively sit down and ask questions designed to surface what keeps someone engaged and what might pull them away. It's not a performance review. It's a retention conversation. Luna: Right. And it's not just about asking 'What would make you leave?' because that feels confrontational. There are better ways to frame it. Lucas: Absolutely. So let's get specific. I want to look at one company that has systematised this: Microsoft. A few years ago, their HR team developed a structured stay interview process that they rolled out to thousands of managers. The core questions are public now, and they're worth stealing. Luna: I'm listening. What are they? Lucas: First question: 'What do you look forward to when you come to work each day?' That sounds soft, but it tells you whether the person has intrinsic motivation tied to the work itself. Second: 'What's one thing you would change about your role if you could?' That surfaces friction points before they become deal-breakers. Third: 'What kind of projects make you lose track of time?' That's about flow and strengths alignment. Luna: Those are good. The third one is especially clever because it's positive — you're not accusing them of being unhappy, you're asking about engagement. Lucas: Right. And the fourth one is the closer: 'What would tempt you to leave?' Now, that is a direct question. But by the time you've asked the first three, the rapport is there. You've shown genuine curiosity. So when you ask the hard one, they're more likely to give a real answer. Luna: I imagine a lot of managers are scared to ask that question because they don't want to hear the answer. But isn't it better to know? Lucas: Way better. Because if the answer is 'I'm underpaid,' you can fix that. If it's 'I don't see a path to promotion,' you can work on a development plan. If it's 'I'm bored,' you can find stretch assignments. But if you never ask, you just lose them. Luna: There's a stat I remember from Gallup — I think it was from a 2024 study — that said something like 68 percent of employees who left a job did so because their manager didn't address a single issue that could have been resolved. Lucas: That's the one. And it's heartbreaking because it means most turnover is preventable. The manager doesn't need to be a mind reader — they just need to ask the right questions and actually listen to the answers. Luna: So the stay interview isn't a one-time thing, right? It has to be regular? Lucas: Yeah. Microsoft recommends doing a version of it every quarter. Not the full formal thing each time, but a lighter check-in. Because people's priorities change. A year ago, your top performer might have wanted more responsibility. Now they have a new baby and they want flexibility. If you don't check in, you miss the shift. Luna: That makes a lot of sense. So the manager's job becomes less about annual reviews and more about ongoing calibration. Lucas: Exactly. And here's the thing — when you do stay interviews well, you also build trust. Employees feel seen. And that alone is a retention factor. There's a reason people stay at companies where they feel their manager genuinely cares about their growth. Luna: Okay, but let me push back a little. What if the employee says something you can't fix? Like 'I hate the industry' or 'I want to move to another city'? Then you've just accelerated their departure. Lucas: That's a common fear. But think about it — would you rather they leave in six months with no warning, or in twelve months with a plan? If you know they're planning to relocate, you can start transition planning early. You can even help them find a role in a different city within the company if that's an option. The worst outcome is blindside. Luna: Fair point. And I've seen cases where the manager actually helped the employee find a better role elsewhere, and the employee became a vocal advocate for the company. That kind of goodwill is invaluable. Lucas: Absolutely. So let's talk implementation. If you're a first-time manager and you want to start stay interviews next week, what does that look like? I'd say block forty-five minutes. No laptops. No phones. Take notes by hand. Ask the four questions we talked about, plus one more: 'Is there anything else you want me to know?' Luna: That open-ended question is crucial. Often the biggest issue comes out after the 'official' questions are done, when the person feels safe enough to be honest. Lucas: Right. And one thing I'd caution against: don't turn it into a performance review. Don't bring up their metrics. Don't give feedback during the stay interview. The whole point is to listen, not to evaluate. Luna: That's a trap I could see a lot of managers falling into. They hear an opportunity to coach, and they jump on it. Lucas: Yeah. Resist that urge. The stay interview is about the employee's experience, not the manager's agenda. Save the coaching for your regular one-on-one. Luna: So what about remote teams? Does the format change? Lucas: Good question. The core questions are the same, but you have to be more intentional about creating psychological safety over video. I'd suggest starting with a personal check-in — 'How are you really doing?' — and making sure your camera is on and you're not multitasking. Also, consider doing it as a walking meeting if that's possible in their time zone. Some managers find that the lack of eye contact on a walk helps people open up. Luna: Honestly, this episode is the kind of thing that could save a manager from losing their best people. I know I'm going to use these questions with my team. Lucas: Yeah, and if it helps you keep even one key person, that's a huge win. And if this conversation was valuable to you, I'll just say — if it was worth a coffee to you, there's a link. You can find us at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. That's the smallest ask I can make, and it genuinely helps us keep the show ad-free. Luna: Yeah, totally. If you've gotten any value from the show, that's a great way to support us. No pressure at all. Lucas: So back to the stay interview — I want to give you one more concrete example. A friend of mine managed a team at a mid-size tech company. She had a top engineer who was consistently exceeding expectations. She did a stay interview and asked 'What would tempt you to leave?' He said 'I want to work on machine learning projects, but my current role is all backend infrastructure.' She worked with her VP to shift his project allocation, and he stayed for three more years. Luna: That's perfect. He probably would have left within six months if she hadn't asked. And all it took was one conversation. Lucas: Exactly. So the lesson is: don't assume you know what your people want. Ask them. Regularly. And be prepared to act on what you hear. Luna: One thing I'd add is that you should also ask about what they love. Sometimes the reason someone stays is just as informative. You can reinforce those elements. Lucas: Great point. The stay interview isn't just about risk mitigation. It's also about amplifying what's working. So ask 'What's the best part of your week?' and then try to give them more of that. Luna: Alright, so to recap: schedule quarterly stay interviews, ask the four core questions, listen more than you talk, don't turn it into a review, and act on what you learn. Lucas: That's the framework. And if you do it well, you'll dramatically reduce the chances of being blindsided by a resignation. Plus, you'll build a team that feels valued and understood. Luna: I think that's plenty for one episode. Next time, maybe we can talk about what to do when you're the one who wants to quit. Lucas: That's a great idea. We'll call it 'The Graceful Exit.' For now, thanks for listening. Luna: See you next Monday.