Latest / 10 Minute Murder | Bingeable True Crime Stories / The Occult Killing of Colleen

Transcript

The Occult Killing of Colleen · 10 Minute Murder | Bingeable True Crime Stories

• 0:15
  Eighteen year old Christa Pike's relationship with her classmate Colleen Slimmer had quickly become full
• 0:21
  of one sided distrust and jealousy. Krista was convinced that Colleen was infatuated with
• 0:28
  her boyfriend to Darrell Ship and was trying to steal him away from her.
• 0:33
  Christa adored to Darryl, and even though he was a year younger than her,
• 0:37
  the two of them had a very intense relationship. Krista's life up until
• 0:42
  that point had been full of adversity. She had never completed high school,
• 0:46
  dropping out before graduation to join a government program called the Job Corps, which
• 0:51
  helped disadvantage young people to gain skills that would allow them to get jobs.
• 0:56
  Despite everything she'd been through to Darrell still loved her. He made her into
• 1:00
  a better person, and she liked to think that she did the same for
• 1:04
  him. She wasn't about to let Colleen come between them, and she decided
• 1:08
  that she'd do whatever she had to to make sure that Colleen wouldn't get what
• 1:14
  she wanted, or what she thought Colleen wanted. Despite Christa's accusations, Colleen's
• 1:19
  friends were adamant that she was not interested in too Darrell at all. It
• 1:25
  seemed as if Christa had misinterpreted Colleen's friendly nature and innocent conversations with to Darrell
• 1:32
  as romantic interest. As time went on, Krista became angrier and angrier at
• 1:37
  Colleen. She started to obsess over Colleen's behavior, worried that she would lose
• 1:42
  to Darrell for good, and angry because she thought Colleen wanted someone who belonged
• 1:47
  to her. Finally, she reached a breaking point. She talked to one
• 1:52
  of her friends, Chadola Peterson, and began to make a plan to teach
• 1:56
  Colleen a lesson. It was the twelfth of January nineteen ninety five when the
• 2:01
  plan was set into motion. Christa to Daryl, Colleen, and their friend,
• 2:07
  eighteen year old Shedola Peterson, all signed out of their dorms and made
• 2:10
  their way to an abandoned steam plant in the woods near campus. Colleen knew
• 2:16
  that Christa didn't like her, but she believed that the trip was sort of
• 2:20
  a peace offering where the group was going to smoke some weed together and overcome
• 2:24
  their differences. However, when the four teenagers arrived at their destination, it
• 2:30
  was clear to Colleen that she had been lied to. Krista and her boyfriend
• 2:35
  immediately turned on Colleen and began beating her. Chidolah didn't participate in the attack
• 2:42
  and instead stood nearby to warn the couple if any witnesses approached the area.
• 2:47
  This role as a guard or lookout had been decided by Christa during her planning
• 2:53
  of the attack. For around half an hour to forty five minutes, Colleen
• 2:58
  was ferociously toward shirt. She was severely beaten and cut, and the couple
• 3:02
  used a blade to carve the shape of a pentagram into her skin. Finally,
• 3:08
  the attack ended when Christa grabbed a large piece of asphalt and hit Colleen
• 3:13
  in the head with it. The force of the blow shattered Colleen's skull.
• 3:17
  It killed her instantly. Christa didn't regret the murder. In fact, she
• 3:23
  pride one of the broken pieces of skull free and took it back with her
• 3:27
  to her dorm to keep as a trophy. She didn't just feel a lack
• 3:31
  of remorse, she felt pride. Over the next day and a half,
• 3:36
  Christa carried this piece of calling skull around campus with her while Colleen's family and
• 3:40
  friends were gradually realizing that she was missing. It didn't take long for authorities
• 3:46
  to view Christa, to Darryl, and Chidola as suspects. The evidence was
• 3:51
  clear four students had signed out of the dorm together and then the group had
• 3:55
  returned without Colleen, resulting in Christa and her accomplices being arrested thirty six hours
• 4:01
  after the murder. It's almost like they didn't even try to hide their crime,
• 4:06
  which, don't get me wrong, I'm glad they got caught so quickly,
• 4:10
  but with all due disrespect, what a stupid plan. When Christa was
• 4:15
  arrested and her clothes were searched for evidence, police found her disgusting trophy,
• 4:20
  the fragment of Colleen's skull, tucked in the pocket of her coat. Christa
• 4:26
  quickly confessed to her involvement in Colling's death, but she insisted that it had
• 4:30
  not been a murder. She and Tadarrel had just been trying to send Colleen
• 4:34
  a message and scare her a little bit, but then got carried away and
• 4:40
  accidentally killed her. A search of the three accomplices dorms uncovered more pieces of
• 4:46
  the puzzle, especially when a religious occult book, the Satanic Bible, was
• 4:50
  found into Darrell's room. Christa and Tadarrel had not been into Satanism before they
• 4:57
  got together, but during their relationship a mutual interest had spiraled into a full
• 5:01
  blown devil worship. It had become a cornerstone of their relationship. For Christa,
• 5:08
  it gave her security and a sense of purpose. Suddenly, the pentagram
• 5:13
  carved into Colleen's body made sense to the investigators. At the nineteen ninety six
• 5:18
  trial, the jury found it easy to reach a verdict. Even though Christa
• 5:23
  had insisted Colleen's death was an accident, she had already confessed to being the
• 5:27
  one to kill her. The rest of the evidence brought forth by the prosecution
• 5:30
  made it clear that no part of the killing had been an accident. It
• 5:35
  had been premeditated torture ending with cold blooded murder. On the twenty second of
• 5:43
  March nineteen ninety six, Christa Pike was found guilty of both conspiracy to commit
• 5:47
  murder and murder in the first degree. Four days later, she received her
• 5:53
  sentence twenty five years of jail time and death by electrocution. The other murderer
• 6:00
  to Darrell received a much lighter sentence of life in prison with the possibility of
• 6:03
  parole. Shadola, who had stood guard during the attack and had been involved
• 6:09
  in the planning of Colleen's death, had already pleaded guilty to being an accessory
• 6:14
  to murder and then acted as an informant for investigators. In exchange for a
• 6:18
  reduced sentence, she received credit for four hundred and sixty days in prison and
• 6:24
  probation for six years. Krista's violent, vengeful behavior didn't stop when she was
• 6:30
  imprisoned. The twenty fourth of August two thousand and one, she and another
• 6:34
  inmates, Natasha Cornett, attacked a prisoner named Patricia Jones. The two women
• 6:40
  attempted to murder Patricia by strangling her to death with a shoelace. While the
• 6:45
  attack caused serious injury, Krista and Natasha did not succeed in killing Patricia.
• 6:50
  Although there wasn't enough evidence to charge Natasha for her role in the assault,
• 6:55
  Christa was not so lucky. She received additional charges for the attack, tempted
• 7:00
  first degree murder. While incarceration, Christa made a friend. His name was
• 7:04
  Donald Cohut, and he was a personal trainer who had for some reason started
• 7:09
  writing letters to Krista. In two eleven, the two of them regularly wrote
• 7:14
  back and forth, and eventually Donald started driving to Tennessee, which was an
• 7:18
  eighteen hundred mile long road trip from his home in Flemington, New Jersey,
• 7:24
  so that he could see Christa in person. He made this journey multiple times
• 7:28
  every month. Donald wanted to help Christa, so he devised a plan to
• 7:32
  help her escape from prison. He got in touch with a guy named Jason
• 7:35
  Hefflin, who was a corrupt corrections officer, who agreed that he would help
• 7:41
  and aid Christa's escape for a fee. But the plan did not get very
• 7:46
  far before it was discovered and two twelve prison staff were tipped off about an
• 7:50
  escape plan involving Christa Pike. The investigation was launched in both Tennessee and Donald's
• 7:56
  home state of New Jersey, and the details of the plot were covered.
• 8:00
  Donald had planned to use Justin's role in the facility to obtain the tracing of
• 8:05
  a key, which could then be used to create a copy. The finer
• 8:09
  details of the plan have never been released to the public due to concerns that
• 8:13
  prison security could be impacted, but the Tennessee Bureau of Investigations simply stated that
• 8:18
  the plan had been in the early stages when it was discovered saying quote Christa's
• 8:22
  jailbreak was not imminent. Donald Cohut was charged with conspiracy to commit escape as
• 8:28
  well as bribery. He received seven years of jail time. Justin, the
• 8:33
  corrections officer was charged with conspiracy to commit escape, bribery, and official misconduct.
• 8:39
  Because of Justin's willingness to cooperate with the police, the only consequence he
• 8:43
  faced was losing his job at the prison. Investigators were unsure whether Christa had
• 8:48
  actually taken part in any of the plan, or if she was just aware
• 8:52
  that Donald wanted to break her out of jail. Because of this uncertainty,
• 8:56
  Christa was not charged to this. Christa's fate is still hanging in the balance.
• 9:03
  In two twenty her attorneys were given extensions due to the COVID nineteen pandemic,
• 9:07
  giving them more time to compile a convincing argument to save christoph from death
• 9:13
  by electrocution. In June of two twenty one, Christa's attorney filed a motion
• 9:18
  that requested a certificate of commutation, which would allow Christa's punishment to be reduced.
• 9:24
  Ultimately, the decision about the execution is now down to the courts.
• 9:28
  If Christa Pike's execution does go ahead, she will make history as being the
• 9:33
  only female criminal to be executed in the state of Tennessee in the past two
• 9:37
  centuries. Colleen Slimmer's mother just wants closure and for this case to be finally
• 9:43
  over, because the fragment of Colleen's skull that was once a trophy for Krista
• 9:48
  is still considered evidence and in custody of the police. When this story finally
• 9:54
  ends, the last piece of Colleen can be laid to rest. That's ten
• 10:09
  minute murder for today Brief and binge able True Crime. I'm Joe the host,
• 10:13
  and I really appreciate you listening, and I hope your day is fantastic.
• 10:18
  I made myself a cup of coffee earlier. I spilled a little bit,
• 10:22
  and during the process of cleaning up, I got the sleeve of my
• 10:24
  shirt wet. I was washing my hands, and you know it gets in
• 10:28
  the water a little bit, and we know that ruins your whole day.
• 10:33
  So your thoughts and prayers are welcome during this difficult time in my life.
• 10:35
  I could just change my shirt, but I don't want to do that.
• 10:39
  Hey, if this is your first time listening to ten Minute Murder. Please
• 10:41
  subscribe now so that you can catch up on all the back episodes, never
• 10:46
  miss any of the new ones. Connect with me on social media, see
• 10:48
  the visuals that we're talking about doing the podcast, And if you liked this
• 10:52
  episode, please leave a rating and review on Apple or any place that is
• 10:56
  possible. Your positive feedback is a preciated go to ten minute murder dot com
• 11:03
  for all things ten minute Murder