Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Practical PAGA: Real-World Strategies for California Labor Law Litigation
Transcript
- 0:03Hello, my name is Marie Weiner and welcome to
- 0:06Practical Paga. We appreciate being invited by
- 0:10the Beverly Hills Bar Association and the program
- 0:13is also in conjunction with ADR services. So
- 0:17I'm Marie Weiner and I was a judge of the Superior
- 0:21Court in San Mateo County for 22 years, including
- 0:25doing complex civil litigation for over 11 years
- 0:32as that judge as well as civil supervising judge.
- 0:35So I did dozens and dozens of Paga cases as well
- 0:39as multiple Paga trials. Before that, I was an
- 0:43attorney for 19 years doing complex civil litigation,
- 0:46and I'm now a neutral with ADR services. And
- 0:50we have other panelists if you'd introduce yourselves.
- 0:54Sure. Good afternoon. I'm Jen Kramer. I'm a partner
- 0:58at Kramer Brown Wheat in Los Angeles, and I've
- 1:01been representing California workers since 2000,
- 1:04and I've experienced litigating Paga claims back
- 1:07to its inception. And so in fact, I actually
- 1:11did a bench trial in front in Judge Weiner's
- 1:13courtroom back in the day, and she ruled in our
- 1:17favor. So thank you. So in 2024, I worked with
- 1:23mediator Steve Pearl in a attorney, Julie Trotter,
- 1:26on a study of Paga trial results that we published
- 1:29in the California Lawyers Association Labor and
- 1:32Employment Bulletin. And I was also part of the
- 1:35team working on the Paga reforms in 2024 on behalf
- 1:39of the California Employment Lawyers Association,
- 1:42of which I'm a board member. So that's a little
- 1:44bit about my Paga bona fides. Thanks, Jennifer.
- 1:49My name is Corey Cabral. I'm a partner and the
- 1:53chair of the POG litigation practice at CDF Labor
- 1:57Law. We're a California -only management -side
- 2:01defense firm. I've been handling POG actions
- 2:06throughout my professional practice and I'm looking
- 2:11forward to speaking with my panelists on the
- 2:14subject today. All right, so let's get started.
- 2:18And I should say the slides that we'll be showing
- 2:21are in your written materials. We have in there
- 2:25references to cases and statutes if you need
- 2:28that reference, but we're just gonna hit the
- 2:30meat and potatoes of this subject. So things
- 2:34to consider and know before you file a Paga case.
- 2:37who can sue, pre -litigation notice, what's the
- 2:41difference between class versus representative
- 2:43actions, their pros and cons, the scope of the
- 2:47claims, and is there arbitration clauses? So
- 2:51why don't we go ahead and get started with that.
- 2:54All right, so I'm gonna lead us off on who can
- 2:57sue. So one thing we need to differentiate today
- 3:01right off the bat is there's old PAGA and there's
- 3:04new PAGA, right? So in 2024, PAGA was reformed.
- 3:11and significant changes were made, and this is
- 3:14one area where there were significant changes.
- 3:17So Old Paga had a broad reading of who could
- 3:20sue. You could include violations for the representative
- 3:24aggrieved employee that they didn't personally
- 3:26suffer, and you could also include violations
- 3:29for which the statute of limitations had expired
- 3:32for your representative plaintiff. Now, no one
- 3:35can file new actions under Old Paga, but you
- 3:39have to be aware that if you filed in action
- 3:42before June of 2024, you're operating under the
- 3:45old Paga rules. Under the new tightened requirements
- 3:49of new Paga, a representative plaintiff must
- 3:53now have suffered each violation that's alleged
- 3:56in your notice. And that violation must have
- 3:59occurred within the one year statute of limitations
- 4:01that applies to your plaintiff. So there's some
- 4:05little exceptions for things like if you're a
- 4:08qualified nonprofit, like Legal Aid at Work,
- 4:11but that's generally who can sue. And I think
- 4:16everybody has to keep in mind, too, that because
- 4:18of this significant change, a lot of the case
- 4:21law that people might see might now not apply
- 4:24to their case, because it used to be kind of
- 4:28a free -for -all. And now you really do have
- 4:30the link between the plaintiff and what are the
- 4:32claims that they can pursue. Right. So Huff and
- 4:38the Johnson case are not good law under Nupaka,
- 4:41correct? And there have been. after Huff in particular,
- 4:46a lot of cases that came out that relied on Huff.
- 4:51That likewise, you know, even though those cases
- 4:55might not address the same issue, the scope of
- 4:58the claims of Paga plaintiff can maintain, they
- 5:00relied on Huff. Huff was based on old Paga. So
- 5:04the new standing provision will have a material
- 5:08impact on a lot of things going forward. So once
- 5:13you have a client, who can sue or former employee,
- 5:17current employee who's suing you, they have to
- 5:19submit a pre -litigation POG notice. And that's,
- 5:24again, pre -litigation before the lawsuit's filed.
- 5:26The notice is submitted online to the LWDA and
- 5:30sent to the employer by certified mail. And the
- 5:34most critical aspect of the notice is that it
- 5:37includes the alleged facts and theories of liability
- 5:40to support each of the alleged labor code violations.
- 5:45And on both sides, the importance is the same.
- 5:49The scope of the notice, the scope of the facts
- 5:52and theories of liability, will shape the scope
- 5:55of the PAGA plaintiff's authority to represent
- 5:59the state of California and seek civil penalties
- 6:02on its behalf. It remains true that a PAGA plaintiff,
- 6:07with respect to their PAGA claim, only represents
- 6:10the state's legal rights and interests. in particular,
- 6:14the interest in labor code enforcement and the
- 6:17right to collect civil penalties for violations.
- 6:21So the authority to represent the state will
- 6:24be dictated by the notice. And that creates a
- 6:29balancing for, I think, plaintiff's attorneys
- 6:31when it comes to how broad do we want to assert
- 6:37the violations and the notice, and on behalf
- 6:41of whom? If it's very narrow, but specific, then
- 6:47the resulting Paga claim is not likely to face
- 6:51early challenges based on the adequacy of the
- 6:55notice. If it identifies a particular job classification
- 7:01that the Paga claimant slash plaintiff was a
- 7:05part of. facts or allegations of fact and theories
- 7:10of liability that are specific to that job classification
- 7:14and supports each of the alleged violations,
- 7:18there's not likely to be a challenge to the adequacy
- 7:20of the notice. If the notice alleges that plaintiff
- 7:24and all non -exempt employees in California suffered
- 7:28violations and the alleged violations are vaguely
- 7:31asserted, that can create problems down the road.
- 7:38The notice, I guess, procedures is pretty well
- 7:42laid out in this slide. Essentially, an employer
- 7:46can provide a response or initiate a cure within
- 7:5033 days of the postmark date of the notice. It's
- 7:5560 days for the LWA to respond and let the parties
- 7:58know whether it's going to investigate or not.
- 8:00More often than not, the LWA doesn't issue any
- 8:02response to a notice letter. In that case, which
- 8:08again, happens almost all the time, no response
- 8:11from the LWA and 65 days after the notice is
- 8:15mailed and submitted, the claimant can pursue
- 8:19a Paga action in court. Notably, if a plaintiff
- 8:24already has class claims or even individual wage
- 8:26and hour claims, when or soon after they submit
- 8:31a Paga notice, after the 65 day period expires,
- 8:36they have 60 days to amend that pending complaint
- 8:41to add the PAGA claims as a matter of right.
- 8:46So the plaintiff wouldn't even need to seek leave
- 8:48to amend. They could just file the amended complaint
- 8:50to add the PAGA cause of action or cause of action.
- 8:56Now to the next topic, I think Judge Weiner is
- 8:58going to talk about. Back on the other one just
- 9:00for a second. Sure. Go ahead, Jen. Well, I was
- 9:05going to say is, you know, the plans bar should
- 9:08be aware that the LWDA the state agency that
- 9:12They're actually reviewing the Paga notices,
- 9:15and they are kicking back notices that they don't
- 9:18find to be legally compliant under the current
- 9:21statute. Also, they're in the process of adding
- 9:26regulations that will regulate different aspects
- 9:29of Paga, and this is one area they're seeking
- 9:31to regulate. They've been in a rule -making process.
- 9:34If you just search in your search engine for
- 9:37LWD, LWDA rulemaking, you can sort of see where
- 9:41it is in the process. But under the proposed
- 9:44regulations, the notice is supposed to avoid
- 9:47conclusory statements, general or vague allegations,
- 9:51or statements just merely summarizing the law.
- 9:54So coming into more of the giving, this is what
- 9:57we've been seeing when they get kicked back,
- 9:59what they're getting kicked back for, and this
- 10:00will be in the regulations. Judge Weiner? Yeah,
- 10:04no, it looks and and they're going to create
- 10:05their own form and it's going to be very detailed
- 10:08So it's going to walk you through being sure
- 10:10that you've got the details of your pre litigation
- 10:12notice All right. Um, so class versus representative
- 10:17case So if you're doing a pogger representative
- 10:21case, you're basically doing it on behalf of
- 10:24the state to protect the rights of employees.
- 10:28So you don't have to go through class certification.
- 10:31You don't have to send a class notice. There
- 10:33isn't an opportunity for the employees to opt
- 10:35out. Technically there's no typicality requirement
- 10:41so you can bring in other job descriptions than
- 10:45the plaintiffs as long as they're being subject
- 10:47to the same sort of violation. You only have
- 10:50to prove a violation. You don't have to prove
- 10:52that an employee suffered actual monetary loss
- 10:56or something like that. And it gives the opportunity
- 10:59under PAGA for an employee to sue to enforce
- 11:04labor laws that there otherwise would be no private
- 11:08right of action. Under the statute, there's a
- 11:12right to recover fees and costs if you're a prevailing
- 11:16plaintiff, which we'll talk about more later.
- 11:18And if there's an arbitration clause, the representative
- 11:25aspect of the case cannot be forced arbitration
- 11:28and it cannot be waived by an employee because
- 11:32it is the rights of the state. Now, what's kind
- 11:35of the difference if you're doing a class action
- 11:37under the labor law? Well, under a class action,
- 11:40you'd be suing for monetary damages under those
- 11:43claims under which there'd be a private right
- 11:44of action. And you don't have to share the money
- 11:47because under PAGA, 65 % and it used to be 75
- 11:51% of the recovery goes to the state and only
- 11:5535 % Previously, 25 % goes to the employees,
- 12:00which is only shared by employees pro rata. So,
- 12:04in a class action, you might have a named plaintiff
- 12:07and they get an incentive award and they get
- 12:09their damages and everything. In a Paga case,
- 12:12Paga only provides for the class representative
- 12:14to get just whatever is their pro rata share.
- 12:18to participate. And if you're going to do fees
- 12:21and costs in a class action, it's done as a common
- 12:25fund pool. So normally lawyers ask for a percentage,
- 12:28as we'll discuss more later. Under PAGA, there's
- 12:32just the right to reasonable attorney's fees
- 12:34and costs, which is kind of a lodestar concept.
- 12:39Okay. All right, so the scope of the claims,
- 12:45as we've discussed before, the representative
- 12:48now must have suffered the alleged violation
- 12:51under new Paga. And so I think the tendency,
- 12:54though, is to file what I would. call overly
- 13:00broad Paga notices that include every potential
- 13:03violation out of a concern, that you may uncover
- 13:06facts during discovery that support other claims,
- 13:10and also keep in mind, under the current case
- 13:14law, you can't release violations that aren't
- 13:17pled in your complaint or contained in your Paga
- 13:20notice, so you're limited to what's in your Paga
- 13:23notice. I try to advocate for keeping the scope
- 13:27relatively narrow. For example, in a recent suitable
- 13:31seating case I filed with a Paga claim, I filed
- 13:38it just on behalf of the specific store location
- 13:41where my client worked. So think about that.
- 13:48And don't sleep on also seeking injunctive relief.
- 13:52Injunctive relief is now part of new PAGA. It
- 13:55wasn't part of old PAGA. So now your scope of
- 13:58your claims that you can seek are not just for
- 14:00the civil penalties, but also seeking changes
- 14:03to the workplace. And then also we'll talk about
- 14:07this more, but a court can limit the scope of
- 14:11the claims presented to ensure cases can be managed
- 14:14effectively under new Paga. And I think that
- 14:17comes from the holding of a case interpreting
- 14:21old Paga Estrada that was written into new Paga
- 14:25labor code 2699 subsection P. So be aware that
- 14:31you may broadly define who your aggrieved employees
- 14:35are. But as the court works with you on managing
- 14:41discovery and managing the trial plan, you may
- 14:44find yourself with the court does have the power
- 14:49to limit the scope. Corey, do you have thoughts
- 14:53on scope? Well, it goes back to the notice, right?
- 14:58They're hand in hand. From the defense perspective,
- 15:03I would say just from an objective perspective,
- 15:07if the alleged violations are broad, that can
- 15:15benefit the employer in some ways if you're talking
- 15:18about settlement negotiations. If you're going
- 15:22to pay for a release and you can show during
- 15:25negotiations that some of the claims lack merit,
- 15:28you don't assign great value to them, you may
- 15:32still be able to get a release of those claims
- 15:34because they're pled. Conversely, if it's a very
- 15:40narrow claim and there's risk, you pay to settle,
- 15:44but you get a very narrow settlement release.
- 15:48I think from the plaintiff's perspective, the
- 15:51concern I would have if I was prosecuting a pocket
- 15:54claim and I was... either new or strongly believe
- 16:01that there are expense reimbursement violations.
- 16:06And from what I've seen, what I know, I'm going
- 16:08to win on that claim. And I think that there's
- 16:13probably break claims too. I don't know. Whatever
- 16:15the process is, a plaintiff might have. So you
- 16:18include a variety of other claims and you prosecute
- 16:22broadly. Well, the problem I would have is By
- 16:28the time you win on your expense reimbursement
- 16:30claim, you will have litigated potentially a
- 16:33bunch of other claims that maybe lack merit.
- 16:36Then when it comes time to seek your attorney's
- 16:38fees, you might find that you're not going to
- 16:40get the recovery you hoped for because you litigated
- 16:44claims that ultimately lacked merit. I just think
- 16:46it's important to be mindful about what you want
- 16:49to achieve with the case at the outset. And I'll
- 16:53just highlight that under the proposed new regulations,
- 16:57when you settle a case, if something isn't contained
- 17:00in your notice, you can't immediately amend your
- 17:04notice to add new claims that you want to release.
- 17:09There's going to be a demonstration you're going
- 17:12to have to make that you actually investigated
- 17:14and litigated those new claims that you want
- 17:17to add for settlement purposes. Sorry, I just
- 17:19wanted to highlight that. All right, great. So,
- 17:24Corey, without getting into excruciating details,
- 17:27just highlight what happens if there's an arbitration
- 17:29clause. Yeah, essentially, the U .S. Supreme
- 17:35Court held that the FAA allows parties to an
- 17:39arbitration agreement to agree to require arbitration
- 17:45of the individual component of a Paga claim.
- 17:49the individual component being the Paga plaintiffs
- 17:53claim that they personally suffered violations.
- 17:58The US Supreme Court went on to opine about what
- 18:02should happen with the non -individual portion
- 18:04of the Paga claim. The allegation that other
- 18:07people experienced violations. But ultimately
- 18:10the California Supreme Court came in and cleared
- 18:12up that issue saying that Essentially, when there's
- 18:16an arbitration agreement requiring arbitration
- 18:18of the individual component of a Paga claim,
- 18:22the representative portion of the claim remains
- 18:24in court, while the individual portion of the
- 18:26claim goes to arbitration, and that the matter
- 18:32in arbitration or the issue in arbitration and
- 18:34the representative claims that remain in court
- 18:37remain part of the same action. So it's still
- 18:40one action that's essentially bifurcated into
- 18:42two different venues. And so it's more of a bifurcation
- 18:50than a severance, creating two separate actions.
- 18:54So the employee who's been compelled to arbitrate
- 18:56the individual portion of the claim doesn't lose
- 18:59standing to maintain the representative portion.
- 19:04After that decision, the next issue that's come
- 19:08up, which is on the next slide, is, well, you
- 19:12know, can the plaintiff who... Next slide. Thank
- 19:17you. Can the plaintiff who has an arbitration
- 19:20agreement forego the prosecution of that individual
- 19:25component of the Paga claim in some manner that
- 19:29would allow them to circumvent the arbitration
- 19:31agreement, avoid arbitration, and directly prosecute
- 19:36the representative portion of the claim in court?
- 19:39And that's an issue that the... California Supreme
- 19:42Court will likely soon address, I would expect,
- 19:47a decision early next year, perhaps in the summer,
- 19:52in the Liepard v. Ship case. And the questions
- 19:55presented are here on the slide. The first being,
- 19:59does APAGA claim necessarily include individual
- 20:02or non -individual components? And can a plaintiff
- 20:07choose only to bring that non -individual Paga
- 20:11claim solely on behalf of others. And I think
- 20:16the plaintiff's side of the argument, they characterize
- 20:18it as, well, the plaintiff is alleging that they
- 20:22suffered violations, but they're not seeking
- 20:24to recover any civil penalties for those violations.
- 20:27So there's no individual claim to arbitrate.
- 20:33And I think the defendant, the employer side
- 20:36of the argument is a Paga claim doesn't necessarily
- 20:41have individual and non -individual components.
- 20:44It's the FAA and the arbitration agreement under
- 20:47the FAA that allows parties to agree to bifurcate
- 20:52into individual and non -individual components.
- 20:56So an employee can't just choose to bifurcate
- 21:00it on their own. It's only bifurcated because
- 21:04of the arbitration agreement. And then on the
- 21:07second issue, the employer's argument or one
- 21:10of them at least, is Paga doesn't allow the parties
- 21:14to decide what civil penalties are recovered.
- 21:18It's the court's job to assess civil penalties.
- 21:22And the state's interest is not in picking and
- 21:26choosing on which agreed employees it'll recover
- 21:30civil penalties on behalf of. So it's an interesting
- 21:33issue. And as I mentioned, I expect a decision
- 21:37on it within the next 12 months. And I think
- 21:40that this sort of arose because I think the default
- 21:42for a lot of judges, and Judge Weiner, I don't
- 21:45know if you were still on the bench when this
- 21:47issue was coming up, but they've been staying
- 21:51the representative portion while the individual
- 21:54arbitration goes forward. But I've recently seen
- 21:57judges pushing back and not staying the representative
- 22:01portion just because courts today are so backlogged
- 22:05that if you let a case go through the individual
- 22:09arbitration, which is going to take one to two
- 22:11years, one year if you're super lucky, but two
- 22:14years realistically, and then you're going back
- 22:16to court, most cases Most cases today are not
- 22:20getting tried until the five -year rule comes
- 22:24up. So then you're six to seven years into a
- 22:28case when a lot of your witnesses' memories have
- 22:32faded, documents have been lost. So I've seen
- 22:34some judges say, no, I'm not going to stay the
- 22:37representative portion. And I think that's sort
- 22:40of where this issue in Lieber versus Shipp. I've
- 22:42never done this, but why it came up was because
- 22:45of this delay. As a judge, I didn't like to stay
- 22:54the cases. I wanted to keep them moving for that
- 22:57very reason. So I wanted to keep them moving
- 23:00because I didn't want to have some five -year
- 23:01thing dumped on me at the end. Other judges are
- 23:04like, hey, if I can stay a case and I've got
- 23:07plenty else to do, that that's what I'm going
- 23:09to do. So it really does depend on the approach
- 23:12that your judge wants to take. I like to move
- 23:15cases. That's how you get them to settle if you
- 23:17move cases. Other other people just want it off
- 23:21the plate. Okay, well, we need to move on to
- 23:23the concept of settlement. So, um, all. Yeah,
- 23:29I'm going to briefly run through the cure conference
- 23:32that. We ready for that? No, well, just give
- 23:34me one second. Oh, sorry. Sorry. Yeah. Yeah.
- 23:37So just so everybody knows, all PAGA settlements
- 23:40have to receive court approval. So that's normally
- 23:42done by doing a motion for PAGA representative
- 23:46settlement approval. The notice has to be given
- 23:48to the LWDA by their electronic. Online filing
- 23:55and if it's approved, you have to send the dismissal
- 23:58or the judgment to the LWDA. They're presently
- 24:02working on regulations to even get more precise
- 24:05about what it is you need to send to them. All
- 24:07right, go ahead. Yeah, no, and it's an important
- 24:09reminder that. steps along the way in your civil
- 24:13litigation, you are required to be submitting
- 24:15documents like a conformed complaint through
- 24:18the Paga portal. So don't forget those. Next
- 24:23slide. Next slide. I'm going to briefly talk
- 24:26about the Cure Conference. So this is something
- 24:27that happens pre -litigation during that notice
- 24:30period. And this only applies to employers with
- 24:34less than 100 employees. And again, this is a
- 24:37new Paga development. expedited process through
- 24:41the LWDA, where the employer can submit a confidential
- 24:47cure proposal to the LWDA within 33 days of receiving
- 24:52a PAGA notice. And then the procedure is set
- 24:56forward in the statute for how it goes, but it
- 25:01is an expedited procedure. I can say that my
- 25:03partner, Xuxi Hui, participated in one of these
- 25:06last year, and it was extremely efficient and
- 25:09effective. The LWBDA is doing a good job handling
- 25:12these. So if you're representing an employer
- 25:15with less than 100 employees, you might look
- 25:18into using this cure process. Oh, and I forgot
- 25:23to mention, if anyone out there has a question,
- 25:26you can certainly put it in the chat and we will
- 25:28try to get to the questions during our presentation,
- 25:31most likely at the end. All right, Corey, have
- 25:37you done the pre -litigation cure or are your
- 25:40clients more than 100 people? Yeah, I have not.
- 25:43It's 100 employees anywhere in the country. first
- 25:48of all, it's not just California. And it's 100
- 25:51employees, regardless of their status, part time,
- 25:56seasonal, intermittent. And again, 100 within
- 26:00the year proceeding to Paganotis, essentially.
- 26:06So I think employers that might employ fewer
- 26:12people on a day to day basis, those are also
- 26:15employers that tend to have high turnover. or
- 26:18sees all employees. So when you see small employer,
- 26:24you know, CURE conference, it is a very small
- 26:26employer. All right. So the statute also has
- 26:31been revised to provide the opportunity for early
- 26:36evaluation to see if the case can resolve early.
- 26:39If you'd move to the next slide, please. So it's
- 26:43as of October 1, 2024, but I say new. because
- 26:48it's new for people to really be using. This
- 26:51is if an employer has more than 100 employees
- 26:54during the relevant time period, then the defendant
- 26:58employer can file a demand asking for a neutral
- 27:02early evaluation of the case and have a temporary
- 27:05stay of the lawsuit. So the employer requests
- 27:09this, has to be filed before or with the initial
- 27:14appearance or the first response to the complaint.
- 27:19The court then issues a stay of the case and
- 27:24sends it to mandatory early evaluation. It has
- 27:29to be within 70 days. It requires the defendant
- 27:33submit confidential information Specifically,
- 27:37are there any violations that the employer plans
- 27:40to cure and how they plan to cure it? And then
- 27:43what are the facts and evidence that the employer
- 27:46says about the allegations made as to the violations?
- 27:52That has to be done within 21 days of when it's
- 27:55submitted to the neutral. The plaintiff employee
- 27:58then, 21 days later, submits any response about
- 28:02the plan and also has to present evidence of
- 28:06the factual basis for each violation, calculation
- 28:10and the amount of the civil penalties for each
- 28:13violation, the amount of attorney's fees and
- 28:15costs to date, any demand for settlement, etc.
- 28:19So then the early evaluation is to be conducted
- 28:22by a judge or a commissioner or somebody experienced
- 28:25in the field. And this has to be concluded within
- 28:3030 days. And if there's a cure plan, then the
- 28:36neutral decides whether or not that cure plan
- 28:38should be adopted. The employer has to show within
- 28:4110 days that it was done on and on. So how are
- 28:47courts dealing with this? Normally they are sending
- 28:51it to the existing ADR division of their court
- 28:55to go through the usual processes, although it
- 28:58has to be done within a specific time period.
- 29:01If you'd go to the next slide for me, please.
- 29:04And some courts don't even have this rolling.
- 29:09I mean, it's just not happening. So the statute
- 29:12also provides that the parties are welcome to
- 29:17stipulate to a mediation and pick their own mediator
- 29:21and agree to move forward with all of this, which
- 29:26does help the process along. It's see whether
- 29:29you can resolve the case. This is the sort of
- 29:32detail you're going to use in an remediation
- 29:34anyway. But if the case is stayed, how am I supposed
- 29:37to get this? So parties might agree that they're
- 29:43going to do early swap of discovery in order
- 29:46to know how many employees are there and what
- 29:49is the situation here? How are you going to get
- 29:52the data for calculating all this if you don't
- 29:54have any pretrial discovery? It's to the benefit
- 30:00of both sides to try and cooperate to see if
- 30:03it can be resolved early, which actually a lot
- 30:05of pocket cases did resolve early before this
- 30:08was even created. Jen, what's your experience
- 30:12in regard to discovery or this process? I have
- 30:16not seen it used. I litigate mostly in the LA
- 30:19Superior Court, where it's important to understand
- 30:21that Paga cases don't go to the complex department.
- 30:25They go to the individual judges, usually at
- 30:28mosque. And there's no, first of all, LA Superior
- 30:32Court really doesn't have an official ADR program.
- 30:37They've done away with settlement, settlement
- 30:40conference judges. So I haven't seen this being
- 30:46used. I mean, mostly in our cases, I don't know
- 30:48if Corey has a different experience, but We're
- 30:52just agreeing to early mediation and not using
- 30:55this process. So I don't know, Corey, have you
- 30:59used this? Or has someone using it? Yeah. Some
- 31:04colleagues have used it. I think the nature of
- 31:08the claims and also the employer's evaluation
- 31:10of the claims is critical. There are some limited
- 31:15scenarios where this might make the most sense.
- 31:19with respect to the information that might be
- 31:24needed. I think it's important to take a step
- 31:26back. This is an employer -initiated evaluation.
- 31:30So the employer is electing to do this and must
- 31:32do so when or before it makes its first appearance.
- 31:38And employers, they don't have insurance for
- 31:41these claims. They're paying their attorneys
- 31:42by the hour. If they're using their money on
- 31:44this, that should be for good reason. They should
- 31:47be putting their best foot forward. Otherwise,
- 31:50it's just a waste of time. If they just plan
- 31:52on submitting a, you know, cure or evaluate,
- 31:56I guess, a confidential statement about how they're
- 31:58going to fix things and evaluating the claims
- 32:00without supporting evidence, it's not going to
- 32:02go anywhere. It's going to be a waste of time
- 32:04and money. So if I'm on the plaintiff's side,
- 32:07I wouldn't anticipate a lack of information.
- 32:11And if you are confronted with a lack of information
- 32:13in an employer's confidential statement, then
- 32:18you can just say that in your opposition. I'm
- 32:20sure that your argument is going to carry the
- 32:22day because the pay period data, the timekeeping
- 32:26data, that's all in the employer's possession.
- 32:30I think Jennifer made a remark about it depends
- 32:33on your court. In San Mateo, we had a very robust
- 32:36ADR division and the local rules specifically
- 32:42state that Paga cases are complex. I thought
- 32:47it was interesting, the California Supreme Court
- 32:49in Estrada said at least three times that Paga
- 32:52cases are complex. So treating them as non -complex
- 32:57as a calendaring concept doesn't really take
- 33:02into account now having to do this or have this
- 33:07opportunity for people to resolve these cases
- 33:09early. All right, moving on. We need to move
- 33:12on. Next slide. Next slide. All right. So I'm
- 33:18going to briefly talk about financial hardship.
- 33:23We're going to talk about the factors for assessing
- 33:25penalties and APAGA action later. But remember,
- 33:29in the context of settlement, that when you are
- 33:32plaintiff's counsel, you need to get out ahead
- 33:34of this issue early to ask the defendant if they're
- 33:39going to intend to argue. financial hardship.
- 33:43Because if you are going to enter into any type
- 33:46of negotiation, you need to fact -dive that in
- 33:49and also have documents from the defendant to
- 33:53back that up. Because when you go before the
- 33:56court and you're asking for the court to approve
- 33:59your settlement, you need to be able to explain
- 34:03the amount of penalties that you're, the amount
- 34:06of the penalties you're asking be assessed. And
- 34:10so you need to be able to competently represent
- 34:13to the court that you have, in fact, reviewed
- 34:16financials and that you feel confident that it
- 34:20should be taken into account. I don't consider
- 34:23tax returns to be enough. I think tax returns
- 34:27are meant to show as little profit as possible.
- 34:31So work with your accountant to create a list
- 34:35of documents you should request. if the employer
- 34:38is gonna rely on financial hardship in assessing
- 34:42the Paga penalties and in the settlement negotiations.
- 34:48Yeah, I'm just a quick note on this. It's important
- 34:50to look at the financial hardship issue as a
- 34:53spectrum. And there is this middle ground where
- 34:57you have employers who generate revenue directly
- 35:01from labor, the security industry. If you have
- 35:07a small security company, the revenue is an hourly
- 35:13rate from the client who's paying for the security
- 35:17guard. So a company like that might have enough,
- 35:23I'd say, gross profit when you account for the
- 35:29revenue less labor costs and only labor costs.
- 35:35to fund litigation, to defend itself generally
- 35:37on a month -on -month basis. But if that is a
- 35:41heavy litigation, that company is not going to
- 35:45be developing reserves to pay for itself. There
- 35:48are a lot of businesses like that, especially
- 35:50in California, where the revenue is directly
- 35:53tied to each hour of labor provided. And those
- 35:58are really tricky cases when it comes to financial
- 36:00hardship. I find that the clients in that position
- 36:02are often capable of defending themselves, but
- 36:06while doing so, any reserves to pay for a settlement
- 36:10are not accruing. So I think that's an important
- 36:13distinction. There's not really financial hardship,
- 36:16like we can't pay to defend ourselves, but we
- 36:19can't pay to defend ourselves and pay a significant
- 36:21settlement or judgment. And the way these cases
- 36:24end up getting valued because of the alleged
- 36:26continuing violations, the value of a settlement
- 36:30grows as time goes on. So I think both sides
- 36:33can be very cautious about that issue and address
- 36:37that early on. So you don't litigate for nothing.
- 36:41And generally, insurance in this area might only
- 36:44cover the cost of defense that I've seen. It's
- 36:48never going to cover the claims in a wage case,
- 36:51in a Paga case. So we need to keep moving. So
- 36:59size of the Paga group when it comes to settlement.
- 37:01more often than not, I want to talk about when
- 37:04courts review a proposed settlement, they will
- 37:06most often turn to how many employees are covered
- 37:10by the agreement and how many pay periods did
- 37:12they work? What's the value of the settlement
- 37:15per pay period? It's a easy way to kind of test
- 37:19it against other cases that have been settled.
- 37:25And so the size of the Pogger group, meaning
- 37:28the employees, is certainly less critical than
- 37:32the number of pay periods that would be covered
- 37:34by the release. That's really the only aspect
- 37:39to consider, I think, when it comes to the size
- 37:41of the group. Right. And Jen, if you're in settlement
- 37:47on fees and costs. So remember, this isn't a
- 37:51class action. There's an argument to be made
- 37:55that you're creating a common fund. But on purely
- 37:58PAGA actions, I generally have negotiated my
- 38:01fees and costs after resolving the civil penalties.
- 38:05Sometimes we just sort of write into it that
- 38:07we'll file an application for fees and costs
- 38:09and then you end up settling them. So you're
- 38:13entitled under the statute to reasonable attorney's
- 38:16fees in addition to the settlement and in addition
- 38:20to the civil penalties. So, you know, make sure
- 38:25that you're keeping track of the hours that you
- 38:27work and then do an assessment of whether or
- 38:30not you think that you're creating enough of
- 38:34a common fund. But remember, you can't take money
- 38:36from the state. So you'd only be taking from
- 38:40the common fund that you're creating is the 25
- 38:44or 35 % of the fund that is going to the workers.
- 38:49So that's why we usually just negotiate our reasonable
- 38:52load star rather than using common fund here.
- 38:57And I've seen it both ways. It's best if they
- 39:00negotiate the fees and costs ahead of time and
- 39:02then it's done. But I have had it where they
- 39:05agree on the penalties, but then they have like
- 39:07a mini trial. on reasonableness of fees and costs
- 39:11and have the judge decide on that. So I've seen
- 39:14that both ways. So let's move on to what happens
- 39:18at trial. So you get a court trial, not a jury
- 39:24trial, when it comes to Paga claims, because
- 39:26it's a statutory right, not based on common law,
- 39:29and not seeking damages. So what you're going
- 39:31to get is a court trial. When I did trials We
- 39:40did it in phases So and it can you can slice
- 39:44this bread any any different way you need for
- 39:46the needs of your case? so I would generally
- 39:50have a phase one court trial about the aggrieved
- 39:54plaintiff, you know, are they aggrieved in the
- 39:56first place and what are those violations? Because
- 39:59sometimes they'll have 10 violations and you
- 40:02find out that the plaintiff was only subjected
- 40:04to five of them or something like that. So you're
- 40:06narrowing the field of the cost and expense of
- 40:09the trial full -blown on everything. If you do
- 40:13it in phases and you're going to have the same
- 40:16adjudicator, you don't have a jury. They got
- 40:17to hang on to so you can take advantage of that.
- 40:19You can also stipulate under 437 C subdivision
- 40:23T as in Tom to have a summary adjudication of
- 40:28issues like aggrieved and which are the violations
- 40:31and again streamlining it. On the other hand,
- 40:33some people say I got to present the same thing
- 40:35anyway, so I may as well just tee it up at trial.
- 40:37So then you would move on to phase two. Okay,
- 40:40you know your plaintiff, you know what violations
- 40:41they were subjected to. Now you figure out how
- 40:45broad is this, what other types of employees
- 40:48had this, or what was the time period, or was
- 40:51it just one store and not the whole state of
- 40:53California. You're figuring out what is really
- 40:58the extent of this, or sometimes you do it based
- 41:02upon the type of violation. So you might have
- 41:06multiple violations, but one factually is a group
- 41:09like meal and rest breaks versus a violation
- 41:16for requiring the employees to say that they
- 41:18won't disclose their wage and benefits or something
- 41:23like that. That there are different factual scenarios
- 41:26and they might do one and then a different one.
- 41:30because of evidence, different witnesses, that
- 41:32sort of thing. And then sometimes it's a phase
- 41:34three. If you got through that and you showed
- 41:36violations and the extent of it, or maybe it
- 41:40windowed down, again, not all the violations
- 41:43were out there. It was only that one plaintiff
- 41:45and it was basically not anybody else. Then you
- 41:47can do a phase three. That's the calculation
- 41:51of the civil penalties, the award of fees. There's
- 41:56a lot of different ways to approach this, but
- 41:58that's what you can kind of expect at trial.
- 42:03Council, what were your kind of experiences in
- 42:06a nutshell? I've seen them generally phased that
- 42:09way, not necessarily the first phase of determining
- 42:12whether or not they're a grieved employee. What
- 42:15I've seen is, you know, a grieved employee may
- 42:20also have brought their individual labor code
- 42:23claims. And so when my firm handled a case, the
- 42:27way the judge phased it was we did the first
- 42:29trial on their individual labor code claims.
- 42:33And then after prevailing at that, then we were
- 42:36moving on to the Paga phase. And that's when
- 42:39the case settled because you've already it's
- 42:41almost like doing, you know, an old fashioned
- 42:44the words flowing out. flown out of my head,
- 42:50but you're sort of doing a test case first. And
- 42:53then that's going to sort of lead to settlement,
- 42:56generally. Thoughts, Corey? Well, it's the same.
- 43:01Same. Like we'll discuss here with respect to
- 43:04discovery, you know, how the trial will be conducted,
- 43:08any sequencing or bifurcation will very much
- 43:11depend on the claims alleged. The nature of the
- 43:14claims, whether they're There are individual
- 43:16claims in conjunction with the representative
- 43:18claims, like individual wage labor code claims,
- 43:21plus the Paga claim, or the nature of the Paga
- 43:24claim itself. If you have a wage and hour, if
- 43:29you have a Paga action as typical wage and hour
- 43:31claims and a suitable seating claim, those are
- 43:34going to be split. You don't need to hear from
- 43:36an ergonomics expert on suitable seating and
- 43:39also HR people, payroll people on pay data. It
- 43:43makes sense to spread those things out. And the
- 43:47same with discovery. What kind of discovery you'll
- 43:49use exhibits is very much going to depend on
- 43:51the nature of the claims. I will say that if
- 43:56your claims can be demonstrated by policies and
- 43:59procedures and supporting testimony, the plaintiff
- 44:02is in a very good position. If it is more granular
- 44:06and you're getting into data that reflects actual
- 44:11violations, sometimes, but not always. The court
- 44:17will likely entertain that, and it'll be used
- 44:19to demonstrate violations, but ultimately you
- 44:22might find that the court will say, I have discretion
- 44:24on issuing civil penalties here, and they'll
- 44:27find violations, and they'll say, you know, a
- 44:30couple bucks a pop. It won't be a $100 penalty.
- 44:34So when it comes to the discovery to use the
- 44:36prosecutor to claim and relatedly to defend it,
- 44:40the more individualized you're getting, The lower
- 44:43the civil penalties likely going to be. That
- 44:46that's my general assessment of it. All right,
- 44:51so what kind of witnesses. Would you present
- 44:55do you expect to present? Yeah, next slide. Okay,
- 45:00so so for we have the next slide please. All
- 45:07right, so talking about experts. You're going
- 45:12to need a statistician when you get to the damages
- 45:14phase, so employ them early. A good statistician
- 45:20and also a database expert can help you identify
- 45:25patterns in the data that you're looking at that
- 45:31can help you with liability issues. So don't
- 45:34wait to employ them until you're getting to the
- 45:37damages phase. Get them involved earlier. You
- 45:41know, we've tried to have policy and procedure
- 45:44experts testify at wage trials. And we found
- 45:47that courts generally are granting motions and
- 45:50lemonade on their testimony. So we try and get
- 45:52in a lot of that policy and procedure stuff through
- 45:55defendants, representatives, to sort of have
- 45:58them, you know, back door, get in what the laws
- 46:01and what the laws should be through those witnesses.
- 46:05You know, as Corey mentioned, when you're getting
- 46:06into something like suitable seating. You know,
- 46:10there are different types of cases that you're
- 46:13going to need experts on generally in wage and
- 46:17hour cases beyond the statistician. You don't.
- 46:21When it comes to lay witnesses, it's really going
- 46:24to, you know, depend on the nature of your case.
- 46:27But I just want to emphasize it's important because
- 46:30this is a bench trial to make sure that the judge
- 46:34on your case is connecting with the claims in
- 46:37a human way. and not just having dry testimony
- 46:42about these are the policies, these are the procedures,
- 46:45these are the violations. You really want your
- 46:47lay witnesses to actually describe the workplace,
- 46:51talk about what a typical shift is like, to really
- 46:54give... you know, we can forget to sort of humanize
- 46:58wage and hour cases. And I think that's important
- 47:01through the lay witnesses. Remember the cautionary
- 47:04language, though, I think it's an estrada about,
- 47:08you know, the employer doesn't have the right
- 47:09to call every single aggrieved employee to the
- 47:12stand to defend itself. So there's going to be
- 47:16some middle ground there in terms of how many
- 47:20lay witnesses. both sides are allowed to bring
- 47:23in. The court doesn't want to keep hearing the
- 47:25same thing over and over, but enough to sort
- 47:28of confirm that this is a, this policy and practice
- 47:32applied to your aggrieved employee group. Corey,
- 47:38anything to add on witnesses? No, nothing to
- 47:42add, but there is a question that I think is
- 47:44relevant here and it's directed towards you Judge
- 47:46Weiner. Yeah. I'm going to summarize it. If An
- 47:51employer finds itself in a position where the
- 47:53plaintiff doesn't really have a trial plan. Just
- 47:56the plan is to present witnesses and there's
- 47:59no real indication about exactly how they're
- 48:01going to put on the witnesses or a clear, I guess,
- 48:08expectation about how the plaintiff attempts
- 48:10or plans to prosecute the claims of trial. What
- 48:14would you recommend in that case or what have
- 48:17you seen employers do? to try and get a trial
- 48:22plan? And to what extent does it matter to the
- 48:24court? I guess it depends on how involved your
- 48:29judge is in management. So some judges are kind
- 48:35of laissez -faire and whatever happens, happens.
- 48:38I try and get people to be pre -organized so
- 48:42that we move the case. So I have people have
- 48:45to present. Well, they've got to let each other
- 48:48know kind of The witnesses that they anticipate
- 48:51they have to meet and confer about all the trial
- 48:55exhibits. All the trial exhibits have to be presented
- 48:58ahead of time. I put in a rule that the who is
- 49:03ever presenting the next day has to tell. the
- 49:06other side, what witnesses they plan to present
- 49:09the next day so you know how to pack your litigation
- 49:12bag. But the issue was, and Estrada now helps
- 49:16because it used to be that the defense would
- 49:18say, we're just going to call every single person
- 49:20as our defense to show how individualized this
- 49:23is. And the court can now control that and control
- 49:26manageability. I also try and control the...
- 49:31the efficiency of the discovery in the first
- 49:33case so that we're not delving into this huge
- 49:36mountain of a mess where they're just throwing
- 49:39it up against the wall. So I think that a judge,
- 49:43and I certainly did, can manage what is going
- 49:46on. You want everybody be able to say that they
- 49:49got to present their case, but If it starts bogging
- 49:54down, you have the right to say, look, you know,
- 49:56that's enough on this and you need to finish
- 49:59up or something like that that can proactively
- 50:02work on that is my thought, or at least how I
- 50:05approach it. If there's any follow up question
- 50:10on that, feel free to put it in the chat and
- 50:12we'll address at the end. Thank you. So, remember,
- 50:16you don't get damages, you get monetary penalties.
- 50:20So, and it's divided with the state, they get
- 50:23the lion's share. The rest goes to the grieve
- 50:25employees who then you got to figure out how
- 50:27to distribute to them if you get a recovery.
- 50:30But there is no provision for the plaintiff to
- 50:34get anything other than their pro rata share
- 50:37of the penalties. You now also have to consider,
- 50:41is there a claim for injunctive relief and how
- 50:44is that going to be enforced? Did you award enhancements
- 50:50to Paga representatives when you were on the
- 50:51bench? I've seen it done differently. It depends
- 50:56on the nature of the case. A lot of times you
- 50:58won't have a pure Paga case. So I had seen ones
- 51:01where it was a class action on damages and then
- 51:04a Paga representative case. back in the Stone
- 51:06Ages of Paga. I've seen it where you have an
- 51:10individual case for the employee, like they might
- 51:15have a wrongful termination case. So they have
- 51:18their individual claims and then they'll also
- 51:19have their Paga claims, which you work it out
- 51:23that they're getting their money from their individual
- 51:26claims and not as a representative of Paga because
- 51:31that is cleaner. So no, I do not give incentive
- 51:35awards to the plaintiff. Sometimes they will
- 51:38ask for expenses of having been deposed and things
- 51:41like that. Sometimes you can work that out towards
- 51:45them for reimbursement, but normally it's done
- 51:48through the individual case. Or they get a waiver
- 51:52of their individual claims, and that's how you
- 51:55negotiate it. But in terms of awarding, I don't
- 51:58award it. Okay. So I'm going to talk about the
- 52:02calculation of penalties on the next slide. So
- 52:07remember old PAGA, 75 % went to the state, new
- 52:11PAGA, 65%. This is a pay period analysis for
- 52:18the pay periods within the statute of limitations.
- 52:21You got to know the initial violation rate. The
- 52:23default in PAGA is. $100 per pay period, but
- 52:28there are a lot of exceptions to that. So really
- 52:31study Paga and the labor code closely. Like for
- 52:34example, under labor code 558, you're looking
- 52:37at I think a $50 default initial penalty. And
- 52:42then there's for under new Paga, there are lower
- 52:46penalties for certain types of wage statement
- 52:49claims. What's been labeled as isolated. Violations
- 52:54were something sometimes, you know, there's a
- 52:57payroll. There's a mistake, right? That happens
- 52:59and it's an isolated event. Derivative penalties
- 53:04are limited under new Paga. Um, if you have,
- 53:09um, if you pay your employees weekly, that's
- 53:12considered the pay period. Um, and then, you
- 53:15know, there's also the, uh, voluntary cure process,
- 53:18um, after you receive the notice. Um, so there
- 53:21are ways that under new Paga that those penalties
- 53:25can be, um, limited the, the subsequent penalty.
- 53:31And there was a huge debate about this under
- 53:33old Paga and this is the way the case law fell
- 53:35out was. that you can only get the subsequent
- 53:39penalty in a statute. If you can show that the
- 53:42labor commissioner or court had made a finding
- 53:46that there was a prior violation. Now under new
- 53:50Paga, they've added in, if you can demonstrate
- 53:53malice, fraud or oppression, almost a punitive
- 53:55damages statute because. these penalties are,
- 53:59in effect, a punitive damage. So that's something
- 54:04that's new in PAGA that you may consider doing
- 54:08discovery on the malice, fraud, and oppression
- 54:11to see if you can get the subsequent penalties.
- 54:18Oh, and this slide sort of runs through the exceptions
- 54:23to the PAGA default that I was talking about.
- 54:27Yeah, so the trial court then has discretion.
- 54:32So the plaintiff comes in and they ask for all
- 54:34the maximums of everything. And then the issue
- 54:38is whether or not that should be the amount of
- 54:41the trial court has discretion to adjust penalties.
- 54:43You can't go higher than the maximum and you
- 54:46can't give zero, but you can go lesser. And as
- 54:51stated in the Tadurin case, there isn't a particular
- 54:56method provided in PAGA. So there's a lot of
- 54:59discretion for the court to adjust the penalties
- 55:03down actually in Tender and they adjusted it
- 55:09down to 1 % of what was the maximum and that
- 55:11was upheld on appeal. So you have to look at
- 55:16What's going on here? And Paga does say, though,
- 55:19that you can adjust it because if otherwise would
- 55:23be unjust, arbitrary, or confiscatory, as in
- 55:27confiscating. So you need to have that in the
- 55:31decision if you're going to be reducing it. Things
- 55:34to look at. Was the violation something egregious
- 55:38that really harmed, personally harmed the employees?
- 55:41They really lost money? Or is it just a technical
- 55:47violation. How pervasive was this? Was it just
- 55:51one store with one manager? Does it go beyond
- 55:54that? Did the company change their policy to
- 55:59try and fix this? Did they change their procedures
- 56:01immediately to try and fix this? Did they fix
- 56:03it during the course of the litigation? You look
- 56:06at the financial health of the employer. You're
- 56:08not helping these employees or the state if the
- 56:11penalties are gonna put somebody out of business
- 56:14and they're gonna lose their job. I mean, you
- 56:16have to weigh all of these things. Was the conduct
- 56:20intentional? Was this part of their corporate
- 56:23policy? Or was this an innocent thing that nobody
- 56:26really realized or once they realized that they
- 56:30fixed it? So this all goes into adjusting the
- 56:33penalties. I don't think I ever gave a maximum.
- 56:40Always weigh these sorts of things because otherwise
- 56:42the penalties just can be crazy exorbitant. And
- 56:45I'll do another plug for the article that Steve
- 56:48Pearl and jury Trotter and I wrote where we actually
- 56:51studied every Paga Award we could find and you're
- 56:56right. I don't think we ever saw a hundred percent
- 56:58awarded. Yeah. All right. We're low on time.
- 57:02So we're going to move on to attorneys fees awards.
- 57:05Yeah. Yeah. I'll just briefly say that you have
- 57:08a statutory right to reasonable attorneys fees
- 57:10and costs. It's a one way statute. You need to
- 57:14plan that you're going to seek a lodestar and
- 57:16keep contemporaneous records of the time that
- 57:20you're spending on the case. Of course you want
- 57:24to know what your judges, how they rule on attorney's
- 57:28fee motions, but judges change during the course
- 57:31of your case. Assume that they're going to want
- 57:33to see contemporaneous records. All right. And
- 57:36on allocation of fees, that's an issue in cases
- 57:41because Sometimes you'll start out with a whole
- 57:44bunch of violations and then it windows down
- 57:47during the course of the case. Either some of
- 57:49them were dismissed or thrown out because the
- 57:53plaintiff wasn't aggrieved on that. Or as a trial
- 57:57strategy, the lawyers reduce the number of claims
- 58:01that go to trial to keep it straightforward,
- 58:04simple, economical. But when it comes to a prevailing
- 58:09plaintiff and you went through the trial and
- 58:11you want your fees, The defense normally argues
- 58:14that they shouldn't get all of it and that there
- 58:16was unsuccessful claims and that that should
- 58:19be subtracted. It's up to the court about allocation,
- 58:27but the law supports the concept of if the dismissed
- 58:33claims are the same factual basis as the successful,
- 58:39and that that was the lion's share of the case,
- 58:41then you should be able to get all your hours,
- 58:43not have it parseced. If it was unsuccessful
- 58:46and it's a completely separate type of claim
- 58:49that has its own facts that just didn't make
- 58:52it, then that can be lopped off. And if a judge
- 58:56reduces what are the load star, it can be done
- 59:03by percentage, by employee, whatever, there's
- 59:05not. a specific case, although we did give to
- 59:09you the Gunther and Hensley test that was used,
- 59:13but is basically what I just said. That's what
- 59:15you look at. So we've come to the end of our
- 59:20time, but I believe we're willing to stay to
- 59:22answer any questions that people have. Yeah,
- 59:26there's one, I guess, a couple questions about
- 59:29the early neutral evaluation process. Okay, I
- 59:32guess we can take off the slides. And I think
- 59:39I've been thinking about it's been up there for
- 59:40a while. And I think just an analogy is a good
- 59:43way to kind of address the question. I think
- 59:47early neutral evaluation would be the perfect
- 59:49vehicle to resolve claims that are largely based
- 59:53off of a regular rate of pay issue. So let's
- 59:57say an employer has a quarterly or annual non
- 1:00:02discretionary bonus that's maybe something like
- 1:00:06a safety bonus, relatively small, maybe $100
- 1:00:08if there's no safety issue or something that
- 1:00:12affects. That payment is not going to tremendously
- 1:00:17affect the regular rate of pay. We're also assuming
- 1:00:23that the employer did not factor this bonus into
- 1:00:26the regular rate for purposes of overtime and
- 1:00:29meal and rest period premiums and whatnot. So
- 1:00:31there's an underpayment. But that $100 spread
- 1:00:36out over a quarter or a year has a very small
- 1:00:39impact on the regular rate of pay. It's likely
- 1:00:42going to be less than 50 cents per hour. In some
- 1:00:48cases, much less. So the underpayment will be
- 1:00:50nominal. We're not talking about overtime that
- 1:00:52wasn't paid at all. It was just paid slightly
- 1:00:55below what the regular rate of pay is when you
- 1:00:58factor in this $100. So when you're looking at
- 1:01:01a Paga claim where it's $100 per violation, but
- 1:01:05the underpayment could be one to 10 cents per
- 1:01:10pay period, something like that, this is a great
- 1:01:14issue to get resolved through an early evaluation
- 1:01:17conference. It's a technical issue that is evidenced
- 1:01:23and fixed through payroll mechanisms. readily
- 1:01:30show the issue with evidence, show how you fixed
- 1:01:32it with evidence, what the underpayment was with
- 1:01:35evidence. It's all math. And rather than litigate
- 1:01:39that aggressively, spend a bunch of money on
- 1:01:41attorney's fees, let the limitations period go
- 1:01:44on and on so more pay periods are at issue. So
- 1:01:47if you do go to mediation in a year and then
- 1:01:50come up with a settlement, there are twice as
- 1:01:53many pay periods at issue. By then, the employer
- 1:01:57might have the position of, look, the total underpayment
- 1:02:00is $10 ,000. But there have been 20 ,000 pay
- 1:02:03periods covered by the settlement. How are we
- 1:02:06going to get that approved? So in that case,
- 1:02:09the E &E makes a lot of sense. And if the employer
- 1:02:13does a good job of showing the issue, the resolution
- 1:02:16of the issue, the effect of the issue, i .e.
- 1:02:19the underpayments, how it's going to cure, then
- 1:02:23it seems unlikely that the neutral or the other
- 1:02:28side will really dispute it. And a proposal can
- 1:02:32be presented to the court for approval in the
- 1:02:36case. One of the questions was, is it just giving
- 1:02:41information to allow the other party to assess
- 1:02:44the claims? No, it can achieve final resolution
- 1:02:48of a claim. If the claims are typical meal and
- 1:02:53respirate claims, interrupted breaks, I'm not
- 1:02:57sure how you go through the E &E process to get
- 1:02:59that resolved. That sounds like a type of claim
- 1:03:03that would require testimony from the allegedly
- 1:03:07aggrieved employees. But on these tactical violations
- 1:03:10that can be resolved by looking at payroll data,
- 1:03:17time data, that's where you might want to use
- 1:03:21the E &E process, and you can achieve. final
- 1:03:24resolution of those types of problems. And I
- 1:03:28saw multiple times where the plaintiff firm had
- 1:03:37a disgruntled employee and they'd immediately
- 1:03:39file a pocket case without really investigating
- 1:03:42the employer. And then they'd find out, gee,
- 1:03:46they only had 20 employees, you know, and it
- 1:03:48just, it wasn't going to make economic sense
- 1:03:51to pursue this case. So early settlement was
- 1:03:57the way to go. Get them done and then the employer
- 1:04:00has the approval that the issue has been resolved.
- 1:04:06They can't go after them, that sort of thing,
- 1:04:08and just resolve it very quickly. So that's helpful.
- 1:04:11And you never know on wage and hour. I mean,
- 1:04:14I had cases where the meal break, rest break
- 1:04:19thing was because they set up this automatic
- 1:04:21computer system. So people were forced. There
- 1:04:25was no real time records and there was a presentation
- 1:04:28of there was no real time records. So there was
- 1:04:31a pattern practice that could be figured out
- 1:04:35early on to see if the case could be resolved
- 1:04:37in that regard. Jennifer, good question for you.
- 1:04:41I'm not sure if you've seen it, but financial
- 1:04:44hardship issues. I saw Lynn's question. Yeah.
- 1:04:47Yeah. So what do you think about that? Yeah.
- 1:04:50So listen, Every defendant is going to want to
- 1:04:53tell you they don't have the money, unless you're
- 1:04:55litigating against Google. When you're dealing
- 1:05:00with a publicly traded company, you can easily
- 1:05:03go and verify yourself. But if you can't do that,
- 1:05:08you have to be able to go to the court and say,
- 1:05:11I looked at evidence that there is a financial
- 1:05:15inability to pay. And so I don't accept, and
- 1:05:21I tell my mediators this, I don't just accept
- 1:05:23their word. In the build up to the mediation,
- 1:05:27when I send my things over that I want to see,
- 1:05:30you know, the payroll data, in order to build
- 1:05:33a damages model, I also give them a list of,
- 1:05:36if you want to talk about financial issues at
- 1:05:39the mediation, you also need to give me these
- 1:05:42documents to look at ahead of time. You know,
- 1:05:45and then when we get to the mediation, all of
- 1:05:47a sudden, they bring it up, I pull out the letter
- 1:05:49and I'm like, We were supposed to have dealt
- 1:05:51with this ahead of time. Leaving things to deal
- 1:05:54with the day of the mediation is just going to
- 1:05:56sink the mediation. So that's something that
- 1:05:58I would recommend mediators like Lynn, you know,
- 1:06:02make sure that the parties are exchanging and
- 1:06:04talking before the mediation so that you can
- 1:06:07have a successful mediation rather than having
- 1:06:10everything fall apart because there's just a
- 1:06:12blind allegation with nothing to back it up.
- 1:06:14I hope that that helps. I think if you're representing
- 1:06:17an employer, you should tell them early on, before
- 1:06:22the mediation. If you start talking about financial
- 1:06:25hardship, be very careful. It's like a term of
- 1:06:27art. It's a trigger. When you pull that trigger,
- 1:06:32the immediate response will be, show me your
- 1:06:35tax records, your bank records, et cetera. You
- 1:06:37don't save financial hardship or anything similar
- 1:06:39to it unless you are fully prepared to demonstrate
- 1:06:42financial hardship. Period. Full stop. Otherwise,
- 1:06:45we're wasting a bunch of time. And we're hurting
- 1:06:48our credibility and other things. So you have
- 1:06:51to be very cautious about those issues. And there
- 1:06:55are times when the demand is funny money demand,
- 1:07:0020 million. And it's like, our point isn't financial
- 1:07:04hardship. It's just, that's ridiculous. So the
- 1:07:07number's too high. And it's, yeah, max liability,
- 1:07:11100 % on every claim is 20 million. But we're
- 1:07:17here to settle. And as we discussed earlier,
- 1:07:20we're not aware of any case that has resulted
- 1:07:23in a full freight civil penalty. So you really
- 1:07:27have to be careful about the verbiage you use
- 1:07:29when you're representing employers and your clients
- 1:07:31as well. When we're talking to the mediator,
- 1:07:33if you bring up financial hardship in the context
- 1:07:36that we can't pay a typical settlement that's
- 1:07:41been fully negotiated, then you need to be fully
- 1:07:43prepared to provide those records. And you have
- 1:07:46to do it anyhow, because the court has to approve
- 1:07:50the Paga settlement. And if it's a lowball amount,
- 1:07:52then I have to be shown in the declaration that
- 1:07:56there really was a financial hardship and that
- 1:07:58the information was put out and they don't have
- 1:08:00insurance and blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. You
- 1:08:02can't just say, oh, financial hardship. Yeah,
- 1:08:05I mean, you really need to put on your punitive
- 1:08:07damages hat when you're thinking about civil
- 1:08:10penalties. And just like if you had a punitive
- 1:08:13damages phase, you could require them to bring
- 1:08:15in all their financial documents. The same thing
- 1:08:19goes with civil penalties, I think, you know,
- 1:08:22that you can require them to bring in their financials.
- 1:08:25Corey, any other questions we need to hit? No,
- 1:08:30I think that counts. All right. Well thank you
- 1:08:35everyone for coming to Practical Paga today.
- 1:08:38We hope you found it informative and we then
- 1:08:41again appreciate being invited by Beverly Hills
- 1:08:44Bar Association to present this today in conjunction
- 1:08:47with ADR services. So thank you all. Thanks for
- 1:08:50inviting us to be here. Thank you.