Latest / Markets to Menus by ArrowStream / Scarce Cattle, Smart Supply
Transcript
- speaker-0: For me, one of the first things that I tackled was inventory management. And I would say that that goes for any chain. I mean, if you can't have visibility into where your inventory is, how much inventory is coming in, what your sell price is, it's really hard to be successful, a really successful supply chain if you don't have that visibility. So to me, that was the most important tool that I needed to get up and running when I started at Nye. I think I tackled that within the first week 'cause I can't do my job well if I can't see where my inventory is, what the price of the product is going out, and managing that all within one system. speaker-1: Welcome back to Markets to Menus. I'm your host, David Maloney from Aerostream, and glad to have you with us today. Joining me once again today is John Goodwin, Senior Commodity Analyst here to break down the latest moves in the commodity markets, including the ripple effects of the Iran-US conflict and what's happening with the cattle supply. Then later in the episode, I sit down with Megan Posonado, Vice President of Supply Chain and Quality Assurance at NIA. One of the most authentic emerging restaurant brands on the scene today. Megan and I dig into supply chain best practices across the industry with a special focus on what it takes to build and scale an emerging brand the right way. This episode, as always, is brought to you by Aerostream Commodity One, providing customized commodity research, forecasts, and consulting to help you drive value in your own supply chain. Now let's get into it. So the AeroStream commodity index last week was a little firmer, but still down pretty hard year on year. And we're seeing that some reflected in the Aerostream food price index, where across our network, the index is actually tracking kind of flattish to down a little bit versus 2025. In the commodity markets last week, grain markets were mixed. We're having a great start to the summer row crops. And that's good news because we had a historically poor winter wheat crop, as most of you know. And what we're keeping an eye on also is look at soybean oil, flirting with that 70 cent a pound support level, which a move through there would be good news. And we're seeing that in the deferred futures. And the dairy markets continue to be very soft, as we talked about a couple of weeks ago. Largest milk cow herd we've seen since 1993, which is fueling strong milk and dairy product production. To give you some perspective, We're likely to have the second lowest CME cheese block average for June in the past decade. In pork, prices have kind of been erratic, where we've seen some weakness in butts being offset by some increase in the belly markets. The cutout is down roughly 1% in the last month. So really hasn't gotten as seasonal gains going yet as a whole. But pork bellies are up 10% during that same time period. And that's important because pork bellies will drive your bacon prices. And the chicken markets, much like dairy soft, where overproduction is really causing some of these markets to move counter-seasonal. Again, to give you perspective, chicken wings are almost certainly going to have their least expensive June average price here in well over a decade. And the beef markets, news flash, cattle supplies are tight, beef supplies are tight, but the USDA choice and select. Cutouts or index of the choice beef and select beef haven't kind of flatish as of late. And we've seen the inflation versus a year ago temper some. Now, you remember a couple of weeks ago we talked about ribs providing a value. We've seen some strength in the last couple of weeks in the rib markets. In the beef trim markets, again, this is important because it goes into hamburger, which is a major exposure for the food service and retail supply chain. Softer last week, which is good news, but Again, don't let that fool you, still historically high at near record levels. In the fuel markets, gasoline, 11 week lows again. So that's good news. But just to give you perspective, we're still well over a dollar higher than where the where we were before the Iran-US conflict started. And then diesel, similar story, 13 week lows, but we're a full dollar fifty higher than where that conflict started. All right. So speaking of the Iran-US conflict, we had a memorandum of understanding signed last week. And there were talks amongst the two sides in Switzerland over the weekend. So encouraging news. Strait was open, conflicting news that the strait is open or has been closed over the weekend. Well, I just mentioned fuel prices have softened as of late, but the impact on fuel markets may not be as, let's say, abrupt. as we had on the way up. Is that fair, John? speaker-2: Yeah. Yeah, the domestic side of things with much lower imports than we're used to for this time of year and you know, near record or even record at one point exports regardless of the time of year. Those two things together really took a toll on the domestic balance sheets, especially as we got closer to the summer driving season that we're in now. And you know, we have another three months of summer driving ahead, another three months of higher refinery runs, higher crude going into refineries. So we really need to get those imports and exports back on track until that happens. We're not returning to our pre March norms anytime soon. speaker-1: And stocks are pretty tight too, right? speaker-2: Yeah. For this time of year, yeah. You know, like I said, with three months of summer driving ahead you'd like to s have a looser balance sheet than you do right now. speaker-1: Yeah, well, beef buyers would certainly like to have a looser balance sheet. We got some information around the cattle supply last week. Before that, screw worm pretty much kept at bay. We talked about that a couple weeks ago. So far, good news there. We got the cattle on feed inventory report from the USDA last week, and that's as of June one. And just to give you some background. Cattle are typically placed on feed for roughly 150 days before being sent to slaughter. And this is what we're talking about the box beef, as I referenced earlier, the choice beef index and the select beef index. So, anyways, at June 1, cattle on feed inventory was 2.1 bigger than a year ago. So certainly good news. And the largest for the date since 2022. Now, this is cattle are backing up in the feed lots, and we've talked to as our Talked about that quite a bit as our clients know. But before we get too excited here, we're reminded that the overall cattle supply is very tight. So cattle placements into feedlots in May were down 9.7% year on year. And the lowest for the date, get this, and John and I were just talking about this offline. My kids played a video game named Minecraft. And according to John, who is our commodity one video game expert. Between the two of us, Minecraft is the most popular video game of all time. Debuted in May 2009. That is the last time that we had smaller cattle placements in the feedlots during May. So again, cattle supplies, folks, are historically very tight. Now we talked a couple weeks ago about the El Nino forecasted to develop here this spring or summer. And guess what? Last week it was officially confirmed that we got that El Nino. Now Not that it has this recent weather issues in Brazil necessarily would be El Nino impacted, but we have had some weather issues that John we think are pretty important, right? speaker-2: Yeah, I mean the timing is a little bit a little coincidental and you know, linking El Nino to these weather events is not an exact science as far as I know. But I have seen people throw around this could be like the ⁓ early impacts of El Nino. But you're right, southern Brazil, we're about a month or two into their dry season at this point, and they've seen pretty substantial rainfall, especially the further south you go, the heavier the rainfall totals have gotten. And that's led to a number of issues that I think have already shown up on the coffee futures boards already kind of impacting coffee prices. ⁓ you've seen Aribica coffee market get its best shot in the arm in months, maybe even year to date, because of the rainfall, because of the harvest delays and disease pressures, all the different ways that rainfall during the dry season can screw up Brazil's coffee crop. And then I think something that hasn't really showed up on the futures board yet is the way that it can affect sugar. So I mean sugar's stuck in a multi month or maybe not a multi month, but you know, it's stuck in reverse right now. It's following crude oil lower because of the link between the two. A higher crude oil tends to raise ethanol demand in Brazil, hence less sugar going to sugar I mean less sugar cane going to sugar production, more going to ethanol production. So there is that link there. I don't wanna undersell just how bearish crude oil sell-off is for sugar. But like I said, the further south you go, the more rainfall there is. And the big sugar growing areas are to the south of the big coffee growing areas in Brazil. So I'm sure farmers are having issues right now, you know, just as much, if not more, as coffee farmers. I think we'll see that showing up in these next few harvest reports. You know, see lower harvest totals. I think that has the chance to keep sugar prices underpinned for a while. At the end of the day, Brazil is still expecting a pretty big sugarcane crop this year. So, you know, I'm talking mostly temporary support here, but we do need some drier weather, give farmers a chance to actually get out in the fields and make some progress on these two harvests. speaker-1: All right. Thanks for that, John. All right, Megan, welcome to the show. Tell us a little bit about yourself. speaker-0: I'm Megan Pasanato. I'm currently the Vice President of Supply Chain and Quality Assurance at Naya. Prior to Naya, I spent over 10 years at Shake Shack building their supply chain team. And prior to Shake Shack, I worked at Finley's, which is a team manufacturer, and I handle domestic and international supply chain for them. speaker-1: And was your academic background in supply chain or how did you get into it? speaker-0: Nope, not at all. I got my degree in finance. I thought I was definitely gonna end up working for Morgan Stanley or EBS or doing something in that field and kind of fell into supply chain out of college through an internship at Finlay's. And I just fell in love with the business and really, really liked doing supply chain, realized I was pretty good at it, had a natural knack for it. So I just continued my career down that path. speaker-1: Cool. And you all really have built something at Shake Shack, you built something special there. You guys should be very proud of that. And I'm sure Naya's very excited to have you, right? You recently there, right? speaker-0: Yep, I'm coming up on three months at the end of this month. So it's very fresh, still very new, but it's really exciting. It's a growing brand. It's fun to be back in this forty units on this rapid growth trajectory again. speaker-1: So along those lines, tell us a little bit more about Naya. Like what attracted you? Well, what's the brand? So just in case people don't know, because I think it's predominantly in the Northeast, right? speaker-0: Yeah, it's predominantly in the northeast. Most of our locations are in Manhattan. We do have some locations in New Jersey, Massachusetts, Connecticut, and Philadelphia with plans to expand to Florida by the end of this year. ⁓ good. Yeah, it's pretty fast paced growth, which is really exciting. But yeah, the brand itself, it's a Middle Eastern concept. The founder and owner is from Lebanon. He came here in, I believe, 2004, really missed his mother's cooking, decided to open a restaurant. with her recipes. And that's kind of how the concept was born. And I think just a really unique and and cool story that I really liked and really attracted me to the brand as well as the food. I mean, the food's amazing. My husband and I were avid customers before I started working here. So that was something that really drew me to it when I saw the growth plans that they were planning and also they were based in New York. speaker-1: Yeah, and when I hear ⁓ Mama's recipes, I think authenticity, right? speaker-0: Yeah, it is very authentic still t you know what his home cooking was growing up, which is really cool story and I think just a really unique position for a brand. speaker-1: Wonderful. So stepping back for a second, like what experiences at Shake Shack prepared you for this role at Naya? speaker-0: So I mean I started at Shake Shack when they had only 40 locations, and I left there when they had about 500 in the US. So I'm uniquely in this position where I've done it before. Naya currently has 47 locations. Our 47th is actually opening today. They have plans to get to 200 by 2030. So having already done it and scale the supply chain at a really fast pace at Shake Shack really put me in this unique position of being able to come here and do it all over again. taking all the knowledge and experience and learnings that I had at Shake Shack and being able to get ahead of things that we were solving for, you know, at a hundred and fifty locations and really putting those things in place at forty seven locations is a great place to be and be able to really bring that like knowledge and experience to them. speaker-1: Cool. So what's your typical day like? speaker-0: So right now, I mean, my typical day is really built building out the foundation of the supply chain. There was no supply chain team prior to me joining about three months ago. So there's a lot of like foundational work that needs to be done. So a lot of it is putting things in place like an inventory management system. I mean, there was nothing when I came in and to do my job well and for any of us to do our job well in the role that I have. You have to have visibility into your inventory and where you sit, your contract management system needs to be very thorough so that you're doing the best that you can and servicing the locations the best you can. So that's really right now where my focus is is really just building that foundation, you know, looking at our distribution, what that's gonna look like in the future, in the next three years. I mean, that we're gonna expand quite a bit in the next three years. So setting up our distribution for the future. And really setting up also new processes for new restaurant openings. That's been a big focus. We have 10 more opening before the end of the year. So getting plans in place and systems in place to make sure that those openings run smoothly is something that's a big focus of mine. And luckily, having been at Shake Shack, we were opening upwards of 65-70 locations in a year when I left. So having that knowledge and bringing that kind of process to here at an early stage is is definitely helpful to the team. speaker-1: Right. And I'm remiss, we talk about visibility and inventory. Welcome to Aerostream, kinda, right? You're with Aerostream at Shake Shack, but welcome to Aerostream, right? speaker-0: Yeah, so I was with onboarded Arrow Stream at Shake Shack about n almost ten years ago and now I'm redoing it here at Naya. So I'm hoping to be fully done with implementation by the end of the month. speaker-1: ⁓ great. So yeah, along the distribution and new processes, I mean, most of your growth being in the northeast, and now I heard you say Florida, which makes me excited because that's where I reside, that's quite a shift, right? Mm-hmm. Of taking maybe a more centralized distribution and and expanding. Remind me, are Nye is are is it a corporately owned restaurants, franchised? Can you walk us through that? speaker-0: Yeah, so we're corporately owned. We are still a privately held company. We do have one license deal at JFK, but you know, for the foreseeable future, there's no plan for us to franchise. speaker-1: Yep. So similar model to Shake Shack then. Good for you all. So I know it's early, right? And you're probably drinking from a fire hose there, but maybe throughout your career and what you're trying to get to. So you mentioned visibility and inventory, new processes for opening stores, distribution. What are some key KPIs or impact data points that help you institute these new processes, make your distribution more efficient, inventory visibility and all the key things that you're working through? speaker-0: Yeah. Yeah, it's interesting because, you having just transitioned to Naya, I I would definitely say my KPIs have shifted a bit to what my KPIs were at Shake Shack at the time that I left three months ago. But you know, really right now, the KPIs that I'm striving to get to that are gonna be huge factors in setting up us to be successful as we grow are really inventory management again and really our cost of goods. I think if Focusing on those two KPIs right now for me are my top priority and making sure that we have the visibility and are striving to what where we need our inventory levels to be and also where we need our cogs to be. speaker-1: So what's your process or tools to work on those key performance indicators? speaker-0: Yeah, that's part of the problem right now. I don't quite have the systems I need fully up and running to get those KPIs set and be able to track against them. So I'm kind of in the process of building what I need to be able to measure those KPIs and track two specific numbers. So I'm in the middle of trying to put all those things in place, but that's the overall goal, you know, by the end of the year is to have everything really set up so I have the visibility that I need, the contracts in place to actually get to a certain CODs that I'm striving for. So it's kind of happening at the same time. Like I've identified those are two of the priorities that I need to get across the line before the end of the year so that I can set our supply chain up for success. speaker-1: Very good. So let's shift a little bit here. So there's probably some manufacturers, some vendors out there that may have not heard of Naya, right? And are also probably very attracted to an emerging brand like Naya. What makes a vendor, whether that's a food vendor, a tech vendor, a service vendor, valuable to you in your supply chain? speaker-0: Yeah, I always used to say to my team, and I live this pretty thoroughly on my end with suppliers. I really always say it's a people business that we're in. Relationships are incredibly important. I think you need suppliers that you can depend on and that are adaptable to a growing business. And that was something that early on at Shake Shack was really, really important for us to identify were who are the suppliers we had a really strong foundation with, a really strong partnership with that was going to bend over backwards for us as we were expanding and growing and they were gonna be adaptable and be able to change. Cause you know at a young company where it's very founder led that there's a lot of last minute changes. So we needed to make sure that we had those really strong relationships. So I would say for me, what I always look for in a supplier is the relationship, making sure that that's really strong and we have really good foundation, but also knowing companies that are going to be able to adapt to our needs and are going to be flexible to what we need. Sometimes you run into suppliers that they're just not flexible. They're not gonna go and do the smaller pack size that you need or they're not gonna take a look at their business and how they can kind of adapt to what your needs are at the time. So those are two of like the things that I would say are really important to me on the supplier side. speaker-1: Cool. If you had to s kind of looking broader now, if you had to grade the current status of the food service supply chain, and I said A to F in the notes, but you can grade it however you would like. How would you grade it and why? speaker-0: Yeah, I would say a B minus. I think sometimes people don't give enough credit to some of the supply chain teams and what they've built. And I'm talking also from my own experience of what I built over at Shake Shack and that team. But I think we still have a long way to go on catching up in technology. I think the food service industry as a whole is pretty behind on the technology front. I think we've made a lot of strides, at least in my last ten years on the chain side. But I think there's still a f a long way to go and a lot of improvements on things that we can do in the supply chain to just make our jobs more efficient and easier. So that's why I give it a B minus. Okay. speaker-1: So you think technology and probably data maturity, right? The next question is where do you think the supply chain is headed? I mean speaker-0: Think so. Every time we go to the conference, a huge focus is AI and how AI is going to play a part in the supply chain and how it can make us more efficient and it can help ⁓ with our everyday work. So I think that there's been a lot of improvement over the past couple of years, but I think we're gonna just see that continue to increase throughout the next three to five years. You know, particularly I would say a lot of the conversations I've had with peers are around forecasting, right? Like No one has a great solution or solve for forecasting. A lot of people are doing it, you know, an Excel. I mean, some people have homegrown systems, but I think that that's like the biggest area of opportunity. We all have to do forecasting on a regular basis for suppliers, especially when you're at a growing chain that's in this rapid growth. You're not gonna have the same usage, you know, six months from now when you have multiple locations that have opened up. So being able to do that more quickly and more efficiently, I think is gonna be crucial to us continuing to evolve as a supply chain. Okay. Sorry, forecasting case movement for suppliers. So providing like a rolling 12 months, a quarterly update of what expected usage is on cases. speaker-1: Forecasting what? Okay, great, thank you. And what data w should play a part in that, do you think? speaker-0: What I've always found beneficial is past usage, seasonality, and then layering in new store openings. So if you have new store openings, finding a comparable sales location to kind of forecast the kind of pull what that store has done historically and use that as a baseline for a new store opening. So I think being able to have that data of like the past few years of what's actually happened, what that seasonality trend is. If there is seasonality, I mean most businesses Especially at Naya here, there's much more seasonality than I was used to at Shake Shack. They definitely have seasons where they're much more busy than others. So being able to really trend that out and figure out what that looks like and then layering in those new store openings. speaker-1: So if you've accomplished quite a bit and are accomplished, you at Shake Shack and at Naya and more to come, sure, but for operators who currently lack the tools or the staff to effectively manage their supply chain. So Naya before you came in, because I think you were the first, right? What are one or two prioritized actions that they should think about? speaker-0: Yeah, I mean, coming into NIA and not having any systems built out or really any any foundation, I was kind of in that put in that place of not having the tools that I need to succeed. So for me, one of the first things that I tackled was inventory management. And I would say that that goes for any chain. I mean, if you can't have visibility into where your inventory is, how much inventory is coming in, what your sell price is, it's really hard to be successful, a really successful supply chain. If you don't have that visibility. So to me, that was the most important tool that I needed to get up and running when I started at night. I think I tackled that within the first week because I can't do my job well if I can't see where my inventory is, what the price of the product is going out, and managing that all within one system. speaker-1: And that would be inventory at the distribution centers. speaker-0: Yes, inventory and the distribution centers. speaker-1: Thank you. All right. So in one or two sentences, and I hate to wrap this up with you because this has really been fun. What is a single best piece of advice for supply chain leaders today, would you say? speaker-0: So I thought a a lot about this. I would say my advice isn't specific to only supply chain leaders, but my advice is to like really any leader. I think it's really just to always remember that you're only as strong as your team and as good as your team. I'm big on having a really cohesive team, and I learned that really early in my career that to be successful and to be able to expand at the rate that we wanted to expand, we needed really great people, but we also needed a team that was gonna work really well together. And what I found in building my team at Shake Shack, I mean, it took a long time to get to where we needed to get to, but the amount that we were able to achieve as a team together because of how well we worked together and how strong each individual was independent of the team is really what made us such a great team. We were always lean. Everybody would always say, We're so lean. How are you able to accomplish all of these things? And it really comes back to the team. I truly believe лідер is only as good as their team. speaker-1: Yeah, and and Shake Shack team, including yourself, very good people. ⁓ And I can't help but think coming off the NBA Finals, are you a Knicks fan? So the Knicks may not have been the most talented team in the playoffs, but boy were they cohesive and did they play well, huh? speaker-0: Thank you. Thank you. Course I'm a Knicks fan. Okay. Yeah, that's what it's all about. speaker-1: Yeah, well thank you for being on the show, Megan. Really appreciate it. Great stuff. speaker-0: Well thank you so much, David. speaker-1: That wraps up another episode of Markets to Menus. A big thank you to John Goodwin and Megan Postonado for sharing their insights today. And thank you for tuning in. If you enjoyed this episode, please leave us a five-star review. It really helps the show grow. And be sure to share it with your colleagues and industry partners who could benefit from the conversation. Until next time, this is David Maloney with Aerostream, helping you navigate from markets to menus.