Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Howard Marks: The Real Risk Is Not What You Think
Transcript
- 0:00When I say the word risk, you know in the context of your
- 0:03money, what's the very first image that flashes into your
- 0:07mind? Be honest.
- 0:10Is it a stock chart? Just, you know, zigzagging like.
- 0:13Pretty jagged. Line, Yeah.
- 0:14Or is it that feeling, that pit in your stomach, that just
- 0:17absolute terror of losing it all and having to start over?
- 0:21It's a great question because how you answer that, I mean, it
- 0:24basically determines your entire financial future, right?
- 0:27Most people, they obsess over that jagged line, but they
- 0:30really should be worrying about the empty bank account.
- 0:32Exactly, And that's why today we're unpacking a master class
- 0:35lecture from the legendary Howard Marks of Oak Tree
- 0:38Capital. A giant in the field.
- 0:40It's titled How to Think About Risk, and I have to say I love
- 0:44that wording. Not what to think, but how to
- 0:47think. It's a huge distinction.
- 0:49He challenges all the academic stuff, the things you read in
- 0:51textbooks, and he replaces it with something that's just much
- 0:54more practical. Yeah, he moves us away from
- 0:56these, you know, elegant math formulas and into this messy
- 1:00real world philosophy of human behavior.
- 1:03And just the sheer uncertainty of the future.
- 1:05We're going to get into the Nifty 50 bubble.
- 1:07The weird paradox of high tech safety gear, and this is my
- 1:13favorite why traffic accidents actually go down when you remove
- 1:17stoplights. Sounds completely insane.
- 1:20It does, but stick with us. The logic is, well, it's
- 1:23undeniable. But before we get into the
- 1:25philosophy, we should probably touch on the practical side.
- 1:27I mean, understanding market risk requires having the right
- 1:31tools. That's right, you need a compass
- 1:33to navigate these waters. So if you're trying to track,
- 1:36let's say, the total market temperature, you might want to
- 1:38check out the iOS App Buffett indicator, right?
- 1:42You can just search and download it from the Apple App Store.
- 1:44It's a really useful tool for just getting a sense of where
- 1:47valuations are, you know, relative to history are.
- 1:49Things overheated or are they ice cold?
- 1:51It helps frame the discussion definitely.
- 1:53Worth a look. And of course, before we start
- 1:55deconstructing the market's biggest myths, we have a bit of
- 1:58a necessary housekeeping to take care of.
- 2:01Indeed, we have to keep the lawyers happy.
- 2:04So here we go. Full deep value research reports
- 2:07can be found in the description links.
- 2:09All analysis is based on publicly available sources and
- 2:12may be subject to revisions or differing interpretations.
- 2:16All contents from this channel is for educational and research
- 2:18purposes only and does not constitute investment advice.
- 2:22Conduct your own due diligence before making investment
- 2:25decisions. Please do.
- 2:26If you want to access more advanced contents, welcome to
- 2:28subscribe on Deep Values dot AI. We will share our latest
- 2:32researches and the most advanced AI agent tools for our
- 2:35contrarian friends. Don't forget to like this video.
- 2:38Much appreciate it. OK, housekeeping is done.
- 2:40Let's get into the meat of this. The mission for this deep dive
- 2:44is pretty simple. We want to tear down that idea
- 2:47that risk equals volatility and replace it with a framework that
- 2:51actually works. So let's start there.
- 2:53The definition If risk isn't volatility, what is it?
- 2:58Because every single finance textbook I've ever seen says it
- 3:00is. Well, to really get Marx's view,
- 3:03you have to go back. You have to look at what he
- 3:04calls the academic trap. I think 1960s University of
- 3:07Chicago. This is where modern financial
- 3:09theory is being born and the academics they needed a way to
- 3:13measure risk for their models. They needed a number.
- 3:17They needed a number, but the problem with risk is it's
- 3:20slippery. It exists entirely in the
- 3:23future, and you can't measure something that hasn't happened
- 3:26yet. So they were kind of stuck.
- 3:28They needed a number for the spreadsheet, but the number
- 3:30didn't actually exist. Exactly.
- 3:31So they needed a proxy and they settled on volatility.
- 3:36How much does the price bounce around?
- 3:38And they pick that just because it's quantifiable.
- 3:41For that one reason, it's historical.
- 3:43You can run the numbers and you can say this stock has high
- 3:45volatility, therefore it is risky.
- 3:48It made the math work. But Mark says that's just it's
- 3:51that's total nonsense. And complete nonsense.
- 3:53I mean if I buy a stock at 100 and it drops to 80 then shoots
- 3:57up to 120, the volatility is high sure, but I made 20 bucks
- 4:01how is that risky? Precisely, Mark's calls
- 4:04volatility A symptom, not the disease.
- 4:07In the real world, and this is really the key insight, risk is
- 4:10the probability of loss. Permanent loss.
- 4:12Permanent loss when you demand a higher return for a risky asset.
- 4:17You're not saying pay me more because the price might wiggle.
- 4:20You're saying pay me more because I might never see this
- 4:22money again? That distinction is just it's
- 4:26huge. It shifts the focus from how
- 4:30bumpy is the ride to will the car actually crash?
- 4:33Yes. And he uses this really great
- 4:35comparison of investment managers to drive this home.
- 4:39He talks about asymmetry. Asymmetry is the Holy Grail.
- 4:43It's everything. He lays out a few scenarios.
- 4:45So imagine Manager A When the market is up 10%, they're up
- 4:4910%. OK.
- 4:50Market down 10, they're down 10. So that's just an index fund, a
- 4:53robot, no skill. You're just on the roller.
- 4:55Coaster, right, No value add. Then you have Manager B market
- 4:58up 10%, they're up 20. Oh, OK.
- 5:00Market down 10%. They're down 20.
- 5:02So that's just leverage or being super aggressive.
- 5:05High beta. You win big, you lose bigger.
- 5:07Yeah, genius. That feels like gambling.
- 5:09It is gambling. But then look at Manager C This
- 5:12is the goal, right? When the market's up 10, Manager
- 5:15C is up 10, they participate. But when the markets down 10,
- 5:19Manager C is only down 5%. That is the asymmetry.
- 5:23They get the upside, but they cut off the downside.
- 5:26That is the true test of skill. Marks argues, that returns alone
- 5:30tell you absolutely nothing. If you tell me you made 20% last
- 5:33year, I don't know if you're a brilliant investor or if you
- 5:36just took a terrifying amount of risk and got lucky.
- 5:38Risk is the ultimate test. It's the ultimate test.
- 5:40The real skill is losing less when the world falls apart and.
- 5:44Avoiding that big loss is so important.
- 5:47Mathematics. Oh.
- 5:48Absolutely. If you lose 50% of your money,
- 5:50you don't need a 50% gain to get back to even you.
- 5:52Need 100% gain? You need to double your money
- 5:55just to get back to where you started.
- 5:56Wow, I love that line from him. Risk is the ultimate test of an
- 6:01investor's skill. It's like you don't know how
- 6:04good a pilot is until they have to fly through a storm.
- 6:07Exactly. But this gets tricky, doesn't
- 6:09it? Because if risk is about the
- 6:11future, and we can't see the future, how on earth do we
- 6:15assess it? And this is where we get to the
- 6:17philosophical core of his thinking.
- 6:19He quotes Peter Bernstein and Elroy Dimson, who said something
- 6:23that really just. It stops you in your tracks, OK?
- 6:26Risk means more things can happen than will happen.
- 6:29More things can happen than will happen.
- 6:31Let's let's unpack that because it sounds like a Riddle.
- 6:34It is a bit of a Riddle, but it's about the nature of the
- 6:36future. We tend to think there's one
- 6:38future out there waiting for us. Right that it's pre written.
- 6:41But it's not the future is a probability distribution, a
- 6:45whole range of possibilities. You know, maybe there's a 60%
- 6:48chance of rain, a 30% chance of sun, a 10% chance of snow.
- 6:52Those are the more things that can happen.
- 6:55But we only get one of them. We don't get 60% rain, we just
- 6:57get rain or sun. Exactly.
- 7:00We live in the sample, not the universe.
- 7:02The universe is all the possibilities.
- 7:05The sample is the one reality we actually get.
- 7:08And that creates a massive blind spot for us because we judge the
- 7:12quality of a decision based on the outcome.
- 7:14Not the process that led to it. Marks use that Super Bowl
- 7:17analogy for this the 2016 game Denver versus Carolina.
- 7:21I thought it was perfect. Yeah, Carolina was the heavy
- 7:24favorite. They had Cam Newton, they were
- 7:26on fire. The betting markets, the
- 7:29pundits, they all said roughly an 80% chance Carolina wins.
- 7:33And then what happened? Denver won.
- 7:35And so everyone immediately says, see, the prediction was
- 7:39wrong. The experts were idiots.
- 7:40But were they wrong? I mean, if I tell you there's an
- 7:4380% chance of something happening, that implies a 20%
- 7:47chance of the other thing. So one out of five times.
- 7:49One out of five times Denver should win.
- 7:51The fact that the 20% outcome happened doesn't mean the
- 7:54probability was wrong, It just means that specific ticket was
- 7:57pulled from the bowl. That is so hard for our brains
- 8:00to accept. We crave certainty.
- 8:02We want to be told Who Will Win, not who will probably win.
- 8:06And that desire for certainty leads to what he calls the
- 8:09expected value fallacy. He uses this dead simple
- 8:12numerical example. Imagine an investment with four
- 8:16equally likely outcomes, 246 and 8.
- 8:20OK. 25% chance of each. So if you do the math, the
- 8:24average the expanded value is 5. Right, 2 + 4 + 6 + 8 / 4.
- 8:29It's five. You can never get A5.
- 8:31You can never get A5. You will get a 2A4A6 or an 8.
- 8:36Relying on the average is so dangerous because the average
- 8:39outcome might not even be possible.
- 8:41And he makes that point about the river, Yeah.
- 8:43You can drown crossing a river that is on average 4 feet deep.
- 8:48If one of those outcomes is ruined, the average is
- 8:50completely irrelevant. That is a terrifying thought.
- 8:54It really is. And that brings us to the
- 8:56weirdest part of this whole lecture.
- 8:58Risk isn't just math. It's behavioral.
- 9:01And Mark says it's perverse. It acts in ways that are totally
- 9:05backwards. This is my favorite part, the
- 9:07idea that safety actually creates danger.
- 9:10The Drachton traffic experiment. This just blew my mind.
- 9:13A town in Holland, Drachton and they decide to do something that
- 9:17sounds like absolute madness. They remove all the traffic
- 9:21lights. All the signs, all the road
- 9:22markings, just bare. Pavement logic says total chaos.
- 9:26It should be a demolition Derby. It wasn't.
- 9:28Accidents went down. Because risk lives in human
- 9:30behavior. When you take away the signs,
- 9:34drivers suddenly feel unsafe. They feel uncertain.
- 9:38So what do they do? Oh, they slow down.
- 9:39They slow down. They look around.
- 9:41They actually make eye contact with other drivers.
- 9:43The perception of risk made them safer.
- 9:45And the flip side of that is the Avalanche gear.
- 9:47The Avalanche gear paradox. Yep, every year climbing gear
- 9:51gets better. It's stronger.
- 9:52You've got airbags, GPS. You'd think fatalities would
- 9:55plummet, but they don't. They don't because with better
- 9:58gear climbers just say hey I'm invincible now I can go climb
- 10:01that much more dangerous this peak.
- 10:03They just consume the safety benefits by taking on more risk.
- 10:07So applying this to the market when everyone feels safe, when
- 10:11everyone thinks things can only go up.
- 10:13That's the moment of maximum danger, 100%.
- 10:16Think about the Nifty 50 stocks in 1969.
- 10:19IBM Xerox, Polaroid. The one decision stocks.
- 10:22The only decision was to buy. You never ever sell.
- 10:26And because everyone believed they were so safe, they bid the
- 10:28prices up to the stratosphere. We're talking 8090 times.
- 10:33Which made them unbelievably risky.
- 10:35Of course, when investors aren't worried about losing money, they
- 10:38don't demand a risk premium. They'll tell any price.
- 10:42And paying a high price is the easiest way to lose your shirt.
- 10:45Marks also brings up this idea of hidden risk.
- 10:48Uses the analogy of a house in California.
- 10:50Yes. So you have a house.
- 10:52It looks perfect, but it has this serious hidden construction
- 10:56flaw. As long as the weather's nice
- 10:58and the ground is still, you'd never know.
- 11:01It looks safe. It looks safe.
- 11:03The flaw is completely invisible.
- 11:05Until the earthquake hits. The earthquake doesn't create
- 11:08the flaw, it just reveals it. In investing, you can have a
- 11:11strategy that looks brilliant for five years straight just
- 11:14because the environment is calm. You're swimming naked, as
- 11:17Buffett says. But the tide is high, so no one
- 11:18can see it. Exactly.
- 11:20Then the market crashes. That's the earthquake, and
- 11:23suddenly the risk that was there all along becomes a permanent,
- 11:27devastating loss. Which leads to this really
- 11:29uncomfortable truth he drops on us.
- 11:32You can't quantify risk in advance, which kind of new, but
- 11:35he says you can't even quantify it after the fact.
- 11:37It's so disturbing, isn't it? If you buy a stock for a dollar
- 11:41and sell it for $2.00, was that a safe investment?
- 11:44I'd say yeah, I doubled my money.
- 11:46But you don't know. Maybe it was a sure thing, or
- 11:49maybe it was a 99% chance of going to 0 and you just got
- 11:52ridiculously lucky on the 1% chance of doubled.
- 11:55The outcome doesn't tell you about the risk you took to get
- 11:57it. That is wild.
- 11:59It means you can be a terrible investor who gets lucky for a
- 12:02while and you'll think you're a genius.
- 12:03Until your luck runs out. That's why process matters so
- 12:07much more than any single outcome.
- 12:09OK. Let's talk about quality versus
- 12:11price, because I think most of us have this default setting.
- 12:15Buying high quality assets is safe, Buying junk is risky.
- 12:20But Mark's just. He says no.
- 12:22He completely destroys this myth using his own career.
- 12:25He started with the Nifty 50 blue chip.
- 12:27High quality companies lost 90% of his money because they were
- 12:30overpriced. And then he switched to.
- 12:32High yield bonds literally called junk bonds.
- 12:35Low quality companies on paper and he made a fortune safely.
- 12:39How? Is that even possible?
- 12:41How can junk be safer than IBM? Price.
- 12:44It's always about the price. The junk bonds were so hated, so
- 12:48feared, that they were trading for pennies on the dollar.
- 12:51The market was pricing in this massive default rate.
- 12:54So even if some of them went bust.
- 12:56The price was low enough that it created a huge margin of safety.
- 13:00So the mantra is it's not what you buy, it's what you pay.
- 13:04That's it. A great asset at a high price is
- 13:06a risky proposition. A bad asset at a low enough
- 13:10price can be very safe. Marks also says we need to
- 13:13redraw that standard risk versus return chart.
- 13:16You know the one. It's just a diagonal line going
- 13:19up. More risk equals more return.
- 13:21That chart is so dangerous because it implies a guarantee.
- 13:24It tells your brain if I take more risk, I will get more
- 13:27return so. What does he change?
- 13:29He says it shouldn't be a thin line, it should be bell curves
- 13:32kind of on their sides all along that line.
- 13:34OK, help us visualize that we're audio only here.
- 13:36OK, imagine that diagonal line at the very bottom left for low
- 13:39risk. The bell curve is really tight
- 13:41and narrow. The range of outcomes is small.
- 13:44Think of a Treasury bill. You know what you're going to
- 13:45get. Right.
- 13:46Small risk, small variance in the outcome.
- 13:49Exactly. Now as you move up that line to
- 13:51higher risk, imagine the bell curve gets wider and wider and
- 13:58wider. So the potential upside gets
- 14:00higher. Yes, the expected return in the
- 14:02center of that curve moves up, but the range of possible
- 14:06outcomes just explodes. The tails of the curve stretch
- 14:09way out. The bad outcomes become much,
- 14:11much worse. So higher risk doesn't guarantee
- 14:14a higher return. It guarantees higher
- 14:16uncertainty. It means that left hand tail,
- 14:18the disaster scenario is now a real possibility.
- 14:22The possibility of losing everything enters the picture.
- 14:25That's it. So if we understand all this,
- 14:28that risk is hidden, It's perverse.
- 14:30It's about price and probability.
- 14:32How do we actually manage it? What's the solution?
- 14:34Marx goes back to the tickets in the bowl analogy.
- 14:37The market is just a giant bowl of lottery tickets.
- 14:40The future is 1 ticket being pulled out.
- 14:42And we don't know which ticket it's going to be.
- 14:43We don't. But the superior investor, the
- 14:46one with real skill, has a better sense of the contents of
- 14:48the bowl. They can look and say, hey, this
- 14:51bowl seems to have mostly winning tickets, or whoa, this
- 14:54bowl is 90% losers. I'm staying away.
- 14:57They can't predict the draw, but they understand the
- 15:00probabilities better than everyone else.
- 15:02And then you have to decide what to do.
- 15:03He makes a distinction between risk avoidance and risk control.
- 15:09This is critical. If you avoid risk completely,
- 15:12you avoid return. You put your money under the
- 15:14mattress. That's hiding, not investing.
- 15:17The goal is intelligent bearing of risk for profit.
- 15:21And he uses the insurance industry as the perfect model
- 15:24for this. Which is funny, right?
- 15:26We think of insurance companies as so boring and conservative,
- 15:29but think about a life insurer. They're insuring people who are
- 15:32100% guaranteed to die it. Sounds like a guaranteed loss.
- 15:35You're betting on something that is absolutely going to happen.
- 15:38But it works because of three things.
- 15:40One, they know the risk. They have the actuarial tables.
- 15:432, they diversify. They don't only insure skydiving
- 15:46chain smokers. And three, most importantly,
- 15:49they charge a premium. They get paid to take the risk.
- 15:52So they're not avoiding the risk of death, they're managing the
- 15:55financial impact of it. Precisely.
- 15:57And that's the lesson for us as investors.
- 15:59We don't buy a stock assuming it can never go down.
- 16:03We buy it knowing the risks, diversifying our bets and making
- 16:06sure the potential return the premium is high enough to
- 16:10justify the uncertainty. I really liked his last analogy
- 16:13about sports, American football versus soccer.
- 16:16This is about when you manage risk.
- 16:19In American football, the game stops all the time.
- 16:22You have an offense team, a defense team.
- 16:24You know exactly when you need to be on offense and when you
- 16:27need to be on defense. But the market isn't like that.
- 16:30You don't get a time out. You can't just say hold on,
- 16:32recessions coming, let me sub in my goalie, No.
- 16:34Investing is like soccer. The clock is always running.
- 16:37The same players are on the field for 90 minutes straight.
- 16:40You have to switch from offense to defense in a split second.
- 16:43You can't just say, OK market pause for a SEC, let me swap out
- 16:46my aggressive portfolio for my defensive.
- 16:48One, exactly. The risk control has to be built
- 16:51into the portfolio at all times. You need assets that can score,
- 16:55but can also get back and defend when the tide suddenly turns
- 16:59against you. It's about being prepared for
- 17:01the unknown all the time. Yes.
- 17:04If you build a portfolio that only works if one specific
- 17:07future happens, you're fragile. If you build one that can handle
- 17:11a range of outcomes, all those different tickets in the bowl,
- 17:14then you're resilient. So let's bring this all home.
- 17:18What does this mean for someone listening right now looking at
- 17:20their four O 1K or their brokerage account?
- 17:22It means you have to stop looking at volatility as the
- 17:25enemy. Volatility is just the price of
- 17:28admission. The real enemy is permanent
- 17:30loss. The real enemy is buying high
- 17:33because it feels safe and selling low because you're
- 17:35terrified. Marx calls that the cardinal sin
- 17:38of investing, being forced to sell at the bottom.
- 17:40It's the ultimate tragedy if you buy at the highs and the market
- 17:43crashes. If you can just hold on, you'll
- 17:45probably recover. History shows the market
- 17:47eventually comes back. But if you sell at the bottom.
- 17:50You make that loss permanent, you lock it in, and then you
- 17:54miss the recovery. You've gotten off the
- 17:55compounding train and you might never get back on.
- 17:58That's a. Really sobering thought.
- 18:00It highlights that the biggest risk factor isn't the economy,
- 18:03it's our own reaction to it. It is.
- 18:06The biggest risk isn't in the chart, it's in the mirror.
- 18:09So here's a final question for you to Mull over as you go about
- 18:12your day in your own portfolio. Are you acting like the traffic
- 18:15planner in dragged and alert? Aware of the uncertainty, making
- 18:19eye contact with the risks. Or are you trusting the better
- 18:22gear, the high tech tools, the safe blue chip stocks and just
- 18:27letting complacency creep in? Are you checking the tickets in
- 18:30the bowl or are you just closing your eyes and hoping for a lucky
- 18:33draw? Something to think about.
- 18:35That's it for this deep dive into Howard Marks on Risk.
- 18:38You should check the description for the full source material.
- 18:40It is absolutely worth your time.
- 18:42And remember, risk is hidden. Stay sharp.
- 18:45Thanks for listening. We'll see you in the next deep
- 18:48dive.