Latest / The Vegan Report / The Brutal Truth Behind the Egg Industry. With Nigel Osborne & Juliane Priesemeister | Ep. 08
Transcript
- 0:00Hello everyone, my name is Ryan and you're listening to The Vegan Report.
- 0:05If you're vegan for the animals and you care to do more for animal rights, but you're not sure
- 0:12where to start, then this podcast is for you. Every week, let yourself fall in love with
- 0:18passionate animal rights leaders who will inspire you to find your voice, your own special
- 0:25contribution to the animal rights movement, however small or big it is. Today, we are going to talk
- 0:33about chickens. And let me set the table by quoting an article I found preparing for this episode.
- 0:42It is from the Weather Network and it is titled, Why Chickens Might Be the Biggest Legacy We Leave
- 0:50on this Earth. It says, before you throw away that chicken bone, you should know, it may wind up on
- 0:58our permanent record. A study released by researchers in England last December showed that
- 1:05our lasting legacy here on Earth may be just that, as the sheer number of the world's most popular
- 1:13foal stands to leave its mark on this slice of the geological record. At any given time,
- 1:21there are an estimated 23 billion chickens on Earth, about 10 times more than any other bird
- 1:29species. They've got us outnumbered too. That's about three chickens for every person on the
- 1:37planet. According to the study's authors, the world's domesticated chicken is likely to be
- 1:45the largest standing population of a single bird species in Earth's history. Of course, reading this
- 1:55as a vegan, I think about the horrendous scale of chicken exploitation. Yes, chickens will be part
- 2:04of humans' legacy, but this is a dark and shameful legacy. To talk about this topic, I have with me
- 2:13the team behind the Truth Organization, the two co-founders Nigel and Julie. What is the Truth
- 2:20Organization? It is the non-profit behind the Egg-Truth.com initiative, which educates the
- 2:29public about the true nature of egg production, from hatchery to plate. Julie and Nigel,
- 2:39welcome to the podcast. Hi. Thank you. Hi, how are you doing? I'm great. Thank you. How about you?
- 2:46Good, good, good. Would you like to first introduce yourself and talk about your role with
- 2:52the Truth Organization? I might just go first. Hi, I'm Julie, I'm Prismaster. I go by Julie,
- 3:00and I'm the newly appointed executive director of the Truth Organization, where we host the Egg-Truth
- 3:06and the Day Earth-Truth websites and social media channels. I started off as a marketing and social
- 3:12media manager and started to transition into executive director this year. And so this will,
- 3:18from just outreach, I'll take on more strategic work and look at how we can grow and how we can
- 3:24become a key player in the vegan movement. And that's basically the plan for the coming year and
- 3:30years, I think, for me anyway. My name's Nigel. I'm the founder of the Truth Organization and its
- 3:38various incarnations, egg-truth.com and dairy-truth.com. And I started the organization
- 3:49around 2018, set up the social media platforms, obviously the websites, and developed a lot of
- 3:57the content. And then as Julie mentioned, I brought her on to manage social media,
- 4:03which is a big role and a pretty fundamental role these days in any organization, whether you're
- 4:07for-profit or non. And she did such a great job. I wanted to promote her up into executive director
- 4:16and I could then focus a bit more on fundraising, on being a bit more strategic and look at
- 4:25developing some more content while she ran the front office and social media and so on.
- 4:30And that's it. So I'm sorry I gave you both the title of founders, but Nigel, you're the sole
- 4:40founder of the organization. Is that right? Yes. Okay. So I assume both of you are vegans.
- 4:48Am I correct? Yes. So please talk about your journey from being, I guess,
- 5:01raised like everyone else with a loose understanding of our impact on animals to becoming vegan, to now
- 5:12running a vegan organization. Right. So as you just mentioned, I was like everyone else, raised
- 5:21meat, meat and three vegetables, our usual dinner or weekend food. I always had a dislike for meat.
- 5:28I just never liked eating it. I just did because your parents tell you to eat up. So I did, but
- 5:33always disliked it. And as I got older and then moved out, I started eating less and less meat,
- 5:37just naturally because I just didn't like it. And at some point I just decided, okay, today is
- 5:41the day I'm going to go vegetarian. And this was when I was a student. And then it took a long time
- 5:47to actually go to veganism. I never thought about it for me. Like for many, I think veganism
- 5:52always felt like a bit extreme and it felt restrictive. And the only people I would know
- 5:59as vegans would be the people that are out in the streets with the screens and with the
- 6:02horrible pictures of animals and blood and tortured. And so I never really thought about it until
- 6:09I became a mother when certain things click in terms of milk and nursing. And because my child
- 6:17was diagnosed with lactose intolerance, I had to give up dairy because I was nursing and the lactose
- 6:22gets through my milk as well. So I stopped dairy. And because that was such an impactful
- 6:28thing I had to do, I started researching on dairy and I started, that was like, I had one blog post,
- 6:33but I started a blog about the dairy industry and dairy. And when I finished my maternity leave,
- 6:39I was looking for a job and I found Egg Thruz. And so I technically was a vegetarian that didn't
- 6:46consume dairy. I would still eat eggs. And when I found the posting for Egg Thruz, I started then
- 6:51reading about the website and everything they put out. And I'm like, oh, I guess, I guess I'm going
- 6:56vegan. I guess we dropped the eggs too, because that was just awful. The things I read. So ever
- 7:00since I joined Egg Thruz, which was in 2020, I completely stopped eating any animal products.
- 7:06And then the other aspect, because people most, or often just think of food, but obviously goes
- 7:12beyond that. It goes to the cosmetics, to other products we use, like laundry detergent, dish soap,
- 7:18like all the little bits and pieces. And that took a little longer just to find products and
- 7:25something that's affordable, that's available. But bit by bit I made my way to hopefully fully vegan,
- 7:32and at least in my house. Yeah. Nigel?
- 7:36I've been vegan, I guess, for around 16, 17 years now. But I think like a lot of people,
- 7:45there was a couple of years of transition. I had met my wife in 2002. And when we met,
- 7:54she was a vegetarian. And of course, I knew lots of people who were vegetarian. Vegetarian is,
- 8:01and the term has been around for a long time. And we were dating, obviously, and then inevitably
- 8:07conversations would evolve to, why vegetarian? And we would learn and discover about one another.
- 8:17And that was always a topic on the table. And I understood intuitively and understandably that,
- 8:26I get vegetarianism. They take the animal, they slice its throat, or knock it unconscious,
- 8:33and then they dismember it. It sounds like a pretty ghastly and bloody process. And so you're
- 8:39kind of like, yeah, I get that. And my wife did a lot of cooking, and she was a very good cook. And
- 8:47to me, food is either good, or it's not good. There's good vegan food, and there's bad vegan
- 8:53food. There's good omnivore food and bad omnivore food. It either tastes good to you or it doesn't.
- 8:58So, but then the conversations would evolve and I'd have questions. I would pose the same
- 9:10questions that I get all the time now, whether online or through talking to family and friends.
- 9:15So it's that cognitive dissonance working its magic. And my wife would answer as best she could.
- 9:24And if she wasn't sure or thought it would be better, just here, read this or watch that.
- 9:29And I would. And so I kind of went through the process myself. There was no coercion. There was
- 9:36no, hey, you have to be, if you were going to keep carrying on this relationship, you've got to be
- 9:41vegan or vegetarian. And it was none of that. And really, at the end of the day, if you're going to
- 9:46make any commitment to a philosophical position, you got to get there on your own, because otherwise
- 9:52it's not, you know, it ain't going to stick, so to speak. So, and yeah, I gave up meat.
- 10:02I got rid of it. I understood it. I was glad to get rid of it. Then I thought, oh, I felt pretty
- 10:08good. You know, I thought, Hey, I've gotten to this place where I'm feeling good about my decision,
- 10:14my choice. Then I discovered about eggs and dairy. And I'm like, Oh, come on, really? And, you know,
- 10:23and then I realized how horrendously bad it was. It was worse, you know, than, you know, often what
- 10:32the meat industry would produce in terms of, you know, the suffering and from a welfare perspective.
- 10:38So I started to eliminate that from my diet and never to go back. I think eggs was probably the
- 10:48last thing I abandoned. And I think my experience, my transition, I think for most vegans,
- 10:58that is a very common story. I will say that actually, no, not eggs was the last thing. Cheese
- 11:04was the last thing. And at the time, not realizing that cheese was actually addictive because of the
- 11:10case of morphins in the milk that mother cows pass on to their infant calves to help the bond. This
- 11:20is passed on through the food that we consume. And sure enough, I think if you talk to most vegans,
- 11:25they'll say, yep, cheese was the last thing to go. So, and then, you know, I think like a lot of
- 11:33people, I started out in life eating like most other North Americans, my family's from the UK.
- 11:40They immigrated to Canada in the 1950s. So I grew up eating a lot of British food, which was pretty
- 11:45bad, you know, blackened meat, boiled vegetables to a mush and potatoes, and a salad was a ripped
- 11:53up, you know, iceberg lettuce, and there was some sliced up tomatoes. So, you know, that's what I
- 11:58kind of grew up on. So trust me, I didn't, I don't miss any of that for a whole host of reasons.
- 12:04Forget veganism. So what's your favorite vegan cheese brand?
- 12:12Go ahead, Julie. Yeah, I think I don't really have a favorite as in like, that's the best and don't
- 12:19taste the difference. But I just get what's in the supermarket. And this is a day, I think you
- 12:24pronounce it. And sometimes video life. But yeah, I try just the way I cook is then it's not focused
- 12:33on the cheese. It's added maybe, but it's not the focus. It doesn't carry the flavor kind of. So
- 12:40I think cheese still has a long way to go. If we really try, if we keep comparing it to dairy
- 12:45products, and if we keep asking for the same experience, I think there's still a long way to
- 12:50go. And let's see what happens to all the lab created cheeses. I'm very excited about those
- 12:55coming out and trying them. But yeah, I just that that's my way around, just to, you know, take
- 13:00cheese out of the equation and not focus the food too much around it. What about you, Nigel? Do you
- 13:06have any recommendations? I have my fast food cheese and then my gourmet cheese. My fast food
- 13:12cheese is day of shreds for melting, whether you put it on pizza or something. It's such a great
- 13:18melting cheese. I like the day of block cheddar cheese. I think that is really probably the
- 13:27closest thing to a, you know, your grocery store supermarket cheese brick you'll get.
- 13:34I think it's a little better to be perfectly honest. But for gourmet, hands down, no question.
- 13:39Miyoko's Mount Vesuvius Black Ash. The best ever. Of course, especially with fresh bread and baked
- 13:49garlic. Amazing. So let's get to the launching of the Truth Organization. How did that happen?
- 14:00And how did the world welcome your initiative? I think it was 2017. My wife, Dr. Krista Hedema,
- 14:13had been involved with Mercy for Animals here in Canada. She had undertook probably 11 or 12
- 14:23undercover investigations on farm in transport and slaughter. In the early years, I certainly
- 14:28would help and support her on that from a social media standpoint. And she was exceedingly busy,
- 14:38her exceedingly active in exposing what was on in the animal agriculture here in Canada.
- 14:45She went out to get a lot of corporate commitments. And I was proud of her and I admired her for what
- 14:51she was doing. But as the years went on, I felt I needed to do my own thing. I needed to have
- 15:00something, some contribution that I could make directly. And eggs, like I said, one of the last
- 15:10things I gave, one of the things when I found out, I just, it was a head shake. It was like,
- 15:16oh man, this is terrible. This is really, really bad. And most people think, well, birds, chickens
- 15:25lay eggs and cows give milk. What's the harm? Well, plenty. And so I thought, okay, as a graphic
- 15:33designer and a web designer, I decided, well, the first thing I'm going to do is develop the focal
- 15:39point, which is the website. So I spent a lot of time developing the website and the content. I had
- 15:46to educate myself on a lot of the information. I had to write it, had to get an editor, because
- 15:54I'm not a professional writer by any means. And the last thing that I contemplated doing is
- 16:01addressing the issue of human health and egg consumption, which I struggled with because
- 16:08a lot of times you want to focus on the animals, the welfare issues, the use, philosophical
- 16:14issues with just using living sentient beings and treating them as a commodity.
- 16:21You know, the health and nutrition side of things is such a complex thing. And it's even,
- 16:27it's one week, it's coffee's bad for you. The next week coffee's good for you. Alcohol, this cholesterol.
- 16:34So I thought, well, the egg industry, like the dairy industry, are really unchallenged in that
- 16:41area. So I thought I'm going to find out, find a source that is not a vegan source, not a plant
- 16:48based doctor source, but somebody who, you know, has been critical of the egg industry and egg
- 16:58consumption and cholesterol. And I found Dr. J. David Spence, University of Western Ontario
- 17:06professor of pharmacology and neurology, I believe it is. And he has written and has been interviewed
- 17:14by the media around the world. He's written for the World Health Organization and he's very,
- 17:21very critical. I reached out to him one day just on a whim thinking, maybe I'll see if I can get
- 17:27him to respond. And he did. And he sent me so much information. I was overwhelmed, but I poured
- 17:35through these studies and research and I started to coalesce in my mind what the issues were.
- 17:40So I formulated that on the website and it's a pretty big part of the website.
- 17:46I don't, we don't necessarily focus on it anymore, or not anymore, as much as the others or any less.
- 17:52Julie will tell you that a lot of the content that she's programmed over the years for social media,
- 17:57again, is on the animal side of things, the welfare side of things. But I'm
- 18:04proud of that component of the website because it was the hardest to write and understand.
- 18:11And I really sort of, I'm pretty good at it now. If I were to get into a debate with somebody,
- 18:17I think I could handle my own. So it was good for me to know that. Don't focus it on it too
- 18:24much because like I said, the welfare stuff is really central. Because we often in the vegan
- 18:30movement go down these rabbit holes of talking about, well, what if the cage was this size? Or
- 18:37if a barn has this many birds and it's multi-tier aviaries and the litter is properly clipped.
- 18:43You get into these conversations and you're like, we get sucked into it. I do sometimes too. And
- 18:50we have to be careful not to do that too much. So then did an ad campaign in, I think it was 2018,
- 18:59July or 2019, an outdoor ad campaign in Toronto at 45 transit shelter posters put up around the city.
- 19:09I designed and printed an eight page full-color booklet that went into the Toronto Star,
- 19:1417,500 inserted in Saturday home delivery skewed towards a specific area and demographic.
- 19:22And we did some collaboration with Anonymous for the Voiceless and Vegan Outreach to leaflet
- 19:28and run a campaign in Dundas square all within this four week period and social media ads.
- 19:37And so there was this multi-pronged approach and you could really see the impact it was having.
- 19:44And one of the most memorable responses I received was an email from a young woman
- 19:53who was a refugee from Syria, from the war in Syria. And she had seen the poster in the transit
- 20:00shelter and she said, I didn't know what was this egg truth. So she went literally sitting in the
- 20:07shelter, she went to the website and she couldn't believe what she was seeing. One of the first
- 20:12videos on the homepage shows, it's a high definition video filmed in Australia by Animals Australia,
- 20:18great organization. And they had filmed maceration and high definition.
- 20:27And it's barbarism. And she saw that for what it was, especially coming from Syria.
- 20:36And she commented, she says, I thought when I saw the cruelty that humans inflicted on other humans
- 20:44in the war in Syria, and then I come here to a peaceful country like Canada, and here we are
- 20:51doing the same thing, but to animals. And she said, she cried, she was in tears. And that was like,
- 20:57wow, that was pretty powerful. So through that experience, I thought, well, dairy truth next,
- 21:05it's got to be dairy. And those are the two areas that I wanted to focus on because everyone
- 21:11focuses again on the welfare and the slaughter and the killing of the animals. But these are
- 21:16slaughter industries. And they're worse because they prolong the suffering of these animals,
- 21:22dairy for five years, the male cast into the veal production and the hens, the male chicks,
- 21:29day old and 18 months, confined or even not confined, but producing an egg almost every day.
- 21:37And now they're producing up to almost 500 eggs per hen before they're slaughtered. It's horrendous
- 21:45what we're doing to them. And that was the focus and the purpose. I think to come back to the
- 21:54reception, because you ask how did the world receive Act Truth. And I think what's unique about
- 21:58Act Truth is that we really focus on that one industry because there's obviously there's many,
- 22:04many organizations out there, bigger and smaller one. And usually they talk about all of the animals
- 22:08used for food. And then eggs are usually not an afterthought, but it's on the side. It's usually
- 22:14not really focused on. And then if you see big campaigns, it's often about cage free, but
- 22:18obviously this is not helping anyone, not the hens. And so Act Truth is the first one that really
- 22:23focuses on that. And what I see through my work on social media is that many vegans say, hey,
- 22:29they say a video where someone shares say an egg recipe or something related to eggs. And they're
- 22:35like, Hey, did you know that eggs are actually terrible for the animals? Check out. And then
- 22:39they link us Act Truth. And then that's all they do. They don't start citing all the bad things.
- 22:44They like go to Act Truth and then you learn. And I think that's what's happening. And that's what
- 22:47we really want to push for and focus on that Act Truth is that one step source that people go to
- 22:52when it goes to act to help educate people, help themselves get more in depth knowledge. As Nigel
- 22:57said, we do focus on nutrition as well, even though it's not our main focus, but it's all there. We
- 23:03got the environment bit, we have the health bit, but obviously also the animals. And we also
- 23:09are beyond that have resources that help people. Okay. I learned all this crazy stuff. What do I
- 23:14do next? What's happening now? And I think that's what is unique about Act Truth. And then with
- 23:20their rituals, we try to go down a similar route. It looks very similar to Act Truth if you compare
- 23:25those two. But I think that's what's the main effect that people now had a resource at hand
- 23:30they can use to educate people and point people towards to learn. What I love about Act Truth.com
- 23:39is you can personalize your approach education to the reality of egg production. You don't have to
- 23:51sit there and have to watch one hour of footage like you would do with Dominion. You can really
- 23:59take your time. And also it is referenced. And like you said, there are different arguments for
- 24:08different people. Nigel, you were talking about the health arguments. I'm one of those people who
- 24:14don't believe that the health arguments are very convincing, but I've met vegans who were very,
- 24:24you would not have made them vegan with ethical arguments, but the health arguments resonate with
- 24:33them. And then later on, they educate themselves on the ethical aspect of the whole vegan movement.
- 24:42And yeah, I think it's a great initiative and it is a great idea. Julie, why were you attracted
- 24:53to working for the Truth organization? I mean, this is a job where you're exposed to lots of footage
- 25:02of animals being literally tortured. It's tough on your mental health. So what attracted you
- 25:14and why did you decide to get engaged professionally with the Truth organization?
- 25:23Yeah. So as I mentioned, I started off dropping dairy first and that's when I started doing
- 25:27research and that's when you automatically end up with all these organizations that educate yourself
- 25:32and you end up with the animals. And then through my job search, I found Act Thruz and
- 25:37How does with many vegans that you have this aggression, passionate first, where you learn
- 25:42all these cruelties like, oh my God, I did not know we have to change the world. How do I help
- 25:47change the world? Kind of like that mindset. I think that happens to many vegans. You want to
- 25:52help change it. And obviously with the job posting that I found with Act Thruz, it looked like an
- 25:57opportunity to be part of that change, to help put it to an end. And I liked Act Thruz for the
- 26:01reasons I mentioned earlier, it focuses on one thing because especially if you start out new,
- 26:05it's overwhelming. Like all the different aspects of food, the food industry and all the different
- 26:10animals involved and tortured, it's just so complex. So having it reduced down to the
- 26:15chickens and to the eggs was very helpful for me to then also educate myself on that topic.
- 26:19And they kind of were a gateway then to learn about all the other aspects. And you're right,
- 26:25the footage you see every day is horrendous. It's awful. And especially me in the position
- 26:32where I post, where I try to educate people and where you learn that people react to the
- 26:36cruel ones more than to the cute ones. You are then also always on the search for cruel images.
- 26:42Like I have to look, I can't say, okay, I've seen enough. That's all I need to know. And
- 26:47I can go out and educate. No, I have to keep going back. I have to find new investigations to keep,
- 26:51you know, that in people's minds, like this is still ongoing. Like you saw this one, but it's
- 26:55still happening. And all these campaigns, there's still cruelty happening. They're still tortured.
- 27:00If there's a cage or not, it's still horrible. So I have to go back to all this footage every day.
- 27:04And as bad as it is, to be honest, you know, what's worse that you tell people all this,
- 27:09you show them the images and they don't care. This is so much harder than it looks.
- 27:14You show them the images and they don't care. This is so much harder and so much traumatizing
- 27:19to me, especially when it comes to friends and family where you think they're on your side,
- 27:23they take your stand. They understand. They would totally agree that abusing and exploiting an
- 27:28animal should not be done under any circumstance if it's not needed. And we do not need X to survive.
- 27:35And then they're like, yeah, but I like it. And that's the end of it. And you're like,
- 27:40and that makes it harder and more traumatizing, to be honest, that you are against those walls.
- 27:47And that's the cruel part. But that's also a part that motivates me to do a better job and to look
- 27:52at it from different angles and to find different ways of presenting the information to get through
- 27:57to people, because it's a very individual choice and a very individual journey for everyone. And
- 28:03people respond to different messages differently. And sometimes it's just a tiny seed you plant,
- 28:08something that just stays in the back of their head. And you keep bringing back messages.
- 28:13But yeah, that's the challenge. But definitely, yeah, you have to take a step back sometimes,
- 28:19because you can what they call over witness. But it's also what brings me back and what keeps
- 28:25me going and what keeps me motivated and what will hopefully keep me going until we see actual
- 28:31change. Well, let's talk about the negative reaction to your initiative. You know, I recently I was
- 28:39posting on Instagram and the algorithm just put me on the radar of a lot of, I guess,
- 28:47let's call them anti vegans. And all of a sudden, you know, my posts were flooded with people,
- 28:53you know, posting images of meat and talking about obscure studies on how my brain would shrink
- 29:02because of my vegan diet. And, you know, it felt ridiculous. It felt a bit funny, but it was also,
- 29:11you know, a bit disturbing. So did you have any of that?
- 29:18Honestly, it's it's actually more happening on our dairy through platforms.
- 29:21People feel more threatened if you tell them to, you know, stop eating cheese. But when it comes to
- 29:29eggs, it's what what happens more is that people come forward, say, oh, but I have backyard chickens
- 29:34and I'm nice to the chickens. So I have have good eggs. So that comes out first. And that really
- 29:40isn't isn't helping in our argument, because from our point of view, is it still exploiting the
- 29:45animals, you still use an animal that has been bred to lay eggs more than is necessary for
- 29:51for them in nature to like, you know, keep their their group and their species alive. So you still
- 29:55like abusing them and you're still helping the egg industry making eggs looks like a natural and nice
- 30:01and like cute little food, you know, from the cute little hen. So that's more happening on
- 30:07X-Ruice. Of course, there are sometimes people that say, oh, yeah, I love to eat chickens. And
- 30:11they post a picture of a roast chicken. But I mean, it's understandable if you
- 30:15if you confront people with something like this, something they've grown up with. And I see it in
- 30:23the children books that I read to my son, like you see the cute little farm and there's a hen and
- 30:28there's a cow and there's a pig and they're all happy there. And you know, they eat and they're
- 30:31just there there. And there's nothing else to it. But that's how we grew up. We learned that those
- 30:35animals, they live on farms. And they're happy on that farm. And then as you grow older, you never
- 30:41give it a second thought because those pictures kind of continue throughout the supermarket, right?
- 30:45It's on the labels, it's on the pictures above the shelves. So it's just a continuum. If then
- 30:49someone comes out, yes, look at that picture. That's the actual truth. People obviously feel,
- 30:54you know, offended. It's like, you know, we're not one to point fingers and say you are the cause of
- 31:00and because of you just take and die because I don't think it's very effective. But that's how
- 31:04people feel if you're threatened in their food choices and what many people do if they feel
- 31:08threatened, they fight back. Right. And usually it comes in with those crazy arguments and they
- 31:12find those ridiculous studies or whatever argument they bring forward just that they're able to hold
- 31:17on to their world feels like no, I'm right. I'm right. And here, this is why. And sometimes it
- 31:22looks very desperate, especially for us vegans who have been in this fight, so to speak, for many
- 31:27years. You've seen it repetitively brought up certain crazy arguments. But yeah, as I said,
- 31:36it's more it's people feel more threatened about their cheese than about their eggs. So we have
- 31:40bigger problems on dairy truth and bigger arguments. And for some reason, more farmers come forward
- 31:47that feel threatened because obviously we say that their industry has to be stopped, shouldn't be
- 31:52subsidized and so forth. And then the farmers come forward and they tell you all about it and that
- 31:57you have no idea. And because you're not a farmer, you are not allowed to speak about cows and what
- 32:02makes them happy and not. So that's more happening on dairy for some reason. Yeah. And we will talk
- 32:09about dairy truth later. But this is a great segue for my next question, which is what do you think
- 32:18of the clean and innocent image of the egg production industry? You know, this when I go
- 32:27to the supermarket and I look at the place where they put all the eggs, you know, it's white,
- 32:34it's clean. There are cute images, like you said, of chickens in the farm. And it's such a contrast
- 32:44with what you can find on eggtruth.com. So what do you think of that, of that whole marketing to
- 32:53just sell the eggs and that cultural image of the egg production? Nigel, would you like to comment?
- 33:05Yeah, I think it's great marketing, smart marketing, clever advertising. They are literally taking
- 33:20something that is ugly and violent and where there's immense suffering. And they have turned
- 33:32it into something that is welcomed, happy, wholesome, family oriented. I mean, you could go on
- 33:41with all sorts of adjectives. This is not by accident. This is by intention. The egg industry
- 33:49as the dairy industry have access to millions of dollars, not only in government subsidies, which
- 33:55they'll deny tooth and nail they receive any, which is an outright lie. And through checkoff
- 34:03programs, which is a hidden fee inside the eggs and dairy and the supply chain between the
- 34:08wholesaler and the retailer. Some of that money goes back to the national or provincial lobby
- 34:14groups to spend money on advertising. They go into schools, they develop educational programs.
- 34:22It's all by design. It's not by accident or anything. So, and to be quite honest, if I was
- 34:33head of an ad agency or head of creative for an ad agency or the lobby group, and I have a product,
- 34:40I have a product, there is a problem with it. How do we get people to consume it? And how do we get
- 34:47people to consume more of it next year than they did this year? And so you have to sanitize it in a
- 34:56way that people aren't going to think that you're trying to pull the rug over their eyes, but you're
- 35:04going to position it in such a way that, you know, encourages them and makes them feel good about
- 35:09buying it. And, and you know, it's interesting. I remember many, many years ago, I'm going to be
- 35:19dating myself here, but I used to get TV Guide magazine in the home, like millions of households,
- 35:26and it had your entire TV schedule for the week and TV Guide, but there was always BDS articles
- 35:31in there. And there was an article in there, one issue, and it was by an orthopedic surgeon.
- 35:38And the orthopedic surgeon described what would happen if you saw, if two men got into a fist fight,
- 35:49just like what you see on television. So the topic was violence on television and what you're seeing
- 35:57on television. And he would describe a television fight as this endless brawl with fists flying,
- 36:04it would go on for several minutes, chairs, and you know, and then he said in real life, what would
- 36:10happen, he would describe it clinically. He would refer to the bone in the hand that would crack,
- 36:16it might protrude through the skin. He depicted this ugly reality of what a simple fist fight
- 36:23would look like. And it would be over in 30 seconds, less so. And he said, the problem is,
- 36:28is that we as a culture take violence and we sanitize it because we want to sell it to other
- 36:36people en masse, whether it's in the form of entertainment, whether it's in the form of food,
- 36:42it doesn't matter. You show people the truth, the reality, they don't want to know. Show, lie to me,
- 36:50and show me something else. And I'll feel good about consuming it, whether again, whether it's
- 36:56watching violence or, and look, I consume entertainment like most people, but I know
- 37:04it's, you know, when I see, I know when I see real violence, you see the war in Ukraine,
- 37:08that's really disturbing. That's really upsetting and it should be, but we've sanitized it in our
- 37:14society. And so it's natural that they would do the same thing in terms of food. So, you know,
- 37:23through social media, through social media advertising, and we, you know, pockmark the year
- 37:29with small social media ad campaigns, but they're out there. We do do them. And occasionally we do
- 37:35some bigger campaigns if we can, you know, get the fundraising or the funds to execute a bigger
- 37:42program. But, and that's what we try to do sometimes is go into their domain, which is the
- 37:48advertising realm where they are have unfettered access and no one ever challenges them to go
- 37:53there and say, uh-uh, that's not what it's like. This is what it's like. Go to egg-truth.com or
- 38:00dairy-truth.com, learn the truth. And, um, and like Julie said, you're going to get people who,
- 38:09um, you know, will fight you tooth and nail, uh, you know, and, you know, I, I even, I remember I
- 38:15had somebody recently on egg truth, uh, posting about, uh, maybe it was, I shared the website.
- 38:22So I always see when I see anything news or posts, I'll share the website wherever again.
- 38:27And somebody said, well, it's, you know, they were talking with such authority that there's no way
- 38:32that a chick can be sexed. It's impossible. They can't sex a child. They can't have sex with a
- 38:37child. It's impossible. They can't sex a chick. What are you talking about? You're lying. And I'm
- 38:42like, dude, that's exactly what they call it. Sexing. There's a room where, where people sit
- 38:49around a table, a table where the chicks come in, they pick up the chicks, the male goes down one
- 38:55shoot and the female goes down another shoot. They're trained to sex the chicks, you know, so
- 39:00the people will, will just, just, just pull out the complete opposite reality and present that as
- 39:08if that's just a indisputable fact. Um, so, but again, like you said to your question, um, uh,
- 39:16I don't fault the industry for presenting it the way they do. Uh, their job is this is, this is,
- 39:21this is what it's about. It's about money. It's about their members. It's about supporting industry,
- 39:26growing in the industry, and they're doing what they should do as a for-profit industry to promote
- 39:32it. Um, uh, you know, moral and ethical issues aside, but in a free and open society that needs
- 39:41to be challenged. It should be challenged. And we do get pushback. Like when we, I can tell you lots
- 39:47of stories about outdoor ad companies who, who really, you know, um, um, refuse to run ads, you
- 39:56know, are antagonistic, outright belligerent because they, they don't want to give, they don't
- 40:03want to give an opportunity for another voice to come into the marketplace and present something
- 40:08that the only, the one side has had, you know, uh, generations, uh, an opportunity to do unopposed.
- 40:14What, what I find interesting, um, when you started a podcast, you brought up that, um,
- 40:19that, that article that talks about that if many years from now we would dig up the earth,
- 40:24we would find so many chicken bones that it may seem that chickens must have ruled the world at
- 40:29that point, which is our point right now. And that's the crazy part. How many chickens do you see in
- 40:34your daily life, considering the billions of chickens that are out there that are raised for
- 40:38meat that are used for, for eggs you don't. And even if you, um, go to the supermarket, there's
- 40:45one chicken on that packet, right? And even if you go beyond that and you go on their website
- 40:50from the egg industry with certain egg farmers, it's mostly about the egg farmer. They might show
- 40:55the farm and then a couple of hens, but the sheer size of it, the millions and millions of hands
- 41:03that are locked away for this industry, you'll never get to see this. And that's, and that's the
- 41:07crazy part, um, that we never get to see them, you know, like, um, I think, um, Ed Winters, the
- 41:13earthling at said, uh, posted the other day that, you know, people mostly meet those animals, what
- 41:19we call farm animals on a plate. They never see them in real life. They never touch the hen. They
- 41:23never see a hen or a cow or a pig or whatever it is. And, and that is the crazy part. And it's
- 41:28obviously used in our marketing scheme and used to keep the narrative alive, the narrative of like,
- 41:33this is a farm animal and this is one we keep at home. This is okay to eat because of the
- 41:37because of that. And, and yeah, you see that on the packaging and it helps people as much as that
- 41:42to feel good about it. You feel good about buying eggs because it feels wholesome. It feels natural.
- 41:47Um, yeah. I always say I can forgive the consumers for, you know, the cultural, uh, conditioning for,
- 41:56you know, that marketing, but what about the executives, you know, the, the people running
- 42:02those ads, uh, the people running those, uh, industries from their, uh, offices. Um, have you
- 42:10ever had any interactions with them? And do you know if they are aware of the harm they are causing?
- 42:19So me personally, I have spoken to someone. Um, and the crazy thing is they grew up with the same
- 42:27narrative. They grew up in the same cultural setting where this is a farm animal and this is
- 42:32why it's okay. That what you do to them. Um, and obviously as I said, they are, they are with an
- 42:37economical interest, right? They want to make money. And so that will always be their point of
- 42:42view. That will always be the set of glasses they look through and they look at the hands.
- 42:46And, um, the question is, do they even think it's cruel? Do they even think it's bad to do that to
- 42:52the hands? Um, does it matter? Um, and then, you know, they also have cognitive dissonance, you know,
- 42:59um, they also can compartmentalize this. They might even call themselves a good farmer if they
- 43:04implement a couple of more welfare, uh, rules on their farm. Um, so I think they fall for the same
- 43:12cultural and narrative, uh, upbringing that the consumer falls too. Um, and the economic
- 43:20investment that they have in a farm probably helps to keep them there. And it's hard to,
- 43:25to move away in that if you invested your life savings on a farm and now it has to, you know,
- 43:30pay the bills and help raise your children and maybe they even step up to take over.
- 43:36So there's so many aspects to it that kind of help them to stay and keep doing what they're doing.
- 43:42I think, um, there are a few farmers that do kind of have this epiphany and wake up one day and say,
- 43:48what am I doing? And that's very single cases and they're out there and they speak
- 43:53about the cruelty that's going on and what's really happening and, um, what it means for the
- 43:57animal that, but that's a minority and, um, probably often not heard and not, you know,
- 44:02pushed out there in, uh, in the public media. Well, let's, yeah, I, I, sorry, I'll just add,
- 44:09you know, um, when you mentioned executives, you know, there's the ad execs and there's the,
- 44:14the execs of these companies. Um, you know, my wife, when she was with mercy for animals,
- 44:20they did an investigation of West. Um, and it was, uh, you may recall it, it was where
- 44:28they had video of the farm workers who catch the chickens and put them in the slam them in the
- 44:32crates and put them onto the trucks. And there's a firm that whose business is, is as, as a
- 44:38contractor to do that. And there was workers caught on camera, literally slamming the, picking up
- 44:46the chickens by the legs and slamming their heads against the wall and on the ground. One was, uh,
- 44:52uh, emulating or mock copulation with a chicken. Um, you know, just really horrible things.
- 45:00And the company was, um, I believe it was the brand was Lilydale, but the parent company was
- 45:06Sofina foods, which is located in Burlington, Ontario. Well, the owner of Sofina foods is Michael
- 45:12Latifi and Michael Latifi lives in, uh, the bridal path or Rosedale somewhere in Toronto,
- 45:18when a very wealthy neighborhood on a large estate, very wealthy, his son, Nicholas Latifi
- 45:25ended up racing for the Williams F1 racing team for three years. Um, and Sofina foods was
- 45:31sponsorship on, on, on the car for the team. Um, it was funded by Michael Latifi and you know,
- 45:38in many of my wife's previous investigations, when they go to the corporate company and say,
- 45:44Hey, this is what we've done. Some have stepped up and said, okay, I want them out of our supply
- 45:49chain done until that's fixed, you know, but even them, they all think it's an isolated incident.
- 45:56And Michael Latifi made no response. He left it to his PR people. They took the position. It was
- 46:03an isolated incident, even though there was another investigation involving Lily, Lilydale,
- 46:08brand turkeys also in BC. Um, uh, when you're in a Julie alluded to it, when you're that wealthy,
- 46:18when your livelihood and the income and, and, uh, is, is so dependent, um, uh, you either,
- 46:26you probably don't spend a lot of time visiting your suppliers. You don't walk into chicken
- 46:30barns. You probably don't go. Why would you, you know, that's for, that's for underlings to do.
- 46:35You know, you, you know, you were, you have this cognitive dissonance, the same as farmers do to
- 46:42some degree. Um, and it's a philosophical position, you know, um, some people are animals
- 46:49are for food, period. That's it. It'll never change in their minds. Um, like Julie said,
- 46:54sometimes you'll get the odd farmer who breaks away and says, I can't do this anymore. Um,
- 47:00there's lots of examples of that. And, um, I don't know, maybe the wealthier you become as a result
- 47:06of this exploitation of animals, uh, the more invested you are in maintaining that power
- 47:13structure, because it's, it's made you very, very wealthy. And, um, uh, I don't know, maybe it's
- 47:23a greater level of, of cognitive dissonance. Maybe it's not, maybe you just simply don't care.
- 47:30It's probably a number of things, but, uh, you know, it's a good question. And I, I don't know.
- 47:36I often wonder what goes through those people's minds because they do inevitably, they're going
- 47:42to see something on the news. They're going to see something, or even their kids, their kids got to
- 47:47come home at some point and say, dad, did you know this? You know, my friends at school said that
- 47:55this is what you do. This is, this video is one of your farms out in wherever, or maybe the kids,
- 48:02I don't know, maybe private schools, they know they don't do that so much. I don't know. But,
- 48:06uh, you know, they've, and look, there are examples of where an executive will change.
- 48:13Look at Canada goose, look at the protest they used to do outside of that guy's home, the owner
- 48:19of Canada goose. And I may be mistaken, but recently I think that they're in the next several years,
- 48:25they're going to eliminate, um, uh, coyote fur from their, from their coats, from their clothing
- 48:33wear. Now they haven't gotten to the goose down yet, but they're looking at getting rid of fur
- 48:38from coyote. So there are examples of those who were intransigent and then there are those who
- 48:45just, you know, do bow to public pressure. So got to keep it up.
- 48:50I used to be a volunteer for Oxfam and I remember Oxfam America would always target the employees
- 48:57of corporations they would go after. And I think that's something lacking among, uh, you know,
- 49:04vegan organizations and vegan activists to really target the employees and, uh, not just, you know,
- 49:11the, the consumers. Um, but let's get to the life of those chickens we have been talking about,
- 49:20uh, since the beginning of this episode, eggtruth.com has a section called life of a hen.
- 49:26And I would like to know, you know, what is the fate of the chickens exploited by this industry?
- 49:33Uh, what is, uh, their life like and why, yeah. And are they sentient? You know, this is something,
- 49:43um, I think at the most basic level, there are some people who don't even believe that
- 49:51animals are sentient. They don't think that they can experience pain. They think of them as machines.
- 49:58Um, so are they sentient? What is their life like in this, uh, industry? Um, yes, go ahead.
- 50:08Um, uh, to answer the first question, yes, they are sentient. Um, they are mammals. They have brains,
- 50:16they have central nervous system, they have pain receptors, they're conscious, they have memories,
- 50:22they have, um, uh, exhibit all the cognitive functions that we would describe as sentience.
- 50:29Um, on our, one of our blogs on egg-truth.com is, uh, one called the Cambridge declaration
- 50:36of consciousness. And this is a group of scientists and neuroscientists who had, uh, had had had
- 50:43an event a number of years ago at Cambridge university in the UK, in which all these scientists
- 50:50came together and basically said animals are sentient, even cephalopods. Um, and they, they
- 50:57have, they meet all the requirements for what we, what we deem to be sentience. And they actually
- 51:02pointed out, they singled out, uh, cephalopods and birds. And we've seen, you can go to YouTube and
- 51:10find countless examples of birds exhibiting extraordinary behavior from making tools and
- 51:16memory and so on. There's no question that they're sentient and ask anybody who rescues these animals.
- 51:25They form relationships, they purr when you pet them, just like a cat, they, um, and they,
- 51:33they respond to stimuli, compassionate, friendly stimuli versus aggressive and hateful stimuli,
- 51:41just like all living beings. So when people say these animals aren't sentient, they, they are
- 51:48just, they are, they either they're lying or they're, or they're fools. One of the two, I don't
- 51:53know which one it is in terms of their life. You know, 18 months is typically cited as the last
- 52:00of a female hen. Um, they're obviously all bred in commercial hatcheries. Uh, they're sexed,
- 52:08the males into the macerator, which is a giant stainless steel hopper with high speed spinning,
- 52:14spinning blades at the bottom. They all get dumped in there because males don't lay eggs and
- 52:18they're not ideal for raising for meat. Uh, what they call broilers are genetically engineered,
- 52:25selectively bred to produce large breasts and reach slaughter weight in 45 days. Those are not
- 52:30male chicks as in the egg industry. Females will get d beat often, uh, to prevent predatory behavior
- 52:39in confined spaces. Um, they'll get, sometimes they'll get their toes clipped. Usually the
- 52:44roosters do cause they'll tend to be aggressive when copulating with the, um, the females. Um,
- 52:50but, uh, they'll get vaccinated and they'll be sent to, um, uh, uh, temporary housing until
- 52:58they're mature enough, uh, to, uh, lay eggs, which they'll then be either on the same farm or shipped
- 53:04to another farm where they'll be housed for egg laying and that egg laying will take, you know,
- 53:11uh, they'll lay an egg every, you know, 24 to 30 to maybe to 36 hours.
- 53:16Um, they will, you know, often in Canada, certainly, uh, they'll often be finding confined
- 53:23in cages, maybe six or eight to a cage on a wire floor. Um, they'll defecate and urinate through
- 53:30the cage wire cage floor. They're usually built in a shape like this, so everything can fall down
- 53:35into the manure pits, but inevitably it gets in on the other cages and the birds beneath them.
- 53:40Um, they will, uh, have suffered feather loss, um, inactivity and, uh, being stationary for so long,
- 53:49they'll often develop fatty liver syndrome. Um, they can experience egg impaction where the egg
- 53:55gets stuck in their overduck, uh, their ovary, um, and, uh, the shell will soften, it'll get infected.
- 54:03They could have, um, prolapses where literally the reproductive organs just fall out of their body.
- 54:09They'll often die in the cages and then they'll end up, you know, workers will come along and,
- 54:14and, um, uh, take them out, throw them in the garbage. Um, they'll, like I said, they'll lay
- 54:22anywhere between 320 to 350 and some farms will lay about 300 to 350. Um, they'll lay about,
- 54:31um, 350 and some farms, there's one in Iowa now, one in Germany that have reached 518 months. Um,
- 54:39and you know, for clarity, birds lay eggs for reproduction only, uh, like in nature,
- 54:46look at your birds in the spring. When they come out in the spring, they may lay a clutch or two a
- 54:49season. That's it. Laying an egg every 30 hours is not natural. They have been selectively bred and
- 54:56genetically altered to do that. And that is a horrendous burden on their reproductive systems.
- 55:02Um, despite being supplemented with calcium, their bones will still become brittle in, in,
- 55:11in, in housing before they get transported and slaughter. Um, uh, I think compassion for world
- 55:17farming in the UK found that one third of all hands that go to slaughter either go to slaughter
- 55:22with either broken bones or have had broken bones that have healed improperly as a result. Um,
- 55:29then of course, the birds are hung upside down, throats are slit, put into scalding hot water
- 55:34tanks for de-feathering. Some of them are alive when they go into the scalding tanks and they come
- 55:40out and then go through the, um, have the dismemberment phase of the slaughter process.
- 55:46Um, some will argue that the male chicks have it easy because they're day old, but they're conscious
- 55:53and alive and aware. Uh, they're, they're what I think I may get this word wrong. They're coccicidial
- 55:59so that they're, when they're hatched, they're fully conscious and aware. Their eyes are open.
- 56:03Unlike, you know, other mammals where their eyes will be closed for a period of time and they'll
- 56:07squeak and you know, the mother has to make sure they all get milk. Chicks are born conscious. They
- 56:13even can communicate with the mothers in, while they're in the shell, they have, there's that
- 56:19evidence of communication. Um, so it's really the female hands that have, you know, uh, have the
- 56:26greatest duration of suffering and, and they're ultimately sent to slaughter. So it's, it's, um,
- 56:32uh, I don't know that if I sat around for a few hours, if I could think of anything worse in terms
- 56:39of my goal was to impose as much suffering and torture on an animal, you know, than what they
- 56:45do in the egg industry. Uh, maybe dairy, uh, you know, it's academic, whether you want to discuss
- 56:52whether dairy or eggs are worse, but they're both horrendous in my view, but eggs in particular is,
- 56:57um, is very nasty. Yeah. I think you can summarize by saying that the egg is sorry, not the egg,
- 57:03the hen, obviously the hen and all the other things are commodified. So from the first day
- 57:08is like, you know, naturally you see this fan on her nest sitting on her eggs until they hatch.
- 57:13But what do you have in the egg industry? You have crates and crates full of eggs. There's no mother
- 57:17hen around and they're in incubators. And that's where they, how their life starts. And that's
- 57:21goes from that tray to the next tray to the sorting to the cage and so on. It's just a commodity from
- 57:27day one, um, until their last day. And even the other aspect of the industry that people usually
- 57:32don't talk about are what they call the parent flock. So who lays these eggs, who, you know,
- 57:37someone has to lay these eggs that make the hens that layer eggs. And that's another aspect of the
- 57:41industry. That's absolutely cruel where you put a couple of roosters with lots of hens and they're
- 57:46like, you know, aggressively breeding to lay eggs, um, that then become our layer hens. And that
- 57:53aspect is just as cruel and they have just as a short of a lifespan and are what they call
- 57:58depopulated when they stop producing enough fertilized eggs. Um, and that's all part of the
- 58:04industry. And, and as you mentioned, we have that page on our website called the life of a hen. And
- 58:09this is one of the most visited pages on our websites. And there we obviously go into greater
- 58:14detail as a Nigel outline. We look at, um, the different housing systems and what that really
- 58:19means, um, for the hens and, um, to help people understand what's going on behind, uh, those sheds
- 58:26and, uh, to make a better choice and see that certain labels don't really make a difference
- 58:31in the lives of those hens. Yeah. Going back to that point on sentience, um, I had a guest, uh,
- 58:38Kennedy little from, uh, farm transition academy. And she made the point that a lot of those workers
- 58:45have a distorted view of animals because the animals they see have been broken. Um, their
- 58:53spirit has been broken. You know, they're traumatized creatures. And so they look at them
- 58:58and they don't see, uh, signs of, uh, you know, sentience, vitality or, or something like that.
- 59:05They see just the, this poor creature. And so maybe that's why they, they get the idea that
- 59:12this is just a machine. This is nothing more than, uh, an object. Um, I think also on that point,
- 59:20Brian workers often, especially if you're new, you're getting into chicken catching,
- 59:25you're a summer university student, or maybe you're living in a rural environment and your
- 59:29job opportunities aren't very broad. Um, you go working on a farm, there's almost, um, a necessity
- 59:36for those workers who have to desensitize themselves to the plight of the animals because
- 59:43they can't function on a daily basis. And we know from studies and research, um, that, you know,
- 59:51I'll cite Smithfield Foods down in North Carolina, a massive pig slaughter facility. It's now owned
- 59:57by a Chinese firm. Um, but workers there, you know, um, uh, managers of the company, they would have,
- 1:00:06they would have African-American employees, Indigenous American employees, and poor white
- 1:00:12employees. And they would literally pit the groups against one another. So there was racial conflict
- 1:00:17within the workplace. So certain groups would work in another area. One ethnic group would work in
- 1:00:22another area, but all eventually, you know, they wouldn't report their, their injuries because they
- 1:00:29would get taken off the line, fired. There was no medical support. So they would suffer some of the
- 1:00:34highest workplace injuries occur in slaughter facilities of any industry, anywhere. And they also,
- 1:00:41um, they also, um, uh, there are excessive crime rates, domestic violence in these communities
- 1:00:49where these massive slaughter factories are. This is no coincidence. These are people, again,
- 1:00:55some who have no other options for, for employment, go to work in these places and
- 1:01:02have, suffer either from PTSD, a lot of them do, unrecognized, undiagnosed, and, you know, they come
- 1:01:10home and, and they have this level of irritation and aggravation and even aggressiveness. Uh, they
- 1:01:16come home and, you know, you come home and the kids are screaming and the wife hasn't made dinner
- 1:01:22or whatever, you know, traditional households. You come home and you blow, you blow a fuse and somebody
- 1:01:30gets smacked around, somebody gets hit. These things, again, no coincidence. And these large
- 1:01:36companies, you know, um, they are responsible for the social ills that come out, come out of
- 1:01:44this industry. And there are many from health to mental health, um, workplace injuries and so on.
- 1:01:52And many of them, you know, especially in the United States, less so here, but it still happens
- 1:01:56here. Um, they have a responsibility for that. And, you know, even if you look at something like,
- 1:02:03uh, immigration issues, which in the States, it's all they ever talk about, build the wall,
- 1:02:08immigration. Well, you go down to Mexico or Central America, you can hear recruitment ads in print,
- 1:02:15on radio, in Spanish, all these massive slaughter companies trying to get people to come up to work
- 1:02:22and they'll even, they won't outrightly help them to get into the country illegally. But,
- 1:02:27you know, if you come in undocumented, they're not going to spend too much time asking you for
- 1:02:31your documentation. They are one of the biggest recruiters of illegal immigrants into any,
- 1:02:36many countries to work in these, in these slaughter facilities, because most American
- 1:02:42born citizens, as most Canadian born citizens, they don't want to do these jobs. They don't
- 1:02:46want to do this kind of work and undocumented or temporary foreign workers. They don't care. The
- 1:02:54employers don't care about them. They don't care about their PTSD. They, they're going to, um,
- 1:03:01they're going to use them up and spit them out because they know next season, they're going to
- 1:03:04get a whole new crop of temporary foreign workers or illegal immigrants. And that's where the,
- 1:03:09the connection between human rights and animal rights is, is, is very, very clear. I know that's
- 1:03:13a little off topic, but I just wanted to get that in there. It's, it's a pertinent point. Uh, you
- 1:03:18know, I always, I'm always shocked by how this industry is just bad on every level, you know,
- 1:03:26environmental level, human level, uh, of course, animal welfare. And, you know, sometimes I'm,
- 1:03:34I'm stuck with using some religious language, like this is evil. You know, this is an evil industry.
- 1:03:39Like there, there's no better word to describe this, uh, activity that, that we're, um, uh,
- 1:03:47doing as humans. Um, do you think it's possible? And you brushed off on that, uh, Julie, uh, do
- 1:03:55you think it's possible to have a humane egg production industry as, uh, many companies, uh,
- 1:04:01you know, market themselves to be, uh, you know, this, uh, chicken was raised, uh, free range and,
- 1:04:09uh, it was happy during its life. Um, and things like that we can read on, uh, on the packaging of
- 1:04:17those products. Well, question back, how would you define the humane aspect of this? What is humane?
- 1:04:24Do you have a definition? Well, we would need to ask them what is really humane. Why are they
- 1:04:32saying it is humane? Um, but I understand your point. So the problem is that it's not like many
- 1:04:40other labels or certification. There's no, uh, no official definition or official, um, regulation
- 1:04:47about it. And what I like to say when it comes to agony, I can choose like there is no right way to
- 1:04:52do the wrong thing. Right. Um, no, I don't think there is a humane way to produce eggs because it's
- 1:04:59intrinsically wrong to exploit that animal. As Nigel hinted earlier that the amount of eggs
- 1:05:05they lay, no matter the setting where she lays them, that is already the cruelty because she's
- 1:05:10been bred to do that. Um, hence develop over in cancer because of the over overly activities of
- 1:05:16their, um, in our organs. And there's just no way to do it. Right. Um, even if you look at backyard
- 1:05:23situations, they still rely on that breeding, uh, that came initially. They often also rely on,
- 1:05:30um, getting the chicks from hatcheries, which is still a cruel place where they kill the male chicks.
- 1:05:36Um, many, um, if you stay with the backyard situation are probably not willing to care for
- 1:05:44the animals that goes beyond them laying enough eggs, say they get, they get sick. First, they
- 1:05:49might be hard pressed to find a vet that has any knowledge about how to treat a chicken. Second,
- 1:05:54are they ready to spend say $500 on one vet bill? If they find one that treat them, are they ready
- 1:06:01to do that? I'd say many wouldn't because then they look at, okay, how many X does this hen produce?
- 1:06:07Is that worth the $500 for that one treatment? And then you go back to the commodification
- 1:06:13and you end up in the same situation, even if it's dialed down to a backyard. Um, and the worst is
- 1:06:19that even if the people that have those many Instagram accounts that, you know, share their
- 1:06:24perfect picture, perfect life of the few hens roaming around in their garden and being part of
- 1:06:28their little garden ecosystem, they just help people to feel good about eating eggs. They still
- 1:06:35feel good about if they buy the cage free supermarket egg, because they remember that video where that
- 1:06:40hen was so happy. And isn't that the same? Isn't that that where that came from? So I don't think
- 1:06:46there's a humane way to do it. And you know, the thing is we don't need to eat eggs. There is no
- 1:06:51reason why we have to fight for this industry to survive. We don't need eggs to survive. We don't
- 1:06:58need eggs to be healthy. We don't need eggs to have a complete, um, diet. So if we keep fighting
- 1:07:05for our eggs, then really what we're doing is saying, I like eggs and that's why I want to eat
- 1:07:09them. And that's why I'm okay with those animals going through whatever they're going through.
- 1:07:14And that what it comes down to, no matter if they're from a backyard operation or from a large
- 1:07:20large industry and cages or cage free situations.
- 1:07:25Um, yes, it's a really good point. Did you want to add something Nigel?
- 1:07:32Um, um, I, you know, Julie touched on backyard, uh, hence, and I think that's probably
- 1:07:42the one scenario where you'll get, um, um,
- 1:07:46um, people advocating for more than anything else in terms of this humane sort of scenario.
- 1:07:56And, uh, you know, look, do I think a hen living in a small backyard with a coop and
- 1:08:05places they can, you know, dust, bathe and pack off the ground and walk around
- 1:08:10that are, yes, inevitably going to lay an egg and the person who owns the home is going to
- 1:08:14eat that egg. Is that better than, you know, being in a battery cage? Um, yeah, I mean,
- 1:08:22let's be honest, it is better. Um, but again, as I may have alluded to earlier,
- 1:08:30you know, we can often discuss the issue of treatment and that's what this is about.
- 1:08:36When you bring up the issue of humane, it is an issue of treatment, which means
- 1:08:41regardless of the scenario, you are accepting that treating an animal as a commodity is using
- 1:08:50them as a resource for the sole benefit or utility of us humans. You're, you've already
- 1:08:56crossed that line and now you're into this discussion about treatment. So the, the issue
- 1:09:04of use is, is really, you know, the treatment compounds the initial harm. The primary harm
- 1:09:12is use. And like Julie said, you know, yeah, they're in a backyard, but they're still going
- 1:09:19to be laying an egg every 24 to 30 hours because they have 10,000 years of human intervention
- 1:09:25acting as an artificial agent for natural selection. And here we are, the 21st century,
- 1:09:31the 21st century, they're laying 350 up to 500 eggs in 18 months, which is, which is,
- 1:09:39anyways, it's, it's, it's, it's insanity. And, you know, I have this discussion on social media
- 1:09:46with people sometimes, and I always say to people, why did you get a backyard hen? Is it for you
- 1:09:53or is it for the hen? If it's for the hen, as you say, then my recommendation is, is to find an
- 1:10:00avian vet, take your, your hen to the avian vet and have a subcutaneous hormonal implant
- 1:10:09and they're readily available or so in Canada and the U S there's issues in the U S with the FDA and
- 1:10:16limitations on these hormonal implants, but they will prevent that hen from laying eggs for months
- 1:10:22and months. It isn't cheap, but you know, I mean, we all know a visit to the vet with our cat or
- 1:10:28dog and ended up with three or $400 just like that. So this was really no different. And that will
- 1:10:34result in egg laying cessation. And you talk to people on farm sanctuaries where they do this to
- 1:10:41prevent egg impaction, to limit the risks of ovarian cancer, which I forgot to mention in the
- 1:10:46life of a hen, Julie mentioned it earlier. So thank you for reminding me on that ovarian cancer,
- 1:10:52they had the highest rates of spontaneously occurring ovarian cancer of any species in the
- 1:10:57world. And that is because of their manipulated reproductive systems. So this implant will help
- 1:11:04them eliminate egg laying for months on end. It has to be renewed every so often, but if the hen
- 1:11:11and their welfare is a primary consideration, which they always say they are, and it's really
- 1:11:16not thereafter the eggs without the guilt, they want guilt free eggs, but it's, you know, and
- 1:11:22farm sanctuary workers will tell you time and time again, the difference in the animal's behavior,
- 1:11:27personality is dramatically is altered once these hormonal implants are put in, because
- 1:11:37this constant laying, this constant hormonal activity in their bodies to lay eggs almost daily
- 1:11:42takes a toll. I mean, and look at a pregnant human being, a woman, look what she goes through in nine
- 1:11:48months of gestation, look at the postpartum depression sometimes that they can endure
- 1:11:52after giving birth. So look at all the hormonal flux that goes on in a human being's body,
- 1:12:00woman's body during, you know, that period of time, think about it for a small animal,
- 1:12:05who's doing it every 30, 36 hours for, you know, for the rest of their lives, potentially. So
- 1:12:11to stop that would really be to the benefit from their, from a health perspective, and from their
- 1:12:17own well-being. So the answer is no, there is no humane scenario. It isn't humane. And you're still
- 1:12:26crossing that, that in what is in my mind, an impenetrable moral barrier with you cannot cross
- 1:12:34that line into accepting the idea that we can use other living beings for, for our own benefit.
- 1:12:41And maybe one last thing to add to that point. People often when they look at nitrocosm,
- 1:12:47guilt-free eggs, they think about, you know, the carton of 12 eggs, but eggs are in so many other
- 1:12:51products, you know, that you buy and no one looks at those eggs and where they come from. So there's
- 1:12:57a big part of that industry that feeds into that. And even if you spend an extraordinary amount of
- 1:13:03money to like happy or good eggs, you still are not free of all the eggs that are in those products.
- 1:13:10Same as when you go to a restaurant, you do not know where those eggs came from. So the best is
- 1:13:16if you really care for hands, if you really love hands, then just don't eat eggs. And we're
- 1:13:23recording this conversation, we're in the month of August. And it's often during autumn that we see
- 1:13:31people wanting to get rid of their hand, their backyard hand, because it stopped laying eggs.
- 1:13:38You know, there's a period of two years for those chickens where they're laying their eggs.
- 1:13:47And then after that period, they stop and often their caretaker just, you know,
- 1:13:55put them online on social media and try to find someone to take care of them. Yeah.
- 1:14:03So we mentioned on that point, Ryan, I'll just interject. You're right. And since a lot of
- 1:14:09municipalities across the country are starting to allow people to have and raise backyard hands
- 1:14:16and backyard flocks under the guise of, you know, local food, right. That's a good thing. Local,
- 1:14:22you know, less than 100 kilometers from your home, produce your own food. So municipalities,
- 1:14:27cities are now starting to allow this. And as you said, once they start to develop either health
- 1:14:32problems or their egg laying wains after 18 months, two years, I've read stories and Montreal SPCA
- 1:14:40was a perfect example saying, we're now starting to see people dumping hens. You know, it used to
- 1:14:46be just cats and dogs and the odd reptile. Now they're seeing birds and hens showing up
- 1:14:51because people don't want them anymore. So now that's that cost, that burden is now falling
- 1:14:55towards the municipality. Their local or regional SPCA body or entity has to deal with that. And of
- 1:15:05course, what ends up happening, it'll often get euthanized or sometimes they'll get rehomed. But
- 1:15:10you know, it's just the same pattern all over again, different species, but same pattern.
- 1:15:15Oh, yes. I'm based in Quebec here in Montreal. And, you know, when I talk to sanctuary, you know,
- 1:15:23vegan farm sanctuaries, owners, they often tell me that we're at full capacity. And every year
- 1:15:33there is just an army of new chickens, even roosters, looking for homes, looking for
- 1:15:41places where to and it started with this whole backyard trend. So yeah, it's a sad situation.
- 1:15:50We mentioned that egg truth is just part of, you know, it's one of the initiatives that
- 1:15:59the truth organization has launched. There is also dairy truth.com. And I would love to hear you
- 1:16:08talk, you know, say a few words about this platform. And I'm very curious about,
- 1:16:14is your organization planning on launching a new platform of the sort maybe about pigs this time?
- 1:16:25Go ahead, on the initial thought of why launching dairy truth, Nigel.
- 1:16:28Okay. Yeah, I guess, you know, again, it was, you know, once egg truth was up and running and,
- 1:16:39and, you know, the activities were, you know, in play, the social media channels were set up and
- 1:16:47I ended up thinking, okay, well, I can just simply replicate this. You know, I don't have to reinvent
- 1:16:53the wheel. So it'll, you know, be a lot easier to, to produce a website and social media platform for
- 1:17:02the other obvious, or at least to me, the obvious focus, which was, you know,
- 1:17:06the obvious focus, which was dairy. Because again, that whole, you know, transition and the
- 1:17:13experience of so many vegans is that is that dairy and eggs, you know, is one of the last sort of
- 1:17:22things that we recognize are problematic. And, and sometimes people give up dairy last, sometimes
- 1:17:30they give up eggs last, but again, everyone says, I only know when I first started this, I would have
- 1:17:36probably started there. So, and so the, you know, the, the, the one thing that I wanted to add to
- 1:17:44the, to the, to the dairy truth side of things was the environmental aspect, because dairy has a
- 1:17:49certainly much more significant environmental impact than on the egg industry. Both are not good,
- 1:17:56but dairy in particular is very, very troublesome. And we, we had a professor who's written on this
- 1:18:09subject many times provide the content for that page on our website. And again, as you'd mentioned,
- 1:18:19Ryan earlier, that there are some vegans, you know, who come to veganism by way of, you know,
- 1:18:24the animal welfare issue, some come from the health aspect, health and nutrition, some come
- 1:18:30from the environmental side. So this was an opportunity to, you know, put information out
- 1:18:38there that hopefully those who were, you know, whose main concern was environment would could
- 1:18:43find their way to a dairy free life as well. So, and having Julie on board, you know, this would
- 1:18:52this would double the work. And so I can't even remember now, Julie, whether we had dairy truth
- 1:19:00running at the time when you started or... No, you already knew that you wanted to launch it. And,
- 1:19:05and then when I was already working with Egg Truth, I think it was just, it just fit the overall theme
- 1:19:11that as Nigel mentioned, also the last big obstacles for vegetarians usually become vegan.
- 1:19:16And again, with the idea that really single out that one industry, because to every of these
- 1:19:22industries, there's so many layers, so many aspects to it that we mentioned the workers,
- 1:19:26we mentioned environment, there's so many parts of it. And I find it hard to give it justice and the
- 1:19:32space it needs and the information it needs on a website where you just put in all the farm animals
- 1:19:36and maybe then even animals for entertainment and, and so on and so forth. And I think that was the
- 1:19:40idea to have the basically the, yeah, the look and feel of the Egg Truth kind of, so people were
- 1:19:48familiar with that. And then just do that for dairy as well. And I think we had great responses. I
- 1:19:55think people really, really took to it and really liked it again as a source to share and point
- 1:19:59people to, but also to educate themselves on various aspects of the dairy industry. And there
- 1:20:04are so many, so many parts to it that are just so cruel and not even known to most people that
- 1:20:10don't even know that cows not continuously give milk. So we educate on a very basic level, but we
- 1:20:16also go really down into detail. And again, we also help people then to transition out of dairy. Like
- 1:20:23what do I eat and study? We're asking about our favorite cheese. We have a long list of products
- 1:20:28that are not to promote, they're not sponsored. It's just like here, if you want to replace it,
- 1:20:33if you can't give it up, those are great products you might look at and use. And that's on there.
- 1:20:38And what we also try is to highlight and share sanctuaries, which are a bit an important part
- 1:20:44of the vegan movement, a big part of educating and sharing animals and animals as individuals and not
- 1:20:50animals of like a mass in a crowded shed where it's easier to not care. It's harder to not care. If
- 1:20:59you see that one that has a name, but it has a story that has feelings, that has preferences
- 1:21:04and that you keep seeing on social media. And we're trying to give them space and to have their
- 1:21:09animals shown and heard and just help people to like fall in love with those animals. And if it's
- 1:21:16sometimes feels hard to not eat cheese, then go back to those animals and then you get reminded
- 1:21:21why you're doing it, why it's important to not eat that cheese that is made of dairy.
- 1:21:27And then so for the future right now, we're really focused on growing what we have right now,
- 1:21:32because I think there's still potential. We really see ourselves as that one step
- 1:21:36place where people go to educate themselves on eggs or dairy. As I said, usually they're just like,
- 1:21:42oh, just check egg throughs or just take dairy throughs. And I think there's still a place for
- 1:21:46us to grow that people see us at that resource. And then who knows what the future holds. I think
- 1:21:52it would make sense to stay in the space of maybe food, but not food that obviously is caused in
- 1:22:00slaughter. So I could think honey would be something like that, but there's nothing of this planned
- 1:22:04yet. It's just, as I said, I think it would make sense to stay in that part of the food industry.
- 1:22:10But as for now, we're just trying to push egg throughs in there, through out there,
- 1:22:16and try to be more present, find different ways of presenting the information and make people care
- 1:22:22and hopefully become vegan. And I encourage people to visit those two websites, eggthrough.com and
- 1:22:31dairytruth.com. I just want to correct you on that, Ryan. It's egg-truth.com and dairy-truth.com.
- 1:22:38I did try to get the other URLs and I couldn't. I've got some other ones too, like eggtruth.ca
- 1:22:46or dairytruth.ca and so on. I've got so many URLs that redirect to our website, but the eggtruth.com
- 1:22:53one actually was, I think it was a pig farm in Iowa, had that URL. For some reason, I have no idea
- 1:23:00why. I did try to get it, but I couldn't. So I had to put the dash in there. And like I said,
- 1:23:06we have other iterations of the URLs that redirect there, but yeah.
- 1:23:09Well, the links will be in the description. And I know that they are essential tools for me.
- 1:23:15Like you said, Nigel, earlier, I like to just post the link instead of starting to argue my way with
- 1:23:26people. I wish it was translated in French because I have many friends here who speak French and
- 1:23:32would benefit from reading egg-truth.com in their native language.
- 1:23:41Well, it's interesting that you should say that. And Julie's right. We're going to just stay focused
- 1:23:50on egg-truth.com and dairytruth.com for now, continue to grow those social media platforms,
- 1:23:57try to create awareness about those resources. But yeah, having the website in other languages
- 1:24:08is certainly something that's down the road. Interestingly, when I did the
- 1:24:17outdoor ad campaign back in 2018 or 2019, spring, the number of inquiries I had from around the world
- 1:24:28where they wanted the poster that was created, but they wanted it in their language. So I said,
- 1:24:34okay, you send me everything in, whether it's Spanish, I think we did Spanish, Italian,
- 1:24:44Polish, and we didn't do a French one, but we did a number of them. And I basically recreated the
- 1:24:54posters in those languages and sent them to creative that they could print however big or small
- 1:24:59they wanted. And so one of the languages that we may look at doing initially is, well, certainly
- 1:25:08French, but Spanish, because Central and South America is massive markets. And yeah, that's
- 1:25:17something that certainly should be in the pipeline. And even although Australians speak English too,
- 1:25:28the brochure that we had for that campaign, I had a couple of farm sanctuaries in Australia,
- 1:25:34who wanted it. And I said, well, I said, you can have it. I said, but it actually references a hen
- 1:25:40that lives at Happily Everest or farm sanctuary in Campbellville, Ontario. And it mentions
- 1:25:47famous celebrities in Canada who were vegan, Brian Adams, and the hockey player, George LaRocque,
- 1:25:55and some other ones that, and a figure skater came figure skater. So I'd have to go to the
- 1:26:01Australianize that for you. So they sent me information and pictures of a hen that they
- 1:26:07had at a sanctuary and mentioned some Australian celebrities who were vegan. So I Australianize
- 1:26:12the brochure and just sent it to them to give it to them to print and use however they wish.
- 1:26:17Because at the end of the day, collaboration and sharing of all this information is really
- 1:26:24an important part of what we do. And when I see an egg truth post, like I'll see,
- 1:26:31I'll remember even before Julie came on board and I was doing memes every day and designing memes,
- 1:26:36I designed a meme and I put it out there. And two years later or three years later, I see like,
- 1:26:40I don't know, Jean Bauer from farm sanctuary sharing it with a comment. And of course,
- 1:26:45Jean Bauer is going to get like, you know, 15, 20,000 likes and reactions to it.
- 1:26:49That's that makes me feel great because, you know, I love to see it. Other people posted
- 1:26:57people I don't even know some I do some I don't. But our goal is to as a resource, like you said,
- 1:27:04you use it as a resource for people who were either active animal rights activists and advocates or
- 1:27:11people who were passive and on social media and don't always have the right media to share it.
- 1:27:16And on social media and don't always have the right words or how to argue or take a position.
- 1:27:21You can just simply say, here, I think you should read this, you know, and that's that's great.
- 1:27:28As long as, you know, it can be a resource for resharing.
- 1:27:33That's tremendous. I can reach so many people.
- 1:27:37I love hearing that. And I'm so grateful that you're working so hard on those two initiatives,
- 1:27:43you know, it's so it's done by experts. And it's not, you know, we see a lot of pseudoscience in
- 1:27:52vegan circles, you know, a lot of unfiltered articles and things said about the industry.
- 1:27:59And I like to see to have trust in a in a tool like yours. So thank you so much for working
- 1:28:08so hard on egg-truth.com and dairy-truth.com. And before we end this conversation, did you want to
- 1:28:19add something? Well, as you said, we have the website, but we also very active on social media
- 1:28:24because for the website, people actively have to want to educate themselves. But I think we're also
- 1:28:30out there to get the people that might need a little push. And so we're very active on social
- 1:28:36media. We're on all the known platforms on Facebook, Instagram, Twitter, and now the new
- 1:28:42threat. We're all out there so people can find us there same name. And we're happy for people to
- 1:28:49check us out to share us to just reference us. And that's a big part of our advocacy to like
- 1:28:57actively go out and actively put the content in front of people, hoping that even if they don't
- 1:29:03reply, even if they don't share their story, but hoping to plant some seeds in the back of the
- 1:29:07heads and hopefully convince people that it might be better if we leave eggs and dairy off our plates.
- 1:29:14I hope so. I truly hope so. I'm rooting for you from the bottom of my heart. Thank you both of you
- 1:29:21for having taken the time to answer my questions, share your insights. Thank you so much. Thank you
- 1:29:28Ryan very much. It was a pleasure. And we're hoping to do something a bit more
- 1:29:36public in the fall. We're working on some things right now that hopefully we'll certainly let you
- 1:29:45know or give you the heads up if it happens. And so you can actively share and promote that with
- 1:29:51your listeners. But again, yeah, thanks for having us on. Thank you everyone for listening. What an
- 1:29:56amazing conversation this was. I am so grateful that the truth organization exists. I invite you
- 1:30:03to share this episode with your community. They need to learn what is happening behind the scenes
- 1:30:10of the egg industry. And finally, let me know if you liked this conversation, leave me a good review
- 1:30:18or reach out on Instagram at vegan report podcast. Thank you again for listening. Take care and see
- 1:30:26you next Tuesday for a new episode.