Latest / Marketplace Businesses with Fexingo: Two-Sided Networks, Liquidity, and Take Rates / How Vinted Built a Marketplace Without Charging Listing Fees
Transcript
- Lucas: If you have ever listed a used sweater on Vinted, you probably noticed something strange — you listed it for free. No listing fee, no final value fee, nothing. Vinted makes its money entirely on the buyer side. Luna: That is almost the opposite of how most peer to peer marketplaces work. eBay, Poshmark, Depop — they all charge the seller a commission. Lucas: Right. And that choice is not just a pricing quirk. It is the strategic foundation of how Vinted solved the cold-start proBlem. So let us step back. Vinted launched in Lithuania in 2008, founded by Milda Mitkute and Justas Janauskas. The premise was simple — a place to sell clothes you no longer wear. But they hit the classic chicken and egg problem: buyers would not come without listings, and sellers would not list without buyers. Luna: And the standard marketplace playbook is to subsidise one side to attract the other. Uber subsidised drivers with guarantees. Airbnb subsidised hosts with free photography. Vinted subsidised sellers by not charging them at all. Lucas: Exactly. But here is the twist — Vinted did not just waive listing fees temporarily as a promotion. They made zero seller fees a permanent part of the model. That was a bet that the supply side was the harder side to unlock in secondhand fashion, and that once you had supply, demand would follow. Luna: And it worked. Vinted grew to over 80 million members across Europe, and in 2024 they reported revenues of over 600 million euros. But almost all of that revenue comes from a single source: the buyer protection fee. Lucas: Which is typically between 3 and 8 percent of the item price, plus a fixed fee. The buyer pays it at checkout. So the seller walks away with the full listing price. That structure removes a major friction point for sellers — the mental tax of 'How much will I actually get after fees?' Luna: And that mental tax is huge. Research on peer to peer markets shows that fee salience disproportionately affects seller listing behaviour. When sellers see a commission, they either inflate the price to compensate or they do not list at all. Lucas: Right. And for low-priced items — which is most of secondhand fashion — a 10 to 20 percent commission can eat a meaningful chunk of a 10-euro sale. Vinted essentially said: we will collect the fee on the side where the transaction pain is lower — the buyer, who is already in a purchasing mindset. Luna: But does that put too much friction on the buyer? I mean, you are checking out and suddenly there is an extra fee. Lucas: That is the risk. But Vinted mitigates it in two ways. First, the fee is transparent at checkout — it is shown as a separate line, not hidden. Second, the buyer gets something for it: Vinted holds the payment in escrow until the buyer confirms the item arrived as described, and they offer a purchase protection policy. Luna: So it is framed as insurance, not a tax. That makes a difference psychologically. Lucas: Exactly. And the numbers suggest buyers accept it. Vinted's take rate — the percentage of gross merchandise value they keep — is around 15 to 20 percent, which is actually higher than many seller-commission marketplaces. Poshmark takes 20 percent from sellers on sales over $15, but Vinted achieves a similar take rate entirely from the buyer side. Luna: Which is remarkable because the seller side is usually where marketplaces extract more margin. Vinted flipped that. Lucas: They did. And the result is that Vinted has some of the deepest supply liquidity in secondhand fashion. On any given day, there are millions of listings — dresses, shoes, kids' clothes — and the variety is enormous. Because there is no cost to list, sellers put up items they might not bother with on eBay or Depop. Luna: I have seen people list things for one euro. That would be pointless on a platform that takes a 50-cent listing fee. Lucas: Right. And those low-priced items actually create a positive network effect for buyers — they see a huge selection at very low prices, which draws them in. Then once buyers are on the platform, they discover higher-priced items too. Vinted's data shows that the average basket size is actually higher than on many competitor sites because buyers bundle multiple items to offset the fixed portion of the buyer protection fee. Luna: So the fee structure incentivises buyers to buy more items per transaction. That is a clever behavioral design. Lucas: It is. But Vinted's model also created a challenge: how do you expand into new markets where buyers are less accustomed to paying fees? In the UK, for instance, buyers are used to free shipping and no surcharges. Vinted had to educate the market. Luna: How did they handle that? Did they lower the buyer fee initially? Lucas: They did not lower it permanently, but they used promotions — free buyer protection weekends, for example — to get people comfortable with the platform. And they invested heavily in logistics: they partnered with shipping carriers to offer discounted labels, so the buyer sees a lower total cost even with the fee. Luna: So the bundling of shipping and protection fee into one line item made the fee feel smaller? Lucas: Exactly. The buyer sees a single 'total with fees' amount, and the shipping is included in that. That reduces the sting of an itemised fee. It is a small UX choice but it matters. Luna: Now, Vinted is not the only marketplace that tried the zero seller fee route. Let's talk about a few that failed. Lucas: Sure. There was a company called Covet, a fashion marketplace that tried no seller fees in 2020. They raised venture funding, but they could not achieve buyer density fast enough. Without seller fees, they had no revenue from the supply side, and their buyer protection fee was too low to cover operating costs. They shut down in 2022. Luna: What went wrong? Was it just not enough buyer volume? Lucas: Partly. But also, they did not have the logistics integration that Vinted has. Vinted's shipping labels are deeply embedded — you buy a label on the platform, and Vinted negotiates bulk rates. That creates a secondary revenue stream and a lock-in effect. Covet left shipping to the seller, which added friction and reduced the number of completed transactions. Luna: So the zero seller fee model only works if you have other monetisation levers and operational efficiencies. Lucas: Correct. And Vinted has another lever: they offer optional promotional tools for sellers — like bumping a listing to the top of search — for a fee. That is a small but growing revenue stream. But the core remains the buyer protection fee. Luna: Let's talk about the regulatory angle. In the EU, there is increasing scrutiny on digital marketplace fees. Do you see any risk that regulators might classify Vinted's buyer fee as a hidden charge? Lucas: It is possible. The EU's Digital Services Act and the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive require transparency. Vinted has been proactive: they display the fee clearly before purchase, and they have a dedicated page explaining what it covers. But regulators in Germany — Vinted's largest market — have been looking at this. In 2023, the German consumer protection agency Verbraucherzentrale challenged the fee structure, arguing it was not sufficiently transparent. Vinted settled by adding more prominent disclosures. Luna: So the model is not without legal friction. But it has survived so far. Lucas: Yes. And the reason it survives is that buyers perceive value. Vinted's buyer protection is actually quite good — if an item does not arrive or is significantly not as described, the buyer gets a full refund. That trust is essential for a peer to peer marketplace where you are buying from strangers. Luna: That trust is also what allowed Vinted to expand into categories beyond fashion — books, electronics, home goods. They have a general marketplace now in some countries. Lucas: Right. And in each new category, the zero seller fee model gives them an immediate supply advantage. If you are selling a used phone, why list on eBay where you pay 10 to 15 percent when you can list on Vinted for free? The buyer pays the fee, but the buyer is also getting protection. Luna: So the model effectively transfers the cost from the seller — who is price-sensitive and has low margins — to the buyer, who values protection and convenience. Lucas: That is the insight. And it is a lesson for any marketplace: the side that is harder to attract should be the side that pays less. For Vinted, sellers are the scarce resource — because secondhand fashion has low barriers to entry for buyers but high friction for sellers — listing takes time, pricing is uncertain. So you make it free for them. Luna: And you monetise the side that is already in a buying mood and can absorb a fee. That is the playbook. Lucas: Exactly. And honestly, if today was worth a coffee to you, that is the link — buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Luna: Yeah, listener support is what keeps this show ad-free and focused on the real mechanics. Lucas: So back to Vinted — the question is whether this model is replicable in other verticals. We have seen it in fashion, but what about furniture, or cars, or services? Luna: Cars seems hard — the transaction value is high, and buyers expect dealer-level protections. But for lower-ticket items, maybe. Lucas: Some marketplaces are trying. There is a platform called Vinterior for vintage furniture that uses a buyer premium model. But the challenge is that high-ticket items have more fraud risk, and the buyer protection fee would have to be large enough to cover that risk, which might deter buyers. Luna: So the model works best where item values are low to moderate, and where supply is the primary bottleneck. That seems to be the sweet spot. Lucas: And that is exactly the zone Vinted dominates. As of mid-2026, they are profitable in several markets and continue to expand. It is a case study in fee architecture as a strategic weapon. Luna: One last thought — what happens if a competitor copies the zero seller fee model? Can Vinted defend its moat? Lucas: They have a few advantages. First, brand: Vinted is synonymous with free listing in Europe. Second, scale: their logistics network and buyer protection infrastructure are expensive to replicate. Third, data: they know which items sell, at what price, and they use that to optimise search and recommendations. A copycat would need years to catch up. Luna: So the fee model is hard to copy in isolation. You need the whole system. Lucas: Exactly. And that is the real lesson: a marketplace's fee structure should not be an afterthought. It should be designed to solve your specific liquidity problem. Vinted's problem was seller liquidity. They solved it with zero fees. And they built an entire platform around that decision.