Latest / Deconstructing Horror / THE EXORCIST (1973) | Father Karras, Faith Deconstruction & Ontological Shock
Transcript
- Ryan Does: Hello everyone, we are gonna jump back into another horror analysis discussion ⁓ here on the channel in this episode. I am very, very excited ⁓ knock off a major horror bucket list item today. ⁓ that was ⁓ have finally seen The Exorcist. And I thought this was gonna be a movie that I was gonna build up to more, but ⁓ my guests today ⁓ and I were talking about like other movies we could do. ⁓ And Annie suggested another movie in the Exorcist franchise. I was like, have not seen the original Exorcist yet. So ⁓ this is where we are starting this journey and I'm excited to talk. About the Exorcist and themes of religion, good versus evil, kind of how how deconstructing faith works into this with ⁓ Annie DeRolf. Annie, I am so excited for this because we have kind of been planning this for a long time, very casually. And you are a teacher, so I want to get ⁓ want to get this done before the school year starts. ⁓ so I wondering if you could just tell people who you are and what you what you're doing ⁓ right now, what you find yourself doing in the world with. Annie: Yes, we have. Yeah. Yeah. Ryan Does: work and ⁓ yeah, tell us a little about yourself. Annie: Yeah. Yeah, well, Ryan, yeah, I echo the excitement. I'm so happy to be here and really excited that you've invited me and just thank you for having me. so so I'm Annie DeRolf. I ⁓ am occupational therapist. ⁓ currently working in education. So ⁓ I'm clinical faculty member at Indiana University Indianapolis. ⁓ Ryan Does: Okay. Annie: And so that's kind of part of the lens that I will be bringing in. ⁓ there is a little nuance between like occupational therapy and occupational science. And I will say I'm going to kind of be working within the occupational science aspect of it ⁓ in terms of how I was seeing the films. ⁓ but then also I'm up a Master of Arts in religion and theology. ⁓ so the last thing on my ⁓ list is just finishing. Ryan Does: Okay. Okay. Annie: This thesis. ⁓ And that's the perspective I'm coming from. Ryan Does: Okay. So I I have to get this out of the out of the way because you said Indiana University. Are you from the Indiana area? Are you like a lifelong Hoosier? Ooh. My Annie: I am, yes. But Ryan Does: My Iowa Hawkeye upbringing only just jealous of the fact that my football team almost beat the national championship winning team last year. but I I saw that in your bio and I was like, god, I have at least say it, or it's gonna be like, we were a touchdown from beating you guys, but no big deal, whatever. but I ⁓ Annie: Yeah. Ryan Does: my gosh. I Signetti is a vibe ⁓ with the with ⁓ the football coach over in Indiana. He's a total vibe. But anyway, ⁓ that aside, I ⁓ really to I I asked you to bring your lens to the Exorcist and ⁓ I ⁓ I'm I'm now having seen it for the first time. I had made that request before ⁓ Annie: Yes. Yes. Ryan Does: I had finished the film. So I was kind of like leading myself ⁓ forward and I think I I think this is gonna be perfect because so many lenses could be applied to the exorcist. ⁓ that's one of the things I really wanted to bring to these various conversations. Like these these films can be viewed a few different ways, and I I think the exorcist now having seen it is Annie: Yeah. Ryan Does: I get why it's so widely critiqued and why it's been written on so many different times and there are several different ways you can approach it. ⁓ I w I wanted to know before we dig into some details about the film, h what is your personal history with The Exorcist? How did it come into your life? Annie: Yeah. Yeah, my family is just very much a movie family. it very much like different movies through different times in my life almost were rites of passage. I mean, we really are that type of family. And a lot of like, ⁓ especially with a like this, there will be stories that accompany it, right? And so there's stories where ⁓ I've got a cousin who's like, I don't know, a a bit older than me. And my family loves to tell this story of when, you know, she was a toddler and at some family party it just happened to be on the television. And they just hear her like screaming when she looks at it. And so they're making fun of her and just kind of poking fun of like, you know, remember when Linda Blair's head turned all the way around? and so there was always like that kind of running story, but also my Ryan Does: Okay. Yeah. Annie: Dad, so this is kind of funny. my dad specifically would tell me growing up how ⁓ This had been the scariest movie that he had ever seen. He was a teenager at this time, and he went to the drive-in with ⁓ his girlfriend at the time. he was just talking about how it was so scary. And then he kind of had like the basement bedroom because my uncle was in Vietnam and whatever. ⁓ And he was like on the phone with her the whole night because they were both just ⁓ really out. But then in the last five, ten years, ⁓ he Ryan Does: ⁓ my god. Okay. Annie: It just conveniently, I guess, had left out that he was tripping while watching it for the very first time. So I I can only imagine seeing the exorcist in at the drive-in while tripping. You know, it was 1973, but Ryan Does: ⁓ a ⁓ a really good trip and I'm like, let's go to the movie. I don't even care what's playing. It's just like you create a core memory out of that. ⁓ Annie: So yeah. Literally, literally. So think for me, you know, like ⁓ had those stories and then of course that expectation of like this movie is gonna be the scariest movie I've ever seen. And then by the time I did, you know, of course it it didn't feel that way, but I can imagine ⁓ I been them and this is a new movie, I would have been I don't think I could have watched it, honestly. Ryan Does: ⁓ huh. Yeah. I well I know I know for sure I wouldn't have been allowed to. That that's that is for ab darn sootin'. ⁓ yeah, that would have that would have not happened. I and I can say like as as an adult now, like almost thirty six years old, I'm like ⁓ I had some trepidation where, you know, I I was telling you before we got started, ⁓ there's like I was like wa watching it and I was like, Okay, like is this turn into something or not? No ⁓ my gosh, that's actually Annie: Yeah, sure. Ryan Does: That's actually a lot scarier than I thought it was gonna be. But like this movie is also kind of weird to encounter for the first time as an adult later on, so much like fifty plus years after the film came out, because so much of it is just pop culture now. And it's just it's been parodied a thousand times and really like the possession, demonic possession genre. Annie: Sure. Yes. Yeah. Ryan Does: is it's it's like this movie it this is like the Jaws of possession movies you know every shark monster attack movie ⁓ Jaws is like ⁓ that's like lesser jaws ⁓ every possession movie I've heard after this is like ⁓ that's just like a play on the Exorcist. but I I ⁓ I I wanna jump into just a few details ⁓ and and then your brain about different aspects of ⁓ the Exorcist ⁓ Annie: Mm. Ryan Does: And what we can glean from that about religion and ⁓ belief systems and things of that sort. So this film ⁓ is based on ⁓ the book The Exorcist by William Peter Blady. He also was part of the ⁓ screenwriting process. ⁓ the producing ⁓ Friedkin directed it, and movie stars ⁓ Ellen Burston ⁓ and Linda Blair, Max Von Seidau. a young a young Max Van Seidau playing an old man. ⁓ that I could I as I as I saw him first I like, that guy looks nothing like Max Van Seidau. ⁓ and I and I it took me a minute to realize, ⁓ he's playing a younger Annie: Mm-hmm. Ryan Does: He's a younger man playing an older version of a character. Whatever. I I I've gotta stop being confused about this. just a fantastic ensemble cast. ⁓ this movie came out right around Christmas of 1973. So pack up everybody in the car and head off, you know, from is Exorcist a Christmas movie. Annie: Ha ha ha Yeah. Ha ha ha. Ryan Does: I don't know. It's like the the diehard question has to be asked, I guess. ⁓ the budget for this film was ⁓ around 12 million and it grossed just a truck ton. almost 450 ⁓ And I don't know if that is ⁓ just domestic here in the States or if that's global. Either way, that is a big return on investment, and that's been kind of a theme ⁓ of movie horror movies in 2026 of like Annie: Yeah. Ryan Does: Itty bitty budgets these massive, ⁓ box offices like with ⁓ ⁓ backrooms, especially. but ⁓ movie like The Exorcist and Texas Chainsaw in the 70s, like they did it first and they did it to a big degree as well. so the the the story of The Exorcist is rather simple, but ⁓ I will you a little bit of a ⁓ of a summary here ⁓ A ⁓ priest finds a pagan artifact in the Middle East and through a series of ⁓ interactions, a girl comes to be possessed by this entity. And this really the story of a a a unbelieving priest interacting this demonic entity and a mother ⁓ trying to hang to what's what's happening to her daughter. And and all these characters converge to do what is best and what is good ⁓ to save this girl. And some consequences towards the end, ⁓ ⁓ the girl is saved from this demonic entity ⁓ due to them performing a Catholic exorcism. ⁓ and ⁓ this this whole movie has so ⁓ it overtly religious in the the mechanics of it because we do use a a Catholic priesthood and we do use fathers in the Catholic Church to about our conclusion. ⁓ like ⁓ in broad strokes, ⁓ ⁓ your opinion, what does this movie say about religion in more like in a ⁓ widesweeping way? Annie: Yeah, I think it really touches on ⁓ how religion ⁓ or maybe we have the expectation that religion can and will help us make sense of our lives, ⁓ the suffering that we endure, all of us ⁓ in way or another. ⁓ but I think that also lends itself to this ⁓ crisis of ⁓ that, you we see ⁓ the priest Ryan Does: Yeah. Annie: And I think because at some level there's this failure to sense ⁓ like your everyday lived experience with the of God that you have or that you've been working with. ⁓ so I think it's a huge meaning making but also sense ⁓ making of ⁓ Ryan Does: S y you me you you mentioned Father Karis. ⁓ kind of our like he is our figure who is going through a prolonged dark night of the soul. As he's trying to find this the ⁓ meaning and the one the first lines he actually says to a fellow priest is, I feel like I'm losing my faith. Like we just ⁓ we drop into a bar scene and he just is he's already saying that. ⁓ Annie: Yeah. Yeah. Ryan Does: He feels entirely alone in his doubt and Reagan's mother, ⁓ Chris, she also feels isolated in the crisis she's going through as a mother. we start questioning our like inherited faiths, why that experience often feel so lonely? And ⁓ and does movie maybe say about how we how how processing that alone is different than processing it in safe spaces with other people? Annie: Yeah. No, it's such a such a good question and such a real question. because I do ⁓ you know, as someone who has, you kind of felt like I've gone through similar sorts crises at different points in my life, ⁓ it ⁓ really kind of feel unbearably ⁓ lonely. Like is just it it seems like a natural loneliness to it. and I think You know, maybe we'll probably even touch on it with like the other film with Mitsmar of like there was this emphasis on trying to tell Danny or Florence Pugh, right, like I understand you, my parents died too, right? Like there's this level of trying to connect. so I if I were to say why this can or tends to feel so lonely, I think ⁓ Ryan Does: Yep. Annie: A lot of people, if not most people, who are going through this period of like questioning their faith system, feel like before that point, there tends to be a very like subjective, like unique the person event ⁓ that sort of disruptive, ⁓ right? in terms of that sense making, like we talked about before, ⁓ right? Ryan Does: Yeah. Yeah. Annie: And because it's so unique to them, I think, like you know, have you heard the term ontological shock? Ryan Does: You know, I I know I look like someone that's heard that before. I have not. Co I I this is the summer when we're recording this, but could you teach me what that means, please? ⁓ Annie: ha ha ⁓ yeah. I mean it's it's ⁓ obnoxious to say, but the I the idea behind ontological shock is like an event ⁓ that disrupts ⁓ your of how the world works. ⁓ so think you lose people the way that well let me here. So Ryan Does: Hmm. Annie: When you're going through this ontological shock, right? Like there's this total upending of the worlds that you know and how you think the world in God worked, right? It's incredibly disorienting. So, course, like you're feel isolated and alone when you aren't living in the same world anymore, right? Like almost this, like. ⁓ Ryan Does: Okay. Okay. Okay. Annie: dissociation from everybody else, right? Like when others try to encourage you when you're going through something like this, sometimes we have that in the back of our head, even if we don't say it of like, no, but you don't understand, right? Like you don't understand what I'm going through. Like if you went through what I went through, you would be questioning this too, right? Ryan Does: Yeah, o okay. I I So I have two I have two like quick piggyback thoughts, like just to maybe tease that out and understand it a little better. It kind of feels like when when like a a teenager will tell their parent, like, no, no, no, like you don't get it. Like this breakup I'm going through is like the end of the world. Like and and you don't understand, but like your parent has also gone through heartache and heartbreak and all that. And they're like, because you can't feel that experience the way they felt it, it does Annie: Yeah. Sure. Ryan Does: incredibly lonely, like you're on an island because you you're feeling it yourself for the first time. Is that is that part of the loneliness? Is that like you can't have felt something before you felt it for the first time? Is is that even close to what you're referring to? Annie: Hmm. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, I think, mean, especially if we think about the actual circumstances of like Father Karis, right? Like ⁓ he ⁓ his mother, right? So lose, like, and for what I know, you know, we don't know anything about his father. And so is this person that literally gave him life that was his tether to the world that is now gone. Ryan Does: Yeah. Annie: Right. So it is so disorienting. And you know, he becomes a quote unquote orphan, right? And it's really destabilizing and disorienting. I think, ⁓ just contributes to that sense of aloneness. Ryan Does: ⁓ other ⁓ thing I was thinking through that is this sounds this this ontological shock you're talking about top ⁓ it me think of what is commonly referred to or has been referred to in recent years ⁓ as deconstructing a a faith system or a belief system. Are are there ⁓ are overlaps and intersections with those two ideas? Annie: I would I would think so. ⁓ you know, I haven't like, you know, in the literature explored this explicitly, but if I were to just think, you know, about this, I would say that deconstruction, ⁓ process of deconstruction, I think is for many people probably precipitated by ⁓ An experience of ontological shock or their world bottoms out, you know, they have an experience that just totally them feel lost. And how could God allow this to happen to me? Or where was God in this thing? now I don't know what God is or how the world works. and ⁓ here am, ⁓ you know. and so then I need to rethink. ⁓ Ryan Does: Yeah. Annie: what I believe or know about God or what can be known about God or the world. Ryan Does: I and I think that actually like ⁓ that makes perfect sense, especially like you said, in the context of Father Karras's journey in the film, where his worldview completely collapses in on itself. He expresses that doubt to someone still very much aligned and inside the religious system of, you know, Catholic Orthodoxy around the University of Georgetown. but he immediately has to face ⁓ evil that he can't explain. So how does this like how does this movie express both the like the the rigid dogmas ⁓ of systems, but then also balance balancing that out with Karis's lived experience because he does have to then go use a mechanic the Catholic Church ⁓ to against this evil. I so how like in your opinion, how does this movie balance those two or use those two to explain its its theme. Annie: Yeah, so I think if we're thinking about a crisis faith like Father Karis is going through, it like this At least a cognitive breakdown of institutional dogmas, right? Like, okay, here's what the church tells me to believe. if I believe those things, then I have faith. and therefore, because I'm questioning these things, you know, I feel like I've lost my faith. So I think there's that aspect of what's going on, but I also feel like that has ⁓ Up until like the exorcism itself, like the right of the exorcism, I feel like it's been ⁓ ⁓ and that's sort of the climax ⁓ ⁓ theological journey like, you know, he ⁓ he supposedly moves away from his mom, right? For where he's working, and she's struggling to live independently and he's not there. dies ⁓ he's not there. He is also his day-to-day context, is a psychiatrist, presumably in the 1970s or whatever, where these people who are suffering from severe mental illness, but also individuals with just, you know, disabilities and things like that, they're institutionalized and subject to grave abuse like inhumane. treatment. And so ⁓ have to think about, of course, you're gonna be asking, like, as priest, as that psychiatrist, where is God in this? These people are suffering, they hate being here, right? ⁓ So sees evil ⁓ or ⁓ suffering in every part of his life, you know. So I feel like it just was really building and building and building. And so he's got this real lived experience trying to balance that with, okay, well, how can what I supposedly believe about God, how can I reconcile that with all of the loss I've experienced and the trauma the, you know, secondary trauma I experience every day? Ryan Does: Yeah, and and even like I I just with you saying that, I kinda like I reminded of the scene during the actual exorcism where ⁓ Father Marin says like do not engage. Like we are here basically we're here to do a job. Like and we have to do the we have to do the job a certain way, we are going to get pulled in a direction that we we really can't go. ⁓ Annie: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Ryan Does: Father Karas does. Like they're performing the right, the mechanic, the the technique is very well done. Like even Father Marin like tells ⁓ this the spirit embodying Reagan to, you know, to to to to shut up, to go away, to be gone. Like and he almost doesn't like look directly at it, but Karis is transfixed. ⁓ can't ⁓ interact with it. ⁓ like the the the the the dogma ⁓ Annie: Mm-hmm. Yeah, that's so good. Ryan Does: Of the Catholic Church and this rite that they're doing. It like he's performing it, but also he he can't help but engage with it, and that's when he breaks and he has to leave. but he brings that personal experience ⁓ it, and the the spirit ⁓ off of you know his his mom having died. ⁓ like there's this clash of like the ⁓ mechanical, unemotional version of this is just we go in, we say these things, you know, ⁓ sprinkle the holy water, and then it's done. But Karis is bringing all of his baggage and his is like his emotions and engaging with it is actually what saves Reagan in the end. like ⁓ it's a messy combination. Annie: Mm-hmm. that's that's so good, Ryan. ⁓ I thinking about that, you know, how you're saying like it that demonic spirit you know, whatever that entity was, really like ⁓ feeding off of Karis, as you were just saying. And I think something I was thinking while watching it and reflecting on it was this idea that Father Caris, but also as an aside, every single one of these characters was swimming in loss and grief, including Reagan. Especially Reagan, maybe, ⁓ with her father. I think I so. One the images I kept getting was the open window in Reagan's room. Ryan Does: Yeah. Yeah. Okay. Annie: They kept flashing, right? She would her mother would always go in the room, the window would be open, and she would go in there and close it. I kept thinking about this idea of like loss grief almost functioning as like a portal, right? Like they become this open window and vulnerable to Ryan Does: Okay. Annie: something like this entity that can then exploit Father Karis's vulnerability, knowing like he's really torn up about the fact that his mom just died, right? And all of these things. So I don't know. I I found that relationship kind of interesting. Ryan Does: Right. Well I I ⁓ to to add to the messiness of the ⁓ dogma religious themes and the very much like messiness spirituality and interacting with themes of religion was going into this movie, ⁓ I I'm going in with this pre-conception that like this is a movie about how the devil is so powerful. That's really not Annie: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Ryan Does: The conclusion, like I people may have come to that and was like, okay, that may have been what you were looking to find. but I came away from this like feeling very invigorated by Karis's sacrifice, Chris's ⁓ Chris's maternal like love for Reagan no matter what, even the times where she shies away, in in if it for her own safety. ⁓ like there is so much humanity in this movie. I think if you were to interact with this movie and you're like, ⁓ my gosh, isn't isn't the devil so scary? I'd be like ⁓ Annie: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Ryan Does: Were we watching the same movie? Because like they they they win in the end. Like it's their love for each other, their love for Reagan, their their human spirit. Like it it it it it bolsters everything up in this movie. And I was like, ⁓ my gosh, that was actually like a a great movie about you know the good in people. ⁓ that was like maybe that's not the line I should lead with when I talk about The Exorcist with somebody. ⁓ but like but Annie: Mm-hmm. No, no. Ryan Does: With with this movie and the conclusion of it being kind of messy, is there what did what does this say to you like in the middle of the chaos and the suffering of this movie? Like where did where does God show up in this movie? Where does grace show up in this movie? Where does ⁓ show up in this movie for for you? Annie: Yeah. my own I to impose my ⁓ own kind like theological framework, ⁓ like that not one that I myself have constructed, but that, ⁓ you know, read about and ⁓ have been into ⁓ sort of thesis work is this like Ryan Does: Impose away. Okay. Absolutely. Annie: again here's obnoxious words pantheistic religious naturalism the main thing main thing the main point here is actually point that makes most uncomfortable which is if we take this idea that nature like all reality and God are ⁓ right god and are the same then there is this like Ryan Does: Aha. Okay. Annie: what they would say moral ambiguity to God, especially on one's perspective. Like if we think about in nature, like a lion and a gazelle, there is a moral ambiguity there, right? If you're on the side of the lion, it's being able to eat and sustain its life. If you're on the side of the gazelle, this is like, okay, now I'm dead. Like, ⁓ you know, there's Ryan Does: Okay. Yeah. Okay. Annie: There's that natural moral ambiguity, and that's kind of this underlying assumption to ⁓ religious naturalism. And so I say that to say that think that God, then, if we take that assumption, is like ⁓ active in part of this movie, like even the terrible parts, right? Because we're not talking about a God that's loving, you know, we're not working within that paradigm. ⁓ Ryan Does: Okay. Yeah. Right. Annie: So to me, like where the grace shows up and how we approach like suffering and especially human suffering is like nature includes human nature. And so can we work with God and ⁓ as ⁓ to these humanly constructed ideas of grace ⁓ and ⁓ and and responsibility and work toward that? ⁓ Ryan Does: That's good. Annie: preventing and mitigating suffering where we can. Ryan Does: That's good. That that that that works for me. And I I I wanna I wanna just give one like final opportunity like with Annie: Well that's my thesis, so I'm glad you said that. Ryan Does: with your work in occupational therapy, with the thesis you're working on and trying to to finish up that major milestone. And what the were there any is there anything in this film that you you you saw through those lenses that ⁓ we hadn't we haven't touched on yet or haven't finished up ⁓ cohesive thought on that you feel like we need to wrap up before we we close this conversation? Annie: You know, no, I think think you know, the the last question about and kind of talking about like human agency and what we, ⁓ you as human nature can do. Like you see that in the film, as you were saying, right? And as you pointed to, like everybody was really working together. If we think about occupations, right? We like to think about work. ⁓ we were all working together to save ⁓ young ⁓ Ryan Does: Yeah. Annie: Right. so I think, yeah, how can we use our agency? How can we work within our means and within our systems and all that? No, I feel like it wraps up well. ⁓ Ryan Does: I lo I I gosh, I love this. I I love I love I love having a ⁓ substantive conversation about a very ⁓ classic and beloved ⁓ terrifying movie. ⁓ and just bouncing ideas off and being able to come away with something, ⁓ kind of a little nugget to to hang on to. ⁓ but yeah, that that is the exorcist, everybody. and it's it's so simple. Like he just ⁓ Annie: Yeah. Yeah, me too. Yeah Easy peasy. ⁓ Ryan Does: Such an easy movie to understand. But Annie, thank you, ⁓ thank you so much for this conversation and ⁓ I can't wait to do the next one. Annie: Absolutely. Yes, me too. Thank you, Ryan. Ryan Does: And just remember, everybody, the horrors will persist. I I'm I'm so sad to I'm I'm so sad to remind you of that, but the horrors will persist. ⁓ like the people in the Exorcist, though, you can as well. Annie: Hmm.