Latest / Bloomberg Law / SCOTUS Skeptical of Jan 6 Charge & Trump Trial Day 2
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:10Speaker 2: Prosecutors have brought obstruction charges against more than three hundred
- 0:14Speaker 2: and fifty defendants in the Capitol Riot cases, including two
- 0:18Speaker 2: counts against Donald Trump for his efforts to overturn his
- 0:21Speaker 2: election loss in twenty twenty. But during oral arguments today,
- 0:26Speaker 2: several Conservative Supreme Court justices like Neil Gorsuch express skepticism
- 0:31Speaker 2: about the potential scope of the charge and the kinds
- 0:34Speaker 2: of conduct it could criminalize.
- 0:37Speaker 3: Would a sit in that disrupts a trial or access
- 0:42Speaker 3: to a federal courthouse qualify? Would a heckler in today's
- 0:46Speaker 3: audience qualify? Or at the State of the Union address,
- 0:50Speaker 3: would pulling a fire alarm before a vote qualify? For
- 0:56Speaker 3: twenty years in federal prison.
- 0:58Speaker 2: The case involves Joe Joseph Fischer, a former Pennsylvania police
- 1:02Speaker 2: officer and January sixth defendant, who argues the felony obstruction charge,
- 1:08Speaker 2: which carries a prison sentence of twenty years, was intended
- 1:12Speaker 2: to prevent evidence tampering, not insurrection. Justice Clarence Thomas, whose
- 1:17Speaker 2: wife Ginny is a conservative activist, who was at the
- 1:21Speaker 2: rally on January sixth, asked the US Solicitor General, Elizabeth
- 1:25Speaker 2: pre Lagger, if prosecutors have ever used this statute before
- 1:29Speaker 2: in response to violent protests.
- 1:32Speaker 4: So have you enforced it in that manner?
- 1:35Speaker 1: We have enforced it in a variety of prosecutions that
- 1:38Speaker 1: don't focus on evidence tampering. Now, I can't give you
- 1:40Speaker 1: an example of enforcing it in a situation where people
- 1:43Speaker 1: have violently stormed a building in order to prevent an
- 1:45Speaker 1: official preceding a specified one from occurring, with all of
- 1:48Speaker 1: the elements like intent to obstruct, knowledge of the preceding,
- 1:53Speaker 1: of having the corruptly mens raa. But that's just because
- 1:55Speaker 1: I'm not aware of that circumstance ever happening prior to
- 1:58Speaker 1: January sixth.
- 1:59Speaker 2: Joining former federal prosecutor Jessica Roth, a professor at Cardozo
- 2:04Speaker 2: Law School, Jessica explain what the issue is here.
- 2:07Speaker 5: So the issue here is how to interpret the obstruction
- 2:12Speaker 5: of an official preceding statute, which is one of a
- 2:15Speaker 5: series of statutes that address obstruction of justice in various forms.
- 2:20Speaker 5: It's a particular provision that was enacted in two thousand
- 2:23Speaker 5: and two as part of the Sarbanes Oxley Act following
- 2:27Speaker 5: the Enron scandal and the revelation of significant accounting frauds
- 2:31Speaker 5: on the part of the accountants for Enron, and the
- 2:34Speaker 5: revelation that although those involved in the shredding of documents
- 2:39Speaker 5: related to Enron were prosecuted, that there was essentially a
- 2:44Speaker 5: gap in the obstruction of justice statutes because it was
- 2:48Speaker 5: not possible to charge somebody for destroying evidence essentially on
- 2:53Speaker 5: their own. The statutes required that a person direct or
- 2:58Speaker 5: somehow get another person to destroy documents. And so it
- 3:03Speaker 5: wasn't that there was so much a problem charging in
- 3:05Speaker 5: the Enron case, but that it was identified that this
- 3:08Speaker 5: could be a problem in future cases. And so the
- 3:11Speaker 5: particular statute that was charged here against mister Fisher, that's
- 3:15Speaker 5: been used against over three hundred defendants who are charged
- 3:18Speaker 5: arising out of the January sixth insurrection, and that also
- 3:21Speaker 5: is the basis for two of the charges against Donald
- 3:24Speaker 5: Trump and the January sixth case against him. And the
- 3:27Speaker 5: question is whether or not that statute can be used
- 3:30Speaker 5: to charge a person for obstructing and a proceeding, including
- 3:34Speaker 5: a proceeding of Congress, where the destruction of evidence or
- 3:38Speaker 5: tampering with evidence per se is not part of the
- 3:42Speaker 5: factual allegation.
- 3:43Speaker 2: Did it seem during the oral arguments that the conservative
- 3:47Speaker 2: justices were skeptical about the Justice Department using the obstruction
- 3:52Speaker 2: charge against Fisher and the other January sixth defendants.
- 3:56Speaker 5: There were clearly some justices who were skeptical of the charge.
- 4:00Speaker 5: I would say Justice Alito was the one who seemed
- 4:02Speaker 5: most clearly skeptical. Chief Justice Roberts also expressed some concerns,
- 4:07Speaker 5: although he did not ask that many questions. Justice Gorschitz
- 4:10Speaker 5: had some concerns about the breadth of the potential application
- 4:13Speaker 5: of the statute if the Court were to rule for
- 4:16Speaker 5: the government. There were several justices who seemed much more
- 4:20Speaker 5: inclined to rule for the government, notably Justice Soto, Mayor,
- 4:24Speaker 5: Justice Kagan, and Justice Katangi Braun Jackson all seemed supportive
- 4:28Speaker 5: of the interpretation of the statutes that the government was advancing.
- 4:32Speaker 5: But then there were several justices who seemed sort of
- 4:35Speaker 5: in the middle and open to persuasion. So I can't
- 4:39Speaker 5: stay with any confidence how this case is going to
- 4:41Speaker 5: come out.
- 4:42Speaker 2: Let's talk about some of the concerns of the very
- 4:46Speaker 2: conservative justices on the far right of the court. So
- 4:49Speaker 2: Justice Neil Gorsuch said, would a sit in that disrupts
- 4:53Speaker 2: a trial or access to a federal courthouse qualify? Would
- 4:56Speaker 2: a heckler in today's audience qualify? Or a State of
- 4:59Speaker 2: the Union address us what pulling a fire alarm before
- 5:02Speaker 2: a vote referring to an incident in Congress that happened
- 5:05Speaker 2: recently qualified for twenty years in federal prison. So they
- 5:09Speaker 2: were sort of questioning the breath I guess of this.
- 5:13Speaker 5: A number of the justices asked questions and post hypotheticals
- 5:17Speaker 5: that really were geared at testing the outer limits of
- 5:20Speaker 5: the construction of the statutes that the government was advancing,
- 5:24Speaker 5: and those did include hypothetical protests, for example, or somebody
- 5:28Speaker 5: in some way disrupting an official proceeding, such as protesting
- 5:31Speaker 5: outside a courthouse or pulling a fire alarm, And the
- 5:35Speaker 5: justices wanted to know, well, would the government charge that
- 5:38Speaker 5: person with obstruction of an official proceeding under its interpretation?
- 5:42Speaker 5: And this Lister General responded by saying, there are a
- 5:45Speaker 5: number of safeguards in the statute that would preclude a
- 5:50Speaker 5: prosecution in those circumstances, even if the court rules our way.
- 5:55Speaker 5: She said, the obstruction or the impediment of the official
- 5:59Speaker 5: proceding in a sense, must be more than dominionists. It
- 6:02Speaker 5: has to actually, in some way that is not insignificant
- 6:07Speaker 5: impair the proceeding, And so that would be something that
- 6:11Speaker 5: might preclude a prosecution for somebody who pulled a fire
- 6:15Speaker 5: alarm that caused a disruption that was only a matter
- 6:18Speaker 5: of minutes, or that would preclude prosecution of protesters who
- 6:23Speaker 5: only minimally disrupted a proceeding inside a courthouse, perhaps where
- 6:27Speaker 5: things had to quiet down for a few minutes, just
- 6:29Speaker 5: to make sure that the protest was moving on and
- 6:32Speaker 5: was peaceful. So that was one way in which she
- 6:34Speaker 5: said the statute would not apply because the actus rays
- 6:37Speaker 5: in the sense of the impeding, it has to be
- 6:40Speaker 5: construed in a way that it's more than minimal disruption.
- 6:43Speaker 5: The second thing she said is that the men's raya
- 6:45Speaker 5: requirement of the statute, which is that the person has
- 6:47Speaker 5: to act corruptly, also would preclude prosecution of people in
- 6:52Speaker 5: some of these hypotheticals, because it would be unlikely that
- 6:55Speaker 5: the government could prove that those people acted with corrupt intents,
- 6:59Speaker 5: that is, doing something knowing that it was wrong and
- 7:02Speaker 5: contrary to law. If people thought, for example, they were
- 7:06Speaker 5: engaged in peaceful protests protected by the First Amendment. In
- 7:09Speaker 5: some circumstances, they might be wrong about whether their activity
- 7:13Speaker 5: was protected by the First Amendment, but their belief that
- 7:15Speaker 5: it was might preclude a finding that they acted with
- 7:18Speaker 5: the requisite corrupt intent. So those are two of the
- 7:22Speaker 5: ways in which she said the statute is limited and
- 7:25Speaker 5: doesn't need to be limited further by the interpretation advanced
- 7:28Speaker 5: by Fisher. And one final thing she said is that
- 7:31Speaker 5: there's a nexus requirement in the statute.
- 7:33Speaker 4: It has to be the.
- 7:33Speaker 5: Natural and probable consequence of the defendant's action that it
- 7:37Speaker 5: actually would more than minimally disrupt the official proceeding in question.
- 7:41Speaker 5: And so she said, when you add on that third
- 7:43Speaker 5: element of the nexus, that also would contain the potential
- 7:49Speaker 5: breadth of the statute. And actually, now I'm realizing there's
- 7:52Speaker 5: a fourth thing she said, which is, in some circumstances,
- 7:55Speaker 5: there could be an as applied First Amendment challenge to
- 7:58Speaker 5: a prosecution in some of the hypotheticals raised by the justices. So,
- 8:02Speaker 5: in other words, she said, the court could rule in
- 8:04Speaker 5: the government's favor on its interpretation of the statute as
- 8:08Speaker 5: applied to official proceedings and not be worried about some
- 8:12Speaker 5: of the sort of pervaded of horribles that the court
- 8:15Speaker 5: seem to be concerned about.
- 8:16Speaker 2: Would that kind of answer satisfy the textualists, I mean
- 8:20Speaker 2: her saying how the Justice Department won't bring this kind
- 8:24Speaker 2: of a case and that has to have corrupt attent
- 8:26Speaker 2: and all that. Would that satisfy the textualists who we're
- 8:29Speaker 2: just looking at the wording, which seems problematic.
- 8:32Speaker 5: I think the textual argument interpreting the statute in context,
- 8:38Speaker 5: I think the argument is actually quite good for the government.
- 8:41Speaker 5: But the listener General was really emphasizing is that this
- 8:44Speaker 5: statute fifteen twelve f two, which is the one that
- 8:49Speaker 5: contains this introductory word or otherwise obstruction official proceeding, is
- 8:55Speaker 5: a separate statutory paragraph from the section that precedes it,
- 9:00Speaker 5: which is the one that talks about impairing evidence. And
- 9:04Speaker 5: she attached great significance to the fact that Congress chose
- 9:07Speaker 5: to make a separate statutory paragraph for this residual provision otherwise,
- 9:13Speaker 5: and she said that's what distinguishes this particular statute from
- 9:17Speaker 5: other statutes where courts have interpreted otherwise or other similars
- 9:21Speaker 5: of general language as being modified by the specific terms
- 9:25Speaker 5: that come before it. She said, here, there's really a
- 9:28Speaker 5: lot of significance in the fact that it is an
- 9:29Speaker 5: entirely different statutory paragraph, is effectively stand alone, and it's
- 9:34Speaker 5: meant to address ways of obstructing an official proceeding that
- 9:38Speaker 5: are not captured by the previous provision C one, which
- 9:42Speaker 5: is the one about destroying or altering evidence. So there's
- 9:48Speaker 5: a textual reading that I think is consistent with the
- 9:51Speaker 5: government's position. The concerns about the application of the statute
- 9:55Speaker 5: to these very broad set of circumstances I think are
- 9:58Speaker 5: practical concern and I think the question is is the
- 10:02Speaker 5: court prepared to let the government's interpretation go forward in
- 10:07Speaker 5: this case and let these questions of Statuto interpretation on
- 10:11Speaker 5: the other parts of the statute sort of percolate through
- 10:14Speaker 5: the courts, so that the Statute is given a narrowing
- 10:17Speaker 5: interpretation with respect to those other provisions such as what
- 10:20Speaker 5: actually counts as obstruction, for example, or the men's rea,
- 10:25Speaker 5: and let that actually be said as a matter of
- 10:28Speaker 5: law in the courts, as opposed to just trusting the
- 10:31Speaker 5: government to say, well, this is how we interpret and
- 10:33Speaker 5: apply the statute.
- 10:34Speaker 2: A couple of the Justice has seen concerned about the
- 10:37Speaker 2: stiff possible twenty year sentence, and Justice Brett Kavanaugh brought
- 10:42Speaker 2: up the six other charges that Fisher is facing.
- 10:45Speaker 3: Why aren't those six counts good enough?
- 10:48Speaker 4: Just from the Justice.
- 10:50Speaker 3: Department's perspective, given that they don't have any of the hurdles.
- 10:55Speaker 5: I thought the Slicer General's response to that question was
- 10:58Speaker 5: actually quite compelling. She said, yes, he was charged with
- 11:02Speaker 5: other counts, but that those other counts did not fully
- 11:05Speaker 5: capture the harm of his conduct, and that it was
- 11:08Speaker 5: important that the charges reflect the harm that his conduct
- 11:13Speaker 5: allegedly inflicted, which was impairing the official proceeding of the
- 11:19Speaker 5: congressional certification of their electoral College vote. And prosecutors frequently
- 11:26Speaker 5: charge a number of offenses for one set of conduct
- 11:30Speaker 5: in order to have the charges fully reflect the seriousness
- 11:34Speaker 5: and the scope of the conduct. It is important to
- 11:38Speaker 5: note that Fisher has not actually been tried yet, so
- 11:41Speaker 5: I should qualify all of this with he is alleged
- 11:43Speaker 5: to have done all of these things. This charge was
- 11:45Speaker 5: dismissed by the trial court before it went to trial,
- 11:48Speaker 5: and then that went up to the DC Circuit Court
- 11:51Speaker 5: of appeals, and so there's actually a factual dispute among
- 11:54Speaker 5: the parties about what exactly it is that Fisher did
- 11:57Speaker 5: and how violent was he at the Capitol. But the
- 12:00Speaker 5: government is saying that at least as alleged in the indictment,
- 12:03Speaker 5: he engaged in violence against members of the Capitol police
- 12:07Speaker 5: and participated in conduct that collectively obstructed the official proceeding,
- 12:13Speaker 5: which was the counting of the votes coming up.
- 12:16Speaker 2: If the court rules for Fisher, what happens to the
- 12:18Speaker 2: charges against Trump? This is Bloomberg. I've been talking to
- 12:22Speaker 2: Professor Jessica Ront of Cardozo Law School about Supreme Court
- 12:26Speaker 2: oral arguments today over the obstruction charge levied against hundreds
- 12:31Speaker 2: of January sixth Capital Riot defendants as well as Donald Trump.
- 12:36Speaker 2: Many of the conservative justices expressed skepticism about the Justice
- 12:40Speaker 2: Department's use of the charge in the cases. So a
- 12:44Speaker 2: couple of the justices, and particularly Clarence Thomas, asked the
- 12:49Speaker 2: US Listener General Elizabeth Prelager, if prosecutors have ever used
- 12:54Speaker 2: the statute, this obstruction statute in other violent protests, and
- 13:00Speaker 2: she said that there weren't any other specific instances because
- 13:04Speaker 2: nothing like this has happened. She did bring some other
- 13:07Speaker 2: prosecutions up, though did all of them concern the destruction
- 13:11Speaker 2: of evidence.
- 13:13Speaker 5: That was an interesting exchange because she was asked if
- 13:17Speaker 5: the government had brought similar prosecutions for obstructing official proceeding
- 13:23Speaker 5: essentially against those who engaged in political protests other than
- 13:27Speaker 5: January sixth, and there one had the sense that some
- 13:31Speaker 5: of the conservative justices were trying to get a concession
- 13:34Speaker 5: that this statute was only used essentially against the January
- 13:37Speaker 5: six protesters. And her response effectively was there hasn't been
- 13:41Speaker 5: a similar fact pattern where people, through violence tried to
- 13:45Speaker 5: obstruct an official proceeding that would have lent themselves to
- 13:48Speaker 5: such a charge. But when she was pressed about using
- 13:52Speaker 5: the charge against defendants and situations that, aside from political violence,
- 13:58Speaker 5: simply just didn't evolve destruction or alteration of evidence, she
- 14:03Speaker 5: said there were examples that she could point to, and
- 14:05Speaker 5: there are some in her brief that involved, for example,
- 14:09Speaker 5: tipping off somebody that they were the subject of a
- 14:11Speaker 5: grand jury investigation, or identifying an undercover informant to an individual,
- 14:17Speaker 5: and she said, those don't involve tampering with evidence, and
- 14:20Speaker 5: we've used this same charge against individuals in those circumstances.
- 14:24Speaker 5: The response from the attorney for mister Fisher was, well,
- 14:28Speaker 5: those are also examples of cases involving efforts to tamper
- 14:33Speaker 5: with evidence, because those are witnesses, in effect, who have
- 14:37Speaker 5: been identified such that a person could arguably intimidate the
- 14:42Speaker 5: witness or alter their testimony. It just would be sort
- 14:45Speaker 5: of witnesses as opposed to documents as evidence. So it's
- 14:49Speaker 5: an interesting categorization question is do those in fact count
- 14:53Speaker 5: as non evidence related obstruction charges, as she argues, or
- 14:58Speaker 5: are they just another version of of evidence campering, as
- 15:02Speaker 5: Fisher would argue. It points to one of the big
- 15:05Speaker 5: questions here, which is what is the concern of this
- 15:10Speaker 5: statute fifteen twelve C. Is it concerned with campering with
- 15:16Speaker 5: documents and other forms of evidence, which was the specific
- 15:20Speaker 5: concern identified by Congress following the Enron scandal, or is
- 15:26Speaker 5: the concern of the statute better stated at a broader
- 15:29Speaker 5: level of generality, which is obstruction of official proceedings and
- 15:34Speaker 5: attempts to obstruct with official proceedings in whatever form such
- 15:38Speaker 5: obstruction might take, not limited solely to obstruction that is
- 15:44Speaker 5: accomplished through interference with evidence. The Splister General's position is
- 15:50Speaker 5: that it is the latter, more general concern, and that
- 15:54Speaker 5: is evidenced by the fact that Congress broke the section
- 15:57Speaker 5: into two parts. C one, which is address to evidence tampering,
- 16:02Speaker 5: and C two, which is the catch all, which starts
- 16:05Speaker 5: with the phrase or otherwise and then describes essentially any
- 16:10Speaker 5: other manner in which a person would obstruct an official proceeding.
- 16:14Speaker 5: And so she says, the concern of Congress was to
- 16:18Speaker 5: anticipate and outlaws ways of obstructing official proceedings that were
- 16:25Speaker 5: not limited to evidence tampering. And Congress couldn't anticipate and
- 16:30Speaker 5: articulate all the different forms that might take, and that's
- 16:34Speaker 5: why they inserted this C two provision that was charged
- 16:37Speaker 5: here and which she says fits the facts.
- 16:40Speaker 2: Jessica, you yourself looking at this, do you think that
- 16:43Speaker 2: the Justice Department was stretching it to charge these defendants
- 16:47Speaker 2: with obstruction?
- 16:49Speaker 5: I think if you look at the statute and you
- 16:53Speaker 5: follow the government's argument about how the statute can be
- 16:57Speaker 5: read as applying to any means of obstructing an official
- 17:02Speaker 5: proceeding so long as the person acts with corrupt intent
- 17:06Speaker 5: and this requisite nexus is satisfied, I think it is
- 17:10Speaker 5: a fair interpretation of the statute that it applies to
- 17:13Speaker 5: these facts. It is unprecedented, but that I think speaks
- 17:17Speaker 5: to the fact that there's been no similar fact pattern
- 17:21Speaker 5: where people have attempted to and did obstruct for a
- 17:25Speaker 5: time an official proceeding through such acts of violence. So
- 17:29Speaker 5: it is novel, but I don't think that it is
- 17:33Speaker 5: beyond the pale of what is covered by this statute.
- 17:37Speaker 5: I do think we'd be getting into some very interesting
- 17:40Speaker 5: territory if the Court were to say that it's finding
- 17:44Speaker 5: for Fisher and the statute cannot be read beyond applications
- 17:49Speaker 5: involving evidence, and whether the government then seeks to apply
- 17:53Speaker 5: the statute so limited to the facts presented here. The
- 17:58Speaker 5: government said in a footnote in its brief, and it
- 18:01Speaker 5: reiterated at the argument today, that it would like the
- 18:04Speaker 5: opportunity to argue that even under such a narrowed construction,
- 18:08Speaker 5: that the facts can meet that construction because the proceeding
- 18:14Speaker 5: before Congress involved the counting of the electoral votes, and
- 18:18Speaker 5: that involved essentially the evidence of the votes presented to Congress.
- 18:24Speaker 5: That's I think going to be very interesting to think
- 18:26Speaker 5: about whether that application strains the statute too much, and
- 18:31Speaker 5: that is precisely the argument that has been advanced by
- 18:35Speaker 5: some watching the Fisher case for its significance for the
- 18:39Speaker 5: case against Donald Trump, on the theory that if the
- 18:42Speaker 5: court rules against the government in Fisher and says that
- 18:45Speaker 5: acts of violence to obstruct official proceeding do not fall
- 18:49Speaker 5: within the statute, could a sort of backup argument be
- 18:53Speaker 5: that the electoral votes being certified in the course of
- 18:57Speaker 5: that proceeding before Congress, that that could be essentially the
- 19:02Speaker 5: hook to the documentary evidence that would be required to
- 19:07Speaker 5: satisfy the statute.
- 19:08Speaker 2: Could the Special Council go ahead with just two of
- 19:11Speaker 2: the charges against Trump?
- 19:13Speaker 5: Absolutely, the case could go forward based on the conspiracy
- 19:16Speaker 5: charge to defraud the United States and the conspiracy to
- 19:20Speaker 5: deprive people of the right to have their votes counted.
- 19:23Speaker 5: There's no reason the case couldn't go forward without the
- 19:26Speaker 5: two obstruction related charges.
- 19:29Speaker 2: A Trump appointee was the only District Court judge out
- 19:33Speaker 2: of fifteen in DC hearing the January sixth cases to
- 19:36Speaker 2: adopt this narrow reading of the statute dismiss Fisher's obstruction charge.
- 19:41Speaker 2: Then you had on the appellate court. Another Trump appointee
- 19:46Speaker 2: was the one who dissented and what does it say
- 19:48Speaker 2: if you have six conservatives or five conservatives on this
- 19:52Speaker 2: court with three Trump appointees. What does it say if
- 19:56Speaker 2: they dismiss the charges against Fisher and so the charges
- 20:01Speaker 2: fail against the other January sixth defendants, including Trump.
- 20:05Speaker 5: Statuto interpretation questions often do not line up exactly with
- 20:11Speaker 5: judges and justices perceived political affiliations. So one of the
- 20:15Speaker 5: cases that was discussed in the briefs and in the
- 20:19Speaker 5: argument today was a case called Yates, which involved the
- 20:23Speaker 5: construction of a related obstruction of justice statute. That was
- 20:27Speaker 5: a decision authored by Justice Kagan and involved the question
- 20:30Speaker 5: of whether a fish was a tangible object for purposes
- 20:34Speaker 5: of another statute that's nearby, and Justice Kagan wrote an
- 20:37Speaker 5: opinion for the court holding that a fish was not
- 20:39Speaker 5: a tangible object for purposes of that statute, which the
- 20:42Speaker 5: Court ruled in that context was limited to objects that
- 20:47Speaker 5: were similar to records of the kind maintained by businesses
- 20:51Speaker 5: and used as evidence, and that were the primary motivating
- 20:55Speaker 5: concern of Congress when it enacted the Sarbainanes Oxley Act.
- 20:59Speaker 5: Justice Kagan is usually thought of as being more aligned
- 21:01Speaker 5: with the liberal wing of the Court, but she wrote
- 21:03Speaker 5: that opinion that ruled against the government on its interpretation question.
- 21:07Speaker 5: There are a number of the justices, namely Justice Gorsuch,
- 21:10Speaker 5: who is somebody who's really advocated for robust application of
- 21:15Speaker 5: a doctrine known as the rule of lenity, which is
- 21:17Speaker 5: a defendant favoring doctrine that statutes criminal statutes should be
- 21:22Speaker 5: construed in a way that is more favorable to the
- 21:24Speaker 5: defendant when there is ambiguity about their terms. And he's
- 21:28Speaker 5: generally viewed as being more part of the conservative court.
- 21:31Speaker 5: So statute of interpretation questions sometimes lead to interesting outcomes
- 21:35Speaker 5: that don't align necessarily with the justices political orientation or
- 21:40Speaker 5: the political affiliation of the president who appointed them. So
- 21:43Speaker 5: I really don't know how the case is going to
- 21:45Speaker 5: come out, and I don't know that we should necessarily
- 21:48Speaker 5: predict it based on the appointing president of the judge
- 21:51Speaker 5: or justices who's considering the issue.
- 21:54Speaker 2: If the court finds for Fisher here, what happens to
- 21:57Speaker 2: the one hundred and twenty or so January sixth defendants
- 22:01Speaker 2: who've been convicted and sentenced under the same charge.
- 22:05Speaker 5: So I'm fairly certain that no defendant associated with January
- 22:09Speaker 5: six has been charged solely with this obstruction statute, but
- 22:14Speaker 5: there were other charges for each of them, so those
- 22:19Speaker 5: other convictions would stand even if the Court were to
- 22:22Speaker 5: rule against the government here. And if the court were
- 22:24Speaker 5: to rule that this obstruction statute cannot be used in
- 22:27Speaker 5: the context of January sixth because it didn't involve the
- 22:30Speaker 5: destruction of evidence, so the defendants in those other cases
- 22:34Speaker 5: would be resentenced.
- 22:36Speaker 2: Is there any way that the justices could come down
- 22:38Speaker 2: with a decision that affects Fisher but not the rest
- 22:42Speaker 2: of the January sixth defendants.
- 22:45Speaker 5: I mean, one of the things that's interesting here is
- 22:46Speaker 5: that because the case hasn't gone to trial yet, the
- 22:49Speaker 5: court has to decide the case based on its interpretation
- 22:54Speaker 5: of the statute and thinking about the facts as alleged
- 22:58Speaker 5: in the indictment only, not as established in a factual
- 23:01Speaker 5: record at trial. The case is presented on a legal
- 23:06Speaker 5: question of whether or not the obstruction of justice statute
- 23:10Speaker 5: in question encompasses acts that are not aimed at altering
- 23:17Speaker 5: evidence or things similar to documents and records as enumerated
- 23:24Speaker 5: in the closely related statute of fifteen twelve C. One.
- 23:28Speaker 5: The court I think is going to have to decide
- 23:31Speaker 5: that legal question in a way that it has ramifications
- 23:36Speaker 5: for all other similarly situated defendants who are charged based
- 23:41Speaker 5: on obstructing the preceding without the allegation that they specifically
- 23:49Speaker 5: were involved in the alteration of evidence or efforts to
- 23:52Speaker 5: impede evidence being used in the preceding. So it's hard
- 23:58Speaker 5: for me to imagine that the court renders an opinion
- 24:01Speaker 5: that does not have broad application with respect to the
- 24:06Speaker 5: other January sixth defendants, of whom there are at least
- 24:10Speaker 5: three hundred charged with this crime. If there were a
- 24:13Speaker 5: way for the court to write a narrow opinion that
- 24:16Speaker 5: decided the case solely based on the facts is alleged
- 24:19Speaker 5: against Fisher himself, that would mean it wouldn't have implications
- 24:25Speaker 5: for other cases. But given the particular posture of this
- 24:28Speaker 5: case and the way the question presented was framed and argued,
- 24:33Speaker 5: it's difficult for me to see a very narrow holding.
- 24:36Speaker 2: Thanks so much for your insights, Jessica, I appreciate it best,
- 24:40Speaker 2: Professor Jessica Garroth of Cardozo Law School. Coming up next
- 24:44Speaker 2: on The Bloomberg Law Show, It's day two of Donald
- 24:47Speaker 2: Trump's hush money trial, and some jurors have actually been
- 24:51Speaker 2: sworn in. I'm June Grosso and you're listening to Bloomberg.
- 24:57Speaker 1: I think we have a very much appl clicked at.
- 25:00Speaker 4: Judge shouldn't be on the case.
- 25:02Speaker 2: He's rushing this trial and.
- 25:04Speaker 4: He's doing as much as he can for the Democrats.
- 25:07Speaker 3: This is a Biden inspired win.
- 25:10Speaker 2: Shut day two of Donald Trump's criminal trial in the
- 25:14Speaker 2: hush money case, and he had familiar complaints about the
- 25:18Speaker 2: judge and new complaints about the speed of the trial.
- 25:21Speaker 2: Jury selection did seem to go into overdrive this afternoon,
- 25:25Speaker 2: with seven jurors sworn in and told to return on Monday.
- 25:29Speaker 2: Could the judge be anticipating opening statements on Monday joining
- 25:34Speaker 2: me to talk about the jury selection process. Is Michael
- 25:37Speaker 2: Weinstein a partner at Cole Shots. I'm wondering if the
- 25:42Speaker 2: reality of being a criminal defendant is setting in because
- 25:46Speaker 2: during his civil trials, Trump could breathe in and out
- 25:49Speaker 2: when he wanted to. Now he asked the judge to
- 25:53Speaker 2: be off on Wednesdays when the trial is not in session,
- 25:56Speaker 2: to go to Supreme Court arguments on presidential immunity, and
- 26:00Speaker 2: the judge said, you know your client is a criminal defendant.
- 26:03Speaker 2: He's required to be here. So it's different for Donald
- 26:08Speaker 2: Trump now than it was in the civil cases.
- 26:10Speaker 4: It is different, and the reality may have struck him,
- 26:13Speaker 4: but I don't think we'll ever really know what he
- 26:16Speaker 4: thinks about it, other than the way he positions himself
- 26:20Speaker 4: in that he's getting persecuted, not prosecuted. I think he
- 26:23Speaker 4: also will play this out in the media unlike any
- 26:27Speaker 4: other defendant, And so even if he does feel somewhat
- 26:32Speaker 4: abused by the system, he's going to turn that to
- 26:34Speaker 4: his advantage.
- 26:36Speaker 2: And I do want to straighten at one thing. Trump
- 26:38Speaker 2: had said after court that the judge wouldn't let him
- 26:41Speaker 2: skip court on May seventeen to attend his son's graduation
- 26:45Speaker 2: from high school. But the judge has yet to rule
- 26:48Speaker 2: on that, So I just want to clarify that.
- 26:49Speaker 4: And oftentimes, you know, Trump says things which are belied
- 26:54Speaker 4: by the facts, and so you know, he wants the
- 26:58Speaker 4: world and the public to think every decision is being
- 27:01Speaker 4: made against him, when in reality, some of the decisions
- 27:04Speaker 4: being made by the court or specifically this judge are
- 27:07Speaker 4: pretty traditional, you know, normal things that a judge would
- 27:11Speaker 4: say when a criminal defendant is charged as he is here.
- 27:14Speaker 2: This is not the first time that Trump has, you know,
- 27:18Speaker 2: tried to degrade the judges. He comes out of court
- 27:21Speaker 2: or goes into court every day saying, this is a
- 27:24Speaker 2: Trump paiding judge, he's biased. This judge is very professional.
- 27:28Speaker 2: I assume he's not going to let that get to him.
- 27:30Speaker 2: But what is the point of that. It just seems counterproductive.
- 27:34Speaker 2: And even in the court room you have the lawyers
- 27:38Speaker 2: repeating arguments.
- 27:39Speaker 4: Because his audience is not the general public. His audience
- 27:43Speaker 4: is his supporters where he could fundraise for his presidential campaign.
- 27:48Speaker 4: So you have to look at it under the view
- 27:50Speaker 4: of why is he doing it? And his motivation is
- 27:53Speaker 4: very different than a normal criminal defendant, where they would
- 27:56Speaker 4: be talking about the evidence and they'd be talking about,
- 27:59Speaker 4: you know, their repute. Here he's using it as a
- 28:02Speaker 4: narrative to support his overall candidacy, and that's why it's
- 28:06Speaker 4: so different.
- 28:07Speaker 2: Last week, Trump said that jury selection is luck, and
- 28:12Speaker 2: I'm wondering how much of that is true. How much
- 28:14Speaker 2: of it is luck the kind of jury pool you get,
- 28:17Speaker 2: and how much of it is the skill of the
- 28:19Speaker 2: lawyers or you know, the knowledge of the judge.
- 28:24Speaker 4: So look, being a criminal defense lawyer for twenty five years,
- 28:27Speaker 4: I want to believe that there's some skill involved, so
- 28:30Speaker 4: I won't agree with him that it's completely luck. There
- 28:33Speaker 4: are some nuances, of course, to the selection process, just
- 28:36Speaker 4: like if someone was painting their house. You know, painting
- 28:39Speaker 4: a house is not traditionally hard, but there are nuances
- 28:41Speaker 4: doing it properly and having an end result, which is good.
- 28:45Speaker 4: I think the one thing that Trump doesn't appreciate, or
- 28:48Speaker 4: does appreciate and is scared of, is that the jury
- 28:51Speaker 4: pool from Manhattan, the City of New York, is heavily democratic,
- 28:56Speaker 4: and therefore that does not bode well for him. So
- 28:59Speaker 4: even if it's as he says it is, he's drawing
- 29:02Speaker 4: from a jury pool which is not favorable for him
- 29:06Speaker 4: in any way.
- 29:07Speaker 5: I think he.
- 29:08Speaker 2: Understands that because he wanted to get the case moved
- 29:10Speaker 2: to Staten Island, where the votes are in his favor,
- 29:13Speaker 2: rather than in Manhattan, where he got only eleven percent
- 29:16Speaker 2: of the vote.
- 29:17Speaker 4: Yes, I'm sure he would love to have it move
- 29:19Speaker 4: to Oklahoma or Indiana or one of the other states
- 29:21Speaker 4: as well, but the likelihood of it being transferred out
- 29:24Speaker 4: of the District of New York and Manhattan is pretty small.
- 29:28Speaker 4: They handle these types of cases all the time. And
- 29:30Speaker 4: this is putting aside the defendant himself. This issue fraud
- 29:34Speaker 4: is a pretty bread and butter type of issue that's
- 29:37Speaker 4: brought by these types of district attorney and prosecutor in
- 29:41Speaker 4: Manhattan all the time.
- 29:43Speaker 2: Now you'll hear lawyers, both prosecutors and defense attorneys say
- 29:47Speaker 2: we just want a jury who can hear the evidence
- 29:50Speaker 2: and be impartial. That's really not the case. They're looking
- 29:54Speaker 2: for jurors who will be receptive to their case. So
- 29:58Speaker 2: what are they looking for here.
- 30:00Speaker 4: Well, of course they want a jury that is receptive
- 30:02Speaker 4: to their case and is open to their arguments. But
- 30:05Speaker 4: they can't say we want a jury that's only going
- 30:07Speaker 4: to you know, believe me, as a defense lawyer and
- 30:09Speaker 4: as a prosecutor, you can't. You can't be so clean
- 30:12Speaker 4: and clear cut as to what you're looking for. You
- 30:14Speaker 4: have to be a little more nuanced and being fair
- 30:17Speaker 4: and impartial. And look, I mean, the prosecutor's trying to
- 30:20Speaker 4: do the right thing and getting a fair and impartial jury.
- 30:23Speaker 4: The defense lawyers are doing their part to get a
- 30:25Speaker 4: jury to their narrative and their story, and ultimately, you know,
- 30:30Speaker 4: history will show that difficult cases, you know, they are
- 30:34Speaker 4: able to get jurors, and the jurors are able to
- 30:37Speaker 4: hear it, and the cases they are able to be tried.
- 30:41Speaker 2: The going narrative that the defense is looking for more
- 30:46Speaker 2: blue collar working class, less well educated, and the prosecution
- 30:52Speaker 2: is looking for white collar and you know, college educated
- 30:56Speaker 2: or better.
- 30:57Speaker 4: I suspect that's probably a fair representation. It's actually funny
- 31:00Speaker 4: because if you look at it from a political standpoint,
- 31:04Speaker 4: what Trump is looking for is really the base of
- 31:06Speaker 4: the Democratic Party, and what the prosecutor is looking for
- 31:10Speaker 4: is really the base of the Republican Party. So it's
- 31:13Speaker 4: really flipped for purposes of bringing a case like this.
- 31:16Speaker 2: The jury questionnaire, there are lots of questions where you
- 31:19Speaker 2: get your news from. So if you get jurors who
- 31:23Speaker 2: say I get my news from MSNBC and the Times,
- 31:28Speaker 2: and other jurors who say, well, I get my news
- 31:30Speaker 2: from the Wall Street Journal and Fox, I mean, do
- 31:33Speaker 2: you pretty much know what their political leanings are?
- 31:37Speaker 4: I think the answer is yes to a degree. But
- 31:41Speaker 4: here's the key. The question is not whether the jurors
- 31:44Speaker 4: like or dislike Donald Trump, but whether they're feelings would
- 31:49Speaker 4: interfere with their ability to serve without bias. So even
- 31:54Speaker 4: if they listen to Fox News and they read the
- 31:57Speaker 4: Wall Street Journal, or they read the New York Times
- 31:59Speaker 4: religiously and watch CNN in the evening, that's not the
- 32:03Speaker 4: end of the test. You have to look and see
- 32:05Speaker 4: whether or not by doing that it will influence their
- 32:09Speaker 4: ability to be impartial and act without bias. That's the key.
- 32:14Speaker 2: How do you avoid getting a stealth juror on the case,
- 32:18Speaker 2: one who has an agenda either way?
- 32:20Speaker 4: Yeah, that's difficult. That's always an issue in a criminal case,
- 32:23Speaker 4: and you traditionally ask written questions and you ask them
- 32:27Speaker 4: to answer under oath, and then each attorney is able
- 32:31Speaker 4: to ask additional questions to flush out whether or not
- 32:34Speaker 4: they have true feelings which didn't come out in the
- 32:37Speaker 4: written questions, and then the judge of course has an
- 32:39Speaker 4: opportunity to ask them questions as well. But it is
- 32:42Speaker 4: always a risk, and there are cases where a stealth
- 32:45Speaker 4: juror does kind of appear, but traditionally, through the juror
- 32:49Speaker 4: selection process, you can try to flush those type of
- 32:51Speaker 4: people out.
- 32:52Speaker 2: And in this case it's even harder because of the
- 32:56Speaker 2: high profile nature. You have to believe that some jurors
- 32:59Speaker 2: are going to want to get out on the jury
- 33:00Speaker 2: just because of that. Today, a dismissed you, a dismissed
- 33:04Speaker 2: juror did interviews on at least two cable news outlets,
- 33:09Speaker 2: and you know, how much does she have to say
- 33:12Speaker 2: after a day. So it seems like there are going
- 33:14Speaker 2: to be a lot of people who want the attention
- 33:17Speaker 2: and want to be on the case.
- 33:19Speaker 4: I think that's a fair concern. I think, you know,
- 33:22Speaker 4: the risk also is social media. Is what are these
- 33:24Speaker 4: people going to be posting either during your trial, in
- 33:27Speaker 4: the evenings of the trial, immediately after the trial. In
- 33:30Speaker 4: this day and age, you know, it seems like no
- 33:32Speaker 4: one can keep a secret and everybody wants to talk
- 33:35Speaker 4: at all times of the day and in all formats,
- 33:37Speaker 4: And I think that's a real risk. I think what
- 33:39Speaker 4: the judge will do is lay down the law and
- 33:41Speaker 4: make it very clear to the jurors that they need
- 33:44Speaker 4: to be, you know, off social media and not read
- 33:46Speaker 4: papers and just be dedicated to the service at hand,
- 33:49Speaker 4: which is listening to the evidence and making an ultimate
- 33:52Speaker 4: decision on his guilt or innocence.
- 33:55Speaker 2: The judge admonished Trump at one point today after he
- 33:58Speaker 2: apparently spoke loudly in gestured while the judge was questioning
- 34:02Speaker 2: a woman about a social media post. I mean, how
- 34:05Speaker 2: much are the jurors watching the defendant and sort of
- 34:09Speaker 2: taking stock of him during the jury selection?
- 34:13Speaker 4: So look, I think jurors watch the defendants, the lawyers,
- 34:19Speaker 4: the judge like a hawk. I think they pick up
- 34:22Speaker 4: on even the most subtle things. I think they look
- 34:24Speaker 4: to see what the defendant is saying to his council,
- 34:27Speaker 4: whether he's writing furiously, whether he's nodding off, whether he's gasping, oh,
- 34:33Speaker 4: I can't believe that type of you know, reaction. All
- 34:36Speaker 4: of those things jurors pick up and I think that
- 34:38Speaker 4: does start to lay the groundwork for, you know, whether
- 34:41Speaker 4: they really like the defendant. And by extension, that does
- 34:46Speaker 4: play into in my experience, whether or not, you know,
- 34:49Speaker 4: they'll give the benefit of the doubt to the defendant.
- 34:51Speaker 4: If a defendant is just so brusque and so rude
- 34:55Speaker 4: and just you know, disregards everything about a juror and
- 34:58Speaker 4: their service, I don't both well for them for the defendants.
- 35:02Speaker 2: So Judge Wanmershawn, very experienced trial judge. He seems to
- 35:08Speaker 2: have set the tone even during the pre trial motions.
- 35:13Speaker 2: How important is it that He's set the tone as
- 35:16Speaker 2: far as the gag order too, because Trump over the
- 35:20Speaker 2: weekend commented on potential witnesses, not naming them, but it
- 35:25Speaker 2: was obvious that it was Stormy Daniels and Michael Cohen,
- 35:28Speaker 2: and the prosecutor is asking for him to be held
- 35:31Speaker 2: in contempt and fined. Should the judge right now draw
- 35:35Speaker 2: the line?
- 35:36Speaker 4: I think it's very important for this judge, or any
- 35:39Speaker 4: judge in the situation like this, to make it very
- 35:42Speaker 4: clear to defendants and counsel as to what is acceptable
- 35:46Speaker 4: and what is not, especially since there is a pre
- 35:49Speaker 4: existing gag order. What's happening here is Trump is flexing
- 35:54Speaker 4: his muscle a little bit and trying to challenge the
- 35:57Speaker 4: gag order. And if he's able to do that on
- 35:59Speaker 4: day one, day two, day three of the trial, I
- 36:02Speaker 4: can only imagine what's going to happen on day thirty
- 36:04Speaker 4: and forty five. It's just going to be like there
- 36:06Speaker 4: was no gag order in the first place. So I
- 36:09Speaker 4: think the judge has to come down someone hard and
- 36:12Speaker 4: somewhat strict and be very very strident with the defendant
- 36:16Speaker 4: and his counsel about what's acceptable and what's not. Otherwise,
- 36:19Speaker 4: all bets are off, and it's going to be as
- 36:21Speaker 4: though the gag order never existed in the first place.
- 36:24Speaker 2: I'm sure there are more antics ahead. Thanks so much, Michael.
- 36:27Speaker 2: That's former federal prosecutor Michael Weinstein of Cole Shots. And
- 36:31Speaker 2: that's it for this edition of the Bloomberg Law Podcast.
- 36:34Speaker 2: Remember you've can always get the latest legal news by
- 36:37Speaker 2: subscribing and listening to the show on Apple Podcasts, Spotify,
- 36:41Speaker 2: and at Bloomberg dot com, slash podcast, Slash Law. I'm
- 36:45Speaker 2: June Grosso and this is Bloomberg