Latest / Conversations for Equal Pay / #5, Interview with Kate Gallagher Robbins, Sr. Economic Justice Fellow at the NPWF
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: Across the board, women continue to earn less than men.
- 0:05White women make about eighty cents to a man's dollar,
- 0:10Black women earned sixty six cents, Native women and latinas
- 0:17just fifty eight cents, and Asian American women, though often
- 0:24reported higher earnings, still face wide pay gaps depending on
- 0:30ethnicity and industry. The numbers tell a story about the
- 0:38urging need for change. I'm Juline Allen, and this is
- 0:43Conversations or Equal Pay, where we talk with leaders, innovators,
- 0:51and change makers about closing the gap and uplifting women
- 0:55of color in the workplace.
- 1:00Speaker 2: Listening to Conversations for Equal Care, we're talking to doctor
- 1:09Kate Gallager Robbins today, the Senior Economic Justice Fellow at
- 1:14the National Partnership for Women and Families.
- 1:17Speaker 1: A nationally recognized expert on gender and racial equity, Kate
- 1:23has dedicated her career to advancing policies that strengthen economic
- 1:28security for women, particularly women of color, through research, advocacy,
- 1:34and systemic change. Thank you for joining us today, Kate, Juline, thank.
- 1:41Speaker 3: You so much for having me on for this conversation.
- 1:45Speaker 1: So, Kate, giving your extensive background and economic justice, what
- 1:50are the most significant barriers that still prevent women, particularly
- 1:55women of color, from achieving equal pay in the US today.
- 2:00Speaker 3: There are so many barriers that prevent women of color
- 2:03and all women from achieving equal pay, and there's some
- 2:07that women have been facing for generations. So, first off,
- 2:12women face a long history of discrimination at work. What
- 2:16kinds of jobs they can do? Do they get that promotion?
- 2:21Are they able to be paid fairly compared to their
- 2:23male counterparts? And that is doubly difficult for women of
- 2:28color who are facing both racism and sexism on the job.
- 2:35But there are also factors outside of work that are
- 2:38contributing to a lack of equal pay for women, namely
- 2:42the balance between caregiving and taking care of their families,
- 2:47and that work falls disproportionately on women when they're trying
- 2:50to compare that to their time in the paid labor market.
- 2:53So our research shows Americans do a trillion with a
- 2:59tea unpaid care work every year and women are doing
- 3:03two thirds of that work.
- 3:06Speaker 1: Wow, that is it is definitely a stark difference between
- 3:13women and men, and caregiving is predominantly follows on women,
- 3:17particularly women of color. Asian American women are disproportionately affected
- 3:24by caregiving.
- 3:26Speaker 3: Is that that's right. That's right too. Lean Asian American
- 3:29women are doing almost an hour of unpaid caregiving every day,
- 3:34and that's more than any other group of women.
- 3:38Speaker 1: So the National Partnership for Women and Families has a
- 3:41long history of advocating for policies like pay, family and
- 3:46medical leaf. How does the lack of these policies directly
- 3:51contribute to and widen the gender and racial pay gap.
- 3:56Speaker 3: Yeah, we the National Partnership, have been fighting for more
- 4:00than fifty years for policies that support working women, and
- 4:04we have had some great victories with our partners and
- 4:07other activists, things like the Family and Medical Leave Act,
- 4:12which gave women job and men job protected leave, Things
- 4:16like the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act, which enshrined common sense
- 4:20accommodations for pregnant workers on the job, like being able
- 4:24to have water during work or sit on a stool
- 4:27of your nine months pregnant. But while we've made some
- 4:31important progress, there's still so much more to do, and unfortunately,
- 4:36the Trump era policies are actually taking us backwards. So
- 4:40if you look at Trump's changes over the last nine months,
- 4:44they've likely driven increases in pay disparities so we're talking
- 4:48about things like cutting government workers who we know are
- 4:52especially likely to be black women, sort of dismantling things
- 4:57like the EEOC, undermining that organization which combats discrimination and
- 5:04unfair pay at work, undercutting protections for federal contractors. So
- 5:10our tax dollars at work should not be leading to discrimination,
- 5:16and yet the president and Trump's policies have been undercutting
- 5:20those efforts. And so we've made a lot of progress,
- 5:26we still have so much further to go, and unfortunately
- 5:29we're actually moving backwards over the last couple of months
- 5:33at the national level.
- 5:36Speaker 1: Just going back to paid family lead the medical leave.
- 5:40It's it's not just the benefit, which many people think
- 5:45that it's just the benefit. It is a it is
- 5:48a necessity.
- 5:52Speaker 3: Yes, paid family and medical leave is a necessity. There's
- 5:56I think every one of us has had an experience,
- 6:00whether we're taking care of a family member, taking care
- 6:05of ourselves. I think people don't always realize this, but
- 6:08the most common use for paid family and medical leave
- 6:11is actually personal medical leave. Something happens, you break an ekal,
- 6:17you need to have chemo, you know, like these are
- 6:20the things people use them for, and everybody needs it,
- 6:26right everybody, name one person out there who has not
- 6:30gotten sick, gotten injured, or had a loved one in
- 6:33that circumstance. And no one should be in the position
- 6:36of having to choose between I need to take my
- 6:39mom to this doctor's appointment and help advocate for her
- 6:43and you know, take care of her after surgery, or
- 6:47I'm going to lose my job. No one should be
- 6:49in that position.
- 6:51Speaker 1: Absolutely, and women, it's it's critical for women and women
- 6:55of color to have it. I mean, it's critical for everyone,
- 6:59but it's so critical for women and women of color
- 7:02have it because caregiving and caring for children and loved
- 7:06ones that disproportionnately falls on women.
- 7:14Speaker 3: Yeah, it absolutely does. And I think the other thing
- 7:17people don't always realize is, you know, some folks get
- 7:21paid leave through their jobs, and we can talk about
- 7:24that as well, But the people who are least likely
- 7:27to be getting this paid family and medical leave is
- 7:31exactly women and women of color, because they're working in
- 7:35the kinds of jobs where their employers are less likely
- 7:38to provide this leave, right, And so it's this sort
- 7:42of I use this phrase a lot like this compounding factor,
- 7:47where you know women of color are doing so much
- 7:50of the caregiving, and they're also less likely to be
- 7:54having the leave and the supports that they need that,
- 7:56as you rightly say, are not a benefit, they are
- 8:00a necessity for life and for this balance. And so
- 8:04you're seeing that double whammy at work every day.
- 8:09Speaker 1: Absolutely, So from your perspective, what role do employers in
- 8:15the private sector have in closing the pay gap and
- 8:19what are the most effective actions they can take beyond
- 8:22legal compliance?
- 8:26Speaker 3: Yeah, legal compliance is a great start, and let's make
- 8:29sure they're doing that. But you know, I think sometimes
- 8:34because the laws and the policy changes are so important,
- 8:38we don't talk enough about what businesses can be doing
- 8:42themselves right. And so there's a whole range of things
- 8:46that businesses can focus on. First of all, they can
- 8:49look at their own books and conduct what we call
- 8:51an equal pay audit, so they can look across all
- 8:54of their employees, take into account job type, gender, disability,
- 9:01all the factors that we know impact pay, and do
- 9:05an internal analysis of hey, are we actually paying everybody
- 9:10equitably just ourselves? Just to start with, that's like I
- 9:14want to say, the bare minimum those so many companies
- 9:17are not doing it, and then they should also make
- 9:20that public to their employees, so people know and understand
- 9:25even if they're falling short, what are the commitments they
- 9:28have to getting to pay equity for people. So that's
- 9:32really important. They should also be transparent. I think you've
- 9:36probably seen if you look at jobs listings in the
- 9:38last couple of years, there's a greater focus now on
- 9:43your applying for a job. And you and I know,
- 9:46twenty years ago it never said how much it was
- 9:49going to be right. You were kind of guessing what
- 9:51am I going to get paid here? And now there's
- 9:54an increasing move and some states have legislation around paid transparency,
- 9:59but that's an act. Employers can easily take post the
- 10:03job with the amount of salary that it's going to have.
- 10:08And then, you know, one other thing I would say
- 10:09that I think is a little under the radar is
- 10:13supporting unions. You know, we know that unions increase pay
- 10:19for everyone, but there's a smaller gender wage gap among
- 10:23union workers. The effects are particularly big for Latinas who
- 10:27see the biggest union bump. So if you're an employer
- 10:31and your employees are organizing or you're already have a union,
- 10:35supporting that union and working in good faith with that
- 10:39union is a huge step to pay transparency and pay equity.
- 10:44Speaker 1: Yeah, it is encouraging that there are steps that employers
- 10:49can take, but I would like to see more companies
- 10:52commit to those steps.
- 10:55Speaker 3: Yes, companies, And this is where I think that consumer
- 10:58buyer power is so important. Is you know, by from
- 11:03companies you know we're doing the right thing. Do a
- 11:06little bit of research, and they're usually pretty good at saying,
- 11:09hey we don't have a way to yap, or hey
- 11:11we are committed to pay equity. You know, they like
- 11:15to highlight these things because if it's a value for
- 11:18the company, it can be a value for the consumer.
- 11:21And I do think, you know, it's very important. This
- 11:24has made a lot of progress in terms of the
- 11:27environmental movement, but I do think we have farther to
- 11:30go in the pay equity movement of folks and consumers
- 11:34focusing on and we know women drive a lot of
- 11:37the consumer economy by from companies who are doing the
- 11:41right thing, and that's going to help move more companies
- 11:44to do the right thing.
- 11:46Speaker 1: Yeah, you know, and it's kind of difficult in today's
- 11:50economy when there are companies that are solely are driving
- 11:56the marketplace for a particular product, So you don't you
- 12:01don't have any choice but to go to that particular,
- 12:04that particular company. So, but you're right, actionabal steps that
- 12:10people can take is actually buying from companies that are
- 12:13doing the right thing.
- 12:15Speaker 3: Yeah.
- 12:17Speaker 1: So your work often focused on telling a holistic story
- 12:22about the policies that support women. Could you elaborate on
- 12:26how separate issues like access to affordable childcare and pay
- 12:31leads are fundamentally linked to a woman's economic security and
- 12:37her ability to earn equal pay.
- 12:41Speaker 3: Yeah, you know, I think of this so much in
- 12:44our work because we often have these policies that might
- 12:48be focused on maternity leave or focused on paid discrimination,
- 12:53but in people's everyday lies, it's all part and parcel
- 12:57of the same conversation, right, and is like it's Tuesday,
- 13:01it's paid discrimination day. Tomorrow I'm going to wake up
- 13:04and think about childcare, right, It's on your mind all
- 13:08the time, and so, well, you know, one example I
- 13:11think about a lot is, you know, if you're a
- 13:14mom and you're thinking about maybe going back to work,
- 13:18but childcare costs more than you're actually going to make
- 13:23at your job, and in part because you're being paid
- 13:27less at your job than maybe a man might be
- 13:30being paid. That's going to impact your decision on how
- 13:34much you work, what kind of work you do, And
- 13:37of course that time out of the labor market is
- 13:41going to impact your economic security, not just now, but
- 13:46way into the future. You know, some people who are
- 13:49twenty years younger than I am are just starting out
- 13:52in their career and they're maybe not thinking about their
- 13:55retirement right. It seems far away, but the decisions they're
- 13:59making today are impacting that, and that influences everything, you know.
- 14:04I think a lot about my grandmother who had six kids.
- 14:09She's basically raising kids. She'd a kid in the house
- 14:12for over thirty five years, and that was of course
- 14:17at a time when we didn't have maternity leave, which
- 14:20we still don't have, and of course that impacted her
- 14:24inability to be able to go into the paid libor
- 14:27force and have her own economic security right. And so
- 14:32these things are so intimately connected in people's everyday lives
- 14:36and the decisions they're making for themselves, their careers, their families.
- 14:42All of those factors are shaped together, which is why
- 14:45we need so many multifaceted solutions that truly support people
- 14:50across the board.
- 14:52Speaker 1: Yeah, and you bring up the balot point. I know
- 14:56a woman in particular who chose not to work and
- 15:00stay at home and take care of her children while
- 15:03they were young because childcare was so expensive it just
- 15:08didn't make sense to work. And so these are the
- 15:12choices that women have to make. So, looking at the
- 15:17current political and economic landscape, what gives you the most
- 15:21hope that we can finally close the pay gap for good?
- 15:25Speaker 3: I love this question because I think it's so hopeful
- 15:28and the right one for us to keep in mind,
- 15:32particularly in this moment when everything feels like it's on fire,
- 15:36right and we're on the heels of the pay gap
- 15:38getting wider for the second year in a row. I
- 15:43would say the good news here is we know a
- 15:46lot about what works to help close the pay gap.
- 15:49And there are the things you and I have been
- 15:50chatting about already, Right, how do we support women's caregiving
- 15:55and childcare responsibilities? How do we have childcare? Also? How
- 16:01do you help women go into some jobs that are
- 16:04maybe a little non traditional for them, things like construction,
- 16:07things like manufacturing where the pay might be better right
- 16:10than say waitressing or you know, working in an early
- 16:15child care facility. We both need to improve the pay
- 16:19across all jobs and open new doors for women into
- 16:23non traditional jobs. So we have a lot of tools
- 16:27at our disposal that will help us close the wage gap.
- 16:32And then I would say the second thing that's good
- 16:34about those is these things are popular. People get it,
- 16:39they want paid leave, they love childcare right, and so
- 16:45people across of all different stripes, political affiliations, regional, you know,
- 16:50all different groups of different racial groups, men and women,
- 16:53they are behind these policies that we know support people,
- 16:59support all working people and help to close the wage gap.
- 17:04So I would say we have the tools, and people
- 17:07like the tools. We just need to be able to
- 17:10use them.
- 17:11Speaker 1: Yeah, it's encouraging to hear the change is actually happening,
- 17:15all these organizations that are coming together to close the
- 17:19page gap. Even though it's incremental, but change is happening.
- 17:26Speaker 3: Yes. Absolutely. You look back at where we were when
- 17:29the equal payacked passed some sixty plus years ago, and
- 17:34we've closed the gap dramatically, and so it is possible.
- 17:39And I think that's the important thing for folks to
- 17:41keep in mind.
- 17:42Speaker 1: Yeah, so many young women starting their careers are unsure
- 17:49how to navigate salary negotiations. What is your single most
- 17:54important piece of advice for a young women to ensure
- 17:57she has paid what she's worked from the very beginning
- 18:01of her career.
- 18:03Speaker 3: Yeah, it's a great question, and it's a hard one
- 18:06because we've talked about all these systemic factors.
- 18:09Speaker 1: Right.
- 18:09Speaker 3: Unfortunately, there's nothing any individual woman can do to like
- 18:15de haack, all of that at one time, but there
- 18:18are certainly some individual level things. So first of all,
- 18:23as we were chatting about pay transparency, you know, do
- 18:26your research if you want to go be a graphic
- 18:29designer or a nurse or a teacher, look around, look
- 18:34at glassdoor, and indeed research what the pay is for
- 18:39your field, your organization, so you're equipped to be able
- 18:44to make, you know, make those decisions and evaluate if
- 18:48the pay is being done fairly. We also talked about
- 18:51from a consumer perspective, trying to work for companies or sorry,
- 18:55trying to buy from companies who hold your values. That's
- 18:58true as a worker too, right, especially for some of
- 19:02these bigger companies, you can do research into knowing what
- 19:06types of policies they have, who they support, what they support.
- 19:11So you know, young men, young women, young everybody they
- 19:15can all look into that and know what's happening. I
- 19:18would also say, you know, it's in the States, it's
- 19:23a little taboo to talk about money. People don't talk
- 19:26about how much they're making. But maybe be that change
- 19:30chat with your girlfriends. You know, this is what I'm
- 19:33considering with this job. This it's gonna pay me fifty
- 19:36thousand dollars. What do you think about that? Does that
- 19:39seem fair?
- 19:40Speaker 2: Right?
- 19:40Speaker 3: Sort of break down those barriers that we have that
- 19:45keep you know, folks in the dark about how much
- 19:48they're making. And then I'll just add to say, you know,
- 19:52organizations like the National Partnership where I work, we try
- 19:56to put out information about companies who are leading in
- 19:59these the areas. We have a project called the Leading
- 20:03on Leave Index. It assesses paid leave policies and highlights
- 20:07some leaders of paid leave policies. So you can always
- 20:11look to sort of you know, independent third parties who
- 20:18are kind of doing that work for you and pulling
- 20:20all the information together to assess things.
- 20:23Speaker 1: And also even if it's your first job at McDonald's.
- 20:26Speaker 3: Negotiate, negotiate. It never hurts to ask right, never hurts,
- 20:32and keep negotiating right. Once you're in there, ask to
- 20:36move up. Right. I think women in particular think they're
- 20:40not qualified or they're you know, not ready for it.
- 20:44But yes, keep pushing.
- 20:47Speaker 1: Yeah, giving your work with the National Partnership. What is
- 20:53a simple actionable step a young woman can take today
- 20:58to support policy changes will benefit not only her but
- 21:02also future generations of women in the workforce.
- 21:06Speaker 3: Yeah, I feel like I'm assigning a lot of homework
- 21:09to all these young women, but I do think My
- 21:12answer again is, you know, do your research. Do you
- 21:15know what your values are? You know what you're supporting,
- 21:18and if it's, for example, diversity, equity and inclusion policies
- 21:23that ensure that women, women of color, disabled women have
- 21:28a fair shot in the workplace, you know, figure out
- 21:33which politicians are supporting that, which policy makers are supporting that.
- 21:37So you can align your values with the values of
- 21:42the people that say you're voting for or supporting in
- 21:44some other way. Right, make those informed choices to make
- 21:50sure that the people you're working with and you know, supporting,
- 21:55are aligned with where you wanted to go. And that's
- 21:58true for example, if you in a state where maybe
- 22:01there's ballad initiatives, sometimes it's a little confusing. There's a
- 22:04lot of language on those, but you know, take your time,
- 22:08do your research, make sure you're registered to vote, and
- 22:12then dig in so you know that your voice is
- 22:15being heard, not just for your own future, but for
- 22:19all of the policies that you want to see to
- 22:22support everyone. Right, So that's kind of I guess maybe
- 22:25the last piece of homework I would give people is
- 22:28engage in your local community and up to the national
- 22:32level and really learn about the things that you hold
- 22:36dear and that you think are important and who also
- 22:39supports those.
- 22:41Speaker 1: And I will just add on today, just follow organizations
- 22:44like National Partnership for Women and Families that are doing
- 22:47the work and they suggest actionable steps that you can take.
- 22:54Speaker 3: That's a great point, and I should have said that.
- 22:57You know, if you sign up for an org like ours,
- 23:00you're on our list serve. We'll let you know. We
- 23:02have our finger on the pulls. You know. We have
- 23:05folks who are meeting with legislators. We know, you know,
- 23:08like if there's going to be a vote in Congress,
- 23:11we can help demystify that for you and be able
- 23:14to say, hey, this is happening right now, this would
- 23:18support fair pay or this would support paid leave and
- 23:21here's what you can do. So yeah, definitely sign up
- 23:25for those so that piece of information and we and
- 23:30our partners will be sure to tell you what's going on.
- 23:34Speaker 1: Well, thank you so much, Kate. That is some excellent
- 23:38advice and it's great that there are some actionable steps
- 23:42that we can take that will really impact generational change.
- 23:49Speaker 3: Well, thank you so much, Juliane. And also you guys
- 23:51should keep listening to Julin. I mean, she's going to
- 23:55keep bringing you all this great information and all these
- 23:57different perspectives, so make sure you're doing that as well.
- 24:00Speaker 1: That's it for this episode of Conversations for Equal Pay.
- 24:05To tune into more episodes, log onto our website at
- 24:09Conversations forequalpay dot org. You're listening to Conversations for Equal
- 24:17Pay