Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / From Deal to Dispute: Litigation Lessons for Entertainment Transactional Attorneys
Transcript
- 0:03I think we are ready to begin. Hello, everybody.
- 0:06I'm Keith Cooper. I'm the vice chair of the Beverly
- 0:09Hills bar entertainment law section. And today's
- 0:14panel panel today's speaker is here to talk about
- 0:17from deal to dispute litigation lessons for entertainment
- 0:21transactional attorneys. One note, kind of a
- 0:25housekeeping note, I need to mention that this
- 0:28is uh sponsored today's event is sponsored by
- 0:31lawyers mutual insurance company and lawyers
- 0:34mutual insurance company for those of you who
- 0:36are not familiar with it has for five decades
- 0:39been the only california -based company to continuously
- 0:43provide lawyers with professional liability insurance
- 0:46coverage their experience and expertise are contemplated
- 0:50by the fact or complemented sorry by the fact
- 0:52that They are directed by a group of dedicated
- 0:56lawyers. They offer special rates with competitive
- 0:59programs for a wide range of areas of practice,
- 1:02including entertainment law. And you could learn
- 1:05more if you go to lawyersmutual .com. I will
- 1:08mention that apparently they, I've just learned
- 1:11they have an ethics hotline similar to the state
- 1:14bar. ethics hotline. So if you do sign up with
- 1:18them, you can give them a call and say, hey,
- 1:20we have an ethical quandary here or ethical question,
- 1:23and they will respond to that for you. So that's
- 1:25kind of a handy tool to have. And now I am excited
- 1:31to announce Ashley Defintorum, our speaker today.
- 1:35Ashley is an attorney at Kinsella, Hawley, Isser,
- 1:39Kump, and Steinspar. If I'm butchering that,
- 1:43that's a mouthful as it is. But they are a preeminent
- 1:47litigation boutique for entertainment, media,
- 1:49music, and IP matters. Ashley handles a wide
- 1:52range of entertainment litigation, including
- 1:54breach of contract, copyright, and trademark
- 1:57infringement and employee claims. She also leads
- 2:02workplace investigations for company in response
- 2:05to employee complaints of discrimination, harassment,
- 2:09and retaliation. I will elaborate on that just
- 2:12for a quick second, because that is somebody
- 2:14that's handy to know if ever a client comes to
- 2:18you and says, we're having an employee dispute,
- 2:21you as the attorney. don't want to do the investigation.
- 2:24It's really good to utilize outside counsel such
- 2:27as Ashley to do an objective investigation in
- 2:30the matter. I've done that for clients in the
- 2:33past, so that is a very handy service and skill
- 2:35that she provides. She has also served as outside
- 2:39pro bono counsel to GLAAD, which is a national
- 2:42organization with a mission to garner full acceptance
- 2:45of the LGBTQ plus community through accurate
- 2:49media representation. Beyond work, Ashley is
- 2:52active in the community and dedicated to public
- 2:55service and promoting diversity. for the LGBTQ
- 2:59plus centers and has created an elimination of
- 3:03bias CLE presentation titled exactly that LGBTQ
- 3:07plus allyship for legal professionals which is
- 3:11presented to several companies and organizations
- 3:15and with that I'm going to turn it over to Ashley
- 3:18and thank you very much Ashley for agreeing to
- 3:20do this and thank you for your time. Everybody
- 3:23please enjoy the presentation. Thank you so much,
- 3:27Keith. I really appreciate it. As Keith mentioned,
- 3:30I'm Ashley Duffing -Torum and I work at Kinsella
- 3:33Holley, Eiser Kump and Stein's Appear. We're
- 3:35a boutique entertainment litigation firm that
- 3:37goes by Kix for short. And although we can go
- 3:41ahead and go to the next slide, sorry. Thank
- 3:45you so much. Although I'm a litigator, I really
- 3:48do have great respect for the work that transactional
- 3:52attorneys do. Really, the way I understand it
- 3:55is that transactional attorneys are really what
- 3:57run the entertainment industry. You're the architects,
- 4:01right? You're the ones building the deal structures,
- 4:03anticipating the business needs, aligning the
- 4:05incentives, and trying to prevent the disputes
- 4:08before they ever arise. So when things go well,
- 4:11the project just moves forward and litigators
- 4:14like me just never get involved. But sometimes,
- 4:17as you all know, the parties are going to fight
- 4:19with each other, and sometimes that's going to
- 4:21happen, you know, regardless of how solid your
- 4:24architecture is. Honestly, it's extremely rare,
- 4:28if ever. I really can't recall a specific situation
- 4:31off the top of my head of handling a litigation
- 4:34matter and thinking to myself that the transactional
- 4:37attorneys really messed it up. In fact, more
- 4:40often than not, the problem is that maybe that
- 4:43no transactional attorneys were consulted in
- 4:45the first place. So maybe the parties were operating
- 4:48off of handshake deals or informal understandings
- 4:51or even the assumption that the paperwork would
- 4:54come later down the road. And then sometimes,
- 4:57obviously, attorneys, transactional attorneys
- 4:59are involved, but maybe the deal memo never became
- 5:03a long -form agreement, or maybe everyone just
- 5:06assumed, again, that this would be something
- 5:07that would be papered later and then later never
- 5:10came. And then even where... even in cases where
- 5:14there is a formal and negotiated agreement, the
- 5:18issues being litigated are often very incredibly
- 5:23nuanced issues. And from my experience, they
- 5:26tend to arise from how the project actually unfolded
- 5:29in practice and not from any glaringly obvious
- 5:33drafting failure. In many of those cases, there's
- 5:36actually it seemingly very little the transactional
- 5:39attorney realistically could have done to anticipate
- 5:43how the facts would later be framed in litigation,
- 5:46which maybe sounds a little bit daunting, right?
- 5:49Because we all want the magic formula of how
- 5:51to draft something so that there will never be
- 5:53a dispute. But from my experience, sometimes
- 5:56there's going to be disputes regardless of how
- 5:59it was drafted. So my goal with this in mind,
- 6:03I really have kind of two things I'm going to
- 6:06go through today and two ultimate goals. The
- 6:08first is that I want to walk you through some
- 6:10of the specific and nuanced issues that I've
- 6:13seen come up on the litigation side or even the
- 6:15pre litigation dispute side, including those
- 6:18like nuanced and hard to spot issues. My goal
- 6:21with this portion is just to give you some additional
- 6:24perspective or ideas on where the exposure might.
- 6:28tend to arise, right? So the idea being even
- 6:31if there's not a magic formula to create an agreement
- 6:34where it will never ever be disputed to still
- 6:37see some of these nuanced examples of where things
- 6:40fell apart. And maybe that helps inform for your
- 6:43clients or for a situation where similar things
- 6:46might come up. And then really the second part
- 6:49of the presentation, I'm going to spend some
- 6:51time talking specifically about what happens
- 6:54in a situation where a Company has a creative
- 6:57professional contribute to a project, but the
- 7:00parties fail to sign an agreement before that
- 7:02project is complete or before it's released into
- 7:05the public. And this portion is kind of going
- 7:08to be at a little bit of a higher level in some
- 7:10ways, because obviously that topic in and of
- 7:13itself could be talked about for hours. But this
- 7:16is an issue I've heard transactional entertainment
- 7:19attorneys come across. You know, that is specifically
- 7:22the issue where the production company hires
- 7:24the creative professional. to work on a project,
- 7:27but they never happen to end up executing or
- 7:30signing that agreement. So I wanted to be sure
- 7:32to go over that. And then I should have time
- 7:35to answer hopefully at least a few questions
- 7:38at the end of the presentation. So please do
- 7:40feel free to drop any questions you have in the
- 7:44Q &A portion and I'll do my best to get through
- 7:46them at the end of the presentation. And then
- 7:49if we run out of time, I'm always happy to chat
- 7:51individually offline as well. Next slide, please.
- 7:58Thank you. Okay, so first, as promised, I'm going
- 8:00to spend some time talking about the entertainment
- 8:04litigation issues I've specifically worked on.
- 8:08Again, these issues are going to be incredibly
- 8:10nuanced, but I think it's helpful to share them
- 8:12because perhaps they're going to shed light on
- 8:15where that exposure tends to arise, which can
- 8:17then obviously help you all or help transactional
- 8:20entertainment attorneys when they're putting
- 8:21the contracts together. Next slide, please. Okay,
- 8:28so this first matter is a pre -litigation dispute
- 8:30that was resolved discreetly without litigation.
- 8:33So obviously, for all of these, I'm not gonna
- 8:35tell you any of the party's names or the precise
- 8:37details of any of the films or the projects at
- 8:40issue, but I can obviously speak about them more
- 8:43generally. So this matter involved a documentary
- 8:47film about our client's primary business. our
- 8:51client ultimately bought the production company
- 8:54and the producer out of the project. So our client,
- 8:58through a written agreement, acquired all of
- 9:00the rights, the title, and the interest pursuant
- 9:03to that written agreement that was signed by
- 9:05all the parties. Important for this matter is
- 9:09that the written agreement limited the production
- 9:11company's ability to promote or publicize the
- 9:15film. It included, you know, I think this is
- 9:17standard in these types of agreements, right?
- 9:19So some sort of section where, you know, this
- 9:22one required prior written permission to make
- 9:25pretty much any statements about the film whatsoever.
- 9:29And importantly, you know... kind of feeding
- 9:32into that or related to that for this issue is
- 9:34the agreement also stated that the production
- 9:37company would have to return some portion of
- 9:41the purchase price for the rights if they breach
- 9:43this portion of the agreement. But then after
- 9:46the agreement was executed, the production company
- 9:49in this matter continued to make some public
- 9:51statements about the project. And they did so
- 9:54without first getting that prior written permission.
- 9:57So for example, and probably most troublingly
- 10:00to our client was the production company would
- 10:03go to some of the film festivals and speak with
- 10:07the organizers and sort of preface what the film
- 10:10was about. And there were different things going
- 10:12on there that our client didn't. want happening,
- 10:16even just for the optics of there should really
- 10:19be one point person our client thought in speaking
- 10:22about the project and the owner wanted it to
- 10:24be themselves and not the prior owner. So in
- 10:29doing that, we put together the demand letter
- 10:31asking them to stop pointing to the points of
- 10:34the agreement as one would do in this type of
- 10:36dispute. So we carefully explained that there
- 10:39was a breach of the agreement and then, you know,
- 10:42the ramifications and just really just wanting
- 10:44them to stop the actions, cease and desist letter.
- 10:47The production company responded by claiming
- 10:50that they were within their rights to talk about
- 10:52the project to the organizers of the film festivals.
- 10:56And to support their argument, they cited one
- 10:59single sentence that was... It was one sentence
- 11:02in the agreement that did allow that production
- 11:05company and the producers or the prior owners
- 11:07to make reference to the project and the producers
- 11:11professional publicity. That point is really
- 11:15why I wanted to talk about this matter, because
- 11:17I know those types of sentences or clauses and
- 11:19these types of acquisition rights deals are common.
- 11:24So practically speaking, the prior owner, in
- 11:27this case, the producer, is still going to want
- 11:30to be able to credit themselves, have it listed
- 11:32on IMDB, and those types of things. So to be
- 11:35able to talk, reference their work on it in professional
- 11:39publicity makes sense. But in this case, I think
- 11:42it was interesting because it was being used
- 11:45to, you know, in our client's view to open the
- 11:48door to more things that the parties didn't intend.
- 11:53So we responded that they're, you know, unsurprisingly,
- 11:58we disagreed with their interpretation of the
- 12:00sentence. and pointed back to the whole section
- 12:05that was dedicated to needing this prior written
- 12:07permission for the company to talk about the
- 12:10film. And we reiterated the fact that we didn't
- 12:14want them to continue speaking with the organizers
- 12:16of the film festivals. Now the end here is, they
- 12:20never wrote back. To my knowledge, we got, you
- 12:22know, the client got what they needed, those
- 12:24types of communications stopped, which is obviously
- 12:27good for our client, for the parties involved,
- 12:29for the film itself. But the takeaway here really
- 12:32is, I think it emphasizes the importance of detailing
- 12:36exactly what the parties want in the written
- 12:38agreements, right? So here the parties, again,
- 12:42from our perspective, clearly intended that the
- 12:45production company... wouldn't make any public
- 12:47statements about that project unless they get
- 12:49the prior written authorization. But there was
- 12:53apparently some confusion over a separate sentence
- 12:56that did allow that production company to make
- 12:58reference to the project in their professional
- 13:02publicity. So perhaps, I guess, for one takeaway,
- 13:06perhaps an even stronger way to write that portion
- 13:08would be You know, you could add a sentence immediately
- 13:11following that sentence about professional publicity
- 13:13stating that, you know, nothing in this clause
- 13:16is intended to alter that other section. It's
- 13:19very, you know, I know that's common. A lot of
- 13:21you probably already do it, but just, you know,
- 13:24it may seem like a minor detail, but thought
- 13:26it might be helpful to point that out. And I
- 13:29also wanted to point out that it was hard for
- 13:32the drafters of this agreement to assume exactly
- 13:35how the production company might interfere with
- 13:38the project in the future. I don't think our
- 13:43client genuinely thought there was a possibility
- 13:46here or any confusion where the prior owner would
- 13:49go speak to the organizers of the film festivals.
- 13:52But thankfully here, I think the agreement was
- 13:56drafted in a way that was specific enough, again,
- 13:58at least we think, to cover these specific circumstances.
- 14:03Next slide, please. Thank you. So I also want
- 14:09to briefly discuss another pre litigation dispute
- 14:12that was resolved again, discreetly without litigation.
- 14:15So. For this matter, we represented an individual
- 14:18who was hired by a company in the entertainment
- 14:21world to introduce television projects on which
- 14:24the company would provide their services. I'm
- 14:27being vague here intentionally because I don't
- 14:29want to give too much away. But I think this
- 14:32is, in other words, so our client was hired on
- 14:35a commission basis to bring new business into
- 14:37the company. And the parties later parted ways
- 14:40and our client claimed that the company still
- 14:43owed him. frankly all parties agreed that there
- 14:45were still monies owed under the agreement the
- 14:47issue just became how much and based on what
- 14:50and I'll get into that but I just I think it's
- 14:53interesting to pause for a second and flag this
- 14:55because I know this structure of having a you
- 14:59know bringing in a contract or a worker to be
- 15:01paid on a commission basis is popular in many
- 15:05industries, frankly, but obviously in the, I
- 15:07think it's popular in the entertainment industry
- 15:09in particular, where so much of the business
- 15:13and the deals are sort of relationship based.
- 15:15I've seen some, quite a few commission based
- 15:18agreements like this. So the parties for this
- 15:22matter had a signed written agreement, but the
- 15:26agreement itself was incredibly big. So I, And
- 15:31in this, I don't believe it was actually written
- 15:33by a lawyer. It was like a one page agreement
- 15:36that was, I think, like 10 lines. Like it was
- 15:39incredibly vague. And essentially it said that
- 15:41the our client, the worker, would get a bonus
- 15:44for introducing projects and that the bonus would
- 15:47be capped at a certain amount per year. Now,
- 15:51as I mentioned earlier, our client ultimately
- 15:53parted ways with the company, but there were
- 15:55still monies owed under the under the agreement.
- 15:59So we got but there was disagreements on how
- 16:03much was owed and what calculation was to be
- 16:06done. So we got involved on behalf of the client
- 16:08where ultimately we were able to resolve that
- 16:11matter through just discussion and negotiations
- 16:13with the company's attorney without having to
- 16:15ever get to litigation. But highlight this issue
- 16:20because or this pre -dispute matter because pre
- 16:25litigation dispute matter because the issues
- 16:27we went back and forth on with the company's
- 16:29counsel had really just everything to do with
- 16:32how vague that one page agreement was. So for
- 16:35example, the agreement was missing several key
- 16:38details such as with a written agreement was
- 16:41missing these details. So the first was what
- 16:44counts as an introduction by our client? So what
- 16:48happens if our client introduces the head of
- 16:50a television series to the company? but there's
- 16:53someone else in the company who's already kind
- 16:55of met someone else at the entity being introduced,
- 16:59right? So would that count as an introduction?
- 17:02I think that's, and in speaking with some other
- 17:04transactional entertainment attorneys, I know
- 17:07that that can be somewhat of a common issue,
- 17:09right? And I know it's hard to paper as well,
- 17:11but at least to have your clients, to have them,
- 17:14to flag this for them. sort of vagueness or what
- 17:18does introduction mean to you? What do you want
- 17:20it to mean? And kind of thinking about these
- 17:22scenarios beforehand and finding a way to draft
- 17:25those into the written agreement so that all
- 17:29of the parties are on the same page I think would
- 17:32be helpful. Another issue in this particular
- 17:36matter was when do the commission payments become
- 17:39due to our client? This was a... big one because
- 17:44the specific agreement, understandably, the company
- 17:46wanted to cap the commissions for certain, cap
- 17:50it at a certain amount each year, which our client
- 17:53agreed to, but then the disagreement and the
- 17:55issue became, well, when are the payments due,
- 17:58right? So does the company owe the payments to
- 18:02our client, excuse me, owe the commissions to
- 18:05our client at the time the company receives the
- 18:08money from a project? or only once that entire
- 18:11project is completed, right? Because you might
- 18:15be working on a project and you're paid in pieces
- 18:17and then eventually the entire television, the
- 18:19entire television season is over. So is it based
- 18:22on the company receives the payment, sporadic
- 18:25payments, or is it based on overall wrapping
- 18:28and end of the project? Again, that was an important
- 18:31detail here because the parties had agreed to
- 18:35cap the commissions on an annual basis. The kind
- 18:40of last big issue here was what happens if our
- 18:43client introduces a television project to the
- 18:45company and the company Ultimately does services
- 18:49for several seasons of that television show,
- 18:51right? So it was pretty clear on the face of
- 18:53the written agreement that you know for introductions
- 18:56made for a season Course is gonna get payments.
- 18:59I think everyone agreed with that. But what happens
- 19:01on follow -up seasons? What happens if you introduce
- 19:04a project and it's very successful and it continues
- 19:07for five six so -and -so seasons, are the commissions,
- 19:11is he also getting commissions for that or is
- 19:13he not? You know, of course we had our arguments
- 19:17back and forth in this, but I think the lesson
- 19:19here is really to encourage your clients to think
- 19:26of these issues, discuss these issues with the
- 19:28other side, negotiate them and get them into
- 19:31the agreement, you know, the formalized document
- 19:34just to try to help prevent this type of situation.
- 19:39Next slide, please. Thank you. This next matter
- 19:45is a consumer class action case that was filed
- 19:48in federal court against a retailer and its influencers,
- 19:53alleging that the influencers did not properly
- 19:55disclose on social media posts that they were
- 19:58being compensated. by the retailer to make the
- 20:00posts. Plaintiffs in this case argued that the
- 20:04retailer and its influencers had schemed and
- 20:07devised a plan together to have the influencers
- 20:10discreetly post about the retailer's products
- 20:13to essentially trick customers into buying the
- 20:16products. So ultimately, this case was about
- 20:19essentially false advertising allegations and
- 20:22some other related claims. And the same plaintiffs
- 20:25council for this case actually filed a number
- 20:28of these lawsuits around this time, I believe,
- 20:31last year in courts across different jurisdictions.
- 20:34So I saw a few in the central district here in
- 20:38California. I saw some in this particular Illinois
- 20:41Federal Court or Illinois District Court. So
- 20:45in different places, I just wanted to flag that
- 20:47this is happening and pausing here for a moment.
- 20:50I know I'm getting. Again, this is my point of
- 20:52trying to get, I know these are very nuanced
- 20:54issues, but again, some of the examples of things
- 20:57I've worked on in the past year or two that I
- 20:59think could be helpful. So that's why we're kind
- 21:01of jumping around a little bit on some of these
- 21:03different nuanced issues. In this matter, the
- 21:08plaintiffs, frankly for all of these class actions
- 21:12they filed last year, they pointed to the FTC's
- 21:152023 guidelines for social media influencers,
- 21:19which I've clipped the relevant portion I wanted
- 21:22to talk about here. So it says, if you endorse
- 21:25a product through social media, your endorsement
- 21:28message should make it obvious when you have
- 21:30a relationship. or material connection with the
- 21:34brand. A material connection to the brand includes
- 21:37a personal, family, or employment relationship,
- 21:41or a financial relationship such as the brand
- 21:44paying you or giving you free or discounted product
- 21:48or services. So in other words, it's stating
- 21:52that the influencer should disclose when they're
- 21:54getting paid or getting free product to post
- 21:56on Instagram and on other social media sites.
- 21:59Now, in this case, plaintiffs argued that the
- 22:02influencers needed to put clearer disclosures
- 22:05on their posts that clarified that they were
- 22:07being paid by the retailer to make the posts.
- 22:09But notably, neither these FTC guidelines or,
- 22:13frankly, any FTC guidelines or any law at this
- 22:18point, any kind of all -encompassing federal
- 22:21law, states what constitutes a sufficient disclosure
- 22:25on on the social media posts. So for this matter
- 22:30that it was kind of a unique scenario the retailer
- 22:33was actually is a client of the firm but for
- 22:36this matter we represented each of the individual
- 22:38influencers and the retailer had its own council.
- 22:42Ultimately the parties did enter into a global
- 22:44settlement and the case was dismissed very early
- 22:47on before there was even any formal response
- 22:50to the complaint that was filed. Obviously I'm
- 22:53not going to provide any details about the settlement
- 22:55but I can tell you if it hadn't settled the you
- 22:59know, we had prepared in place. I do think there
- 23:01are arguments that could be raised against some
- 23:04of these claims. And there are of the other cases
- 23:07that were filed that were similar to these, the
- 23:10same plaintiffs' counsel, I believe some of them
- 23:12have been dismissed or some of the claims have
- 23:15been dismissed pretty early on. So it's kind
- 23:17of interesting to watch it play out. But regardless,
- 23:20I wanted to flag this, I think a take away from
- 23:23it. is that, you know, as I mentioned, this is
- 23:26one of several class actions that were brought
- 23:28by plaintiffs council last year on this exact
- 23:31issue. And unfortunately, that FTC guidance does
- 23:35not expressly state what the influencer must
- 23:37put on their post to disclose that relationship
- 23:40to the company. But I think this means that it's
- 23:42it's kind of been a little bit of a hotbed of
- 23:44for litigation right now, or at least recently
- 23:47within this past year. And it might be worth
- 23:50it to flag that issue to those of your clients
- 23:52who are either influencers themselves or maybe
- 23:55they're companies that work with or hire influencers
- 23:58for advertising or other things. So, for example,
- 24:02the company might want to include in their contract
- 24:05with the influencer precisely which hashtags
- 24:08or which disclosures the company wants the influencer
- 24:12to include in their post. Now obviously this
- 24:15leads to that natural question of what should
- 24:18the disclosure be and what's sufficient under
- 24:21the law. But as I mentioned, the answer to that
- 24:24question isn't entirely clear right now because
- 24:27nothing expressly states that. But I can tell
- 24:31you one option. Again, this isn't It's tough
- 24:35because there's nothing that's been black and
- 24:37white. This is good. This is not but just a suggestion
- 24:41or one option that could be included is Hashtag,
- 24:44you know company name partner on all of the promotional
- 24:47posts and also potentially if you want to be
- 24:50cautious as well to include something like company
- 24:54partner even on the bio and like the Instagram
- 24:56page or On tick tock or wherever the the influencer
- 25:00is posting things for the company Next slide,
- 25:05please. Okay, so for this one, it's kind of gonna
- 25:11dovetail nicely into the second portion of this,
- 25:14but this is, I wanted to talk about a copyright
- 25:16case that we filed in, obviously, federal court
- 25:21a few weeks ago. So for this case, my firm and
- 25:24I, we represent the plaintiff against a production
- 25:27company. Again, I won't. you know, give specific
- 25:30names or even a case name. But just I think it's
- 25:33a it is a helpful one to talk about. So Plaintiff
- 25:36in this case is a songwriter, a singer and songwriter.
- 25:40But for this one, he had been approached by the
- 25:43production company to write and produce music
- 25:46for an animated film. The key part of the pitch
- 25:51to get him to write on it was that the song was
- 25:54going to be sung by a particular kind of like
- 25:57a megastar singer or artist. The production company
- 26:01had promised that that recording of the song
- 26:05by the megastar would then be included on the
- 26:08soundtrack for the film, that it would be released
- 26:11in a single, and that the production company
- 26:14would make the song a full marketing campaign,
- 26:17including for an Academy Award. The production
- 26:21company continued to kind of reiterate that that
- 26:24was the plan all along for, I think it was like
- 26:27two, two and a half years. So the songwriter
- 26:29was working on the song at some point. he was
- 26:32asked to write another song for the same for
- 26:35the same film and did so. Now the parties in
- 26:39this case had begun negotiating licenses for
- 26:43the songs and for the recordings so these would
- 26:45be the work made for hire agreements and those
- 26:49negotiations kind of throughout the process were
- 26:51based on an economic framework where there was
- 26:55this understanding where the megastars you know
- 26:58piece that her song would be pushed for like
- 27:04giving a full marketing campaign and released
- 27:06as a single. Just the deal structure was based
- 27:09on that essentially. So less money upfront for
- 27:11our client, but potentially stronger backend
- 27:14with the commercial release of the song. But
- 27:16then just a few weeks before the release of the
- 27:18film, the company told the songwriter for the
- 27:21first time that... that one particular song by
- 27:24the megastar was no longer going to be commercially
- 27:26released at all. As you can imagine, that shifted
- 27:29the tides quite a bit and the negotiations halted
- 27:32as a result. You know, our client had... made
- 27:37its demands for you know in his perspective now
- 27:40wanted more upfront money since there wouldn't
- 27:42be back end because it wouldn't be commercially
- 27:44released and all these things. Essentially though
- 27:46the deal fell through there was no no certainly
- 27:50no signing of any written agreement and the film
- 27:55the animated film was released with both of the
- 27:58two songs in it anyways and the production company
- 28:02never paid for any of the songs, for either of
- 28:05the two. So there's four copyrights, right? Because
- 28:07there's in two of the songs. So there was no
- 28:10work made for hire agreement on either of the
- 28:13songs. And there also was no payment for either
- 28:17of the songs. And the kind of talks and negotiations
- 28:21or, you know, demands for payment and for these
- 28:24things in a different agreement continued after
- 28:27the film's released. But it, you know, it halted
- 28:30at some point. Essentially that's the punchline
- 28:32is there was never signed agreements and there
- 28:35was never any payment for use of any of the four
- 28:38copyrights. So as a result of that the our client
- 28:43or the songwriter has sued for copyright infringement,
- 28:48there's some misrepresentation claims, and there's
- 28:51both intentional and negligent misrepresentation
- 28:54claims. So in this case, we haven't yet stated
- 28:57the amount of damages that we're seeking, but
- 28:59I can tell you the types of damages for this
- 29:01type of case would be compensatory damages, disgorgement
- 29:05of profits, punitive damages, attorney's fees
- 29:09and costs, and potentially even injunctive relief
- 29:12as well. Those are the types of damages in these
- 29:15copyrights. claims. The takeaway for this one
- 29:18is really that I wanted to flag this because
- 29:22it's going to be a costly dispute. It's arguably
- 29:27not fun for anyone, anyone except maybe the litigators,
- 29:30to actually be in litigation. And for this matter
- 29:34in particular, I know the production company
- 29:36has put forth its position that their hands were
- 29:40tied at the last minute. It wasn't their fault
- 29:43that the song couldn't be commercially released.
- 29:45It had to do with other issues. But even then,
- 29:48you know, from certainly from our perspective,
- 29:51but I think also just the legal perspective,
- 29:53the production company is probably going to be
- 29:55on the hook right for for promising one thing,
- 29:58it not happening and for deciding to then continue
- 30:01to release the film with the two songs in it
- 30:05without paying for it and without any sort of
- 30:07written agreement on it. And. I think just coming
- 30:15from the production company had the choice to
- 30:18release the film with those copyrighted works
- 30:20in it without first getting the permission or
- 30:24the license to do so. And that was really, I
- 30:28mean, that's the takeaway I kind of wanted to
- 30:29flag for this one. But I think if we can go to
- 30:32the next slide, I think this dovetails nicely
- 30:34into sort of the second half or the second portion
- 30:37of the presentation where I wanted to talk about
- 30:40what happens when a creative contributes to a
- 30:43project without signing an agreement. So as you
- 30:47know, it's important to get written signed work
- 30:49made for hire agreements in circumstances like
- 30:51this where the creative or excuse me, where the
- 30:54company has a creative contribute to a project.
- 30:57Next slide, please. So first, I want to go over
- 31:02a little bit of background regarding why this
- 31:05is important. So under US copyright law, the
- 31:08person who creates the work is by default considered
- 31:12the owner of the copyright. That's true. unless
- 31:16there is a written and signed work made for hire
- 31:19agreement between the company and the creative
- 31:23professional. So if there is a signed work made
- 31:25for hire agreement, then the company for which
- 31:28the work is created and not the creative is the
- 31:31owner of that copyright. But if there is no signed
- 31:34agreement, the default rule is that the creator
- 31:37is the copyright owner. So for example, Maybe
- 31:41just like the example I gave, maybe a studio
- 31:43or a production company hires a songwriter to
- 31:46write a song for an animated film, but you see
- 31:48it in other areas too. So maybe you hire a dance
- 31:51choreographer to create a sequence for a television
- 31:53show or a writer to draft a scene for a film
- 31:57or a TV, a television series. So without that
- 32:00signed work made for hire agreement, Any copyright
- 32:03created for the project is owned by the creative
- 32:07and not the studio. That's going to be true even
- 32:10where the studio pays the creative and also even
- 32:13when it's clear, even if it's otherwise clear
- 32:16that all of the parties agree that the work was
- 32:18created for that commercial project. So then
- 32:23what happens when the project is released without
- 32:26the company first getting that signed work made
- 32:28for hire agreement? Well, the creative professional
- 32:31can assert different types of claims against
- 32:33the company. Some examples of the most common
- 32:38types of claims are breach of implied contract,
- 32:42copyright infringement, fraud, and just kind
- 32:45of another bucket of employment -related claims.
- 32:47So the creative could even bring all of these
- 32:50claims in the same lawsuit against the company.
- 32:52As you can imagine, this could get pretty messy.
- 32:56big, blow up into a big dispute much faster than
- 33:00anyone probably wants it to. So, next slide please.
- 33:07This leads me to my next point. So, okay, so
- 33:08what's at risk? What do these claims actually
- 33:10mean and what's at risk for the company? I want
- 33:15to talk about the damages that the company might
- 33:18owe if they lose on any of these types of claims.
- 33:22You may already know this, but I just I found
- 33:25it even for my own practice to kind of go through
- 33:27and write it out. I thought it might be helpful.
- 33:29So for breach of implied contract, other types
- 33:33of damages involved for but essentially the most
- 33:35important one to know for this is the company
- 33:38loses on this type of claim. It's going to owe
- 33:40the creative the value of the creative services.
- 33:44Other damages like punitive damages and injunctive
- 33:47relief are typically not available on a breach
- 33:50of implied contract claim. But for copyright
- 33:53infringement claims, this next one, the stakes
- 33:56are much higher. So if the company loses on a
- 33:59copyright infringement claim, it's going to owe
- 34:02the creative. several different types of damages,
- 34:06including compensatory damages, disgorgement
- 34:08of profits, the creative's attorney's fees in
- 34:12pursuing the claims, statutory damages are also
- 34:15available, including enhanced ones if it's determined
- 34:18that the infringement was willful. And then injunctive
- 34:22relief is also available on copyright infringement
- 34:24claims. So obviously something like injunctive
- 34:27relief, which would require that company to stop
- 34:29exploiting or distributing the project, could
- 34:31be dire for the company after In many instances,
- 34:35they've likely spent years and a lot of money
- 34:36to help develop and create the project. Now for
- 34:40fraud claims, this would be the type of claim
- 34:44where the creative says that kind of similar
- 34:46to the... the one I just mentioned, or we just
- 34:51walked through the specific example, but it's
- 34:52where the creative says, essentially, you know,
- 34:54the company promised me that they would give
- 34:56me X, they knew they wouldn't give me X, and
- 34:59then, you know, it induced me to provide the
- 35:03services, and then they didn't give me what was
- 35:05promised. For those types of claims, if you're
- 35:08able to prove them on the creative side, the
- 35:11company would be liable for... for punitive damages
- 35:14as well. Punitive damages are the damages that
- 35:18are meant to punish the other side. So the jury
- 35:22is allowed to take whatever the actual damages
- 35:24are and multiply them by some amount. It could
- 35:27be typically, different courts have different
- 35:29rules, but typically it's up to like 10 times
- 35:32the amount. So for example, but I think it's,
- 35:35candidly I think it's a little bit rare for it
- 35:37to go up to 10 times unless it's, you know. whatever
- 35:39the issue is, is the jury finds it's essentially
- 35:42so outrageous or warrants a lot of punishment.
- 35:45But even let's just take a three time multiple.
- 35:48So let's say actual damages, a jury finds the
- 35:50actual damages of five million. And let's say
- 35:53they do a three times multiple for punitive damages,
- 35:56because it was fraud. That would be 15, right?
- 36:01So it could be, that would total. the five plus
- 36:04the 15 and 20 million. So that inflates the claim
- 36:07from something or inflates the damages amount
- 36:09quite a bit for, you know, if the other side's
- 36:13able, the plaintiff's able to prove fraud. Now,
- 36:17employment, for employment -related claims, Essentially,
- 36:22these types of claims would look like where the
- 36:24creative would argue that they were misclassified
- 36:27as an independent contractor when they should
- 36:30have been treated as an employee. For those types
- 36:32of claims, if the worker is successful, this
- 36:35would open the door to a array of different issues
- 36:38for the company. The company could face liability
- 36:41for unpaid wages or overtime, employee benefits,
- 36:46payroll, taxes, penalties, interest, attorney's
- 36:50fees. and statutory penalties and all of this
- 36:53would add up very quickly as you can imagine.
- 36:56So that's a little bit of what's at stake for
- 36:59the company if the project is released without
- 37:02the company first getting a signed work make
- 37:05for hire agreement. Next slide, please. Thank
- 37:12you. Okay, so now I want to talk about how courts
- 37:16deal with claims in the entertainment industry
- 37:18for breach of an implied contract and for the
- 37:21copyright infringement claims. For purposes of
- 37:24this presentation, I'm not going to dive into
- 37:27the fraud or employment claims just because we
- 37:30just don't have enough time. And I think it might
- 37:32be a little bit more helpful to go through this
- 37:34breach of implied contract and the copyright
- 37:36claims in this instance anyways. First, let's
- 37:40walk through the breach of implied contract claims.
- 37:44In California, contracts can be formed by words
- 37:47or by conduct. A contract formed by words can,
- 37:50of course, be written or can be verbal. And I
- 37:53want to pause here just for a second to emphasize
- 37:56that this means there can be times where the
- 37:58creative professional can say that there was
- 38:00a verbal agreement reached with the company.
- 38:02Of course, the issue is then going to be proving
- 38:04or disproving, depending on what side you're
- 38:06on, what was actually verbally agreed upon. But
- 38:10as I said, California law states that contracts
- 38:13can also be formed by conduct in addition to
- 38:16words. So when contracts are formed by conduct,
- 38:20these are called implied contracts. The implied
- 38:24contracts must have all of the same elements
- 38:27of the written or verbal contracts. So there's
- 38:31going to need to be mutual consent, consideration,
- 38:33and everything else that's normally needed for
- 38:36your standard written or verbal contract. You
- 38:39need the same for implied contracts. The only
- 38:41difference is that the agreement is formed by
- 38:44conduct of the parties. So, do California courts
- 38:49recognize the existence of implied contracts?
- 38:52Absolutely. But what does that look like in this
- 38:54context where the company hired the creative
- 38:57professional to contribute to a project, but
- 38:59the parties later fail to sign an agreement?
- 39:02Well, to answer that, I want to examine some
- 39:04of these cases here. So the Seminole case on
- 39:07the issue of implied contracts in the entertainment
- 39:10industry is a California Supreme Court case from
- 39:121956 called Desney versus Wilder. In the Desney
- 39:17case, the court ruled that a creative professional
- 39:19can state a claim for breach of implied contract,
- 39:22even where the work created does not itself constitute
- 39:26a copyright. I'm going to say that one more time,
- 39:28because it's super important. So in this Desney
- 39:30case, the California Supreme Court held that
- 39:32even if an idea itself is not protected by copyright,
- 39:36is not unique enough, or for whatever reason
- 39:38does not constitute a copyright, the creative
- 39:40could still have a claim for breach of an implied
- 39:44contract. I point out this case is it really
- 39:48is honestly the seminal case for this and it
- 39:50remains the law today. It's nearly always referred
- 39:53to in idea submission cases and those are cases
- 39:57where a creative or a person argues that they
- 40:00had the idea for a project and the company should
- 40:03be paying them for that idea. Now the Desney
- 40:07case was about a writer who submitted to Paramount
- 40:10an idea for a photo play. I actually had to look
- 40:14with that word up. I had to look that word up
- 40:16because I wasn't sure what it meant. But apparently
- 40:18it's an old -fashioned term for film. This is
- 40:21a case from 1956. But when the person presented
- 40:25the idea, he told Paramount that he would like...
- 40:29them to pay him if they use the idea. And then
- 40:32later, without paying the writer, Paramount released
- 40:34a film that the writer claimed was based on his
- 40:37idea. So ultimately, the writer sued Paramount.
- 40:41And Paramount argued that the entire lawsuit
- 40:44should be tossed out before ever getting to a
- 40:46jury because the writer's idea was not unique
- 40:50enough to constitute a copyright. The court agreed
- 40:54with Paramount that the idea couldn't possibly
- 40:57be a copyright because it wasn't unique enough,
- 40:59but it still held that the writer might be able
- 41:01to prevail on a claim for breach of an implied
- 41:04contract. Now, this next case is the Grosso versus
- 41:10Miramax Film Corp case from the 9th Circuit back
- 41:14in 2004. But it's still good law today. So this
- 41:18case kind of expanded on or explained the Desney
- 41:21case a little bit more. So for this one, it put
- 41:25forth the standard of how to state a claim for
- 41:28breach of implied contract under Desney. It said
- 41:32that the plaintiff would need to show that three
- 41:35things, that the plaintiff prepared the work,
- 41:37that the plaintiff disclosed the work for sale
- 41:40and did so under the circumstances under which
- 41:43it could be concluded that the offeree voluntarily
- 41:47accepted the disclosure, knowing the conditions
- 41:50on which it was tendered and reasonable value
- 41:52for the work. In that case, in this Grosso or
- 41:55Miramax case, the writer sued Miramax for both
- 41:58breach of an implied contract and for copyright
- 42:01infringement because he claimed that he submitted
- 42:03a screenplay to Miramax and that Miramax subsequently
- 42:07released a film that was based on the writer's
- 42:09idea. The film at issue, by the way, was the
- 42:12Rounders film. But the court in the Miramax case
- 42:16agreed to toss out the copyright infringement
- 42:19claim early, finding that the two works were
- 42:21not similar enough to constitute copyright infringement,
- 42:25but it nonetheless held that the writer might
- 42:27still be able to prevail on a claim for breach
- 42:30of implied contract. Now the significance of
- 42:33these holdings are that even if the work at issue
- 42:36isn't copyright or even if the two works are
- 42:39so dissimilar that there could be no finding
- 42:42of copyright infringement, courts would still
- 42:44let those claims for breach of implied contract
- 42:46go through and reach a jury. For context, I think
- 42:51it's important to note here it costs significantly
- 42:53more to litigate a case through a jury trial
- 42:56than if the litigation is resolved. earlier right
- 42:59so this might be somewhat intuitive but maybe
- 43:02to transactional attorneys maybe it's not something
- 43:05that's thought about as often or maybe it is
- 43:07i'm not sure but just for what it's worth i wanted
- 43:10to note that you know these types of cases that
- 43:13you know this claim can get through to the jury
- 43:14what does that mean well just to put it in context
- 43:17it is not um it is common for, if I had to, you
- 43:24know, the cases could cost a million dollars
- 43:25between the time of after summary judgment through
- 43:28trial. Like just getting it through trial could
- 43:30cost so much in attorney's fees and in expert
- 43:33fees that I think it's worth noting these types
- 43:37of cases. And really both of these just still
- 43:41emphasize the importance of having the written
- 43:43agreements in the first place, which I know you
- 43:46all know as transactional attorneys. Now, Lastly,
- 43:51so I'd be remiss if I didn't mention that back
- 43:53in 2024, my firm successfully defended Mattel
- 43:57against a claim for breach of implied contract.
- 44:00That case did go all the way to a jury trial
- 44:03and it lasted months, but we got a full defense
- 44:07verdict on behalf of Mattel. So in that case,
- 44:11the plaintiff had met with Mattel and one of
- 44:13the producers of Shark Tank to discuss his idea
- 44:16for a TV show. called Playmakers, which would
- 44:19involve adult toy inventors pitching their toy
- 44:23inventions, similar to Shark Tank, where the
- 44:25panel of sharks were made up of children, and
- 44:28then plaintiff proposed that he would finance
- 44:30the show and produce it, and that Mattel would
- 44:32manufacture and distribute the winning toy and
- 44:35be a sponsor of that program. Plaintiff claimed
- 44:38that he disclosed the idea for the show with
- 44:41the expectation that he would be paid if that
- 44:43idea was used, and that Mattel breached that
- 44:45implied contract by deciding not to create or
- 44:48work with him on that playmaker show, but then
- 44:52three years later, financing and acting as the
- 44:54sponsor of the toy box. So the Toy Box was a
- 44:58short -lived ABC primetime reality show that
- 45:01was broadcasted back in 2017. And for the case,
- 45:06and I personally wasn't involved, but different
- 45:09partners at my firm were. Larry Iser led the
- 45:12way on this one. But we had argued on behalf
- 45:14of Mattel that no implied contract was ever formed,
- 45:18but that even if it was, Mattel didn't breach
- 45:20the purported contract because it didn't use
- 45:22the plaintiff's ideas in the Toy Box show. After
- 45:26a multi -month trial, the jury found that the
- 45:29plaintiff and Mattel had entered into an implied
- 45:32contract, but it found that Mattel did not breach
- 45:35the implied contract. So that's how we get the
- 45:37result of a full defense verdict for Mattel with
- 45:40no money owed to the plaintiff. I flagged this
- 45:45too, I wanted to note one point about this I
- 45:46thought was interesting. I mentioned earlier
- 45:48that if the creative professional prevails or
- 45:51wins on a breach of the implied contract claim,
- 45:54the company would owe the value of the creative
- 45:56professional services. In that Mattel case, we
- 46:00had actually argued at trial that even if the
- 46:03jury got to that issue of damages, the plaintiff
- 46:05should still get nothing because there wasn't
- 46:08any value to plaintiff's idea as shown by the
- 46:11fact that the toy box show that was made didn't
- 46:15do well and that Mattel actually lost money on
- 46:18that show. Next slide, please. Perfect. So now
- 46:27that we've walked through claims for breach of
- 46:30implied contract, I wanted to shift gears a little
- 46:32bit and talk about how courts deal with copyright
- 46:35infringement claims under these circumstances.
- 46:39So again, as I explained earlier, More is at
- 46:41risk for the company on a copyright infringement
- 46:44claim than a breach of implied contract claim.
- 46:46Just financially speaking, the buckets of damages
- 46:49are there's more that's available to a plaintiff
- 46:52on a copyright infringement claim. And that's
- 46:54because on these copyright infringement claims,
- 46:57the company could owe, again, compensatory damages,
- 47:00disgorgement of profits, attorney's fees, statutory
- 47:03damages, and even that injunctive relief as well.
- 47:06So I wanted to talk about a couple of key California
- 47:09cases regarding copyright infringement claims
- 47:12within the entertainment industry in particular.
- 47:16The first one is effects associates versus Cohen
- 47:18is a ninth circuit case from 1990. It's still
- 47:21good law. This is an important case because it
- 47:24held that all it acknowledged and agreed that
- 47:27all exclusive copyright licenses must be in writing
- 47:31and sign just as I talked about earlier. But
- 47:34it found that you could still implicitly grant
- 47:37a non -exclusive license to a company. So in
- 47:41this case, it involved Larry Cohen, who wrote,
- 47:45directed, and executive produced a film called
- 47:47The Stuff. The plot of the film's a little bit
- 47:50relevant for this, and honestly, I think it's
- 47:51a little bit fun, so I'm gonna go through it
- 47:53quickly. The plot for the film was that the Earth
- 47:56was invaded by an alien life form that... looks
- 47:59and tastes like frozen yogurt, but has secret
- 48:01negative side effects. So a spy hired by a large
- 48:05ice cream maker, obviously a frozen yogurt competitor,
- 48:08uncovers the truth and saves Earth by blowing
- 48:11up the yogurt factory. So for the film Cohen
- 48:14had asked a small special effects company to
- 48:17create that footage or certain footage for the
- 48:20film But specifically also the piece at the end
- 48:22where the yogurt factory explodes The parties
- 48:26in this case and they were on the same page They
- 48:29agreed that they had verbally agreed that Cohen
- 48:32would pay the special effects company for their
- 48:34work, but they never discussed who would actually
- 48:37own the copyright and the footage, and there
- 48:40was no written signed agreement at all. The special
- 48:44effects company ultimately created the footage,
- 48:46gave it to Cohen, but Cohen wasn't super happy
- 48:50with it, so he used the footage, but he only
- 48:52paid half of the price of what the parties had
- 48:55agreed upon. Cohen then released that film with
- 48:58the footage in it, and a special effects company
- 49:01sued Cohen for copyright infringement. Cohen
- 49:05argued that the special effects company transferred
- 49:08copyright ownership to him verbally or implicitly
- 49:11by handing over that footage to be used in the
- 49:13film such that he shouldn't be liable for copyright
- 49:16infringement. Cohen's attorneys in this case
- 49:20acknowledged that US copyright law requires all
- 49:23transfers of copyright ownership to be in writing
- 49:26and signed. By the way, that comes from 17 US
- 49:30code 204. Cohen still or his side, he still argued
- 49:35that the statute shouldn't apply to movie makers
- 49:37because essentially, not quoting this part, but
- 49:41essentially it was that movie makers are too
- 49:43busy to making movies to worry about contracts
- 49:46being made. This line of argument in the case
- 49:49made me chuckle a little bit because I think
- 49:51we've all seen it. Understandably, this industry
- 49:56in particular, there is a lot of different pressures
- 50:00and different things where you need to get the
- 50:02project made. And I get that. But the court here
- 50:06rejected that argument and stated that exclusive
- 50:09copyright licenses absolutely need to be in writing
- 50:12in order to count. The court's line with respect
- 50:15to this point that I liked is, quote, it doesn't
- 50:18have to be the Magna Carta, a one line pro forma
- 50:21statement will do, end quote. That's from you
- 50:25know, 908F2DF557. The court also said this, I'm
- 50:31going to quote this as well. So quote, common
- 50:32sense tells us that agreement should routinely
- 50:35be put into writing. This simple practice prevents
- 50:38misunderstandings by spelling out the terms of
- 50:41the deal in black and white, forces parties to
- 50:43clarify their thinking and consider problems
- 50:46that could potentially arise and encourages them
- 50:49to take their promises seriously because it's
- 50:51harder to backtrack on a written contract than
- 50:54an oral one." That's at the same site, so at
- 50:56page 557. I like this because it's kind of what
- 51:00I'm sure it's a lot of... the time you spend
- 51:04sometimes even talking to clients and getting
- 51:07them to understand the importance of the agreement,
- 51:09not just for everything negative that can happen,
- 51:12but or all the litigation that can happen on
- 51:14the other side, but just because it's good for
- 51:16the parties to get their understandings and writing.
- 51:18So I liked that quote from it. But ultimately,
- 51:21So although the court disagreed with Cohen on
- 51:24his argument that there should be no written
- 51:26requirement for movie makers, the court nonetheless
- 51:30tossed out the copyright infringement claim altogether.
- 51:33In doing so, the court explained that although
- 51:36all exclusive copyright licenses need to be in
- 51:39writing and signed, the creative could still
- 51:41implicitly grant a non -exclusive license by
- 51:44creating a work at the request of another and
- 51:47then delivering that work to the user with the
- 51:49intent for it to be used and distributed in the
- 51:51ultimate project. So the court applied that reasoning
- 51:54to the facts of the case and found that the special
- 51:57effects company did implicitly grant that non
- 51:59-exclusive license for Cohen to use the yogurt
- 52:02factory blowing up footage because the special
- 52:04effects company did create that footage at the
- 52:07request of Cohen and then delivered the footage
- 52:09to Cohen to be included in the film. But the
- 52:13court didn't stop there. It also went ahead and
- 52:16noted that because only the non -exclusive license
- 52:19was granted in this instance, the court made
- 52:22a point to state that the special effects company
- 52:24could still do whatever it wanted with that footage,
- 52:27that there couldn't have been an exclusive license
- 52:30because it wasn't in writing. So it was saying
- 52:31that the special effects company could still
- 52:33license, sell, or even give away for free its
- 52:36remaining rights in the footage. The court even
- 52:40went on to kind of talk about, I don't know,
- 52:42who else would want or need. this footage of
- 52:44a yogurt factory blowing up, but maybe it could
- 52:47go in some type of music video or other projects.
- 52:50The court explained that regardless of whatever
- 52:52the special effects company chooses to do with
- 52:54the footage, Cohen, quote, will have no basis
- 52:57for complaining, and that's an important lesson
- 53:00that licensees of more versatile film properties
- 53:02may want to take to heart, end quote. So. One
- 53:07major takeaway from this case, I mean the takeaway
- 53:10really I think from this case is that without
- 53:13assigned agreement the company does not own the
- 53:15exclusive rights in the work such that the creative
- 53:18could use the work in any way that they want
- 53:20to. Now I also want to talk about this 2010 case
- 53:26from the Ninth Circuit called I'm gonna butcher
- 53:29the first name. But it's the Xenon Pictures case.
- 53:33So the case involved a parody film featuring
- 53:36a series of sketches. called National Lampoon's
- 53:39TV The Movie. The plaintiff in this case was
- 53:42a writer who brought a claim for copyright infringement,
- 53:45also brought a claim for breach of implied contract,
- 53:47but for our purposes, I want to focus on the
- 53:49copyright infringement claim. This claim was
- 53:52brought against the film's distributor, against
- 53:54the production company, the director, and the
- 53:56screenwriter, alleging that the defendants had
- 53:58used several skits that he authored without his
- 54:01permission and without payment. So the defendants
- 54:04in this case moved for summary judgment, arguing
- 54:08that the undisputed facts demonstrate that the
- 54:10writer at most co -authored those skits with
- 54:14them, and as co -authors, defendants can't be
- 54:17liable for infringing the copyright. because
- 54:19they're co -authors. The District Court granted
- 54:22defendants motion, but the Ninth Circuit, so
- 54:25this Xenon Pictures case, ultimately reversed
- 54:28the Lower Cards decision. The Ninth Circuit,
- 54:31in this case, explained that, quote, whether
- 54:34defendants made any independently copyrightable
- 54:36contributions to the skits is hotly disputed,
- 54:40end quote, such that the issue must be decided
- 54:43by a jury and not at summary judgment. Now, Like
- 54:47I kind of touched on earlier, this is important
- 54:50because when claims may get past this summary
- 54:52judgment phase, it means they're going to go,
- 54:55you know, get to trial unless it's settled before
- 54:57and going through to trial will cost significantly
- 55:01more, obviously, to litigate the case to that
- 55:03point than it would be if the defendants here
- 55:05were able to prevail at the earlier stage of
- 55:08summary judgment. Next slide, please. Thank you.
- 55:15Okay, so I did a lot of talking and I wanted
- 55:18to give a chance to have you all ask questions
- 55:21or Yeah to answer any questions you might have
- 55:25so you can take a look in the chat to see if
- 55:26there's anything That's been posted and feel
- 55:31free to ask in that Q &A portion The first one
- 55:39usually treble damages makes the total award
- 55:42three times So it would be 15k, not 20k. You
- 55:45are correct. My math is not always my strong
- 55:49suit. So yes, I think you were talking back to
- 55:52the, when I mentioned punitive damages and that
- 55:54it could be up to 10 times. And then for my example,
- 55:58I gave, you know, let's say it's three times
- 56:00and I'd say actual damages are 5 million, which
- 56:03you're right, would make then the punitive damages
- 56:0615 million if it's a three time multiple. Let
- 56:13me see. Must the work for hire agreement be signed
- 56:21before the work starts? So a later work for hire
- 56:26agreement might not be effective. That is a good
- 56:30question. So the standard for it being, I think.
- 56:36Typically, what I was speaking on is you certainly
- 56:39want to have it signed before the project is
- 56:44released because that's when, you know, or is
- 56:47distributed in any way because that's where it
- 56:50would trigger the use of the copyright, right?
- 56:53So you want the permission to be given certainly
- 56:56before it's ever. released. I think in practice,
- 57:00obviously, most ideal, you would want it to get
- 57:03it done ideally on the front end. I think that
- 57:06would be a most ideal world. But as far as triggering
- 57:09the piece where you could be at risk for infringement,
- 57:11I believe that would come after the work has
- 57:15been publicly displayed. So after it's been distributed
- 57:20or introduced into the market, you most definitely
- 57:23need it before that point. But that's a good
- 57:27That's a good question. Certainly something to
- 57:29keep in mind. And just, I've seen this. I've
- 57:33heard of it happening so many times from friends
- 57:36who are transactional entertainment attorneys
- 57:38where there are negotiations or there are talks
- 57:41or there's an understanding between the parties
- 57:43and yeah, we'll get to the papering of it later.
- 57:45We'll get to it at some point. But then think
- 57:47of the position it can put the company in too,
- 57:50right? So you've hired this creative or you're
- 57:54working with them and you've You're on the same
- 57:57page about what it's going to look like, but
- 57:59you don't yet have that signed written agreement.
- 58:01They do all this work and now you're ready to
- 58:04release it, but you need them to sign it before
- 58:06they release it. Sometimes those creatives can
- 58:08be hard to track down. Sometimes it's not like
- 58:11a nefarious thought process on the creative.
- 58:15Sometimes they're just, again, hard to track
- 58:17down or hard to pin down and get their signature
- 58:19on the page. So certainly in practice. wanting
- 58:22to get it done as soon as possible I think is
- 58:25the best advice. Did Desney ultimately prevail
- 58:30based on implied contract? That is a good question
- 58:35that I should know, but I for some reason don't
- 58:38have it off the top of my head. You know, I don't
- 58:44recall off the top of my head of how that ended
- 58:46up, but I can certainly I see Ralph asked that
- 58:49question. I can connect with you after. That's
- 58:54a good question. OK. What about where defendants
- 59:00can assert an employment relationship work for
- 59:03hire, not a commissioned work? No writing required,
- 59:07right? How challenging do you find proving or
- 59:10disproving such a relationship? So in the employment,
- 59:15I have done some litigation in the employment
- 59:17context and I can tell you that proving and disproving,
- 59:22you know, the worker classification on whether
- 59:25they're employment or independent contractor,
- 59:28I think that's part of your question. I hope
- 59:29I'm answering it. It can be difficult and it
- 59:34is the type of, it's relatively rare for a claim
- 59:38like that to get. kicked out early at the dismissal
- 59:43or certainly at the summary judgment stage. definitely
- 59:48difficult in that sense and I know California
- 59:50law in particular has changed quite a bit starting
- 59:53back in 2018 on the different worker classification
- 59:57standards and what the courts are looking at
- 1:00:00in far as far as it's become a little bit more
- 1:00:03fuzzy or a little bit more difficult I would
- 1:00:05say for the employer or for the company to prove
- 1:00:09that the worker was just an independent contractor
- 1:00:11but you are correct if they are and you are correct
- 1:00:16in that it's If it's an employee working for
- 1:00:18a company, there does not need to be a work made
- 1:00:21for hire agreement. It's assumed that the, you
- 1:00:23know, by default, the copyright then belongs
- 1:00:25to the company. Oh, and Jay said that he thinks
- 1:00:31that Desney settled. Perfect. Well, that settles
- 1:00:34that issue. Makes it easier. Thank you, Jay.
- 1:00:38Are there criteria to prove an implied contract
- 1:00:42strict regarding the interpretation of the facts?
- 1:00:47The criteria is to prove an implied contract
- 1:00:49strict regarding the interpretations of the facts.
- 1:00:52That's a good question as well, Mohammed. I,
- 1:00:58you know, so for an implied contract. If you're
- 1:01:03first of all, if you're talking about the interpretation
- 1:01:05of the facts, you're at the jury stage, so you
- 1:01:07your past. This isn't something that's going
- 1:01:10to be, you know that if you if they need to look
- 1:01:13at the facts for it, right? It's not going to
- 1:01:15be. on the summary judgment stage unless it's
- 1:01:18undisputed facts. I'm not sure exactly how to
- 1:01:26answer this one. It's a little bit tougher to
- 1:01:30answer because it is something. If they're getting
- 1:01:33into the facts of what happened here, were they
- 1:01:36presenting it with the intention of getting paid?
- 1:01:39Yes, it can be messy and tricky and it's going
- 1:01:41to be up to the parties and the attorneys at
- 1:01:44trial and what They try to try to show to persuade
- 1:01:49the jury one way or the other that the facts
- 1:01:51point to no implied contract or there was and
- 1:01:55then, you know, because there's multiple elements
- 1:01:57to it. There's proving that there was an implied
- 1:01:59contract and then breach and then damages as
- 1:02:02well. And I think. That's all we and I hope that
- 1:02:12answered your question. By the way, Mohammed,
- 1:02:14feel free to reach out to me and all of you.
- 1:02:16Honestly, if you want to reach out to me and
- 1:02:18more than happy to talk one on one to answer
- 1:02:20any other questions you might have. OK, we've
- 1:02:23got one more from Judith saying did you mean
- 1:02:26a moment ago that? No, that in an employment
- 1:02:30agreement, the employer does not have to state
- 1:02:32that the employees work is work made for hire,
- 1:02:36so I apologize if that's how it came off. It's
- 1:02:38the employment agreement should. certainly make
- 1:02:41it clear that any work being created in the context
- 1:02:47of that employment is absolutely a work made
- 1:02:49for hire. So if I misstated, I apologize. You
- 1:02:52should most definitely include that in the employment
- 1:02:54agreement. What I meant is if you have an employee
- 1:02:57with that employment agreement already in place,
- 1:03:01Then for each individual project, are you going
- 1:03:03to need the employee to sign a completely separate
- 1:03:05work made for hire agreement? No, I think that
- 1:03:07overall employment agreement with the work made
- 1:03:11for hire clause in it should suffice. Okay, perfect.
- 1:03:16I think that's all we had. Again, please feel
- 1:03:18free to reach out to me and thank you to the
- 1:03:21Beverly Hills Bar Association for having me.
- 1:03:24This concludes today's presentation. Thank you
- 1:03:26so much, Ashley for a excellent program and thank
- 1:03:30you so much to our audience. Have a great day.
- 1:03:31Everybody. Thank you.