Latest / The Piano Pod - a global hub for innovation, education, and connection in classical piano music / Schumann Beyond the Myths: Jarred Dunn on Poetry & Schumann Daydreams
Transcript
- 0:03It's sort of like a voyage through the underworld.
- 0:06And in the end, just a flood of light and a blaze.
- 0:10And the F sharp minor sonata remains definitely
- 0:13one of my favorite pieces. And I couldn't wait
- 0:15to record it, not only in this hall and on this
- 0:17piano. But I've been thinking about doing this
- 0:19for years because my path as a pianist changed
- 0:22significantly when I learned it. Welcome back
- 0:37to the PianoPod, everyone. What if one of classical
- 0:40music's most renowned and iconic composers has
- 0:44been reduced to a diagnosis, his distinctive
- 0:47musical language too often explained away as
- 0:50a symptom of mental illness. And we've been missing
- 0:53both the poetry in his music and the extraordinary
- 0:56imagination behind it. Two seasons ago, pianist
- 1:02Jared Dunn joined us with his teacher and collaborator,
- 1:05Anna Goretzka, to introduce their landmark album,
- 1:09Goretzky's World of the Piano. That recording
- 1:12went on to become a pre - Opus finalist for Album
- 1:16of the Year. Today, in our second alumni conversation
- 1:20of the season, Jared returns, but this time for
- 1:24a solo conversation about his latest album, Schumann
- 1:27Daydreams. We explore Robert Schumann's inner
- 1:32world, the role of daydreaming and spontaneity
- 1:36in his music, and why Jared believes it is time
- 1:39to hear this composer with greater curiosity,
- 1:41empathy, and imagination. Before we begin, please
- 1:46subscribe to The Piano Pod and give this video
- 1:49a like. It truly helps more people discover these
- 1:52conversations. Here is my conversation with Yamaha
- 1:56artist Jared Dunn. Please enjoy the show. You
- 2:04are listening to The Piano Pod, where we talk
- 2:07to the brightest minds in the industry about
- 2:09how they are bringing the piano into the future
- 2:11and thriving in a complex, ever -evolving world.
- 2:16Jared, welcome back to The Piano Pod. Thank you
- 2:19so much for being here. Thank you for having
- 2:21me. It's great to be back. Where are you joining
- 2:23us from actually today? I'm at home in Montreal.
- 2:26Great. I know you lived in Poland for several
- 2:30years and have continued to travel back and forth
- 2:32between Canada and then Poland. So I was wondering
- 2:35about that. So do you still spend some time in
- 2:38Poland as well? Oh, yes. Every Christmas and
- 2:41at least a couple of times during the year. Oh,
- 2:44wonderful. In fact, we just had our wedding reception
- 2:46there in July. Which was really great. Yeah.
- 2:51Really? So when did you get married? We got married
- 2:54a year ago in Montreal. And then we planned the
- 2:57reception for a year later with my husband's
- 2:59family and all his friends in Poland. So, yeah,
- 3:02that was in July. It was a really great, great
- 3:06experience. Oh, and then your in -laws live in
- 3:08Poland. That's why you also go back and forth.
- 3:11Wonderful. That's great. So, you know, in our
- 3:14previous conversation, you joined us with your
- 3:17teacher. and collaborator pianist, wonderful
- 3:19pianist, Anna Goretzka, and the daughter of,
- 3:22of course, Henrik Mikolaj Gretzky. And then together,
- 3:26you know, we explored Mr. Gretzky's legacy and
- 3:29then his lesser known piano music, as well as
- 3:32your first album, Gretzky's World of Piano. So
- 3:35since our last conversation, how has the journey
- 3:38of that first album continued? Well, Fortunately,
- 3:43it was broadcasted quite regularly here in Canada,
- 3:46which was wonderful. And it led to a nomination
- 3:50of the Opus Prix Awards. That's a Quebec recording
- 3:53prize. There was a finalist in the category Contemporary
- 3:57Album of the Year, which was really very exciting.
- 4:01And so it's gotten off to a really good start.
- 4:04My hope is that Anna and I will play many more
- 4:08concerts together in the future because she's
- 4:10such a great pianist to work with. Yes. Yeah.
- 4:13Wonderful. So for our listeners, if you missed
- 4:16Jared and Anna's conversation or would like a
- 4:20refresher, it's season five, episode 17 titled
- 4:23Inside the World of Gretzky. You'll find a link
- 4:26in the episode description. So last time, you
- 4:29know, we entered the musical world of Gretzky.
- 4:32And today we're entering the very different musical
- 4:35and artistic world, the world of Robert Truman.
- 4:38So you're here to introduce. Your second album
- 4:42with Lexicon Classics. The title is Schumann
- 4:47Daydreams. Congratulations. Thank you very much.
- 4:50This is the second album I've done with Lexicon
- 4:53Classics. The first was a few years ago, Chopin's
- 4:56Diary, the Mazurkas with the complete Mazurkas.
- 4:59And so they're a wonderful support of my work.
- 5:03And we always do great collaborations together.
- 5:05I love working with Lexicon. Oh, great. So this
- 5:08is the second album with them. That's right.
- 5:11Yeah. It's my fifth album. Wow. Yeah. So, yeah,
- 5:18I'm proud of this. Yeah. And work, as I said,
- 5:21working with Lexicon is always a pleasure. They
- 5:22do great work. Amazing. So where did the idea
- 5:26for this album begin? Well, it started for me
- 5:32actually in childhood when I started learning
- 5:35Schumann's music. I was sort of forced to do
- 5:39it by a teacher who really loved Schumann and
- 5:41saw that I took to learning new repertoire very
- 5:43quickly. And so she would constantly assign me
- 5:47new Schumann pieces. And I remember even from
- 5:50the very beginning of doing piano exams here
- 5:52in Canada with the Royal Conservatory of Music
- 5:55Examinations Program. That was what it was called
- 5:59at the time. Now it's called the Certificate
- 6:01Program. And one of my exams, I was determined
- 6:04to play, I remember, a Chopin piece. And my teacher
- 6:08insisted I learn some Schumann. And it was the
- 6:11Waldsehnen, number six, the Wayside Inn. And
- 6:15that's where I started learning the basics of
- 6:18Schumann, by learning that piece. It was my first
- 6:20Schumann piece. And I was immediately annoyed
- 6:25with my teacher for making me do Schumann instead
- 6:27of Chopin, because I'd done a lot of Chopin already.
- 6:31But now I look back on it, it was the best possible
- 6:34decision that she could have made. And then when
- 6:37I moved up to a teacher at the pre -college who
- 6:41was a little bit more professional in approach,
- 6:45then Schumann became a main component of my musical
- 6:49diet. And so I was learning when I was very young,
- 6:53the whole waltz scene and the kinder scene and
- 6:55the arabesque, the fantasy shtuka. I started
- 6:58to learn when I was 16, the notes, the symphonic
- 7:00etudes, Kreisleriana and the concerto. And I
- 7:03had no idea that any of this music was something
- 7:06that should be touched only when you're already
- 7:07an expert. Because, again, my professor at the
- 7:12time was so interested in Schumann and I was
- 7:14so interested in learning new music that it sort
- 7:16of took off like a whirlwind. I liked Schumann
- 7:21and I didn't like him at the same time because
- 7:23I was always being forced to play Schumann. And
- 7:26I was a child with a lot of interest in music
- 7:29of Bach and musical logic. And Schumann does
- 7:32not have the same kind of musical logic or approach
- 7:35to structure in melody or harmony that you might
- 7:39find in a Bach or in a Mozart or a Chopin. And
- 7:43so there were moments where I really didn't like.
- 7:46playing Schumann. And I thought this is just
- 7:48being forced into me, but I don't really understand
- 7:50why everyone loves it so much. But then, you
- 7:55know, over time, I started to really, really
- 7:57see more in that music. And then a couple of
- 8:01years ago, I decided I think I'd better return
- 8:03to that and see what I missed, see what I didn't
- 8:06get as a kid. So that's where Schumann Daydreams
- 8:08came from. So what does the title Schumann Daydreams
- 8:15mean to you? You know, when you're talking to
- 8:19someone and they say something so inspiring and
- 8:21in the back of your mind, a thought occurs to
- 8:23you that you've never thought of it before. It
- 8:25was in a conversation in New York with one of
- 8:27my mentors at the time, David DuBal, who was
- 8:30talking about one of the competitions that I
- 8:34had entered and I hadn't reached. It was either
- 8:36the semifinals or the finals. And I was really
- 8:38dreaming about getting to the finals of this
- 8:40competition. And we were debriefing it afterward
- 8:42at City Diner, I believe, in Manhattan. And he
- 8:46said, you know, sometimes the things you've really
- 8:48worked toward and dreamed about consciously are
- 8:52actually nightmares. And it's your daydreams,
- 8:55the things you don't talk about that are the
- 8:57things you really want. And as soon as I formed
- 9:00the repertoire of the album that we're talking
- 9:02about, I remembered that conversation. And I
- 9:05remembered being a child daydreaming about playing
- 9:08other music than Schumann. Just like Schumann
- 9:11was daydreaming about a bigger career than he
- 9:13could have, was daydreaming about more poetry
- 9:17in life and less exposure to the musical competitive
- 9:22world and traditional world. And he lived his
- 9:25life basically in that same state that Duval
- 9:27was talking about. Go to your daydreams to find
- 9:30out what you really want. And so then I assembled
- 9:33these six pieces thinking, I don't think it's
- 9:35possible to write those pieces. outside of being
- 9:39in a state where you're dreaming of something
- 9:40else. And it really influenced my feeling of
- 9:45that moment that you're talking to somebody and
- 9:48they say something that makes you think about
- 9:50a totally unrelated situation to the one you're
- 9:52talking about then and there. And a connection
- 9:54happens in your mind and you go, oh, I never
- 9:56thought of that before. That's kind of what Schumann
- 9:58Daydreams is all about. He's going in one direction
- 10:01in each of these pieces for a little while and
- 10:03then he suddenly switches direction. And it feels
- 10:06like you're in a conversation with someone who's
- 10:07not entirely listening to what you're saying
- 10:09and yet keeps the conversation going, is really,
- 10:12really happy to continue this conversation. But
- 10:15their mind is somewhere else. That makes sense.
- 10:22Let's explore that a little bit more further.
- 10:26So a lot of times people think that the Shema
- 10:29was just mentally. You know, had mental challenges,
- 10:33whether that is sometimes I hear bipolar, sometimes
- 10:36people say schizophrenia or many different descriptions.
- 10:41But no one knows because, you know, we can't
- 10:44only diagnose from where we are today. Right.
- 10:47So what do you think when you hear his music
- 10:51and experience his music? So is that something
- 10:56that. You think that's true? Or maybe is that
- 10:59his sort of daydreamy sort of personality? I
- 11:04think it's the daydreaming personality and the
- 11:06fact that he lived in a constant state of conflict
- 11:09between what the outside world is really like,
- 11:12the sometimes brutal elements and lack of continuity
- 11:15of real life and all the gray areas it forces
- 11:18us into. His mind was more a poetic one, where
- 11:22the way music works is supposed to be the way
- 11:24life works. And about the diagnosis, I consulted
- 11:30with a few clinicians, actually, psychiatrists,
- 11:33psychologists, yeah, to discuss this issue. And
- 11:35I'm working on a collaborative publication, actually,
- 11:38with a therapist right now, a behavioral specialist
- 11:40in personality disorders. The Schumann writings
- 11:44demonstrate at the beginning of his life, this
- 11:49is according to some therapists, some interpretation,
- 11:52the ability to have these two personalities in
- 11:56his mind, the Florestan -Eusebius combination.
- 11:58But then there's this third one, Raro, who tries
- 12:01to equivocate everything, make everything a little
- 12:04more balanced. So we don't often talk about that
- 12:07because people like things to be in clear categories.
- 12:10There's the introvert, poetic and isolated, and
- 12:14the extrovert, theatrical and almost too theatrical
- 12:19for words. But then what is the balance between
- 12:22them? That's not so interesting, right? My thinking
- 12:25is there weren't words to diagnose whatever it
- 12:29was he had. And of course, at the end of his
- 12:31life, he thought these people started talking
- 12:33back to him. That's the real tipping point. When
- 12:35he imagined later in life, when he was writing
- 12:38Waldseinen or the ghost variations, that the
- 12:41characters he'd created in his mind. to represent
- 12:44his personality, his preferences, his different
- 12:46aspects, these people actually started talking
- 12:48back to him. That's a little disturbing. He believed
- 12:51the voices were real. He believed there were
- 12:53demons telling him, kill yourself. He believed
- 12:56that there were lions and hyenas chasing him
- 12:58at night, and he really saw them. So we know
- 13:01he did become mentally ill. But, you know, over
- 13:04the course of recording this, I started discovering
- 13:06there are also people who think Beethoven was
- 13:09deaf his whole life. It's the same ignorance.
- 13:11He became deaf later. But he wasn't always deaf.
- 13:15Schumann became mentally ill later. But the early
- 13:18years, he wasn't mentally ill. He was poetic
- 13:21and he was different than other people. And he
- 13:23created these different imaginary things to shield
- 13:27his personality from the brutalities of life
- 13:29or the difficulties of life. But composition
- 13:32at the beginning was his safe haven. It's only
- 13:35in the very last few pieces, like around 1849,
- 13:381850, when he attempted suicide, that he really
- 13:42did start thinking all these voices he created
- 13:44were really talking back to him. And I like to
- 13:47think of it now as these early pieces that I
- 13:50recorded, like the first sonata, the Fantasy
- 13:52Stuka, Kindersein in arabesque, these pieces
- 13:54from the tormented years of struggling all the
- 13:57time for Clara. This was his safe haven to be
- 14:00connected with her. What was the thing they loved
- 14:02most together? Music. What did she love? His
- 14:05composing. She thought his imagination was so
- 14:07exciting. And he had such a different take on
- 14:10music than all the stuff that she had studied
- 14:12in her very classical and technical education.
- 14:15Here comes this totally different take on what
- 14:19music can be. And as their love went through
- 14:24so many trials and as his personal life was basically...
- 14:28put in headlines and all his private uh details
- 14:32and intimate secrets were suddenly known to everybody
- 14:35because clara's father was so angry with him
- 14:38for trying to seduce her that all of a sudden
- 14:40he was spreading all these rumors about schumann
- 14:42robert schumann i would get angry too i might
- 14:45have some trauma for that if my whole private
- 14:47life was suddenly in the public view. And I think
- 14:50that's where we misunderstood Schumann and where
- 14:53music history needs to do a bit of revising.
- 14:55He didn't have a personality disorder or schizophrenia
- 14:58from the start. He wasn't always crazy, any more
- 15:01than Beethoven was always deaf. Wow, that is
- 15:05a very interesting take and sort of makes sense.
- 15:09But kudos to you for this research. Like, you
- 15:14know, almost like you're reclaiming his name.
- 15:18There was an element of that. You're right. In
- 15:20discussing this with a clinical psychologist
- 15:23who'd done her reading on the Schumann letters
- 15:25and the story and said, you know, this was the
- 15:28question that fundamentally changed my perspective.
- 15:30What if we removed from Schumann the need to
- 15:33diagnose him? The word diagnosis. What if we
- 15:36just thought this is a person with a certain
- 15:38amount of trauma, with a certain amount of closeness
- 15:41to his father. His father dies and now he doesn't
- 15:43have his main relationship anymore with his safe.
- 15:47parent and is sent to do a career that he doesn't
- 15:51want to do and he's not capable of doing it and
- 15:53told that all his dreams are worthless in music.
- 15:57That's enough to crush someone right from the
- 15:58beginning. But he persevered and he wasn't a
- 16:02particularly disciplined person. But this was
- 16:04the second thing that really convinced me from
- 16:06this point of view of a cognitive behavioral
- 16:09psychologist or a clinical psychologist, I should
- 16:12say. What if all your dreams are invalidated?
- 16:16And then you're told, now go do this other life
- 16:18that I'm telling you you have to do. And you
- 16:21have to really fight for it. It builds a resilience
- 16:23in a person to believe in their own voice, to
- 16:25believe in their own dreams, rather than an insistence
- 16:29or a... a submission to what other people are
- 16:31telling you to do. And in a way, we should be
- 16:33thankful that Schumann fought against what his
- 16:35mother was telling him to do and persevered in
- 16:37music, fought against even what his teacher,
- 16:40Frederick Wieck, was telling him. You have to
- 16:41do this to become a pianist. You have to do this
- 16:43to become a composer. Schumann trusted his inner
- 16:45voice. And it wasn't a stable voice, but that
- 16:48doesn't mean he was just crazy. And if we looked
- 16:52at him from today's clinical psychological perspectives,
- 16:55there would be work done with him over a longer
- 16:58period of time before ever labeling him. And
- 17:01so I really like the, I've settled on this, at
- 17:03least from my own understanding of him. And I
- 17:05am trying to reclaim this or promote it among
- 17:08our general knowledge of Shuman. He began as
- 17:13someone with incredibly difficult circumstances
- 17:15to start out with as a musician. And he persevered.
- 17:18And life got twice as hard after that because
- 17:21musician life is not easy. He still wrote a few
- 17:25really coherent pieces like the Symphonic Etudes
- 17:27and the Papillon. It's brilliantly coherent.
- 17:31But it was later on in life when he thought those
- 17:34inner voices in his head started to talk back
- 17:37to him. That's by modern standards or yardsticks.
- 17:41the point where you go, that's a little unhealthy.
- 17:44But to create an imaginary world and populate
- 17:47it with beautiful music, that's not necessarily
- 17:49bad. That doesn't mean he's crazy. And I think
- 17:53we miss that because in general, you know, music
- 17:55history classes, we like to gloss over what's
- 17:57a composer's, how do we categorize this composer?
- 18:00You know, Bach is counterpoint, Bach is sacred
- 18:02music, Beethoven is symphony, Haydn is humor,
- 18:05but there are more dimensions to composers than
- 18:07we think. This is a very interesting take. And
- 18:12then I cannot wait to share this with my audience,
- 18:16but also my students, too. And then your album
- 18:19title, Schumann Daydreams, makes so much more
- 18:22sense rather than Schumann Psycho or Schumann
- 18:26Depressed. Yeah, because I think we're beneficiaries
- 18:31of the greatest. pain the composers went through.
- 18:35Look at the Chopin Third Sonata or the Rachmaninoff
- 18:38Second Concerto, or Mozart A Minor Sonata. These
- 18:42are written at the moments they suffered terrible
- 18:44tragedies in their lives, and they turned it
- 18:47into beautiful art. What a loss for us if we
- 18:50think, well, Schumann music is, you know, it's
- 18:52eccentric because he was schizophrenic, but that's
- 18:54it. He went through similar problems. I think
- 18:57it's just we have to understand him and empathize
- 18:59with him. when we interpret him and when we listen
- 19:02and we have to override a little bit of our conditioning
- 19:05that just is, it's so tempting to say, like I
- 19:08was saying, categories. Schumann is the crazy
- 19:10one. He's an artist, but he's crazy. It allows
- 19:13us to write off some of the things we don't understand
- 19:15about the way he wrote music. When in fact, those
- 19:18are some of the most beautiful things. Yeah.
- 19:21Tell me more about that. I think, you know, as
- 19:25pianists, I've also done several. you know Schumann
- 19:29pieces not all of them but he has an extensive
- 19:32amount of piano pieces yeah you know he switches
- 19:36well of course the sort of personality wise you
- 19:41know Eusebius to Florestan that's a you know
- 19:43two contrasting personalities but also I feel
- 19:46like all of a sudden like almost the phrase or
- 19:50the piece ends abruptly and then it's just going
- 19:54into different things so it is sometimes that's
- 19:59one of the the things that people say oh see
- 20:02he's crazy yeah that's right and this is something
- 20:08that makes you'll probably have had this experience
- 20:09with students they play something by Schumann
- 20:12and they notice that moment and that's the one
- 20:13they don't like that's because it's the music
- 20:17represents something other than our basic understanding
- 20:21will allow us to access we have to access a different
- 20:24level of human understanding here and that's
- 20:26the level of empathy and most people lack that
- 20:28when it comes to interpreting music they feel
- 20:31like this complex language of signs and symbols
- 20:33needs to be obvious and Schumann says no it doesn't
- 20:37have to be obvious Sometimes the change is obvious,
- 20:40but the reason why is buried in the score somewhere,
- 20:42the relations between the themes, the fact that
- 20:45sometimes it's the same theme, but just in a
- 20:48different key, jump cut, sort of like, I'm going
- 20:51in this direction in major, I stop, I'm now in
- 20:53minor, but the same theme continuing. Whereas,
- 20:57let's say, a classical sonata, let's say by Beethoven
- 20:59or Mozart, is going to have very clear formal
- 21:02markers of when things are over and the transition
- 21:05is felt. Schumann asks us the question constantly,
- 21:09are you going to fall for what I'm presenting
- 21:12on the surface or are you going to look deeper?
- 21:14And he does it by writing things that make you
- 21:17ask the question, why did he just stop there?
- 21:19Or as in the case of the Arabesque or Kreisleriana,
- 21:23why are you starting here? Nothing has happened
- 21:26before the moment of the first note. And yet
- 21:29when the piece starts, I get the feeling I'm
- 21:31being thrown into the middle of something that's
- 21:32already happening. And that's his special understanding
- 21:38of the human psyche, actually, which is things
- 21:41do not always happen to us internally in a way
- 21:45that we can predict. Wouldn't that be lovely
- 21:49if we could always know what was coming next
- 21:51in our emotions, if we could always regulate
- 21:54our emotions perfectly to suit the needs of every
- 21:56moment? And so much of the repertoire before
- 21:59Schumann gives you the illusion that you can
- 22:01do that. Schumann removes that illusion. He says,
- 22:05what are you really thinking about here? Do you
- 22:06need it all to make sense on the surface? Or
- 22:08are you willing to dig deeper and figure out
- 22:10what psychological state, what emotional world
- 22:13I'm representing here and go there? Perfect example
- 22:16is the Kinder Sehnen. And it's the reason I started
- 22:18the album with Kinder Sehnen. It's reflections
- 22:20on childhood from an adult. They are not children's
- 22:23pieces. When I sign Kinder Sehnen, it's never
- 22:25to children. Children cannot play that. They
- 22:28don't know yet that life is about to get a lot
- 22:31more difficult and that you're going. This is
- 22:33a whole 13 piece dedication to the motto. Youth
- 22:38is wasted on the young. I wish I'd known better
- 22:42when I was young. I wish I'd appreciated more
- 22:44what I had when I was young or how easy it was
- 22:46compared to the responsibility of being an adult.
- 22:49So I started there because it immediately pulls
- 22:52you into a world where you can't help but daydream.
- 22:54In Kinder Sehnen, the music is too obvious. It's
- 22:57too easy to understand what he's getting at.
- 22:59So you let your mind wander when you listen to
- 23:02these pieces anyway, because the melodies are
- 23:04so familiar and the harmonies are so beautiful.
- 23:07That it's almost involuntary to, you know, in
- 23:11Traumerei, you're not sitting there wondering,
- 23:13what was Schumann dreaming about when he wrote
- 23:15Traumerei? No, you're dreaming about your own
- 23:18life. And then you enter this magic space where
- 23:21Schumann is still there. His ideas, his concept
- 23:25for music lives in these pieces. And it reminds
- 23:28me of his quote. It's my favorite quote from
- 23:30his journal on music. Only that music that has
- 23:34poetry and intelligence will... echo into the
- 23:37future. And the slower and longer the echo, the
- 23:41deeper the chord that was initially struck. And
- 23:44he meant in our hearts, the chord within us.
- 23:47And he touched it, he felt it, he wrote something
- 23:49that represents a deep heartstring tug. And he
- 23:53wrote exactly enough music for that particular
- 23:56heartstring. So when we play it, we're joining
- 23:58him there. Wow. I don't think that's from the
- 24:03mentality of someone who didn't understand what
- 24:05music could do. I think he profoundly understood
- 24:07what music and poetry were really about. Now
- 24:17that we understand where Schumann fits within
- 24:20this context, so let's enter the album itself.
- 24:24So could you walk us through Schumann Daydreams,
- 24:27introducing each work and explaining why you
- 24:30chose these pieces? Well, it started with a series
- 24:34of face palms in which I went over my old scores,
- 24:37saw what my teacher had written there and went,
- 24:41she was so right. That's exactly how you play
- 24:43that. And I never did any of those things at
- 24:45the beginning. I was just there had to be a programming,
- 24:48a certain amount of study needed for Schumann.
- 24:50And of course. Some of my own students nowadays
- 24:52even say that, you know, if they don't like a
- 24:54piece by Schumann, they're now willing to admit
- 24:56it's because they lack the experience or the
- 24:57knowledge to play it. So I started with Kinder
- 25:00Sehnen for the reasons I just mentioned. I think
- 25:02it lures you into this world of daydreaming and
- 25:04it's light. As an adult, you think back to being
- 25:08a nine or ten year old and you remember certain
- 25:10landmarks in your life. And the Kinder Sehnen
- 25:14are supposed to start us there. And then. They
- 25:18end on a G major chord in the 13th piece, The
- 25:20Poet Speaks, which is a beautiful way to transition
- 25:23into the arabesque, which is in C major. So it's
- 25:26a dominant to tonic relationship. And then after
- 25:29the arabesque, I thought, where am I going to
- 25:32put the forest scenes? Because these are late
- 25:34pieces, but they're so subtle. You couldn't end
- 25:36with them, even though chronologically they came
- 25:39much later. I knew I'd have to finish with the
- 25:42sonata because it's the biggest one. So I went
- 25:44with the Waldsehnen next because it's sort of
- 25:46a... an expanded version of Kinder Sehnen. And
- 25:50it's written at a time when I felt, or when I
- 25:54noticed from the Schumann letters and his documents,
- 25:58he was experiencing terrible trauma at the end
- 26:02of his compositional life. Of course, this was
- 26:04a few years before he died. And so I wanted to
- 26:06put them in the middle because I didn't really
- 26:08want to end on that note. And Waldstein in our
- 26:12extraordinary pieces for someone going through
- 26:14constant episodes, schizophrenic episodes and
- 26:18hearing voices and tearing hair out, ripping
- 26:21things, having psychotic breakdowns, and then
- 26:24writing something like the first and the last
- 26:27pieces of the sixth. I can't imagine something
- 26:29more organized to demonstrate the. the musical
- 26:35response to each title. And I remembered in particularly
- 26:38the sixth, because I played this on one of my
- 26:41RCM exams as a child, the comments right away
- 26:45from the examiner who heard that were, you have
- 26:47a natural feeling for Schumann. And I didn't
- 26:49even know what that meant yet because I was so
- 26:51busy not doing everything my teacher told me
- 26:53I should be doing that I thought, probably I
- 26:56don't know anything about Schumann and I hate
- 26:57having to play this. But these... constant reminders
- 27:00from my old scores. It's still, it's sitting
- 27:02on my piano right now, the old Schumann volume,
- 27:04this Dover print of the complete works of Schumann.
- 27:07You know what I'm talking about? I have all the
- 27:10same highlights from childhood and I wanted to
- 27:12basically create, retrace my steps in playing
- 27:16these pieces. And they actually did go in that
- 27:18order. I started with Kinder Sehnen quite young,
- 27:20actually, because my teacher thought I would
- 27:21get it. I didn't get it. It definitely took until
- 27:26now to get it. After the forest scenes, I decided
- 27:30to put the first four of the Fantasy Stücke because
- 27:32he was having a better time in general at this
- 27:36period. He was writing something that is closer
- 27:40in style to the Carnival, which I love very much.
- 27:42And I remember learning the notes to Carnival
- 27:44at the same time as I learned the Fantasy Stücke.
- 27:46And then the last two pieces, the Romance from
- 27:49Op. 28, also on F -sharp. leading into the F
- 27:53sharp minor sonata, they have the same kind of
- 27:55accompaniment in three note groupings of the
- 27:57left hand. So they link really beautifully one
- 28:00to the next. And the F sharp minor sonata as
- 28:03the ending, because that's the only place that
- 28:06such a piece could possibly go. Why did these
- 28:10six works feel right for exploring the idea of
- 28:14daydreaming? Because on one hand, they all have
- 28:18very clear formal structures. Each, like the
- 28:21miniature sets, Kinderszenen, the Fantasiestücke
- 28:25and the Waldsenen, each has a separate title
- 28:27and we know where one begins and one ends. But
- 28:30it gives me the feeling when I play them, like
- 28:34moving from one beautiful thought to another
- 28:35or moving from one thought based on a poem I've
- 28:40read or some fantastical image to another. And
- 28:44they're not too... too short in the sense that
- 28:48you don't really get much from them and they're
- 28:49not too long in the sense that it doesn't drag
- 28:51so i liked the feeling of recording a couple
- 28:55of sets like this and then a really mammoth piece
- 28:58like the f sharp sonata which one of his longest
- 28:59pieces um and um the f sharp sonata is very special
- 29:04to me as a piece of music in general because
- 29:07of its content and because most people think
- 29:09it's basically unplayable It's not something
- 29:12that would be comfortable to play. It's not easy.
- 29:15I mean, a lot of people do play it, of course,
- 29:16not unplayable, but it's hard. It's not an easy
- 29:20piece to execute. And I learned it because a
- 29:24teacher recommended it to me. And I thought,
- 29:25if another person tells me to play Schumann,
- 29:27I'm quitting the piano. But now I can't get enough
- 29:30of that piece. I absolutely love it. And it had
- 29:34to be the centerpiece of the album because I
- 29:36just I needed to play it at this time of my life.
- 29:40It's magnificent. piece as you say and so how
- 29:44do you experience the journey from the opening
- 29:46movement to finale this is the last movement
- 29:50is just so so hard but i really enjoy the album
- 29:54by the way thank you beautiful beautiful performance
- 29:57i was really uh really grateful to the the label
- 30:03for letting me do this and for the to the studio
- 30:05for making it possible to record this in such
- 30:07perfect circumstances What you need to play the
- 30:10F sharp minor sonata is a perfect concentration
- 30:12and unity within yourself, a perfect focus on
- 30:16who you are, what story you're telling and how
- 30:19you're going to tell it, because there is not
- 30:20a single note of that piece that you can leave
- 30:24up to chance. You have to interpret every note
- 30:26of this. And I think one has to realize the scope
- 30:29of the piece because it's so long. And Schumann
- 30:32wrote so many short stories. Here, he's writing
- 30:34a novel. And that novel is his novel about love
- 30:38and despair and being separated from the one
- 30:42you love. And it really resonated with me because
- 30:45it felt like telling a real life love story,
- 30:48including conflict, including not knowing if
- 30:53it's going to work out, including being separated
- 30:55from the person and experiencing incredible loneliness,
- 30:58which is a state a lot of artists live in. um
- 31:01i like when schumann shows us his loneliness
- 31:05and shows us how he's really feeling and looks
- 31:09us straight in the eye and says there's no other
- 31:11way to put it this is what it is and if you're
- 31:14going to be in love it's going to be excruciating
- 31:16one day if you're going to marry someone or be
- 31:18with someone your whole life one of you will
- 31:20eventually be gone and it will be the worst pain
- 31:23you've ever been through in exchange for all
- 31:25the love you've had. And that's the only way
- 31:27through this. And to think of someone at that
- 31:30time in his life, 1830s, fighting for Clara,
- 31:33longing for her, not being told he's never going
- 31:36to have her and still saying, if you knew how
- 31:39luxurious it was, all of the rest of you who
- 31:41have good relationships, I long for the pain
- 31:45you will one day be in over this. Do you know
- 31:47what I mean? That's a powerful place to write
- 31:50a piece from, knowing that that love is causing
- 31:53him the most agony and will cause him the most
- 31:55agony or cause her the most agony in the future.
- 31:58And he says, this is what I want, actually, because
- 32:00it's being kept from me. Now, those are complex
- 32:03feelings we have to know how to feel, empathize
- 32:05with, hold and interpret in the score. And there
- 32:09are some moments in that piece where I don't
- 32:13think anyone else in the history of music wrote
- 32:15love better than that. I think that honestly
- 32:19has more in it than, he said his favorite was
- 32:22Kreisleriana. She said one of her favorites was
- 32:25the G minor sonata because she loved playing
- 32:27it. I'm convinced that those first few times
- 32:29she played the F sharp minor sonata when she
- 32:31was far away from him on tours, her father had
- 32:33sent her on to keep them apart. I'm convinced
- 32:36there was a deeper emotion in her for that piece.
- 32:38There would have to be. It's just so much deeper
- 32:41about the saga of love and loss than any other
- 32:45sonata that's been written. About the second
- 32:57movement, the aria. Yeah. Yeah. Tell me. Well,
- 33:03do we have 10 years? The first time when my teacher
- 33:09said, you should try this. I said, okay, I'm
- 33:11going to start with the aria because I already
- 33:12heard it in concerts before. I know I like it.
- 33:15And I was a puddle just sight reading that piece.
- 33:18I knew there's something there and something
- 33:21overwhelmingly powerful about the nature of love.
- 33:25And the moment they say, I love you too. And
- 33:30you really didn't know. You took the risk. You
- 33:33said it first. And now you're waiting. The feeling
- 33:36right after they say it, eyes straight looking
- 33:39into yours. I can't think of a piece that does
- 33:43that better than the aria. It's the emotional
- 33:45core of the music. And then the second, the return
- 33:48of that same theme, you can tell the whole life.
- 33:53has been summarized in some ways about that feeling
- 33:57that lasts a long time. And my image for the
- 34:00end of the piece is, you know, they're still
- 34:01in love. He's still very much connected to her,
- 34:04but either he or she is holding a flower over
- 34:08the grave and one of them is gone, but they still
- 34:10remember to the end of their lives, the moment
- 34:13that they said, I love you too. And to capture
- 34:16that feeling in three minutes is a perfect amount
- 34:20of time because you think, You know, I can still
- 34:22remember when my husband told me he loved me
- 34:24and wanted to marry me. I will never forget that
- 34:26moment. But it felt in the moment like it lasted
- 34:30an hour. And now looking back, I realize it was
- 34:33only a few minutes. And Schumann wrote this,
- 34:37like just a few minutes to summarize a whole
- 34:39lifetime experience, something that summarizes
- 34:42the greatest joy one can experience and the greatest
- 34:46pain that it can cause you. I think that's remarkable.
- 34:51He gets real with us. I mean, that's what makes
- 34:53Schumann sometimes a little bit uncomfortable.
- 34:54He's just telling you how he feels and how life
- 34:57is. He's not covering it up with anything. He's
- 35:00just getting real. Let's go behind the scenes
- 35:09of the recording itself. You know, I saw the,
- 35:14I think, promotional video or behind the scenes
- 35:16video. The concert hall looks amazing. Is that
- 35:19where you recorded the whole entire? Yes. Oh,
- 35:23wow. I had such a privilege. I was on the jury
- 35:25of the Bader Overton piano competition. It's
- 35:29a national competition here in Canada. And the
- 35:32Bader Foundation supported this album by giving
- 35:36me the hall for three days afterward to record
- 35:38the album. In the end, I only needed two days.
- 35:41But the crew, this incredible Steinway I got
- 35:44to record on, and the performance hall at the
- 35:47Isabel Bader Center for the Performing Arts,
- 35:49I mean, I owe them everything. because I was
- 35:52on the jury for a week before. It was difficult
- 35:55not to practice for a whole week before you record
- 35:57an enormous album like this, but I couldn't wait
- 36:00to touch the piano. And this two days went by
- 36:05almost like a daydream. Everything was very smooth.
- 36:08The sound crew knew exactly how to mic the piano,
- 36:11and every bit of response from the first few
- 36:15listeners before the album went public was, the
- 36:17sound is so clear. And for a composer like Schumann,
- 36:21it has to be because you really can't give the
- 36:24full impression without making sure every line
- 36:26of this polyphony, every line of the texture
- 36:28is clear and colorful, especially in the louder
- 36:32places where it can't just sound like a mad race
- 36:35or a brash attack. It has to sound poetic still.
- 36:39And somehow dreamy because I sentenced myself
- 36:41to this brutal title, which means every work,
- 36:44even the most symphonic, still has to sound like
- 36:46a daydream. That was in retrospect, that was
- 36:49kind of stupid because it could be easier if
- 36:51the title was just Schumann, the symphonic, and
- 36:54then I could play as loud and as passionate as
- 36:56I want. But I had to keep reminding myself in
- 36:57the studio, this album is about daydreaming,
- 36:59even in the coda of the sonata of the fourth
- 37:02movement. But the process was incredibly smooth
- 37:05and the hall is incredible. The piano was perfectly
- 37:10maintained. So, you know, what more can one hope
- 37:13for? Well, congratulations for everything. Successful
- 37:16recordings too. So it's streaming now. Available.
- 37:20It's streaming. And one of the components that
- 37:22I really loved was that as soon as we finished
- 37:25the recording proper, they set up the lights
- 37:28and cameras and started interviewing me. So how
- 37:31was it? How was your playing? What do you think
- 37:33of Schumann? Let's do all our backstage stuff
- 37:35now. Wow. Right now, all I would do is recommend
- 37:39someone to give me a sleeping pill and give me
- 37:41a week. But the backstage, the behind the scenes
- 37:45footage is so raw. Some of it I thought in retrospect
- 37:48isn't. isn't as coherent as we're talking now.
- 37:51But I really felt that was necessary to do a
- 37:55behind the scenes series on topics like spontaneity
- 37:59in the repertoire and how people should listen
- 38:01to this music and what was Schumann like, all
- 38:03the psychological topics we were just speaking
- 38:05about. It was important to me that the listener
- 38:07had an immersive experience and understood. And
- 38:11I included this in my note, my personal note
- 38:14on the Lexicon website to listeners. if a spontaneous
- 38:17feeling or thought grabbed me in the recording
- 38:19studio i went with it even if i had practiced
- 38:22it a million times another way or performed it
- 38:24a million times another way i dared in this album
- 38:27to go off book on a lot of my let's say well
- 38:31-worn instincts and i wanted it to feel like
- 38:33they're hearing a live concert of this spontaneously
- 38:35flowing out and that's why the behind the scenes
- 38:39was so important to me to be able to explain
- 38:41where that was coming from and what that's supposed
- 38:43to sound like. And I'm hoping that in the future,
- 38:46when people listen to it, they can hear my voice
- 38:49involved with, you know, how I hear this, how
- 38:52I listen when I play, what I'm listening for,
- 38:54because we can't play Schumann beautifully by
- 38:57acting like a piano teacher. We have to be an
- 39:00artist. Not to say piano teachers aren't artists,
- 39:03but you know what I'm talking about. We cannot
- 39:04be worried about accuracy and thinking every
- 39:07note has to be perfect. And we have to be able
- 39:09to allow ourselves to access that very special
- 39:12psychological, emotional space that Schumann
- 39:14was in, which says music is my safe haven for
- 39:17my whole being. And whatever happens there is
- 39:20OK. So, yeah, this is an album I'm really proud
- 39:23of. And it gave me a retake on a lot of pieces
- 39:26I played when I was young. And I learned so much
- 39:29from the process. As you can tell, I keep overflowing
- 39:32with information that I really want to share
- 39:34about Schumann. And I actually now, I would equate
- 39:37him in my love of music to my top few composers
- 39:41that were in childhood. So Bach, Chopin, Mozart,
- 39:44Liszt. I think Schumann is now closer to where
- 39:47Bach is. It's just so fundamental to me. And,
- 39:51you know, especially right now at the time, you
- 39:55just... got married and then yeah love story
- 39:59you mentioned so it's just you know the perfect
- 40:02time that you have this album sounds like so
- 40:07it's beautiful when life falls into place that
- 40:09way oh yeah yeah and i can really um hear that
- 40:14through your performance so do you plan to develop
- 40:17this album further through like you know lecture
- 40:21recitals master classes Yeah, that's the plan.
- 40:25And there's another there are plans for another
- 40:27Schumann album with other repertoire as well.
- 40:29So I'm preparing for that now. Yeah. So for listeners,
- 40:33please listen to Jared's Schumann Daydreams available
- 40:39on all music streaming services. And is there
- 40:43like a physical album available or just the streaming?
- 40:47They went just digital this time. There's no
- 40:49physical album. Great. And also the behind the
- 40:53scenes YouTube is available. Yeah, that's publicly
- 40:59available via, you have to Google Lexicon Classics
- 41:02and go on their YouTube channel, but it's a playlist
- 41:04under Lexicon Classics. I will make sure to put
- 41:07the link in the show notes. Of course. So before
- 41:13we close, I also want to discuss very briefly
- 41:16about this new exciting piano festival called
- 41:19MUNZ. Summer piano recital? Am I pronouncing
- 41:23correctly? Yeah, Kalmunz Summer Piano Festival.
- 41:25You're right on point. This is in Kalmunz in
- 41:28Germany. It's near Bavaria. It's in Bavaria.
- 41:32And our goal is to offer young artists recitals
- 41:37that are paid as part of the festival. So we
- 41:41have our setup to provide. live performances
- 41:45and basically debut concerts for four young artists
- 41:48at the festival and then the remainder of the
- 41:51program is for master class participants so budding
- 41:54young artists who are looking for performance
- 41:55opportunities and for teachers and our real goal
- 41:59is connection this is a small town in bavaria
- 42:02actually the artist kandinsky spent considerable
- 42:04time there it's this beautiful little market
- 42:08town on a river and we hold master classes for
- 42:11nine days and between six and eight concerts.
- 42:15The last two years we've done about eight concerts.
- 42:18And four young artists receive a German debut
- 42:21as recital pianists, which is really exciting.
- 42:25And, you know, we really value in Kalmunz bringing
- 42:28people together and letting them share music
- 42:30together and united by this love of piano playing.
- 42:33Oh, wow. And then what's the age group? We've
- 42:36had to this point, mostly. collegiate so starting
- 42:41an undergrad all the way up to a pianist going
- 42:44into their doctorates and then piano teachers
- 42:47who have perhaps not played in many years and
- 42:50want to do a recital as a group effort they'll
- 42:54play a few pieces so the age range is roughly
- 42:57from 18 and up But this coming year, we've created
- 43:03a cooperation with the Federation of Canadian
- 43:05Music Festivals, its national competition. So
- 43:07the first prize winner automatically becomes
- 43:10one of our young artists and all the finalists
- 43:13are invited as well as masterclass participants.
- 43:16So we're very lucky to have our cooperation as
- 43:19well with the Canadian Music Festivals Association
- 43:22and its national competition. And I'm very honored
- 43:25to be the artistic director of this organization.
- 43:27It's a great privilege. Wonderful. And it's taking
- 43:31place once a year, right? It takes place once
- 43:34a year. Our dates are next summer, August 5th
- 43:36through 13th, 2027. Students who want to apply
- 43:41for this festival, it's by, I assume they have
- 43:47to send videos, video auditions? They send videos
- 43:50and teacher recommendations. And yes, and we
- 43:54have our website at kspianofestival .com. where
- 43:57they can find all the information in the applications.
- 43:59Thanks for mentioning that, actually. This is
- 44:01an exciting new project for me, serving as an
- 44:05artistic director of a festival, teaching its
- 44:07masterclasses and curating all the concerts.
- 44:09And I'm really looking forward to how it's going
- 44:12to develop in the coming years. Oh, wonderful.
- 44:15So before you go, you know, beyond Human Daydreams
- 44:20and the Summer Piano Festival, what's next for
- 44:22you? Well... I'm going to be playing the Schumann
- 44:26Concerto with a couple of orchestras this season.
- 44:29I'm looking forward. In May with Oakville Symphony,
- 44:32and there are some other discussions upcoming.
- 44:35Recitals and solo recitals, I have taken a backseat
- 44:39for now, but I do have a few this season. I decided
- 44:42after doing 120 Schumann concerts before I recorded
- 44:45the album, I needed a little bit of time offstage
- 44:48as a soloist. And so I'm focused on preparing
- 44:51new repertoire in the next Schumann album at
- 44:53the moment and preparing for the Schumann concerto.
- 44:56I have some chamber music concerts, piano quartets
- 44:59and quintets. That'll be announced in due course.
- 45:02And on October 15th, I believe, or it might be
- 45:05the 16th, my book with Bloomsbury Academic is
- 45:09being published. That's Goretzky's solo piano
- 45:10music. So I'm very excited about that. Oh, it's
- 45:14a book scholarly. Oh, that's right. Wonderful.
- 45:19That's right. So a quick plug on that. I'm really
- 45:22excited for it. It's got the first English translations
- 45:25of his composition notebook, which includes his
- 45:28comments on how to play his music, on the content
- 45:31in his music. English translations of his daughter
- 45:35Anna Goretzka's book on the role of the piano
- 45:38in his life, and then the first appearance of
- 45:40autograph original manuscripts so people can
- 45:43see the sources from the Goretzky family archive,
- 45:47which I'm really very excited about because I
- 45:49love studying autograph manuscripts. I'm such
- 45:51a music nerd for that. So it's a scholarly book
- 45:55and an interpretive book on his music in particular,
- 45:58but it's also a source study on how to do archive
- 46:01research. Oh, great. Will you send me the link
- 46:04to the book? Absolutely. Absolutely. Great. I
- 46:07will make sure to, of course, include that link
- 46:10in the show notes as well. Jared, thank you so
- 46:13much for returning to the PianoPod and taking
- 46:15us inside the musical and imaginative world of
- 46:17Schumann Daydreams. And to everyone listening,
- 46:20Schumann Daydreams is available now on all major
- 46:23streaming platforms through Lexicon Classics.
- 46:26Jared has also created a series of behind -the
- 46:29-scenes films exploring the album. the recording
- 46:32process, and his evolving relationship with show
- 46:35notes music. We will include links to the album
- 46:39and everything else in the show notes. If you
- 46:41enjoyed this conversation, please subscribe,
- 46:44share this episode, and follow The Piano Pod
- 46:46for more conversation from season seven, Culture
- 46:50and Courage. Thank you, everyone, for tuning
- 46:53in. See you in the next episode. Jared, thank
- 46:56you so much. Thank you again for being here.
- 46:59Thank you so much.