Latest / Marketplace Businesses with Fexingo: Two-Sided Networks, Liquidity, and Take Rates / How Marketplaces Use Promoted Listings to Raise Take Rate
Transcript
- Lucas: So Etsy reported last quarter that promoted listings revenue crossed a billion dollars in 2025. That is roughly twelve percent of their total marketplace revenue. And it's not just Etsy — Amazon's sponsored products business is now a massive line item. Today I want to dig into how marketplaces use promoted listings to raise their take rate without breaking the user experience. Luna: It's interesting because a lot of people think of marketplace revenue as just the commission. But promoted listings are basically a second revenue stream that comes entirely from sellers. Lucas: Exactly. In a typical transaction, the marketplace takes a cut — say fifteen percent on Etsy. But then on top of that, sellers can pay extra for visibility. That's an additional take rate that doesn't directly increase the price the buyer sees. The seller pays for placement, not the buyer. Luna: So it's like a bid for attention. How do marketplaces decide which listings to promote without making the search results feel like a mess? Lucas: That's the critical design question. Most marketplaces use a combination of bid and relevance score. On Amazon, for example, the winning ad is not just the highest bidder — it's the highest bid times an estimated click-through rate. So a product that's highly relevant but bids low can outrank a less relevant product that bids high. The goal is to keep user experience intact. Luna: It's basically a quality score model, like Google Ads. But for a marketplace, the stakes are higher because if the promoted results are bad, buyers lose trust and liquidity dries up. Lucas: Right. And that's why Etsy limits the number of promoted slots per search page. They did a test a few years ago where they increased the number of ads and saw click-through rates drop on organic results. So they recalibrated. The trick is to find the sweet spot where advertisers get enough return to keep bidding, but buyers don't feel overwhelmed. Luna: And this has become a huge profit driver. Amazon's ad business is now over forty billion dollars annually. Most of that is sponsored products within the marketplace. Lucas: It's ironic — Amazon originally built its marketplace to be the 'everything store,' and now it's essentially an advertising platform that also sells things. But the model works because sellers are willing to pay for access to that demand. The marketplace captures value from both sides: commission from the transaction, and ad revenue from the seller. Luna: This kind of ad-funded marketplace model is something we talk about a lot on this show, and it's part of why we keep these episodes ad-free — because we think the best insights come from focusing on the structure, not from selling you something. If you find these breakdowns useful for what you're building or running, you can support us at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Lucas: Yeah, every little bit helps us stay independent and dig into the details like this one. Now, another interesting aspect is how promoted listings affect smaller sellers. On Etsy, the average promoted listing campaign has a return on ad spend of around six to one. So for every dollar a seller spends on ads, they make six dollars in revenue. That makes it a pretty efficient tool for discovery. Luna: But it also means that sellers who don't use promoted listings get less visibility. That can create a two-tier system where the rich get richer. How do marketplaces handle that? Lucas: Some marketplaces, like eBay, take a different approach. They have a promoted listings feature, but they also offer organic discovery tools like 'trending' and 'deals.' And they cap the number of promoted slots per page to ensure there's always room for organic results. But the reality is, if you're a small seller and your product is genuinely great, you can still rank organically if you have good reviews and price. The algorithm still values relevancy. Luna: So it's not just a pay to win system. It's more like pay to accelerate. Lucas: Exactly. And that's why the take rate from promoted listings is so sustainable. Sellers see a clear return, so they keep bidding. On Etsy, over two million sellers have used promoted listings at least once. That's a massive base. And Etsy's take rate from promoted listings alone is now over two percent of gross merchandise value. Luna: That's a big number. For comparison, their core transaction take rate is around six and a half percent. So promoted listings add roughly a third more revenue. Lucas: Right. And that incremental take rate has very high margins. The cost to serve an ad impression is basically zero once the infrastructure is built. So it's incredibly profitable. But the risk is that if you push too hard, sellers revolt. There have been seller strikes on Etsy demanding lower fees and less emphasis on ads. Luna: So it's a balancing act. The marketplace has to keep the seller community healthy, because without sellers, there's no inventory. Without inventory, no buyers. Then the whole thing collapses. Lucas: Right. And that's why the best marketplaces use promoted listings as a supplement, not a replacement. They don't throttle organic traffic to force sellers into ads. They let sellers opt in. And they provide analytics so sellers can see exactly what they're getting for their money. Transparency builds trust. Luna: Let's talk about Amazon for a second. They have a more aggressive approach. Sponsored products are everywhere. But they also have a massive organic search algorithm. How do they balance it? Lucas: Amazon actually uses a technique called 'organic offset.' When a seller wins an ad auction, the organic result for that product is often removed from the page to avoid duplication. That means the ad slot substitutes the organic slot. So the total number of results doesn't change much. It's a clever way to keep the page clean while still monetizing. Luna: That's a smart hack. But it also means that if you're a seller and you don't bid, you might lose that placement entirely because a competitor's ad takes your organic spot. Lucas: Exactly. It creates a prisoner's dilemma for sellers. To maintain visibility, they almost have to bid. That's part of why Amazon's ad revenue is so high. But it also means that the cost of selling on Amazon has gone up. The total take rate — including commissions, fulfillment, and ads — can exceed thirty percent for some sellers. Luna: And that's where we see some sellers leaving Amazon for other platforms. So the take rate increase from ads can backfire if it pushes sellers away. Lucas: That's the key insight. Promoted listings are a powerful tool, but they have to be calibrated to the health of the overall ecosystem. The most successful marketplaces treat ads as a way to improve matching, not just to extract rent. When ads help buyers find what they need faster, everyone wins. Luna: Yeah, it's about alignment. If the ad system is aligned with user intent, it works. If it's just a tax, sellers and buyers both suffer. Lucas: So as we look at the next few years, I expect more marketplaces to adopt sponsored listing models. Already, platforms like Uber Eats are testing sponsored restaurant listings. And even B2B marketplaces are getting into it. The lesson is: if you have a search-driven marketplace, you can probably add a promoted listings feature as long as you keep relevance high and clutter low. Luna: Any final numbers to leave us with? Lucas: Sure. According to a 2025 report, marketplaces with promoted listings saw an average 20% increase in take rate without a corresponding drop in conversion. So for marketplace builders, it's one of the highest-leverage features you can add. But you have to build it right — prioritize the user experience first, then monetize.