Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Bitcoin Is the New Hurdle Rate: Corporate Treasuries Are Waking Up
Transcript
- 0:00Let's be clear, Bitcoin is an international asset.
- 0:04We are spending like drunken sailors.
- 0:08Bitcoin is the only economic entity where the.
- 0:11Supply is unaffected by the demand.
- 0:15If you want to preserve your wealth, you have to convert.
- 0:18That currency into an asset that's scarce, desirable,
- 0:22portable, durable, and maintainable.
- 0:31We just recorded this episode with Tim Kotzman and Ethan Peck.
- 0:35And if you're wondering what the next wave of Bitcoin adoption
- 0:38looks like, this is the one to tune into.
- 0:41Ethan joins us as the Director of Bitcoin.
- 0:43What a title, right? At Shrive Asset Management, and
- 0:46we dig into how corporate adoption is accelerating from
- 0:49the inside out. We discuss shareholder proposals
- 0:53at Microsoft, Dell and Meta, the rise of dedicated Bitcoin
- 0:57treasury companies and the growing battle inside
- 0:59boardrooms, capital markets and public perception.
- 1:03The remarkable part though is we've all had a chance to front
- 1:07run the big boys, so let's not mess this up.
- 1:10If you're holding Bitcoin for the long term, consider on
- 1:13ramps. Multi institution custody, a
- 1:15secure vault solution that eliminates single points of
- 1:18failure. Includes insurance coverage
- 1:20through Woods of London and makes inheritance as simple as
- 1:23logging into your account and clicking a few buttons.
- 1:27Get your Bitcoin situated now so as the price marches higher and
- 1:31bigger pools of capital step in, you can enjoy it without having
- 1:34to stress about the what ifs. It's almost summertime, so don't
- 1:37worry about the Bitcoin head to on rampbitcoin.com.
- 1:41You can sign up in minutes or you can book a consultation with
- 1:44myself, Cam, Michael, whoever. I'll see you then.
- 1:47Enjoy the episode. All right, well, it's time for
- 1:50scarce assets. We have an interesting 1 today
- 1:53because if Tim Kotzman, Tim is usually on the last trade.
- 1:58We did record the last trade just yesterday.
- 2:00And the audience wanted to know, wanted to know where Tim was.
- 2:05And so my, my concern and the audience concern was last time
- 2:08that Tim was on the last trade. He allegedly was recording from
- 2:12the back of a taxi cab, but we weren't sure if it was actually
- 2:15a police car. And so I just assumed that Tim's
- 2:17been locked up for the past two weeks.
- 2:18So Tim, it's nice to see you're back to business as usual.
- 2:21You have the orange tie on. And then the guest of honor
- 2:25today is Ethan Peck. Ethan is the director of
- 2:28Bitcoin. We were just talking about how
- 2:30cool the title that is at Strive asset management and Ethan and I
- 2:34I guess we briefly encountered back at Poms event in New York
- 2:38in February, the Bitcoin investor week on rampant Strive
- 2:42Co hosted a lunch. So I had a brief opportunity to
- 2:44connect there. But Ethan, it's great to see
- 2:46you, really excited about all the work that you're doing and
- 2:49get to know you a little bit better on today's show.
- 2:51Thanks for joining us. Thanks for having me on.
- 2:54It's a pleasure. Good to see you again, Tim and
- 2:57Jackson. And yeah, there's a bunch of
- 2:59good companies in this space on ramp too, and a pleasure to be
- 3:03here. Excellent.
- 3:05Well, Ethan, why don't you just tell us a little bit more about
- 3:08your background? So director of Bitcoin, that's
- 3:11it's a big title, it's about as big as it gets.
- 3:13And so would love to just understand a little bit more
- 3:16about your background. How did you land at strive doing
- 3:19the work that you're doing? And then we'll, we'll go further
- 3:22from there, but let's just get people familiar with the your
- 3:25background and the work you're you're focused on and strive.
- 3:28Cool. Yeah.
- 3:29So first of all, I'm on the corporate governance team at
- 3:31Strive. So I'm on, I'm the director of
- 3:33Bitcoin on all matters relating to corporate governance more
- 3:37specifically. So it's not as broad of a title
- 3:40as it sounds, but that's because of my background, my backgrounds
- 3:44in shareholder activism. And so for three years, I was a
- 3:47shareholder activist at a non profit filing shareholder
- 3:50proposals. Most of those shareholder
- 3:52proposals dealt with ESG pushing back against ESG, specifically
- 3:59at the companies that took it too far.
- 4:02We're doing things against fiduciary duty, against the
- 4:06interest of their shareholders. And so I just tried to keep
- 4:08corporations honest. As part of that, last year, I
- 4:11submitted A shareholder proposal to Microsoft asking them to add
- 4:15Bitcoin to their balance sheet just because I thought that it
- 4:17fit within the frame of fiduciary duty and because
- 4:20corporations were ignoring their mismanagement of their treasury.
- 4:26So it didn't really come from a place of like rah rah Bitcoin,
- 4:30even though I am, but it was just for the best interest of
- 4:35Microsoft shareholders for the, you know, that's that's where it
- 4:38came from. And Strive saw that, Matt Cole,
- 4:41CEO Strive saw that. And as Strive's dedication to
- 4:45Bitcoin and being a responsible asset manager that really puts
- 4:49his clients first realized that we need to also include in our
- 4:55voting paradigm for directors for shareholder proposals and
- 5:01engagement with corporations a pro Bitcoin stance because
- 5:05that's in the best interest of shareholders and Stripes
- 5:08clients. And so that's how I got hired at
- 5:10Strive and I've been focused on engaging with corporations on
- 5:13all matters relating to Bitcoin. Very cool natural synergies here
- 5:19between you and Tim, host of the Bitcoin Treasuries podcast,
- 5:22which everyone should certainly check out.
- 5:24So Ethan, that's an interesting background.
- 5:27So right before we hit recording, just mentioned ESG
- 5:29briefly and I figured we'd save it for the conversation.
- 5:32So how did you end up in a role where you were, I guess on the
- 5:36other side of ESG? Not to say that I, I guess the,
- 5:41the bigger point there is like ESG was this very popular way of
- 5:45investing for the past like half a decade or so, perhaps longer.
- 5:49And everyone was on board with ESG and DEI.
- 5:53And then things kind of shifted over the past, call it year or
- 5:56so. And I know Strive was really
- 5:59loud about their advocacy for just doing things, let's say,
- 6:03the right way, focusing on the business, focusing on the
- 6:05shareholders and focusing less on these, like more subjective
- 6:09things around ESG. And so how did you end up in a
- 6:12role where you were doing that? And then I'm interested to hear
- 6:16how like Bitcoin kind of fits into this as well.
- 6:18Like, is this, were these like 2 totally separate interests of
- 6:21yours? Or was there any sort of overlap
- 6:24between the two before you joined?
- 6:25Strive there. Were two separate interests.
- 6:29So I actually got into it because I started getting
- 6:34interested in politics a couple years ago.
- 6:37I joined my former job, National Center of Public Policy Research
- 6:41as a shareholder activist a couple months before Strive
- 6:46became a company. So a lot of different
- 6:49organizations around that time like popped up and, and started
- 6:53pushing back against ESG because it got so loud and was really
- 6:58taking over the culture. And so I was kind of like
- 7:03reformed liberal. I used to be more on the left
- 7:07when I was younger and as part of my becoming conservative like
- 7:11a little bit before COVID and around COVID, I started getting
- 7:14interested in more of these ideas And I, I reached out to a
- 7:19conservative nonprofit because I saw their job listing and it was
- 7:23about shareholder relations and getting companies back to
- 7:27neutral. And I was like, that's something
- 7:28I could definitely get behind. And they asked for a writing
- 7:31sample. And actually at the time, the
- 7:34writing sample that I gave them was this like this 20 page paper
- 7:39on Bitcoin for my master's degree on cybersecurity.
- 7:44And that's what got me hired there.
- 7:45So it wasn't there were two separate interests, but I'm
- 7:49happy that it sort of started there like together and now it's
- 7:52it joined back. So came full circle.
- 7:56Very cool. So you must have a knack for
- 7:58writing then because you mentioned so.
- 8:01Yeah. So did I understand correctly,
- 8:03you mentioned you got on the radar of Matt Cole and strive by
- 8:08the shareholder proposal or letter that you wrote to
- 8:11Microsoft and was that toward the end of last year would maybe
- 8:15fill in some of the gaps around that?
- 8:16So Strive muster their credit because they're the best asset
- 8:20manager in the game. I'm not just saying that because
- 8:22I worked there. Thought that before too was the
- 8:25only like the only big asset manager shareholder to vote for
- 8:29that proposal. If you guys remember it only got
- 8:31.55% and Strive voted for it. So you know, big credit to
- 8:34strive as leading the way in at the responsible investment
- 8:39stewardship. And it was just from that that
- 8:41Matt saw me and podcast that I went on including one of 10 and
- 8:46with pomp and and he reached out and it's just a natural fit
- 8:50based on my background and been great.
- 8:54That's incredible. So today at Strive, are you
- 8:58focused predominantly on drafting proposals and letters
- 9:02to public companies? Is that the core focus of your
- 9:05role? And perhaps, if there's anything
- 9:07else, what else are you working on at Strive these days?
- 9:11Yeah. So it's a couple of different
- 9:12kinds of engagement. So there are proposals.
- 9:14It's right now not proposal season.
- 9:16So the the season for submitting proposals are in the fall and
- 9:19we're going to submit a few and look to submit a few.
- 9:23And then but for now, since it's the offseason of when you can
- 9:26submit, there have been a few different engagements.
- 9:29So you guys saw the letter to GameStop, you guys saw the
- 9:32letter to into it. Did you see that?
- 9:35So we we sent the letter to into it because into it was censoring
- 9:40MailChimp was censoring its users that were sending out
- 9:44emails that included Bitcoin in it.
- 9:48And so that's a completely first of all, it's a completely
- 9:50inappropriate policy to censorship users and customers.
- 9:54That way. It's, you know, runs against the
- 9:56interest of shareholders to have such a stringent anti free
- 10:00speech view. So from there, just from that
- 10:03standpoint alone, we sent them a letter and then we also asked
- 10:06them to add Bitcoin to their treasury in that letter because
- 10:09one of their flagship products, TurboTax, is at risk of AI
- 10:15disruption. Because, you know, we feel that
- 10:17a lot of companies that can be automated by AI will go away in
- 10:23the future, that there's going to be a lot of disruption in the
- 10:26next decade. And that a Bitcoin war chest is
- 10:29the best thing that you can do as a company to protect yourself
- 10:32against that, you know, these sorts of events.
- 10:35And so that that was our recommendation letter to them.
- 10:38We also had a couple of other engagements with other companies
- 10:40that have to remain private for now, But we're we're actively
- 10:47reaching out to companies and we're also considering different
- 10:53Bitcoin related things in the way that we folk.
- 10:56So there's, it's not just the, as an asset manager, it's not
- 10:59just we're not just like we're not a activist like in my former
- 11:04role, we also have to vote on these proposals on behalf of our
- 11:07clients. And so if we see a director
- 11:09that's particularly against Bitcoin or even AI is not
- 11:14forward-looking, that's something that we consider in
- 11:17our, in our voting paradigm. And definitely we're going to do
- 11:21that more going forward. So that's, that's what I'm
- 11:23focused on. And then other matters relating
- 11:26to our general Bitcoin strategy? Awesome.
- 11:32Yeah. It's incredible to hear that the
- 11:35there was only .55% vote in favor of Microsoft adopting a
- 11:40Bitcoin strategy. And so that just goes to show
- 11:43how early we are. And I'd also assume that it goes
- 11:47to show how challenging of a challenging of a role you're
- 11:52sitting in, right where it's still Bitcoins not still fully
- 11:56accepted within the traditional finance institutional investment
- 11:59space. It's starting to get there, but
- 12:02it's really still a long road ahead, even if people don't want
- 12:05to admit that the ETFs have only existed for a little over a
- 12:09year. It's creeping its way into
- 12:11portfolios. But for the most part, Bitcoin
- 12:15is still treated as as this like radioactive asset class that
- 12:20people don't understand it. It's, you know, anchoring back
- 12:23to its teeth. It's too volatile and so it's an
- 12:29uphill battle, but it's a really good battle to be fighting.
- 12:32And so I'm curious, like as you think about the strategy at
- 12:35Strive, first, could we answer the obvious question like how do
- 12:40you kind of position Bitcoin as part of a treasury strategy for
- 12:43a company? What like what are the leading
- 12:45talking points there to advocate for it?
- 12:48And then the second part, and I can reiterate, if you forget Bo,
- 12:51just be like what are the type of companies that you're going
- 12:54to focus on as part of this shareholder activism?
- 12:58Got it. So first of all, yes, it's a
- 13:00completely uphill battle, no doubt in my mind.
- 13:03But I was sitting in the same exact position in 2020, in 2021
- 13:08and 2022 with ESG. And it was also you guys
- 13:12remember back then how you know in the culture and powerful like
- 13:16DEI was. And now it's on its last legs.
- 13:19And I remember submitting a proposal to Boeing asking them
- 13:23to get rid of DEI, and it got 5.6% of the vote.
- 13:29And then three months later, Boeing dropped the EI.
- 13:32So these things happen, you know, gradually and then
- 13:34suddenly. So I'm actually very excited and
- 13:37very hopeful for the future of Bitcoin treasuries.
- 13:41And I think it's actually happening faster than the death
- 13:44of ESG happened, but it still is an uphill battle.
- 13:48The kind of companies that we're targeting are ones that are
- 13:52susceptible to AI disruption, first of all, ones that have
- 13:58mismanagement of their balance sheet.
- 14:00So if they have like a large cash position relative to their
- 14:05market cap, that's something to consider as well.
- 14:10And companies that may have an interest in doing this already,
- 14:13because a big part of this is that there's such a resistance
- 14:16from like the boomer directors at a lot of these companies,
- 14:21They're just like this. The directors at these companies
- 14:23are such an echo chamber. They sit on multiple boards at
- 14:26the same time and they're so overlapping and they, they just
- 14:29have their view of the world and there's not a lot of heterodoxy.
- 14:35So any time we get a director at a company or ACEO of a company
- 14:40that has shown some, you know, positive views towards Bitcoin,
- 14:45we say, hey, you know, we try to open a conversation there.
- 14:49And so those are the different things that we're considering.
- 14:52And then the last thing, as you guys have seen with our recent
- 14:55announcement, I'm assuming, is that we thought that as we're,
- 14:58you know, advocating this on behalf, you know, for other
- 15:02companies, we looked at ourselves and we thought that we
- 15:06should also be a Bitcoin treasury company.
- 15:08And so we're very proud that we're moving towards that
- 15:11direction. And if anyone wants to see more
- 15:13on that, they can, they can't speak any more on that because
- 15:16it's, you know, private information.
- 15:18But anything that's publicly available, you can go on our
- 15:20website andstrive.com and and there's a bunch there.
- 15:25Yeah, that is exciting. I'm I'm looking forward to
- 15:28following that a bit closer. And so that's an interesting
- 15:31point. The last piece that you
- 15:33mentioned where it's looking for people who are within an
- 15:36organization that may have expressed some sort of
- 15:38inclination or interest or ownership in Bitcoin.
- 15:42Because at On Ramp, we help quite a bit on the private
- 15:45client side, the individual side, our clients are incredibly
- 15:48sophisticated and their understanding of Bitcoin in the
- 15:51value proposition of the business.
- 15:53But then when you go to the institutional side, it's more
- 15:56going back to that radioactive asset, right?
- 15:58And so typically on the institutional side of the
- 16:01business, you need to find people within those
- 16:04organizations who already own Bitcoin themselves, you know
- 16:07what maybe identify themselves as a Bitcoiner.
- 16:10And so it's interesting to hear that you're applying that same
- 16:13framework for some of these conversations because if you
- 16:16have that internal champion or advocate, I'd imagine you could
- 16:19really accelerate things versus trying to work only from the
- 16:22external. Yeah, absolutely.
- 16:25And Tim's interviewed like, I think more than anyone on earth,
- 16:29the most CE OS and directors that like have adopted a Bitcoin
- 16:34treasury. So I think he he could speak
- 16:36better than anyone on what's the who's the kind of person that
- 16:39would actually do this. What do you think, Tim?
- 16:45Yeah, I mean, certainly really comes down to, as Sailor would
- 16:50say, people who have a need to know.
- 16:52So yes, zombie companies, but also to your point, companies
- 16:58that are already being disrupted or otherwise need to hear from
- 17:05their shareholders about you're just like needlessly censoring
- 17:10free speech. That's just kind of crazy to
- 17:13even realize that that's happening in 2025 in, you know,
- 17:19globally. But in the United States it just
- 17:21is kind of is mind blowing. So I would say any company but
- 17:27the ones that are probably going to be last or maybe not a
- 17:31leverage strategy, but just putting someone on the balance
- 17:34sheet would probably be the mag 7 excluding strategy when they
- 17:38get into the S&P 500 because they have a business that is
- 17:43going to be probably right. We the buzzword this week is
- 17:48Moat, right? Do you have a Moat?
- 17:50How big is your Moat? Do you have a boat with your
- 17:52Moat like all these Moat type adjectives?
- 17:57But in all seriousness, if they have a cash flowing business,
- 18:01they they are either have they're either of a certain size
- 18:06or they are just so focused on their current operation that
- 18:13this is kind of the last thing that they would even be focused
- 18:16on. And then layer into that, if
- 18:18they don't have someone that's at all vocal about Bitcoin as a
- 18:23commodity, as an asset class in house, then that probably is an
- 18:27even tougher climb uphill. Yep.
- 18:31And I completely agree. And I also think that some of
- 18:36these like some of these directors or, or or CE OS that
- 18:40show a positive attitude towards Bitcoin, like in their personal
- 18:44lives, they're still hesitant to, to adopt it for their
- 18:48company. And that's, that has been the
- 18:50biggest frustration. Like Michael Dell, for example,
- 18:55I think you guys may have seen that the proposal at Dell, they
- 18:59requested that the company, the company requested that the
- 19:04proposal that I sent that Dell back a couple months ago be left
- 19:07off the ballot and not be even allowed to be voted on by
- 19:10shareholders. And they requested that at the
- 19:12SEC and the SEC granted them permission to do that,
- 19:16unfortunately. So that's a little bit of a set
- 19:18back and we can discuss that a little bit.
- 19:20But Michael Dell, someone that's shown a number of times like a
- 19:25positive view towards Bitcoin and still his company went
- 19:29against this proposal just asking for like a report on
- 19:33Bitcoin. And so that shows you the
- 19:34dichotomy between what a lot of these people are willing to do
- 19:37in their personal lives and what they're willing to do for their
- 19:40companies. And I think that a lot of that
- 19:41just comes down to nobody wants to, I think nobody wants to be
- 19:46held responsible if they make a mistake or they play it so safe.
- 19:52And it just gets back to like this like environment of
- 19:56quarterly capitalism that we live in, all these companies
- 19:58just going quarter to quarter, you know, playing with numbers,
- 20:01playing all these little tricks just to make the next 10 Q look
- 20:05good. And they're not thinking about
- 20:07the long term interest of their shareholders.
- 20:09And that's just the way that directors are put on boards, how
- 20:13people retain their jobs. And nobody's, you know, going
- 20:16out on a limb. It takes someone like a Michael
- 20:18Saylor to say I'll do it and. That a part of the theme at a
- 20:24Strategy World and I think that Tim, I think you guys talked
- 20:27about this on the last podcast that you had with Matt Cole and
- 20:31Ben and Jeff, shout out to hurdle rate Pine that courage is
- 20:40in scarcer supply than intelligence and that's really
- 20:43what it takes. Yeah, either be a disruptor or
- 20:49be disrupted and it might not happen overnight, but I think in
- 20:53the in the coming months and quarters, you're going to see
- 20:58it, right. Maybe not weeks, but definitely
- 21:00not years at this point. That's my personal view.
- 21:04Yeah, I saw that stat that Sailor included in one of his
- 21:08presentations in Orlando. About 96% of companies, I
- 21:13believe it was underperforming T-bills.
- 21:15Is that right? If one of you could correct me.
- 21:17Did you see that one? I think it was, I don't remember
- 21:21the exact stat. I, I, I think it was that 96% of
- 21:25the companies like underperform the S&P in the S&P underperform
- 21:28the S and Pi. Wasn't sure, but was it T-bills?
- 21:32I'll have to check it was one or the other.
- 21:34But it yeah, I guess, I guess the broader point is that the
- 21:39there's so much concentration in the S&P 500, Tim already called
- 21:45out the Max 7. I mean there that's probably
- 21:47what like 2530% of the index in terms of market cap and then it
- 21:53drives the outsize of the returns.
- 21:55And so if I'm one of these other 493 companies in the S&P 500,
- 22:02that is either whatever it is, whether they're struggling to
- 22:05beat the index itself or they're struggling to beat T-bills, I
- 22:08should know that stat will hopefully find it during this
- 22:10episode. But either way, I think I'd be
- 22:13looking at opportunities to potentially increase my
- 22:18shareholders return. And Bitcoin feels like an
- 22:21obvious place to go because you mentioned Bitcoin as a hurdle
- 22:25rate and something we focus on at early riders as well.
- 22:28Tim's an advisor to the venture fund, but every capital
- 22:32allocation decision is made with Bitcoin as the hurdle rate.
- 22:36And so, yeah. And so do you want to talk more
- 22:39about that at Strive, just in terms of how that informs your
- 22:43business decisions and maybe how you articulate that to companies
- 22:48that aren't as convinced about the merits of Bitcoin as we are?
- 22:52Yeah. Well, I can't speak more to our
- 22:54treasury strategy right now. I got to point you guys to the
- 22:57website, but Bitcoin is the hurdle rate for capital
- 23:01deployment. And you know, you've seen Matt
- 23:04has said this himself, he holds himself as the CEO to that same
- 23:08exact standard. And he said that anyone that
- 23:11deploys capital and doesn't beat Bitcoin should be fired.
- 23:16And we, we hold ourselves to that standard.
- 23:18And and that's the way that as we look to become a Bitcoin
- 23:22treasury company and that's the way that we're going to evaluate
- 23:26opportunities going forward against Bitcoin and that we
- 23:29believe that every company, especially the ones that have
- 23:33already adopted Bitcoin should do that.
- 23:36Yeah, I mean, it makes a ton of sense.
- 23:38I think it was Fidelity, Chris Kiper, head of research there,
- 23:41who was speaking about this idea, right?
- 23:44Where if you're in a, if you're deciding how to allocate capital
- 23:50within your organization, you really should be evaluating
- 23:53those decisions based on Bitcoin as a hurdle rate, which I think
- 23:57the number he pointed to, I forget the time frame was it
- 24:00probably was five years, 65% kegger.
- 24:03And so if you reorient your capital allocation decisions to
- 24:07Bitcoin, it totally changes the game, right?
- 24:10Like if you're sitting on a pile of cash and you have to beat a
- 24:1465% kegger, well, there's very, very few ways to do that.
- 24:20It's just like it totally changes the game.
- 24:22It flips the script of capital allocation.
- 24:25Yeah. And what I think that it does
- 24:26the most is this gets to, you know, the idea of a Bitcoin
- 24:29standard compared to a Fiat standard.
- 24:31It cuts a lot of the nonsense. It cuts a lot of the waste.
- 24:35Having lived through a century of easy money, There's a lot of
- 24:41there's a lot of nonsense, there's a lot of waste, There's
- 24:43a lot of low quality products going around.
- 24:46And, you know, we believe that if you're stringent and you have
- 24:51to be really careful and, and, and in the way that you allocate
- 24:57your capital and, and really discriminate only for the best
- 25:01ideas and the best opportunities, it's going to
- 25:04lead to an era, not just success for your own company, but an
- 25:08era. The more that more companies do
- 25:11this and the more that this becomes a standard across many
- 25:14corporations and across countries and markets, this will
- 25:18raise the standard of the goods and services, I believe.
- 25:24How do you articulate that though to if you go back to
- 25:28Microsoft, right, just to use them as an example, not even a
- 25:32percent of shareholders wanted to approve that proposal to add
- 25:37Bitcoin. And so that just goes to show
- 25:40again the uphill battle that we talked about how early we are.
- 25:44And so it's probably really challenging to tell people that
- 25:49Bitcoin is a hurdle rate if they lack an understanding of what
- 25:53Bitcoin is, right? So what are what are some of
- 25:57like the more one O one types of conversations or positioning
- 26:02that you use at shrive as part of the shareholder activism
- 26:05strategy to convey the merits of Bitcoin?
- 26:08Like how, how do you get from we're a board, we don't really
- 26:12know anything about Bitcoin to eventually deciding that Bitcoin
- 26:16is a hurdle rate and it's worth deploying our cash into that
- 26:19until we can further allocate resources.
- 26:22Yeah, First of all, even though only like less than a percent
- 26:26voted for that proposal, we have to remember that it's not the
- 26:29actual ultimate shareholders that voted on that.
- 26:31It's the big three asset managers, BlackRock, Vanguard
- 26:34and State Street and other big asset managers like Goldman and
- 26:39JP Morgan and Bank of America, They're the ones voting on
- 26:42behalf of their clients. And then you have the big two
- 26:45proxy advisory services, ISS and Glass Lewis.
- 26:48They're, they're recommending the votes on behalf of a lot of
- 26:51these pension funds and state pension funds.
- 26:54And so that Dom and a lot of retail investors, they don't,
- 26:59they don't vote their shares. And So what you end up with a
- 27:02situation with is over 90% of the vote, even higher maybe is
- 27:07coming from these large institutional asset managers.
- 27:11And that's why the votes are so lopsided.
- 27:13As soon as like BlackRock and Vanguard flip, all of a sudden
- 27:16the vote 40%. So it's like that.
- 27:18That's that's what we're really dealing with.
- 27:21If you actually pull the clients of the funds, you know,
- 27:26BlackRock and Vanguard funds, it's not going to be 1 less than
- 27:301%. So that's why these things can
- 27:34be such a lopsided votes, but it's also why they can flip very
- 27:38quickly. So that's the first thing.
- 27:42The second thing I would say is that when I'm discussing this
- 27:45with, with, with companies, when I discussed it with Amazon, with
- 27:48Dell, with McDonald's, with Microsoft, Meta, there's almost
- 27:56the same conversation every single time.
- 27:58The, the very first thing that they bring up and that their
- 28:01biggest concern by far is volatility.
- 28:05And so when you look at it, a lot of these companies, yes,
- 28:09they have a lot of cash. When you look at it as a, as a
- 28:13relative to their market cap, their treasuries are usually not
- 28:17that big in, in the 1st place. So, so their own, you know,
- 28:22their own credit, their treasuries, the, the amount of
- 28:25cash that they have really, and their short dated treasuries
- 28:28really only covers their short term expenses and a, and a
- 28:32little bit beyond that. So it's not like a lot of it is
- 28:36inflating away. And this is something that, you
- 28:38know, I learned having engaged with them a little bit more.
- 28:42But that's the problem that they're so short minded.
- 28:46They're only thinking about the next quarter.
- 28:48They're not thinking 5-10 years down the road.
- 28:52They're only thinking about the short, short term interest of
- 28:54shareholders when they need to be balancing the short term and
- 28:57long term interest of shareholders.
- 28:58Think about how many shareholders own Microsoft and
- 29:01or these funds for 20-30, forty years.
- 29:04Like do they not have an interest to, you know, to serve
- 29:07those in those interest for those shareholders too?
- 29:10Of course they do, but they're not considering that because
- 29:13they don't want to get fired. They don't want to rock the boat
- 29:16and they're just comfortable running their corporations in
- 29:20this quarter to quarter way. And what I found was that, you
- 29:26know it, what's really interesting is, is, is this
- 29:29quarterly capitalism is this mindset of short dated
- 29:32treasuries? Like is this the byproduct of
- 29:37Fiat? Like that's, that's really where
- 29:41my head's been going lately. So it's not like I think that
- 29:44once corporations adopt A Bitcoin standard or adopt
- 29:48Bitcoin, it's not just going to like adjust their hurdle rate.
- 29:52It'll also like be a solution. It's a hedge against inflation.
- 29:56It's it'll adjust their hurdle rate, but it'll also, it's also
- 29:59an answer like in a hedge against managerial myopia,
- 30:02against short termism. And it fixes their time
- 30:05preferences and it completely reorients companies I believe.
- 30:11Yeah, absolutely. No, that it's a fairpoint.
- 30:13And I think at the end of the day, this is more of a
- 30:17grassroots adoption that we've experienced in Bitcoin.
- 30:20And so I mean all these people are individuals within
- 30:24organizations, right? And so the the path of least
- 30:28resistance is to have more individuals understand the
- 30:32merits of Bitcoin for their own personal lives.
- 30:34And then to your point, Ethan, there needs to be an opportunity
- 30:39or a path towards more courage in corporate boardrooms and in
- 30:44institutional investor community to actually be some of the first
- 30:48people to adopt Bitcoin in a more meaningful way.
- 30:51And so that seems to be a challenge at the moment.
- 30:54Just when I look at Bitcoin treasuries, we have of course,
- 30:58strategy leading by a wide margin, but then the other
- 31:03largest treasuries are, call them Bitcoin or crypto native
- 31:07businesses. So you have some miners in
- 31:09there, you have exchanges, but then there's very few companies
- 31:12that are not in the industry that have adopted a Bitcoin
- 31:16treasury playbook. But it's exciting to hear that
- 31:20Strive is at the forefront of doing this and I am encouraged.
- 31:24I think it's just a matter of survival.
- 31:26I did look up the status we were talking through this. 96% of the
- 31:30companies have returns in line or below T-bills not, not S&P
- 31:35500, right. So these companies are at pace
- 31:40or worse than what's perceived to be a risk free asset.
- 31:43Now does is it risk free? That's a topic of a different
- 31:47discussion. But at the same time it's like
- 31:50we all know if you're getting a 3% or 4% coupon on something,
- 31:54you're losing purchasing power over A1510 year horizon.
- 31:58And so there does become a point where these companies just
- 32:02adopted out of necessity. I mean, it at some point it
- 32:05doesn't become a choice anymore. It's like, all right, we either
- 32:07want to continue to exist as a business and to do so, we need
- 32:11to figure out ways to invest our capital that will outpace the
- 32:14basement or we don't exist anymore or we're required,
- 32:17right? I mean, isn't it that simple?
- 32:18It's just it's, it's a matter of survival.
- 32:22A lot of these companies also, when I engage with them, they're
- 32:25doing a lot of like the, the treasuries aside, right?
- 32:29If those cover their short term expenses, they're doing a lot of
- 32:32buybacks and a lot of dividends. And so like something that
- 32:36Amazon told me was that that the, you know, Bitcoin is too
- 32:40volatile, but then they're investing, they're buying back
- 32:43their own stock and Amazon stock this year.
- 32:47I believe I saw stat was more volatile than Bitcoin over the
- 32:50last 90 days. And so like it's, it's funny
- 32:55that Bitcoin is also still, you know, you're still seeing upside
- 32:59with it, but the volatility is going down especially.
- 33:02And we're in an era now where securities are also volatile.
- 33:07So and they're and they're not performing well.
- 33:11So this is makes Bitcoin more and more attractive.
- 33:15And I believe we'll eventually get to a point where even those
- 33:19that have already come around to Bitcoin but don't have the
- 33:22courage to implement it themselves for their company,
- 33:26you know, beyond their own personal lives, they're going to
- 33:29be forced to. And that's the sailor's point.
- 33:31Like people find Bitcoin when they have to.
- 33:34And so it looks like that's that is showing us that these
- 33:38companies very soon will have to.
- 33:40Yeah, it's like 2017 called. They want their line back.
- 33:44The volatility thing is just so tiresome.
- 33:48First of all, Bitcoin has more positive volatility than
- 33:52negative volatility, so there's more positively skewed days.
- 33:55So the returns are, if you look at the distribution curve of
- 33:59Bitcoin and perhaps gold might be this as well, there's more
- 34:02positive skew, meaning more days of volatility to the upside than
- 34:05downside. Whereas with equities and bonds,
- 34:08it's the opposite. There's more of a negative skew.
- 34:10So this environment of several past decades of modern portfolio
- 34:14theory and 6040 portfolio, they associate volatility with being
- 34:19an inherently bad thing because the traditional assets that we
- 34:24have invested in in a meaningful way have more downside
- 34:28volatility. So when you introduce something
- 34:30like Bitcoin, there's more upside volatility to the asset
- 34:33class. That's a good thing.
- 34:35I mean, volatility is an opportunity.
- 34:38If you're strategic as a company and you're sitting on a
- 34:40stockpile of cash, you can strategically deploy that cash
- 34:44into Bitcoin and it take advantage of the downside
- 34:47volatility and enjoy the upside volatility, right.
- 34:50So I think there's just like a lack of critical thinking or
- 34:55maybe it is just the human nature to not want to go against
- 34:58the grain or against the herd and wait for more people to step
- 35:02out and push the frontier forward before entering this.
- 35:07What's still perceived to be risky asset class because of its
- 35:10volatility. But for the reasons we just
- 35:12talked about, that doesn't make it a risky asset.
- 35:14It's good. It's just like it's, it's
- 35:16ridiculous. Absolutely.
- 35:19I agree completely. And then we'll just also add
- 35:21that like as soon as you adjust your time preference beyond the
- 35:24scope of like 3-4, five years, even four years, you know,
- 35:29bitcoins never had a negative return over I think even three
- 35:32years. So as soon as you adjust your
- 35:34time preference beyond three years, then the volatility
- 35:37doesn't matter. So.
- 35:39Yeah. What can you speak at all to?
- 35:41Just what one thing you mentioned I think is interesting
- 35:45is the votes are concentrated with the largest asset managers,
- 35:50right? And so how does that relate to a
- 35:53strategy of shareholder activism where maybe there's only so much
- 35:57you can do to move the needle by going to a company directly
- 36:00versus trying to partner or collaborate with the largest
- 36:03shareholders, BlackRock, Vanguard to push things forward?
- 36:07I mean, I know it seems that Larry Fink, who was a very
- 36:12staunch critic of Bitcoin five years ago, is now in favour of
- 36:17Bitcoin. Who's to say how much he
- 36:19understands it? I, I don't know.
- 36:21It honestly doesn't even matter. But he's in the business of
- 36:23making money and their firm had the most successful ETF of all
- 36:27time last year with IBIT. And so he sees this while it's
- 36:31still a small percentage of their revenue, it's a growing
- 36:34percentage of the revenue. And so I'm just curious like how
- 36:38do you think about from Stripes perspective working with these
- 36:42large shareholders to push forward a Bitcoin treasury
- 36:45strategy rather than trying to go direct?
- 36:49Well, I wouldn't say working with them, like first of all,
- 36:52you have to remember that BlackRock voted against that
- 36:55Microsoft proposal. So they might be like, so
- 36:58there's a, there's a disconnect between the investment
- 37:02stewardship departments that some of these asset managers and
- 37:05then how they behave outside of those investment stewardship
- 37:08departments. What I'm very proud of its
- 37:10strive is that we don't have that disconnect.
- 37:13You know, we actually practice what we preach, which is why
- 37:16we're becoming a Bitcoin treasury company and why we vote
- 37:19consistently with that. I think that that's what gives
- 37:22us the edge and what corporate governance is something that
- 37:26matters. If you have a pro shareholder,
- 37:28pro fiduciary corporate governance and you're the only
- 37:31asset manager that does that, then you're going to attract
- 37:34clients because you because you do that and because that will
- 37:37make a difference in the way that companies are run.
- 37:41And so I, I believe that Strive has, you know, a positive future
- 37:44ahead of it also with his asset management.
- 37:46Business understood. Yeah, I guess it's less about
- 37:52collaborating, but it's more so just recognizing that these
- 37:55companies do have majority, in many cases majority of the
- 38:00voting interest. And so it's like there's a lot
- 38:03of opportunity for you guys to go direct and and push things
- 38:06forward. But it seems like to some
- 38:08extent, at least for some companies, you want to work with
- 38:11these other firms need to be on board.
- 38:14Right. Well, I spoke, I spoke with
- 38:16BlackRock about the Microsoft proposal back in November and
- 38:24they sounded just like Microsoft.
- 38:25They sounded like like, well, the company says it's volatile.
- 38:30It's like, OK, now you trust the company, but when you push these
- 38:34other ESG stuff on them, like then it's then you don't trust
- 38:37the company. So it seems like BlackRock has
- 38:41their own agenda and they're just going to do what they do,
- 38:45and that's not within our control.
- 38:46We're just going to make the best pitch possible that we can
- 38:49for Bitcoin, and we believe that eventually more people than not
- 38:51will see it. Makes sense.
- 38:55Yeah. Well, there's been a lot of
- 38:57Bitcoin treasury companies that have been launched and
- 39:00announced. And so I'd be curious, Tim, I
- 39:03would welcome your thoughts on this topic as well.
- 39:08But what do you both just make of this?
- 39:11So Ethan, you mentioned strive becoming or is however you want
- 39:15to categorize it, Bitcoin asset management company.
- 39:18Then you have other firms that have been announced and launched
- 39:24in the past couple weeks, I think of 21 with Jack and Tether
- 39:29and Cantor. And so there seems to be more
- 39:33competition entering the space from a Pureplay Bitcoin treasury
- 39:37company or Pureplay Bitcoin asset management company.
- 39:41So this is a space that I don't follow as closely and I would
- 39:45really enjoy to hear from either one of you, just your thoughts.
- 39:48As this landscape evolves and more players enter the space,
- 39:52how do you think about the competitive environment?
- 39:57Want to go first time? Sure.
- 40:04I mean, I think it's certainly a net positive to have additional
- 40:08entrance in the space. I mean, Michael Saylor has said
- 40:11there's room for dozens of companies to be leverage Bitcoin
- 40:18equities or whatever term you want to use to really describe
- 40:23the micro strategy playbook of engaging with the capital
- 40:26markets to sell additional shares, issue debt, issue
- 40:31preferred shares, use these different strategies to really
- 40:36tap these different pools of capital to build Bitcoin on the
- 40:40balance sheet. Certainly some of these
- 40:45companies are going to thrive. Some of them are going to be OK.
- 40:49Some of them are going to make some strategic mistakes, whether
- 40:53it's a leverage ratio or just going down some other path that
- 40:59or or in my view, making it more complicated than it needs to be.
- 41:05I don't think that you need to follow one strategy to a tee and
- 41:11not have any outside or critical thinking of your own involved in
- 41:16it. But it's very obvious now that
- 41:21strategy is the gold standard of doing things in a measured,
- 41:26thoughtful, constructive, but in a way that gains scale and is
- 41:36innovative. I mean, part of the talks in
- 41:39Orlando walk through how the strategy team used the deep
- 41:44research function of AI to come up with these preferred
- 41:48products. I mean, talk about shaving years
- 41:53off of iterating ideas. That's that's really interesting
- 41:58and and forward-looking to just use, use all this technology.
- 42:04But you know, will some of these companies outperform on a
- 42:09certain time frame the strategies of the world?
- 42:11Sure. Will some of them crash and
- 42:13burn? Sure.
- 42:14That's why none of this is ever financial advice.
- 42:17But you know, for the longest time, and by longest time, I
- 42:23mean the last seven months since I started the Bitcoin Treasuries
- 42:26pod, it's really at least, and I focus on this a lot, right?
- 42:32I like wake up in the morning, talk about Bitcoin, go to sleep.
- 42:35That's pretty much my life. And really the household names
- 42:38have been MicroStrategy, now, Strategy, similar Scientific and
- 42:42Metaplanet, and there have been others, but not in a way that's
- 42:49like a household name. So I think it's a super
- 42:53interesting time. I mean, there's only ever going
- 42:58to be a company like 21 that comes to market with Cantor,
- 43:02Tether and SoftBank all being involved.
- 43:05That's only going to happen once in like humanity, at least for
- 43:10the United States. I mean, those are just such
- 43:13massive and unique organizations that we could spend an hour just
- 43:17talking about that project. And then you have other names in
- 43:23the industry, right? With Nakamoto, with David
- 43:26Bailey, I mean, he literally coordinated orange peeling
- 43:30President Trump. Like, it doesn't get much better
- 43:33than that as far as leaders in the industry that are coming to
- 43:37market with some of these projects.
- 43:39So I think it's going to be super interesting to see how it
- 43:45all develops on so many fronts, not just the regulatory aspects
- 43:51that we focused on a lot over the past year for all the
- 43:55obvious reasons, but from a marketing standpoint, right?
- 43:59Like you can double down on the capital side of it, but are you
- 44:03going to double down on the culture side of it and the
- 44:06social side of it because strategy is just leading the way
- 44:10and and put the numbers aside. I mean, if you look on social
- 44:14media over the past week, they have podcasters and influencers
- 44:18in their offices playing pool, drinking beer, interviewing the
- 44:22Ceoi mean, that's being innovative and that's connecting
- 44:28with. I mean, last night on True
- 44:30North, LA Dozier joined, joined us and he said, you know, he
- 44:34said, I see people in the chat right now on this live stream
- 44:37that are strategy employees. He said, I know for a fact that
- 44:40strategy employees watch True North videos as part of their
- 44:43training. I mean, it's really this
- 44:46confluence of really bringing together your employees in the
- 44:49case of strategy, their investors, and just really the
- 44:55community at large. Like putting that out there and
- 44:57not dismissing traditional media, but not relying on only
- 45:04traditional media, right? That we have all this new media
- 45:07and we could go down the list. There's a lot of what I've been
- 45:09posting about over the past week is like 1 meme a day, one
- 45:13podcast a day, you know, one event every month, one
- 45:19conference a year. I mean, yeah, is I, I just think
- 45:23we're entering this whole new world where not every company
- 45:27needs to, you know, do all of these things.
- 45:31But I think if people are not thoughtful about embracing what
- 45:35Ethan's talking about on the AI front and the Bitcoin front and,
- 45:40and wherever all this technology is going, not for technology's
- 45:43sake, but for productivity sake, for the shareholders, for, for
- 45:49everyone that's a stakeholder in these, in these firms, in these
- 45:52projects, in these companies, we need, especially when the
- 45:57Bitcoin treasury company front, you know, I, I really think
- 46:01there's going to be a lot of positions like a director of
- 46:03Bitcoin, but I think you're going to see like a Bitcoin
- 46:06treasury strategist, which is maybe just a different name for
- 46:10investor relations and community outreach.
- 46:13But my 1 take away from Orlando and being invited to the
- 46:17speaker's dinner with Fong and Sailor and, and all the speakers
- 46:20on the last night is, you know, it's a small room, but you still
- 46:24have 4 tables with 30 or 40 some people there.
- 46:28We need the next level of leadership in the Bitcoin space,
- 46:32specifically in the Bitcoin treasury space.
- 46:34I mean, it's going to get to the point where it's not scalable
- 46:37that any company that wants to pursue this strategy is going to
- 46:39be able to get on a call with Dylan or Sailor, right?
- 46:42Like it's just not really scalable.
- 46:45And there's great service providers that are coming into
- 46:48the space to to help with that. But I think you're going to see
- 46:51a Bitcoin treasury strategist at every Bitcoin treasury company
- 46:55and they're going to be really engaging in the traditional
- 46:58media and on the social side. In addition to I mean, this is
- 47:03all kind of investor relations and and community outreach.
- 47:06You're going to see a director of Bitcoin strategy some more to
- 47:09like a Dylan Leclair. And then you're going to see an
- 47:13executive like a Fong Lee or Sale or write a CEOACFOACIOA
- 47:19chairman and executive chairman that they're really, you know,
- 47:23doing a lot. But one of their primary
- 47:25functions is exactly what Sailor has been doing for half a
- 47:28decade, believe it or not, right?
- 47:30It's almost like, wow, five years is half a decade and he's
- 47:33been just pounding the table on Bitcoin, the Bitcoin story,
- 47:40managing his Twitter account and doing phone calls.
- 47:44I mean, that's a full time job. So I just think this entire
- 47:48ecosystem is at this really interesting inflection point.
- 47:53Tim, you're you're an excellent case study too.
- 47:56I mean, you just launched the podcast in October, November.
- 48:01I forget the story you told me one time, but you just kind of
- 48:04like did it right. And you didn't even have an
- 48:06expectation of making a business or career out of it.
- 48:11You just did the podcast. For some reason I forget.
- 48:14And then whatever it is, nine months later, maybe not even
- 48:18you're on stage with Michael Saylor at the conference.
- 48:21I mean, what is that? Like, what is that?
- 48:23What is that a lesson for people listening there?
- 48:25Because people want to get involved in the space.
- 48:27Yeah, people think it that it's that it's just kind of like a
- 48:30funny saying or a meme that you can just do things or it's just
- 48:34a meme. But like the reality is Ellie
- 48:36Dozier created digital art that had Michael Saylor wearing an
- 48:41orange tie and then Michael Saylor wore an orange tie on
- 48:44CNBC. And then Ryan and Jeff and
- 48:47myself saw that and I was actually pretty upset because
- 48:51they came out with their men in orange or whatever episode of
- 48:54Quant Bros. The day that I put on the orange
- 48:57tie in the studio, which was October 5th.
- 48:59Not that I'm keeping track or anything, but so like Sailor
- 49:03wore like Ellie Dozier literally create a meme, Then Sailor wore
- 49:08an orange tie, then Ryan and Jeff wore an orange tie, and
- 49:12then I wore an orange tie. So like 4th, unless you want to
- 49:17count digital sale or maybe I'm 5th to wear an orange tie.
- 49:20But this all is part of that social aspect that, you know,
- 49:27Eric Semler has has talked about he as an activist investor, as
- 49:32an LP, He doesn't really he kind of shies away from companies
- 49:36that are like a little too bombastic, right, a little too
- 49:40showy. And I totally understand that
- 49:42from that activist or investor LP standpoint, but look at what
- 49:47Michael Saylor is doing it. It doesn't have to be, it's not
- 49:49necessarily showy. It's just putting a spotlight on
- 49:53Bitcoin. And I think just all this is so
- 49:56unique because Bitcoin is a commodity.
- 49:59So you can talk about Bitcoin all day long, right?
- 50:01Senators and Congress people can talk about Bitcoin because it's
- 50:03a commodity. It's not a security.
- 50:06So like when you pair that with a equity, right?
- 50:09And there's regulations out there that you shouldn't be out
- 50:12there like necessarily like promoting and, and trying to
- 50:16pump your stock. But bitcoins just this
- 50:19interesting commodity when, when you can put it all into all
- 50:23these different wrappers. And, you know, I think I share
- 50:29some other of people, prominent people's views in the space that
- 50:34I'm surprised there are not more structured products on top of
- 50:38Bitcoin yet. They're coming, right.
- 50:40But you see all these products that I mean, that's just a nice
- 50:44clean wrapper that people like go, right, whether it's a
- 50:47product like a preferred product from strategy or it's some sort
- 50:50of ETF product. I mean, these are all doorways
- 50:53into Bitcoin. Like I'll just speak for myself.
- 50:56I don't really care how people get to Bitcoin.
- 50:58I just want them to get there and, and, and really accelerate
- 51:01that story. And I'm, I'm pretty positive on
- 51:06Bitcoin treasury companies and nation state adoption being able
- 51:10to, you know, I think it's going to feel like you're pulling the
- 51:13future forward a little bit, even though the reality will
- 51:16probably be closer to, you know, sailors forecast of 30 to 60%
- 51:20appreciation a year for the next, you know, 21 years.
- 51:24All right, just a quick break. Have your friends and family
- 51:27ever made fun of you about Bitcoin?
- 51:29They probably have. Or maybe they just dismiss you
- 51:32every time you bring it up. But perhaps that is changing
- 51:35with Bitcoin again crossing 100K and potentially going much
- 51:39higher this year. Not financial advice, of course.
- 51:42Your friends and family might actually need a secure place to
- 51:45buy Bitcoin. And so that's where on Ramp
- 51:47trade comes into play. It is our latest account tier.
- 51:50It's purpose built for secure long term Bitcoin accumulation.
- 51:54You can see here on the screen what you get there.
- 51:57If you're listening on video, you get low fees, you get your
- 52:00own segregated vault on chain. You have access to the on ramp
- 52:04terminal, you get access to human support.
- 52:06You can speak with me Cam, whoever on the team you're not
- 52:09just chatting with thoughts. Best part is if you sign up
- 52:12before June 30th with the code TLT, get 0 trading fees through
- 52:16September. So your friends and family, even
- 52:18you if you want to buy more Bitcoin got a check coming in.
- 52:21You just sold all your chairs in your house and you want to buy
- 52:23some more Bitcoin and now you can do it.
- 52:25No trading fees and you get 50% off of account fees and you get
- 52:3050 to $150.00 in Bitcoin for every person you refer.
- 52:34So listen, your friends and family, they might have made fun
- 52:37of you before, but you should help them out if you're a good
- 52:39person and maybe you want to buy some more Bitcoin yourself.
- 52:42So head over to on rampbitcoin.com.
- 52:44You can open an account in minutes or you can also speak
- 52:47with Cam myself, whoever Michael even you want to talk to
- 52:51Michael, you want to hear Michael yell.
- 52:53So book a consultation online or just sign up on our website.
- 52:56Enjoy the rest of the episode for for both of you.
- 52:59I'm curious like looking through the rest of the year.
- 53:02So it's mid-May when we're recording.
- 53:05Tim, you mentioned structure products.
- 53:07So maybe my umbrella question would be just thoughts on
- 53:11adoption or announcements. So adoption of Bitcoin within
- 53:16corporate treasuries is let's say just like vanilla strategy
- 53:19starting to move some cash or some T-bills and parking in
- 53:23Bitcoin to just buffer the balance sheet, grow the the
- 53:26company. The next piece would be pureplay
- 53:29companies. So we saw a few that have been
- 53:31announced. Tim, you mentioned Nakamoto,
- 53:33totally forgot about that. 121 thoughts on more pureplay
- 53:39companies entering the space and then structured products.
- 53:42I mean, I hear of all these structured products.
- 53:45I actually have not spent much time learning about them just
- 53:48yet. But to my understanding, there's
- 53:50only a few that exist. I mean, ETFs aside, let's talk
- 53:52about like, you know, strategy products, Tim, that you probably
- 53:56know better. What are your thoughts?
- 53:58Just in terms of the remainder of this year where we see the
- 54:01most growth? Is it pureplay companies?
- 54:04Is it vanilla? Are there more structured
- 54:06products announced? You're just like, tell me what,
- 54:08what excites you guys and, and where do you where are you
- 54:10paying attention? Yeah.
- 54:14I think that the first of all, strike and strike are very
- 54:17unique products and I think that there are going to be more
- 54:20similar products coming from strategy and others as this
- 54:25space grows. Bitcoins really becoming an
- 54:28asset class, not just an asset. You have ETFs, you have Bitcoin
- 54:33treasury companies. I think those are going to be
- 54:35different kinds of Bitcoin treasury companies, pureplay
- 54:37ones, you know, micro strategy copies, companies that do things
- 54:41more innovative than strategy and take it to the next level.
- 54:45You're going to have companies that just use Bitcoin as a hedge
- 54:48against inflation, like a Tesla. There's going to be all
- 54:52different kinds of ways to gain exposure to Bitcoin.
- 54:55And I think that that's a good thing.
- 54:57It's not that not just that it's a good thing.
- 54:59If you look back and you think about, you know, what would the
- 55:03game theory look like of Bitcoin becoming the money of the world?
- 55:09Like it would have to happen in steps.
- 55:11It would have to infiltrate, you know, the little bit of
- 55:15governments, a little bit of corporations, some, you know,
- 55:18retail, some countries are going to start using it where they
- 55:22don't have a stable currency and it's just going to take time.
- 55:25And so I think that these are the first iterations of that
- 55:28happening. That's what I believe is going
- 55:30on. And so there's going to be a lot
- 55:34of different products and corporate approaches and nation
- 55:39state approaches, whether it's just buying Bitcoin, whether
- 55:43it's, you know, buying Bitcoin and dips, dollar cost averaging,
- 55:47mining Bitcoin, trading in Bitcoin, Steak and Shake is now
- 55:50accepting Bitcoin. There's a There's a lot of
- 55:53different ways. Yeah, when I posted a few days
- 55:58ago, I said what what Bitcoin treasury company should I
- 56:01consider going to work for or one of the comments was Steak
- 56:04and Shake. And I, I was on a phone call
- 56:06with a guy and I said, you know, I like steaks and I like shakes.
- 56:10So maybe that's the play. But yeah, I there's just this
- 56:16proliferation of companies and products.
- 56:20I think we'll see more of that as the year goes on.
- 56:24And I think as you see call them the MicroStrategy copycats
- 56:31continuing to iterate that playbook meaning or just follow
- 56:36that playbook, not just on the equity and the depth of the
- 56:40preferreds. I think that is a huge unlock
- 56:44because you know, when you have products that have an 8% coupon
- 56:48with upside to conversion of the equity or you have a preferred
- 56:52product that's just a 10% perpetual yield forever.
- 56:57How many people are buying rental properties just trying to
- 57:00get 10%? They're doing all that work.
- 57:02And that's an example that Fong used during the one talk in
- 57:05Orlando. It's like, yeah, when the word
- 57:09hits the street and people actually like start to
- 57:13understand and, and, and there's an awareness level of these
- 57:16products. I think that, you know, to
- 57:20Ethan's point, that's why they're so unique and, and even
- 57:23just these pools of capital in the fixed income space, if the
- 57:27best product prior to strategy launching A preferred stock was
- 57:33giving you 600 basis points and you can get 800 basis points.
- 57:37I mean the math maths. So I, I think we're at a really
- 57:40interesting time to see all of these markets being built.
- 57:47And Jeff Walton actually did a great job last night on the True
- 57:50North Call kind of talking about creating a market.
- 57:54When he was in the reinsurance industry.
- 57:55He literally flew to London, flew to New York, flew to
- 58:00Bermuda, had 30 to 50 meetings, had one person say yes.
- 58:04And he like literally created a market for a product.
- 58:09But it's, it's a slow start. So like he did, he told that
- 58:12story. Then he went back the next year,
- 58:13did the same meetings, New York, London, Bermuda, and got four
- 58:16people to sign up. So it's like, I think I'm, I'm
- 58:21mentioning it because I'm guilty of it as much as maybe some
- 58:24other people have like, OK, well, you launched this ticker.
- 58:29One of them has AATM facility on it.
- 58:31Why aren't you cranking out a billion dollars a week of
- 58:34Bitcoin buys from it? Right?
- 58:35What's taking so long? We live in this like attention
- 58:38society and ADD Society of like, well, it's digital.
- 58:42Like I just sent a tweet and now it's done.
- 58:44Why can't you do the same of the capital markets?
- 58:47And it's not going to take forever.
- 58:48It might not even take that long, but it, you know, might
- 58:51take a few months or quarters or or a year to really ramp up from
- 58:540 from like not even an, an idea to hundreds of millions or
- 58:59billions of dollars a week worth of capital out of these markets.
- 59:02I mean, it's happening fast. But again, I think I'm as guilty
- 59:06as the next person of like, why isn't it happening faster?
- 59:09And so some of those stories I think are really helpful.
- 59:14Yeah, for my vantage point, because I don't follow the
- 59:17strategy space as closely as the two of you do.
- 59:21Just one day these products existed.
- 59:23I, I guess I didn't, I don't know how much of the development
- 59:26of the products was actually done in public to maybe you
- 59:29could expand a bit further on that, but I just logged in on X1
- 59:33day, which I'm even trying to be on X even less.
- 59:36So anyways, I just log in one day and these products exist,
- 59:40right? And so then I'm like, well, now
- 59:42I need to spend a little bit time to learn about them.
- 59:44But it's remarkable just how technology allowed for just the
- 59:49rapid acceleration of creating new financial product structure
- 59:52products. And I guess it was Sailor and
- 59:56Fong right, talking about how they just used AI to essentially
- 1:00:00design most of these new products.
- 1:00:02So I don't know like Tim from your vantage point, was there
- 1:00:07was there any public awareness about these being developed or
- 1:00:11just one day there was an announcement of the products and
- 1:00:15go ahead on that first? Yeah, there, there was no public
- 1:00:19awareness until they were launched, but it was just super
- 1:00:23cool to have executives opening up and and kind of letting you
- 1:00:28peer behind the curtain and speaking to that process of,
- 1:00:30hey, we, we, we iterated on deep research.
- 1:00:34And then once, right, they had amalgamated all this
- 1:00:39information, then they put it in front of their legal team and
- 1:00:43said, OK, this is what we want to do.
- 1:00:46Here's all the information, go make it happen, right?
- 1:00:48Which started the process of the legal team telling them why they
- 1:00:51couldn't do it. So but yeah, just the the
- 1:00:55transparency. And again, the probably also
- 1:00:58speaks to the cooperative competition, right?
- 1:01:01I mean, Bitcoin has a finite supply.
- 1:01:06It's the only game that I'm aware of where everybody is kind
- 1:01:12of right. You're buying some Bitcoin, I'm
- 1:01:14buying some Bitcoin. And at some point, if there's
- 1:01:18more buyers than sellers, the price is going to go up.
- 1:01:20So it's a, it's a unique space. Yeah, No, certainly is.
- 1:01:27I know we're coming up on time, Ethan.
- 1:01:29I wanted to just hear a little bit more about before we wrap
- 1:01:32up, a little bit more about Dell.
- 1:01:34And so it's interesting because when I read about the news at
- 1:01:40some point the past couple days, the way it was framed at least
- 1:01:44online by people or their perception of it was this is a
- 1:01:47positive thing or like, you know, the shareholders don't
- 1:01:50need to vote on it, but you obviously have a far more
- 1:01:54knowledgeable take and nuance take.
- 1:01:55So I'm curious, like, what do you actually make of this
- 1:01:57decision to, you know, to bypass a vote?
- 1:02:00And you know, just like, how can you break that down for us?
- 1:02:03Yeah, it's not a positive thing, but.
- 1:02:06Which is hilarious because, like, everyone's like, all fired
- 1:02:08up about it. And it's like, yeah, what?
- 1:02:10But I do think it's something we're going to recover from.
- 1:02:12So when I first submitted these proposals, and they're basically
- 1:02:17the same from one company the next, I was very careful in the
- 1:02:21way that I worded it. I remember when people first saw
- 1:02:25the Microsoft proposal, they were like, oh, this is lame.
- 1:02:27It's not even asking them to buy Bitcoin.
- 1:02:29It's asking them to do a report analyzing if they should buy
- 1:02:32Bitcoin. And the reason I did that was
- 1:02:35because I thought even this might not make it past the SEC
- 1:02:40because the SEC is so biased against shareholders, sometimes
- 1:02:44for good reason, because you don't want a situation in which
- 1:02:46a small group of activist shareholders can completely
- 1:02:49change a company, you know what I mean?
- 1:02:51So there has to be some protection in place for
- 1:02:53companies against, you know, bad acting shareholders.
- 1:02:57That being said, you have a biased SEC.
- 1:03:01Yes, it's changing. Yes, it's more pro Bitcoin than
- 1:03:05it was before, but it's not that quick to change.
- 1:03:08And a lot of these processes to evaluate these proposals started
- 1:03:11before Trump took office. And so I think that in the
- 1:03:16future you're going to see a more friendly SEC that's not
- 1:03:20going to discriminate so hard against proposals.
- 1:03:23That being said, once you set a precedent that one of these
- 1:03:26companies that which is why I was so careful in the first
- 1:03:30place and I was as careful as I could be, but that wasn't good
- 1:03:34enough. You had now the SEC decide this
- 1:03:38proposal cannot be voted on. And so if you submit the same
- 1:03:43proposal now to another company, they're just going to say, hey,
- 1:03:46look, there's president at Dell to leave this off the ballot.
- 1:03:49And So what we're I'm going to have to do and we're going to
- 1:03:51have to do it strives, we're going to have to reword these
- 1:03:54proposals in different ways more broadly that addresses things
- 1:04:00perhaps beyond just the treasury strategy.
- 1:04:03And I believe that with a more friendly SEC and different
- 1:04:06worded proposals, we'll be able to get these proposals in front
- 1:04:09of companies. But it is a small set back that.
- 1:04:13So if I'm being honest with you, but these exactly the same
- 1:04:17setbacks that I had with the EI going back to 2021, the SEC
- 1:04:24voted against a lot of our proposals and a lot of companies
- 1:04:29are you know my former employer, a lot of my proposal that is
- 1:04:32submitted. And as the time changed, as the
- 1:04:36SEC became more aware that there are true risks, the shareholder,
- 1:04:41the shareholders of the companies for implementing ADEI
- 1:04:44process, they became a little bit more lenient especially
- 1:04:47after that Supreme Court ruling SFA.
- 1:04:52And so I think the same thing is going to happen here.
- 1:04:55Now we have a strategic Bitcoin reserve that's a federal, you
- 1:05:01know, policy. So if the federal government
- 1:05:03policy is, yeah, let's, you know, let's stack Bitcoin, but
- 1:05:06the SEC is saying that, you know, shareholders can't ask
- 1:05:10corporations to do that as well. That changes the game.
- 1:05:13These decision at Dell actually started first at Amazon prior to
- 1:05:18the strategic Bitcoin Reserve and then for the sake of
- 1:05:20consistency, the SEC has to be give the same ruling at Dell as
- 1:05:24well. So small set back, but I think
- 1:05:27we're going to recover and there still will be a lot of
- 1:05:30shareholder engagement with corporations regarding Bitcoin
- 1:05:33and Bitcoin in their balance sheet.
- 1:05:35Yeah, appreciate you breaking that down.
- 1:05:37It's just, it's funny because you mentioned it earlier in the
- 1:05:40show about it being not a good thing.
- 1:05:43But then when I logged into X earlier this week, everyone's
- 1:05:46all fired up because their perception, I guess, is, oh,
- 1:05:49they're just going to do it now. They don't need to, you know,
- 1:05:51they don't need to ask for permission.
- 1:05:52But it's, I guess, reality. Yeah, but it's a little bit more
- 1:05:56nuanced as you just broke down. So to wrap things up here.
- 1:06:01One more thing on that on that front though, yeah, yeah, there
- 1:06:04is still a proposal at Meadow, so that one will be on the
- 1:06:09ballot. So look out for that.
- 1:06:12Oh nice, can you? When is that?
- 1:06:16You guys will see it. I want to start yeah.
- 1:06:18Cool. So to wrap things up then I
- 1:06:22wanted to just touch on something.
- 1:06:23Give me give me something bullish, give me something to
- 1:06:25fire some people up because we just talked on also Meta is
- 1:06:28exciting. So we'll keep an eye on that.
- 1:06:29But Dell maybe not so much. You said earlier in the show
- 1:06:34that the Bitcoin treasury adoption accelerating or
- 1:06:37happening faster than the DEI stuff kind of came to a halt.
- 1:06:41So there's probably a lot of bullish things going on, some of
- 1:06:45what you can't share, but what could you share, Ethan?
- 1:06:48And then Tim want to hear your, your quick thoughts as well.
- 1:06:50Just what, what are you guys excited about?
- 1:06:52Give the audience something to be fired up about as we close
- 1:06:55out this episode. Yeah, I just the fact that we've
- 1:07:00seen, you know, so many new Bitcoin treasury companies just
- 1:07:04in the last announced just in the last month and there's going
- 1:07:07to be a lot more I believe in the coming months.
- 1:07:10And I think that we're at the stage in the the happening cycle
- 1:07:14where we're at the beginning of a bull market.
- 1:07:19I'm just very excited about the direction that Bitcoins going in
- 1:07:22and both in terms of, you know, number go up and, and in terms
- 1:07:27of just general adoption. I, I'm, I'm very bullish about
- 1:07:32the next year and I think that we're going to keep seeing good
- 1:07:35news. Yeah.
- 1:07:39I mean from strategy having 40 billion or more of Bitcoin on
- 1:07:45their balance sheet and they started with converting their
- 1:07:50cash $250 million into Bitcoin just five years ago to now
- 1:07:56seeing other entrants with from public filings looking to enter
- 1:08:04the market with, you know, 5-6, seven $100 million to start or
- 1:08:09with like 21 right, 4042 thousand Bitcoin to start.
- 1:08:13What's that 4 billion some dollars.
- 1:08:16I mean, these are numbers that if you just extrapolate that out
- 1:08:24over the next couple quarters, if you have fast followers or
- 1:08:30you just have a couple of companies that continue to
- 1:08:34iterate. I think it's for me, it looks
- 1:08:38like the writing's on the wall that between Bitcoin being
- 1:08:42decentralized and AI and technology just pulling us
- 1:08:46forward faster and faster that the the guys and gals that are
- 1:08:52really leading from the front are speeding up.
- 1:08:55They're not slowing down and super bullish on that.
- 1:09:00Yeah, but you frame it that way, Tim.
- 1:09:02It's pretty wild. Two 250 million to $40 billion
- 1:09:06war chest and just getting started.
- 1:09:09Well, awesome stuff. Appreciate both of your time,
- 1:09:13Ethan. Anywhere you want to hand off
- 1:09:15folks to just learn more about either your work or strive as a
- 1:09:19whole. I would say go to strive.com,
- 1:09:23check out our recent, recent death that we published and on
- 1:09:28on becoming a Bitcoin treasury company.
- 1:09:30And then, yeah, stay tuned for for more announcements from us.
- 1:09:34And you know, check out Strive on Twitter, check out Matt on
- 1:09:38his podcast with Tim and yeah, good things for coming.
- 1:09:42Good things to check out. Awesome.
- 1:09:44And Tim, how about you? You have how many podcasts these
- 1:09:47days? Where do you want people to go?
- 1:09:52You can just search on YouTube for Bitcoin treasuries.
- 1:09:54You can search on YouTube for scarce assets.
- 1:09:57The last trade. I already said Bitcoin
- 1:10:00treasuries, the hurdle rate, MSTR true north.
- 1:10:04I think that's it for now, maybe four or five.
- 1:10:07Tim is the crown for most Bitcoin podcasts, and you're
- 1:10:10just getting started. I hope.
- 1:10:12I hope we're at a dozen by the end of this year, Tim.
- 1:10:15We're going higher. 21 podcasts. Yeah, there we go.
- 1:10:19Now we're talking. Well, gentlemen, thank you.
- 1:10:21Appreciate both of your time. Good chat.
- 1:10:24Thank you. Thanks for listening to this
- 1:10:27week's episode of the show. If you found the information
- 1:10:29valuable, please share the episode with a friend or leave a
- 1:10:31rating on your favorite podcast app.
- 1:10:34All the links we discussed in today's show will be in the show
- 1:10:36notes inside your podcast app. Before we finish, a quick
- 1:10:39reminder that On Rat Media is for informational and
- 1:10:41entertainment purposes only, and nothing should be construed as
- 1:10:44investment or legal advice. Regardless of where you are on
- 1:10:47your Bitcoin journey, we'd love to hear from you.
- 1:10:50Visit onrampbitcoin.com contact to schedule a consultation with
- 1:10:54one of our private client advisors.