Latest / Ego and Other Things / What is Philosophy? - Part 1
Transcript
- William: Alright, so today's video is going to be part one of a two-part series trying to answer the question: what is philosophy? And how do we practice it? And today's video, we're going to be focused on the first part of that question: what is philosophy? And what we're going to do is discuss quickly the popular definitions of philosophy, the so-called Standard definition of philosophy as well as its origins in the history of philosophy. We will talk about how philosophy is the mother of all disciplines and how different kinds of disciplines of knowledge end up coming out of the discipline of philosophy. Then we'll move on to the real definition of philosophy, what philosophy actually consists of compared to the popular notion of philosophy. And we will also talk about the ideal of philosophical inquiry, which is total justification or else assumptionlessness. So I'll just start off right here with the with the popular definition of philosophy. And this is kind of the definition that you would run into if you took a philosophy 101 class or you cracked open an introductory history of philosophy, or just to an any kind of introduction to philosophy at all, the way that they will typically describe it is that philosophy is the study of the fundamental. nature of things. In fact, the if you want to relate it even more primordially, the actual definition of the word philosophy is split into Philo and Sophia. Philo being the love of, and Sophia translating to wisdom. And so the actual definition of the word philosophy in the original Greek is the love of wisdom. But it tends to be related to this study of the fundamental nature of things. And you can see this definition come out practically through the Typical kinds of branches that philosophy deals with, which happen to be metaphysics, which is the study of the fundamental nature of reality, epistemology, the study of the fundamental nature of knowledge, how we gain knowledge, the philosophy of human nature and the philosophy of mind, which deals with what does it mean to be human, what does it mean to be conscious, the study of ethics, which is the study of the n the fundamental nature of good and evil, right and wrong, and how we should go about living our lives. The branch of t of politics, which is the fundamental nature of society and how we ought to order that kind of society, and the study of aesthetics, which is the fundamental nature of beauty and of art. As you can see in each of these kinds of branches, the way that they are defined is that they are the the fundamental, the ne the study of the fundamental nature of any of these different g given given areas, that they are trying to get to the essence of reality, of knowledge, of good and evil, of society, of art, of human nature. And this characterization of philosophy as driving towards the essence of things and driving towards the study of the fundamental nature of any of these different Areas of knowledge really comes out of the original Greek in philosophical inquiries. So the Greeks, meaning Socrates, Plato, and Aristotle. As well as many of the the pre Socratics and in fact in some ways the pre Socratics can be almost unilaterally defined as thinkers who are interested in the essence of things, all of these kinds of thinkers were deliberately engaged in trying to get to the fundamental essence of the different kinds of concepts or the different kinds of things that they were experiencing around them, whether it was in their direct sensation or whether it was in concepts like like justice or knowledge or truth. And of course, It was in Greece and through these thinkers that philosophy first really came about as distinguishing itself from the sort of religious explanations of phenomena or of reality. and Greece was the was the first attempt to understand rationally the the nature of the world around them, including both the natural world as well as the social world. And again, all of this was characterized by this drive towards essences. And so a drive towards the fundamental nature of whatever topic that they were trying to investigate and explore. And often the example, the most popular example to come up with this is Socrates, the so-called father of philosophy himself. Who would often go into the agora the sort of meeting place or marketplace? Within Greek within Greek cities. To ask people basic questions like what is justice or what is truth. He would approach a person and ask them, What is justice? And of course, the person, being a typical member of Greek society at that time, perhaps a part of the aristocracy, would give them the sort of troped common explanation of what justice was. And Socrates would sort of skillfully question this person by by breaking apart the concept that they the the argument that they had made for their definition of justice and test it against other kinds of arguments or try to universalize it in a way to see whether it could sustain. its explanatory power. Through a variety of other circumstances, and so be truly called the essence or the nature of it, because it persisted in a universal way across all these different kinds of phenomena. So Socrates was famous for doing this, famous for trying to get to the essence of things by deliberately engaging with people's definitions of these fundamental concepts like reality and justice and truth to see what actually stuck in a universalizing or essential or fundamental way. Plato, who was also a major philosopher, was a direct student of Socrates and learned this attitude towards philosophy from his teacher. He applied this in poetry and through dialogues, where he would actually use Socrates as. A character within those dialogues to do the same kind of thing that Socrates was doing in the Agora, but through the written work. And Plato would later go on to to use sort of Socrates in this way as a mouthpiece for exploring and explaining his own philosophical ideas, especially in in a in a popular way, in a way that could be given to The masses to be able to understand. And the next great Greek philosopher, Aristotle, was a student of Plato. And so again, took up this kind of tradition of asking after essences, actually developed systems of logic and really extended the whole project of essences. To a significant degree, to a really a formalized degree. And in fact, you know, Socrates, Plato, and Aristotle all continue to to significantly affect philosophical speculation and philosophical work today. But all of the work it at least appeared to be the work of essences, the work of What is the nature of whatever we are inquiring about? What is the real essence of whatever we are inquiring about such that it persists over time and it persists in a universal way across all these different kinds of circumstances? And many interesting philosophical program problems came out of that exact kind of task. Now, of course, in the beginning, many of the disciplines that we would recognize as separate from philosophy today were actually considered a part of the philosophical project. One of the most striking is probably is probably science. much of the work of Aristotle, for instance, was actually in an area that we would call biology. Aristotle really didn't consider biology to be separate from philosophy, but rather to be a branch of philosophy And in many ways, Aristotle's more metaphysical and epistemological philosophy was influenced by his empirical biological studies. And he developed a sort of nascent science and a nascent biology, even though he himself did not formalize or or understand that explicitly at the time. And many other branches of knowledge, such as logic. Mathematics, science, psychology, sociology, history. And literary criticism actually grew out of what were once philosophical speculations. But which were later crystallized into a discipline by fixing certain premises and ideas as the standard for the discipline, which then were went on to be logically extended to the a given question or field of inquiry. So again, the most clear example that you can give of this is science itself. People such as Francis Bacon and others famously crystallize certain metaphysical and epistemological ideas such as causality and materialism and empiricism into what is now known as a scientific method. Which became the standard for scientific work going forward. Now that standard has been has been modified and changed, but generally speaking, the Scientific method has come to define what it means to be a science. Insofar as one is investigating things scientifically, they investigate them based on the premises of the scientific method. And insofar as they are pursuing science, they don't necessarily question or attempt to undermine these kinds of premises. Rather, the entire profession is defined by these kinds of premises. And in many ways, Areas like psychology and history have their own set of metaphysical, epistemological, and even Understandings of human nature and the mind that inform and define these kinds of professions. These kinds of disciplines of knowledge. And so in this way, philosophy has often been called the mother of the knowledge disciplines because it is often the starting point of speculation for further branches of knowledge who later go on to crystallize a set of premises or crystallize a certain methodology, which then gets consistently and logically applied to a given field of knowledge or pursuit. But all these disciplines, regardless of their content, become split off or get split off from the fundamental philosophical speculation that happens prior. And this is where we can get into we can start to get into the real definition of what philosophy is and how it distinguishes distinguishes itself from other kinds of disciplines of knowledge. How does it fundamentally distinguish itself from science or history or psychology or sociology or any of these other kinds of knowledge disciplines? Well, philosophy really defines itself not by its content so much, not by the fact that it involves itself in these different kinds of branches, or even involves itself in so called fundamental questions, but it actually gets identified with its methodology, what the philosopher is uniquely doing as opposed to these other kinds of knowledge disciplines, or as opposed to the kinds of religious myths and explanations. That were used to explain phenomena before the rise of philosophy. What the philosophical method really is, is a way of relating oneself to one's own assumptions, one's inherited ideas, and one's premises about the world. Rather a specific Exploration of a cutoff. section of questions. It is not about the arbitrary branches themselves, metaphysics, epistemology, ethics, what have you. It is actually about a methodology methodology of questioning, deconstructing, and trying to justify one's assumptions, ideas, premises, and inherited explanations for the purposes of justifying it as far as one can. So for so for example, as I talked about before, science is defined by a crystallized methodology. And a scientist is a scientist insofar as they use the scientific explanation to explore a given question or the material world or what have you. But as soon as a scientist moves from applying the scientific method to a field of knowledge, to Beginning to question the premises or the assumptions of the scientific method itself, wondering: can these premises be justified? Can these assumptions be justified, or can they be modified or improved? You start to go away from the realm of science proper and into the philosophy of science. You become more and more philosophical the more. or the degree to which you begin to question the premises, assumptions, inherited ideas that underlie the crystallized methodology of science itself. A philosopher, again, on the other hand, does not does not purposefully rest on assumptions, premises, explanations that they've inherited from somebody else. They attempt to justify, understand, and identify these as far as they can. In the same way, this doesn't merely apply to something like science, but it applies to myths and theologies as well. So we can take the example of Christian theology. the field of Christian theology is defined by a certain set of premises or ideas that get applied to the problems of the world that they're trying to deal with. So they rely on Assumptions about God, assumptions about the divinity of Christ, assumptions about the validity of the word of God. about a spiritual well realm, about in certain schools, ideas of predestination or free will. There is a class of premises or ideas that defines this discipline of knowledge called theology. And if a theologian begins to question the underlying premises and assumptions that underpin Christian theology, if he begins to doubt whether God exists or at least tries to justify God's existence, and the same thing with with Christ's divinity or the reality of miracles, etc., as he begins to seriously question these kinds of premises, which build up the discipline of theology itself, he moves from being a theologian into the mode of being a philosopher, being philosophical. You get into the philosophy of relig religion. And again, this applies to myths as well. If one seriously believes in a myth as an explanation for natural reality and then begins to question the premises of that myth or the content of that myth and tries to justify it, they become philosophical about those myths rather than a member of rather than trying to apply that myth to their life. And this applies to every single kind of domain of knowledge that we are familiar with today. Every domain of knowledge beyond philosophy itself has some sort of crystallized premises, assumptions, ideas, inherited methodologies, which, insofar as they are used for the sake of the discipline, go unquestioned. And Again, a discipline of knowledge outside of philosophy is defined by its set of premises, assumptions, inherited ideas that are used, its methodologies which are used in the pursuit of the given field. As soon as any one of these members of any discipline of knowledge begins to question those ideas, tries to revise them, tries to understand them, tries to justify them, they are making a move towards philosophical inquiry rather than a move in their particular field. And so again, philosophy is not defined by any kind of of content. It is defined by the fact that it drives towards this kind of total justification of its own ideas, this kind of total assumptionlessness. of its premises all the way down, or at least as far as possible. A philosopher doesn't stop questioning their assumptions, their premises, their inherited ideas, or the explanations given to them for the different kinds of phenomena that they're investigating. Rather, they try to do as deliberately, as thoroughly, and as far as they can for the sake of the particular interests that they they are pursuing. And we'll get into that probably in the second video. But the the again, I just want to emphasize here that the move the philosophical movement is That striving towards assumptionlessness, that striving towards total justification, whether or not that actually gets achieved or not. And so kind of going back to look at the common branches of philosophy, metaphysics, epistemology, the philosophy of mind, ethics, politics, and aesthetics, the reason why philosophy gets associated with these branches is not because philosophy is defined. by a sort of arbitrary cut off section of knowledge, but because philosophy ends up Trending towards those areas in its striving or driving for assumptionalists. It ends up in more and more fundamental areas of thoughts because the serious philosopher is driving his assumptions down into more and more fundamental natures of reality, more and more fundamental natures of what he is considering. A scientist at the beginning of questioning the premises of science or a Christian theologian at the beginning of questioning the premises of theology is engaged in as great a philosophical movement as is the one miring in the complexities of metaphysics and ontology. And so the philosopher is not defined by what branch of philosophy he studies or how or what area of philosophy that he is he is implying himself into, but he is defined by the movement of philosophical assumptionlessness, the movement of philosophical total total justification that is involved. In the movement itself. A lot of this work gets done in the mere identification of assumptions. In fact, philosophers, some of the most famous philosophers, including Descartes, Hume, and Kant, have been distinguished by the fact that they uncovered certain famous assumptions of their predecessors. Hume was critiquing both the materialist positions of his former empiricists as well as the idealist philosophers such as Descartes. When he wrote his own work, and was distinguished by the fact that he followed the material and empiricist conclusions to what appeared to be their logical end. Kant, on the other hand, was reacting largely to whom to Hume when he wrote his critique of pure reason. And identified that Hume himself was assuming certain categories of the mind in his explanation of material reality and his empiricism, and then went on to extend a revised understanding of the categories of mind, which went on to sort of revolutionize philosophical history. And so there is this cycle of philosophy where a philosopher tends to grow up in a given intellectual or philosophical climate. it inherits the ideas or is exposed to sort of the popular ideas of the time. And the greatest among philosophers are often the ones who identify the assumptions that everybody else is making, question them, find them wanting, and develop alternatives to explanations to these assumptions, or else discard those assumptions in favor of better explanatory concepts, ideas, or examples. There is this cycle of questioning, discarding and reformulating, and then creating new premises out of which to develop a more coherent picture of reality, of oneself, of good and evil, of beauty, of whatever. Now, there is great debate about whether this kind of total justification or assumptionlessness can actually actually be entirely achieved. there seems to be something about the limits of human life, of course, or the limits of reason, or the lean limits of what we can actually get objective to, that suggest that we really can't get to the bottom of certain assumptions or beyond certain assumptions. In fact, one of the things that again Kant is most famous for is attempting to articulate the limits of reasons, the things beyond which we could not rationally analyze. Now, of course, there are reactions to Kant and there are reactions to this idea that we couldn't get beyond these assumptions or analyze them in a rational way. So there is plenty of room for debate in the whole question of whether we can actually get to total justification, whether we can actually get to assumptionlessness. Or whether every philosophy and every philosopher is necessarily going to carry with them some kind of unexamined premise, unexamined assumption, unexamined idea or explanation. But beyond the debate about whether this is possible or not, the movement is still reality and is still what distinguishes philosophical thought from any other kind of discipline of knowledge. The philosopher doesn't stop at their premises and assumptions and inherited ideas and explanations. There are better and worse philosophers, of course, philosophers who do this more consistently and more explicitly relative to their peers. But the movement in the attempt is the same within any given individual. The degree to which you are being philosophical is the degree to which you are trying to justify, pinpoint, understand, and explicate the premises and assumptions that have been given to you or that you hold yourself and really test them rigorously for their truth value. But even if it is impossible to get to ultimate assumptionlessness or total justification, philosophy is still of value because it it helps us to actually see which models of understanding of the world or what have you are actually going to be useful, which can be tested in the most rigorous way, which can stand up to scrutiny in the most consistent way, which have the most pragmatic value. for the individual, which one holds the most explanatory value. Arguably as well, philosophy allows us to understand our limits. If you follow the Kantian line, then philosophy gives us an understanding of of what the human mind is capable of understanding and what it must leave as a mystery. And beyond that, it kind of gives us the limits or an understanding of the limits of what actually works. So, for example, the law of non-contradiction excludes many kinds of speculations based on the fact that it is logically incoherent or simply metaphysically impossible due to the nature of of contradiction. And so we can get a lot of work out of explanatory models and understanding our limits and understanding what is possible and isn't possible. And not only that, but when a premise gets tested and tested and then crystallized into a discipline of knowledge, oftentimes the disciplines of knowledge that survive were the ones that are of most benefit. So science is a again a perfect example of this where the scientific method was crystallized, it has been modified here and there in the development of the philosophy of science and has become better and better at helping to explain the the causal and material nature of of the world around us. And so the very disciplines of knowledge which have come out of philosophical explanation are themselves proof of the value of philosophy, even if it can't get to the sort of total justification or total assumptionlessness. But of course, it's incredibly important for the philosopher to have that attitude because assumptions, premises, inherited explanations can easily lead into dogmatics, into uncritical understandings of the world around us that can lead to an inability to actually navigate the reality of the world. So many religions have had this kind of negative effect on humanity as a whole, but also certain kinds of Uncritical examinations of evolution, for example, have led to Racism and intolerance. Uncritical examinations of economic foundations have caused economic pain and suffering for people. And so this kind of critical willingness to examine one's premises as far as one can for their rigorousness and their truth value and their ability to uphold their own justifications is incredibly valuable to. the expansion of knowledge itself and even if one is not a sort of deliberate philosopher, the philosophical mindset has a great many benefits that it can apply to many different realms of knowledge and human life in general. So given that philosophy is defined by a certain kind of method and not a certain Subject matter or branch. How does this impact how we answer the question who a philosopher is and how they actually practice philosophy? Well, that's going to be the subject of the next video, part two, in this series where I'll talk about the structure of philosophical inquiry, who counsels a philosopher and who doesn't, and my critique of the modern academic philosophy that is popular. But what do you guys think? Do you think this definition of philosophy holds up? Do you think it can be extended or narrowed? Do you think that Philosophy can still have value even if it doesn't reach total understanding or total justification. Let me know your thoughts in the comments. I would love to to have that conversation with you guys and just explore this whole understanding of philosophy itself. If we are to be consistent with this definition of philosophy, as much as we apply the philosophical method to different domains in life, we ought to apply the philosophical methodology to the question of what is philosophy and who is a philosopher itself. So I would love to do that with you guys. But if you like this video, please give it a like. If you think that somebody would find this interesting, please share it with them. And if you'd like more videos like this, then please hit that subscribe button for more. And as always, thank you guys for watching.