Latest / Interfaiths / Children of Abraham on Sacred Ground: America at 250 and the Interconnected Futures of Jews and Muslims
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Deep Dive. We are doing something
- 0:02a little distinct today, a bit of mental time
- 0:05travel. I want you to look at your phone, look
- 0:07at your calendar, and just mentally adjust the
- 0:10date. We are projecting ourselves forward to
- 0:13February 2026. Which, depending on when you're
- 0:17listening to this, is either right around the
- 0:18corner or uncomfortably close. It's looming large
- 0:22on the horizon. It really is. And the reason
- 0:24we're setting the scene in early 2026 is because
- 0:27the United States is staring down the barrel
- 0:29of a massive once in a lifetime milestone. We
- 0:32are just months away from July 4, 2026, the semi
- 0:37-quincentennial. The big 250, 250 years, two
- 0:40and a half centuries since the signing of the
- 0:43Declaration of Independence. I mean, that is
- 0:45a quarter of a millennium of the American experiment.
- 0:47And usually, you know, when you think about a
- 0:49birthday of that magnitude, the vibe is celebratory.
- 0:52supposed to be a party. Absolutely. You picture
- 0:54the tall ships sailing into Boston Harbor, the
- 0:57inevitable fireworks over the National Mall,
- 0:59the commemorative coins, all the speeches about
- 1:02how far we've come. It's usually a moment for
- 1:04a, you know, a victory lap. Right. But the research
- 1:07we're unpacking today, specifically a really
- 1:09provocative article called Children of Abraham
- 1:12on Sacred Ground by a scholar named Iqbal Akhtar.
- 1:16It suggests that if we're preparing for a party,
- 1:18we are reading the room completely wrong. Yeah,
- 1:21Akhtar frames this moment not as a celebration,
- 1:25but as a stress test. And I think that is such
- 1:28a useful, if a little sobering, metaphor. A stress
- 1:31test? Yeah. I mean, think about it. When engineers
- 1:33stress test a bridge. They don't do it on a sunny
- 1:36day. They load it with immense weight. They subject
- 1:38it to pressure to see if the beams hold or if
- 1:41the steel snaps. Oktar is basically arguing that
- 1:44this 250th anniversary is applying that kind
- 1:46of pressure to the structural integrity of the
- 1:48United States. And he's seeing fractures. He's
- 1:50seeing cracks appear. And the source material,
- 1:52it paints a very specific and frankly kind of
- 1:54grim picture of the national mood in this 2026
- 1:57scenario we're imagining. It talks about a decline
- 2:00in institutional trust that has gone from a slide
- 2:03to a complete freeze. Right. Trust in everything.
- 2:06Government, media, even in each other. It also
- 2:09describes an ambient polarization, which is a
- 2:12great, terrifying phrase. It is a great phrase.
- 2:15It suggests the tension isn't just, you know,
- 2:17in Washington, D .C. It's in the grocery store.
- 2:20It's at the school board meeting. It's at the
- 2:22Thanksgiving dinner table. It's everywhere. And
- 2:24specifically, there's a rising tide of hate incidents.
- 2:28That ambient tension is the key. Because it means
- 2:31the political has become deeply personal in a
- 2:34way that feels unsafe for a lot of people. And
- 2:38this is where the deep dive takes a turn that
- 2:41might surprise you. Because usually when pundits
- 2:44talk about the health of the nation, they look
- 2:46at the S &P 500 or they look at election polling
- 2:49data. The usual metrics. The usual metric, Oktar
- 2:51says. Stop looking there. If you want to know
- 2:54if America is going to survive its 250th birthday.
- 2:57If you really want to know if the experiment
- 2:59is actually working, you need to look at two
- 3:01very specific, relatively small populations,
- 3:04American Jews and American Muslims. It does feel
- 3:07a little counterintuitive at first. I mean, these
- 3:09aren't the largest demographic groups in the
- 3:10country by a long shot. Not at all. But the argument
- 3:13here is that they are the bellwethers. They are
- 3:16the canaries in the coal mine for American democracy.
- 3:19So if they're not OK, nobody's OK. That's the
- 3:22idea. Because the central tension of the American
- 3:24project isn't really, can we make money or can
- 3:27we build a powerful army? The real fundamental
- 3:30tension is, can we live together with deep, profound,
- 3:34fundamental differences? That is the question
- 3:37the country was founded to answer. And right
- 3:39now, Jewish and Muslim communities are navigating
- 3:42the most. intense, high stakes version of that
- 3:45question. They're facing this landscape of rising
- 3:48hostility and really competing narratives about
- 3:51whether they even belong here in the first place.
- 3:53So the thesis we're exploring today is pretty
- 3:55heavy. It's that the fate of American religious
- 3:57pluralism, the entire machinery that allows us
- 4:00to function as a diverse society, it all hinges
- 4:03on whether these two communities can figure out
- 4:05a way to move from what the author calls fair
- 4:07weather dialogue to a rugged, shared commitment
- 4:11to one another's safety. Rugged commitment. I
- 4:13love that phrase. And I want us to keep coming
- 4:15back to that. It implies the relationship has
- 4:17to be durable. You know, it has to be strong
- 4:19enough to survive bad weather. It's not just
- 4:21about having tea and hummus when things are calm.
- 4:23Right. It's not a garden party. Not at all. It's
- 4:26about what you do. When the storm hits, what
- 4:29do you do when the hurricane is bearing down
- 4:31on you? So we've got a serious roadmap for this
- 4:33deep dive. We're going to start by aggressively
- 4:36debunking the standard history book narrative
- 4:39because it turns out our timeline of who arrived
- 4:42when regarding these communities is just factually
- 4:46empirically wrong. It's a major historical correction
- 4:49that we need to make. Then we're going to get
- 4:51really granular and parse the difference between
- 4:53diversity and pluralism, a distinction that a
- 4:56Harvard scholar Diana Eck makes, which is just
- 4:59absolutely crucial for understanding our current
- 5:01moment. And after that, we have to go through
- 5:04the fire. We're going to have a difficult, honest
- 5:06conversation about the collapse of the interfaith
- 5:08movement after October 7, 2023, and really try
- 5:12to understand why the old models failed so spectacularly.
- 5:15And finally, and this is where it gets hopeful,
- 5:17we're going to look at the secret weapons that
- 5:19are hidden inside Jewish and Muslim theology,
- 5:22the source code, if you will, that might actually
- 5:24offer a solution to this crisis, a way forward.
- 5:28It's a lot to unpack, but I think it's really
- 5:30the only way to truly understand what's at stake
- 5:33for the country in 2026 and beyond. OK, let's
- 5:36start with that historical correction, because
- 5:38I think if I went out on the street right now
- 5:39with a microphone and asked the average person
- 5:41to just, you know, sketch out the timeline of
- 5:44religion in America, I'd get a very specific
- 5:46story. Oh, for sure. You and I both know what
- 5:48they'd say. It would start with the pilgrims
- 5:51and the Puritans, Protestant Christians. Then
- 5:53you get the founding fathers, mostly deists or
- 5:55liberal Protestants. And then much, much later,
- 5:58maybe around Ellis Island or the mid -20th century,
- 6:00the others arrive. The Jews, the Muslims, the
- 6:04Hindus, the Buddhists, they show up late and
- 6:06kind of have to ask for permission to join the
- 6:07club. That is the default setting in our cultural
- 6:11memories, baked in. And it frames American history
- 6:14as a kind of dinner party where Protestant Christianity
- 6:17is the host. They own the house and everyone
- 6:20else is a guest. And guests have to be polite.
- 6:22Guests have to be polite. Guests can't make too
- 6:25much noise. And guests ultimately can be asked
- 6:28to leave if they become inconvenient. But the
- 6:31source material we're looking at today argues
- 6:34that this is historically incomplete. In fact,
- 6:36it's just wrong. Jews and Muslims aren't guests
- 6:40who arrive late to the party. They are what Akhtar
- 6:43calls constitutive threads of the fabric. Constitutive
- 6:47threads, meaning if you pull them out, the fabric
- 6:50itself unravels. It's not the same piece of cloth
- 6:52anymore. Exactly. They were here before the United
- 6:54States was the United States. They aren't just
- 6:56in America. They helped make America. The structure
- 6:58is built with their contributions. Okay, let's
- 7:01dig into that. Let's look at the Jewish roots
- 7:03first. The source points us to a really specific
- 7:05location, Newport, Rhode Island, and Congregation
- 7:09Sherith Israel. This is such a pivotal piece
- 7:11of American history that just it often gets glossed
- 7:13over in the textbooks. This congregation was
- 7:16officially organized in the 1650s. The 1650s.
- 7:19I just want to pause on that date for a second.
- 7:21We're talking more than a century, like 120 years
- 7:23before the Declaration of Independence. A long
- 7:26time. George Washington and Thomas Jefferson
- 7:29weren't even born yet. Not even close. This is
- 7:31the era of Oliver Cromwell in England for context.
- 7:35And the origin story of this community is just
- 7:37fascinating. These were Sephardic Jews, Jews
- 7:41of Spanish and Portuguese descent, who were actually
- 7:44fleeing persecution in Brazil. From Brazil? I
- 7:46didn't know that. Yeah, they'd gone to Brazil
- 7:48when the Dutch controlled a portion of it, because
- 7:50the Dutch were relatively tolerant. But when
- 7:52the Portuguese retook that territory, the Inquisition
- 7:56followed, and they had to run for their lives.
- 7:58So they got on boats and sailed north to the
- 8:01British colonies, seeking safety. They ended
- 8:04up in places like New Amsterdam, which became
- 8:06New York and Newport. So by the time George Washington
- 8:09is inaugurated as the first president of the
- 8:11United States, there has been an organized, functioning,
- 8:15multi -generational Jewish community in Rhode
- 8:17Island for, what, 140 years? For four or five
- 8:20generations, at least, yes. That just completely
- 8:22blows the immigrant guest narrative out of the
- 8:25water. They had been here longer than many of
- 8:27the so -called founding fathers' own families
- 8:29had been. Absolutely. They weren't newcomers
- 8:32asking for a favor. They were established residents.
- 8:34And this deep presence forces the new— government
- 8:37to reckon with them. It's not a theoretical question
- 8:40of what if Jews lived here. They do live here.
- 8:43And this leads to that famous letter, right?
- 8:45The Washington letter. The letter to the Hebrew
- 8:48congregation at Newport, 1790. It is, in my opinion,
- 8:52one of the top five most important documents
- 8:54in American history. It's right up there with
- 8:56the Declaration and the Constitution. Washington
- 8:59visited Newport on a tour, and the warden of
- 9:01the synagogue, a man named Moses Sykes, wrote
- 9:04him a letter welcoming him. Washington replied
- 9:06with this incredible text. And the famous line
- 9:09is that the government of the United States gives
- 9:11to bigotry no sanction, to persecution no assistance.
- 9:14Chills every time I read it. To bigotry no sanction.
- 9:17But I want to understand the political mechanics
- 9:19there. Was he just being nice? Was this just
- 9:21a polite, you know, thank you for the warm welcome
- 9:23note? Right. Was this just 18th century PR? Exactly.
- 9:27And the answer is no. This was a radical philosophical
- 9:30break from 3 ,000 years of European history.
- 9:35You have to understand, in Europe at that time,
- 9:37the absolute best a minority religion could hope
- 9:40for was toleration. And toleration sounds nice
- 9:44to our modern ears. It sounds nice, but it's
- 9:46actually a hierarchy. It means I am the dominant
- 9:49group, I hold all the power, and I, in my magnanimity,
- 9:52will tolerate you. I will allow you to exist.
- 9:55But because it's an allowance, a permission I
- 9:58grant, I can also revoke it if you get too loud
- 10:01or too annoying or if it becomes politically
- 10:03convenient for me to persecute you again. Right.
- 10:05It's like letting your younger brother play video
- 10:08games with you. You're letting him play, but
- 10:09it's your console, it's your house, and you can
- 10:12unplug his controller whenever you want. That
- 10:14is a perfect analogy. Washington's letter completely
- 10:17flipped the table on that dynamic. He wasn't
- 10:20offering toleration. In fact, he explicitly says
- 10:22in the letter, it is now no more that toleration
- 10:25is spoken of. He was rejecting that old model.
- 10:27He was acknowledging a natural right. A natural
- 10:30right. So it's inherent. It's inherent. He was
- 10:32saying that their religious liberty didn't come
- 10:34from him or from the Congress or from the Protestant
- 10:36majority. It was endowed by their creator as
- 10:38part of their humanity. So he wasn't inviting
- 10:40them into the country. He was acknowledging that
- 10:42they were already home. They were co -owners
- 10:44of the house. That is a massive distinction.
- 10:46It shifts the entire power dynamic. Okay, so
- 10:49if the Jewish history in early America is surprising
- 10:51to some, the Muslim history that the source outlines
- 10:54is. It's genuinely shocking to most people. I
- 10:58think most of us date the Muslim presence in
- 11:00America to... I don't know, immigration waves
- 11:02in the 1960s or 70s. Which is a complete erasure
- 11:06of the actual demographic reality of the founding
- 11:08era. It's a historical blind spot the size of
- 11:11a continent. The source is very, very clear on
- 11:13this. The timeline of Islam in America begins
- 11:16with the slave trade. Right. And the numbers
- 11:18are just staggering. Mainstream academic scholarship
- 11:21now estimates that somewhere between 15 and 30
- 11:24percent of the enslaved Africans brought to this
- 11:26continent were from Muslim regions of West Africa.
- 11:29Wait, I want to make sure I heard that and that
- 11:30you at home heard that. Not one. To 3%, 15 %
- 11:34to 30%. 15 % to 30%, yes. A massive demographic
- 11:38slice. That means that in some areas of the colonial
- 11:41south, Islam was likely the second most dominant
- 11:44religion after various forms of Christianity.
- 11:46Without a doubt. And we need to break down the
- 11:49stereotype of who these people were. The source
- 11:51really emphasizes that these weren't just laborers
- 11:54or people without culture, kind of blank slate.
- 11:57Many of them were Quranic scholars. They were
- 12:00hafiz, which means they had memorized the entire
- 12:02Quran, all 6 ,000 plus verses, by heart. Incredible.
- 12:07They were literate in Arabic. They were highly
- 12:09educated intellectuals, theologians, jurists
- 12:12who were captured in wars or kidnapped, stripped
- 12:14of their freedom, and brought to a land where
- 12:16they had to try and maintain their faith under
- 12:18conditions of the most extreme repression imaginable.
- 12:20The source mentions a few specific figures that
- 12:22I feel like should be household names in America.
- 12:25Omar ibn Said. Omar Ibn Said is a monumental
- 12:28figure in American religious history. He was
- 12:31a Fula Islamic scholar from a region that's now
- 12:33part of modern -day Senegal. He was enslaved
- 12:36in his late 30s, already a deeply educated man,
- 12:39and brought to North Carolina. But here's the
- 12:41incredible part. In his old age, he left behind
- 12:45an autobiography written in his own hand in beautiful,
- 12:48classical Arabic. An autobiography in Arabic
- 12:51from an enslaved man in the 1830s. Think about
- 12:54the significance of that artifact. We have a
- 12:56primary source document written in the language
- 12:58of his longest scholarship by an enslaved man
- 13:01in the antebellum South articulating his life,
- 13:03his theology, his sorrow. It's one of the most
- 13:06important documents we have. That completely
- 13:07destroys the racist paternalistic idea that African
- 13:10slaves were blank slates just waiting to be civilized
- 13:13by their masters. It shatters it. And he wasn't
- 13:16just writing his autobiography. The story goes
- 13:18that when he was first captured and sold, he
- 13:21ran away and was found in a jail cell. And he
- 13:23had been writing verses of the Quran on the walls
- 13:25of his cell in charcoal. His existence proves
- 13:28that Islam is not foreign to American soil. It
- 13:32is in the soil. It was here, in the minds and
- 13:35hearts of the people who literally built the
- 13:37economy of the early United States with their
- 13:39forced labor. And there was another one mentioned,
- 13:42even earlier, Estevanico. Right, Mustafa Zamori,
- 13:45who is known to the Spanish as Estevanico. He
- 13:48was a Moroccan Muslim. He was enslaved by Spanish
- 13:50conquistadors in the early 1500s. But he became
- 13:54one of the first Africans, one of the first non
- 13:56-Indigenous people, period, to explore the North
- 13:58American continent. In the 1500s. In the 1520s
- 14:01and 1530s. He was traversing the American Southwest,
- 14:04what is now New Mexico and Arizona, decades before
- 14:06the English settlement at Jamestown was even
- 14:08a thought. So a Muslim man was exploring the
- 14:11American frontier before the pilgrims even landed
- 14:13at Plymouth Rock. Correct. He is a constitutive
- 14:16threat. And this presence continues right into
- 14:19the Revolutionary War. If you go through the
- 14:21muster rolls, the official military lists of
- 14:24the Continental Army, you find names like Bambit
- 14:27Mohammed and Yusuf bin Ali. So men with Muslim
- 14:30names fighting for American independence. Fighting
- 14:33and dying. for the cause of American independence.
- 14:36It really reframes the whole picture. It isn't
- 14:39just European Christians fighting the British.
- 14:41It is this much more complex, much more diverse
- 14:44coalition of people from the very, very beginning.
- 14:48And this brings us to Thomas Jefferson, a complicated
- 14:51figure to say the least, but one who was thinking
- 14:53about these issues. We know he owned a Koran.
- 14:56He did. He bought a copy as a young law student
- 14:59in Williamsburg. And it wasn't a souvenir or
- 15:02a curiosity. Jefferson was a student of the Enlightenment.
- 15:04He was interested in comparative law, comparative
- 15:07religion. He bought it to understand Islamic
- 15:09law or Sharia because he wanted to understand
- 15:12how other societies structured themselves. And
- 15:14that study, it influenced his politics. Deeply.
- 15:17When the Virginia Statute for Religious Freedom
- 15:19was being debated, which is really the precursor
- 15:21to the First Amendment's religion clauses, Jefferson
- 15:24argued explicitly that its protection should
- 15:27extend to everyone. He listed them out in his
- 15:29autobiography when he was describing the fight
- 15:31to get it passed. He said the law was meant to
- 15:34comprehend within the mantle of its protection
- 15:36the Jew and the Gentile, the Christian and Mohammedan,
- 15:39the Hindu and infidel of every denomination.
- 15:43Mohammedan being the 18th century term for Muslim.
- 15:46So he's naming them. He's saying Muslims belong
- 15:49under this protection. He's saying everyone belongs.
- 15:52But here's the catch. And this is a really important
- 15:54and sobering nuance the source brings up. That
- 15:57specific, incredibly inclusive listing of religions,
- 16:00it was removed from the final text of the statute.
- 16:03So they cut it. They took out the specific protections.
- 16:06They kept the broad principle of religious freedom.
- 16:09But they cut the specific list because it was
- 16:11too controversial for the Virginia legislature
- 16:12at the time. There were people, like Patrick
- 16:15Henry, who wanted to maintain a kind of soft
- 16:18establishment of Christianity. And that is the
- 16:21key takeaway here for our deep dive. The source
- 16:24argues this proves that American pluralism was
- 16:27always aspirational. Aspirational, not actual.
- 16:30Exactly. The intent was there at the founding.
- 16:33Jefferson wanted it. Madison wanted it. But the
- 16:35fact that that language was amended shows it
- 16:38was never. Settled. It was never a done deal.
- 16:41We have been fighting about who belongs, about
- 16:43the scope of that protection since day one. So
- 16:46what here? The big conclusion for this section
- 16:49is that the 250th anniversary in 2026 isn't about
- 16:52inviting Jews and Muslims to the American table
- 16:55for the first time. It's about finally fully
- 16:58recognizing that they helped build the table.
- 17:00You cannot tell the story of America accurately
- 17:02without them. They're not an asterisk. They're
- 17:04a chapter. OK, so that's the history. We were
- 17:06always here. But just being here, you know, just
- 17:09having different groups living on the same plot
- 17:11of land, that doesn't automatically mean everything
- 17:14is working. Which brings us to section two of
- 17:17our outline, the architecture of pluralism versus
- 17:20diversity. This is such a crucial intellectual
- 17:23distinction. And the source here relies heavily
- 17:26on the work of Diana Eck, a scholar from Harvard
- 17:29who founded the Pluralism Project. She makes
- 17:32a very simple but profound point. Diversity is
- 17:35a fact. Pluralism is an achievement. That sounds
- 17:38like a great bumper sticker, but let's break
- 17:39it down. What is the actual practical difference
- 17:42between those two words? Okay, so diversity is
- 17:44just demographics. It's the census data. It means
- 17:47you have different kinds of people living in
- 17:49close proximity to each other. Baghdad in the
- 17:519th century, at the height of the Abbasid Caliphate,
- 17:53was incredibly diverse. The Ottoman Empire was
- 17:56diverse. The Antebellum South, tragically, was
- 17:59diverse. But none of those were pluralist in
- 18:01the modern democratic sense. Because there was
- 18:04a clear hierarchy. There was a dominant group
- 18:06and then everyone else. Exactly. Diversity can
- 18:10exist with rigid segregation. Diversity can exist
- 18:13with oppression. Diversity can exist with violence.
- 18:17Pluralism is what happens when you take that
- 18:19fact of diversity and you build something with
- 18:22it. You build a society where people from different
- 18:25backgrounds actually engage with one another
- 18:27constructively. where they are committed to each
- 18:30other's dignity and participate in a shared society
- 18:32as equals. So diversity is the raw material and
- 18:35pluralism is the finished product. That's a great
- 18:38way to put it. And as another scholar in this
- 18:40field, Ibu Patel often says, pluralism is not
- 18:44a birthright. It doesn't just happen because
- 18:45you have different neighbors. It is a responsibility.
- 18:48You have to build it and you have to maintain
- 18:49it. It's like a garden. If you don't tend to
- 18:52it, the weeds of prejudice and hatred will take
- 18:54over. So if pluralism is a construction project,
- 18:57how is America's building looking after 250 years?
- 19:00It's a mixed bag. Structurally, it's a bit of
- 19:04a mess, honestly. On the good side, the blueprint
- 19:07is brilliant. You have the First Amendment, free
- 19:09exercise, and the non -establishment clause.
- 19:12We have to stop and acknowledge how radical that
- 19:15is. No other nation in human history has attempted
- 19:18to have this much diversity with this much religious
- 19:20freedom. for this long. It is structurally a
- 19:24miracle that it has worked as well as it has.
- 19:26But then there's the bad, the long history of
- 19:28failures in the architecture. Right. The source
- 19:31points to what it calls the contested architecture.
- 19:33We have a blueprint for a beautiful building,
- 19:36but we have a history of failing at pluralism
- 19:38repeatedly, often violently. You look at the
- 19:41nativist riots of the 1840s in Philadelphia,
- 19:44mobs of Protestant citizens burning down Catholic
- 19:46churches and convents because they believed Catholics
- 19:49couldn't be real Americans, that they were loyal
- 19:51to a foreign power, the Pope. And that same logic
- 19:53gets used again and again. Again and again. We
- 19:56have the history of institutional anti -Semitism.
- 19:59In the 1920s and 30s, elite universities like
- 20:02Harvard and Yale actually had official quotas
- 20:04on how many Jews could attend. There were housing
- 20:07covenants in neighborhoods all across America
- 20:09saying you couldn't sell a house to a Jewish
- 20:11family. This was structural. This was policy.
- 20:14And then most recently in our memory, post 9
- 20:16-11. Right. After September 11, 2001, we saw
- 20:19that architecture of exclusion turned against
- 20:21Muslims. You had surveillance programs with the
- 20:23NYPD that specifically targeted Muslim neighborhoods,
- 20:26mosques, student groups. exclusion, the constant
- 20:30media portrayal of every Muslim as a potential
- 20:32suspect, the feeling that you had to constantly
- 20:35prove your loyalty. And the source argues we
- 20:37are in another one of those dark moments right
- 20:40now. It cites some really terrifying numbers
- 20:42from the period following October 7, 2023. The
- 20:45numbers are staggering. And they show the system
- 20:48is flashing red. The ADL, the Anti -Defamation
- 20:50League, they do an annual audit of anti -Semitic
- 20:52incidents. Their 2024 audit recorded 9 ,354 separate
- 20:56anti -Semitic incidents in the U .S. 9 ,354.
- 21:00That is an all -time high since they began tracking
- 21:03in the 1970s. And notably, that includes an 84
- 21:07% increase on college campuses. 84 %? I mean...
- 21:11That means if you were a Jewish student, your
- 21:13environment, your sense of safety fundamentally
- 21:16changed almost overnight. It did. The entire
- 21:19atmosphere shifted. And at the same time, KRR,
- 21:23the Council on American Islamic Relations, reported
- 21:25a parallel and equally terrifying escalation
- 21:28in anti -Muslim incidents. Reports of discrimination,
- 21:32bullying of children in schools, hate crimes
- 21:35like the stabbing of a six -year -old Palestinian
- 21:37American boy in Illinois. It's just horrifying.
- 21:40It is. And the expert insight from the source
- 21:41material here is absolutely vital for everyone
- 21:43to understand. These are not two separate problems.
- 21:46That's hard because they feel like separate problems
- 21:48when you watch the news. It feels like side A
- 21:50versus side B. It's framed as a conflict. That
- 21:52is the trap. And it's a dangerous one. The source
- 21:56argues that these are two faces of the same single
- 21:59failure. When the immune system of pluralism
- 22:02breaks down. When we stop seeing our neighbors
- 22:05as individuals holding natural rights and start
- 22:07seeing them as symbols of a political conflict
- 22:09or as threats, Jews and Muslims are both the
- 22:12first to get sick. The canaries in the coal mine.
- 22:15They are the first targets. They're often the
- 22:17minority groups that carry the most distinct
- 22:18markers of difference, whether it's Yarmulke
- 22:21or hijab. So a rise in hate against one is almost
- 22:24always a predictor of a rise in hate against
- 22:26the other. They are structurally linked. Which
- 22:29brings us to what is probably the most difficult
- 22:31part of this conversation. Section three, the
- 22:34crucible. October 7th and the failure of dialogue.
- 22:38This is where the rubber meets the road. This
- 22:39is the stress test in action. The source describes
- 22:42the aftermath of the October 7th attacks and
- 22:44the devastating war in Gaza that followed as
- 22:47a shattering. And specifically, it shattered
- 22:49the assumptions of the American interfaith movement.
- 22:52Yes. For about 20 years prior. really since 9
- 22:56-11. There had been a growing and, you know,
- 22:58many ways, very positive interfaith movement
- 23:01in the U .S. A lot of good people doing what
- 23:03they thought was good work. But the source critiques
- 23:05it as having been a fair weather friendship.
- 23:08That is a harsh assessment. What did that fair
- 23:11weather friendship look like in practice? It
- 23:13was polite. It was civil. It was often centered
- 23:16on the least controversial things, food and festivals.
- 23:20I'll come to your Iftar dinner during Ramadan.
- 23:22You come to my Seder dinner during Passover.
- 23:25I'll eat your samosas. You eat my latkes. And
- 23:28we'll talk about how we all want peace and we
- 23:29all love our children. Which is nice. I mean,
- 23:31it's not bad. It's not bad. It's better than
- 23:33nothing. But the source argues it was brittle.
- 23:36It relied on actively avoiding the hard stuff.
- 23:39It built a relationship by carefully avoiding
- 23:42the one thing that everyone knew was the source
- 23:45of potential conflict. The political situation
- 23:47in the Middle East. It was the elephant in the
- 23:50room that everyone pretended not to see. So when
- 23:52the war started, when that elephant went on a
- 23:54rampage, that avoidance wasn't possible anymore.
- 23:57Exactly. When October 7th happened, when real
- 24:01visceral grief and political anger and historical
- 24:04trauma just exploded into the open, those polite
- 24:08relationships couldn't hold the weight. They
- 24:11hadn't built the muscle for disagreement. The
- 24:13source mentions that so many of these interfaith
- 24:15partner, people who had been meeting for years,
- 24:17just stopped talking to each other. There was
- 24:20silence. Because they didn't have the tools,
- 24:22they didn't have the language to handle the raw
- 24:24emotion. There's a line in the article that just
- 24:27floored me. It says, if a relationship can't
- 24:29survive honest disagreement, it was never a relationship.
- 24:32It was just proximity. That is the core truth
- 24:35of this entire deep dive. Proximity isn't enough.
- 24:38Standing next to someone in line at Starbucks
- 24:40doesn't mean you have a relationship that can
- 24:42survive a war or even a heated political argument.
- 24:45It just means you both want coffee. So the source
- 24:48argues we need a pivot, a totally new model of
- 24:51engagement. We have to move away from prioritizing
- 24:53politeness and toward holding space for disagreement.
- 24:56And this is where it gets really interesting
- 24:57because they suggest we can find the models for
- 25:00this within the traditions themselves. They use
- 25:02some specific terminology, right? From Islam
- 25:04and Judaism. Yes. From the Islamic tradition,
- 25:08they use the term Majlis. A Majlis literally
- 25:10means a sitting, a gathering. But culturally,
- 25:14it implies a serious discussion, a place where
- 25:17weighty matters are hashed out by the community.
- 25:19It's not a casual chat. It's a space for deep,
- 25:22sometimes difficult, conversation. And from the
- 25:25Jewish tradition, the concept is, Did I say that
- 25:31right? It did. It translates literally to argument
- 25:36for the sake of heaven. That sounds like a contradiction.
- 25:38How is arguing for heaven? That sounds like the
- 25:40opposite. It's a foundational concept from the
- 25:42Mishnah and the Talmud, the core texts of rabbinic
- 25:44Judaism. The rabbis disagree on almost everything,
- 25:48vehemently. They argue, they shout, they dissect
- 25:50every word of the law. But they don't stop being
- 25:53part of the same community. The argument itself
- 25:55is considered a form of worship, a form of collectively
- 25:58grappling to find God's will. So the goal isn't
- 26:01to win. The goal isn't to destroy your opponent
- 26:04or prove you're smarter. The goal is to grapple
- 26:07together in good faith to find the truth or at
- 26:10least a better path forward for the community.
- 26:13If you and I argue just to prove who's right,
- 26:16that's an argument for the sake of ego. If we
- 26:19argue because we both care deeply about an issue
- 26:21and want to find the best solution. That's an
- 26:23argument for the sake of heaven. And the author
- 26:25gives a real -world example of this pivot in
- 26:28action. Iqbal Akhtar himself, the author of the
- 26:31piece, and a local rabbi named Jamie Akhlepi,
- 26:33they founded an organization called Miami Interfaith
- 26:36immediately after the attacks. Right in the heat
- 26:39of it. In October 2023, when everyone else was
- 26:42retreating to their corners, putting up walls,
- 26:44they made the conscious choice to step toward
- 26:47each other. And they didn't do it to issue a
- 26:49joint statement saying, we agree on everything.
- 26:51Right. They weren't trying to solve the Middle
- 26:52East from Miami. Not at all. They did it to sit
- 26:56together in the mess, to create a space where
- 26:59Jews could mourn their dead and Muslims could
- 27:01mourn theirs, to hold the grief of the other
- 27:04side without having to validate the politics
- 27:06of the other side. That's a very difficult, very
- 27:08adult thing to do. And this leads to a really
- 27:11hard truth for the listener. And I want everyone
- 27:13to really hear this because it completely changes
- 27:15the goalposts of what we're trying to achieve
- 27:17here. The source says the goal is not to agree
- 27:21on Middle East politics. We may never agree on
- 27:24that. And that have to be OK. The narratives
- 27:27are so divergent. The pain is so deep. The history
- 27:29is so contested. If the prerequisite for being
- 27:32good neighbors in America is that we first have
- 27:34to agree on the borders and history of the Middle
- 27:36East, we are finished. The American experiment
- 27:38will fail. We will never make it. So if that's
- 27:41not the goal, what is? The goal is solidarity
- 27:43in the American public square. It is committing
- 27:46to each other's dignity and safety here, regardless
- 27:49of what happens there. It is the ability to say,
- 27:52I might completely disagree with your view on
- 27:54the war. I might find your political stance abhorrent,
- 27:57but I will fight to the death for your right
- 28:00to be safe in this country, to pray in your synagogue
- 28:02or mosque without fear, to send your kids to
- 28:05school without them being bullied. That is a
- 28:07much higher bar than just being nice over some
- 28:10hummus. It is. It is a rugged pluralism. It requires
- 28:14a very thick skin and a surprisingly soft heart
- 28:17at the same time. So where do we find the strength
- 28:19to do that? Because honestly, that sounds exhausting.
- 28:22Usually people blame religion for this conflict.
- 28:24They say, if we just got rid of the God stuff,
- 28:26we'd all get along just fine. But section four
- 28:28of our outline argues the exact opposite. It
- 28:30says the solutions are actually hidden deep in
- 28:33the theology of both faiths. This is the secret
- 28:35weapon part of the deep dive. And it's the most
- 28:38counterintuitive part. We tend to think of religion
- 28:41as the source of the division, my God versus
- 28:43your God. But Akhtar argues that if you actually
- 28:47read the foundational texts, the Quran and the
- 28:50Jewish scriptures, they provide the roadmap,
- 28:53the actual software, for building this interconnected
- 28:55future. Let's start with the Muslim perspective.
- 28:58There's a verse from the Quran that the source
- 29:00highlights. So to 49, verse 13. It's a very famous
- 29:04verse. All mankind, indeed, we have created you
- 29:07from male and female and made you peoples and
- 29:09tribes that you may know one another. Know one
- 29:11another. That sounds simple enough. But the Arabic
- 29:13verb that's used here is litā 'ārafu. And as
- 29:16with so many things in Arabic, the root implies
- 29:19so much more than the simple English translation.
- 29:21It isn't just shaking hands or recognizing a
- 29:24face. It implies a deep, mutual recognition,
- 29:28a knowing that transforms you. The theology here
- 29:31is profound. The Quran is saying that God created
- 29:33diversity on purpose. It wasn't a mistake. God
- 29:36could have made everyone the same. Right. And
- 29:38another verse, Surah 5, verse 48, explicitly
- 29:40says that. Had God willed, he could have made
- 29:43you one single community. But he didn't. He made
- 29:46us different to test you in what he has given
- 29:49you. So diversity is a test, a divine pop quiz.
- 29:53It is a test. It's a divine setup. And what is
- 29:55the correct answer to the test? The verse continues.
- 29:58So compete with one another in good works. I
- 30:00love that framing. A race to righteousness. Not
- 30:03a race to conquer or convert, but a race to see
- 30:06who can do the most good in the world. Exactly.
- 30:09It completely reframes the other. My religious
- 30:11neighbor is not my enemy. They are my competitor
- 30:14in goodness. If my Jewish neighbor is building
- 30:17a homeless shelter, my response as a Muslim shouldn't
- 30:19be to stop him. It should be to try and build
- 30:21a better, bigger homeless shelter right next
- 30:24to his. That's the competition God wants. That's
- 30:27a powerful idea. And what about the Jewish perspective?
- 30:29What are the theological tools there? Well, it
- 30:31starts with the most fundamental concept in the
- 30:33entire Torah, Beslem Elohim. Every single human
- 30:37being is created in the image of God, not just
- 30:40Jews, everyone. If you truly deeply believe that,
- 30:44you cannot dehumanize your neighbor, no matter
- 30:47how much you disagree with them. To harm a human
- 30:49being is to deface the very image of God in the
- 30:52world. And then there's that famous line from
- 30:54the Mishnah about saving a life. Right, from
- 30:56Tractate Sanhedrin. Whoever destroys a single
- 30:58life, it is as if he's destroyed an entire world.
- 31:01And whoever saves a single life, it is as if
- 31:04he has saved an entire world. It emphasizes the
- 31:07infinite cosmic value of the individual. But
- 31:10I think the most powerful theological tool for
- 31:12this specific challenge comes from the late great
- 31:14Rabbi Jonathan Sachs. He wrote a seminal book
- 31:17called The Dignity of Difference. Great title.
- 31:19Very direct. And his argument was revolutionary.
- 31:23He said that in the Abrahamic tradition, God
- 31:25makes a particular covenant with a specific people.
- 31:28the Jews. But that particular covenant does not
- 31:31negate God's universal care for all other peoples.
- 31:34God is the God of all humanity, but he relates
- 31:36to us in our particularity. So, I can be fully
- 31:40and unapologetically Jewish, and you can be fully
- 31:42and unapologetically Muslim, and we can both
- 31:44be loved by God and part of God's plan. My truth
- 31:47doesn't require your falsity. That is the dignity
- 31:50of difference. It completely solves the zero
- 31:53-sum game of my religion is right, so yours must
- 31:55be wrong. Yes. And this all leads to the practical
- 31:58concept of interconnected futures. This isn't
- 32:00just abstract theology. It becomes a political
- 32:02and social strategy. And the source quotes Jonathan
- 32:05Greenblatt, the CEO of the ADL, to illustrate
- 32:08this. This was back in 2016. Right. This was
- 32:10during the presidential campaign. And there was
- 32:12a lot of political rhetoric at the time about
- 32:14creating a Muslim registry. forcing Muslim citizens
- 32:18to register with the government. And Greenblatt,
- 32:20the head of the largest and oldest organization
- 32:22fighting anti -Semitism in America, stood up
- 32:25and said, and I'm quoting, Wow. That's a powerful
- 32:36statement of solidarity. It's the ultimate statement.
- 32:39Now, obviously, the political landscape has become
- 32:42much more complicated and fraught since 2016.
- 32:44And there are very real tensions between these
- 32:46groups and organizations now. But the principle
- 32:49of that statement holds. It is the realization
- 32:51that a threat to one is a threat to the other.
- 32:54If you allow the government to target one religious
- 32:56minority, you have destroyed the constitutional
- 32:59protection for all of them. It's that idea again.
- 33:01Our fates are structurally linked. You can't
- 33:03actually be safe if your neighbor isn't safe.
- 33:06Precisely. Your safety is dependent on mine and
- 33:09mine on yours, whether we like it or not. OK,
- 33:11so we have the corrected history. We have the
- 33:13diagnosis of the crisis and we have the theological
- 33:16resources. Now we need the action plan. We're
- 33:20hitting July 2026. What do we actually do? The
- 33:23source gives us a very practical to -do list
- 33:25for America at 250. And it is a practical list.
- 33:28It's not just wishful thinking. It's about moving
- 33:30from nostalgia to actual work. Commitment number
- 33:33one, from dialogue to shared practice. This is
- 33:36a big one. Stop just talking. do things together.
- 33:39The source specifically suggests joint study
- 33:41of sacred texts. Like actually sitting in a room
- 33:44and reading the Torah and the Quran side by side.
- 33:46Yes. And not in a debating society kind of way
- 33:49where you're trying to prove your book is better.
- 33:51Akhtar calls this creating intellectual intimacy.
- 33:54When you sit down and you seriously study someone
- 33:56else's holy text with them, not to convert or
- 33:59be converted, but to understand how they see
- 34:01the world, what their deepest values are. It
- 34:04builds a bond that is much stronger than just
- 34:06eating falafel together. You see their values.
- 34:09You see their struggles. You see that they are
- 34:11wrestling with God and with meaning just like
- 34:13you are. That sounds incredibly challenging,
- 34:15but also incredibly powerful. OK, commitment
- 34:18number two, invest in the next generation. This
- 34:21is absolutely critical. The college campuses
- 34:23are where the heat is right now. They are the
- 34:25epicenters of the conflict. But the source points
- 34:27out that they are also where the hope is. The
- 34:30Interfaith America Leadership Summit. In 2025,
- 34:33it says, had its largest attendance ever. So
- 34:36despite all the news stories we see about campus
- 34:39chaos and division, students are actually showing
- 34:41up for this work. They are. Young people are
- 34:44hungry for a better way. The force says students
- 34:47are proving that interfaith friendship is both
- 34:49commonplace and extraordinary. But they need
- 34:53support. They need funding. They need mentorship.
- 34:55You can't just expect a bunch of 19 -year -olds
- 34:58to figure this out on their own while the entire
- 34:59world is shouting at them through their phones.
- 35:01We have to invest in the programs that teach
- 35:03them how to have these difficult arguments for
- 35:06the sake of heaven. Commitment number three,
- 35:08develop a shared narrative. This goes right back
- 35:12to the history section we started with. We need
- 35:14to stop telling the Jewish story of America and
- 35:17the Muslim story of America as if they're two
- 35:19separate books on the shelf. Because they're
- 35:21not. They're chapters in the same book. It's
- 35:23a braided narrative. The story is about the colonial
- 35:26Jewish congregations and the enslaved West African
- 35:29Muslims. It's about the civil rights coalitions
- 35:32where rabbis and imams march together with Dr.
- 35:35King. It's about the post -9 -11 solidarity where
- 35:38Jewish communities protected mosques from vandalism.
- 35:41We need to tell that story as one single stream.
- 35:44Because when you tell the story together, you
- 35:47create a sense of shared ownership of the country.
- 35:49If I know that your ancestors helped build this
- 35:52place alongside mine, I can't look at you as
- 35:54an outsider or a foreigner. And finally, commitment
- 35:57number four, build stormproof structures. This
- 36:00is the ultimate lesson from October 7th. Don't
- 36:03wait for the crisis to start building the relationship.
- 36:06That's like trying to build a lifeboat in the
- 36:08middle of a tsunami. You have to build the institutions
- 36:11now that expect the crisis. You need to design
- 36:14your community organizations, your interfaith
- 36:16councils, your campus groups, so that they can
- 36:19handle anger and disagreement and grief without
- 36:22collapsing. It's like building a house in a hurricane
- 36:25zone. You don't build it for the 300 sunny days
- 36:28a year. You build it for the Category 5 storm
- 36:30that you know is coming eventually. Exactly,
- 36:32because the storms will come. That is the nature
- 36:35of a diverse democracy. If you build a structure
- 36:37that only works when everyone is happy and in
- 36:39agreement, it's fundamentally useless. This brings
- 36:42us to the end, and the source leaves us with
- 36:45a really powerful full -circle image. It brings
- 36:48us right back to George Washington's letter to
- 36:50the congregation in Newport. He closes that letter
- 36:53by quoting the prophet Micah from the Hebrew
- 36:55Bible. He offers a vision of the America he hopes
- 36:58to build. He writes that in this new nation,
- 37:01everyone shall sit in safety under his own vine
- 37:04and fig tree, and there shall be none to make
- 37:06him afraid. None to make him afraid. And that's
- 37:09the dream of America, isn't it? Freedom from
- 37:11fear. It is. It's the ultimate promise. And the
- 37:14source points out that this vision of safety
- 37:16and peace of salam, which means wholeness in
- 37:19Arabic, is just as central to the Quran. It is
- 37:23the shared dream. of the children of Abraham.
- 37:25So to summarize the entire argument of this deep
- 37:28dive, Jews and Muslims are not guests in America.
- 37:32They are co -inheritors of the Abrahamic tradition
- 37:34and co -stakeholders in the American project.
- 37:37Their futures here are structurally linked. If
- 37:39one goes down, the other goes down. And if they
- 37:41can figure out how to build a rugged commitment
- 37:43to one another, the entire American experiment
- 37:45has a chance to survive and even thrive. That
- 37:48is the equation. That is the stress test of 2026.
- 37:51So as we approach July 4, 2026, here's the final
- 37:55provocative thought for you, the listener, to
- 37:57take with you. The source makes it clear that
- 37:59we are 250 years... into this experiment, and
- 38:02that beautiful vision of the vine and fig tree
- 38:04is still just a promise. It's not a reality for
- 38:07a lot of people in this country. For far too
- 38:09many people, it is definitely not a reality yet.
- 38:11They are still afraid. So the question for you
- 38:14is... Are you treating pluralism as a spectator
- 38:18sport? Are you just watching the news, scrolling
- 38:20through social media and shaking your head at
- 38:22the division? Or are you actively building the
- 38:26structure that keeps your neighbor safe? Because
- 38:28if you're waiting for someone else to build that
- 38:31vine and fig tree for you, it's not going to
- 38:33get built. It is on us. It has always been on
- 38:36us. Thanks for diving deep with us. We will see
- 38:38you next time. Take care, everyone.