Latest / TheThinkingAtheist / I Didn't Choose to Be Born (and More Deep Existential Stuff)
Transcript
- 0:00Understand the thinking atheist. It's not a person, it's a symbol, an
- 0:09idea. The population of atheist in this country is going through the rule,
- 0:13rejecting faith, pursuing knowledge, challenging the sacred. If I tell the truth,
- 0:19it's because I tell the truth, not because I put my hand on
- 0:23a book and made a wish and working together for a more rational world.
- 0:29Take the risk of thinking. Feel so much more happiness, truth, beauty,
- 0:32and wisdom will come to you that way. Assume nothing, question everything,
- 0:39and start thinking. This is the Thinking Atheist podcast hosted by Seth Andrews.
- 0:56Fast Approaching on my speaking roster Dallas, Houston, in Tulsa, Kansas
- 1:00City. I'll be in dressed in New York and then Sarnia, Ontario,
- 1:04Canada. Details on dates, times, addresses, locations, tickets, whatever
- 1:11at Seth andrews dot com slash Events. I have a confession to make.
- 1:19I have to be careful because I don't want this to sound arrogant like I'll
- 1:29be honest. I'm confident in what I do. I'm thirty three year broadcaster.
- 1:33I wouldn't do this if I didn't think I had something to offer.
- 1:36And I've developed a style and a perspective and opinions over those three plus decades.
- 1:42Okay, and I'm sure some are going to hear what I'm about to
- 1:46say and say, well, Seth's just full of himself and he's you know,
- 1:51he's total ego. This is what's going If you know me, please
- 1:55accept this in the spirit in which I offer it up. Okay, And
- 2:02people ask me what podcasts do you listen to? And I don't usually listen
- 2:10to podcast I do a lot of wondering of material you've heard me talk about
- 2:15them, and I love those guys, and long form audiobooks. I do
- 2:20enjoy audiobooks. I listen to a lot of true crime and some biography stuff,
- 2:28you know. And there is a podcast I do listen to, smart
- 2:30Less. I think that's kind of a fun show. And it's a nice
- 2:35balance between conversational levity and interviewing. I mean, the questions are really softballs,
- 2:42and I get it right. It's not like you're watching a deep,
- 2:45probing interview. This is friendly territory as celebrities come on and talk about their
- 2:50careers. But I follow a lot of those celebrities on the big screen and
- 2:53I enjoy their work, so that's fun for me. But it's very rare
- 2:59that I listen to somebody else's material or want somebody else's material, especially in
- 3:02the atheist movement, because I am busy producing atheist content. The last thing
- 3:07I want to do is listen to another show debunking the Book of Genesis.
- 3:10That's what we do. Oh look, we're going to go after the New
- 3:15Testament and deconstruct the Gospels. You know, We've got a show on that.
- 3:20Or we're going to do a cult show about scientology or whatever. And
- 3:23we've done that, and so it's not of great interest to me. Not
- 3:28that it's not valid, but it's it's just I do it already. So
- 3:31I'm looking for other stuff. So I decided I'm going to sort of scroll
- 3:38the podcast verse. My car's got a little interface, a little media interface,
- 3:43and it's got streaming media. I click that podcast search, and I
- 3:46just typed in comedy podcast and true crime, and I think I did one
- 3:53horror movie podcast, like a fan podcast, because I love horror movies.
- 4:00Those who know me listen to ghost Stories. You know, I've produced a
- 4:03ghost Stories audio book. So I'm gonna dip my toe into the waters and
- 4:09within five minutes, I wanted to shove my face through the windshield. I
- 4:17mean, it's a mine field when you're producing a broadcast, a difference between
- 4:23sharing interesting anecdotes and parts of your personal life that other people can relate to.
- 4:28In fact, in radio we call them a relate as a little behind
- 4:31the scene stuff going on here, I'll pull back the curtain. But you
- 4:35know, if you're talking about something other people can relate to, even if
- 4:40it's a personal anecdote, or if it's fun or interesting, there goes in
- 4:43a bizarre, entertaining direction, that's a journey worth taking. And it's okay
- 4:47if it's a digression from the subject at hand. Hell, you've listened to
- 4:51me before I've started the theme of a show. I'll go off on a
- 4:55bunny trail, you know. In twelve fifteen minutes later, I have to
- 4:59pull myself back back to the topic that we were supposed to do the theme
- 5:02of the show. I'm guilty of that. But this is the stuff I
- 5:06was hearing. And it literally screamed, we want to make you drive off
- 5:13of the bridge just to end this. That's what I was hearing. Stuff
- 5:18like this, Hey, Bob's in the studio today, Hi Bob, Hi
- 5:25Steve. Bob's wearing his favorite green shirt today. You love that shirt.
- 5:30I love this shirt. You love the color green, don't you. Oh
- 5:34yeah, I have green shirts, and I've got green shoes and some green
- 5:40socks, even green socks. Wow. You know it's nine months till Saint
- 5:46Patrick's Day. You don't have to wear green. It's okay for every day
- 5:50it's Saint Patrick's Day. For me. You love the color red. Oh
- 5:56yeah, stop shut up. Nobody cares like if you're going to tell me
- 6:08the green shirt story, that shit better go somewhere you can tell. I'll
- 6:12take the green shirt journey with you. If you have a destination that I
- 6:16can relate to that's entertaining, compelling, funny, whatever, But I love
- 6:21my green shirt. It just went on and on and oh it's another trap
- 6:31that some broadcasters fall into. This was huge in FM radio, and I
- 6:38was guilty myself when I first started. We call them the pukers, and
- 6:43that is when you're not talking to an audience, you're talking at them.
- 6:48So you go on and you are trying to sound like what you think or
- 6:53radio announcer sounds like. And I was guilty for about two or three years.
- 6:57You punctuate the consonants in these weird ways, like, hey, Q,
- 7:01what oh seven? Thanks so much for listening today, Gonna be a
- 7:04great day, chance of showers by the weekend, could be stormy on Sunday.
- 7:10Done forget to be listening tomorrow morning to the secret song of the day
- 7:13at seven twenty you could win a brand new car. You hear that you're
- 7:19punching the syllables because that's what radio disc jockeys are supposed to sound like.
- 7:25You know, we try to emulate that Scott Shannon counting down the top forty
- 7:30songs of the nation. Yes, that's what DJ sound like. And you
- 7:33become this homogenized, vanilla, instantly replaceable, robotic kind of puker. And
- 7:41I tried that for a while until I finally came to my senses and realized
- 7:45that I need to be speaking to people instead of talking at them. It's
- 7:47okay to have a personality of your own. You can be professional without being
- 7:51some sort of a like a puker. Right, And a lot of these
- 7:56podcasts I'm scrolling through and the role kind of sounded like this, and they've
- 8:00all got that canned laughter. They're laughing much too hard at stuff that's not
- 8:05that funny. Shut the hell up, Shut the hellop stop it. I'm
- 8:15just saying the comedy podcasts. I've come to the point in my life when
- 8:24one of the most terrifying things I hear from someone is, hey, they've
- 8:31scheduled a great comedian. Somebody asked me if I want to go out on
- 8:37a double day with Natalie and we're gonna go to the comedy club. I
- 8:41usually just weasel my way out sticky stand up comedy. Everybody's like so and
- 8:50so, they're so funny, such and such, they're hysterical. I have
- 8:54this comedian and I'll go, you know, look him up on Amazon,
- 8:56Primer, Netflix, and I stare at the screen like I'm reading stereo instructions.
- 9:01I know comedy is subjective, right, everybody's comedy frequency is going to
- 9:05be different. But I think as I'm getting older, shit is becoming less
- 9:09and less funny. Terry Gilliam of Money Python Fame has said the same.
- 9:16He said, as you age, you find yourself laughing less about jokey type
- 9:22stuff because there are much fewer surprises. You've heard the punchlines before, you've
- 9:28heard the stick before. And the secret to humor really is surprise, right,
- 9:33If you see it coming, it's one thing. But if you're surprised
- 9:37and it's comical, you laugh. The secret to humor is surprised. And
- 9:43more and more I find myself less surprised. And as I'm listening to the
- 9:46comedy podcast, you know who's laughing the host and co host at each other
- 9:52over the dumbest, laziest shit you have ever heard? Yeah, yeah,
- 10:01ah, stop it, stop talking, stop it. So here I am.
- 10:13And if I have an opinion about this, people think, oh,
- 10:16Seth thinks he's all that, thinks he's better than everybody else when it comes
- 10:20to podcasting. Hell no, I think you can be pretty good at what
- 10:26you do, but also know there's a ton of people better than you who
- 10:30could do it better than you. Some people talk about and I'm so grateful
- 10:33they enjoy listening to the narrated audible version of my books, and I will
- 10:39shamelessly shill for those audio books any chance I get. Look for Seth Andrews
- 10:45narrator audible dot com. I've narrated ten books over the past twelve years.
- 10:50Somebody was saying that d converted my autobiography kind of mirrored their own experience,
- 10:56and as they were driving, they were listening to the audio book and it
- 11:01was a companion for them, and it was an encouragement to them, and
- 11:03they appreciated the polish of it. And I can receive that and say thank
- 11:07you, knowing that there are many many superior audiobook narrators out there, but
- 11:16I know how to do it. And i'd like to think I know how
- 11:18to podcast. I don't know. And by going off on this random I
- 11:22guilty of the same thing that I've been accusing other people of doing on their
- 11:26own podcast. People are screaming, right now, get to the point,
- 11:30sath, get to the point. Who wants to hear about your personal opinions
- 11:37and private life? Blah blah blah'd somebody complained the other day I was telling
- 11:43stories about my dogs, Linus and Gracie. An unless I do an atheist
- 11:46podcast to hear about your dogs, Okay, that's valid. I see them
- 11:52as personal anecdotes that connect us host an audience, friend to friends, and
- 11:58it's interesting when I go out on the road and we get a chance to
- 12:01actually stand next to each other and talk to each other that people have taken
- 12:07my family into theirs in that amazing way. Hey tell Natalie we missed her.
- 12:11I wish you'd be able to bring her with you. How are Linus
- 12:16and Gracie and cats? How is Linus's foot healing up? I mean,
- 12:20I don't know. It's it's a connective thing. It's an intangible it's hard
- 12:24to really qualify. It's different than man I should like wearing my green shirt.
- 12:28This is my lucky shirt. I don't know. I'm sorry, I'm
- 12:39sorry. Is that arrogant? Am I being an egomaniac? Or is it
- 12:46confidence? The confidence that comes with years of experience. I don't think you
- 12:50should do something unless you feel like, let me say it this way.
- 12:54I don't think you should attempt to do something in a professional way or a
- 12:56formal way unless you feel like you can pull it off. Like if there
- 13:01is a comedian who was genuinely funny, there's going to be a time when
- 13:03they take the stage for the first time, it's amateur night or whatever,
- 13:07and they want to go out and they have something to offer. You never
- 13:09want to kill the dream. You never want to kill the dream of someone
- 13:13who may be learning by doing just tipping their foot in the water. But
- 13:16there are some people who have new business opening the microphone and attempting to communicate
- 13:24with other people in this format. This is not their gift. Their gifts
- 13:28are over here, over there there. Look, you're much better at that
- 13:33than I am than anybody else in your region. Is that's what you should
- 13:37be doing this? No? No, no, no, is that arrogant?
- 13:43I hope not. Anyway, I was listening to I tried listening to
- 13:46podcasts, and you know, there's like, I forgot how many podcasts.
- 13:50Aren't there like nine hundred thousand plus podcasts in the world, So I know
- 13:54there's a ton of great ones, and I only tried out five and a
- 13:58ram dam search. Do you have a podcast beside this one that you like?
- 14:05Leave it in the common section, let me know what it is.
- 14:07I'm most interested in real stuff. I do like true crime. I do
- 14:13enjoy a good horror story, although most of them that are told. I
- 14:18don't know why. Everybody feels like they have to sound like John Houseman at
- 14:22the beginning of the fog when they's sitting over the campfire, you know,
- 14:26and all they found was an iron hook. No, it's not it's not
- 14:31interested in that, And who chooses the music for those? Why the theremin?
- 14:39It's the year twenty twenty three. Somebody's telling a story and all you
- 14:41hear is that's not scary to me? Not scary. Sometimes less is more.
- 14:50Sometimes just the voice of a storyteller is a and then your brain connects
- 14:54the dots and paints the picture and fills in the blanks. Good storytelling actually
- 14:58in age as you you're not just a spectator. You become a participant in
- 15:03that way. Is there a podcast that does that when it tells fictional horror
- 15:07stories? I welcome your opinions, your contributions and suggestions in the comments box,
- 15:16and I welcome your calls. Nine one nine Roger, thanks for calling.
- 15:22What's on your mind? Hey? Hey, I just wanted to tell
- 15:26you. First off, I really appreciate everything you do. I've read all
- 15:30your books, listen to your podcasts. Thank you, really love your Paul
- 15:33Harvey stuff. Thank you. But no, my question to you is is
- 15:39just what do you think of Christopher Hristians would think what we live in today?
- 15:41People being so easily offended and as much as he came back with his
- 15:46read retorts and such I just wonder how the reception he would get nowadays.
- 15:50Well, he would be as horrified by the insanity of the world as you
- 15:54and I are. You know, he was a free speech absolutist. I
- 15:58remember one speech he gave where he said, you know, you go into
- 16:02a crowded theater and screaming fire, and that is protected. I'm not quite
- 16:07there. I'm not quite the free speech absolutist. I think there is a
- 16:11social contract, and there are issues of safety, etc. And it's messy.
- 16:15But he was such a reasonable voice and an encyclopedic rolodex of knowledge about
- 16:22history and religion that you know, if he saw the rise the resurgence of
- 16:29the theocrats and the bigots, etc. You know, I think he would.
- 16:33I would love to hear what he had to say. I think I'd
- 16:36like to hear how he strung the words together. He had that gift for
- 16:40elocution, didn't he. Man, he's really did it. Just can listen
- 16:44to it over and over again and always walk away with feeling a little less
- 16:48than than you did before. Right, I always felt dumber because he was
- 16:52so freaking smart, you know. I always felt it like I'm an idiot
- 16:56and he's got this, And I think the recall was one of the things
- 17:00that struck me the most because I can't remember why I walked in this room.
- 17:03Oh where did I put my wallet? Where are my keys? What
- 17:07was I saying? I can't remember? And yet he would be able to
- 17:10draw upon the history of the world and do so immediately without notes, And
- 17:15it's just it was remarkable, perfect recall. Yeah, after having much to
- 17:22drink. Right on many accounts, right, I think he found many things
- 17:29in this world offensive. He was offended by Islam's assault on women, he
- 17:33was offended by Christianity's assault on science, reason, human rights, common sense,
- 17:37good sense. But I get what you're saying. I think he didn't
- 17:42want to live in a world where people used, i'm offended to insulate themselves
- 17:48from analysis and criticism. And I totally agree. And I do find there
- 17:53are people in tribes of all shapes and stripes, including the atheist movement,
- 17:59who do like to play the offense card. Is a kind of conversation stopper.
- 18:04Right, I'm offended. I think that infantilizes some people, not all,
- 18:10certainly, I think there are things we can be offended about, but
- 18:12there are some people they broadcast their buttons, and then when other people they
- 18:18allow other people to push them, they blame everybody else. There's a level
- 18:22of individual responsibility. I think that must be at least a part of that
- 18:26equation. And some don't want to talk about that, but I think Christopher
- 18:30Hitchens certainly would. Absolutely, absolutely, But I just wanted to thank you
- 18:36for having you're doing them. Keep up at what you work, you're doing
- 18:38them. You are appreciated. Thanks so much. Take care, we'll see
- 18:41a have a doing. I never got a chance to meet Christopher Hitchens,
- 18:48shake his hand and tell them about the time I was watching that debate video
- 18:52on YouTube and how it propelled me into this journey. I wish I could
- 18:56have rita at three five two high. What's going on? I'm a philosopher
- 19:03myself, and I have my own YouTube channel, and I've recently been like
- 19:07promoting and talking about two philosophies I think you may know about them, anti
- 19:12natalism and ethylism. Aren't familiar with these? I really am not familiar.
- 19:18Can you explain? Anti natalism is the philosophical position where it's immoral and unethical
- 19:26and theological for anyone to have children for multiple different reasons, and there's different
- 19:33philosophers with different arguments, but the asymmetry argument is there is guaranteed pain coming
- 19:40into existence and no pain by not being born. Also, there's the consent
- 19:45arguments, where you can't ask the unborn for consent to being born, so
- 19:51it's in a position an agolis to rape. So every one of us is
- 19:57a victim of being born without consents. And this is what unifies all mankind
- 20:04under one banner. And it's in line with Buddhism, where life is suffering
- 20:11and it's promoting utility by continuing the human projects. That's anti nuedalism and ethylism
- 20:18is the same thing, but just including the animals. Have we spoken before,
- 20:26No, we have not. I have never called before, and I
- 20:27only recently discovered your podcast because of one of my viewers told me about it.
- 20:32I had a conversation like that, a little bit like this years ago.
- 20:37I'm getting a flash of it now. I don't see reproduction as rape.
- 20:45I don't see it as a consent issue. I think you know it's
- 20:48explained evolutionarily. You're right that people don't choose to be born, but framing
- 20:55it as a kind of violation to me, I don't buy that. What
- 20:59you position if you're unable to ask the girl who's drunk in the alley for
- 21:04consent and you proceed to have sex with her body. If you cannot ask
- 21:08consent, it's an imposition. Since the unborn are not able to be asked,
- 21:15it falls under the imposition of not getting consent. An evolution squanders suffering
- 21:22only so the advancement of the intelligence can be used as a better scheming tool.
- 21:29There is no need to make need, and that's all a human being
- 21:33does when they're alive. Hang on, So the scheming of the advancement of
- 21:38the intelligence or what was I hearing? I just want to make sure I
- 21:42understand the human being is using their intelligence to get the heroine instead of asking
- 21:51how to stop wanting the heroine. If you don't make a person, they
- 21:56can't be an addict. And so all human life, in all organic life
- 22:00is is just consumption and reproduction for no end and no purpose. Okay,
- 22:07well, so we're just figuring out new what. I just disagree with your
- 22:10premise. First of all, the idea that the cost benefit of the suffering,
- 22:14even though it sucks, the pain of childbirth, etc. Is horrible,
- 22:18and I would like to remove that from the reproductive process. The cost
- 22:22benefit of that is not just net suffering. The person who is born then
- 22:29has many opportunities to be alive, to breathe the air, to fall in
- 22:33love, to set and achieve goals, to fulfill dreams. There are so
- 22:38many positives they wouldn't be deprived. You. I know you've accessed through a
- 22:45computer right now, right like you've a monitor right next to you. Yeah,
- 22:49can you pull up David Bennettar's asymmetry arguments. It's on Google Images,
- 22:56and that will help me its pain. I will after the show. I'll
- 23:00read the argument after the show. What I'm interested in though, is this,
- 23:04I mean, would you rather that you would not have been born because
- 23:07you were not given consent to be born? Book? That's the title of
- 23:12Benetar's book, It's better never to have been. And I am one of
- 23:17the people who wish I had been aborted or swallowed by my mom. I
- 23:22wish I was aborted. I hate my life and I hate the human race.
- 23:26Well, that grieves me because I think there is much. I can't
- 23:30tell you nothing. I'm going to finish this, Okay, I can't tell
- 23:34you what your position or opinion on humanity should be. This is your journey
- 23:40to take on your terms, and so your opinion certainly belongs to you.
- 23:44But I'm really convinced that your perspective on being alive, on humanity, on
- 23:52the opportunity to breathe the air, and love and all those things that are
- 23:56part of our experience, you know, they're worth having and worth knowing.
- 24:00And I'm thankful I was born, and I think there were so many millions,
- 24:03if not billions, who feel the same. I understand your point of
- 24:07view, and I understand what you're saying, But this right here, I'm
- 24:11gonna make. I guess I'll make one more point because I know you have
- 24:12more callers. But the difference between what go ahead? No, No,
- 24:17go ahead, Okay, I just go rush, and I know you know
- 24:19no, I can take some time here, go ahead, okay. These
- 24:23are important. So anti natalism and ethalism are about stopping birth, preventing new
- 24:30people from coming here. Me and you seth We're already here, so we
- 24:34can make the best of it. The difference between anti natalism and etholism is
- 24:41the third step, which is called the promortalism, and it's the human right
- 24:47to die, which no one is talking about, where it's like there's no
- 24:51euthanasia censors, where it's like I can't just go and check out because suicide
- 24:56is taboo. And I have a friend who is fellow philosopher and had his
- 25:00own channel and he took his own life because the philosophy there was no arguments
- 25:07against it. So it's like only the good die young. It's better to
- 25:11live a shorter life than a longer life. In the argument logic is this,
- 25:17the longer one exists, the more suffering they will continue to experience and
- 25:22cause others. They will cause others to suffer, and they will experience more
- 25:26themselves. So the shorter life is the better life because of the pain they'll
- 25:32experience and the negatives. One hammer to the jaw is more detrimentally a bad
- 25:38thing than one makeout session. The negatives always as the good. All right,
- 25:44So I'm a fifty five year old man. I'm guessing I'm older than
- 25:48you are. Let's say I make it just seventy. Are you saying that
- 25:52I am I'm cheating goodness by existing for a longer period of time. The
- 25:59longer I am a live the more damage I'm doing, it's a bad thing.
- 26:03I wouldn't say cheating. That wouldn't be has to be the right term.
- 26:07But I think there is a term. I'm not sure what it is,
- 26:10but it's some mood or emotion that people feel where it's like they've already
- 26:15they think or they've felt that they've already experienced every emotion that life has to
- 26:19offer, and it's just a repeat of the other ones. So an orgasm,
- 26:25a cheeseburger, a soda on a hot day, or a handshake or
- 26:29a high five, it's the same things repeating themselves cyclically over and over,
- 26:33and humanity goes to these cycles of times and extinctions where they forget And right
- 26:40now we're on this cusp of flirting within artificial intelligence, and we're going to
- 26:44wipe ourselves out. And the trick for humanity to figure out how to stop
- 26:48this is to leave records that survived the cataclysm, and so far the only
- 26:52things that survive are like the pyramids or like the Eastern Islands, and no
- 26:56one knows how they were made. It's like, obviously it was advanced technology,
- 27:00and it's like we're trying to figure out how to stop this endless cardinal
- 27:04fucking flesh prison of suffering. Well, I mean they're fact look and I
- 27:11am. I think I'm going to draw this. What I don't want to
- 27:14do is is dry the listeners crazy, as they're probably clawing at the at
- 27:18the speakers at the podcast. But yeah, that's like the thing is the
- 27:22free speech, Like, like Christopher Inshon said, free speech. I'm a
- 27:26free speech absolutist, and the human right to die is something that our lawmakers
- 27:33need to fucking acknowledge that we need to taboo suicide. We treat suicide people
- 27:37like they're mentally ill. And I'm mentally ill. I have schizophrenia, but
- 27:41I'm still coherent and logical and competent to have these conversations, okay, And
- 27:47I'm not saying that we all need to kill ourselves, but I would press
- 27:52the red button to blow up the earth if I could, because all right,
- 27:56right, the fact that you've been very transparent about your on struggles with
- 28:00mental illness, and I don't want to in any way betray that or minimize
- 28:04that. I just think you and I definitely I'm going to I'd like to
- 28:08finish this sentence. I think you and I simply disagree that we are merely
- 28:15processing on the hamster wheel of emotion, and once we have experienced those emotions,
- 28:19repeating them becomes this banal exercise, this redundant thing that renders everything meaningless.
- 28:26I don't think joy felt yesterday disqualifies the joy I feel today or seek
- 28:33tomorrow. I don't think the love that I had enjoyed yesterday will negate or
- 28:38nullify or diminish the love I feel today or tomorrow. And I think life
- 28:44is a wonderful, beautiful thing for a great many people, and so many
- 28:48of us would like to extend that as long as we can. It doesn't
- 28:52mean we seek eternal life through AI, Heaven, etc. Which would render
- 28:56everything meaningless. We know we're on the close. There's a sense of urgency,
- 29:02but you know, this idea that's being born against our will is kind
- 29:06of a form of rape, and it's all suffering, and I wish I
- 29:11could blow up the world. That to me is a tragic position. It's
- 29:15an unfortunate point of view. And it's my hope that you will be able
- 29:18to see an extract real joy and meaning out of being alive, because this
- 29:22is the only ploth we have Okay, Rita, are you closing off now
- 29:27or that I don't want to have another point? Is our goodbye? I'll
- 29:30think of bye if you're saying godby too, I don't want to have another
- 29:32point. If you hear that was it? If you would, I feel
- 29:34like this is probably a good closing chapter point for the call. Okay,
- 29:41respectfully, No, respectfully, I appreciate your position. We stand apart on
- 29:45this, but it's something that you've given our listeners to chew on and we'll
- 29:48see what happens. Okay, Okay, thank you for having my call.
- 29:52Yeah, I appreciate it. I mean, there are some things I hear
- 29:55in that call that you know, I hate people or I hate humanity.
- 30:00To make sure I'm remembering that correctly, I hate being alive. And of
- 30:03course, when he references his own struggles with schizophrenia, etc. You've got
- 30:07to be very careful. I'm going to make sure that I'm not at all,
- 30:11I don't know, building an argument on or unnecessarily highlighting or exposing someone
- 30:18who may be at a place where cognitively we are not in a healthy place.
- 30:23You know. I mean, that's very that's touchy. But his sentences
- 30:29were coherent. His point was made certainly with passion and conviction. What do
- 30:33you think I think life's beautiful or can be beautiful. I'd rather be alive
- 30:37than not. I'm thankful I was born. I think connecting and living and
- 30:44loving and dreaming are amazing, wonderful things, and I'm every day grateful to
- 30:48be able to experience them. And it's my wish that other people would feel
- 30:52the same as well. You know, and I certainly hope Rita finds that
- 30:56fulfillment, love and joy in his own life. Your perspective on some of
- 31:03this and whatever else is on your mind, we'll talk more next. We
- 31:14get a chance to tell a lot of stories on this show, and I'm
- 31:17thankful for that. But I have a second podcast which really feeds the storyteller
- 31:22in me. I get a chance to tell five minutes stories, true stories
- 31:26about stuff. Something may have happened last month or hundreds of years ago.
- 31:33It could be true crime or celebrity trivia or weird news to something bizarre,
- 31:38interesting stuff that occasionally might blow your mind. So subscribe on all major podcast
- 31:45apps. True Stories with Seth Andrews Bryce at six one a tie. Thanks
- 31:56for calling. What's On your mind. Hi, So I've been dealing with
- 32:00my fiance's grandmother for some time will both of us have, obviously, and
- 32:07she posts some very boring on disturbing things on Facebook. Here's a prime example.
- 32:15Here's a post from back in December, Santa Claus not welcome here that
- 32:22includes his eight reindeer, Rudolph two and his elves. They are a big
- 32:27lie themselves. Christmas is to honor Jesus and that alone is what should please
- 32:35us. Only Jesus had to die, but not to spread the Santelli.
- 32:42Jesus said, he is the truth. That is what to teach our youth.
- 32:47It sounds a lot like what I've heard in fundamentalist Christian cultures that Santa,
- 32:52the story of Santa, cheats the Jesus narrative that they believe is the
- 32:58core of Christmas. So there's nothing really surprising there. What is it that
- 33:02you want to accomplish? Are you asking that? If you should respond or
- 33:06intervene somehow more or less. We've tried to disengage a lot lately, but
- 33:15she just really lashes out over Facebook, because that's really else she has at
- 33:20this point. But it's not just the direct correlation with Fanta and the Christmas
- 33:25season. It's anything that could possibly be used as an idol to draw attention
- 33:34away from Jesus. So she posts about the tooth Fairy, the Easter Bunny.
- 33:39These are lies. We shouldn't lie again, the irony. But no,
- 33:45she's apparently I don't know if she'd been diagnosed with schizophrenia, but there
- 33:51is a point long time ago bipolar when they attempted to medicate her for that
- 33:58and apparently didn't go as well as she had helped, and she's been long
- 34:02unmedicated. She doesn't think she has a problem. So we're talking about someone
- 34:09who is expressing a fundamentalist faith and her own opinions about Santa on her own
- 34:15page. She also may be suffering from some kind of a mental illness of
- 34:22some kind and it bothers you, and you would like to see her rescued.
- 34:25Yeah, I'd say that's certainly a good way of putting in. My
- 34:30opinion is probably for some might be controversial, But I've got fundamentalist religious relatives
- 34:37that post this kind of screed on their own pages. Doesn't affect my life
- 34:44one bit. In fact, the mute or unfriend button has actually served me
- 34:49quite well, this is their space, whether it's wacky or not. It's
- 34:53their Facebook page, and I can decide to follow or not. The odd
- 35:00are pretty long that you're going to be able to go and create a complete
- 35:04mind position change in this person, especially if this delusion is linked to some
- 35:10kind of mental illness, schizophrenia or otherwise. I get that it bothers you,
- 35:15but I think trying attempting to change this person, I think that's probably
- 35:22one step forward and about ten steps back for your own peace of mind,
- 35:27I just consider unfollowing and getting on with your life. That's my two cents.
- 35:31Yeah, I think that's some solid vice stuff and definitely take it into
- 35:37consideration at the very least. I don't want to sound cruel in this sense,
- 35:40but it's bordering on amusing some of the things she posts. I get
- 35:47it myself, have you know. I think we all have the fantasy of
- 35:52rescue, and there are some who can be rescued, but it's situational.
- 35:57I think you look at her age capacities and on what form or format would
- 36:05you be successful. It ain't going to be by commenting on Facebook. I
- 36:07guarantee you that. So you know, if you see a window of opportunity
- 36:12for a meaningful discussion. I certainly would never discourage that, but committing yourself
- 36:17to changing her, you know, that's a place where madness lies. Okay,
- 36:22all right, I really appreciate the advice up and will definitely take it.
- 36:28Take it or leave it one guy's perspective, hang in there. Thanks
- 36:31for Colin. Appreciate you, Appreciate you. Take care. I see you.
- 36:36I got a relative and it's all conspiracy. I mean it's the typical
- 36:40one world government and the Jews and George Sorrows and COVID conspiracy and satellite tracking
- 36:50and just the wankiest shit. I swear someone passed away on Natalie's family tree,
- 36:57a woman of eighty who had lived a wonderful life, who had heart
- 37:00attack and died suddenly, and someone else in the family. Their first question
- 37:07when they called had they gotten the vaccine? Meaning they believed that COVID vaccine
- 37:15had killed her. Now, I will counter that publicly, But will I
- 37:22commit myself to attempting to change this person's mind? No, No, it's
- 37:28rare. I'm working on a speech that talks about identity beliefs and how so
- 37:35often when you and I try to bring data points and they don't work,
- 37:39and people not only don't change their minds or they're not curious, but they
- 37:44actually doubled down and get pissed off. Why does that happen? We get
- 37:47into in grouping, social identities, communities, group think, and how there
- 37:55is an emotional bond that is created two ideas and two others of like ideas,
- 38:01people who validate us and all humans can be guilty of it. We
- 38:06get into the COVID communities and the anti mask communities, and the flat earth
- 38:13communities and the wellness communities, you know. And so anyway, I've been
- 38:20kind of nibbling away at that something I'm probably going to launch when I travel
- 38:24in the fall. I've got so it looks like an international area code of
- 38:30forty four. Alexis, Are you there? Yes, I'm here as thanks
- 38:35for calling. Where are you calling from? I'm calling from Glasgow, Scotland.
- 38:39Wonderful, It's so great to have you. What's on your mind?
- 38:43Alexis anti vaccination movement and how how can somebody be anti vax and this day
- 38:51and age, it just flab augusts me, don't understand it, And also
- 38:55flab augusts me is se on newspools are entertainment programs, say daytime television,
- 39:05if they're talking about health and specifically vaccinations, and then they'll bring on doctor
- 39:10and then they'll have some celebrity. I've got an example to tell you.
- 39:15Years ago, on a brit daytime TV program called This Morning, they were
- 39:21talking about the vaccination for young teenage girls against the human papaloma virus, which
- 39:27causes sur vical cancer. So they had on two doctors to practicing medical doctors,
- 39:32and then they had odd to counteract these doctors arguments an ex glamor model
- 39:39who just happened to have teenage daughters, and I just couldn't believe it that
- 39:45it dis astounded me. I understand your concern. It's hard. There seems
- 39:51to be a pride in resisting science. One of the arguments I've heard is
- 39:54well, science is always changing. Science used to say this was true,
- 39:59and then it changed and now it says that is true. Or it's anecdotal
- 40:04I knew someone who got vaccinated and the next day they were sick as a
- 40:07dog. Or it's a correlation causation argument. We get into social in grouping.
- 40:14Look at all the people who agree with me they don't trust vaccines either.
- 40:17There's a personal freedom angle where they've decided, you know, you're not
- 40:22going to tell me, you're not going to require me to get a vaccine.
- 40:25No, no, no, My freedom expression will be one of resistance.
- 40:30There's a hundred gears in the machine, all of them frustrated. And
- 40:34I remember talking to Karasena Marie about this, and she had a great point
- 40:37about the absence of collectivist values, this idea of social responsibility. What can
- 40:44I do to keep other people safe, even potentially to minimize harm and the
- 40:50loss of life? How can I help? That? Attitude seems to be
- 40:52missing And a lot of these people. Have you seen that in Scotland,
- 40:57These people who say you're not going to tell me what to do whatever,
- 41:00not under guards to anti vaccination, or at least I haven't knowingly come across
- 41:06any people who are anti vax but I have come across people who were against
- 41:09social distancing and against wearing their mask. And about two jobs ago, there
- 41:15was one one of my colleagues who I got on stone very well, but
- 41:20he was so getting social distancing and at that job, at the place where
- 41:24I worked, then you weren't allowed to go into the elevator by yourself,
- 41:29and so I wouldn't go in if anyone else was in the elevator. But
- 41:32one day Finns going in for my shift, met my colleague whether we chat
- 41:37outside and we went in to go to our shift, and he went in
- 41:40the lift and he said, don't worry, let's just coming here with me.
- 41:43It doesn't bother me. And I went, no, no, I'm
- 41:45not going to do that. Well, if they don't think he would have
- 41:49been bothered, any of the supervisors managers would have told him off. I
- 41:53don't want to get told off for that, and I don't want to put
- 41:55someone's health at risk. It's funny, Ale sister. In the high to
- 42:00the pandemic, we had some people who they would purposefully go and cough on
- 42:05other people in public just to show off, like, not only am I
- 42:08not going to wear a mask because hashtag freedom, but I'm going to go
- 42:13and force my you know, my particles on other people And thought and I
- 42:17just think, how how do we get there? And it's frustrating to live
- 42:22in an anti science culture where everybody in their dog can come up with the
- 42:27wackiest conspiracy theory and find validation for it on the internet. I don't know
- 42:31what the solution is. Just no, I feel you. I sympathize with
- 42:35you of them. I'm glad you're there, you know, masking and vaccinating
- 42:38and standing up for a good science. That's encouraging to me. Yeah,
- 42:44well, I'm just one test. No no, no, You're not just
- 42:49one person. You are one person and that matters. So Alexis you keep
- 42:53kicking Okay, okay, well thanks, all right, take care, bye
- 42:59bye bye. A lovely accent, Oklahomans have an accent. We have an
- 43:05accent, and it's people just start deducting IQ points. I can get my
- 43:10y'alls on, you know, I start saying euan's and y'alls when I get
- 43:14real tired. But if you're from Scotland, didn't you've got an accent?
- 43:19It's just lovely. It's lovely. Australia, what a lovely accent? Anybody
- 43:23from the UK? What a lovely accent? South Africa? What a great
- 43:29accent? Oklahoma? Not so much. I've got Michael at seven seven zero.
- 43:36Are you there? Hey, I'm right here. Thanks for calling.
- 43:39What's on your mind? Oh? I was just wanting to talk about Christian
- 43:43metal since you like to go on about Christian rock. I was just seeing
- 43:47there. Do you have any experience in that genre Christian heavy metal? My
- 43:52experience is going to be decades old. Brother, This was back in the
- 43:57nineteen eighties and nineteen nineties, right, Stryper and such. I'm talking more
- 44:04along line like bands becoming the archetype, Eternal Decision and the Second Sea.
- 44:14Yeah. Sorry, I think we had I don't know if raz band would
- 44:17be considered metal. It was just hard rock. There was a band called
- 44:21Deliverance, you know, and we had some other The problem is I'm not
- 44:27familiar enough to speak with authority about genres. So was it death metal or
- 44:30thrash metal or whatever? Wherever you log on and it's just double base riffs,
- 44:36you know, some gaiging certains, you know that kind of thing.
- 44:40There is a whole genre of Christian music where people do that. You know.
- 44:49My experience is pretty honestly, So do you listen to it? I
- 44:52mean, why why bring it up? Why is it on your money?
- 44:54Absolutely? Well, it's like I've been I've been wanted to talk to you
- 44:59about these particular bands because one of the things we talk about Striper, we
- 45:06talk about Skillet and how cringe their performances are, and how they try too
- 45:12hard to try to get on the mainstream and whatnot, which they really are
- 45:15mainstream, and it's just that Christian metal itself isn't really mainstream. Like Eternal
- 45:24Decision actually had an album Aware they have an extraordinarily similar sound to Metallica,
- 45:30which I think is absolutely hilarious. Well, I did a whole speech called
- 45:35the Copycats, or we talked about Christian culture and it's radar up to see
- 45:39what was happening in secular culture, and it says, oh, that's popular,
- 45:45let's do a Christian version of that. Music is certainly a great example,
- 45:49and we would just wait. An artist has a hit song, a
- 45:52band has a great album, and about six months later, there would be
- 45:55a Christian version of it, usually much weaker, much lamer of pale imitation,
- 46:01very generic, but at least we had it, and there was a
- 46:05charm to that because we're like, now we've got a Christian version, man,
- 46:08we don't have to participate in the world. I'm gonna rock for the
- 46:12rock man, I'm gonna rock for the King. And that's how we felt
- 46:15in the eighties when these big hair bands came out like Baron Cross. You
- 46:19know, we well right for the King, you know, that's how those
- 46:25albums went all right, right, I think I heard a little bit of
- 46:32that talk you did about the coffeecat. Yeah, that's awesome. You know
- 46:37it's awesome. And if you really want to have fun, google search Christian
- 46:42heavy metal album covers. It is the greatest thing in the universe to see
- 46:46these album covers. It's just a gift to all human kind. So if
- 46:51your board Christian heavy metal album covers, just go google it. Okay,
- 46:55Oh, I've done that. In fact, actually had a CD of becoming
- 47:00the archetypes of their album Dichotomy. More hairspray was used in a fifteen year
- 47:07period. I think it's probably the reason that we have holes in the ozone
- 47:12right now is the metal hair bands of the eighties and nineties, and so
- 47:16they oh, an apology to the species. Gotta run, Michael, thanks
- 47:21for colin brother, and we'll see you later. Yes, sure, not
- 47:23a problem, all right, to see you later. Oh my gosh,
- 47:27that takes me back. I was second row It's striper for the to Hell
- 47:31with the Devil tour. I was there. I took this poor girl.
- 47:36It was a date I was on with. Tina was her name. She'd
- 47:38never been to a concert of any kind in her life. So I said,
- 47:44hey, why don't we go to Stryper. They're awesome. They rock
- 47:47for the rockman. So I got us second row at the Brady Theater,
- 47:52which was a place that we called the Old Lady on Brady. It was
- 47:55this charming theater still here in town. And we were right that, we
- 48:00were right up front, and it was ear splitting. The speakers were just
- 48:06right there, pointed at us and ah, I mean they were screaming.
- 48:09You could feel your ear drum actually sort of flutter from the vibration of the
- 48:15sound. I'm sure I've got permanent hearing loss. At one point, the
- 48:20opening band, their name was Hurricane. The guy pulls out it's very spinal
- 48:24tap. He pulls out a guitar, an electric guitar and a gem studded
- 48:30cello bow and he just screeches it across the strings, just yeah, and
- 48:38we're all like, yeah, man, awesome rocking for the King. Oh
- 48:45I'm so embarrassed. I'm so embarrassed. I was there. I lived it.
- 48:51I was heavy meddling for Jesus Man. Let's take a look a here.
- 48:58Wow, if you could meet the young your seth, you would just
- 49:00shake your head and wonder what happened. Let's take a look here at nine
- 49:05four zero Cody, Hi, thanks for calling. Hi. I was just
- 49:09kind of sort of wondering. He's like, I've been watching a lot of
- 49:13atheist content for like a while now, and sometimes they'll talk about like this
- 49:16certain college that does gives people the fake degrees and stuff, and turns out,
- 49:22I'm pretty sure that's actually my grandpa. Hang on, miss, I
- 49:25missed the first part of that. They hand out what degrees, just not
- 49:30credited to degrees. Oh like gray Mill where you just go and they yeah
- 49:36they degree farm. Yes, Pice, Okay, go ahead, yes,
- 49:38sir. Well, I've watched a lot of videos like that, and I'm
- 49:43pretty positive that it's my grandpa that runs that. And I honestly didn't know
- 49:46that he did that until I heard a bunch of people into the internet talking
- 49:51about it. And I'm honestly not sure if I should, you know,
- 49:54like asking him about that, because I don't know what he thinks he's doing.
- 49:59It's like ant Hovend the Apologist. Have you seen the place where he
- 50:04got his degree. It looks like a double wide mobile home. It is
- 50:07a degree B that is actually my grandpa. Like I think that is the
- 50:12one that gave him the diforma. These places exist, and so then you
- 50:15become doctor. So and so. I remember I worked in a building with
- 50:22a traveling evangelist and he was given an honorary doctorate by his home church.
- 50:29Tell me that's not a rigged game. And from then on his office manager
- 50:35required everyone on staff to refer to him as doctor. And he didn't receive
- 50:44a doctorate. He didn't have a PhD. He didn't actually have enough life's
- 50:49work to qualify for an honorary doctorate. He was just a preacher whose own
- 50:53church decided he deserved a PhD or to be called doctor, and he played
- 51:00that card for freaking decades. I wouldn't say anything to your grandfather, but
- 51:06I think it's a it's certainly fertile ground for conversation among you and your friends,
- 51:09you know, And if it comes up, I would lead with questions,
- 51:14what were their course studies, what were their requirements? Are they accredited?
- 51:16Were they vetted? You can ask questions and kind of see what happens.
- 51:21Hell, I might be curious about that, but I don't think i'd
- 51:24walk in with, Hey, I heard you were the dean of bullshit University.
- 51:29I don't think i'd lead with that. I mean you can, And
- 51:31just like also, I guess talking to him about general because honestly, like
- 51:37he kind of knows I don't really believe in a god anymore, and like
- 51:39we haven't had the greatest conversation since then. I've kind of been avoiding talking
- 51:44to him in general. He's kind of trying to like guilt me into him.
- 51:46He's like he's kind of sickly and about to die. Probably he's playing
- 51:52the I may die at any moment card. He's just like, did I
- 51:57really waste my entire life? Do you want this to be the last conversation
- 52:00we have together? That sort of thing. That's just bullshit. First of
- 52:05all, he's asserting falsely, and I don't think he believes that his sole
- 52:09purpose in life was to have a Christian grandson. There were many purposes in
- 52:15his life, self generated and otherwise. Secondly, this is emotional blackmail,
- 52:21and I don't think you have to put up with it from anybody, including
- 52:22a dying grandfather. That's a boundary violation. And I would respond if it
- 52:29was me with actually, I'm in a good place. I'm happy with my
- 52:31life. And just as no one could tell you how to live yours and
- 52:37how to take your journey, I'm going to take mine on my own terms.
- 52:40Now, I'm here for you if you need anything. But this part
- 52:44of our conversation really is a personal thing, and we need to move on.
- 52:47And if he refuses to move on, I think you physically move on.
- 52:51Have a nice day. Thank you for letting me talk to you.
- 52:54Karty, is nice talking to you, and we'll see you later. Look
- 52:58at me counseling people, relational advice as if I had a PhD and family
- 53:05therapy, counseling psychology. Who knows, Maybe I do. Maybe maybe I
- 53:12went to one of those little shacks out in the weeds. Yeah, walked
- 53:15into the lobby and filled out a form, dropped a few hundred bucks cash
- 53:20only, cash only, and they gave me my degree. Congratulations, PhD
- 53:27Doctor Seth Andrews. And then whenever I spoke in public, when I'm traveling
- 53:30and touring and speaking, I would be introduced from the stage ladies and gentlemen,
- 53:36Doctor Seth Andrews, how many people would actually go and check out my
- 53:43degree, find out where I had graduated. I think in this community a
- 53:49lot of people. I think the news would break pretty soon. This is
- 53:54skeptical audience. You know. I always think about Saul Goodman from the show
- 54:00Breaking Bad and Better Call Saul, especially when he was really in his sort
- 54:05of slimy bus bench ambulance chasing billboard shill of a lawyer. He got his
- 54:12degree by mail from the University of American Samoa Law School. Now, I'm
- 54:20not knocking anybody who does correspondence courses, because I think those can be extremely
- 54:23valid, But University of American Samoa does not exist in real life. This
- 54:29is not an actual college, but it was sort of sold in the series
- 54:34as kind of a pretender. You know, it's college light. It's sort
- 54:39of the fast track to a law degree. And I just picture one of
- 54:44those double wides out in the wilderness. You drive the dirt road, you
- 54:50go in, you get your degree. That's kind of what I picture in
- 54:52my mind, Doctor Andrews. Oh, if I wanted to, could I
- 54:58get away with its? Probably not with this audience. I think your bullshit
- 55:06meter would be going off pretty much right away. The prestigious, highly esteemed
- 55:14doctor Andrews will continue hosting and taking your calls next. Thanks so much for
- 55:29including me in your day. I appreciate your listening so much. Kind of
- 55:32a random show. We're talking to you about the stuff that's on your mind.
- 55:39I've got Ruth at seven zero seven. Hello Ruth, Hi, this
- 55:45is the second time I get to talk to you. I'm so excited.
- 55:49How long has it been. It's been about a year and a half.
- 55:52I'm working with the homeless now, I'm feeding the hungry and the nunsheltered in
- 55:58bushes. And when it comes to schizophrenia, the young man that wanted to
- 56:04blow up the planet and hate his life, You're right, it's very sensitive
- 56:08and most of my clients have schizophrenia on top of mess at it. So
- 56:16sometimes when they get that way, it's best to let him spew sometimes to
- 56:22get it out of their brains. And he was very distraught. How would
- 56:30you critique my approach? How might I have like? I wanted to make
- 56:32sure I gave plenty of room at the same time, while respecting the audience
- 56:37and the limited time we have together. Do you have any critique for me
- 56:40how I might improve my approach with something like that. Well, I thought
- 56:45you did a really good job. I know you've probably been doing this for
- 56:49a really long time. When it comes to when he wants to starts getting
- 56:55really going on, you just kind of bring them back down to where they
- 57:00started. You know, he started he hates life, you know, apparently
- 57:05he didn't have the choice of being born. None of us do. And
- 57:10it's hard when I don't know if he was on his medication, Seth was
- 57:16not. I think he said he had been off his medication. Maybe that
- 57:20was the next scholar was talking about his grandma. And I think we have
- 57:22to be fair and say that it's very possible that his position on life and
- 57:28death, existence, etc. May exist legitimately apart from schizophrenia or any other
- 57:35condition. I mean, he might just hold that opinion. I've heard it
- 57:37expressed elsewhere that nobody chooses to be born. It'd be better off if we
- 57:42had not been born, or we all went extinct. I mean, I
- 57:45know that this position does exist not there. It does, and it does
- 57:47with the unsheltered when they're living in a berry bush and they have literally nothing.
- 57:54But I have to give credit to the outreach program I work with.
- 58:00And I'm I'm an atheist. I'm not out there to get into heaven and
- 58:02I tell everyone that. But sometimes these people who have zero, nothing,
- 58:07and they're schizophrenic and they're going off the deep end, some of the religious
- 58:13people do bring them in and it helps them. It gives them only one
- 58:19thing to have hope for. And I know they're all going to be disappointed
- 58:22when they die. It just gives them that one little bit of hope.
- 58:27That and cigarettes. I don't think they're going to be anything what they die,
- 58:30but I understand what you're trying to get the spirit of what you're saying.
- 58:32It's not like they'll be conscious to be able to acknowledge there was no
- 58:36heaven. They're just going to fall asleep. That's my position, right.
- 58:39Who was it Twain who said mine? I hadn't existed for billions of years
- 58:44before now, and I hadn't been inconvenienced really at all by it, So
- 58:49I take that right. That's just a saying I say when I'm talking to
- 58:54my mother about my born again Christian brother, I just make light of it,
- 58:59like ge mom, he's going to be so disappointed. I get well,
- 59:04you know, it's interesting. We talk a lot about how we construct
- 59:07the mechanisms for coping or navigating, and if you are hopeless, if you
- 59:13have nothing but suffering around you, it's going to certainly color how you see
- 59:16the world. Some people will, I think, want to see the world
- 59:20destroyed because you know, the world's been so cruel to you, why continue?
- 59:24And others will build a happy ending to their story. One day I
- 59:30will have a mansion and be rich and be whole and be loved and all
- 59:32those things. And it's understandable. And I think this construction of this afterlife,
- 59:37this wonderful next chapter. I think we have to approach that with empathy.
- 59:42Instead of saying, well, how stupid is that? We say,
- 59:45you know, I understand these people are hurting, and we get it.
- 59:49Yeah, not everyone gets it. It takes a real I don't know,
- 59:52a real special person not to argue with them. The last thing I would
- 59:57ever say to one of my homies, I'm sorry, but there is no
- 1:00:01God. They would literally od and die. And they're humans. I look
- 1:00:07at them as human beings. They have a heart, they bleed, they
- 1:00:12suffered. You know, we've all suffered these people need us, and no
- 1:00:19one preaches to them. There's an open church when they want to go,
- 1:00:22they don't have to pray to get a meal. We feed them what we
- 1:00:27feed ourselves. So there is the place here in Santa Rosa were you have
- 1:00:32to give yourself to the Lord to get a meal, and no one wants
- 1:00:37to go there. They want to make that choice for themselves. Let me
- 1:00:43ask you a personal philosophical question, Ruth, are you glad you were born?
- 1:00:50Do you look forward to the future or do you feel like you're just
- 1:00:52on the hamster wheel and it's all meaningless. I have never felt meaningless.
- 1:00:59My life is and such a joy I love every day. I wake up
- 1:01:02early. I'm happy. You know I hear God fearing people say that if
- 1:01:07you're an atheist, you have no morals, you can't be happy, or
- 1:01:13you have nothing to look forward to. Coming from a nonbeliever, here's how
- 1:01:19most of us probably wake up. Everything we do, every choice we make,
- 1:01:24every time we make someone happy sad. We do it because it's our
- 1:01:30free well to do it. No God tells me what I can and cannot
- 1:01:36do. I was taught critical thinking, and the problem with they take their
- 1:01:40kids and really really young, and they get them hooked on it and it's
- 1:01:46a drug. But you are a happy person, glad to be alive,
- 1:01:51looking forward to tomorrow. Yes I am. I can hear it in your
- 1:01:57voice, Ruth, and I appreciate your perspective on ours call and thank you
- 1:02:01so much for calling me. A thank you fair you can't care. I
- 1:02:06see you later, Bye bye. I've got Bruce at two five four.
- 1:02:10Bruce are you there? Hey, Seth, Hey have voices? Thanks for
- 1:02:16calling? Man, what's going on? Yeah? You are the voice though
- 1:02:21joy. Listening to your show brings me joy. Walking outside brings me joy.
- 1:02:27We live in a world where I think we're easily manipulated, and as
- 1:02:32an atheist, when I speak to Christians, they say, how are you
- 1:02:37so happy? How do you know everyone? I've never met a stranger,
- 1:02:42but I've met a lot of strange people, but I've never met a stranger.
- 1:02:46Hey, it's good to see you. I'm just glad to be part
- 1:02:50of this existence. Call live. You know. I was kicked out of
- 1:02:53the Catholic school in the first grade because I asked too many questions they couldn't
- 1:02:58answer, and my grandmother said, you're gonna be just fine. Search and
- 1:03:04keep asking questions is your cup half full or half empty? And I said,
- 1:03:07I'm just glad I have a cup. Yeah. And my grandfathers they
- 1:03:10both said, you're gonna be just fine. And my parents let me choose
- 1:03:15my own path. Even though I was raised in the Catholic family, I
- 1:03:20wasn't considered different and I was always a pretty happy kid. The simplest things
- 1:03:25make me happy. And people don't understand how that can be. You're an
- 1:03:30atheist, you should be full of hate, and they just don't get it.
- 1:03:34And part of it, I laughed, insided them for being so narrow
- 1:03:37minded. You know, there's a few that I speak to, a few
- 1:03:43of these young Christians that I work with, and I talk about how easily
- 1:03:46humans are manipulated with the social media and the thumbox, the phone. You're
- 1:03:52buying shoes because you saw somebody else wearing them. Do you not think that
- 1:03:58religion easily manip let you that easily? And they're thinking a little bit,
- 1:04:02they're thinking, you know, and that's all I wish people would do is
- 1:04:06think a little bit more about others and quit being so selfish. I remember
- 1:04:12that great is it a Jatteruski quote birds born in a cage think flying is
- 1:04:18an illness, and you and I are like open the cage, baby,
- 1:04:23just spread your wings. There is no feeling like that liberation that comes with
- 1:04:28breaking out and breaking free. You feel it, I feel it. I
- 1:04:31think we want other people to feel it as well. Right, Yeah,
- 1:04:33I don't force anybody, but I'm the guy that always jumped in the deep
- 1:04:38end. Come on, we can swim, Come on, you know.
- 1:04:41And something my grandmother said that always stuck with me. And she was raised
- 1:04:45canceolate, but she had a very open mind, and I think of her
- 1:04:48time she had to put on that face. But she said, along your
- 1:04:53journey to the mountaintop of nirvana, you might meet the Buddha along the way
- 1:04:58and reach up, meet Jesus and reach up and he'll give you a hand.
- 1:05:01Reach down and help somebody else. But find your own way, find
- 1:05:06your own path to nirvana, your inner happiness, and don't let anybody tell
- 1:05:12you their way is the only way. Those are the ones that are scary,
- 1:05:15the ones that run around the bottom of the mountain with a book and
- 1:05:18a gun or a weapon and say my way is the only way, because
- 1:05:21it's not. We're all individuals, we all have a different path, we
- 1:05:26all have different ideas. Your enthusiasm is contagious, and I think it's a
- 1:05:30great way to sort of cap the show. You know, there's no one
- 1:05:33way to be happy. Find what fits for you, be kind, find
- 1:05:39the joy, get the goodness. I love it, Bruce, thanks for
- 1:05:43calling our slowman. Have a great day, all right, We'll see you
- 1:05:45later. I like that. Let's end on a high note. Man,
- 1:05:50That's what we'll leave each other with as we call it a day, and
- 1:05:54I'll see you back here for the next show next time. Follow on Facebook
- 1:05:59and Twitter for a complete archive of podcasts and videos, products like mugs and
- 1:06:03t shirts featuring the Thinking Atheist logo, links to atheist pages and resources,
- 1:06:09and details on upcoming freethought events and conventions. Log on to our website,
- 1:06:14The Thinking Atheist dot com.