Latest / Her Journey: Women, identity, culture & modern life / Choosing Singlehood When the World Wants a Ring | Her Journey
Transcript
- There is a specific kind of silence that follows you out of a building you spent twenty years treating like your second home. It’s not just quiet; it’s the sound of a thousand invisible threads snapping at once. I want to talk about the physical sensation of walking out those double doors for the last time. Not the dramatic, cinematic exit where you toss your hymnal in the air, but the mundane, heavy reality of simply turning your back and not looking up. For so long, that church wasn’t just a place you visited on Sundays. It was the grid by which you measured everything. It was the calendar of your life, marked by Advent candles and Easter lilies, by potlucks where you knew exactly who sat where and who brought the good potato salad. It was the safety net that caught you when you fell, or at least, that’s what we were told it was. But somewhere along the way, I started noticing the fraying edges. I started noticing that the warmth of the community came with a price tag, and that price was often my own voice. You learn quickly, in these spaces, how to modulate your tone, how to shrink your questions until they fit neatly into the accepted answers. You become an expert in polite ambiguity. And I think that’s why leaving feels so much harder than staying. Staying is comfortable. Staking your claim on a new identity, one that doesn’t have a pulpit behind it, is terrifyingly open-ended. Let’s sit with that for a second. Because if you’re listening to this and you’ve left, or you’re thinking about it, you might feel guilty for feeling sad. You might feel like you should be celebrating your liberation, your newfound freedom from dogma or rigid expectations. And sure, there is relief. There is a lightness in no longer having to perform piety for people who don’t actually know you. But beneath that relief, there is often a profound, hollow ache. It’s complicated, isn’t it? You are grieving the loss of a tribe. You are mourning the version of yourself that believed, truly believed, that she was held by something bigger than herself. And now, you have to figure out how to hold yourself. I remember the first few months after I stopped going. I’d walk past the steeple on my morning commute and feel a phantom limb pain, a twitch in my soul that expected comfort and found only empty sky. It’s a strange grief because society doesn’t really give you a script for it. If you leave a marriage, you get sympathy. If you quit a job, you get congratulations on the new chapter. But if you leave the faith that raised you, you often get confusion. People ask, 'But why?' as if it were a simple matter of preference, like switching from coffee to tea. They don’t see the layers of identity, history, and family dynamics wrapped up in that decision. They don’t see that you’re not just changing a ritual; you’re dismantling a worldview. And then there’s the family. This is the part that hurts the most, I think. The person who made you the sign-up sheet for vocation, the mother who prayed over your high school graduation, the father who taught you that faith was the foundation of integrity. When you step away, you aren’t just stepping away from a building; you’re stepping away from their hopes for you. You become the disappointment, the wild card, the one who didn’t make it. I had to navigate conversations where love felt conditional on my compliance. I had to sit at dinner tables where the topic of God was used as a shield against any discussion of my actual struggles. It’s exhausting to explain that your doubt isn’t an attack on them, but a necessary journey for you. Where does that live in you? That tension between wanting to honor your roots and needing to prune the branches that are choking your growth? I learned, painfully slowly, that I couldn’t fix their discomfort. I couldn’t soothe their fear that I was lost. I could only stay present, gentle but firm, in my truth. And that required a strength I didn’t know I had. It required me to separate my worth from their approval. Which sounds simple in theory, but in practice, it feels like walking a tightrope over a canyon while everyone below is shouting advice that contradicts each other. So, what do you replace it with? That’s the big question, isn’t it? When you remove the external structure, the weekly reinforcement, the communal chanting of beliefs, you’re left with a void. And humans hate voids. We fill them quickly. For a while, I filled mine with noise. Podcasts, books, endless scrolling through different philosophies, trying on different identities like coats in a department store. I wanted to find the perfect system, the one that would finally make sense of the world. But the more I searched, the more I realized that the search itself was the point. I wasn’t looking for a new church; I was looking for myself. I started to notice the small moments of connection that didn’t require a label. The kindness of a stranger holding a door. The awe of watching the sunset without feeling the need to thank a specific deity for it. The deep, resonant peace of sitting in silence and realizing that the silence wasn’t empty, but full of presence. It was a slow awakening to the idea that spirituality isn’t a destination you reach by following rules. It’s a quality of attention you bring to your life. It’s showing up, fully, for the messy, beautiful, imperfect reality of being human. And that’s a lot scarier than sitting in a pew, because there’s no one else to blame when it goes wrong. It’s just you, and the universe, and the choices you make. I want to acknowledge how brave it is to live in uncertainty. Our culture loves certainty. We want the five steps, the three pillars, the guaranteed outcome. But real growth happens in the gray areas. It happens in the questions that don’t have easy answers. Leaving the church forced me to develop a tolerance for ambiguity. I had to learn that I could be wrong and still be worthy. I could have doubts and still be good. I could be angry and still be loving. These aren’t contradictions; they’re complexities. And embracing them has made me more compassionate, not less. I see people differently now. I see the struggle behind the judgment. I see the fear behind the rigidity. And while I don’t agree with their conclusions, I can hold space for their humanity. That shift—from judgment to empathy—is perhaps the greatest gift I’ve received from this exodus. It hasn’t been linear. There are days I miss the order, the predictability, the sense of belonging. There are nights I lie awake wondering if I’m making a mistake, if I’m drifting without an anchor. But then I wake up, and I breathe, and I choose again. And again. And that choosing, that active participation in my own life, is what makes it mine. It’s not given to me by an institution; it’s built by me, brick by brick, choice by choice. If you are in this season of leaving, or considering it, I want you to know that you are not alone. There is a growing community of people who have walked this path. We are the ones who speak in metaphors of gardens instead of churches, of journeys instead of destinations. We are learning to build new tables, wider tables, where everyone is welcome regardless of their belief system. It’s messy work. It requires vulnerability, honesty, and a willingness to be seen. But it’s also joyful. There is a lightness in knowing that you belong because of who you are, not because of what you believe. So, take your time. Let yourself grieve what you’re losing. Celebrate what you’re gaining. And trust that you are enough, exactly as you are, right here, right now. You don’t need a title to validate your worth. You don’t need a congregation to confirm your value. You just need to show up for yourself. And that, my friend, is a sacred act in its own right. Where does that live in you? In the quiet spaces between the noise. In the breath before you speak. In the courage to say, 'This is who I am,' even when your whole world expects you to be someone else. You are doing better than you think. Keep going. I’ll be right here next week, ready to listen. Until then, be gentle with yourself. Love, Quinn.